Military Review

Cossacks as a new branch of the army

245
Territorial defense in Russia is not secured and requires unconventional ways to solve this problem.


Solving the issue of the country's territorial defense can be achieved by creating a special component in the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation - territorial troops formed on a militia basis, that is, by actually re-creating the Cossacks as a military-service class.

The collapse of power in Ukraine clearly showed that reliance only on power structures and support of the unorganized mass of the population does not guarantee the stability of power and the stability of the state. When mass demonstrations of people take place, especially those distributed over a large territory, law enforcement agencies simply do not have time to ensure timely response to all actions.

At the same time, there is still the problem of territorial defense, which in our country has not been solved at the proper level.

The question of territorial defense

In military theory, territorial defense is defined as “a system of legal, military, and state defense measures conducted by heterogeneous forces deployed in a particular territory of the Russian Federation to protect facilities and communications in both peacetime and wartime from enemy actions, acts of sabotage and terrorist acts, and with the introduction of martial law - its establishment and maintenance. "

Cossacks as a new branch of the armyTerritorial defense is organized according to the territorial-zonal principle. In peacetime, its main body is the military district, and with the start of hostilities it is the military district of wartime. Within the county, zones of territorial defense are distinguished in advance, and within these zones there are districts.

All responsibility for planning and organizing territorial defense lies with the district commander and his headquarters. The military commissariats, the bodies of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Federal Security Service of Russia, and other executive bodies participate in the planning and execution of tasks for the territorial defense plan.

Based on the definition of territorial defense and in accordance with modern views on its content, the range of its main tasks is very wide.

First of all, it is the protection and defense of important military, state, economic and communications facilities.

The second most important task of territorial defense, especially relevant in wartime and, as Ukraine’s experience has shown, in the face of social and political instability in the country, is active opposition within the zone of responsibility and on its borders to forces that can damage the protected objects. First of all, this is the fight against landings, sabotage and reconnaissance groups, terrorist groups and gangs.

Another important task of territorial defense is to ensure the establishment and maintenance of special legal regimes, martial law or a state of emergency in the country or in its individual regions. Under these conditions, the protection of public order and public security is of great importance. To do this, only patrols on the streets in a large metropolis may require up to two or three thousand or more. And it will also be necessary to strengthen the protection of particularly important state and other objects.

Another major task of territorial defense is the elimination of the consequences of various destructive impacts.

To accomplish such a volume of tasks, you need an appropriate amount of personnel and technical equipment.

The security forces do not have enough personnel

Today, the number of Russian Armed Forces is estimated at no more than 800 thousand people. Of these, the number of the Ground Forces (which alone can participate in solving the tasks of territorial defense) does not exceed 300 thousand people. The number of actually linear motorized rifle units is no higher than 100 thousand people. For territorial defense, even under the condition of full formation of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, individual units with a total of no more than five to eight thousand people in wartime and up to 30 – 40 thousand can be allocated when solving problems in an internal armed conflict. The rest will address issues of dealing with an external enemy and covering the border in other strategic areas.

The number of internal troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia is about 180 thousand people. At the same time, their main tasks largely coincide with the tasks of territorial defense. However, of these, no more than 30 – 40 thousand people can be involved in solving problems within one district.

In addition to the internal troops from the Ministry of Internal Affairs, regional formations, such as OPON, as well as local police units will be involved in solving territorial defense issues. The total number (based on the total number of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia) of these forces, which can be brought in to solve the tasks of territorial defense within one district, can be estimated at no more than 15 – 20 thousand people.

The Ministry of Emergency Situations is called upon to perform mainly the tasks of liquidation of consequences The organs of the FSB, resolving questions of a counterintelligence nature, will not be able to make a noticeable contribution to increasing the number of groups of territorial defense forces.

Thus, the total number of territorial defense groups within one military district will be, depending on conditions, from 50 – 60 to 100 thousand people. That is, the power structures of the state are incapable of forming the required grouping of troops (forces) to effectively accomplish the tasks of territorial defense even within the same military district.

Solution - the revival of the Cossacks

The main requirements that today it is advisable to present to this kind of troops, include:

1. Economic autonomy with minimization of the burden on the state budget.

2. Self-reproduction through a specific system of parenting.

3. Maintaining the designated level of combat readiness, serviceability of weapons and military equipment mainly at their own expense with minimal government support.

The territorial militia principle of the formation of such troops most fully meets these requirements, which presupposes the presence of personnel (ranked as active service in territorial troops) in areas of permanent residence if they have weapons, ammunition and military equipment warehouses in places within walking distance. At the same time, some of the light rifle weapons can be stored at home, as is the case in Switzerland.

The main tasks assigned to such troops as part of territorial defense include those that, on the one hand, require a large number of personnel and good training, and on the other hand, they do not place high demands on the quality of weapons and military equipment. This is primarily the fight against sabotage and intelligence groups, terrorist groups and gangs, as well as ensuring the establishment and maintenance of special legal regimes, martial law or a state of emergency in the region.

The government can pay for such a service by creating preferential conditions for economic activity - by providing land plots, materials for construction and business development free of charge and at extremely favorable prices, in the form of various banking and tax benefits, in other forms. As an exception, cash payments for certain types of service are possible.

The primary organizational basis can be a military industrial settlement (small town, village, village). Each such settlement is assigned a zone of responsibility, within which the personnel residing in it solves the tasks of territorial defense assigned to it.

The requirement of economic autonomy assumes as the main entrepreneurial activity carried out on the scale of both individual families and the settlement as a whole (a collective enterprise can be the economic base of such a settlement). As key areas of economic activity are possible agriculture, transport, processing industry, as well as logging.

Depending on the number of personnel recruited by the settlement in the territorial troops, we can talk about the villages (villages) of the company, battalion and regimental scale, which should be able to recruit people who can be equipped with a company, a battalion and a regiment.

Each such settlement should be assigned a base for storing weapons and military equipment, for which the head of the settlement is personally responsible and collectively the entire settlement. Armament and military equipment must be stored under strict control by the territorial military authorities, the Interior Ministry and the FSB. In particular, the head of such a settlement and part of its apparatus may be appointed by the military command.

Territorial troops must have the types of weapons that are necessary to solve the tasks assigned to them: light and heavy small arms, lightly armored vehicles, off-road vehicles. Based on the specifics of the tasks, this may be weapons and military equipment of obsolete models, currently available in abundance in the warehouses of the Moscow Region.

Administratively, the military-industrial settlement should be subordinate to the administration of the respective area, and in operational terms, to the territorial body of the military administration or command of the nearest military unit.

The total number of such settlements and their inhabitants is determined by the needs of full-fledged staffing to ensure the solution of all tasks of territorial defense. If within one military district, in order to achieve the required number of personnel, territorial troops must have about 100 – 150 thousand people for an extraordinary period, then the total amount of residents of military-industrial settlements in the district may be 400 – 500 thousand people living in 50 – 80 villages (villages). For our huge districts, this is quite a bit, especially if we consider the large number of abandoned military camps on the balance of our MO.

That is, in essence, it is about recreating the Cossacks as a real armed support of the state instead of its modern imitation.

The limited length of the article does not allow for a more or less complete assessment of the economic and operational effectiveness of such a concept. Only the following positive aspects can be noted:

1. Quite numerous contingents of genuine professionals, literally from childhood, appear.

2. The life of such settlements will be entirely connected with military service, which will become the meaning of their existence, forming a specific way of life. As a result, there will be a special class (and maybe a nationality), inextricably linked with the military service to the state. The mentality of its members, formed by the specific highly patriotic environment of educating young people, will make this estate one of the most reliable pillars of the state.

3. The cost of maintaining such a Cossack is incomparably less than the conscript and especially the contract.

4. The problem of recruiting troop contingents will be solved, primarily to solve the tasks of territorial defense, as well as others.

Fears that weapons and military equipment may fall into unkind hands should not be regarded as serious, because today there are a large number of bases and warehouses with weapons and military equipment, for the protection of which in conditions of lack of troops, the Defense Ministry is forced to resort to the help of civilian organizations. So really the Cossacks who are in the service of the state will be less reliable custodians of this property than private organizations.
Author:
Originator:
http://vpk-news.ru/articles/19450
245 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. not good
    not good 13 March 2014 12: 49
    +34
    Good thing. Why not create a national guard on the basis of the Cossacks ?!
    1. TAMERLAN 7
      TAMERLAN 7 13 March 2014 12: 53
      +15
      Good idea. They always served well. Such a militarized formation and on the borders of Russia is perfect and within the country will provide assistance in case of natural disasters, catastrophes, etc.
      1. Spnsr
        Spnsr 13 March 2014 13: 00
        +14
        Quote: TAMERLAN 7
        Good idea. They always served well. Such a militarized formation and on the borders of Russia is perfect and within the country will provide assistance in case of natural disasters, catastrophes, etc.

        only do these masquerades with changing clothes lie for a full-fledged army, if only as a parade, but in general, the Cossacks assume that every military man comes with his trunk and horse, but what kind of horse is in the 21st century? where the Cossacks will take so much dough to arm themselves with the latest modification of technology?
        1. Canep
          Canep 13 March 2014 13: 35
          +4
          Quote: SpnSr
          only these masquerades with changing clothes lie

          I agree as a public association they have the right to exist, but as a military formation ... Why then these mummers do not go to the army, but prefer to draw on the square in uniform (?) And with a whip ?, I’ll answer myself, I need to work with the army morning to night, military service, physical. training, combat training, field exits and exercises, park and household issues, educational work will leave them neither the strength nor the time to draw themselves in public, and this, in my opinion, is the main point of their work.
          1. Kazakh
            Kazakh 13 March 2014 13: 57
            +25
            Why then are these mummers not going to the army
            I’m 49 years old, the army will not take me even the strength and experience I have. And why can’t I go out into the street in my grandfather’s order? For some reason, you are not annoyed by the Kazakhs in jeans and skull-caps on the streets of Ekibas, and I should be embarrassed by my father. It seems to me that everything is that people saw Cossacks only on TV and compare them with TV characters. Once in stripes, it means a special person AND WE ARE SAME LIKE YOU and we both have drunkards and loafers, we don’t need to magnify us, not subvert us ordinary people, we only try to remember our traditions
            1. Canep
              Canep 13 March 2014 14: 16
              +6
              And who forbids you to go in Cossack uniforms? I wrote that military service is not only uniform and Cossack surroundings. At 49, it’s too late to join the army; at this age, officers are retiring. If you served, you should know what kind of burden falls on the soldiers and junior officers, and if you didn’t serve then it makes no sense to explain. And if you put on officer epaulets, then please be familiar with the following disciplines in theory and practice:
              Tactical training.
              Special tactical training.
              Engineering training.
              Fire training (small arms, RPGs, MANPADS, AGS).
              Driving and device of army vehicles.
              Drill.
              Military charters, UGiKS.
              Military topography.
              Fundamentals of educational work with l / s.
              And comply with the standards:
              in physical training
              fire training
              by driving.
              And also you need to have good health.
              If you at least know this, you will be able to carry officer uniforms.
              1. Kazakh
                Kazakh 13 March 2014 14: 33
                +4
                At 49, it’s too late to join the army; at this age, officers are retiring.
                Because I do not serve what's in stock
                And who forbids you to go in Cossack uniforms?
                And no one is just some of your statements snag soul
                to be drawn in public, and this, in my opinion, is the main meaning of their work.
                And I go to the public in reference so that both enemies and friends know that the Cossacks live and haven’t gone anywhere. This is the countryman.
                1. Canep
                  Canep 13 March 2014 14: 48
                  +3
                  Quote: Kazakh
                  And I go to the public in reference so that both enemies and friends know that the Cossacks live and haven’t gone anywhere.

                  Your last words just confirm all my words. Good luck. soldier
                  There are Cossacks who served and fought in Avfgan and Chechnya as part of the regular army, received wounds and orders, and some immortalized their name, but there are those who claim to be in the square. For the sake of the first, do not dishonor the Cossacks.
              2. dark_65
                dark_65 13 March 2014 20: 17
                0
                it will be necessary, and we will dress, but as a second tier, we are invaluable, the preparation is still Soviet, and then it formed life in different places.
            2. RND
              RND 13 March 2014 14: 37
              +3
              Quote: Kazakh
              Why then are these mummers not going to the army
              I’m 49 years old, the army will not take me even the strength and experience I have. And why can’t I go out into the street in my grandfather’s order? For some reason, you are not annoyed by the Kazakhs in jeans and skull-caps on the streets of Ekibas, and I should be embarrassed by my father. It seems to me that everything is that people saw Cossacks only on TV and compare them with TV characters. Once in stripes, it means a special person AND WE ARE SAME LIKE YOU and we both have drunkards and loafers, we don’t need to magnify us, not subvert us ordinary people, we only try to remember our traditions

              I will be brief - ++++++++ !!!
              hi hi hi
            3. Black
              Black 13 March 2014 16: 04
              +5
              Quote: Kazakh
              WE ARE THE SAME LIKE YOU, and we have both drunkards and loafers, we don’t need to magnify us, not to subvert us ordinary people, we are only trying to remember our traditions

              Stop pleasing the haters !!
              No, we are not the same. Drunkards and loafers are, of course, how without them ?! But they are not the essence.
              A Cossack woman is born a warrior and raised by a warrior, by the age of 18, by the time of the draft, being already a military unit requiring only polishing.
              Education, responsibility, fighting spirit.
              Here you have the Guard.
              Below Minesweeper lists disciplines ... But what? _ Who is against? Or will the Cossack officers not study at military schools and will "acquire" knowledge by birth?
              1. Thompson
                Thompson 13 March 2014 17: 26
                +1
                Did you smoke something? Throw it!
                Cossack is born a CHILD! It grows with how to educate or how it will turn out, like any other child ..
                And do not carry nonsense and nonsense. Do not make people laugh and do not increase the number of haters! You yourself and produce them! hi
              2. Thompson
                Thompson 13 March 2014 17: 26
                0
                Did you smoke something? Throw it!
                Cossack is born a CHILD! It grows with how to educate or how it will turn out, like any other child ..
                And do not carry nonsense and nonsense. Do not make people laugh and do not increase the number of haters! You yourself and produce them! hi
            4. Thompson
              Thompson 13 March 2014 16: 59
              -3
              You are subverted in response to your desire to be magnified. From time immemorial, your gluttony, narcissism and the desire to jump above your head and ruined that under the Soviet regime, that under tsarism, and even in more ancient times and in other countries too. And history does not teach you anything.
              That is precisely because you are the same as us, why do you need such benefits and concessions? Have your own tradition, history, clothes, who are against. But why are you a better husband and protector than any other people living in the area?
              But do not you think that the self-defense units of the Maidan, and Bandera, is their local variety of the Cossacks?
              1. Kazakh
                Kazakh 13 March 2014 17: 10
                +4
                That is precisely because you are the same as us, why do you need such benefits and concessions?
                And please list the benefits and concessions that we use?
                1. Thompson
                  Thompson 13 March 2014 17: 32
                  -3
                  Just don’t say that you are white and fluffy. Announce your salary? Announce your benefits, I’m generally silent about your appetites! Read the text above.
                  But do not tell me why the population of Russia, the tsarist was afraid of you, like hell incense? Be Cossacks, whoever you want, as a nation, a union, but there’s nothing to go where they don’t ask, but where do you want with such persistence! Another kind of pseudo Bandera, the most Ukrainian of Ukrainians!
                  1. Setrac
                    Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 37
                    +3
                    Quote: Thompson
                    Announce your salary? Announce your benefits, I’m generally silent about your appetites!

