Military Review

Official economic rating by region of the Russian Federation

90
The end of December. As they say, time to sum up. And against the background of a huge coma of large-scale international events and processes, it would be wrong to ignore the Russian regional results of the year. It is wrong to ignore, if only because Russia is a federal state and national interests, including economic interests, are a kaleidoscope of the interests of the subjects of the Russian Federation. Similarly, national successes or failures are primarily a reflection of the successes or failures of each individual Russian region taken.


Holding office wisdom in your head about what is a lie, is a blatant lie, and there are statistics, you still have to turn to official statistics. Well, if only because official data is the only source of this kind of information. Before considering such statistics, I would still hope that the above-mentioned office wisdom has nothing to do with the data presented below. Moreover, the right to hope, as they say, has not been canceled ...

So, some, I want to think, interesting economic statistics of the regions of Russia on the results of the outgoing year.

Based on data from the Federal Service for Labor and Employment (Rostrud), the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection of the Russian Federation and the Federal Portal of Administrative Personnel, a multi-level rating of the subjects of the Russian Federation is presented. The rating was compiled on several points at once, including such as
average wages, unemployment rate, price level, housing affordability for various categories of citizens, regional economic dynamics (growth / decline rates), accessibility of pre-school education (accessibility of kindergartens).

You can start with regional economic dynamics. To begin with, it is necessary to remind that the all-Russian economy (GDP) for the year is reduced by about 3-4%. The official forecast for the “narrowing” of the Russian economy from the IMF for the current year is 3,7%. At the Ministry of Economic Development, the forecast is different - about 3%. And what about the regions?

Official economic rating by region of the Russian Federation


The leaders in terms of positive economic dynamics are the following regions (results, frankly, somewhat unexpected): Republic of Ingushetia (economic growth 11,3%!), Tambov region (economic growth 9,9%!), Sevastopol (economic growth 7,6%), Tyumen region ( economic growth 7,1%), Republic of Dagestan (economic growth 5,7%).

For the first time, Ingushetia and the Tambov Region are at the top of this rating, as is the Republic of Dagestan, which was among the favorites among the Russian regions for the first time in terms of economic development. For the first time, Sevastopol is at the top of the rating, but for Sevastopol and full participation in the rating is actually the first.

Here you can afford to joke, saying that the head of the Ingush Republic, Yunus-Bek Yevkurov, can rejoice, because, firstly, he left Chechnya far behind the neighbors - Chechnya (Chechnya has a minus 1,5%), and secondly, economic growth Ingushetia has overtaken ... the Chinese. It turns out that either statistics gurus work in Magas, or irony is inappropriate here, and Ingushetia has managed to really achieve such impressive indicators.

Perhaps, after reading such data, readers from among the residents of the listed regions will say that the data is “linden,” the author supposedly found everything; to shower him with rotten eggs and tomatoes ... But, as has already been noted, these are the results shown in the materials collected by Rostrud and the Ministry of Labor. But really seriously to treat this data - the opinion of each individual reader.

Who are the economic outsiders? From the same rating:
Republic of Crimea (-5,5%), Vologda Region (-4,1%), Kemerovo Region (-3,7%), Kaluga Region (-2,6%) Primorsky Krai (-2,3%), Komi Republic (-2,3%).

Moscow and St. Petersburg - "by zero". Moscow has a fall in the economy at the level of 0,1%, in St. Petersburg - a strict zero.

It was noteworthy that the indicators of the Republic of Crimea and Sevastopol, which are members of the common Crimean Federal District, differ. If Sevastopol is at the top of the table, then the Republic of Crimea is an absolute outsider of the rating. It would be possible to write off everything on anti-Crimean sanctions, but then how to relate the Sevastopol indicator to this? Or do you still need to dig deeper than what is explained only by the sanctions regime?

What do we have (more precisely, theirs) on employment?

By employment ahead: Moscow (unemployment at the level of 1,8%), St. Petersburg (2%), Samara region (2,5%). And behind, “suddenly”, Ingushetia (30,6%).

As they say, attention is the question: how did a republic with a third of the unoccupied population manage to achieve economic growth in 11,3%? How could the region be the first in terms of economic growth to be the last in the list of regions in terms of employment? Once again, you are convinced that statistics is a wonderful thing ... It can be assumed that the whole thing is federal infusions, but infusions were certainly not smaller in the Republic of Crimea, and there is a significant economic decline and the average unemployment in Russia is 6%. Practically, everything is exactly the opposite. Or Simferopol really has not mastered the funds allocated by Moscow, not wanting to do it rush for the New Year, and therefore such an indicator ...

In terms of prices in the undisputed leaders of Kamchatka (22,4 thousand rubles for a fixed set of goods), Chukotka (20,8 thousand rubles), the Magadan region (19,5 thousand rubles).

Moscow is also in the upper part with 14,68 thousand rubles. for a fixed set of goods (per month).

The most “cheap” region of the country is Sevastopol (10,9 thousand rubles).

High affordability of housing (at a price for renting a one-room apartment per month) in the Oryol region (7,1 thousand rubles), Kursk region (7,2 thousand rubles), Penza region (7,2 thousand rubles). The most expensive rental housing on Sakhalin, in Moscow and in the Nenets Autonomous District. True, the statistics here are very interesting. So, it is reported that in Moscow the average cost of renting odnushki will cost 26,7 thousand per month. And if you walk through sites that offer data on rental services in the capital, the average bar will be at best 2-3 a thousand higher.

