“Shale Revolution” devours its children

40
Brent oil is already worth less than 48 dollars per barrel. And it is clear to all market players that prices will continue to fall. One gets the impression that some oil traders are even happy about this. No, not Russia, not Venezuela, but Saudi Arabia rejoices. Statements of her other subjects suggest the right thought: the price will collapse to twenty per barrel. And with it, the US shale economy will collapse.

“Shale Revolution” devours its children


Kommersant writes that the pre-New Year anti-crisis scenarios of the Russian government "lost relevance in the early days of the coming 2015 year", because even the pessimistic forecasts of economists were based on the average annual price of "Brent" in 60 dollars per barrel.

The media noted that the price of oil continues to fall. According to information RBC, February futures for a barrel of Brent oil fell in price below 48 dollars.

Known forecast analysts «Goldman Sachs». According to them, in the first half of 2015, oil prices will be about $ 40 per barrel.

One of the reasons for the fall in prices is a statement by Saudi prince al-Walid Talal al-Saud. He said that oil will never cost 100 dollars per barrel.

Interview with the Prince took the newspaper USA Today (January 11 material released).

According to Saudi billionaire Prince Al-Walid bin Talal, the world will never again see the price of 100 dollars per barrel of oil. The fall in 50% prices in 2014 has already had a negative impact (“wide and deep”) on major oil producers such as Saudi Arabia and Russia. Already, oil-producing Texas felt a blow.

The “insightful investor” (as the publication calls him), the prince of the royal family of Saudi Arabia, predicted that the fall in prices would hit the economic growth in the United States, which was caused by the “shale revolution”. Over the past two weeks, several large drilling rig operators have reported receiving notifications canceling drilling contracts. This means that it is more profitable for companies to pay the operator (penalties for cancellation) than to drill at current prices.

His Royal Highness said that the press talk about Saudi Arabia’s allegedly existing intention of “harming the cheapening of oil to Russian President Putin” is “nonsense,” because the sharp drop in prices caught the Saudis just as unawares as the Russians. “Saudi Arabia and all countries were taken by surprise,” the prince said. “No one expected this to happen.” The one who says that he foresaw this 50% drop says nothing. ”

The decision of Saudi Arabia not to reduce production, the prince considers "reasonable" and "insightful". If Riyadh reduces production by 1 or 2 million barrels per day, these 1 or 2 million will be produced and sold by other countries. That is, Saudi Arabia will produce less (give up part of the market), and receive less profit. Will not work.

According to the prince, prices are affected by oversupply in the global market. “Now Iraq is producing a lot,” he said. “Even Libya, where there is a civil war, is still producing oil.” The US is currently producing both oil and gas in shale. Thus, there is an excess of supply on the market. ”

However, the Saudis noted weak demand. Japan’s economic growth is almost zero, China’s growth will decline, India’s growth has halved, and Germany is waiting for about the same decline. The demand for oil is decreasing, the excess oil on the market is growing. Hence the fall in prices.

“If supplies remain at the current level, and demand remains weak, then you better believe that the price will go even lower,” says the prince. “However, if some players leave the market and there is some increase in demand, prices can go up.” But I am sure that we will never see more prices in 100 dollars per barrel ... "

Al-Walid bin Talal spoke out about “pressure on Russia” - that is, about the “conspiracy” in which the United States and Saudi Arabia allegedly participate, who have decided to repay Putin for what he “did in Ukraine”.

“Two words: nonsense and nonsense,” said the prince. “I tell you, there is no way Saudi Arabia could do it. Because Saudi Arabia is as bad as Russia, period. <...> And there is no political conspiracy against Russia. "

As for the American shale, the prince here spoke very cautiously, noting that the collapse of the relevant industry in the US is questionable, because the shale and shale gas are “new products on the market”. And "no one knows for sure what price for shale will be a turning point." However, the Saudi said that shale oil has a “higher production cost”. Is it advisable to produce such oil at a price of 50 dollars per barrel? "It is not clear," said the prince. This industry is still developing.

The hazy statements of a man from Riyadh suggest that the prince knows much more than he voices.

