Tactics of the Syrian General Staff raises a number of questions

105
Tactics of the Syrian General Staff raises a number of questionsThe confrontation in Syria in some places has taken the character of a war of “all against all,” but this does not prevent the government army from developing the well-being of the Russian aviation offensive in a number of key areas. Another thing is that success is heterogeneous and ambiguous. And although the strategic goals of the Syrian general staff are quite obvious, the methods for achieving them sometimes raise questions.

After several days of lull caused by the artificially halted offensive of government forces, fighting in Syria resumed in several key sectors at once. The events around Aleppo brought newness to what is happening, where, for the first time since the beginning of the Russian operation, the opposing sides vividly demonstrated what the “war of all against all” means in practice and how it all ends.

It began with the fact that the pro-Western rebels (the name is conditional: there are Islamists mimicking “democrats” and semi-mythical “secular liberals”) were forced to re-group their forces by transferring units from under Aleppo to the “Homsky front”, where the offensive of government forces if it were a little better organized, it could well overturn them altogether. Parts of the Islamists and the “Westerners” were filmed mainly from the positions north and north-west of Aleppo, where they did not undertake anything active, preferring medieval tactics of siege the fortress.
The ISIS units immediately poured into this weakened zone and, on the backs of the “Free Syrian Army” that had run, took up “serfs” positions around Aleppo. The city and its adjacent territory have been in a circular siege for more than three years, the only difference is that for some time Aleppo and the surrounding area were mainly terrorized by pro-Western forces, and only in the last 10 months the ISIL fighters were drawn to them from the east. The panicked cries that the radicals "are standing on the rails of the Aleppo tram" (there is no tram there - and there has never been, this is just a figure of speech) - is an exaggeration. In the line of sight of the residential areas of Aleppo, the besiegers are crowding, we will repeat, a long time ago, and the appearance of “black flags” in the area of ​​the cement plant did not fundamentally change anything.

Another thing is that the logic of the behavior of government forces initially comes down to lifting the blockade of Aleppo, creating a solid front and restoring a full supply of all the blocked major cities and regions, including by destroying enclaves of armed opposition of different ideological and religious affiliation. Hence, the constant attempts to attack on various, often not directly related sectors of the fronts.

And so, after the rapid advance of ISIS last week north of Aleppo, government forces finally came to action in this enclave. It should be understood that the forces of government troops in the area, which includes the full airfield Kuwaireis, are limited in supplies, and to lead from there a massive attack on ISIL is impossible without destroying militants in the actual rear. What was undertaken.

The troops began to advance in two opposite directions. First, from the region of Nasiriyah to the northeast, to the area of ​​the city of Buraij, in the direction of the base of Kuwairis. The distances there are small, and not mountains, but the plain is an agricultural region with a developed (by local standards) network of roads. The command of government troops apparently decided that ISIS, also now possessing a small margin of safety, is rapidly melting due to air strikes, advancing north of Aleppo, will further weaken its position around the airbase. It was not there.

Russian aviation (most likely, at the request of Damascus) was ironed by the attacking units of ISIL for several days, which apparently should have restrained them, but did not lead active air preparation directly in the offensive zone of Nasiriyah. As a result, government forces were able to enter Buraiju, where they stopped, as they did last week when they attempted to conduct an attack in the direction of Kfar-Nabuby on another sector of the front. The attack on Kuveiris, thus, ended, practically not having begun, and at the moment the attempts to unblock the air base were stopped.

At the same time, the triumphant advance of ISIS north of Aleppo, which lasted 24 hours, was indeed stopped by Russian air strikes, which (in this paradox of the “all against all” war) were beneficial to the pro-Western opposition who had fled; Further attempts by the Islamists to move to the position of the SSA ended in complete failure and dozens killed. The question of whether it was worth supporting an air attack from Nasiriy instead of “holding back” ISIS north of the city remains open. And this question should be addressed to the Syrian general staff, which selects the direction and timing of the attacks, while the Russian VKS only provide this whole thing.

The second offensive of the government troops from the Aleppo area developed much more successfully and even indicatively, but went in the opposite direction - to the south-west. It was a natural and understandable move: the troops began to break through their way to connect with the "main" front in order to release the zone of Aleppo. Relying on Azzan Mountain (the terrain there is flat, and control over Azzanum gave obvious advantages for an offensive using armored vehicles), Assad quickly advanced almost a hundred kilometers, occupying a dozen different settlements and operational importance. Moreover (and this is a very encouraging innovation), the offensive has not stopped and continues to this day, although its pace has slowed down. It is possible that the main operational target is Al-Khader, a large settlement and transportation hub, starting from which you can continue to move to join the front in the province of Hama.

On the front in this province, active hostilities in the area of ​​the "Latami ledge" and on the flanks near it actually stopped. On the other hand, the government troops quite successfully continued to advance on the front a little to the west, in the al-Ghab valley (formally, this is already the province of Latakia, but the front is solid here, and the old administrative division of Syria does not play a role). For the Syrian army, this is the normal pace of the offensive, although many could quite reasonably recall some representatives of the animal world, in particular, turtles. This offensive has been going on with the general goal of Jizr al-Shugur through Sirmania and Karkor for a week and a half, and all the recaptured settlements are heaps of ruins unsuitable for life. And what's next, only Drones know.


The offensive in the valley of Al-Gab is limited from the west by a mountain range, which for almost a week they have been trying to storm frontal through the town of Salma, which has been passed from hand to hand several times. This occupation is hopeless, because the war in the highlands will require special knowledge and skills that the cat seems to have cried from the government army. But from a political point of view, an offensive in the Al-Gab valley and an attack on the mountains are extremely important, since in the long term they will give direct access to the Turkish border or even isolate militants and their surroundings in parts throughout the province of Idlib. This embarrasses Turkey, since the supply of militants in such a situation can only be conducted through Turkish territory, which is unacceptable for anyone.

Another serious success was achieved in the province of Homs, where a large enclave of insurgents has existed and flourished for five years, in which several dozen small groups of various orientations were pressed together. Potentially, this enclave in the deep rear was a serious danger to Damascus. In addition, attacks were periodically carried out from it in order to cut off the communications of the government forces. Now the Assad troops, with the direct support of Russian aviation, have finally managed to dismember it in two. Most likely, the enclave will be finished up slowly and gradually, hanging a sign "for the funeral": in the current situation there is no point in throwing large forces, since it no longer represents such a danger as 7 – 10 days ago, when from the last time someone ran out, cutting the road Homs - Hama. There are directions and more important. The same deblockade of Aleppo, for example. Or fighting in the eastern suburbs of Damascus.

