Humor beyond?

The scandal with the publication of caricatures in “Charlie Hebdo” is gaining momentum. It is possible that the editors will be attracted to an international court. The public in social networks found in cartoons of a drowned Syrian boy a variety of meanings, including a poisonous mockery of migrants, as if traveling to Europe not for the sake of salvation, but because of the blessings of a well-fed and peaceful life. Cartoonists, however, do not agree with the public reaction.


Humor beyond?
One of the cartoons depicts Ilan lying on the sand. The above inscription: "So close to the goal." Nearby we see a fast food café banner: “Two children's menus for the price of one”


Recall the background.

Two weeks ago, journalist Nilufer Demir from Bodrum (Turkey) photographed the body of a three-year-old drowned Syrian boy named Alan Kurdi. His family fled Syria by sea. Overloaded boat capsized; the body of the child carried to the Turkish coast. A photograph of a Turkish journalist was sold in front pages of European newspapers.

The flash of the picture in a major press attracted the attention of the staff of the magazine “Charlie Hebdo”, which became “famous” for the whole world thanks to the caricatures of the Prophet Mohammed and the subsequent deadly terrorist attack.

This time, the artists depicted caricatures of the deceased Syrian boy. On the cover of the magazine appeared a dead child lying on the beach. Background: a big billboard with an advertisement for a fast food restaurant: “Two children's menus for the price of one.” And above the boy - the inscription: "So close to the goal."

And one more caricature: "Proof that Europe is Christian." It depicts a smiling bearded Jesus in a crown of thorns, easily walking on the water, and the boy's legs sticking out of the water. "Christians walk on water, and Muslim children are drowning," the cartoon says.

This time, the inhabitants of social networks did not shout "I am Charly", but subjected the magazine to sharp criticism.

According to many Internet users, “Charlie Hebdo” lost its bearings and attacked the “defenseless” with its drawings. The magazine was also accused of racism, intolerance, immorality and cynicism. It got to the point that the French community of black lawyers threatened to file a lawsuit in the International Criminal Court (ICC).

In Russia, social networks are also overwhelmed with comments about new French caricatures. The authors of the reviews consider the drawings “utterly abominable”, “mockery over the corpse”, “ridicule over Christianity”, as well as “ridicule over Islam”: they say, the artist had in mind the following: if Muslims drown, then “that's what they need”.

There is also such a (positive) interpretation of the drawings: “You (that is, Europeans) consider yourself to be Christians, and children are dying nearby!”

From such contradictory responses it can be seen that there is no single point of view on caricatures. People did not understand the idea of ​​cartoonists.

The noise in the networks and the press forced the authors of the cartoons to explain their creative idea. The explanation was made for Russian readers as well.

Initiated by the TV channel LifeNews: its employees turned to the editorial board of Charlie Hebdo with a request to decipher the meaning of the drawing. French cartoonists answered the letter.

“This tragic image of little Ailan has become a symbol of the plight of migrants and refugees today,” answered Charlie Hebdo. - Our works cover the same events as you (journalists. - LifeNews). It is human trafficking, organized by smugglers, and illegal migrants fleeing the disaster zone, and Europe’s inaction. ”

The editorial satirical edition complained that the audience does not know how to understand social satire. Caricaturists do not consider most of the accusations to be fair: after all, “Charlie Hebdo” stands for human rights and objects to discrimination.

“You need to be able to correctly read the message of this cartoon. This is ignorance that kills our colleagues and friends, the letter says. “Charlie Hebdo has always been on the side of equality, on the side of illegal migrants, always fighting against racism and discrimination, against injustice and abuse of authority.”


This cartoon, titled “Proof that Christian Europe”, shows Jesus walking along the water beside the boy. He says: “Christians walk on water. Muslim children are drowning. ”


Two excuses can be drawn from this excuse, we add.

The first. Probably, the cartoonists wanted to show that Europe had given the refugees to the mercy of Christ, doing almost nothing to save them.

Second. Cartoonists stepped up the moral line by drawing a fast food ad near the child. Could not resist, must be, from the black humor. And this “impetuous” caricature has led to a flurry of criticism from the world community. If the concept of one picture can still be interpreted, then questions arise to the other. Even more questions appear when you see both pictures side by side.

If an artist managed to do it with one illustration, the public might consider the publication to be bold or slightly beyond, but no more. Scandal could not be.

