Military Review

To Russia - with love

101
To Russia - with love



Why is the government afraid to develop their own country?

RBC holding experts have prepared beautiful statistics on the places of registration of the largest Russian companies. The results are both predictable and monstrous.

It is not difficult to guess in which region 296 from 500 of the largest (by revenue) Russian companies is registered. We add that these Moscow enterprises have 78,5% of the total revenue of participants in the RBC 500 rating ... And a significant part of the taxes on this money remains in the capital.

For comparison: in the American Fortune 500 list, the most companies are registered in the state of New York, but this is only 48, less than 10%.

And it is this fact that determines the key difference between the Russian Federation and the United States, which is much more serious than all the chatter about political systems and global interests. Russia is historically centripetal, America is centrifugal. We gathered around Moscow and in the name of Moscow, the Americans did not go to the frontier for the sake of Washington or New York. But from this distinction of communal and individualistic creation, quite concrete economic consequences follow.

Freeze entropy


But first, a retreat about politics. The political system of the Earth, like the whole Universe we observe, is at the stage of expansion: separatism obviously dominates over unity. Over the past decade alone, several new, fully or partially recognized states have appeared on the world map, two Ukrainian regions, Catalonia, Scotland, Quebec, are seriously looking at the exit ... Under these conditions, Russia, the most multinational state in the world, simply has no other way to preserve unity territory, in addition to tight centralization, inevitably combined with elements of authoritarianism. When Konstantin Leontyev said that “Russia needs to be frozen”, he meant precisely the struggle against entropy, which already today is taking possession of the world in an obvious way.

However, the inevitable imperial habit of subjecting economic expediency to political interests led to the centralization of not only politics, but also the economy. Moreover, two attempts at economic decentralization undertaken in the country after the war did not give good results.

Sold by Nikita Khrushchev, the administrative and economic reform of 1957 of the year replaced the sectoral leadership by the territorial one. If earlier a small textile factory in Ivanovo was ultimately subordinate to the Allied Ministry of Light Industry, then from that moment on - the Economic Council of the Ivanovo Region. Like any drastic reform, this resulted in a violation of the existing ties, and Khrushchev could not reverse the “verticality” that had become firmly established in Stalin's time, and the hierarchy of management thinking. A new round of centralization began when Nikita Sergeevich was in power. His undertaking cannot be called a complete failure, but it returned to the former mode of management with relief.

The second decentralization was spontaneous: at the end of the USSR and immediately after its collapse, in the midst of a severe economic crisis, regions unwittingly switched to semi-natural economic management, barter flourished, and economic separatism followed. The integrity of Russia was saved only because of the lack of own funds from the regions and the need to turn to the center for oil and gas money, which only kept the remnants of the economy afloat. Yeltsin’s generous slogan "Take sovereignty as much as you can" did not have the financial support and only for this reason it was not implemented.

The rest of the time, the political and economic systems are constantly centralized. The Russian Federation has long been no longer a federation in its essence: regional parties are actually (until recently and formally) banned from us, and the income of the subjects takes the center for itself and then redistributes it at its discretion. Unfortunately, we consistently pay for the consistent implementation of the ideas of centralization with severe distortions in the development of the regions and force the economic dying of parts of the country with our own hands, such as, for example, the Pskov region with its phenomenal governor, dozens of abandoned villages and a constantly decreasing population.

In this case, it cannot be said that we have never moved in the right direction. The development of virgin soil (from Stolypin to Brezhnev), Siberian construction projects, the great resettlement of Komsomol members are excellent examples of a rational attitude to their own country. The most important role in the development of the regions, primarily the Urals, was played by the Great Patriotic War: the factories that moved from the west of the country still have considerable significance for the local economy. But all this was carried out according to the same vertical scheme: the region will live and develop as they say in Moscow. Where, of course, far from always sensibly represent the real situation.

All roads - in the third Rome


The radially concentric layout of Moscow marks Russia: all roads lead to the center, the path between the neighboring border regions can be embarrassingly difficult (from East Biryulyovo to West - via the Moscow Ring Road or the Third Ring).

From the millionth city of Voronezh in the far west of Russia, direct regular flights can only fly to Moscow, St. Petersburg and Sochi. From the million-plus city of San Jose in the far west of the United States, direct regular flights can fly to more than 30 cities in the country.

From the largest city of the Lower Volga region, Volgograd, it is easy to get to Moscow by train (900 km), but there is no direct road (neither automobile nor iron) to the Black Earth Region of Voronezh (500 km).

With what hatred did Russia have to be equipped, that after, for example, the terrorist attacks in the same Volgograd, it was necessary to allocate a special board to transport the injured to Moscow? And we know that the same thing would have to be done at any other point of the Russian Federation, with the careful exception of St. Petersburg. We do not have regional medicine, there is little regional education.


An ambulance car at the Emergencies Ministry plane at the Volgograd airport during the transportation of seriously wounded people after an explosion in a LiAZ passenger bus. Photo: Dmitry Rogulin / TASS

We are investing in the construction of the Moscow-Kazan high-speed railway, and from Kazan to the neighboring regional center of Ulyanovsk there is a single-track non-electrified branch.

We no longer build cities near mineral deposits. Once, the Urals giants Chelyabinsk and Yekaterinburg appeared exactly this way, but now nobody perceives a place of work and earnings as a permanent place of residence.

The saying “Where he was born, it was useful there” sounds like an absolute anachronism: hundreds of thousands of people cross 100 – 150 km at one end every day to work in any prestigious place. This is completely meaningless loss of funds and man-hours, which hardly anyone will take to calculate.

New development of the Pskov region


There is not and cannot be a truly united Russia without permanent close ties between neighboring regions, and equal relations, and not like in Yasnogorsk, Tula region, from which hundreds of adults go to Moscow every day or every week - 150 km one way. Such a “unity”, in which Moscow is the only center of gravity on 17 million km2, does not need Russia or Moscow itself.


Suburban train at rush hour. Photo: Pavel Smertin / TASS

Unfortunately, the designated problem has such deep roots, so serious traditions, it has become so familiar with the mentality that it must be solved gradually and delicately. The simple guys from the Ministry of Economic Development, apparently, derived a simple formula: “Business cannot develop in a poor region, because there is no effective demand, and demand cannot appear, since there are no jobs with adequate pay,” which means that nothing can be done and you need to quietly build stadiums for the World Cup.

Meanwhile, the development of regions exist, but require state planning. We now have no resources for the next development of Siberia? Well, let's learn, for example, the same Pskov region: we will build there roads (not pathetic highways, but narrow, but high-quality routes of regional significance), carry gas to the surviving settlements, place a small part of the state defense order at enterprises, in the end, for this and built people who were certainly not smarter than us.

Of course, there must be a response, a reciprocal movement from the outskirts to the center. Velikoluksky meat-packing plant is known throughout Russia, the enterprise works perfectly, but it is the only trade brand in the region. We need new ones - either in the same food industry or in other areas, for example, in tourism. The region is the only subject of the Russian Federation that has a border with three states at once. Consequently, this is a great place for eco-and ethno-tourism, and here everything again rests on the infrastructure. Roads and gas, if carried out without embezzlement, are inexpensive and pay for themselves quickly. Now more than half of the tourists in the Pskov region are residents of St. Petersburg and its environs, and yet the potential of the region is much wider.

This is just one example. Each region has its own potential, but the development of this potential is not a large-scale national project, but a point investment of small money with a medium-term payback. It seems that this is why such things are of little interest to the federal government.

From Moscow to Russia


Returning to the beginning of the article, we emphasize that the government has one more task: the economic squeezing of a large but not focused on the capital business from Moscow. There is nothing impossible here - Gazprom has moved to St. Petersburg and is doing well. What the Russian Railways is doing in the capital, for example, is clear: it “milks” the stations, but, really, such an organization would be more decent to be in the geographical center of the country. The metallurgical giant Evraz or the raw material Norilsk Nickel have no relation to Moscow at all. MTS and X5 Retail Group are operating throughout Russia and could well be located in other major cities. You can, of course, regret the staff of the head offices of these companies, who would have had to leave the capital, but their appearance in Novosibirsk or Omsk would have provided serious assistance to the relevant areas.

Much of what has been said sounds like a utopia. But without the realization of this utopia, we will not achieve anything. The nuclear bomb and the well-being of the people are much more convincing than just a nuclear bomb. From the development of the regions there will be no damage to political centralization and autocracy.

Moscow is the heart of Russia, but obesity has been diagnosed in this heart, and at least a diet is shown to it. The prosperity of Russia is the prosperity of every corner of it. If we want to have a loud and respected voice by the entire planet, we need to become an example of prudent and conscientious business ourselves. Brilliant Moscow, St. Petersburg and Kazan can not forever close the ghost 23 thousands of populated areas disappeared from 1990.

Real import substitution should take place not on the shelves, but in the minds of people, and first of all, people making important decisions for the country.
Author:
Originator:
http://rusplt.ru/society/v-rossiyu--s-lyubovyu-19026.html
101 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. smith7
    smith7 1 October 2015 05: 54 New
    +5
    Historically, "Moscow princes - collectors of land." It is very deep in us ... The economic feasibility for the common people, the argument is not explicit and not convincing. Another thing is if the production of any company in the region, then taxes to the region, despite the Moscow accreditation. This is understandable and fair at the same time, which will support the development of the country.
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 1 October 2015 07: 09 New
      48
      Quote: smith7
      It is very deep in us ..


      It’s not in us, it’s in power ... the desire to build EVERYTHING for oneself: the chambers are the largest and white-stone, there are more than 1000 cathedrals in all. and it’s necessary from head to toe in gold, slaves and servants to make it unmeasured at all. This is foul swagger to seem prosperous and not to be him, it’s a brilliant capital in a necklace of villages with rotten roofs, these are “contemporary-style” crafts in the style of Potemkin villages ( Skolkovo). This is a great-power nonsense with the cost of tens of billions of rubles for the useless HSR of the M-va - Kazan, so that the Kazan Khanate could say, "We are sitting at the same table with the princes of Moscow" with health care, education and social programs falling into failure.
      It has long been said, back in the Union, that the head office should be where the product or service is produced, but this sound principle devours M-va, growing like a cancerous tumor in Russia and absorbing only half of the taxes that could be collected in Russia, But in order to eliminate this bias, it would be enough to take a tax of "5% on capital" - and the nonsense would immediately end!
      ...Feast in Time of Plague...
      1. Vladimir 1964
        Vladimir 1964 1 October 2015 09: 36 New
        +4
        Quote: hydrox
        It’s not in us, it’s in power ... the desire to build EVERYTHING for oneself: the chambers are the largest and white-stone, there are more than 1000 cathedrals in all. and it’s necessary from head to toe in gold, slaves and servants to make it unmeasured at all. This is foul swagger to seem prosperous and not to be him, it’s a brilliant capital in a necklace of villages with rotten roofs, these are “contemporary-style” crafts in the style of Potemkin villages ( Skolkovo). This is a great-power nonsense with the cost of tens of billions of rubles for the useless HSR of the M-va - Kazan, so that the Kazan Khanate could say, "We are sitting at the same table with the princes of Moscow" with health care, education and social programs falling into failure.


