Military Review

German director: Russia did not invade Ukraine

58
Director from Germany Mark Bartalmay took a documentary tape about the conflict in the Donbass and the political crisis that preceded him, reports Ридус.




The director has lived in Ukraine for over a year. In his film “Ukrainian agony. The hidden war "he tried to build the whole chain of events that led the country to an internal military confrontation.

“We tried to show not the fighting itself, but the chronology of events and what is happening here in the Crimea or Odessa. These are all the consequences of the Maidan, and not the fact that Russia invaded Ukraine "- said Bartalmay.

The film has already been shown in Berlin and Donetsk, “now it's Moscow’s turn”, said the director.

“Many prokaty do not want to show the film, as they fear the reaction of the Germans to him. After all, what is displayed in the German press contradicts what is shown in the film, ”he said.

Photos used:
mil.gov.ua
58 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. oleg-gr
    oleg-gr 31 August 2015 15: 16 New
    +99
    The film contradicts the official version. That's the "freedom of speech" in European.
    1. milann
      milann 31 August 2015 15: 20 New
      +58
      Quote: oleg-gr
      The film contradicts the official version. That's the "freedom of speech" in European.

      And there is the same “freedom of speech”, as well as “democracy”.
      All this "Anglo-Saxon plutocracy" is called.
      1. marlin1203
        marlin1203 31 August 2015 15: 23 New
        +43
        It’s good that anti-fascists still remained in Germany! Not all is lost.
        1. Sigurd
          Sigurd 31 August 2015 22: 32 New
          +8
          In Germany, unfortunately there are plenty of anti-fascists, who are actually neo-fascists. Democracy is in a beautiful wrapper and lies in all its compartments, it leads to the destruction of national identity and, as a result, the destruction of the state.
          1. Weyland
            Weyland 1 September 2015 19: 17 New
            +1
            Quote: Sigurd
            In Germany, unfortunately there are plenty of antifascists who are actually neo-fascists


            There is such an old joke:
            German "anti-fascists" are divided into 2 categories - anti-fascists and fascists! laughing
        2. DMB_95
          DMB_95 2 September 2015 15: 49 New
          +3
          In Germany there are still few people with brains. The fact that the Russian Army does not fight in Ukraine, the directors already understand. And one retired German general said last year that regular Russian troops would take Kiev in a maximum of 48 hours. You will not drink experience.
    2. sever.56
      sever.56 31 August 2015 15: 22 New
      +47
      Quote: oleg-gr
      The film is contrary to the official version


      Yes you are right. This film is the voice of one crying in the wilderness ...
      Politicians of the European West are well aware of what is happening in Ukraine, but they can’t do anything, because Obama took them by the throat in such a way that they cannot breathe without his approval. The states dragged Europe into their crazy adventures in the Middle East, from there went an uncontrolled flow of migrants, again to Europe. It seems that the goal of the Americans is to bring chaos to Europe. And they, behind a puddle, will sit out and be in chocolate against the background of a mess and the Islamization of Europe. The EU has already become a vassal of states.
      1. Truth
        Truth 31 August 2015 15: 36 New
        +16
        Quote: sever.56
        since Obama took them so by the throat

        Too much honor, to take them by the throat ... by the Faberge, he holds them ... all these euro-routers.
        1. Koshak
          Koshak 1 September 2015 21: 48 New
          +3
          Quote: Truth
          ... for Faberge, he holds them ... all these euro-routers.