                    Well, announce it. You announce it, you sing about benefits, I don’t know such people.
                    1. The comment was deleted.
                    2. Thompson
                      Thompson 13 March 2014 17: 41
                      -1
                      Are you a Cossack ?, a member of the Cossacks?
                      1. Setrac
                        Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 54
                        +2
                        Quote: Thompson
                        Are you a Cossack ?, a member of the Cossacks?

                        I am not a Cossack, but I live in the Kuban (I’ll draw the attention of all Ukrainians, not in the Kuban and I’m not worried about this), I live in the most ordinary Cossack village, which there are many in the Kuban.
                      2. Thompson
                        Thompson 13 March 2014 19: 06
                        -2
                        I am also not a Cossack and live in the Kuban. Here, walk around your neighbors to the Cossacks, but ask why they suddenly became all SUCH Cossack Cossacks?
                        GROWTH ON THE FIRST PLACE, on the second show off and on the last everything about the homeland and protection. ONLY WOULD NOT WORK!
                      3. Setrac
                        Setrac 13 March 2014 20: 05
                        -1
                        Quote: Thompson
                        I am also not a Cossack and live in the Kuban.

                        Come on, who will believe you, you have masked your flag with the flag of the USSR, you do not even live in Russia. Well, actually the rest of your words are not true.
                      4. Thompson
                        Thompson 13 March 2014 23: 40
                        0
                        smile fool Do not judge by yourself!
                        I live in Russia, I was born in the USSR !!!
                        Therefore, unlike you, I have honor and dignity!
                      5. Setrac
                        Setrac 13 March 2014 23: 55
                        0
                        Quote: Thompson
                        Therefore, unlike you, I have honor and dignity!

                        What "honor and dignity" you have. You throw mud at the Cossacks here - where is the honor of throwing mud at others? Can you only have dignity between your legs?
                      6. Thompson
                        Thompson 14 March 2014 00: 04
                        -1
                        Are you ill? Be treated! Do you have three yellow cards?
                        I don’t water anyone with mud. I just state the facts!
                        Unlike you, I do not scream, give my nation weapons, privileges, benefits, rights, although I love her no less than your love for the Cossacks.
                        That is the difference! Therefore, the price to you among the people is one- clowns and mummers, without honor and dignity!
                        And the past merits of the Cossacks-this is not your merit and does not boast of it to you!
                      7. Setrac
                        Setrac 14 March 2014 00: 20
                        0
                        Quote: Thompson
                        I don’t water anyone with mud. I just state the facts!

                        You state your emotions, give facts, maybe we are mistaken and change our mind! laughing

                        Quote: Thompson
                        Unlike you, I do not scream, give my nation weapons, privileges, benefits, rights, although I love her no less than your love for the Cossacks.

                        Dear Tom, they did not say to you in a special school in America that such names in Russia are not used for people, they are not used at all, only for cats.
                        Your American nation already has the most weapons, privileges, and privileges on the planet.
                        Quote: Thompson
                        And the past merits of the Cossacks-this is not your merit and does not boast of it to you!

                        I’m telling you Russian in white, I’m not a Cossack, so I didn’t deserve this right to be called a Cossack.
                        Quote: Thompson
                        Therefore, the price to you among the people is one- clowns and mummers, without honor and dignity!

                        It’s not for you to judge, you, like any foreigner, are afraid of the Cossacks, the Russians are not afraid of the Cossacks.
                      8. Thompson
                        Thompson 14 March 2014 00: 41
                        0
                        smile Are you the same Setrak as all Armenians?
                        Then I'm not the same Thompson as the Americans!
                        Or, according to your logic, whoever has only letters or numbers in a nickname, is a primer and a calculator talking to you? fool laughing
                      9. Setrac
                        Setrac 14 March 2014 01: 05
                        0
                        Quote: Thompson
                        Are you the same Setrak as all Armenians?

                        I have Armenian blood in me, and Setrak is the name of my grandfather. This is the prose of life, the system does not allow identical accounts, and there are many who want to register with Sergey.
                        Quote: Thompson
                        Then I'm not the same Thompson as the Americans!

                        Your acc, hastily created for a new round of information warfare, lack of information about yourself, flag disguise ... and so on and so forth including your comments. Each detail in itself does not mean anything, but all together create a complete picture.
                      10. Thompson
                        Thompson 14 March 2014 01: 15
                        0
                        Smiled! I was born and live my whole life, 50 years in Russia.
                        About the page and account - no need to dock the inconsistent! Therefore, I am not Tom, that there are many such people, too. This is already the fruit of your excited imagination! I am no less patriotic than all your Cossacks! With uv! hi
                      11. Setrac
                        Setrac 14 March 2014 01: 43
                        0
                        Quote: Thompson
                        About the page and account - no need to dock the inconsistent!

                        But how can you not join, if it itself has developed, without any efforts on my part.
                        Quote: Thompson
                        I am no less patriotic than all your Cossacks!

                        From how it is. And what is your patriotism expressed? What is comparable with the development of Siberia, the Far East, the North Caucasus?
                      12. Thompson
                        Thompson 14 March 2014 01: 52
                        0
                        Quote: Setrac
                        From how it is. And what is your patriotism expressed? What is comparable with the development of Siberia, the Far East, the North Caucasus?

                        This is too big a topic to knock on the clave here.
                        The answer is simple - the Cossack and Cossacks are not a panacea for all the ills of Russia. And most importantly - the Cossacks are no better than any other Russian people! This is what I mean and nothing more!
                      13. Setrac
                        Setrac 14 March 2014 02: 19
                        0
                        Quote: Thompson
                        And most importantly - the Cossacks are no better than any other Russian people!

                        The fact that you so persistently call the Cossacks - the people betrays a foreigner in you, as well as your hatred of the Cossacks. This is the usual hatred of mediocrity for the good.
                        Quote: Thompson
                        The answer is simple - the Cossack and Cossacks are not a panacea for all the ills of Russia.

                        And no one says that this is a panacea, but the tool is reliable and of high quality, unlike your PMCs.

                        In Russia, from the 2nd half of the XNUMXth century, the estate division into:
                        The nobility, divided into hereditary and personal;
                        Clergy;
                        Estate of honorary citizens;
                        Merchants;
                        Raznochintsy;
                        Philistinism;
                        Cossacks;
                        Peasantry.

                        Hu from hu nation and class distinguish? Not?
                      14. Thompson
                        Thompson 14 March 2014 02: 30
                        0
                        ... I will not say anything about the estate of HONORARY citizens
                        And stop talking nonsense about my foreignness. Already not even funny.
                        This is you implying the estate mean Nationality. Or don’t you say how so among the Terek why there are Ossetians, here the Armenians are already adjusting to the KAZAKH CONDITION! Perhaps what will fall ???
                        And here they are driven from the lands allotted for the Cossacks., HERE is abroad, in Sochi! Well, here I am a mishandled failure!
                        Cossacks - ethnic, social and
                        a historical community (group), uniting, due to its specific features, all Cossacks, primarily Russians, as well as Ukrainians, Kalmyks, Buryats, Bashkirs, Tatars, Evenks, Ossetians, etc., as a separate
                        the sub-ethnic groups of their peoples into a single whole. Russian legislation until 1917 considered the Cossacks as a special military estate, which had privileges for performing compulsory service. Cossacks were also defined as a separate ethnic group, an independent nation (the fourth branch of the Eastern Slavs), or even as a special nation of mixed Turkic-Slavic origin. The latest version was intensively developed in the 20th century by Cossack emigrant historians.
                      15. Setrac
                        Setrac 14 March 2014 02: 41
                        0
                        Quote: Thompson
                        The latest version was intensively developed in the 20th century by Cossack emigrant historians.

                        Speak directly, it was developed by Western propaganda and you are its mouthpiece, and if you are not a foreigner, but still a Russian, then you are simply a traitor.

                        Give a link from where you got all this garbage, I'll go "educate"
                      16. Thompson
                        Thompson 14 March 2014 09: 01
                        0
                        Quote: Setrac

                        Give a link from where you got all this garbage, I'll go "educate"

                        Sure you are sick! I don’t even see the point of continuing the dialogue with you. You are no longer diagnosed, but the verdict of spying and all who are not with us are against you! !
                        "educate yourself" - in a Yandex search, not even a foreign Google, type Cossacks into the search engine and you will find the answer in the first 3-5 links, along with the history, heroism and crimes of your apponents.
                        On the sim I stop flood with you! Learn, study and study again!
              2. Thompson
                Thompson 14 March 2014 01: 56
                0
                And what is comparable with the crimes of the Cossacks? Were they not the weapons of repression and terror in the hands of the autocracy, were they suppressing all the riots and uprisings of the common people for the desire to live better?
                Didn’t the kings terrorize you when you went too far in your desire to be more right than all the right? Learn the whole story, not pieces!
              3. Setrac
                Setrac 14 March 2014 02: 22
                0
                Quote: Thompson
                Were they not the weapons of repression and terror in the hands of the autocracy, were they suppressing all the riots and uprisings of the common people for the desire to live better?

                Quote: Thompson
                Didn’t the kings terrorize you when you went too far in your desire to be more right than all the right?

                I don’t understand. Are you for or against the Cossacks? Either your Cossacks are an instrument of repression, then the unfortunate terrorized by the tsar and the Communists.
              4. Thompson
                Thompson 14 March 2014 02: 32
                0
                I am not against the Cossacks, but even less so in the form in which they want to revive it! Therefore, I say, learn history in all its diversity!
              5. Setrac
                Setrac 14 March 2014 02: 43
                0
                Quote: Thompson
                I am not against the Cossacks

                In this case, here you are asked not to pour stamps of Western propaganda
                Quote: Thompson
                weapons of repression and terror in the hands of the autocracy

                Quote: Thompson
                terrorized the kings

                And speak in your own words.
              6. Thompson
                Thompson 14 March 2014 09: 13
                0
                Quote: Setrac
                Quote: Thompson
                I am not against the Cossacks

                In this case, here you are asked not to pour stamps of Western propaganda
                Quote: Thompson
                weapons of repression and terror in the hands of the autocracy

                Quote: Thompson
                terrorized the kings

                And speak in your own words.

                Excuse me! Well, I’m not to blame, which is more competent and educated than you
              7. Setrac
                Setrac 14 March 2014 13: 50
                0
                Quote: Thompson
                Excuse me! Well, I’m not to blame, which is more competent and educated than you

                You probably received education in the USA, since you are so generously pouring stamps of pinguosovskoy propaganda.
  2. RND
    RND 14 March 2014 00: 57
    0
    Honorable sir, let me say that "on the Kuban" you apparently live, not live. Do you have Russia with a capital letter too? And you are really not a Cossack. You are mister troll.
    Z.Y. Excuse me generously, but - Is Thompson an American submachine gun? what
  3. Thompson
    Thompson 14 March 2014 01: 22
    0
    Then we are one field of berry! lol ? Are you a troll too? drinks I’m neighing a magician! Very unpleasant!
    Is RND a purely Cossack name? I have never seen such a thing in Russian!
    Is this your habitat? And I have a place of residence! Do not judge by yourself!
    Or are you seven years old too? Learn to take criticism with dignity! No tantrums jokes and insults! I have friends and acquaintances of the Cossacks, and I’m fighting against them, no, no, but that does not change my attitude towards your ambitions !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! It is to them, and not to the Cossacks as such!
  4. Setrac
    Setrac 14 March 2014 01: 39
    0
    Quote: RND
    Hon. Sir

    Dear Rostovchanin, this is how you can’t answer such a fun shot like this Thompson, he is like Tamogochi, you need to feed him.
    Quote: Thompson
    Is RND a purely Cossack name?

    You really don’t understand what RND means?
    Quote: Thompson
    I have friends and acquaintances of the Cossacks, and I’m fighting with them, no, no, but

    This is one of the favorite tricks of trolls and other Internet fighters, a reference to non-existent friends who are like "our", and they are great guys, but ... there is always a "but", which, in theory, should convince others that you are right.

    Listen to yourself! MARASME on the march.
    You like Cossacks, but the Cossacks do not.
    You love Russia, it gives you gas, but you hate Russians, they take money from you for gas. wassat
  5. Thompson
    Thompson 14 March 2014 01: 48
    0
    Boy! Go study, be treated!
    You’ve been told go play toys! Here you are not there!
    By your logic and RND troll, he is also hitting the site too! Or is he his troll? (this is not addressed to RND)
  6. Setrac
    Setrac 14 March 2014 02: 27
    0
    Quote: Thompson
    Boy! Go study, be treated!

    Tambov wolf you a boy.

    Quote: Thompson
    By your logic and RND troll, he is also hitting the site too! Or is he his troll?


    Quote: Setrac
    Each detail in itself does not mean anything, but all together create a complete picture.

