Military Review

Project "ZZ". The worse the better

145
At the ASEAN summit, President Putin spoke about the sustainability of the Russian economy and the passing of the "bottom of the crisis." Later, advisor to the head of state Andrei Belousov said that since the beginning of the crisis in Russia, almost 5 millions of “new poor” had appeared, and this is a problem. However, one columnist in the Chicago Tribune suggests that Russia is recovering and even forms an economy outside the oil sector. The economic observer Die Welt thinks differently: he ridiculed the recent "failure" of Russia in world financial markets.




At the recent Russia-ASEAN summit in Sochi, it became known that ASEAN states need hydrocarbons and electricity, and Russia is ready to meet demand.

As noted by "Russian newspaper", President Putin spoke at the event about the stability of the Russian economy and the passage of the "bottom of the crisis."

“Our economy has proved its stability in the conditions of unfavorable external conjuncture,” V. Putin quotes the publication. “The bottom of the crisis in 2015 can be considered as passed.”

The president also praised the government’s anti-crisis measures and the actions of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation to introduce a flexible ruble exchange rate, the RG reports.

In parallel with Putin, another well-known optimist spoke out and a great specialist in bottom economics - Minister of Economic Development A. Ulyukayev. According to him, the Russian economy out of recession. However, in the first quarter of 2016, the GDP dynamics will be ... in the negative zone.

“But so close to zero that I do not change my position, that, starting from the third quarter of last year, we are out of recession,” Ulyukayev’s statement "Lenta.ru".

There were also other statements about the Russian crisis. Not so optimistic anymore.

On the eve of the presidium meeting of the Economic Council under the President of the Russian Federation, presidential adviser Andrei Belousov told the public about the appearance of nearly five million “new poor people” in the country since the beginning of the crisis.

“The number of citizens with incomes below the subsistence minimum is now 13 percent of the population, before the crisis there were 10 percent. These are almost five million new poor people ", - quotes the adviser "Lenta.ru".

Belousov believes that the increase in the number of citizens with incomes below the subsistence minimum has become a serious problem for the economy. The Russian economy as a whole overcame the crisis, although the number of poor people turned out to be much higher at the new equilibrium point. It may take several years to restore the population’s income, Belousov thinks.

Much more optimism about the Russian economy is shown by analysts, whose materials are published in the ... American press.

В "The Chicago Tribune" Russia is believed to be not only recovering, but even forming a non-oil economy based, apparently, on agriculture and information technology.

As Olga Tanas points out, the Russian economy is experiencing the time of the “biggest restructuring” that President Vladimir Putin has started.

Problems in the commodity industry led to the fact that some other sectors of the economy survived and even "found a way to flourish." The journalist quotes Deputy Finance Minister Maxim Oreshkin, who said that the “new growth drivers” in Russia were agriculture, the chemical industry, the food industry and domestic tourism. Of course, they have not “compensated” for the fall in non-commodity sectors, which was of a one-time and structural nature.

And yet the Russian economy is beginning to raise its head. The decline in QNUMX Q1 was less than the estimated values. The fall in gross domestic product by 2016 percent compared with the corresponding period of the previous year was the lowest since the decline that began in 1,2.

What was done with the ruble exchange rate at the end of 2014 of the year (the transition to a freely floating exchange rate), the journalist calls "shock therapy." This measure had to be taken because of the confrontation with the West, which arose after the Ukrainian conflict and the decline in oil prices. The ruble has fallen sharply, inflation has jumped, consumer demand has declined, which is connected with the fall in wages. However, with further stabilization of oil prices, inflation was only 7,3% compared to a year ago. The 13-year high inflation rate reached in March 2015 of the year (16,9 percent).

Further, the article reports on the achievements of agrarians: agriculture, whose share in GDP grew to 4,4% last year, demonstrated the highest indicator from 2003. The journalist attributes the success of farmers to the ruble weakening.

The information technology industry in Russia is also doing well. There, production last year "soared by 28 percent."

To improve “in other areas”, alas, the “source of vitality” still remains oil and gas.

Proceeds from the sale of energy to Russia gives about a third of budget revenues. This compares with 23 percent in 1996-1999. and on average with 50 percent in 2011-2014, according to Morgan Stanley.

Any profit will be short-lived, if there is no thorough modernization, followed by investment. Perhaps the biggest obstacle is the business climate in Russia. On the other hand, there is some progress: in the World Bank's index of ease of doing business, Russia has risen from 61-th place (2013) to 51-th in the current year.

First Deputy Head of the Central Bank Dmitry Tulin said that the economy is doomed to stagnation without reform. “The main factor for sustainable growth is an increase in investment,” the newspaper quotes Tulin. “At present, we cannot ensure the stability of the exchange rate due to the structure of our economy, its excessive dependence on commodity exports.”

Just one large German newspaper told something about investments.

Senior Editor News Business «Die Welt» Holger Zshepitts spoke about how Putin “disgraced the world financial markets” (“Putin blamiert sich an den globalen Finanzmärkten”).

Investors will stand in line, assured people of the Kremlin. What? It turns out that for the first time in ten years, Russia decided to sell dollar bonds again (Dollar-Anleihen). But already in the course of preparation, the project “crashed,” the editor notes.

The Kremlin simply flaunted: investors did not line up for Russian papers. The project failed at the preparatory stage. “Vladimir Putin probably imagined otherwise that the country was returning to the arena of world finance,” the journalist points out with unkind irony.

Putin was going to demonstrate to the world that Russia is acting on the international financial markets as a world power, and at the same time to get the money that is so necessary for the budget.

However, nothing happened. On Monday, the Russian Ministry of Finance was forced to announce that Moscow had difficulties with the placement, which will now be carried out by the forces of VTB Capital alone.

The reluctance of foreign investors to mess with Russian securities is explained very simply. In February and March 2016, the author recalls, European and American governments warned Western financial institutions from participating in the placement of Russian Eurobonds. The “warning” was allegedly tied to the existing sanctions. Therefore, Putin’s plan “failed miserably.”

What is waiting for Russia? Here is the forecast from the agency Fitch: the deficit in the budget of the Russian Federation will grow in 2016 year to 5% of GDP. The “hole” is explained by the low price of oil.

However, note that the “crack” with the Eurobonds was slightly exaggerated by the German.

As the RBCThe Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation completed the placement of Eurobonds by closing the bid book of 24 in May at 20: 00 Moscow time. The volume of sold securities - 1,75 billion. Demand exceeded supply by several times. “More than 70% of the placement fell on foreign investors. It was this group that we focused on, ”the Ministry of Finance specified.

As for the sanctions mentioned, Europe is unlikely to abandon them. We are talking about those states that allegedly objected to restrictive measures against Russia.

If 23 February, 2016, Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico called for the lifting of restrictions imposed on Russia as soon as possible, and a 20 on May 2016, a Brussels-based diplomatic source said that Slovakia, along with Hungary, Cyprus, Greece and Italy, supports the lifting of anti-Russian sanctions, in the evening 24 May suddenly it turned out that Slovakia does not intend to remove the sanctions. This was reported not by any European anonymous author, but by the head of the Ministry of Economic Development and Trade of the Russian Federation, Alexei Ulyukayev. He informed the public about it following the results of negotiations with Slovak Deputy Prime Minister for Investments Peter Pellegrini and the Minister of Economy of the country Peter Zhiga.

"The sanctions were discussed, the Slovak colleagues raised the question of what they consider to be an ineffective and unpromising sanction regime," Ulyukaeva quotes "Lenta.ru". Having said this, the interlocutors suddenly declared that they were “loyal members of the EU, therefore they would fulfill his demands.”