And for sure: «Bloomberg» He writes about the emerging crisis in the case for the use of shale.

After a six-month drop in oil prices, American shaleburs "sent a clear signal": they are retreating. Big problems for operators in Texas and North Dakota. The publication marks the “largest drop” in drilling (by 35% in just a week!) Since the “drilling boom” six years ago.

The publication believes that this very “boom” ultimately led to a “global price war”. The warring parties, according to Bloomberg, are the United States and OPEC.

"The largest decline in a decade and seventh in a row threatens to halt US economic growth," the newspaper notes. A drop in the price below 50 dollars per barrel leads to a halt of drilling rigs.

If oil prices do not recover, an absolute end will come to shale drilling, says James Williams, a top manager of the consulting company WTRG Economics.

It is also interesting that the drilling will be less and less, but the US seems to set a new record in oil production by the end of the current year. In the US, an average of 9.130.000 barrels per day is produced (data from the last four weeks). “You will not see a decrease in growth rates until the second half of 2015, and it will not manifest itself until 2016,” the expert notes.

Three driller operators, Helmerich & Payne Inc., Pioneer Energy Services Corp. and Ensign Energy Services Inc. have been instructed to early terminate drilling contracts. The last of the named companies has already laid off 700 workers.

But the data of oilfield services company "Baker Hughes".

Only from 5 to 9 in January in the USA was the 61 drilling rig stopped. Over the past year, the change was not so significant: the number of drilling rigs was reduced by 4 units (for comparison: in Canada - by 111).

Oil market analysts know that a noticeable drop in the number of working rigs reflects the current decline in the shale industry (in the so-called horizontal drilling).

Mindful of the cautious statements of the Saudi prince about the shale industry in the United States and taking into account the opinion of authoritative experts from Bloomberg, who believe that the shale boom is the cause of a price war, we can conclude: Saudi Arabia wants to reduce oil supply on the world market. The oil surplus is caused by the growth of shale production in the USA, which in the process of price war will not withstand the competition. In the coming months, the price will drop to forty dollars per barrel and go lower - and in America, drilling will stop completely.

It is then that the Saudis will take their money: after all, they did not stop saturating the market with oil. The American recession will inevitably cause a rise in oil prices in the world. The only question is when. And the other question is whether the Americans will then take the risk of “horizontal drilling” again. The last question can be answered, however, it is possible: American drillers will calculate long-term risks and measure them out seven times before they stop ... once.

Observed and translated by Oleg Chuvakin
- especially for topwar.ru
    Our news channels

    Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

    40 comments
    Information
    Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
    1. 0
      14 January 2015 07: 07
      The end of the shale revolution! Here you have low oil prices: shale oil production is already unprofitable. Shale gas in line.
      1. +1
        14 January 2015 07: 42
        I read somewhere that shale gas is profitable to produce only in conjunction with oil, without which gas production would be unprofitable. Plus it liquefies badly.
        1. +2
          14 January 2015 09: 11
          Any gas is "liquefied" in the same way, the method of extraction does not affect it .... But everyone has long known about the high cost of extracting shale resources, and based on current realities, extraction in this way is unprofitable. But first of all, ordinary people will suffer from this, since neither the United States nor Canada as a state will cover the costs of the extraction and processing of hydrocarbons, and oil companies will have to take money from somewhere, hence the rise in fuel prices, etc.
          1. +5
            14 January 2015 09: 58
            Quote: POKPAH
            Any gas is "liquefied" in the same way,


            Oh don't tell !!!!! stop The liquefaction of propane-butane is one thing, and the liquefaction of methane is another, the cost is many times greater !!!! hi
            1. +2
              14 January 2015 11: 51
              Any gas is "liquefied" in the same way

