Military Review

Defense-tested complex. Prosecutor General's Office acquainted the military and the Ministry of Industry and Trade with the devastating results of the audits in the defense industry

30



29.01.2014 leadership of the Prosecutor General, the Ministry of Defense and the Ministry of Industry and Trade held the first joint meeting of the board, which discussed the state of law in the military-industrial complex (DIC). The conclusions are disappointing: aviation and shipbuilders invest budgetary funds in commercial banks in order to extract their own benefit, the leaders of industry enterprises often are themselves the organizers of theft, and the Ministry of Industry and Trade has simply “withdrew itself” from monitoring the implementation of targeted programs.

According to the Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation, Yuri Chaika, who spoke yesterday at the board, as a result of the MIC checks, "numerous facts of the overpricing of contracts were revealed." In the United Aircraft Building Corporation (UAC) and the United Shipbuilding Corporation (USC), 48 initiated criminal cases involving embezzlement and deliberate bankruptcy of enterprises. "Another 43 material is at the stage of pre-investigation checks," he added.

In the background documents prepared by the departments for the meeting (available to Kommersant), it is said that according to the results of inspections in 2012-2013, prosecutors revealed about 7 thousand violations in the field of state defense order. The Federal Service for Defense Order in 2013 revealed violations for 35 billion rubles, of which 14 billion rubles were unauthorized use of funds. In the interests of the Ministry of Defense last year, 87 government contracts were not executed, advance payments for which were made by 80%. In addition, in the opinion of the auditors, the corporations have not fulfilled the statutory tasks of integrating organizations into a single complex, and strategic failures have led to "serious negative consequences."

Prosecutors found that the financial condition of USC organizations deteriorated: the money allocated by the state for their rehabilitation was not used, and the corporation actively placed them on deposit accounts of commercial banks. According to prosecutors, over three years more than 34 billion rubles have been placed, and 200 million rubles received as interest on them. spent on current activities and payment of bonuses. It was also noted that weak personnel work contributed to the participation in the theft of direct managers of enterprises. For example, in October 2013, the authorities of the Baltic Plant illegally transferred property to commercial structures for 23 million rubles. And in the Khabarovsk Territory, a criminal case was initiated into the theft of more than 300 million rubles. using the bill of exchange system - by creating an artificial debt of the Amur Shipbuilding Plant to companies registered in Cyprus.

In the part of the naval fleet as of December 2013, the amount of debt owed by order executors was more than 21 billion rubles: violations were identified, in particular, in the Far Eastern shipbuilding and repair center, the Baltic Yantar shipyard and the Zvezdochka ship repair center. The latter enterprise is also a defendant in the criminal case of embezzlement: instead of the proper equipment, one of the ships was used in the repair of counterfeit goods. "We will analyze the claims presented, and for those positions with which we will not agree, we are ready to give counterarguments," Kommersant told the USC yesterday, commenting on the devastating results of the audit.

According to prosecutors, things are no better at the KLA enterprises. The documents state that, despite the "unprecedented state support measures" in the amount of 70,5 billion rubles intended to restructure existing debts, their financial condition leaves much to be desired - the corporation's total debt for November 2013 of the year was over 260 billion rubles. The authorized capital of UAC due to a decrease in the value of assets of subsidiaries decreased by 30,7 billion rubles. Directed in the period from 2007 to 2012 year from the budget 50 billion rubles. for the implementation of projects for the construction of civil aircraft of domestic production were brought by the corporation to affiliated companies "on extremely unfavorable conditions": instead of donating to the authorized capital of companies, the money was provided to enterprises in the form of interest loans (sometimes up to 14,5% per annum). In addition to income from accrued interest, the corporation also received interest-free loans from its plants. In addition, the documents state that since 2007, the corporation has received about 4 billion rubles from its enterprises. dividends. While the societies themselves were forced to take commercial loans, the KLA was placed in 2011-2013 for more than 685 million rubles in order to earn income on deposits.

