Military Review

Ambiguous interview with Vladimir Pozner portal "Lenta.ru"

150
The network vigorously discusses the interview with Vladimir Pozner, which he gave to the journalists of the Lenta.ru portal before holding his creative evening in the Moscow House of Music (the creative evening was held on October 18). The most lively discussion caused Posner's answer to the question of whether Russia has become his motherland for him.


Vladimir Pozner (quote Lenta.ru):
Not. The country can not become a homeland, if you have already arrived almost adults. I went 19-th year, I did not know the Russian language.


Further, Posner tried to smooth over his categorical answer with respect to Russia, adding that the country to which he had arrived seemed to become a home. However, answering the following question about where Pozner’s homeland is, the TV host said that “somewhere between Paris and New York”, and the house, as it turned out from his answer, he considers not Russia, but France.



Posner:
(...) I'm just more comfortable in Paris. I feel more at home there. This is a million little things: how people walk, how they talk, how they smile. This is the atmosphere. This is when you immediately feel that it is yours. I can admire something in Russia, but I understand that this is not mine. Russian folk songs are very beautiful, but American ones are much closer to me. Because I grew up on them. They evoke a completely different response in my soul.


The interview taken from Vladimir Pozner provoked a strong reaction not only from ordinary Russians, but also from representatives of the authorities. Thus, State Duma Deputy Valery Trapeznikov noted that he was personally insulted by the answers of the “great journalist”.

Speech by MP Trapeznikov (YouTube channel, the press service of the United Russia faction):



Trapezniki:
We all citizens of Russia, regardless of nationality, attitudes, social status, the main thing that unites us - it is love for our country, our great country. Thanks to this feeling, our people defeated enemies at all times, won victories and will win. (...)
I just want to ask: “Why are you suffering in Russia? Bring down, Mr. Posner, to your favorite France or America. But does something hold you strongly here? Restaurant "Geraldine" on Ostozhenka need to check: what kind of restaurant, what is there doing? Next - the School of television skills, under which the mayor's office took the land in the very center of Moscow, on Bolshaya Dmitrovka Street - what does he teach there? It is also not clear. I also did not forget your words on the air, where you called the Russian parliament “Gosudura” with a malicious smile, but then apologized, but also smiling. That is, you insulted 450 deputies elected by the people of Russia of all regions of our country. (...)

And in conclusion I want to say. Mr. Posner, you need to have time to buy tickets to America, before the administration (USA) closed the sky, as their colleagues in Ukraine closed the sky to Russian airlines. And then you will have to live and live out your life in your unloved country. That is why I advised you just in case to buy a cottage in Vorkuta or in Magadan.


In an interview, Vladimir Pozner gave comments on how citizens in Europe relate to the actions of Russia in Syria, and about his personal attitude to the operation. Here Posner wasn’t as categorical to Russia as, for example, in the case of folk songs ... According to Posner, ISIS today is an enemy for Russia (and threatens Russia more than the United States), and if they manage to win a victory over the group, This will be an undoubted advantage for the Russian Federation.

Posner:
Imagine the French shocked history with execution Charlie Hebdo. They finally saw that there is a country that can give these scum in the eye. If we succeed in rejecting ISIS, this will be a tremendous plus for Russia from the point of view of the peoples. Hollande can say anything, but the attitude of the average Frenchman to Russia will be very positive.
150 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. IAlex
    IAlex 21 October 2015 13: 04 New
    +129
    Well, you can rejoice for Pozner, at least he is not wildly hypocritical, and he admits that he is pure Yankees, and honesty is quite worthy of respect ...

    I would rather suggest that the hypocritical deputies and officials answer the question on the polygraph when they are going to finish a long working trip to the Russian Federation, and finally go to their home for a cordon from our country, to families, real estate and business for a well-deserved rest ???
    1. vovanpain
      vovanpain 21 October 2015 13: 07 New
      +41
      Quote: IAlex
      Well, you can rejoice for the dude, at least he is not wildly hypocritical, and he admits that she is a pure Yankee ...

      And for him, Russia is only a place where he earns money, but he would have to ask a deputy. And where else does he earn money?
      1. Baikonur
        Baikonur 21 October 2015 13: 11 New
        +23
        And Russia for him is just a place where he earns money, but he would have to ask a deputy. And where else does he earn money?
        Not just for the sake of dough! He is also a CIA agent !!! conspiratorial! Like a journalist! And if you carefully watch his many programs, interviews, you can see his veiled posing of questions in favor of the United States and against the USSR (formerly) Russia (now)!
        1. Penetrator
          Penetrator 21 October 2015 13: 18 New
          +32
          Quote: Baikonur
          He is also a CIA agent !!! conspiratorial! Like a journalist!

          The CIA agent wouldn’t be so angry - Posner is just a liberoid to the bone marrow. But the real agents of the CIA and the State Department are sitting in our financial and economic bloc of the government - silently and slowly doing their job to destroy the country.
          1. Sober
            Sober 21 October 2015 13: 34 New
            +16
            I do not agree. Legalized agent provocateur. Well paid, for so many years the whole program on the FIRST channel ...
            1. captain
              captain 21 October 2015 13: 47 New
              +14
              Mr. Sober, I agree with you about the agent provocateur. Posner is an enemy of Russia and Russophobe. On our TV there are many. Moreover, they are also specially invited to our TV, so as not to be unfounded, I give an example with Daniil Grachev from Ukraine. There was a wild Russophobe, of all the crap he poured on our Motherland and nothing, they warmed on NTV and did not care about the indignation of citizens. This speaks volumes. who rules the ball on our TV,
              1. Penetrator
                Penetrator 21 October 2015 13: 55 New
                +8
                Quote: captain
                I give an example with Daniil Grachev from Ukraine. There was a wild Russophobe, of all the crap that he poured on our Motherland and nothing, they warmed on NTV and did not care about the indignation of citizens.

                And where is he, along with his program ("Coffee with Milk"), if I’m not mistaken? The viewer voted with a button - the rating is low, the program was closed. Even a T-shirt with Putin did not help.
              2. podpolkovnik
                podpolkovnik 21 October 2015 13: 57 New
                +13
                the answers of the "great journalist" ....

                I never took him seriously.
                Dirty programs, dreary comments (and - in prime time!).
                And his general - is anyone watching?
                And generally speaking -
                this "great journalist" is time to send on a long business trip ...
                1. Alexander Romanov
                  Alexander Romanov 21 October 2015 14: 17 New
                  +3
                  Quote: podpolkovnik
                  And his general - is anyone watching?

                  If they hadn’t watched, his show would have been closed.
                  1. podpolkovnik
                    podpolkovnik 21 October 2015 14: 46 New
                    +9
                    Quote: Alexander Romanov
                    Quote: podpolkovnik
                    And his general - is anyone watching?

                    If they hadn’t watched, his show would have been closed.

                    "This is not a fact, Monsieur Duke!" (WITH)
                    I asked around others at work here:
                    - such a surname (Posner) heard;
                    - Almost nobody watches his programs.
                    A few facts from pedovikia:
                    He advocates the right to euthanasia, is an opponent of homophobia and a supporter of the legalization of same-sex marriage, supports the idea of ​​combating drug trafficking and crime among drug addicts by legalizing the sale of drugs

                    And more:
                    On April 8 on 2012, the premiere of the program “Parfyonov and Pozner” took place on the Dozhd TV channel, where two journalists discuss the most striking, in their opinion, events in the world over the past week. On June 24 of the same year, the program was closed because:
                    The management of the First Channel set a choice for me: either I am doing a program on Channel One, or I am doing a program on Rain. I stay on Channel One with my Posner program. - Vladimir Pozner, interview with Newsru.com

