Military Review

Fear of active change. To the next decrease in growth forecast for Russia

68
Fear of active change. To the next decrease in growth forecast for RussiaThe Ministry of Economic Development has worsened the outlook for the growth of the Russian economy. The fourth time this year. The forecast for the 2014 – 2015 years is also worsened. In such a situation, the implementation of the May decrees of Vladimir Putin becomes an almost impossible task, which is directly stated without hesitation in the Government. What it is - sabotage, inability to work or the pressure of external circumstances - we analyze below.


Putin they do not decree

The new forecast for economic growth on 2013 year from the Ministry of Economic Development - 1,4%. It was preceded by forecasts in 3,6%, 2,4% and 1,8%. It seems that if the year had not ended so unexpectedly quickly, we would have waited a couple more adjustments down. The forecast for 2014 and 2015 years has also been lowered - from 3 to 2,5% and from 3,1 to 2,8%.

Note that in order to fulfill the May presidential decrees in the part of only raising public sector wages, the country needs an increase of 4%. And for the implementation of all decrees in general - no less than 7%.

As is easy to see, in the forecasts of the Ministry of Economic Development, these figures do not even smell.

But this is a trifle compared to the main trouble - no one in the government really knows how to achieve high performance. Or know, but do not say. And there is something to speculate about.

May decrees of Vladimir Putin, as we recall, were met with a positive and even somewhere with enthusiasm. Because it seemed that now the president, who had returned to his post again, would ask the officials to the fullest extent for their implementation. And because of this, confidence was born in the depths of my soul that one way or another they will be fulfilled. Well, maybe not on 100% - we are all human. But even being executed percent on 80% - they promised us a lot of pleasant and useful for the country.

And we began to wait. But soon unpleasant signals began to appear and the first conversations that the government could not cope with the tasks assigned to it. We cautiously assumed that if it "does not pull," then it makes sense to change it to a more capable composition. However, Vladimir Putin himself rejected this idea, explaining that too little time had passed to ask for the execution of decrees. And we began to wait further.

Then, when it seemed to us, there was enough time for some conclusions - that the decrees would not be executed, they suddenly spoke openly in the Government itself. And it seemed to us unheard of audacity. However, even here the president stood up for the ministers, explaining that the unstable situation in the global economy was to blame. And after a while, Vladimir Putin admitted that he deliberately laid down in the decrees excessive figures to encourage the government to work.

And this is very strange. No, this method is known and often works well. When a subordinate receives a super task, he begins to work with triple energy, hoping to fulfill it at least partially, in order not to be punished too severely. But this method is usually supported by two important circumstances: the inevitability of punishment for failure to comply with the plan and the absence of even hints from the authorities that it can be partially implemented.

As we can see, none of these material circumstances have been respected. The president protects the government from criticism and openly declares that he deliberately raised the bar for assignments. As a result, the government generally loses all incentives to work, in each case it is convenient to grasp the saving mantra about the “unfavorable external conjuncture." And lowers the growth forecast four times a year.

... In the spring of 2012, we were happy about presidential decrees, not because there were some separate positive figures (many of us are not directly affected by them at all). We rejoiced, because we saw the hope of an integrated approach to solving the difficult, long-standing problems of our economy. After all, even to a person who was far from economics, it was clear that the fulfillment of the presidential assignments implied the beginning of a new global project, a new industrialization (which only costs the creation and modernization of 25 million jobs by the 2020 year). However, so far, instead of this, we have received only a series of questionable reforms and the actual refusal of officials to perform the tasks assigned to them.

Lack of incentives

There is a version that the economy of our country is controlled by deliberate pests sent by British intelligence. If this were the case, then the problem would have good prospects for solution in the form of a series of loud exposing processes and purification of power from pests. Experience in this matter is available. But, I'm afraid, the reason for the failure of presidential decrees is not at all in this.

The reason seems to lie in more prosaic things - the lack of motivation for change. Overcoming it is much more difficult than calculating spies.

I think that there is an understanding of the need for a modernization breakthrough not only for us, ordinary citizens, at the level of sensations, but also for the Government at the level of figures and forecasts. It should be even deeper than ours. As well as the understanding that this breakthrough is inevitable and is approaching the country with the inevitability of a bulldozer in the Ukrainian “euromaidan”. That's just to exercise it scary.

What lies behind this very "jerk", in addition to our vague ideas, based on the old Soviet newsreels about the course of industrialization and the development of virgin lands? In the first place - a cardinal change of the usual way of life, generating a strong social reaction. The reaction, in the course of which inevitably many will have to part with the usual standard of living, with even abused, but such a cozy job and trips to the resorts of the Red Sea. And with many other “side effects” that we are not thinking about right now.

