Military Review

Expert: Military operations in eastern Ukraine will end within a year with the victory of the militia

111
The war in eastern Ukraine between the Kiev security forces and the army of Novorossia will end within a year with the victory of the unrecognized republics, leads RIA News opinion of the President of the Academy of geopolitical problems of Doctor of Military Sciences Konstantin Sivkov.

Expert: Military operations in eastern Ukraine will end within a year with the victory of the militia


“Based on the analysis of the military-political situation and the nature of the armed struggle, I think the conflict in Ukraine will end within a year.”, - said in an interview with Sivkov.

According to his forecasts, the Ukrainian security forces "will inevitably be defeated, because during the armed conflict they lost a lot of equipment, and the morale of the Ukrainian soldiers weakened significantly."

The same opinion was previously expressed by the director of the Center for Military Forecasting Anatoly Tsyganok. He said that the former head of the DPR Defense Ministry Igor Strelkov managed to form an efficient army, and now, unlike the situation of previous months, the militia of the DPR and the LPR have finally begun to fight in a coordinated way, unlike the Ukrainian security forces, who have lost common control.
111 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Yellow white
    Yellow white 2 September 2014 15: 19
    +46
    The truth behind the militia!
    And victory will be theirs!
    God is with you guys ... who is against you then?
    1. Giant thought
      Giant thought 2 September 2014 15: 23
      +27
      Your bit card, gentlemen of the junta! Get ready to run away from Ukraine soon.
      1. DVxa
        DVxa 2 September 2014 15: 36
        +6
        Not far to winter .. Who knows how everything can turn around ..
        Politics is such a thing, you can predict a lot of things and there is a chance to "hit the mark."
        1. Andriuha077
          Andriuha077 2 September 2014 15: 41
          +107
          "When are you going to Kiev?"
          1. The comment was deleted.
        2. The comment was deleted.
          1. Vadivak
            Vadivak 2 September 2014 16: 11
            +3
            Quote: Paradoxov
            To fight with Russians in winter is trouble by definition


            Several of my Russian acquaintances, who of those that can’t survive without war (Dagestan, Chechnya, Ossetia) ran to the military registration and enlistment offices, tried to recruit themselves, looked at them like idiots and sent them to a psychiatric hospital for treatment.

            You understand what I mean.
            1. Paradoxov
              Paradoxov 2 September 2014 16: 21
              +8
              (I redid that post)
              I didn’t understand where your friends wanted to recruit through the military registration and enlistment offices?
              Russia is fighting with someone ???)
            2. DPZ
              DPZ 2 September 2014 16: 24
              +7
              I do not understand what you mean. our military registration and enlistment offices are not engaged in mobilization because we are not a warring party. why run on them? The site has repeatedly had contacts for volunteers. There are also sites of Rusvessky and Ikorrpus, groups in contact. whoever wants to will find his way into this war.
            3. Underwood
              Underwood 2 September 2014 17: 13
              -1
              Quote: Vadivak
              You understand what I mean.

              we get it, bro.
              Your Russian acquaintances did not need the military commissars to "Hey, dude ..." to say ...
              Two "Russian friends" (c) have already returned.
              Without a draft board ...
              Quote: Vadivak
              You understand what I mean.

              ?
        3. Paradoxov
          Paradoxov 2 September 2014 16: 15
          +6
          To fight against Russians in the winter is suicide, everyone knows about it!
          But it’s too early to deduct dills!

          In the meantime, the winter is far away, the events are as follows:
        4. sgazeev
          sgazeev 2 September 2014 16: 29
          +4
          Quote: DVxa
          Not far to winter .. Who knows how everything can turn around ..
          Politics is such a thing, you can predict a lot of things and there is a chance to "hit the mark."