        But a very good comment, Dear hydrox.

        something like this. hi
        1. Azitral
          Azitral 1 October 2015 12: 55 New
          +9
          Please, please - do not exaggerate about rotten roofs. I myself come from Voronezh, and generally live for a long time. I do not belong to cheers-patriots, but ... do not call too much. After a vacation in Adler, in 2011 I was traveling from Voronezh to Zadonsk (by the way - a city like a toy) and suddenly caught myself thinking that the landscape outside the window without the usual filth in life. As far back as 1964, I found sheds under thatched roofs - this is along the Zadonskoye highway (absorbed by the federal highway "Moscow - South of Russia")! What was away from the eyes ?! The Black Earth region has become much, much more attractive, stronger, calmer.
      2. antoXa
        antoXa 1 October 2015 10: 29 New
        11
        hidrokh
        I partially agree with the article that it is absolutely necessary to develop regions.
        But immediately I want to say that the example with the FSA is completely incorrect
        "For comparison: Fortune 500 has the most companies in New York State on the US list, but it's only 48, less than 10%."
        Before making such a comparison, it is necessary to study the tax systems of the two countries, and for the sake of objectivity, write that the tax policy in the ASP is developed and fixed at the state level, naturally unofficially, but I am sure that it is subject to strict coordination (decree) from above.
        For example, take an interest in what the state of Delaware is with a population of about 700 tons, but in which the largest corporations and banks in the world are registered. The state clearly has all the signs of an offshore. This is the state in the FSA ...
        Here gentlemen need to decide whether we are offshore or not, America had no choice, otherwise corporations would register in offshore companies outside the country.
        Do we need this ??? Well, this is a question ...
        In my opinion, the centralization of money around Moscow does not depend on any mentality, but is due to the convenience of resolving issues and conducting large business, just like most corporations have headquarters in New York and management is there, but they are registered and pay taxes in others states.
        I agree that the state needs to slightly change the pyramidal system of budget revenues and expenses, but to write nonsense hydrox about the “white stone” I don’t understand the economic essence of the problem - it's just plain ugly! for this I put you a minus!
        1. avg
          avg 1 October 2015 18: 10 New
          +1
          antoXa
          I fully support you. Regions need to be developed, it is simply necessary, but it is precisely by regions, clusters, otherwise there aren’t enough funds, Russia is very large. And you won’t order business to go to Uryupinsk. There are global centers of capital attraction, and Moscow is only trying to become one of them.
          I also agree with Azitral, "... that the landscape outside the window (becomes) without the usual filthiness that has been habitual in life". It’s worth at least to look at the results of the annual “Competition for the best city of Russia”, and even better to visit these cities, you will be tired of wondering. I agree that more taxes should be left in local budgets, but then, with our share in the global economy, we need to forget about the second army in the world, about space, and much more. And if, as called by "hydrox" to take a special tax "on capital", then you will have to collect it somewhere in the Isle of Man.
          1. Scraptor
            Scraptor 1 October 2015 18: 51 New
            -1
            With the help of taxation you are very much ordered, And how can Maine be better than Cyprus or the warm settled places in Segezha and near Krasnokamensk? belay
            1. antoXa
              antoXa 2 October 2015 11: 05 New
              -1
              Scraptor
              Are you talking about?
      3. vladimirZ
        vladimirZ 1 October 2015 12: 01 New
        +5
        Meanwhile, regional development paths exist, but require state planning. We now have no resources for the next development of Siberia ...
        - from an article by Mikhail Melnikov

        Well, what does Russia not have? Will be in China, Japan, USA. Who else is in line for Siberian wealth?
        Albright said that Siberia is the world's pantry and should not belong to Russia?
        Yes, with such liberal rulers as Dima Medvedev & Co., all declaring that "Russia will adhere to a liberal development path," "we will not have a state (read their "shovel") planning, "they will come to Russia as part of the Moscow Principality.
      4. Cherdak
        Cherdak 1 October 2015 12: 53 New
        +4
        Quote: hydrox
        these are “contemporary” crafts in the style of Potemkin villages (Skolkovo)

        The Potemkin villages are a historical myth about fake villages ... the authorship of the legend is attributed to Saxon diplomat Georg Gelbig.

        Quote: hydrox
        It’s a meager swagger to seem prosperous, and not to be it, it’s a brilliant capital in the necklace of villages with rotten roofs,

        Have you ever wondered why? Do you even imagine the change in the population of the Russian state, let’s say so from the XNUMXth century and its structure?

        Quote: hydrox
        But in order to eliminate this bias, it would be enough to take a tax of "5% on capital" - and the nonsense would immediately end!


        Have you tried the dust?
      5. Andrey NM
        Andrey NM 1 October 2015 17: 27 New
        +5
        It's simple - you need to pay taxes at the location of production facilities or fixed assets. Then the people in such a city as Norilsk will simply break into the richest city.
        1. Vadim237
          Vadim237 1 October 2015 18: 47 New
          0
          That’s why they don’t really like to pay taxes in Russia.
          1. Scraptor
            Scraptor 1 October 2015 19: 02 New
            +1
            The people have every right to relate to the tax system of the state as they relate to it.
            1. Vadim237
              Vadim237 2 October 2015 09: 57 New
              0
              If you don’t pay taxes, then the budget will not be replenished, and if it is not replenished, then there will definitely not be any increase in salaries, pensions, benefits, and general economic development, taxes must be paid wherever you are.
              1. Scraptor
                Scraptor 2 October 2015 10: 00 New
                0
                1. The budget is replenished not only with taxes, 2. the problem is wider.
      6. Asadullah
        Asadullah 1 October 2015 17: 44 New
        -1
        Feast in Time of Plague


        Where did you see the plague? I remember, about twenty years ago, an elderly Jew at a restaurant at a table, threw a tipsy aunt, you muss about salt, and ask for bread. What is true in relation to these groans about the past and attempts to degenerate modern Russia into a hermaphrodite of the past and future. Everything falls, everything collapses, something needs to be done, scream half-mixed during breaks watching the Olympics, wars online and applauding across the Crimea.

        From the millionth city of Voronezh in the far west of Russia, direct regular flights can only fly to Moscow, St. Petersburg and Sochi. From the million-plus city of San Jose in the far west of the United States, direct regular flights can fly to more than 30 cities in the country.


        What is it? In the US, has the government ordered San Jose business firms to fly to 30 cities? There would be such a stream of passengers from Voronezh, and would fly to 50 cities. This is the very law of the market against which sympathizers are trying to fight with examples from the very center of capitalism.

        If previously a small textile factory in Ivanovo was ultimately subordinate to the Union Ministry of Light Industry, then from that moment on to the economic council of the Ivanovo region


        So what? Thousands of idiotic decisions and hundreds of methods of how to do everything through the ass can be pulled out of the past. How does this apply to today? Subordinate all private seamstresses to one ministry? The author replaces one absurdity with another. Shaken in one glass of kerosene with milk and offer to enjoy a drink. I do not give a damn about the minuses, but thank you all so much for not deciding anything, that you cannot put your schizophrenic projects into practice, and experiment with the people again. I bow to you. that you voice your legions of thoughts in order to shudder to those who have an imagination in the ability to simulate what will happen in this case. We will somehow calmly, by trial and error, carefully build the country.
        1. Scraptor
          Scraptor 1 October 2015 18: 35 New
          +4
          Quote: Asadullah
          Where did you see the plague? ...

          Quote: Asadullah
          There would be such a stream of passengers from Voronezh, and would fly to 50 cities.

          And why is there such a passenger flow from San Jose, but not from Voronezh?
          When oil rises in price - gas rises in price, and oil rises in price - all the same, gas rises in price, then there is no market, forget it!

          How do you see the construction of a country in such conditions?
          1. aksakal
            aksakal 1 October 2015 22: 02 New
            +3
            Quote: Scraptor
            And why is there such a passenger flow from San Jose, but not from Voronezh?
            When oil rises in price - gas rises in price, and oil rises in price - all the same, gas rises in price, then there is no market, forget it!

