Media: another test launch of the Indian rocket Nirbhay ended in failure

In India, the regular test launch of the ground-to-ground Nirbhay medium-range cruise missile failed, reports MIC With reference to yesterday's message of the newspaper "Business Standard".

Start Nirbhay in October 2014

According to the newspaper, "a cruise missile was launched from the Chandipur test site in the state of Odish in eastern India."

According to the sources of the publication, “the launch took place in a regular mode, despite some problems during the pre-launch preparation”.

“However, after 11 minutes after launch, the rocket left the calculated trajectory and collapsed into the Bay of Bengal,” writes Business Standard. “With a range of applications from 750 to 1000 km, the test sample covered the distance only in 128 km.”

The newspaper reminds that “the first test launch of this type of cruise missiles in March 2013 also ended in failure - the rocket fell after 20 minutes of flight, and during the second launch in October of 2014, Nirbhai failed to reach a predetermined height.”

It is noted that the Nirbhai subsonic is being developed for the Indian army "as a supplement to the joint Russian-Indian supersonic BrahMos rocket with a range of about 290 km."

The Nirbhai is a two-stage cruise missile with a length of 6 m and a diameter of 0,52 m. The wingspan of its wings is 2,7 m, the combat load is up to 1,5 t.

Comments

[AdekvatNICK]

there will be no take-off without falls

[Andrea]

The zeal of the Indians is laudable, but the Chinese have chosen a more reliable path.

[Vitaly Anisimov]

Hindus will be with you until you make one system ... (buying everything up ... like women in shopping) And Russia would help you in these matters ... Advice and specialists, but alas .. Buy different technologies and toys! Here is the result!

[bulvas]

Is it time to do something with the INF Treaty?

It turns out that one can, the other can not.

You must either sign it all or cancel it

It’s better, of course, to sign everyone

So, soon the third countries will also have airborne missile carriers, we will be at a disadvantage in Eurasia

Or, we need to build more marine carriers

[Altona]

Quote: bulvas

Is it time to do something with the INF Treaty?

It turns out that one can, the other can not.

-----------------------------
Putin mentioned that we are even lagging behind in equipment. Third countries have already decently increased their power, China alone pulled out such an assortment of missiles to the parade that it will not seem like a little ... As for India, she is apparently trying to build an analogue of the "Tomahawk" herself, but so far she has reached what she has reached ...

[nrex]

But he did not say where we are lagging behind. Maybe from the planned plan? "Caliber" was also not included in the number of strategic weapons. So no one has yet learned the ultimate range thereof. It is enough that we have learned to swallow tongues for a week.

[ssn18]

"So no one has yet learned the ultimate range thereof"

Well, why? Infa on Caliber is more than enough. Not so long ago, one of the comrades laid out in a table form. Very colorful! In pedivics, there is also infa, although I would treat it with a sufficient degree of caution.

[avt]

Quote: bulvas

Is it time to do something with the INF Treaty?

You have missed something in life, well, except that the Volga flows into the Caspian Sea. Or they were carried away for a long time complaining about the fact that Buyan M "lacks weapons"

Quote: bulvas

So, soon the third countries will also have airborne missile carriers, we will be at a disadvantage in Eurasia

Well, here it is more likely not about third countries to worry about, but about quite a USA, here their potential in the form of RSRD for us on autopilot becomes strategic. And with the "third" we will figure it out in the long run.

[Garris199]

I think the ground-based "caliber" already exists.

[zennon]

Quote: Garris199

I think the ground-based "caliber" already exists.

Yes, it exists, but only its range is limited to 500 kilometers in accordance with the 1987 treaty on the elimination of medium and short-range missiles (INF) signed by a hunchback moron. We even then destroyed the S-10 Grenade, then Bish RK-55 with a range of up to 2500 km

[ssn18]

Well, let's put not only the "Pomegranate", but also the Oka 9K714 OTRK, which did not fall under the INF Treaty at all. And all thanks to the marked homosexual.

[zennon]

Quote: ssn18

Well, let's put not only "Pomegranate", but also "Oka" 9K714 OTRK,

I wrote about lionfish. And so-RSD-10 "Pioneer", "R-12", "R-14" yet.

[Manul]

Quote: ssn18

but also the Oka 9K714 OTRK, which did not fall under the RIAC at all. And all thanks to the tagged bugger.

I have a vague suspicion that Iskander could be upgraded to a greater range than 500 km in a short time.