* * *


The emergence of millions of officially recorded “new poor people”, excessive dependence of the budget on the export of commodities and invigorating statements of the upper classes about the passing of the next bottom suggest the idea of ​​the bottomlessness of the Russian economy. Undoubtedly, the latter, under the guidance of optimist Ulyukayev, exists according to the principle discovered by Pushkin: the worse, the better.

“I wanted to talk with you about the change of the ministry,” wrote the poet P. A. Vyazemsky in June 1824. - What do you think about it? I'm happy and not. It has long been the motto of every Russian the worse the better».
Author:
Photos used:
http://photocorrespondent.com
145 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. razmik72
    razmik72 25 May 2016 09: 28
    +29
    Mr. Ulyukaev is so selflessly looking for the bottom that he can already be said to have been re-qualified as a diver. wassat
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. siberalt
      siberalt 25 May 2016 09: 49
      +30
      Perhaps Russian oligarchs and high-paid officials are doing well. Who would doubt that. But we, as something, do not feel this in our pockets. The population eats up deposits, as it was planned by the Central Bank (the "defatting" operation). It is possible that we have passed the "bottom" if vertically. But how long are we going to crawl along it horizontally before we float up belly? This begs a reasonable question. Why has the Russian government not yet provided its people, who are ready to endure hardships from the "hybrid war," with a clear plan for overcoming the crisis with dates, deadlines and persons responsible for implementation? Or is it such a state secret that the people are not informed about? Where we are going - it is not clear what to do, unknown.
      1. NordUral
        NordUral 25 May 2016 09: 58
        +4
        And their plan is completely different, the people and the power of the liberals are on the opposite course. And it is a pity that they are not afraid of popular anger.
        1. NordUral
          NordUral 25 May 2016 13: 31
          +10
          I read that he wrote about the fact that they are not afraid. And I thought, but the National Guard is also afraid - this is an armed force designed to extinguish popular indignation, if any. And not the protection of the president from his friends of the liberals. I would be glad to make a mistake, but reality just screams about the first.
      2. Altona
        Altona 25 May 2016 10: 07
        +15
        Quote: siberalt
        Why has the Russian government not yet provided its people, who are ready to endure hardships from the "hybrid war," with a clear plan for overcoming the crisis with dates, deadlines and persons responsible for implementation? Or is it such a state secret that the people have not been informed about? Where we are going - it is not clear what to do, unknown.

        ------------------------
        Medvedev, Dvorkovich, Ulyukayev and Siluanov are sure to go surrender to the West. No movement towards the real sector, no restrictions on the withdrawal of capital, reduction of incomes of the population, support of monopolies and the commodity sector.
        1. Scoun
          Scoun 25 May 2016 10: 19
          +6
          Quote: Altona
          Medvedev, Dvorkovich, Ulyukaev and Siluanov are definitely going to surrender to the West. No movement towards the real sector, no restrictions on the withdrawal of capital, lower incomes, support for monopolies and the commodity sector.

          Plus!
          RIAMO - May 18. Moscow authorities are asking the Federal Antimonopoly Service (FAS) of the Russian Federation to check the reason for the increase in prices for metal and fittings, which rose by 30-60%, for collusion of manufacturing companies, deputy mayor of Moscow on urban planning policy and construction Marat Khusnullin told reporters on Wednesday.

          He noted that the metal over the past two weeks has risen in price by 30-40%, and prices for fittings, which are used in construction, rose by 60%.

          The Russian Carriage Builders Association will send an appeal the other day asking for sorting out pricing and limiting exports to metallurgists to support the domestic market, a source in the carriage builders lobby told Reuters.


          According to him, the plants led by Uralvagonzavod received notifications from metallurgical companies about price increases of up to 20 percent from January 1 for certain types of rolled products.

          How will FAS be sorted out! I confuse one person ... but here she is. And I also recall the words of Manturov that they will impose duties and ended last year with a conspiracy, how they recouped on us and recouped.
          Rustamova Zumrud Handadashevna
          Member of the Board of Directors of OJSC Magnitogorsk Iron and Steel Works, member of the HR and Remuneration Committee, Deputy General Director of OJSC Polymetal UK, Deputy General Director of OJSC Polymetal (concurrently) .http: //mmk.ru/corporate_governance/the_structu
          re_of_government
          / board_of_directors /

          Wife above voiced by Dvorkovich ........ yeah, they will take anti-crisis measures, only they will run away. (((
      3. ibu355yandex.ru
        ibu355yandex.ru 25 May 2016 10: 38
        +4
        "Where we are going - it is not clear what to do, no one knows."
        The most annoying thing about this is that the liberal government itself does not know this ...
        1. NordUral
          NordUral 25 May 2016 13: 32
          +2
          He knows, even as he knows, but from this country death.
          1. Al1977
            Al1977 25 May 2016 14: 43
            -4
            Quote: NordUral
            He knows, even as he knows, but from this country death.

            Why are you different? Do you have enough money for food? Are you bomber? There isn’t enough for behu, so be a patriot - buy a fret viburnum and enjoy life. You can’t go to Europe - to Crimea please, soon the bridge will be, on the fret viburnum there it is. And about the death of the country here in every topic, then the United States will fall apart, then Ukraine, then the European Union, now Russia. Some kind of pessimist club, not a site. How everyone lived. and they will continue to live, calm down already.
            1. 34 region
              34 region 25 May 2016 15: 09
              +10
              14.43. And who is aching? If you do not like the wallpaper and you want to repair this nagging? If your car is booming and you are going to a car service, is it nagging? People do not whine here. Personally, I do not see whiners here. People see problems and want to solve them. And they tell our government what to do. But the government is so self-confident that it spits on everyone. Here are some comments about this.
              1. Al1977
                Al1977 26 May 2016 14: 25
                -1
                Quote: Region 34
                And who is aching? If you do not like the wallpaper and you want to repair this nagging?

                You look at what I answered, here they say that the country is death. I personally do not see any death. I don’t see a torn economy.
                You said it right - repair, but it’s not like the car is broken in the trash.
                Here's a comment about it. About the fact that here all countries are buried in a row, now we have reached ours.
      4. The comment was deleted.
      5. weksha50
        weksha50 25 May 2016 11: 09
        +3
        Quote: siberalt
        Where we are going is not clear what to do unknown.


        We, the people, at least approximately understand WHERE we go with such an economic policy of the state ...

        But it is not known what to do - this is most likely the case with the government ...
        They can only claim that the next bottom has already been passed ...

        PS Damn, how many levels are there at the bottom, Mr. Ulyukaev ???
        1. Oldwiser
          Oldwiser 25 May 2016 17: 51
          +1
          Quote: weksha50
          Damn, how many levels are there at the bottom, Mr. Ulyukaev

          The bottom of the Russian economy is like in geometry the surface of the Mobius strip
      6. Greenwood
        Greenwood 25 May 2016 13: 25
        +7
        Quote: siberalt
        a clear plan for overcoming the crisis with dates, dates and persons responsible for execution
        "There is no money in the country! But you hold on!" (C) Medvedev. That's the whole plan.
      7. sodick
        sodick 25 May 2016 14: 50
        +3
        We have already delved into the ground and continue to drill the well.
        1. 34 region
          34 region 25 May 2016 15: 13
          +2
          14.50. Both on! Wonderful. We find more and more layers of crisis! Yes, there are whole deposits! This is Klondike! Finally found what they were looking for! Lavrov smokes quietly on the sidelines.
      8. sodick
        sodick 25 May 2016 14: 50
        +1
        We have already delved into the ground and continue to drill the well.
      9. Alf
        Alf 25 May 2016 20: 22
        +1
        Quote: siberalt
        Why has the Russian government not yet provided its people, who are ready to endure hardships from the "hybrid war," with a clear plan for overcoming the crisis with dates, deadlines and persons responsible for implementation?

