“I don’t blame the mirror if it’s crooked”

10
“I don’t blame the mirror if it’s crooked”


“I don’t blame the mirror if it’s crooked.” (The epigraph and the plot of N. V. Gogol’s comedy “The Inspector-General”)


The Russian army continues to test on itself numerous reformist ideas: from the reduction of the service life on conscription to outsourcing. Reduction of service life is intended to end such a concept as hazing, and outsourcing should allow the soldier to be freed from duties not related to military affairs.

But as for any embodiment of change in life takes time. And to say that in the army now everything has changed only for the better, at least prematurely. Despite the fact that the external and internal control of the Russian armed forces seems to be gaining momentum, there are still a lot of dark spots that scare young people away from military service.

Recently, a round table was held, which brought together representatives of the Chief Military Prosecutor’s Office, the FSB, the Commissioner for Human Rights, and the public. During the round table issues of inter-ethnic relations in the army were discussed. According to Vladimir Molodykh, who represented the GVP, the national question in our army, if not absent altogether, then the matter goes precisely in this direction. He said that it was the efforts of prosecutors and the FSB that led to the fact that the level of army extremism fell to almost zero.

But if we assume that Mr. Young speaks obvious things, then why so far in those parts where draftees from the North Caucasus Republics serve, the situation is not always smooth. It happens so that if even a small group of Dagestan soldiers appear among the personnel of a part of the military personnel of a unit, then a real ethnic conflict may flare up in units. At the same time, the rights are far from being infringed by Caucasian soldiers, but by Russians, although their numbers are several times higher. What could be the reason for this state of affairs? The main reason is not only the special spiritual closeness of the Caucasian peoples, but also the fact that these guys, coming into the army, are better prepared for it. Already in the same Dagestan, recruitment into the army is almost on a competitive basis: really the healthiest and strongest guys are selected who wish to serve, to work in the law enforcement bodies of their Republic in the future, or to continue service under the contract due to high unemployment in the Caucasus.

The Committee of Soldiers' Mothers even proposes to limit the call of young people from the North Caucasus, or even to cancel it altogether. This option, of course, can reduce the level of interethnic tension, but it will not solve the problem of a complete set of the Russian army.

And besides the situation with national extremism, there are enough problems in our armed forces. As it turned out, the transition to the “annual” military service did not at all save the Armed Forces from such a phenomenon as hazing. We began to talk about hazing in our army not only in Russia, but also abroad, demonstrating all its ugliness.

The situation in the Elan garrison, which is located in the Sverdlovsk region, can be cited as an example of flourishing non-statutory relations. A unique phenomenon for Russia was the appeal of the residents of the village of Araslanovo, who say that as long as there is no order in the Russian army, they will not allow their children to serve. This is due to the fact that in recent years the third soldier, who was drafted into the army from this locality, is returning home to his grave. The last episode took place with private Ruslan Aiderkhanov, the prosecutor's office acknowledged suicide as the cause of death. Aiderkhanov allegedly hung himself on a tree bough. The villagers questioned such a verdict, as Ruslan went to serve with enthusiasm.

Relatives decided to open the zinc coffin. From what they saw for a long time they could not recover: the corpse had no eyes, instead of teeth, prostheses were inserted into the mouth, the whole body of the soldier was bruised, his leg was broken. The representative of the military prosecutor’s office claims that the soldiers suffered such injuries in the process of committing suicide. And he knocked his teeth out to himself, and an eye ... The villagers decided to send the posthumous photos of Ruslan to Anatoly Serdyukov and stand up for their conscripts.

It is worth noting that the Elansky garrison gained notoriety long before the death of Ruslan Aiderkhanov. Not a year goes by without a case of non-statutory relations. Enough in any search engine to type the query "Elansky garrison", as in the top ten will be materials about the "lack of custody" in this part. Then the soldiers beat an officer who did not allow one of them to bring alcohol into the territory of the unit, then the private soldier shot himself in the head during the shooting, then during the same shooting the bullet pleased the soldier directly in the heart. There are also frequent epidemics of pneumonia, which, according to many local residents, occur after the soldiers in the cold force to run half-naked for several hours.

