Five years after the crash near Smolensk, the Polish prosecutor’s office indicted Russian air traffic controllers.

91
Almost five years later, after the collapse of the Polish side of the No. XXUMX near Smolensk, the prosecutor's office of Poland decided to charge the Russian dispatchers. Polish prosecutor Ireneuszhe Shelong said that in Warsaw, the main perpetrators of the tragedy are the dispatchers who were at the airfield in Smolensk. Prosecutor Shelong quotes news agency TASS:

The experts evaluated the actions of dispatchers. One of them is accused of creating a situation of immediate danger in the air. Another is accused of inadvertently bringing to a catastrophe in the airspace.




“Creating a situation of immediate danger in the air” is how? Smolensk dispatcher himself let the fog over the Katyn forest, creating bad weather conditions, or what?

And how could another dispatcher “bring the plane to a catastrophe” if he recommended the crew of the Tu-154 due to the poor meteorological conditions to send the Polish side No. XXUMX to the alternate aerodrome?

It must be recalled that more than 2,5 years ago, the Polish side, after conducting an investigation, confirmed the findings of the International Aviation Committee that the cause of the plane crash near Smolensk was a decrease below the minimum allowable height in adverse weather conditions, which did not allow it to go to the second round. At the same time, the recordings of the “black boxes” were published, from which it became clear that a representative of the Polish Defense Ministry was in the cockpit, who actually gave direct orders to the pilots to land without paying attention to the warnings of dispatchers.

Now, it turns out, the Polish prosecutor’s office blames both in bad weather conditions and the crew’s decision to sit “here and now” Russian dispatchers. One can only guess who Poland will indict even five years after the disaster that killed 96 people (including the President of Poland) ...
    Our news channels

    Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

    91 comment
    Information
    Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
    1. Boos
      +34
      27 March 2015 14: 19
      In your Lyakhia, look for the "extreme" ones!
      1. +12
        27 March 2015 14: 24
        They came round. Why not in 20 years?
        1. +15
          27 March 2015 14: 50
          So spring is now violent, people with a moving psyche are moving.)))
          1. +20
            27 March 2015 15: 13
            Psheks, you will answer us for Susanin ...
          2. The comment was deleted.
          3. +4
            27 March 2015 15: 57
            Ours have already shown the middle finger on the topic for the psheks, or not yet?
          4. +1
            27 March 2015 21: 59
            Dispatchers invited prosecutors to Smolensk.
          5. The comment was deleted.
        2. 0
          27 March 2015 22: 27
          preparing for the election.
        3. +1
          27 March 2015 22: 44
          Quote: Wend
          They came round. Why not in 20 years?


          So today they are encouraged to hang everything on Russia — and this is a crash, both the Donetsk Boeing, and the Second World War, and the eruption of volcanoes, etc.
        4. 0
          28 March 2015 22: 02
          Quote: Wend
          They came round. Why not in 20 years?

          It's only the beginning. Wait, the Poles will also hang the "Titanic" on Russia.
      2. +22
        27 March 2015 14: 24
        Yes SHCHAZ!
        Looks nothing zhek history does not teach. The deceased in that plane crash also arranged dances on the bones and rewrote the story. The outcome, or final, is obvious.
        To the new leadership of Poland - comrades go the right way!
        1. avg
          +5
          27 March 2015 14: 47
          It is time for the Poles to warn that in the event of the next demarche, as well as provocations with monuments to our soldiers. the way to Smolensk and Katyn will be generally ordered to them.
      3. +16
        27 March 2015 14: 43
        Kachinsky's plane fell into the fog and crashed into a birch. Mist calculation and Birch operator presented for awards
        1. +6
          27 March 2015 15: 41
          The fog was real .... I lived in Smolensk and saw that weather on April 10, the tram approaching the stop was only heard on the call. My work colleague walked with the child on Pokrovka 1,5 kilometers from the explosion-disaster, so the fog extinguished the sound. By the way, after about forty minutes, the weather became sunny.
          Quote: Private ICU
          Kachinsky's plane fell into the fog and crashed into a birch. Mist calculation and Birch operator presented for awards
          1. +1
            27 March 2015 19: 19
            this is fate and a lesson to pshekam. seems to have to be repeated. repetition is the mother of learning
      4. good fair
        +9
        27 March 2015 14: 51
        Quote: Boos
        In your Lyakhia, look for the "extreme" ones!