“Most of the comments relate to the initial period of the corporation’s activities in 2007-2010,” Alexander Tulyakov, UAC Executive Vice President, told Kommersant. “In 2011, many of the issues of interaction within the group were revised, the corporation abandoned a number of financial issues that were used before 2011. and management tools. " According to him, from the end of 2011 of the year, in accordance with the decisions of the management and the board of directors of the corporation, the practice of issuing interest-bearing loans to companies was discontinued: “in 2014-2015, it is planned to complete the procedure for paying additional shares of companies by offsetting monetary claims regarding payment of the principal amount of debt and accrued interest on previously concluded loan agreements. "

The prosecutors also stopped separately on the results of the inspection of the Ministry of Industry and Trade. According to the report of the Accounts Chamber, to which the supervisory authority refers, only half of all industrial enterprises are ready to carry out mobilization tasks for production. It is noted that the ministry lacks control over the targeted use of subsidies to prevent bankruptcy of enterprises: only 60% of organizations that received over 2009 billion rubles in 2013-14 have achieved financial recovery. "The Ministry has actually withdrawn itself from the fulfillment of customer duties for federal targeted programs, transferring these functions to subordinate enterprises and commercial organizations," the supervisory authority believes.

Prosecutors note that the tasks facing the Ministry of Industry and Trade are not being fulfilled. So, the indicators of the program "Development of civil aviation RF technicians for 2002-2010 and for the period until 2015 "in terms of sales in 2011-2012 were only 48% complete. For the first nine months of 2013, sales of final products amounted to only 24 billion rubles. Instead of the planned 144 billion rubles. None, according to the auditors, and monitoring the implementation of research and development work. "With the connivance of officials of the department, scientific developments of the past years are issued by manufacturers for new ones," the Prosecutor General’s office says. "And after that they report on the performance of the concluded agreements." The Ministry of Industry and Trade informally says that "they are ready to develop constructive solutions that will effectively solve the accumulated problems."
Author:
Originator:
http://www.kommersant.ru/doc/2395137
Photos used:
Gleb Schelkunov / Kommersant
30 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. jjj
    jjj 31 January 2014 07: 09
    +11
    The most offensive, the saddest thing is that it is not uncles who arrived to plunder the defense complex, but the people who developed in this complex who became known and did a lot before for the country. But a lot of money and temptations shot down the sights of many
    1. Pit
      Pit 31 January 2014 07: 17
      +16
      From here the conclusion: the complete nationalization of the military-industrial complex and all production associated with it. And tight control by government agencies.
      1. philip
        philip 31 January 2014 07: 30
        +2
        not you conclusions, just differently not possible
      2. Alexander Romanov
        Alexander Romanov 31 January 2014 07: 37
        +7
        Quote: Pit
        From here the conclusion: the complete nationalization of the military-industrial complex and all production associated with it.

        This will not solve the problem of theft. Our system itself is so slow that a person who has already been convicted can continue to manage the plant for years, and then calmly dump it abroad. For example, now in the article we are talking about billions of dollars, a lot of violations, fraud and hell knows what else, there is everything. There is only information about who has been held responsible. UD seems to be there, but it seems there are no guilty parties request
        Where is the landing ???
        1. SHOCK.
          SHOCK. 31 January 2014 08: 10
          +1
          . At us, the system itself is working so slowly that a person is already caught, can continue to manage the plant for years, and then calmly dump him abroad.

          I fully support. Punishment must be quick and inevitable, and this is the most important thing. It is necessary to return to the practice of "triplets" again.
          The decisions were made by the three in absentia - on the materials of the cases submitted by the NKVD bodies, and in some cases, in the absence of any materials - on the submitted lists of people arrested (for example, from Igarka to Krasnoyarsk, the lists for approval of the “troika” were submitted by telegraph). The proceedings were free; no protocols were kept. A characteristic feature of the cases considered by the “triples” was the minimum number of documents on the basis of which a decision was made on the use of repression. In a cardboard cover with typographic inscriptions “Top Secret. Keep forever ”is usually filed: a decision on arrest, a single protocol of search and arrest, one or two protocols of interrogation of the arrested person, an indictment. Next in the form of a tablet of three cells on a half-sheet is the solution of the “troika”. The decision of the “troika” was not subject to appeal, and, as a rule, the final document in the case was the act on the enforcement of the sentence.
        2. Veteran Vlad.
          Veteran Vlad. 31 January 2014 15: 36
          0
          Quote: Alexander Romanov
          Where is the landing ??

