Military Review

Rebuke the barbarians

41
“We view the fight against terrorism as part of a wider system of measures to counter it”


10 years ago, on March 6, the federal law "On Countering Terrorism" was adopted, which strengthened the legal and organizational framework for the fight against the plague of the 21st century. How was this document born? What preceded him? How to block the path of the militants banned in Russia IG to the North Caucasus? The President of the Club of Military Commanders of the Russian Federation, General of the Army, Doctor of Economic Sciences Anatoly Kulikov answered the questions of the Military Industrial Complex.

- Anatoly Sergeyevich, you had a direct connection to the development of a law against terrorism. What was the problem?

- In the new Russia, we are faced with such a formidable phenomenon as separatism. Having received the first rebuff in the North Caucasus, the separatists adopted terrorist forms of struggle, which international emissaries immediately used. The Afghan experience and an extensive network of training bases for militants in Pakistan and Afghanistan were involved. The sending of so-called rebels to the North Caucasus, to other regions of the country, including through the Pankisi Gorge in Georgia, began.

At that time, we actually had no experience in fighting the plague of the XX – XXI centuries. The very first law was passed, but we fought terrorism, as they say, after the fact. The attack happened - a headquarters was created, its head was determined (from the Ministry of Internal Affairs or the Federal Security Service). Calculations were provided for in the security structures in case of emergency, but there was no detail, no one knew who would be in charge of what, etc. This went on for a long time, until the seizure of the Swedish embassy in Moscow and the killing of one of our employees. That case showed that manpower and resources are not enough, we are poorly prepared. A terrorist attack in Beslan in September 2004, finally forced the political leadership and security officials to come to the conclusion: we do not have an effective system to counter terrorism.

- How did we even find ourselves in a similar situation? Understanding this is very important in order not to step on the same rake.

- The fact is that the social, political and economic consequences of the collapse of the USSR have created many negative phenomena. The most tragic of them are rampant criminality and banditry, separatist manifestations in national formations (warmed up and even encouraged by the well-known expression: “Take sovereignty as much as you can swallow”), massive “cleansing” of the Russian-speaking population in a number of North Caucasian republics, kidnapping, embezzling money funds with fake advices. The prospects for Russian statehood were not entirely clear, dormant antagonisms, instantly supported by foreign extremist forces, revived within civil society. With the onset of the constitutional crisis and the military conflict in Chechnya, Russian citizens experienced prolonged horror from unprecedented terrorist attacks with the seizure of large groups of hostages (2000 in Budyonnovsk hospitals, more than 3000 in Kizlyar), from apartment buildings in Moscow, Buynaksk, Kaspiysk, Volgodonsk and You can also recall the attacks on government bodies and law enforcement, the terrorist attacks in the Moscow metro and theatrical center on Dubrovka, the bombings of passenger trains and airplanes. All this put on the agenda the question of the need for legislative regulation of countering terrorism, which has become a daily reality.

Rebuke the barbarians

The damage carried by the attacks is measured in huge sums. But human losses cannot be assessed. So, as a result of only well-known terrorist attacks committed in the Russian Federation, 3005 people died, injured - 6394. The accuracy of these figures is very relative, because no one is tracking the fate of those injured by injuries and injuries. Consequently, the death toll is much greater than it is called in the first days after the terrorist attacks. Moreover, these statistics do not include combat losses of the personnel of the Armed Forces, internal troops and law enforcement agencies during the counter-terrorist operation (CTO). And these are still thousands of ragged young lives.

I repeat: in the 90-ies in the country there was no anti-terrorism legislation. Up to January 1, the Criminal Code of the RSFSR was in effect in 1997, inheriting from its former life. Judicial legal culture and power (political, economic) were built on a new foundation of the still not established statehood.

- You went through the Chechen war, saw the suffering of people. And how was all this perceived in the silence of the Moscow authorities?

- I was already the deputy chairman of the State Duma Security Committee, and we have long suggested that we develop a law on countering terrorism. Not about the fight against him, but about opposition, because this concept is much broader. I was assigned to lead a working group to prepare a new law. A variety of opinions were expressed on the formulations of the conceptual apparatus: in the world, more than 100 definitions of a terrorist act were given. But life has shown that preventive actions, that is, a system of measures aimed at preventing crimes, must be at the heart of the fight against terrorism.

The first step in this direction was adopted in 1998, the federal law "On Combating Terrorism", which determined the basic principles of work, the competence of public authorities. Without diminishing his role (at a certain stage, he fulfilled his purpose), I will say that over time, and the shortcomings emerged. First of all, he was directed to a terrorist plan that is being implemented or has already been implemented, and the powers to curb it were assigned only to security forces, which acted separately, without proper coordination.

This circumstance indicated the direction in which the legislation should be improved: to create an integral system of preventive measures, to organize the management of this activity, to clearly define the competence and responsibility of public authorities and officials at the federal level, in the subject, on the ground, as well as restrictions on civil rights in an emergency.

The development of the bill took place in hot debates. Many positions required mental changes, encroached on the inviolability of established institutions. Some people considered unacceptable the involvement of the Armed Forces in the fight against terrorist groups on the territory of the Russian Federation and abroad. It was difficult to perceive the position of unity of command in the decision-making and leadership of the KTO.