    I don’t even have to answer, I wrote the answer earlier, but, as I said earlier, the Chukchi is not a reader, the Chukchi is a writer.
  • Kazakh
    Kazakh 13 March 2014 17: 39
    +1
    but there’s nothing to go where they don’t ask,
    laughing I think Ermak Timofeevich associates: Ivan Ring, Yakov Mikhailov, Nikita Pan, Matvey Meshcheryak.
    Vasily Poyarkov.
    Simon Dezhnev.
    Erofei Khabarov.
    Vladimir Atlasov.
    Gavrila Pisemsky. also heard these words more than once. And why can not I be proud of these people?
    1. Thompson
      Thompson 13 March 2014 17: 46
      0
      Quote: Kazakh
      I think Ermak Timofeevich associates: Ivan Ring, Yakov Mikhailov, Nikita Pan, Matvey Meshcheryak.
      Vasily Poyarkov.
      Simon Dezhnev.
      Erofei Khabarov.
      Vladimir Atlasov.
      Gavrila Pisemsky. also heard these words more than once. And why can not I be proud of these people?

      You can be proud of these people! You have no right to disgrace!
      1. Kazakh
        Kazakh 13 March 2014 17: 48
        +1
        You can be proud of these people! You have no right to disgrace!
        And what was the shame on my part?
      2. Thompson
        Thompson 13 March 2014 23: 59
        0
        Personally with your nothing. Communicating with you in your person I mean all your gang-watering can, which has little in common with real Cossacks!
        Therefore ... do not take everything personally until, in any case, no reason was given!
  • Setrac
    Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 20
    +4
    Quote: Thompson
    That is precisely because you are the same as us, why do you need such benefits and concessions?

    Do you think that the Cossacks are some kind of God's chosen nation, which has an indulgence in front of the state! A man who is ready to defend the interests of his country, even in peacetime, must have tax and social advantages over those who want to defend their country.
    And you don’t need to exempt military men from taxes, no, you need to apply draconian measures against non-military men.
    And then such a couch "citizen" sits and is indignant, "why should the military have any indulgences", but with such that it is necessary to defend the Motherland.
    Cossacks - this is the tool with which the Russian Empire carried out expansion, the Cossacks were abolished and the expansion ended.
    1. Kazakh
      Kazakh 13 March 2014 17: 28
      +2
      Cossacks - this is the tool with which the Russian Empire carried out expansion, the Cossacks were abolished and the expansion ended.
      And not only ended but also went in the opposite direction
      1. Setrac
        Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 39
        +2
        Quote: Kazakh
        And not only ended but also went in the opposite direction

        Exactly, and the Americans adopted our method, now they have private military companies.
        1. creak
          creak 13 March 2014 18: 39
          0
          By the way, we also have PMCs ... And what of this? What does all this have to do with the Cossacks? People who are not sovereigns work in PMCs, although sometimes they can perform tasks in the interests of the state ... It is necessary to seriously establish retraining and service for conscripts who are in reserve, and not as the gatherings of those who were once called "partisans" were held, turning this process to put it mildly into an empty formality ...
      2. Thompson
        Thompson 13 March 2014 18: 10
        +1
        Quote: Kazakh
        Cossacks - this is the tool with which the Russian Empire carried out expansion, the Cossacks were abolished and the expansion ended.
        And not only ended but also went in the opposite direction

        If you follow your logic, STALIN is the most that neither, Cossack! There are no peers in the world like him as an expansionist!
      3. Thompson
        Thompson 13 March 2014 18: 10
        0
        Quote: Kazakh
        Cossacks - this is the tool with which the Russian Empire carried out expansion, the Cossacks were abolished and the expansion ended.
        And not only ended but also went in the opposite direction

        If you follow your logic, STALIN is the most that neither, Cossack! There are no peers in the world like him as an expansionist!
        1. Setrac
          Setrac 13 March 2014 19: 06
          +1
          Quote: Thompson
          If you follow your logic, STALIN is the most that neither, Cossack! There are no peers in the world like him as an expansionist!

          And in what territories did the expansion of Russians spread under Stalin?
    2. 11111mail.ru
      11111mail.ru 13 March 2014 17: 36
      +2
      Quote: Setrac
      Cossacks - this is the tool with which the Russian Empire carried out expansion, the Cossacks were abolished and the expansion ended.

      That is why the "Russian miraclesYuda", riding the authorities, will try to prevent the revival of the Cossacks, as the support of the Russian State.
      1. The comment was deleted.
      2. Hon
        Hon 13 March 2014 17: 53
        +1
        Quote: 11111mail.ru
        That is why the "Russian miracle-yuds", who have ridden the authorities, will try to prevent the revival of the Cossacks as the support of the Russian State.

        Come on? If militarily, then the Cossacks were always only part of the expeditionary forces. And often by the way and on the side of the enemy fought.
        1. 11111mail.ru
          11111mail.ru 13 March 2014 18: 21
          0
          Quote: Hon
          If militarily, then the Cossacks were always only part of the expeditionary forces. And often by the way and on the side of the enemy fought.

          Cossacks-Nekrasovtsy, Cossacks Dutova, Cossacks Annenkov, Cossacks Semenov, Cossacks von Pritvits, yes, they fought. And they fought well. And they, what: from another planet or what? There were Cossacks of Platov, Cossacks of Dumenko (Budyonny).
          Read VK Arsenyev "Across the Ussuriysk Territory". Who did he walk in the taiga with (we don't need Dersu Uzal about gold, we know), what kind of people were there, his support in his travels?
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. Hon
            Hon 13 March 2014 18: 34
            0
            Well, for some reason, it was the Cossacks who were the instrument of expansion, and the fact that the soldier always participated dozens of times more is not taken into account.
          3. Setrac
            Setrac 13 March 2014 19: 15
            0
            Quote: Hon
            Well, for some reason, it was the Cossacks who were the instrument of expansion, and the fact that the soldier always participated dozens of times more is not taken into account.

            There are such things, books are called, their people read, enlighten, and if they don’t read, then they keep quiet and do not demonstrate their ignorance.
          4. Thompson
            Thompson 14 March 2014 00: 10
            0
            The yellow press also publishes books.
            Mine Kapp also book
            Quran, the Bible is also a book
            How much blood is on their pages ????????
          5. Setrac
            Setrac 14 March 2014 00: 23
            0
            Quote: Thompson
            The yellow press also publishes books.
            Mine Kapp also book
            Quran, the Bible is also a book
            How much blood is on their pages ????????

            And so you do not need to read? Chukchi is not a reader, Chukchi is a writer.
            Read the Torah.
  • Thompson
    Thompson 13 March 2014 17: 37
    -3
    Expansion (from lat. Expansio - distribution, expansion) - the territorial, geographical or other expansion of the habitat, or zone of influence of an individual state, people, culture or species.
    judging by your conclusions, you are a biological species!
    As I wrote above, the same Bandera, but a side view and camouflaged.
    And then you are surprised that they do not accept you like that. For what? Minus at least round the clock. There are more normal people and it pleases!
    1. Kazakh
      Kazakh 13 March 2014 17: 46
      +1
      Minus at least round the clock.
      Yes you are my friend masochist laughing
      Expansion (from lat. Expansio - distribution, expansion) - the territorial, geographical or other expansion of the habitat, or zone of influence of an individual state, people, culture or species.
      And why did you stop only at the last definition? Or is your breadth of vision not enough? laughing And in the words of Bendera’s, it’s better not to rush about them, but I just heard from the news that you personally didn’t touch it, otherwise I would be silent
    2. Setrac
      Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 58
      0
      Quote: Thompson
      You are a biological species!

      Yes, there are a great many such "biological species" in the country: workers, peasants, officials, military men, Cossacks, policemen and others and other "species".
      Your attempts to discredit the Cossacks are miserable and inappropriate, in our country at the moment there is no such military force as the Cossacks.
  • dark_65
    dark_65 13 March 2014 20: 15
    0
    I am 49 ... in May, experience and desire are higher than the roof, and we are not alone, there are many of us who think so.
  • Tersky
    Tersky 13 March 2014 15: 45
    +7
    Quote: Canep
    Why then these mummers do not go to the army,

    Sergey, hi ! Before writing google at your leisure how many Cossack cadet corps in Russia, and where and in whose capacity their pupils serve.
    Quote: Canep
    I’ll answer myself, in the army you need to work from morning to night, military service, physical. training,

    But the Cossacks are only mummers? And in Crimea, they also only show off (Police and Cossacks repelled an attempt by the Tatars to seize the building of the Armed Forces of Crimea) For several years now, we have established joint patrolling of Cossacks with PPSniki on the spot, everyone is happy, the population in the first place. As for work - all Cossack formations exist at the expense of communal shares, be it land, water, forest. The land needs to be cultivated, the fish itself does not jump in the net, and the fry must be purchased and fed. So the Cossacks not only drink vodka and wave whips, but also plow black. At the expense of education and upbringing in the first paragraph. And as a result: DECISION OF THE RF AF OF 16.07.92 N 3321-I "ON REHABILITATION OF THE COSSACKS" 3. Recognize the Cossacks the right to:
    the revival of the traditional social and economic way of life and cultural traditions, subject to the law and generally accepted human rights; revival within the limits of the current legislation of the traditional forms of land ownership, land use and land disposal for the Cossacks (without prejudice to the rights of other citizens living in the area and not related to the Cossacks), military service in the units of the Armed Forces and the Border Troops of the Russian Federation;

    restoration of the traditional names of settlements and localities, streets, squares, cultural facilities, education, industrial and other facilities on the basis of free will of all groups of the population in places of compact residence of the Cossacks on the basis of current legislation;

    the creation of public Cossack associations with historically established names, including fraternities, unions and others; their registration and activities in the general manner established for public associations of citizens.
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. Hon
      Hon 13 March 2014 17: 25
      0
      Quote: Tersky
      Before you write google at your leisure how many Cossack cadet corps in Russia, and where and in whose capacity their pupils serve.

      There are many cadet corps in Russia, and not all of them are Cossack.
      Quote: Tersky
      And in Crimea, they also only show off (Police and Cossacks repulsed an attempt by the Tatars to seize the building of the Armed Forces of Crimea) We have been on the spot for several years already jointly patrolling Cossacks with PPSnikov,

      But other Crimeans did not participate in this? So do our warriors walk, so what?
      Among the Cossacks there are many young men who want to serve in the military enlistment offices. Why do they need to create special troops? Create a national guard, will we disperse explosives?
      1. Kazakh
        Kazakh 13 March 2014 17: 35
        +2
        But other Crimeans did not participate in this? So do our warriors walk, so what?
        Yes, they did, but he wrote these words in response to the statement that the Cossacks mumbled only in stripes along the streets, etc.
        1. The comment was deleted.
        2. Hon
          Hon 13 March 2014 17: 42
          +1
          Quote: Kazakh
          Yes, they did, but he wrote these words in response to the statement that the Cossacks mumbled only in stripes along the streets, etc.

          But I don’t understand why the Cossack always needs a special relationship with himself? They constantly need statuses, laws on Cossacks, separate troops, etc. Why not separate laws for Kalmyks, or for Khakasses? Let each nation have its own law.
          1. Tersky
            Tersky 13 March 2014 23: 28
            +2
            Quote: Hon
            Let each nation have its own law.

            And why did you take that the Cossacks are the people? This is an ethnic group ...
            Quote: Hon
            They constantly need statuses, laws on Cossacks, separate troops, etc.

            Re-read the Rehab Act ...
      2. Tersky
        Tersky 13 March 2014 23: 25
        +1
        Quote: Hon
        There are many cadet corps in Russia, and not all of them are Cossack.

        I have clearly written to mine-Cossacks.
        Quote: Hon
        But other Crimeans did not participate in this? So do our warriors walk, so what?

        I am glad for you, only taking into account the fact that I live at the intersection of the borders of the three SK republics, combatants are somehow not a panacea for our region. There was a replica of wearing stripes and narcissism, so I gave an example in the Crimea.
        Quote: Hon
        Among the Cossacks there are many young men who want to serve as military enlistment offices

        And what do you think of them in the refuseniks? Or refuse to serve? Reread my leading post, for those especially gifted in bold italics, where and in what troops should the Cossacks serve. For reference: Since the beginning of the 19th century, the entire male Cossack population has been considered military liable from the age of 15. Each family allocated one serving Cossack, who served for 25 years. So do not you Cossacks draft military commissariats ..
    3. Thompson
      Thompson 13 March 2014 17: 40
      -2
      so everything looks like the laws of Ukraine on the rehabilitation of Bandera ... Do not you find?
      All these laws on rehabilitation were adopted by political prostitutes, both in Russia and Ukraine, for the sole purpose of enticing this electorate to their side, so as not to lose power. And the whole price! And do not beat your chest with your fist! She is nothing bustier than the breasts of other peoples of Russia!
      1. Tersky
        Tersky 13 March 2014 23: 32
        +2
        Quote: Thompson
        so everything looks like the laws of Ukraine on the rehabilitation of Bandera ... Do not you find?

        I find ... that you are not far from the mind, since you are able to put scumbags from UNA-UNSO and Cossacks on one board.
        1. Thompson
          Thompson 13 March 2014 23: 48
          0
          It is precisely their intentions and actions that lead me to this conclusion!
          And not for you to evaluate my mind.
          I am telling and citing facts, but you are engaged in demagogy, Terek land!
          I don’t even want to write about you minuses here, everything in history has already been, literature, Krylov- Cuckoo and cock!
          A cuckoo praises a rooster for praising a cuckoo!
          you look around and see who you are, what you are and by whom the PEOPLE perceive you! This is a fact and an indicator!
          1. Setrac
            Setrac 14 March 2014 00: 02
            +1
            Quote: Thompson
            It is precisely their intentions and actions that lead me to this conclusion!

            When you blame someone, you need to be specific, as one great man said: "Every mistake has a name and surname."
            In order not to be unfounded windbag, clarify about "intentions and actions."
            1. Thompson
              Thompson 14 March 2014 00: 50
              -1
              Quote: Setrac
              In order not to be unfounded windbag, clarify about "intentions and actions."

              The whole article that is being discussed is your intentions and actions! You are the sole support of the empire! Therefore, the royal empire is still alive ..?
              Are you talking about her?
              1. Setrac
                Setrac 14 March 2014 01: 58
                +1
                Quote: Thompson
                Are you talking about her?