The offensive there is extremely slow, taking into account the harshest conditions of a completely destroyed infrastructure, broken residential and industrial buildings, and indeed, dense urban battles have never been a reason for vigorous reports. Government troops managed to recapture several quarters, counting the liberated territory has to be carried out in almost every house, but a positive trend is already visible. If two weeks ago it was believed that ISIS, Dzhebhat al-Nusra and now deceased Jaish al-Fatah were ready to seize the center of Damascus, now they are only sluggishly gnawing with “wandering mortars” and “technicals”, and they don’t even think about the attack.
Something similar is happening on the very peripheral - southern and south-western - fronts. The appearance of Russian aviation was preceded by several local attacks of Islamists in the Deraa region and on the Golan Heights, but now the government army has stopped all these enemy achievements and slowly began to beat the lost back.

The “first speed” of what is happening has already become somewhat straining, but apparently the solution of one or, with God's help, several large front-line tasks will be able to radically change the balance of forces. Now, no frontal offensive by government forces against ISIL is possible without solving problems in the rear, the de-blockade of Aleppo, the Kuwaireis base, the elimination of enclaves and access to the Turkish border (Golan Heights can wait). And we'll see.
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

105 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +7
    22 October 2015 05: 46
    Our military generals must be advisers to their General Staff.
    1. +21
      22 October 2015 06: 04
      government troops are exhausted, otherwise they would not have asked for help, so there is nothing surprising in the fact that their actions seem passive.
      Quote: Tartar 174
      Our military generals must be advisers to their General Staff.

      Uv.Zemlyak, I think the Syrians have more fighting experience in their conditions, the moral condition of Assad’s army is high (thanks to us), they perked up, but it takes time to bring everything back to normal after defeats. Surely we will see a turning point in the near future, ours the number of combat sorties increased. (private opinion) hi
    2. -45
      22 October 2015 06: 07
      Quote: Tatar 174
      to their General Staff advisers

      Does Syria have a General Staff?
      1. +21
        22 October 2015 06: 49
        Quote: V.ic
        Does Syria have a General Staff?

        Do you have a head on your shoulders, or is it just that?
        1. -21
          22 October 2015 08: 03
          Quote: EvgNik
          А you have a head on your shoulders, or just the appearance of it?

          A counter question to you: (read above written)?
      2. -23
        22 October 2015 08: 00
        Does Syria have a General Staff?

        And what has this office been doing so far? The opponents of Assad, who are directly at war with his troops, do not have a "General Staff", but the spooks slowly tightened the noose around Assad's neck until our group intervened! So, ladies and gentlemen, there is no General Staff in Syria, but only a sign with this name.
        1. +11
          22 October 2015 08: 11
          Quote: V.ic
          And what has this office done so far?

          look at the map of fronts, questions will disappear ....
          1. -9
            22 October 2015 08: 41
            Quote: Andrey Yurievich
            look at the map of fronts, questions will disappear ....

            Six months ago or annual?
          2. +9
            22 October 2015 17: 59
            Quote: Andrey Yurievich
            And what has this office done so far?

            Actually, this "cantor" has been fighting for 2 years, in fact, against America and NATO and terrorists from all over the world, and is still alive ... ... have respect ...
            1. +3
              23 October 2015 02: 36
              In fact, there are already Russian and Iranian representatives of the General Staff there, and an offensive is hardly planned without them. It's another matter why there is no "central direction of the offensive" !? The offensive is taking place in different places and so far the successes are local. The reason is apparently in tactics. To strike in different directions, apparently it is difficult for the enemy to transfer supplies, people and weapons from one region to another. With this tactic, it is probably easier to identify the warehouses and logistics of the terrorists. Depriving ammunition, in fact, the militants will have nothing to fight with. First of all, this means heavy weapons and ammunition for them. The enemy armored vehicles are practically invisible. The bandits buried themselves like moles in the population. points, fighting in open spaces is not visible. And it seems to me that everything will end with boilers in us. points.
              They are "poisoning the beast" so that it is impossible for them to escape because of the videoconferencing, it remains to burrow in us. points. Ammunition is being dispersed in all directions, and the militants' ability to attack has significantly decreased - there is no way to concentrate large reserves somewhere. Previously, they beat the Syrian army everywhere unexpectedly, now they are "thrashed" in the same way. It is necessary to prepare for the fact that it will be necessary to "smoke" them out of all holes - and this will not happen quickly - they managed to bury themselves there in 4 years. If there are mountains in the Caucasus, then there are "holes" in Syria. hi
          3. The comment was deleted.
        2. SSR
          +5
          22 October 2015 09: 01
          Quote: V.ic
          Does Syria have a General Staff?

          And what has this office been doing so far? The opponents of Assad, who are directly at war with his troops, do not have a "General Staff", but the spooks slowly tightened the noose around Assad's neck until our group intervened! So, ladies and gentlemen, there is no General Staff in Syria, but only a sign with this name.

          How would you answer? ...... Do not tell me how the Ishilites who did not have heavy equipment began to squeeze equipment and take entire cities of Iraq? .... This is so for reflection and, to be honest, it’s not bad to read other articles.
          Quote: V.ic
          Quote: Andrey Yurievich
          look at the map of fronts, questions will disappear ....

          Six months ago or annual?

          Here is not "caught", or sarcasm or something .....
          Messages from the lord of the Sith, look, there were the freshest cards (this is one offhand).
        3. +3
          22 October 2015 09: 05
          Quote: V.ic
          The opponents of Assad, who are directly at war with his troops, do not have a "General Staff", but the spooks slowly tightened the noose around Assad's neck until our group intervened!

          based on the reports of the VKS press service, terrorists have at least more than a hundred headquarters hit by missile and bomb strikes. And on the basis of how well they are holding, the creation of GS for them is more minus than plus.
          You wanted to say that the General Staff of Syria exists, but is not effective !?
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. +5
            22 October 2015 11: 20
            based on the reports of the VKS press service, terrorists have at least more than a hundred headquarters hit by missile and bomb strikes.


            The main thing is that at these headquarters, someone else was amazed.

