American Colonel: Sale of Russian C-300 complexes to Iran will cause serious consequences

58
The American edition of The National Interest published an article by Colonel of the US Air Force Clint Hinouta, which talks about three serious consequences of lifting the ban on the sale of Russian C-300 anti-aircraft missile systems to Iran, RIA reports "News".

American Colonel: Sale of Russian C-300 complexes to Iran will cause serious consequences


The first, according to Hinout, will be a “fundamental shift in military power in the region”: for decades, the US and its allies dominated the air, and their opponents, by contrast, were vulnerable to surveillance and attacks aviation. This was true for Iran, but after the arrival of the S-300, everything will change, the colonel notes.

Hinoot notes that if Washington decides to attack Iran’s nuclear facilities, now it will need to deploy large air, sea and land forces, including the most effective and expensive weapons, and this will make the mission "more difficult and time consuming."

The second consequence, according to the colonel: if Iran has C-300, then it will significantly speed up the spread of the A2 / AD system (Anti-Access / Area-Denial, Chinese security doctrine). Earlier, some US officials said that countries such as North Korea and Iran would begin to procure effective systems, so Washington will have to change the approach to the projection of military power.


“This day seems to have come,” notes Hinoot.

The third consequence of lifting the ban on the supply of C-300 to Iran will be a return to the era of geopolitical competition, the US Air Force Colonel is sure. According to him, from this moment on every event in the international arena should be viewed in the light of political competition with another strong country. Russia suffered from Western sanctions, but now it has managed to find a way to drastically increase US spending.
58 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. 0,5
    0,5
    +26
    April 21 2015 06: 31
    By acquiring C-300, Iran is practically introducing a no-fly zone over its territory for foreign planes and cruise missiles.
    And no matter how it infuriates the Saudis and Israel, but the bombing of objects in Iran will not be as painless for them as before and in reality Iran declares itself in B. Vostok as a leader, if they also lift the embargo ...
    And there, it seems, like Russia made a fuss about changing Iranian oil for weapons and manufactured goods with food ...
    1. +15
      April 21 2015 06: 57
      Every American colonel imagines himself a generalissimo and a great strategist and politician of a global scale, this is a psychiatric clinic in person. That way, and soon to the corporal is not far. Apparently he was bitten by McCain, a contagious thing to see.
      1. +9
        April 21 2015 07: 44
        in vain you so he reasonably argues that the polar fox came to American permissiveness. laughing
        1. anakonda
          +5
          April 21 2015 07: 49
          I ran through the comments here, but there are still no gentlemen of Jews, probably in Israel it’s still a deep night, it’s somehow boring without them smile .
      2. +2
        April 21 2015 08: 06
        The times of lawlessness are over !!!
        Fuck you! Hypocrites overseas !!!
      3. 0
        April 21 2015 08: 09
        No, it's just that their generals "smart" have all expressed themselves, now they have gone down the command ladder ... so soon ordinary "experts" will become ...
      4. SSR
        +2
        April 21 2015 09: 29
        Quote: juborg
        Every American colonel imagines himself a generalissimo and a great strategist and politician of a global scale, this is a psychiatric clinic in person. That way, and soon to the corporal is not far. Apparently he was bitten by McCain, a contagious thing to see.

        I can certainly be wrong ... But if my memory doesn’t fail me, then the number of US colonels is comparable with the number of generals in our country and not in our favor. This I mean that the statement of their colonel is comparable to the statement of some of our generals, but ..... I do not want to continue.
      5. 0
        April 21 2015 09: 30
        Quote: juborg
        Sale of Russian C-300 complexes to Iran will cause serious consequences

        Every gopher in the field agronomist laughing
        Sale of Russian C-300 complexes to Iran will cause serious consequences