              Talk nonsense, my friend wink
            2. +1
              14 January 2015 16: 36
              It is also necessary to clean shale gas before liquefying - it also costs money.
              1. +3
                14 January 2015 18: 26
                I can add:
                - shale gas generates less heat during combustion
                - exploration of shale deposits gives ... inaccurate data, there are cases where the exploration code provided huge reserves, and later it turned out that there was little gas.
          2. +3
            14 January 2015 15: 35
            It liquefies poorly due to impurities during fracking, that is, they badly affect the process, and not because it is bluntly shale.
            Well, in the appendage it can be stupidly in the furnace, but in Neftekhim it will be problematic. Therefore, the Yankees are replacing - slate in the furnace, the traditional - in Neftekhim or plan to export. In short, something like this.
      2. +1
        14 January 2015 19: 40
        Even if it is unprofitable, the United States will still mine it, since this is a matter of energy security of the states. A trifle, of course, go broke, but large companies do not. Moreover, if shale oil production drops sharply, then prices will rise again and this production will again be profitable. But in general, the resources on Earth are not infinite, and that which will not be obtained today, will be obtained tomorrow. And the more resources run out, the more they will cost tomorrow. Albeit at a slow pace, but large economies are still growing, which means that consumption will also grow, which means that either more resources will be mined or their prices will rise.
      3. Gluxar_
        0
        15 January 2015 17: 49
        Quote: ya.seliwerstov2013
        The end of the shale revolution! Here you have low oil prices: shale oil production is already unprofitable. Shale gas in line.

        There is one more point. The shale bubble will burst twice. The first cotton is today's curtailment of drilling and the subsequent bankruptcy of more than $ 200 billion.
        And the second cotton is due to the fact that the shale bubble had a margin of safety of environmental standards. Some analysts believe that shale drilling is the future that adapts to market conditions. Today, the price drops and stop drilling. Tomorrow, when prices rise. They will immediately restore drilling.
        But this is far from the case, if the price failure lasts two three years, then by the time prices rise to the surface, the consequences of environmental fracking will come out. And no one will agree to continue this bacchanalia.
        Moreover, there will be a third cotton, already in the financial sector. Bankruptcies worth 200 billion are worth more than 600 billion loans. And those loans are worth more than $ 3 trillion of derivatives ... and all this will go awry.
        So isolation of the Russian economy from the western one can play a plus when this avalanche goes.
    2. Dumb
      +15
      14 January 2015 07: 21
      Ready to go to doshirak, just to look at convulsions in
      "revolutionary" industries in the United States ...
      1. +2
        14 January 2015 07: 58
        I’m ready to go to Doshirak just to see their entire top on the gallows and in gas chambers and their offspring in the form of fertilizers in the ground
      2. +10
        14 January 2015 08: 35
        I wonder if mattress mats will begin to sow "democracy" on the Arabian Peninsula in such a combination? This will be joke.
        1. tkhonov66
          +2
          14 January 2015 16: 12
          "...
          I wonder if mattress mats will begin to sow "democracy" on the Arabian Peninsula in such a combination? This will be joke.
          ..."
          .
          - yeah ...
          this "joke" will immediately raise the price of oil!
          8-))
      3. +1
        14 January 2015 18: 54
        Why do you start with trump cards right away? lol But seriously, at a price of $ 30 a barrel, the Yankees' patience may well burst. Suffer losses, and even leave your destroyer with a profit ... well, no pipes. These guys have a completely different philosophy. It may well happen that an oil storage "accidentally" explodes in Arabia, or there ... a ship, while mooring, "accidentally" enters an oil terminal. Or "suddenly" the oppressed subjects of the kingdom will desire democracy - any excuse that can scare buyers with the prospect of a possible rise in price will do. Which will be the reason for the rise in price.
    3. +2
      14 January 2015 07: 27
      I bet the Americans will start pushing the subsidy project through Congress, because in their opinion a whole state is opposed to private companies
      1. +4
        14 January 2015 09: 02
        the idea is correct, but tax preferences are already included in the "shale" ... therefore they are competitors in price (especially hectares) in America, but beyond the hillock, except for delivery + tax "burden" ... here is the end of the "fairy tale" )))
        1. +3
          14 January 2015 10: 10
          Quote: biv61
          that's the end of the "fairy tale"))


          And who got into it, zvizdets !!!! laughing
    4. +2
      14 January 2015 07: 38
      No, it’s not Russia that rejoices, not Venezuela, but Saudi Arabia. The statements of her other subjects suggest the correct idea: the price will collapse to twenty per barrel.


