Military Review

The Gaidar Institute diagnoses the North Caucasus and issues recipes for “treatment”

107
Before the Olympics, more and more talk in the media and various public organizations and foundations is devoted to the possible development of the situation in the North Caucasus after the Winter Games. Most professional experts and, say, amateur experts agree that major changes can be expected in the region. At the same time, some are confident that the changes will go exclusively from the top down, that is, the federal government will begin, as they say, tighten the screws and ask for each allocated ruble, while others believe that the changes can go in a different direction - either in the form of rapid growth of social tension associated with the economic turmoil and oddities of the political organization of the subjects of the federation of the North Caucasus Federal District, or in the form of universal fraternization within the framework of a single state and regional concept.


The Gaidar Institute diagnoses the North Caucasus and issues recipes for “treatment”


A large-scale study of the current situation in the regions of the North Caucasus and the designation of ways for the further development of the region are published by the Gaidar Institute for Economic Policy (hereinafter the Gaidar Institute). 14 January 2014 of the year Institute staff Konstantin Kazenin and Irina Starodubrovskaya published a detailed report, the name of which looks like “The North Caucasus: Quo vadis?”, Which you can fully read on the website "Polit.ru". The report was presented to the members of the notorious Committee of Civil Initiatives, headed by the well-known Aleksey Kudrin.

The authors of the report, as follows from the preface, tried to carry out work for those people who do not study Caucasian problems specifically, but they really want to understand it. And since the report was presented to the OIG, then, apparently, the first person who wants to understand the North Caucasian issues so much, without plunging into it, is Mr. Kudrin, or the ex-Minister of Finance together with his entire committee in this case acted as an audience. , on which the staff of the institute Gaidar simply "run in" the report.

So, the first thing that Mr. Kazenin and Mrs. Starodubrovskaya focus on is the question of the maturing of the Caucasian crisis. The authors emphasize that there are crisis prerequisites (to be honest, it would be strange if the staff of the Gaidar Institute did not reveal such prerequisites in the North Caucasus Federal District) and note that they are mainly connected with a high percentage of federal subsidies (three times the budget investments exceeded the national average) , with increasing conflict in terms of the distribution of funds allocated from the federal budget, is already at the level of the North Caucasus regions themselves, with a poor investment climate in the region, poorly functioning “vertical lifts” "The lack of coordination among the different regional management structures.

The second is the enumeration and disclosure of the essence of individual components of the North Caucasus crisis: the crisis of “modernization from above,” the land crisis, the crisis of policies regarding elites, the crisis of anti-terrorism activities, the crisis of confessional politics, the image crisis.

As they say, the diagnosis is made. The diagnosis, it should be noted, is quite accurate, but this diagnosis is, by and large, well known to both the “patient” himself and all those around him (that is, all the other regions of the country). Everyone is well aware that social tensions are a result of economic insecurity (low incomes of the population, high unemployment), the existence of a clan system of leadership of individual territories, large amounts of corruption among regional officials. Everyone understands that the large-scale subsidies to the region cannot be infinite, especially since such subsidies do not lead to real positive results in the North Caucasus Federal District. Everyone understands that radical organizations are ready to take advantage of economic problems that can stop at nothing, which ultimately strikes both the image of the region as a whole and the image of the peoples of this multinational and multi-confessional region.

However, to know the "diagnosis" and understand what methods of "treatment" to use in this case, up to the complete recovery of the "patient" are two different things. Today, all those who are not lazy are engaged in diagnostics today, but who will suggest truly productive methods of overcoming the imminent crisis?

If we turn to the same report by employees of the Gaidar Institute, then the North Caucasus is suggested to use the quotation: “activity from below” as a way out of the crisis. Such use, according to the authors of the report, should be based on the support of local initiatives, on the creation of conditions for the development of modernization centers within the informal economy, on dialogue with civil society (and the report’s authors believe that civil society is very active in the North Caucasus region) tradeoffs between different stakeholders.
In this regard, the speakers draw the most favorable scenario for the development of the NCFD, called the scenario of civil reconciliation, when the government is elected solely on the basis of direct elections, when civil society regulates the socio-political processes in the region, when even force actions get under civilian control, when militants are adapted to peaceful life, and when North Caucasian youth get access to social elevators.

Well, the findings in the report are certainly benign. They even resemble something similar to the outlined sermon of a priest. That is, everything is approximately at the next level: in order to live in Russia (particularly in the North Caucasus), life has become wonderful, you need to stop everyone drinking, smoking, using foul language, starting to plant trees and corrupt officials, then sow the fields, turn in weapon (if there is), everyone to embrace, kiss and give each other a bouquet of violets ... Well, if at a medical level, then something like this: a patient has a sore heart, a sick liver, sore lungs, sore blood vessels, kidneys and joints, which means to cure it, you need to transplant the heart, liver, lungs, joints, blood vessels and kidneys ...

But who exactly and how will change the “organs”, who will give violets and show initiative about universal fraternization and mass kisses? .. If the federal center continues to do this, then the North Caucasus is unlikely to leave the situation it is in today. If someone believes that the elected leaders of the subjects of the North Caucasus Federal District will do this “honestly and plainly”, then several questions arise at once: first, who will control the “fairness and transparency” of the elections, secondly, how “honest and simple” »The elected official in general will be ready to transfer the power to another person in the next elections just as honestly and transparently. Obviously, for the current North Caucasus, the very phrase “transparent elections” is more like an oxymoron, as it is also obvious that almost any “lawfully elected” will try to stay in power for as long as possible without disdaining to use the dirtiest technologies.

Words of compromise between stakeholders look no less naive. After all, the interested parties here are not only the authorities and the people, but also radical (including external) forces whose task is to do everything so that the people and authorities speak different languages, so that the region is mired in violence, economic and political squabbles. And is a compromise possible at all, if a corrupt official will act a priori as one of the parties to the dialogue? In this case, a compromise is possible only at the level: gild a pen and do what you want. But if so, then almost the entire North Caucasus today lives on the platform of such a compromise ...