        There will be consequences, this is with the USA. Now, with impunity, atrocities in the airspace of Iran will no longer succeed. And there, maybe other countries will buy defensive systems, which will hit the United States aerial rake well.
    2. +8
      April 21 2015 06: 57
      This is the reason for the screeching of the West - discord has been introduced into the strategy of controlling the West. Iran will become "completely uncontrollable" in the face of the threat of violence ... This is what the "civilized world" fears - barbarians should always be in fear of the colonizer's boot!
    3. +4
      April 21 2015 07: 02
      By and large, Iran "does not care for us," but by supplying these complexes we are plunging the United States into huge spending of the military budget, which is akin to a won battle.
    4. The comment was deleted.
    5. +8
      April 21 2015 07: 06
      Strange and one more thing, the Yankees all the time openly declare their intention to carry out bombing raids. Nuclear and other facilities on the territory of a sovereign state. Do not strain to look for and present a reason or reason for the attack. The Yankees are, in principle, incapable of negotiation, because do not and do not want to comply with any agreements.
      1. +2
        April 21 2015 07: 32
        Moreover, I believe that this signal is not for Iran, not for us, not for China. Rather, this signal to European countries and countries wishing to join the ABII. This bank is an alternative to the transatlantic financial space. Remember, Obama recently stated that global financial power should be held in the states. And the most interesting, none of our leadership has tweeted on the topic of American threats to sovereign states. Generally no obvious reaction.
      2. +4
        April 21 2015 07: 43
        How else can Russia cooperate with Iran in the military-technical direction?

        - Traditional directions - purchase and sale of military equipment. Here we can expand cooperation in the supply of ships and aircraft. We have already supplied 877-KM submarines of the Varshavyanka project to Iran. We can supply there our missile boats and small ships equipped with the latest missile systems. This, of course, is the supply of other equipment for the anti-aircraft missile forces. Russian tanks and self-propelled howitzers are also very interesting to Iran. We can supply modern fighters. Iran needs it now. Its main fighter is now thoroughly outdated. Therefore, the receipt of the latest modifications of the SU-30 MKI, SU-30 MKA, MiG-29 aircraft would be very appropriate for Iran.

        PS "Deliveries of S-300 to Iran are still flowers." How does it happen! bully
    6. +1
      April 21 2015 07: 12
      They (that of the colonel, that of the general, that of American politics) are enraged by the fact that they will have to pay for their crimes. And pay a considerable price. Yes, and have to prepare for crimes more seriously and longer. With a snap it will not work. The habit of being unpunished is too deeply rooted in their minds. And these figures must understand that pain and suffering, devastation and death can come to their land.
    7. +1
      April 21 2015 07: 30
      Quote: 0,5
      By acquiring C-300, Iran is practically introducing a no-fly zone over its territory for foreign planes and cruise missiles.
      And no matter how it infuriates the Saudis and Israel, but the bombing of objects in Iran will not be as painless for them as before and in reality Iran declares itself in B. Vostok as a leader, if they also lift the embargo ...
      And there, it seems, like Russia made a fuss about changing Iranian oil for weapons and manufactured goods with food ...

      I fully agree that the supply of the C 300 will have serious consequences if America wants to bring democracy to Iran on the wings of military aircraft.
      1. 0
        April 21 2015 12: 42
        democracy ??? or chaos and contention for the dollar? They in the church will ruin the air for a single cent!
    8. +1
      April 21 2015 07: 42
      Quote: 0,5
      By acquiring C-300, Iran is practically introducing a no-fly zone over its territory for foreign planes and cruise missiles.

      And let the US explode with anger. The no-fly zone for Americans on our southern borders is not so bad.
    9. +2
      April 21 2015 07: 50
      Quote: 0,5
      By acquiring the S-300, Iran is practically introducing a no-fly zone over its territory for foreign planes and cruise missiles

      Nothing like this! To do this, the number of air defense systems delivered to Iran needs to be increased - at least - by a factor of 10, and even that will not be enough. The current number - only FIVE divisions of any no-fly zone over the territory of Iran will not be able to create - only cover one - a maximum of two objects.
    10. +2
      April 21 2015 08: 31
      Quote: 0,5
      By acquiring C-300, Iran is practically introducing a no-fly zone over its territory for foreign planes and cruise missiles.
      And no matter how it infuriates the Saudis and Israel, but the bombing of objects in Iran will not be as painless for them as before and in reality Iran declares itself in B. Vostok as a leader, if they also lift the embargo ...
      And there, it seems, like Russia made a fuss about changing Iranian oil for weapons and manufactured goods with food ...