Regions in which matters regarding the availability of kindergartens are worse than others are Stavropol and Krasnoyarsk Territories, Karachay-Cherkessia and North Ossetia-Alania. High provision of preschool children with kindergartens in the Vologda, Vladimir, Novgorod, Arkhangelsk regions, on Chukotka, Sakhalin and in the Primorsky Territory.

In general, the indicators make you think. And first of all, think about how the official figures will coincide with the real ones, if there was a possibility of such a comparison across all regions of the country?

More official statistics can be found on the Internet site. trudvsem.ru.
Author:
90 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. avvg
    avvg 30 December 2015 06: 24
    +5
    Where regional authorities are economic, there will be no failures.
    1. Sura
      Sura 30 December 2015 07: 27
      +5
      I agree. For example, in Udmurtia http://ok.ru/video/64766335388651-1
      1. Pirogov
        Pirogov 30 December 2015 17: 48
        +3
        I agree. For example, in Udmurtia http: //ok.ru/video/64766335388651-1 .................................. ...........
        .................................................. ..... Tell me, how can you not kill these local kings? The Chinese urinate such creatures in spite of merit.
    2. The comment was deleted.
    3. siberalt
      siberalt 30 December 2015 07: 43
      23
      Very good curious. There is only one country, and population incomes by region vary by a factor of ten. Liberal politics, however! For government (state employees) employees it is simply necessary to establish a salary scale. Well, it can not vary hundreds of times.
      1. DIVAN SOLDIER
        DIVAN SOLDIER 30 December 2015 08: 43
        +9
        Yes, because the state is such a scam, they crawl out at the expense of the requisitions of the population, if only someone from the bureaucracy cut their own bastards !!! All people are ripped off.
        1. Boos
          Boos 30 December 2015 09: 50
          +9
          I support, I clearly separate the present state from the Motherland, and I do not want to have anything to do with it, because I do not see any concern for the people on the part of the "state". With the current achievements of science and technology, with the availability of Our natural resources, the people could live under communism. Under a sound government. And this is a fact!
          1. Dewa1s
            Dewa1s 30 December 2015 12: 46
            22 th
            This is crap, not a fact.
            The results of attempts to build communism we saw in the nineties.
            Haha.
            1. bondarencko
              bondarencko 30 December 2015 20: 09
              -1
              Excuse me, are you, an hour, not blind?
            2. dzeredzavkomimu
              dzeredzavkomimu 30 December 2015 21: 58
              +2
              actually in the nineties they built capitalism, the official Gaidar-Chubais economy, privatization, etc., an attempt to build communism under Khrushchev was unsuccessful
          2. samarin1969
            samarin1969 30 December 2015 14: 07
            +1
            +++++++++++++, and marsh - in the swamp
          3. Dimon19661
            Dimon19661 30 December 2015 15: 05
            +3
            The fact is when something happened, when something can be demonstrated, show where you see communism? Continuous talking room.
      2. Sura
        Sura 30 December 2015 08: 49
        16
        In Udmurtia during the reign of Volkov (17 years), only on a large scale and the fact that he gave the entire oil industry to Tatarstan, the entire gas system was given and controlled from Moscow, Izhmash (weapons) went bankrupt, the IZ plant went bankrupt, closed (one of largest in the USSR) ball-bearing, etc. etc.
        1. kote119
          kote119 30 December 2015 09: 20
          +5
          Yes, this demon did things, Udmurtia is in debt like silk, roads are bad
          1. Sura
            Sura 30 December 2015 18: 30
            -1
            More precisely, a ghoul.
        2. Alexl
          Alexl 30 December 2015 09: 41
          -1
          IL-auto works, weapons Izhmash also works.
          1. Sura
            Sura 30 December 2015 12: 10
            10
            IL-auto works, weapons Izhmash also works.

            Izh-auto after bankruptcy invested 4 lard (voiced) of government money, Izhmash don’t know for sure I don’t know the figures, whoever took this money out of my mouth? ... clearly not a single oligarch or official was hurt.
      3. Uncle VasyaSayapin
        Uncle VasyaSayapin 30 December 2015 09: 30
        +2
        If everything is equalized, 90% of the population will want to live in Sochi or on the southern coast of Crimea. And the rest is inside the regions in the countryside. Is it not clear?
        1. bondarencko
          bondarencko 30 December 2015 20: 12
          0
          Well, if the Kremlin is moved to Sochi, then 10% of the population will remain in Moscow, and those are pensioners.
      4. Corsair
        Corsair 30 December 2015 11: 08
        +2
        Quote: siberalt
        For government (state employees) employees it is simply necessary to establish a salary scale. Well, it can not vary hundreds of times.