          Then for the loin. And then Merkel and Faberge, as it does not fit together.
      2. ermolai
        ermolai 31 August 2015 16: 28 New
        +4
        Quote: sever.56
        Obama took them by the throat so much that they cannot even breathe without his approval. States pulled Europe into their crazy adventures

        well, for what smoked people took them, everyone knows that, but the states didn’t pull them in, they just pulled the geyropus on the banana shoot, more precisely, and then Europe pulled it in according to the tonsils.
      3. Sergey Vl.
        Sergey Vl. 2 September 2015 19: 03 New
        +1
        And they, beyond the puddle, will sit out

        You are right, from the Libya the Atlantic on a dilapidated vessel with a steaming motor will not move ... Everything to Geyropu!
    3. EvaFerrari
      EvaFerrari 31 August 2015 15: 30 New
      +18
      I don’t remember who said it, but the meaning of the phrase is: “Under the slogans of freedom of speech and democracy, the most bloody crimes have been committed in history”
    4. Samaritan
      Samaritan 31 August 2015 15: 30 New
      +15
      Finally released, otherwise I thought it was a sinful thing to hushed up ...
      it’s a pity that there are few such truthful and true journalists!
    5. Major Yurik
      Major Yurik 31 August 2015 15: 39 New
      +16
      It took the Westerners a year to realize that on 08.08.08/XNUMX/XNUMX our peacekeepers did not shell themselves and killed themselves. Seven years have passed since then and the cynicism in their heads has grown to enormous proportions. So I think about five years, for their recognition of obvious things, they will procrastinate !!! am
    6. armageddon
      armageddon 31 August 2015 15: 52 New
      +8
      I am glad that there are still worthy journalists !!! It’s a pity that a little ...
    7. jaguar
      jaguar 31 August 2015 15: 58 New
      +12
      Please do not confuse officials and ordinary people. Very many are well aware of what is actually happening. I communicate with many from Europe and with friends from Israel ... believe me, thanks to the Internet, people have learned to figure out which of hu.
    8. vodolaz
      vodolaz 31 August 2015 17: 40 New
      +4
      Quote: oleg-gr
      The film contradicts the official version. That's the "freedom of speech" in European.

      So in the UK they attack RT, but the Air Force is above the law, as it reflects the official version of the events. Look, when you see news about separatists in the tape of the same mile, then 99% is news from the Air Force.
    9. Nikolay K
      Nikolay K 31 August 2015 18: 09 New
      +1
      Nowhere do they like someone’s version to diverge from the official, we also
    10. yushch
      yushch 31 August 2015 18: 34 New
      +4
      We hope that the Internet will fix the problem of the refusal of the distributors to demonstrate this film and everyone in the world will be able to see it.
    11. kig
      kig 1 September 2015 03: 22 New
      +3
      There was such an anecdote in Soviet times on the topic of freedom of speech: I, too, can go to Red Square and shout “Reagan for soap,” and there will be nothing for me.
    12. silinigo
      silinigo 1 September 2015 22: 36 New
      -1
      why is everyone so drawn to the geyropu ?? that Peter is crazy ... that all the following liberalists ??
  2. Erland
    Erland 31 August 2015 15: 18 New
    +10
    "Truth" is now being removed to order, and such Truth is not held in high esteem by those in power. "To whom is war, and to whom is mother dear."
    1. AUL
      AUL 31 August 2015 18: 22 New
      +2
      There are also mongrel there, who will declare the director "the fifth column" and the white carpet (well, in their German terminology)!
      1. antipendos
        antipendos 1 September 2015 20: 39 New
        +1
        AUL
        (well, in their German terminology)!
        Now, or they’ll even find houses dead due to a heart attack
  3. taburetka
    taburetka 31 August 2015 15: 19 New
    +14
    There would be more such directors and the world would see what is happening in reality in the Donbass. Reproaching Western Media
  4. ALEA IACTA EST
    ALEA IACTA EST 31 August 2015 15: 19 New
    +8
    Some are already seeing. Perhaps in about twenty years it will reach their power.
    1. avia1991
      avia1991 31 August 2015 16: 58 New
      +4
      Quote: ALEA IACTA EST
      Perhaps in about twenty years it will reach their power.