      The no-fly zone is too loud and pompous, to be honest, it is more of a "high risk" zone. More difficult, but still surmountable, is the question of the funds spent on this (more UAVs, more missiles, more powerful electronic warfare).

      A truly no-fly zone can only be created by fighter aircraft.
      The eagle will always eat the turtle, no matter how hard the shell it has, the only question is how long it will take for it.

      Gross underestimation of the enemy leads to painful surprises on the battlefield, because while some hats are throwing, others diligently do their "homework".
      1. +1
        April 21 2015 17: 02
        Quote: And Us Rat
        A truly no-fly zone can only be created by fighter aircraft.
        The eagle will always eat the turtle, no matter how hard the shell it has, the only question is how long it will take for it.

        Well, this is not a completely correct comparison. Firstly, because air defense aviation always interacts closely with the ground-based air defense system, and secondly, where did you see the turtle not only with the shell, but also with its beak and claws?
      2. 0
        April 21 2015 19: 33
        I agree with us.

        S-300 is not enough - you need to supply aviation to Iranian friends - at least 20-30 Su-30 or 35 pieces, 30 35 X-pieces and 100 Chinese low-cost aircraft

        And of course the armor for covering C-300 and a couple of c-400 (the Chinese may be able to wait - it seems more important to me over Iran)
    11. 0
      April 21 2015 10: 16
      Something I don’t quite understand the hatred moods.
      I do not think that Moscow’s sale to Tehran of the five S-300PMU-1 divisions (total forty launchers) as it will fundamentally change the defense of Iran. To do this, we need a global air defense / missile defense system of a country with aviation and coastal defense. This system will cover a maximum of 1-2 objects, no more.
      For example: "... Each Arleigh Burke-class destroyer is armed with up to 56 cruise missiles BGM-109 Tomahawk Block 3 (with a launch range of up to 1250-1609 km in the tactical (non-nuclear version) and 2500 km in the strategic (nuclear) ... "
      In the ranks 62 PCS. destroyers Arly Burke. This is only one type of ship, not counting other types of ships and missiles and submarines with cruise missiles. And if you add aircraft carriers with hundreds of planes here, it becomes completely sad.
      That is, the entrance to the Persian Gulf of at least 5 destroyers under the cover of other ships and the aircraft carrier's avigroup can completely destroy the entire air defense of Iran. I hope it doesn't come to that, but screaming "we will defeat everyone" is stupid.
      1. +1
        April 21 2015 10: 48
        After all, we can deliver to Iran and "Bastions", then the US aircraft carriers with hundreds of aircraft will go to the bottom without reaching their target ...
    12. 0
      April 21 2015 13: 31
      Quote: 0,5
      The third consequence of lifting the ban on the supply of C-300 to Iran will be a return to the era of geopolitical competition, the US Air Force Colonel is sure. According to him, from this moment on every event in the international arena should be viewed in the light of political competition with another strong country. Russia suffered from Western sanctions, but now it has managed to find a way to drastically increase US spending.

      to further increase costs. it is necessary to put still coastal complexes Bastion. Americans like them too
  2. +4
    April 21 2015 06: 31
    so why are they so pissing then that’s it? request What, she doesn’t let you live in peace?
    1. +9
      April 21 2015 06: 38
      === Russia suffered from Western sanctions, but now it has managed to find a way to sharply increase US spending. ===
      And what to do?
      The sanctions caused financial damage to us, holes formed in the budget and Russia found a way to patch these holes with the proceeds from the sale of the S-300, what is bad about it? Our democracy has strengthened! laughing
      But we won’t sell these systems to the Yankees, because they don’t have RUBLES! laughing
      1. +2
        April 21 2015 07: 16
        The hype that arose on this occasion suggests that the S-300 complex forces itself to be respected in front of all opponents, there is an assumption that after everything subsides, "tests" of this complex will be carried out and not at all on the initiative of the Iranian air defense, this provocation will be carried out in order to address several issues at once; the efficiency of the complex, its weaknesses, the decisiveness of the use of air defense by military personnel, and so on.
        So it seems that this is not the last hype with this complex, the Iranians would like to advise less use of the S-300 complex in political games blah, blah ..... but it is better to study this complex for its DIRECT PURPOSE!
        1. MMX
          0
          April 21 2015 08: 41
          The hype that rose on this occasion suggests that the S-300 complex forces itself to respect all opponents