The discussion on the conceptual apparatus was accompanied by sharp discussions. But as a result, it was possible to give an exact formulation of terrorism. This defined the concept and logic of the bill. An analysis of terrorism, which took root in the Caucasus and raided Central Russia, made it possible to identify and legally fix such an integral feature of the phenomenon as ideological motivation.

It was decided that the ideology and practice of violence should be understood as terrorism. That is, a belief system expressing the interests of a certain organization or community, aimed at committing illegal actions to achieve certain goals. Consequently, terrorism, terrorist activity, terrorist act are phenomena and concepts that are interconnected, but different. They are manifested in their own way in time and space, which means that the methods of counteraction must be different. This “split” view of the phenomenon allowed us to formulate the state’s reaction in a different way, namely, to consider the fight against terrorism as part of a wider system of measures to counter it.

The current law on countering terrorism (March 6 of 2006) took into account the experience of fighting the underground in the North Caucasus, the provisions of international conventions that our country ratified by taking on the obligations to bring national norms into line with international ones. The principal difference, I repeat, in the definition of terrorism as a phenomenon. If earlier it was considered as a terrorist attack (explosion, fire, arson for the purpose of intimidation, threats, violence ...), we defined: “Terrorism is an ideology of violence and the practice of influencing decision-making by state authorities, local governments or international organizations, related to the intimidation of the population and (or) other forms of unlawful violent actions. ” This made it possible to take preventive measures against criminals at the design stage.

The new law can be considered as a legal act regulating the three states or activities of the authorized state bodies in countering terrorism: preventive and preventive measures to ensure the safety and protection of the rights of citizens, a counter-terrorist operation, minimization of damage and elimination of consequences, including social rehabilitation of participants and victims during the CTO .

- How did the organizational structure of the forces and means involved in the fight against terrorism change after the release of the law?

- A Presidential Decree on Measures to Counter Terrorism (February 15 2006) established the National Anti-Terrorism Committee (NAC) chaired by the Director of the FSB. Approved the composition and Regulations of the NAC. Anti-terrorist commissions have been created in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation, and they are headed by the heads of the highest executive bodies of state power.

For the organization of planning the use of forces and means of the federal bodies of executive power and their territorial counter-terrorism structures, as well as for the management of operations, the following were formed:

- as part of NAC - the Federal Operational Headquarters (FOS). Its head is appointed by the chairman of the NAC. The decisions of the FORS, made in accordance with its competence, are binding on all government bodies whose representatives are members of it;
- operational headquarters in the subjects of the Russian Federation, headed by the heads of the territorial bodies of the FSB.

By Decree 664 of December 26, 2015 established operational headquarters in the sea areas - in Kaspiysk, Murmansk, Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsky, Simferopol and Yuzhno-Sakhalinsk. They are headed, as a rule, by the heads of the FSB border agencies in areas of responsibility.

- 10 years ago, not everything went smoothly. They say you even wanted to be dismissed after you decided to defend your formulation of terrorism?


“They tried to impose on us that, they say, terrorism is“ a theory and practice of influence ... ”, etc. But I, as a scientist, know what a theory is. This is a system of scientifically based views. It was necessary to ask a tough question in the state-law administration of the presidential administration: why are you doing terrorism science? Of course, it did not like it. One of the representatives of the management then stated that I should be removed from the leadership of the group on the development of the law. Offered this mission to Alexander Gurov. But he said I'm right. They invited Alexei Volkov, but he also refused, sharing my point of view. And time propped up. Then a meeting was convened in the Security Committee at Vasiliev. There they finally came to a consolidated formulation that terrorism is not a theory, but an ideology of violence. By the way, in foreign forums I have always found support for this position.

The law defined the vertical of the state system and competence in the field of countering terrorism: the president - the government - federal ministries and departments - the authorities of the subjects of the Russian Federation and local self-government. The personal responsibility of managers at all levels was established. After all, what happened in Beslan and why was it so outraged by the country's political leadership, first of all the president? Imagine: two days are taking hostages, but the head of the operation is not.

That terrorist attack highlighted a lot of flaws, including at the highest level. As I was told, some heads of law enforcement agencies flew to Beslan and, not having stayed for a day, returned to Moscow. As a result - a large number of victims. It does not allow to consider that operation successful. And everyone had to think about the development of a coherent anti-terrorism strategy - such a task was set by the president. But even after that, those who were against personal responsibility did not give up. Already on the third reading of the bill, some people tried to throw this provision away, moreover, behind my back. I had to talk in the strictest manner with the representative of the staff of the State Duma’s Security Committee. I still think: it was not a technical mistake, but the desire of some officials to go into the shadows.

6 March 2006, the law was signed and the National Anti-Terrorism Committee was immediately created, without which everything would remain on paper.

- What, in accordance with this law, was imputed to the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, which was not there before?