          Let Sivkov go on a business trip on a pawn and determine, more precisely, the timing. And fortune telling on the coffee grounds, like Kedmi, is ungrateful. With God's help, the new Russians will decide when to finish.
      2. diz1975
        diz1975 2 September 2014 15: 47
        +7
        Let the junta prepare for a people's court. Mandatory fair and correct after the war should be the detention, investigation and imposition of a junta to the people's court. And you need to get the reptiles at least from underground, even from America, from anywhere in the world. Steal if necessary and transfer at least as baggage. So that others do not get used to littering fraternal peoples.
      3. mirag2
        mirag2 2 September 2014 15: 48
        +1
        The militia at its own expense will not be able to wage this war.
        Despite the fact that the junta plants are even completely dismantled, exported retreating.
        And the enterprises are in terrible condition.
        Money, money, labor ...
        And how much of this labor flowed out of there?
        What is this pseudo-expert?
        The militia will survive both a year and two, but as sabotage-guerrilla groups.
        And to conduct such an offensive operation as it is now, and even for a year ...
        Tales.
        1. The comment was deleted.
        2. albi77
          albi77 2 September 2014 16: 14
          +4
          And who says at their own expense?
          The Ukrainian Armed Forces, too, not at their own expense since the beginning of hostilities, and the Americans admitted that they had invested 5 billion in "democratic" undertakings.

          An interesting question is the actions of the eastern oligarchs ... I personally will not believe in life that Akhmetov wouldn’t be safe and don’t transfer to the DPR a tidy sum to support anonymously (but what would anyone know among them), since if Kolomoisky crushes him ... just do empty.
          1. Underwood
            Underwood 2 September 2014 18: 14
            -4
            Quote: albi77
            An interesting question is the actions of the eastern oligarchs ...

            fucking, how interesting.
            Quote: albi77
            I personally will not believe in life that Akhmetov wouldn’t

            and then! all these cockroach races with St. George ribbons and Kalash are worthless without prospects.
            Donbass will not share these on TV ...
      4. nikay69
        nikay69 2 September 2014 16: 53
        +1
        Yes, not soon, but it’s time for a long time!
      5. Sandov
        Sandov 2 September 2014 19: 53
        +2
        Quote: Giant thought
        Your bit card, gentlemen of the junta! Get ready to run away from Ukraine soon.

        Under the court of murderers, it will be funny if the same Americans swallow when their stooges will be judged.
    2. max702
      max702 2 September 2014 15: 27
      +3
      And how could it be otherwise? If there is no betrayal from the very top, then of the options only VICTORY!
    3. Mountain shooter
      Mountain shooter 2 September 2014 15: 33
      +4
      A whole year? Through the winter? something for a long time. IMHO, in winter they will take Kiev on ice, if the mind is enough to blow up bridges.
      1. start thinking
        start thinking 2 September 2014 16: 13
        +3
        Who is this advice to "blow up bridges"? I think that by this time Kiev will have no one to defend: the "top" will pull over the hill, and the rest will hide from retaliation!
      2. DPZ
        DPZ 2 September 2014 16: 30
        +3
        I think we are talking about this year i.e. 2014 m.
    4. nils
      nils 2 September 2014 15: 39
      +8
      No need to wait until the fall
      To put out the flame!
      After all, Novorossia is in trouble -
      She needs to live in peace!

      How to live in the hours of madness?
      She’s a baby,
      So brave though young
      Decent country.

      Defenders, Warriors,
      You are your chest - under the explosion ...
      Punishers, stranglers
      Throw everything into a breakthrough:

      Fire, shell, madness ...
      The bandits of all are on trial!
      In the minutes of the full moon
      They’ll bring the chopping block ...

      And you guys, by fall
      Sweep the mountains of trouble
      For the glory of New Russia,
      In the name of all victories! ..
      ______________

      V. Shumilova
    5. Estet59
      Estet59 2 September 2014 15: 40
      +32
      Companions, let's move away from the definition of "militias". ARMY OF NEW RUSSIA has already taken place today! Armed with modern weapons, well-coordinated, shelled, controlled! Given this fact, Mr. Poroshenko spoke about the need to find diplomatic ways to resolve the conflict. Too late, however! It is necessary to work out ways to urgently leave the country that was left of Ukraine!
      And yet, until when will the word Novorossiya on the website be underlined by a red line? It's time to drive it into all web dictionaries.
      1. Sandov
        Sandov 2 September 2014 20: 16
        +2
        Quote: Estet59
        Companions, let's move away from the definition of "militias". ARMY OF NEW RUSSIA has already taken place today!

        The army of New Russia has strengthened in battles with the Nazis. I wish her further victories. But I hope for the help of Russia. The Nazis went to Amer and Geyropeyskuyu help.
    6. Good_Taxist
      Good_Taxist 2 September 2014 15: 51
      +20
      Something recalled from childhood

      Konstantin Simonov - poems

      Major brought the boy on a gun carriage

      Major brought the boy on a gun carriage
      Mother died. The son did not say goodbye to her.
      For ten years in this and this world
      He will be counted for these ten days.