Again, the scandal for publication is an additional opportunity to attract attention. It is possible that the editors anticipated the scandal and even “anticipated” him.

Condemning the cartoons, we believe the public is right. The massive, on a global scale, lack of understanding of the social satire of the journal and a large number of its contradictory interpretations suggest that the authors should reconsider something in their approach, otherwise they will not have any admirers. In any art requires a clear understanding of the idea. If it is not, the artist loses benchmarks, unable to choose the main one. It is also good to have a sense of proportion.

Both of these items were broken by artists.

Good for the author to also thoroughly know your audience. In fact, today French caricaturists create illustrations for an audience that cannot understand them. But this means that the audience as such does not exist!

Instead of explaining the meaning of their drawings to the public, caricaturists would rather listen to criticism and apologize for the child at the billboard with fast food advertising.

As for the message about the “inaction of Europe,” Syrian President Bashar Assad spoke out clearly and unequivocally.

According to him, Europe, if it really wants to solve the problem of refugees, should stop supporting terrorists.

“The question is not whether Europe accepts refugees or not, but the need to remove the root causes of this problem,” the Syrian leader quotes. LifeNews. - If Europeans are concerned about the fate of the refugees, let them stop supporting the terrorists. This is our opinion on this issue. This is the essence of the refugee issue. ”

Further, Assad said about the possibility of reaching agreements between political forces in Syria, but expressed doubt that they can be implemented without a victory over terrorism.

Asad is absolutely right. But is Europe able to think? Not long ago, the French and British governments were eager to help. weapons and the bombing of "moderate opposition" to overthrow the "tyrant" of Assad and to carry out the ideas of "democracy" in Syria. Fighting Frenchman Hollande and hunter deer Cameron stopped two reasons: the disagreement of British parliamentarians and the reluctance to fight Barack Obama. Later, the “Islamic State” appeared in Syria and Iraq - the fruit of joint destructive activities of the West in the Middle East. The West is aware of the fear of militants cutting their heads, horrified by the number of refugees, but does not recognize its mistakes and does not wish to help Assad in the fight against thugs.

And this is what the real “Europe’s inaction” means.

Observed and commented on Oleg Chuvakin
- especially for topwar.ru
Ctrl Enter

Noticed a mistake Highlight text and press. Ctrl + Enter

106 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Kos_kalinki9 17 September 2015 05: 32 New
    • 17
    • 0
    +17

    Again, the scandal for the publication is an additional opportunity to attract attention. It is possible that the editors foresaw the scandal and even “anticipated it

    Once they have already "attracted" attention to themselves. What came of it? Guys play with fire, and matches for children are not a toy.
    1. Andrea 17 September 2015 06: 08 New
      • 19
      • 0
      +19
      Cretenism goes wild! It's just dementia, not freedom of speech.
      Apparently gentlemen are not able to earn money in any other way, it is impossible to explain this nonsense any more!
      1. Kos_kalinki9 17 September 2015 06: 21 New
        • 6
        • 0
        +6
        They generally do not even want to admit their mistakes. Well, are they really the ones who last shot easier from the fact that all “free and progressive humanity” insulted them? Or did they resurrect from this grief? Well, I regretted that we walked through the march and forgot. All.
        1. Private IITR 17 September 2015 07: 24 New
          • 10
          • 0
          +10
          Few magazines received last time, I would also add
          1. insafufa 17 September 2015 08: 22 New
            • 6
            • 0
            +6
            Probably soon the dad of this child will come to the editorial office and will shoot everyone as it was before

            Charley journalists got what they deserve and apparently still want fool
        2. Grabberxnumx 17 September 2015 17: 57 New
          • 3
          • 0
          +3
          Again we are waiting for literary and art critics with Kalash!
        3. boozer 17 September 2015 20: 15 New
          • 0
          • 0
          0
          And yesterday, when I saw when the police baton wet the poor refugees who survived in the meat grinder of the wars in Syria, Libya, Iraq, asking for basic, human help ... There are no words in short. Fascists in this Europe!
      2. insafufa 17 September 2015 08: 56 New
        • 18
        • 0
        +18
        Quote: Andrea
        Cretenism goes wild! It's just dementia, not freedom of speech.
        Apparently gentlemen are not able to earn money in any other way, it is impossible to explain this nonsense any more!
      3. Vend 17 September 2015 09: 32 New
        • 6
        • 0
        +6
        Quote: Andrea
        Cretenism goes wild! It's just dementia, not freedom of speech.
        Apparently gentlemen are not able to earn money in any other way, it is impossible to explain this nonsense any more!