- Provided legal regulation of their application in the country and abroad (articles 6 – 10 FZ). This is the suppression of the flights of aircraft used for terrorist attack or captured; suppression of acts of terrorism in inland waters and in the territorial sea of ​​the Russian Federation, on the objects of marine industrial activity located on the continental shelf of the Russian Federation, as well as to ensure the safety of national maritime navigation; participation in the KTO; suppression of international terrorist activity, including outside the country. The number of contingents, areas of stay, tasks, terms and procedure for replacement or withdrawal are determined by the president.



All multi-departmental military personnel, employees, specialists from the beginning to the end of the KTO were reassigned to its head. I would like to note that political demands put forward by terrorists are not considered. The bodies of the militants who died during the suppression of terrorist acts are not issued to relatives, the burial places are not reported. The constitutional court of the Russian Federation recognized the rule as legal. The motivation is not to turn their burial places into objects of worship, as well as vandalism.

The law prohibits the activities of organizations whose goals or actions are aimed at promoting, justifying and supporting terrorism. The structure, recognized by the decision of the court of terrorism, to be liquidated. This also applies to territorial offices. A unified register of prohibited organizations is maintained, which is published in the Rossiyskaya Gazeta and on the NAK website (http://www.fsb.ru/fsb/npd/terror.htm). Currently, the registry contains 24 organizations whose activities in the Russian Federation are being pursued.

- And yet, despite the measures taken, the likelihood of terrorist attacks, unfortunately, remains, the fundamental human right to life is violated ...

- The search for effective strategies continues, as terrorism itself changes the tactics, methods and targets of attacks. In particular, the aforementioned December presidential decree “On measures to improve public administration in the area of ​​countering terrorism” reflects changes in the content of challenges and real and potential threats to national security.

During the validity of the new strategy, we received evidence that the decisions were timely and correct. From 2006 to 2015, 9000 crimes of a terrorist nature, including 340 terrorist attacks, were recorded, of which 161 is an organized criminal group. 5300 perpetrators of terrorist crimes have been identified and prosecuted.

In general, the number of acts of terrorism in the first years after the adoption of the law has noticeably decreased, but in the 2014 – 2015 years it has more than doubled. And although their share in the structure of grave and especially grave crimes for the said period was about 0,16 percent, the scale of disasters and damage caused are incomparable with any other encroachment, as they take away human lives, traumatize the mind, psyche and memory of the population for a long time. But it is precisely the identification of crimes of a terrorist nature that says that the law is effective and quite effective. A recent case, when in Yekaterinburg, law enforcement agencies came out on the trail and captured igilovtsev, who were preparing the terrorist attacks in St. Petersburg, Yekaterinburg and Moscow, evidence of this.

Does this mean that such an emergency will not happen again? Unfortunately not. It takes a lot of work to prevent the fight against terrorism, from activities in schools to institutions, housing services, private security companies, performances in the media, etc. We have no right to let our guard down, we should only increase it.

- How do you explain the emergence of the IG prohibited in Russia and the attractiveness of certain terrorist slogans for some young people?

“The fact is that since the beginning of the 21st century, the world has been awaiting the benefits of globalization, cross-border cultural and scientific exchanges, anticipating the progress of technology and the next achievements of civilization. At the same time, sensible politicians and experts warned of the possibility of new challenges, called for unity in the fight against terrorism as a comprehensive threat to humanity, but did not meet with complete understanding. What is not wrong? The fact that Islamism, driven by the ideology of the barbarians, is becoming a global threat to states, nations, cultures, religions. Today DAISH-ISIL is an even more sophisticated form of terrorism than the traditional one that we thought was relatively studied. Even the al-Qaeda sectarian network has not sowed as much grief as it has already brought and will still bring IS, although its roots are in Al-Qaida, created by the US special services. This is the first.

Secondly, crafty politicians did not see terrorism where it made attacks and was accompanied by huge victims, or called this word processes that are not (for example, in Novorossiya), and thereby confused the public consciousness in assessing the realities, crossed out the idea of ​​partnership in favor of political interests. Therefore, it is so important to cooperate, to connect the national diplomacy. Therefore, the same manipulation of concepts, the practice of double standards are unacceptable.

Thirdly, one of the causes of the “color revolutions”, about which little is said, is social. Too wide the gap between the poor and the rich. According to some reports, in today's world, 87 families own and manage all of its wealth. The number of poor continues to grow, which allows the ideologists of terrorists to play on these facts, using to recruit new adepts from such a social environment.

Fourth, after the collapse of the USSR, the United States began to harbor the idea of ​​world domination, for which they needed a mechanism of absolute control through the creation of controlled chaos in weak states. This allows us to achieve not only political, military, but also economic goals. For example, printing a $ 100 bill and issuing it costs only 12 cents. But with the help of these pieces of paper, the US gets access to global mineral reserves, cheap labor. That is, they live at the expense of other countries, which is modern neo-colonialism.

Finally, fifthly, igilovtsy, treating recruits, point them to drunkenness, debauchery, greed, corruption of modern Western civilization, thus calling for the fight against the infidels. But thereby turning them into real executioners, killing old men, women, children involved in the slave trade, the execution of Christians, etc., without talking about them. Speaking of high morality in the future caliphate, they turned into a fiend of the human race in practice, which was clearly shown in Syria.