      He was taken from the fortress, from Brest.
      It was scratched by carriage bullets.
      It seemed to father that the place was safer
      From now on, there is no child in the world.

      Father was injured and a gun was broken.
      Tied to a shield so that it doesn't fall
      Clutching a sleeping toy to his chest
      The gray-haired boy was sleeping on a gun carriage.

      We went to meet him from Russia.
      Waking up, he waved a hand to the troops ...
      You say there are others
      That I was there and I have to go home ...

      You know this grief firsthand
      But it broke our hearts.
      Who once saw this boy,
      Will not be able to come home to the end.

      I have to see with the same eyes
      That I cried in the dust
      How that boy will come back with us
      And he will kiss a handful of his land.

      For all that we cherished
      Military law called us to battle.
      Now my house is not where we used to live,
      And where he was taken from the boy.
      Poems about love and about love


      To tears!!!
      1. start thinking
        start thinking 2 September 2014 16: 18
        +6
        What poems !!!
        Bravo!
        Shed to tears !!
    7. Underwood
      Underwood 2 September 2014 17: 09
      -4
      Quote: Black and White
      The truth behind the militia!
      And victory will be theirs!
      God is with you guys ... who is against you then?

      this is understandable, yes, blah-blah, "god", "the right thing", "WE (?) will win", other popcorn chants from the sofa ... but - during a year... ?? And early with this furunculosis in any way? Maybe diplomatitski somehow still sort out this mess?
      1. Vitaly72
        Vitaly72 2 September 2014 20: 19
        +2
        where did you get that mess? at first the junta was plaguing the civilian population, now the Novorossiysk army is plaguing the punishers as you say orgnung
  2. MSA
    MSA 2 September 2014 15: 19
    +14
    Death to the invaders !!! There is no excuse and future for the Nazis.
    1. corrado
      corrado 2 September 2014 17: 43
      +1
      The Ukrainian army leaves the city of Krasnoarmeysk, Donetsk region.

      http://podrobnosti.ua/accidents/2014/09/02/991578.html
      1. Underwood
        Underwood 2 September 2014 18: 50
        -1
        Quote: corrado
        Ukrainian army leaves

        Yes FSU all already on the fact that the army is leaving. Everyone is waiting for the elections and, ssna, related headlines. The national idea, like the army, was lost - Maidan tutochki .. It is necessary, after all, new successes ... or a new p ... c. Equally good.
    2. Underwood
      Underwood 2 September 2014 18: 40
      -5
      Quote: MSA
      Death to the invaders !!!

      what the fuck invaders ??? xoxly eb.sh.a.t xoxlov! Who occupied whom?
      1. Sandov
        Sandov 2 September 2014 20: 19
        +3
        Quote: Underwood
        Quote: MSA
        Death to the invaders !!!

        what the fuck invaders ??? xoxly eb.sh.a.t xoxlov! Who occupied whom?

        The evil rats of Bandera were occupied. After all, everything is obvious.
  3. MIV999
    MIV999 2 September 2014 15: 20
    +5
    We hope that this will be so! ... God help you !!!
  4. muks
    muks 2 September 2014 15: 20
    +6
    With the help of General Frost for half a year can not cope?
    1. Stiletto
      Stiletto 2 September 2014 15: 28
      +14
      Quote: muks
      With the help of General Frost for half a year can not cope?


      I'm afraid that General Frost will get to all parties to the conflict. Lugansk, Donetsk and its environs were badly damaged by artillery strikes of the Ukrainian army, but no one bombed Kiev, Dnepropetrovsk and other cities. And if the Natsiks have places to winter (relatively), then the army of New Russia willfully have to decide for the winter issues of a humanitarian nature. So, I would not really trust in General Moroz in this matter, if Russia would help ... hi
      1. vsoltan
        vsoltan 2 September 2014 15: 36
        +8
        We will predict after sending another pair of three humconvoys. Plus - in the Donbass there are still coal. Maybe whip up at least how the boilers and pipes will be patched. But winter - yes, they will have a difficult one, true, worse than in Kiev or the Carpathian region.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  5. volot-voin
    volot-voin 2 September 2014 15: 21
    +5
    Military operations in eastern Ukraine will end within a year with the victory of militias

