Military Review

Indian military noted the special approach of Russians to anti-terrorist operations

56
The Indian general at the exercise noted the differences in the approaches of the Indian and Russian military to anti-terrorism measures, reports RIA News with reference to the press service of the Southern Military District.

Indian military noted the special approach of Russians to anti-terrorist operations


The Indra-2014 joint Indian-Russian tactical exercises, which began on September 23 at the Prudboy proving ground (Volgograd region), will continue until October October 2. The units are working on joint actions for the protection of state objects, the maintenance of columns and the destruction of gangs.

"As Brigadier General of the Indian Armed Forces Birbal Singh Jahar noted, the main difference in the actions of the units was that the Russian military actively used armored vehicles when blocking the town seized by the enemy, but the Indian forces focused on the actions of the infantry groups," release

The general also noted the different approaches to the storming of buildings - during the training operation, the Russian military began to seize the building from the lower floors, while the Indian military began the assault from the upper floors, which they reached via staircases. At the same time, the Indian general stressed that “the experience gained is useful for both parties and is worthy of analysis and study.”

Singh Jahar, in addition, intends to report to the Indian military leadership his "proposals on the advisability of purchasing Russian weapons and equipping motorized infantry units, taking into account the example of Russian motorized infantry troops."

The press service noted that “Indian servicemen studied the specifics of Russian weapons by performing live firing from RPG grenade launchers, Kalashnikov machine guns and machine guns, as well as SVD sniper rifles.”
Photos used:
ria.ru
56 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. svp67
    svp67 29 September 2014 20: 39
    +10
    Here's what you can’t disagree with, and so with this
    that "the experience gained is useful for both parties and worthy of analysis and study."
    And it's good that the troops are learning what is needed and not "on the fingers ...", but in reality
    1. Shaitan
      Shaitan 29 September 2014 20: 41
      +5
      I don’t know what Indians can teach, but ours certainly have something to learn!
      1. The comment was deleted.
      2. Vitaly Anisimov
        Vitaly Anisimov 29 September 2014 21: 07
        +6
        Quote: Shaitan
        I don’t know what Indians can teach, but ours certainly have something to learn!

        If you just judge by their hats .. laughing
      3. Siberian
        Siberian 29 September 2014 21: 09
        +9
        .... And what is even the difference in the approaches of storming the building of some from above, and ours from below, also makes you think, or maybe you should learn from the Indians ......
        1. uralkos
          uralkos 30 September 2014 00: 35
          +1
          No, you should not storm from above how the security will pass, etc. ???
      4. Paradoxov
        Paradoxov 29 September 2014 21: 12
        +10
        Indian military noted the special approach of Russians to anti-terrorist operations

        Interestingly, did the Russian military not note the special approach of the Indians to anti-terrorist operations? laughing
        The Hindus block the building from the upper floors - the "blocked" ones leave the bottom, everything is logical - quickly and without unnecessary collisions. wassat
        I recalled the grandfather's joke: two vigilantes ran into the police station and reported to the duty officer - We detained the suspect on the street, tied him to a post! Hands tied? - Not! So he will untie himself and run away! - No, this one does not think of it; he is from our village! laughing
        1. Veteran of the USSR
          Veteran of the USSR 30 September 2014 00: 30
          +6
          Well, I don’t know how it is in your village, but when you listen to the conversations of Moscow high school students, it seems that they have just fled from the fools of a house with a criminal smack. And the Indians of 60 years almost did not get out of the war. The Indians are an old and reliable friend of our country, whom it is an honor to help and not a sin to learn something. Well, mocking a friend’s mistakes is at least not a sign of intelligence.
          1. 76rtbr
            76rtbr 30 September 2014 05: 16
            -2
            it’s interesting and what kind of wars they are waging, dancing around an art installation (whoever saw the video will understand), this is called a fight, damn it, you can die with laughter !!!! and who will fight, the poor and ragged billion, but they will go to the jungle, they will eat boas without chewing, than to get pindyuly for castes !!!
        2. Weniamin
          Weniamin 30 September 2014 06: 16
          +4
          Quote: Paradoxov
          The Hindus block the building from the upper floors - the "blocked" ones leave the bottom, everything is logical - quickly and without unnecessary collisions.