            How do you see the construction of a country in such conditions?
            - I liked the subject in general, but there are inaccuracies. For example, hypercentralization in the USSR is clearly far-fetched. Just in the USSR it was very skillful, well, among the population, at least, more precisely, the incomes of this population, the whole thing was decentralized. I mean, when an Uzbek in his remote village or a Dagestan in the mountains, having grown crops and went to Russia to sell his raisins, dried apricots or pomegranates with oranges, they lived better than a Muscovite lived in Moscow. This refers to the average farmer and the average Muscovite, which were the majority. And even in this situation Moscow got from those who wanted to come and live in it. But, you see, the same Uzbeks and Dagestanis were not eager to stay in Moscow - they sold the crop, bought Zhiguli and rather go home, it was better for him there. Now that there is no sensible work in the regions, the problem of hypercentralization has generally become more acute. A vicious circle in the regions - business does not go to the regions, motivating it with personnel shortages (you won’t even find an intelligent programmer in Uryupinsk, not to mention other specialists), and people in the region cannot acquire these professions until these professions are definitely sustainable first of all, because you don’t know what kind of professions a business needs for lack of one in a given region, and because risking such uncertainty also doesn’t need to study for five years - it turns out you didn’t study that way. Well, the more interesting the task for those in power is to break this circle. Well, firstly, specialists from Moscow, where they are often overabundant to the detriment of other regions, need to somehow (almost say "kick out") to lure from Moscow. It is easier to lure business - in Moscow you increase taxes, in the region you reduce. But still, you need to take a bunch of additional measures, otherwise the corporation will register in Uryupinsk, open an office for 5-10 people there and call it the “head office”, and the “biggest boss” will sit in the “branch” in Moscow. which used to be the head one, with all its servants, but at the same time pay less taxes. Sochi won before the Olympics, how it grew, how the oligarchs were eager to invest money there)))). And now they’ve lost interest))). In general, the question is complex. One cannot dismiss such a psychological moment - in our countries the problem of hunger is not worth it, thank God. The problem of people is different - they do not have the opportunity to SELF-REALIZE! Such an opportunity exists only in the five largest cities of Russia, I will not name them, you yourself know them. It is necessary to make sure that people can fulfill themselves where they live! And here, of course, the question of the development of transport infrastructure is very acute. Say a talented guy Azamat lives in some kind of Kamyzyak, it would be quite affordable for flights and more flights from Kamyzyak - he would not need to leave for Moscow. What for? Have you been invited to the shooting? He took it and flew. They called in ches? Also not a question. In general, something like that ...
            1. Scraptor
              Scraptor 2 October 2015 10: 26 New
              0
              A qualified staff is needed (unless it is a programmer). This is the topic of single-industry towns.
              If there is a head office in Uryupinsk, then there’s nothing to worry about, such an “offshore is the other way around”.
              If the company is a programmer, then there is absolutely nothing to worry about, since the work is being adjusted and its results are sent over the Internet. At the same time, specialists and their leadership can be scattered away from headquarters around the globe, not like throughout Russia. Programming learns in months, not years. In the West, this is not considered a higher education.
              1. aksakal
                aksakal 5 October 2015 23: 54 New
                0
                Quote: Scraptor
                A qualified staff is needed (unless it is a programmer). This is the topic of single-industry towns.
                If there will be a head office in Uryupinsk, then there’s nothing to worry about, such an “offshore vice versa”

                - I didn’t detail, I generally said ... In any head office of a large corporation, such a complex information system, because called IT, which already in Moscow is difficult to find a competent (in the sense, professional enough for this corporation and its IT-system) "ITISHNEGA". I am silent on the move of this office to Uryupinsk! And this is only one of the problems, and there are a lot of others!
                1. Scraptor
                  Scraptor 6 October 2015 00: 34 New
                  0
                  If work with remote access is correctly organized, then there will be no problems at least where.
                  In Moscow and other megacities, large corporations usually look for several IT people (each is a specialist in their field).
    2. pv1005
      pv1005 1 October 2015 07: 15 New
      +3
      Quote: smith7
      Another thing is if the production of any company in the region, then taxes to the region 'in spite of Moscow accreditation. This is understandable and fair at the same time, which will help support the development of the country.

      If this is done, then Moscow will become a subsidized subject, i.e. will live like all of Russia. But who will let you do this?
      1. Beaver
        Beaver 1 October 2015 10: 01 New
        +5
        We had one governor who allowed the districts to keep part of the taxes to be transferred to the regional budget. Almost all areas ceased to be subsidized. In the next election, this governor was defeated.
        True, under the new governor there were no subsidized districts - instead of the word "subsidy" the word "subvention" began to be used. Well, in the sense, the districts have become "subventional."
      2. SmileSimple
        SmileSimple 1 October 2015 11: 50 New
        +4
        However, to be exact ... for more than 10 years
        according to the law, despite the fact that the head office of the company in Moscow ... taxes are paid in all branches in accordance with the size of the turnover!
        Therefore, if the plant is in Lipetsk, and the office is in Moscow, then most of the taxes are paid and remain in Lipetsk. hi

        please see "Tax Code of the Russian Federation (branches)"
        1. APS
          APS 1 October 2015 13: 54 New
          +2
          This is the case if the branches are registered in other cities, and if not, and the TIN of the organization starts at 77 taxes go to Moscow ...
      3. The comment was deleted.
    3. Scraptor
      Scraptor 1 October 2015 10: 32 New
      -1
      And in fact, now Moscow is a growth on the body of Russia which sucks it and does not allow it to live. In order to understand this, you just need to travel around the country.
      1. Reserve officer
        Reserve officer 1 October 2015 11: 18 New
        14
        Well, again, the whole world attacked Moscow. Just give a reason.
        And the problem of Moscow is different - any real business and any real production is squeezed out of it, if all this is not connected with the personal interests of the city leadership, their friends and relatives.
        What was the hallmark of Moscow in 70-80? ZIL, AZLK, universities, industrial defense institutes and industries. And now? Office skyscrapers, a cloud of flashing lights on the roads, one-day firms, the dominance of the population from Central Asia.
        People who want and know how to work, who have not yet lost their qualifications - either pay not salaries, but alms, or create impossible working conditions.
        The tax on retail space alone - and the mass of people somehow making ends meet - went broke. This tax is for Moscow and St. Petersburg.
        I myself had a serious production in Moscow. Metalwork. So this production had to be transferred three times from one area to another - production areas were liquidated, turning into office centers. Instead of workers, office plankton is required. Victims of the exam, even on the phone who can not talk.
        As a result, we left Moscow completely. One serious enterprise in the capital has become less. Highly skilled manufacturers were left without work - for the sixth decade, it is not so easy to leave the city where he lived all his life. They won’t go to the market — not the hardening of life, but will settle on normal production — there’s less chance.
        And there are thousands of such examples.
        1. Scraptor
          Scraptor 1 October 2015 11: 41 New
          -2
          You didn’t get anything. Moscow really strangles the province, not only Muscovites-producers - the whole country.
        2. dmb
          dmb 1 October 2015 14: 36 New
          +7
          The Romans have deduced the coined formula, look for whom it is beneficial. There is only one option - the current government. Revolutions take place in capitals. This is the power that squeezes the main organized force out of it, capable of fighting for its rights - the working class. The remaining shopkeepers, office plankton and bohemia are capable of only a riot. And not even a riot, but a rebellion that will never be supported by the people of Russia (see the attitude towards Muscovites in general and Navalny with Rynskaya in particular). Therefore, our dear power will continue to rob us.
          1. Basarev
            Basarev 1 October 2015 15: 02 New
            0
            In general, in a good way, all taxes should remain in the area. Not a penny in the regional center, and even more so Mosike. Then the districts will become surplus, which means the region. So - and sovereign budget will become surplus. And the regional centers and the capital will be cleared of freeloaders, thereby greatly reducing social tension and significantly moving forward in resolving the transport issue.
            1. Vadim237
              Vadim237 1 October 2015 18: 57 New
              0
              It is necessary to develop the region, what will cut the tax threads of Moscow and taxes will remain areas - this will not lead to any surplus in their budgets.
              1. Scraptor
                Scraptor 1 October 2015 19: 03 New
                0
                It is much easier to collect taxes at the place of production - everyone knows everyone. In order to make it more convenient to steal and sit on the streams, everything just goes through the thieves Maskwa.
          2. rosarioagro
            rosarioagro 1 October 2015 17: 30 New
            +2
            Quote: dmb
            The remaining shopkeepers, office plankton and bohemia are only capable of rebellion. And not even a riot, but a rebellion that will never be supported by the people of Russia

            Well, if you look at history, then all sorts of different upheavals there conceived faces close to the body, if we proceed from this. it turns out that power itself is building up a critical mass, a paradox, no?
            1. dmb
              dmb 1 October 2015 18: 18 New
              0
              I did not quite understand the meaning of your phrase in terms of citation. Revolt, coup and revolution are purely different things. The rebellion is not “in the name of”, but “against”, it is easily suppressed: either by insignificant concessions, or by repression (or a combination thereof). The coup does not change the essence of power but of its representatives. The revolution is changing not just power, but socio-economic relations. Therefore, I do not see any paradox in the actions of the authorities. The critical mass created in the capital is capable of rebellion, not revolution. And the rebellion of power is not terrible.
    4. The comment was deleted.
    5. siberalt
      siberalt 2 October 2015 08: 28 New
      +2
      They go to Moscow to earn money for 150 km. So Ukraine and Central Asia will be far away. And from there not millions of sony go. Because the earnings are incomparably higher for the same work than in the regions. In the USSR, it was not for nothing that they used climatic zones with an allowance for salaries and for the cost of products. Now the opposite is true, the farther from Moscow, the harder it is to live.
      1. Basarev
        Basarev 2 October 2015 19: 28 New
        +1
        According to the canon, the state should exist only at the expense of its foreign economic activity, and inside, all types of taxes and loan interest should be banned. And then the current state of affairs resembles a company who keeps afloat due to requisitions from employees. An absurd picture, right?
      2. The comment was deleted.
  2. venaya
    venaya 1 October 2015 05: 55 New
    +1
    Moscow, St. Petersburg and Kazan cannot forever hide the ghost of 23 thousand settlements that have disappeared since 1990.

    The development of the country's economy is directly related to the development of communications (transport). The development of transport should give a tangible leap in the development of industry, and this is our first priority.
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 1 October 2015 07: 11 New
      -5
      Please stop broadcasting the insinuations of the Russian Prospect, because you can take them for a fool ...
      1. venaya
        venaya 1 October 2015 07: 33 New
        +7
        Quote: hydrox
        Please stop broadcasting the nonsense of the Russian Prospect, ...

        Thank. We are discussing the "Glazyev’s program", then we are looking into a holey pocket .... And at the same time we don’t want at all where does that ringing come from. Apparently, the mood in the morning is strongly connected with which foot it turned out to get up with. Where did it go 23 settlements, and why roads are built only to the nearest airport? Well, why think about the sad, it's easier about what is ringing now. The fact that cities are inconceivably blacken, so no one wants to give birth. In the city this is not possible (well, no where else). And in the village? So there is already nobody there. There are no roads, and the youth scattered.
        Everyone wants everything at once and more. But where to get all this from? Here it is already necessary to think, and laziness to think. Sad
        1. Scraptor
          Scraptor 1 October 2015 14: 40 New
          +1
          Do you think this is not organized specially?
    2. GRAY
      GRAY 1 October 2015 08: 53 New
      +3
      Quote: venaya
      The development of the country's economy is directly related to the development of communications (transport). The development of transport should give a tangible leap in the development of industry, and this is our first priority.