      In the power that "they" that we have, do not go. They are sitting! The moral image, the prohibitive level of cynicism is not necessarily inherent in people without brains. So that they all understand perfectly! But they do, nevertheless, in accordance with the overseas doctrine. And this economic benefit can only change this situation, which they cannot refuse!
      So, does the truth “reach” the West, despite the efforts of all normal people - this is a big question.
  5. RUSIVAN
    RUSIVAN 31 August 2015 15: 19 New
    +14
    German director: Russia did not invade Ukraine.
    The State Department has already expressed concern about this version of the German director?
  6. Alexey-74
    Alexey-74 31 August 2015 15: 20 New
    +16
    You need to throw it on the Internet, this tape will find its viewers ....
  7. atamankko
    atamankko 31 August 2015 15: 21 New
    +12
    Thank God there are still people
    who are not afraid of the truth.
  8. andrei332809
    andrei332809 31 August 2015 15: 22 New
    +42
    ----------------------
    1. Snake AAA
      Snake AAA 31 August 2015 15: 28 New
      +4
      Cool sketch :))))! Have fun, thanks !!!
  9. polite people
    polite people 31 August 2015 15: 27 New
    +6
    At least one normal person was found. More to such.
  10. sl22277
    sl22277 31 August 2015 15: 28 New
    +5
    An honest film, an honest director. I wish this film a successful rolling fate and insight to the Europeans ...
    1. veksha50
      veksha50 31 August 2015 16: 37 New
      +4
      Quote: sl22277
      An honest film, an honest director. I wish this film a successful rolling fate and insight to the Europeans ...



      Unfortunately, the rental itself is unlikely to take place ... shut up, block, putty all channels ... So that’s just the Internet ...

      PS Angela would scroll every morning, forcing to look ...
    2. antipendos
      antipendos 1 September 2015 20: 44 New
      0
      sl22277 SU
      Honest film, honest director.
      It is interesting that they will say about this on the censor.
  11. chelovektapok
    chelovektapok 31 August 2015 15: 30 New
    +7
    Sense of b / y "invade"? They shoot themselves, they blow up. All events, including the most recent, are evidence of this. To introduce troops of the Russian Federation means to designate the "enemy" to schizophrenics, paranoid and maniacs. They successfully destroy themselves by suicide and near the Verkhovna Rada. Rocks when the loot is shared, not even animals, but intestinal protozoa. Activity in devouring those around them only in a state of freezing ceases along with processes in brainless organisms. Frosty and snowy winters dill, without the usual free Russian gas!
  12. rf xnumx
    rf xnumx 31 August 2015 15: 30 New
    +25
    Russia did not invade Ukraine
    The ruins leadership has a different opinion ...
  13. Alexey Boukin
    Alexey Boukin 31 August 2015 15: 32 New
    +9
    Quote: sever.56
    It seems that the goal of the Americans is to bring chaos to Europe. And they, beyond the puddle, sit out and will be in chocolate