      Let's wait a little more. There, at the Saudis, the king is on his last legs. And after death, anything can happen! Including the price of oil can climb up. hi
    5. +3
      14 January 2015 08: 01
      It is believed that the price war against the "shale companies" is being waged not so much by the Saudis as by the so-called "five sisters", the largest oil companies that have collectively invested about a trillion dollars in offshore and other costly projects. And they need a high oil price. to "recoup" the money invested. But first you need to drown the competitors who were obviously dumping. Is this so, or not, wait and see ...
    6. +1
      14 January 2015 08: 04
      “Shale Revolution” devours its children... and the sooner they gobble up the better ..
    7. +6
      14 January 2015 08: 25
      “Shale Revolution” devours its children

      Well, again 25 ...
      Quote: ya.seliwerstov2013
      The end of the shale revolution!

      Quote: Dumb
      Ready to go to doshirak, just to look at convulsions in
      "revolutionary" industries in the United States ...

      Cool down gentlemen / comrades, shale oil will never "die" now (unless, of course, oil is needed). Even if the oil price reaches the bottom and shale oil production stops, as soon as the oil price rises, shale oil production will resume. Oil is not going anywhere, so the price of oil will jump in the corridor of $ 60-$ 80 per barrel ...
      Shale mining is more flexible and can be quickly restored as soon as the price situation improves. If a conventional well was shut, it might take months, if not years, to return to its previous production level, said Isa Ramasami, director of Platts in Houston. But recovery of production at a well where fracking is used takes only a week, “therefore, American shale oil producers can return to the market in a short time, as soon as prices begin to rise
      1. +4
        14 January 2015 09: 13
        Precisely because the mining of "shale" is quickly renewable, the words of the cunning prince are simply "noodles". All these references to the world economic situation are an excuse on duty. The Saudis are ready to suffer losses only on condition of counter bonuses from the USA. And there can be only one bonuses - the rise in oil prices after the default in Russia, and the decline of the oil-extracting industries in Venezuela and Norway. After that, St. Arabia will receive "permission" to reduce production and stimulate a sharp rise in the price of oil, American companies will speed up the production of "shale" and will try to get the EU on it. Time is key. Who will be the first to fail? - S-Arabia will not be able (conditionally) to "keep" low prices, or Russia / Venezuela / Norway will bend in an economic collapse.
        1. +1
          14 January 2015 09: 31
          Quote: andrew42
          ... After that, St. Arabia will receive "permission" to reduce production and stimulate a sharp rise in oil prices

          A dubious option ... just a world on the verge of an energy revolution that will finally determine the price of oil and the fact that it will never be $ 100 per barrel is already probable.
    8. +1
      14 January 2015 08: 56
      “Shale Revolution” devours its children



      To the very point. The shale revolution kills nature; it cannot be measured with any money.


    9. nicollider
      +3
      14 January 2015 09: 14
      Al-Waleed holds a little for all fools: Saudi Arabia is the main Arab ally of the United States. and something they don’t hear about problems with democracy, in any other country there would already be a revolution and NATO would iron peaceful cities
      1. Nikolav
        +1
        14 January 2015 12: 42
        King of Saudi Arabia at death. Serious political upheavals are expected, right up to the collapse of Saudi Arabia into 3-4 states.
    10. nicollider
      0
      14 January 2015 09: 15
      Yes, put the United States on slates, if necessary - they will print more greens and give them to the Saudis. the question is about the continued existence of the hegemon, and not about some kind of oil
    11. Taltanbek
      +1
      14 January 2015 09: 25
      As long as there is greed, they will get and try each other’s HOSE, today they left tomorrow they came - this is a race on the spot for Humanity.

