Military Review

The Golden Apple of Eris by Russian Human Rights Defenders

34
The entry into force of the law on "foreign agents" greatly overshadowed the everyday work of non-profit organizations in Russia that received foreign funding. However, during discussions at NPO congresses, they found a way out of the situation - creating a union that would be able to lobby for the interests of non-profit organizations when interacting with government authorities. However, the non-governmental agents themselves perceived this initiative as a means of obtaining additional funding, which, in fact, sabotaged the entire project implementation.








https://homment.com/ZyLLG6WkfJ

The document reveals with the naked eye the style of work of Russian human rights defenders - the need for a joint division of foreign sponsorship among the leading “missionary” organizations. The report notes that the Golos Association is not able to organize and carry out the necessary measures to create a body for interaction with the state, upholding the interests of NGOs and democratic principles - the Russian Union of the Third Sector. In addition, it is indicated that a number of NPOs are extremely dissatisfied with the work of the curator of this process - Grigory Melkonyants, Deputy Executive Director of the Golos Association. The Golos movement ordered advisory, research, legal and other services from various non-profit organizations, but the leadership of the movement decided to postpone payment for the work done without the consent of the implementing NGOs.

So far, Golos has solved problems of cooperation with leading 1 NGOs in December 2015, during the sixth congress of Russian NGOs, the Russian Union of Non-Profit Organizations was created, which de facto became a competitor to the unformed Russian Union of the Third Sector. What, in fact, Melkonyants confirms with its statement: “The union of NGOs created by the VI congress of non-profit organizations of Russia is not the organization, the need for the creation of which was spoken by experts during the Civil Forum. The work on creating such an organization is being done and this is a lot of work. kondachka, you cannot create this union. It is not a quick process to create what we considered useful. "

(http://polit.ru/news/2015/12/02/nko_com/) Moreover, according to experts who analyzed the activities of Golos, the failure of the movement not only complicated the creation of the NPO trade union, but also disrupted the program to overcome the limitations set by Russian legislation, the sources of financing NPOs and the abolition of repressive measures against non-profit organizations, in particular laws on "foreign agents" and "undesirable organizations." In other words, it prevented an international project to change the legislation of the Russian Federation for the free work of non-profit organizations in the political direction, the protection of recipients of foreign sponsorship and the financing flows from abroad.

Therefore, the author of the report considers it necessary to stop funding from international organizations of all NGOs that are included in the Russian Union of Non-Profit Organizations, and to entrust the formation of a new association to protect the rights of non-profit organizations to specialists from the Center for the Development of Non-Profit Organizations.

All in the best traditions of the "human rights business" - the organization of unfair competition, the discrediting of the opponent, advertising the customer and receiving thanks in the form of a kickback or the possibility of participating in the joint sawing of sponsorship financial income. In an interview with a senior advisor to the Norwegian Helsinki Committee, an anonymous employee "Vote" talks about the internal kitchen of the organization and the process of turning the western grant into an elegant cut with a flick of the wrist. Some part of the funds went to overcome differences with the disgruntled curator of Golos of the creation of the Russian Union of the Third Sector. Another part of the sponsorship money by the decision of the Golos management went to the "stabilization fund." It is noteworthy that the employees of “Voices” themselves find it difficult to answer whether such a fund exists at all. The next article is the mastering of funds - bonuses to the chairmen of the movement and especially distinguished employees. Plus spending on banquets in the restaurants "Siberia Moscow" and "Parisien". Unfortunately, the budget is not rubber, so there is no extra money left to pay for the services provided to Golos by the Iofe Memorial Fund, the Public Verdict and the Center for the Development of Non-Profit Organizations.

Summarizing the information presented by the employee of Golos, the author writes: “The statement of the NGO employee clearly shows what is happening inside non-profit organizations in the Russian Federation. Judging by this information, the work of many NGOs is not about upholding democratic principles and freedoms, developing civil society, the fight against the arbitrariness of the authorities and the security forces, the monitoring of electoral processes, and an internecine squabble for financial support. International funds should understand one thing - before cooperating Russian human rights activists, it is necessary to eradicate corruption within their organizations. "