        What for? And it's so clear - Russia is to blame. Actually, everything is very vague here. The fact is that in the archives they "found" documents confirming that the very birch was planted by order of Stalin himself after his consultations with Wolf Messing. So: cash in the cashier.
        1. +3
          27 March 2015 18: 16
          He personally planted T. Beria. and boy Putin watered it. smile
      5. +2
        27 March 2015 14: 52
        Psheks do not fly on airplanes, but ride a tattered goat on holidays!
        1. +5
          27 March 2015 15: 13
          The next time the charge will be brought against those who created the TU-154 aircraft. Tupolev and those who collected it.
      6. +3
        27 March 2015 15: 41
        Quote: Boos
        In your Lyakhia, look for the "extreme" ones!

        Russian dispatchers are clearly guilty of the stupidity of the Poles. lol
      7. +2
        27 March 2015 16: 12
        Completely overwhelmed, or is the Chernobyl echo affected? Mutants for the whole head fool
      8. +1
        27 March 2015 16: 44
        A giraffe at the zoo, "and the fox told a good anecdote last month," and laughs, and so are these.
      9. 0
        27 March 2015 18: 03
        Of course, blaming Russian dispatchers is easier than admitting that your minister
      10. +2
        27 March 2015 18: 12
        Quote: Boos
        In your Lyakhia, look for the "extreme" ones!

        Girl you have $ 100 fake!
        The guard was raped!
        1. +1
          27 March 2015 18: 34
          Something is incomprehensible, today I read in the news that the Poles recognized the pilot’s mistake. What, again, an article from a sock with mothballs?
          1. +2
            27 March 2015 19: 19
            Quote: almost demobilized
            Something is incomprehensible, today I read in the news that the Poles recognized the pilot’s mistake.


            The pilot just warned about the danger of landing, but Pan Kachinsky ordered: "PLANT!", So that all claims to the one who shouted from the branches: "The giraffe is big, he knows better." bully
      11. +1
        27 March 2015 19: 17
        everything suggests that it is time to load the Polish government into the next plane and send it to Smolensk.
      12. +2
        27 March 2015 19: 18
        and who else is to blame, not the Poles themselves ?! wassat
      13. 0
        28 March 2015 12: 54
        "in the cockpit there was a representative of the Polish military department, who actually gave a direct order to the pilots to land, not paying attention to the warnings of the dispatchers"

        Poles conceal the fact of sexual abuse by the representative of the Polish military department over the pilots of this airliner ... Poor pilots could only commit suicide, which they did !!! wassat
    2. +10
      27 March 2015 14: 21
      Yes, only the Smolensk birch is to blame! And Rafik Nevinoven!
      1. +6
        27 March 2015 14: 24
        Quote: Riperbahn
        Yes, only the Smolensk birch is to blame! And Rafik Nevinoven!
    3. +5
      27 March 2015 14: 21
      How else to bend into Russophobian perversions? No mind - what's the name? Polish pilot ...
      1. +6
        27 March 2015 15: 00
        Once upon a time, when perestroika and new thinking raged in our country, my parents, who lived in Belarus, traveled to Poland as shuttle traders to survive, like the majority of the population in border towns and villages. They traded there in the markets, made purchases and returned home. So there in the market there were also "noble nobles" who behaved in a boorish way, but we must give it their due, there were also people there who, in defense and defense, said "Pan, the threshing floor is everywhere" and smiled guiltily. So it is with this accusation. I feel sorry for the lost people, sympathy for their relatives. But you shouldn't be on the same board with everyone's "threshing floor" ...
        1. +2
          27 March 2015 19: 22
          not at all sorry. there you can dial a few more planes.
      2. The comment was deleted.
    4. +7
      27 March 2015 14: 22
      What, excuse me ?! Guilty of the dispatcher who gave the command to care for the spare ?!
      1. +1
        27 March 2015 15: 09
        Well, the master’s brains from the gentry couldn’t crap like that, it’s clear that the subhuman from barbaric Russia are to blame.
      2. +2
        27 March 2015 15: 13
        .... What, excuse me ?! Blame the dispatcher who gave the command to go to the spare ?!

