Military Review

NASA publishes photos of the Antares rocket explosion and final conclusions on the causes of the crash

47
NASA publishes images of the Antares rocket explosion that occurred about a year ago. All this time, the Americans tried to find out the cause of the accident, which did not allow the cargo ship Cygnus, which delivered food and scientific equipment to the ISS, to be put into orbit. As a result of a lengthy investigation, the Americans found that the AJ-26 rocket engine was “to blame”. This is one of the modifications of the engine still of Soviet production - NK-33, developed at the enterprise named after N.D. Kuznetsov in Kuibyshev (Samara).


NASA publishes photos of the Antares rocket explosion and final conclusions on the causes of the crash


in the report NASA it is reported that the cause of the explosion was a defect in the turbopump assembly, as well as the presence of a defect in the bearing of the same assembly. Another reason for the accident, American experts called the pollution of the turbopump unit "foreign particles".



While the experts continued to bring the investigation to the end, the liberal blogosphere has already begun to scribble posts that "the useless Russian industry is to blame." Some even said that the deployment of the "Russian" AJ-26 was malicious intent to harm the "exceptional nation of this world." The Ukrainian Svidomo audience has joined the spread of malicious publications. However, as it turned out, the Ukrainian Yuzhnoye Design Bureau was involved in modifying the US rocket engine. Ukrainian specialists carried out "modernization" of the fuel system and associated engine equipment, including the very turbopump units.
Photos used:
http://www.nasa.gov
47 comments
Ad

The editorial board of Voenniy Obozreniye urgently needs a proofreader. Requirements: impeccable knowledge of the Russian language, diligence, discipline. Contact: [email protected]

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Engineer
    Engineer 5 November 2015 10: 36 New
    13
    Who would doubt that they would dump everything on our engine!
    1. Now we are free
      Now we are free 5 November 2015 10: 40 New
      +8
      The Ukrainian Svidomo audience joined in the dissemination of malicious publications. However, as it turned out, a modification of the rocket engine for the United States engaged in the Ukrainian OKB "South". Ukrainian experts carried out the “modernization” of the fuel system and related engine equipment, including the very turbopump units.

      Всё "лучшее" от Нэньки -"Чёрному Господину"...
      1. The comment was deleted.
      2. Karasik
        Karasik 5 November 2015 10: 51 New
        +2
        Quote: Now we are free
        Всё "лучшее" от Нэньки -"Чёрному Господину"...

        Уверен, ещё много сюрпризов получат "исключительные " от "нэзалэжных ".
    2. The comment was deleted.
    3. Lyton
      Lyton 5 November 2015 10: 41 New
      -4
      Ours is this, have you read it to the end?
    4. vovanpain
      vovanpain 5 November 2015 10: 51 New
      13
      There are no words here, only emotions, one thing is so pleasing this gratitude to the slaves of ukrov to his black master, they poured sand into the bearing, and they scream that Russia is to blame.
      1. oldseaman1957
        oldseaman1957 5 November 2015 11: 07 New
        +2
        "К распространению злорадных публикаций подключилась и украинская свидомая аудитория." - У них аж страсть болезненная,- над Россией позлорадствовать. Перестарались...
    5. Sweles
      Sweles 5 November 2015 11: 23 New
      0
      Oka experts continued to finish the investigation, the liberal blogosphere has already started scribbling posts that “the useless Russian industry is to blame.”


      Do not want to take it, who forces you? get your F1 and even to the moon, even to Venus.
    6. Juborg
      Juborg 5 November 2015 14: 22 New
      +2
      I am more and more intrigued by the question, but on what did they fly to the moon ??? YES HAS ALREADY BEEN MANAGED TO RETURN BACK, YES NOT MORE THAN ONCE. Or did they forget how these engines were made?
  2. Armored optimist
    Armored optimist 5 November 2015 10: 42 New
    +8
    Was there an honest crest, put sand in the bearing?
  3. Grigorievich
    Grigorievich 5 November 2015 10: 42 New
    +5
    So they wrote about it already and the Americans refused to deal with the Ukrainians.
  4. Mister22408
    Mister22408 5 November 2015 10: 44 New
    +2
    То двигло и "Южное" и америкосы пытались модернизировать и копировать...В результате...
  5. Kolka82
    Kolka82 5 November 2015 10: 45 New
    0
    Quote: Lyton
    Ours is this, have you read it to the end?

    Некогда, нужно скорее "супер-коммент" выплюнуть, дабы плюсиками обрасти - а тут такой облом laughing
  6. Wildfox
    Wildfox 5 November 2015 10: 47 New
    +3
    Actually, the Russian representatives immediately nodded at the engine! He was not tested in a full cycle as in Roscosmos. And by the way, here's an article about him on VO
    http://topwar.ru/27115-rossiyskie-dvigateli-nk-33-aj26-vyveli-amerikanskuyu-rake
    tu-antares-na-zaplanirovannuyu-orbitu.html
    1. demon1978
      demon1978 5 November 2015 11: 09 New
      +3
      Quote: WildFox
      Actually, the Russian representatives immediately nodded at the engine! He was not tested in a full cycle as in Roscosmos.