                    No comment.
                    1. The comment was deleted.
                    2. Now we are free
                      Now we are free 21 October 2015 15: 05 New
                      +12
                      I read the article, I did not discover anything new for myself. What do you want? Posner has repeatedly quite openly expressed his position, but for some reason the public and deputies of the State about his position. Duma recalls when you need to be promoted by yourself, Look they say what kind of Posner Mr. ..., conjuncturist and generally latent / non-latent Russophobe! And I say mine, I love my homeland !!! -And what are you the so-called "lover of the motherland" still have not voiced anything regarding Pozner, who has been on the Russian TV and radio for several years? .. It seems to me that if the wind blows in the other direction the same “Persons- shouting "will brand the current government from the rostrum of the State. Thoughts a la Sakharov Syndrome ...
                      Pozner, in spite of all the sometimes justified claims against him, I respect, since this is a person who has made several eras, social. Having lived and lived in many countries, the man is by no means stupid and does not suffer from a radical form of Russophobia. Rather, Posner is an old “Philosopher from the outside,” whose opinion is not objective, but should always be seen and heard by those people who sincerely love and believe in Russia. Posner is a "softly creeping" sarcastically interviewing Russophobe interlocutors, this is a kind of litmus test for Russian politicians, businessmen and other "Stars". In his programs, one can clearly see who:
                      - The "Talking Head" (which is absolutely nothing: no brains, no conscience / honor, no desire to develop their homeland) just sat down with its pampered woman ... on the mainstream of Patriotism and exploiting sincere love for the motherland among the widest sections of the population in their purely mercantile interests.
                      -Rusofobe, because Posner’s questions and the manner of conducting the conversation compel Posner’s interlocutor to open up completely (and if a person lies, then he gradually begins to contradict himself) and even the very latent Russophobe reveals his true essence ...
                      -A man (with a capital letter), who does not shine his face on TV 24 hours a day proving what he is YOURS and PATRIOT! But at the same time, a great professional with clearly structured thinking and sincere faith in his country, a person appealing to Pozner with facts and analysis systems about which even Posner himself has a very vague idea (if at all). In a word, Clever girl you need to follow and learn a lot from (Prilepin, Satanovsky).
                      - A strong statesman is a good performer, maybe not as developed as the previous category, but knowing the weaknesses of his opponent and beating at them calmly and monotonously until he achieves the result he needs (Yarovaya, who freaked Pozner out of herself, just “trolling” him).
                      1. Now we are free
                        Now we are free 21 October 2015 15: 07 New
                        +16
                        Again, to the credit of Posner it is worth saying that work on Russian TV he was given and they pay well for it, actually why he is working here now and not in France or America ... But the question is, first of all, why Posner (a kind of Rusophobe-ponimash! and Conjuncturist ponimash!) He works on TV and has access to brains viewers / listeners should be asked first of all to directors of TV channels / radio stations, and not to Pozner.
                        Thanks to Vladimir Vladimirovich, regardless of whether I like him or not, I have the opportunity to understand who his and who is not (regardless of nationality / religion), and even more so if a person YOUR OWN what’s in his head (if there is one at all) ... Thanks to Pozner, I personally recognized Prilepin and Satanovsky if the first one with dignity left the Purgatory by his Pozner’s “Russian Idea” (moreover, at the end of the program, Pozner expressed his respect to Zakhar, that such a young man was finally able to EXPLAIN and JUSTIFY the old Hebrew cosmopolitan, what is the “Russian Idea” calmly and reasonably).
                        -And the old Sensei invited to the exam smiled, seeing that the samurai who had passed the exam, despite his young age, was a smashing sword for: his speeches are sharp like a Katana's blade; his spirit is strong as the steel of which the sword is made; his mind is all-embracing because he bends under the pressure of the opponent’s arguments but does not break, and having defended his opinion, straightening up becomes even stronger; its path is direct and leads to the top because he realized the meaning of his existence and follows the intended path without turning off ...
                        Then Evgeny Yanovich Satanovsky generally put Posner on the shoulder blades for ALL POSITIONS (including the same JEWISH QUESTION, in which Pozner considered himself Doka ...) Satanovsky did not begin to finish Pozner by proving that he was not only a worthy opponent but also an observant person. "Code of honor".
                        -And the old Sensei, invited from the side, and one of the Dojo’s disciples, who was also not young anymore, came together and gasped when they saw how the main inspector of all the Dojos laid the elderly student on the shoulder blades and he laid the wise veteran in all twelve rounds, after which he bowed to Sensei took his place among the rest of the students.

                        P.S. I posted a video of the Pozner / Satanovsky conversation (And by and large, the monotonous beating of Pozner in his own territory).
                        Posner no need to fear or hate Pozner need to win and for this you need to develop yourselfto challenge him, and even more so to win, if at the same time you position yourself as Russophile and argue your position, supporting each argument with facts, then honor and praise be to you! (unfortunately, many "stupid" people prefer simpler solutions to the "Posner Problem") ...
                      2. Army soldier2
                        Army soldier2 21 October 2015 15: 56 New
                        +8
                        Thank Now we are free! In my opinion, your comment is much more informative and interesting than the original article.
                        I cannot agree with you on one thing. Posner has long been uniquely disagreeable to me as a person. And that's why. In the days of the USSR, Pozner, for a number of reasons, ate much more sweetly and slept softer than the bulk of the country's population. Yes, he is an educated and intelligent person. He joyfully went on business trips and held the high-paying posts that the "communist system" offered him. In an interview, he talked about the fact that at the direction of the KGB of the USSR he followed the conversations of the participants of the youth festival in Moscow. That is, he not only accepted the communist system, but also actively worked for it. And after the fall of this system, he tirelessly stigmatizes everything Soviet. And how does this characterize him?
                        And the fact that he is an adherent of liberal ideology is his business. Has the right to.
                        Thanks again for your comments.
                      3. The comment was deleted.
                      4. Hleb
                        Hleb 21 October 2015 17: 38 New
                        0
                        I decided to watch the video and, even looking at the end, I want to ask what, from the end of the fifth minute, Satanovsky has been talking about the first military potential among the republics of the USSR, and in case of war would it roll us out at once? that the heroes took the Crimea back then were wrong and that Yeltsin is right? I misunderstood something?
                        it is in your Satanovsky rolled Posner?
                      5. Kindof
                        Kindof 21 October 2015 18: 10 New
                        0
                        At least Monumental commentary, maximum - an approach to life. Thank!
                        I’ll just add: sometimes a philosopher takes on a brush.
                        I mean his cunning Gapon game in Kiev in the spring of Maidan 2013. This is my comment. higher.
                        According to my feelings, Posner’s post will be transferred to Urgant, who is now growing his flock on cosmopolitanism covered in Hochma, an ironic, detached, polite attitude to key events and figures, matryoshka-Sochi patriotism.
                        [media = http: //svpressa.ru/society/article/66929/]
                      6. podpolkovnik
                        podpolkovnik 21 October 2015 19: 29 New
                        +2
                        Quote: Kindof
                        According to my feelings, Posner’s post will be transferred to Urgant, who is now growing his flock on cosmopolitanism covered in Hochma, an ironic, detached, polite attitude to key events and figures, matryoshka-Sochi patriotism.

                        I do not watch shows with Posner.
                        I hate Urgant. Therefore, I do not watch either his programs or programs with him.
                        In general, I rarely go to the First.
                        How did Professor Preobrazhensky express himself about reading newspapers before dinner, remember? Here I am guided. There is enough news and for VO, analytics are also enough.
                      7. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
                        Vladimir Pozlnyakov 21 October 2015 22: 35 New
                        0
                        0,14% of the population of Russia are God's chosen tribesmen of Pozner, listeners of the Echo of Moscow, Rain, Voice of America and other horns of the FIFTH COLUMN! (And the stench of these 0,14% ......................................... .)!
                  2. Hleb
                    Hleb 21 October 2015 18: 11 New
                    +1
                    while I look at this stage too, Satanovsky calls the outflow of scientists from Russia in the 90s the Russification of the world and the spread of Russian civilization, he says that it’s normal and in the arguments through the word it sounds approvingly “Jews” ... I am a little bit sick of the fact that Pozner looks smarter, and Satanovsky is worse than the enemy.
                    Is this Posner rolling?
                    I’ll definitely watch the video, thanks, but I don’t understand, did you watch it yourself? understand the point?
                  3. Now we are free
                    Now we are free 22 October 2015 08: 21 New
                    +2
                    Quote: Gleb
                    I’ll definitely watch the video, thanks, but I don’t understand, did you watch it yourself? understand the point?

                    Of course I looked to the end. I understand the essence of the conversation between them otherwise I would not have posted such a video ...
                    In simpler terms, two very clever Jews communicate, one pro-Western and the other pro-Russian. The pro-Western "Kulturnenko" spits on Russia as it has already done more than once and offers the pro-Russian to join it, but it receives not just a refusal but also a culturally on the forehead ... The question of "Brain Drain" Satanovsky burned like a hot iron, but comparing the distribution of Russian Jews, but it must be borne in mind that he did this so that Posner, obsessed with the idea of ​​"world Israel", would understand him better. Moreover, tell me why the described E.Ya. There can’t be a Satanic version of the spread of Russianness? .. The Chinese have shown very well that they are not only spreading around the world exponentially, but are also China's “Disputes” + Remain loyal to their homeland, wherever they live ... Watch Satanovsky’s interview - Posner needs to reject emotions and understand that Satanovsky is playing on the Posner field, but by no means in his team ...
                  4. Hleb
                    Hleb 22 October 2015 08: 35 New
                    0
                    Yes, you are Iskander’s enemy) from the 90s to this day, the problem of the departure of scientists, doctors, designers ... from the country is one of the most important that cannot be solved even through all sorts of state programs, but for you is the spread of Russianness?
                    people were dying because of wrong diagnoses because the doctors of the highest level were leaving.
                    the state spends money on training specialists, and they are leaving to benefit the same West. are you like a "free man"? The concept of "brain drain" and its consequences are not familiar?
                    But the fact that Ukraine was stronger than us after the collapse and could roll us out at once - what does Satanovsky say? and the fact that Crimea was left to them right? and that Yeltsin was right? Yes, this Satanovsky looks like an idiot, and Pozner wonders how it is possible to consider the loss of specialists a problem-free phenomenon and say, well, what can we do ...
                    and about the Chinese explain where you see the scientists, engineers, designers of the Chinese in our country? in vegetable plantations and clothing markets? what do you call labor or brains? Eka turn over.
                    I am surprised both to you and those to whom you roll around here, in unison with the resonance associated with Posner.
                    enemies.
                    and Posner looks like an adequate leader in the transfer and brought to the clear water just Satan.
                    anyway, thanks for the video, now I will know the liberal liberal Satanovsky in person.
                    Ukraine would roll us out at a time ...
                  5. Now we are free
                    Now we are free 22 October 2015 09: 12 New
                    +1
                    Am I an enemy? Well, thanks Gleb ...))) hi
                    There were no “enemies” in this program, there was just an examiner-provocateur Pozner and a man who broke his entire manner of conducting an interview giving sarcastic Russophobia. Tell him that it was necessary to cry in front of Pozner's eyes, sobbing and blowing his nose in a handkerchief with the words -Yes leave! Yes, we are all about ... whether! We all end! Where did Vova jerk against the Great States?!? So they would quietly kill us and now they will kill in front of everyone and it hurts, oh, how painful! ..
                    Satanovsky cited him as an example of his beloved Posner Jews and, using the example of Jews, he proved that the Russians would not dissolve in the world, but the Jews did not dissolve. Fact? Fact ... And the Russian language and culture by means of modern communications living abroad Russians will not lose, by the way, they will live it by switching to a foreign language only when they need to buy something or communicate with colleagues at work ...
                    In the Army of Ukraine and Russia, I agree with Satanovsky (as if from today's positions it did not seem insanely).
                    Why:
                    Of all the former Soviet republics in 1991, the strongest level of Russophobia guess where was it? More precisely, the most aggressive behavior in relation to the military contingent of the Russian troops was in Ukraine ... Google how the aircraft carrier Kuznetsov was saved, which we might not have now ... Moreover, Satanovsky cites facts where there was really the most powerful group of troops at that time ? GSVG where returned from Germany? Where were the largest rear bases of the same powerful GSVG? = Ukraine was a relatively monolithic society (in relation to Russia at that time for sure), no interethnic conflicts, no interethnic ones, powerful production, excellent agriculture, access to Europe, access to the sea YES, and still a VERY BIG desire to finally get rid of Raska Parashka all my life I’ve eaten around the bright, good, rich Nenka ... as you understand, we would not use the Brats then, but how many troops didn’t you remind us of at the borders directly with MladoUkraina? And do not say that Russia as a whole had more troops (spread out over the vast expanses of the Russian Federation) yeah, logistics for the movement of troops of the Russian Federation has always been famous since the days of the Crimean War ... + Motivation of our Armed Forces? + At that time, the guilt for the bloody years of humiliation of the poor republics of the former USSR, planted in the heads of the Russian people by Liverales ... + Remember 1994 and the war in Chechnya, now imagine that it would not be 1 million. Chechnya but 40 million Ukraine ...
                    That's why I agree with E.Ya. Satanovsky, but you can not take his opinion as an axiom, but listen to him and emphasize a lot for myself, after this transfer I began ...
                  6. The comment was deleted.
    2. The comment was deleted.
    3. The comment was deleted.
  • avg
    avg 21 October 2015 13: 36 New
    +12
    Let him earn money in his restaurant, etc., who doesn’t mind. But why he was given the opportunity to push his ideas on the leading state channel, this is a question.
    1. Zoldat_A
      Zoldat_A 21 October 2015 14: 07 New
      +10
      Quote: avg
      Let him earn money in his restaurant, etc., who doesn’t mind. But that's why he was given the opportunity to push his ideas on the leading state channel, this is a question.