        In the hundreds it cannot, in theory the differences should only be in the coefficients (regional and for harmfulness) plus all kinds of local premiums from the government, but we have a wonderland - everything can be here fellow
      5. seos
        seos 7 January 2016 17: 39
        0
        Revenues depend on prices ... in regions prices are 5-10 times different ...
    4. shtanko.49
      shtanko.49 30 December 2015 11: 55
      +2
      In regions where there has generally been a decline, there is a rise in relation to that level, I think so. And where the bar was high enough, they did not jump, that’s the whole mystery.
      1. SRC P-15
        SRC P-15 30 December 2015 13: 40
        +2
        And in our apartment there is gas! And you? - I live in the Moscow region, on December 24 they spent natural gas in an apartment, life is getting better ... smile
        1. Andryukha Siberian
          Andryukha Siberian 30 December 2015 21: 36
          +5
          Excellent. I live in Siberia. There is no gas and is not expected. Here we are !!! request
    5. seos
      seos 5 January 2016 18: 39
      +1
      The addicts made up the rating - they lied in 3 boxes .... on this govnoreytingom in Moscow a grocery basket is more expensive than in the Far East ... to catch the compiler and send a link to the month to the Far East ...
  2. parusnik
    parusnik 30 December 2015 06: 26
    +2
    As the classics said: Statistics know everything ...
    1. Amurets
      Amurets 30 December 2015 06: 36
      20
      Quote: parusnik
      As the classics said: Statistics know everything ...

      As the classics said: we need to calculate how the bosses need it. Statistics is crafty: the glass can be half empty and the glass can be half full. And in spite of the laws of statistics with the MAPPING NEW YEAR FRIENDS!
    2. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov 30 December 2015 06: 51
      13
      Quote: parusnik
      Statistics know everything ...

      She doesn’t know nichrome!
      In terms of prices in the undisputed leaders of Kamchatka (22,4 thousand rubles for a fixed set of goods), Chukotka (20,8 thousand rubles), the Magadan region (19,5 thousand rubles).
      In general, nonsense, the prices in Kamchatka cannot be higher than in Magadan and Chukotka, since in these regions prices are sky-high. This is Anadr.
      Here you can compare the prices of Kamchatka and Chukotka, though for 2012, but the difference can be understood.
      http://maxpark.com/user/2976644430/content/1298949
      Looks like the one who compiled the statistics has never been not in Chukotka, nor anywhere else and even in the Internet did they look.
      1. afdjhbn67
        afdjhbn67 30 December 2015 07: 05
        +5
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        She doesn’t know nichrome!

        Hi Sasha hi after your comment, ashamed of your own - we are fattening lol
        1. Alexander Romanov
          Alexander Romanov 30 December 2015 07: 11
          17
          Quote: afdjhbn67
          ashamed of our own - we are fattening

          Prices for 12 years, multiply by 2 and get the price of this day. Cool Kolya drinks
          Magadan 2015 - Bon Appetit laughing
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. Erg
            Erg 30 December 2015 08: 05
            +6
            belay Nothing to yourself ... In the USA, kefir is 3-4 times cheaper (with their salaries). And I thought that in the suburbs everything is expensive ...
            1. Alexl
              Alexl 30 December 2015 09: 43
              +3
              In the USA, everything is produced locally, but everything is imported to Magadan and Chukotka.
            2. a housewife
              a housewife 30 December 2015 13: 16
              +2
              Is there kefir in the USA? Or didn’t you understand something?
              1. Rumata
                Rumata 30 December 2015 19: 53
                +4
                Quote: housewife
                Is there kefir in the USA? Or didn’t you understand something?

                In the US, there is everything you can find a buyer for. A liter of Kefir costs about $ 3-4, you can find it yourself cheaper and certainly, you can find it much
          3. KareL1978
            KareL1978 30 December 2015 08: 17
            +3
            Not a damn thing ... You can choke ...
          4. The comment was deleted.
          5. inpu
            inpu 30 December 2015 09: 05
            +8
            Majors etit !!!! They drink kefir for 300 r and eat red caviar with spoons from a barrel!
          6. aiden
            aiden 3 January 2016 01: 30
            0
            What about locally made products?
      2. Eugene-Eugene
        Eugene-Eugene 30 December 2015 07: 10
        18
        It seems that those who compiled the statistics have never been not in Chukotka, nor anywhere else, nor even looked at the Internet

        Ministries operate with data from regional authorities and plenipotentiaries. If their employees still wander around the local shops and markets, then why bother with the statorgans of local administrations at all?
        In Stalin's time, an effective system for checking the reports of the provincial authorities was built, and at the same time it was simple to madness: local units of the OGPU / NKVD independently monitored the socio-economic situation in the territories and regions, compiling their own operational and annual reports, which lay on the table of the secretary general. Sometimes in these reports the local authorities were caught in "fraud".
        1. MMX
          MMX 30 December 2015 10: 56
          +1
          Quote: Eugene-Eugene
          It seems that those who compiled the statistics have never been not in Chukotka, nor anywhere else, nor even looked at the Internet

          Ministries operate with data from regional authorities and plenipotentiaries. If their employees still wander around the local shops and markets, then why bother with the statorgans of local administrations at all?
          In Stalin's time, an effective system for checking the reports of the provincial authorities was built, and at the same time it was simple to madness: local units of the OGPU / NKVD independently monitored the socio-economic situation in the territories and regions, compiling their own operational and annual reports, which lay on the table of the secretary general. Sometimes in these reports the local authorities were caught in "fraud".