        This is not freedom of speech, but freedom of lack of culture.
        The scandal with the publication of cartoons in "Charlie Hebdo" is gaining momentum. It is possible that the editorial board will be brought before an international court.
        But when they painted caricatures of Muslims or a terrorist attack in the Moscow metro, they were not brought to trial. Double standards, norm for Europe and the USA
        1. marlin1203 17 September 2015 10: 59 New
          • 3
          • 0
          +3
          First they set fire to the Middle East and waited until people ran out en masse from there. Then they told everyone to accept, though they did not say how and did not establish order. And now caricatures of dead children are being drawn ... ..
      4. 222222 17 September 2015 14: 55 New
        • 10
        • 0
        +10
        ...that's all....
    2. Kaluzhanin 17 September 2015 11: 43 New
      • 4
      • 0
      +4
      They hold all for idiots. "You are stupid that you do not understand our satire, not us!" - so it turns out. Those. all people are like people, I am the queen alone! There are topics that cannot be joked - parents (close relatives), death, religion. And they managed to combine all this in one image. Vile, low and vile. No need to explain to me that they wanted to show something completely different, but I, the dumb one, didn’t understand anything. I understood everything as my morality allows me to understand, but they don’t have it. They have no sympathy, God is their judge. They achieved what they wanted - noise by any means. In case of a negative reaction, they prepared "noble" answers and now they unsubscribe.
      1. Dilshat 17 September 2015 18: 24 New
        • 2
        • 0
        +2
        This "satire" beyond our understanding and I think of many Europeans. Europe is pulled back to fascism, to the dark ages and therefore to slaughter.
    3. Kos_kalinki9 17 September 2015 12: 25 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      You look, minusanuli. "tolerant" I got ......, at least I would explain what I disagree with, or even stealthily ...... That's how they sell Russia, quietly and stealthily !!!!!! (sorry, maybe too pathetic).
    4. sherp2015 17 September 2015 14: 11 New
      • 2
      • 0
      +2
      Quote: Kos_kalinki9
      Kos_kalinki9 (3) Today, 05:32 New

      Again, the scandal for the publication is an additional opportunity to attract attention. It is possible that the editors foresaw the scandal and even “anticipated it
      Once they have already "attracted" attention to themselves. What came of it? Guys play with fire, and matches for children are not a toy.



      This is Charlie, in my opinion, specific arsonists and provocateurs ...
  2. evil partisan 17 September 2015 05: 43 New
    • 10
    • 0
    +10
    They come to life. They will come to them a second time.
    1. beer-youk 17 September 2015 11: 41 New
      • 3
      • 0
      +3
      And in the second and third ... Yes, even in the thousandth! Magazines are such a genotype that only considers its opinion to be the ultimate truth and despises everyone who reads its bowel movements.
      And almost in topic. "The first case of prostitution in the history of mankind has been widely covered in all the many thousands of media"
  3. S_Baykala 17 September 2015 05: 44 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    The coast is lost. . U. o.d. I hope Muslims will not forgive them for this. In antiquity, because of a smaller war began.
  4. Sergey Sitnikov 17 September 2015 05: 47 New
    • 10
    • 0
    +10
    Freedom of speech does not imply the right to cast oneself out and mock other people's grief, just such actions of the “free” are a vivid illustration of arbitrariness as freedom outside the mind ((((
    1. GRAY 17 September 2015 08: 09 New
      • 24
      • 0
      +24
      Quote: Sergey Sitnikov
      Freedom of speech does not imply the right to cast oneself out and mock other people's grief, just such actions of the “free” are a vivid illustration of arbitrariness as freedom outside the mind ((((

      It’s not they alone who create “illustrations”.
      If you turn off emotions, then what can be called a step-by-step instruction below: "How to organize the shooting of a dead boy"

      1. Scour the coast in search of nature, find the corpse of a child

      2. Move the corpse to a suitable landscape.

      3. Beautifully placed in the sand.

      4. Invite colleagues to a photo shoot.

      Here!