      This is a question from the series - “Why, in spite of all the exploits, Chubais is not sitting?”, “And why is no one interested in how Tatyana Borisovna drove IMF tranches through Australian banks with dad-drunkard?”, “And where did Abramovich get the first million and what is this murky story with the missing fuel oil tanks? "... The shout, panimash, democracies that Posner, and therefore such questions hang in the air. Part of the guarantees to the "former" ...

      Too many such questions have accumulated over the past 25 years. I’m afraid that we all know the answers, but in the history textbooks they’ll write about this not during our lifetime ...
    2. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
      Vladimir Pozlnyakov 21 October 2015 22: 37 New
      0
      And who leads the First - ERNST!
  • lwxx
    lwxx 21 October 2015 13: 37 New
    +6
    No, Posner is an agent of influence !! And the question of who oversees him with us gives time on TV.
    1. SRC P-15
      SRC P-15 21 October 2015 13: 51 New
      +1
      However, answering the next question about where Pozner’s homeland is, the TV presenter said that “somewhere between Paris and New York”, and this, as it turned out from his answer, he considers not Russia, but France.

      Finally, the presenter admitted where he is located in the soul. Paraphrasing the famous proverb: "Better Posner than never!"
    2. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
      Vladimir Pozlnyakov 21 October 2015 22: 38 New
      0
      I answer! Leads the First - ERNST!
  • Sober
    Sober 21 October 2015 13: 31 New
    +3
    I remember, 15 years ago, in his program, collecting Yarmolnik, Yakubovich, Khazanov, he showed very well how he loves Russia. Ah, everything else is hypocrisy and a lie.
    1. Zoldat_A
      Zoldat_A 22 October 2015 13: 05 New
      +1
      Quote: Sober
      I remember, 15 years ago, in his program, collecting Yarmolnik, Yakubovich, Khazanov, he showed very well how he loves Russia. Ah, everything else is hypocrisy and a lie.

      You can in PM in more detail what kind of transfer. I would like to see how an ardent liberalist Yarmolnik, moderate to all and all Yakubovich and certainly “in the wake of the course of the party and government” Khazanov, spoke in one program. Yes, all this is still cunning and bending in all directions Posner.
  • evgenii67
    evgenii67 21 October 2015 13: 50 New
    +1
    Quote: IAlex
    I would better suggest the hypocritical deputies and officials to answer the question on the polygraph

    ++++ An article about what Posner is "bad", and all the bumps in the comments fell on the deputies. Although if the deputy did not speak, then Pozner would have been the main focus.
  • ZU-23
    ZU-23 21 October 2015 13: 51 New
    +1
    Even in childhood, he already understood that Pozner was drizzling, always stupid questions to guests in his programs, naturally he was very tied up with a mattress and Europe, why would he even be here if he is not an employee of the diplomatic mission, he just doesn’t have smart patriotic friends here, if he has no soul for Russia it’s all automatically an enemy of the people, so it feels awkward here communicating with the fifth column.
  • yushch
    yushch 21 October 2015 14: 38 New
    0
    As far as I remember, Posner never associated himself with the patriot of Russia. His position is clear and understandable. Russia doesn’t harm him, I don’t know about the benefit, so I can’t say. Well, he doesn’t paint the proposal to “blame Russia”, but puts it in one row at least with Kiev officials pronouncing similar phrases at any opportunity.
    Ps. Let’s say Solovyev generally lives in Italy permanently, but no one shouts to him that he would completely dump him and come to Russia.
    1. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
      Vladimir Pozlnyakov 21 October 2015 22: 44 New
      +1
      Solovyov also “boasted” that he had a choice between “Rain” and FIRST! I chose bread! And frankly - already got these "SAVIKI SHUSTERS"!
      1. Sober
        Sober 23 October 2015 01: 53 New
        0
        Bread, it's raining.
  • The comment was deleted.
  • The comment was deleted.
  • The comment was deleted.
  • Fox
    Fox 21 October 2015 17: 02 New
    +1
    Quote: Baikonur
    He’s also a CIA agent

    there is such a thing as "AGENT OF INFLUENCE".
  • Kindof
    Kindof 21 October 2015 17: 52 New
    +1
    He is a very powerful agent of influence. It is the subtext of their programs and performances - 5% of tar in a barrel of honey is dangerous.
    I remember that in the spring of 2013 (the year of Maidan), he and his successor Vanya Urgant contributed to the heating of Russophobia in Ukraine: one, as a “Russian journalist” in an interview with media outlets, said that he knew Ukrainians, mainly as a fan, the other in Smak compared the cutting of greens (dill?) with the actions of the Red Army in the Ukrainian village.

    if ISIS can be discarded, it will be a huge plus for Russia from the point of view of the peoples. Hollande can say anything, but the attitude of an ordinary Frenchman towards Russia will be very positive


    only in Pozner’s lips does it sound ironic as always “and a quilted jacket can be useful to Charlie’s friends”, since we have already learned well the attitude of “ordinary” Europeans towards the USSR, which defeated fascism. First of all, through the tacit support of the Nazis.
  • lelikas
    lelikas 21 October 2015 13: 26 New
    +1
    Why not - honest answers are better for me, and what the deputy got into is not clear.
    I’m not going to upload stupid pictures from there as a special - everyone knows them anyway.
    Or should Posner like Depardieu - swear in love, and then topple to live back over the hill?
    1. Victorio
      Victorio 21 October 2015 13: 53 New
      +4
      Quote: lelikas
      Why not - honest answers are better for me, and what the deputy got into is not clear.
      I’m not going to upload stupid pictures from there as a special - everyone knows them anyway.
      Or should Posner like Depardieu - swear in love, and then topple to live back over the hill?

      ====
      so depardieu did not sit for decades in the role of oracle
      1. lelikas
        lelikas 21 October 2015 14: 30 New
        0
        Quote: Victorio
        so depardieu did not sit for decades in the role of oracle

        Those. can you be a patriot for a year and all is well, or for forty years working normally, telling the truth and all is bad? So ?
  • Rzhev
    Rzhev 21 October 2015 13: 41 New
    +6
    So already many "stars" of our stage live with their families over the hill, and they fly to Russia to earn money, and many family officials also have it.
  • vovanpain
    vovanpain 21 October 2015 13: 49 New
    +11
    Quote: vovanpain
    Quote: IAlex
    Well, you can rejoice for the dude, at least he is not wildly hypocritical, and he admits that she is a pure Yankee ...

    And for him, Russia is only a place where he earns money, but he would have to ask a deputy. And where else does he earn money?