It turns out that the scenario described by the staff of the Gaidar Institute is a real utopia that has nothing to do with the objective North Caucasian reality. Today it is extremely naive to talk about some mature civil society in the same Dagestan or Ingushetia, as it is naive to believe that representatives of such regional “civil society” can change the situation themselves, “from below”. Moreover, such an idea, in the end, can only exacerbate the existing crisis, because radical forces, fueled, including from abroad, can take these liberal theses as a bait for the peoples of the North Caucasus - they say, inside Russia will not allow to realize the scenario of "civil reconciliation", which means - go ahead! - without Russia, against Russia! And this, Russia and the North Caucasus region itself, have already passed - the work on the mistakes has not been completed to the end today.
Author:
107 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. A.YARY
    A.YARY 16 January 2014 08: 42
    +50
    The diagnosis from the "Beria Institute of Pathology" to the Institute of Traitors to the Motherland is a lowered level of metal in the blood.
    Recipe; Invasion through the forehead 1 time per day,
    dose is 9 grams.
    1. Angry reader
      Angry reader 16 January 2014 09: 11
      +18
      Sorry, I brought a delegation of builders of democracy here, you can also have a few ...)))
      1. A.YARY
        A.YARY 16 January 2014 09: 16
        +9
        Dmitriy
        OK alive( bully ) queues .....
        1. Angry reader
          Angry reader 16 January 2014 09: 20
          +6
          Sorry ... they are not local. And can they take 2-3 doses at a time, so that they probably fall sick? The builders are no matter how)))
          1. sledgehammer102
            sledgehammer102 16 January 2014 09: 35
            +20
            When the Gaidar Institute releases some creations on the subject "How to build a state" it becomes terribly similar to the situation when Nemtsov and Co. began to write on the topic "How to fight corruption"
            1. Angry reader
              Angry reader 16 January 2014 09: 39
              +6
              Bees vs. Honey or Skunk Flavor laughing
            2. ele1285
              ele1285 16 January 2014 09: 58
              +2
              Quote: sledgehammer102
              When the Gaidar Institute releases some creations on the subject "How to build a state" it becomes terribly similar to the situation when Nemtsov and Co. began to write on the topic "How to fight corruption"

              No, bl ... this is Sharikov, Polygraff Polygraphych, Yeah .... bki, the Heydar Institute, where is it?
              Give money to Alexander Romanov and I think that the institute will be much better. Maybe the only one who will not cut it.
              1. Alexander Petrovich
                Alexander Petrovich 16 January 2014 17: 07
                +1
                Yes, he already lights them with them, no offense Alexander Batkovich hi
            3. Ascetic
              Ascetic 16 January 2014 12: 49
              +11
              Quote: sledgehammer102
              When the Gaidar Institute releases some work on the topic "How to build a state" it becomes eerily similar to the situation when Nemtsov and Co. began to write on the topic "How to fight corruption"



              “The circle of these revolutionaries is narrow. They are terribly far from the people. But their cause was not lost. The oligarchs woke Gaidar. Gaidar woke Kudrin and he began revolutionary liberal agitation. "
              1. vezunchik
                vezunchik 16 January 2014 16: 51
                +2
                And now Khodorkovsky joined them. a guy rushing from Germany to Switzerland and back ... The traitor’s bread is heavy ...
              2. The comment was deleted.
            4. APASUS
              APASUS 16 January 2014 22: 18
              +1
              Quote: sledgehammer102
              When the Gaidar Institute releases some work on the topic "How to build a state" it becomes eerily similar to the situation when Nemtsov and Co. began to write on the topic "How to fight corruption"

              For me, the very name of the institute is NONSENS!
          2. lapo32
            lapo32 16 January 2014 10: 15
            +4
            You can’t save everyone, reusable rope with soap is safer and cheaper smile
        2. vladimirZ
          vladimirZ 16 January 2014 13: 11
          +6
          When you hear that "proposals" and "development scenarios" have been received from the "Gaidar Institute", you immediately understand that the pro-Western 5th column of traitors, again offers something harmful for Russia and working for the destruction of Russia, for the glory and victory of their beloved West.
          Drive them, drive them with all the "Gaidar Institute" to hell and with all their proposals and scenarios !!!
      2. 225chay
        225chay 16 January 2014 10: 21
        +6
        Quote: Angry Reader
        Angry Reader Today, 09:11 ↑
        Sorry, I brought a delegation of builders of democracy here, you can also have a few ...)))


        Gaidars fulfill the will of their superiors from overseas who are just engaged in inciting hatred among peoples ..
        1. Angry reader
          Angry reader 16 January 2014 10: 33
          +3
          There will always be someone overseas. Only the fewer "writers' grandchildren" they find among us in the future, the better.
          That is why they should not be forgotten.
    2. Civil
      Civil 16 January 2014 09: 33
      +8
      Gaidar, Chubais, Krasnov, Shkuro, Vlasov ... all one are traitors to Russia.
      1. AVV
        AVV 16 January 2014 13: 04
        0
        One company, and all that is good for Russia, seems deadly for the West !!!
        1. invisibility
          invisibility 16 January 2014 19: 55
          +1
          I barely read from disgust. One thought - on the count.
          No, no, changed my mind !! Let them live their whole lives on average Russian salary ...
          Or on the count, though ..
          1. invisibility
            invisibility 16 January 2014 20: 01
            +1
            I wanted to have dinner, I remembered the face of the Gaidar, my appetite was gone. I am not kidding...
            1. alone
              alone 16 January 2014 21: 32
              +2
              belay Gaidar Institute. For what such merit. For the collapse of the country's economy?))
            2. 225chay
              225chay 17 January 2014 06: 10
              +1
              Quote: invisible
              I wanted to have dinner, I remembered the face of the Gaidar, my appetite was gone. I am not kidding...


              And if I face EBN here show close up general vomiting, I think it will begin ...
              1. CALL.
                CALL. 17 January 2014 08: 07
                0
                Doctor: Do you know that you have pubic lice?
                Patient: I know.
                Doctor: What are you treating them with?
                Patient: Nothing, they don’t get sick from me.
  2. Valery Neonov
    Valery Neonov 16 January 2014 08: 49
    +19
    Gaidar forum is just a bunch FROM RUSSIA(some co.oz.ls.), and "Activity from below." will soon follow in lack of activity of the RF Government.
    1. Colonel
      Colonel 16 January 2014 09: 36
      +16
      Quote: Valery Neonov
      Gaidar Forum ...

      Yesterday I had the imprudence to watch the channel "Russia 24", when they told about this very forum, well, they showed a story about it. Listening to crap about "stagnation amid inflation" and "falling GDP growth due to a decrease in investment" is bad for health, and I let it go deaf ear (I dined because), but when I saw the faces of those who were sitting in the hall and on the podium , I was really scared. These are the ones who ruined the Union and continue to drink the blood of Russia and they are "on horseback". Gaidar, damn it, Timurovites. And those like them, who rocked the Caucasus, mold pharisaic councils for "civil reconciliation" and, on the sly, rub their hands and count the amount of spioneer dough. The question is - who let them go there ???
      1. Ascetic
        Ascetic 16 January 2014 13: 08
        +10
        Quote: colonel
        The question is - who let them go there ???