    Yes, this is not an impression at all, but a fact. America absolutely does not need a single strong Europe. Her goal is to be a “watchman” in a world that everyone will obediently obey.
    1. Temples
      Temples 31 August 2015 16: 20 New
      +8
      The sole purpose of creating the EU is the unified management of all EU members.
      It’s easier. Rather than agree with each Member.
      The choice was either you are an independent state or a Member.
      They (Europeans) decided to be Members! With what I congratulate them.
  14. EvgNik
    EvgNik 31 August 2015 15: 46 New
    +5
    Have we shown it? The box is off, so I'm out of touch. But I think they won’t show it, they say it is too small for us.
  15. AdekvatNICK
    AdekvatNICK 31 August 2015 15: 49 New
    +16
    The voice of Germany about the shooting of a true film about the Donbass.
  16. roskot
    roskot 31 August 2015 15: 57 New
    +4
    From European democracy for a long time smacks of. She does not accept such films.
  17. Oman 47
    Oman 47 31 August 2015 16: 08 New
    +3
    So the Germans on their TV for a long time, back in the 14th year, with might and main troll horses.
    YouTube has a lot of info on this topic.
    The climacteric grandmother is one thing, the Germans have long figured out that
    "No matter how much the wolf feeds, the ass is thicker."
  18. olimpiada15
    olimpiada15 31 August 2015 16: 09 New
    +2
    It is a pity that the film will be uploaded to the Internet at the end of the year.
    In the West, it is still few who see it-freedom and democracy there only for paid information.
    And the appearance on the Internet would help many people see the truth about the Donbass.
    It is no secret that very many, including in Russia, do not know the truth.
    I would like to see a movie.
  19. Dim Bes
    Dim Bes 31 August 2015 16: 22 New
    +6
    By the standards of Western journalism, the director of the film is very strange: crawls under bullets, shows the unnecessary Truth, and most importantly, "ruins" his career. After all, he will not make a name there on this film, the topic is not popular, and He is speaking on the wrong side. This "Exception to the rule." All the more respect we will receive.
    Thanks to AdekvatNICK (1) for the movie about filming.
  20. sv68
    sv68 31 August 2015 16: 40 New
    +3
    Yes, everyone there understands everything well, but not everyone will remain a decent and honest person and go against the system !!! the better for us that this German turned out to be a man and not an eurotruder.
  21. Patriot 771
    Patriot 771 31 August 2015 16: 50 New
    +1
    Quote: chelovektapok
    Sense of b / y "invade"? They shoot themselves, they blow up. All events, including the most recent, are evidence of this. To introduce troops of the Russian Federation means to designate the "enemy" to schizophrenics, paranoid and maniacs. They successfully destroy themselves by suicide and near the Verkhovna Rada. Rocks when the loot is shared, not even animals, but intestinal protozoa. Activity in devouring those around them only in a state of freezing ceases along with processes in brainless organisms. Frosty and snowy winters dill, without the usual free Russian gas!

    It is somehow very hard to find at least something suitable human for them. And there are very few enlighteners by the number of those killed. Anger begins to speak and nothing more.
  22. Berthan
    Berthan 31 August 2015 16: 53 New
    +5
    << ... Many rentals do not want to show the film, because they fear ... >>

    Is it so important?! Is the role of television exaggerated in our time? Still sitting on the dedicated lines ... Anyone who wants to see, hear, read, in general KNOW - will know ...
    1. arane
      arane 31 August 2015 19: 53 New
      +2
      Quote: BERTRAN
      << ... Many rentals do not want to show the film, because they fear ... >>

      Is it so important?! Is the role of television exaggerated in our time? Still sitting on the dedicated lines ... Anyone who wants to see, hear, read, in general KNOW - will know ...


      This role is even downplayed! The media is forming the "truth", and people are looking for confirmation of this. The rest is a priori a lie!
      And the truth is - Russia attacked Ukraine, captured Crimea, supported separatist bandits with arms and troops, shot down an airplane, and in general all the troubles of Ukraine over 140000 years because of Russians!

      All that is different is dirty lies and propaganda
  23. gladysheff2010
    gladysheff2010 31 August 2015 17: 08 New
    +1
    Whenever such a post is published, there are surely those who absolutely EXACTLY know: WHAT IS THE VOICE'S VOICE, etc. Maybe there is little consistency in the look, or is it a purposeful vision?! Well done director, man! Good rental! This tape sure to find your viewer! hi
  24. solovey
    solovey 31 August 2015 17: 11 New
    +3
    I don’t understand what << ... Many rentals do not want to show the film, because they fear ... >> can it really be that it will never open? What then will they be afraid of? request
    1. arane
      arane 31 August 2015 19: 57 New
      +2
      Quote: solovey
      I don’t understand what << ... Many rentals do not want to show the film, because they fear ... >> can it really be that it will never open? What then will they be afraid of? request


      Why won't it open? Everything is as before! Until the world is washed in blood .....
      Then they will repent
  25. Vladimir Pozlnyakov
    Vladimir Pozlnyakov 31 August 2015 17: 52 New
    +1
    They took into account the "mistake" of 2008, when the media came to their senses and only after 8 months began to admit that Georgia attacked Russia, and not vice versa! 1.5 years have passed already! Only now are rare and timid glimmers of truth appear in the Western media!
  26. AntonioPt
    AntonioPt 1 September 2015 04: 33 New
    0
    Do many have problems?