    God help the army of New Russia. I hope they won’t conclude any Minsk truces.
    Only unconditional surrender of the junta and landing of the guilty or lynching courts.
    1. ybrcfy27
      ybrcfy27 2 September 2014 16: 15
      -1
      You are hoping here, and people are dying
      1. Black Colonel
        Black Colonel 2 September 2014 17: 46
        +1
        And why this post?
    2. Revolver
      Revolver 2 September 2014 17: 18
      +1
      Quote: volot-voin
      Only unconditional surrender of the junta and planting the guilty
      On stake am
  6. vitaz
    vitaz 2 September 2014 15: 21
    +6
    No need to be an expert, and so it is visible. It's a question of time.
  7. iConst
    iConst 2 September 2014 15: 21
    +4
    ... unlike the Ukrainian security forces, who have lost uniform control.
    But did it happen?
  8. Altona
    Altona 2 September 2014 15: 21
    +3
    Semyon Semenchenko yesterday made a debriefing and gave an assessment to the General Staff of the Armed Forces ...))) And each of us can already do the after-fact analysis of the victory of New Russia and its coercion of Kiev to recognize the rights of Russians in Ukraine ...
    1. blind
      blind 2 September 2014 15: 31
      +5
      Semenchenko is a miserable clown, and it is unlikely that he can make any assessments. He is able to deprive him of bashing and fascist slogans. unless even he came to understand the imminent window
  9. Russ69
    Russ69 2 September 2014 15: 22
    +11
    02.09.14/15/00 XNUMX:XNUMX Message from LifeNews correspondent.

    Militias freed Telmanovo in the DPR. The Ukrainian flag is removed from the administration, in the city of the checkpoints of the army of New Russia.
    Telmanovo is a large settlement in the DPR. For the militia is of key importance on the southern front. In connection with the liberation of Telmanovo, the army of New Russia gained access to the transport system, in particular, militias will be able to transfer forces to Mariupol.
    1. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov 2 September 2014 15: 56
      +7
      Quote: Russ69
      Militias freed Telmanovo in the DPR. The Ukrainian flag is removed from the administration, in the city of the checkpoints of the army of New Russia.

      The most interesting part remains behind the scenes. There are a lot of prisoners and vedeos with them on the network, everyone sees it. But the faces of those who were loyal to the junta in the same Telmanov administration should be looked at. The measure of the former prosecutor and everyone else.
  10. Carlos
    Carlos 2 September 2014 15: 22
    +12
    After losing the war, they will turn to terror. It is time for New Russia to increase its special services.
    1. blind
      blind 2 September 2014 15: 32
      +4
      Well then you have to make buffer zones in the image of the Golan heights due to the territory of the enemy
    2. Sergeqr
      Sergeqr 2 September 2014 15: 42
      +2
      With this, it’s normal there. The young will return even with a victory - they will strengthen. It is paid too much for everything ...
  11. vinc
    vinc 2 September 2014 15: 22
    +3
    We will only be happy. Thank you. cap.
  12. pvv113
    pvv113 2 September 2014 15: 22
    +7
    The victory of Novorossiya is obvious, since the defenders of the republic have an idea and a goal, in contrast to the banderlog, who fight for money and for other people's interests. The slogan "OUR CASE IS RIGHT, WE WILL WIN!" remains relevant today hi
  13. el.krokodil
    el.krokodil 2 September 2014 15: 23
    +17
    VICTORY OF NEW RUSSIA! soldier here it’s not even clear for strategists that dill lost! laughing
  14. Anisim1977
    Anisim1977 2 September 2014 15: 24
    +11
    Victory will be 100% - the intrigue is only where the border of New Russia will go !!!!
    In my opinion, Odessa, Dnepropetrovsk, Kirovohrad, Sums are quite optimal - with all due respect to Kiev, such a bureaucratic burden as the former capital, awash with managers, economists, political scientists, journalists, an army of officials of all stripes - a young state, is not permissible and empty luxury.
    1. Mama_Cholli
      Mama_Cholli 2 September 2014 15: 41
      +3
      Today, however, as well as yesterday, respect for Kiev is no longer / was not ...
  15. viktorrymar
    viktorrymar 2 September 2014 15: 24
    +9
    Military operations in eastern Ukraine will end within a year with the victory of militias