          I do not agree. The upper floors are the most advantageous position for the defenders, and therefore the greatest concentration of soldiers. On the other hand, on the contrary, they are limited in assaulting stairs from above - in terms of quantity and maneuver, and therefore are most vulnerable.
      5. Kasym
        Kasym 29 September 2014 21: 28
        +24
        There is always something to learn from others. I remember at joint anti-terrorist exercises a couple of years ago, when the command was growing up. the parties noted the actions of "saboteurs-terrorists" (in this role the mountain rifle unit of the Armed Forces of the Republic of Kazakhstan played). "We were surprised at the skillful use of horses in the mountains by saboteurs. They are like mountain crushers in the mountains - try to unhook the region, cut the paths of advancement and neutralize such !? We even completed the task, but had to" sweat "and learn a good lesson. learn and gain experience for analysis. "
        Hindus have experience in liberating the Taj Mahal Hotel and the Buddhist Golden Temple (in my opinion, such names). The slaughter there kept the whole world in suspense. There radicals from Pakistan "showed themselves". These animals shot at everyone, indiscriminately. Especially the Europeans were not spared. Special Forces of India "Black Cats". India has suffered from terror since the dawn of independence. Jawaharlal Nehru, Indira Gandhi and their son are worth - constant assassination attempts. So there is a lot to learn from them. hi
      6. And Us Rat
        And Us Rat 29 September 2014 21: 42
        +7
        Quote: Shaitan
        I don’t know what Indians can teach, but ours certainly have something to learn!


        Until recently, there was no normal anti-terrorism unit in India. There were saboteurs ("Black cats"), but in terms of freeing the hostages (something more serious than a lone psycho) they were in difficulty.
        After the terrorist attacks in Mumbai on 26-29 on November 2008, the Indians decided to fill this gap.
        The first full-fledged counterterrorism unit was "Force One" belonging to the Mumbai police.

        Force One was founded in 2009 from volunteer officers (army and police). Out of 3000 candidates, 216 fighters completed the first graduation, the best of whom became instructors for subsequent graduations (also for army special forces).
        The first issue was trained and prepared by three special forces officers of the IDF border service.



        And as for the stairs to the upper floors - the author messed up something, probably meant - that the storming of the building is going on simultaneously from above and below.
        1. Stypor23
          Stypor23 29 September 2014 22: 44
          +3
          Quote: And Us Rat
          The first issue was trained and prepared by three special forces officers of the IDF border service.

          Not a single serious booze is complete without Jews. laughing
      7. Patton5
        Patton5 30 September 2014 01: 49
        +4
        I don’t know what Indians can teach
        I don’t know, I don’t know ... But I watched a movie about "Pennant" So it was said there that I learned a lot from the Vietnamese ... I think you should not underestimate!
      8. radar1967
        radar1967 30 September 2014 02: 13
        +3
        Hindus can teach the war in the jungle. Probably ... But the cleaning of buildings from the upper floors, although welcomed by special forces .... But in practice is difficult.
        1. We have not only 2-storey houses, but also 9 floors in bulk.
        2. There are no helicopters.
        3. From the roof you can protect one building. But if a whole block is under control, then you will be swept away from neighboring houses. Together with a helicopter and stairs.
        4. You can storm without heavy equipment only a separate building. When the enemy’s whereabouts are known, both the sniper and the machine gunners keep the windows under the gun and prevent them from popping out.
        Consequently, the naive Indian general admitted that, seriously, they not only did not work, but also did not plan to do this. But in vain ... The case is different.
        1. kodxnumx
          kodxnumx 30 September 2014 07: 55
          0
          I’m sure our guys had something to punish! It’s not for nothing that our special forces are the best in the world, and the tactics of the Russian Armed Forces are one of the best, no doubt.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  2. Gray 43
    Gray 43 29 September 2014 20: 45
    +6
    It would not hurt ours to actively transfer the experience of the fight against terrorists to the army of New Russia, they have a real problem with this
  3. Alez
    Alez 29 September 2014 20: 47
    +1
    Indians get to the upper floors with the help of stairs. And if a skyscraper or a skyscraper? Unclear...
    1. SSR
      SSR 29 September 2014 22: 09
      +3
      Quote: Alez
      Indians get to the upper floors with the help of stairs. And if a skyscraper or a skyscraper? Unclear...

