Military Review

“They were supposed to work along the lines of the French gendarmerie”

120
“They were supposed to work along the lines of the French gendarmerie”



“Now, naturally, the National Guard military intelligence will become the subject of operational investigative activities, because in the fight against extremism and terrorism it cannot be without it. This will make the guard a full-fledged intelligence service, ”the former commander-in-chief of the internal troops, former Interior Minister Anatoly Kulikov told the newspaper VIEW, commenting on the presidential bill on the creation of the National Guard.

On Wednesday, a bill on the creation of a new power structure, which was introduced by President Vladimir Putin the day before, was announced in the lower house of parliament. If the document enters into force in this form, the National Guard will receive all the functions and powers that the Internal Troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs had, and also take away some of the important activities of the police department.

“The troops will have a better base, training methods, discipline, weapons, test sites, equipment and everything else. Including its helicopters and airplanes "

As the newspaper VIEW, reported on the creation of a new department, subordinate directly to the president, it became known the day before, when the presidential decree on the formation of the Russian Guards was published.

According to the decree, the National Guard should be created by transforming the internal troops and joining some units of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, mainly power purposes, such as the SOBR, OMON, the rapid reaction force and aviation. In addition, the structure of the National Guard includes units of the licensing and permitting system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs that control turnover weapons and private security activities, as well as private security.

As calculated by Vedomosti, about 170 thousand people serve in the internal troops, about 30 thousand people serve in the riot police and special forces forces, and the number of private security, Federal State Unitary Enterprise Protection and licensing and permitting divisions is about 200 thousand people.

The National Guard will also engage in the fight against terrorism and organized crime. One of the objectives of the reform is to increase the efficiency of command and control of troops, but there is a transitional period in the law - for the first time, the operational control of the riot police and SOBR will be left to the Ministry of Internal Affairs, although formally they will be transferred to the Guard.

Former Commander-in-Chief of the Interior Troops of Russia, former Deputy Prime Minister - Minister of Internal Affairs, former State Duma deputy, now the head of the “Club of Military Commanders of the Russian Federation” Anatoly Kulikov told the VIEW newspaper about the difficulties that the new guard might face at first.

VIEW: Anatoly Sergeyevich, double submission always creates grounds for conflict. Will there be any disagreement between the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the new department during the “adjustment”?

Anatoly Kulikov: As of today, as stated in the decree, they have been withdrawn to the National Guard, but forces and means, for example, the same riot police and SWAT, remain under the operational control of the Minister of the Interior. As for the details, the implementation mechanism is still required. Of course, any business in the period of "grinding" carries with it difficulties for a period. Naturally, it will not be easy, but it is fixable. Practice will show.

VIEW: Why not leave it as it is? Do not leave SOBR and riot police just in the Ministry of Internal Affairs?

AK: I think so: the troops will have a better base, training methods, discipline, weapons, test sites, equipment and everything else. Including, for example, aviation control - its helicopters and airplanes. And the Ministry of Internal Affairs needs a reinforcement of some kind to help them quickly today. Suppose for the operation, for the protection of the perimeter, for the capture of a group.

Keywords: police, Ministry of Interior, Vladimir Putin, crime, police, Vladimir Kolokoltsev, law on police

VIEW: Does hardware competition, which can now begin with the National Guard and the Interior Ministry, benefit the cause? Similar to the one that unfolded at the General Prosecutor's Office with the Investigative Committee?

AK: I think this will not happen. It dealt with supervisory functions, subordination, and here there are completely different things. The troops used to be together with the police, and now they will be, so to speak, to help the police.

VIEW: One of the most important tasks that have been given to the guard is the fight against organized crime. The deputy chairman of the State Duma Security Committee, Alexander Khinshtein, complained that, as an independent line in the Ministry of Internal Affairs, it had been lost since 2008, since the abolition of the UBOP. He expressed the hope that now “own intelligence”, which explosives have, will join the fight against mafia structures. According to the deputy, such a department cannot exist without an operational component.


AK: This is the usual military intelligence. The internal troops were not the subject of operational investigative activities (PSA), since there was no law to this effect. But it was used, for example, in conducting counter-terrorist operations, operations to search for and eliminate DRG, criminal groups, armed criminals. Now, of course, the National Guard military intelligence will become the subject of operational investigative activities, because in the fight against extremism and terrorism is impossible without it. This will make the guard a full-fledged intelligence service.

VIEW: And who will follow this OSA for abuse? Previously, troops were monitored by the internal security service of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.

AK: It will be enough in the framework of the Main Command of the National Guard. It also has its own security service and military counterintelligence. There is someone there ... On the contrary, in the internal troops there has always been more order than in other structures of the Ministry of Internal Affairs - in the GUIN or in the internal affairs bodies. Mainly due to military discipline, due to greater rigor. And in the organs reigned some liberty.

Therefore, submission to the troops will be better. So I served a lot in the internal troops - from the 1963 year, starting with the school. I don’t remember any major scandal for the whole service. Yes, there were heavy emergency, death of people. But such that the frames were rotten, to show cowardice, do not perform their tasks or something else? This has never happened before me.

Corruption? Generally excluded. We had such a legendary commander of the USSR Interior Ministry Ivan Kirillovich Yakovlev. So we, the commanders of the division, were afraid to pick up the phone - to report to him. Because he skin down for the slightest incident.


Number of police / police officers per 1000 people in different countries of the world

VIEW: You are not afraid that the National Guard will reconnoiter with subcontractors from the FSB and the Interior Ministry during the hunt for extremists in their jurisdiction?

AK: Look, today there is an Investigative Committee, there is an investigative department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, there is an investigative department of the FSB. They simply have separated functions. And here will be divided, I guess. For example, street and organized crime, extremism will be for the National Guard, the rest - murder, another crime - will be in others.

At least that's exactly what we assumed more than 20 years ago, in the 1995 year when the concept was asserted. Only then we assumed to work on the model of the French gendarmerie. To free oneself, in particular, from the functions of the protection of correctional labor institutions.

We then transferred all the schools to a legal profile. The officers were taught to conduct a simplified inquiry, a protocol form to conduct an investigation in order to transfer cases to the courts, bypassing everyone so that everything was quickly and efficiently. But then, unfortunately, after 1998, everything was quickly forgotten, although Yeltsin approved the concept.

Now returned to this issue. I wonder what the powers of the National Guard officers will now be? Will they be able to conduct an inquiry, for example, in a simplified form to transfer the case to court?

VIEW: The National Guard will now oversee private security companies and will take over private security. 3 million people work in the security sector in Russia. How can they be used in the interests of the state, but without interfering with the competence of private business?

А.К .: After the First World War, according to the Versailles Treaty, Germany was allowed to have an army of no more than 100 thousand, and then almost all the officers left for the so-called small business. This is described by Erich Maria Remarque in his novels. Remember the "Black Obelisk", "Without Change on the Western Front"? Almost whole units, for example, all the officers of the company went into these structures. The Germans understood that it was necessary to preserve the officers.

So our private security companies also have a very high degree of readiness. Of course, you also need to work with them. Private security companies can do a lot to maintain stability, in the fight against illegal migration, against street crime. Although this was new to me, I did not expect this when I read the presidential decree.