                No, not us. Cossacks supported the old dynasty until they refused to fight.
                Cossacks are an irregular army. With all due respect to their skill, the Cossacks did not have heavy weapons and were not pulled against the regular army.
                So the Romanovs proklili their empire without the help of the Cossacks, on their own.
          2. Tersky
            Tersky 14 March 2014 08: 22
            +2
            Quote: Thompson
            I am telling and citing facts, but you are engaged in demagogy, Terek land!
            Demagogy from you sprinkles in all directions, and where the facts are, request ? Single verbiage and bile.
            Quote: Thompson
            you look around and see who you are, what you are and by whom the PEOPLE perceive you! This is a fact and an indicator!
            I see an indicator of your next stupidity, because you should not pass off your personal hostility as an opinion of the people ..
  • ty60
    ty60 13 March 2014 13: 37
    +8
    Regarding the provision of equipment and weapons, the detailed answer is in the article. The Cossack form varies depending on the region, even stripes of different colors. Therefore, it is applicable only as a parade. Everyday, in accordance with the form of the Ministry of Defense. Lampas will remain different from the personnel of the Ministry of Defense. It is advisable to preserve the original report card of ranks-officer, esaul, etc.
    1. Setrac
      Setrac 13 March 2014 14: 11
      +2
      Quote: ty60
      It is advisable to keep the original report of the ranks of the officer, esaul, etc.

      This is unnecessary, the ranks should be the same as the military, and uniform. Ranks, uniforms are all window dressing, the main idea is that the people and the army are united - the army and the police should be able to locally strengthen at the expense of civilians with military training, and what to call the Cossacks, the police or the national guard is the tenth thing.
      Let the police work with military registration and enlistment offices, keep records of those liable for military service, the police know who has legal weapons (hunters, security guards, and so on).
      Here legislators and lawyers should work, the Ministry of Defense and the Ministry of the Interior should be able and entitled (including legal) to call on civilians without declaring a general mobilization.
      Create first-rate military men - people who have weapons and ammunition with ammunition stored at home in a safe, and which can be put into operation very quickly. to consider tax benefits for this category and material assistance from the state, albeit insignificant.
      1. afdjhbn67
        afdjhbn67 13 March 2014 15: 42
        +2
        serious people, only in the 21st century we already live
        1. Thompson
          Thompson 13 March 2014 17: 44
          -1
          Quote: afdjhbn67
          serious people, only in the 21st century we already live

          They have a motto - back to the future!
        2. Thompson
          Thompson 13 March 2014 17: 44
          -2
          Quote: afdjhbn67
          serious people, only in the 21st century we already live

          They have a motto - back to the future!
          1. Tersky
            Tersky 14 March 2014 08: 25
            +1
            Quote: Thompson
            They have a motto - back to the future!

            As I understand it, "facts" have grown into banal trolling. Minus.
      2. The comment was deleted.
        1. Setrac
          Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 45
          +1
          Quote: Hon
          And we are not united now?

          In Ukraine, they are not united. With us - I’ll see I think in the near future.
          Quote: Hon
          And why call without mobilization?

          There is a partial mobilization, then that the provided mobilization mechanisms are very slow and start from the center, gears will not spin without an order from Moscow.
          Quote: Hon
          type a, let's take Vasya into the army, let him serve a second time.

          And let's not pretend like a fool.
          Quote: Hon
          What for

          The point is to give the mobilization system flexibility and autonomy, so that events like the Chechen ones were impossible in principle.
          1. The comment was deleted.
            1. Kazakh
              Kazakh 13 March 2014 18: 07
              0
              . Your idea is that the reservists would react before the army, and even without an order from above?
              But in Ukraine, we observe PMCs before the regular army
              1. The comment was deleted.
              2. Hon
                Hon 13 March 2014 18: 13
                0
                Quote: Kazakh
                before regular army

                Which army? they have one and a half cripples, their weapons depots could not be protected from asshole with bats.
                1. Setrac
                  Setrac 13 March 2014 19: 17
                  +1
                  Quote: Hon
                  Which army? they have one and a half cripples, their weapons depots could not be protected from asshole with bats.

                  What for? These same PMCs in Ukraine are at the same time with "assholes with bats".
          2. Hon
            Hon 13 March 2014 18: 04
            0
            Quote: Setrac
            In Ukraine, they are not united.

            Ukraine itself is not united; there were many Cossacks on the Maidan
            Quote: Setrac
            There is a partial mobilization, then that the provided mobilization mechanisms are very slow and start from the center, gears will not spin without an order from Moscow.

            For quick action, there are quick reaction forces and parts of constant combat readiness. The reserve is always the forces of the second and third stage. Your idea is that the reservists would react before the army, and even without an order from above? And if such a system in '93, how would it prevent the Chechen events? Would you gather and go to war in Chechnya, before the start of the troops? And if the actions of the reservists diverge from the plans of the command, then what?
            1. Setrac
              Setrac 13 March 2014 19: 19
              0
              Quote: Hon
              And if such a system in '93, how would it prevent the Chechen events? Would you gather and go to war in Chechnya, before the start of the troops?

              If the Russians had weapons and the right to use them in Chechnya, then yes, the events would have gone according to a more favorable scenario for the Russians.
      3. Hon
        Hon 13 March 2014 17: 34
        +2
        Quote: Setrac
        the main thing is the idea itself - the people and the army are united

        And we are not united now?
        Quote: Setrac
        army and police should be able to strengthen locally at the expense of civilians with military training

        But is it all that all eligible in the service are on military records, those who served have training, and to maintain it at the proper level, are training?
        Quote: Setrac
        Here legislators and lawyers should work, the Ministry of Defense and the Ministry of the Interior should be able and entitled (including legal) to call on civilians without declaring a general mobilization.

        And why call without mobilization? for fun? type a, let's take Vasya into the army, let him serve a second time.
        Quote: Setrac
        Create first-rate military men - people who have weapons and ammunition with ammunition stored at home in a safe, and which can be put into operation very quickly.

        Well, I agree with this, the idea is good.
        1. Setrac
          Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 50
          +2
          Quote: Hon
          Well, I agree with this, the idea is good.

          So this is the main idea of ​​the Cossacks, to have civilians in the problem regions of the country and the world who have weapons and are ready to get into operation in the shortest possible time.
          Why exactly the Cossacks, and not just those liable for military service? The traditions, succession of generations, when the father of the Cossack teaches the son of the future Cossack from an early age, will give a very high level of training, but you can even call them Martian infantry, it’s not the name.
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. Hon
            Hon 13 March 2014 17: 56
            0
            And as soon as the Swiss do without the Cossacks?
            1. Kazakh
              Kazakh 13 March 2014 18: 05
              +3
              And as soon as the Swiss do without the Cossacks?
              Because they have the largest country laughing that did without Ermak
              1. Hon
                Hon 13 March 2014 18: 11
                0
                Quote: Kazakh
                Because they have the largest country and that without Ermak

                And they do not have the smallest army, and all men are not divided into Cossacks and the rest by reservists with military weapons at home. Now, what would Yermak do in modern conditions? The British in the past half of the world colonized without Cossacks.
              2. Hon
                Hon 13 March 2014 18: 11
                -1
                Quote: Kazakh
                Because they have the largest country and that without Ermak

                And they do not have the smallest army, and all men are not divided into Cossacks and the rest by reservists with military weapons at home. Now, what would Yermak do in modern conditions? The British in the past half of the world colonized without Cossacks.
                1. 11111mail.ru
                  11111mail.ru 13 March 2014 21: 15
                  0
                  Quote: Hon
                  The British in the past half of the world colonized without Cossacks.

                  http://dvforpost.su/pervye-russkie-na-dalnem-vostoke.html
                  "The sea voyage of the Muscovites ended in the same navigation season of 1640. It is one of the most important events in the history of the great Russian geographical discoveries. Its participants were the first Europeans to discover the Amur and Sakhalin. This was three years before she visited the coast of southern Sakhalin the Dutch expedition of Martin de Vries (July 1643), whose participants were undeservedly considered the discoverers of Sakhalin. "
                  I hope you heard about Semyon Dezhnev? Long before Cook passed through the Bering Strait!
            2. 11111mail.ru
              11111mail.ru 13 March 2014 21: 07
              +1
              Quote: Hon
              And as soon as doormanTsy do without the Cossacks?

              Dear, think about the question: why did a word appear in pre-revolutionary Russia that means the profession of a person who opens the doors to respectable visitors to an institution? The tooltip is highlighted.
              I suspect that you probably know that the Don Cossacks led by Matvey Ivanovich Platov participated in the Swiss campaign of A.V.Suvorov?
          3. The comment was deleted.
          4. Hon
            Hon 13 March 2014 18: 16
            0
            Quote: Setrac
            Why exactly the Cossacks, and not just those liable for military service? The traditions, succession of generations, when the father of the Cossack teaches the son of the future Cossack from an early age, will give a very high level of training, but you can even call them Martian infantry, it’s not the name.

            If you have such traditions and preparation, then why do Caucasians bend you down to the very tomatoes? The rebuff by the way they are given not in the Cossack and in the Russian regions.
            1. Setrac
              Setrac 13 March 2014 19: 25
              0
              Quote: Hon
              The rebuff by the way they are given not in the Cossack and in the Russian regions.

              Cossack areas are no longer Russian? And who do you think lives in the Cossack villages and what nation is the Cossacks?
              Quote: Hon
              If you have such traditions and preparation, then why do Caucasians bend you down to the very tomatoes?

              I do not know who the Caucasians are bending down to the very tomatoes, in the Caucasus they are adequate, this capital is crying about the "dominance of blacks."
      4. Tersky
        Tersky 13 March 2014 23: 35
        +2
        Quote: Setrac
        This is superfluous, the titles should be the same as the military, and uniform.

        Regarding the ranks, I agree to all 100, the Cossacks have a uniform as a ceremonial, as well as everyday and field:
    2. Spnsr
      Spnsr 13 March 2014 14: 41
      +1
      Quote: ty60
      Regarding the provision of equipment and weapons, the detailed answer is in the article. The Cossack form varies depending on the region, even stripes of different colors. Therefore, it is applicable only as a parade. Everyday, in accordance with the form of the Ministry of Defense. Lampas will remain different from the personnel of the Ministry of Defense. It is advisable to preserve the original report card of ranks-officer, esaul, etc.

      then you need to create parks for equipment, training buildings like a normal military unit, training grounds and much that should be, and let them serve in preparation for hostilities, carry out guard duty, go to field exits! free, like Cossacks, feeding on their household
  • ty60
    ty60 13 March 2014 13: 37
    +1
    Regarding the provision of equipment and weapons, the detailed answer is in the article. The Cossack form varies depending on the region, even stripes of different colors. Therefore, it is applicable only as a parade. Everyday, in accordance with the form of the Ministry of Defense. Lampas will remain different from the personnel of the Ministry of Defense. It is advisable to preserve the original report card of ranks-officer, esaul, etc.
  • The comment was deleted.
  • siberalt
    siberalt 13 March 2014 14: 41
    0
    Interesting idea. Commercial Cossacks on state allowance. Oh well.
  • pts-m
    pts-m 13 March 2014 14: 43
    +4
    we forget about the main thing. Generation must be brought up from the cradle and we are brought up from diapers in which they go before being called up for military service. It's time to change the approach to the upbringing of the younger generation.
  • wow
    wow 13 March 2014 15: 16
    +6
    I would not agree with you about the "masquerade". In Great Britain, the National Guard (Royal Riflemen) is generally in bear hats and "parrot" red uniforms. But this is in plain sight, and in which case they quickly take their proper form. The form does not always determine the content.
    1. Spnsr
      Spnsr 13 March 2014 15: 27
      +1
      Quote: yo-mine
      In Great Britain, the National Guard (Royal Riflemen) is generally in bear hats and "parrot" red uniforms.

      this is just a masquerade for tourists
  • TAMERLAN 7
    TAMERLAN 7 13 March 2014 15: 30
    +2
    There is a full-fledged army in Russia, and I am sure that there are enough Cossacks in it. Cossacks, this is a militarized formation, nor a full-fledged army, much less a regular army, a faster militia. There is a problem - gathered, no problem - live quietly. Of course, the uniform is ceremonial, and it’s great for the national guard (original and the world knows it, the French after the Napoleon scared children with Cossacks). But armaments - the question depends on the status that they will have. In Switzerland, for example, a man works quietly for himself, and then comes to the training camp and flies on an airplane, or shoots from a gun. It is necessary to determine their tasks, to assign a certain status, then it will become clear what they need and weapons and ammunition and equipment and organization.
  • Sibiriya
    Sibiriya 13 March 2014 13: 10
    +5
    I agree with you not to find patrols of the best mobile units
  • ed65b
    ed65b 13 March 2014 15: 06
    +4
    Quote: TAMERLAN 7
    Good idea. They always served well. Such a militarized formation and on the borders of Russia is perfect and within the country will provide assistance in case of natural disasters, catastrophes, etc.

    So they will also support our Russian-speaking compatriots in all unstable countries with an armed method. Ukraine is an example. Instead of "polite people", "polite Cossacks"
  • afdjhbn67
    afdjhbn67 13 March 2014 15: 35
    +3
    unfortunately the days of the quiet Don are gone, the medals assigned to Cossacks epaulettes from the ceiling are some kind of medal, the orders are all a sham - if a Caucasian is not afraid of a Cossack, then you are not a Cossack, but you are very mumbled. it was impossible to discredit the idea; the second thing, neither in the Kuban nor in the Stavropol Territory, did you bring about the matter on your own? (they’ll definitely peck now)
    1. Setrac
      Setrac 13 March 2014 15: 50
      +1
      Quote: afdjhbn67
      Neither in the Kuban nor in the Stavropol Territory did they bring order into their own hands?

      The law protects the criminal, the Cossacks are in the same unfavorable position as the rest of the citizens of Russia.
    2. Stanislas
      Stanislas 13 March 2014 16: 15
      +2
      Quote: afdjhbn67
      if a Caucasian is not afraid of a Cossack then you are not a Cossack
      Stupidity you just said. It is more correct: if a Caucasian does not respect a Cossack, then you are not a Cossack.
  • svp67
    svp67 13 March 2014 12: 54
    +9
    Territorial defense in Russia is not secured and requires unconventional ways to solve this problem.
    and this was always the DUTY of the Cossack troops ...
    Quote: Negoro
    Why not create a national guard based on the Cossacks ?!
    It is possible, but only as part of it, since we have a lot of land where there were no Cossack Troops (districts), so we must form the National Guard there on a different basis ...
    1. Spnsr
      Spnsr 13 March 2014 15: 29
      0
      Quote: svp67
      we have a lot of land where there were no Cossack Troops (districts

      belay
  • Hs487
    Hs487 13 March 2014 12: 54
    +14
    Quote: Negoro
    Why not create a national guard based on the Cossacks ?!