          What Damn nafig planting-they are certainly bitches of children, but they are Putin's bitches of children
      3. velikoros-xnumx
        velikoros-xnumx 31 January 2014 08: 22
        +4
        Quote: Pit
        From here the conclusion: the complete nationalization of the military-industrial complex

        Plus the complete nationalization of the extractive industry (at least for the extraction of strategic resources), plus the heavy engineering industry of the group "A" enterprise. The rest can be left in private hands.
        According to the Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation Yuri Chaika

        Who knows where Yuri Skuratov is now?
        1. Gamdlislyam
          Gamdlislyam 31 January 2014 11: 15
          +1
          Quote: velikoros-xnumx
          Plus the complete nationalization of the extractive industry (at least for the extraction of strategic resources), plus the heavy engineering industry of the group "A" enterprise. The rest can be left in private hands.

          But this is more than a reasonable offer! good

          Quote: velikoros-xnumx
          Who knows where Yuri Skuratov is now?

          Skuratov Yuri Ilyich Head of the Department of Constitutional and Administrative Law and Professor of the Russian State Social University. In addition, he heads the Legal Technologies of the 2011st Century Foundation. Since XNUMX, he has also been Chairman of the National Council of Self-regulatory Organizations of Arbitrators and Judges.
          In 2013, he became a member of the Organizing Committee for the preparation and conduct of commemorative events dedicated to the 20th anniversary of the shooting of the Congress of People's Deputies of Russia and the Supreme Council of the Russian Federation [14].
    2. Volkhov
      Volkhov 31 January 2014 07: 18
      -25%
      This phenomenon is completely positive - the more they steal in the production of weapons, the less they die from these weapons - theft is a less serious article than murder, especially mass.
      1. Lantau
        Lantau 31 January 2014 07: 26
        +4
        By your logic, if the army is plundered, this is a real blessing for everyone. And let's do better, in general we will cancel the army !!! Here comes the life wassat
        1. Alexander Romanov
          Alexander Romanov 31 January 2014 07: 31
          +8
          Quote: Lantau
          According to your logic

          There is no logic, there is some kind of nonsense laughing
          1. Volkhov
            Volkhov 31 January 2014 12: 56
            -2
            Quote: Alexander Romanov
            There is no logic, there is some kind of nonsense

            Well, if the weapons that Grachev handed over to Dudaev were stolen by Siberian ensigns, then there would be more life and it would be more correct ... but the ensigns had a conscience and this had to be disentangled.
            Weapons and politics in the Russian Federation are controlled by madmen and traitors, so it’s quite logical not to rush to equip the madhouse and the policemen.
        2. Volkhov
          Volkhov 31 January 2014 12: 48
          0
          Quote: Lantau
          we’ll do better, in general we will cancel the army !!!

          This is the way of Ukraine - in the process of army building, they once noticed that the army is in the western part (the former Carpathian region), has mountains of weapons (its own and exported from Hungary, Czechoslovakia and the GDR), Western contract soldiers and Bandera around ... and now the whole the world of Zionism is preoccupied with the abolition of the Ukrainian army - the EU offered to dispose of 2000 tanks, and Obama even ordered the double to read (like Putin earlier) and teaches Ukrainian language around the clock and sends Strong Nuts to help Berkut, which they decided to increase by 6 times ...
      2. Tersky
        Tersky 31 January 2014 07: 30
        +5
        Quote: Volkhov
        This phenomenon is completely positive - the more they steal in the production of weapons, the less they die from these weapons - theft is a less serious article than murder, especially mass.