    - At work

    - In family

    - In health

    - In love


    Problems are a component of your life. However, all problems are easily solved.

    To do this, just look at what you are doing and bring out a common denominator that brings discord to the quality of your life.

    It so happened our society that everyone needs money !!!

    Money gives what you are missing.

    - Freedom. Freedom of choice, freedom of movement, freedom of thought.

    - Health. When you have enough money, you worry less, get nervous, so spend less health. You can easily be treated in the best clinics in the world. Learn the secrets of recovery, lead a healthy lifestyle.

    - Love. Love is one hundred percent responsibility for the happiness of another person. But how can one make a person happy if own happiness is a big question. A poor man cannot love, because there is nothing to give him !. His thoughts are preoccupied with the fear of losing his job, the fear that the other half will not survive and will go to the other. Fear that love ends because all the time, all thoughts and all attention are occupied with how to make money.

    These are not obvious facts, but there are other, more commonplace ones, but we will return to the most interesting.

    How to get money and all the components? Need to sell something!

    Goods, Time, Services. It’s good if you have something to sell!

    And what if there is nothing to sell, then you need to use what you have.

    1. If you have already fixed income, You can direct part of the funds to investments. Even if the amounts you measure are small. The discipline itself, stingy with interest on investments, will provide an opportunity to get a new goal that will help you raise your self-esteem, confidence in the future, and possibly revise your future plans.

    We choose a modern, highly profitable investment tool.

    We are aware of the fear that prevents a person from making a choice in favor of investing.

    We make a decision and set off on a pleasant path of financial independence.

    (Today, the PAMM account is considered to be the leading investment tool in the market. What is a PAMM account can be read here:

    http://www.bankcreds.ru/what_is_a_pamm_account.htm )

    2. If your income is very small, then you need to invest your time. To do this, you must also use a modern tool and use it to your advantage. Take the liberty of choosing a new profession for yourself. You can easily see that you can do it by looking at the old story about the king of stock futures: (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZH5_IhfFkAE), where ordinary people from the street earned billions of dollars, without much knowledge.

    We choose a modern, highly profitable, working tool.

    We are aware of the fear that prevents a person from deciding in favor of a new profession.

    We make a decision and set off on a pleasant path to financial education.

    Go to the website http://www.bankcreds.ru/, select the best investment tool and go ahead to your dreams.
  27. Vasisualiy
    Vasisualiy 1 September 2015 10: 51 New
    +3
    If pin-dosia changes his mind about ho-chlo-pithec, then the truth will be revealed right away. Stripes rule the ball in all Western leading media outlets. Psaki rule! They are like lemmings, running for minke whales.
  28. Balagan
    Balagan 1 September 2015 11: 10 New
    +3
    The Dutch have already opened the site with an apology addressed to Putin. The people are actively subscribing and not only the Dutch. Europe is still emerging, not everyone has maidanulis ...
  29. Wasiliy1985
    Wasiliy1985 1 September 2015 11: 55 New
    +3
    Quote from the novel by Valentin Pikul "To each his own":
    "Jefferson was over sixty, but he looked cheerful. He lived in modest simplicity, the president’s table was no different from the table of ordinary American citizens. At first, as usual, served boiled ham with dill, Mrs. Jefferson herself poured Moro peach vodka. In plates lay pickled pickles and boiled fruit. At the end of the dinner, they served fried chickens with boiled potatoes. This whole gastronomic mess did not interfere with the conversation. After listening to Moro’s story about the order in France, the president said:
    - I can sympathize with you - it was not easy under Napoleon. However, I know this! When I was Secretary of State under Washington, I was terribly ostracized in Philadelphia, and in the whole city only three families were not afraid to receive me. I then demanded very drastic measures - like Marat, like Robespierre! I was in a hurry to legitimize the rights of civil liberties ... And why was I in a hurry?
    “I have no idea,” Moreau said.
    - I was in a hurry to formalize freedom, while our presidents had not yet spoiled themselves in corruption and mercantile interests, until they were touched by bribery and bribes, while the ideals of freedom were not yet defiled. After me, ”said Jefferson,“ congressmen will not judge the people holy, as I judge. We Americans will surely slide down the mountain of democracy, and our presidents will no longer reckon with the rights of the people. And our people will forget about everything in the world, busy with one thing - making money, and America’s freedom will perish in convulsions ... "[12]