        ...... The decision to land is made by the commander ..... And no dispatcher decree to him ..... hi
    5. 0
      27 March 2015 14: 22
      what a coincidence, especially the connection with the events with the Boeing in Ukraine ... Poles, don’t tell me my underpants))))))))) to help them, the program on the national geographer about just the president’s plane, where they explained everything with a crew error, got it with an altimeter !!!!!
    6. +4
      27 March 2015 14: 22
      Yes, anyone would doubt it !! Something late they !! It’s not like sprats !! laughing
      1. +2
        27 March 2015 14: 25
        Quote: boa constrictor
        Yes, anyone would doubt it !! Something late they !! It’s not like sprats !!

        Duc, bye-by-bye agreement came from America, and now they are late.
      2. +2
        27 March 2015 14: 26
        Infected next door
    7. +9
      27 March 2015 14: 24
      Damn, after all, we sincerely sympathized with them, empathized with them. What country is so rotten? Why so much anger and hatred of the Russians ?!
      1. +11
        27 March 2015 14: 32
        They cannot forgive Catherine II because she is from Polish gold the throne Piast dynasty made itself golden toilet (historical fact).
      2. +1
        27 March 2015 14: 38
        A strange question, especially when you consider that I have not met a Russian person, which could positively characterize the Poles.
    8. +3
      27 March 2015 14: 25
      who actually gave direct orders to the pilots to land, not paying attention to the warnings of the controllers.


      Again the old song. Either the twin brains rinsed with a terrorist attack and killing the surviving FSB officers, then the Polish Natsiks came out on the spot. Before May 9th, they decided to pat their nerves again.
    9. +8
      27 March 2015 14: 25
      And there was no need for "blue sadness" to pinch into the cockpit!
    10. +1
      27 March 2015 14: 25
      Where did previous Polish experts go? Where did the new come from? In this connection, a case that is closed and clear, like a tear, is being actively exaggerated again? The answer to the last question is obvious - in connection with the corruption of the Polish authorities. Well, the answers to the first two, of course, come from the same place.
    11. +2
      27 March 2015 14: 25
      Took off the tongue ...
      Almost five years after the crash of the Polish side No. 1 near Smolensk, the Polish prosecutor's office decided to indict the Russian dispatchers. Polish prosecutor Jereneusz Shelong said that in Warsaw, the main culprits of the tragedy are the controllers who were at the airport in Smolensk. Shelong prosecutor quotes TASS news agency:

      The experts evaluated the actions of dispatchers. One of them is accused of creating a situation of immediate danger in the air. Another is accused of inadvertently bringing to a catastrophe in the airspace.
    12. ZAM
      +2
      27 March 2015 14: 25
      But what about the tree, for which the plane has hooked, has not yet been charged? It is also Russian.
      1. +1
        27 March 2015 16: 18
        Quote: ZAM
        But what about the tree, for which the plane has hooked, has not yet been charged? It is also Russian.

        There’s an alibi here. Moreover, it’s complete. The entrance to the strip is from the Dnieper (western part of Smolensk), there are no tall trees there, and the territory is cleared in front of the strip, and he went across the strip from the southeast. So wherever I wanted, there and sat. I could not immediately at the Katyn Memorial, and then again, double work .....
        1. good fair
          0
          27 March 2015 20: 12
          Quote: Predator
          There’s an alibi here. Moreover, it’s complete. The entrance to the strip is from the Dnieper (western part of Smolensk), there are no tall trees there, and the territory is cleared in front of the strip, and he went across the strip from the southeast. So wherever I wanted, there and sat. I could not immediately at the Katyn Memorial, and then again, double work .....