VIEW: Already there are fears that the National Guard is created in order to suppress future social unrest. The former deputy chairman of the same State Duma security committee, now radical oppositionist Gennady Gudkov, told Kommersant that "the government is preparing for future shocks that are inevitable against the background of the crisis."

AK: Now you can attribute anything. The upcoming elections, the economic crisis ... But I will ask only one question. Look at Western Europe. Migration crisis, unrest - what happened in Germany on the New Year. And now what are students doing in Paris? Do we want this? Where is the golden mean? How to choose between security and human rights? What do you prefer? Most prefer safety.

The main purpose of the creation of the guard is to assess the new threats related to terror, what we observe in Western Europe. To be ready, to oppose this — this goal is pursued by reform, in my view. This is a justified measure.
Author:
Originator:
http://www.vz.ru/politics/2016/4/6/803915.html
120 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Abbra
    Abbra April 8 2016 21: 37
    +17
    In any case, an interesting interview ...Corruption? Generally excluded. Eh, I would like to sincerely believe ...
    1. RUS96
      RUS96 April 8 2016 21: 52
      +1
      Not on this topic .. but still interesting.
      Russia helped free American in Syria at Obama's personal request
      http://tvzvezda.ru/news/vstrane_i_mire/content/201604082118-akus.htm
    2. neo.
      neo. April 8 2016 22: 24
      +29
      Quote: A. Kulikov
      Let's say street and organized crime, extremism will be behind the National Guard
      Something I did not understand: the President needs a directly subordinate National Guard to combat street and organized crime?
      What the hell for ... belay And the police will do what.
      Extremism. (but it seems like the Federal Security Service is better suited within the meaning).
      It seems to me, gentlemen, that someone does not finish something on this issue.
      1. Reserve officer
        Reserve officer April 8 2016 23: 00
        +16
        Putin’s guards appeared. A word for Medvedev - we are waiting for the musketeer regiment.
        1. sabakina
          sabakina April 8 2016 23: 27
          +2
          Quote: Stock Officer
          Putin’s guards appeared. A word for Medvedev - we are waiting for the musketeer regiment.

          Putin and cardinal-meddedev & guards are incompatible things. Stop, the beer has affected. Putin as guards, Mededev as musketeers ... What am I? drank? In short, "oprichnina" and truncated will be all right!
      2. Nik_One
        Nik_One April 9 2016 01: 55
        +10
        There are several reasons for the formation of the National Guard:
        1 - Given the re-subordination of the FSKN and the Migration Service of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, it turns out to be too strong a special service, which must be limited by separating the explosives and special forces into a separate structure.
        2 - In the light of the events, it is necessary to remove the power component from the direct subordination of the departments of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the regions and national republics.
        3 - Restructuring and optimization of the management of internal armed forces and special forces under a trusted leader directly reporting to the President.
        1. The comment was deleted.
        2. Nosgoth
          Nosgoth April 12 2016 10: 39
          -2
          all items "past the checkout" :-)
      3. Blondy
        Blondy April 9 2016 04: 12
        -4
        Quote: neo.
        It seems to me, gentlemen, that someone does not finish something on this issue.

        Of course they do not agree, all the more, well, they just cannot, so that the name of the mattress mats does not rip off. They would call it modestly "Imperial Guard" (we still have a multinational state) and all the reservations would disappear, and everyone would understand everything.
      4. Alexander 67
        Alexander 67 April 9 2016 06: 26
        +3
        What about the police? Almost 2/3 of the entire state is the so-called public security police, subordinate to the municipal level. She will continue to deal with problems at the household level. For example, in the United States there is a municipal level, an institute of sheriffs and the federal police, the FBI. As for the FSB, since the days of the KGB of the USSR, this is more of an analytical level. And most importantly. We have to do something with the police. And to clean the rot from these "Augean stables" can be a related structure, but not subordinate to the Ministry of Internal Affairs. Therefore, they do not say that the authors themselves probably have not quite decided on the technical side of the issue.
      5. sgazeev
        sgazeev April 9 2016 06: 52
        0
        Quote: neo.
        Quote: A. Kulikov
        Let's say street and organized crime, extremism will be behind the National Guard
        Something I did not understand: the President needs a directly subordinate National Guard to combat street and organized crime?
        What the hell for ... belay And the police will do what.
        Extremism. (but it seems like the Federal Security Service is better suited within the meaning).
        It seems to me, gentlemen, that someone does not finish something on this issue.

        It's time to take on the godfathers.
      6. Oden280
        Oden280 April 9 2016 10: 42
        +8
        That’s all garbage. To fight crime, anyone needs an opera with a good agent network, which has been developed for years. Good opera will not go to this sharashka, it’s good for them in the Ministry of Internal Affairs. Because of their departmental specifics, the divorce divisions of the explosive are suitable for working in conflict zones, but to catch the fugitives in conjunction with zonovy godfathers. If they rely on OMON and SOBR, then in vain. Riot police didn’t do any operational work, and the Special Operations Regiment would disperse into departments, so as not to risk the length of service and ranks.
        1. hohkn
          hohkn April 9 2016 19: 21
          +2
          Quote: Oden280
          SOBR will disperse into departments, so as not to risk the length of service and ranks.

          Why are you so sure of that? Until now, nothing really is known. Trial the states will come only in the summer (I guess by the end of the summer). And then there will be food for thought. And until 2017, there is still a car (until 2017, according to the Decree, even old service certificates are still valid), and until 2018 (when they will transfer riot police, special police forces, private security guards and permits for military service) and even more. I think the issue with professionals from the bay-flounder will not be resolved.
      7. Nosgoth
        Nosgoth April 12 2016 10: 37
        -1
        The FSB oversees terrorism more; extremism is the police. But terrorism and extremism (secondary functions) intersect both there and there.
    3. snifer
      snifer April 8 2016 22: 41
      -6
      small exercises of the national guard
      1. 34 region
        34 region April 8 2016 23: 07
        +4
        Sniffer! 22.41. Judging by the plot, this is a type of Maidan. Considered the experience so to speak. But there, in addition to dispersing the crowd, it was necessary to disperse the top leadership of the outskirts. Perhaps this was also taken into account. With a squabble, there will be a seizure of leadership supporting the squabble. Expedited interrogation and in court.
      2. avva2012
        avva2012 April 8 2016 23: 12
        +16
        If the teachings are secret, then where the video comes from. Tynos agentos?
      3. Foofighter
        Foofighter April 9 2016 02: 06
        +7
        This is not the same Kulikov, who, along with his Mercedes Pasha, the popular uprising of 1993 against Yeltsin in Moscow suppressed?
        wikipedia.org/wiki/Kulikov_Anatoly_Sergeevich
        "An active participant in the events in Moscow in October 1993 on the side of President B. N."
        1. Mahmut
          Mahmut April 9 2016 05: 57
          +11
          This is the expert who drove the first Chechen prosl. L into the Grozny boiler, and then dumped everything on Lebed.
        2. RUSS
          RUSS April 9 2016 09: 23
          +6
          Quote: FooFighter
          This is not the same Kulikov, who, along with his Mercedes Pasha, the popular uprising of 1993 against Yeltsin in Moscow suppressed?