    But who should ask the deputies.
  • MrK
    MrK 21 October 2015 15: 04 New
    +3
    Quote: vovanpain
    And Russia is just a place for him where he earns money,

    I agree. And here is what the liberal public writes.
    Beginning.
    “We settled in your socialism. We divided the country created by you. We have earned millions in factories built by your slaves and your scientists. We bankrupted the enterprises you built, and stole the money received for the cordon where we built our palaces. Thousands of real palaces. You never had such a summer residence, smallpox. We sold the ice drifts and nuclear powered vessels you laid down and bought yachts. This, by the way, is not a metaphor at all, it is a fact of our biography. Therefore, your name itches and itches inside of us, we want you never to be.
    You saved the life of our family. If it weren’t for you, our grandfathers and great-grandfathers would be strangled in gas chambers neatly placed from Brest to Vladivostok, and our (Jewish) question would be finally resolved. You put seven layers of Russian people in order to save the life of our seed.
    When we say about ourselves that we also fought, we are aware that we fought only in Russia, with Russia, on the ridge of Russian people. In France,
    in Poland, in Hungary, in Czechoslovakia, in Romania, and further everywhere we don’t fight
    happened. They gathered us there and burned us. It turned out only in Russia, where we found salvation under your ugly wing. We do not want to be thankful for your life and a kind of life, a mustachioed. But secretly we know: if there weren’t you, there wouldn’t be us. This is the usual law of human existence: no one wants to be grateful to someone for a long time. This is tiring! Any person is annoyed and tormented if he is obliged to someone. We want to be indebted to everything only to ourselves - our talents, our courage, our intellect, our strength.
    In order to get rid of you, we come up with more and more new stories in the genre of alternative history, in the genre of muhlezh and cheating, in the genre of blunt lies, in the genre of delightful and vile demagogy.
    We say - and here is a rare case when we speak almost the truth - that you did not spare and periodically exterminated the Russian people. We traditionally increase the number of victims by tens or even hundreds of times, but these are details. The main thing is that we are silent about the fact that we ourselves are not at all dear to this people or their intelligentsia. In today's seven-mile, unceasing disappearance of the country's population and people's aristocracy, we tirelessly and selflessly blame - what a charming paradox! - you!
    So, leave me alone, leave me alone, do not stand before my eyes, rot, nasty thing. It’s not we who killed the Russian village, Russian science and reduced the Russian intelligentsia to the level of tramps and bastards - this, don’t laugh, all of you. You! Died 60 years ago! And we have nothing to do with it.
    When we came here - everything was already broken and bent. We earned our billions ourselves, with our labor, from scratch! We swear by our mom.
    In extreme cases, in the withering away of the Russian ethnos, we see an objective process. After all, this was when you were killing people, and when we were they were dying themselves. You did not even have time to kill them so much, how quickly they die of their own accord today. Objectivity, is not it?
    We also confidently say that the victory took place in spite of you. True, a little strange, but since then in Russia for some reason nothing has been achieved contrary to. For example, it does not become a rational and strong power in any way, neither in spite of, nor even thanks to us and our creative activity. Again a paradox, damn it.
    1. MrK
      MrK 21 October 2015 15: 14 New
      +2
      Read more.
      We say that you yourself wanted to start a war, although you did not find a single document proving this.
      We say that you killed all the red officers, and sometimes we even put the military experts you killed on a pedestal, and we hate and trample those whom you did not kill. You killed Tukhachevsky and Blucher, but left Voroshilov and Budyonny. Therefore, the last two are mediocrity and ki. If it had happened the other way around, and Tukhachevsky and Blucher were left alive, then they would have been mediocrity and kami. Be that as it may, we firmly know that you have beheaded the army and science. The fact that with you we contrary to you had the army and science, and with us not to make out either one or the other, does not cancel our confidence.
      We say that on the eve of the terrible war you didn’t want to come to terms with the “Western democracies”, despite the fact that there are only “Western democracies” like us
      we secretly know that we ourselves agreed very well with Hitler, and other Western, as well as individual Eastern democracies professed fascism, and built fascist states. Not only that, at the same time financial circles, with the unearthly light of the shining ones, the United States of America invested huge funds in Hitler and his filthy future.
      We have forgiven everything and everyone, we have not forgiven only you. “Western democracies” and “western autocracies” hated you, and these same financial circles still hate you because they remember who they once had business with. And they were dealing with something in all respects opposite to us. You are a different starting point. You are the other pole. You are the bearer of a program that our small-town consciousness will never contain.
      You stood at the head of a country that won the most terrible war in the history of mankind. Hatred of you is proportionate only to your deeds. They hate those who do. For those who do nothing, there are no complaints.
      What did the heads of France, or Norway, or, say, Poland, do when the war began, to recall? They did not give the order "Not one step back!". They did not enter detachments in order to “save their power” (that’s how we altruists and silver-free people love to talk about you).
      They did not throw regiments and divisions under bullets and shells, nor poured blood over the fields in the name of a small high-rise. They did not force teenagers to work in military factories.
      Not! Millions of their citizens only, calmly and responsibly, worked for Hitler Germany. What can be their claims? Claims of the whole world are addressed to you.
      1. MrK
        MrK 21 October 2015 15: 16 New
        +2
        Read more.
        The basics of space exploration were laid before you - if you had lived a little longer, space flight would have happened under you - and that would have been completely unbearable. Can you imagine? - a king, a whiskered Caesar, who redrawed the whole world and released a man, like a chick, beyond the borders of the planet - from his ever-smoking pipe! Oh, if you had lived another half a century - no one would have exchanged the great cosmic odyssey for iPods and computer games.
        Yes, besides, they created an atomic bomb with you - which saved the world from nuclear war, and Russian cities from American nuclear strikes, when instead of Peter there would be warm and phosphorescent Hiroshima, and instead of Kiev - cloudy and peaceful Nagasaki. And that would be the triumph of democracy so dear to us.
        You have made Russia what it has never been - the most powerful country on the globe. No empire in the history of mankind has ever been strong as Russia was with you. Who might like all this?
        We are trying very hard and in no way are we able to waste and let your inheritance, your name, replace the bright memory of your great achievements with a black memory of your, yes, real, and, yes, monstrous crimes. We owe everything to you. Damn you.
        The Russian liberal public. ”

        Written down - writer Zakhar Prilepin.
    2. evge-malyshev
      evge-malyshev 21 October 2015 17: 34 New
      0
      Quote: mrark
      We also confidently say that the victory took place in spite of you.


      I didn’t understand a damn thing: who? ... who is he talking to? ... what is it about? ...
    3. The comment was deleted.
  • oblako
    oblako 22 October 2015 05: 49 New
    +1
    On the one hand, respect for his honesty. And on the other, the question arises, and who gave him the broadcast on the first channel? Patriot? The man on the safari arrived, earn some money. Who paid him? Who directed? Who was interested and profitable? He came to do something between New York and Paris from Russia? An interesting person, no doubt, but to make dominant his mood on the main channel of the media to put it mildly not according to the state. Eh Mother Russia, when will lessons be going to you for good? !! ... The dollar and the ratings have closed your eyes ..
  • MIKHAN
    MIKHAN 21 October 2015 13: 12 New
    +14
    And this man, taught us life for a couple of decades, without "getting out" of TV screens and the media? I well remembered his malicious smile and sarcasm (he arranged telebridges) You need to drive him into the neck ... But you better know yourself what ..
    1. podpolkovnik
      podpolkovnik 21 October 2015 14: 57 New
      +3
      Quote: MIKHAN
      And this man, taught us life for a couple of decades, without "getting out" of TV screens and the media? I well remembered his malicious smile and sarcasm (he arranged telebridges) You need to drive him into the neck ... But you better know yourself what ..

      In 2007, on the square of Kursky Station, unidentified persons pasted a billboard with a social advertisement by V. V. Pozner “I love Moscow, which is almost gone: quiet, old, with a creak of snow underfoot,” an obscene reminder to the TV presenter that, in their opinion , the reconstruction of the building allocated for the “School of Television Craftsmanship” led to the destruction of the architectural monument: “P ... (censored) don’t toss bags, Volodenka ... House No. 20 on Malaya Dmitrovka”
  • Evgtan
    Evgtan 21 October 2015 13: 16 New
    +18
    And the speaker said to the People’s Deputies:
    - Who among you is without sin - let him be the first to vote for the abolition of immunity!
    1. Coconut Tima
      Coconut Tima 21 October 2015 13: 27 New
      +3
      Quote: EvgTan
      And the speaker said to the People’s Deputies:
      - Who among you is without sin - let him be the first to vote for the abolition of immunity!

      And for the law on the complete confiscation of the property of corrupt executives and the property of all its immediate surroundings, if they do not prove the legality of the acquired property. And for real terms of imprisonment for them
  • Samaritan
    Samaritan 21 October 2015 13: 16 New
    +3
    C'mon ... at least one journalist told the truth, pounced like kites ...
    and it would be better, like Depardieu, to sing singing when $$ is in the eyes!
    1. lelikas
      lelikas 21 October 2015 13: 32 New
      +3
      Quote: Samaritan
      C'mon ... at least one journalist told the truth, pounced like kites ...
      and it would be better, like Depardieu, to sing singing when $$ is in the eyes!

      Distracted by work, as a result, my comment later - but word for word! :)
    2. kotvov
      kotvov 21 October 2015 18: 43 New
      +1
      at least one journalist told the truth, pounced like kites ... ,,
      the question is, could our journalist conduct such programs in the West. I remember Pozner watched for a long time, I remember the pronounced Russophobia of this subject. Now the question is: who benefits from his performances on the Rostelevision?
  • Vend
    Vend 21 October 2015 13: 18 New
    +3
    Quote: IAlex
    Well, you can rejoice for Pozner, at least he is not wildly hypocritical, and he admits that he is pure Yankees, and honesty is quite worthy of respect ...