      What does the engine have to do with ??? !!! request

      NK-33 engines were shipped to the United States from a warehouse where they dusted for over 40 years. Age is age, even for iron. “When we tested the engines, we found signs of age-related fatigue, including cracks,” Culbertson said. “We conducted a thorough inspection of them and cooked them in some places.”

      In addition, according to the Guide, “each AJ-26 engine was equipped with a modern element base and passed fire tests at the Stennis Space Center before being mounted on a carrier.”

      True, there is one fly in the ointment in this barrel of honey: in May of this year, during the tests at the Stennis Center, one AJ-26 refused. But after that, fire tests of the modernized NK-33 were carried out in August in Russia. The tests were attended by representatives of Aerojet Rocketdyne. The engine worked successfully, there were no comments.
      http://www.golos-ameriki.ru/content/karash-antares-crash-opinons-investigations/
      2502557.html

      the cause of the explosion was a defect in the turbopump

      Согласно данному документу, «Базовые элементы первой ступени, включая топливные системы, изготавливаются государственным предприятием "Южмаш" под контролем КБ "Южное". И то и другое находится на Украине».
      http://www.golos-ameriki.ru/content/karash-antares-crash-opinons-investigations/
      2502557.html
      1. lablizn
        lablizn 5 November 2015 18: 18 New
        0
        Что значит "подварили трещину"? Это в двигателе, где микронные допуска?
        Ну если так "модернизировать", то дальше п-ва Флорида ничего и не улетит!
        1. mark2
          mark2 5 November 2015 19: 35 New
          0
          Что значит "подварили трещину"?


          Silicone coated, as all tamers do))
  7. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 5 November 2015 10: 47 New
    +4
    “The useless Russian industry is to blame”

    Как обычно. Модифицировали лучшие американские друзья украинцы, а по обыкновению виновата российская промышленность, которую к тому же те же американцы "разорвали в клочья". Что-то не сходятся концы с концами.
  8. roskot
    roskot 5 November 2015 10: 57 New
    0
    Something logic often began to fail amers.
  9. gridasov
    gridasov 5 November 2015 11: 20 New
    +2
    Если кто-то читает мои комментарии , то я очень часто говорю о предельных возможностях работы этих турбонасосных агрегатов и подшипников. Только их работа ограничена физическими принципами , а не какими -либо иными причинами. Это значит , что борьба с засорением , дефектами и прочим это прикрытие своих ошибок банальной ограниченностью в том , что не могут понять причин этой и дальнейших аварий. Сейчас произошел тот разрыв . когда производитель ракет и двигателей не способны удовлетворить заказчиков увеличивающих свои потребности по выводу больших объемов и веса в космос. Создалась ситуация когда толпа всех совокупных учреждений и конструкторов не способна решить маленькую техническую задачу только потому , что все мнят себя значимыми и умными. А" проблеме" на всех их наплевать. Эта проблема есть и будет пока ее не осмыслят и не решат," что такое хорошо и что такое плохо".
    1. 2s1122
      2s1122 5 November 2015 12: 06 New
      -1
      I do not think that dumbasses are sitting in NASA who are not able to solve the problem with the engine.
      1. gridasov
        gridasov 5 November 2015 12: 37 New
        0
        Even in my thoughts I will not allow myself to name scientists and developers of rockets and engines with the word that you called. However, there is a process related to the evolution of knowledge. Sometimes it’s possible for centuries to improve some technical issues, but this will only lead to the limits of the extreme capabilities of the level of operation of these devices. Therefore, new devices are, first of all, an understanding of new physical principles and patterns that will expand the potential of new devices. For example, I watched the new DAYUNOV engine. Yes, this is really a new step in a new technical solution on how to place windings in email. engine, but this does not solve all problems and even more so does not allow to reach new levels of energy processes. This decision is in the status of energy efficient, but no more. But! We are talking about a cardinal principle that changes the entire energy of processes in a turbine. Therefore, their ability to breakthrough scientific and technical solutions does not depend on the number of scientists and engineers producing high-tech equipment or anything else. I would not even correlate this ability with the personality of a person. It’s just that someone’s brain reaches the parameters of such an effective work in analyzing and comprehending the experience of its predecessors that it produces something that defines this as the so-called
        1. Simple
          Simple 5 November 2015 13: 50 New
          +1
          Quote: gridasov
          It’s just that someone’s brain reaches the parameters of such an effective work in analyzing and comprehending the experience of its predecessors that it produces something that defines this as the so-called




          The likelihood that the future genius will receive not only a proper upbringing, but also teachers who are capable of lighting a star in a potential genius with his extraordinary lessons and lectures is very small.