          The S-300 complex itself is not a panacea, and a likely adversary has the opportunity to fight it (all the more with the insignificant number of complexes delivered to Iran).
          It seems to me that the question here more likely comes down to the fact that a number of countries strongly dislike the military-technical cooperation between Russia and Iran, as well as the convergence of their interests on this basis. So they create an informational background of negativity.
          And in the event of a military conflict, the S-300 will not save Iran.
          1. +1
            April 21 2015 09: 08
            Even the Americans and Jews admitted that even without the c300, the Iranian issue has no military solution, even in the case of mass bombing, the Iranian nuclear program will slow down for a few years at a time, but then Gulf oil will be closed for the world market, which is 40 percent of world production.
            1. MMX
              +1
              April 21 2015 10: 19
              Quote: Pissarro
              Even the Americans and Jews admitted that even without the c300, the Iranian issue has no military solution, even in the case of mass bombing, the Iranian nuclear program will slow down for a few years at a time, but then Gulf oil will be closed for the world market, which is 40 percent of world production.


              Maybe so. Man is such a creature that if he really wants something, he will strive to get it by all means (including nuclear facilities). Although I would prefer that Iran did not have nuclear weapons, and the existing nuclear program was aimed exclusively at the "peaceful atom".
    2. +2
      April 21 2015 06: 59
      Quote: andrei332809
      so why are they so pissing then that’s it? request What, she doesn’t let you live in peace?

      But how then to bomb with impunity? Through the mouths of Amerov: - And what about us? belay
  3. +3
    April 21 2015 06: 33
    For the US Air Force / Israel the consequences - "then we began to count wounds, to count comrades ..."
  4. +4
    April 21 2015 06: 39
    And you thought you could bomb countries cheaply, without punishment. am
  5. 0
    April 21 2015 06: 40
    Americans shit bricks ...: - X At only the beginning
  6. +1
    April 21 2015 06: 41
    Let everyone buy their S-300s and sleep soundly
  7. +7
    April 21 2015 06: 41
    "- I'm normal!
    - Normal ?! What normal adult makes soldiers out of eggs, and then gives them ranks?
    - Just messing around.
    - What are you? Then nothing if I eat this?
    - Don't touch the colonel! This will undermine the morale of the soldiers. "

    So to say a moment of humor. Already got these American colonels and their opinions.
  8. +3
    April 21 2015 06: 42
    The United States, Israel is also very concerned that Iran (after the delivery of the S-300) cannot be "bombed" like Yugoslavia anymore. So they are all like that, they do not give up their intentions to "bomb" Iran.
  9. +1
    April 21 2015 06: 43
    The opinions of the Russian colonels have not yet been asked, in response to the statements of the mattress makers. I think the answer is obvious - the monitor screen will turn red sharply. And the letters "in" and "on" will be the most peaceful.
  10. +2
    April 21 2015 06: 53
    Ay-yai-yai Russia, so meanly to strike a blow at the exclusivity of the planet’s chief There is no goddamn thing on you! crying
  11. +2
    April 21 2015 06: 55
    Well, all new heartburn. Now if something is airplanes, like dead flies will fall from heaven to earth. Let them understand nothing and never in this life go unpunished, you have to pay for everything.
  12. +3
    April 21 2015 06: 57
    The understandable right of Iran to protect its sky from the aggressor, but the aggressor raised a howl. Cooperation and mutual trade between the Russian Federation and Iran are not in many places, it’s unnerving. Like it or not, oil does not give rest.
  13. +7
    April 21 2015 06: 58
    They trumpet openly, they are worried that they cannot bomb without punishment. What a cynicism.


    now she has managed to find a way to dramatically increase US spending.