        Just because there is no such plan.
    3. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 09: 56
      +4
      I’m all waiting for this bottom to suck him and the friends of the liberals, rather, already.
      1. dmi.pris
        dmi.pris 25 May 2016 12: 19
        +5
        So the bottom of them will not suck, they are afloat .. If only we ourselves do not flip this yacht with the oligarchs ..
        1. NordUral
          NordUral 25 May 2016 13: 36
          +3
          I agree with you, wait, bringing the people to white heat. We are ready to endure hardships only for a great purpose or in the fight against national disaster. But far from everyone understood that this trouble was already a quarter century in our yard. We all cling to the illusion that the supreme power cannot be so dishonest. But no, it really can! And so it will be until we, the people, come together and demolish them in the elections.
          1. dmi.pris
            dmi.pris 25 May 2016 14: 18
            +4
            Please tell me how to demolish these villains in the elections by themselves.
            Quote: NordUral
            I agree with you, wait, bringing the people to white heat. We are ready to endure hardships only for a great purpose or in the fight against national disaster. But far from everyone understood that this trouble was already a quarter century in our yard. We all cling to the illusion that the supreme power cannot be so dishonest. But no, it really can! And so it will be until we, the people, come together and demolish them in the elections.
          2. 34 region
            34 region 25 May 2016 15: 23
            0
            North Ural! 13.36. How old is this slogan already! Here will bring the people! So what? We’re sitting here, and then what? What, the first time or the first year is? Or have the people not yet heated up? Or are there really few violent? Our actions commander !?
            1. Oldwiser
              Oldwiser 25 May 2016 17: 55
              +2
              Quote: Region 34
              Our actions commander

              Vote for the Communists (although they are more European-style Social Democrats), and then watch how the GDP will work with the new composition of the Duma.
            2. Oldwiser
              Oldwiser 25 May 2016 17: 55
              -1
              Quote: Region 34
              Our actions commander

              Vote for the Communists (although they are more European-style Social Democrats), and then watch how the GDP will work with the new composition of the Duma.
    4. yehat
      yehat 25 May 2016 11: 32
      +3
      just a person did not read "At the bottom" at Gorky's school. Losers rules the finances of the country.
      1. NordUral
        NordUral 25 May 2016 13: 38
        +3
        I don’t know about the D-grade, but now, for more than a quarter of a century, the power in the country is the power of villains.
    5. ImPerts
      ImPerts 25 May 2016 11: 39
      0
      Here you can also recall the "Dune" group:
      "...
      If there was a sea of ​​beer
      I'd become a dolphin beautiful
      If there was a sea of ​​vodka
      I would become a submarine. "
      1. ImPerts
        ImPerts 25 May 2016 11: 42
        0
        So it turns out ...
        The series "The Seekers", starring - ...
  2. Spartanez300
    Spartanez300 25 May 2016 09: 33
    +2
    Everyone is working, then they are being poured in order to lower the Russian economy, but nothing works, it’s time to break off on this score.
    1. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 09: 58
      +5
      Who are you talking about, my friend? About Kudrin and K?
    2. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 10: 31
      +3
      http://finobzor.ru/13413-katasonov-na-pensiyu-net-deneg-a-kak-zhe-to-chto-uhodit
      -za-predely-strany.html

      And minus it. Only do not hide the truth.
    3. 34 region
      34 region 25 May 2016 15: 27
      +2
      09.33. Y P R S T! Can I learn about the achievements of the Russian economy? Only without reference to Made with us. Too small achievements. At the level of brigades, sections, the maximum workshop of the times of the USSR.
  3. Yarik76
    Yarik76 25 May 2016 09: 37
    +19
    Gentlemen from the government should not climb on summits and trend with journalists, but work hard from morning to night! Bottom seekers - their mother!
    1. weksha50
      weksha50 25 May 2016 11: 12
      +1
      Quote: Yarik76
      Gentlemen from the government should not climb on summits and trend with journalists, but work hard from morning to night! The bottom of the seekers is their mother!


      Maybe give them all to seafaring neighbors ???
    2. yehat
      yehat 25 May 2016 11: 37
      +4
      in the USSR, when there was no crisis, business ministers worked really hard
      and not at summits / conferences, but constantly engaged in their own households.
      and now a severe economic crisis, but Ulyukaev seems to have become a PR girl
      only does what confers and gives interviews.
  4. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 25 May 2016 09: 43
    +7
    The businessmen are our government. Live one day. Managed to knead the loan and happy. Where is the development strategy? Slovakia refused and now what? Paws to the top?
    1. 34 region
      34 region 25 May 2016 15: 36
      0
      09.43. What to the top !? Down, look for the bottom! This has never happened and here again! What to take from majors? Here are the scum scum! Do not rummage at all! The scoop is gone. How do they rummage around now? Not enough brains or money for brains? The crisis hit! And if you are so smart, why didn’t you keep the blow? Didn't wait or think? (The phrase of Lavrov). The curtain.
  5. The comment was deleted.
    1. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 09: 59
      0
      Optimist you, however ...
  6. dr. sem
    dr. sem 25 May 2016 09: 48
    +7
    Quote: razmik72
    Mr. Ulyukaev is so selflessly looking for the bottom that he can already be said to have been re-qualified as a diver. wassat

    Someone is simply obliged to cut scuba hoses to this diver to the bottom detector ...
    1. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 10: 00
      +6
      NOT someone, but we - in the elections. And not only him, but the whole party of divers.
      1. Al1977
        Al1977 25 May 2016 10: 29
        0
        Quote: NordUral
        NOT someone, but we - in the elections. And not only him, but the whole party of divers.

        We have no election of members of the government. Where and when are you going to choose.
        Or remind you of the rating of Putin, the only person we choose and who is approved by the government. Learn the materiel.
        1. NordUral
          NordUral 25 May 2016 10: 55
          +3
          You need to choose in all elections.
          1. Al1977
            Al1977 25 May 2016 14: 25
            0
            Quote: NordUral
            You need to choose in all elections.

            So what do you choose such a government every time then?
  7. atamankko
    atamankko 25 May 2016 09: 51
    +3
    Professionals in government and parliament can be counted on the fingers,
    here with a creak and try to come up with something sensible, but it does not always work out.
    1. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 10: 01
      +11
      There are enough professionals there, they are perfectly ruining our country.
      1. Al1977
        Al1977 25 May 2016 10: 32
        +7
        Quote: NordUral
        There are enough professionals there, they are perfectly ruining our country.

        The president appreciates their work positively. Remind Putin's rating?
        1. NordUral
          NordUral 25 May 2016 13: 40
          +4
          And Putin himself is a liberal, if not clearer ...
          1. Nforce
            Nforce 25 May 2016 22: 58
            -1
            But you forgot that we have a power vertical. And it will become clear who is to blame. And then anyone is to blame, except for the head of the fish.
      2. 34 region
        34 region 25 May 2016 15: 40
        0
        North Ural! 10.01. And whose school of robbery? Good teachers were however! Well taught, or students are so capable, straight nuggets.
    2. kepmor
      kepmor 25 May 2016 11: 17
      +14
      The main thesis of the article - the worse the better - very accurately reflects the internal policies of our rulers.
      Well, you yourself decide who is easier to manage for the poor and destitute, who think about their daily bread, and every minute just try to survive in this country, the victorious oligarchy, and do not particularly delve into the domestic political realities - not before that, or more or less provided with citizens, who will ask the rulers various uncomfortable questions about the elections, the work of the executive branch, the police, and the courts?
      For the king with the boyars, the most convenient scenario is that the worse the bulk of the population lives, the easier it is to manage the authorities, i.e. better to them!
      Therefore, they created a layer of well-fed and loyally subjects from among the security forces of all stripes, prosecutors, judges, officials of all levels, and the apogee was the creation of the National Guard with punitive powers and subordination to Putin personally!
      Add to this the "tame media", which day and night "smash" the fifth column of liberals, talk about the wisdom of the president with the government, about "decaying" Europe with states, about "dying" Ukraine, etc.
      There is only one conclusion: under the existing power, you don’t have to expect the best in our life!
      All that remains is to go to the polls and vote! Everything else - rallies, marches, strikes, is practically forbidden in our country or under the strict guidance of the same government!
      A step to the side, a jump on the spot - this is extremism and an attempt at a coup d'etat, and then, like clockwork - "the most humane" court in the world "and welcome to the zone.
      1. dr. sem
        dr. sem 25 May 2016 12: 39
        +1
        "They took it off the tongue" ... To the point!
      2. NordUral
        NordUral 25 May 2016 13: 45
        +4
        Although I urge myself to vote correctly in the elections, including my head, and not listening to the zombie man, it would be more correct to organize a referendum on the topic: liberal (market) economy or planned-market economy (nationalization of the stolen is obligatory in this scheme).