          Well then, remember Shoigu when, in 93, he brought for Yeltsin’s supporters a truckload of machine guns taken from Moscow’s GrazhdOborona warehouses that were under his control and intended to equip the Moscow militia in the event of World War III.
      4. The comment was deleted.
      5. Prapor-527
        Prapor-527 April 9 2016 06: 32
        +9
        These are not exercises, but demonstrations. They are held regularly, with the obligatory invitation of a bunch of "writing people". I personally took part several times. But this "show" is preceded by real grueling workouts - with knocked out teeth, dislocated joints, and other "delights". Journalists have nothing to do there, and the sound will have to be edited - solid "PI-PI-PI" ...
        1. Chiropractor
          Chiropractor April 9 2016 09: 54
          +7
          I confirm - on a regular basis, speeches are held, covered by magazines.
          Disorder comes - the entire free squad of the city SOBR "plays", for example, football fans, and VVs practice their schemes.
          As a result, we come to the point in tracksuits, shout, swagger at the "cosmonauts", they push us back, divide and neutralize us. Whatever hero you are, only such a system can work against a spent system.
          And all this accompanied by the chirping of fotik, the work of the "calculation" of video cameras.
  2. Dr. Bormental
    Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 21: 39
    +22
    The so-called. liberals - "police state!" No need to get out - you won't get a club on the ridge. In St. Petersburg, they used to drink in the subway, and on the streets, now it is sooooo rare to meet a person with a beer in his hand. I am personally glad. We have such a mentality that we need to intimidate, then there will be less rubbish.
    1. avva2012
      avva2012 April 8 2016 21: 45
      +6
      Quote: Dr. Bormental No need to snuggle up - you won’t get a club on the ridge.

      Which, this is a liberal, if he does not curse himself. Under the root chop. They don’t want to go along the ridge, but YOU. want to. The Guard, its very existence, is already a threat to democratic values, because, according to the Law, it is possible to get a real grudge. Oh, do not want to. laughing
      1. Dr. Bormental
        Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 21: 59
        +24
        In my "nourishing" years, too, liberal white tape ideas slipped through my head, I confess. And then, as the mess with Ukraine went - he immediately "sobered up" - an excellent example of what the so-called "Sober" wants to do with us. "west". So if the creation of the National Guard improves something ... only for hi
        1. avva2012
          avva2012 April 8 2016 22: 15
          +6
          And then, as the mess with Ukraine went - he immediately "sobered up" - an excellent example of what the so-called Kevin wants to do with us. "west". So if the creation of the National Guard improves something ... only for

          Yes, partners overdone with Ukraine. Well, they also stopped pouring so much informational dung on their heads. Or so to speak, a different opinion has appeared. Nadia is the last to die, so we'll see. hi
          1. Dr. Bormental
            Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 22: 30
            +3
            Quote: avva2012
            Yes, partners overdone with Ukraine

            I am not surprised. It is worth recalling the classics - Bulgakov, Sholokhov, Babel - it all happened already, nothing new happens in Ukraine. The trouble is probably that we read these authors, but they do not. hi
            1. avva2012
              avva2012 April 8 2016 23: 09
              +6
              Quote: Dr. Bormental The trouble is probably that we read these authors, but they do not.

              Yes, they didn’t read anything. Not when. There was a feeling, apparently, that there was a little bit left, here she is, already in her paws. And they know much better what is happening with the towers in the Kremlin. The President did what was not expected. Knockdown. A partner has sailed. They began to play rudely, because the compromising evidence published was already a loss. It has at least some value if it causes concern that information will become available. They threatened, but they were not afraid. Brute force. And, the guard, in my opinion, this is just in case. To know. After all, a person does not need to break his jaw at every step, if others have information that he is a master of sports in boxing?
          2. The comment was deleted.
          3. The comment was deleted.
          4. sgazeev
            sgazeev April 9 2016 07: 04
            +2
            Quote: avva2012
            And then, as the mess with Ukraine went - he immediately "sobered up" - an excellent example of what the so-called Kevin wants to do with us. "west". So if the creation of the National Guard improves something ... only for

            Yes, partners overdone with Ukraine. Well, they also stopped pouring so much informational dung on their heads. Or so to speak, a different opinion has appeared. Nadia is the last to die, so we'll see. hi
          5. Koshak
            Koshak April 9 2016 21: 27
            +2
            Quote: avva2012
            Yes, partners overdone with Ukraine.

            They also sat down in a puddle with the opposition of the white ribbon. According to Kasyanov, you can see how he, grown by the overwork of the Parnas partners, is thrusting deeper into the ass. What kind of director is writing them scripts in Washington? Apparently the same one who invented the moronic Svidomye races.
        2. midivan
          midivan April 8 2016 23: 05
          +4
          Quote: Dr. Bormental
          In my "nourishing" years, too, liberal white tape ideas slipped through my head, I confess. And then, as the mess with Ukraine went, I instantly "sobered up"

          uh doc! et white-haired little ideas were laughing "our" belolentochniks do not care about everything, even the outskirts, but even though Moscow is on fire, they will not give up on their own wink repentance accepted drinks hi
          1. Dr. Bormental
            Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 23: 08
            +1
            Positive blowing from your words ... approving fellow drinks
          2. The comment was deleted.
        3. The comment was deleted.
        4. sgazeev
          sgazeev April 9 2016 07: 00
          +4
          Quote: Dr. Bormental
          In my "nourishing" years, too, liberal white tape ideas slipped through my head, I confess. And then, as the mess with Ukraine went - he immediately "sobered up" - an excellent example of what the so-called "Sober" wants to do with us. "west". So if the creation of the National Guard improves something ... only for hi
      2. The comment was deleted.
      3. Bayonet
        Bayonet April 9 2016 07: 15
        +1
        Quote: avva2012
        The Guard, its very existence, is already a threat to democratic values

        And what is the threat? Democratic values ​​are the freedom, justice and sovereignty of Russia. This is the equality of all citizens before the law. smile
        1. sa-ag
          sa-ag April 9 2016 07: 35
          +5
          Quote: Bayonet
          This is the equality of all citizens before the law.

          Some truth is more equal than others :-)
        2. avva2012
          avva2012 April 9 2016 08: 40
          0
          Quote: Bayonet And what is the threat? Democratic values ​​are the freedom, justice and sovereignty of Russia. This is the equality of all citizens before the law.

          Out of context, why did they pull out the proposal or am I not clear about what freedoms the commentary wrote? laughing There, the continuation below followed. Spoiled phone, damn it. Here it is, yes, there is no comment below, promptly!
          1. Bayonet
            Bayonet April 11 2016 20: 43
            0
            Quote: avva2012
            Out of context, why did they pull out the proposal or am I not clear about what freedoms the commentary wrote?

            About those that I cited in my comment.
            "The Guard, its very existence, is already a threat to democratic values" - your words? Or do you interpret democratic values ​​differently?request
    2. Galich Kos
      Galich Kos April 8 2016 21: 55
      -3
      Quote: Dr. Bormental
      The so-called. liberals - "police state!"