          Absolutely right. If the numbers are incorrect, then the local workers "tried" and all the questions to them (their own, it turns out) ... But not all ordinary people understand this and the minister in Moscow is personally to blame for everything (at least).
    3. oblako
      oblako 30 December 2015 07: 15
      22
      Looking at the map, it becomes clear that we were "torn to shreds" ...))) In fact, we ourselves were torn when we began to adjust the country's economy not to our own needs, but to the needs of the "world (Western) economy" with serving uncombed our reformers. For these purposes, so that the commies would not return, we "turned" into the dollar and left our ruble inconvertible. Now that he is, that he is not - no one worries much. And the "reformers" do not see this as bae ... The iron curtain has been lowered to us, but from the other side, and we still believe in the "ideals of perestroika". Maybe it's enough already? It is also necessary, on our part, to close the gate for the removal of the loot ... Or else to live with wolves, so bombing the oil fields is "not fancy", since the VKS and VZO have been invested ... Investments should bring benefits to the state ...
    4. EvgNik
      EvgNik 30 December 2015 07: 42
      16
      Quote: parusnik
      As the classics said: Statistics know everything ...

      And at the same time, he knows nothing. I am very surprised by the term "average wage". How is this "average" value obtained? The oligarch and the bum are taken, and the money is divided in half? Or something else? Complete nonsense, if not deception.
      1. afdjhbn67
        afdjhbn67 30 December 2015 07: 54
        +3
        Quote: EvgNik
        Complete nonsense, if not cheating.

        exactly so - but for "statistics" it is the most, pirduha lol (oh forgot the space bar to press ..) laughing
      2. The comment was deleted.
      3. The comment was deleted.
  3. Kibalchish
    Kibalchish 30 December 2015 06: 26
    +3
    We have a general collapse here.
  4. afdjhbn67
    afdjhbn67 30 December 2015 06: 39
    +8
    Buryatia is sadly complete .. crying Statistics, too, as in Ingushetia, were corrected, otherwise it would have been necessary to draw pure white ... fellow Tax presses like that angry that the whole big business fled to Crimea and Vladivostok .. but on TV dada dada - all in a bunch .. repeat fool
  5. inkass_98
    inkass_98 30 December 2015 06: 57
    +5
    "There are lies, blatant lies and statistics" (C). And you can't argue, statistics - "a corrupt girl in the service of capital" (C). laughing
  6. Cap.Morgan
    Cap.Morgan 30 December 2015 07: 03
    +6
    Well, growth in Ingushetia! Probably a couple of cheburechniks opened on the road and car service numbers on the engines to interrupt.
  7. fa2998
    fa2998 30 December 2015 07: 19
    11
    Quote: Kibalchish
    We have a general collapse here.

    The statistics are good, but even if the region is in a good place, you need to look at how things are inside the region. Often it is the regional center "afloat", but in the region-seams. This is exactly the case here. crying hi
    1. a housewife
      a housewife 30 December 2015 13: 26
      +2
      But in our country in Adygea, on the contrary. In Maykop, the factories that the economy has always held on to, almost all do not work, but they have spawned small firms. Agriculture - more or less, and even all kinds of shopping centers are being built closer to Krasnodar. You read in the newspaper - that’s what they built and discovered. Where? Near Krasnodar. request
  8. Great-grandfather of Zeus
    Great-grandfather of Zeus 30 December 2015 07: 34
    +7
    I’m not at all happy about the state statistics or howl of a beluga?
    1. afdjhbn67
      afdjhbn67 30 December 2015 07: 56
      +2
      it's time to learn to tell the truth to the people

      You want to lose sleep and appetite from this truth .. belay
      1. samarin1969
        samarin1969 30 December 2015 14: 32
        +1
        Are you pr. Preobragensky? wink
        1. afdjhbn67
          afdjhbn67 30 December 2015 14: 48
          +2
          Quote: samarin1969
          Are you pr. Preobragensky?

          “If Darya Petrovna and I start painting the toilet in yellow and blue, then my toilet will be destroyed.”
    2. Erg
      Erg 30 December 2015 08: 16
      19
      At the end of the 15th year, my family can afford 1.5-2.0 times less than at the beginning of 2014 ... And what do I care about these "extras"?
      1. KareL1978
        KareL1978 30 December 2015 08: 20
        +8
        I fully subscribe to your comment.
      2. The comment was deleted.
  9. samarin1969
    samarin1969 30 December 2015 07: 51
    +9
    Pay taxes! ... In Crimea, the owners of dead shops, yoghurt traders, sellers of the Chinese junk trade with 300% wrap up drive decent cars, swollen from laziness "resortmen" lead an expensive lifestyle ... And they demand "help for small business" am
    A country should not live only on oil industry and income tax.
  10. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 30 December 2015 07: 55
    +6
    Quote: siberalt
    Very good curious. The country is one, and incomes of the regions vary dozens of times

    Not only income but also payment for utilities. In Khabarovsk, for a kopeck piece in the winter, 8 thousand, with an average civil pension of 10-11 thousand rubles.
    1. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov 30 December 2015 08: 19
      +4
      Quote: rotmistr60
      In Khabarovsk for kopeck piece in the winter of 8 thousand,

      The main payment is heating. Komsomolsk dvushka for December 2015.
      hot water 330
      heating 2
      gas 80
      light 1116
      overhaul 175
      home repair 797
      cold water 186
      water supply 117
      Why do you have 8000 pieces flies then?
      1. rotmistr60
        rotmistr60 30 December 2015 13: 04
        +3
        I will not paint, but I have almost 8.500 rubles with two prescribed. I don’t know where you got the data from Komsomolsk. How are you in Primorye?
        1. Alexander Romanov
          Alexander Romanov 30 December 2015 15: 09
          +1
          Quote: rotmistr60
          How do you get data on Komsomolsk I don’t know