    Perhaps, because the Cossacks should preserve their historical name, and not change it to an overseas counterpart.
    1. afdjhbn67
      afdjhbn67 13 March 2014 15: 46
      +1
      why do we need nat. Guard, Cossacks if there are internal troops? Do you need to strengthen and modify them?
      1. Setrac
        Setrac 13 March 2014 15: 58
        +1
        Quote: afdjhbn67
        why do we need nat. Guard, Cossacks if there are internal troops? Do you need to strengthen and modify them?

        First, in peacetime, the Cossack contains himself, including personal weapons and uniforms. Secondly, in theory, the Cossack settles in a problem region, or even in another country.
        If we now had "those" pre-revolutionary Cossacks, then the government of the Russian Federation would simply send a hundred thousand Cossacks to live in Ukraine and the Maidan would end there.
  • The comment was deleted.
  • GreatRussia
    GreatRussia 13 March 2014 13: 01
    +9
    Cossacks left for Volgograd to Crimea

    According to Volgograd Business Television, citing Volgograd Orthodox, on March 11, with the blessing of the spiritual mentor of the Cossacks of the Volgograd Region, Archpriest Oleg Kirichenko and at the invitation of the Cossacks of Crimea, 35 Cossacks of the Volgograd District and the Volga Yurt, a combined detachment, left for the Crimean peninsula.

    There fellow countrymen will assist their Cossack brothers. The Cossacks of the Volgograd region and Crimea are connected by a long-standing friendship and partnership.

    Immediately before departure, a prayer for travelers was served by a clergyman of the John the Baptist Church in Volgograd, confessor of the Volgograd Regional Cossack Youth Organization Donts, Priest Sergiy Savenkov.

    http://vd-tv.ru/news.php?15359
    1. ty60
      ty60 13 March 2014 13: 40
      +6
      I wish them good health and glorious victories!
    2. ty60
      ty60 13 March 2014 13: 40
      +1
      I wish them good health and glorious victories!
  • yan
    yan 13 March 2014 13: 08
    -1
    I completely agree with you, the Cossacks become the basis for the national guard, with the relevant territorial divisions
  • Spnsr
    Spnsr 13 March 2014 13: 26
    +2
    I have the ancestors of the Ural Cossacks! laughing the state is ready to allocate me a horse in the form of an armored troop carrier laughing it would be cool, I’m on an armored car in a store for vodka laughing I’ll still paint it white, I’ll get a license, put a checker and I’ll tax laughing and what to beat off as the same laughing
    1. ty60
      ty60 13 March 2014 13: 43
      +6
      Hi, I’m also Ural. However, you don’t have to charge an APC, any equipment has a limited resource. Combat is for exercises and security tasks. For vodka, on a personal bicycle.
      1. f.lourens
        f.lourens 13 March 2014 13: 59
        +2
        I’ll fix the training, combat training, fighting a little .. the latter is practically not used but is in case of war hi
      2. Spnsr
        Spnsr 13 March 2014 14: 51
        0
        Quote: SpnSr
        I have the ancestors of the Ural Cossacks! laughing the state is ready to allocate me a horse in the form of an armored troop carrier laughing it would be cool, I’m on an armored car in a store for vodka laughing I’ll still paint it white, I’ll get a license, put a checker and I’ll tax laughing and what to beat off as the same laughing

        Quote: ty60
        Hi, I’m also Ural. However, you don’t have to charge an APC, any equipment has a limited resource. Combat is for exercises and security tasks. For vodka, on a personal bicycle.

        Hi!
        and who said that this will not happen? if in the regular army this happens, then what can I say ...?
  • Kazakh
    Kazakh 13 March 2014 13: 29
    +8
    . Why not create a national guard on the basis of the Cossacks ?!
    At the moment, it seems to me better than a type of private military company. And the Cossacks in deed and the government are not chapels, but the work will be a rampart all over the world. Thank God we are Cossacks
  • Russ69
    Russ69 13 March 2014 13: 31
    +1
    Quote: Negoro
    Why not create a national guard based on the Cossacks ?!

    Probably not the national guard, but to have an always ready priority reserve is quite reasonable.
  • jjj
    jjj 13 March 2014 13: 37
    +6
    Cossacks, Cossacks! Come, ride through Berlin, our Cossacks!
    1. strannik595
      strannik595 13 March 2014 13: 58
      +9
      after the village of Kushchevskaya, I have no respect for the mummers..... I talked with my clients in the Krasnodar Territory, they said that they came to the institute, pointed the finger at the girls: "you, you and you", took them away and no one could protect them in the Cossack Territory ..... and this for many years ........ masquerade fighters with spillikins and tsatzky ....... ancestors trampled Paris and made it a "bistro", and the descendants of och pale shadow of those legendary Cossacks ....... if they were the same - the Maydauns were already walking in chains to Novosibirsk
      1. Kazakh
        Kazakh 13 March 2014 14: 08
        +1
        after the village of Kushchevskaya, I have no respect for the mummers
        As of April 1995, seventy-three "Slavic" PGs and seven ethnic groups were operating in Moscow. Do you respect yourself? for such a number of organized crime groups and do not say just that everyone has already been defeated and the Orkhovskaya and Kemerovo and Solntsevskies have not gone anywhere, they just become a little quieter
        1. strannik595
          strannik595 13 March 2014 14: 19
          0
          Do you respect yourself?
          and you come to my daughter ... my T. 8 (953) 355-71-39
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. matross
            matross 13 March 2014 16: 10
            +1
            Why did you bicker with each other here ?? Because of which? It is clear that the Cossacks have just begun to revive, a lot of unnecessary, ostentatious. But it's a good thing, ours, primordial Russian ... So many Cossacks have gone to Crimea to help with law and order! It will get better soon, the adhered will disappear, the meaning and essence will remain. In the article, the author said the truth - the territorial defense cannot be provided with available forces, this is what we need to think about, our neighbors did not think, now they have the Nazis "defending"! We have a lesson for the near future.
    2. RND
      RND 13 March 2014 14: 49
      0
      Quote: jjj
      Cossacks, Cossacks! Come, ride through Berlin, our Cossacks!

      We went, and still let's go !!!
      And for skeptics making petty tricks to colleagues in the form of cons, I highly recommend studying the story!
      Z.Y. Basically, I’m not dealing with minus, due to the incompetence of some opponents in this matter ...
  • Setrac
    Setrac 13 March 2014 14: 07
    +3
    Quote: Negoro
    Good thing. Why not create a national guard on the basis of the Cossacks ?!

    This is the American National Guard, Russians and Americans have a different meaning in the word guard.
  • knn54
    knn54 13 March 2014 14: 10
    +6
    Of course, it’s not for someone-BB that’s doing the wrong thing; in the Ministry of Emergencies, 5 controllers per rescuer.
    The Don Cossacks were one of the first to recognize the independence of Ichkeria. During the 2nd Chechen battalion, not patriots, but ONLY Cossacks were taken into the ranks of the Ermolovskaya battalion. Everyone knows that Kushchevskaya stanitsa. with the Center ???
  • Er22345
    Er22345 13 March 2014 14: 16
    -2
    I don’t understand why are you all so happy? You do not have enough of these guys to live normally in your country?
  • midashko
    midashko 13 March 2014 17: 33
    +2
    I fully support. And what to do with corrupt power? She can deal with cattle, but with the armed people?
  • Spnsr
    Spnsr 13 March 2014 22: 42
    0
    for me so "Cossacks" mobilization reserve. people who are ready to leave home at any time to defend the fatherland. in civilian life, ordinary people who just look after themselves a little and who (in the future) once a year, for a month or less, go to training camps to prepare and study new types of weapons ...
    1. Thompson
      Thompson 13 March 2014 23: 31
      -1
      Those are ALL! But the Cossacks for some reason for the money ...
  • sscha
    sscha 13 March 2014 12: 51
    +8
    In Kiev, the detachments of "Berkut" by the decision of the Court were outlawed!
    The guys have now untied their hands and the number of "Berkutovites" and Kuban Cossacks at Perekop will definitely increase ... (And why isn’t a "Berkutov" Cossack?) hi
    1. svp67
      svp67 13 March 2014 13: 09
      +7
      Quote: sscha
      (And what is the "berkutovets" not a Cossack?)
      The only difference is that now they become a Cossack from birth, but they went to "Berkut" by conviction ... Although earlier they went to the Cossacks in the same way ... A new round of history ...
  • Kornilovets
    Kornilovets 13 March 2014 12: 51
    +10
    Why, just call on the Cossacks for service ... Restore the good old Cossack regiments, etc.
    1. svp67
      svp67 13 March 2014 13: 26
      +5
      Quote: Kornilovist
      Why, just call on the Cossacks for service ... Restore the good old Cossack regiments, etc.

      What has long been done, but it is part of the Armed Forces. The author, however, calls for the use of people who work peacefully, but at the right time and in the shortest time, are ready to gather in the indicated places and come out in the SHORTEST TIME to help both the Armed Forces and the Internal Troops, and in particular to assist the police in maintaining order in the streets , including emergency situations ...
      And of course, helping Border Troops ...
      1. Spnsr
        Spnsr 13 March 2014 13: 29
        +2
        Quote: svp67
        Quote: Kornilovist
        Why, just call on the Cossacks for service ... Restore the good old Cossack regiments, etc.

        What has long been done, but it is part of the Armed Forces. The author, however, calls for the use of people who work peacefully, but at the right time and in the shortest time, are ready to gather in the indicated places and come out in the SHORTEST TIME to help both the Armed Forces and the Internal Troops, and in particular to assist the police in maintaining order in the streets including emergency situations ..

        the campaign has not yet called you from the military registration and enlistment office! and there are a lot of those you speak of, and without Cossacks
        1. svp67
          svp67 13 March 2014 13: 37
          +6
          Quote: SpnSr
          the campaign has not yet called you from the military registration and enlistment office!

          And why should I call, I periodically visit myself there ... from old memory ... I remind you of my existence, so as not to relax.
          1. Spnsr
            Spnsr 13 March 2014 14: 57
            0
            Quote: svp67
            Quote: SpnSr
            the campaign has not yet called you from the military registration and enlistment office!

            And why should I call, I periodically visit myself there ... from old memory ... I remind you of my existence, so as not to relax.

            laughing
  • Sma11
    Sma11 13 March 2014 12: 53
    +8
    Territorial Defense Forces. Many countries, along with regular armies, have territorial troops in their combat forces. In these states, it is the territorial troops who are tasked with covering the mobilization deployment of the armed forces, protecting strategic objects and elements of the military and civilian infrastructure, and actually conducting territorial defense. The territorial defense troops are formed according to the principle "Where you live, you fight there."
    Territorial troops are equipped with senior reserve personnel. Based on the territorial principle, they perform tasks in places of residence. On the equipment of the territorial troops, as a rule, there are small arms and other weapons, the possession of which does not require special training. The important tasks of the territorial troops are also the elimination of the consequences of emergencies, the conduct of armed struggle in the territory temporarily captured by the enemy.

    http://topwar.ru/35386-vrag-ne-proydet.html

    http://topwar.ru/579-samaya-militarizovannaya-strana.html


    Long overdue! good Stop playing democracy and liberalism! Got played by yourself sickeningly!
    1. pts-m
      pts-m 13 March 2014 14: 53
      0
      I support the idea 100%! Correctly said!
    2. Thompson
      Thompson 14 March 2014 00: 33
      -1
      Let's do it! Armed Cossacks will guard the Kuban, Rostov and the stavropol region!
      The southern borders are armed dzhigits of Chechnya, Ingushetia, Ossetia, Kabarda, Dagestan,
      Northern peoples on deer instead of armored personnel carriers, in the east of the Chukchi, etc.
      Everything according to your declaration, where we live, we protect there (we’re definitely not fighting ??)!
  • VNP1958PVN
    VNP1958PVN 13 March 2014 12: 57
    +7
    Everything is new, well-forgotten old! wink
  • Capyar 48315
    Capyar 48315 13 March 2014 13: 02
    +10
    HIGH TIME AND THREE ARCHIVAL. If only again not limited to conversations and under-measures. Even the autocracy did not see anything other than a stabilizing border factor in the armed Cossack districts. My second argument is that this is not a remake but a centuries-old protective tool of Russian civilization and therefore does not pose a threat from unpredictable development
  • Standard Oil
    Standard Oil 13 March 2014 13: 04
    +7
    At the moment, the Cossacks have proven their effectiveness as irregular troops "Russia has nothing to do with it." If they want to use them to guard, for example, the border, then let them use it. But you should not get too carried away with this matter either.
  • Astartes
    Astartes 13 March 2014 13: 05
    +8
    The question is posed correctly, the creation on the territory of Russia of an estate of people who would be an active support for power and order in the localities and border territories. This should not be a completely militarized structure, since this is already part of the army, but devote most of its time to military training, based on on traditions, culture and serious benefits from the state. Cossacks in Ingushetia were large and medium landowners, they knew what they were fighting for and what they were defending. What can modern government offer to new "Cossacks" ??
  • Gagarin
    Gagarin 13 March 2014 13: 07
    +7
    That's right, it was a long time ago.
  • Leshka
    Leshka 13 March 2014 13: 11
    +1
    I hope that our proposals will pay attention to this
  • zeleznijdorojnik
    zeleznijdorojnik 13 March 2014 13: 12
    +3
    How does the author represent the collective responsibility of stanitsy for weapons depots? Decimation would still be remembered ...
  • Same lech
    Same lech 13 March 2014 13: 15
    +10
    We really need Cossacks now, and here's why:
    we all know that a war is being waged against us with unconventional forms of hostilities: these are various rallies and rallies of scumbags (rice paths, artistists nailing their eggs to the pavement, swamp adventurers using dissatisfaction with the power of people to organize the overthrow of power and then) smoothly turning into an attempt to destroy the state system, many do not notice this, but I see when the number of provocations is already transferred to the quality of a full-scale civil war, you can’t put police and special forces to every provocateur ... therefore it’s logical to have a mobile organization of people in the state (who are in the position of the law and the preservation of the civil world) - Cossacks (not dressed up of course) are the best suited for this, and for joining their ranks there should not be any restrictions on the nationality of the worldview and then the only requirement for them to serve the civil peace in RUSSIA within the framework of the law. (NATIONAL REPUBLICES may also be such organizations naturally under full co by the role of the society AND THE RUSSIAN STATE)
  • konvalval
    konvalval 13 March 2014 13: 16
    +5
    Yes, after the collapse and downsizing of the Army by smerdyukov, this will be very good reinforcement of the regional defenses. The defense of the Motherland is honorable, and the defense of the Little Motherland is even more honorable and effective.
  • fisherman
    fisherman 13 March 2014 13: 17
    0
    This is the utopia of creating some gangs of formations on a social basis, this is complete nonsense, what measure of responsibility these people have, who will control their activities, who will finance it all, public initiative is good, but what is the prospect, and if there is a conflict of interests with the federal power, who will solve it ?. The initiative is very dangerous so that it doesn’t happen that in the Caucasus we did not have our Cossacks
    1. Sergg
      Sergg 13 March 2014 13: 36
      +1
      Absolutely agree. No need to look for a black cat in a dark room.