            This article appeared in the View a few days ago. The author, to put it mildly, is an amateur who has run out of chips, but goes to the stall, is afraid to miss something interesting. During the Great Patriotic War, he was allowed to pay for such a scribble. Not from evil, but to order.
        4. +5
          22 October 2015 10: 28
          Here, the opponents of Assad, who are directly at war with his troops, do not have a "General Staff", but the spooks slowly tightened the noose around Assad's neck until our group intervened
          - Assad's opponents have such a "shadow general staff" with advisers from the United States, Saud. Arabia, and so on. - Whoa. There, hired specialists earn LP.
          1. +3
            22 October 2015 11: 22
            "shadow general staff" is


            Not shadow, but the most real, in Jordan. With a general from Qatar.
        5. +1
          22 October 2015 23: 12
          Yes, they did nothing, except for a few states they fought against the rest of the world ..
      3. +4
        22 October 2015 11: 09
        Quote: V.ic
        Does Syria have a General Staff?

        Yes.
        The organizational structure of the Syrian armed forces
        MO and GSH

        The General Staff is in charge of the operational management and staffing of the armed forces, and the development of plans for their use. The General Staff has the following main departments: operational, reconnaissance, organizational and mobilization. The chief of the general staff is assigned the duties of the first deputy minister of defense and the commander of the ground forces. In operational terms, the commanders of the armed forces and military branches are subordinate to him.
        It is understandable
        USSR military assistance, which included the supply of weapons and military equipment, the sending of Soviet troops to the SAR as military advisers and specialists, and the organization of the training of national military personnel. Currently, the SAR Armed Forces maintain military-technical contacts with China, the DPRK, Czechoslovakia, Bulgaria and several other states.

        There is a GS, but the effectiveness of its actions ...
        Arab-Israeli wars: 1948 - 1949, 1967, 1973 - 1974 and 1982
    3. +19
      22 October 2015 06: 32
      Quote: Tatar 174
      Our military generals must be advisers to their General Staff.

      Here the author is sent there, sitting on a sofa in Russia, he is much better than the Syrian generals and our advisers who are there, he knows how to quickly win and what needs to be done.
      1. +5
        22 October 2015 06: 59
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        Here is the author to send there, he is sitting on a sofa in Russia

        Sasha often reading your comments, I think - can we not write anything at all? True, I’m writing not on the couch, but in the chair, but still ... laughing
        1. +3
          22 October 2015 07: 01
          Quote: afdjhbn67
          True, I’m writing not on the couch, but in the chair, but still ...

          A chair is a completely different matter, it’s more convenient from a chair wink
          1. 0
            22 October 2015 07: 23
            if there is no common enemy, people bite each other ... laughing laughing laughing
            1. +7
              22 October 2015 07: 42
              Quote: Andrey Yurievich
              well, people bite each other ...

              I'd rather drink, and there at the table after 5 bottles the enemy will always get enough laughing
              1. +2
                22 October 2015 07: 55
                Sasha, Sasha ... what can I say: http: //topwar.ru/84479-kak-alkogol-pobezhdaet-stranu.html#comment-id-509
                8560 laughing laughing laughing
              2. +4
                22 October 2015 07: 56
                Quote: Alexander Romanov
                Quote: Andrey Yurievich
                well, people bite each other ...

                I'd rather drink, and there at the table after 5 bottles the enemy will always get enough laughing

                Of course - after the fifth bottle, there is always a fight with "helicopters" ... bully drinks
                1. The comment was deleted.
      2. 0
        22 October 2015 11: 27
        Here is the author to send there


        Yeah, to collect a hundred more of these authors in an assault company, give Zhenya a parabellum, draw stars on the shoulder straps and forward, storm the abreks. The benefit is undoubted, in the media there will be less game.
    4. +15
      22 October 2015 08: 23
      AND? The developed operation will crash at the execution level.

      A couple of weeks ago there were pretty talking videos of the advance of the SAA marching column. TOU flies into them from the roof of the house = gets into the column, the tank is intact. What does CAA do? Could it be unfolding in order? Maybe moving away? Can it cover itself with smoke and cause art support, simultaneously leading a harassing fire? Not! Pret the same column, not even adding speed. The second TOU flies in them, the column was gone - the tank burned down. And all from one roof, one operator and a teenager charging done. Then the third in the BMP. Then the fourth is already on the tank standing in the field.

      The artillery preparation in the area of ​​the offensive was - but four hours before the advance. Its effectiveness is zero with such timings. But in the news was something to show.

      To each officer from the major in the head to drive the basic tactics of attack, movement, retreat? And in general, drive them what should have been driven into the military commissar. So this one will take many months ...

      If without this, then any operation will fail on execution, at least someone would have planned it.
      1. +3
        22 October 2015 10: 14
        A couple of weeks ago there were pretty talking videos of the advance of the SAA marching column. TOU flies into them from the roof of the house = gets into the column, the tank is intact


        Do you seriously think that it was a real movie, not an Al Jazeera decree?
        I personally deeply doubt that when even non-fired boys are "worked out" from ATGMs along the column, they will simply stupidly continue to move "without even increasing their speed." Still, this is not a square of the 18th century, which slowly crawls under the fire of cannons, the cannonballs of which are laid in it, and it again closes the ranks. So either the video was not available, or it was the decision of Al-Jazeera.
        1. +4
          22 October 2015 13: 52
          I saw this video. There the landing behind the tank didn’t even react to the hit, the crew alive but burnt out ran away but fell under the rifle. Pearl was a dense column with almost no intervals, a fact. We didn’t spot either the place or the launch direction - fact. it’s not at all understandable. But the militants calmly, as if on a dash, didn’t scamper around them. They could have covered themselves with smoke and something. They crawled there for a long time. Such a poor performance turned out. .
          1. 0
            22 October 2015 14: 06
            .Not frail such a statement turned out. We need to learn, especially to us, as long as there are other people's mistakes.


            Well, taking Tripoli will be cooler, but nothing worked.
      2. 0
        22 October 2015 12: 50
        Conclusion: for each battalion, an adviser (specialist)
      3. 0
        22 October 2015 14: 11
        Quote: donavi49
        To each officer from the major in the head to drive the basic tactics of attack, movement, retreat? And in general, drive them what should have been driven into the military commissar. So this one will take many months ...


        In war, people learn faster. No matter how we want quick victories, it is more important to keep as many people in the SAA as possible and teach them how to fight well.
  2. +6
    22 October 2015 05: 51
    war in the highlands will require special knowledge and skills

    After the victoriously voiced victories of the Syrians, the number of articles on serious problems of the Syrian army itself is increasing day by day. I understand that there is an opportunity to send advisers, but it looks like it should have been done the day before yesterday. What now? Hope only for the Iranians? Also not clear.
    1. +1
      22 October 2015 10: 53
      I understand the ability to send advisers exists

      Most likely, advisers from all the regions there are available, including from Asia. And yes, now all hope for the Iranians, the Syrians and the Hezbollahs are already specifically tired.
    2. +2
      22 October 2015 11: 52
      Quote: venaya
      war in the highlands will require special knowledge and skills

      After the victoriously voiced victories of the Syrians, the number of articles on serious problems of the Syrian army itself is increasing day by day. I understand that there is an opportunity to send advisers, but it looks like it should have been done the day before yesterday. What now? Hope only for the Iranians? Also not clear.

