NI: a new strategy is needed to solve the Ukrainian problem; it is not based on sanctions and the supply of weapons

26
To bring Ukraine out of the crisis, we need not sanctions and arms deliveries, but a fundamentally new approach, says Michael O'Hanlon of the Brookings Institution and National Interest magazine columnist. His article leads RIA News.



“The current policy of NATO and the United States is inadequate to the tasks at hand,” writes the analyst. - The strategy of the West runs the risk of exacerbating the situation and, possibly, of a clash between Russia and NATO. In particular, in the event of the failure of the Minsk agreements, NATO countries may begin to deliver lethal weapons to Kiev.

According to him, “in order to resolve the conflict, we should first of all reconsider the European security architecture.” O'Hanlon believes that "along with the implementation of the Minsk agreements and the granting of autonomy to Donbas, the former Soviet republics that are not members of NATO should receive neutral status on a permanent basis." And the guarantors of the sovereignty of these countries should be NATO and Russia.

In this case, “geostrategic Ukraine will not become part of the Western world, but this will not prevent it, for example, from receiving financial assistance from the West,” writes the analyst.

“Moreover, if such an agreement is reached, NATO will be able to gradually abandon the buildup of military power in Eastern Europe, which will significantly reduce the risks of a clash between the alliance and Russia and improve Ukraine’s economic prospects,” he adds. .

A neutral organization such as the OSCE should monitor compliance with the agreement, says O'Hanlon.

There is not much time left to make such a decision. "It is necessary to start the implementation of this plan before the aggravation of the situation and before the presidential campaign of 2016 in the United States, which will limit Washington’s opportunities for political maneuvers," the analyst concludes.
  • http://www.globallookpress.com/
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

26 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +18
    17 September 2015 08: 40
    We got already ... Surround Kiev, catch and shoot (while on the heap) ... am
    1. +2
      17 September 2015 08: 49
      absolutely true, you can’t say otherwise.
    2. +4
      17 September 2015 08: 54
      Why shoot? They must be judged and carried in cells so that people can spit on their faces.
      1. 0
        17 September 2015 09: 41
        Quote: Vovochka15
        carry in cells so that people can spit in their faces.


        Spit a little!
        to carry on foot behind a chaise, so that anyone who wants it for the soul could weigh a kick
      2. +1
        17 September 2015 10: 26
        And for me, words from the gentlemen of fortune come right away! You need to carry them in a vat with shit! And so that a Cossack with a saber stands on top wink
  2. +1
    17 September 2015 08: 41
    "... redefine the European security architecture." And who will review it? Europe no longer has independent politicians. Some puppets of Americans. The OSCE is no longer trusted for such an observation.
    1. WKS
      +3
      17 September 2015 09: 42
      “The current policies of NATO and the USA are inadequate to the existing tasks,” the analyst writes.

      It was as if someone had dedicated this analyst to the existing tasks of US foreign policy. Destabilization and chaotization away from American borders - this is the main task. In its mainstream, the USA is floating. And stabilization processes occur contrary to this task.
  3. 0
    17 September 2015 08: 42
    How who Americans lol
  4. 0
    17 September 2015 08: 43
    softly spreads ... but experience shows that such statements from the United States confirm the proverb about where the well-laid road leads
  5. +1
    17 September 2015 08: 47
    “In order to resolve the conflict, the European security architecture should be reviewed first.”

    The United States, and under their pressure, Europe will not agree to this. They are still satisfied with the state of affairs, although the EU has already begun to feel all the "charms" of unconditional support for the American position. The United States also felt that with Ukraine it did not work out what they intended. But support for even a smoldering conflict in this region plays into their hands.
  6. 0
    17 September 2015 08: 48
    However, there are sound thoughts. On this, in principle, they can and agree.
    1. 0
      17 September 2015 10: 48
      However, there are sound thoughts. On this, in principle, they can and agree. ,,
      There are thoughts, but this will not happen. Sasha has other tasks and goals. Do not be naive.
  7. 0
    17 September 2015 08: 52
    “We need to start implementing this plan before the situation worsens and before the 2016 US presidential campaign, which will limit Washington’s ability to political maneuvers,” the analyst concludes.