That is, the “jerk” will be accompanied by such a whirlwind of transformations that will sweep away the entire former way of life and the Government itself in its current form. Moreover, if in the course of gradual degradation, which we are now witnessing, the Government has the opportunity to constantly complain about the “bad situation” and, in the worst case, peacefully go to an honorable retirement, then “jerk” will take upon them such responsibility that they have never in their life borne . The question is - do they need it?

One could turn to a sense of duty to the Motherland as an additional motivating factor. But we know that the economy of our country is controlled by people for whom the dogmas of liberalism are the only guideline. And it very conveniently allows you to abandon all responsibility by shifting it to the "invisible hand of the market." The country will die - what to do - did not fit into historical conjuncture.

Another powerful brain stimulant is, conditionally, the muzzle of a revolver at the back of the head. But this factor is absent. The worst thing that our ministers and their subordinates could face in the current situation is a reprimand or resignation. Or article for negligence. But the real barrel appears just in case of the beginning of global changes, which the authorities do not want to initiate.

In general, no matter how sad it is, one doesn’t have to think about any “jerk”. And this means that the May decrees of the president will be mostly merged. Moreover, those that will be fulfilled may be provided by cutting back on other important articles. As a result, the country will not receive any practical benefit from this activity.

I would venture to suggest that Vladimir Putin understands all this as well as you and me. And it does not put pressure on the Government precisely because it itself fears these global changes. In this case, there is only one question left - does he have an alternative, less traumatic plan for overcoming the crisis, or does he simply, like everyone else, hope for a change in the “external conjuncture”?
Author:
Originator:
http://www.odnako.org/
68 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. AVV
    AVV 6 December 2013 14: 59
    17
    The only incentive for the brotherhood of managers should be his current position and work for the good of the state !!! And if such an individual fails to show the trust of the state and the people, then deprive him of the opportunity to head some kind of state institution for a period of at least 5 years !!! How did it become , regrettably, with Serdyukov, who failed to work in one post, and he is transferred to another state post and generally convicted figures or involved in particularly serious corruption cases, deprive him of such a right to work in state structures for life !!! Here it will be ideal incentive when the guillotine is constantly hanging over your head !!!
    1. RBLip
      RBLip 6 December 2013 15: 24
      +7
      Quote: AVV
      And if such an individual fails to show the confidence of the state and the people, then deprive him of the opportunity to head some kind of state institution for a period of at least 5 years !!! As it became, regrettably, with Serdyukov, who failed the work at one post, and his transfer to another state post and generally convicted figures or involved in particularly grave corruption cases, deprive of such a right to work in state structures for life !!! This will be an ideal incentive when the guillotine is constantly hanging over your head !!!

      to deprive such individuals of the possibility of free movement with serving their sentences in places not so remote for a period of 5 years, with the wording "did not justify the high confidence of the people of Russia." plus confiscation from him and his immediate family. in the case of stooltkin - the abolition of the moratorium on the death penalty + confiscation + life fine on close relatives (until they are paid) in an amount exceeding at least twice the amount of "errors" thief ..... officials. then you look, and GDP will grow and pensions will increase and there will be enough for the army both for medicine and for education and for housing and communal services ...
      1. Walker1975
        Walker1975 6 December 2013 17: 36
        +8
        Luzhkov was removed "as not justifying high confidence." They pinched a little, but did not his wife save many billions?
        1. matross
          matross 6 December 2013 22: 31
          +1
          A bit left. But pinch specifically.
          1. Walker1975
            Walker1975 6 December 2013 22: 58
            +2
            So in crime it’s always like this - the entrance is the ruble, and the exit is two
            1. dark_65
              dark_65 6 December 2013 23: 16
              0
              Have you been there? What do you know about this?
              1. sams
                sams 7 December 2013 00: 05
                0
                was or wasn’t, but we must remember
                1. sams
                  sams 7 December 2013 00: 17
                  +1
                  We fucked with you
                2. sams
                  sams 7 December 2013 00: 25
                  0
                  I will definitely be back
                3. sams
                  sams 7 December 2013 00: 31
                  0
                  Russia is still alive ... while still alive
                4. sams
                  sams 7 December 2013 00: 38
                  0
                  Now Russia is paying daily tribute of about 1 billion dollars.
                  To whom and for what!?
                  This is without any hutspa regarding the guys in the video. I respect them.
      2. The comment was deleted.
      3. Severok
        Severok 6 December 2013 18: 20
        +1
        146% true. If so, then the real work will begin, and not the talking room, as it is now.
        Bravo.
      4. S_mirnov
        S_mirnov 6 December 2013 20: 26
        +1
        Quote: RBLip
        in the case of stooltkin - the abolition of the moratorium on the death penalty + confiscation + a life fine on close relatives (until they are paid) in an amount exceeding at least twice the amount of "errors" thief ..... an official. then you look, and GDP will grow and pensions will increase and there will be enough for the army both for medicine and for education and for housing and communal services ...