      ===
      I think before the start of the VKS operation, options for the development of events were calculated taking into account the state of the SAR troops. as an option they counted on joint efforts with the West, maybe only part of the country could be reconquered, well, other options
  3. +5
    22 October 2015 05: 51
    Without cutting off the supply and financing of ISIS and the like, "head-on", the war in Syria will drag on for years ...
    1. +1
      22 October 2015 06: 06
      Quote: Oman 47
      Without cutting off the supply and financing of ISIS and the like, "head-on", the war in Syria will drag on for years ...

      So they try to cut them off from the sea. Yes
      1. +1
        22 October 2015 08: 00
        Quote: Andrey Yurievich
        Quote: Oman 47
        Without cutting off the supply and financing of ISIS and the like, "head-on", the war in Syria will drag on for years ...

        So they try to cut them off from the sea. Yes

        Is it from the sea? So far - from the Turkish border. And then, perhaps, it will come to Iraq. Or do you mean the Persian Gulf through the territory of Iraq?what
        1. 0
          22 October 2015 08: 46
          Quote: andj61
          Is it from the sea?

          and from the sea, and from the Turkish border. we are looking at the scheme of hostilities, especially since we are interested in the coast being "clean" ... hi
      2. 0
        22 October 2015 09: 54
        Quote: Andrey Yurievich
        Quote: Oman 47
        Without cutting off the supply and financing of ISIS and the like, "head-on", the war in Syria will drag on for years ...

        So they try to cut them off from the sea. Yes


        hello, Andrey, in general, their main weapon is from Iraq and the captured Syrian, in general, they don’t have access to the sea
        1. +3
          22 October 2015 11: 32
          in general, their main weapon is from Iraq and the captured Syrian


          From Jordan, too, dear. Just what is most effective against armor.
          1. 0
            22 October 2015 12: 00
            Quote: Asadullah
            From Jordan, too, dear. Just what is most effective against armor.

            Let from Jordan. Is that Hashim? Well, what is licensed in Russia?
            1. +1
              22 October 2015 12: 53
              Another t90 to sell to the Saudis, and then t90 will appear in Syria (among the bandits)
            2. 0
              22 October 2015 15: 19
              Yes, waking you my friend, the weapon is subjective, and is a consumable for someone who is sharpened for this "expense". Turkish specialists will train militants to spend according to the designation of Hashima, Hashim will appear. And Jordan is just a playground, the local Hashemite kings, by agreement, will let and place on their territory not only militants with instructors, but a herd of pigs, which will be kissed every day, just by the power of persuasion. No matter how the Israelis may not know about this, is it not, dear friends? wink
    2. +2
      22 October 2015 08: 14
      From which sea? They have no sea. Only the Turkish border in the north and the Jordanian in the south, where Allah regularly gives gifts.
      1. 0
        22 October 2015 08: 49
        Quote: donavi49
        From which sea? They have no sea.

        oh how! the word Tartus, does it mean anything to you? (close to Damascus, 200 kilometers or so) winked
        1. +8
          22 October 2015 09: 09
          So the whole coastal Latakia under the complete control of government troops. And they don’t really like baboons there, that is, if the baboons break out of the mountains, then there will be quite a people's war, for Latakian population two ways - win and survive or become heroes of the HD kin without special effects / slaves for 15-20 bucks in Idlib or Raqqa, depending on what kind of baboons will capture them. And no one is building any illusions. Islamists, moderate and IS equally declares - Alawites and Latakian Christians under the knife.

          The broads have no sea, see maps. The positions closest to the sea in the Mountains, but there still have to break through and break through.

          Red is Assad.
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. 0
            22 October 2015 09: 43
            The broads have no sea, see maps. The positions closest to the sea in the Mountains, but there still have to break through and break through.
            that is, the fact that TAM has to keep troops doesn’t mean anything? ... well, you are a strategist ...
          3. 0
            22 October 2015 10: 34
            Monthly map
          4. 0
            22 October 2015 11: 40
            become heroes of the HD kin without special effects / slaves for 15-20 bucks


            This is in case of accepting a new faith. After that, they "voluntarily", until the end of their lives, must work off their sin. For food.
      2. +2
        22 October 2015 09: 12
        Quote: donavi49
        From which sea? They have no sea.

        So, well this is already 6 bottle.
  4. -5
    22 October 2015 05: 52
    Something tells me if he will come, the day of the victory of the Syrian army. Right because. Beat the scoundrels face. Do they even have an ideology, well, at least some other than the destruction of everything and everything?
    I remember who tried to build a new world here who was nothing. From nothing, nothing happens. And the ideology was, instead of Christ Ilyich. The results are not impressive (I’m talking about the standard of living). Achievements were, but porridge slurp for a long time yet.
    1. +1
      22 October 2015 06: 09
      Quote: iliitch
      . These have at least an ideology, well, at least some other than the destruction of everything and everything

      of course the caliphate ...
    2. +4
      22 October 2015 06: 34
      Quote: iliitch
      Something tells me he will come, the day of the victory of the Syrian army

      It is impossible to win this warrior, you can only conquer a part and divide Syria into zones of responsibility. In the end, two or three states.
      1. +2
        22 October 2015 06: 53
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        Quote: iliitch
        Something tells me he will come, the day of the victory of the Syrian army

        It is impossible to win this warrior, you can only conquer a part and divide Syria into zones of responsibility. In the end, two or three states.

        I think San, the main thing for Assad is the coast, who controls him is the one and the dad. and the breakdown of Syria into two or three parts is a balm for the states, this cannot be allowed, otherwise "kapets" to all good intentions. hi
        1. +4
          22 October 2015 07: 04
          Quote: Andrey Yurievich
          and the breakdown of Syria into two or three parts is a balm for the states, this cannot be allowed, otherwise "kapets" to all good intentions.

          The Kurds will create their own state, consider the fact. Part of Syria will still be scumbags, the question is what.
          Andrea hi
          1. +3
            22 October 2015 07: 20
            if the Kurds agree with Assad, then perhaps this is not a bad option, if only they wouldn’t unwind further! and then, if Shiite-Sunite-Alavite, separate republics will appear, do not wait for good ... Alexander hi
            1. 0
              22 October 2015 07: 43
              Quote: Andrey Yurievich
              and then, if the Shiite-Sunite-Alavite, separate republics appear, do not wait for good ..