    Link [12] in V. Pikul’s novel: “Let the reader not be surprised at the prediction of T. Jefferson. His political views have long been falsified by US historians, they are simply silent about many of the“ prophecies ”of the third president. In the text I cite the true statements of T. Jefferson. "
  30. maxnemoy
    maxnemoy 1 September 2015 15: 14 New
    +3
    Finally, a sane person ...
  31. Evil 55
    Evil 55 1 September 2015 16: 05 New
    +3
    True, like plasticine ... It’s all the same somewhere, let it come out ...
  32. beer-youk
    beer-youk 1 September 2015 18: 25 New
    +2
    I am glad that among the young men there are such sane and talented people! This instills a fragile faith in the future!
  33. polkovnik manuch
    polkovnik manuch 1 September 2015 21: 01 New
    +2
    Do you colleagues really think that the leadership of the Geyropey states does not know the real situation on the outskirts? I answer: he knows perfectly well, just for the population all the information of the media is very carefully filtered, retouched, tinted, otherwise how to live on, because otherwise, the basic principle on which capitalism (imperialism) rests will collapse. If someone forgot, I remind you: "Divide and rule !"
  34. sellrub
    sellrub 1 September 2015 22: 51 New
    0
    Quote: milann
    Quote: oleg-gr
    The film contradicts the official version. That's the "freedom of speech" in European.

    And there is the same “freedom of speech”, as well as “democracy”.
    All this "Anglo-Saxon plutocracy" is called.

    Of course, it’s a shame that for more than 500 years the Anglo-Saxons have been trampling Russians together.
    For all that, these Anglo-Saxons are significantly better off than we Russians. I wonder why? I know for sure that the Russians were NEVER lazy.

    Recently I learned from the screen of Russian television that during the years of Napoleon's invasion (1812) the Russian church and the nobility declared him (Napoleon) by the Antichrist. Now, that sounds funny ... But! The question arises: And how else could in those years mobilize the Russian people against the aggressor? The army, after all ... WAS incompetent!
  35. yuriy55
    yuriy55 2 September 2015 16: 34 New
    0
    Yes, and so everything is clear. It remains to stop "doing a good face with a bad game" and demonstratively showing that Russia, everything happening in Europe, and in the world, the events of recent years are of little concern and concern so far as. This ongoing flirting with the states (in the hope of what? For relaxation? A 180-degree turn?) Needs to be finished. Only a real answer can stop the presumptuous and deceitful.
    And Germany should in a more intelligible form (the benefit of winter is just around the corner) explain and recall how the Second World War ended and how and what the United States took part in and how it ended ... Thank God, with German, judging by the past speeches, our President did not have difficulties ... yes
  36. akm8226
    akm8226 2 September 2015 18: 51 New
    0
    And two years have not passed ...
  37. Aandrewsir
    Aandrewsir 2 September 2015 18: 55 New
    +1
    Quote: oleg-gr
    The film contradicts the official version. That's the "freedom of speech" in European.

    oleg-gr! This is probably a typo. Probably not “European freedom,” but “European freedom.”