        Only how to implement this is a question of questions. Too many people have successfully entered the service of the thieves' leaders and will never allow a legal change in the situation in favor of public justice. They will not be allowed because now we have not a state, but an organized criminal group, which pretends to be a state. And all the pseudo-patriotic gestures of "our" government only from the realization that their senior partners will treat them like the leaders of Yugoslavia, Iraq and Libya. And we are glad to be deceived, fools.
        1. Al1977
          Al1977 25 May 2016 14: 48
          0
          Quote: NordUral
          but it would be more correct to organize a referendum on the topic: liberal (market) economy or planned-market economy (nationalization of the stolen is obligatory in this scheme).

          And let's hold a referendum to give millions to ordinary people and take the money from the oligarchs. What do you think will be the result?
          1. Greenwood
            Greenwood 25 May 2016 16: 17
            0
            Quote: Al1977
            What do you think will be the result?
            Half with the millions received will immediately fall over the hill from sin away.
          2. Oldwiser
            Oldwiser 25 May 2016 18: 01
            0
            Quote: Al1977
            give millions to ordinary people

            It is you, my friend, you are directly quoting Yegor Gaidar with Anatoly Borisovich Ch. - remember about the "vouchers" -
            every Russian citizen will be able to buy a Volga car for one voucher
        2. 34 region
          34 region 25 May 2016 15: 45
          0
          North Ural! 13.45. There recently, something very intensively promoted by Tsar Nicholas2. Not otherwise going to restore the monarchy? Then we’ll dream about elections in sweet dreams!
      3. Oorfene Deuce
        Oorfene Deuce 25 May 2016 16: 32
        -1
        Quote: kepmor
        All that remains is to go to the polls and vote!

        You believe? But what about ...
        1. kepmor
          kepmor 25 May 2016 21: 59
          0
          I do not believe them, BUT .... do I have an alternative ?!
  8. NordUral
    NordUral 25 May 2016 09: 53
    +3
    Oh, how our country lacks Baron Munchausen .... Well, he would have pulled himself and the country in one famous way, without foreign investments and standing in the pose of the laundress before the West.
    1. The comment was deleted.
      1. kepmor
        kepmor 25 May 2016 12: 07
        +5
        And the closer the elections, the more there will be all sorts of "storytellers" from among our near-trone beau monde!
        The fundamental principle of our power is that life without a sucker is bad ...
  9. Elk
    Elk 25 May 2016 09: 54
    +2
    Whole problem that there is no plan
    1. siberalt
      siberalt 25 May 2016 11: 22
      +6
      The system needs to be changed, then plans will appear. And now everything is manual and in the dark.
      1. gladcu2
        gladcu2 25 May 2016 16: 23
        0
        siberalt

        Right. You need to change the system. But rather, it's correct to say changing the system.

        Theoretically, the system should look like 75% state ownership 25% private property. And then the balance in society will be commensurate. Like, who wants to be rich and happy be it, you have a 25% niche. Who wants to have confidence in the prosperity of tomorrow, he has a 75% niche in society.

        We must take into account the errors of history. After all, the USSR collapsed due to excesses. Natural morality prevailed over ideology. And at the core of the USSR was ideology. So the country has perished.
    2. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 13: 51
      +1
      There is a plan, not ours, but Anglo-Saxon.
      1. gladcu2
        gladcu2 25 May 2016 16: 52
        -1
        NordUral

        Do you have any ideas? To have a plan you need to know what to do.

        Communists, for example, want to change the tax system, so that the state supposedly wring out the rich, and add the poor socially. Complete nonsense. However...


        Can you say something? Not baricades. "Cowardly" is for others ...
  10. dr. sem
    dr. sem 25 May 2016 09: 56
    +2
    Quote: atamankko
    Professionals in government and parliament can be counted on the fingers,
    here with a creak and try to come up with something sensible, but it does not always work out.

    And what generally "turns out" except for the collapse in everything (social sphere, medicine, education at all levels, a dead small business ....) ???
  11. Stas157
    Stas157 25 May 2016 10: 15
    +3
    . According to him, the Russian economy has come out of the recession. True, according to the results of the first quarter of 2016, the dynamics of GDP will be ... in the negative zone.

    Yes, how can we get out of recession if GDP falls ?? If we fall already not so fast, then this does not mean that the bottom of the crisis has already passed! We are falling, just not so fast!
    Now, when GDP grows, then it can only be assumed that a crisis has occurred.
    1. siberalt
      siberalt 25 May 2016 11: 29
      +3
      Because of the recession, the GDP is falling. But we are no longer a recession, but a systemic crisis. Even if a barrel of oil costs 200 bucks, prices in stores will not fall, but the retirement age will be raised, and education with medicine will be "re-optimized" to the point. Our system is already screwed up and secured by the Constitution, which has a Guarantor.
    2. gladcu2
      gladcu2 25 May 2016 16: 58
      0
      Stas157

      It’s easy to get out of the recession.

      Ask yourself, what is the crisis? Why recession? And the answer will come. Even a revolution is not necessary. Everything is simple.

      Sit and think. He who seeks will find.
  12. asiat_61
    asiat_61 25 May 2016 10: 27
    +4
    If I understood correctly, Vladimir Putin joined the Lyulyukaev divers group.
    1. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 13: 55
      +2
      He's just the commander of this detachment, it's time for us to understand this. And not only to us, but to those who, with the support of the people, can lead the country on the right path. Naturally, these are not those for whom the "ear of Moscow" is crucified, but real professionals and patriots of the Motherland.
      1. gladcu2
        gladcu2 25 May 2016 17: 02
        -3
        NordUral

        Well GDP, squad leader. But recognition to him for real merit. He led the country out of the abyss, raised the army. Created the country an acceptable sovereignty.

        You put yourself in his place. Yes, and estimate the surrounding conditions. Well, and besides, if you criticize, make a proposal.

        And you yourself know that you don’t have to carry bags.
        1. Alf
          Alf 25 May 2016 20: 32
          0
          Quote: gladcu2
          army raised.

          He raised the army for a completely different reason, in order not to defend the rudiment with the crap, but so that overseas friends would not come in once and were not fired from work. And these can.
          1. gladcu2
            gladcu2 26 May 2016 18: 37
            -1
            Alf

            Wow. You are shortsighted apparently.

            By protecting himself, he protects others. You and your family.