[nazar_0753]

There was information that Iskander-M could be equipped with a cruise missile with a range of about 2500 km if necessary

[Boa kaa]

Quote: Garris199

I think the ground-based "caliber" already exists.

Well, damn it, you give! (C)
And also air, underwater and surface (well, you probably know this?)
Free tip: * google *, you may not have to ask such questions in the future!
Good luck, colleague!

[Strezhevchanin]

Quote: Garris199

I think the ground-based "caliber" already exists.

Not only that, in container ships around the world, a hundred pounds are skating, the number of stories is silent. There is no need to make an easy target out of such complexes.

[nrex]

In order for something to appear, the “appearance” must first grow, and if there isn’t one, then nothing will appear in the near future. (((

[ssn18]

"Isn't it time to do something about the INF Treaty?"

Honestly, this is a big topic that needs to be discussed separately. I think that no one doubts that the INF Treaty was flawed for Russia.

[zennon]

Quote: ssn18

The fact that the INF Treaty was flawed for Russia

What is the signatory, such is the contract ... Clickable.

[PSih2097]

Quote: bulvas

Is it time to do something with the INF Treaty?

And a caliber with an iskander for what? I understand that increasing the range on these complexes is not a problem, as well as changing the head for special ...

[Mera joota]

Quote: bulvas

Is it time to do something with the INF Treaty?

It’s time, we have China nearby, which has hundreds of medium-range missiles in service.

[demon1978]

Quote: MIKHAN

.Buy different technologies and toys! Here is the result!

And who knows how the "Caliber" will be in Indian ??? !!
Hindus, apparently, do not know yet

[vlad7777kul]

Russia cannot participate in such projects. We fall under the agreement on medium and short-range missiles. If the launch is from the sea or an airplane, then OK can’t be from the ground.

[veksha50]

Quote: Vlad7777kul

but from the earth it is impossible.

What is Kerry or who else said about various Russian platform ? Here, make an air cushion launch platform ... Legally - not ground ... just kidding ...

[Vladimirets]

Quote: veksha50

Here, make an air cushion launch platform ... Legally - not ground ...

It is possible on a river barge and moor somewhere on the Neman or Klyazma.

[Boa kaa]

Quote: veksha50

Here, make an air cushion launch platform ... Legally - not ground ...

Only if this platform "slides" into the sea!
Then (de jure and de facto) - she is marine!

[PSih2097]

Quote: veksha50

Here, make a hovercraft launch platform ...

You can drop the ICBM from the IL-76, then it will fly by itself ...

[Boa kaa]

Quote: Vlad7777kul

Russia cannot participate in such projects. We fall under the treaty on medium- and short-range missiles.

Think in the right direction, but that's just the non-proliferation treaty ...
Which is successfully managed by * former * specialists of the defense design bureaus, research institutes, enterprises privately concluding contracts with the foreign company we need. And that’s all - abgemacht! - as deutschers say.

[ssn18]

"Russia cannot participate in such projects. We fall under the treaty on medium and short-range missiles."

Well, this is only theoretically. And if you carefully look at what the SGA is used as target missiles, then this is a very good reason to withdraw from the INF Treaty. It’s just that now it’s apparently not time, there are more important problems.

[Angro Magno]

Nothing, years through 50 will bring to mind.
They brought Arjun.
My grandfather did not believe, father did not believe, I did not believe, but they did.

[nrex]

It’s not necessary, “dirt,” in the relations of the two countries, let everyone go their own way. So, they have helped the whole world more than one hundred times, but what in return? If it was necessary to help, they would help.

[Boa kaa]

Quote: nrex

If it was necessary to help, they would help.

How about atomoses, or what?

[ssn18]

"If I had to help, they would."

I do not want to offend anyone, but I would really like to understand what your confidence is based on.

[Boa kaa]

Quote: MIKHAN

Buy technology and toys are different! AT

And they’re doing it right! After all, our SPIERS need to do something under the guise of employees of joint ventures, design bureaus and research institutes.
So let them buy it! We have to spend less.

[varov14]

advice can help and that is ambiguous, let them soar themselves.

[Kostyar]

First damn lump, and the second lump .... damn !!!

[st25310]

Meanwhile, a Yemeni missile strike destroyed 17 F-15 fighters, 9 Apache helicopters and 66 Saudi officers.
http://warfiles.ru/show-97775-yemency-unichtozhili-raketami-skad-17-istrebiteley
-f-15-9-vertoletov-apach-i-66-saudovskih-oficerov.html

[Vladimirets]

Quote: st25310

Meanwhile, a Yemeni missile strike destroyed 17 F-15 fighters, 9 Apache helicopters and 66 Saudi officers.