    Well, here I agree. but
    A country cannot become a homeland if you have come almost as an adult.
    But with this, no. Not only history, but also private examples of citizens of other countries who moved to Russia, show the opposite. If you do not let Russia into your heart, then you will remain a man without a homeland. A person who is comfortable.
    1. reservist
      reservist 21 October 2015 13: 22 New
      +7
      Quote: Wend
      But with this, no. Not only history, but also private examples of citizens of other countries who moved to Russia, show the opposite. If you do not let Russia into your heart, then you will remain a man without a homeland. A person who is comfortable.

      +1
      1. anti-Semite
        anti-Semite 21 October 2015 17: 31 New
        +1
        skinte link to this photo
        1. reservist
          reservist 21 October 2015 19: 32 New
          0
          In Germany, on July 7, 2010, the country's first monument to the Russian Empress Catherine II was inaugurated and solemnly opened on July 9. The monument was erected in the city of Zerbst in eastern Germany.
          The monument, installed in front of the city administration of Zerbst, is a bronze statue 4,7 meters high. The author of the project was a member of the Russian Academy of Arts sculptor Mikhail Pereyaslavets. The monument was cast in 2009 and donated to the city of Zerbst in June 2010.

          historical-persons.ru/view_post.php?id=25
          www.pushkin-town.net/.pushkin/rus/zerbst01.htm

          Monument to Sofia Augusta Frederic of Anhalt-Zerbst
          1. anti-Semite
            anti-Semite 21 October 2015 20: 13 New
            0
            thank you very much! hi
            1. reservist
              reservist 22 October 2015 20: 23 New
              0
              Yes please drinks
      2. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
        Vladimir Pozlnyakov 21 October 2015 22: 54 New
        0
        Catherine the Great admitted that she is proud of her West Slavic roots!
        1. reservist
          reservist 22 October 2015 20: 25 New
          0
          where does it come from Slavic roots, is she kind of German by origin?
    2. BecmepH
      BecmepH 21 October 2015 13: 41 New
      +4
      A country cannot become a homeland if you have come almost as an adult.
      But with this, no. Not only history, but also private examples of citizens of other countries who moved to Russia, show the opposite. If you do not let Russia into your heart, then you will remain a man without a homeland. A person who is comfortable.
      There is such a popular wisdom: "The side where the navel is cut is sweet." And there is nothing to be done about it ... Those who have lived in one region may not understand. You need to feel it. Of course, his words scratched his soul. But at least he honestly said everything. I did not cheat. Although, I repeat, spat in the soul (((
    3. kizhe
      kizhe 21 October 2015 14: 10 New
      0
      "Where a Jew is, There is a Homeland"
  • mQn
    mQn 21 October 2015 13: 25 New
    +10
    I do not see anything criminal in his words, the man spoke honestly. The deputy is a clown who decided to promote on the topic.
    1. Das Boot
      Das Boot 21 October 2015 14: 09 New
      +1
      Quote: mQn
      I do not see anything criminal in his words, the man spoke honestly.

      I agree. Those who, with or without reason, crucify their love for the Motherland, frankly, give the impression of nerds.
  • Samaritan
    Samaritan 21 October 2015 13: 42 New
    +2
    Pozner is a man with a strong life position, he even asks the president provocative questions ... when I pledged with the GDP I only nodded my head and crushed the “lip” like a policeman, I’m still ashamed repeat :))
    1. Cossack Ermak
      Cossack Ermak 21 October 2015 14: 01 New
      +7
      Pozner is a Jewish face! Behind which is the Jewish lobby and capital is all!
    2. Sling cutter
      Sling cutter 23 October 2015 02: 34 New
      0
      masterpiece)) it must be shown on the ladies' channels)))
  • Boatsman_Palych
    Boatsman_Palych 21 October 2015 13: 44 New
    +1
    Wouldn’t it be better to deprive them of the loot before this?
    1. Sober
      Sober 23 October 2015 02: 04 New
      0
      Yes, he did not rob, Posner. He honestly received the earned salary there.
  • Finches
    Finches 21 October 2015 14: 03 New
    +4
    Mikhalkov has about fables like Posner:

    "We know there is still (ur .. yes)Families
    Where our screaming and scolding,
    Where they look with emotion
    On foreign stickers ...
    And lard ... eat Russian! "
    1. Das Boot
      Das Boot 21 October 2015 15: 57 New
      0
      Quote: Cossack Ermak
      Pozner is a Jewish face!

      Quote: Finches
      And fat ... Russian eat!

      finally decide ...
      1. Semurg
        Semurg 21 October 2015 19: 59 New
        +1
        Quote: Das Boot
        Quote: Cossack Ermak
        Pozner is a Jewish face!

        Quote: Finches
        And fat ... Russian eat!

        finally decide ...

        is there "Russian fat" is it cannibalism, or was it referring to the fat obtained by cutting Russian-fed pigs? . But Pozner's "Jewish face" is already a violation of the rules of the site, and I don’t know the article in Kazakhstan in Russia.
      2. The comment was deleted.
    2. Sober
      Sober 23 October 2015 02: 05 New
      0
      Something reminds me deeply of Mikhalkovsky, I’ll look.
  • RUSIVAN
    RUSIVAN 21 October 2015 13: 04 New
    +3
    You can advise Pozner: Suitcase-Station-Paris ...
    1. Penetrator
      Penetrator 21 October 2015 13: 09 New
      +14
      Quote: RUSIVAN
      You can advise Pozner: Suitcase-Station-Paris ...

      And who needs him in Paris? Here he is a wise old man with a tired squint, like a guru broadcasting in a zombie, and there he will be an ordinary pensioner in a diaper.
      1. Sober
        Sober 21 October 2015 13: 38 New
        +2
        It's not about who he is in Paris ... but about getting out of the hated Russia as soon as possible.
    2. Corsair
      Corsair 21 October 2015 13: 17 New
      +5
      Quote: RUSIVAN
      You can advise Pozner: Suitcase-Station-Paris ...

      laughing why is this? he said between Paris and New York - take a map and oops! between them in the middle of the ocean ... Can I take it out there and leave it on a rowing boat with a dry ration for enlightenment and meditation, so to speak?
    3. JACTUS RECTUS
      JACTUS RECTUS 21 October 2015 13: 21 New
      +3
      Why Paris ???? He said that his homeland is somewhere between New York and Paris, and this is the middle of the Atlantic Ocean, so that he goes to the bottom of the ocean, to feed the fish.
    4. Das Boot
      Das Boot 21 October 2015 14: 11 New
      0
      Quote: RUSIVAN
      You can advise Pozner:

      grandfather, I think, will somehow manage without advice.
    5. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
      Vladimir Pozlnyakov 21 October 2015 23: 02 New
      0
      You can advise Pozner: Suitcase-Station-Paris ... and then-port-steamer-New York!
  • roskot
    roskot 21 October 2015 13: 04 New
    +6
    Wise. He feels his nose where it’s better, so he serves. I can’t understand one thing - that they warmed him on our TV.
    1. Aleks28
      Aleks28 21 October 2015 13: 10 New
      +3
      Quote: roskot
      Wise. He feels his nose where it’s better, so he serves. I can’t understand one thing - that they warmed him on our TV.

      And who rules the ball on Russian TV? That's the answer.
    2. reservist
      reservist 21 October 2015 13: 11 New
      +5
      so on our TV once and Schuster felt good ...
    3. Severomor
      Severomor 21 October 2015 13: 12 New
      +8
      Quote: roskot
      - that they warmed him on our TV.

      On our? TV has never been ours: Pozdner, Svanidze, Mlechin, Pivovarov - this is our type)))))
      1. Sober
        Sober 21 October 2015 13: 41 New
        +2
        Even on October 16, an hour-long advertising campaign was launched on Rossiya 24.
    4. afdjhbn67
      afdjhbn67 21 October 2015 13: 15 New
      +9
      Quote: roskot
      I can’t understand one thing - that it was warmed up on our TV.


      Posner is an enemy who will be worse than any “tomahawks”, he was only recently removed from the front line — pushed off the screen, He is the guru of liberal journalism, how many students infected with his poisonous spores have spread through the media? So, it turns out that Yasin’s students are experimenting with us, and the students and Pozner himself justify all this ...
      1. vladimirw
        vladimirw 21 October 2015 13: 20 New
        +2
        I agree categorically, this is an enemy, hidden.
        1. CAMS
          CAMS 21 October 2015 14: 15 New
          -1
          What an enemy he is. A man lives, works, honestly expressed his position, not being afraid of repression. He works for a democratic image of the country, remember our immigrants Solzhenitsyn, Dovlatov, Brodsky. The West was simply reveling in delight! And now why give this reason. He wants to live, wants to bring down, I think that it’s just not worth paying any attention to the inform resource, and especially to the near-term deputy. Not before that, the country would be pulled out of shit, and there it will be seen who will be given an entry visa.
        2. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
          Vladimir Pozlnyakov 21 October 2015 23: 07 New
          0
          Evening Urgant, night Posner and day Ernst! Kagal for three!
    5. Sober
      Sober 21 October 2015 13: 39 New
      0
      Dollars from America.
  • tsvetkov1274
    tsvetkov1274 21 October 2015 13: 04 New
    +3
    And ours and yours .. how !!!
    1. Sober
      Sober 21 October 2015 13: 42 New
      +1
      No, not ours!
  • chunga-changa
    chunga-changa 21 October 2015 13: 05 New
    +6
    What is ambiguous here. The citizen quite clearly and clearly expressed everything.
    1. Albert1988
      Albert1988 21 October 2015 13: 16 New
      +2
      Quote: chunga-changa
      What is ambiguous here. The citizen quite clearly and clearly expressed everything.