            So what is the moral of GDP does not match yours? And what is the moral of GDP does not coincide with billions of inhabitants of the planet who also do not want war.
    2. 34 region
      34 region 25 May 2016 15: 52
      +1
      10.27. But the scuba diver controls. From above. Suddenly they will find and steal the amphora! And so pleased with their work.
  13. Gardamir
    Gardamir 25 May 2016 10: 29
    +3
    Gone bottom is how? Not just drowned, but also buried?
  14. okunevich_rv
    okunevich_rv 25 May 2016 10: 34
    +4
    These gentlemen are not capable of raising the economy, they are economically not wealthy.
    Joseph Vissarionovich raised the country from ruins without kissing the imperialist asses, industrialization was the greatest, the people of the country prayed for the leader, and after the death of the leader they sincerely cried.
    The current leaders ALSO. Only mantras are able to pronounce the bottom passed. Where are the reviving factories and enterprises, only in the Moscow region? If an enterprise intends to develop, it expands and increases its staff, while only massive reductions in "optimization" are visible, including in law enforcement agencies, what are they preparing for? - towards extinction?
    1. gladcu2
      gladcu2 25 May 2016 17: 13
      0
      okunevich rv

      Where have you seen gentlemen capable of feats?

      Only comrades are ready for feats. And what gentlemen ... but to whom are they ... gentlemen?

      In a crisis of capitalism, there are only those exits that lead to ruin, in order to restore this capitalism again. But in order not to get this devastation it is only necessary to recognize that capitalism is a system that does not self-repair. This system lives exactly as long as there is no concentration of capital in the same hands.

      Just admit to yourself that capitalism is a one-way road.

      And stop using that vile word mister. I’m not a lord to anyone and I won’t tolerate lords over myself.
  15. russmensch
    russmensch 25 May 2016 10: 37
    +1
    Spiteful critics in shock.
    The Kremlin simply flaunted: investors did not line up for Russian papers. The project failed at the preparatory stage. “Vladimir Putin probably imagined otherwise that the country was returning to the arena of world finance,” the journalist points out with unkind irony.
    However, nothing came of it. Monday (this is May 23rd, my comment) the Russian Ministry of Finance was forced to announce that Moscow had difficulties with the placement, which will now be carried out by VTB Capital alone. .... investors did not line up for Russian securities. The project failed at the preparation stage.


    But on May 24, the Ministry of Finance completed the placement of Eurobonds, the volume of securities sold amounted to $ 1,75 billion. The transaction went through the National Settlement Depository. The budget for this year includes external loans worth $ 3 billion.
    Everything would have failed so ...
    1. 34 region
      34 region 25 May 2016 15: 58
      0
      10.37. But earning thrust is not enough. Just a loan? It is like tearing down the porch.
  16. Alex66
    Alex66 25 May 2016 10: 45
    +3
    It is high time the plan to draw up a way out of their crisis, to appoint responsible and responsible. And if you don’t listen to everything literate in the government, the academies have finished and are doing everything right, only there is no result yet, but there will be. Hold on ...
    1. 34 region
      34 region 25 May 2016 16: 01
      0
      10.45. I will supplement the comment. We have a higher school of economics. But apparently the name is completely wrong. Rather, a fossil school of economics. We’ve reached the bottom. Now we have to go deeper!
    2. gladcu2
      gladcu2 25 May 2016 17: 19
      0
      Alex66

      The government is doing everything possible to maintain the cap system. But this cannot be done in principle. The system has come to its fundamental end. Capital has already come in one hand. There is nothing more to capitalize. You need to return the money to the hands of users of resources. But the question is, why did you take them, take them away?

      The principle must be changed.
  17. Al1977
    Al1977 25 May 2016 10: 55
    +8
    If the people are dissatisfied with the course followed by the government, and it is appointed by the president, then it elects another president. What is happening with us. Putin cleared the clearing, the people are offered the idea that "well, who if not Putin, if he leaves, the country will be torn to shreds, not a single person in the world is able to take Putin's place." In this situation, it remains to follow Medvedev's advice "you hold on there ..".
    Russia's course cannot change under Putin. And that's it. There is Putin, we love him, support his actions - then no need to whine. The "hawks" are in power, not the "doves". We are happy for the fighting in Syria and other points. The economy is in the background. Economists play with the cards the President gives them. They do not decide in the country how and what to be. FSB and security officials rule the economy.
  18. Tektor
    Tektor 25 May 2016 11: 04
    0
    Tulin is right: stagnation awaits us without effective investments. The whole question is how to make investments effective? To appoint responsible Titov and ask him in full?
    1. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 14: 03
      +4
      1. Hold a referendum on changing the liberal economy to a planned market economy, with emphasis on a planned one. 2. According to the results (atoms, I personally have no doubt that the people will choose the planned one), revive GOSPLAN on a new technological basis. 3. Revive planning, five-year plans. 4. Tough leadership and demand for the commissioned. 5. To expel oligarchs from the country, without even taking away the stolen goods, to take away only the main assets. And take off all the officials stained by bribery and theft. Let them go.
      1. Al1977
        Al1977 25 May 2016 14: 36
        0
        Quote: NordUral
        1. Hold a referendum on changing the liberal economy to a planned market economy, with emphasis on a planned one. 2. According to the results (atoms, I personally have no doubt that the people will choose the planned one), revive GOSPLAN on a new technological basis. 3. Revive planning, five-year plans. 4. Tough leadership and demand for the commissioned. 5. To expel oligarchs from the country, without even taking away the stolen goods, to take away only the main assets. And take off all the officials stained by bribery and theft. Let them go.

        A concrete example of successful countries is possible with this model of economy?
        Personally, the USSR economy does not suit me at all.
        1. Gardamir
          Gardamir 25 May 2016 15: 28
          0
          Personally, the USSR economy does not suit me at all.
          Which one suits you?
          1. Al1977
            Al1977 25 May 2016 16: 24
            0
            Quote: Gardamir
            Personally, the USSR economy does not suit me at all.
            Which one suits you?

            Germany, France, Switzerland, Canada, USA.
            In the first three I was not once, I want to live like them, but in Russia, with a Russian mentality and characteristics, but with the same standard of living
            1. gladcu2
              gladcu2 25 May 2016 18: 00
              +1
              Al1977

              Another connoisseur of life ...

              To be a tourist is not to live and work. Live from scratch without lifting money. Then you will become a patriot of the USSR. This I guarantee you. True, those who knew life under the USSR are becoming few and they cannot transfer their experience.
            2. Alf
              Alf 25 May 2016 20: 40
              +1
              Quote: Al1977
              I want to live like them


              It's all right ? I didn’t look for something, but I never came across similar photos from the times of the USSR.
        2. 34 region
          34 region 25 May 2016 16: 05
          0
          14.36. Are capitalist economies successful? If they are so wonderful, why are there crises and poverty? Then the news of democracy brought to Iraq and Libya. How do they evolve?
          1. Al1977
            Al1977 25 May 2016 16: 34
            0
            Quote: Region 34
            If they are so wonderful, why are there crises and poverty?

            By what indicator did they decide that there is poverty? Average salary? Pension? Inflation?
            Compare the average salary doctor of Germany and ours?
      2. PHANTOM-AS
        PHANTOM-AS 25 May 2016 14: 38
        0
        Quote: NordUral
        NordUral

        All that you offer is called Revolution.
        1. gladcu2
          gladcu2 25 May 2016 18: 02
          0
          FANTOMAS

          Do not teach people directly. Let your mind reach. Only through the difficulties of cognition does a steady outlook on life come.
      3. gladcu2
        gladcu2 25 May 2016 17: 55
        0
        NordUral

        Your item is the first. You can not talk anymore.

        How are you going to implement it? Are you going to ask the GDP that he again sweep out this liberal trash with his own hands, as JV Stalin once did. What is his gratitude, as he rowed this heat with his own hands.

        Before you talk nonsense, you think for yourself how to realize this nonsense.
    2. gladcu2
      gladcu2 25 May 2016 17: 51
      0
      Tektor

      Ask yourself a question. Why do you need investments, what will you do with them and what do you mean by the word investment. Investment is what? Money, natural resources, human resources, free lands?