      And if not liberals, they will also start? Or do you have liberals who do not smoke in your window and don’t sit on your toilet?
      1. Dr. Bormental
        Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 22: 03
        +6
        Well, go ahead. Start by saying that "you" on this resource is said only to acquaintances. And then at the discretion ...
        1. Galich Kos
          Galich Kos April 8 2016 22: 12
          -14%
          On "YOU" I speak with everyone on the Internet, regardless of ranks and titles, do not blame me. You do not deserve the appeal "YOU" .., but you just do not deserve it and that's it!
          By the way, the chief physician of my little Galich that in the Kostroma province was removed from office for the death (murder) of a baby!
          1. 34 region
            34 region April 8 2016 22: 54
            +7
            Galich Kos! 22.12/XNUMX. There is a version that in Russia, an appeal to YOU ​​meant an expression of disrespect. Like you are a rare bastard! And the respected were addressed to YOU. Indeed, in our midst we all poke. Such an appeal of trust. But you should not be rude. hi
            1. The comment was deleted.
          2. EvgNik
            EvgNik April 9 2016 05: 44
            +3
            Quote: Galich Kos
            On "YOU" I speak with everyone on the Internet, regardless of ranks and titles

            Darling, this is called rudeness, echoes of poor education. And to be rude, as I noticed, you are used to everything in a row.
        2. The comment was deleted.
          1. Dr. Bormental
            Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 22: 38
            +7
            Quote: Galich Kos
            You do not deserve the appeal "YOU" .., but you just do not deserve it and that's it!


            Quote: Galich Kos
            Yes, you are one of those acquaintances whom you do not want to meet ..

            Dear Galich Kos! I did not claim to get to know you. I expressed my opinion about the article, you do not agree with him, I do not agree with your opinion - nevertheless, I heard you, you, me. For this, VO exists to communicate and possibly to discuss. The only thing that did not understand what I had to do with the murder of the baby ..
            1. Galich Kos
              Galich Kos April 8 2016 22: 54
              -9
              VO and debate? You yourself, then realized what he said?
              1. Dr. Bormental
                Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 23: 00
                0
                I realized what I said. I can repeat it. hi
                1. The comment was deleted.
                  1. midivan
                    midivan April 8 2016 23: 45
                    +6
                    Quote: Galich Kos
                    Dear burmentul, I can assure you that you and others like takin zh stupid starlings like you ..

                    as I understand it, I can safely assume that your circle of communication is exclusively sharp.
                    1. Galich Kos
                      Galich Kos April 8 2016 23: 51
                      -5
                      You can pretend anything you like, including that!
                      1. 79807420129
                        79807420129 April 9 2016 00: 23
                        +13
                        Quote: Galich Kos
                        You can pretend anything you like, including that!

                        But I can assume that you fool and boor, countrywoman damn fucking.
                      2. Dym71
                        Dym71 April 9 2016 00: 37
                        +2
                        Quote: 79807420129
                        Countrywoman damn horseradish.


                        I’m on you brothers laughing
                        Vlad, why is your countrywoman? He is from Kostroma, and you are from Yarik.
                      3. sgazeev
                        sgazeev April 9 2016 07: 23
                        0
                        Quote: Dym71
                        Quote: 79807420129
                        Countrywoman damn horseradish.


                        I’m on you brothers laughing
                        Vlad, why is your countrywoman? He is from Kostroma, and you are from Yarik.

                        I don’t want to offend Kostroma’s, but I understand their joyless life with the local ghouls in power. Some, escaping on the Yaroslavl highway, press the trigger on the gun, violating all traffic rules, just to feel the whistle of the wind in their ears and leave this swamp. on God. Observation when traveling from Moscow to Yaroslavl, not to be confused with Petersburg to Moscow.
              2. Dym71
                Dym71 April 9 2016 00: 10
                +3
                Quote: Galich Kos
                Dear burmentulya, I can assure you that you and others like takin zh stupid starlings that you ....


                Lesh! laughing Tie up after taking the wine in VO to be delayed, chesslovo ...! lol
                1. Galich Kos
                  Galich Kos April 9 2016 00: 21
                  -1
                  I didn’t ask you))) You better stick a finger behind and stretch it at your point ...
                  1. Dym71
                    Dym71 April 9 2016 00: 52
                    +6
                    Quote: Galich Kos
                    I didn’t ask you)))


                    I understand this, but the rest is disgusting to what? request
          2. The comment was deleted.
          3. vsoltan
            vsoltan April 8 2016 23: 13
            +7
            Gentlemen moderators! Turn it off. .... Galich Kos, finally! Why do you allow rudeness on the site?
            1. Dym71
              Dym71 April 9 2016 00: 43
              +3
              Quote: vsoltan
              Gentlemen moderators!


              What moderators do you have at 23:13 Moscow time? Oh and rzhaka today ..laughing
        3. sgazeev
          sgazeev April 9 2016 07: 07
          +1
          Quote: Dr. Bormental
          Quote: Galich Kos
          You do not deserve the appeal "YOU" .., but you just do not deserve it and that's it!


          Quote: Galich Kos
          Yes, you are one of those acquaintances whom you do not want to meet ..

          Dear Galich Kos! I did not claim to get to know you. I expressed my opinion about the article, you do not agree with him, I do not agree with your opinion - nevertheless, I heard you, you, me. For this, VO exists to communicate and possibly to discuss. The only thing that did not understand what I had to do with the murder of the baby ..

          He was drunk and did not own his head laughing
      2. The comment was deleted.
    3. 34 region
      34 region April 8 2016 22: 49
      +2
      Dr. Bormental! 22.03/XNUMX. But what about the appeal to God. After all, everyone is turning to him at YOU! God save us (me)! After all, an appeal to YOU ​​is brought from outside. Well, the emperor wanted to be elevated and ordered to call him in the plural. Well, Peter the Great introduced this to emphasize inequality. But what about brotherly YOU? Especially here in VO.
      1. Dr. Bormental
        Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 22: 57
        +5
        I don’t know where God and Peter I are, and I was taught to turn to strangers at YOU. You can ask your interlocutor for permission to communicate with you. In St. Petersburg, this is customary.
        1. 34 region
          34 region April 8 2016 23: 16
          +3
          Dr. Bormental! 22.57. I understand that so taught. Although to me personally such an appeal is unpleasant. Gives obsluzoblyudom. Unpleasantly like that. About politeness. I communicate with people and observe an interesting pattern. Fans of appeal to YOU ​​are very scandalous. The debate on VO confirms this. As soon as a person addresses (and requires an appeal) to you, then wait for the scandal. Here already in life you begin to strain from weeping. Like YOU, so hitting. Why am I? Maybe you shouldn’t react so violently if you consider yourself so cultural? No offense. hi
          1. midivan
            midivan April 8 2016 23: 51
            +6
            Quote: Region 34
            Dr. Bormental! 22.57. I understand that so taught. Although to me personally such an appeal is unpleasant. Gives obsluzoblyudom.

            heard the saying about someone else’s monastery? here create your site, set the rules and if it is admissible it will be interesting to me, I will accept them
            1. 34 region
              34 region April 9 2016 00: 07
              +2
              Midivan! 23.51. What does your site and rules have to do with it? People just expressed their opinions. What is the crime?
              1. midivan
                midivan April 9 2016 01: 04
                +6
                Quote: 34 region
                Midivan! 23.51. What does your site and rules have to do with it? People just expressed their opinions. What is the crime?

                site rules state- On our site you need to behave respectfully to all visitors to the site.
          2. sa-ag
            sa-ag April 9 2016 07: 38
            +2
            Quote: Region 34
            Here already in life you begin to strain from weeping.