      A helicopter to a skyscraper or a skyscraper, that is, the scale of the operation. Damn, probably when storming a skyscraper, our special forces will begin to use scaffolding with a protecting net, so that no one falls out. At the expense of armored vehicles, is there a difference a tank pulled up or for example a shilka?
  4. Magic archer
    Magic archer 29 September 2014 20: 47
    +2
    Could Indians instead of SVD and something newer to palm off! You look and the contract would be immediately signed wink
    1. Siberia 9444
      Siberia 9444 29 September 2014 21: 44
      +1
      And what alternative to SVD do we have? (semiautomatic machine chambered for 7.62x54) "bolts" are not even the shaft and the screw cutter is a special weapon too. request
    2. Siberia 9444
      Siberia 9444 29 September 2014 21: 44
      0
      And what alternative to SVD do we have? (semiautomatic machine chambered for 7.62x54) "bolts" are not even the shaft and the screw cutter is a special weapon too. request
  5. Barakuda
    Barakuda 29 September 2014 20: 50
    +7
    Hindus, do not be offended, but you are stunted, I guarded you at the school so that the hooligans would not fill their faces on the street. But cook the rice - super! there really are many spices .. smile
    1. FREGATENKAPITAN
      FREGATENKAPITAN 29 September 2014 21: 20
      +12
      Alexander the Great received in the first (excuse me, I'll write in a simple way) in the face in India .... where his great campaigns ended ........ It was from the "stunted" Indians!
      1. Turkir
        Turkir 29 September 2014 22: 45
        +1
        No, from Russian Aryans repeat
      2. Starley from the south
        Starley from the south 29 September 2014 23: 10
        +5
        Not quite right. For the first time in the face he received in Central Asia, when Samarkand (then Marakanda) could not take. From anger, then destroyed to the foundation the small town of Chach (now Tashkent).
    2. samoletil18
      samoletil18 29 September 2014 21: 25
      +2
      Quote: Barracuda
      Hindus, do not be offended, but you are stunted, I guarded you at the school so that the hooligans would not fill their faces on the street. But cook the rice - super! there really are many spices .. smile

      Then it’s clear what they’re starting from above.
    3. And Us Rat
      And Us Rat 29 September 2014 22: 57
      +5
      Quote: Barracuda
      Hindus don't be offended, but you're stunted


      not to look nervous laughing

      1. Stypor23
        Stypor23 29 September 2014 23: 10
        +3
        Quote: And Us Rat
        not to look nervous

        What are you happy builder? fool They killed so many building materials. belay.They will break your bricks when they come to visit you bully
      2. goose
        goose 30 September 2014 10: 46
        0
        This is not tin. You should have seen what they can do in various sects, where they teach ancient martial arts. Let's just say, practice strikes on the rail - this is for beginners. And they have a bunch of special exercises for training, no worse than in Shaolin.
        These showmen aren't cool at all. Cool people will not have blood after such exercises. But something showed. I understand that this is something like a standard army entertainment group. A la our airborne troops.
        Chinese special forces can also show all sorts of unique chips.
  6. skeket
    skeket 29 September 2014 20: 51
    +6
    The general also noted different approaches to the assault on buildings - the Russian military during the training operation began to capture the building from the lower floors, while Indian soldiers began the assault from the upper floors, which were reached by stairs.