          Why is Greenpeace silent, where is the green patrol, comrades! ? THEY BROKE US A TREE TO US! ! ! Yes, another 10 tons of kerosene were poured into the green space and burned. And all this because of ambition and stupidity. The state suffered significant environmental damage, and even moral. . . We, too, were worried, sympathized.
          Counterclaim, collect signatures!
    13. +3
      27 March 2015 14: 25
      Almost five years later, after the collapse of the Polish side of the No. XXUMX near Smolensk, the prosecutor's office of Poland decided to charge the Russian dispatchers. Polish prosecutor Ireneuszhe Shelong said that in Warsaw, the main perpetrators of the tragedy are the dispatchers who were at the airfield in Smolensk.
      How is it in polish! It is necessary to conduct an investigative experiment, only this time this prosecutor needs to be put on a plane. laughing
    14. +4
      27 March 2015 14: 26
      Amerokosa told them something, what else to tickle the nerves of Russia? Russophobes, what do you take !!! request
      1. 0
        27 March 2015 14: 36
        Of course, a gringo, all the teams for the buildup of the situation are distributed there, right now, and sprats with kaklami declare agree they say they support. Downed Boeing will be paralleled by parallels.
        Porridge, honey, shit and nails = triumph of American democracy.
    15. +3
      27 March 2015 14: 26
      And its Polish president - the tyrant and the boor can hardly be called a natural natural cause, washed down the tops of the country ... This next, but bright Polish shame now can not be cut out from history by false decisions of the prosecutor's office.
    16. +6
      27 March 2015 14: 27
      Another miserable attempt to slander Russia. They would still sue the descendants of Ivan Susanin, miserable.
      1. good fair
        +7
        27 March 2015 15: 02
        Quote: lewerlin53rus
        . They would still sue the descendants of Ivan Susanin, miserable.
    17. +2
      27 March 2015 14: 28
      Hmm ... Debelism pshekov rolls over. After all, all the points over And placed, all studies conducted, conclusions made. These just woke up, turned out to be slower than the Eeeestonians ... In short - they go through the forest.
    18. +5
      27 March 2015 14: 29
      Sign of the sea: If a seagull flies ass forward, then the wind is very strong
    19. +2
      27 March 2015 14: 31
      I think it’s not even worth the attention and discussion of the decision of the Polish prosecutor’s office, we may soon hear the Poles’s legal decision to recognize the creators of the Polish army as enemies of the Polish people during the war.
    20. +6
      27 March 2015 14: 35
      It is necessary to present the Poles for the Time of Troubles then, for the delusional thoughts of Pilsudski, for help during the Warsaw Pact and for the fact that the Poles are simply enraged laughing A vile nation that respects only power. The Germans nobly let them into World War II - the Poles respect. Conclusion - you have to beat.
      1. good fair
        +1
        27 March 2015 15: 06
        Quote: noncombant
        A vile nation that respects only power. The Germans nobly let them into World War II - the Poles respect. Conclusion - you have to beat.

        Well yes. You spit in the face - they fight, you do not spit - they are offended. (wisdom of the fathers)
      2. +1
        27 March 2015 19: 03
        And kick yes on the head wassat
    21. nicollider
      +2
      27 March 2015 14: 36
      Well, the southern park is:

      step 1: accuse Russia (USSR) of something and demand compensation
      step 2: ...
      step 3: profit
    22. +2
      27 March 2015 14: 40
      Everything in the prosecutor's office was rightly said about the proven guilt of Russia, and about the dispatchers and, to the extent of philosophicism. But...!!! A lot of questions.
      Where is the participation of the bloody FSB the successor of the lesser KGB?
      In what year did the former KGB colonel Putin prepare this diversion?
      Where are the revelations of the Stalinist regime?
      Where is even a word about the participation of the executioners from the NKVD in the execution of the elite of the Polish officers?
      And most importantly - Where are the claims for compensation for a downed Boeing?
      1. +2
        27 March 2015 14: 45
        There was a Tu-154.
        1. +2
          27 March 2015 15: 26
          Correctly. The bloody KGB even during construction programmed the TU-154 for a catastrophe near Smolensk.
    23. +2
      27 March 2015 14: 41
      This is called a provocation to rape.
    24. +5
      27 March 2015 14: 41
      but it’s weak to carry out an investigative experiment in Pshekia, how was everything — load up your bailiffs, wait for the fog, and forward towards the Smolensk birch?
      1. +1
        27 March 2015 14: 46
        This would be the best option - not all birch trees ended at Smolensk delegation near Smolensk.
      2. 0
        27 March 2015 15: 22
        There is a bummer, the birch tree has already been cut. And the new ones have not grown up yet ...
    25. +2
      27 March 2015 14: 44
      once again showed that the Poles are sick all head, the mind is turned off and common sense is completely.
    26. +3
      27 March 2015 14: 46
      The experts evaluated the actions of the dispatchers. One of them is accused of creating an immediate danger situation in the air. Another is accused of unintentionally causing a catastrophe in mid-air.