        Well, well ... still look for such nonsense ..... The more "tweaks" pulled out of your pocket, the happier you will feel, the less money - the more guarantees that you will not starve to death ... Full paragraph ...wassat
        1. Volkhov
          Volkhov 31 January 2014 12: 59
          0
          Quote: Tersky
          The more "tweaks" you pull out of your pocket,

          And since when has my army pocket been - a security guard’s pocket to protect the oligarchs, and the less rounds there are, the calmer the others.
    3. Canep
      Canep 31 January 2014 07: 21
      +7
      The scale of theft is depressing, I think it is possible to stop this bacchanalia only by tough measures, it was stolen under the state. order - the owner, director, chief accountant - for government grub with the confiscation of property to cover damage, and if this money is not enough, then the confiscation of property of close relatives. 3-4 demonstration landings and those who want to steal folk money will be significantly less.
      1. jjj
        jjj 31 January 2014 07: 24
        +7
        Rogozin correctly said that corruption in the military-industrial complex should be equated with treason
        1. shaitan
          shaitan 31 January 2014 07: 30
          +1
          That's right, but in fact the abuse of authority and no less fat position :(
    4. major071
      major071 31 January 2014 07: 38
      +8
      Too large a share in the defense industry of private shops. And as they say, your pocket is closer to your body and the state will not become poor. Drive such people from the defense industry (plant with confiscation) and nationalize the complex. hi
      1. jjj
        jjj 31 January 2014 07: 43
        +3
        And in these "shops" more and more children and nephews are warming up
      2. demel2
        demel2 31 January 2014 07: 55
        +3
        You might think state shops are white and fluffy, our whole state is built on bribes and theft. IMHO
        1. SHOCK.
          SHOCK. 31 January 2014 08: 16
          +1
          Quote: demel2
          You might think state shops are white and fluffy, our whole state is built on bribes and theft. IMHO

          So in the good old days it was like? "Stole-drank-to jail, stole-drank-to jail", and now ... you know.
    5. ser 190
      ser 190 31 January 2014 14: 35
      0
      QUOTING "WE ARE NOT 37TH YEAR !!!!"
    6. alone
      alone 31 January 2014 23: 40
      0
      Quote: jjj
      The most offensive, the saddest thing is that it is not uncles who arrived to plunder the defense complex, but the people who developed in this complex who became known and did a lot before for the country. But a lot of money and temptations shot down the sights of many


      And what can they do? The temptation of impunity rises. If the director of the enterprise is punished with a fine of 30000 rubles for disrupting the state defense order, what do you want? In this situation, even I couldn’t resist, would have stolen everything, would have disrupted the order, would have paid the fine and that’s it! Famous people are people too, with their pros and cons!
  2. predator.3
    predator.3 31 January 2014 07: 15
    +5
    The chief military prosecutor made over 150 submissions to the former head of the defense department, Anatoly Serdyukov. But Mr. Chaika did not support these ideas. It turns out that the military prosecutor’s office of art Serdyukov saw, and the General turned a blind eye to them.

    http://warfiles.ru/show-47367-razvorovannaya-oboronka-o-hischeniyah-v-opk.html

    Yes, damn it closes its eyes, Comrade Seagull, our prosecutor's office is working in the regime of "not to do something superfluous!"
  3. ia-ai00
    ia-ai00 31 January 2014 07: 20
    +4
    You read, and for each paragraph of the article in your head, like a splinter, the thought revolves: without a hard hand, without modern Stalin, there is no way to restore order in the country!
  4. makarov
    makarov 31 January 2014 07: 35
    +1
    The material, in principle, can be identified with a couple of three phrases: - Brothers Craduts !!! Craduts !!!!
    The phrase V.S.V. : - I’m a hammer, so I will cross over any of mine !! So the brothers do not give me a hammer !!! Around the enemies!
  5. philip
    philip 31 January 2014 07: 40
    0
    I liked the article, but in the conditions of a tough information war, it’s unlikely that
  6. rodiy2007
    rodiy2007 31 January 2014 07: 45
    +2
    Previously, they complained that there was no money, orders. Now, money is being sent and orders, but as they say, another trouble. I agree with the authors of the comments that strict control in this area cannot be dispensed with. The theft or misappropriation of funds, the head and chief executives was revealed to account with real terms and redress to the state! And so it resembles pumping a thin chamber into the air.
  7. Nitarius
    Nitarius 31 January 2014 07: 46
    +3
    Quote: Pit
    From here the conclusion: the complete nationalization of the military-industrial complex and all production associated with it. And tight control by government agencies.