      You still drag nano-technology syuda.
  19. Konstantin Yu
    Konstantin Yu 25 May 2016 11: 05
    0
    Quote: Alex66
    It is high time the plan to draw up a way out of their crisis, to appoint responsible and responsible. And if you don’t listen to everything literate in the government, the academies have finished and are doing everything right, only there is no result yet, but there will be. Hold on ...


    To whom? what to hold on to? .. and what will happen? explain - is it better to rejoice, wait or work with hands and brains?
    It’s they up there all stupid and thieves, and here we are all honest, smart and hands from that place are growing ...
    1. asiat_61
      asiat_61 25 May 2016 11: 59
      +2
      In order to work with your hands, you need not to buy a new shovel, but an excavator.
      1. PHANTOM-AS
        PHANTOM-AS 25 May 2016 15: 30
        +2
        Quote: asiat_61
        In order to work with your hands, you need not to buy a new shovel, but an excavator.

        The question of who owns the means of production is very relevant., In Russia, the owner is large capital, and, for the most part, foreign. And we, in this sense, are extras of the processes that are being imposed on us.
        "When a spy or a traitor is caught, the indignation of the public knows no bounds,
        she requires execution. And when a thief is wielding in front of everyone, stealing
        public good, the surrounding public is limited to good-natured
        laughs and pat on the shoulder. Meanwhile, it is clear that a thief stealing
        public good and digging under the interests of the national economy, there is one
        a spy and a traitor, if not worse. "
        ("On the economic situation and the policy of the Party" v. 8, page 136) I.V. STALIN.
        1. Al1977
          Al1977 25 May 2016 17: 31
          0
          Quote: PHANTOM-AS
          in Russia, the owner is large capital, and, for the most part, foreign. And we, in this sense, are extras of the processes that are being imposed on us

          Right? Can the three largest, city or industry-forming enterprises that belong to foreign capital? Well, unless you are talking about Messrs. Timchenko and Rotenbergs, who are also citizens of other countries.
          1. Alf
            Alf 25 May 2016 20: 54
            0
            Quote: Al1977
            Can the three largest, city or industry-forming enterprises that belong to foreign capital?

            2013 - present - Alliance Renault-Nissan and Rostec.
            Ownership Structure [edit | edit the wiki text] As of December 31, 2015, Avtovaz Group is controlled by the offshore company Alliance Rostec Auto BV, which in turn represents the interests of a group of investors with the following voting rights: Renault sas - 50% (-1 share); State Corporation Rostec - 32,87%; Nissan International Holdings BV - 17,13%.
            50 + 17 = 67%. The foreign alliance owns a 67% stake in VAZ. Any questions ?
        2. gladcu2
          gladcu2 25 May 2016 18: 17
          0
          FANTOMAS

          Large private capital is not nationally owned.

          When they talk about a capitalist country, they mean three main components.

          The state is an institution protecting the country from external and internal dangers.
          Big private capital, which in itself.
          And a people that is characterized by a single morality, a survival system.

          So the merger of the state and private capital is this final stage of capitalism.

          The merger of the state of the people and private capital is fascism.

          The merger of the people and the state in the absence of a layer in the form of large private capital is socialism. Socialism allows insignificant private capital.
  20. weksha50
    weksha50 25 May 2016 11: 06
    +6
    "invigorating statements of the top about passing the next bottom suggest the bottomlessness of the Russian economy "...

    We have not gone through any bottom yet ... I have long ceased to believe these "invigorating" statements ...

    In my opinion, it would be much better if the US informed the government more honestly ...

    Yesterday I did not write my comment about whether there is an economic crisis in Russia now or not ...
    Well, I’m slow-witted ... I thought about how to carefully answer such a question ...

    So, in my opinion, the economic crisis, of course, exists in Russia ...
    However, as always, our Russian mentality manifested itself in the fact that the problems created by the global financial crises in general and sanctions in particular are many times realistically increased by our officials, financiers, economists, educated by HSE, various entrepreneurs and employers - starting with billionaires and ending with a little if not a small business ...

    Justifying all their actions by the crisis and sanctions, they reduce not only salaries, but also jobs, make wraps at the stage of mediation between the manufacturer and the buyer in unimaginable amounts, etc., etc.

    All these crises could have been overcome with minimal losses, if there had been a unity of the people, the ruling elite and business ... But this, by definition, is not and is unlikely to be ...

    In general, my opinion is: OUR "guardians" themselves exacerbate the impact of this crisis, shifting all the problems onto the shoulders of the people ... Most of this crisis here, in Russia, has been inflated to ugly proportions by mediocre leaders and super-greedy entrepreneurs ... Who, by the way , these very actions play into the hands of the opposition (read - the United States and its whineers) ...
    1. NordUral
      NordUral 25 May 2016 14: 06
      0
      "the invigorating statements of the top about the passing of the next bottom suggest the idea of ​​the bottomlessness of the Russian economy" ...
      These statements inspire thoughts of how powerful a reserve even left us to rot under Brezhnev and the followers of the USSR, which until now had rested on this with unbridled destruction and theft. And only now the legacy of damned socialism began to deplete.
    2. 34 region
      34 region 25 May 2016 16: 16
      +1
      11.06. If they were as smart as they consider themselves, we would not have a crisis. And then accrue millions of salaries and index them on the value of inflation here they are smart. And they are not able to work without a crisis. Put them on their minimum wage for a sense of reality. Quite already divorced from life. Then maybe the brains will work better. And if they die? There will already be according to Chubais. They did not fit into reality. Do not worry about them.
  21. Konstantin Yu
    Konstantin Yu 25 May 2016 11: 41
    +1
    Quote: weksha50
    All these crises could have been overcome with minimal losses, if there had been a unity of the people, the ruling elite and business ... But this, by definition, is not and is unlikely to be ...


    Unity is with us, as usual only during the invasion of us. And so: some stupid and take kickbacks, others give and break prices, while others contrary to create and create. and some bleed everyone. .. And that's it,
    Each has its own truth .. It is a pity that the concept of HONOR in peacetime is blurred by self-interest, laziness, and nonsense ...

    "Now, if they ... then I would uh ... heal"
    1. weksha50
      weksha50 25 May 2016 12: 09
      +1
      Quote: Konstantin Yu.
      It is a pity that the concept of HONOR in peacetime is blurred by self-interest, laziness, and nonsense ...



      It is not just blurry ... They have been trying to destroy it for a long time, level it to zero ...

      But in spite of them, the concept of honor and dignity is still inherent in very many people ... But these people are far from being in government and not in "high" business ...
    2. PHANTOM-AS
      PHANTOM-AS 25 May 2016 16: 13
      +2
      Quote: Konstantin Yu.
      The impact of the US, as usual only during the invasion of us. And so: some stupid and take kickbacks, others give and break prices, while others contrary to create and create. and some bleed everyone. .. And that's it,

    3. gladcu2
      gladcu2 25 May 2016 18: 31
      0
      Konstantin Yu

      Here you are severely mistaken.

      Unity in Russia did occur before a common danger. But first you must always look at the historical period. Unification has always arisen subject to the existence of a single morality of survival. Which in every way once supported the church. And that, in turn, exercised its power by controlling this morality.

      For the current historical period, we have the following.

      The church is weak. The state has no ideology, which is not bad, but it also weakens the state before the enemy. The education system is absent, which forms a single moral. Masmedia means form a fragmented egoistic morality. And the farther the worse.

      The only thing that remains is history in the form of victory in the Patriotic War. Which was demonstrated by the "Immortal Regiment" and stopped the beginning of the third world war.

      So do not be mistaken. It will cost dearly to everyone in the world.
      1. Alf
        Alf 25 May 2016 21: 02
        +1
        Quote: gladcu2
        The only thing left is a story in the form of a victory in World War II.