      The BEST ABSOLUTE for the remnants of all RUSSIAN-HUMANITY would be:
      IMMEDIATELY as much as ALL THEM and THEM! preferably in a "slow instant" would devour the Yellowstone volcano, neatly, beautifully somewhere on the horizon, flowing around the RUSSIAN Earth with lava! ...
    12. +2
      14 January 2015 10: 00
      In any case, this is a chance for us to get off the notorious oil needle. Sooner or later, but it had to happen. Of course, it’s bad that this happened now, when the Sochi construction site of the century had just died down and the football one loomed, and even without this, a wagon and a small cart. But for us it is definitely a matter of survival. Or we will adapt to the low price of oil, or as the Soviet Union, we order a long life. We have no other way, comrades. It’s time to forget the sweet bliss of recent years, when $ 120 and above allowed us to practically do nothing without riding like cheese in butter. It's time to start WORK.
    13. itr
      0
      14 January 2015 10: 17
      Yes, neither of which amers will not collapse! since this is the only country that does not make money but prints it!
      The only solution I see
      it is to sell Gazprom to a "private person" and he will unilaterally return the old gas prices for all counterparties, more precisely for Europe
      It's disgusting but I think it will hit the economies of our "friends" very hard
    14. +5
      14 January 2015 10: 27
      Quote: mitya24
      It’s time to forget the sweet bliss of recent years, when $ 120 and above allowed us to practically nothing without creating a ride like cheese in butter. It's time to start WORK.