        We created the Gaidar Foundation, I am the chairman of the board. This is an important social story: right now it’s worth remembering and continuing everything that Gaidar did. fund organizing committeewhich is going to by the same principle as the Snob project.We gather people who are truly interested in developing a civic discussion whose goal is to stimulate the development of mankind.(!!!)
        We are forming a platform where economic, social and other humanitarian issues will be discussed, under the name of Gaidar, because, in my opinion, Egor Timurovich was not just an economist
        Those who believe that Gaidar was wrong are fundamentally wrong. His only “mistake” is that he thought about the development of society, and not about the next election. sad In this sense, he suffered the fate of all the reformers in our country: Speransky, Alexander II and others - the people did not accept them. That is why it is so important for us to engage in social activities under his name.
        link
        Boris Mintz is a billionaire. Chairman of the Executive Committee of the Union of Right Forces Party (2000-2001), President of the Otkritie Financial Corporation, the main beneficiary of the O1 Properties investment company. Member of the Board of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs. Born in Moldova in the family of a military engineer, Major Joseph Samuilovich Mints (born 1932, Nevel). [1] Mother, Lusia Izrailevna Milter (born 1936, Kodyma of the Moldavian Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic), worked as a librarian; as a child in 1941-1944 she was deported to the Chechelnitsky ghetto in Transnistria, where 14 family members died. Both grandfathers - Samuel I. Mintz (1892-1942) and Srul Gershkovich Milter (1901-1944) - died at the front
        And now the granddaughters are successfully trying to finish off the Motherland for which their grandfathers died ... That is why Yegorushka Judushka Gaidar is close to him. In general, Mints is considered one of Chubais' "wallets", and Chubais is known to be one of the prominent representatives of the interests of Jewish financial capital in Russia
        History of Chubais purses of Mints and Belyaev
        1. Colonel
          Colonel 16 January 2014 14: 07
          +2
          Hello. And, for some reason, I'm not very surprised
          1. Ascetic
            Ascetic 16 January 2014 17: 20
            +5
            Quote: colonel
            Hello. And, for some reason, I'm not very surprised


            And what’s interesting, Valery. While we were valiantly squandering without pay in the Ivanovo forests in the Guards Missile Division, this Mints was at that time the chairman of the KUGI of Ivanovo in 1993. That is, he was engaged in the privatization and distribution of state property and was a direct subordinate of Chubais who was engaged in this at the federal level.
            It was Chubais, who appreciated the privatization successes of Mints in Ivanovo, and suggested that he continue his career in Moscow.

            In 1993, voucher privatization was ending, and Chubais asked Mintz, as head of the Association of Chairmen of Regional State Property Management Committees, to prepare a report and address the Supreme Council. The report was critical, but Chubais liked it, then Mintz participated in the commission's work to complete the privatization. And in the end, Chubais called him to the post of his deputy in the State Property Committee.
            1. Colonel
              Colonel 16 January 2014 17: 52
              +2
              Already not on the go-ahead of this ped ...., to blame, the official disconnected our KP from the power transmission line. The security company said that when they kicked the electricians out of the substation (halfway to Kuprit), they (electricians) banged something about the fact that they would punish everyone from Ivanov !!!
              1. Ascetic
                Ascetic 16 January 2014 18: 02
                +3
                Quote: colonel
                Already not on the go-ahead of this ped ...., to blame, the official disconnected our KP from the power transmission line.

                Surely he could not do without people like him ... We remember the same bespectacled activists blocked the road to Bunkovo ​​(on the Yaroslavl Highway) with an armored personnel carrier slightly ... and even our wooden engineer with a BAT was drawn just in time smile also threatened with some sort of higher authorities.
                1. Colonel
                  Colonel 16 January 2014 22: 28
                  +1
                  Quote: Ascetic
                  engineer with BAT
                  You were cruel! Persuade should be exclusively butts. Very intelligible. soldier
                  1. Ascetic
                    Ascetic 16 January 2014 22: 38
                    +4
                    Quote: colonel
                    You were cruel! Persuade should be exclusively butts. Very intelligible.


                    At that time, we just had the AKS74U 5,45 (then they were removed and the AK-74M came) and you won’t wave them with rifle butts. I remember getting sick of shooting them, which idiot had the idea ...
                    1. Colonel
                      Colonel 16 January 2014 22: 56
                      +1
                      Gee, gee, gee. I remember this garbage. At that time, in Bogatyrev’s position, they attacked the PBO and one barrel disappeared. I then had, as the chief of communications of the regiment, in the light of the presence - the absence of communication at the post. Damn, it was interesting. And then rearmed for normal AK-74. The enemy did not notice.
                      1. Ascetic
                        Ascetic 16 January 2014 23: 35
                        +1
                        Quote: colonel
                        At that time, in Bogatyrev’s position, they attacked the PBO and one barrel disappeared.

                        I heard such a story. Only in the order, if the memory doesn’t fail, it was said about two trunks, just the post of the security guard ... It was supposed that one soldier was in the MOS and the other was outside and they had a TA-57 connection, we sometimes gave r / st from the TCO kit Kill Vitim, I don’t remember what they were called, although they didn’t actually enter Vitim but were listed as guards
                      2. Colonel
                        Colonel 17 January 2014 09: 03
                        +1
                        No, the trunk was one and rumored to have surfaced somewhere in the Caucasus before the first Chechen one. And the stations were R-148 from the MOBD set.
                      3. Ascetic
                        Ascetic 17 January 2014 10: 13
                        +1
                        Quote: colonel
                        And the stations were R-148 from the MOBD set.


                        Yes, for sure, Kid, the Kid was on the MOBD pump and the radio station too ... We also got the PNV-57et kit stolen from the MOBD in the Caucasus surfaced. Now this kit is freely sold for 15 thousand rubles. (I saw an advertisement in the internet)
    2. aksakal
      aksakal 16 January 2014 15: 49
      +1
      Quote: Ascetic
      In this sense, he suffered the fate of all the reformers in our country: Speransky, Alexander II and others - the people did not accept them. That is why it is so important for us to engage in social activities under his name.

      - Greetings, Ascetic! As always, you have the most inveterate and at the same time the most reasoned post. I really liked this Mintz quote! How did he forcibly make happy the Russian and, in general, the Russian people gathered laughing laughing Say, the people don't want to? Ah well? well then we ... and further in the text. The classic with his "good intentions, for which the road to hell is paved", involuntarily comes to mind. The recipe from Yary is just perfect for such benefactors !:
      Quote: A.YARY
      Recipe; Invasion through the forehead 1 time per day, the dose is 9 grams.
      . Just perfect!
      1. Ascetic
        Ascetic 16 January 2014 16: 22
        +2
        Quote: aksakal
        ! How did he forcibly make happy the Russian and, in general, the Russian people gathered


        Take it higher
        Quote: Ascetic
        .We gather people who are truly interested in developing a civic discussion whose goal is to stimulate the development of mankind.