      The regional leaders are very fond of investing in infrastructure projects, because it is safe - they built, let's say, a road and you can write off money for its repair.
      The beauty. And the budget is being developed and the pocket is still in the loser.
      Or you can build nothing at all - to support the old, still Soviet.
      And this business is muddy and incomprehensible to deal with the support of their regional business - they don’t need to.
      1. The comment was deleted.
    3. Andrey NM
      Andrey NM 1 October 2015 17: 46 New
      +5
      What is the development of transport? What are you talking about? Here is an example, road transport. First, a large amount of heavy equipment is sold in the country. It is certified, allowed to use, etc. Then they suddenly impose restrictions on mass, and for an advantage they come up with paid passes, etc. The price of them is growing all the time. And then why are taxes paid? On the roads, weight control posts suddenly began to appear, and the equipment that was previously allowed for operation in the country can not drive if it is loaded more than half. And for vehicles weighing more than 12,5 tons in a month, any trips will be paid at the rate of 3,25 rubles per kilometer. But no one has canceled the pass yet. And again the question: why do we pay taxes? And on paid sites double payment?
      And now there are trucks on the side of the road, and wait until the traffic police with the "weights" go to sleep.
      And you are talking about the development of transport ...
  3. Barboskin
    Barboskin 1 October 2015 05: 59 New
    17
    Moscow is the heart of Russia, but this heart is diagnosed with obesity and is shown at least a diet. The prosperity of Russia is the prosperity of every corner of it.

    Golden words, it’s time to return some of the money to the regions that earn them.
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 1 October 2015 07: 21 New
      +1
      Quote: Barboskin
      It’s time to return some of the money to the regions


      Yes, it’s not a part of the money to be returned, but to leave the bulk in the region, to give M-ve only the tax “for capitalism” - and everything is slowly normalizing
      1. GRAY
        GRAY 1 October 2015 08: 57 New
        +2
        Quote: hydrox
        Yes, not part of the money to return, but to leave the bulk in the region,

        It is interesting how much the watch collection will replenish after this and how many floors the mansions will have to be built to make money. fellow
      2. GRAY
        GRAY 1 October 2015 09: 16 New
        +2
        Quote: hydrox
        Yes, it’s not a part of the money to be returned, but to leave the bulk in the region, to give M-ve only the tax “for capitalism” - and everything is slowly normalizing

        This is stupidity.
        What will you do with subsidized regions? This is exactly where it "normalizes." Since the federal center has no money, then there is nothing to distribute.
        Then it remains only to break into the principalities then precisely all the money on the ground will remain.
        1. max702
          max702 1 October 2015 09: 59 New
          0
          Quote: GRAY
          What will you do with subsidized regions?

          With the current policy of the center, whoever he likes will become subsidized ..
          1. GRAY
            GRAY 1 October 2015 10: 52 New
            +1
            Quote: max702
            With the current policy of the center, whoever he likes will become subsidized ..


            There is one list and it does not change (unless Crimea has been added).

            As of 2014, Moscow and the Moscow region, St. Petersburg and the Leningrad region, the Republic of Tatarstan, the Samara region, the Tyumen region with autonomous okrugs (Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug and Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug) and Sakhalin Oblast are considered as donors.

            Clickable
        2. antoXa
          antoXa 1 October 2015 11: 09 New
          +7
          GRAY
          I agree with you, the person writes, who simply does not quite understand how the country's budget system is organized. He does not understand that if you follow this scenario, and there is such in some European countries, for example, you can forget about the military-industrial complex and the army, or that each region will independently finance military programs ??? About space, about the development of the Arctic, or let the regional government finance them?)))))))
          People (hydrox) government structure is a very complicated matter, please do not make fun of your stupid things! From what you describe here with two catchy (revolutionary) phrases the current domestic policy of our state, you are the only thing that will show is that your level of understanding is like that of a revolutionary sailor of 1917 ...
    2. afdjhbn67
      afdjhbn67 1 October 2015 08: 44 New
      +3
      They will be stolen there even faster than in Moscow ..
      1. Azitral
        Azitral 1 October 2015 13: 04 New
        +2
        Fact. Either the prince’s eye, or real democracy. Otherwise, it will be stolen together with the cash desk lining.
  4. Gray 43
    Gray 43 1 October 2015 05: 59 New
    +5
    There is a good saying that reflects the meaning of the article: “Do not lay all your eggs in one basket”, but in our country it’s all folded. With modern means of communication, the location of the head office of any company does not matter, for example, the Ministry of Agriculture can be placed closer to the fields, it was also possible to move the main fisherman somewhere in the people of Vladivostok, where the fish are harvested. Automobile assembly plants can also be located throughout the country, and not just around Moscow, St. Petersburg, Kaluga
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 1 October 2015 07: 23 New
      -1
      Not possible, but NECESSARY and necessary, but compradors and top management like to live "capitally" ...
    2. GRAY
      GRAY 1 October 2015 09: 10 New
      0
      Quote: Gray 43
      the location of the head office of any company does not matter

      And it has a legal address.
      I don’t understand how you imagine it. Suppose I am the owner of a Moscow company - I acquired a factory in the Omsk region.
      And what do you command me to do? Move there or what? And how do you make me?
      Since the company is registered in Moscow, then I must pay taxes in Moscow.
    3. antoXa
      antoXa 1 October 2015 11: 15 New
      0
      Gray 43
      Yes, and each minister to buy a private jet that would fly 5 times a day there back to the meetings to DAM or GDP ...
      1. Scraptor
        Scraptor 1 October 2015 11: 37 New
        0
        Skype already canceled? fellow
        1. antoXa
          antoXa 1 October 2015 13: 06 New
          +3
          Scraptor
          And you ask Snowden this ...
          God (((make the most important decisions for the country on skype ... I'm with you h..yu
          1. Scraptor
            Scraptor 1 October 2015 13: 14 New
            -1
            And what about the military with this? love
  5. Reptiloid
    Reptiloid 1 October 2015 06: 00 New
    +3
    Once there was a TV broadcast about the life of the Indians on the reservation — there is no medicine, schools, roads. The state does not build, they themselves do not have the funds. I love my homeland, I was born in Leningrad. I lived in the Far East as a child. I often think - how do people live in the distance now? The TV can lie.
    1. 3 Gorynych
      3 Gorynych 1 October 2015 06: 07 New
      +6
      We live normally, but I would like better!
  6. 3 Gorynych
    3 Gorynych 1 October 2015 06: 06 New
    +8
    Do not forget that RBC is liberals, firstly, and secondly, the lion's share of companies ended up in Muscovy for one simple reason (the author did not say)! -Money and mafia center is Muscovy! and practically many successful companies in Russia are being bought up (or squeezed out) by the Moscow “business.” therefore they are there ... All the swindlers there ...
    1. EvgNik
      EvgNik 1 October 2015 07: 49 New
      +3
      Quote: 3
      Do not forget that RBC are liberals

      This is so, and we remember this. But sometimes they have sound thoughts.
    2. antoXa
      antoXa 1 October 2015 13: 09 New
      +1
      3 Gorynych
      I agree))) with you, but for the sake of objectivity, it should be noted that most of these "swindlers" are not from Moscow, but were born in other parts of our beautiful homeland and have already moved to Moscow for a number of reasons, or rather for one! It’s more convenient for them to go about their business in Moscow !!!
  7. EvgNik
    EvgNik 1 October 2015 06: 07 New
    15
    "" Moscow is the heart of Russia, but this heart is diagnosed with obesity, and he is shown at least a diet ""
    Article +, and under this I subscribe to all 100. They organized the state in the state, and do not care about the regions from the height of the Kremlin tower. And spit. The same in the regions - the regional city lives on the principle of Moscow. And spits on the areas. A bad example is contagious.
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 1 October 2015 07: 28 New
      -1
      Spit out, Eug. Nick.!
      We don’t have enough saliva to spit Moscow’s power, and the Muscovites will die, but they won’t give it to the regions. They don’t understand, hell, that thereby create separatism and hatred of M-ve.
      1. Amurets
        Amurets 1 October 2015 07: 56 New
        +2
        But what does it spit? The truth is all this. And hatred of Moscow is growing stronger every year. And not only in Siberia and the Far East. A friend came from Novgorod and there are the same things. The country is big and it’s hard to manage it only from Moscow. U we are already in full swing and in the west of the country they are just starting to get up, in Kamchatka the working day is rolling towards the end. The capital of the country should be in the center of the territory, like in Brazil. And the economic and political center should not be in different places. In principle, economic centers there should be several. This is nonsense, the creation of a big Moscow, as well as the creation of Skolkovo and other Moscow satellites. We destroy scientific centers created in Soviet times instead of supporting them, and we are building new ones closer to Moscow, so that there is money easier to steal.
        1. Cherdak
          Cherdak 1 October 2015 13: 04 New
          0
          Quote: Amurets
          The country is large and it’s not possible to manage it only from Moscow.

          laughing He lies with this name and rises with this name. (c) Yaroslav Smelyakov

          With such approaches, you definitely do not need local authority, since you don’t have your own head.

          Sorry, but this is “Yaroslavna’s crying”, such as “the gentleman will come, the master will judge us.”

          ***
          Most of all I respect Americans for just one phrase:

          "Do not ask what the country has done for you. Ask yourself what you did for the country."John Kennedy delivered on Friday January 20, 1961 during his inaugural address.

          Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do foryour country.
  8. Bthuk
    Bthuk 1 October 2015 06: 21 New
    +4
    That's right people say that Russia and Moscow are two different states!
  9. Reptiloid
    Reptiloid 1 October 2015 06: 23 New
    +2
    It may turn out like this - it’s hard for the population in the region to move to the city. And who does this get the place?
    Quote: 3
    We live normally, but I would like better!

    I am glad that everything is fine with you, let it be as best as possible. In the Far East we lived in a small village, everyone knew each other. It was healthy!
    1. EvgNik
      EvgNik 1 October 2015 07: 02 New
      +3
      Quote: Reptiloid
      And the place is who gets it

      To nobody. At first, villages were dying, now small towns are dying. Small plants, factories are dying. Nothing is being built (except for shops and all kinds of offices - the first floors of residential buildings go under it. And so the housing stock is declining).
      1. IS-80
        IS-80 1 October 2015 10: 18 New
        +1
        Quote: EvgNik
        To nobody. At first, villages were dying, now small towns are dying. Small plants, factories are dying. Nothing is being built (except for shops and all kinds of offices - the first floors of residential buildings go under it. And so the housing stock is declining).