              Well, they will live, as in Lvii, and that's all. Although no, they will go to Europe for happiness. It’s also normal, there Merkel will warm them.
              1. +1
                22 October 2015 07: 57
                Quote: Alexander Romanov
                Merkel warms up.

                Germans, as it were, of a different opinion ... what
                1. +12
                  22 October 2015 09: 16
                  Quote: Andrey Yurievich
                  Germans, as it were, of a different opinion ...

                  It seems to me alone that she does not care what the Germans think.
                  Mohammed squats in Berlin and spits on the ground through a hole in his teeth. Suddenly a fairy appears and says:
                  - I am a socialist social liberal fairy! I flew to fulfill three wishes!
                  - Look, what a hole in my mouth! I want to be cured and put in all my teeth!
                  Before Muhammad could utter these words, the law on free treatment and prosthetics for social foreigners immediately came out, and his mouth shone with a snow-white Hollywood smile.
                  - I really miss my four wives and fifteen kids, as well as my parents, brothers and sisters, parents and siblings of my wives! I want us all to live in a luxury villa, and always have a lot of money!
                  Mohammed did not have time to finish, as he ended up in a beautiful villa! On the table is the text of the law on family reunification for social foreigners, as well as bank printouts with information about the benefits received. The house is fully furnished and equipped with electrical appliances in accordance with
                  the law on assistance in acquiring furniture and household appliances for social foreigners.
                  Happy Muhammad simply does not know what else to ask him, because one desire still remains. And he asked:
                  - I want to become a real German. Not only by citizenship. I want to be a blue-eyed blond, and that my name was Fritz Schulz!
                  Before he could finish the sentence, when everything had disappeared, he found himself squatting again and spitting on the ground through a hole in his teeth.
                  - What happened? He asked the fairy.
                  - It’s not a shame, Mr. Schulz, to beg the state! You must take care of yourself! Go and look for work!
                  1. +2
                    22 October 2015 09: 23
                    Quote: Alexander Romanov
                    Sits Muhammad

                    Well, yes, yes, it's funny ... Yes
                    Quote: Alexander Romanov
                    It seems to me alone that she does not care what the Germans think.

                    and she doesn't give a damn what the Omerikans think ... then you're right ... hi
          2. -1
            22 October 2015 09: 12
            Quote: Alexander Romanov
            The Kurds will create their own state, consider the fact. Part of Syria will still be scumbags

            Quote: Alexander Romanov
            It is impossible to win this warrior, you can only conquer a part and divide Syria into zones of responsibility. In the end, two or three states.

            Weighted and objective position. good
            1. -1
              22 October 2015 09: 24
              Quote: MACCABI-TLV
              Weighted and objective position.

              You have, of course, outlined the "zone of influence"? wink
              1. 0
                22 October 2015 20: 53
                Quote: Andrey Yurievich
                You have, of course, outlined the "zone of influence"?

                But did you doubt it? But seriously, Israel maintains good relations with Iraqi Kurds wink
              2. +1
                23 October 2015 00: 06
                Quote: Andrey Yurievich
                You have of course outlined the "zone of influence"

                plant me along the border (on the other side) of friends' villages. That will be enough.
          3. +1
            22 October 2015 09: 57
            Quote: Alexander Romanov
            Quote: Andrey Yurievich
            and the breakdown of Syria into two or three parts is a balm for the states, this cannot be allowed, otherwise "kapets" to all good intentions.

            The Kurds will create their own state, consider the fact. Part of Syria will still be scumbags, the question is what.
            Andrea hi

            Kurds will not create, Turkey will not, and Assad’s promises to the Kurds are absolutely worth it, as much as Assad now controls Syria
        2. -1
          22 October 2015 09: 56
          Quote: Andrey Yurievich
          Quote: Alexander Romanov
          Quote: iliitch
          Something tells me he will come, the day of the victory of the Syrian army

          It is impossible to win this warrior, you can only conquer a part and divide Syria into zones of responsibility. In the end, two or three states.

          I think San, the main thing for Assad is the coast, who controls him is the one and the dad. and the breakdown of Syria into two or three parts is a balm for the states, this cannot be allowed, otherwise "kapets" to all good intentions. hi

          for Assad, the main sea of ​​shopping mall is the Alawite enclave, but for the Sunni Syria, the sea is important, so the war is for years and this is understandable
    3. +11
      22 October 2015 07: 08
      Quote: iliitch
      The results are not impressive.

      You need to think. Won the Second World War. By what efforts, by what blood. It was necessary to restore everything again. Corncracker Nikitka ruined a lot. Brezhnev’s stagnation, when everyone was floating along the stream of the sleepy river. However, all the oligarchs grew up on these results, which are not impressive to you. Until now, all communications in the buildings of the buildings of the USSR. (Unless in new buildings - modern). But the main housing stock is from the times of the USSR. And how many fortunes have grown in the sale of scrap metal to the West? Recently, the monument to E. Leonov was sawn and sold. We still use what has been accumulated people THE USSR. And these are unimpressive results? You should be ashamed. And we disentangle the porridge precisely because we have turned off our path.
      1. +7
        22 October 2015 08: 35
        Quote: EvgNik
        However, all the oligarchs grew up on these results that are not impressive to you.

        On the property of the USSR, the world's financial clans have enriched even more steeply than before. But we are watching the remaining devastation after this and trying to clean up some kind of mess. Someone else is trying to blame the "brainless, corrupt communists" for the failed attempt to build the world's best society. But they just cannot understand that such a society was almost built when the maize traitor began to destroy it, preparing the ground for Gorbachev's perestroika. And to compare the savages, dismembering living people and destroying ancient shrines, with our ancestors, who for us created a Great Empire with equal rights for all, is simply disgusting and blasphemous. I agree with you.
    4. +5
      22 October 2015 08: 08
      Quote: iliitch
      I remember who tried to build a new world here who was nothing. From nothing, nothing happens. And the ideology was, instead of Christ Ilyich. The results are not impressive (I’m talking about the standard of living). Achievements were, but porridge slurp for a long time yet.

      The results are just quite impressive - even about the standard of living. It was impossible for a country with a population of 250 million to withstand open enemies with a population of under 800 million and at the same time feed - literally - and arm even not allies, and it is not known who with a population of 2 billion. That’s overturned ... These were burps of world theory revolution. They did not reject it completely along with Trotskyism, and so they got a mine under the building of their own country.
      1. +1
        22 October 2015 11: 42
        Quote: andj61
        They did not reject it completely along with Trotskyism, and so they got a mine under the building of their own country.