        But actually, in real life the following happens ...
        "Former Defense Minister Anatoly Serdyukov has been formally charged with negligence and causing major damage," the Investigative Committee said and stressed that this is still the initial version of the charge, and in the future it can be clarified and expanded.

        See the original material at http://www.1tv.ru/news/crime/247765 "

        I repeat - in NEGLIGENCE !!! Probably often went in a bathrobe! laughing
        1. bif
          bif 7 December 2013 01: 35
          -1
          Quote: S_mirnov
          Serdyukov formally charged with negligence and causing serious damage

          "Don't say gop until you've jumped over" - it's too early to draw conclusions until the court's verdict has been announced. The charges can change every day.
    2. APES
      APES 6 December 2013 16: 33
      +5
      Quote: AVV
      incentive for a brotherhood of managers


      can make closed "government sharashki" like closed scientific research institutes and design bureaus of the middle of the last century?

      with food rations based on the cost of living - approved by them.
    3. The comment was deleted.
    4. The comment was deleted.
    5. 0251
      0251 6 December 2013 17: 00
      +1
      In general, the article is interesting. But let's wait. Putin to the Federal Assembly on December 20. It is possible there about the state of the economy and its future and not only will be said.
    6. Walker1975
      Walker1975 6 December 2013 17: 34
      +5
      And who will do all this? Putin So I'll tell you a secret - it was he who appointed this government and Serdyukov to boot ... Does it need Putin to offend friends? Already living only on the salary of the President, he was able to become almost the richest man in the world (salaries are good in Russia), he sent his daughters to Europe - the same scary gay Europe that Ukraine is so scared of. But the Russians are proud of their president, forgetting that his wealth is taken out of their wallets.
      1. Nevsky_ZU
        Nevsky_ZU 6 December 2013 18: 41
        +4
        Walker1975

        I sent my daughters to Europe - the worst gay Europe that Ukraine is so afraid of. But the Russians are proud of their president, forgetting that his wealth is taken out of their wallets.


        Let's separate the elite from the aspirations of the peoples of Russia and Ukraine, okay? Do not pretend to be a fool here, uv. Russian-speaking liberal, citizen of Ukraine? In the West, a representative of juvenile justice will never enter the regions where the elite lives, in elite charter schools - they will not teach homosexuality and lesbianism as "normalcy", they will teach the basics of government.

        This is me, by the way, wrote for you, did not read by chance?

        http://topwar.ru/36726-intervyu-patriota-otryvok.html
        1. Walker1975
          Walker1975 6 December 2013 23: 00
          +1
          Let's separate. Who is arguing? But where is that thin line between the people and the elite? For example, if the elite of the Russian Federation says - let’s move the tanks to Ukraine, force it to peace and friendship, then what will the people of Russia say?
          1. avg
            avg 6 December 2013 23: 57
            0
            if the elite of the Russian Federation says - let’s move the tanks to Ukraine, force it to peace and friendship, then what will the people of Russia say?

            The people of Russia will say that they cannot pay for gas, and all the more they will not pay for tanks. Better sell them to the Indians. laughing
            In general, you, Svidomo, already got GRU special forces near Kiev and submarines in the steppes near Kherson. Just like Putin’s daughters in geyropov. yes
      2. Mature naturalist
        Mature naturalist 6 December 2013 23: 43
        0
        Quote: Walker1975
        But the Russians are proud of their president, forgetting that his wealth is taken out of their wallets.

        We are proud! You should have seen what a palace he had built in Praskoveevka! A new wonder of the world.
      3. The comment was deleted.
    7. Skiff-2
      Skiff-2 6 December 2013 22: 13
      +1
      Eugene, (I’m the author) don’t tear your soul, Putin’s Medvedev’s gang will be touched now (before the Olympics) like the Trotskyists in the 37th - the stench will be to heaven and an occasion for a boycott of the Olympics. By sabotage, the Medvedevites are gathering firebrands on their heads - in March there will be something to not only remove, but also to isolate for a long time from the government with a tag about unsuitability. By spring, much can change in the world (or donkey will die, or padish, or maybe both of us will please this news), many questions will be easier to solve. I think so .
      1. Victor-M
        Victor-M 6 December 2013 23: 16
        +1
        Quote: Skif-2
        By spring, much can change in the world.