    I am not a great strategist, but I think that the war can end only with the disappearance of Ukraine from the face of the earth.
    1. nvv
      nvv 2 September 2014 15: 30
      +3
      You vainly stoop, only so be it.
      Quote: viktorrymar
      Military operations in eastern Ukraine will end within a year with the victory of militias


      I am not a great strategist, but I think that the war can end only with the disappearance of Ukraine from the face of the earth.
  16. Kulakov_Dmitry
    Kulakov_Dmitry 2 September 2014 15: 25
    +5
    I’ll go buy a padded jacket!
  17. Berrick
    Berrick 2 September 2014 15: 27
    +9
    The turning point happened! Miners began to enlist as volunteers! The people along the way of the militia advance will join them in progression.
    The main thing is that politicians do not lubricate these heroic merits and allow to bring the matter to Transnistria !!
    1. coolvoldik
      coolvoldik 2 September 2014 16: 36
      +1
      Often military victories are converted into political dividends by people whose ideals are far from the ideals that fought on the battlefield. In New Russia there was one political figure capable of using a military victory in the interests of the Republic - I. Strelkov
      There is no other figure of this scale there now. Who beheaded the region and in whose political interests is this done?
      1. Fornit
        Fornit 2 September 2014 17: 09
        +1
        Important pepper on TV hinted that Strelkov was engaged in mobilization problems ... DNR is now more needed.
  18. cerbuk6155
    cerbuk6155 2 September 2014 15: 27
    +2
    Victory will be for New Russia, the junta and its owners will be defeated and destroyed. soldier
  19. kaluganew
    kaluganew 2 September 2014 15: 29
    +6
    Damn, I can not find the link. There was news and a photo of Strelkov on the rambler. Alive and well! Not injured, resting.

    Infu posted a blogger, his friend.
  20. Alexander
    Alexander 2 September 2014 15: 33
    +4
    If Russia continues to support the armies of the unrecognized republics and steadfastly endure the attacks of its henchmen, then there will definitely be a victory. There is another question - where will the victory parade be, in Kiev or Donetsk (Lugansk)?
  21. Murz-on
    Murz-on 2 September 2014 15: 35
    +3
    Victory has always been, is and will be on the side of "TRUTH", no nits and ki can ever break a person who protects his family and land !!!
  22. Black
    Black 2 September 2014 15: 36
    +8
    the miners went into the army .... we all shamed them here, but in vain, along the way. many simply did not believe in the support of Moscow, and until a certain point they did not see it. now only the blind woman does not see her, people have understood that the Motherland is behind her, and she will never throw them! Ukraine has already received help - buns and waffles! Let them eat and ... ut.
    Victory is inevitable. I look forward to the fall of Kharkov and especially Dnepropetrovsk, oh how I wait !!!!!
  23. moremansf
    moremansf 2 September 2014 15: 37
    +14
    The truth and the people of Donbass will win !!! They are fighting for their homeland and their families, and not for 30 ova silver coins !!!
    1. desertfox
      desertfox 2 September 2014 16: 01
      +3
      The illustration you are using is from the Technotma book series. The book of 2010, and so, which is symbolic, it mentions the conflict "Western Ukraine against Eastern Ukraine", and the armed forces of western Ukraine are called the National Guard, and the armed forces of the eastern part are unofficially supported by Russia ...
  24. mackonya
    mackonya 2 September 2014 15: 37
    +5
    I doubt that during the year Ukraine itself will remain in the traditional sense. And in a couple of months the Army of New Russia will already be officially, because the militia forces are more like a regular army, without the Air Force and Navy, of course.
    1. Sergeqr
      Sergeqr 2 September 2014 15: 51
      +4
      There will be both the Air Force and the Navy.
      There are already airfields, we’ve come to the sea,
      and the Kiev zoo Maidanutykh himself will run skipping in the EU laughing . Only there is a place for him.
      Like .. - were you waiting for us? We came. laughing wassat fellow
    2. Black Colonel
      Black Colonel 2 September 2014 17: 51
      +1
      You look there, and Transnistria with Transcarpathia will catch up ...
  25. Oleg NSK
    Oleg NSK 2 September 2014 15: 39
    0
    hostilities end .... the first frosts
  26. Mactep
    Mactep 2 September 2014 15: 39
    +6
    Well, the people's militia will win well. I have no doubt. What's next? Who will take on the work of rebuilding and restoration. Etozh eperic stos as much as necessary means and forces. What control is needed for these funds. And I’m not sure that the bloody struggle for power and access to these funds will not begin later.
  27. Rigla
    Rigla 2 September 2014 15: 40
    +8
    If everything goes on like this, then IMHO:
    The boilers will be sorted out this week.
    There was a lot of trouble with the airports, especially Donetsk, but they took it (this is very successful).
    Numbers up to 15-20 will be released Mariupol with simultaneous serious liberation of the territory of Zaporozhye.
    By October, the front line will return to Slavyansk, by mid-December ALL the territory of the DPR and Lugansk People’s Republic will be liberated, at the same time part of the territory of the People’s Republic of China, Poland, Dnipropetrovsk (but small in area) will be freed, by January Zaporizhzhya, Kharkov, Dnepropetrovsk will be freed, by March ALL NEWS will be released.
    Please do not scold, this is IMHO.
  28. Yellow white
    Yellow white 2 September 2014 15: 41
    +3
    Quote: kaluganew
    Damn, I can not find the link. There was news and a photo of Strelkov on the rambler. Alive and well! Not injured, resting.