        The theory of the world revolution was just completely rejected, and successfully opposed world imperialism, survived two terrible wars, revived and flourished, but the mine was planted with the remaining unfinished Trotskyists in the person of a corncob and his comrades.
  5. +10
    22 October 2015 05: 55
    You can send our General Staff to the Papuans, whether there will be any sense. The Syrian army is very exhausted by the war. That is why ours are waiting for the Iranian contingent and supply Assad with new weapons. It would not be bad to cooperate with the Kurds, but the United States privatized them. By cut, a very significant victory is needed to raise morale, for example, the complete liberation of Damascus. However, a bunch of Syrian men flee to Europe. So this war will not be fast. I hope our pilots will be as lucky as before.
    1. +1
      22 October 2015 06: 54
      Quote: Marconi41
      By cut, a very significant victory is needed to raise morale, for example, the complete liberation of Damascus. However, a bunch of Syrian men flee to Europe.


      - While Europe is gloatingly watching the war in the East, the Arabs are gradually turning Europe into Syria. 750 policemen guard the tunnel through the English Channel from refugees, and the French minister asks for help from the army; apparently, there is no hope only for police forces. There, of course, are not only Syrians. But, I think, the Europeans will not care who cuts them - Libyan, Syrian, Iranian ... and small-town clashes have already been, and still will be, more than once. This is the price of the policy of condoning USA games in the East.
  6. +3
    22 October 2015 06: 04
    Patience ... and more patience! Experience itself does not appear! Our young and Syrians need experience!
    The experience of warfare! Future wars .. God forbid! just will be in the Cities Millionaires!
    So .. EXPERIENCE and EXPERIENCE again!
  7. +4
    22 October 2015 06: 04
    Apparently, that is why Assad was "invited". Russia does not need a sluggish war for years. And the Syrian army is demoralized and no longer understands what a strategic initiative is.
    1. +2
      22 October 2015 10: 01
      Quote: Mountain Shooter
      Apparently, that is why Assad was "invited". Russia does not need a sluggish war for years. And the Syrian army is demoralized and no longer understands what a strategic initiative is.

      the Syrian army is the Alawites and they will not climb into the Sunni enclaves, and in general, if someone thought that a fairy in the face of 50 aircraft could turn the tide of the war - this is a mistake, they can help the ground forces, and fight the infantry and tanks all the same - but with the fighting efficiency of these troops and morale - the problem
  8. -1
    22 October 2015 06: 11
    and why be surprised, typical Arab tactics, nothing has changed, read the memoirs of famous commanders participating in the Russian-Turkish wars ...
  9. +3
    22 October 2015 06: 12
    May Allah allow Assad and his companions to catch their breath ... So far, our aviation group has only slightly reduced the Wahhabi grip on Damascus's throat. Well, then, as in a joke: "we'll shake grass, take a drink of water, quietly go down and re ... love the whole herd!"
  10. +5
    22 October 2015 06: 13
    The war in Syria shows that, like in the last century, the most difficult thing is to break through a well-organized enemy defense. No bombing and cruise missile attacks can break into a well-prepared defense, you need artillery, tanks and infantry and well-organized logistics to provide all the necessary military equipment the time of the offensive, but the Syrian army has a problem with this.
  11. +2
    22 October 2015 06: 14
    So Assad was dragged onto the carpet to Putin, I hope he was popularly explained the role of the General Staff in the war. Arabs fight much against a weak enemy, and a little harder - they run to the nearest "Canadian border".
  12. +7
    22 October 2015 06: 25
    Assad's army is not only exhausted, resources are also depleted, logistics are disrupted, which of course does not add momentum to the offensive. It would be strange to expect high rates of advance, plus the city battles themselves, as one of the most difficult types of combat units, do not contribute to rapid advancement, and of course everyone is against everyone. Have to fight with the so-called opposition, which seems to be "neutral"
    1. +2
      22 October 2015 07: 13
      Quote: Nehist
      It would be strange to expect high rates of attack, plus urban battles themselves as one of the complex types of databases

      Moreover, Alexander, as you correctly noted, the urban battles in Syria are fundamentally different from everything that we have seen and known before. they do not burst to "clean up" the buildings, they stupidly water each other from a distance, and from such that the "Kalash", only in the form of a PKK gets it, and a little closer, the RPG works. with such tactics, rapid advancement is impossible, although it is probably rational in order to preserve L / S. hi
      1. +1
        22 October 2015 10: 01
        It’s bad that we don’t have combat drones there, equipped with thermal imagers and missile-bomb weapons - just the technique for destroying small groups on cars and in ambushes.
  13. 0
    22 October 2015 06: 38
    Quote: igorra
    So Assad was dragged onto the carpet to Putin, I hope he was popularly explained the role of the General Staff in the war. Arabs fight much against a weak enemy, and a little harder - they run to the nearest "Canadian border".


    Well, no way, you can’t do without a land operation. I don’t want to, but I need to. Some kind of curse hangs on us. Constantly got into conflicts, nafig not needed. Well, after all, the marines will fill the faces of everyone. Until they bite off in full, they don’t understand.
  14. +2
    22 October 2015 06: 57
    It would not hurt to attach a map to the article.
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. +1
      22 October 2015 08: 06
      I will try to help:
  15. +4
    22 October 2015 07: 01
    After the "shapkozakidatelskih" articles, this one is closer to real. It is clear that aviation cannot solve the problem. Assad is also probably having a hard time, internal political and personnel problems are also enough. I think our advisers understand all this better than we do, and work on bugs is underway. But we must look to the future and train new officers in the schools, it is they who will later become the basis of the Syrian army and the country's elite. They have enough practice, now they need to mix it with the theory and experience of others. Remember 1 Chechen? And compare with 2. We also learned, unfortunately from our mistakes. The war with ISIS will end, the struggle for power will begin, I think it is the proven and reliable fighters who will become the mainstay of President Assad. Good luck everyone!
  16. Riv
    +3
    22 October 2015 07: 54
    Well, do not make me laugh in the morning. Not the mood on Thursday morning to listen to Petrosyan. What other "tactics of the Syrian General Staff"? There, in the line units, the overwhelming majority of the soldiers are yesterday's peasants, for whom even a machine gun is an incomprehensible shaitan machine. The monkey is really smarter. With more complex techniques, even trying to teach them is useless. The officers are the same.
    Why was ISIS crushing the Syrian army? Yes, because professionals are hired and paid to them (at least to those who survive). So there is no need here about some tactics with strategy. A soldier must be trained seriously, as was done in Soviet times. Egypt prepared the army so that the school is still felt. The same thing must be done with the Syrians - to cook them. To bring to Russia, to train according to our charters and on our equipment.
    Then it makes sense to talk about some kind of tactics.
    1. -1
      22 October 2015 10: 05
      . ) So there is no need here about some tactics with strategy. A soldier must be trained seriously, as was done in Soviet times. Egypt prepared the army so that the school is still felt.