    Drag Together THEY and GOS.ORGANY and CUSTOMER!
    HOW IT WASN’T HAPPENING BUT THE PERFORMANCE AND CONFISSION - IN URGENT ORDER, IT IS NECESSARY TO RETURN!
  8. FID
    FID 31 January 2014 07: 47
    +4
    Good morning everybody! The KLA only thinks about super, talking about all other types of aircraft is equated with treason - from here (and the sale of each new super is unprofitable, you can read about the increase in losses of the GSS, which grow with the growth in sales of aircraft) it follows that only the GSS receives subsidies and loans, and all other plants, except VASO, which is loaded with GOZ, eke out a miserable existence. The prosecutor's office had to deal with the KLA for a long time.
    1. Normal
      Normal 31 January 2014 08: 37
      +1
      Quote: SSI
      Good morning everybody! The KLA only thinks about super, talking about all other types of aircraft equates to treason


      Hello and respect to the Specialist! Hello, Sergey.
      I haven’t met you on the site for a long time, rarely are you.

      Here we got a "specialist" in super (and in general in matters of civil and transport aircraft) with the nickname sledgehammer102
      Pay attention at your leisure. I would like to know your opinion about his argument.
      I do not have enough knowledge.
      1. FID
        FID 31 January 2014 09: 01
        +1
        Greetings, Vladimir! Yes, nowadays I rarely visit, business trips, business trips ... Specialists for super a dime a dozen, they do not understand one thing - the plane is successful when it is bought in the homeland, and not forced to take one or two pieces under the stick. According to the "specialists" of the a / c Yakutia is to tears satisfied with the operation of the two supers, but for some reason is not going to take them anymore. And where will the 10 cars taken from the AFL go to ... Many questions, many.
  9. SHOCK.
    SHOCK. 31 January 2014 07: 57
    +1
    According to the Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation, Yuri Chaika, who spoke yesterday at the board, as a result of the MIC checks, "numerous facts of the overpricing of contracts were revealed." In the United Aircraft Building Corporation (UAC) and the United Shipbuilding Corporation (USC), 48 initiated criminal cases involving embezzlement and deliberate bankruptcy of enterprises. "Another 43 material is at the stage of pre-investigation checks," he added.

    All this talking shop is bored. There are no real results (for example: the Stouretkin case). A person is weak, if you can steal, he will steal. Only the inevitability of punishment can stop. All the more so because morality in our time is absent. therefore, the thief is now in high esteem. But ... by and large, "Who are the judges?"
    Where, tell us, fatherland fathers, *
    Which ones should we take for samples?
    Are not these people robbery rich?
    Protection from court in friends found, in kinship,
    Magnificent building chambers,
    Where they are poured into feasting and drunkenness,
  10. VadimL
    VadimL 31 January 2014 08: 00
    +2
    Yeah. If our selectively short-sighted prosecutor's office dug up so much - then it's rubbish. If urgent measures are not taken, then corruption and "effective managers" will drive our country into the Stone Age .... or into a cemetery.
  11. vo.dum
    vo.dum 31 January 2014 08: 02
    +2
    An inspector is coming to us !!! It’s good that at least they see something ... But as Putin said ... where is the landing? And Zin ...? angry
    1. ZU-23
      ZU-23 31 January 2014 08: 42
      0
      For landing, you need tough unconditional criminal articles, not articles on which yesterday a law student will pull out the ass of any thief.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  12. Orakyl
    Orakyl 31 January 2014 08: 34
    +1
    The fish rotted from the head, this state of affairs has no effect on the defense industry of Serdyukov and Co., only it is possible to kill the industry in a year, and it will take decades to restore.
  13. Stinger
    Stinger 31 January 2014 08: 41
    +1
    Woke up! First, obscene laws will be written, and then they will look for those responsible. To begin with, the authors of 94 Federal Laws need to hide them by 10 years. With such a law on procurement for state needs, you don’t want to, they will do so with a swindler. And how do you like the provision that line ministries do not have the right to interfere in the economic activities of subordinate enterprises?
  14. ilya_oz
    ilya_oz 31 January 2014 10: 12
    +1
    And all you need to do is send a few dozen leaders for 20 years to places not so remote and to cover this whole country.
  15. kelevra
    kelevra 31 January 2014 18: 48
    0
    It would be nice if this revision will be the beginning of the conclusion to the clear water of all those involved in theft!