        This is all true, but for the sake of objectivity, the problem is not only that Moscow takes all the money. In our city, there is a plant, before the modernization of production, as far as I remember, about 2000 people worked there, now about 400. At my enterprise, the number decreased as a result of optimization by about 25 percent, if I'm not mistaken, and this is not the limit, in principle, there is much more to be reduced. The problem in increasing labor productivity is exacerbated by the fact that for many years just nobody did anything in this direction, plus a crisis in the economy. And the problem, in my opinion, is global, global, and not just ours. Yes, the skew in income is also extremely bad for the state of the economy, but the problem is not only that.
  10. tyras85
    tyras85 1 October 2015 06: 26 New
    +4
    "... Real import substitution should take place not on the shelves, but in the minds of people, and first of all people making important decisions for the country."

    Very true, but I will add a reservation. Important people (managers) should and must make such decisions so that our counters are full of our, high-quality products, with an affordable price, oriented primarily to the average consumer. No other way...!
    1. pv1005
      pv1005 1 October 2015 07: 30 New
      +1
      Quote: tyras85

      Important people (managers)

      Managers, these are those who are "specialists" in everything (read nothing) ??? Maybe it’s time to already make an IMPORTANT MAN a peasant, a worker, an engineer, a teacher and many others who really do the work, and do not drive their hands? And it’s time to put the servants back in place.
  11. vobels
    vobels 1 October 2015 06: 28 New
    +1
    And the mentality is different, and the relationship between people is different. And it's time to apply a diet for a long time.
  12. marina1811
    marina1811 1 October 2015 06: 29 New
    +1
    I do not trust the local authorities. We must go the other way. You can’t just leave money in place. Steal.
    1. VEKT
      VEKT 1 October 2015 09: 20 New
      +5
      Well, you can work with local people like this.
  13. rosarioagro
    rosarioagro 1 October 2015 06: 30 New
    +1
    Well, what they wanted, when the ruble was devalued by box, it was said that the salaries of Russians are higher than labor productivity, so don’t expect changes, it’s the lever for controlling the electorate, there will be some kind of indexation and increase before the elections so that the electorate is happy and does “Ku ":-)
  14. fa2998
    fa2998 1 October 2015 06: 30 New
    +3
    For another 10-15 years, the word "Muscovite" will become an equal right among curses! I understand political political, but financial? First the regions are torn off as sticky, and then the governors, the deputies go to Moscow for alms, they shout. 3/5 rich enterprises settled in Moscow, probably still 1/5 is in the northern capital. What remains for great Russia, from Kaliningrad to Chukotka? The income gap between Muscovites and Russians is constantly growing. And the very comforts of life of backward Russia still catch up to 100 years.
    Muscovites would try our smelly tap water (for 150 rubles / cube) - it would be an emergency. The only reservoir was DRAINED by the local oil and glass factory. From their activities, the city of Shish, and the money and products, bye-bye! negative hi
  15. Monster_Fat
    Monster_Fat 1 October 2015 06: 34 New
    +9
    Moscow is the heart of Russia and it feeds on the blood of the regions. So they say in the people. However, the author comparing the United States and Russia did not mention the main difference between these states which allows developing in a different tax system. We have all taxes shifted to production, not to citizens, and they go to the treasury, in other words, to Moscow, that is, Moscow "sits" on money and distributes everything. All the money is in Moscow. Hence the “Moscow” salaries, hence the influx of migrants and so on. In the United States, only the income of citizens-enterprises is taxed for the most part; they do not pay the bulk of the tax — owners pay it with their profit — the “salary” that goes into their “pocket” "(except for the corporation (type C) and LLC that have chosen the corporate tax option). That is, in the United States, the tax burden is shifted from production to citizens, on the one hand, it allows production to develop without being burdened by an excessive tax burden, and on the other hand, it stimulates high salaries so that deductions from them go to the treasury. But this is only part of the taxes. A large role in the development of regions in the USA is played by different types of regional taxes that remain in the region - each state has its own. It is the regional taxes, which in some states even exceed the federal tax and allow the regions to develop. An important role in the "decentralization" of production in the United States is played by the so-called land use tax, which is increasing in arithmetic progression in urban and near-urban areas, which forces companies to look for more distant and less taxable land to locate their production. The same goes for the green recycling tax. But we don’t have all this. It will not work in Russia to develop regions without changing tax legislation.
  16. A1L9E4K9S
    A1L9E4K9S 1 October 2015 06: 39 New
    +7
    Quote: EvgNik
    A bad example is contagious.


    Here, not an example is contagious, but the disregard for their country, who runs the center, simply stuff their pockets, the country turned into a feeder, to which the elect were allowed, and they laid greetings on the rest of the population, they didn’t spend on the anti-people’s, anti-Russian government to extend the term for retirement, but it’s crap .... the nations rejected the increased tax from the oligarchy, but you have to reduce the budget and where to get these funds, from whom you won’t get any answers, but from pensioners, they froze indexing, but prices everything went sky-high, it is a pity the industry abandoned dust for a long time to produce, otherwise I would have poisoned all pensioners with dust for a long time, I don’t know how visitors to the VO site are, but I had the opinion that the enemies of the people and Russia are leading us.
    1. murking
      murking 1 October 2015 07: 01 New
      -11
      A buddy having Internet access and a good education in certain areas, earning 2-3 thousand bucks is not difficult, but I see you can only whine and demand that someone be taken away and given to you. If you want a communist paradise, you can leave for North Korea, in Russia you can be without money and whine about it, or work, think with your head and there will be no problems with money.
      1. EvgNik
        EvgNik 1 October 2015 07: 26 New
        +2
        Quote: murking
        making 2-3 thousand bucks is easy

        I looked at several ways to make money through the Internet. Mostly fraud and pyramids. There are honest ways, but not everyone will do. For example, voice acting of books. The method is honest, but you must have the talent of a reader. That is, to earn honestly - you need talent, in extreme cases, a specialty on a necessary topic. Everything else is from the evil one.
      2. pv1005
        pv1005 1 October 2015 07: 44 New
        +1
        Listen, dear, and who feeds your friend and dresses, who does so that quickly running electrons appear in his socket that date the ability to work on his computer and have the Internet ?????? Man is not alive by the Internet. And if your parents did not explain this to you in childhood, then apparently, unfortunately, no one will explain it. So you can bring it yourself down to where you will be fed and paid 30 pieces of silver for poking into the "Claudia".
        1. murking
          murking 1 October 2015 08: 11 New
          -1
          And I didn’t say that everyone should work on the Internet, demand creates supply if a bunch of comrades can definitely do work, then the price of payment will be lower, there the Chinese work for 100 bucks and plow like slaves, and someone earns millions of dollars for 2 clicks, Not everyone can be the best of the best, but many here on the site go on a socialist utopia that the worst should receive as the best, because of this the Soviet Union collapsed. The best will simply go to other countries where they will be provided with chocolate and it is the best that drive progress. Man is the purge of our planet and the laws of our planet are elementary, the desire to become the best drives progress, if this goal is killed by crazy-wise experiments in the form of leveling, then there will be no progress. Yes, many climb to the top thanks to luck, and not to their qualities, but without luck there would be so interesting to live.
          1. pv1005
            pv1005 1 October 2015 09: 18 New
            +2
            And I didn’t say that everyone should work on the Internet,

            However, you give just such an example.

            demand creates supply, if a bunch of comrades can definitely do work, then the payment price will be lower, the Chinese will work for 100 bucks and plow like slaves, and someone will earn millions of dollars in 2 clicks

            This is just the demand for the work of 100 Chinese people, but you can do without a mouse click of a banker, but here a banker will quickly stretch his legs without the work of 100 Chinese.

            Not everyone can be the best of the best,

            There is nothing to argue, this is an axiom.

            and many here on the site go on a socialist utopia that the worst should be received as learners, because of this the Soviet Union collapsed.

            Based on what you have made such a conclusion? Here, just many work and understand the difference between socialist utopia and capitalist utopia.

            The best will simply go to other countries where they will be provided with chocolate and it is the best that drive progress.

            And without chocolate, far from the HOMELAND, progress does not move in any way ????

            Man is the purge of our planet and the laws of our planet are elementary, the desire to become the best drives progress, if this goal is killed by crazy-wise experiments in the form of leveling, then there will be no progress.
            That is, the FIRST nuclear power plants in the world, the nuclear icebreaker fleet, manned space flight, the BEST education and medical support are apparently unsuccessful results of semi-smart experiments ?????

            Yes, many climb to the top thanks to luck, and not their qualities, but without luck it would not be so interesting to live.

            As for luck, in the presence of knowledge, skills, right. There is no arguing. But if you have successful grandfather, dad, uncle and climb to the top of the pyramid thanks to them, not representing absolutely nothing, then what should I call it?

            hi
            1. murking
              murking 1 October 2015 09: 53 New
              -2
              Well, there is a demand for the Chinese, and dofig Chinese, and people who know how to press the right button, at the right time, in the right place, units =)
              As for chocolate, people leave when they have the opportunity or they are invited to the same England is a fact, ideological units.
              As for the achievements of the USSR, this is connected with the intellect of Russians, namely, the human intellect, namely, the logical department in which we think and which distinguishes us from animals, arose when speech appeared, it allowed us to accumulate information. Speech is based on sound, which is a derivative of vibration, that is, the essence the universe which is formed by dark energy and dark matter, namely, overcoming resistance is contained in speech and language. The Russian language gives certain intellectual advantages to Russians. There is nothing for ordinary people such information =)
              1. IS-80
                IS-80 1 October 2015 14: 12 New
                0
                Quote: murking
                As for the achievements of the USSR, this is connected with the intellect of the Russians, the intellect of man, namely, the logical department in which we think and which distinguishes us from animals, arose when speech appeared, it allowed to accumulate information.