          So write down what and how much it costs. I'm now in Komsomolsk, I need you to print a screen of quantifications here.
      2. rotmistr60
        rotmistr60 30 December 2015 13: 30
        +2
        Counted on receipts with two prescribed, rub
        mountains water - 700
        heating - 2393
        gas - 308 (counter)
        light - 925
        thorough repair - 256
        maintenance and repair of housing - 1744
        cold water - 563
        water disposal-548
        Total 7437 rubles (without telephone (300) and intercom (80))
        1. Alexander Romanov
          Alexander Romanov 30 December 2015 15: 10
          +1
          Quote: rotmistr60
          gas - 308 (counter)

          Is gas burning around the clock?
          Quote: rotmistr60
          cold water - 563
          water disposal-548

          Fuck you rate
      3. a housewife
        a housewife 30 December 2015 13: 31
        +1
        I live in my house, so I don’t understand - hot water, cold water, and what is water supply at the same time?
        1. jjj
          jjj 30 December 2015 16: 39
          +1
          Quote: housewife
          What is water supply?

          This is a sewer. It is slightly less in volume than the sum of the obtained volume of cold and hot water
          1. Siberia 9444
            Siberia 9444 30 December 2015 20: 09
            +1
            We do not have prices, such dairy products are not vegetables and fruits! For one bottle of ryazhenka in Novosibirsk, you can buy 6 liters of milk from 45 to 57 rubles, and then I take only our Novosibirsk region and Irmen started producing yogurt in plastic cups not so long ago, so far there are only two flavors - peach and blueberry.

            Weight: 250 g about 50 rubles.
  11. Foxtrot-krim
    Foxtrot-krim 30 December 2015 08: 13
    +2
    Something really is the author -> author -> the author confused. Crimea is 5,5% worse than it was in the independent ...? I’m from Simferople, roads are being built all over Crimea, long-standing enterprises are launched, agriculture has revived- new vineyards are planted, new livestock farms are being organized, new housing is being rented out, whereas in Sevastopol everything is much more modest and the Sevastopol residents themselves think so.
    1. aleks 62 next
      aleks 62 next 30 December 2015 12: 30
      +3
      ..... I’m from Simferople, roads are being built all over Crimea, long-standing enterprises are being launched, agriculture has revived, new vineyards have been planted, new livestock farms are being organized, new housing is being rented out ....

      .... Well this is where in Crimea they saw it ???? ..... Enterprises are launched (what, where ???), new vineyards are planted - where ????), etc. ... Except perhaps expensive .... And even that is a big question ..... belay
    2. samarin1969
      samarin1969 30 December 2015 14: 53
      +2
      A fellow countryman, where are "long standing enterprises started up,"?
      Nothing political ... I hate marsh and ukrov am
      ... But where is the progress?
  12. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 30 December 2015 08: 23
    +7
    Father told his son that Santa Claus is a fiction.
    In retaliation, the offspring told dad that Channel One news was fake.
  13. Shark Lover
    Shark Lover 30 December 2015 08: 23
    24
    I have my own statistics and they are not happy. By the way, I went to the store the other day, scored local cucumbers, 1,6 kg, something decided to take more, weighed and went crazy, 356 rubles. I asked the seller, someone ??? At least the seller did not lie, as there was a flood in the summer, they raised prices, but they simply forgot to lower them. At what the producers raised a little, the rest of the rest freeloaders, resellers screwed up the rest. Producers in debt were flooded, speculators in chocolate, especially the last in the chain. I would like to ask a question to fat-ass figures in chic suits: Does it regulate the market itself, is it a market economy according to Gaidar ??? Why, then, are you sitting there at meetings, babbling bullshit. I don’t whine, in principle, we earn normally (in the family), but we just feed the idlers, parasites and stupid bureaucrats in the government. Why do they need such privileges? Are local bureaucrats outraged? Again the question is, why are you sitting in Moscow with pants? Do I have to deal with your local vassals and henchmen? So right away the fins are wrapped up by law enforcement officers))) This statistic is the result of the work of our "managers-brains", even this one is sparing, not to mention the real one. The generation of the 90s stupid fuckers has grown up.
  14. Million
    Million 30 December 2015 08: 30
    +2
    Statistics can be very different from reality.
    as the hero of one movie said: Round off, then we'll figure it out
  15. Born in USSR
    Born in USSR 30 December 2015 08: 38
    11
    I live in the Khanty Mansi Autonomous Okrug. This is where the gas is extracted. 1000 cubic meters of gas 4700 for the population is where heating is needed for 8 months in a year, and in the summer it blows 2 degrees of heat in July. And heating in a wooden two-story building for 54 sq.m. repair 3700 repair 1200 maintenance 1094 is not sickly yes. Bread 47 rubles, sausage type Krakow 700, and live.
    1. Alexl
      Alexl 30 December 2015 09: 47
      +2
      In conditions where in summer only + 2 shift workers should live.
      1. samarin1969
        samarin1969 30 December 2015 14: 54
        +1
        Selkups wept and emigrated wink
  16. sleeping sayan
    sleeping sayan 30 December 2015 09: 05
    +3
    He worked at the Yuzhno-Priobskoye field. A man worked with us, he is 57 years old. Pension 17t. Plus, salary 44t. And generally in Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug, finding work is easy. They work, do not whine.
    1. yuriy55
      yuriy55 30 December 2015 15: 36
      +5
      Quote: sleeping Sayan
      He worked at the Yuzhno-Priobskoye field. A man worked with us, he is 57 years old. Pension 17t. Plus, salary 44t. And generally in Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug, finding work is easy. They work, do not whine.