It looks like a fake.

[ssn18]

It seems a trifle, but nice.

[marlin1203]

Here are some interesting people! Half of the population of a billion-dollar country is in animal poverty, vegetarians are not at all of their own free will, but because there is nothing, and they pump budget money into their own missile program, and even build strategic nuclear powered plants. And all this is "so-so" for them. Maybe it is correct in a long historical perspective, but it is already easier to buy everything you need from us and to master it further. It will be cheaper and faster.

[Observer2014]

I'm afraid to write an seditious thing, but still.
If you fill the pipe with gunpowder and then dance over it. And then decorate it with flowers and read a spell like: Rex Pax Fax. So it won’t fly. I think so.

[ssn18]

I absolutely agree with you. But honestly, the information on the topic is practically zero. How many launches? How many of them are successful, how many are unsuccessful? The article does not allow even an approximate calculation of CTG (coefficient of technical readiness).

[theadenter]

Little experience with Indian developers and designers. Experience comes with luck and failure.
Good luck to them in this and in between do not forget to buy time-tested, Russian.

[Professor]

It's a shame for the Indians. The Pakistanis of the Kyrgyz Republic fly without any problems with their enemies.

[kil 31]

Professor It's a shame for the Indians. The Pakistanis of the Kyrgyz Republic fly without any problems with their enemies.

It's okay, brahmos is already flying. Now our guys will be removed from the brahmos and they will bring this rocket to mind.

[Vitaly Anisimov]

Quote: professor

It's a shame for the Indians. The Pakistanis of the Kyrgyz Republic fly without any problems with their enemies.

Here is the correct opinion ...! And why..? Because help is right! Paid and everything they have flies (but under control ..))))

[Gronsky]

What a piercing and sincere sadness in these words !!!!

[Lenivets]

"Their enemies, the Pakistanis, have KRs flying without problems."

Own development or purchased?

[Thunderbolt]

India failed another test launch of a medium-range cruise missile Nirbhay

Quote: professor

It's a shame for the Indians.

This event was probably greeted with glee by the Pakistani public. Jubilant Pakistanis spilled out onto wide avenues. PS News tells us that the Indians are developing their own CR. We got to the test trials.

[Vladimir 1964]

With all due respect to our Indian colleagues, we must admit that the technological and production potential of India is not yet sufficiently developed, and to add to this the rather indiscriminate mentality of the Indians, it turns out what happens.
But in the end, the Indians are ahead, will slowly learn.

[2s1122]

Well, why is it careless, everything in the further process of work will be brought to mind. Last year, too, it seemed like a machine gun, it fell, it didn’t fly, then the satellites went to the ground with cancer. Even the Lord made a woman for the second time.

[Vladimir 1964]

Quote: 2s1122

Well, why is careless

Dear Mikhail, if only because the number of incidents with military equipment not related to the conduct of hostilities, the Indians occupy one of the leading positions.

Data of the magazine "International Defense" for the last year.

Something like this.

[2s1122]

If the Indians are lame in the technical part, along with the scientific one, that is the same thing. This does not say that they are bad masters, everything has its time. And I agree with the losses, SU in the Indian harvest fall like apples.

[AlexTires]

I confirm, Washington is still intact !!!!
Judging by how Indians behave in the arms market, it’s time for the domestic manufacturer to start acting up

[IAlex]

Interestingly, and after such a start, the tires on the platform will not melt?

[Boa kaa]

Quote: IAlex

Interestingly, and after such a start, the tires on the platform will not melt?

So make a mortar start! Or PAD for them, too, the secret behind seven locks?
Judging by the fact that the KR left the trajectory at the 12th minute, then all the "cockroaches are sitting in the head" ... The avionics of the KR is clearly "not in the star, nor in the Red Army!"
Maybe the element base from the hunfuz? or is the assembly technology melee to the point of insanity? Then - fuck you guess! It's like with our "Bulava", at the initial stage of testing ...

[ssn18]

"So make a mortar launch! Or is PAD a secret behind seven locks for them too?"

Well, if you are familiar with the mortar launch, then you probably know that the problem of the PAD is far from the only one. There is still the problem of the pallet, slip motors and cable tether.

[lelikas]

So packs like copy-paste their amers?