          If they approached correctly in matters of searching and raising highly gifted children. ...
          1. gridasov
            gridasov 5 November 2015 13: 58 New
            0
            Абсолютно согласен! И вы правильно отметили "тонкую нить" того , что гениев может воспитать только гений. Но!!! Гений это терминология обывателей, а по сути это люди с расширенными возможностями работы механизма анализа и выбора правильного направления применения этих способностей. И опять но! Статистика говорит о том , что все-таки гении "творят себя сами ". Не зря поговорка гласит , о том, что "только в тишине глубокого болота зарождаются глубокие мысли". Да и сама физика об этом говорит , что любому взрывному этапу процесса предшествует то, чему не уделяется внимание, это -сжатие и уплотнение магнитных силовых процессов.
  10. Wayna qhapaq
    Wayna qhapaq 5 November 2015 11: 23 New
    +1
    Скатилось ОКБ «Южное» в полное ...оно - до конца 2015 года необходимо обеспечить запуск телекоммуникационного спутника «Либідь». Где двигатель возьмете ребята для своего "Зенита"?
  11. press officer
    press officer 5 November 2015 11: 34 New
    +1
    Quote: oldseaman1957
    "К распространению злорадных публикаций подключилась и украинская свидомая аудитория." - У них аж страсть болезненная,- над Россией позлорадствовать. Перестарались...


    а когда узнали, что они виноваты в данной истории, сразу сказали, что это все "происки Кремля"! Не иначе! У них (у матрасов и страны 404) виновата всегда Россия! Сами то они "белые и пушистые и какают цветами"!
  12. DobryAAH
    DobryAAH 5 November 2015 11: 44 New
    0
    КБ "Южное" работает на Россию, только тссс...
    Your player in a foreign team ...
  13. Manul
    Manul 5 November 2015 11: 57 New
    +3
    Inspired winked
    - When he found out that we had cured the bird, he was terribly angry. And when he flew away - we started an epidemic.
    “He put diamond dust in your grease.” Have to change the grease.
  14. Dragon-y
    Dragon-y 5 November 2015 11: 58 New
    +1
    Отмазка про "попадание посторонней частицы" - это еще со времен Королева, можно в книге у Бориса Чертока прочитать ("Ракеты и люди").
  15. Abakan
    Abakan 5 November 2015 12: 08 New
    0
    "хох ляшка" минусануло wassat about))))
  16. vtorov.andrej
    vtorov.andrej 5 November 2015 12: 32 New
    0
    Though dill can be praised for something. So the owners to spoil in their nature.
  17. bad
    bad 5 November 2015 12: 56 New
    0
    [quote] [However, as it turned out, the modification of the rocket engine for the United States was carried out by the Ukrainian OKB Yuzhnoye. Ukrainian experts carried out the “modernization” of the fuel system and related engine equipment, including the very turbopump units. / Quote] ... no comment .. laughing
    1. gridasov
      gridasov 5 November 2015 13: 17 New
      0
      Скажу , что весьма сложно связать решение, крайне важной, технической задачи работы ответственного узла ракетного двигателя с тем , что имеет отношение к Украине , России , либо США. Существует научная школа регионального характера , т.е это школа немецкая, которая и зародила основы ракетных двигателей, а может я и ошибаюсь. Существует американские подходы , российские , а сейчас и китайская и индийская. НО! При этом все они опираются на истоки заложенные основателями и создателями первых ракетных двигателей и в дальнейшем систем нагнетания топлива и др. Поэтому "фундамент" нужно несколько изменить , а не исправлять "косметическим ремонтом" и тем более привязывать к этом политические или иные мировозренческие понятия.
  18. 1rl141
    1rl141 5 November 2015 13: 37 New
    0
    There is nothing to argue and talk about at all. This report is written for the American dumb taxpayer.
    From this report, the taxpayer should understand:
    1. Нельзя экономить, покупая "русское дер мо".
    2. Russians generally have everything. Even elementary engines.
    3. The Russians cannot do anything normal.
    4. You need even more money to make your engine or to buy extreme Chinese.
    5. Our American specialists are still the best in the world, they found a defect in the blown up Russian bearing.
    6. We need more money, we need more money, we need more money ....
    1. gridasov
      gridasov 5 November 2015 13: 43 New
      -1
      Well, who said that the Americans do not have the same system of governing the people as the Russians. The Ukrainian authorities simply cannot and cannot control the people — that is, they have plundered the country. And so everything is the same everywhere. Moreover, in any country there are more than enough non-smart people in power.
  19. 1rl141
    1rl141 5 November 2015 14: 35 New
    0
    Quote: gridasov
    Well, who said that the Americans do not have the same system of governing the people as the Russians. The Ukrainian authorities simply cannot and cannot control the people — that is, they have plundered the country. And so everything is the same everywhere. Moreover, in any country there are more than enough non-smart people in power.