        Yushchenko is still alive? At the beginning of the meal, Tymoshenko did not open diarrhea? Nicknames will soon be given another belt - the martyr's belt.
  2. military
    military 6 December 2013 15: 18
    11
    Note that in order to fulfill the May presidential decrees in the part of only raising public sector wages, the country needs an increase of 4%. And for the implementation of all decrees in general - no less than 7%.

    the dough really was enough only for indexing the salaries of deputies and bureaucrats from the administration ... well, and ... for saboteurs from the government ... the rest, it seems, will get killed ...
    1. Vadivak
      Vadivak 6 December 2013 15: 45
      12
      Quote: military
      the dough really was enough only for indexing the salaries of deputies and bureaucrats


      Absolutely true, and in confirming your words -

      The Ministry of Finance planned to increase the salaries of federal state civil servants by 2,6 times by 2018 and put 2014 billion rubles for these needs into the draft federal budget for 2016-135. The average salary in Russia is 26 thousand rubles a month. The salary of a Russian official is almost 64 thousand.

      Director of Macroeconomic Research at the Higher School of Economics Sergey Aleksashenko: “Raising the salaries of our officials has nothing to do with the fight against corruption. President Putin’s decision is to support his allies. The Russian bureaucracy is the force that ensures the party on which it relies, victory in the elections. The current Russian bureaucracy has lost the ability to work, and no matter how you raise its salary, it will still be inefficient and thieving. It should be a complete restructuring of the civil service, a radical change in the people working there, a change in motivation, and the development of some goals and objectives. They don’t know how to work better, many of them don’t know how to work at all. ”
      1. military
        military 6 December 2013 17: 07
        +3
        Quote: Vadivak
        They do not know how to work better, many of them do not know how to work at all

        and most of them initially never skillfully and did not want to work ...
        parasitism and mutualism are completely different types of symbiosis ...
      2. bif
        bif 7 December 2013 01: 46
        0
        Quote: Vadivak
        The Ministry of Finance has planned to increase the salaries of federal state civil servants by 2,6 times by 2018 year and put in the draft federal budget for 2014-2016 years 135 billion rubles for these needs

        "Dec 3 - RIA Novosti. Russian President Vladimir Putin signed a law on the suspension from January 1, 2014 for a year of indexation of salaries of civil servants, parliamentary assistants, military salaries, the corresponding document has been posted in the bank of regulatory and administrative acts. This document proposes to suspend indexation until 2015 taking into account the level of inflation of salaries of federal civil servants.As previously reported, such a step will help to save 3,6 billion rubles on salaries of civil servants, 10,4 billion rubles on the income of the military personnel of the Russian armed forces and a little more than 20 billion rubles - on the income of the Interior Ministry troops, employees OVD and other law enforcement agencies. "
        http://ria.ru/society/20131203/981556422.html
    2. Yarosvet
      Yarosvet 6 December 2013 18: 59
      -1
      Quote: military
      the rest seem to be interrupted ...
    3. mountain
      mountain 6 December 2013 21: 55
      0
      What are you worried about, now the yuan rules, maybe we are still in the black.
  3. Vadim-Skeptic
    Vadim-Skeptic 6 December 2013 15: 30
    +8
    There is nothing for ministers to execute presidential decrees. There is no industry for ministers - it is in private hands and is registered in offshore. The Minister of Defense or the Ministry of Emergencies, or the Ministry of Internal Affairs are exceptions, the rest are not ministers, but dispatchers of financial flows.
    1. bif
      bif 7 December 2013 02: 06
      0
      "Aide to the President of Russia Andrei Belousov said on Thursday that the country has colossal reserves to accelerate economic growth, but the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Economic Development are not looking for such resources."
  4. ziqzaq
    ziqzaq 6 December 2013 15: 32
    10
    It seems that Khazin has some calculations that if corruption is reduced to an acceptable level (not even completely!) And the number of officials is reduced to the level of the USSR, this alone will give a 3-5% increase in GDP. Liberasty know only one thing - to rob their own country. Eh, to return the 37th year with Joseph Vissarionovich ...........
    1. Rusich-Svarog
      Rusich-Svarog 6 December 2013 16: 49
      +3
      Quote: ziqzaq
      It seems that Khazin has some calculations that if corruption is reduced to an acceptable level (not even completely!) And the number of officials is reduced to the level of the USSR, this alone will give a 3-5% increase in GDP. Liberasty know only one thing - to rob their own country. Eh, to return the 37th year with Joseph Vissarionovich ...........

      here I fully support. Reducing the staff of officials in favor of the quality of their work
    2. Tersky
      Tersky 6 December 2013 19: 09
      +2
      Quote: ziqzaq
      . Eh, I would return the 37 year together with Joseph Vissarionovich ...........