                This looks especially interesting in light of the fact that not only Russians, but also representatives of other nationalities are involved in the achievements of the USSR.
            2. murking
              murking 1 October 2015 13: 54 New
              -3
              There was no time to write it off completely. In medicine and education the USSR was far from the best, everything related to meeting the needs of citizens was low. By education it is easy to verify that the number of Nobel laureates, the number of scientific discoveries, and successes in science were only in several areas, especially related to the military industry, in medicine the lag was generally catastrophic, there was no serious medical equipment, the number of medical discoveries, in comparison with the Americans, was simply ridiculous. Many famous people when leaving the USSR refused to return when they saw a prosperous life in the same America. The USSR with its planned economy, aging leaders who could not transfer power because they were dying, the biggest loss of territory, without firing a shot, in the entire history of mankind, the lag behind America is so great that it cannot be overcome in a hundred years, take that same qualitative composition of the population, in America it is very She was tall, she sucked the best from all over the planet, if not for the Russian language, which has a number of properties, both in complex structure and pronunciation, which gives us a number of advantages in intelligence, there would be no chance of catching up.
              1. IS-80
                IS-80 1 October 2015 14: 16 New
                0
                Quote: murking
                There was no time to write it off completely. In medicine and education the USSR was far from the best, everything related to meeting the needs of citizens was low. By education it is easy to verify that the number of Nobel laureates, the number of scientific discoveries, and successes in science were only in several areas, especially related to the military industry, in medicine the lag was generally catastrophic, there was no serious medical equipment, the number of medical discoveries, in comparison with the Americans, was simply ridiculous. Many famous people when leaving the USSR refused to return when they saw a prosperous life in the same America. The USSR with its planned economy, aging leaders who could not transfer power because they were dying, the biggest loss of territory, without firing a shot, in the entire history of mankind, the lag behind America is so great that it cannot be overcome in a hundred years, take that same qualitative composition of the population, in America it is very She was tall, she sucked the best from all over the planet, if not for the Russian language, which has a number of properties, both in complex structure and pronunciation, which gives us a number of advantages in intelligence, there would be no chance of catching up.

                That is, everything was bad in the USSR in your opinion?
                1. Scraptor
                  Scraptor 1 October 2015 14: 24 New
                  +1
                  Yes, and Gagarin did not fly into space, and lasers were not invented, and Theodorov and Bakulev did not treat the foreigners who arrived ...

                  America’s best sucked out quickly become Americanized and become like everyone else.
              2. pv1005
                pv1005 1 October 2015 15: 10 New
                0
                Quote: murking
                There was no time to write it off completely. In medicine and education the USSR was far from the best, everything related to meeting the needs of citizens was low. By education it is easy to verify that the number of Nobel laureates, the number of scientific discoveries, and successes in science were only in several areas, especially related to the military industry, in medicine the lag was generally catastrophic, there was no serious medical equipment, the number of medical discoveries, in comparison with the Americans, was simply ridiculous. Many famous people when leaving the USSR refused to return when they saw a prosperous life in the same America. The USSR with its planned economy, aging leaders who could not transfer power because they were dying, the biggest loss of territory, without firing a shot, in the entire history of mankind, the lag behind America is so great that it cannot be overcome in a hundred years, take that same qualitative composition of the population, in America it is very She was tall, she sucked the best from all over the planet, if not for the Russian language, which has a number of properties, both in complex structure and pronunciation, which gives us a number of advantages in intelligence, there would be no chance of catching up.

                I look at you here and think why you still live in Russia ???? request
    2. EvgNik
      EvgNik 1 October 2015 07: 13 New
      +1
      Quote: A1L9E4K9S
      who cares about their country, who runs the center, just stuff their pockets

      I agree with all of the foregoing. I will add. Not a single one who has stolen in the regions and escaped to Moscow has not returned to his small homeland. Continue to build up capital in Moscow. There it is easier and not so noticeable in the crowd.
    3. murking
      murking 1 October 2015 09: 01 New
      -4
      About why they do not introduce a progressive tax scale for the rich instead of a flat one, because after they introduced a flat one and the progressive tax was canceled, the collection of taxes became larger, while the progressive one simply went into the shadows and envelopes. Uncle Zu as usual drives the snowstorm, and someone He listens to him and still believes, this is a real joke. Of course, you can shout, we will poison the police so that whoever doesn’t pay, then we are rinsed through the media so that all investors will run away. to repeat.
      1. IS-80
        IS-80 1 October 2015 09: 29 New
        0
        Quote: murking
        everyone just went into the shadows and envelopes

        I’ll now tell you a terrible secret and the shadow and envelopes they still exist even in quite prosperous respectable enterprises.
        Quote: murking
        we will set the policemen so that whoever does not pay punishment

        This is actually their job. And why then is the police needed if she does not fulfill her duties, for a sign?
        Quote: murking
        Of course, you can shout, we will poison the police so that whoever doesn’t pay the penalty, then we are rinsed through the media so that all investors will run away. When the press was pressed, our economies were pretty bent, so right now there is no desire to repeat this.

        Are you still awake? This is a fact. Does the word "sanction" say nothing to you?
    4. Vladimir 1964
      Vladimir 1964 1 October 2015 09: 45 New
      +1
      Quote: A1L9E4K9S
      , but I got the opinion that we are led by enemies of the people and Russia.


      Alexander, the site has repeatedly voiced the idea that it is not an external enemy that will destroy us, our own officials will strangle us.

      So somehow unfortunately. good hi
  17. valokordin
    valokordin 1 October 2015 07: 04 New
    +3
    The article is correct, but whoever listens to it. Moscow is a great city, but also a big bloodsucker, a leech (not medical) of the whole country. Moscow sucks out all the juices from Russia, leaving the outskirts to flounder something like that, allocating a little money. In the USSR, Moscow spent money allocating the lion's share to the most ambitious republics, the Baltic states, Ukraine, Georgia (especially Georgia) and the rest according to the residual. Now it gives the opportunity to use its pocket to Tatarstan (Tatarstan leaves its money to itself), to Chechnya, because it is afraid. Well done Tatars did not let their republic break up the liberals and shit, so they have everything okay. Chechnya, you understand. Moscow keeps the rest in a tight rein. Given the current political and economic structure and the present government, whatever the president says, there will be no breakthrough in the economy, only import substitution will remain.
    1. murking
      murking 1 October 2015 07: 33 New
      0
      Russia is afraid of Chechnya, you repeat for Ukrainians. Do not post nonsense.
      1. VEKT
        VEKT 1 October 2015 09: 36 New
        +1
        And you tell me, my dear, who else of the governors has an entire army? Which consists mainly of "repentant" militants?
        1. murking
          murking 1 October 2015 10: 22 New
          0
          In Chechnya, democracy is impossible, there are completely different customs and psychology, so we supported the dictatorship there, it is beneficial for us, all who mow down there are severely and severely punished, and the presence of the above-mentioned features and other nuances is quite natural for the dictatorship.
  18. EvgNik
    EvgNik 1 October 2015 07: 06 New
    +3
    Quote: fa2998
    Another 10-15 years, the word "Muscovite" will be an equal among curses!

    Error. It became abusive back in the days of the USSR.
  19. Reptiloid
    Reptiloid 1 October 2015 07: 19 New
    +1
    Quote: EvgNik
    Quote: Reptiloid
    And the place is who gets it

    To nobody. At first, villages were dying, now small towns are dying. Small plants, factories are dying. Nothing is being built (except for shops and all kinds of offices - the first floors of residential buildings go under it. And so the housing stock is declining).

    I think a little wrong with the villages. There are rumors that those lands are so-so. Everyone has left. And then it turns out quite the opposite, and all are sold out. I don’t know anything about small cities. The village where I lived small remained exactly the same. I look at it online.
    1. EvgNik
      EvgNik 1 October 2015 07: 46 New
      +1
      Quote: Reptiloid
      I think a little wrong with the villages

      In our area all the fields are overgrown. Remained a little in the private sector, and it is declining. Roads to villages are killed, bridges are destroyed. In some places, retirees remained to live in the villages. The plant "privatizer" brought to bankruptcy. Like this. However, we live, we chew bread. But the regional center! There Wow! And roads, and construction, and the rise of the economy!
      1. Mordvin 3
        Mordvin 3 1 October 2015 13: 07 New
        +2
        We have the same crap in the villages. From the satellite - yes, it’s like they’re standing at home. And in real life you come - sheer devastation. You can still drive in summer, and in winter only on a tank.
  20. murking
    murking 1 October 2015 07: 28 New
    -2
    Enterprises are registered in Moscow because it is more convenient, the state will redistribute money to the regions anyway. Yes, Muscovites get much more salaries, living conditions are better than in the regions. Moscow is the capital, since Russia has a certain democracy framework, you can influence Russia through soft power, demonstrations, buildup is possible only through the capital, it is logical and natural that the state appeals to residents of the capital.If there is a salary of 3000 rubles in the regions, this will not greatly affect the authorities, if in Moscow there is a salary of 3000, there will be serious destabilization of the country.
    1. IS-80
      IS-80 1 October 2015 09: 32 New
      +2
      Quote: murking
      If in the regions the salary will be 3000 rubles

      Yeah, especially in the Caucasus, this does not affect anything much.
    2. VEKT
      VEKT 1 October 2015 09: 42 New
      0
      Well, there is a way out, we transfer the capital to Siberia or the Far East to a town of thousands per 100 inhabitants, and that’s all, Moscow is turning into a province. The demonstration that is not visible from the bureaucratic window of the official is not interested.
      1. V.ic
        V.ic 1 October 2015 11: 10 New
        +1
        Quote: VEKT
        and that's it, Moscow is turning into a province

        "12 chairs" probably reread the other day? Ostap Ibrahimovic was broadcasting something similar there in Vasyuki.
        1. VEKT
          VEKT 1 October 2015 13: 41 New
          0
          "12 chairs" probably reread the other day? Ostap Ibrahimovic was broadcasting something similar there in Vasyuki.

          No, I remembered one leader who built a new capital in the Chukhon swamps, away from the rotten Moscow nobility.
          1. V.ic
            V.ic 1 October 2015 14: 13 New
            0
            Quote: VEKT
            one leader who built a new capital in the Chukhon marshes

            That everything was drunk conceived, but paved with Russian bones. As a result, from September 1941 to the end of January 1944 they had ... / as it were easier to put it / bloody hemorrhoids. The government of Ulyanov was smarter by moving to Moscow.
  21. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 1 October 2015 07: 29 New
    0
    Moscow is the heart of Russia, but this heart is diagnosed obesity, and he is shown at least a diet

    Only for such a conclusion can you put a lot +. Moscow really lives its own life and has long moved away from Russia.
    1. rotmistr60
      rotmistr60 1 October 2015 08: 44 New
      0
      Muscovites, it's time to really look at life and not build the navel of the Earth out of ourselves. It is not your merit that all cash flows are concentrated in Moscow. It is for this neglect of others (not Muscovites) that they do not love you. It’s time to take this for reality and boast less of their residence permit, all the more so since it was not the native Muscovites who reacted painfully, but those who moved.
      1. rotmistr60
        rotmistr60 1 October 2015 09: 10 New
        0
        Yes, at least turn blue before turning blue, but you won’t get away from the truth. Even here a rotten essence is manifested - they are minus, but they cannot specifically answer. You come to us in the Far East and tell people that you are the most, and that others cannot live. Then I'll look at your pale look. Open contempt for others is a road to nowhere.
  22. Reptiloid
    Reptiloid 1 October 2015 08: 09 New
    0
    Quote: EvgNik
    Quote: Reptiloid
    I think a little wrong with the villages

    In our area all the fields are overgrown. Remained a little in the private sector, and it is declining. Roads to villages are killed, bridges are destroyed. In some places, retirees remained to live in the villages. The plant "privatizer" brought to bankruptcy. Like this. However, we live, we chew bread. But the regional center! There Wow! And roads, and construction, and the rise of the economy!