    Yeah, the first Tuesday after the first Monday of November of the month of a leap year ... 1 year, 1 month and 16 days left. It seems that according to the prophecies of the mystics smoked should be the last of the presidents of the USA?
  8. 0
    17 September 2015 08: 52
    NI: a new strategy is needed to solve the Ukrainian problem; it is not based on sanctions and the supply of weapons


    The author is right, a monkey with a grenade (APU) is a terrible thing! Diet for Ukrainians will be very useful.
  9. +5
    17 September 2015 08: 53
    Naive or naive O'Hanlon.
    How much money to invest for the milking parlor of Europe and the spread of Russia and just curtail - tales. They do not need security in the world, only chaos and lawlessness. And most importantly, away from their borders. Until popularly they don’t get bread, I think everything will only get worse!
  10. zzz
    zzz
    -1
    17 September 2015 08: 54
    Very interesting from another resource, spread in parts, because a lot of obscene words, you need to adjust, and the bukaf a lot!WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 16, 2015
    Every little thing and cho there with Yakunin

    Karochi's case was this: let's start. from ... from afar
    Last August, Girkin was suspended (August 14), on August 30, an assassination attempt was made on Zakharchenko, the muridka sculpted an alibi Girkin, about which I wrote.
    Here is a new alibi from Beard
    "Village madman" ... that is, all these multimillionaires Malofey, beards and others financed and supported the CRAZY ... a wonderful attempt to move out under schizophrenia, by the way, I wrote about the use of these techniques (and I will not be surprised if Girkin really "shows up" some kind of disease BUT I'm not talking about that)
    What is the main thing in this text? The main thing here is that some "security" really took Girkin out of Donbass and even in a tied state (did he have seizures? An autumn exacerbation? ...) That is, an alibi - Boroday as BE confirms that Girkin was not on August 30th in Donbass for "security" took him out .... we do not know about any security, this is the first time we hear it. We know that Girkin was "revealed to the world" only on September 11 (9 1 1 - they love this date)
    1. zzz
      zzz
      0
      17 September 2015 08: 56
      And from here we draw a short conclusion - the cat was absolutely right when he wrote that there were no ultimatums. on the topic, either leave or starve the Donbass, no FSB showed him what Girkin directly hinted at.
      (by the way, why isn't the Washington Post interviewing Zakharchenko?)

      So, okay, I just noted that.

      Then Zakharchenko became president of the DPR, then the younger Gabrellianov dumped in the United States, several dozen employees of life were fired. Further, in parallel with this, we carry out a secret special operation for a long time - we substitute the nipples according to their method of room-lip, which for months has been negotiating with the Kolomoisky end company for the future. The result of the special operation was the expulsion of Kolomoisky from the game and many different nishtyaks, ESPECIALLY - laws were adopted, including on the special status of Donbass, which Putin directly reminded in Crimea - the law was passed, it just wasn’t enacted ... so
      Here is a bit. just a hike, we note an important one. What conclusions can we still draw from TOY special operation? Look: they were satisfied that Gubarev, Girkin, and others would enter the parliament - EASY! You understand - it didn’t bother them, they made all the laws for this case. They were not embarrassed by the special status of Donbass. nor recognition of the legality of the elections and representatives .... but what changed dramatically when they realized that Gubarev is a joint-mouth member? ear .... why such a pancake hysteria and the abolition of all adopted laws? WHAT CHANGED ?
      1. zzz
        zzz
        0
        17 September 2015 08: 57
        I’ll tell you that - according to that scheme, the Gubarevs would not deprive the Waltzman of power, they would only share it with them .... And now it’s clear to the Waltzmen that the power will be taken away, with all the consequences
        Damn ... the cat doesn’t want to talk about it at all, but I have to dump it all again to get to the point that I ...