How is going to leave such a situation, the main military department? Measures are being taken that will be aimed at making our army an analogue of the American army. They say that in the armed forces there will have to appear qualified professional sergeants, including the Chief Sergeant, who will bring order to the rank and file level. However, today in sergeant schools about 1200 people are trained, and the need of the armed forces for junior commanders is no less than 50000. It is easy to calculate that at such a pace the Russian army will be staffed with a professional sergeant staff at best in years through 40-45.

If we analyze the situation with contractors, if there were no mass layoffs (about 180 thousand people) a couple of years ago, we would have been prepared to perform the required tasks even more than 50 thousand sergeants. But we have, as always: "to the ground, and then ..."

It is not yet known what forces, but by the 2017 year, the number of contract soldiers and draftees in the Russian army should be leveled. This, according to senior military officials, should fundamentally change the problem with hazing, because professional sergeants who will work for a decent salary in 35 thousand rubles will vigilantly watch the soldiers.

In the media, a certain social advertisement is beginning to appear about how now it will be good for young people to serve in the army. It is said that now they will not need to revenge the parade ground and dig potatoes, they will be spared from the clothes in the kitchen. Instead, a Russian soldier will study the device. weapons, test it in practice. There will be two whole weekends, during which the soldier can go to the city in civilian clothes - to meet with his girlfriend and parents. Leave will be saved, as with an ordinary civilian, and the benefits of enrollment will be enormous. In general, if you believe the Russian Defense Ministry, it will not be a service, but a paradise. Soldiers can only complain about her too short a time ...

However, not everyone enthusiastically perceives information about the prospects of “heavenly service”. As you know, the Constitution of the Russian Federation guarantees those who do not wish to do military service, the passage of alternative civilian service. Since 2004, in connection with the issuance of the relevant law, such a right has been given to those who motivate their desire to go through the ACS. Today, the term AGS is reduced from the initial 3,5 years to 21 a month. At the same time, employees of the military enlistment offices are trying to make it so that by those who have expressed the desire to undergo the ACS, dismiss this desire. The statistics asserts that from 5388 applications submitted by young people about the passage of AHS, about 80% are satisfied. The rest had to take up arms, although they claimed that this was not in their moral principles.

Today, the ACS is a job in not the most prestigious positions: orderlies, janitors, foresters, painters, postmen, etc. At the same time, it should be noted that the same social guarantees are observed in the ACS as in the case of a regular employment contract: salary (average 8 -9 thousand rubles), sick-lists, holidays, etc. I would like to present statistics on the ratio of the number of people serving in regular service and AHS. This ratio is at the level of 130: 1.

The figure eloquently indicates that, nevertheless, Russian guys are trying to give their military duty to their homeland. And the point here is not even that the military registration and enlistment offices impede the passage of ACS.

Yes, the Russian army has many drawbacks, but if we pay attention only to them, then we simply risk leaving our country without any protection at all. Hazing and army extremism are rudiments that need to be disposed of purposefully and systematically. No one-sided law will solve this problem, therefore, there should be a wide public discussion here.
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

10 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +15
    26 October 2011 10: 18
    Everything resembles the pre-war years, when it was already clear to the fool that Hitler would attack the USSR, and we had a mess in our army (weapons in one place, bullets in another, guns in the third ...) No matter how we had to step on the same rake and again at the cost of heavy human losses to prevent our Country, our Civilization from disappearing. After all, it is easy to make another Libya from Russia, such a development of events is just asleep and seen by some countries of the West and the USA. No matter how it seems that the modern world is a world of prosperity, that people have already suffered wars and will now live in peace and harmony - this is a mistake. War is coming even worse than it was for resources. And no one who has the strength to cope with a weaker opponent will not be stopped by the UN or conscience. It will be just a massacre, like 70 years ago, and 1000, and 2000 ... as it always has been.
    We must not allow us to be destroyed, in any sense! We are Russia, and let the rest go ... to yuh!
  2. Motherland
    +6
    26 October 2011 10: 27
    The army needs more exercises close to real actions
  3. NUT
    NUT
    +12
    26 October 2011 10: 40
    again, according to tradition, we are conducting discussions and are looking for a way out that here it is, next to it, without a door, it’s just shut by the curtain of our forgotten history

    under the sovereigns there were regiments of Vitebsk, Ryazan, Smolensk
    and the servicemen tried, competed whose regiment is better and more beautiful