    IF away from St. Petersburg, probably the same. There are places where electricity failed several years ago during a hurricane, so far they have not settled. Moscow is absorbing small towns. Respectfully.
  23. Northwind
    Northwind 1 October 2015 09: 21 New
    +2
    I agree with everything that is written in the article and in the comments.
    But I would like to summarize all of the above by putting forward such a project - to move all ministries to the regions according to the sectors of activity of such ministries, for example:
    the Ministry of the forest industry (I may be mistaken in the name, but I apologize in advance for such incompetence) to the Irkutsk region closer to Lake Baikal so that officials from the windows of their offices look at the results of conflagrations and move accordingly in those same chairs ...;
    Ministry of Heavy Industry in the Urals;
    the Ministry of Agriculture in the Far East - to implement the idea of ​​the Prime Minister "to everyone 1 ha of land for the development of agricultural production";
    mining ministry (if there is one, but you will understand me) - in Magadan - "where gold is digged in the mountains"; the Ministry of Fisheries on Sakhalin (since the Sea of ​​Okhotsk has become a legal and almost inland sea), let them monitor the distribution of fishing quotas directly at the mooring wall;
    I propose to place the Ministry of Transport in Anadyr. I think they will immediately have a plan on how to organize inter-regional transportation, and so on.
    How many problems the capital will solve at once: there will be no traffic jams because ministers, their wives, lovers and lovers, lovers of lovers, lovers of lovers, children, nannies and other servants with cars to move to the regions - this is at least a million people. down from the capital.
    Those who are still dreaming of conquering the capital will no longer have this stupid thought and these people will also remain in the regions.
    In the field, these officials will immediately want to drive along good roads, walk along clean sidewalks, etc. And how many local budgets will receive income from taxes on their salaries and other income of these servants of the people.
    Well, for scheduled meetings it will be enough once a month to fly to the capital, and unscheduled as necessary ...
    I propose to support my idea (maybe there is such an idea, and someone else has ripened it in my head) and organize the promotion of this idea in the State Duma. Volfovich and Zyuganov, I think we will be supported unconditionally.
    1. tolyasik0577
      tolyasik0577 1 October 2015 10: 10 New
      0
      Yeah, and all the ministers will have to rush on the first meeting of the chapter on a special flight to Moscow? No, the ministry should remain in the capital, but the regional offices should be located on the ground. And nihai ministers rush around the country and get acquainted with the situation on the spot. Though they will be afraid of commissions and ministers will have more control over the situation when they see everything with their own eyes
      1. Tatar 174
        Tatar 174 1 October 2015 10: 15 New
        0
        Quote: tolyasik0577
        Yeah, and all the ministers will have to rush on the first meeting of the chapter on a special flight to Moscow?

        Do not! It is necessary to develop and establish communication technologies that already exist.
  24. The comment was deleted.
  25. tolyasik0577
    tolyasik0577 1 October 2015 10: 05 New
    0
    if large financial companies leave Moscow, she will suffocate. Own production, which means city-forming enterprises, is cut into pieces and sold under office centers and trading floors. What remains of ZIL, AzLK? And these are only those that everyone knows about. And smaller ones but no less significant? ... No, this will be a very hard blow for Moscow. It is fundamentally necessary to change the system of farm planning. Like advice. The fact that the Japanese took over the Planned Economy, where it was planned to spend funds for the whole country for 5 years in advance. And the country was one and a half times larger. And of course, a competent, science-based sectoral development program for the region in each case. Why is there no direct road from Voronezh to Volgograd? Yes, because in the Union it was not needed. The goals of the two regions did not overlap. There was a more cost-effective union of these areas with other areas.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 1 October 2015 18: 44 New
      0
      Zil was no longer needed by anyone and went bankrupt - the products are sea, but no one buys it and it’s good that they closed it, otherwise it would be a bottomless hole for pumping money in there, large financial companies in Moscow no longer define anything — their units but private traders here are hundreds of thousands, if not a million, and I am one of them, and the population of 15 million defines this financial system of Moscow, and due to the fact that Moscow doesn’t produce anything, even how it produces, starting from pins ending with aviation turbines.
      1. corn
        corn 4 October 2015 17: 09 New
        -1
        Quote: Vadim237
        and a population of 15 million, this is precisely what determines the financial system of Moscow,

        The average teacher salary in the country is 20 tyrov. The average teacher salary in the province is 18tyrov, the average teacher salary in Moscow is 38 tyrov (18 * 9 + 38 = 200, 200: 10 = 20). So it turns out that 9 teachers from the provinces have incomes more than two times lower than the Moscow teacher and, accordingly, they can afford half as much. That's all the taxes, that's the whole standard of living. But teachers from the provinces cannot come to Moscow to achieve a smaller income gap, and Moscow teachers will not let them do this if someone breaks through with a helmet on Red Square to knock. And revolutions are being made in capitals.
        So the Muscovites are paying power so that they also protect it. And the whole system of taxation and income distribution is built on this. All Other Reasoning and Commentary - Talking to the Poor
        1. Cat man null
          Cat man null 4 October 2015 17: 47 New
          0
          Quote: corn
          ( 18*9+38=200, 200:10=20)

          That is, in your opinion, 9 out of 10 teachers in the Russian Federation work in Moscow? Where did you find this, interesting? belay

          Quote: corn
          The average salary of a teacher in the province is 18 thousand, the average salary of a teacher in Moscow is 38 thousand

          Mdya .. funny numbers .. see:

          Quote: http://top-rf.ru/places/131-rejting-regionov-rf-po-zarplate-shkolnykh-uchitelej-
          2014.html
          As it turned out, according to the Federal State Statistics Service for the first half of 2014, teachers receive most of all not in Moscow or St. Petersburg, but in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous District (83 rubles) and in Chukotka (174 rubles). The Nenets Autonomous Okrug (76 rubles), the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug-Ugra (713 rubles) and the Magadan Region (5 rubles) were also included in the top 75 regions of the Russian Federation in terms of average teacher salaries.

          The lowest salaries for teachers in Russia are in Dagestan (17 rubles), the Karachay-Cherkess Republic (448 rubles) and Mordovia (19 rubles)

          Quote: corn
          So it turns out that 9 teachers from the provinces have incomes more than two times lower than the Moscow teacher and, accordingly, they can afford half as much

          The concept of "cost of living" (communal apartment + transport + food, clothes, some + school-kindergarten + ...), we, of course, ignore .. scientific approach, what ..

          I mean, in Moscow it is much more expensive than even in the nearest suburbs .. not to mention the "province" (and what is the "province" in your opinion, by the way?).

          Quote: corn
          So Muscovites pay power so that they also protect it

          In delirium .. belay

          Quote: corn
          All Other Reasoning and Commentary - Talking to the Poor

          Yours for example yes

          Since the subject, which is taken to judge, you do not know. From the word "completely" yes
          1. Cat man null
            Cat man null 4 October 2015 20: 23 New
            0
            Amendment:

            That is, in your opinion, 9 out of 10 teachers every tenth teacher in Russia works in Moscow? Where did you find this, interesting?

            Everything else - no change hi
            1. corn
              corn 4 October 2015 22: 32 New
              0
              Quote: Cat Man Null
              That is, in your opinion, 9 out of 10 teachers every tenth teacher in the Russian Federation works in Moscow? Where did you find this, interesting?

              In Russia - about 146 million, the population of Moscow (permanent) - about 12 million. I am not going to catch fleas, and if you do not have a clue about enlarged calculations, then these are your problems, the order of numbers will not change. The average salary in Russia in 2015 is 32 thousand, in Moscow - 60 thousand, in the regions around Moscow from 20 to 25 thousand, in Oryol - a little more than 15, and among the Chukchi, Khanty, etc. (where regional coefficients are at least 2) less than in Moscow (Business Life site).
              Prices in Moscow slightly exceed the national average (10-15 percent), and for many goods even lower.
              You probably live in Moscow?
              Sell ​​your housing in Moscow, come to our town with a population of 40 thousand, find 12 tyrov jobs, buy a house, several apartments (you will rent them) and live. Weak?
              I'm not going to Moscow, you are angry there.
              18 * 11 + 42 = 240. 240: 12 = 20. This is because every 12th teacher is in Moscow, and the salary gap has become even greater. This means that for 11, the salary is only 10 percent less than the average, and for one, twice as much as the average, and due to free money, he will buy what is necessary for those 11 and resell them a little more expensive, multiplying his wealth more and more, or in the simplest case, will protect the current state of affairs so as not to lose their income.
              This is all very simplified, life is much more complicated.
              It is sad that this is not obvious to you.
              1. corn
                corn 4 October 2015 22: 43 New
                0
                And the average teacher salary in Moscow is about 60 tyrov, not 42, but in the Oryol region - 20.
                1. Cat man null
                  Cat man null 5 October 2015 14: 51 New
                  0
                  Well, damn it, you give (s)

                  Quote: corn
                  In Russia - about 146 million, the population of Moscow (permanent) - about 12 million

                  Clear. Accepted.

                  Quote: corn
                  Prices in Moscow are slightly higher than the national average (10-15 percent), and for many goods even lower

                  Um .. there is such a thing - the "cost of living index." This is a slightly more objective (although not ideal) criterion than "prices in Moscow". We look:

                  Moscow - 126.7%
                  Tver - 102.3%
                  Vladimir - 101.6%
                  Nizhny Novgorod - 100.3%
                  Rostov-on-Don - 98.8%

                  That is, the difference is not "10-15 percent, but for many goods even lower", but strictly more by 25%, at least. The cost of living. In Moscow.