        Tex ... in order to negotiate with Merkel Oland and Obama, we need to control the situation. (The cat wrote down Obama for it is obvious that although he didn’t have a signature near Minsk 2, his representative in the Security Council approved this plan without blinking, so we can make it anyway) controlled from the outside, and therefore ... Batman and company, for example, went to the cemetery .. but again, I’m not right

        Right now, about that .. and now, when the most important days arrived - February 11 and 12, Merkel and Oland arrived in Minsk, Putin came to Minsk, Zakharchenko and Plotnitsky were doing the torn years of the junto army at that very moment, in short, work practically went to the coveted signatures of BUT so that some would not have thought of throwing some kind of a trumpet precisely at that time. I had to have their henchman and their wallet in their hands exactly on these two days. So that it would sit and not even dare to utter a peep, not to give a command to its mercenaries to arrange something in Donetsk at that time. That the signing would not take place
        1. zzz
          zzz
          0
          17 September 2015 08: 58
          Further .... here is now the information from the source of the cat Moti:

          Yakunin was framed by Malofeev. Yakunin is not in a dream about that INTO. Malofeev is far from acting in the interests of the Russian Federation and far from "on instructions from Putin." Yakunin, of course, "was involved" in the transportation of "Holy relics" and other things, because he heads the fund of St. Andrew the First-Called ... and fucking Malofeev put Girkin into the guard and he wandered around everywhere and sniffed out everything and smeared the stain. How did Yakunin know who Girkin was and what he was going to do ... damn
          In short, what is the essence - the investigation of the event in the Donbass will certainly be and it is already underway, it’s just a closed investigation. If, or rather, when. if the courts begin, then the name of Yakunin can be pulled out by the asshole of Malofeev INTENTIONALLY to force him to help them.
          So, well, I practically quoted the source of the cat, in my own translation. I will say right away that the sources of the cat are not the sources of those who are "entering the Kremlin" who know exactly when Kadyrov fled to Jordan and when Putin died. If Motin said the source, that means it is ... however, this particular source has one big drawback - he is not a cat, and therefore, to my chagrin, he did not think of asking his source at least a couple of leading questions, everything is complete put in place ... well, nicho. Next, the cat will dig.
          Hereafter, I, encore of the source. We look, we have. (this is me yesterday, in the wake of what I heard I dug up an interesting nuance)
          OK, watch out for the tail: the U.S. sanctions were imposed against Yakunin, but did not introduce the EU.
          And now: against Malofeev, he imposed EU sanctions, BUT DO NOT ENTER THE USA
          Can you smell the difference ??? She's fucking on her own! In the United States, it is more difficult to lift sanctions, because a bunch of senators will be in the know and it is better not to introduce them FOR OWN. Malofeev can go to the USA at any time, they "for some reason" do not consider him to be involved in the events in Donbass (... uhaha)
          1. zzz
            zzz
            0
            17 September 2015 09: 02
            (Here, the navaliers have long received an order for Yakunin, but there is nothing worse than the patriots, the liberalists are not suited for wrecking, they didn’t lie near bl)
            Now Navalner ..., by the way, due to the fact that Yakunin refused senatorship yelling at him, they say, clearly - a thief. therefore does not want a declaration. Like, dump it. Vile stupid animals

            Tex .. by the very first comment, the cat realized that. softly speaking, not everyone is aware of what I'm talking about .. right now, briefly schematichiski lyapanu
            So. Malofeev is the direct employer of Girkin and Beard. Communication with Yakunin - only thanks to the friendly (commonwealth) relations with Yakunin. he managed to put Girkin in the Orthodox mission. Girkin, under the cover of this mission, came to Kiev, including during the Maidan in KIEV-PECHERSKAYA LARA. WHERE AND MET WITH A CIA recruited now arrested by a high-ranking church figure. It was Malofeev who paid and armed Girkin’s brigade initially, when they march to Slavyansk and AT THIS - the USA did not find reasons to apply sanctions against him (!)
            Well now it’s clear, probably .. it’s so short
            It was Malofeev who threw in Novaya Gazeta with a fake memo on his own behalf, allegedly to Putin. This memo was supposed to convince the public that everything is being done in agreement with Putin That is, he made a stuffing (like a traveler he wrote about himself) and Malofeev immediately sluggishly denied that this was his memorandum, but the media naturally emphasized that he could not confirm, for this is a secret memo. In short, the scheme is the same with Girkin - he hinted that Putin had sent him and Malofeev hinted that he was acting in agreement with Putin By the way, take a look at Borodai's text above, we are talking about THAT time when Borodai was in the DNR - HE ALSO STUFF PUTIN HERE "he acted carefully and competently "UNDERSTAND? - didn’t seem to say anything bad. but PRINCED PUTIN to events because "HE ACTION" - is that clear?
            1. 0
              17 September 2015 10: 52
              like said nothing bad. but he SUSPENDED PUTIN to the events because "HE ACTION" - is that clear?
              Well, why this nonsense here, you didn’t get anything wrong?
  11. +3
    17 September 2015 08: 56
    First of all, we must stop screaming about the mythical annexation of the original Russian Crimea, illegally gifted Ukrainian Khrushchev Ukraine.