Like it or not, the creation of a trade union of non-profit organizations will not affect the effectiveness of the work of non-profit organizations. The very desire to unite pro-Western human rights defenders is nothing more than the desire to get the opportunity to cut common funds at a higher level. Even Honore de Balzac in his novel Father of the Goryo described a situation that perfectly illustrates the work of Russian NGOs. "Cruelty, calculation, money reign everywhere. There are no principles, there are only events, there are no laws, there are circumstances. Success falls to those who manage to marry events with circumstances in order to direct them themselves. Considering that fifty thousand good places are all can't find any more, you have to devour each other, like spiders in a can. "

A source: http://mikhailbeliin.livejournal.com/518.html
Author:
Originator:
http://mikhailbeliin.livejournal.com/518.html]http://mikhailbeliin.livejournal.com/518.html
34 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Same lech
    Same lech 25 December 2015 08: 26 New
    36
    I am shocked ... to create a union of foreign agents in RUSSIA .... this has not happened in our history what

    Soon, the accompanying attributes will appear ... trips to a sanatorium somewhere in FLORIDA for the treatment of the undermined health of an agent of a foreign country.

    Damn ... I did not think that the joke would become a reality.
    1. vkl-47
      vkl-47 25 December 2015 08: 29 New
      14
      cockroaches stirred
      1. oleg-gr
        oleg-gr 25 December 2015 08: 38 New
        11
        This is not a union, but a gathering. Looking and handing out finances has long been appointed.
        1. GRAY
          GRAY 25 December 2015 10: 15 New
          +6
          Quote: oleg-gr
          This is not a union, but a gathering. Looking and handing out finances has long been appointed.

          There is such a profession - to betray the homeland.
          1. blackenergy89
            blackenergy89 25 December 2015 11: 05 New
            +2
            What is the homeland of the Jews?
            1. GRAY
              GRAY 25 December 2015 11: 17 New
              +2
              Quote: blackenergy89
              What is the homeland of the Jews?

              And where are the Jews? In the Jewish Autonomous Region, there are only enemies, do you think they live?
              Betrayal of nationality does not have.
            2. Prager
              Prager 25 December 2015 13: 32 New
              0
              hit the spot!
          2. Altona
            Altona 25 December 2015 12: 29 New
            0
            Quote: GRAY
            There is such a profession - to betray the homeland.

            ------------------
            Yes, they are in deep decline. They have discredited themselves since the 90s, the entire ea liberation of Russia. I got out on the "dungeons of Ryzhima", and under Yeltsin there were more prisoners than under Stalin, and there were over a million children homeless. The people no longer believe them.
    2. Decathlon
      Decathlon 25 December 2015 08: 31 New
      10
      Wait! Given the current situation in the field of education, they will also begin to be trained in our universities. We will definitely reach you! "Foreign agent of general profile"
      1. Diana Ilyina
        Diana Ilyina 25 December 2015 09: 02 New
        12
        So the education with us is supervised by a foreign agent! And unlike NKoshny agents, this one is effective, I would even say very effective, it is not for nothing that he receives two salaries! Just a couple of educational reforms in the form of the exam in the third grade and it will be possible to put an end to the economy and the military-industrial complex and everything else, but what’s the rest, you can immediately put on the country!
    3. The comment was deleted.
    4. bocsman
      bocsman 25 December 2015 08: 36 New
      +6
      Why be surprised? These scum have long turned the betrayal of the motherland into a business! And now they simply confirm the fact of the deed!
      1. kazachyok69
        kazachyok69 25 December 2015 12: 03 New
        +3
        Betrayal? Homeland? I don't care about the minuses - can you tell Power who? Overly rich Friends? For which the Leader is not ashamed? Are they Patriots of the Motherland? And how does the word "Motherland" refer to the People of Russia? Our gas ... at sky-high prices ... our oil at sky-high prices ... our electricity? Everything that belongs to the Motherland is someone's property ... someone on "our" has billions? And what does the People have to do with this? Are the people and "Motherland" different concepts?
    5. Ami du peuple
      Ami du peuple 25 December 2015 08: 36 New
      +3
      Quote: The same LYOKHA
      trips to a sanatorium somewhere in FLORIDA for the treatment of the undermined health of an agent of a foreign country.