If someone thinks that all this is far away and doesn’t touch us, they are deeply mistaken. Just one example. In previous years, dozens of schools were built and funded with Turkish money in Russia, which today continue to implement just such an ideology. Why do we calmly relate to this and why do people who are responsible for state security do not feel the danger?

We all need to recognize as an inevitable reality: it is the counter-terrorism that will determine the future guarantees of humanity in the field of universal security.
Author:
Originator:
http://vpk-news.ru/articles/29466
41 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. avvg
    avvg 2 March 2016 18: 49
    +7
    Without the Army, it was not possible to break the back of terrorism and conduct CTO, to repulse it with a "barbarian" in the North Caucasus, and today "specialists" in the North Caucasus can easily cope with terrorists.
    1. Pravdarm
      Pravdarm 2 March 2016 18: 53
      19
      We all need to recognize as an inevitable reality: it is the counter-terrorism that will determine the future guarantees of humanity in the field of universal security.
      And still need to recognize the need for the death penalty! For these and other monsters!
      And do not feed and keep them in prisons for 10-15 years, and even more so for life! cheap, non-wearing reusable rope, one for all - the most THAT !!!
      1. MASK
        MASK 2 March 2016 19: 06
        +5
        Only Russia and Israel know how to fight terrorism .. (for real!) The rest either do not know what it is, or they support it in every way, being afraid to touch it and directing it in one direction or another!
        1. DMB_95
          DMB_95 2 March 2016 19: 24
          +3
          China is also not bad in this necessary matter. It is a pity that the IG is not interesting to him yet.
          1. GYGOLA
            GYGOLA 2 March 2016 19: 35
            +1
            DMB_95 (1) RU Today, 19:24 ↑

            China is also not bad in this necessary matter. It is a pity that the IG is not interesting to him yet.
            not bad is very very modest about a world leader.
        2. vovanpain
          vovanpain 2 March 2016 19: 31
          20
          Quote: MASK
          Only Russia and Israel are able to fight terrorism .. (for real!)

          Well, the teachers were good. hi
        3. Gorodovik
          Gorodovik 2 March 2016 20: 23
          -3
          Well, you say such big words. Your speech yes in life would be. Tell this to those who were taken hostage in the Nord-Ost and in Beslan. How skillfully we fight a. Once, almost in 2010, terrorists were shot in a neighboring village. Yes, they undoubtedly figured they followed them for a long time. Prepared and in the end - minus one of our soldiers and purely by chance none of the civilians. For they shot right in the village and indiscriminately where the civilians lived and where they did not live.
        4. Nyrobsky
          Nyrobsky 2 March 2016 20: 24
          +2
          Quote: MASK
          Only Russia and Israel know how to fight terrorism .. (for real!) The rest either do not know what it is, or they support it in every way, being afraid to touch it and directing it in one direction or another!

          The rest of it (terrorism) is generated in the necessary quantity to maintain fear in the world, thanks to which they have the opportunity to advance their interests and intervene in the affairs of other states.
      2. Naum
        Naum 2 March 2016 19: 32
        +6
        Quote: Pravdarm
        do not feed and keep them in jail

        It is necessary to return hard labor for life. So that life does not seem like paradise, and death is the long-awaited deliverance from torment. Shooting or hanging is too easy a reckoning for atrocities. In a flash, that's all. Something more terrible is needed. Well, do not put the freaks on the count? Though...
      3. Asadullah
        Asadullah 2 March 2016 21: 16
        +1
        And still need to recognize the need for the death penalty! For these and other monsters!


        Believe me, practically it already exists. Have you heard a lot in recent years who were taken prisoner? But before it was not clear what stood behind the order to take alive. Operational need, or the rustle of crispy notes in the pocket of what rank. Then everything was given into the hands of the fighters themselves. Relatives gathered grandmothers during the siege, to bow to the commander - leave the son, son-in-law, matchmaker alive there, we give so much and so much. The commander of the fighters is your choice! The assault group decides for itself, because this is an increasing multidimensional risk. In general, I do not condemn and disapprove of such cases, all the same in those years the guys put their lives on the edge for a beggarly salary. And now other times, today a gangster should not be in prison, he should live, but not very long.
        1. Naum
          Naum 4 March 2016 09: 48
          +1
          Quote: Asadullah
          he must live, but not very long.

          ... and not happy! And anyway, who knows what they did with the banduk during the assault? Eliminated forever for society - and that's it. It’s also very correct that ammunition is being undermined at the place of their discovery, in the houses where the barmalei were hiding. The hosts will think three times before giving shelter to the freaks.
    2. Giant thought
      Giant thought 2 March 2016 19: 08
      +3
      The barbarians understand only power, and from the action of such a postulate we must act.
    3. tol100v
      tol100v 2 March 2016 19: 39
      +2
      Quote: avvg
      Without the Army, it was not possible to break the back of terrorism and conduct CTO, to repulse it with a "barbarian" in the North Caucasus, and today "specialists" in the North Caucasus can easily cope with terrorists.