    Secondly, you need to stop shamanistic dances with tambourines around the criminal junta.

    After that, we can talk about something concretely - about "associations", security guarantees, agreements on conventional weapons, economic relations (including the notorious $ 3 billion in state debt to Russia), about Donetsk coal, Russian gas, military-technical cooperation, humanitarian problems.
    1. 0
      17 September 2015 13: 49
      Quote: Gormengast
      donated Ukrainian Khrushchev Ukraine

      They say that the true name of this bastard Perlmutter (translated from Yiddish = mother’s pearl).
  12. +5
    17 September 2015 08: 59
    Nonsense! The states do not need a solution to the Ukrainian problem, they do not need a way out of Ukraine from the crisis! They want more chaos on our borders!
  13. 0
    17 September 2015 08: 59
    As "hell" smelled, so immediately from the "goblin" into a normal language ..., luring into protracted negotiations.
  14. +3
    17 September 2015 09: 03
    Now Ukraine, more and more begins to play the role of "weights", on the feet of the EU, whose main problem, at the moment, is emigrants. So, I think that soon in Ukraine and in the matter of the implementation of all agreements, it will begin to change in a positive direction for Russia.
  15. 0
    17 September 2015 09: 03
    These are all bright theories. They are far from reality. It will be as it will be. Pintos will rest until the end.
  16. 0
    17 September 2015 09: 22
    With the junta and its support by the West
    there will be no changes.
  17. +1
    17 September 2015 09: 43
    These dreams of the American romantic about taming the Ukrainian crisis are illusory, as are the desire of Sir John Ashton to introduce Russians to sodomy and wild gay-European debauchery. Bloodthirsty US politicians, and behind them the gay-European tame pugs, are surprised and annoyed by the sudden appearance of a completely different Russia, which got in the way Western dependency and the cruel exploitation of "subhumans" And Ukraine is a storehouse of venal souls who are ready for a promise to allow them for free to ghostly gay European depraved values ​​to finally ruin their country .... And now Geyrope has no time for residents - lovers of freebies from Ukraine, now there in Due to the influx of refugees, there is the question of the survival of the EU.
  18. 0
    17 September 2015 10: 28
    Bounced in the dill. Then only a cliff and a free fall.
  19. 0
    17 September 2015 10: 47
    A neutral organization such as the OSCE
    such an OBSE is already an OBSA ... on monitoring the implementation of the Minsk agreements.
  20. 0
    17 September 2015 11: 56
    According to him, “in order to resolve the conflict, we should first of all reconsider the European security architecture.” O'Hanlon believes that "along with the implementation of the Minsk agreements and the granting of autonomy to Donbas, the former Soviet republics that are not members of NATO should receive neutral status on a permanent basis." And the guarantors of the sovereignty of these countries should be NATO and Russia.

    Plagiarism. Russia proposed this option 10 years ago, but the State Department and the EU-sovskie rejected it more than once. It seems that this time - purely "blah blah". stop
  21. 0
    17 September 2015 20: 12
    Somewhere there, everything remains - the Sevastopol Marine Plant, the Liphen Factory Roshen, the grain terminal in Sevastopol, hopes for a quiet old age ... a strong and reliable neighbor. Bitch, this Obama!

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar people (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned), Kirill Budanov (included to the Rosfinmonitoring list of terrorists and extremists)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"