      A good idea. And, it is desirable to organize a similar sea cruise to the shores of the United States with the full composition of the trade union of workers of foreign NGOs. Well, as in the joke: "I, you harlot, gathered for three years for one ship" bully
    6. Russian Uzbek
      Russian Uzbek 25 December 2015 09: 09 New
      +1
      it is the same operetta "trade union" as the Russian "oppositionists" themselves
    7. Aksakal_07
      Aksakal_07 25 December 2015 09: 11 New
      +5
      Quote: The same LYOKHA
      create a union of foreign agents in RUSSIA .... this has not happened in our history

      Lived!?! It remains only to create a "Union of veterans of subversive operations against the USSR-Russia" and establish the title "Honored Spy against Russia", which gives the right to social benefits from the budget.
  2. kursk87
    kursk87 25 December 2015 08: 34 New
    +2
    Western-funded NPOs violate the stability of the state, destroying it from the inside, introducing false Western liberal values. Many of us "appreciated" the help of such organizations in building our economy in the 90s
    1. Grbear
      Grbear 25 December 2015 10: 35 New
      +2
      Quote: kursk87
      Western-funded NPOs violate the stability of the state, destroying it from the inside, introducing false Western liberal values. Many of us "appreciated" the help of such organizations in building our economy in the 90s

      IMHO of course, but NPOs must be. They, if under the vigilant control of services, perform three important functions:
      First, they work like the Mantoux vaccine. They infect the body, but do not kill and form immunity. If the vaccinated person does not understand and begins to "wet and comb", then this is his problem and a reason for "treatment".
      Second, NPOs play the role of a "flavored" heap, into which already formed "individuals" flock and do not fly away. Controlling the size of this pile is much easier and cheaper.
      Thirdly, NPOs respond quite quickly to real negative trends in society. More precisely, they seek them out. Therefore, they can and should be used as indicators of the social situation.

      Without flies and g ... nature does not exist. Question in quantity. hi
      1. kotvov
        kotvov 25 December 2015 13: 58 New
        0
        but there should be NGOs, that is, do you still offer them vouchers to issue? These members working against the country are open,
        will create a union, then the state should provide them with help. maybe you didn’t get enough sleep?
  3. mpzss
    mpzss 25 December 2015 08: 34 New
    +4
    in principle, it is necessary to close all of these NGOs and send all those who are listed in factories, factories, to fields, work the way there, and do not live off, at the expense of amers, in our country and on our neck!
    1. kazachyok69
      kazachyok69 25 December 2015 12: 21 New
      0
      in principle, it is necessary to close all of these NGOs and send all those who are listed in factories, factories, to fields, work the way there, and do not live off, at the expense of amers, in our country and on our neck!

      Sorry .... not about NGOs and other bastards ... but you don't want to send YOURSELF to the plant, so that you work there for free "for Uncle"? It's genius - let's send everyone to the factories and the countryside to work "at home" to work .... for specific Owners of this "Motherland" ... Oh, how the Motherland (specific Uncles) will be good to have free slaves and for their slave labor to have all lol
  4. Andrey Yuryevich
    Andrey Yuryevich 25 December 2015 08: 35 New
    +5
    All NPOs must be sent to this address.
  5. aszzz888
    aszzz888 25 December 2015 08: 36 New
    +1
    but to internecine squabble for financial support.


    This principle has always been present with them. Who will rip out their financial piece more. End them ALL, these NGOs.
  6. silberwolf88
    silberwolf88 25 December 2015 08: 38 New
    +3
    NGOs ... this is a cynical business of preparing for the collapse of the country ... uniting all those who hate Russia ... this is the platform of their ideological association ... One thing is for sure ... the lists of names and residential addresses of NGOs and their leaders are known ...
  7. ibu355yandex.ru
    ibu355yandex.ru 25 December 2015 08: 38 New
    +1
    No words only emotions!!! To prohibit the activities of foreign agents whose purpose is the collapse of Russia is the smallest thing you can afford. And it is necessary to transfer them all to sunny Magadan! Nobody has yet canceled the article of the Criminal Code for treason!
    Or forcibly change their homeland, as they once did in Solzhenitsyn.
    1. Hyppopotut
      Hyppopotut 25 December 2015 08: 49 New
      +4
      It is possible to ban, but then all agents will go underground. And an underground agent is more difficult to identify. So they are all in sight.
      In the USSR, they were banned, and the agent "Humpbacked" got to the chair of the general secretary ... am
  8. olegfbi
    olegfbi 25 December 2015 08: 42 New
    +2
    And I’m never surprised at all! am All this is somewhere and / or when it already was.
    Looked at the doc the other day. the film "The Big Game", it tells about the confrontation between the Russian and British empires of the 19th century in the Balkans, the Mediterranean, Central Asia, the Black Sea ... So, if you change the date and names of the characters in the film, we will see modern events!!! Then they found the balance, and what will happen now - We will see.
    No wonder they say that history repeats itself in a spiral or everything new = well-forgotten old!
  9. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 25 December 2015 08: 51 New
    +3
    greatly overshadowed the workdays of nonprofits