            Relax, it's just a polite, respectful appeal to you, it's a pity that it bothers you
      2. The comment was deleted.
    4. The comment was deleted.
  3. The comment was deleted.
  • lwxx
    lwxx April 8 2016 22: 36
    +7
    Judging by your logic We have a mentality that needs to be intimidated, then there will be less rubbish it is necessary for "a bull thrown by the urn" immediately shot on the spot. We have a police state, judging by the number of security officials. But at the same time, there is little DPS and PPS on the streets, but there are a lot of cabinet-type ones, and it increases after each reform and reduction. People must be brought up from childhood: threw garbage on the road - grunt, threw it in the presence of children, grunt twice - children will grow up to be pigs.
    1. Dr. Bormental
      Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 22: 51
      +3
      I agree with you! However, our Russian mentality, unfortunately, is designed in such a way that if it’s possible to shit with impunity in an elevator, we’ll shit, spit in the face of a defenseless person, please beat a wife in a drunken state-easily ... I repeat-with impunity. Personally, I'm for a tough stranglehold that will bring us back to reality.
      1. Red jack
        Red jack April 8 2016 23: 52
        -7
        Start yourself, tighten your beloved Stolypin tie around your neck
  • kinolog2322
    kinolog2322 April 9 2016 00: 00
    0
    Not so rare, I want to note. In the center, yes.
  • Red_Hamer
    Red_Hamer April 9 2016 03: 25
    +5
    Napoleon about the demonstration “ It was necessary to sweep away 500-600 people with guns - the rest would have fled!”- on the day of the assault on the Tuileries and the overthrow of Louis 16 - Napoleon was again on the street and called the revolutionaries“ the most heinous mob ”. These are those who were seated on the throne, himself.
  • vsoltan
    vsoltan April 8 2016 21: 41
    +7
    Kulikov is a decent person, but in setting out his own opinion he adheres only to the official version. .. however, in a different way it is not supposed to. There is no information in the article, everyone has already said the magazine.
    1. sa-ag
      sa-ag April 9 2016 07: 43
      +1
      Quote: vsoltan
      adheres only to the official version.

      "... Let's say street and organized crime, extremism will be behind the National Guard, the rest - murder, other crime - others will."

      Is organized crime like boys from a children's choir, and it’s impossible to kill for them? In general, in my opinion, this whole structure is created for another, here personal power is at stake. And in general, an interesting situation - the bureaucrats and the power apparatus are being increased, numerically increased, not allocated to health care, not to education, not to science, not to industry as a whole, this is evidence of the strengthening of personal power, one of the musicians said, the string sounds best before burst...
  • Mavrikiy
    Mavrikiy April 8 2016 21: 47
    +1
    Or maybe it’s not so. A structure with a distant sight has been created. And the ultimate goal of the power structure is not the fight against terrorists who are unhappy and dissenting. Purpose: Private security companies with the protection of aligarchs.
    1. avva2012
      avva2012 April 8 2016 21: 53
      +3
      Quote: Mavrikiy Purpose: Private security companies with the protection of aligarchs.

      And why, then the President? And oligarchs, is that name or surname? how, will it divide NG to thresh each other? Is there really a technique when you need to bring any thought to the point of absurdity, but managing the state is not psychological training for housewives?
  • Monos
    Monos April 8 2016 21: 54
    +5
    One thing is obvious - this is the only power structure that directly reports to the President. And for what and why? Yes, the President knows him !?
    1. Sergej1972
      Sergej1972 April 9 2016 14: 34
      0
      All power structures are directly subordinate to the president.
  • Hauptam
    Hauptam April 8 2016 21: 59
    +2
    A lot of incomprehensible - why fence a garden? Make those who work work, I think easier and cheaper.
  • a.hamster55
    a.hamster55 April 8 2016 22: 00
    +14
    What is brewing! Why would the number of FSO, FSB, NG and the Ministry of Internal Affairs exceed the number of aircraft? The answer is the internal contradictions of the population! In the distant 1975 year, the director of KhTZ received a salary of about 600 rubles. , and the milling machine at the same factory 200-400 rub. Now compare how modern hard workers and their leaders get it!
    1. Dr. Bormental
      Dr. Bormental April 8 2016 22: 12
      +4
      I don’t know how much modern hard workers and their managers get, only I, the doctor, ride the subway (I can’t afford a car), and next to me there is a department where the plumbers on duty at the hospital - almost all are in cars (and not bad at all) .
      P.S. I've already heard the joke about "who studied what")))
      1. vsoltan
        vsoltan April 8 2016 23: 15
        +3
        I do not agree, colleague. .. paper removers in hospitals earn even more than technical staff. ..
  • a.hamster55
    a.hamster55 April 8 2016 22: 14
    0
    Work in a modern enterprise oriented to the West is very difficult! In our province they are compared with the Zone! Yes it is - knowledge of Western quality standards and a lot of set-offs confirming your knowledge are required! Therefore, he left - according to 5-7 offsets per year, this is too much.
  • cobalt
    cobalt April 8 2016 22: 14
    +4
    Where is the riot police and where is the licensed service, they crossed a fly with a rhinoceros, some kind of nonsense, if I used to check the conditions of storage of weapons by the district police officer, and the license was issued by the licensor, but they were from the same department and were subordinate to one common boss, then this worked fine, then it worked, then Now how it will work is not clear. First of all, the district police officer will do his job, until another agency instructs him, he will have dopey, the licensors will have about 5 people in the regional center, how they will manage to bypass people and issue licenses is not clear.
  • raid14
    raid14 April 8 2016 22: 16
    +5
    The article is about nothing, a new law enforcement structure is being created for specific tasks, here they have gathered everything in one pile, the fight against terrorism, (the powers of the FSB), extremism (GUEP MIA), private security companies and intelligence dragged in, it turned out a "fancy" NKVD-SMERSH to fight with all known and unknown crimes.
  • Papapg
    Papapg April 8 2016 22: 19
    +2
    “The troops will have a better base, training methods, discipline, weapons, test sites, equipment and everything else. Including its helicopters and airplanes "

    According to the long-term experience of mankind, all generations have such dreams, but no one has been able to fully master this "package". The RF Armed Forces are against external enemies, and the National Team-2 is against internal ones. It will be interesting to see some kind of result.
  • erased
    erased April 8 2016 22: 24
    +5
    Two points of the new concept are especially pleasing - to pick up cars and break into houses without orders. Who has a good car and a packed hut - think about it. It can become a stranger at any time. Like values.
    That's what annoys.
  • pashtinio
    pashtinio April 8 2016 22: 24
    +6
    It's a shame that the collector at the defense enterprise receives the same amount as the loader in Pyaterochka ... There is no excitement, but somehow it’s not at all ...
  • cobalt
    cobalt April 8 2016 22: 25
    +7
    And it’s still unclear how the Sobr will now be involved in the force support of the operations of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. If earlier it was one department, they gave a general order and immediately went to the detention and the opera and the on-duty unit of the congregation, but now, for example, Friday, at 17 o’clock in the evening the Opera received information, they need to take a ride, they need to write a request to bring in the congregation, they bring it, and the girl from the office collect - leave the request, the boss has already left, will review on Monday and sign you, that’s all the efficiency in the fight against organized crime, will be covered with a copper basin and broken into instructions, orders and endless interagency coordination and other bureaucratic troubles.
  • marshes
    marshes April 8 2016 22: 32
    -2
    Eat your event.
    We, Kazakhstan, when the NGs formed, there was less noise. First, such as the Presidential Guard, the company of the Honor Guard, security and special forces KOKZHAL. smile
    In 2014, Nezavisimaya Gazeta became different, VV was introduced and subordination to the Ministry of Internal Affairs.
    Now it’s funny to read your portals about NG, damn event. smile
  • From Samara
    From Samara April 8 2016 22: 37
    +3
    Why was the SOBR taken away? Who, for example, will now cover gatherings of thieves in law?
    1. midivan
      midivan April 8 2016 23: 32
      +5
      Quote: From Samara
      Why was the SOBR taken away? Who, for example, will now cover gatherings of thieves in law?