    Mattresses do not consider expenses, they are monopolists in the production of money laughing Think about producing paper and for it they receive all the world's resources. That's where the main world financial pyramid is.
  14. +4
    April 21 2015 07: 02
    Hinoot notes that if Washington decides to attack Iran’s nuclear facilities, now it will need to deploy large air, sea and land forces, including the most effective and expensive weapons, and this will make the mission "more difficult and time consuming."

    Well, maybe that's why the USA will sponsor terrorism less. Since the troubles with the IMF and the World Bank began, we will soon sell oil for rubles, the costs of terrorist operations against sovereign countries will increase, the dollar will fall (and most likely it will be slowly lowered so that there are no financial shocks, because the whole world is entangled with this web), money the USA will not have enough for everything, they themselves will dig the earth with their nose, wherever they get it. It’s possible, with the help of the Snowdenes, that they’ll spend a lot of time on terrorism, scandals again, etc. In America, life will become bad.
  15. +2
    April 21 2015 07: 03
    Russia suffered from Western sanctions, but now it has managed to find a way to sharply increase US spending.

    We did not start an economic war ..
  16. 0
    April 21 2015 07: 06
    American Colonel: Sale of Russian C-300 complexes to Iran will cause serious consequences

    The consequences will be. Let’s bomb Iran with impunity.
  17. 0
    April 21 2015 07: 07
    The consequences - full pants ...
  18. 0
    April 21 2015 07: 07
    The colonel is right. It will be much more difficult to fly with impunity to bomb anyone who pleases the Americans and Israelis. We'll have to switch to unusual diplomatic methods for solving problems. And if they also set up the Bastions, then sea threats can be reduced to the same diplomatic methods. Let them learn to speak, not wave their democratic fists.
  19. Salenik
    0
    April 21 2015 07: 22
    Under this business, the military budget can also be inflated. Fed, give me some more money!
  20. +1
    April 21 2015 07: 26
    Nobody is waiting for the colonel, nobody likes the colonel ... crying
  21. 0
    April 21 2015 07: 34
    Honestly speaking, this masturbation on C-300 is already annoying. So much talk about this and that. But in fact, these complexes have not yet been installed and deployed. Maybe nishtyaki quietly bargain for refusing to accommodate and again we will sit and be surprised. That's when in fact C-300 will stand up there on duty, then it’s worth discussing and planning.
  22. 0
    April 21 2015 07: 36
    however, after the arrival of the S-300, everything will change

    Right. You hunt to bomb Iran will disappear. And you will begin a political allergy amid fear of losses in the Air Force.
  23. +1
    April 21 2015 07: 49
    Whatever the Russian people do on the world stage in any industry, the Americans shout that this entails serious consequences. And if the cities of Cheito are bombing, then this is so-so, no consequences.
  24. 0
    April 21 2015 07: 55
    Here it is the weakest point of the butchers. Cowardice! And if not everyone in the world understands this, then it's time to see clearly. And to think for the future is it worth it to mess with this herd of cowardly scum! After all, life is not a movie from Hollywood!
  25. +1
    April 21 2015 07: 58
    As I said, I repeat, these colonels and generals got their statements out, this is the business of politicians, and the military must go about their business, or else they’re climbing to glorify themselves.
  26. 0
    April 21 2015 08: 05
    The situation is changing and it is time for the Americans to abandon their imperial phobias.
  27. 0
    April 21 2015 08: 13
    So sign that their "correct" boys offend and do not allow them to do whatever they want, and in general bad Russians can become their competitors ... Tin ... !!! What stupidity !! I didn't believe it, but they actually typed in the ad guide ...
  28. +1
    April 21 2015 08: 28
    published an article by US Air Force Colonel Clint Hinout that talks about three serious consequences