    The author put it mildly. Not overshadowed, but they are sick in hysterics. Every year it becomes more and more difficult, without getting into the field of vision of citizens (the authorities know them by sight), to receive green money from Russia's "best friend" and work in the interests of this "friend". It's time, it's time to completely cut off the oxygen to these "human rights defenders" who have not protected a single normal person, fighters against "Stalinism" who are trying to rehabilitate real enemies and traitors, and just people who are clearly not defending the interests of the country.
  10. polkovnik manuch
    polkovnik manuch 25 December 2015 09: 10 New
    0
    It is high time for "shift workers", "bog workers", "effective managers" to weed the tundra!
    1. V.ic
      V.ic 25 December 2015 10: 22 New
      +4
      Quote: polkovnik manuch
      It is high time for "shift workers", "bog workers", "effective managers" to weed the tundra!

      Why to reserve nature reserve? To compost and to fertilize garden gardens.
  11. Per se.
    Per se. 25 December 2015 09: 15 New
    +1
    Everything is in the best traditions of the "human rights business"
    Give them free rein, and the infringed rights of outright spies or terrorist separatists will be protected. There used to be the concept of "enemy of the people", which, even if it was overstepped, but if you look at it, then "enemy of Russia", now, without any excesses, will suit many murky "human rights activists"
  12. TVM - 75
    TVM - 75 25 December 2015 09: 16 New
    +3
    Do not ban them, let them live. But periodically print their portraits and names in the press and on the Internet, how much money they received, what they did, whom they defended. They themselves will die.
    1. cap
      cap 25 December 2015 10: 45 New
      0
      Quote: TBM - 75
      Do not ban them, let them live. But periodically print their portraits and names in the press and on the Internet, how much money they received, what they did, whom they defended. They themselves will die.


      I think they will ask for an increase for a high rating laughing
    2. kazachyok69
      kazachyok69 25 December 2015 12: 12 New
      +1
      periodically their portraits and names, how much money they received, what they did, whom they protected.

      I AM FOR!!!!!!!!!!!!!! That's exactly what you need to do .... laugh at the sums at least ...
  13. delvin-fil
    delvin-fil 25 December 2015 09: 19 New
    +4
    Oooh ... When I was, I won't tell you who, these human rights activists, oh, how they "helped". The case is "trifling", "to finish off" the documents and hand over to the prosecutor. So no, a "handsome man" appears with a TON of incomprehensible heap for which you need to assign expertise, interview a lot of people, etc. And you can't refuse. Comrade is "in sight" in the media.
    A lot of obvious cases in my memory have collapsed.
    WHY DO IT THIS ???
    PS: Later, in an incomprehensible rag, I saw an interview in which it was said (I quote freely, but the meaning is 100% accurate): "I can see at first glance that a person is being coerced, tortured and recognized - I undertake to protect him." It was then about a mother criminal who collaborated with the investigation. At first I collaborated. The case was ruined.
  14. Taygerus
    Taygerus 25 December 2015 10: 49 New
    +1
    So soon the CIA trade unions will appear in Mother Russia, well, and Western "human rights activists" should be sent to labor camps on preferential vouchers, so to speak, to have a good rest in the fresh air laughing
  15. pvv113
    pvv113 25 December 2015 11: 26 New
    +3
    Quote: The same LYOKHA
    create a union of foreign agents in RUSSIA ...

    And transfer the lists of union members to the competent authorities wink
  16. Appraiser
    Appraiser 25 December 2015 11: 33 New
    0
    All "human rights defenders" from NGOs and their "sympathizers" and correctly say the CIA and NSA residents must be identified and registered so that the whole country knows its "heroes." soldier
  17. Kibl
    Kibl 25 December 2015 12: 20 New
    0
    They should take everyone to the ship and take them to the US so dear to their hearts, let them give lectures at all state colleges!