      why cover them? what would then release? let them converge or cover them so that they are forgotten as a "class" (with wooden jackets). How long can I play thug romance I don't understand? it feels like when cars move through the air, they will plow through space and plant apples on Mars, our "thieves" will drive chifir in a circle, and who are the current thieves laughing? sat down for rape but set up a gerych path to the thief’s zone laughing
      1. From Samara
        From Samara April 9 2016 03: 48
        +1
        belay There are many police where special forces are needed, the detention of armed criminals, raids of drug traffickers, drug dealers, the protection of witnesses, assistance in carrying out legal proceedings where they interfere ... and many others ...
        1. midivan
          midivan April 9 2016 08: 08
          +5
          Quote: From Samara
          belay There are many police where special forces are needed, the detention of armed criminals, raids of drug traffickers, drug dealers, the protection of witnesses, assistance in carrying out legal proceedings where they interfere ... and many others ...

          LOOK: One of the most important tasks assigned to the guard is the fight against organized crime.
          1. From Samara
            From Samara April 9 2016 11: 13
            +2
            Our crime creates far from organized crime on the streets ...
            1. midivan
              midivan April 9 2016 21: 01
              +3
              Quote: From Samara
              Our crime creates far from organized crime on the streets ...

              who? I do not think that the "romantics" of loners pose a serious danger, but it is with organizations that you need to start, although judging by your ava, you may know better, by the way, do not enlighten smile? otherwise I could not find what kind of emblem
              1. From Samara
                From Samara April 10 2016 00: 19
                +2
                The organized crime groups are integrated into the economy and politics, therefore, it threatens the national security of the state. Street crime, if it has organized structures, is usually not sustainable ... street crime is very diverse and motley.

                GRU
                1. midivan
                  midivan April 13 2016 07: 43
                  +3
                  Quote: From Samara
                  The organized crime groups are integrated into the economy and politics, therefore, it threatens the national security of the state. Street crime, if it has organized structures, is usually not sustainable ... street crime is very diverse and motley.

                  GRU

                  but understood smile I’m not talking about it a bit, they did not understand each other. belay well respect hi drinks otherwise I thought you weren’t left and the smaller brothers caught laughing (joke)
  • Monos
    Monos April 8 2016 22: 38
    +8
    That's what I thought: in 2 of the year, what have we got? That's right, the presidential election! And what without stopping screaming pindo (sr. N) tsy? Right! They screech that our President is wrong. And the wrong President is usually changed to the right. About the way it was with the neighbors. In such a situation, troops with the appropriate powers in the operational management of the President - that’s it!
    1. Alexdark
      Alexdark April 9 2016 05: 56
      +1
      But that’s the difference. For the same words I get cons. What are our many-sided regulars.
  • iliitchitch
    iliitchitch April 8 2016 22: 49
    +6
    Enough already stroking the ass already. Voryo STATE fattens, and according to statistics 52 pieces on average "in the hospital" people get on their paws. WHERE IS IT ??? Uncle Vova, it's time to solve the issues INSIDE, and not to omit these dolbo-Americans. They are stupid, but we are not, these chelas will bend themselves. What, are we waiting for the Lena mines? So get it. It's good to test people's patience. The Romanovs played out in their time, we do not need a continuation.
  • lukke
    lukke April 8 2016 22: 50
    +4
    To be honest, I didn’t see anything so innovative that this interview would fundamentally change the situation - another confirmation. French experience ?! Oh well...
  • midivan
    midivan April 8 2016 23: 22
    +5
    here the "liberals" need to rejoice, the GDP itself can be said to have cut a leg, since NG will obey personally, then you will not be able to get out and any state of emergency will cast a shadow on the President, the conclusion is that the GDP is confident in this undertaking and will answer personally , I don’t know about you, but this gives me hope for the best, but I still have to live before the elections smile
  • atamankko
    atamankko April 8 2016 23: 31
    0
    I didn’t learn anything new from the interview; the journalists already had everything.
  • lexx2038
    lexx2038 April 8 2016 23: 36
    +3
    Or maybe Uncle Vova is preparing to restore order in the country? After all, it is not visible with an armed look that inside the country, they are not given to steer it properly, and therefore the people are already slowly starting to boil, and the elections are coming up. After all, it is very difficult to deal with the oligarchy almost alone - you can lose your head (remember, they hinted at it — a hole in the head). The oligarchs, because they begin to unite in danger, lead a circular defense - there is a lot of money, there is also an administrative resource and, if desired, they can put the whole country on the ears. So our most important one is trying to create an internal army, his own, not smeared with vice, imprisoned on the almighty gods who are soothed with impunity. And for us, ordinary people, it’s enough for the eyes of what is already there - what can be created there.
    1. lukke
      lukke April 8 2016 23: 43
      +2
      After all, it is clear with an unarmed look that inside the country, they are not given to steer it properly
      ??? the elders in the yard drive? all sixteen years in power ...
      1. lexx2038
        lexx2038 April 9 2016 00: 12
        +4
        Well, the flies on the window mate quickly, but state affairs, especially of such a large country, cannot be worked out on a swoop. Previously, it was necessary to restore the status of "KVO", otherwise, if it had started earlier, we would have received a revolution by analogy with Ukraine and external intervention, and then the Western bearers of democracy would not have allowed us to rise from our knees. After all, he was able to restore the army without advertising, and when he showed it, all the bearers of "good" were unpleasantly surprised, but they were sure that we, except with Georgia, were not capable of fighting with anyone, and in this regard, they wrote us off for a long time. won, and the medals were already distributed to everyone, we were confident, and we disappointed them again) Now the time has come - to joke around in our bins.
        These are of course my personal conclusions, but I really hope that this is so.
        1. iliitchitch
          iliitchitch April 9 2016 15: 24
          0
          The Praetorian Guard was created more than once or twice, the result was sad in Okontsovo. But something must be done. Our state is ZHLOBSKY (not to be confused with the Motherland) since the time of the Communists, it’s sucking your grandmother and strength out of you — and on exhaust 0, you run on crutches for three kopeks, and then a fat toad in the penfond almost spits you, I don’t care she has your problems, although she sits there to solve your problems. We’ll see, we’ll see ... When they announced the ONF, I was against it, but nothing, at least there is some kind of return on them, the country begins to recognize its thieves. Let's wait for the praetorians.
  • Jozhkin Cat
    Jozhkin Cat April 9 2016 00: 19
    0
    oh her, now put yourself in the place of Putin, and ask yourself a question, but would you not have made your PERSONAL army? I would first of all, the state of the FSO has inflated thousands to 200, because there are many large cities, in which case it will be necessary to hold power on a vast territory. I understand why he needs a guard, everything is right, the main thing, in my opinion, is not to BE LATE by force, otherwise it will be worse, people won’t understand right away, grab the axes and riot, severe and merciless. And so we’ll wake up in the morning and the beautiful presenter will say the news, , Tonight, the guardsmen detained the heads and governments of such regions, they are charged with article 275 of the Russian Federation. an investigation is being conducted. laughing
    1. avva2012
      avva2012 April 9 2016 01: 04
      +3
      Quote: Jozhkin the Cat Tonight the guardsmen detained the heads and governments of such regions, they are charged with an article 275 uk rf. an investigation is being conducted.