      An unsuccessful example, by the way, the Syrian army was always built on the model of the Soviet one - by the way, by the way, it did not boast of success
      1. Riv
        +5
        22 October 2015 11: 06
        Apparently at least your grandfather left for Israel? You have a poor idea of ​​what the Soviet Army is. In 1815, Russia began the first Caucasian war. The country had an advanced army at the time, which had just defeated Napoleon and was led by officers with rich combat experience. The economy was in excellent condition. No one disputed the authority of the throne. The army was opposed by the half-wild highlanders. With all this, the war went on for almost seventy years.

        But the Chechen conflict was completely over in ten years, in the most difficult economic and political situation, and not even by the Soviet Army, but by its miserable remnants, which somehow preserved their combat readiness. Almost all the local population and trained mercenaries opposed Russian soldiers. But they did it.

        Compare this with the success of the IDF, which can not cope with half-naked Palestinians ...
        1. 0
          22 October 2015 11: 59
          Quote: Riv
          Apparently at least your grandfather left for Israel?

          Yes ? Have you served in the SA?
          Quote: Riv
          You poorly imagine what the Soviet Army is

          I'm DMB -90, and you?
          Quote: Riv
          Compare this to the success of the IDF,

          Why compare, then?
          the post was
          Quote: Riv
          A soldier must be trained seriously, as was done in Soviet times. Egypt prepared the army so that the school is still felt. The same thing must be done with the Syrians

          All wars, that Egypt, that Syria-have lost outright to Israel, further
          Quote: Riv
          with half-naked Palestinians.

          Assad has not been able to cope with his army for 4 years. but loses one territory after another.
          Googled about the Syrian army and on whose model it was built
          learn materiel laughing
          1. Riv
            +1
            22 October 2015 14: 50
            Tell tales, Jew. In the 90th he was demobilized ... Yes, your dad and mom met already in this century. I look: not only here we have a bad history with school.
            Where would Israel be now if England and France had not harnessed for it during the Suez crisis? Be silent, hussars! No time to rhyme. In Jewish schools, is it not fashionable to teach such historical details?
      2. The comment was deleted.
  17. +5
    22 October 2015 08: 23
    And this is an analysis of the situation? And even with not stupid accusations, or do you naively think that there are no our advisers in Syria, it would be easy and simple Assad would not have lost so much territory and strategically important areas, there is practically no equipment, artillery is only for controlling important directions, a political crisis within the country, refugees, and a bunch of problems, and with all this, the troops go on the offensive, it is difficult, difficult, but your epithets "triumphant" are also inappropriate
    1. +4
      22 October 2015 11: 10
      The author contradicts himself in his article twice. That movement around Aleppo is a mistake, then this is the main task. Either everything was choked with it, then the territories were recaptured in all the provinces ...

      I think that there are advisers at all levels - from the company of special forces to the General Staff. Send a squadron to be commanded by the Syrian general staff? Even an Eskimo would not have made such a mistake.

      And the available aircraft is quite enough for the existing army against the existing enemy. 45 departures per day for 45 flying devices or what? The distance there the cat cried - half an hour in the air and return to base.

      And the slowness is due to the rise in price of soldiers, there are very few of them left over the 4 of the year. Some cite the number in 280 thousands at the beginning of the conflict. Probably in their head Turkey attacked Syria and all 280 thousands are fighting with it. They do not understand that a civil war happened there and at the beginning the Sunnis fought with the rest. Assad may now have 280 thousands, but he has no more thousands of 30 armies (which ensures the current advancement). The rest of the militia is not trained and not equipped - capable of only holding frontiers in the trenches.

      And you don’t need 200 planes to bomb the desert. And the cities will hardly be bombed - they will repeat American mistakes ... The Russians want to be liberators and peacekeepers. Therefore, Assad and on his lips constantly on reconciliation and peace. He is already participating in the political struggle.

      The Chechen scenario will be involved. You’ll see you as your best friends. Even the Kurdish leaders do not have a single word about an independent country - because Turkey simply annexes them. They will all be reconciled and processed by propaganda.

      Who brought the war? USA. Who bombed us? Turkey. Who set up the mercenaries? Qatar. What did the Saud need? Your territory? Who died in this? Every Syrian family lost a member, regardless of faith ... After all, in Syria there was a secular state and there will be a rollback to this state. Take a closer look at the leader of the moderate Sunnis. The same woman performed there. So mercenaries and radical Sunnis will be destroyed and rallied.
  18. +2
    22 October 2015 08: 41
    East is a delicate matter? Moreover, there are no classical fronts and rear. And so, according to Clausewitz, the 1st column ... a marshisht will not work! As in Afghanistan, the militants use the tactics of small mobile units, it is very difficult to destroy them. The main thing is to continue to destroy large ground goals.
  19. +1
    22 October 2015 09: 14
    It seems that they are trying to drag us into a full-scale war, a second Afghanistan. The states and their allies are usually a little taut with fantasy, so they use already tested templates.
  20. +1
    22 October 2015 09: 34
    The eastern slow-moving mentality also affects the habit of positional warfare, but I think that soon the Syrian troops will be reorganized at an accelerated pace. Plus, of course, the dispersion of forces on all fronts is not good, and here we either need to increase the air force. or slow down the hot Syrian heads. The author of the rights of the dumb is all stupid. We need to focus on the key north direction.
  21. +2
    22 October 2015 09: 45
    The clusters of terrorists were the target of Russian air strikes only where these clusters were or are. In urban settings, such strikes do not always lead to immediate capture of objects. "Cyborgs" sat for a long time at the Donetsk airport after there was nothing left to sit there.
    The main goal of the strike of Russian aviation are warehouses and communications. This will not affect the state of terrorists in one day. But it will be reflected. War has its own laws and calculations.
  22. +3
    22 October 2015 10: 55