      I agree with you, is it really that 600 watchmen are really needed in Russia with the modern development of electronics? And, if you adjust the law, then they will not want to steal. ChOP, in my opinion, a certain power structure of the employer ... what
  17. Governor
    Governor 30 December 2015 09: 09
    +5
    Well, to whom, and people in the north of the country cannot be supported at all. After all, at such prices, life turns into survival ...
    And the prices could be much lower. We need a quality and developed infrastructure and control of officials (well, this is already fantastic, of course).
    We can recall the "leveling"; all lived poorly, but with dignity!
    1. Pomeranian
      Pomeranian 30 December 2015 11: 49
      +9
      Quote: Governor
      Well, to whom, and people in the north of the country cannot be supported at all.

      This is what happens, according to last year’s poll, the most dissatisfied with the authorities were in Karelia, the Murmansk region and somewhere else in the North Arkh. What should we rejoice if cretins from the federal center do everything to make life unbearable. Won, despite the protests of the governor and the public, with an absolute overabundance of electricity in the region, Medvedik introduced social norms for electricity. He 100% is not aware that we have a polar night and the light is on for at least 16 hours. Is the Medvedev government working against its country?
      1. Lekov L
        Lekov L 30 December 2015 19: 29
        +2
        Is the Medvedev government working against its own country?

        At the end of the phrase, you did not use that punctuation mark ..
        !
        Respectfully..
      2. denis02135
        denis02135 31 December 2015 15: 32
        0
        Dear Pomeranian

        Again 25, the king is good, and the boyars are bad, Medvedev has a boss who is responsible for the work of the government.
        But seriously, let's compile national statistics by region and put everything in one table. For example, the cost of a kilogram of potatoes, tomato, cucumbers, apples, 10 eggs, a liter of milk,
        Kg of butter (cream and sunflower), tea, sugar, buckwheat, pasta, beef and pork (not the most expensive) write in PM say until January 15, and I will post on site 20, just indicate the city and region and see where to live well. I warn you at the CIA and the State Department is not working. If possible, let our friends from near and far abroad write. And we will compare everything. Please indicate prices in rubles or dollars, euros to make it easier to lead to one denominator.
  18. 31rus
    31rus 30 December 2015 09: 10
    +1
    I’m sure everything is averaged, it’s actually even worse, but not everywhere, the Tambov region pleasantly surprised you, well done! But Peter and Moscow, you need to think hard, don’t pull the situation out with subsidies, here’s another confirmation, a lot of words and PR and lack of real business
  19. Alexl
    Alexl 30 December 2015 09: 49
    +4
    In Ingushetia, just a big shadow economy - informal employment, taxes are not paid ....
  20. Red_Hamer
    Red_Hamer 30 December 2015 10: 01
    -5
    and where is the Crimea, on the map?
    1. Volodin
      30 December 2015 14: 09
      +6
      Quote: Red_Hamer
      and where is the Crimea, on the map?

      Apparently, school geography is not your fad. Crimea in place.
    2. Red_Hamer
      Red_Hamer 10 February 2016 17: 38
      0
      oh, eat well, maybe I didn’t notice))
  21. uskrabut
    uskrabut 30 December 2015 10: 37
    +4
    Quote: siberalt
    There is only one country, and population incomes by region vary by a factor of ten. Liberal politics, however! For government (public sector) employees, it is simply necessary to establish a salary scale. Well, it can not vary hundreds of times.

    I absolutely agree that the difference should be at most 10%, and then only taking into account the travel, the communal apartment is about the same everywhere. It should be borne in mind that education, medicine and culture are much more expensive for people from the hinterland (all these benefits still have to be reached, and this is an additional cost, plus the rental of housing for students). But the Presidential Decree "On the Salary of State Civil Servants" provides for something completely different. In it, the salary is tied to the number of inhabitants of the settlement where the government agency is located. Where is the relationship? Or should civil servants actively engage in sexual reproduction? A very strange criterion. We can say that there is discrimination on a territorial basis, which is prohibited by the Constitution of the Russian Federation. Or am I wrong?
    1. Pomeranian
      Pomeranian 30 December 2015 11: 45
      +3
      Quote: uskrabut
      I absolutely agree, the difference should be a maximum of 10% and that only taking into account the passage, the communal apartment is approximately the same everywhere.