      In principle, he had to go to the last level of “honesty”, namely, to say: “citizens, call me, I’m cosmopolitan, and that's it”
      1. reservist
        reservist 21 October 2015 13: 26 New
        +9
        But hasn't Posner said this yet?
        1. Das Boot
          Das Boot 21 October 2015 14: 12 New
          -4
          Quote: reservist
          But hasn't Posner said this yet?

          so what?
          1. reservist
            reservist 21 October 2015 14: 59 New
            +2
            never mind ...
            his position is not a "secret behind seven seals", he feels himself here on earnings and does not hide it
            1. Das Boot
              Das Boot 21 October 2015 18: 00 New
              -2
              Quote: Das Boot
              so what?

              Quote: reservist
              never mind ...

              I agree.
        2. Sober
          Sober 23 October 2015 02: 09 New
          0
          Aged, poor. It used to be, for Russia ...
  • Cu6up9k
    Cu6up9k 21 October 2015 13: 06 New
    +7
    Personally, I was always sure that Posner is a stranger. And how can a Frenchman consider Russia as his homeland. Nothing surprising or offensive.
    1. reservist
      reservist 21 October 2015 13: 14 New
      +1
      Quote: Cu6up9k
      And how can a Frenchman consider Russia as his homeland.

      well, just like Depardieu ...
      1. voronbel53
        voronbel53 21 October 2015 13: 28 New
        +1
        And Depardieu, what kind of Russian is he, is so exotic ...
        1. reservist
          reservist 21 October 2015 14: 38 New
          0
          Then let's remember the author of our "national salad", the chef Lucien Olivier, who held the Hermitage restaurant in Paris in the early 60s of the XNUMXth century.
      2. Das Boot
        Das Boot 21 October 2015 14: 13 New
        +1
        Quote: reservist
        well, just like Depardieu ...

        that is, you think that "Do you want to pay taxes at home - a suitcase, a train station, Russia" - are these norms?
        1. reservist
          reservist 21 October 2015 15: 00 New
          0
          I think that you should pay taxes where you earn money ...
  • Twice RUSSIAN
    Twice RUSSIAN 21 October 2015 13: 07 New
    +6
    Damn, if you are closer to Paris with New York, then what the hell are you doing here. Did he come to teach us life?

    P.S. I always mistreated Pozner, a muddy uncle.
    1. Das Boot
      Das Boot 21 October 2015 18: 16 New
      0
      Quote: Twice RUSSIAN
      P.S. I always mistreated Pozner, a muddy uncle.

      Do you trust Kiselev?
      1. reservist
        reservist 21 October 2015 19: 35 New
        +2
        specify which of the Kiselevs is in question - the one in Moscow or the one who left Moscow for Kiev crying
        1. Das Boot
          Das Boot 21 October 2015 20: 24 New
          0
          Quote: reservist
          specify which of the Kiselevs is in question - the one in Moscow or the one who left Moscow for Kiev crying

          carcass laughing
  • wulf66
    wulf66 21 October 2015 13: 08 New
    +4
    It is high time to bring these "elitists" back to life ... And you really have to determine the cottages in Magadan.
  • Ai yai
    Ai yai 21 October 2015 13: 08 New
    +3
    I think that you should not judge him strictly. many of us, too, could live abroad or even live, but they feel "out of place." There are different circumstances, including those that are difficult to influence.
    1. Twice RUSSIAN
      Twice RUSSIAN 21 October 2015 13: 13 New
      +7
      No, in this case, nothing to do with it. He got the opportunity to form a view of events taking place among a multimillion-dollar audience. I think a lost sheep will never get such an opportunity.
  • The comment was deleted.
    1. nemec55
      nemec55 21 October 2015 15: 22 New
      0
      CUT..NEW JEWISH! WENT OUT FROM RUSSIA! Lord, when will YOU take these abominations to the other world ?!

      Let’s say you do something that your neighbor doesn’t like and he SAYS you
      CUT..NEW JEWISH! WENT OUT FROM RUSSIA!

      Do you understand the point ???
      All the same, it’s not necessary to love our power and love Russia, these concepts can diverge very far. There are people who just don’t like the political course of Russia (let's say they think that Europe and America need to be banged) But you can’t say about them that they are not patriots of their country just because they dislike power.
      1. anti-Semite
        anti-Semite 21 October 2015 17: 35 New
        +1
        this is true, but there are those who do not share the political course and believe that Russia needs to become part of Europe and America
  • venaya
    venaya 21 October 2015 13: 09 New
    +2
    Vladimir Pozner (quote from Lenta.ru):
    No. A country cannot become a homeland if you have come almost as an adult.

    "Great journalist" - sounds like a great crook. As early as 1902, his grandfather founded a batch of zSzRov. This party launched a real "red cock" in RI, setting fire to estates and destabilizing the situation in the country. His granddaughter, I think, no less "benefits"brought to the country. What to do with those who let him on the main channel in the country?
  • B.T.V.
    B.T.V. 21 October 2015 13: 09 New
    +4
    I can’t understand one thing: “if it’s not so sincere in Russia, why sit here, smoke the sky ?! Go to where the songs and language warm your soul, and here we will somehow manage without such“ smart and correct ”!”
    1. Laksamana besar
      Laksamana besar 21 October 2015 13: 18 New
      +5
      In Paris and New York, he does not earn so much.
      1. venaya
        venaya 21 October 2015 13: 22 New
        +2
        Quote: Laksamana Besar
        In Paris and New York, he does not earn so much.

        He simply cannot find work there. They don’t stand such things there!
      2. voronbel53
        voronbel53 21 October 2015 13: 38 New
        +2
        Quote: Laksamana Besar
        In Paris and New York, he does not earn so much.

        You can’t earn all the money, it's time to think about the soul. He earned money for a comfortable old age, and there is nothing to smoke here. The direct road abroad, especially has already shown what a man of the world is like, we have nowhere to put our liberals ...
      3. Sober
        Sober 21 October 2015 13: 46 New
        0
        They pay for Russia, and there’s nothing for it.
  • Arktidianets
    Arktidianets 21 October 2015 13: 10 New
    +3
    Russia is not his homeland, so let it bring down, no one is holding it. But broadcasting from the television screen, he and I are trying to teach us lives and statements about Russians that allows himself those for whom they hit in the face.
  • g1v2
    g1v2 21 October 2015 13: 11 New
    +6
    Did anyone have doubts about Posner? He’s just making money with us, like a footballer. And honestly talks about it. Why take offense at him? You just need to remember that this is an American and all his words are words on behalf of the American.
  • Kantanara
    Kantanara 21 October 2015 13: 11 New
    +1
    It keeps loots, low taxes, and yet it’s possible to cash out and hide incomes. And this isn’t not the homeland.
  • Masya masya
    Masya masya 21 October 2015 13: 12 New
    +2
    His house is an airplane!
  • propolsky
    propolsky 21 October 2015 13: 12 New
    +1
    This is all good so far, then you can make a booty: it’s both good and you like it here. But if you need to take a rifle in your hands and buy some bread cards, then how to choose your homeland? Or then the motherland "will move overseas", where they do not shoot?
  • dchegrinec
    dchegrinec 21 October 2015 13: 14 New
    +7
    Let him think and speak as he pleases, honestly, so honestly, if only he would not speak scornfully towards our country and show no disrespect and other intolerance. And another moment: the doors to the country's national channels should be closed for him.
  • Asadullah
    Asadullah 21 October 2015 13: 14 New
    0
    This is not the first time Pozner has spoken about this. And not the second one. And from the big screens. Apparently fed up with all his developing insanity. Well, to hell with him.
  • anderles66
    anderles66 21 October 2015 13: 14 New
    +7
    I do not feel any sympathy for Pozner. I respect, as a very intelligent person, but nothing more. His stated position is also worthy of respect (but I do not like it), but Trapeznikov’s position is a tantrum of a not very smart person. Are there any restaurants, and here is the restaurant in general? we have a bunch of objects that belong to foreigners. Will we kick them all out, or only those who the deputies will not like? At all institutes, pseudo-liberals are invested in students’s heads. Will we drive them out?
  • Mama_Cholli
    Mama_Cholli 21 October 2015 13: 16 New
    +6
    Pozdner at least had the courage to honestly tell the truth.
    This is his choice and he does not consider the culture of Russia to be his own, and he cannot strive for it.
    In fact - if only he hadn’t spoiled it, or you’ll sometimes look at it and in a television program he sometimes allows himself to make estimates from the actions of other people by a real Russian person. (maybe I'm wrong, but it seemed to me).


    Pisi: How many patriots with foam at the mouth call themselves Russians, in fact then they are traitors to their homeland.
  • Siga77
    Siga77 21 October 2015 13: 18 New
    +3
    It turns out that Posner has no homeland at all, but only personal preferences. He is neither a Yankee, nor a Frenchman, nor a Russian, but hovering somewhere in time and space ... What national cultural background does he carry ?! Some kind of artificial and rootless international journalist came out. So comfortable to him where they pay more ...
    1. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
      Vladimir Pozlnyakov 21 October 2015 23: 20 New
      -1
      And if they still pay extra from the State Department, then "VAASCHE" .....!
  • jetfors_84
    jetfors_84 21 October 2015 13: 19 New
    +6
    Quote: g1v2
    Did anyone have doubts about Posner? He’s just making money with us, like a footballer. And honestly talks about it. Why take offense at him? You just need to remember that this is an American and all his words are words on behalf of the American.