    Infu posted a blogger, his friend.


    SEARCH !!!!!
    1. tolancop
      tolancop 2 September 2014 16: 55
      0
      http://vz.ru/photoreport/703133/#ad-image-0
  29. surovts.valery
    surovts.valery 2 September 2014 15: 42
    +4
    Here is an excerpt from his interview published May 29:
    Question: How long do you think the Southeast will stand?
    Konstantin Sivkov: In such tension as today, Poroshenko will not be able to defeat the South-East. The mobilized will not fight - they will refuse, and Poroshenko will have only the mercenaries of Kolomoyky and the Americans and the Right Sector. If the losses are the same as they were today, then a couple of similar battles, and that’s all. Therefore, the question rests on whether they will succeed in inciting ordinary people of Ukraine, ordinary soldiers and army officers, against militias. So far, the militias maintain peaceful relations with the army, feed them, because since the beginning of the month no one has been feeding them, and there is no enmity. Active actions are connected with the work of snipers and the actions of aviation, against which there is no opposition. Give the militias a powerful air defense system, and the problem will be solved.

    But everything turned out to be more and more complicated and worse. Sivkov’s position is clearly visible, does not bother and does not keep his nose in the wind.
  30. Dembel
    Dembel 2 September 2014 15: 43
    +1
    From an economic point of view, getting rid of the destroyed Donbass would be beneficial for Ukraine, but from a political point of view, it would be completely unacceptable. Now there are only political motives in the arena. The announced "new ATO strategy" of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is a guerrilla war, terror and sabotage, with the full support of the Western media. This is a completely feasible tactic in view of the lack of autocracy in Novorossiya. But winter is coming soon. Donbass cities in ruins. Who will give warmth and food to the residents of the DPR and LPR? Russia ..., but this requires a certain status of the region, which Ukraine will not give, and there is absolutely no time to change the situation, let alone restore the infrastructure. And if you can't, but really want to - then you can. So who will take out this problem - ... well, right, again it is Great Russia.
    1. Nevsky_ZU
      Nevsky_ZU 2 September 2014 15: 48
      +1
      Quote: Dembel
      From an economic point of view, getting rid of the destroyed Donbass would be beneficial for Ukraine, but from a political point of view, it would be completely unacceptable. Now there are only political motives in the arena. The announced "new ATO strategy" of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is a guerrilla war, terror and sabotage, with the full support of the Western media. This is a completely feasible tactic in view of the lack of autocracy in Novorossiya. But winter is coming. Donbass cities in ruins. Who will give warmth and food to the residents of the DPR and LPR? Russia ..., but this requires a certain status of the region, which Ukraine will not give, and there is no time at all.