      And - yes - those who wept while watching this video can relax and drain the tears.
      You once again nae misled.
      Then - they do not cry.
      This is media, kids.
      1. Jack-b 17 September 2015 08: 33 New
        • 3
        • 0
        +3
        Emotions turn off? People too cease to be? Man, you're wrong.
        1. GRAY 17 September 2015 08: 49 New
          • 9
          • 0
          +9
          Quote: Jack-B
          Emotions turn off? People too cease to be? Man, you're wrong.

          Otherwise, it will not be possible to fully realize what you see.
          In this situation with Charlie, I see that some cynical people just mocked at other, no less cynical people.
          I think that all the noise arose because the magazine employees dared to abuse the picture carefully created for the media and will undoubtedly be punished for it.
          When they used to give out cartoons on similar topics, for some reason, nobody cared.
          And then they immediately lifted the OP - in my opinion everything is obvious.
          1. Jack-b 17 September 2015 12: 15 New
            • 1
            • 0
            +1
            My youngest son is three years old, he is the same age. I am fully aware of what I see.
        2. aleks 62 next 17 September 2015 13: 06 New
          • 7
          • 0
          +7
          .... Disable emotions? People too cease to be? Man, you're wrong ....


          .... And where were THEIR emotions when in the Donbass such dozens of "boys" were shown on TV ???? .... I agree that the PR campaign is very well organized ....
      2. aurano 17 September 2015 08: 42 New
        • 1
        • 0
        +1
        Yes, I do not want to cry, just clench my teeth and fists harder.
      3. Hon
        Hon 17 September 2015 11: 45 New
        • 3
        • 0
        +3
        Quote: GRAY
        And - yes - those who wept while watching this video can relax and drain the tears.
        Once again, you have been misled by nae.
        Then - they do not cry.
        This is media, kids.

        only the child’s corpse is real, and it doesn’t matter where it was originally
        1. GRAY 17 September 2015 13: 18 New
          • 2
          • 0
          +2
          Quote: Hon
          only the child’s corpse is real, and it doesn’t matter where it was originally

          Well, yes, the real one. Just lay ugly.
          Bringing information to people and using information for their own purposes are two different things.
          In this case, this is exactly the use. You do not think that this is the first children's corpse nailed to the shore?
          1. Kos_kalinki9 17 September 2015 19: 19 New
            • 0
            • 0
            0
            Sergei! I beg you, you can’t mock death. We are all ugly leaving this life.
  5. B.T.V. 17 September 2015 05: 49 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    The actions of Europe and the United States in the fight against IG are similar to the treatment of cough laxatives.
  6. Moore 17 September 2015 05: 56 New
    • 7
    • 0
    +7
    The editorial satirical edition complained that the audience does not know how to understand social satire.

    The biggest trouble with this “satirical” vomit is that it’s never funny.
    Which does not negate the presence of satyrs in this "worthy" edition, as such - well, those with horns, tails and hooves.
    1. aleks 62 next 17 September 2015 13: 09 New
      • 1
      • 0
      +1
      ... The biggest trouble with this "satirical" vomit is that it’s never funny ....

      .... Satire does not always have to be funny ... But with the statement: "..... fleeing to Europe not for the sake of salvation, but because of the benefits of a well-fed and peaceful life ....." - I agree ... . Well, Greece, Romania, Italy do not suit them - they don’t shoot there ..... So what is the conversation ???? .... hi
  7. VNP1958PVN 17 September 2015 05: 57 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    It became a shame to everyone who shouted - "I am Charlie" and it’s difficult to wash off shit!
    1. Stanislas 17 September 2015 06: 39 New
      • 22
      • 0
      +22
      Quote: VNP1958PVN
      It became a shame to everyone who shouted - "I am Charlie" and it’s difficult to wash off shit!
      You think these ... have shame?
      Will these be laundered?
      1. boozer 17 September 2015 20: 10 New
        • 2
        • 0
        +2
        Yes, there are no any European values, this is fake, bluff! In Europe, arrogant cynics, with a degrading religion, a substitution of the concepts of family, sexual debauchery, and much more ... And by the way, yes - they are all Charlie ebdo !!! We are NOT!
  8. Utlan 17 September 2015 06: 01 New
    • 10
    • 0
    +10
    The death of a child is always a tragedy and no matter what color his skin and creed. And those who laugh at it are people without morality.
    1. B.T.V. 17 September 2015 06: 20 New
      • 8
      • 0
      +8
      Quote: Utlan
      The death of a child is always a tragedy and no matter what color his skin and creed. And those who laugh at it are people without morality.