        Involuntarily you will believe in the world network government consisting of similar swindlers-speculators of privatizers. Like Chase -The whole world in your pocket
    3. matross
      matross 16 January 2014 16: 05
      +4
      Quote: Ascetic
      We have created the Gaidar Foundation

      It’s interesting, and when Chubais dies, some bastards will also create a fund named after him? am
  • Alexander Romanov
    Alexander Romanov 16 January 2014 08: 57
    +20
    Perhaps it’s time to delete this name from the history of Russia, or at least put it on the same list as Vlasov.
    1. Alex_Popovson
      Alex_Popovson 16 January 2014 09: 21
      +8
      Do not cross out from history - otherwise the people will then lead to some other kind of Gaidar
    2. Angry reader
      Angry reader 16 January 2014 09: 23
      +6
      No no. Don't cross it out. It is necessary to remember about such, so that the new "writers' grandchildren" would not stir up such a thing.
      1. Alexander Romanov
        Alexander Romanov 16 January 2014 09: 26
        +5
        Quote: Alex_Popovson
        Do not cross out

        Quote: Angry Reader
        No no. Cross out is not worth it.

        Okay, then add it to the emergency and put the stamp "Dangerous for society"
        1. Alex_Popovson
          Alex_Popovson 16 January 2014 09: 31
          +1
          Okay, then add it to the emergency and put the stamp "Dangerous for society"

          That's right
        2. 225chay
          225chay 16 January 2014 10: 05
          +3
          Quote: Alexander Romanov
          Okay, then add it to the emergency and put the stamp "Dangerous for society"


          ESPECIALLY DANGEROUS BREED FOR RUSSIA these Gaidars
    3. T80UM1
      T80UM1 16 January 2014 12: 53
      +2
      His great-grandfather wrote good stories, and at 41 died at the front, but the family is not without a freak ...
      1. Volodin
        16 January 2014 12: 57
        +7
        You wanted to say: grandfather (Arkady Gaidar).
  • Standard Oil
    Standard Oil 16 January 2014 08: 57
    +12
    "Gaidar Institute"? And it turns out that there is. No, there is still something in the concept of "Russian sadomasochism", but do we accidentally have an institute or academy named after Adolf Hitler?
  • Riperbahn
    Riperbahn 16 January 2014 08: 57
    +5
    Really nonsense. How many wolves do not feed ...
  • calocha
    calocha 16 January 2014 08: 58
    +6
    US "lions" give recipes for well-being.))
  • the polar
    the polar 16 January 2014 09: 03
    +11
    The review of the report of the Gaidar Institute is good. And of course, there is no "mature civil society" in the Caucasus, but there are radical Islamic groups, all-destroying corruption and the power of clans, and therefore "recipes for Gaidar's cuisine" are absolutely unacceptable. But the author of the review saying "A" does not say "B", but what exactly needs to be done in order to radically and irrevocably correct the situation, because it has been launched in such a way that a social and political catastrophe in the region is inevitable. It was this continuation of the article that could become the subject of discussion. And so, the statement of the fact that the liberals want to make a mess in the Caucasus once again is hardly surprising in itself.
    1. Moon bird
      Moon bird 16 January 2014 19: 01
      0
      if you mind, I’ll adjust a little
      - civil society in the Caucasus is still there, but on a scale not larger than the average in the province. Another thing, what is the use of this society? if we take the largest and most problematic region - Dagestan, under the previous head of the region, Magomedov mobilized this very resource as much as possible - an amnesty and adaptation commission, active work with the media, creating an investment program, etc. The results were, but a radical change did not work.
      - Clan power is relevant only for the Czech Republic, partly Ingushetia. in other subjects, in fact, there are simply no formalized family clans. there is nepotism, kinship, nepotism, fraternity, national patronage, and so on. but these are not clans. so there is enough of such good everywhere, including in both ruling parties of the USA
      - the following fundamentally wrong proposal - radicalism is being fed by poverty and a low level of education. strangely enough, a huge number of radicals from very wealthy families, and the leaders are all people with real HE and even advanced degrees, some defended them at the Higher Attestation Commission in Moscow. By the way, Osama bin Laden himself is the son of a billionaire, a poor man in general and in general.
      - the reasons for which there was, is and will be tension and a bunch of problems - hucha tueva. It is impossible to solve them all once and for all, and even more so in the shortest possible time. too old history, too important geopolitically region, too multi-ethnic and multi-confessional. Therefore, it is advisable to switch from the mode of solving problems "as they come" to the mode of "preventive prevention" of those "whose case is the worst."
      - today the main problem is foreign influence, active work of intelligence and terrorist communities with the local population, especially the brainwashing of young people, and forest bandits and suicide bombers and hooligan Lezginka dancers on the streets of Russian cities, and booted receters and Syrian volunteers - all this from one a bottle, who has enough foolishness for that. unfortunately intelligence and counterintelligence works "in fact".
      1. CALL.
        CALL. 17 January 2014 09: 25
        0
        Quote: Moonbird
        radicalism is fueled by poverty and a low level of education.

        It means. - Ordinary fighters, of which there are many countries in the Middle East. Those who fought in Syria.
  • REDBLUE
    REDBLUE 16 January 2014 09: 07
    +14
    I don’t understand where the anti-Russian Gaidar Institute came from in Russia. Which plundered and ruined the country. Sold everything for a song. And we still have to listen to his opinion.
    1. koshaus
      koshaus 16 January 2014 09: 22
      +13
      Still simple. Did Putin put someone for crimes against Russia, such as Chubais, Serdyukov, or someone else. No, he protects them. And with what fright he will disperse anti-Russian institutions if all of his (Putin's) activities are essentially anti-Russian ....
      1. Alexander Romanov
        Alexander Romanov 16 January 2014 09: 28
        0
        Quote: koshaus
        if all of his (Putin's) activities are essentially anti-Russian ....