      Words and music are folk. laughing I want to hear, but it's nice to read! hi
    2. Ugrumiy
      Ugrumiy April 9 2016 02: 27
      +4
      The 275th Criminal Code of the Russian Federation is under the exclusive jurisdiction of the FSB, if they give the go-ahead, this rag-tag will be enough for "Alpha". Hence the question, why then the National Guard?
      1. Cat man null
        Cat man null April 9 2016 02: 36
        -1
        Quote: Ugrumiy
        if they give the go-ahead, there will be enough for this riffraff and "Alpha". Hence the question, why then the National Guard?

        Children's task:

        - how many cities (of regional significance, for example) in the Russian Federation?
        - how many people can simultaneously allocate Alpha to each such city? Okay, not for every one, but for every third, for example?

        Do not forget that "regional bosses" (not to mention the larger ones) can (and probably do):

        - informants in "their" Ministry of Internal Affairs
        - small "PMCs"

        Total: Are you still sure that Alpha is enough? wink
        1. From Samara
          From Samara April 9 2016 03: 53
          +4
          FSB special forces are in every regional center ...
      2. Jozhkin Cat
        Jozhkin Cat April 9 2016 02: 43
        +1
        in the Criminal Code there isn’t like a straightforward clear decree on jurisdiction under article 275. and it doesn’t matter. Probably there will be a lot of riffraffers. Yes, and what a sin to conceal, a dozen rallies of ordinary people will still have to be dispersed, otherwise they can outgrow into completely disgusting things (
        1. avva2012
          avva2012 April 9 2016 02: 50
          -1
          a dozen rallies of ordinary people will still have to disperse, otherwise they can outgrow into completely disgusting things (

          There is hope that this will not come to this. And the Praetorians will still play the role of a hint of possible complications in someone’s fate. How much the tumor will be possible, bloodless, removed in the head, that’s the question. If successful, metastases will subside, everyone will think that they will carry.
          1. Jozhkin Cat
            Jozhkin Cat April 9 2016 02: 59
            +2
            by the way, I’m thinking about metastases, because it’s not a secret, and a sighted person sees what is happening in the state apparatus. As a result, the question torments me, does he have a personnel reserve? because tens of thousands will have to be planted ...
            1. avva2012
              avva2012 April 9 2016 03: 10
              -1
              Tens of thousands, that's a lot. There are always few locomotives, the rest without counselor, they will not pose a threat. OP, maybe there is a reserve. In Moscow, I wonder what rumors are circulating? In the capital, they always either know or guess.
              1. Jozhkin Cat
                Jozhkin Cat April 9 2016 03: 16
                +2
                not, if you clean all the rot to healthy meat. otherwise later, they will become more cunning and meaner. Moscow she is always on her mind, like Peter.
                1. avva2012
                  avva2012 April 9 2016 03: 26
                  +1
                  This is certainly better. But the question, again, is "personnel?" If the games about approving the work of the government were in order to find these personnel in sufficient quantities, then, yes, it is better at once (although tens of thousands, it is still a lot). Okay, the watch is over. Good luck!
        2. Cat man null
          Cat man null April 9 2016 03: 10
          -2
          Quote: Yozhkin Cat
          Probably there will be a lot of riffraffers. Yes, and what a sin to conceal, a dozen rallies of ordinary people still have to disperse, otherwise they can outgrow into completely disgusting things (

          - IMHO this is what the "local" OMON will cope with.
          - but the withdrawal of this "local" OMON from subordination to the "local" Ministry of Internal Affairs (which, I repeat, is subordinate to the "local" territorial leader) is, IMHO, a very transparent hint to this very leader ..
          - Something tells me that the "territorial" OMONS and others, when transferred to the National Guard, will be "filtered" to screen out people who are especially loyal to the local leadership. If so, the purpose of the National Guard, IMHO, will be much more understandable than it is now

          Voooot ...
        3. Ugrumiy
          Ugrumiy April 9 2016 11: 38
          0
          Yes, see Art. 151 Code of Criminal Procedure. And the rest, if necessary, coordinate the FSB officers and internal troops, and that’s enough for everyone. You form groups: a couple of operas, a track and a dozen heavy ones and forward. Only no one will give such a team ... unfortunately.
    3. Alexdark
      Alexdark April 9 2016 06: 00
      -1
      People just do not rise. All uplifts require enemy money. Laziness to the people, for free then ... At least do something with it.
  • 89130517794
    89130517794 April 9 2016 02: 15
    -1
    I think Vladimir Putin really decided to "clean up" the "vertical" of power! After all, few people associate the outright sabotage of "bureaucrats" with "beloletochniki", and yet these are links of the same chain! First, to arouse public discontent with the local authorities and individual "offices" of the federal government, and already the liberals will save up at every corner, as in the famous film: "And where is the president looking!" At the same time, "bureaucrats", especially local ones, are difficult to pick, they have already "grown together" with "local" law enforcement officers, rotation is no longer helping! And NG is a military structure, there are military personnel and not just employees or employees with special ranks and class ranks, and there are no longer security forces, but special departments! So that together with the FSB it is possible to arrange a "great" purge! And "local bureaucrats" will no longer be able to use "national fermentation" in the regions in their defense! And without "lured bureaucrats" and "business sharks" they will quietly sit on the fifth point and be "socially oriented" in the interests of the country and citizens.
    1. avva2012
      avva2012 April 9 2016 02: 40
      -3
      After all, few people associate the outright sabotage of "bureaucrats" with "beloletochniki", and yet these are links of the same chain!

      Not only that, but the so-called opposition, these are generally clowns. This does not happen. It seems that she is a smoke screen. Behind her are serious people who do not shine.
  • 33 Watcher
    33 Watcher April 9 2016 03: 21
    +3
    "Where is the golden mean? How to choose between security and human rights?"