      And where in Europe and the USA, especially recently, have you seen "morality" ?! There, morality has long been replaced by tolerance (the word is how vile).
    2. Andrei from Chelyabinsk 17 September 2015 07: 55 New
      • 11
      • 0
      +11
      Quote: Utlan
      And those who laugh at it are people without morality.

      Yes, what kind of people ... an animal, and then with the loss of cubs suffers. And these are unicellular.
    3. Andrei from Chelyabinsk 17 September 2015 07: 55 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      Quote: Utlan
      And those who laugh at it are people without morality.

      Yes, what kind of people ... an animal, and then with the loss of cubs suffers. And these are unicellular.
  9. Stas 86 17 September 2015 06: 16 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    Who is the customer?
    This is how civilizations clash today.
  10. The comment was deleted.
  11. strelets 17 September 2015 06: 29 New
    • 6
    • 0
    +6
    You can scoff at the death of a child. But it is impossible to criticize the Americans and support Russia. Strange freedom of speech.
  12. sagitch 17 September 2015 06: 35 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    I won’t be surprised if the second shooter of journalists turns out to be ..., the father of the deceased boy.
  13. sa-zz 17 September 2015 06: 40 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    S.K.o.t.y, nothing sacred. Then they are surprised that terrorist attacks occur.
  14. aurano 17 September 2015 06: 44 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    It’s just a business, anyway what to do grandmas. Their cartoons will not rise above the image of genetics on school desks. Dullness and sheer cretinism in the West is called "freedom"
  15. Combitor 17 September 2015 06: 48 New
    • 5
    • 0
    +5
    Once they arranged a demonstration shooting. I think that they will soon ask for the demolition of the editorial building with all the inhabitants ... I will not say that I will regret it.
  16. Bayonet 17 September 2015 07: 01 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    "including the venomous mockery of migrants, as if fleeing to Europe not for the sake of salvation, but because of the benefits of a well-fed and peaceful life."
    Why do refugees seek precisely to Germany or England? When a journalist asked one of them why not stay in Hungary, he replied: "the standard of living is not the same." That is the whole answer. The allowance of 400 euros is not bad at all - many of our compatriots have less wages! This is definitely a "poisonous mockery!"
    1. Stanislas 17 September 2015 07: 10 New
      • 7
      • 0
      +7
      Quote: Bayonet
      That's the whole answer.
      Canalize the hatred of those who are guilty of chaos in the Middle East? Do you want to blame everything on the craving for a well-fed and idle life in Germany that suddenly awoke from the Syrians? Maybe we need to apologize to Charlie?
      1. Bayonet 17 September 2015 07: 34 New
        • -10
        • 0
        -10
        Quote: Stanislav
        Canalize the hatred of those who are guilty of chaos in the Middle East?

        Don’t choke with hatred, everything is already saturated with it! And your Charlie, to me a light bulb, I’m more worried about the Russians!
        1. Stanislas 17 September 2015 07: 47 New
          • 2
          • 0
          +2
          Quote: Bayonet
          Do not choke with hate
          And you will not choke with laughter when you look at the cartoons associated with this event
          1. Bayonet 17 September 2015 08: 43 New
            • 1
            • 0
            +1
            Unlike you, I do not enjoy viewing photos of corpses. I am not interested in caricatures in French publications. And also Arab and others - there are more interesting things hi
            I recalled the words of a member of the house committee from "Dog Heart"
            "Professor, you do not like the children of Germany ?!"
            1. Stanislas 17 September 2015 09: 02 New
              • 1
              • 0
              +1
              Quote: Bayonet
              I am not interested in caricatures in French publications.
              I understand that you got involved in the discussion of caricatures in the French edition without any interest, but it is worth remembering that the appetite comes with eating.
              1. Bayonet 17 September 2015 09: 10 New
                • 0
                • 0
                0
                Quote: Stanislav
                I understand that you got involved in the discussion of caricatures in the French edition without any interest

                I just opened the page, although I imagined in advance what kind of comments there would be smile I'm more interested in technology and history, but unfortunately something else prevails. hi And you, I’ll see a lover of such creativity (your drawing) smile ?
                1. Stanislas 17 September 2015 09: 27 New
                  • 0
                  • 0
                  0
                  Quote: Bayonet
                  your drawing)?
                  Trying to catch your style of associating your opponent’s comments. It turns out?
                  1. Bayonet 17 September 2015 09: 49 New
                    • 0
                    • 0
                    0
                    Quote: Stanislav
                    Trying to catch your style of associating your opponent’s comments.