        Well, of course, anti-Russian, he carries out orders of the shadow government wink And add here that rearmament is an anti-Russian project laughing
        1. fartfraer
          fartfraer 16 January 2014 10: 03
          +2
          the mass of reforms under the current president is anti-Russian; rearmament here is rare good news.
          As for the Gaidar Institute and the coverage of its activities by the state media, this is also a "significant" contribution to the education of patriotism. I hope it is clear why the word "weighty" is in quotation marks?
          1. Moon bird
            Moon bird 16 January 2014 19: 10
            -2
            look at the very root. it was he who specially pressed all the NCOs to his fingernail and warmed Snowden so that the Gaidar Institute had the whole country on a silver platter!
            No, to take everything, YES AND SHARE!
        2. geptilshik
          geptilshik 16 January 2014 10: 59
          +2
          On the one hand, Putin is rearming, on the other hand, he is robbing, some nonsense request
        3. optimist
          optimist 16 January 2014 11: 18
          +12
          Quote: Alexander Romanov
          And add here that rearmament is an anti-Russian project

          Do you really think that the Vovan is concerned about your safety? He just remembers what happened to Milosevic, Hussein and Gaddafi. So he is more worried about the safety of his glasses and Caudlers .. And if about this article ... Your “idol” will lick the Adam’s point until the last, until the “3rd Chechen” flames. After that, I'm afraid, you and I will have to defend your loved ones yourself, because the army and cops will guard the Kremlin at this time ...
          1. aksakal
            aksakal 16 January 2014 15: 57
            -3
            Quote: koshaus
            And with what fright he will disperse anti-Russian institutions if all of his (Putin's) activities are essentially anti-Russian ....

            Quote: geptilshik
            On the one hand, Putin is rearming, on the other hand, he is robbing, some nonsense

            Quote: optimist
            Do you think the Wowan is concerned about your safety? He just remembers what happened to Milosevic, Hussein and Gaddafi. So he is more worried about the safety of his glasses and Caudlers .. And if about this article ... Your “idol” will lick the Adam’s point until the last, until the “3rd Chechen” flames. After which, I'm afraid, you and I will have to protect your loved ones yourself, because the army and cops will guard the Kremlin at this time

            - Wow, how many Russophobes have come! Let me remind you that Putin was chosen by the Russian people quite legitimately in the elections in 2012, and no matter how much you would like to fulfill McCain's dream of "taking Vlad to hell," I will answer you one thing: "But H. .. you !!! " am Clear. And now, home and fast, more than three liberals are forbidden to gather! Is that clear to you? RUN !!!!
            1. optimist
              optimist 16 January 2014 16: 33
              +4
              Quote: aksakal
              I remind you that Putin was chosen by the Russian people absolutely legitimately in the elections in 2012,

              Just in case, I remind you that the same Russian people chose ebna in 96. As they said then: "Vote with your heart!" That's right, there are no more brains left! laughing Apparently, the bulk of the rasiyans since then have not increased ...
            2. fartfraer
              fartfraer 16 January 2014 17: 43
              +4
              they chose it, aksakal. and I myself voted for him in 2000 when I believed in better than with ebony. but none of those promises were fulfilled. at least of those that I remembered. and I personally got tired when the authorities hold me for an idiot who doesn’t remember what yes how. and about your rudeness, I myself come from KZ (judging by the flag you are from there), and to the credit of the Kazakhs, I can say, there are very few such people as you are there.
              1. Moon bird
                Moon bird 16 January 2014 19: 17
                -4
                born in Kazakhstan, did not like it there
                moved to us in Russia, again do not like
                what is the little things, can you change the planet?
            3. CALL.
              CALL. 17 January 2014 09: 59
              0
              Quote: aksakal
              Wow, how many Russophobes came running! I remind you that Putin was chosen by the Russian people

              People did not choose Putin. He was chosen by the wizard Churov. Still at the registration stage, removing several candidates. But they slipped us a choice of several puppets. When the people saw at the head of the opposition Nemtsov, Kasyanov, Kudrin and other little dogs, he said, let it be better that E-N-T-O-T remains. Brilliant operation.
              On December 5, 2011, when people were indignant at the impudence of election fraud, he went out onto the rostrum on the list and guarded the approaches to the rostrum of the FSO (Federal Security Service), Ivan Mironov spoke about this.
          2. Moon bird
            Moon bird 16 January 2014 19: 14
            -3
            Vova, Adolescent, lick a point, Caudle .....
            Oh no no no
          3. Stanislas
            Stanislas 16 January 2014 21: 54
            -2
            Quote: optimist
            He just remembers what happened to Milosevic, Hussein and Gaddafi.
            All three tried to contrast the interests of their countries with the West?
      2. Moon bird
        Moon bird 16 January 2014 19: 07
        -2
        Putin personally sold Alaska to the USA, overthrew and shot Nicholas 2, signed the Bialowieza Accords, introduced sharia and same-sex marriage instead of the Constitution, and destroyed the chapel.
        but, no, the chapel before it was destroyed in the 14th century.
    2. CALL.
      CALL. 17 January 2014 09: 28
      0
      Quote: REDBLUE
      I don’t understand where the anti-Russian Gaidar Institute came from in Russia.

      For a long time, you have to clean the Augean stables.
  • Altona
    Altona 16 January 2014 09: 08
    +13
    Such recipes have already passed in 1992-1996 for the Caucasus ... And with a "civil" society and with "direct, fair" elections and with activity "from below" ... We know how this ended ... the same therapy is prescribed ...
  • makarov
    makarov 16 January 2014 09: 09
    +3
    "A large-scale study of the current situation in the regions of the North Caucasus and the designation of ways for the further development of the region is published by the Yegor Gaidar Institute for Economic Policy .."

    I look and read a lot of patriots' comments on the site, and is there really no hero who can stop the activities of the traitor institution ?? Is there really not enough money for syrnyks or a catch? lol
    1. not good
      not good 16 January 2014 14: 54
      +1
      It is necessary to send "our" Gaidar specialists far away to exchange experience, well, for example, to SySHYA, or better to Africa, let them train there first, but if they are eaten there, they can be declared fighters for justice with the installation of a monument in their homeland ... a crocodile ...
      1. CALL.
        CALL. 17 January 2014 10: 20
        0
        Quote: Negoro
        It is necessary to send "our" Gaidar specialists to the exchange of experience far away, well, for example, to SyShchyA,

        So they were there, with rare exceptions, trained. Who studied, who went on an internship or exchange of experience. So, is it clear from whose nest these chicks are?
    2. Moon bird
      Moon bird 16 January 2014 19: 37
      0
      it is silly of course to answer on the principle of "myself", but could not resist. here you have a zhovtoblakytny flag, why won't you go to the sirnykams at once to the Maidan? ))
      in decent countries, the opposition does not wreck in the central squares of the capital for months, but leads an intellectual discussion, exerting a corrective influence on the course of development of the state and society.
      tsarist general Brusilov, sided with the Bolsheviks, and with paint Vlasov went to the Nazis, well, who is the enemy?
      a lone barefoot hero in a T-shirt and with a pistol saving the planet, this is a movie. and 100% enemy
  • demotivator
    demotivator 16 January 2014 09: 13
    +9
    .... the script written by the Gaidar Institute staff is a real utopia that has nothing to do with the objective North Caucasian reality.