      That is, with a completely comparable level of wages, if I pay 11 thousand for a kopeck piece in the Arctic, and my relative in the middle band 6 is it about the same communal apartment ?? What difference should there be to recognize it as unequal ??
  22. goblin xnumx
    goblin xnumx 30 December 2015 11: 14
    0
    nonsense taken not even from the ceiling
  23. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 30 December 2015 11: 19
    +3
    "How long we will be fed with such stability is still unclear. Stable and Ulyukaev, who has even been nicknamed a diver for his constant search for the economic bottom. He groped for him both in August and December, and every time" just about, now it is exactly " , but something tells me that the minister will have to do a couple more dives. "

    See full: http://politrussia.com/control/vezhlivaya-nastya-400/
  24. Pomeranian
    Pomeranian 30 December 2015 11: 42
    +7
    An interesting article, the author plus definitely. But there is only one conclusion: if the country does not abandon the destructive monetary-liberal course, in a few years we will already begin to write to each other from the Polar Empires to the Siberian Alliance through the Nizhny Novgorod Republic under the friendly applause of our overseas and Chinese sworn friends. The Medvedev government is incapacitated and leads the country to collapse.
  25. super-vitek
    super-vitek 30 December 2015 12: 01
    16
    Here we sit like a scoop in the kitchens and on blogs procrastinate the situation in the country, but nothing changes, but it gets worse !!!! I am from Taganrog, I have three powerful enterprises in the city "Krasny Kotelshchik", Taganrog Metallurgical , Taganrog Aviation. Over the past two years, the situation with unemployment is simply critical !!!!!! The first two enterprises have cut workers by more than half, there are few orders, the current "effective managers" have brought my enterprise to a pre-bankruptcy state, and this despite the fact that we carry out the state defense order !!!!!!! I have to write at my own expense and look for a temporary job somewhere because there is nothing to feed my family !!!!!! And our management sends reports to Moscow that we have an average plant of 25000 tons. p !!!! Of course, if you add up the salaries of 31 !!!!!!! of the deputy director, where the amounts, as you understand, are approaching six zeros with our hard-working crumbs, such an average is possible !!!! But this is pure kidalovo !!!! And as the article said ATTENTION QUESTION !!! Vladimir Vladim Irovich, look back at your country, look back before it's too late !!!!! We are throwing out billions on the bearded evil, and that's right, but the fact that in our country the ruling thief is robbing the people is not right !!!!! Putin played too much, and a press conference with the press proved that in response to questions about the internal affairs, he cheated and cunning, and this is a call for me personally !!!
    1. Tusv
      Tusv 30 December 2015 18: 33
      +2
      ATTENTION QUESTION !!! Vladimir Vladimirovich, look back at your country, look around before it is too late !!!!! We are throwing billions into bearded evil spirits, and rightly so, but the fact that the ruling thieves in our country are robbing people is not right !! !!! Putin played too much, and a press conference with the press proved that he answered and cunningly answered answers to questions of internal affairs, and this is a call personally for me !!! With the coming of everyone !!!

      In our country they don’t like the people of today, and now, on the other side, the granites are no longer allowed to go west.
      There is the main anthem of our country "The Union is not destroyed", there is an anthem when we are fighting "Holy war" and there is an everyday one:
  26. Vikxnumx
    Vikxnumx 30 December 2015 13: 30
    +4
    Regions in which things are worse in terms of accessibility of kindergartens are the Stavropol and Krasnoyarsk Territories, Karachay-Cherkessia and North Ossetia-Alania.

    The wife in the group of 36 children on the list, go - 30 ... 32 ... Salary - 14000 ... 15000. The assistant tutor (nanny) ZP -5500 !!! Specialists were reduced, and all classes were hanged on teachers. A child must come to school trained!
  27. HollyGremlin
    HollyGremlin 30 December 2015 13: 46
    +5
    Of course "economic statistics" to put it mildly pseudoscience. But the incorrect interpretation of the numbers contributes not a small part.
    As they say, attention is a question: how did a republic with a third of the unemployed manage to achieve economic growth as much as 11,3%?

    This is very logical:
    1. You have a destroyed factory with 2 watchmen, a secretary and 1 worker. You employ another worker and get + 100% economic growth. Or you buy one machine is also a significant plus.
    2. And if you have a high-tech workshop. You cannot find personnel - everything is already arranged, you cannot increase the pace of production due to high competition, and even so everything in your workshop is automated. And then there’s a crisis - and customers are abandoning your services in favor of cheap regional ones.
  28. Gunther
    Gunther 30 December 2015 14: 25
    0
    Wrong to ignore
    if only because Russia is federal
    the state and national interests, including economic interests, are taking shape
    kaleidoscope from the interests of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.

    And how to take into account the "interests of the subjects" when they run counter to national security, and if Russia becomes a single state, what will change, the interests of the provinces will no longer be taken into account?
    ... or the irony is inappropriate here, and
    Ingushetia really managed to achieve such
    impressive performance.

    It is necessary to take into account financial doping, the state program of the government for the development of the North Caucasus at a cost of 300 billion rubles is in force.
    Who are the economic outsiders? From the same rating: Republic of Crimea (-5,5%) ...

    Is it any wonder if, according to Aksyonov, the funds allocated from the budget did not reach the Crimea?
    Boos Quote: ... in the presence of our natural resources, the people could live under communism. With sound rule. And it is a fact!

    But Colonel Baranets disagrees with you, the distinguished Colonel said (www.kp.ru/f/170/arch_file/75/16/141675.mp3 from 30 minutes) that it was time to "correct the realities" to bring the Constitution into line with reality , Gazprom - subsoil, the people, respectively, shish, although this logic leads to the need to legitimize, for example, bribes or pedophilia.
    I agree with V. Baranets that the time has come to look objectively at some provisions in the Constitution, but since my son does not work as vice-president of Gazprombank, the bowels should be left to the people, but, for example, the "realities" of the Central Bank should be brought into line with Art. 75 item 2.
  29. kaluganew
    kaluganew 30 December 2015 14: 28
    +2
    "The Republic of Crimea is an absolute outsider of the rating"

    Without a normal infrastructure, there will be no development and growth. Yesterday they sat without light. Everything has its time.
    1. yuriy55
      yuriy55 30 December 2015 15: 24
      +1
      Quote: kaluganew
      "The Republic of Crimea is an absolute outsider of the rating"

      Without a normal infrastructure, there will be no development and growth. Yesterday they sat without light. All in good time.