                    Really, you should not waste time on me, it distracts from the fight, and the enemy does not sleep! smile hi
                    1. Stanislas 17 September 2015 10: 14 New
                      • -4
                      • 0
                      -4
                      Quote: Bayonet
                      Really don't waste time on me
                      You set an example for us. Who does not want to become a marshal (a rhetorical question). I’ll just train with emoticons and ... repeat
                      1. Bayonet 17 September 2015 10: 42 New
                        • 0
                        • 0
                        0
                        Quote: Stanislav
                        Who does not want to become a marshal (a rhetorical question). I’ll just train with emoticons and ...

                        Good luck! hi
                      2. aleks 62 next 17 September 2015 13: 35 New
                        • 0
                        • 0
                        0
                        ..... Who does not want to become a marshal (a rhetorical question). ....

                        .... And who is stopping you from becoming ???? .... The issue price is only 100000 rating ..... Good luck !!!! hi
    2. forester 17 September 2015 20: 15 New
      • -1
      • 0
      -1
      Quote: Bayonet
      "including the venomous mockery of migrants, as if fleeing to Europe not for the sake of salvation, but because of the benefits of a well-fed and peaceful life."
      Why do refugees seek precisely to Germany or England? When a journalist asked one of them why not stay in Hungary, he replied: "the standard of living is not the same." That is the whole answer. The allowance of 400 euros is not bad at all - many of our compatriots have less wages! This is definitely a "poisonous mockery!"

      In destroyed Libya and Syria, the standard of living was not lower than in Germany and England, so those who flee have the right to receive from those who bombed their countries and live at their expense
  17. Glot 17 September 2015 07: 02 New
    • 7
    • 0
    +7
    This nonsense is from permissiveness, which makes it possible to scoff at the feelings of other people, or a provocation in order to bring migrants to retaliatory actions and then, with this sauce, start pressing them hard, who knows.
    But one thing is clear, caricaturists are these people with clearly downed moral and ethical guidelines. And if they are shot there again, as then, they will not feel sorry for them a bit.
  18. mr.vasilievich 17 September 2015 07: 06 New
    • 6
    • 0
    +6
    The Charlie editorial staff lacks humor. They are engaged in ernichany, mockery of the feelings of people. There is no sense of responsibility, they incite religious and racial hostility and at the same time they are narcissistic and consider themselves the most intelligent.
  19. parusnik 17 September 2015 07: 14 New
    • 7
    • 0
    +7
    If Europeans care about the fate of refugees, let them stop supporting terrorists.... But there are no caricatures on this subject
  20. Aslan88 17 September 2015 07: 15 New
    • 9
    • 0
    +9
    And this is a democratic Europe. And UTB is the wing of democracy. they have no morality. That's why i hate europe angry . And that’s why I respect Russia. This would not be allowed in Russia.
  21. rotmistr60 17 September 2015 07: 49 New
    • 9
    • 0
    +9
    didn’t shout “I am Charlie”

    And I want to ask Europe and the French in particular: If, suddenly, a new incident occurs with this edition, you again, holding hands and decoding, go out onto the French street (though separately from the people)? By supporting them last time, you completely untied their hands. And you have to blame yourself.
  22. far
    far 17 September 2015 08: 02 New
    • 6
    • 0
    +6
    For starters, let Europe be in the shoes of the Serbs - when they were kicked out of Kosovo (this is the heart of Serbia), and then they will tell in the Psaki style that the Arabs have many relatives in Germany and they are going to visit their grandmothers (when almost a million refugees came to Russia from Donbass, not a single European Judas even scratched his head, really like the Ukrainians - And for us, for that. "
    1. Bayonet 17 September 2015 09: 57 New
      • -2
      • 0
      -2
      Quote: far
      For starters, let Europe be in the shoes of the Serbs