                  In addition, this price does not include all kinds of fees (at school, kindergarten, etc.) Believe me, in Moscow (and the region, by the way, too) - it is very developed, "other expenses" sad

                  Further, not all of those who work in Moscow live in it. So - add (subtract, more precisely) the cost of the road. Thousands of 5-6 per month - easy. And at the same time, 1.5 - 2 hours on a one-way trip - how is it for you, in a "town with 40 thousand people"? And by Moscow standards - this is completely normal yes

                  So yes

                  Quote: corn
                  life is much harder

                  Next.

                  Quote: corn
                  at the expense of free money, he will buy what is necessary for those 11 and resell them a little more expensive, increasing his wealth more and more

                  Well, for sure !! And even a janitor in Moscow - he is a malicious exploiter of the working people from the province ..

                  Do not make sneakers ..

                  Quote: corn
                  or, in the simplest case, it will protect the current state of affairs so as not to lose its income

                  Nobody will protect anything. For two reasons:

                  - in order to “defend”, it is necessary that “attack”. Is someone attacking? Is someone going to attack? Nope ..
                  - "defenders" and so plenty. Staff

                  Quote: corn
                  You probably live in Moscow?

                  No, in the area. I ride to work (I rode. Work has ended so far) to Moscow. 5 hours a day on the road, nothing for you?

                  Quote: corn
                  I'm not going to Moscow, you are angry there

                  This is not the main thing, believe me. There are kindly and many. Only -

                  - rent a house - from 25-30 tyrov, as you put it
                  - other - I painted above

                  That is - in order to somehow make ends meet, you need to earn money on one's beloved from fifty dollars and above. Will you pull?

                  That's something like request
  26. Anatoly_1959
    Anatoly_1959 1 October 2015 10: 10 New
    +1
    Undoubtedly, it is necessary that taxes be paid only in the regions: the larger the taxable base, the better the work of governors. And so they sit for themselves, they speak for a good and honest life, and then for some reason they end up on the bunk. the regions must, from their tax revenues, transfer a certain part to the center for general federal needs: the army and the government, partially to the reserve fund; the rest should be managed independently. the main danger in the presence of national entities in the Russian Federation: what separatism has already passed. Therefore, the whole country should be divided into districts that are approximately equal in basic indicators and purely administrative without any “titular nations”, with the unconditional preservation of each people living in them with their culture and habitual way of life. although now everything is very quickly leveled everywhere and national cultures are supported mainly by enthusiasts. only when a person anywhere in the country can feel confident in material terms will the development of every corner of our country and steady territorial stability begin.
  27. Tatar 174
    Tatar 174 1 October 2015 10: 11 New
    -1
    To save Russia it is necessary to burn Moscow. This is not I who said, but a great commander.
    1. V.ic
      V.ic 1 October 2015 11: 12 New
      +2
      Quote: Tartar 174
      To save Russia it is necessary to burn Moscow. This is not I who said, but the great commander

      An interesting logic ... "We will destroy the whole world of violence to the ground" ... And then ... Let's continue to burn further Peter, Samara, Nizhny, Vladimir, Kazan, Ufa, ...
    2. GRAY
      GRAY 1 October 2015 11: 27 New
      +2
      Quote: Tartar 174
      need to burn Moscow.

      And declare Tatarstan a caliphate.
    3. GRAY
      GRAY 1 October 2015 13: 04 New
      0
      Quote: Tartar 174
      This is not I who said, but a great commander.

      Han Mamai? laughing
      1. Tatar 174
        Tatar 174 1 October 2015 15: 03 New
        -2
        Quote: GRAY
        Han Mamai? laughing


        Kutuzov said the same Mamai.

        Quote: GRAY
        And declare Tatarstan a caliphate.

        This is not me either, but you said. wink
  28. Zomanus
    Zomanus 1 October 2015 14: 04 New
    -2
    The correct article. All dumped in Moscow time.
    Regions live by a residual principle.
    Logistics in Russia does not develop at all in terms of supporting and building up communication lines.
    Maybe it will be fixed soon.
    Maybe such work is already underway.
    But so far with the logistics we have .op full.
    Example? EMS, when the parcel from Korea to Vladivostok / Khabarovsk goes through Moscow time.
    So work and work on it.
    1. 97110
      97110 1 October 2015 14: 55 New
      +2
      Quote: Zomanus
      Logistics in Russia does not develop at all in terms of supporting and building up communication lines.

      So what. Boldly. Unflattering. Right in the eye. Not an eyebrow. Do you have any relation to the Ministry of Transport? At least through the VOSO? Then all the more boldly.
  29. 97110
    97110 1 October 2015 14: 52 New
    +4
    What is being done in the capital, for example, by Russian Railways, is understandable: it “milks” the stations, but, really, it would be more decent for such an organization to be in the geographical center of the country.
    Just take the country's railroad map and mark the geographical center of the country on it. And what will the center of the country's railways do there? You have an interesting idea of ​​the work of transport - milking stations. The level of the district commissioner. Orientation - the fight against the unauthorized trade in wild plants.
  30. Vladimir Vasilich
    Vladimir Vasilich 1 October 2015 15: 15 New
    -2
    No matter how they criticize Serdyukov, he managed to "scatter" military universities across the regions. There was a lot of noise, but the military people were disciplined. We need a solid state policy of DECENTRALIZATION and power structures, and economic incentives for entrepreneurs in the regions. Well, laws, as God himself commanded. Where you download resources - pay tax there.
  31. serverny
    serverny 2 October 2015 02: 03 New
    +1
    The author shamelessly distorts, juggles and adjusts the facts to his predetermined narrative.

    This is not an analytical article, but a poorly disguised liberal anti-government propaganda.
  32. Fight cat
    Fight cat 2 October 2015 02: 33 New
    -1
    and I said for a long time it is necessary to scatter not the company, but the ministry. For example, Moscow Region in the center of Russia, a geographical center. To Krasnoyarsk there or to Tom, and the Ministry of Finance, for example, to the Far East, the Ministry of Economic Development to the far north, to Norilsk. The State Duma in Nakhodka, and the Federation Council in Magadan or in Yakutsk. Oh, how they immediately ran ahead developing the economy in these regions !!! lol and the general prosecutor’s office in Perm or also in Magadan. here the Constitutional Court can be sent to Orenburg, and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to Tobolsk ... Living would be more fun, I guarantee it !!! hi
    1. navigator
      navigator 4 October 2015 13: 02 New
      +1
      "The Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Tobolsk ... Life would be more fun, I guarantee it !!!"

      They forgot Ulan-Ude. You will be sent there, life will be more fun, I guarantee.
    2. 97110
      97110 6 October 2015 17: 21 New
      0
      Quote: Fighting Cat
      Oh, how they immediately ran into developing the economy in these regions !!

      Forgot how the head of Chukotka in Anchorage opened an office? These can settle in Fort Ross. Patriotic. So what? All to Khanty-Mansiysk. Perpetrators of liberalism - in Salekhard. For familiarization, so to speak, to the origins.
  33. nomad74
    nomad74 2 October 2015 06: 25 New
    0
    Annoying news: in which a report on what was done in the capital! Damn well, at least give the regions something! Well, all of Russia will not be able to live in Moscow, it will not! Who will feed her? If all the guards and builders rush to Moscow!
  34. 4ekist
    4ekist 2 October 2015 15: 06 New
    0
    Quote: Azitral
    Please, please - do not exaggerate about rotten roofs. I myself come from Voronezh, and generally live for a long time. I do not belong to cheers-patriots, but ... do not call too much. After a vacation in Adler, in 2011 I was traveling from Voronezh to Zadonsk (by the way - a city like a toy) and suddenly caught myself thinking that the landscape outside the window without the usual filth in life. As far back as 1964, I found sheds under thatched roofs - this is along the Zadonskoye highway (absorbed by the federal highway "Moscow - South of Russia")! What was away from the eyes ?! The Black Earth region has become much, much more attractive, stronger, calmer.

    Yes, Zadonsk is a beautiful city, there is an idea to go there after retirement.
  35. user3970
    user3970 2 October 2015 17: 23 New
    0
    The people, but what, Nazarbayev is stupid? I took it and willedly moved the capital from Alma-Ata to a clean field. Built Astana. And after this adventure, Kazakhstan immediately went bankrupt? Not ? And there is no need to compare the administrative structure of the United States and Russia! Cleverly says clever Wasserman: not the United States, but the SGA (Union of American States). Feel the difference . It is enshrined in the Declaration of Independence. And in Russia in our whole life depends on one person - the state, the president. The fratricide and sex giant Vladimir wanted to baptize Russia and baptized. And he became a saint. Question to the Orthodox: is it possible to baptize against desire? If you can’t, but really want to, then for hell with taxes do we build the largest mosque in Europe? Surround Moscow and all blacks with troops in Istra reservoir and dunk, and synagogues, mosques, blow up to hell. After all, Vladimir did so at the time. The GDP believes that it did the right thing once the monument is erected. And move the capital to Novosibirsk, away from the borders! Did Peter do that? He ditched a third of the country's population on this adventure. Well, if urine hit him in the head, why didn’t he justify his northern capital in Riga? Under the Ninstad Treaty with Sweden and for 10 million gold Efimk, Russia bought the entire Baltic forever from the latter. Ready-made city. History does not have a subjunctive mood, but imagine instead of Riga the 8th millionth Russian city with an ice-free (unlike the current St. Petersburg) port. Baltic problems would not exist in principle! Recalling the recent past ... If Tsar Boris had the country as he wanted and changed governments like shoulder whores on the highway, we conclude. Our head can afford everything! It all depends on the cockroaches in this head!
    1. navigator
      navigator 3 October 2015 22: 59 New
      -1
      "Our head can afford everything! It all depends on the cockroaches in this head!"

      That's for sure, judging by the writing, you have a lot of cockroaches!
  36. Fight cat
    Fight cat 4 October 2015 12: 33 New
    0
    if you don’t like my plan for the dispersal of state structures and write a damn thing, it feels like it’s the hand of the internal troops, I like to sit in traffic jams! angry
    1. Scraptor
      Scraptor 4 October 2015 12: 46 New
      0
      ... just "mkadysh", go "mkadovtsev" laughing

      in fact, the capitals of such countries as Canada, Australia and the USA are not megalopolises at all ... rather villages, especially the first two. Therefore, all this games - it’s better to talk about dispersal than reduction. repeat