    And that this Gaidar and his last were not a utopia? These are people who know the country in which they live, the people who feed them. We have not forgotten Gaidar's reforms and his "shock therapy", which only led to massive impoverishment of people and unheard-of enrichment for a handful of impudent crooks. It is known that when the cretin was thrown out of the prime ministers as unnecessary, Gaidar took up the only thing that turned out to be in his mind - he was drunk without restraint, but this in Russia is not a reason to overestimate even now, even after years, even a person, and not only Gaidar ... And here it is - the institute named after him "diagnoses" and issues "recommendations". Here it is just right to remember the gospel advice: "To the doctor - heal yourself." And on recovery, give advice to others.
  • os9165
    os9165 16 January 2014 09: 19
    +20
    Lived moral ur ..... Institute Gaidar still teach us life. In villages - let them bring at least some benefit will bring grazing sheep. Textbook in hand and go.
    1. 225chay
      225chay 16 January 2014 10: 25
      +4
      Quote: os9165
      In villages - let them bring at least some benefit will bring grazing sheep. Textbook in hand and go.

      Gaidarites handbook?
      There is no kilo in the teeth and in the mines ...
  • major071
    major071 16 January 2014 09: 20
    +8
    Gaidar Institute, 5th Jubilee Gaidar Forum, as these "economists" from Gaidar with their advice zadolbali. First, the entire economy of Russia was ditched, now they want to pull us out of the hole by the same methods. Madhouse for a walk.
  • Mace
    Mace 16 January 2014 09: 24
    0
    The mongrel bark at the forum (Gaidar), and Putin will simply make the right decisions. We are getting closer and closer to the beginning of changes, but this time to changes to please Russia and its population.
    1. fartfraer
      fartfraer 16 January 2014 10: 05
      +4
      14 years are getting closer and closer ... when exactly will we start, do not tell me? Otherwise, according to the promises of the GDP and the "united Russia" supported by it (at one time), we should have lived "better and longer than anyone else" in 2012
      1. geptilshik
        geptilshik 16 January 2014 11: 01
        +2
        14 years old, already living in a change. I need more changes
        1. not good
          not good 16 January 2014 14: 57
          +2
          Although it is very sad, but the real changes will begin only when the last Gaidar dies.
        2. Colonel
          Colonel 16 January 2014 16: 31
          +1
          Quote: geptilshik
          14 years old, already living in a change. I need more changes

          Damn, you can’t please you. good
  • drei612
    drei612 16 January 2014 09: 26
    +4
    All that is connected with this name is fascist offices, so that wasted money.
  • demotivator
    demotivator 16 January 2014 09: 28
    +14
    "Sick" Medvedev believes that Russians are paid too much
    Speaking at the V Gaidar Economic Forum, Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev outlined the factors that impede the development of the Russian economy. Along with scientific and technological backwardness, Dmitry Anatolyevich complained of "restrictions on the price of labor, which is quite high." Thus, the prime minister almost openly announced the need to import cheap guest workers to Russia, who can be paid cheaper and forced to work more.
    Medvedev's speech is harmoniously combined with the speech at the same forum by the Minister of Finance of the Russian Federation Anton Siluanov, who called for an early increase in the retirement age. Looking at them from his personal infernal cauldron of boiling resin, the former head. by the economic departments of the Kommunist magazine and the Pravda newspaper Yegor Gaidar chuckles delightfully.
    It's funny that the speech at the forum named after the late "reformer" was more important for Dmitry Anatolyevich than the government meeting, which was chaired by President Vladimir Putin in his absence. According to Andrei Kolesnikov, a Kommersant correspondent, "in the certificate prepared for this meeting by the protocol service, it was indicated that Dmitry Medvedev was absent for a good reason:" ill. "
    1. fartfraer
      fartfraer 16 January 2014 10: 07
      +5
      I agree here. I just clarify that the "patient" (although it is possible without quotes, it seems to me) Medvedev was appointed to the second most important post of state by the "healthy" president
      1. not good
        not good 16 January 2014 14: 59
        +2
        Medvedev forgot to make a reservation that they pay a lot to the government and parliament, and that it would be better to tie the salaries of deputies (and Medvedev himself) to the national average.
  • Same lech
    Same lech 16 January 2014 09: 30
    +3
    It turns out that the scenario described by the Gaidar Institute is a real utopia,

    The Gaidar chicks themselves must be diagnosed for adequacy to the realities of our lives (which they created for us)
    In general, the authority of GAIDAR and HIS followers among the people is lower than the plinth - and when you read their advice you often remember their affairs in the 90s, silently swear and send them three letters in a certain direction.
  • La-5
    La-5 16 January 2014 09: 31
    -1
    Some offended complain about the life of another offended.
  • ia-ai00
    ia-ai00 16 January 2014 09: 39
    +4
    It turns out that the scenario described by the Gaidar Institute is a real utopia ...

    Gaidar's team has already brought the country to "paradise" in 500 days. How can you call an institute by the name of a BAD economist? Well, only if the "helm" still has people from "Gaidar and his team", and their goals are to destroy "to the ground", then it is clear, in their eyes - Gaidar - "deserved" ...
    I have no doubt that only an "exclusive" nation works at the institute.
    1. Stanislas
      Stanislas 16 January 2014 22: 21
      -1
      Quote: ia-ai00
      and their purpose is to destroy "to the ground"
      And what new recipes are expected from them when the old ones work fine, if not interfere?
  • individual
    individual 16 January 2014 09: 52
    +4
    “It is extremely naive to talk today about some kind of mature civil society in Dagestan or Ingushetia, just as it is naive to believe that representatives of such a regional“ civil society ”will be able to change the situation themselves,“ from below ”.