      I will tell you one terrible secret - Serbia is still in Europe! smile And you thought where? hi
  23. Volga Cossack 17 September 2015 08: 13 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    again???? the second part of????? Well, well - they will come to them one more time.
  24. K-50 17 September 2015 08: 13 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    Judging by the saying "a cat scratches its ridge" these "guys" from "Charlie Hebdo" the previous lesson did not teach anything, as they say "fix a humpback grave!" am
  25. Nyrobsky 17 September 2015 08: 13 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    This is not humor - this is idiocy.
  26. Russia 17 September 2015 08: 13 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    Roughly, but practically all of Europe fucked up from "tolerance."
  27. Anita 17 September 2015 08: 15 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    But what do they not draw caricatures on the graves of their dead colleagues?
  28. thinker 17 September 2015 08: 18 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    Yes...! This is all for the ZZ project.
    “Tolerance and apathy are the last two virtues of a dying society.”
    Aristotle
  29. the47th 17 September 2015 08: 19 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    And even provocative caricatures of them look wretched. My first-grader niece draws better.
  30. Alex_2015 17 September 2015 08: 40 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    I wonder why in Paris there is no march with the slogan "I am Charlie"?
    1. Stanislas 17 September 2015 10: 05 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      Quote: Alex_2015
      I wonder why in Paris there is no march with the slogan "I am Charlie"?
      Paris is not the same ... It is believed that in Paris there may already be relatives of this deceased family.
  31. meriem1 17 September 2015 08: 48 New
    • 5
    • 0
    +5
    And it's not just that. This is a cast in search of FACE !!! The world is probed for lice. Cove hatched and promoted. The search for the verge of permissible ...... direct road to the manipulation of consciousness.
  32. Kradi 17 September 2015 08: 51 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    If this is the "European democratic values" so imposed by us by the Lebirastes, then they went to hell. In this case, I am against democracy.
    1. Bayonet 17 September 2015 09: 19 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      Quote: KraDI
      In this case, I am against democracy.

      And what do you prefer - dictatorship, plutocracy, or maybe a monarchy? hi
      1. Kradi 17 September 2015 12: 34 New
        • 0
        • 0
        0
        Monarchy or socialism, but not as it was in the USSR soldier
  33. Support 17 September 2015 08: 53 New
    • -7
    • 0
    -7
    But I don’t care. Drowned. Drawn. So what. If humor is not understood, what now? The opinion of some homosexuals of both sexes from geyropa cannot for me have any meaning. Love to write books for children about poop? Let these cartoons eat ....
    1. IDV68 17 September 2015 22: 28 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      Prop (8) Today, 08:53 AM New
      But I don’t care. Drowned. Drawn. So what.
      Do you have children, woodpecker? The child drowned, does it matter?
  34. sinukvl 17 September 2015 09: 13 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    This is sacrilege, designed for spiritual degenerates, and not otherwise! And judging by the reaction, or rather its absence, in Europe, these degenerates are 90% percent, if not more. If these are the democratic values ​​of European civilization, then I do not need such values ​​as European civilization itself!
    1. sieras 17 September 2015 11: 01 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      Well, do not tell. if you get caught screaming, then the fine is guaranteed. if you are caught when you litter, a fine is provided. Well, if no one sees, you can do anything, the main thing is not to get caught
  35. RuslanNN 17 September 2015 09: 24 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    Critters, nothing sacred.
  36. kirpich 17 September 2015 09: 35 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    Quote: sagitch
    I won’t be surprised if the second shooter of journalists turns out to be ..., the father of the deceased boy.


    If not drowned.
    1. Black 17 September 2015 12: 46 New
      • -1
      • 0
      -1
      Quote: kirpich
      If not drowned.


      No, praise be to Allah. Yesterday Rogatkin on "SK" showed his dok.film. There was just the father of the boy. About "kartinochki" did not know .....
  37. sir_obs 17 September 2015 09: 39 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    Really this time Charlie in ebdo get?
  38. Reptiloid 17 September 2015 09: 59 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    AGAIN stirring up ethnic hatred.
    ??? Children of Donbass ??. Children of Syria for 5 years ?? Children of Libya, Iraq? ? They have a neck like a giraffe or something?
  39. Bassoon 17 September 2015 10: 04 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    What else can I say? Charlie runs into the attack again. The scribbler is not sorry. Another thing is that ordinary citizens may suffer because of them.
  40. Zolotse 17 September 2015 10: 38 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    It seems that this edition is well received for provoking Muslims to righteous anger, and to further increase the atmosphere in Europe. The editors themselves, without influential customers and patrons, would not dare to take such risks and substitute. And they are looking for a reason to pit nations ... it’s not very new, and for them all means are good.
  41. Shadowcat 17 September 2015 10: 42 New
    • -1
    • 0
    -1
    And then someone will tell me again that they are innocent lambs, etc., etc. Few bombed.
  42. ivanovbg 17 September 2015 10: 51 New
    • 6
    • 0
    +6
    For everyone who has not yet fully understood what kind of demons Charlie Ebdo live, I publish emptying their brains after the terrorist attacks in the Moscow metro. Funny huh? And to me, for some reason, not really!
  43. sieras 17 September 2015 10: 58 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    already got this boy. Americans put 100 people in coffins at a time because of friendly fire. In Europe, a bunch of their people die for a variety of reasons. so any topic can be procrastinated
  44. Victor-M 17 September 2015 11: 09 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    From such contradictory responses it can be seen that there is no single point of view on caricatures. People did not understand the idea of ​​cartoonists.