        Already this is not. On official, in the Second World War, the people won. The people, which, according to the official version, were not led by anyone and were not commanded. Gebnya is exceptionally bloody, the commanders are completely fools, the Communists are duped by propaganda, and the main victory was won by fines from criminals armed only with Lend-Lease.
  22. Mihail55
    Mihail55 25 May 2016 11: 52
    +4
    Quote: weksha50
    invigorating statements from the top about the passing of the next bottom suggest the bottomlessness of the Russian economy "...

    We have not gone through any bottom yet ... I have long ceased to believe these "invigorating" statements ...

    In my opinion, it would be much better if the US informed the government more honestly ...

    Yesterday I did not write my comment about whether there is an economic crisis in Russia now or not ...
    Well, I’m slow-witted ... I thought about how to carefully answer such a question ...

    So, in my opinion, the economic crisis, of course, exists in Russia ...
    However, as always, our Russian mentality manifested itself in the fact that the problems created by the global financial crises in general and sanctions in particular are many times realistically increased by our officials, financiers, economists, educated by HSE, various entrepreneurs and employers - starting with billionaires and ending with a little if not a small business ...

    Justifying all their actions by the crisis and sanctions, they reduce not only salaries, but also jobs, make wraps at the stage of mediation between the manufacturer and the buyer in unimaginable amounts, etc., etc.

    All these crises could have been overcome with minimal losses, if there had been a unity of the people, the ruling elite and business ... But this, by definition, is not and is unlikely to be ...

    In general, my opinion is: OUR "guardians" themselves exacerbate the impact of this crisis, shifting all the problems onto the shoulders of the people ... Most of this crisis here, in Russia, has been inflated to ugly proportions by mediocre leaders and super-greedy entrepreneurs ... Who, by the way , these very actions play into the hands of the opposition (read - the United States and its whineers) ...

    1. Likewise, I no longer believe in "cheerful"
    2. I doubt the honesty of informants
    3. Since all of these top superstructures are like the fifth wheel, why are we really looking for these?
    4. But is it sometimes worth these figures sometimes for a month or two IN NIZA? Maybe a little dying in his zeal?
    5. But this will never happen. Already passed ... PEOPLE AND PARTY OF ONE ...
    6. Soon there will be elections, well, aren’t we stupid so that we could again rake on the ERv?
    1. weksha50
      weksha50 25 May 2016 12: 14
      +2
      Quote: Michael55
      4. But is it sometimes worth these figures sometimes for a month another in NIZA? Maybe a little dying in his zeal?


      Hmm ... There is now in the ruling elite such a thing as a "clip" ...
      The right people are simply not allowed to fall out of it ...
      If during the Soviet Union (no matter how someone scolded him - there are such ones) they could have lowered it, removed it altogether, or even planted it, then now we have several other examples ...

      You need to name the names of people who, without absolutely showing themselves positively in one high position, and often - even having hurt while being in it, are moved to higher, or - no less bread-filled positions ??? So the list will be sooooo voluminous ...
    2. Volzhanin
      Volzhanin 25 May 2016 12: 22
      +4
      1. There is no need to harbor the illusion that a handful of those who have seized power will think not of their loved ones, but of the welfare of the people and the prosperity of the state. Under capitalism, this does not happen by definition.
      2. By the way, our leader Putin VV in the work of the economic bloc, and the government as a whole, everything is like and everything suits. He repeated this more than once.
      3. But to step on the ER rake is a personal choice of each individual. So let’s see who is more in our country - those who have Gesheft from the board of EP plus duped simpletons, or thinking people (or at least with the rudiments of the brain).
      1. gladcu2
        gladcu2 25 May 2016 20: 14
        0
        Volzhanin

        A people is a society united by a single morality, a single system of survival.

        EdRo, survives with you? If not, then why vote for them?

        And everyone watched the latest "Time Programs". What did you see during the most expensive viewing hours? Advertising party EdRo ...

        Did you see everything correctly? Surely half did not look.

        EdR representatives were dressed like bums from a garbage can. In washed shirts, wrinkled jackets, jeans hanging on the ass and, of course, without ties.

        This is not proximity to the people, this is hypocrisy.
    3. Alf
      Alf 25 May 2016 21: 03
      0
      Quote: Michael55
      6. Soon there will be elections, well, aren’t we stupid so that we could again rake on the ERv?

      Doubt it? Let's look at the results.
  23. Black Colonel
    Black Colonel 25 May 2016 12: 02
    +2
    "... a great specialist in bottom economics ..."
    Smiled. But somehow sad.
  24. Mountain shooter
    Mountain shooter 25 May 2016 12: 08
    +1
    Ab ovo, as the Latins said - and they knew a lot about logic. First of all, the reasons for the growth of the "poorest stratum" according to Goskomstat. This is an increase in "envelope salaries" and a decrease in official salaries. EVERYWHERE, and no one advertises it - and the State Statistics Committee records it. So the figure is "inflated", and it's still surprising that it's so small.
    And the second thing. Nobody interferes with ANY of us to organize our business and feed ourselves and our family as much as you can, and everyone believes that he himself is "hoo", but they interfere: a foreman, a boss, corrupt officials, liberal ministers, the wrong government, dictatorship ... It is necessary to emphasize.
    So do not interfere. Having chatted around Europe, having worked with the people there, I will tell you my opinion. Everyone plows - we never dreamed of. There is no freedom to express one's opinion - at least for work - there (maybe it is where it is, I haven't been to France, I don't know), I vyaknul something in the smoking room - they immediately reported. And there, depending on the status - if a cool worker - for the first time being dragged out by the boss, if not very valuable - you can walk outside the gate marked "not loyal to the company"!
    Here it is. And God forbid you to work with a hangover - it's generally cranks! Guys, do not confuse the front facade with real housing. And do not watch TV shows from the life of millionaires. Not everyone lives there like that. And we have much more freedom. In all senses. This is my personal opinion, but wherever I come to any enterprise - we have time and ... during work, we take time off and go out a bit out of shape - and nothing gets away with it ...
  25. Mihail55
    Mihail55 25 May 2016 12: 26
    +2
    Mountain shooter, why are you all over the world our great military secret ... about black and white s / n !!!! smile
  26. v.yegorov
    v.yegorov 25 May 2016 12: 28
    +4
    invigorating statements of the upper ranks about the passing of the next bottom suggest the bottomlessness of the Russian economy.

    The bottom has passed successfully. Drilled deeper at 100m. There are great prospects ahead.
    Ulyukaev.
  27. dr. sem
    dr. sem 25 May 2016 12: 29
    +4
    Quote: Al1977
    Quote: NordUral
    There are enough professionals there, they are perfectly ruining our country.

    The president appreciates their work positively. Remind Putin's rating?

    Change the record. "Remind Putin's rating" .... Where these 100500% of the rating come from already and a drunken hedgehog understands - "from the ceiling" .... Real ratings - "in Zh.PE" is called.
  28. mihasik
    mihasik 25 May 2016 12: 47
    +3
    Russia in November 2015 invested $ 6 billion in US government bonds (US Treasuries, UST) ...

    Medvedev to pensioners in Crimea: "No money!"
    1. PHANTOM-AS
      PHANTOM-AS 25 May 2016 14: 06
      +1
      Quote: mihasik
      Medvedev to pensioners in Crimea: "No money!"