    So our task is to destroy the terror, that is, they storm from below, so as not to scatter, and the main thing for Indians is to free the building.
    PS. By the way, I snubbed over the form, just like haute couture hats, although I might not understand something, maybe it's individual locators ...
  7. raid14
    raid14 29 September 2014 20: 53
    +5
    Indians have their own specifics, work in a blocked settlement foot mobile groups without the support of armored vehicles, the loss of soldiers. The assault on the upper floors with the help of stairs that need to be brought to a shot-through, guarded building and immediately flattery without intelligence, famously.
    1. FREGATENKAPITAN
      FREGATENKAPITAN 29 September 2014 22: 24
      +2
      But it’s logical ..... Landing on the roof from a turntable (let the stairs if possible) And the terrorists are squeezed down ... below, they are blocked and also assaulted, and during an assault from the bottom, it is possible to retreat floor, floor up, (and if the floors are 50-?), and if they are prepared in advance for defense .............. I'm certainly not special. Alpha ... but tactfully it seems to me literate!
      1. Starley from the south
        Starley from the south 29 September 2014 23: 19
        +4
        Although I’m not special, but in my humble opinion, the choice of how to storm the building, from above or from below, depends on the specific features of the task. Somewhere better below, and somewhere above.
        1. cyberhanter
          cyberhanter 30 September 2014 00: 58
          +1
          however, in a spherical vacuum, ceteris paribus, literate from above. even in the pamphlets of the Red Army this was written about. nuances are nuances.
        2. Spitfire
          Spitfire 30 September 2014 07: 48
          0
          I agree. If the assault in the old city, then what kind of armored vehicles in the narrow streets, it will not pass there. In addition, do not forget about overpopulation - there are already more than a billion of them, you can afford to storm without armored vehicles (as it is not cynical, but APCs are more expensive).
  8. Mol
    Mol 29 September 2014 20: 56
    0
    A funny form for Indian ... comrades (or partners?) Some kind of peacock tail on a headdress. Interesting - they are storming these ... mmm ... caps of the building ?! laughing
    "The general also noted different approaches to the storming of buildings - during a training operation, the Russian military began to seize the building from the lower floors, while the Indian military began the assault from the upper floors, where they got with the help of stairs."
    And the Indians block the entrances and exits while the building is being cleaned from above? Or does their sweep from the upper floors begin because the enemy calmly left the building without a fight, while the Indian security forces are noisy at the top? lol
    "The press service noted that" Indian servicemen studied the peculiarities of Russian weapons by performing live firing from RPG grenade launchers, Kalashnikov machine guns and assault rifles, as well as SVD sniper rifles. "
    With all due respect to the good old Soviet weapons, haven’t anything newer been found among ours to show the Indians ?! International exercises, after all! Though dust in the eyes ... request
    1. Starley from the south
      Starley from the south 29 September 2014 23: 21
      +2
      SVD is still not out of date. The proverb just refers to it: not everything that is old is bad.
      1. Mol
        Mol 30 September 2014 00: 24
        +2
        Adam, I didn't say a word about the fact that SVD, RPG or PC are bad. Not at all. I'm talking about something else. Due to the fact that this weapon has been produced for a long time, the Indians probably already had more than a dozen opportunities to study the "peculiarities of Russian weapons" of this type. It's just that today in the Russian Federation only the lazy does not talk about the rearmament and re-equipment of the RA. So I would like to understand why the guests were not allowed to get acquainted with new or modernized models of Russian weapons at the international exercises ?! Hindus are actively buying Russian weapons! So show them the Kord machine gun, the Pecheneg PKP, the ASVK sniper rifle, SVDK, RPG 30/32, etc. (Although it is possible that the demonstrated weapon is just superficially described in this article, and some new samples were given to the Indians to "feel".)
  9. Barakuda
    Barakuda 29 September 2014 20: 58
    +4
    These are the allies ... The mix is ​​open.
    1. sabakina
      sabakina 29 September 2014 21: 18
      +4
      How much this video saw, I just can’t understand:
      1. why so push?
      2. If this is a long-range weapon, why all these bells and whistles with the engine? Or are they going to hold a circular defense with this weapon?
      1. The comment was deleted.
      2. Sergey-8848
        Sergey-8848 30 September 2014 04: 17
        +1
        Yes, this video has been laid out for a long time, but the preparation flaws are still visible:
        - no songs;
        - no elephants;
        - There are no separated twin sisters with the same mole in an interesting place.
        Because Since the main Pakistani enemies act approximately the same, but they are not trained to dance, the chances of the Islamabad military are 0,00%.
        But seriously, the Indians (Indians) periodically fight not only on maps, so some experience gained. So when conducting anti-terror, they somehow act in their own way. Learning from each other is the most necessary thing!
        The pen of the general on a turban - pulled out of the back of a peacock in an open fierce battle. Well, the dress uniform is like that! You look at the Greek guards, or at Grachev's cap.
    2. samoletil18
      samoletil18 29 September 2014 21: 39
      +6
      With bitterness, we have to admit that the choreographic training of the Russian gunners is lame. But in vain. What for these tables, all kinds of ballistics ... Ritual and dance, and the target is struck.
    3. Deadmen
      Deadmen 29 September 2014 21: 40
      +2
      why so many extra gestures? will they set up karma on the battlefield for so long?
    4. valentina-makanalina
      valentina-makanalina 29 September 2014 21: 45
      +3
      The movements, as in Indian cinema, probably also sing.
      And if the engine fails? How then to act? Yes, and the time to bring into a fighting position and before the first shot is large. How does it leave a position and how is it applied if firing from cover?
      But in general, interesting and funny.
    5. Bowless
      Bowless 29 September 2014 21: 46
      +1
      The D-30 would have already heated up the barrel a long time ago.
    6. Gradus HuK
      Gradus HuK 29 September 2014 22: 57
      0
      Military Swan Lake. I love the INDIAN BALLET!
    7. kagorta
      kagorta 30 September 2014 07: 43
      +1
      It seems that the British, when they were taught all this, they simply were bored and wanted to neigh. laughing
  10. semuil
    semuil 29 September 2014 20: 58
    +5
    [quote– during the training operation, the Russian military began to capture the building from the lower floors, while the Indian military began the assault from the upper floorsquote] They just don’t know that we are on the drum from which floors (top or bottom) to work.
  11. Aandrewsir
    Aandrewsir 29 September 2014 21: 00
    +1
    Military cooperation with the Indians is a good and useful business. Exchange experience, trade weapons ... That's right. It is high time. And about the different approaches to actions during anti-terrorist operations ... In my opinion, our actions are more balanced and thought out and will lead to less loss. But, each of the partners has the right to their opinion.
    1. Phantom Revolution
      Phantom Revolution 29 September 2014 22: 09
      +1
      with their population, losses in 100 people will turn out to be a drop in the ocean.
  12. Destroyqqqq
    Destroyqqqq 29 September 2014 21: 02
    +4
    Well, so the Russians did the right thing from the lower floors, for terrorists the waste routes are only up and from there they either surrender or jump in the face on the asphalt. And from the bottom you can hide with impunity.
    1. Maki Avellevich
      Maki Avellevich 29 September 2014 21: 22
      +12
      Destroyqqqq : "they did it right starting from the lower floors"