    As P. Volya sang: "Europe - well, it is in ... y". It is already clear to everyone that they did not cope, did not cope with their own safety. For - that "human rights", immeasurably ... Only here these rights are violated, to put it mildly, badly educated Arabs, and the state (police) are powerless. Well, I generally keep quiet about the concealment of crimes of a sexual nature, it turns out that the victim of such a crime was struck in rights, more than once, and from different sides ...
    As an example, I propose Israel. Here, in my opinion, the relations between citizens and special services are the most correct. Everybody understands perfectly well that it will cost a nudge of special services in the struggle for the imaginary freedoms of citizens.
  • Fox
    Fox April 9 2016 05: 06
    +3
    I didn’t understand about weapons: the Ministry of Internal Affairs was always better armed and equipped than the army. In Chechnya, the army men (with whom he served) noted the same thing — the supply in the BB was better.
    more; who will be involved in the ARD? Where will they take them? All the schools that have been standing successfully have successfully taken over, the coolest were the Ministry of Internal Affairs, now sadness. One specialist has to be taught for years. And taught not on paper in the streets. Bad student or undergraduate = two hundredth.
    1. From Samara
      From Samara April 9 2016 11: 16
      0
      Only in Chechnya did the Army make a turning point. Without the BB Army, they smashed there ...
      1. Fox
        Fox April 9 2016 14: 37
        0
        Quote: From Samara
        Only in Chechnya did the Army make a turning point. Without the BB Army, they smashed there ...

        from Samara ... I must remember or know someone from the 81st regiment. Ask, they will tell how they are there. Ask the guys from the riot police Samara and Tolyatti how they fought. Ask about the dead.
        1. From Samara
          From Samara April 9 2016 15: 03
          0
          Then 81 regiments and the Maykop brigade suffered significant losses due to the general state of affairs in the army ...

          Yes, and I well know what I'm writing about, but you're not in the topic ... On that New Year's Eve, there was no riot police in Grozny ... and there was nobody to ask, there was only the Army ...

          Yes, and just in case, I’ll say that even at that unsuccessful time, the Dudaev Palace was stormed by the Motorized Riflemen and the Marine Corps, and Grozny himself also had an avaladela army under the command of Rokhlin and Troshev! the second echelon, they commander Vorobyov died there when the posts were laid out ...

          It was the Army that won all the stubborn battles in Grozny at that time, including the Minute Square!

          And Omon later engaged in sweeps, but they exchanged fire with each other ...
        2. From Samara
          From Samara April 9 2016 15: 29
          0
          Yes, and I have nothing against VV and riot police! But without the Army they would not have been able to cope with Chechnya ...
  • tajrov73
    tajrov73 April 9 2016 05: 22
    -2
    The National Guard is created to suppress the people if the people go against these rich.
    1. Andrey Yuryevich
      Andrey Yuryevich April 9 2016 05: 46
      -2
      tajrov73 - stop hysteria, CossackOk! internal troops were ALWAYS! the name is changed, the liberals are in a panic! wassat
      1. Bayonet
        Bayonet April 9 2016 07: 32
        0
        Quote: Andrey Yurievich
        internal troops were ALWAYS!

        Yes, we celebrated 200 years! A separate building of the internal guard (OKVS) was formed on March 30, 1816. hi
    2. 33 Watcher
      33 Watcher April 9 2016 05: 50
      +1
      People? Who's that? Could it be that Ponomarev and Chichvarkin and Rynskaya? I just believed that I, this is the people (I work at the factory, engineers), and I don’t intend to go anywhere, and there are no problems with the police, etc. I AM FOR! Moreover, I like how the public security police began to work, after the recent reforms (I remember them in the 90s and early 2000s). So who are the people?
      As you, you don’t like to be in a minority, you just can’t put up with it, you can’t, there Nadezhdin repainted, he broke into EP.
      So who are our people? And what will we do with democracy (the rule of most)? Huh? laughing
  • Sandpiper
    Sandpiper April 9 2016 06: 15
    +1
    "The concept of creating a" national guard "is not new and has been in the air since the late 80s, during the Gorbachev perestroika (riot police, sobr, etc.). On the outskirts, was it applied and then refused and after the Maidan returned again?"
  • Stinger
    Stinger April 9 2016 06: 35
    0
    Maybe it is necessary. But the holy word GUARD I would remove from the name. The gendarmerie is more suitable. Do not be like the Americans. Yes, and the meaning is correct.
  • 31rus2
    31rus2 April 9 2016 06: 38
    +2
    Dear, 1) Kulikov is not that expert, although he has high ranks and positions in the past, this is evident even from simple questions, everything is blurry, he knows as much as you and I, 2) military intelligence and street crime, if it's like written, then this is a failure, if the private security company is connected to this, elementary laws are needed, 3) it is still not clear that in eternity the OMON will be able to decide on the territory of the region, without the Ministry of Internal Affairs and vice versa how the Ministry of Internal Affairs will act promptly without the OMON during force actions or think militants, criminals, hooligans, will act where there is power and strength, but no, just the opposite, 4) on the issue of subordination, why directly to the president, they would create generally one headquarters like the MTR, only for internal work, here is coordination and a wide the range of tasks and efficiency means all the same the struggle within the country, under the "sauce of extremism and terrorism" I have another option "army men" after the reforms are gaining strength in the same way as after the "Chechen companies", so a structure is needed to "balance "
  • vladim.gorbunow
    vladim.gorbunow April 9 2016 06: 43
    +1
    The name is terrible. Somehow they chewed on the police with the policemen. And you-the National Guard.
  • vladim.gorbunow
    vladim.gorbunow April 9 2016 07: 24
    +2
    In the company of rioters, conspirators, enemies of the state who climbed onto the BMP, the future Commander of the National Guard is above all. As the German partners say: "Das ist nicht gut". Well, as it turns on the old rails.
  • Riv
    Riv April 9 2016 07: 41
    +1
    The article amused the comments too.
    In fact, everything is very simple. There are internal troops, the soldiers of which are very well trained, but by their purpose they are light infantry. The heaviest weapon is a grenade launcher. The most powerful technique is the armored personnel carrier. This is definitely not enough to fulfill the functions of the military police in the occupied territories and fight against partisan formations.

    For example, in Crimea, the army had to deal with territory control. They managed of course, but this is not their function at all. So, in general, this law was necessary for a long time. And knowing our army system, we can assume that all the actions necessary to fulfill the requirements of the law have already been taken.
  • Zebus
    Zebus April 9 2016 08: 27
    -1
    It was high time to create something like that !!!
  • kvarfax
    kvarfax April 9 2016 09: 35
    0
    What a lot! And opinions and other things!
    I will say this:
    Now when the bandits are surrounded, it will be easier to fit an armored personnel carrier or a helicopter. What seemed to me before was not so simple. And when one structure has at its disposal all the necessary means. This is great!
    Especially when someone starts ordering riots again, etc. Such needs to be quickly neutralized. And then I don’t remember a single case when some unrest and mass protests really made the country better.
  • Felix-A
    Felix-A April 9 2016 09: 40
    +3
    Quiet glanders from the consciousness of people all Soviet is etched
  • 16112014nk
    16112014nk April 9 2016 12: 16
    +2
    Quote: neo.
    Do you need a National Guard to fight street and organized crime?

    Putin promised to create 25 million jobs by 2020? "The kid said, the kid did!"
  • KBR109
    KBR109 April 9 2016 21: 31
    +1
    Congratulations ! Birth of the oprichnina. On the throne - Ivan 4. On armored personnel carriers will brooms and dog heads be?
  • Ros 56
    Ros 56 April 10 2016 12: 41
    0
    Yes, no one is against the rule of law, but these specialists will first stretch a club along the ridge, and then they ask for the name. And no matter the national guard or veveshniki.