      Without the consolidation of all forces, it is impossible to fight against terror! But the number of forces and means involved must be determined individually in each case.
  2. Oleg Lavrov
    Oleg Lavrov 2 March 2016 18: 50
    +6
    Terrorism, the product of the greed of the pinnacle ... And their confidence that they will sit out for a "puddle", in the chaos controlled by them ... but the Russian Federation came and spat in their soup !!!
  3. oxana_iv
    oxana_iv 2 March 2016 19: 05
    +8
    I state in my own words:
    - At first, there was no terrorism, and we lived on the Criminal Code of the USSR (by the way, why wasn’t terrorism in the USSR?)
    “Then terrorism arose, but we were not ready, and for many years we, like delinquent kittens, were snubbed into the nose.”
    - We realized that something went wrong.
    - Now we have correctly defined the concept of terrorism, as well as the vertical and competence.
    - Soon everything will be fine, because (!!!!) "it is precisely the counteraction to terrorism that will determine the further guarantees of mankind in the sphere of universal security."

    No comment ...
    1. lukke
      lukke 2 March 2016 19: 24
      11
      At first there was no terrorism, and we lived on the Criminal Code of the USSR (by the way, why wasn’t terrorism in the USSR?)
      Also touched by the position of the authors ...)))
      The competent authorities had entire units that were engaged in the identification, prevention and suppression. And that allowed the leadership of the country, including all these authors are commanders-in-chief in the 90s — then, and in a year, you will not solve a single army. The authors are cunning that in the USSR, Russia before SevKavkaz didn’t know and didn’t know, maybe they themselves didn’t know and didn’t know anything, but in the Committee the people somehow solved the problems and provided for the Olympics in 1980 and much more
      As I understand it, the main message of the article is that only thanks to Kulikov’s lawmaking did it manage to establish a fight against terrorism in Russia?)
      1. Ami du peuple
        Ami du peuple 2 March 2016 20: 00
        +2
        Quote: lukke
        As I understand it, the main message of the article is that only thanks to Kulikov’s lawmaking did it manage to establish a fight against terrorism in Russia?)
        Kulikov was a very normal Minister of the Interior. Anything better than his successor Stepashin. And, thanks to his practical activities, indeed, at one time, certain results were achieved in the fight against terrorism.
        Quote: lukke
        The authors are cunning that in the USSR, Russia before SevKavkaz didn’t know and didn’t know, maybe they themselves didn’t know and didn’t know anything, but in the Committee the people somehow solved the problems and provided for the Olympics in 1980 and much more
        A lot of "what else"? The problems with total terror, which the internal affairs and state security agencies faced in the 90s, did not exist at all during the Soviet era - only a few cases. Also, don't compare the Soviet law enforcement system with what was left of it in the Yeltsin era. Everything was destroyed, from training / succession of personnel, ending with undercover work. I myself wonder how there were no large casualties among the population as a result of terrorist crimes. Not otherwise, God helped. No kidding.
        1. oxana_iv
          oxana_iv 2 March 2016 20: 36
          +2
          Quote: Ami du peuple
          As there were no large casualties among the population, as a result of terrorist crimes - I myself am surprised. Not otherwise, God helped. Besides jokes.


          And which victims can be considered large, and which small? The victims of terrorism in Russia are already in the thousands. Is it big or not?
          The destruction of the country's security system (along with the country) is a crime for which no one has yet been held accountable. At the same time, the author of the article argues that "it just so happened" and "nothing can be done".
          I ... oh, dear edition!
          I want to hope that they have already grabbed their heads and took up their minds, but this will only be shown by time.
        2. lukke
          lukke 2 March 2016 21: 36
          0
          The problems with total terror, which the bodies of internal affairs and state security faced in the 90s, absolutely did not exist during the times of the USSR
          because the employees for the most part were engaged in the performance of their professional duties, and not ... therefore, they did not allow "total" terror to rampant. What did our special services do there in 1985, when the diplomats were taken hostage in Beirut? and what did Chernomyrdin and Co. do when the hospital was seized?
    2. Sergej1972
      Sergej1972 3 March 2016 11: 13
      0
      The Criminal Code of the USSR has never been. There were the Criminal Code of the Union Republics and the Fundamentals of the criminal legislation of the USSR and Union Republics.
  4. Dr. Bormental
    Dr. Bormental 2 March 2016 19: 15
    +2
    Quote: oxana_iv
    By the way, why was there no terrorism in the USSR?

    Was. There was no such definition. They put it against the wall and let it flow ... the whole story. And the family has a complete confiscation of property and other "benefits". This is now the mash mash with them for years ...
    Personally, my opinion - if the law had been passed now, on the recognition by terrorists of ALL relatives of a real terrorist, up to the newborn children of his distant aunt, would be better. He would probably think several times before committing a crime, perhaps relatives who knew about his intention would stop him.
    1. MASK
      MASK 2 March 2016 19: 33
      +4
      Quote: Dr. Bormental
      Quote: oxana_iv
      By the way, why was there no terrorism in the USSR?