      Need to improve the interaction of law enforcement and the system and the public.
      In the end, people's squads were always created.

      What will be the selection criteria for the Cossacks? Legal basis of activity? And if on one Cossack formation a different Cossack formation is created nearby on another basis, then what? will there be fist fights or a duel on hunting rifles right away?
      I know about serious conflicts within the existing Cossacks. You know, Cossacks will not come from neighboring planets.
      1. Same lech
        Same lech 13 March 2014 14: 01
        +3
        Need to improve the interaction of law enforcement and the system and the public.
        In the end, people's squads were always created.


        You know, I don’t believe in this interaction ... at least because of what is happening with the MILITION IN UKRAINE.

        Any shake-up of power structures and our police will go like a zombie chicken, unable to protect itself and our citizens.
    2. Same lech
      Same lech 13 March 2014 13: 37
      +5
      This is the utopia of creating some gangs of formations on a social basis.


      say utopia ... but various bandits and criminals bring this utopia to life and the state has to spend its resources on the fight against them.

      Cossacks and the like can stop the emergence of the beginnings of such scumbags using national, social and other problems and push people who care for the preservation of the state UP NON-STUPIDITY and NOT-MIND.
      (YANUKOVICH has already shown how insane this stupidity can reach)

      IN CHECHNYA there was a case when in one village a scumbag (I will not name his nationality) calmly walked and shot civilians as if in a dash (killed more than 30 people) - and there was no one to stop him BECAUSE PEACEFUL CITIZENS HOPE IN THE UNABLE TO SAVE THEM CORRECTION

      I personally do not want such a fate, and if it becomes a matter of life or death, I would rather break the law (it is better to be a living prisoner than a dead law-abiding citizen)
      1. Ugrumiy
        Ugrumiy 13 March 2014 14: 08
        +1
        Here, it would not have been the Cossacks who would have helped more, but the existence of an adequate law on weapons and their use, this thug would have slammed and that’s all, and the Cossacks would not have been needed.
    3. 787nkx
      787nkx 13 March 2014 14: 25
      -1
      There are those liable for military service, there are military registration and enlistment offices, and so improve mobilization work.
  • Capyar 48315
    Capyar 48315 13 March 2014 13: 18
    +8
    can you imagine the consequences of the appearance in the armed and therefore self-confident Cossack village of Biloy or Yarosh? in-in! and I introduced. They will argue soberly and send to the city to understand. And if with a hangover then ... But seriously, with such a factor as armed not only with the traditions of the Cossacks, such instances will not work for a cannon shot and they won’t have such an idea
    1. RusSever
      RusSever 13 March 2014 13: 29
      +6
      Hello It’s just that in the country the Army should not be 800 thousand people, but at least 1,5-2 million normal units for combat purposes. And the draft - so that there was a rotation and a mobile reserve. Otherwise - all this to one place.
  • SHAKESPEARE
    SHAKESPEARE 13 March 2014 13: 27
    +11
    A national guard is being formed in Ukraine, now the law on the formation of the National Guard is being adopted in Zrad, I don’t understand how much money and where healthy young people will be taken, because all the sick and not full-fledged, they cannot contain their armed forces but climb without Vaseline in ..., except that, as I understand it, they will form Bandera’s right-wing sector and self-defense, so it will be the punitive guard of the SS-Galychin, they want to legitimize it, and then mass repression and survival from the territory of the Russian and Russian-speaking population. I think Russia should act as a warrior liberator in the ancestors of the cries of the Americans and the Eurosan. Americans have never asked anyone permission for their actions if it is in their interests. The territory of Ukraine must be returned in 1918.
    1. I read the news
      I read the news 13 March 2014 14: 27
      +1
      Russia must become a warrior liberator in spite of the cries of the Americans and the Eurosan
      And while quickly, decisively.
    2. Viktor.N.Aleksandrov.
      Viktor.N.Aleksandrov. 13 March 2014 15: 05
      0
      It is better to return what was before 1914!
  • Mikhail3
    Mikhail3 13 March 2014 13: 27
    +5
    The economic autonomy of the Don Cossacks led to their massive betrayal of the Russian Empire exactly when the Cossacks needed it most. Another Don Republic ... taking into account the idea that the Cossacks are an independent ethnos, a special people, also persistently introduced into the environment of the "Cossacks" ...
    But in general, the idea is not bad. That's just ... No "economic autonomy"! Some benefits in peasant activities. It is in the peasantry that the Cossack is obliged to be connected with the land. But only! Service payment - yes. No "smoking lands"! And further. Something like an input filter. A Cossack can never, under any circumstances, be recognized as one who at least once in a sober state has been seen in idiotic outfits, seamlessly drawn from parrots, as in the photo in the article. Because the Motherland needs warriors, not macaws or toucans.
    1. Kazakh
      Kazakh 13 March 2014 13: 41
      +3
      And further. Something like an input filter. The Cossack can never, under any circumstances, be recognized as the one who at least once was soberly seen in idiotic outfits, seamlessly drawn from parrots, as in the photo in the article.
      And who will filter? Trotsky or Sverdlov? Why can some even accept elves in their outfits and the Cossack in grandfather’s right-winger hurts his eyes? We are told that the Cossacks live in the past. If not externally, then internally. This is not without reason, and there is an explanation for this. We involuntarily feel like partners in all the great events in the life of our ancestors. In every Cossack family, at least one ancestor with whom we feel a spiritual connection is remembered and revered. They live in us, they speak in us, are an example and a role model.
    2. Viktor.N.Aleksandrov.
      Viktor.N.Aleksandrov. 13 March 2014 15: 10
      +1
      I support the comment. However, about "idiotic outfits" this is overkill. If an appropriate structure is created, its own dress uniform should appear, approved in accordance with all the rules. Until then ... everyone has their own toys. Not everyone has an army uniform or a uniform from other law enforcement agencies hanging in their closets.
    3. Metlik
      Metlik 13 March 2014 16: 43
      0
      Quote: Mikhail3
      The economic autonomy of the Don Cossacks led to their massive betrayal of the Russian Empire precisely when the Cossacks needed it most.

      Freedom - that was the basis of the Cossacks.
      And this is a Russian cultural tradition - freedom for all. The warrior could leave the prince at any time. The Novgorod veche was higher than the prince. Even a serf could leave his master on St. George's Day.
      Freedom means development. Dependence is stagnation.
      Without economic autonomy, Cossacks will be just another type of troops. And you will have to pay for them in the end from the budget
      1. GP
        GP 13 March 2014 17: 44
        0
        Quote: Metlik
        Will - that was the basis of the Cossacks.


        That's more accurate. The Cossacks arose, existed and developed at the turn of the Russian borders with the mainly Muslim world (Ottomans-Turks, Persians, Tatars (in a broad sense, not in the national one), etc.), actively adopting and trying on many features, most vividly expressed in clothing. They were free to organized robbery and robbery of the adversary in retaliation for the constant raids on Russian lands ("the Cossacks are writing a letter to the Turkish Sultan"), they themselves, in turn, were under constant threat. When the Russian state gained strength and, finally, was able to more or less ensure the protection of the borders, the Cossacks in their original form lost their meaning, even more, they became a threat themselves (the uprisings of Razin and Pugachev); the question arose of what to do with them, wisely reorganized into an estate. After the 17th year, with its great achievement - the breakdown of the archaic estate of society, the Cossacks again became a threat, and together with the nobility, the landowners were sent to the dustbin of history.
        The Cossacks can be revived, but in no way in the likeness of the past, it should be a neoplasm and only so.
        1. Metlik
          Metlik 13 March 2014 18: 16
          0
          Quote: GP
          The Cossacks can be revived, but in no way in the likeness of the past, it should be a neoplasm and only so.

          I agree, but only by taking the best of my history and traditions. And the best quality was their passionarity, which without will does not exist.
  • Manul
    Manul 13 March 2014 13: 29
    +11
    I have always defended the ideas of the Cossacks and their contemporary movement on the site. We passed mercilessly. I survived. The main thing was that it reached.
    1. Thompson
      Thompson 13 March 2014 18: 45
      -2
      I am also always against the ideas of the Cossacks, in the form as it is now. Also minus, too, will survive! The main thing that comes!
      1. Manul
        Manul 13 March 2014 22: 39
        +1
        Quote: Thompson
        I am also always against the ideas of the Cossacks, in the form as it is now.

        Have you seen the Cossacks near at least?
  • Alex66
    Alex66 13 March 2014 13: 31
    +7
    Only he who works on his land will defend his land to death. The Cossacks is a real stabilizing force with which they will be forced to reckon.
    1. Per se.
      Per se. 13 March 2014 13: 43
      +1
      Quote: Alex66
      Only he who works on his land will protect his land until death.
      It is difficult to disagree with you, but, is it only the Cossacks on earth who work and only they are ready to defend it? Here is one of the comments above for you to think about:
      Quote: SpnSr
      I have the ancestors of the Ural Cossacks! the state is ready for me to allocate a horse in the form of an armored troop-carrier it would be cool, so I am in an armored troop-carrier in a store for vodka
      Such an army ... No offense, nothing personal, I am for the Cossacks, but those who will be engaged in farming on the Amur, somewhere else at distant frontiers, and these borders should be guarded for such ownership of land, not burdened pseudo-Cossacks, with fake awards and a belly drooping from idleness.
      1. Manul
        Manul 13 March 2014 13: 51
        +4
        Quote: Per se.
        Such an army ... No offense, nothing personal, I am for the Cossacks, but those who will be engaged in farming on the Amur, somewhere else at distant frontiers, and these borders should be guarded for such ownership of land, not burdened pseudo-Cossacks, with fake awards and a belly drooping from the beer.

        I’m constantly trying to convey to such an inflamed imagination - why did you get the idea that the Cossacks only do that, they walk day and night with their sabers naked and in pants with stripes? These are the same people who go to work and raise their children. well educated. That is, they also plow the land. And if there is a threat to the fatherland, then the Cossack goes to war, and the women and children plow. It has always been and will never be otherwise.
        1. Spnsr
          Spnsr 13 March 2014 16: 04
          0
          Quote: Manul
          Quote: Per se.
          Such an army ... No offense, nothing personal, I am for the Cossacks, but those who will be engaged in farming on the Amur, somewhere else at distant frontiers, and these borders should be guarded for such ownership of land, not burdened pseudo-Cossacks, with fake awards and a belly drooping from the beer.

          I’m constantly trying to convey to such an inflamed imagination - why did you get the idea that the Cossacks only do that, they walk day and night with their sabers naked and in pants with stripes? These are the same people who go to work and raise their children. well educated. That is, they also plow the land. And if there is a threat to the fatherland, then the Cossack goes to war, and the women and children plow. It has always been and will never be otherwise.

          What is a mobilization reserve? What is a mobilization prescription?
      2. ty60
        ty60 13 March 2014 13: 55
        +1
        I already wrote a fellow countrywoman about the armored personnel carrier and vodka to the near. Perhaps he joked. Humor is different
      3. ty60
        ty60 13 March 2014 13: 55
        +1
        I already wrote a fellow countrywoman about the armored personnel carrier and vodka to the near. Perhaps he joked. Humor is different
      4. Kazakh
        Kazakh 13 March 2014 14: 00
        +1
        not mummers of pseudo-Cossacks, with fake awards and a belly hanging from beer idleness.
        You must admit that among the Russian people, people with fake awards and a belly drooping from idleness are enough about what the whole article on the site
    2. Viktor.N.Aleksandrov.
      Viktor.N.Aleksandrov. 13 March 2014 15: 12
      0
      But what about those who live in cities? They can no longer be patriots?
    3. Thompson
      Thompson 13 March 2014 18: 50
      0
      Quote: Alex66
      Only he who works on his land will defend his land to death. Cossacks is a real stabilizing force with which will be forced be considered.