    And here there’s nothing to understand, the meaning is the same - the West is killing.
  45. Villiam wolf 17 September 2015 11: 43 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    They really - from the beginning, found a dead child, put him on a more photogenic basis, and then invited journalists for a photo shoot!?! If so, so filth !!! both in Turkey and in Europe, cynical and deprived of a pure conscience and morality !!!
    1. GRAY 17 September 2015 12: 07 New
      • 1
      • 0
      +1
      Quote: Villiam Wolf
      They that really

      Yes indeed.
      Everything in order to soften the Europeans, put pressure on politicians and direct the flow of refugees to Europe.
  46. LeftPers 17 September 2015 11: 44 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    If they (Charlie) are bombed again, then it will be 100% of their fault and no one will cry.
  47. DimanC 17 September 2015 12: 20 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    Quote: aurano
    Yes, I do not want to cry, just clench my teeth and fists harder.

    Charlie Ebdo is exactly what works for it: on the one hand, the United States is driving ISIS to bring refugees to Europe, among which young people are specially brought in (ready-made human material for creating bandit formations), as well as Albanian and other terrorists (these are future ideological gurus and commanders). The refugees are crammed with the idea that Europe bombed them, which means that it should be taken care of at the proper level. On the other hand, such cartoons solve the problem of creating tension between locals and visitors - here you have a ready-made information field for conflicts. The task of the United States is to organize a great war in Europe. It doesn’t work through Ukraine, therefore they’ll look for any other place. So the actions of the SE are just one of the stages of unleashing a big war.
    1. IDV68 17 September 2015 22: 34 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      Agree to all 1000
      +++++++
  48. kit-kat 17 September 2015 12: 22 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    I don’t understand why everyone was so excited? All are tender, all have sick feelings. So you can’t speak badly and draw drawings on Muslim people, but please on others? Do not you think that it smacks of hypocrisy or even a fawning in front of muslims? No matter how offended and kicked us. An exhibition with the heads of Christian saints was held in Moscow. Everything is fine. When the offended Christians tried to destroy it, they paid. Where is the logic? Of course, I do not care for all religious tricks, but still. Where is justice and common sense?
    1. IDV68 17 September 2015 22: 35 New
      • -1
      • 0
      -1
      Read the comment above, chocolate.
      1. kit-kat 18 September 2015 10: 53 New
        • 0
        • 0
        0
        In fact of the matter. That their activity is aimed at a fragile consciousness, childishly tender and touchy. But I want to believe that in Russia, at least, sane people live. No, no. All this is sad. Offended by pictures is the lot of religious savages and children.
  49. sledge 17 September 2015 12: 26 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    The time will come Geyropa wash away with bloody tears
  50. Taoist 17 September 2015 13: 07 New
    • -1
    • 0
    -1
    Looking at this "crazy world" I personally acutely feel that I am becoming a complete misanthrope. And it's really scary. Because these are the "Charlie" they wash out any emotions in general. I understand with horror that I don’t feel sorry for anyone at all - not even my beloved, that in this way humanity vigorously proves that it deserves nothing but napalm and cluster bombs.
    1. kit-kat 17 September 2015 16: 25 New
      • 1
      • 0
      +1
      Yes. Just Charlie to do with it? Remember our Crocodile. There were worse pictures. For some reason, no one came to poop. And to humanity indeed, it is time to already teach a lesson. Just how to do this so that the animals do not suffer?
      1. siberalt 17 September 2015 19: 31 New
        • 0
        • 0
        0
        What can I say. Do not go where you can be offended. Kohl made a choice, endure and bear your cross with dignity. hi

        Can burn a Mosfilm for this film?
      2. The comment was deleted.