    Representatives of the Gaidar Institute are busy with their "business". am
    They presented their curator A. Kudrin with a plan for solving the Caucasian problems on the "swamp" Maidan in Grozny, Makhachkala, Nalchik and further on the list according to the model and likeness of "any" Ukrainian model of statehood. am
  • Alex65
    Alex65 16 January 2014 09: 53
    +7
    One-armed bandit
    1. 225chay
      225chay 16 January 2014 10: 27
      +3
      Quote: Alex65
      One-armed bandit


      rather "one-sided" stump
    2. SRC P-15
      SRC P-15 16 January 2014 11: 56
      +2
      Quote: Alex65
      One-armed bandit

      And he apparently erased his right hand while writing his "great programs". It is a pity that not to the neck. lol
    3. The comment was deleted.
    4. vladimirZ
      vladimirZ 16 January 2014 15: 23
      0
      It is interesting to find at least one state figure that raises the question of the demolition of the monument to this one-armed bandit?
      Or they are waiting for the people to break it with a sledgehammer.
      1. Colonel
        Colonel 16 January 2014 16: 37
        +1
        Quote: vladimirZ
        break with a sledgehammer.
        In no case. Take a close look at the monument. I think that the sculptor "loved" Yegorushka honestly. If they put one on my grave, I would have shot myself.
  • Altona
    Altona 16 January 2014 10: 00
    +2
    Quote: demotivator
    Along with scientific and technological backwardness, Dmitry Anatolyevich complained of "restrictions on the price of labor, which is quite high."

    ______________________
    For members of his Government and himself, as well as for deputies, it is prohibitively high ... But in Russia as a whole, $ 1000 / month, and even then not everyone has that, is the price of labor?
    Moreover, judging by the forms, the engineer’s labor cost is almost the lowest, so what does he want then?
    1. fartfraer
      fartfraer 16 January 2014 10: 10
      +2
      it is especially pleasing when at the same time everyone demonstratively gives an example of European prices, they say that we are no higher than there (though they strive so that it is not lower). The total price is higher, w-less, people are happy listening to promises
      1. kaktus
        kaktus 16 January 2014 12: 57
        +1
        How many people have not been promised - but we are all few, all few ... wassat
  • Monster_Fat
    Monster_Fat 16 January 2014 10: 03
    +12
    Once in a TV program devoted to migration from the Caucasian regions, an interesting episode flashed, which suggests one of the methods of solving the "Caucasian problem". In that program, they showed one elderly Chechen who came from Turkey and Germany, where his children immigrated. So, he lamented that his children had changed a lot - they live by different values, and they were no longer Chechens at all. And so he returned to his homeland in Chechnya, where only the values ​​of Islam, Chechen traditions, etc. can be preserved. And he also complained that more and more young people are leaving abroad and that it would be okay to go to Muslim countries, they don’t go to European countries. After a short time, they lose their authenticity there, turning into ordinary consumers, and as a result, their native villages become empty and wither without youth. Here is one of the methods for solving the Chechen problem - let the youth go from there to Europe, study there, etc. We need to encourage this by any means it will be easier for us.
  • Peter76
    Peter76 16 January 2014 10: 06
    +6
    I wonder how much the activities of this institution cost taxpayers?
  • Alex66
    Alex66 16 January 2014 10: 10
    +6
    And they say the apple does not fall far from the apple tree, if grandfather knew, then he would not marry grandmother. The Gaidar Forum, the Yeltsin Fund, the Humpback Fund, how many of them are still with us, why do they work and for what means? Why does the government take part in their work, that in the history of Russia there was no other name for the name of the forum, well, Stolypinsky though. Our government is sick of you.
    1. Djozz
      Djozz 16 January 2014 10: 40
      +4
      Timur Yegorka's father is not the son of Arkady Gaidar (Golikov), he adopted him by marrying the "chosen of God."
      1. ia-ai00
        ia-ai00 16 January 2014 11: 43
        +2
        I think if Arkady Gaidar knew that the offspring of the "chosen of God" already with my "team"will repeat "feat" Bad Boy, I would have strangled him!
  • Christian
    Christian 16 January 2014 10: 16
    +3
    The Gaidar Institute has already diagnosed the Russian economy once!
  • hohryakov066
    hohryakov066 16 January 2014 10: 24
    0
    [quote] [Yegor Gaidar Institute of Economic Policy (hereinafter - the Gaidar Institute) ./ quote]
    Did he die? Or is the institute named after grandfather?
    1. REDBLUE
      REDBLUE 16 January 2014 10: 34
      +2
      Egor Gaidar (March 19, 1956, Moscow - December 16, 2009, Uspenskoe, Moscow Region)
  • dmb
    dmb 16 January 2014 10: 30
    +10
    What would the child not amuse himself as long as he would not ask for vodka. If all these "studies" were carried out at the expense of the "researchers" themselves, then the flag is in their hands. But the whole trouble is that they spend exclusively our money with you, because they receive subsidies from the budget. And when the "preoccupied" fans of the Guarantor blame the iPhone and the liberal government crowd, they simply do not want to remember that it is the Guarantor who keeps them in power. At the same time, hardly any of them, including the Guarantor, can explain how subsidizing parties and non-governmental organizations is consistent with the "market economy." This is not even a fraud, but a robbery, when my money is transferred to Ms. Alekseeva, who uses it to throw mud at the history of my country.
  • REDBLUE
    REDBLUE 16 January 2014 10: 32
    +2
    Quote: fartfraer
    14 years are getting closer and closer ... when exactly will we start, do not tell me? Otherwise, according to the promises of the GDP and the "united Russia" supported by it (at one time), we should have lived "better and longer than anyone else" in 2012

    Probably the date was not written correctly should be 2102 and not 2012
  • uizik
    uizik 16 January 2014 10: 36
    +5
    Torturing language is the lot of lawyers. This Medvedev does brilliantly, especially when you need to distort the facts. As a business executive, he is zero! Why trust such people in the leadership of the Country? We’ve already made sure that the western bazaar doesn’t work for us. And how did the Western partners gobble us up and bankrupt? And now they continue to put sticks in the wheels. Until we start investing in the economy and keep it planned, nothing will come of it.
  • Forest
    Forest 16 January 2014 10: 41
    +5
    This is not a forum, but a coven of traitors-pests, so their findings are stupid to even discuss.
    1. SRC P-15
      SRC P-15 16 January 2014 12: 04
      +2
      Quote: Forest
      This is not a forum, but a coven of traitors-pests, so their findings are stupid to even discuss.