      Yeah, one ran around closing his instruments, made a loud noise and let the fog fall, and the second went around and poured whiskey to the Polish government drunken coder. laughing
    27. alksvet
      +4
      27 March 2015 14: 47
      "All enemies of Russia are dying near Smolensk!" Classic!!!
    28. +2
      27 March 2015 14: 48
      In the words of Lelik- If you, then for a long time ...
    29. The comment was deleted.
    30. +4
      27 March 2015 14: 50
      Gentlemen of the Poles, you have a bunch of crazy Europeans and not very adequate people in Europe, and you appoint them pilots. Your pilot, by chance, didn’t study with the Germans, now 150 people have already soaked. Yes, yes, I know that it’s a Russian plane, but then you ..... they are not Russian. And at the expense of compensation, suck on your American friend !!!
    31. +5
      27 March 2015 14: 50
      I offer the Poles to load another flight with the first persons of the state and fly to Smolensk for the personal detention of the dispatchers, they say a new birch has grown there laughing
    32. +3
      27 March 2015 14: 54
      The crew is to blame, you can’t
      go to the spare and not
      listen to those you are carrying.
    33. +2
      27 March 2015 14: 55
      Yes, let them come to interrogate, but to Russia, I hope the Russian prosecutor’s office will find wording for the prosecution and detention of Polish prosecutors for exceeding their authority!
    34. +3
      27 March 2015 14: 56
      More than seventy years ago, the Polish leader Sikorski crashed while taking off on an English plane, from an English air base, with an English crew. Guess who is to blame? Of course the Russians. Nearby at the base was the plane of Ambassador Maysky, and so the ambassador himself, the toli being with him saboteur damaged the Polish plane. By the way, our ambassador also flew on an English plane, with an English crew. So that.
    35. +1
      27 March 2015 14: 59
      Probably everyone here read the transcript of the negotiations, because there, it is obvious that the dispatcher did not recommend them to sit down.
      And so of course let their prosecutors fly in and look at everything on the spot, birch trees have probably grown up already.
    36. +1
      27 March 2015 15: 05
      Napoleon was also blown away near Smolensk! Such an end awaits everyone who goes to my homeland!
      1. +3
        27 March 2015 15: 44
        how could he sulk near Smolensk, if there was a general battle near Moscow, BORODINO, Colleagues do not write nonsense.

        Near Smolensk, 1 and 2 joined the second Russian army. And you need to know the history of the country!
    37. +2
      27 March 2015 15: 07
      The West, with the help of its pocket mosques, is looking for an excuse to unleash a full-scale war, everything is being used, provocations, threats, ultimatums, we are waiting for the next "loud statements".
    38. +2
      27 March 2015 15: 10
      Polish prosecutor Jereneusz Shelong and the “outstanding” political ... Lev Davidovich Trotsky, as a native of the Kherson province, certainly not fellow countrymen, BUT obviously "party members", and his assessment is "united":
      “Here, admire, comrades, And ... like these holy men, these political prostitutes have betrayed us. Betrayed the party, gave out plans ...! ”
      - "Lenin in October"
    39. +1
      27 March 2015 15: 11
      five years ago, accusing Russian air traffic controllers of a plane crash under the smolensk flag of whether the Polish prosecutor’s office would raise the lie. polska can increase its authority by bringing charges of desecrating monuments to Soviet soldiers, including the defender of Poland, General Chernyakhovsky; indictment of massacres of ethnic Poles in Volyn.
    40. +3
      27 March 2015 15: 16
      Let our people give Poland to the government IL-96 squadron, so that on subsequent visits to the Katyn Forest none of the "rudders" would even accidentally stay at home. That would be enough space for all. I would not regret 10-15 thousand for such a plane. And so on - as much as possible. From the grateful peoples of Russia, so to speak. And the subsequent monument - also at its own expense. am
    41. +1
      27 March 2015 15: 26
      Quote: sv68
      but it’s weak to carry out an investigative experiment in Pshekia, how was everything — load up your bailiffs, wait for the fog, and forward towards the Smolensk birch?