      There is already as the right sector! And who is surprised when I compare them with Ukrainian nationalists? This is whom you want to FORCE ACCOUNT ??? ! Do not dishonor the Cossacks! Cossacks, follow your actions, your actions, slogans and will be your deserts. as long as you have what you deserve.
  • Dikson
    Dikson 13 March 2014 13: 37
    +1
    Well, once the Cossacks were quite formidable fighting force. And put things in order .. It was a long time ago. Where is the guarantee that instead of the noble hardworking stanichniks we won’t get new Tsapki, who will begin to keep in fear whole regions of the territories and regions? all over the country, not counting the south (where the genetic connection remained with the Cossacks), some mummers, calling themselves Cossack chieftains, in trousers with stripes and hung with some medals hang out all over the country .. To revive the Cossacks under the banner of military glory ? So the civil war greatly influenced the glory of these banners. In general, of course, the Cossacks in certain regions of our country are quite a serious force as a people's militia. The pluses are that people living on their land will not give offense to it and indeed can keep order.
    1. Same lech
      Same lech 13 March 2014 13: 50
      +6
      But what really were the HACKS? Cossacks? ... no, of course .. the usual bandits impudent from impunity (through the fault of local authorities).
  • Sergg
    Sergg 13 March 2014 13: 47
    0
    All the same, I am for the creation of national squads based on the law enforcement system.
    The process should be controlled and responsible, random people should not be there - where they are going to counter crime and protect public order. And the financing of these formations can only be state, there should not be private armies in Russia. Not everything is so simple in practice.
    Our law enforcement system is far from smooth, and there is a strict selection of candidates for service, but what will happen to the Cossacks? people are the same from the same country. I'm not a romantic, okay.
    1. Same lech
      Same lech 13 March 2014 14: 12
      0
      I am still for the creation of national teams


      In his youth, he helped the district police officer in this matter, then he realized that he needed me for this matter only as a witness, to sign the papers. (I need such a squad for hell)
  • ty60
    ty60 13 March 2014 14: 02
    +4
    The Cossacks have always been a self-regulating system. A rigid system of education, respect for the elderly as in the Caucasus, regular exercises. There are all the necessary things in the warehouses of the Moscow Region. To maintain the traditions, equestrian sports, work with drafts. A decent life. And after a while, I started to export grain again. ,
  • Ugrumiy
    Ugrumiy 13 March 2014 14: 03
    +8
    It is not necessary to deal with Cossacks, but the armed forces, primarily the ground forces, and internal troops, to bring to life and increase them qualitatively and quantitatively, and to create a national guard from reservists in the territories. Just somewhere, these same reservists may be Cossacks.
    In addition, it should be borne in mind that the Cossacks were never a military branch, but a CONDITION! In the current conditions, I think the revival of such an estate as it was before is not possible, and it is not necessary. The goals voiced by the author of the article can be achieved in other ways.
    1. Same lech
      Same lech 13 March 2014 14: 13
      0
      The AHA and the armed forces in full force will chase the assholes from PUSSY WRIGHT.
  • made13
    made13 13 March 2014 14: 06
    +3
    A normal legislative framework, a charter, an oath, and in a few years all the normal population (not drinking, not chasing power and money) will be Cossacks. And this is a serious percentage of voters in elections at all levels.
  • Magadan
    Magadan 13 March 2014 14: 09
    +7
    Cossacks need the country! These are our traditions and our pride. It should only be reborn precisely from below, as a movement of ideological people united by love for the Motherland, its history and Orthodox values. Those. that spiritual basis on which the Cossacks were built before the revolution. Weapons must certainly be given. Fees must be carried out. The state should not contain Cossacks, but it can finance certain projects (such as the Cadet-Cossack corps), hire Cossack hundreds to carry out certain activities, etc. In a word, a cossack may be a certain PMC but strictly built on certain moral principles.

    PS Well, now I finally have our flag, Russian :)
    1. Marisat
      Marisat 13 March 2014 14: 51
      0
      But do not want gangs?
      Cossacks is a way of life, now it is destroyed. Cossacks need to be created from a kindergarten, now we get private armies, even in the state. financing.
  • RUSS
    RUSS 13 March 2014 14: 35
    +1
    I am sure that the time will come soon when the Cossacks are remembered and called to serve the Motherland as in 1936. Cossacks want to serve Russia, and the state is obliged to hear them.
  • Seryi trifon
    Seryi trifon 13 March 2014 14: 44
    0
    What is the Cossacks in the bathhouse ???
    Cossacks - who is it?
    And you about these mummers? From head to toe in medals and zanchiki, which weighed upon ourselves?
    There has been no Cossacks for a long time! And those that have mustachioed and bearded men standing in temples with candles, dancing at fairs, etc. etc. This is no longer the Cossacks (
    Perhaps Cossacks can be called men with machine guns in the Crimea?
    But let's be realistic already. The time for checkers, feet, Circassians and lame boots has long passed. In the modern world, this is all a place in the museum. And if you want to serve the Motherland in an extreme form, go to the army, the Ministry of Emergencies or the police !!!
    1. Setrac
      Setrac 13 March 2014 15: 35
      +2
      Quote: Seryi Trifon
      The time for checkers, feet, Circassians and lame boots has long passed.

      You have a perverted idea of ​​the Cossacks. And, for example, officers of the ACTING Army of the Russian Federation also go to the parades with sabers, and do not complex.
  • Stanislas
    Stanislas 13 March 2014 14: 50
    +1
    As a result, there will be a special estate (and maybe a nationality) that is inextricably linked with military service to the state. The mentality of its members, formed by a specific highly patriotic environment for educating young people, will make this estate one of the most reliable pillars of the state.
    Article minus. The author does not touch upon such attributes of the Cossacks as the earth and the circle. The Cossacks worked on their land and fought for their land, which constituted "a specific highly patriotic environment for educating young people." For the Cossacks, the land, conquered or donated, became OWN for the Cossacks thanks to a specific form of democratic power - the Cossack circle, which was the highest power after God on this earth. The tsar could not deprive the Cossacks of lands and titles, in contrast to the other military class - the nobility. The Cossacks chose their chieftains and served the state on contractual terms. They were one of the pillars of the Russian state, but they could also oppose the tsarist and communist authorities.
  • mabuta
    mabuta 13 March 2014 14: 50
    0
    In the Cossacks, the military component has always been the main component of the idea. Certainly, somewhere in the backwoods, drunken, disguised men who call themselves Cossacks cause bewilderment and laughter. But if you recall the battalion named after Ermolov in Chechnya, nothing comes to mind except respect and pride. I think that many conflicts can be resolved by professional military wise life with step-by-step access to technology living in the same environment with you.
  • Gardamir
    Gardamir 13 March 2014 14: 53
    +1
    For me, the former Cossacks are "armed, Orthodox farmers." Who is this Cossacks now? Taxi driver in the Kubanka. The idea is certainly interesting. But first, imagine the idea of ​​the modern Cossacks. On the basis of what will the Cossack detachments be created? Possibly armed volunteer squads, ready at any time to stand under arms.
  • saag
    saag 13 March 2014 14: 53
    +2
    I don’t like Cossacks, I don’t have faith in them, probably because my grandfather beat them in civilian life and probably did it well, since there are awards, so there’s no faith in the beaten, one more nuance - no one probably so much loves show-off punching like Cossacks, like that had a chance to get on one resource - "yes we, yes the Cossacks, yes we are support and hope" and so on and so forth, why army and naval service and do not beat themselves in the chest, how cool are they? And finally, just two words - the village of Kushchevskaya, it says it all.
    1. Stanislas
      Stanislas 13 March 2014 17: 48
      +1
      Quote: saag
      therefore, there is no broken faith
      We give two unbeaten for one beaten. And the village of Kushchevskaya is because your "grandfather beat them in civil war and it was good." Under the Cossacks in the villages, this was not close, it is a product of the decomposition of developed socialism, the way of life, which was imposed on the Cossacks by force, according to the instructions of comrade. Trotsky.
    2. Kazakh
      Kazakh 13 March 2014 17: 51
      0
      why are army men and navy men serving and not beating themselves in the chest how cool they are?
      Well, on August 2, go to the nearest fountain laughing
  • Prutkov
    Prutkov 13 March 2014 14: 54
    +1
    Taking into account the current technologies of waging wars with the help of the fifth column and "soft power", work with the Cossacks must be intensified. The experience of Ukraine has shown that one cannot count on the police (police). If the leadership does not have the will to give the appropriate order to the security forces, there will be no one to protect the civilian population from the Banderlog. And the army can only be involved in the aggression of an external enemy, and not of its own people.
  • dmb
    dmb 13 March 2014 14: 55
    +2
    Well amused. But this gentleman is considered to have a military education. It seems that in the courtyard the eighteenth century, and the searchlight Sivkov writes with a quill pen and on parchment. One of the commentators has already spoken about explicit cretinism with collective responsibility, but the rest of the arguments for novelty do not shine. In Russia, there were already cantonists and military settlements. Let's get back to them ?. Cossacks traditionally live with us (if this is news for Sivkov) in well-defined regions on the outskirts of the former. Russian empire. Therefore, Moscow and St. Petersburg are mummers. Apparently Sivkov believes that they from two capitals will go to Naryan-Mar. They will not go, even if he heads this move. This means that territorial defense will be recruited from local citizens who have nothing to do with the Cossacks. Our Chechen and other brethren from among those whom the feds are chasing through the forests are eagerly inscribed on the lists of these valiant troops. That is, they will have a legal opportunity to additionally acquire weapons (except for those already illegally available). To make them collectively responsible for using it in the next robbery, I suggest sending the same Sivkov. No less wise Sivkov and in terms of the use of Cossacks for the protection of objects of strategic importance. Even in specialized explosives, people were specially trained for their protection, and he suggests doing it by chop. In general, if we list all the insults of Sivkov, then you will have to write twice as much as he.
    1. creak
      creak 13 March 2014 19: 14
      0
      Quite right, Sivkov seems to be living in some sort of parallel reality, which has fundamentally not coincided with real life for a long time, hence this is not his first article with a set of similar pearls ...
  • WKS
    WKS 13 March 2014 14: 57
    +3
    I am afraid that during the Soviet era, the Cossack spirit was almost completely driven out of the people. I myself am a descendant of the Kuban Cossacks, my grandfather Kuban Cossack Art. Ilyinskaya, my great-grandfather served in the selected Cossack hundred of the convoy of the Emperor, and all my N-cousins, nephews, etc., their heirs are scattered around the world. In Ilyinskaya today, most of the people do not know anything about Cossacks. This is the Cossacks, not internal troops - this is a way of life and a way of life. This is the possession of weapons since childhood. This is a willingness to order to come up with weapons for combat. This is collective ownership of land, with an annual and honest distribution of it across each family. And so on and so forth. All this was laid down by family and social education, centuries-old traditions. By decision of the government or other authority, this cannot be restored. The Cossacks is a democratic self-organization of the Russian people, I am afraid she is killed forever.
  • Cossacks
    Cossacks 13 March 2014 15: 14
    0
    Tricky question. What is the size of the structure of the larger ground forces of the Russian army or police officers in Moscow?
  • Cossacks
    Cossacks 13 March 2014 15: 19
    +1
    If you know this figure, then it will automatically become clear from where such opuses and projections come from. People think about anything but the real state of affairs.
  • Cossacks
    Cossacks 13 March 2014 15: 19
    0
    If you know this figure, then it will automatically become clear from where such opuses and projections come from. People think about anything but the real state of affairs.
  • Viktor.N.Aleksandrov.
    Viktor.N.Aleksandrov. 13 March 2014 15: 27
    +1
    The times of military settlements, as under Nicholas 1, are long gone. Territorial troops are really needed, but not as voluntary squads, but perhaps as cropped units, with their leader, staff, equipment, which, if necessary, is deployed into a full-fledged military unit from older reservists. Well, the Cossacks - they are really needed in the border regions of Russia. as it was before.
  • Ross
    Ross 13 March 2014 15: 32
    0
    Quote: TAMERLAN 7
    Good idea. They always served well. Such a militarized formation and on the borders of Russia is perfect and within the country will provide assistance in case of natural disasters, catastrophes, etc.

    And they have long been asking for this. And what a patriotic upsurge will arise. Cossacks themselves will deal with the mummers and restore the ancient traditions of the defenders of Russia.
  • chunga-changa
    chunga-changa 13 March 2014 15: 43
    +3
    And let's revive the archers, too, by the way, our pride and tradition, they will maintain order in the cities for lowering business taxes. In the current conditions, to revive the Cossacks in the old form, in the old place, this is not a necessary utopia. There are no conditions and tasks for them that were a hundred years ago. Now, the resettlement of Cossacks along the Chinese border, where there are few troops and police, and where they can actually perform their functions of maintaining order, protecting resources and the border, may be relevant. Who agrees to live in the taiga subsistence farming and guard the border - sign up. I am sure there will not be many who want to. A reasonable and achievable goal is the Cossacks as a trained reserve for explosives, using not at the place of residence, but at any point in the country, as it was on the eve of the revolution. Which is apparently suggested by the author of the article. That is not such a kind of troops and a new one, rather pretty outdated.
  • KononAV
    KononAV 13 March 2014 15: 45
    0
    It sounds beautiful but effective in modern realities.
  • 1976AG
    1976AG 13 March 2014 15: 50
    0
    Cossacks a new kind of troops? Are you serious? The Russian Armed Forces with the current technical equipment cannot compete on equal terms with the United States. In the era of rifles and cannons with cores, they represented strength, but now ... This is the historical way of life of a certain population group. The maximum is the forces of internal order in small settlements, no more! And judging by the appearance, the amusing troops, as in Peter the Great. Atamans with breasts in orders, who is this? Heroes who deserve rewards in battles or buffoons who undeservingly fastened them? What a decent person will walk in undeserved rewards1
    1. Setrac
      Setrac 13 March 2014 16: 08
      0
      Quote: 1976AG
      In the era of rifles and cannons with cores, they represented strength, but now ...

      In the past, everything was the same as now, in our time, like a hundred and two hundred years ago, artillery reigned on the battlefield. Before the revolution, the Cossacks had only light artillery. In our time, as in the past, during a war with the regular army of another state, Cossack units must be strengthened with heavy equipment, which will be done by the state and the regular army.
      Quote: 1976AG
      The Russian Armed Forces with the current technical equipment cannot compete on equal terms with the United States.

      Google such a thing as "logistics shoulder". On the territory of the Russian Federation and in adjacent countries, the Russian army is the strongest.
      Quote: 1976AG
      Atamans with breasts in orders, who is this? Heroes who deserve rewards in battles or buffoons who undeservingly fastened them?

      Of course, I did not check it myself, but it is unlikely that these very mummers wear undeservedly military orders, all sorts of badges and other tinsel are not forbidden to wear, but these are not military orders, although you can always run into a relapse.
      1. 1976AG
        1976AG 13 March 2014 16: 18
        +1
        And if you wear tinsel, are you more respected or do you value yourself more? In my opinion, this is a shame. Regarding artillery, you are very behind, just a hundred to two hundred years. The outcome of the war is determined by means of air attack.
        1. Setrac
          Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 13
          -2
          Quote: 1976AG
          In my opinion, this is a shame.