      stripping tactics "up" not from the good life. there is simply usually no other alternative.

      10 times out of 10 choose the option to fight with the advantage of height.


      ps I once had to take part in a small shootout. approximately 10 soldiers on each side.
      we were in a valley about 60 meters below the enemy.
      the feeling is something else I will tell you. like a mouse in the middle of the room.
      1. Phantom Revolution
        Phantom Revolution 29 September 2014 22: 12
        +1
        well, 60 meters along the slope or 2 meters along the stairs and not always on it, but in the majority on narrow corridors there are two big differences.
        1. Maki Avellevich
          Maki Avellevich 30 September 2014 08: 02
          +4
          Phantom Revolution:

          "Well, 60 meters up the slope or 2 meters up the stairs and not always on it, but in most of the narrow corridors there are two big differences."


          Have you ever thrown a grenade? if so, imagine yourself throwing a grenade up the stairs ...
      2. SSR
        SSR 29 September 2014 22: 14
        +1
        Quote: Maki Avellevich
        Destroyqqqq : "they did it right starting from the lower floors"

        stripping tactics "up" not from the good life. there is simply usually no other alternative.

        10 times out of 10 choose the option to fight with the advantage of height.


        ps I once had to take part in a small shootout. approximately 10 soldiers on each side.
        we were in a valley about 60 meters below the enemy.
        the feeling is something else I will tell you. like a mouse in the middle of the room.

        From the heart +
        Not only that, any assault from the bottom up is fraught with equal armament and, if not equal, a land mine and there is no building. Something like this .
    2. Turkir
      Turkir 29 September 2014 22: 47
      +2
      Well, so the Russians did the right thing starting from the lower floors, for terrorists, the waste routes only to the top