    Yes, no one says that we have a different system. It's not about the system. This system is the same everywhere. Just if there is someone to blame for your headache, why not do it? And there is nothing for us to discuss such reports here. They are not written for us.
    There are no smart people in power. There are arrogant, greedy, unprincipled. And just scum. But not fools.
    1. gridasov
      gridasov 5 November 2015 14: 57 New
      -1
      I would be grateful if you explain to me. what is to blame headache and why its own. And why bother with what are not your competencies?
  20. afrikanez
    afrikanez 5 November 2015 14: 47 New
    0
    In Ukrainians amers aurora with engines. good
  21. 1rl141
    1rl141 5 November 2015 15: 24 New
    0
    Quote: gridasov
    I would be grateful if you explain to me. what is to blame headache and why its own. And why bother with what are not your competencies?

    I explain.
    1. The fact that the engines not only from the factory, they knew? They knew. Why didn’t they check and drive them properly?
    2. Допустим, что во взорванном двигателе можно обнаружить неисправный подшипник. Можно даже доказать, что он был до пуска двигателя плохой.Но как доказать, что это было именно так? И именно из за этого подшипника ракета не полетела? А не из за того, что какой то черномазый Джон топливную трубку не до конца прикрутил. Или прокладку забыл поставить? И не насыпал в агрегат крошек от гамбургера, которые и явились " посторонними частицами"?
    It's easier to say that the engine was not ours. Like, we are not responsible for it. All questions to the manufacturer. The producer is far away. He lives on another planet. It’s cold there and hungry bears walk. And bribes are smooth from us.
    In any case, they themselves are to blame for the accident. Even if it's the engine. It was necessary to walk around the bazaar, look for a newer and more reliable engine.
    1. gridasov
      gridasov 5 November 2015 16: 57 New
      0
      Well, well-reasoned and understandable. Of course, everyone should answer in essence of their work and should not shift responsibility to others
    2. lablizn
      lablizn 5 November 2015 18: 34 New
      0
      In fact, on the NK-33 there are control systems for all the main units and assemblies, with the conclusion of telemetry information to the control point. The bearing, for example, before crumbling, will necessarily warm up above the norm, which will be fixed by the control system. Another thing is that it is already impossible to change anything in the operating mode after the start.
      А вообще я выше уже отмечал про "подваренную трещину". Если это не блеф, то удивляться нечему. С треснутым двигателем даже ни один уважающий себя автомобилист за руль не сядет, что уж говорить про ракетный двигатель!
  22. gammipapa
    gammipapa 5 November 2015 19: 24 New
    0
    Be that as it may, and comrades from the south kb need to be found and presented with orders, this is a merit to the fatherland - 13 spy satellites were destroyed + we already received money for the engines.
  23. Old26
    Old26 5 November 2015 22: 58 New
    0
    Quote: Engineer
    Who would doubt that they would dump everything on our engine!

    Виноват не наш движок, а топливная система разработанная НПО "Южное" и сделанная на Южмаше

    Quote: TSOOBER
    As a result of an unsuccessful missile launch from the Pacific missile range in Hawaii, the United States immediately lost 13 military satellites.

    The first launch, with whom it does not happen.

    Quote: Sveles
    Do not want do not take, who forces you?

    А они отказались от НК-33, доведенного до кондиции AJ-26 украинскими специалистами. С 2016 будут брать чисто русские двигатели РД-181 и все "Антаресы" двухсотой серии будут уже с нашими двигателями
  24. Old26
    Old26 5 November 2015 23: 18 New
    0
    Quote: gammipapa
    13 spy satellites destroyed

    These are the same spy satellites as you or I, the Chinese emperor
    <br>• Hiaka sat - Designed by students for their needs and testing specific devices. Weight 55 kg
    <br>• Supernova-beta. Testing a new platform for communications subsystems. Weight 6 kg
    <br>• STACEM. Created in the dynamics laboratory of the Utah State University Research Fund. testing of optical channels for infrared and spectrozonal surveys as part of environmental monitoring
    <br>• Argus Created at the Vanderbilt University Institute of Defense and Space Electronics. The mission was to improve the ability to simulate the effects of cosmic radiation on modern electronics. Weight 2,5 kg
    <br>• Edsn (No. 1-8). A swarm of 8 satellites was to be deployed for space exploration. A network of these satellites, like sensors, was to be created. The weight of each is 1,7 kg.
    <br>• Printsat. The satellite was built by students of Montana State University from plastic with nano-carbon impregnation using a 3D printer. The goal is to verify the characteristics of printed materials and coatings. Weight - 1 kg.

    That's all your spy companions
  25. The comment was deleted.