      It is right. Any business needs a head and time ...

      And as it happens, yesterday we climbed the branches, and today they are running around with machine guns and bazookas. And as for the Crimea. It has always been a health resort of the USSR, if we build a bridge, there will be a health resort for Russia. yes
  30. Friends
    Friends 30 December 2015 14: 54
    +1
    Quote: oblako
    Looking at the map, it becomes clear that we were "torn to shreds" ...))) In fact, we ourselves were torn when we began to adjust the country's economy not to our own needs, but to the needs of the "world (Western) economy" with serving uncombed our reformers. For these purposes, so that the commies would not return, we "turned" into the dollar and left our ruble inconvertible. Now that he is, that he is not - no one worries much. And the "reformers" do not see this as bae ... The iron curtain has been lowered to us, but from the other side, and we still believe in the "ideals of perestroika". Maybe it's enough already? It is also necessary, on our part, to close the gate for the removal of the loot ... Or else to live with wolves, so bombing the oil fields is "not fancy", since the VKS and VZO have been invested ... Investments should bring benefits to the state ...


    I agree.

    The only thing is that the iron curtain - and after the Second World War - was lowered to us from the same side - from the west. In essence, the story repeats itself. Then, it was the West that began to fence itself off from us, using hostile rhetoric similar to the current one. The anti-Russian bloc - NATO - they created. The Warsaw Pact organization was an answer - it was created 6 years later. Partition of Germany they began. First divided into zones. then the checkpoints were closed (this is an initiative by no means the leadership of the USSR). GDR appeared 3 years later Germany. The West has always found a reason for confrontation with the Russians.
  31. AdekvatNICK
    AdekvatNICK 30 December 2015 15: 02
    +1
    The author has not published all the cunning. And you look at how much the state debt of the regions has grown, especially in the Kranodar region. It's just tin. Just the abyss of dough.
  32. yuriy55
    yuriy55 30 December 2015 15: 15
    +2
    Yes, well, them ... The extras have gone astray ... They dictate to them, and they are happy to "derban" the keyboard ...
    How are we doing? The governor said that everything is fine with us ... Everything we have and everything is equal. And this:
    Who are the economic outsiders? From the same rating:
    Republic of Crimea (-5,5%), Vologda Oblast (-4,1%), Kemerovo region (-3,7%)Kaluga Region (-2,6%) Primorsky Territory (-2,3%), Komi Republic (-2,3%).

    The most common slander. Yes, if you want, we have so much configured in recent years ... these, in short, where they trade and engage in intermediary services. Some, there are some, due to their natural laziness, simply refuse (probably ?!) to free their usual hacks in order to move (?!). Hence the following nuances:
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 30 December 2015 16: 51
      0
      Of course, they will refuse to move, who wants to change the house from the plot to an apartment.
  33. fa2998
    fa2998 30 December 2015 15: 32
    +3
    Quote: Alexander Romanov
    cold water - 563
    water disposal-548
    Fuck you rate

    G. Novoshakhtinsk (Rostov Region) - cold water - 73,51 rubles; water disposal - 62,82 rubles per cubic meter; if you manage 10 cubes per month, multiply by 10. crying We joke that the water is imported directly from Lake Baikal. laughing
  34. Siberia
    Siberia 30 December 2015 18: 12
    +3
    Official unemployment is different from unofficial at times. Well, who wants to get registered there, collect certificates, go check-in and receive from 850r to 4900r per month. Meaning? But you can always report up - we have unemployment close to zero wink
  35. Tusv
    Tusv 30 December 2015 18: 12
    +3
    There are three types of lies: Direct, evasive and statistical reporting.
    The cat Matroskin is right: "Joint labor, for my benefit, it unites" - this is what the entire Federation should say, and if it comes to a fight among themselves, you need to remember the cat Leopold.
    Hard this year in the Crimea. At the beginning of the year, even vodka was not sold. We put the back. Together we are a bone in the throat bourgeois, individually a hamburger for breakfast for the average American
  36. marat023
    marat023 30 December 2015 20: 53
    +1
    I doubt the objectivity since Dagestan is the leader in this rating if everyone from here goes to other regions at work
  37. dzeredzavkomimu
    dzeredzavkomimu 30 December 2015 22: 18
    +2
    yeah, all my life there were the lowest official salaries, but here growth in Dagestan))) rose on black caviar? They’re adjusting the statistics, mark my word, soon after Putin’s words, we won’t raise the retirement age, because the average age of life is low. The statistics will be corrected, and by 17 we will live longer by 10 years according to statistics, and then, well, here’s the increase in the retirement age, so that the feeder (pension fund) is increased
  38. Bylynich
    Bylynich 30 December 2015 23: 10
    +1
    In the Tambov region, the growth is only because they plowed a little black soil overgrown with birch. And do you know how we think "well"? Once I helped to send data by fax for statistics, then when I read it, I was stunned by such virtual numbers.
    And if you compare with 1913, as was loved in the USSR, then we have communism.