      Yeah! Nishtyak idea! Respect for the help! The more Polish crap near Smolensk, the better the harvest! good
      1. +3
        27 March 2015 15: 32
        I’m not sure that Polish .... is at least a little valuable fertilizer ... Let it be scattered at home.
    42. +2
      27 March 2015 15: 30
      Quote: nicollider
      Well, the southern park is:

      step 1: accuse Russia (USSR) of something and demand compensation
      step 2: ...
      step 3: profit

      Stop watching this degenerate American slut ... bang. Words from the series "profit" also do not refer to the great Russian language. It would seem, where does this come from. Moreover, everything starts small.
    43. +1
      27 March 2015 15: 35
      Very clearly, the film tells who and why is to blame for the crash! Show it open to the Poles to shut up!
    44. +2
      27 March 2015 15: 37
      The head of the Main Military Prosecutor's Office of Poland, Colonel Ireneusz Shelong, wants to become a general.
    45. +1
      27 March 2015 15: 49
      where the mouths open off the faces of the Baltic states, there is always insanity, take care of your nerves do not read the news of the Baltic states
    46. +2
      27 March 2015 15: 55
      Quote: Wend
      They came round. Why not in 20 years?

      Senile marasmus, it is senile, because it is not immediately revealed at birth, unfortunately ... Poles from time immemorial still dense "friends" are ours - Do not spill water. And do not screw up, not be a Pole, well, like who does not jump ...
    47. +1
      27 March 2015 15: 59
      dig out the Polish bones and send them to their homeland, demolish the horseradish memorial
    48. kelevra
      0
      27 March 2015 16: 01
      Oh yes, it’s so convenient when everybody ganged up against Russia, even the full one will believe in the guilt of our controllers! The recorders were guilty for a long time, the pilots of the Polish side were guilty, namely, the one who ordered still sits in the fog, someone from the guard the president!
    49. +1
      27 March 2015 16: 02
      The accusations are ludicrous, but now there will be a reason to accuse of "harboring criminals", pathetic little people.
      I think many people paid attention to how they simply unbelievably quickly decrypted the black box (voice recorder) and released the record from the passenger liner that crashed this week? It is monstrous how one inhuman ruined so many people ....
      And what about the downed Boeing over the outskirts ?? Silence....
    50. 0
      27 March 2015 16: 09
      Dear forum users, did any of those who spoke here at least once manage flights? Probably not. The IAC published the disaster conclusions and the Polish side agreed with them, but I indirectly agree with the Polish prosecutor's office. The dispatcher command is law for the pilot, and in this case no clear and clear command was heard. If the flight manager had said the word ZAPPRESH AU, we would not be participating in this discussion now. And he had to do it. Weather conditions at the aerodrome were below the tolerance of the crew commander and the aircraft with the OSB landing system with the CPD. The course and glide path at the airfield were turned off and the pilot can only land on his hands. Tell the head that there are no conditions for landing at the airfield, forbid it to go down and give the command to leave for the alternate airfield all would be alive. Now, of course, we are starting to refer to international standards that we brought information about bad weather and recommended that we go to the emergency one, that the crew commander himself decides - this is all the struggle for the uniform's cleanliness and people can no longer be returned. It was necessary not to recommend, but to command and control the crew.
      1. +1
        27 March 2015 16: 28
        You forget that the airfield and not the airport. Secondly, it is a military airfield. I’m not exactly sure, but military dispatchers cannot prohibit in this case, but recommend it. I live in Smolensk myself. Communicated with people who witnessed these events. From them there is this information.
        1. The comment was deleted.
    51. 0
      27 March 2015 16: 22
      I agree with you, but why did they remain silent for 5 years, what is the reason. This is not by chance a "draft" from the Black Mazago
    52. 0
      27 March 2015 16: 22
      In another 5 years, or maybe less, the Poles will say that Putin personally shot down the plane. That it was not fog, but smoke from the fires that Vladimir Vladimirovich lit. Something like this
    53. 0
      27 March 2015 16: 24
      Well, let the Poles fly to Smolensk to investigate laughing
    54. 0
      27 March 2015 16: 30
      It seems that an excess of fruits also has a detrimental effect on the brain.
    55. 717
      0
      27 March 2015 16: 31
      and so we know who is to blame. The first after God. they envy us and get angry but can’t bite us