      Was. There was no such definition. They put it against the wall and let it flow ... the whole story. And the family has a complete confiscation of property and other "benefits". This is now the mash mash with them for years ...
      Personally, my opinion - if the law had been passed now, on the recognition by terrorists of ALL relatives of a real terrorist, up to the newborn children of his distant aunt, would be better. He would probably think several times before committing a crime, perhaps relatives who knew about his intention would stop him.

      Kadyrov, in principle, with this (unofficial law) suppressed the Wahhabis in his Chechnya (where the houses are demolished at once the relatives of the suicide bomber ..) Cruel? But silence and only reports (there terrorists were blocked and destroyed .. etc.) Now we kill them outside Russia and very successfully (there are many "ours" there too ..)
      The Ottomans are here, an intermediate hornet’s nest .. (then it’s better to keep quiet and everyone knows everything)))
  5. BARKHAN
    BARKHAN 2 March 2016 19: 15
    11
    And again, the expert spoke about what everyone knows.
    And that we must fight terrorism.
    It’s useless to fight terrorism, because terrorism is a way of warfare, for example, as intelligence. Terror (lat. Terror - fear, horror) —Fear, suppression, instilling terror in the enemy.
    And it is necessary to fight with specific characters. Customer, financiers, performers.
    In our Russian realities, financiers are specifically Saudi Arabia, Qatar, the United States ... and others. The customers are the same. The executors are all rabble, from zombie local to quite pragmatic mercenaries.
    Something I’m not hearing from our authorities of specific claims to camels and retaliatory actions on their territory.
    And so, just fighting some sort of terrorism.
    Any problem is ALWAYS confined to a specific person. And this person ALWAYS has a name, surname, position, location.
    This is the specific answer. It requires specific action.
    1. max702
      max702 2 March 2016 20: 55
      +1
      I agree, the time for bowing has passed .. For example, why not plant a pair of "calibers" in Erdogan's residence to shoot down our pilot? Is it illegal? Is it legal to shoot down our planes? So the answer is this .. It would instantly clear the brains of all comers .. The same is with Qatar and SA .. You very rightly noticed that
      Quote: Barkhan
      And it is necessary to fight with specific characters. Customer, financiers, performers.

      That's it! These are the main goals with first and last names! Only after a revealing impudent bloody liquidation, others will not want to spoil .. Only a PERSONAL fear of losing the most valuable can make you think .. Everything else from the evil one, not money, not human losses (if these are not the closest people) do not matter to them ..
      1. gunya
        gunya 2 March 2016 21: 47
        +1
        For example, why not put a couple of "calibers" in Erdogan's residence to shoot down our pilot?


        Not effectively and immediately lose many sympathizers.
        It was much easier, if there was such an opportunity, to "land" several Ottoman fighters with the help of electronic warfare systems and declare that "it was so" - they cannot fly!
    2. Asadullah
      Asadullah 2 March 2016 21: 27
      0
      In our Russian realities, financiers specifically Saudi Arabia, Qatar


      With all due respect, have you heard from the CA and Qatar declarations of support for terrorism? Do you want to hear from the Russian leadership about "retaliatory actions"? The question is rhetorical. Compare in retrospect the fading wave of terror in Russia and the shooting of some odious Nokhchas in Turkey and the Middle East. Who could deny about the "leak" to the East of operational information about the impending attempts on the life of Arab princes and their camels with their wives?
      1. BARKHAN
        BARKHAN 2 March 2016 21: 50
        +2
        Dear, yes, they never hid it. All cash flows to the North Caucasus have always come from there. And our special services have repeatedly reported this. Only Khattab taxied without hiding until the taxi was unscrewed. And what seems like a calm now. us, so it's imaginary. It's just that more sophisticated operations are being prepared. Yes, the focus of attention has shifted closer to their camels, and Operation Refugee is in full swing in Europe.
        Well, the current rashes in our and the Syrian side say that the asses of camels are itchy in search of adventure.
    3. Mikhail3
      Mikhail3 3 March 2016 11: 44
      +1
      Quote: Barkhan
      And it is useless to fight terrorism.