    I also think so. Here, in my opinion, a substitution of concepts. To expel all who do not consider Russia their homeland, we will reach senility. Well, he is not a patriot. And what is all polls patriots? Serdyukovs, Vasilyevs and other thieves and scammers. Agree, talking and doing is not the same thing.
  • mpzss
    mpzss 21 October 2015 13: 19 New
    +5
    Why did you all attack him? for the fact that he honestly answered? but you have to respect him for that! Now, if he, on the contrary, had confessed his love and all that, but actually did poop for us, then it would be a shame! And so he told the truth, and you all think, if you were asked what is closer to you, the place where you were born and spent your childhood or the place where you live now !? all say that the place where you spent your childhood is more expensive! do not be fooled! As for citizen Pozner, I don’t like how he transmits programs, etc., but I won’t scold him or praise him, everyone just has his own opinion and everyone has the right to express his opinion.
  • Averias
    Averias 21 October 2015 13: 22 New
    +2
    I am absolutely neutral regarding V. Pozner. I will say more, I respect him for his mentality, for being smart, for speaking competently. Do I share or not his point of view? So she is at that point of view and nothing more. I have only one question for Mr. Pozner, can I? Sorry for the commercialism, Mr. Posner, but the money is, yes, yes, those very bills are crunchy, loot, lava - you earn in our country, and it’s not very bad. How is it that America, London, France are the cradles and strongholds of civilization. A sinful loot You "chop" with us. This, excuse me, smells of hypocrisy. And on the trail - To be smart does not mean to be decent.
    1. Sober
      Sober 21 October 2015 13: 49 New
      +2
      Sorry, but he cuts the main cabbage overseas.
  • Ural resident
    Ural resident 21 October 2015 13: 22 New
    +7
    here we have young people in American songs is also growing.
    This is very worrying - it all starts with cartoons - they watch it on telly as kids - parents turn on the children's channel so that the child is busy - then booklets, postcards - barbie, etc. Then the movie - in the end we have young people fully educated in American culture - our they don’t perceive at all - and this is the vast majority with a slide. We are still holding on to the older generation - but when it leaves - what will happen? Does anyone think about this?
    1. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
      Vladimir Pozlnyakov 21 October 2015 23: 24 New
      0
      One of my acquaintances from the "children of the war" once bitterly said: "But we lived a bit under communism, but did not notice!"
  • Denis DV
    Denis DV 21 October 2015 13: 23 New
    +4
    Pozner, an excellent interviewer, spent most of his life abroad and no more. No offense at the old man. If he were to be handed over by a Western asshole, he would have butchered him like a tortoise, despite his opinion as a professional.
    1. Sling cutter
      Sling cutter 23 October 2015 02: 27 New
      0
      Yes Yes...
      and you, transmission with posner watched in the late 80s?
  • lazma3
    lazma3 21 October 2015 13: 23 New
    -1
    A person who so simply abandons his homeland is worthy only of contempt. How many Great people forced to leave Russia dream of returning. And this one is just a trader. Where they pay, there will be a homeland for him.
    1. Das Boot
      Das Boot 21 October 2015 14: 19 New
      +1
      Quote: lazma3
      A man who so simply abandons his homeland is worthy only of contempt.

      and when did he refuse from France?
      Quote: lazma3
      How many Great people forced to leave Russia dream of returning.

      example please.
      Quote: lazma3
      Where they pay, there will be a homeland for him.

      Well, they pay in Russia, so what? He does not consider his homeland. You, my dear, contradict yourself.
      1. Sober
        Sober 23 October 2015 02: 13 New
        0
        Yes, not in Russia, not in Russia !!!
  • pts-m
    pts-m 21 October 2015 13: 28 New
    -2
    another traitor was overlooked, but he sang how cool it was in the west. It looked like he was going to his historical ugly pin-ridden tablecloth path.
  • Hort
    Hort 21 October 2015 13: 29 New
    -1
    well, at least honestly said. Although, in general, Posner never hid his pro-Western position, in contrast to the "popularly elected" hypocrites
  • barclay
    barclay 21 October 2015 13: 29 New
    +7
    Nothing new. It has long been known that Posner is not a patriot of Russia. And he can hardly be a patriot at all. He just made a good job in Russia. And the deputy does not need to be so upset about this. I think that the special services are aware of everything that this "citizen of the Earth" does in Russia.
    By the way, a question for Mr. Trapeznikov:
    Will he remain such an eloquent patriot if his salary is not increased, but reduced by three times?
  • Kirk
    Kirk 21 October 2015 13: 32 New
    +3
    Such as he is not enough, especially from showbiz. They disdain Russia, buy their own villas and houses far beyond the borders of Russia, and when they run out of money they come to Chas, and we pay them for concerts, films, shows, etc. If something happens, they will first run away and certainly will not defend the Motherland, they are ashamed of it and CREEP it and us.
  • 020205
    020205 21 October 2015 13: 32 New
    +1
    I can’t understand what the insulting said Pozner? Did he somehow insult our country in his twist? He honestly said that Russia wasn’t his homeland, so it is if he grew up in the West and came to the country when he was 19 who didn’t know the language! He honestly said, he did not begin to gain cheap popularity in the wake of the national rya-patriotism! Everything is competent and clear! But the deputy really decided to promote her own name!
    1. Asian
      Asian 21 October 2015 13: 48 New
      -1
      Read his statements about Russia and Russians. And if after comprehending what you’ve read, you don’t have a definite desire to throw this nits away, then you are spiritually united with this citizen, that is, a liberal who has nothing to do with Russia.
      1. 020205
        020205 21 October 2015 14: 05 New
        +2
        I’m not talking about his statements about Russia, but I’m talking about it in particular, what did he say here that even such a barn as the State Duma of the Russian Federation spoke about this? Secondly, I didn’t find anything criminal from the first time in nete!
      2. Das Boot
        Das Boot 21 October 2015 15: 06 New
        +1
        Quote: aziat
        Read his statements about Russia and Russians.

        Well - where did he speak derogatoryly about the Russians?
        Quote: aziat
        if after comprehending what you’ve read, you don’t have a definite desire to throw this nits away, then you are spiritually united with this citizen, that is, a liberal who has nothing to do with Russia.

        well, my friend, ek rushing you ... Doesn’t cause me. What's next? You unknowingly resorted to Reductio ad Hitlerum, my dear. Of course, they did not hear about such a logical trick?
  • Prutkov
    Prutkov 21 October 2015 13: 33 New
    +4
    The sincerity test in this interview passed Pozner. There is nothing to reproach him with. Worse, when a person declares his love and devotion at the top of his lungs, and only if you turn away you get a bullet in the back. It is important. Unfortunately, Ukraine (not all) did not pass the sincerity test.
    1. Asian
      Asian 21 October 2015 13: 50 New
      0
      In this interview, Posner passed a test for duplicity, or in extreme cases, for hermaphrodism.
    2. Sober
      Sober 23 October 2015 02: 15 New
      0
      Wow, under the age of old he was sedental, became sincere, Sorry!
  • Mercury
    Mercury 21 October 2015 13: 33 New
    +3
    Between Paris and New York, yes he sees the atlas or ichthyander.
    Well, if seriously there was never any doubt that he was the mouthpiece of America, just the love of everything non-Russian passed in Russia and he lost popularity. No one needs to listen more about how they have better than ours and how everything is organized there
  • Engineer engineer
    Engineer engineer 21 October 2015 13: 33 New
    +3
    Quote: anderles66
    At all institutes, pseudo-liberals are invested in students’s heads. Will we drive them out?

    Foul broom! And some even filthy scrap!
  • provincial
    provincial 21 October 2015 13: 34 New
    -2
    I wonder who looked and listened to Posner? They do not show often and very late. Does the majority of the population sleep, only the glamorous intelligentsia drinking tea and eating something stored in France? I think only the side son Urgant is touched by him.
    1. MIKHAN
      MIKHAN 21 October 2015 14: 01 New
      +3
      Quote: provincial
      I wonder who looked and listened to Posner? They do not show often and very late. Does the majority of the population sleep, only the glamorous intelligentsia drinking tea and eating something stored in France? I think only the side son Urgant is touched by him.

      It just disappeared, but didn’t get out of the TV set on airtime ... with its sarcastic smile and insinuating voice and brain hit well ... And I even believed him if it weren’t for Dad, who constantly spit at the sight of this malicious faces and I listened to my father the glory of God and thought .. Why does this constantly teach us life ...? Who needs this and there is no alternative to this head?
  • 020205
    020205 21 October 2015 13: 36 New
    +5
    Quote: Averias
    I am absolutely neutral regarding V. Pozner. I will say more, I respect him for his mentality, for being smart, for speaking competently. Do I share or not his point of view? So she is at that point of view and nothing more. I have only one question for Mr. Pozner, can I? Sorry for the commercialism, Mr. Posner, but the money is, yes, yes, those very bills are crunchy, loot, lava - you earn in our country, and it’s not very bad. How is it that America, London, France are the cradles and strongholds of civilization. A sinful loot You "chop" with us. This, excuse me, smells of hypocrisy. And on the trail - To be smart does not mean to be decent.