      In general, we didn’t work weakly at $ 120, and now we are working hard. And the one who skated like cheese in butter then will not work now.
    15. +1
      14 January 2015 10: 40
      The fall in oil prices was caused not by political or economic reasons, but by leaked information previously widely concealed that oil and gas are RENEWABLE RESOURCES. That organic energy carriers are NOT LIFE SYSTEMS OF BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMS, but are products of GEOTHERMAL SYNTHESIS occurring in the earth's crust constantly and not ceasing for the next hundreds of thousands of years.
    16. +5
      14 January 2015 11: 24
      In the morning I read this article in RBC and was amazed!
      Banking analysts predict the price of oil accurate to half a dollar for years!
      What kind of economy is this, where people who have never seen and do not understand the extraction of mineral resources and their processing, bank clerks - analysts and experts - dictate the prices of the whole and main branch of the economy!
      Where are the real manufacturers with their prices and profitability? Where are the consumers? Where is the recycling?
      Here is the result of the exchange economy, where the real numbers of real production are replaced by a game on the exchange!
      No matter how they spit, they did not throw stones at one well-known book by a German author of the beginning of the last century, namely, Hitler wrote about the danger of a stock exchange economy!
      Alas, this "crazy" corporal foresaw too much.
      And do not hope that this is done in order to collapse the US economy!
      This will never happen!
      They will preserve their deposits (it will be more secure and safe for the future) and will gladly consume cheap raw materials. They have a real working real economy! And they dictate their terms to the world in dollars, in their fleet, army, air force, missiles!
      But Russia has already lowered its status to garbage. And with the real economy it’s tight. The ruble is just in w ..pe. And the country's elite is corrupt and thievish.
      Venezuela will have problems. No wonder Madura flies like a ball around the planet.
      Other countries that are poorly controlled by thieves and traitors will also have problems.
      So let's go wild for our country!
      And it’s not the enemies that destroy, but the friends usually. So our elite and power must show themselves or why it is needed!
      1. +1
        14 January 2015 11: 41
        I agree with you! can't like, newbie)
    17. -5
      14 January 2015 11: 40
      Brezhnev at one time fattened on expensive oil, the result of the collapse of the USSR. Over the past 15 years, Putin has done little to reduce dependence on oil; all the money has gone into the defense. Hard decades are waiting for us!
      1. +1
        14 January 2015 12: 21
        And if he wasn’t fooling into the defense industry, there will be no such decades ... However, then the price drop probably didn’t happen, the PSA suits them quite well. "Well, what are the taxes?"
    18. 0
      14 January 2015 13: 04
      Yes, all the rules, if only Europe would not cancel the sanctions. It is very necessary that your manufacturer grows and becomes competitive. Maybe for this they dropped the ruble?
    19. 0
      14 January 2015 14: 25
      We all need to learn to assess the economic situation in the Russian Federation and the world in a geopolitical context, by the way, we should ALWAYS be able to do this for all of us, both in the 19th century, and in the 20th century, and in the 21st century. When we try to EVALUATE (!!!) the actions of princes and governments in this field, we must understand the initial indicators for each parameter, and the goals of the final task. Any mathematician, physicist, who, as a rule, are involved in solving their profile problems will tell you this: given - V and t, you need to find S. Here is the formula, here is the data, substitute and solve. Problem solved !!! Applause! This does not happen in politics and geopolitics. Since the number of persons who own all the DATA and PURPOSES (what to find) is negligible. Only these people can write such evaluation articles. All the rest are like schoolchildren - Losers, who do not have the opportunity (they cannot, due to objective circumstances) operate with data, just by definition they cannot correctly solve this generally not difficult problem (no more difficult than the Gauss equation). You just need to own all the data, but who will give them this data. So the poor fellows poke their assessments, not knowing the TRUE PURPOSE and the REAL DATA, like blind kittens. Therefore, the conclusions of the author of the article (so to speak, "Analytics") simply have nothing to do with the correct solution of the problem, which, as I see it at the present time (and always before), is how to take away from the Russians their wealth, and so that no one nothing was (bad). That's all!!! Everything is subordinated to this task. All! All these princes, the essence of the doll in someone's invisible hands and what they say is simply not important.
    20. 0
      14 January 2015 16: 02
      Did you believe the words of this prince?
    21. -1
      14 January 2015 16: 37
      Wangyu - soon the United States in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia will discover a lack of democracy with all its consequences ..
    22. skorceny.uncle
      0
      14 January 2015 18: 56
      Four years ago, an analysis was published on the engineering website that compared the cost of oil extracted by Arabs at $ 2 per barrel, and heavy Russian oil at $ 10 for the same herring barrel. Marginality goes off scale, in the first case 5000%, in the second 1000%. They were grandmothers from the air, just arrogant speculation. Now the price is slowly creeping to its real value. Of course, fat cats will not want to lose easy money. Most likely, they compensate for their losses with a cartel agreement with oil producers. Therefore, the prices for fuels and lubricants will remain at the same level, plus or minus 3-5%. And nobody's economy will collapse .... never. drinks
    23. 0
      14 January 2015 21: 02
      That's the site we have! The comments describe so little about the murder of the USSR by a fall in oil prices, which, as it was, was not quite so. But the price began to rise relatively recently. And the potential laid from the Soviet times dragged the Russian economy in the nineties and two thousandths. Why am I doing this.
      How many abandoned workshops, industrial sites, transport infrastructure in the country. We are racking our brains over where to relocate monotowns. And then a gift from God. Sanctions and currency appreciation. The Lord has revealed to Russia the conditions for real import substitution, and not a talking shop for the second decade about diversification. And it will be offensive and bitter if the country skips this chance. Personally, if everything returns to the state of 1.01.2014/1/3 again, I will join the ranks of the "all-consuming". Over there, on the radio, some very competent uncle was arguing that turning on the printing press was disastrous for the Russian economy. And he modestly kept silent about printing money for an industrial product in the form of treasury bills in the USSR (5, XNUMX, XNUMX rubles). And this is the money that created jobs, i.e. production of a national product. And the fact that the market is now and competition with the WTO framework, with such an exchange rate difference, still stimulates the internal consumption of the national product, which will provide printed money, and an increase in the money supply will not allow the exchange rate to fall, but will increase the export opportunities of the manufacturing sector. China is doing this, by the way. And the world financial sector is periodically reproached by China for the undervalued yuan. But the authorities there are probably independent in making decisions on a manitarian policy, while in our country they are looking around where it is clear.
    24. 0
      14 January 2015 21: 39
      Cases in the oil market are dark, but cartel conspiracy and the game of lowering the price of oil can still be assumed with a high degree of probability. There are quite powerful players who were able to organize this process, but the final goals of this event have not yet been announced.
    25. 0
      14 January 2015 21: 45
      Men, and there is still oil produced by Isil and how does it affect the market? I think the price of such oil is not at all market. Explain to knowledgeable people. Thank you!

    "Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar people (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned), Kirill Budanov (included to the Rosfinmonitoring list of terrorists and extremists)

    “Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"