      And I think such forums are very necessary in order to know how it is not necessary to conduct the country's economy. What they say there is a signal to us how not to do it.
      1. The comment was deleted.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  • tank64rus
    tank64rus 16 January 2014 10: 47
    +4
    It is strange that all these "institutions" exist on state money. There is also the HSE liberals from which they took leading positions in the Ministry of Education. and which is being strenuously destroyed. For whom they work, well, certainly not for Russia.
  • Russ69
    Russ69 16 January 2014 10: 51
    +3
    Of course, in the Caucasus it is necessary to solve problems for the economy; such subsidies cannot last forever. But here is the recipe, such a chef as the Gaidar Institute, there is absolutely no trust ...
  • ed65b
    ed65b 16 January 2014 11: 45
    +2
    To be honest, I generally do not consider the opinion of the "pimply" specialists of this office to be any authority. The Institute of Thief and Robber can give nothing but theft and robbery. These figures love to broadcast on RBC and sometimes they carry such a blizzard that it becomes scary for their sick head.
  • Jedi
    Jedi 16 January 2014 12: 14
    -4
    As far as I know from various opinion polls, the majority of Russians (this is plus or minus 90%) want the Caucasian republics not to be part of Russia. they don’t want to think about economic issues being resolved there, initiatives from below to intensify, or, in general, so that these "fraternal peoples" want to work instead of parasitizing on Russia. they just don't want to be one country with the Caucasus and that's it! what prevents to do as the absolute majority wants?
    1. ia-ai00
      ia-ai00 16 January 2014 12: 28
      +3
      So the Caucasus - and so is already all in Russia, and they feel themselves in Russia, as at home, as true masters. Moreover, criminal and gangster formations in Russia, as well as the so-called "shadow economy" - are mainly people of the Caucasus. Yes, and they behave in Russia, rather, like occupiers, while in the Caucasus they are "white and fluffy", they honor the Laws, traditions, respect their ancestors ...
    2. Volodin
      16 January 2014 12: 51
      +4
      Jedi (sorry, I don’t know your name), I understand your emotionality, but still I would like to receive at least one link to the poll with the results mentioned:
      I know, according to various opinion polls, the majority of Russians (this is plus or minus 90%) want the Caucasian republics as part of Russia not to be
      ... I understand what you meant, but your phrase "plus or minus 90%" perfectly reflects the essence of such polls. Today we will separate the North Caucasus, but tomorrow what? - Kuriles, Kaliningrad or Voronezh? No, this is clearly not a solution to the problem.
  • demel2
    demel2 16 January 2014 12: 36
    +2
    I wonder who finances this Kodlu, are we really? And how many such harmful loafers are sitting on our neck.
  • pensioner
    pensioner 16 January 2014 12: 38
    +3
    Gaidar Institute
    But what is it: It’s dead, and the institute is still alive, or what? what No, really! stop Dead - so dead! yes We build in two and move towards the cemetery! People are waiting ... Uncomfortable in front of them ... repeat
  • JonnyT
    JonnyT 16 January 2014 13: 05
    +5
    Well, this is generally a mockery of the people. People who plundered the country in 90's give advice!
    In general, if you think about it, such institutions are a kind of filter ...... People who are highlighted in them must be kept away from the government and state money, knowing what values ​​they adhere to!
  • tverskoi77
    tverskoi77 16 January 2014 13: 42
    +3
    I didn't quite understand what the author of the article wanted to say. The only thing is clear that he is not a liberal and very much dislikes the word "Gaidar")))
    In my opinion, the more the issue of the situation in the Caucasus and the consequences of spreading to other territories will be raised, the better. We must constantly focus on this, and not keep silent the problem. Even if the focus is only on the analysis of the situation without suggesting solutions to the issue.
    For example, Zhirinovsky, because in fact he proposed one of the real measures to restore order, like it or not. Of course, he did it incorrectly, but the thought is not without meaning. And he was banned, why?
    Yes, because many deputies and delegates know more about the weather in Courchevel, and not about the situation in their own country.
    I will summarize my comment - without knowing the situation, it is impossible to solve the problem.
  • pan_nor
    pan_nor 16 January 2014 14: 09
    +2
    How are these "Gaidars" fed up !!! There is no grandfather on them ...
  • Kibalchish
    Kibalchish 16 January 2014 14: 43
    +1
    Treatment: 100000000000 tons of napalm in the villages.
  • mountain
    mountain 16 January 2014 14: 54
    +1
    Which institute? Gaidar? Well, that's one hundred percent a disastrous business.
  • Jedi
    Jedi 16 January 2014 17: 05
    +2
    Quote: Volodin
    ... I understand what you meant, but your phrase "plus or minus 90%" perfectly reflects the essence of such polls. Today we will separate the North Caucasus, but tomorrow what? - Kuriles, Kaliningrad or Voronezh? No, this is clearly not a solution to the problem.

    I will not give links - it will take a long time to search. but for example: a year ago I watched an "open studio" on Channel 5, the program lasted 2 hours, people from all over the country called and voted. As a result, 96% voted in favor of expelling all Chyuchmeks from Russia. and this is one of the central state channels with an appropriate audience ... but about the Kuril Islands or Kaliningrad - no need to pretend to be silly. You perfectly understand that people are enraged by the behavior of Caucasians and Central Asians who have come in large numbers, there are more and more of them and they are getting bolder. the intolerance and irritability of the local grows accordingly. into what all this will grow is unknown. what does voronezh have to do with it?
    1. wanderer_032
      wanderer_032 16 January 2014 17: 45
      0
      What will be unknown next, although it is not difficult to predict ...
      (words from the song "A vicious circle" gr. "ARIA".)
  • wanderer_032
    wanderer_032 16 January 2014 17: 40
    +2
    This institute, like everything organized by the Gaidar & Chubais Company Inc. community, resembles the "Horns and Hooves" office from the famous novel by Ilf and Petrov.
    But they are only zits-chairmen in it.
    Question: who commands the parade?
  • Leshka
    Leshka 16 January 2014 17: 42
    +2
    the inter-national question is what worries many in the Caucasus, first of all, including me
  • The comment was deleted.
  • chunga-changa
    chunga-changa 16 January 2014 19: 04
    +2
    The Gaidar Institute is writing a study for kudrin. Translated into Russian at the branch, the CIA draws the attention of one of the leaders of the economic residency to a successful direction for further destabilization of the Caucasus.
  • Power
    Power 16 January 2014 20: 02
    +2
    Gaidar Institute. Factory of death. Demographic Reforms. Genocide of the indigenous population. Those interested can continue. But people remember the name of each creature.
  • Power
    Power 16 January 2014 20: 25
    +2
    PS Now is your time, and you are in a hurry to steal more and instruct the Monuments. But the people do not forget anything. And here no monuments and "Institutes" will help.
  • Amateur
    Amateur 16 January 2014 20: 45
    +1
    It is hard to believe that all these Kudrinsk experts are mistaken about the Caucasian policy. Well, they are not suckers. They just have a slightly different vision of the future of the Caucasus: unpredictability, chaos, terror, an active "civil" society (disobedience), corruption, clannishness of local authorities and limited influence on the situation of the central government (decentralization). A generously paid position aimed at the collapse of the state. I wonder who is interested in this? Another hand ...? Or a paw? These Gaidar-Kudrinsky are muddy people. As they say, listen to advice and do the opposite!