    don't angry Russians, better sit under sofas
    1. 0
      22 October 2015 16: 23
      So in the frame it’s kind of like not a fighter, and not even Russian at all, but Su-22 Syrian. Well, God bless him ...
  23. 0
    22 October 2015 11: 14
    Interesting comments here on the site, I would like to ask the guys, whose will you be? More than half of them shouted "hurray" very loudly, after the launches of "Caliber" they were delighted with the flight of the militants, and as soon as the situation took on a serious character (which it should have been) , "critical" conclusions and forecasts immediately came out, so whose will you be?
  24. +2
    22 October 2015 11: 17
    Sofa generals.
    You sit and remember the analogue. The end of winter to the beginning of summer 1942. The euphoria of the victories of the winter of 1941 and the army again broken in blood. Everything is about the same.
    Wai do not tell me about the supply of troops? (the tank travels about 320-500 km. In addition to fuel, it needs shells. It needs infantry support, it needs aviation support). There is an analogue already in the winter of the 43rd when the troops are left without supplies because of the stretched lines.
    In order to talk about this, it’s not necessary the reports of the media, among which the military specialists of Adyns-Tory and those who listen to the currents on presentations. Tactical and staff cards are needed for evaluation, and who will give them all the more in military operations?
    If you look purely logically and from the supply side, you need to cut off the supply channels. These are borders with Turkey, Lebanon, Iraq and Jordan. What in the center is it just crushing for several weeks, a maximum of months without supply.
  25. +7
    22 October 2015 11: 18
    The tactics of the Syrian General Staff do not raise any questions. In general, I am surprised that the Syrian army still exists, given the number of participants opposed to the SA: "peaceful opposition", ISIS, Front-al-Nusra, the Muslim Brotherhood, etc. and these are only terrorist organizations, with the support of Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Turkey, the United States ... therefore, there is no need to talk about the ineffectiveness of the Syrian General Staff, they have been waging this war practically alone for 4 years. With the arrival of the Russian Aerospace Forces, the situation has changed, but there is no need to wait for miracles, the Syrian army is tired of fighting, there is a shortage of personnel, equipment, ammunition, from our side, I think it will not be superfluous to supply a massive supply of military equipment, we have so much equipment in our warehouses since the times of the USSR and all this will stand until it decays, since new samples are being supplied to the armed Russian Army and there is nowhere to put the old stuff .... I will immediately make a reservation that "old" does not mean efficiency, just the phrase "made in the USSR" says a lot ... With the personnel, Iran's help would be helpful here, and our support of the Aerospace Forces from the air.
  26. 0
    22 October 2015 12: 04
    for atalef, the Soviet army took Berlin and pulled you snipers.
    1. -1
      22 October 2015 12: 10
      Quote: Boris Zidkov
      for atalef, the Soviet army took Berlin

      And what's the connection?
  27. 0
    22 October 2015 12: 13
    How tired of the news about Syria, we are killing Russians near Donbass, and the public somehow strangely turned our attention ... or maybe on purpose, to merge New Russia
  28. 0
    22 October 2015 14: 54
    Until the border between Syria and Turkey is closed, there will be no sense in fighting. All supplies and personnel of the militants come from Turkey. But about this thing, everyone is silent, although everyone has known this for a long time. Everything was the same in Chechnya until we blocked it, as it should, the borders and liquidated banks in the country, financially helping the bandits. So in Syria. One can assume that there was a conspiracy between our government, the US and the EU on the division of Syria into several parts, as it was before 1941. I can not say good or bad , but once being coerced into a conspiracy, they will be forced to do the rest. This was already the case under Gorbachev. He agreed to surrender the GDR and not expand NATO, got the collapse of the USSR and NATO on our borders. Ratings are certainly a good thing for the "electorate", but for the people it is better would be the resignation of the sabotage government, the amendment of the Constitution to an independent one and the prohibition of enemy ideologues to work in the country under the guise of "freedom of speech."
  29. +1
    22 October 2015 16: 29
    Finally, the obvious things began to come to mind, that PR, and the reality is a little different. If the troops are bloodless, scattered throughout the country, have suffered heavy losses in technology and the country is practically destroyed economically, it is foolish to hope that a miracle will happen and as a result of the 3 weeks of bombing, everything will change dramatically. It is a long road, very long. And I have no confidence (especially after the Donbass) that the Russian leadership is ready to go this way to the end. The main thing is that this is not an element of the next auction. If this is so, and this is really bargaining, then we (or rather, our ruling elite) are no different from the so-called bad Americans ...
  30. -1
    24 October 2015 01: 12
    Quote: EvgNik
    Quote: iliitch
    The results are not impressive.

    You need to think. Won the Second World War. By what efforts, by what blood. It was necessary to restore everything again. Corncracker Nikitka ruined a lot. Brezhnev’s stagnation, when everyone was floating along the stream of the sleepy river. However, all the oligarchs grew up on these results, which are not impressive to you. Until now, all communications in the buildings of the buildings of the USSR. (Unless in new buildings - modern). But the main housing stock is from the times of the USSR. And how many fortunes have grown in the sale of scrap metal to the West? Recently, the monument to E. Leonov was sawn and sold. We still use what has been accumulated people THE USSR. And these are unimpressive results? You should be ashamed. And we disentangle the porridge precisely because we have turned off our path.


    But I do not agree, I do not think so. A simple question: why did my parents die in poverty, even though they didn’t take a penny from someone else in their lives? Worked honestly. EXACTLY, because the Soviet power was curtailed, BECAUSE the results are not impressive either. Do not pull in sophistry, I will not answer. The result of Soviet power is not impressive! Should have been, and were bound to achieve more, and stretched TOTAL 70 years. So, that power was not viable, since it quickly went rotten! And I don’t want to hear songs about traitors and objective difficulties at all. Simply put, all the time, it was sucking in that power to the people that Our poop tastes better than Their poop; and Our AIDS is better than Their AIDS! And what we have achieved is thanks to our patient people, and not thanks to the power of the communist stupid. Well, I’m not a democrat, but now some people are witnessing here, but the communist power was IMAGINOUS, the descendants of the lumpen climbed out of the cellars in the 20th and 30th, and let's steer. If it weren’t for external enemies, and they wouldn’t have survived for 15 years, they would have devoured themselves ... The self-preservation instinct worked, as did all primitive ones. That's it.
    1. 0
      24 October 2015 01: 52
      What a funny one !! So the people once, not listening to any of the rulers gathered and how let's build, reinvent and fight !!!! So the football players don’t need a coach and the orchestra conductor? And in order to make it easier to think, you need to learn a story, but to tighten the economy with geography. And remember about propaganda in other countries.

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"