          Wearing badges is not a shame, it's just badges, of course a military man with such badges looks like a parrot, but this is a personal matter for everyone, if this does not contradict the charter.
          1. 1976AG
            1976AG 13 March 2014 18: 12
            +2
            Wearing badges is not a shame? Excuse me, are you an adult? !!! Are you over seven years old? My son doesn’t allow himself that. The charter does not contradict, but conscience?
            1. Setrac
              Setrac 13 March 2014 19: 29
              0
              Quote: 1976AG
              Wearing badges is not a shame?

              And what's shameful?
              Quote: 1976AG
              Excuse me, are you an adult? !!!

              Let us not be personalized, and I will not send you anywhere.
              Quote: 1976AG
              Are you over seven years old?

              What is the meaning of the question? Are you afraid that the child will be smarter than you?
              Quote: 1976AG
              The charter does not contradict, but conscience?

              How is a meaningless piece of metal on the chest contrary to conscience? And the rivet on the pocket of your conscience does not contradict, or the metal zipper.
              1. 1976AG
                1976AG 13 March 2014 20: 40
                +3
                Do you compare rewards with rivets and zippers? Not ashamed? If you do not see the difference, then I am sorry for you. But to be honest, I did not want to offend anyone. I just don’t understand why to hang different trinkets on myself? Now, judging by the answer, you are offended by me. So you have pride. So you respect yourself too. Will you wear badges too? Undeserved? Well, if so, then the truth is no offense, why? Be real, live in good conscience, let others reward you, and then you will understand what you are worth.
                1. Setrac
                  Setrac 13 March 2014 21: 48
                  0
                  Quote: 1976AG
                  I just don’t understand why to hang different trinkets on myself?

                  Well, you don’t understand, I don’t understand why people smoke, because there is no pleasure from this process! Some people like to hang on themselves various trinkets, they do not unfairly hang military orders, someone hangs heavy metal, someone badges, someone jewelry. Our army also has dubious awards "for twenty years of spotless sweeping of the parade ground."
                  Quote: 1976AG
                  Do you compare rewards with rivets and zippers? Not ashamed? If you do not see the difference, then I am sorry for you.

                  But I’m not sorry, the man put on himself a couple of kilograms of iron - his job, the charter allows and okay, maybe it's iron plaque from enemy arrows?
                  Now, if someone undeservedly put on military awards, then here you need to deal with each individually, and not row everyone under one comb.
                2. Thompson
                  Thompson 14 March 2014 01: 07
                  0
                  Bro, we seem to have been led to teach a blind-deaf-dumb and even a youngster with milk on his lips. And this embryo wants to teach and protect us. Look at his profile picture!
                  Setrak- Seryozha, son, go play shooting games, strategies, do not interfere in the male conversation!
                  1. Setrac
                    Setrac 14 March 2014 02: 09
                    0
                    Quote: Thompson
                    Setrak- Seryozha, son, go play shooting games, strategies, do not interfere in the male conversation!

                    Better strategy than your point game. Daddy, if I had such a daddy, I would have shot myself out of shame.
                    My nickname and avatar is a brand, they are already fifteen years old. My children are less than an avatar picture.
                    Do you think that if you put on such an avatar, then everyone will believe that you are Russian?
                    1. Thompson
                      Thompson 14 March 2014 02: 13
                      +1
                      smile On my profile picture, I’m not Russian like myself! I am Caucasian! Like you almost smile
                      And my nickname is much more patriotic than your avatar, don’t you? smile
                      My children are over 20 and they will tear for me, Without any Cossacks, nationality, anyone! You deserve it!
                      1. Setrac
                        Setrac 14 March 2014 02: 48
                        0
                        Quote: Thompson
                        I am Caucasian!

                        So where does the hatred of the Cossacks come from, you are one of those whom the Cossacks pressed at one time.
                        And are you one of those who swept the USSR?
                        Quote: Thompson
                        And my nickname is much more patriotic than your avatar, don’t you?

                        No, I don’t find it, especially since patriotism is not in nicknames and not in avatars.
                        Quote: Thompson
                        Like you almost

                        Apparently we are on the opposite side of the Caucasian ridge.
  • Old warrant officer
    Old warrant officer 13 March 2014 15: 50
    0
    "As a result, a special class (or maybe a nationality) will arise"
    He set the article a plus, since the need for territorial defense arose a long time ago. For example, for the entire region from Chita to Belogorsk there is one motorized rifle brigade, and the situation is not better in other parts of the eastern state border. Therefore, local territorial defense, an example-fighter units at the beginning of the Second World War, can and should be organized, and the Cossacks should play a role here. In addition, older defenders can and should be recorded in the formation of local defense. But about the emergence of a new nationality - stop joking with the national question! Cossacks are not a nationality or a nationality! If we recognize the Cossacks as a nation, then where is the guarantee that in a few years or decades some regular leader will not announce the right of the Cossacks to self-determination and other crap! I believe that in Russia it is generally necessary to abolish administrative divisions on a national basis, eliminate all national entities, leaving only federal districts where all nationalities and peoples will have equal opportunities, rights and responsibilities!
    1. Dikson
      Dikson 13 March 2014 16: 52
      0
      for the whole region from Chita to Belogorsk there is one motorized rifle brigade, and the situation is no better in other parts of the eastern state border. a year and a half ago, some staff exercises were held ... The result - it is estimated that in two weeks of non-nuclear conflict the Chinese will cross the Ural Mountains. Not straining at all. And no Cossacks at the border will stop them with their sabers ... And even in the case of a nuclear one, we will have to use it more on our territory ...
      1. Setrac
        Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 22
        0
        Quote: Dikson
        The result - it is estimated that in two weeks of non-nuclear conflict, the Chinese will cross the Ural Mountains. Not straining at all. And no Cossacks at the border will not detain them with their sabers ...

        As a matter of fact, what does the Cossacks have to do with it? They are not in the indicated direction, at least as a military force.
  • msv
    msv 13 March 2014 15: 54
    0
    Quote: strannik595
    after the village of Kushchevskaya, I have no respect for the mummers..... I talked with my clients in the Krasnodar Territory, they said that they came to the institute, pointed the finger at the girls: "you, you and you", took them away and no one could protect them in the Cossack Territory ..... and this for many years ........ masquerade fighters with spillikins and tsatzky ....... ancestors trampled Paris and made it a "bistro", and the descendants of och pale shadow of those legendary Cossacks ....... if they were the same - the Maydauns were already walking in chains to Novosibirsk


    Customers are not always right. Like Kushchevskaya, not all of the Krasnodar Territory, and certainly not all of Russia.

    Yes, Cossacks are certainly not the same, since only in my area are several villages that were surrounded in 1918 and completely destroyed by the Reds. Although the Kuban people generally adopted Soviet power.
    But this is certainly not a reason to reject the very rational idea. Cossacks is a social movement that needs to be developed.
    The creation of a national guard or a trained reserve on their basis is a reasonable idea.
    1. 1976AG
      1976AG 13 March 2014 16: 08
      0
      And how do you represent the national guard based on them? But the airborne does not pull on the national guard?
      1. Setrac
        Setrac 13 March 2014 16: 12
        +1
        Quote: 1976AG
        And how do you represent the national guard based on them? But the airborne does not pull on the national guard?

        Russian paratroopers in Kiev and Cossacks in Kiev are completely different concepts from a legal point of view.
        1. 1976AG
          1976AG 13 March 2014 16: 26
          0
          In theory, yes. But in practice, who in international relations respects legal legality? I did not think that after the recent events I would have to return to this topic.
          1. Setrac
            Setrac 13 March 2014 17: 26
            0
            Quote: 1976AG
            In theory, yes. But in practice, who in international relations respects legal legality? I did not think that after the recent events I would have to return to this topic.

            Even Americans are trying to give their actions the appearance of legitimacy through the UN, OSCE and other international institutions.
            1. 1976AG
              1976AG 13 March 2014 18: 26
              0
              UN, OSCE, and where is the legal justification? Based on what articles of international law? And there are no these articles, how do you like this?
  • chainik8080
    chainik8080 13 March 2014 16: 05
    +1
    Quote: Canep
    And who forbids you to go in Cossack uniforms? I wrote that military service is not only uniform and Cossack surroundings. At 49, it’s too late to join the army; at this age, officers are retiring. If you served, you should know what kind of burden falls on the soldiers and junior officers, and if you didn’t serve then it makes no sense to explain. And if you put on officer epaulets, then please be familiar with the following disciplines in theory and practice:
    Tactical training.
    Special tactical training.
    Engineering training.
    Fire training (small arms, RPGs, MANPADS, AGS).
    Driving and device of army vehicles.
    Drill.
    Military charters, UGiKS.
    Military topography.
    Fundamentals of educational work with l / s.
    And comply with the standards:
    in physical training
    fire training
    by driving.
    And also you need to have good health.
    If you at least know this, you will be able to carry officer uniforms.

    Dear, you seem to have read the article poorly !! It also says that military training since childhood, and that the Cossacks have many professionals have no doubt !!
  • kelevra
    kelevra 13 March 2014 16: 09
    +2
    I am a hereditary Cossack, Don! Now I am in the service in the Siberian Cossack army. The revival of the Cossacks has just begun to gain strength and, of course, we want, in the end, that we have both responsibilities and legal protection, because when we go on duty, we have to act on our own fear and risk. We enter the State Register of Cossack Societies, this is our guarantee that we serve the state. There are simply mummers, they need to be dispersed, they only introduce confusion. If someone thinks that we are just for fun, I will present the facts of our usefulness .The police have been reduced from 2 million to 1 million, they themselves do not have time to do anything, especially since they are imposed with a rigid framework in terms of opportunities. Here we help them, control public order and prevent emergencies and various unrest. I live in a small village, two There are a lot of offenses for our 5 thousand people. Beginning in March 2013, we (the Cossacks) personally detained one criminal who was wanted for a series of murders. they imprisoned 8 "hucksters" (those who push and sell drugs), prevented 20 thefts, 4 car thefts, 2 mass fights, helped in the investigation of 11 crimes, including serious ones, stopped the activities of 2 poaching groups, found 3 lost children in the forest, extinguished 7 hotbeds of forest fires in a total size of 18 km in diameter, rescued 8 people from burning apartments. At the same time, we also received injuries, mutilations, wounds.
    1. 1976AG
      1976AG 13 March 2014 16: 33
      +1
      What you write about in Soviet times was carried out by voluntary people's squads - DND. What does the Cossacks have to do with it7
  • Black
    Black 13 March 2014 16: 13
    +2
    Quote: Marisat
    But do not want gangs?


    Well this is for stupidity ?! Galmatit being in the sovereign service ??? Apparently, your grandmother at night didn’t read those fairy tales as a child!
    py.s.
    From Volgograd yesterday, 25 Cossacks departed ... all such "polite" went !!!
    Here above the post they asked where the Cossacks got their rewards ...
    A lot more "funny", it will somehow dry up and fall off.
    But his brother has one for the Pre-Dniester, another for the Abkhaz ...
    Dressed up?
    1. 1976AG
      1976AG 13 March 2014 16: 43
      +1
      By the way, I am also from Volgograd. Who has his own rewards - honor and praise - no bazaar! But you look at the chieftains, all the breasts in the orders, as if the whole World War II passed, only all the crosses. Maybe with the first world? But too young.
      1. 787nkx
        787nkx 13 March 2014 17: 07
        0
        Maybe with the first domestic, Napoleon was driven.
  • 787nkx
    787nkx 13 March 2014 16: 15
    +1
    In our city, he was selected as a Cossack chieftain, a slave of which no light had ever seen.
    Holds a brothel in the city.
  • Orik
    Orik 13 March 2014 16: 17
    0
    The article is essentially correct, the Cossacks should serve Russia. It seems to me that one should not be afraid to give responsibility and rights. I believe that most of the Cossacks are capable of co-organizing, light small arms like in Sweden at home, equipment in battalion depots, except for the automobile, which, according to the available staff in each village, must be monitored and protected by the available staff, but control from the FSB and the Ministry of Internal Affairs needed. I would go further, the administrative bodies where the Cossacks live should also consist of them, the heads can be centurions, Yesauls, foremen and chieftains. Duplication of power is not necessary, they can handle it.
    Of the minuses. Over the past century, much has been lost and there will be excesses in the restoration, but this is not a reason not to let go and forbid, but to creatively solve the problems that arise, which, if correctly resolved, will only increase self-organization. A significant question of the West among the Cossacks on the topic of the Cossacks and the special people, this must be strictly suppressed by deprivation of the right to even be called a Cossack, all the goods issued and landings as separatists, all depending on the degree.
    1. 1976AG
      1976AG 13 March 2014 16: 59
      +2
      Again, I do not understand what the Cossacks? And the rest, who are NOT Cossacks, stupid and not capable of self-defense?
  • Vladycat
    Vladycat 13 March 2014 16: 26
    0
    As an example 165 Cossack regiment MP Pacific Fleet
    "In March 1994, a meeting of the KTOF Council took place, which discussed the relevant Order of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation and the directive of the General Staff. Resolution No. 11 was adopted, which determined specific measures for interaction with the Far Eastern Cossacks in the implementation of relevant state decisions. Similar Meetings of the Military Council of the Pacific Frontier District and the Management Board internal affairs of the regional administration were held in April 1995 and July 1994, respectively.
    One of the points of the Resolution of the Military Council of the CTOF was the decision to recruit a part of the marines with Cossacks. Since 1994, this unit has become the 165th KTOF Marine Regiment, which was given the name “Ussuriysk Cossack Marine Regiment”. One of the initiators contributing to such a solution of the issue by the Military Council of the CTOF was the regiment commander, hereditary Cossack, Lieutenant Colonel I.E. Starcheus. "Http://cossac-awards.narod.ru/UssuriKV_Story.html
    A subjective opinion about the Cossacks is slipping. The mummers are not an indicator of the Cossacks! Yes, and the conscripts remember what "demobels" are? And what will we start to judge about the rest of them? Not to be hay, but to raise the idea that every man could hold a house and a weapon, and not flaunt in a thong around the office :). The Cossacks are alive, the truth is more among the people and individual representatives. I came across the unique combat systems of Plastuns, Cossack Spas. Only here in our country this is equated with extremist knowledge and hayut in every possible way, not everywhere, of course.
    1. 1976AG
      1976AG 13 March 2014 17: 05
      +2
      RIGHT! So it’s not a matter of Cossacks? The matter is in the conscience of every citizen of our country!