    56. +1
      27 March 2015 17: 12
      Polish prosecutors have gone completely crazy! The pilots do not listen to the dispatcher (at military airfields, the flight director), do not respond to warnings from the system of dangerous proximity to the earth’s surface, and decide to land “here and now.” MAC has already figured it out. And the Polish aviation authorities admitted that the main cause of the disaster was the “human factor.” But no. Russia is to blame again.
    57. +1
      27 March 2015 17: 16
      Oh, I’m already tired of these “laughs after a liter”! Stinky bugs...
    58. +1
      27 March 2015 17: 20
      Vain idiots, look in the mirror.
    59. +1
      27 March 2015 17: 30
      Soon we will have the FIFA World Cup, and the Poles will fly to Russia to support their own... I feel like they are in vain when they say this now... Because our weather is unpredictable, sometimes the controllers can also get drunk... I blurted out the wrong thing, I pressed the wrong button. ..
    60. +1
      27 March 2015 17: 33
      If only, after eleven years, another s.ka does not appear and ask the Poles for forgiveness for the disaster.
    61. 0
      27 March 2015 17: 41
      The Poles seem to have crashed themselves on that plane. You need to send an official answer like this)
    62. ZORKA76
      0
      27 March 2015 17: 42
      WE AGREE, PROVIDED THAT THE SECOND HALF OF THE GOVERNMENT OF POLAND WILL ARRIVE TO SUSANINSKY DISTRICT OF KOstroma PROVINCE....
    63. 0
      27 March 2015 17: 44
      Polish prosecutors have gone completely crazy! The pilots do not listen to the dispatcher, do not respond to warnings from the system of dangerous proximity to the earth's surface, and decide to land “here and now.” MAC has already figured it out. And the Polish aviation authorities admitted that the main cause of the disaster was the “human factor.” But no. Russia is to blame again.
    64. +2
      27 March 2015 18: 10
      I’ll paraphrase a deleted comment: if only no female dog breed, after eleven years, asks for forgiveness from the Poles for the disaster.
    65. The comment was deleted.
    66. +1
      27 March 2015 18: 20
      Yes, they are Poles, what can we take from them, they even have a Minister of Foreign Affairs - Skotina, and a Minister of Defense talks to a light bulb. The diagnosis, however.
    67. +1
      27 March 2015 18: 39
      Poles can present anything to anyone. Any person more or less familiar with aviation knows that all over the world, always and everywhere, responsibility for the aircraft and its passengers in all cases in the air rests with only one person - the aircraft commander. No dispatcher in the world has the right to tell the aircraft commander what and how to do, where to take off and where to land. He can only inform; the final decision is always up to the commander of the aircraft.
      Even if the dispatcher forbids landing the plane due to the weather, the aircraft commander may decide to land if he considers it safer than going to an alternate.
    68. The comment was deleted.
    69. 0
      27 March 2015 18: 52
      Read FAPP GA 2004:
      "96. The flight director at the aerodrome during flights is obliged to:
      report to the higher command post and inform the senior aviation commanders of the airport's aerodromes about the start of flights (through the command post or the aerodrome's aviation dispatcher);
      supervise the work of hydraulic fracturing and GOP;
      maintain the established order on the airfield;
      comply with the planned flight schedule;
      permit (prohibit) the launch and taxiing of aircraft onto the runway, distribute airfield zones;
      Allow (prohibit) take-off of aircraft, monitor the progress of take-offs, and, if necessary, issue commands for their termination;
      convey to the crews the direction and speed of the wind during takeoff (if necessary) and landing;
      authorize (prohibit) aircraft landings,, based on reports from crews and observers, control landing gear extension, the position of the wing and mechanization on aircraft approaching to land, if necessary, assist crews in entering the runway, monitor aircraft on the runway, release of braking parachutes and timely release of the runway. By the time the next aircraft (group) lands, the runway must be clear of other aircraft, except for cases when landing is planned at shortened distances;
    70. Petlin
      +1
      27 March 2015 19: 06
      It’s time to send Poland and the Balts a long time ago. These bitches deserve nothing but contempt.
    71. +1
      27 March 2015 22: 20
      And the fog can be Susanin.
    72. 0
      28 March 2015 05: 39
      The Polish prosecutor's office communicated closely with the Etonians, and so they became infected with the "skoorrooosstyuyu".

    "Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

    “Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"