      You are absolutely right. And this article is a miserable, shameful cheapness. If our fight against terrorism is really established at the level described in the article, we cannot survive. Because situational response, based on the vanishingly small base of a weak administrative mind, is a disaster.
      We have military institutes. We have a MO. We have hordes of highly paid loafers ... where are the real-time developments ?! Terrorists are the effectors of the effects of our enemies. Just gloves stretched over different hands.
      I really, really hope that besides this miserable chatter we also have a really smart strategy and tactics based on it. The truth then will have to admit that the times of total nonsense, which destroyed faith in the USSR, and ultimately destroyed the USSR itself, returned. This is also bad, very bad, but if we don’t look further than this rub, then it’s all over!
  6. GUKTU
    GUKTU 2 March 2016 19: 25
    +4
    Terrorism is an artificial creation (product). What do you think, dear forum users, who benefits from the constant smoldering armed conflict in the absence of war as such? Please note for the conclusion that the defense industry of the leading powers is the main part of the budget. Correctly! terrorism invented by the arms lobby The first time I heard this in 1996 was from the Americans. Then it seemed funny to me. Time has passed and now I understand the whole essence of the words of these green berets. That is, they didn’t want a war, but to fight terror, it’s a sacred thing. Now analyze the events of the past 15-20 years and everything will fall into place. In addition, terror is a good tool for influencing people (crowds, voters), especially before the elections to raise the rating. Something like this ....
  7. Mama_Cholli
    Mama_Cholli 2 March 2016 19: 25
    +2
    Even in societies where the number of "informers" among citizens is very large (Germany, USA, Australia, etc.), it is impossible to 100% prevent all terrorist acts. Our situation is much more complicated due to the prevailing mentality of our citizens towards denunciations. Therefore, it is more difficult for our specialists to work. Honor and praise to the professionals of all departments of Russia who are fighting this evil! Low bow to them.
    1. MASK
      MASK 2 March 2016 19: 40
      +1
      Quote: Mama_Cholli
      Even in societies where the number of "informers" among citizens is very large (Germany, USA, Australia, etc.), it is impossible to 100% prevent all terrorist acts. Our situation is much more complicated due to the prevailing mentality of our citizens towards denunciations. Therefore, it is more difficult for our specialists to work. Honor and praise to the professionals of all departments of Russia who are fighting this evil! Low bow to them.

      I myself am surprised how they manage to keep the situation like that .. A huge country and almost the whole world are against us! GOOD we see and pity us just ...
      1. Mama_Cholli
        Mama_Cholli 2 March 2016 19: 59
        +3
        Yes ... sorry. ))) I think in their plans to spare only one million oligarchs and prosperous thieves and five million for servicing drilling rigs, mines and deposits, and for ensuring the transportation of energy and raw materials.

        The rest, according to their plans, has no place on the territory of Russia and indeed on the whole globe.
        1. MASK
          MASK 2 March 2016 20: 11
          +2
          Quote: Mama_Cholli
          Yes ... sorry. ))) I think in their plans to spare only one million oligarchs and prosperous thieves and five million for servicing drilling rigs, mines and deposits, and for ensuring the transportation of energy and raw materials.

          The rest, according to their plans, has no place on the territory of Russia and indeed on the whole globe.

          And we resist and fight ... (while on our borders) And we endure, we persuade all this (so as not to touch us and not make us angry ..) But they will soon see ... For all this!
          1. Mama_Cholli
            Mama_Cholli 2 March 2016 20: 18
            +1
            I hope not, the Russian people are people.
            If we still have to create decent conditions for life (and not the semblance that is now), but this is already a question for the upper classes, which so far can manage in the old way.
            1. MASK
              MASK 2 March 2016 21: 09
              0
              Quote: Mama_Cholli
              If we still have to create decent conditions for life (and not the semblance that is now), but this is already a question for the upper classes, which so far can manage in the old way.

              Yeah .. Life wasn’t sugar before, but now it’s more and more difficult! It smells of war ... And again they will put us first! And then everything from the beginning .. hi
          2. The comment was deleted.
          3. de naturat
            de naturat 2 March 2016 23: 22
            0
            Uncle Petya Fascist
      2. The comment was deleted.
  8. ava09
    ava09 2 March 2016 19: 38
    +4
    Maybe they will finally understand who rules the world, including Russia? Here is an excerpt from an interview with George W. Bush:

    Ah, if we could keep the Union from collapsing, if it got used to our good hand and eventually became tame, like a pet dog ... But nothing can be done. All these jackals themselves decide their fate - I know the Russians, they will not forgive anything, they will not forget anything.
    Jackals are primarily the Fed, founded by five private banks and owned by the Zion world wanderers. It was they who brought to power not just their proteges in Russia, they contemplated their traditional backstage, directly headed the leadership of Russia, trying to destroy it as a state - having prepared for its peoples the fate of total degeneration. What they could not do with Russia in 1917, they did with the United States, having managed to bring their people to the Senate and the Congress of the country - creating the Fed in 1913. They turned our country into their stronghold and base for dollar and military expansion throughout the world, and the world ruined and destroyed by them hated us for this. The terrible US government debt and 61% GDP consisting of frauds with cut paper called the dollar do not leave our country any chance. Lord, how right was Henry Ford in his statement about them back in 1925. And the jackals see salvation for the USA only in the terrible war in Europe, as it was in the first and second world wars, for which they are responsible - ... and this is the death for the country and far from the fact that the death for Russia because of her territorial sizes - not comparable with ours.
    "The New-York Times." - dated 21.10.1992
    1. Monge
      Monge 2 March 2016 20: 57
      0
      Can I link to the source?
  9. iouris
    iouris 2 March 2016 19: 53
    +1
    One cannot fail to see that "barbarism" and connivance at "barbarism" in the territories that are "in the zone of the vital interests of the United States" are well paid. =
  10. cedar
    cedar 2 March 2016 20: 02
    +4
    Terror in Latin means fear and horror. Now take a look at how much the Internet alone offers of HORROR movies and FEAR games, here is a hotbed of future terrorist attacks and violence, for which companies producing these films and games are unlikely to answer before the law.
    It is vital for the mental health of a society to introduce censorship, which is not available today. It is not mentioned in the federal law “On counteracting terrorism” because it is prohibited by the constitution - the basic law of the Russian Federation (Article 29, clause 5)! Thus, the public body is deprived of immunity, which is the institution of censorship. The consequences of this harmful step will be felt more strongly every year if we do not change Article 29 of the Constitution.
    1. Mama_Cholli
      Mama_Cholli 2 March 2016 20: 14
      +2
      Controversial decision. An idiot cannot be forced not to fulfill his will, depriving him of the ability to view a specific connection. Mentally unstable people, people in a state of affect, alcohol, drug intoxication can do anything with a knife, and if a grenade or weapon falls into their hands, they will most likely use it. Ordinary stupid girls jump from the roof because of unrequited love.
      We need something else, to create a society indifferent to their own kind. Not informers, but caring people. Now they don’t give a damn that another person can suffer 5 meters from you, few people can help their own shirt closer to their bodies.
      1. Dr. Bormental
        Dr. Bormental 2 March 2016 21: 26
        0
        Yes, this is some kind of lawyer. Rusk.
      2. The comment was deleted.
    2. The comment was deleted.
    3. Dr. Bormental
      Dr. Bormental 2 March 2016 21: 23
      +1
      "Now look at how many HORROR movies and FEAR games on the Internet alone offer, here is a hotbed of future terrorist attacks."
      It is believed that by releasing adrenaline and testosterone (for men), people become calmer. So you with your censorship will get to the ban of sex - into a living person x..m poke ... an article must be invented!
    4. The comment was deleted.
    5. would
      would 2 March 2016 23: 13
      0
      Now take a look how much the Internet alone offers horror films and games of FEAR, here is a hotbed of future terrorist attacks and violence