      There are 450 more parasites
  29. Damask
    Damask 25 May 2016 13: 28
    +2
    Fool, we must say thanks not to the government and Putin, but to our inert population, they can only manipulate the currency and live on the difference in Russia, this government would be bitten in any other country
  30. iliya87
    iliya87 25 May 2016 14: 32
    +1
    I don’t believe anyone for a long time. He himself is not an economist, and economists will not be able to predict beyond what’s next, so you just have to watch the picture of economic life at the household level and not die
  31. SklochPensioner
    SklochPensioner 25 May 2016 15: 40
    +1
    Oleg Chuvakin, do you write poetry for an hour?
    Pushkin you are ours!)))
  32. Gardamir
    Gardamir 25 May 2016 16: 17
    +2
    Don't worry kind grandfather Putin pardoned Savchenko. Now we will heal the sanctions removed. So the country, even during Yeltsin, was not let down. That's the bottom so bottom.
  33. runway
    runway 25 May 2016 16: 19
    +2
    Yes, everything is clear.
    When THEY say that "everything is fine, we are on the right course", they mean PERSONALLY YOURSELF.
    Despite the crisis in the country, their personal well-being is growing!
    And what did you think that they all cared about our people?
  34. Grave With Cross 3
    Grave With Cross 3 25 May 2016 16: 36
    -2
    Prokhanov about Putin’s statements that offshore companies are good. Good for whom? For thieves to withdraw money from the country?
  35. EvgNik
    EvgNik 25 May 2016 16: 41
    +1
    Guys, never The West will not leave us alone. It just won't be that. There is no other solution, to tear the country apart, cut all the tanks, planes, missiles, give them all the minerals and more. Only then Russia will not be there. So the government has two options - either topple to the West, or to start building the country. Together with all the people. There is no alternative. And just forget about the sanctions. This is an inevitable evil.
    1. Al1977
      Al1977 25 May 2016 17: 45
      0
      Quote: EvgNik
      or start building a country. Together with all the people. There is no alternative

      There is an alternative. And the article is about that. Change NOTHING. The people will become poorer. So what. So it's easy to explain. It is the West that bothers us. Just a question. We also imposed sanctions against them, plus their ban on working with us in a number of sectors. And they were "occupied" by the states, and migrants, terrorists and their own soulless people with gay parades, How else do they even live in the world? We have more resources, we have an independent policy. So why the hell are they not whining, but we ???? Something I don’t hear from them "ahh, Russia has imposed sanctions, we must accept and live with it and build Europe."
      And the last thing. Which means "the west will not leave us." The Kamaras don't leave me every summer. How do I live with this? Germany is the size of the Moscow region. HOW do they interfere with YOU personally?
      1. EvgNik
        EvgNik 25 May 2016 18: 58
        +1
        Quote: Al1977
        HOW do they interfere with YOU personally?

        Personally, Germany doesn’t bother me. Israel and European countries do not bother me. Let them live and develop. Bearing in mind the West - first of all, I mean the states and Britain. So they always interfered with Russia. Although I’ll get better - the states since the 30-40s of the last century.
      2. EvgNik
        EvgNik 25 May 2016 19: 32
        0
        Quote: Al1977
        Do NOT change ANYTHING. The people will get poorer

        So this is the first solution I described. Only slower.
  36. eyed
    eyed 25 May 2016 18: 13
    +2
    Quote: EvgNik
    Guys, never The West will not leave us alone. It just won't be that. There is no other solution, to tear the country apart, cut all the tanks, planes, missiles, give them all the minerals and more. Only then Russia will not be there. So the government has two options - either topple to the West, or to start building the country. Together with all the people. There is no alternative. And just forget about the sanctions. This is an inevitable evil.

    Where did you get that "will not leave alone"? Yes, fuck, nobody needs us there, just like they are to us by and large ... None of the common people are interested in what politicians try, they have their own problems above the roof, and all of Russia is most often associated with maskava and neighbors surroundings, behind which immediately Siberia, about which they finally have no idea. I declare this responsibly, since I myself visit Germany, the Czech Republic, France and Austria almost every year, and my son often visits the States.
    And politicians and politicians to carry nonsense with a smart look. What, aren't we like that? And, in my opinion, you finally need to stop trying to talk about the West and the East, and switch only to your internal problems, of which we have plenty. For the states, Europe, Syria and other Honduras, let the head ache at the Foreign Ministry and the FSB, I don’t give a damn about them, which is what I wish you ....
    1. EvgNik
      EvgNik 25 May 2016 18: 48
      0
      Quote: fake
      Why did you get this

      Michael, I'm sorry, but we didn’t drink, you didn’t allow each other to contact (I, in extreme cases, didn’t allow you). I ask you to consider.
    2. Al1977
      Al1977 26 May 2016 10: 55
      0
      Quote: fake
      I declare this responsibly, since I myself visit Germany, the Czech Republic, France and Austria almost every year, and my son often happens in the States

      People who have not been there most often talk about the fact that they will not leave us. Personal observation. For them, the world is what they say on TV. Also "Nautilus Pompilius" sang "Goodbye America, where I have never been ..". And you will not prove anything. They will watch their films, read Stephen King, use iPhones and iPads, have their money in store, fly on Boeings and tell how America prevents them from living. This is the mentality.
  37. trantor
    trantor 25 May 2016 18: 19
    +1
    I do not understand. There is no economic development, but is there a ministry?
    1. Al1977
      Al1977 26 May 2016 16: 24
      0
      Quote: trantor
      I do not understand. There is no economic development, but is there a ministry?

      This joke has a beard like old Khatabych.
  38. eyed
    eyed 25 May 2016 19: 06
    0
    Quote: EvgNik
    Quote: fake
    Why did you get this

    Michael, I'm sorry, but we didn’t drink, you didn’t allow each other to contact (I, in extreme cases, didn’t allow you). I ask you to consider.

    Tady oh! ....
  39. akudr48
    akudr48 25 May 2016 20: 57
    +2
    The economic bloc of the government is to blame, as the author claims, but Putin praises the work of the Central Bank and this bloc,

    People are getting worse and worse, as price tags in stores, pensions and housing bills show, and the Western press notes that everything is going as it should, the Russian economy is growing stronger, and sanctions are weakening under the mighty pressure of our super-leaders,

    When asked from the people about pensions (they found what to ask), in the Crimea, Prime Minister Mitya said that it’s nothing, that there is no money and offered to hold on to whom and what to hold on to - did not explain, quickly escaping from a politically incorrect audience

    Ulyukaev once again felt for the bottom (and, perhaps, did he feel the station Dno?).

    Of course, Putin knows better, he sits high and looks far, it will not pass another 2-3-4 term, as poverty will be eliminated, possibly in the same way as veterans of World War II are now provided with apartments. Especially since The Chicago Tribune is of the same opinion.

    For a long time the motto of every Russian is the worse, the better ” - this, of course, calms, inspires pride, and recalls other winged words, for example,
    - nothing, that the chest is hollow, but the back is with a wheel,
    - us .... and we grow stronger
    - We’ll transfer everything, if only there would be no war,
    - if there is no bread, let them eat cakes,
    - the rich is lying - no one will take him away,
    - the need for inventions is cunning,
    ..........................
  40. Signaller
    Signaller 25 May 2016 22: 06
    +2
    Statements at the level of gypsy and horse.
    Gypsy-Yes, I will not feed my horse and it will work like an ox.
    Man-Well, how ?? works as an ox. Time is running. Day-two-three.
    The gypsy works like an ox. I do not feed and do not know worries.
    Another day, two or three - People = How ???
    Gypsy-works like an ox. I do not feed and works.
    Three more days pass.
    People, well, how ????
    Gypsy yes everything is fine, only darling died.
    So Putin-Yes, everything is fine with Russia, yes darling died.
  41. kirgudu
    kirgudu 26 May 2016 08: 26
    +1
    Bottom, Dimon here also agrees.
  42. Super Black
    Super Black 26 May 2016 15: 07
    +1
    Lenin called a situation when "the upper classes cannot, but the lower classes do not want" called revolutionary.
  43. The comment was deleted.
  44. Vintcsent
    Vintcsent 26 May 2016 23: 58
    0
    What is project 33 ????????