[Professor]

Quote: lelikas

So packs like copy-paste their amers?

And there is. They reverse engineered missiles that did not reach Afghanistan.

[lopvlad]

“As a supplement to the joint Russian-Indian supersonic missile BrahMos

again tried to apply the principles of one rocket while creating another. Lamers.

[Amurets]

Our first missiles didn’t want to fly either, but then La-350 flew beautifully. And the missile flew only after the 7th launch. The R-7 missile closed the Bure road to the conveyor

[Alexander 3]

As I understand it, this is my own development. It’s difficult to learn, easy to fight. Not yet, you need to chew.

[VNP1958PVN]

Torment and buy in Russia-what will sell

[Vitaly Anisimov]

Quote: VNP1958PVN

Torment and buy in Russia-what will sell

We offer them .. Everything would be clear ... But they themselves want, they bought up all kinds of garbage and start! .. Naive ...

[Mountain shooter]

Long-range "lionfish" can not be bought. The contract gets in the way. So they will suffer themselves, until the result. Corruption in them, in the defense industry, even mattress makers never dreamed of. If they win, there will be a sense, if not - cuckoo.

[svd-xnumx]

You cannot buy a long-range "lionfish". The contract gets in the way.

And help in creating missiles with a launch range of over 300 km

It's okay, brahmos is already flying. Now our guys will be removed from the brahmos and they will bring this rocket to mind.

also falls under non-proliferation.

[kil 31]

Quote: svd-xnumx

You cannot buy a long-range "lionfish". The contract gets in the way.

And help in creating missiles with a launch range of over 300 km

It's okay, brahmos is already flying. Now our guys will be removed from the brahmos and they will bring this rocket to mind.

also falls under non-proliferation.

Our about brahmos there for a long time. They have many local students who can turn to them with a question. And you can go into cases of need for them to production without a pale. It’s already sunbathed for a long time and probably in Hindi they’re no worse than locals.

[Amurets]

And what prevents to sell the Storm, Buran. The missiles are old, which Khrushchev blocked the road to the conveyor. They are not listed in any contracts, but they can help solve many problems and discrepancies. There will be a glider and spent engines. And the control system, on a modern element base , bring already easier.

[Boa kaa]

Quote: Amurets

There will be a glider and spent engines. And the control system, on a modern element base, is already easier to bring.

Do not smack nonsense! It hurts! (with)

About the glider. Storm - diameter 2,2m; Hindu - “Nirbhai” - 0,52m !!!
Engines. I believe that what stood on the Bure (the foremost in the 60s of the 20th century!) Today will take its rightful place ... only in the museum of the history of rocket propulsion engineering!
Control system. We'll beat analog toys into numbers, like "swords into plowshares," so what?
And to understand all ... the flawedness that you have proposed, I will cite photo of our strategic monster La-350! (D = 7500km, V = 3,5M; Vigorous megaton class head). The real horror of our partners today because of the puddle! But there was not enough money for everything, and preference was given to the royal R-7 ...

[iliitchitch]

The racket got lost. It happens . Ah, Indians, Indians, allies ... And why do our missiles hit the target? The drunken ensigns of the Russian Army, the dumbfounded sergeants, the dead lieutenants, and our planes are cardboard and rusty ... Fear of the unfortunate, but organons got confused. Compassion for woodpeckers ...

[pts-m]

well, there are failures, but the white stripes are wider than the black stripes. And maybe someone with a horoscope was mistaken, although it is possible that levitation let us down.

[iliitchitch]

The chief forgot to say gee. You’ll come to us, you won’t go anywhere, kids, yo.

[Gunther]

... and collapsed into the Bay of Bengal ...

Sadness, however.
But it could have fallen on the Blue Ridge or George Washington from the US 7th fleet :-(
Where are they by the way now?
For example: "Roosevelt" on the 13th completed its 6-month b / s in the Middle East and left the zone of the 5th fleet (the Strait of Hormuz passed on the 9th), on the 14th it arrived to the shores of India to participate in the Malabar exercises (starting on the 19th) ©

[qwert555]

Aviation designers have an expression - "if the plane is beautiful, it will fly." I looked at the photo, it will not fly.

[glavnykarapuz]

I think the garland on the rocket interfered with the flight. and the incense sticks were probably superfluous.

[barik92090]

Quote: 2s1122

Even God made a woman the second time.

Indulged animals not understood by him for the needs of Adam. Further, it was cooler. A igil appeared, who, for each, needed 72 pieces.