      Yes, yes, we all know that Hitler conceived the Holocaust after watching a horror movie and several hours of playing Call of Duty laughing

      Censorship Vital to Mental Health Society


      Well that's how it will be! The forbidden fruit is always sweet, have you heard that expression? And the Streisand effect? Imagine this: Films are forbidden. And EVERYONE immediately learns about which films were banned and everyone immediately becomes interested in why they were banned. Accordingly, everyone rushes to see how it was with the articles in Wikipedia that were blocked by the FSKN. And here is the same feeling of the forbidden fruit, a slight tremor, the feeling of something incredible when you step over the law and make fun of it, teenagers are especially susceptible to this. The best advertising for all these films and can not come up with, will be like after the introduction of a bill to tighten control over arms circulation in the United States. Then, in a short time, they bought up weapons that would be more than enough to arm the entire US Marine Corps (ILC).
  11. faterdom
    faterdom 2 March 2016 22: 20
    +2
    As a minister, Kulikov was remembered for the fact that he made everyone, young and old, write daily plans approved by their superiors .... Which, as a rule, did not coincide much with how this “planned” day passed.
    But the practical bulldozer, practitioner was V.I. Kolesnikov (later deputy. GP of the Russian Federation, with a similar work style). It was he who cleaned the Augean stables in Togliatti, Novorossiysk port and Uralmash.
    And it was he who once in Rostov SD opened and detained Chikatilo.
  12. cedar
    cedar 3 March 2016 12: 54
    +1
    Dear ones, we are talking about purposeful programming of consciousness and subconsciousness with the aim of turning a person into an instrument of violence and murder, as well as programming suicides, through not only games and films.
    Dr. Bormental, make an easy experiment, remove the viral virus (analogue of censorship) from your computer and note the time when you begin to release adrenaline and testosterone, you can go ahead .., destroying your immunity - analogue of censorship, secretions guarantee an order of magnitude more. The main thing for you, as I understand it, is not to be a cracker. Go ahead ...

    would, I want to give you the idea that Hitler is also an applied PROGRAM, by someone ... and somewhere ... designed and installed at the right time, in the right place, in the right medium to achieve certain goals. I hope you know which ones.
    "... And then the same feeling of the forbidden fruit, a slight tremor, the feeling of something incredible when you step over the law and make fun of it, teenagers are especially susceptible to this ..." would, try to write detective stories, and there you look and the scripts will reach ...
    But God forbid, you and your loved ones, run into those who like to break the law in search of the forbidden sweet fruit, and even more so once become such "fruits".
    1. would
      would 4 March 2016 20: 00
      0
      rait, try to write detective stories, and there you look and it will reach the scripts ...

      But God forbid, you and your loved ones, run into those who like to break the law in search of the forbidden sweet fruit, and even more so once become such "fruits".


      Thank you, flattered. We all run up against them and in adolescence they are the same, the sweetness of the forbidden it is. There is an article in Wikipedia about the drug "Charas", once upon a time, no one needed it. Few people knew about such a substance. But after the FSKN wanted to block it, and the people wondered what was there that needed to be blocked. The page traffic from 460 views per day explosively increased to 29976 views per day, and this is by the most modest estimates, in my opinion, thanks to the Federal Drug Control Service, the entire Internet learned what "Charas" is and everyone joked that good things should be banned so that they would start watching. This is called the Streisand Effect. I understand that this is what you want?