    In the sense of hypocrisy? are all Tajiks, Uzbeks, Ukrainians and other people who come to our country openly recognizing that their homeland of Tajikistan and further on the list are also hypocrites? Are Russians working abroad but loving Russia also hypocrites?
    1. Albert1988
      Albert1988 21 October 2015 13: 49 New
      +3
      Quote: 020205
      In the sense of hypocrisy? are all Tajiks, Uzbeks, Ukrainians and other people who come to our country openly recognizing that their homeland of Tajikistan and further on the list are also hypocrites? Are Russians working abroad but loving Russia also hypocrites?

      Let's just say that Russians working abroad, for the most part, are not trying to teach the indigenous people how to live in their countries, what is good for them and what is bad. Pozner, for a long time, was doing just that in essence, from which he earned such an attitude.
      But in his defense it is worth saying that at least now he began to behave honestly, openly recognizing that Russia is “this country” for him, and not “his country”.
      1. 020205
        020205 21 October 2015 17: 28 New
        -1
        Come on? Exact info? How did Posner personally teach you how to live?
        1. Albert1988
          Albert1988 21 October 2015 19: 23 New
          -1
          Quote: 020205
          Come on? Exact info?

          And you look at his publications, programs with his participation (not modern, earlier), especially where he speaks on socio-political issues, such questions will immediately disappear.
          Quote: 020205
          And how Posner personally you taught to live?

          We somehow didn’t drink at the Brudershaft in order to contact each other on “you”, but this is already a matter of personal culture. As for me personally, I didn’t have a personal conversation with Mr. Posner, but I had to listen to him a lot from the screen, just like reading his articles. The general message was approximately the same as that of most of our liberals: "undeveloped Russian aborigines should carefully listen to the lights of Western civilization and culture", only filed in an intelligent and gentle form.
          But in his defense I can say that in recent years he has been trying to take a kind of "neutral" position and now criticism from him is heard in both directions.
          1. 020205
            020205 22 October 2015 11: 51 New
            -2
            What kind of cultural are we?
            1. Albert1988
              Albert1988 22 October 2015 12: 58 New
              +1
              Quote: 020205
              What cultural are we right to go nowhere!

              This is an elementary education, nothing more, no complaints.
              Quote: 020205
              You are on the Internet, absolutely everyone is equal here, you don’t need to compete, making yourself an intellectual!

              I don’t “bother” and do not build an intellectual; I was raised in a trite way in childhood in that vein. that disrespectful to communicate with a stranger means to fall to the level of cattle.

              In general, I am somewhat surprised by your annoyance in response to my comments about Pozner, though this leads to some thoughts ...
  • Million
    Million 21 October 2015 13: 38 New
    +2
    Another and again for some reason a Jew ....
    1. provincial
      provincial 21 October 2015 13: 42 New
      0
      this is not a Jew, but as Avigdor Eskin put it ..... generally read for yourself at V. Solovyov
    2. kit-kat
      kit-kat 21 October 2015 13: 45 New
      -2
      Solovyov would say that this is the wrong Jew, because only such as Solovyov and Satanovsky are real. )))
  • RuslanNN
    RuslanNN 21 October 2015 13: 39 New
    +2
    Suitcase, train station, new york
  • Ilya_GN
    Ilya_GN 21 October 2015 13: 39 New
    +7
    This is the type of diploma screaming loudly and sputtering. More like some kind of personal dislike. And he screams about her, from the rostrum and to the whole country. What for?
    He’s not a Russian car, his phone isn’t Russian, but that he doesn’t say anything Russian, and he eats French or Chinese cuisine, probably. And how is he such a lover of Russia, does not use exclusively Russian ???
    If someone (Russian) is more pleasant and dearer to work and live in Bali. And he will openly say it. All! Enemy! Yes ambiguously expressed. Yes, he has his own attitude. Did he become a bad journalist from this? Has he stopped asking the right and uncomfortable questions?
    And what about socialism again? Something like a Ukrainian. president rules our Russia? Why do you need to be dill. Why amass such anger? Envy? What for???
  • tolyasik0577
    tolyasik0577 21 October 2015 13: 42 New
    +4
    Not a biased journalist. The person who covers the events looking from the side without taking one or another point of view. It is very good that he is on our TV. there should be an alternative point of view on what is happening with us.
    PS I was not born in Russia, and I love my homeland. but my parents instilled in me love for Russia, because she and my 2nd house. Adaptation took place in adolescence when self-awareness was not fully formed. What to expect from a person who in adulthood turned out to be "in an unfamiliar" country.
    And all sorts of deputies and politicians should deal with the problems of the state and not with personal dislikes of one or another person, be it Pozner or Makarevich.
  • kit-kat
    kit-kat 21 October 2015 13: 44 New
    +2
    Well, suppose you can agree with the "state duma".
  • Engineer engineer
    Engineer engineer 21 October 2015 13: 44 New
    +1
    And Posner, what is Posner? 100% cosmopolitan. I do not like this category of people. And giving him the opportunity to form a similar worldview among the Russians is at least harmful to the nation, if not criminal. We (I hope so far) lose the ideological war. After all, talented, bastard ...
  • Tatar 174
    Tatar 174 21 October 2015 13: 44 New
    +3
    Since this interview took place and these words were spoken aloud, then this is no accident. Everything was thought out, because they just don’t say that. Are you planning to retire, Mr. Posner? Will you receive a Russian pension? Where are you going to live next? I advise you to choose anything for your future life, but not the territory of Russia, because I imagine how hard it will be for you here, where "not mine"
    1. Sober
      Sober 23 October 2015 02: 19 New
      0
      No, Russian for tea!
  • 020205
    020205 21 October 2015 13: 48 New
    +3
    Quote: Ilya_GN
    This is the type of diploma screaming loudly and sputtering. More like some kind of personal dislike. And he screams about her, from the rostrum and to the whole country. What for?
    He’s not a Russian car, his phone isn’t Russian, but that he doesn’t say anything Russian, and he eats French or Chinese cuisine, probably. And how is he such a lover of Russia, does not use exclusively Russian ???
    If someone (Russian) is more pleasant and dearer to work and live in Bali. And he will openly say it. All! Enemy! Yes ambiguously expressed. Yes, he has his own attitude. Did he become a bad journalist from this? Has he stopped asking the right and uncomfortable questions?
    And what about socialism again? Something like a Ukrainian. president rules our Russia? Why do you need to be dill. Why amass such anger? Envy? What for???

    I completely agree with you, reading the comments of some users here (and not only here), it seems that people are crazy (like another word, censorship will not miss wink ) on your cheers-patriotism! A witch-hunt begins somehow, if God forbid you like something foreign and not Russian, then you are almost a traitor to the motherland!
  • Eastern wind
    Eastern wind 21 October 2015 13: 49 New
    +3
    Posner has always been so flexible that compared to him the gum from underwear is just a titanium alloy ... If he was a gymnast or a ropewalker, there would be no price, and so a weather vane, you can track the weather in certain circles.
  • MIKHAN
    MIKHAN 21 October 2015 13: 50 New
    +2
    And yet, our people are invincible! After all, for 25 years this “zhalitse” washed our brains in the evenings from central channels and the media in the evenings .. (very delicate and careful always) NOT RECEIVED! Well, thank God! These are the most dangerous worms on the body of Russia ...
    1. b-612
      b-612 21 October 2015 14: 16 New
      +2
      just look like him, like a puppy in der mo dipped the Head of the EU Delegation to Russia, Lithuanian statesman, diplomat Vigudas Usackas, what uncomfortable questions he asked and whose interests he defended .. http: //pozneronline.ru/2015/09/12374/
      There and about NATO to the East and about sanctions
      1. MIKHAN
        MIKHAN 21 October 2015 14: 44 New
        +2
        Quote: b-612
        just look like him, like a puppy in der mo dipped the Head of the EU Delegation to Russia, Lithuanian statesman, diplomat Vigudas Usackas, what uncomfortable questions he asked and whose interests he defended .. http: //pozneronline.ru/2015/09/12374/
        There and about NATO to the East and about sanctions

        The nose holds in the wind and earns money ... Such people can usually speak on any topic and always correctly ... But their eyes and a malicious smile give them away, which now has happened! hi I can smell such genes ...
  • 31rus
    31rus 21 October 2015 13: 52 New
    +4
    That's because he speaks honestly, about his attitude to Russia and is worthy of elementary respect, as a professional, he is also original, smart, with his point of view, if there were “sins”, for so many years of work, they would have come out
  • AdekvatNICK
    AdekvatNICK 21 October 2015 13: 53 New
    +7
    purely if we take only this article ... I didn’t see anything like that in his words. Well, he doesn’t feel at home in Russia and so what. You can’t order a heart. Until 19 years he lived outside Russia. So now kick out for it? perhaps the most memorable years passed in Paris and America where he grew up .. we still remember with you as for example in childhood and ice cream was sweeter ... and soda tastes better ... but a lot of things seemed better then. And all because the children the sensations are the most vivid and memorable.
    In our society there is such a tendency ... whoever is not with us is against us. Very jealous of everything.
    And just because our ears hurt France, which is so unpleasant for us ... and the USA .... but how dare he posner ....

    although the hunt itself kick it out)
    1. cherkas.oe
      cherkas.oe 21 October 2015 16: 16 New
      -2
      Quote: AdekvatNICK
      although the hunt itself kick it out)

      Well, you don’t have to give in to altruism, listen to your heart. Such as this liquid do not stand on ceremony with us even on our land, much less beyond its aisles, and therefore we don’t need to engage in self-discipline in relation to such guest workers.