    For all three consequences, only states are the losers. So everything is done right
  29. ed65b
    0
    April 21 2015 08: 50
    This is how a conventional air defense missile became an analogue of a nuclear club, bravo GDP.
  30. 0
    April 21 2015 08: 56
    In Panama, mattresses, as soon as they learned about the presence of ZSU 57-2, did not fall below 5-6 thousand meters. And this is not the C300. And even several divisions will strain them very much.
  31. 0
    April 21 2015 09: 07
    American generals constantly confuse consequence and cause! This delivery of the S - 300 was a consequence of the policy of the mattress, and not vice versa ...
  32. 0
    April 21 2015 09: 40
    Sale of Russian C-300 complexes to Iran will cause serious consequences for american airplanes. He said everything correctly, but did not finish it.
  33. 0
    April 21 2015 11: 17
    For pennies again?
    Who will feel bad? Usually, this is the one who fusses out of measure and out of place. So, this decision really came to a sensitive place.
    Just do not turn this process into a mockery of the tailed animal! Or is covert bargaining being undertaken again? So do not cover it with verbal husk. There will be more harm than good.
  34. 0
    April 21 2015 12: 46
    The S-300 is not aimed either against Israel or against the Saudis. Like missile defense in Europe against RUSSIA.
  35. James Cameron
    0
    April 21 2015 14: 22
    Ways to suppress the S-300 system (my opinion)

    1. Search for "dead" zones not covered by RLO / OLTC, incl. at ultra-low altitudes (radio horizon at altitudes of 10m + 50m is 36 km) - universally for any air defense system
    2. Suppression by active interference (subject to sufficient spectral power, and until the jammer itself is induced by missiles using the triangulation method in the passive mode)
    3. Saturation of the air defense system by means of a massive attack by means of WTO, including anti-radar missiles: missile ammunition consumption and the difficulty of simultaneously targeting dozens of small targets

    The Israeli Air Force mastered all these methods to perfection. Therefore, the presence of the S-300 in Iran is not enough - an integrated approach is needed.

    1. Separated air defense (S-300 must be supplemented with at least adequate air defense systems of medium and short range like Buk-M2 / Tor-M2 / Shell-C1 in sufficient quantity, proper placement and with a single control system). The very presence of the S-300 is like sniper rifleswho in a serious mess without machine guns and ultrasound will not help.

    2. Need more radar!

    3. We need electronic warfare systems and add. PRR countermeasures! (traps, jamming stations, etc.)

    4. Ideally, there is also a network of over-the-horizon radars


    Then the sky over Iran will become impregnable. In the meantime, this is journalistic hysteria. If the S-300 would be enough for 100% protection, then in Russia, apart from the old S-300 and missiles, nothing more would be produced and developed for them (neither the S-400, nor the S-500, nor the electronic warfare, nor new Radar, no medium and short-range air defense systems and so on)!



    Given that these S-300s are likely to be controlled hammer walkers, then Israel doesn’t need to worry so much wassat and "Almaz-Antey" extra 800 million Baku will not interfere
    1. 0
      April 21 2015 17: 14
      Quote: James Cameron
      Considering that these S-300s will most likely be controlled by dolboyas, Israel does not need to worry so much and Almaz-Antey will not be in the way of the extra 800 million Baku

      That's it to the point!
      You also did not mention the interaction of ground air defense with air defense aviation. In general, even in Soviet times, the country's air defense forces included themselves on the ground component - air defense missile defense systems - air defense missiles, air defense aviation and radio-technical troops. Military air defense - all sorts of current Buki - was not included in the country's air defense system at all, but was part of the ground forces. The country's air defense system repeatedly blocked the zones of neighboring units, and there were very few "loopholes" and "dead zones". And as part of the regiment-brigade, the air defense missile systems worked under the control of an automated control system, which greatly increased the effectiveness of the air defense system.
      None of this in Iran is close. Selling only 5 divisions is a gesture - that's all. And Iran is unlikely to have the means to create a full-fledged air defense system - with modern RTV, aviation and air defense systems, capable of really ensuring the country's security. And if you take into account the personnel ... I do not know about Iran, but the "Arab brothers" could not boast of the effectiveness of using quite worthy air defense systems, despite the intensive training from the USSR. How about this in Iran - no one can say for sure.
  36. 0
    April 21 2015 15: 05
    Of course it will. Otherwise, what the hell do they supply? winked Disease fly off. And then they are used to throwing bombs with flying punishment with no punishment.
  37. 0
    April 21 2015 18: 46
    The American military is completely right and sincere: yes, the S-300 systems will lead to serious consequences for the potential aggressor, to which this military man from America also belongs. American Colonel, did you understand everything, horseback horse?