      Partisans will be maximum in Central Ukraine. (not the fact that you need to go there, those cities will be liberated by a collapsed economy) Or do you think there are many who want to partisan for Edin Ukraine in the Donbas?
      1. Dembel
        Dembel 2 September 2014 16: 28
        +2
        Dear Nevsky_ZU, I believe that we have nothing to do on the territory of central and especially western Ukraine. As for the territory of eastern Ukraine, significant destruction of infrastructure and especially housing stock greatly reduced the number of those who voted for secession from Ukraine, well, it did not work out as in Crimea. And as for the south of Ukraine, then a clear example of the east of Ukraine is the best agitator for them, they will not follow this path. Now, if they are "released", and even with the least damage, then ... maybe ..., then, somehow ..., will the compensation be good?
  31. pexotinec
    pexotinec 2 September 2014 15: 43
    +2
    No matter how it all turns into an episode of the game "Stalker" request
    But I am sure that freedom will always triumph. Good luck to the fighters of Novorosia
  32. Corsair0304
    Corsair0304 2 September 2014 15: 47
    +1
    Somewhere there was information that the DPR is buying winter uniforms.
    As for the article, in terms of content it is none. In addition to the scientific title and first name, the opinion is not supported by anything.
    I am 100% for the DNI, for the victory of New Russia. I just want to know what the expert’s calculations are based on and why such a deadline is set.
  33. VICTOR-61
    VICTOR-61 2 September 2014 15: 48
    +1
    Yes, the militia fellows crushed Bander in full I am very happy and it is necessary to drive these fascists to the borders of the EU and to stop until the enemy in a panic can last for six months until the end of the war
  34. muhomor
    muhomor 2 September 2014 15: 48
    +8
    Why do juntas scream about the Russian army? So:
    - militias during attacks and attacks specifically raise the Russian banners and use the identification marks of the Russian troops. Svidomo from all this begins diarrhea.
    -When conducting attacks and sweeps, militias often shout: Wallach akbar! Svidomo from this diarrhea intensifies. Hence the messy waste. Again, an excuse for the authorities.
  35. Sergey-8848
    Sergey-8848 2 September 2014 15: 48
    +4
    It turns out well - to create an office for yourself, to be called an Academy, to rake money from somewhere, and then utter immutable truths from there, passing them off as a deep and thoughtful analysis. The academies are too damned divorced, and with them members (but not correspondents at all). And without such analysts, everything is clear to everyone (well, except for those who skip for now). Here it is, the secret of a carefree life! - with a smart look, calling himself an academician, to pronounce obvious things, and be funded by the one for the sake of whom the analysis is pronounced.
    We have more and more academies - the Academy of Sciences, the Russian Academy of Sciences, the Academy of Medical Sciences, the All-Union Agricultural Academy, etc., etc., but there’s less and less sense.
    1. Fornit
      Fornit 2 September 2014 17: 14
      0
      There is also the Television Academy, with its academics ... Well, Posner there ...
  36. Lyokha79
    Lyokha79 2 September 2014 15: 51
    +1
    I agree that the situation is developing well at the fronts, and there are complete seams in the rear. Houses are destroyed or badly damaged, the infrastructure is in the trash, and winter will come on schedule. The authorities of the LPR and the DPR need to solve problems with establishing the life of citizens of the republics.
  37. Alfizik
    Alfizik 2 September 2014 15: 59
    +1
    The main thing is not that they will be defeated, but that they will no longer be able to rise from the ashes. In the Nazis doubts and fear arose. Here in 2-3 years ... but Novorossia by that time will be different, organized and strong.
  38. Rubmolot
    Rubmolot 2 September 2014 16: 02
    +7
    Veterans of the American intelligence services wrote an open letter to Merkel. It warns that the proclaimed Russian "invasion of Ukraine" is not supported by evidence, and it is a political scam.