    in our brigade on all boxes, the most terrible atrocities of the old-timers were considered, for example:
    stop and ask crucian, what is under you or above you ... find out, report back
    wake up in the middle of the night and ask what we have on ... the eleventh or ... ten eighth frame ... find out, report, etc. etc.
    guilty - punished - month without shore - "lip" - dis.bat

    those with whom we don’t drink forgot that in everything, everywhere and always the officer is at the head and he must, in our best traditions, be a real RUSSIAN OFFICER
    1. Miracles
      +1
      29 October 2011 15: 26
      Excuse me, of course, but what are the RUSSIAN OFFICERS now. You cannot enter a military school without a good bribe or a great star pusher. I live next to the Krasnodar Cryptographic School, I know that in the last set, all were children of generals. In civilian universities, military departments are the most corrupt, they have their own price lists for control, volatiles, exams, tests, when I studied, it cost about $ 1 thousand, so that you would not be recommended for the service. I’m raising my education now, so I have a guy in the group who studied at an artillery school somewhere in Siberia, they said that their senior courses beat, morally broke, he was saved, that his brother was in 4th grade, so he just n .. lei received. The retired father took this guy from there, said that the heck didn’t need such an army. Officers in the Union had excellent salaries, benefits that they could buy for the money they could afford. The girls dreamed of getting an officer in their husbands. Now what? To feed the family, you have to pull everything that is bad, exploit the soldier. Generals push their sons and relatives to normal positions. How to build a career?
      I do not want to say that all the officers we have are like that. And I really respect the RUSSIAN OFFICER. But, unfortunately, the trend is visible very bad.
  4. +2
    26 October 2011 13: 41
    KILLAvolt absolutely agree with you. There will be a war by any means, too much tumor on our planet, called the USA, has given many metastases !!! It’s time to irradiate it too!
  5. Maksim
    +2
    26 October 2011 16: 59
    Russia now, divided into the class of capitalists - who own the factories, railways, mines. And the class of proletarians - those who work in factories, railways, mines. It does not remind you of something. Until the revolutionary times of the last century, (and of our time) history can be repeated
  6. +2
    26 October 2011 20: 40
    He left the Army in 1997. Work on a civilian. About youth, they come to work (there are rare exceptions), everyone wants a lot of money at once, having neither practice nor knowledge, as for the army, almost all are sick, lame, oblique. It's a shame for the country.
    1. kesa1111
      +2
      27 October 2011 04: 27
      The Russian army is now more than ever peasant. And the children of all sorts of Kremlin, Lubyanka and others finish this school in absentia. Solution: in the civil service only after the RA. He is sick and is not fit for public service. When the kosher sons serve, changes for the better will come.
      1. Volkhov
        +1
        27 October 2011 19: 52
        There is nothing left - to create a state where they will be taken over as commanders after the army, and the first task of the new army will be to protect the state from the old one (groups of cops and security officers abandoned by the authorities between despair and repentance) - you will be very surprised how quickly and under what conditions wishes come true.
  7. +2
    27 October 2011 00: 10
    The article did not like everything. Especially the ending. One-sided law, like, can’t be corrected, but there should be a public discussion. Oh well. Public discussions do not solve or change anything, except for the composition of the air around the discussion. What is needed is an intelligent head of the armed forces such as Malinovsky, Konev or other magnificent marshals, and not yesterday’s / today's furniture merchants. A fundamentally different ideology is needed. Other officers, which was already written in the comments above. Great tests are needed for the army and the country (wrote - and jumped at it: God forbid, enough of what is). We need the pre-army training of the conscript - both physical, moral, and educational (this is about sissies). And in the end - a normal ruler who puts the right people in the right places.
    What I wrote above is elementary and clear to everyone. Everyone, except for our ... "high officials".
    Will we ever have something clever to do?
  8. Nachmed
    +2
    27 October 2011 22: 27
    And as always - everything is fine, but it will be generally excellent. The modern army resembles a planned badak. Outsourcing? - how to understand that the soldiers' laundry is washed in a city located 500 km away, and bread is bought there, although the military unit is located in the city where all this is. There is no hazing - in some places it is not, but commanders are beaten like "sidorov goats" for any bruise, therefore everything that is possible is hidden. Although it is bad without hazing (not to be confused with army lawlessness), all kinds of scum begin to rule the teams, ready to report where necessary at any moment and in modern conditions she will always be right.

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar people (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned), Kirill Budanov (included to the Rosfinmonitoring list of terrorists and extremists)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"