[beard64]

...
- Indians - learn to fly ..
/ without banter /

[2s1122]

Quote: AlexTires

I confirm, Washington is still intact !!!!
Judging by how Indians behave in the arms market, it’s time for the domestic manufacturer to start acting up

Regarding Washington, it's about an article in the political survey on earthquake

[exalex2]

Regular and unsuccessful .. This is how to understand? Like all my life, flew past the cottage .. Anything happens, it happens that and so

[Vitaly Anisimov]

Vysotsky sings about everything ...))))

[Old26]

They have an unhealthy desire to do everything on their territory.

A completely healthy desire of the country to enter the group of leaders. And do not buy everything from everyone, but do it yourself so that they buy yours

Bramos is just an Onyx rocket whose technology was simply passed on to the Indians. This is the only time they have succeeded.

Far from the only one. Although co-development has given India new technology. They get pretty good both BR and, in principle, LVs, although India still doesn’t reach the leading countries in this respect

And how they do it themselves is evidenced by the accidents with their Su-30MKI. Assembled by playful Indian pens from our machine kits. What they don’t find there after the accidents: chips in oil and stratification of composites. Why the French and Rafals on products made in India refused to give a guarantee ...

There is nothing supernatural in this. There is a formation of the military industry of India. And as for the shavings - in our 70s, tow was found in missile pipelines ...

Nor can it reach the specified characteristics after 14 years of development ...

And with us, everything works out even 14 after the start of development? Remind "Angara"? or how was the Bulava going?

Quote: exalex2

Regular and unsuccessful .. This is how to understand? Like all my life, flew past the cottage .. Anything happens, it happens that and so

The tests, by the way, are second. During the first flew almost 1000 km. The laser gyro is out of order ... So what? The problem is fixed ...

Aviation designers have an expression - "if the plane is beautiful, it will fly." I looked at the photo, it will not fly.

Well you just luminary from aviation. Even Tupolev, looking at the photo of this could not.

The scheme of their CR repeats the scheme of our Grenade / Caliber, Ukrainian KiteAmerican TomahawkChinese DH-10. And nothing all flew. And then you looked with your perspicacious gaze and said - DO NOT FLY

[s.melioxin]

... another test launch of the Indian Nirbhay rocket failed

Oh, how many wonderful discoveries to us
Prepare an enlightened spirit,
And the experience of the son of errors difficult,
And genius, the paradoxes friend
The main rule of mathematics: if it is solved easily, then you decide incorrectly. The torment of creativity.

[Urri]

Quote: s.melioxin

And the experience of the son of errors difficult,

Professor Pleischner was thrown out of the window for the sixth time in a row. The poison didn't work ...

[yan 2015]

zh tov Indians .. on this money it would be better to make one good Indian film with a happy ending. Well, or in a joint venture with the Russian Federation. and helpful and nice.

[yan 2015]

India became the first country to purchase the Klub strike missile system. They were installed on frigates and submarines of the Indian Navy, which were built in Russia.

from good .. do not look for good. so to speak.

[vovanpain]

Moscow, too, was not built immediately, and we also had problems with the Mace and the Hangar, they will bring it to mind.

[Zaurbek]

There was still an atomic Indian submarine. Terrible thing.

[tatarin_ru]

Successful launches will be at this pace, the main thing is not to suspend work.
India, too, is swaying for global influence. It has its own ambitions, and for this it is necessary first of all to ensure sovereignty, and this is a weapon, so we are waiting ..

[Lunic]

Quote: Old26

They have an unhealthy desire to do everything on their territory.

A completely healthy desire of the country to enter the group of leaders. And do not buy everything from everyone, but do it yourself so that they buy yours

Bramos is just an Onyx rocket whose technology was simply passed on to the Indians. This is the only time they have succeeded.

Far from the only one. Although co-development has given India new technology. They get pretty good and BR, and, in principle, and LV, although yes the leading countries in this regard, India is still not enough ....

Grouchy You are Old, But the truth is yours!

[bos83bos]

If something goes wrong for a long time!

[voyaka uh]

This is how it looks: a ton of weight, 6 m long, 0,52 m diameter.
Bramos, by comparison, weighs 3 tons.

[Old26]

Quote: voyaka uh

This is how it looks: a ton of weight, 6 m length, 0,52 m diameter. Brahmos, for comparison, weighs 3 tons.

Same Tomahawk - side view