      and there they were already waiting for the cunning Indians drinks
  13. Barakuda
    Barakuda 29 September 2014 21: 05
    +2
    Indeed, there is no difference. In practice, I hit the RPG three times, a couple of flash and noise, and on boarding. Only the news will not tell you about it. And the corpses will not show. And before that - two machine gunners are sitting 2 meters away, and "watering" the windows.
  14. PV-Schnick
    PV-Schnick 29 September 2014 21: 06
    +2
    tomorrow I'll go see it
  15. APASUS
    APASUS 29 September 2014 21: 11
    +8
    It’s certainly necessary to build bridges with the Indians, it’s good for everyone, but the difference is rather in the mentality, and there’s a different approach. Whoever sees dockers working in India - their hair stands on end, they don’t even hear about any safety measures or instruction there. It only costs to see how they return from cities home for the holidays - everything becomes clear
    1. Denis 60 rus
      Denis 60 rus 29 September 2014 21: 22
      0
      subway at rush hour smokes
      1. Starley from the south
        Starley from the south 29 September 2014 23: 24
        0
        The metro is resting!
    2. Denis 60 rus
      Denis 60 rus 29 September 2014 21: 22
      +3
      subway at rush hour smokes
    3. The comment was deleted.
    4. Vitaly Anisimov
      Vitaly Anisimov 29 September 2014 22: 00
      +1
      Quote: APASUS
      It’s certainly necessary to build bridges with the Indians, it’s good for everyone, but the difference is rather in the mentality, and there’s a different approach. Whoever sees dockers working in India - their hair stands on end, they don’t even hear about any safety measures or instruction there. It only costs to see how they return from cities home for the holidays - everything becomes clear

      Yeah .. J \ D in India is clearly unprofitable ..))) We need to start electric trains .. (with wires over the cars)))
      1. Kasym
        Kasym 29 September 2014 23: 01
        +2
        That makes Asia more interesting. A lot needs to be built, both infrastructure and housing stock, and money for this has appeared. Another would be to "entangle" with your energy carriers and economically "tie" to your economy.
        Once a European acquaintance said: "We, in Europe, have already built everything. Everything is regulated, spelled out, etc. Infrastructure, roads, etc. And for you this is actual, a lot of cases, work, materials and production. This is LIFE, when you create and create. And in Asia now everything has come together - money, growth of economies and consumption; people want to live better - not worse than in the EU. 20 years what were Korea, China, Vietnam, India and a number of other countries of the continent? And now it is the center of attraction for all world investors and bankers, technologies and new industries. "
        1. APASUS
          APASUS 30 September 2014 21: 31
          0
          Quote: Kasym
          That is why Asia is more interesting.

          In order to work in Asia, a European needs to live a couple of years to study the local mentality, and only then business and everything else. In Asia, there is no concept for cars like carrying capacity, how lucky it is - you can load so much. And so the attitude to many things, so that with one interest not to live in Asia.
    5. Metlik
      Metlik 30 September 2014 09: 29
      0


      We have a lot in common with the Indians.
  16. Deadmen
    Deadmen 29 September 2014 21: 17
    +2
    Well, that’s how we’ll act. We will beat the enemy in the nose and the Indians will come from the back door))
  17. Reserve officer
    Reserve officer 29 September 2014 21: 38
    +2
    Differences in tactics are not so important. The main thing is cooperation. And then there is always something to learn from each other.
  18. combat66
    combat66 29 September 2014 21: 39
    +1
    But they have cool incense! wink
  19. Mih
    Mih 29 September 2014 21: 43
    +2
    Singh Jahar, in addition, intends to report to the Indian military leadership his "proposals on the advisability of purchasing Russian weapons and equipping motorized infantry units, taking into account the example of Russian motorized infantry troops."

    Indus Russia phai, phai !!! fellow
  20. valentina-makanalina
    valentina-makanalina 29 September 2014 21: 48
    +1
    And together they did not try the attack. Some from below, others from above - ticks.
  21. DMB3000
    DMB3000 29 September 2014 22: 09
    +2
    not the topic. in a traffic accident a hiug crashed, which operated on the officer who saved the soldier, covering himself. such a cruel irony of life. mourn ...
  22. Alfizik
    Alfizik 30 September 2014 01: 05
    0
    And if the enemy is on the top floor or on the roof? Still, ours is right: whoever is higher is harder to fall.
  23. ratmir donetsk
    ratmir donetsk 30 September 2014 01: 17
    0
    how tough you are ... but what about cooperation against the West ??
  24. Thunderbolt
    Thunderbolt 30 September 2014 02: 01
    +4
    Kamaz-on and in India-Kamaz
  25. Viktor Kudinov
    Viktor Kudinov 30 September 2014 02: 17
    +1
    Quote: uralkos
    No, you should not storm from above how the security will pass, etc. ???