    http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2014-09-01/ex-nsa-director-us-intelligence-veteran
    s-write-open-letter-merkel-avoid-all-out-ukra
  39. Dies Irae
    Dies Irae 2 September 2014 16: 06
    +4
    And before that, many "experts" predicted the defeat of Novorossiya.
    To believe these "couch fighters" is not to respect yourself.
    They are not military, not officers, for the most part, and they have the most general idea of ​​hostilities.
    So ...
    Let's better continue with the help of "VO" to help the guys in Donbass with equipment and rations, walkie-talkies and other little things that they need.
  40. surovts.valery
    surovts.valery 2 September 2014 16: 13
    +3
    I just thought, over the past just some four months, what a rich material has accumulated for military history science. All the previous historical scraps of ukronostalezhnost such as the Battle of Konotop, the siege of Baturin, the battle near Brody simply fade before the current "great" accomplishments of the reduced forces: the defense of the Crimea, the siege of Slavyansk, the storming of Donetsk and Lugansk, the Ilovaiskaya battle, the naval battle near Mariupol, etc. What scope for military-historical ukromysl! And how many heroes: the father of the nation and the architect of all the victories of Poroshenko, the great strategist Avakov, the invincible commander Geleta, the dashing commander Semenchenko. And if you also involve the masters of literature: epic novels, frontline essays.
    So, I really hope that everything will be limited to a maximum: some memoirs like "Lost Victories" by some Muzhenko, written in a cozy cell or in a house near London and published there. And a couple of essays by an unknown author "How I grew dill on the Maidan."
  41. Vorlon
    Vorlon 2 September 2014 16: 13
    0
    The fact that the confrontation between them will end in less than a year, do not go to a fortuneteller. I want and wish the victory of New Russia. But Sivkov runs in front of a steam train. http://el-murid.livejournal.com/1985422.html correctly a person writes.
  42. unknown
    unknown 2 September 2014 16: 15
    +4
    Donetsk airport freed from punitive Kiev junta. A part of the garrison of ukronazists, fortified at the airport, laid down their arms and, according to an agreement with the defenders of Donbass, left the airport with a white flag.
    BCH units after artillery bombardment cleared the airport. Dozens of mercenaries, allegedly from Poland, the Baltic countries and Scandinavia, refused to surrender and took refuge in the bunker of the old airport building - the former Putilovsky bus station.
    It was the units that were particularly cruel during the hostilities. On their conscience, forays on the outskirts of Donetsk and indiscriminate fire on residential areas of the capital of Donbass.
    Attempts to negotiate with the mercenaries have failed. From bunkers fire was periodically opened.
    Defenders of Donbass brought sewage to the bunker and flooded the dungeon with hiding punishers. Engineers familiar with the underground communications infrastructure and providing the military with dungeon schemes were called to the airport. As a result, all the entrances were bricked up with concrete.
    The unenviable fate of a soldier of fortune smile
  43. wolf1968
    wolf1968 2 September 2014 16: 16
    0
    The guys in New Russia are strong in spirit. I have no doubt in their victory.
  44. Andrey92
    Andrey92 2 September 2014 16: 20
    0
    One thing I’m wondering is what will they do next? Will they go to Kiev? Nato would not like such a deal ... The trouble will probably be specific.
    1. SFIR
      SFIR 2 September 2014 16: 33
      -1
      But in Kiev we have nothing to do ..
  45. novel68rus
    novel68rus 2 September 2014 16: 20
    -1
    trial on the success of the militia another mobilization of cannon fodder in Kiev is not far off .. when the Ukrainians will understand that they have what they want? sent for slaughter as rams for the interests of the oligarchs ...
  46. hawk
    hawk 2 September 2014 16: 25
    -1
    The first impression is that the mountain gave birth to a mouse. Dear people, experts, but they said about the obvious, what we have been fussing about here all the last time. If an objective analysis had been made of how the scenario for the actions of the parties would develop and what the consequences might be, then they would be very grateful.
  47. Arh
    Arh 2 September 2014 16: 26
    0
    Victory of New Russia smells the way it should be !!! I still think it will be more Maidan or Ukrainian soldiers themselves will come to overthrow the junta, the collapse of Ukraine into three parts is possible !!!
  48. ararat
    ararat 2 September 2014 16: 28
    0
    it pleases, but what if Ukraine joins NATO, then what will happen, will RUSSIA help?
  49. Vlad5307
    Vlad5307 2 September 2014 16: 30
    +2
    Quote: Mactep
    Well, the people's militia will win well. I have no doubt. What's next? Who will take on the work of rebuilding and restoration. Etozh eperic stos as much as necessary means and forces. What control is needed for these funds. And I’m not sure that the bloody struggle for power and access to these funds will not begin later.

    I already spoke on this topic a little earlier, I will briefly repeat: the leadership of New Russia, if I am not mistaken, is more in the spirit of the socialist system. the idea was vulgarized by foolish people in the CPSU. Today, the question arises of attracting competent managers, and most importantly, not the current managers who have learned to only take and share, but the pros of their business. There are such shots in Russia, many of them are out of work right now - they are pushed aside by thieving managers. They must be attracted to build a young republic. wink
  50. RomanN
    RomanN 2 September 2014 16: 31
    0
    If the militia continues to succeed, then the PMCs of Amers will connect and take the war game back to nobody's stage, so that it lasts as long as possible.