    Undermining must be taken! Digging!
  26. RusDV
    RusDV 30 September 2014 05: 39
    +1
    A lot of controversy about anything in the comments .... Where did the egg break ...? winked
    No, and there can be no unequivocal tactics (from above - from below). Everything is decided when planning the operation, preferably in the open air. The assault tactics are usually combined.
    Exit to the roof of the building and clean it from top to bottom is the most preferred method of cleaning the building. Cleaning the building from top to bottom is easier due to the fact that the force of gravity and the structure of the building work for the benefit of the capture group when throwing grenades and moving from floor to floor. This method is possible only in cases when access to the upper floor or the roof of the building is possible through the windows or the roof of neighboring, guarded buildings; or when the enemy’s air defense system can be suppressed and the group can be delivered to the roof by helicopter. Helicopters should only land on roofs that have special helipads or on roofs of garages. Fighters can climb ropes to the roof of a building or jump from a helicopter when it hangs at a low height above the roof. Then the groups make passages in the roof or common wall with the help of explosives and use ropes to lower them to the lower floors. Stairs should be protected when not in use.
    Despite the fact that the top-down cleaning method is preferable, the capture of the lower floor and the cleaning from the bottom up are more common, except when the buildings are adjacent to each other and form a single unit. When stripping from bottom to top, the capture group tries to get closer to the building from the flanks or rear. At the same time, all rooms on the lower floor are cleaned. After this, a systematic cleaning of the remaining floors begins.

    It is recommended that the entrance to the building be carried out through breaches in the walls, done with the help of explosives or shots from guns. The capture group avoids penetration through windows and doors, as they are usually mined or covered by enemy fire. If the company is given tanks smile they breach the wall with gun fire.
    After entering the building, the main tasks are to cover the stairwells leading to the upper floors and to the basement, as well as to capture rooms that control the path to the building. These actions are taken to isolate the enemy inside the building and prevent its gain from the outside. The capture groups clean all the rooms on the first floor and then the basement.
    If the capture group is preparing to clean the building from top to bottom, for this it is necessary to make a passage in the common wall or roof of the neighboring building. The capture group, accompanied by sappers, makes a passage in the wall using explosive charges, and goes to the upper floor. Access to the lower floors can be through gaps made in the floor using ropes or by jumping to the lower floor. Stairs can be used after preliminary cleaning.
    When stripping from top to bottom, the security requirements remain the same as with other methods. After making a hole in the floor, a grenade is thrown into it with a delay. Then the fighter processes the room with automatic fire and jumps into it.
    This is far from a complete description of the assault tactics .... The author of the article, apparently, did not know about these features ... he writes about what he does not know, and maybe the task is to mislead the enemy (reading this article) laughing
  27. TECHNOLOGY
    TECHNOLOGY 30 September 2014 07: 14
    0
    different approaches to storming buildings But there is something they can learn.
  28. The comment was deleted.
  29. TECHNOLOGY
    TECHNOLOGY 30 September 2014 07: 24
    +1
    But remember!
  30. demo
    demo 30 September 2014 07: 54
    +1
    And then there was a banquet.
    After which the Indian military for a long time and enthusiastically orally transmitted the events of that evening to their children and grandchildren.
  31. ed65b
    ed65b 30 September 2014 08: 52
    0
    Remember the Terrible and the storming of the Dudayev Palace. what kind of penetration on the roof could there be? Again, the Hindus hotel were beaten off for several days, half hit, and there were XNUMX terrorists in total. Beslan remember Nord Ost. Modern examples of the neutralization of bandits who have settled in homes. They drove the APCs into the house, added a fly or a bumblebee. Of course, we must share the experience and adopt all the best that third-party armies have, only do not forget about our own.
  32. Just
    Just 30 September 2014 10: 15
    0
    Quote: Siberian
    .... And what is even the difference in the approaches of storming the building of some from above, and ours from below, also makes you think, or maybe you should learn from the Indians ......


    Thanks to the Caucasus, the Russian army and parts of the Ministry of Internal Affairs were the most combat-ready in the world. The Indians, unlike us, did not have Chechnya, and there is no REAL experience of storming the building.