      Well .... oooo my friend, not tolerant, suck not tolerant, No. . GDP at the expense of 37 of the completely opposite opinion laughing !
      1. not good
        not good 6 December 2013 20: 51
        +2
        In the USSR, the need for each bureaucratic place was justified by the appropriate job profile, and now the need to add a relative, friend or just the right acquaintance, and no one remembers professionalism. and the corresponding introduction of personal responsibility for their implementation.Then, according to the fulfillment of obligations, conduct annual certification with the appropriate result of remuneration or career advancement.Also, prohibit the reception of relatives of the boss to work in the same department as him.
  5. military
    military 6 December 2013 15: 32
    +6
    I would venture to suggest that Vladimir Putin understands all this as well as you and me. And it does not put pressure on the Government precisely because it itself fears these global changes. In this case, there is only one question left - does he have an alternative, less traumatic plan for overcoming the crisis, or does he simply, like everyone else, hope for a change in the “external conjuncture”?

    our "statesman" simply hesitates along with the general line of the liberals occupying the country and power ... no more and no less ...
    he already had one "plan" ... banners were dangling at every corner ... "Putin's plan is in action!" ...
    1. Vadivak
      Vadivak 6 December 2013 15: 48
      +4
      Quote: military
      "Putin's plan is in action!" ...


      No one really knows what Putin’s plan is, but everyone is talking about him. Everyone is tired of jokes about him, but some are still bastard of the obvious associations arising from the word “plan”.
      1. military
        military 6 December 2013 17: 01
        +2
        Quote: Vadivak
        No one really knows what Putin’s plan is, but everyone is talking about him.

        you always want to believe in "gopher" ... even when he is not there ...
        Quote: Vadivak
        Everyone is tired of jokes about him, but some are still bastard of the obvious associations arising from the word “plan”.

        so it happened today ...
        we say "plan" - we mean "Putin"
        we say "Putin" - we mean "plan"
        .
    2. aksakal
      aksakal 6 December 2013 16: 05
      +2
      Quote: military
      our "statesman" simply hesitates along with the general line of the liberals occupying the country and power ... no more and no less ... he already had one "plan" ... banners were dangling at every corner ... "Putin's plan - in action! "...
      - and Putin has a good "plan"? Kumarite? Strongly swaying in unison with the general line of the liberals and other occupiers?
      Remembered you. Yesterday you recalled with the Peaceful Military:
      "- Peaceful? -
      - military -
      - peaceful military? -
      - military military -
      - shoot! "

      I am glad to see you, I am glad that our assumptions regarding your fate have not been justified and will not be justified.
      1. military
        military 6 December 2013 16: 41
        +2
        Quote: aksakal
        Remembered you. Yesterday you recalled with the Peaceful Military:
        "- Peaceful? -
        - military -
        - peaceful military? -
        - military military -
        - shoot! "

        oh how! ... belay I hiccuped all evening ... laughing Glad to see you, aksakal! ... hi
        1. aksakal
          aksakal 6 December 2013 17: 09
          +1
          Quote: military
          Glad to see you, aksakal! ...

          Likewise. And here we are Putin, or rather his "plan" are sitting, discussing laughing Join laughing
          1. military
            military 6 December 2013 17: 15
            +4
            Quote: aksakal
            And we are here of Putin, or rather his "plan", we are sitting, discussing Join

            Yes, what are you? ... remember the dialogue between the "professor's daughter" and the "son of an academician" in E. Ryazanov's movie "Garage"? ...
            "I envy you ... you are doing what is not ..."
            wink
            1. aksakal
              aksakal 6 December 2013 20: 57
              0
              Quote: military
              Quote: aksakal
              And we are here of Putin, or rather his "plan", we are sitting, discussing Join

              Yes, what are you? ... remember the dialogue between the "professor's daughter" and the "son of an academician" in E. Ryazanov's movie "Garage"? ...
              "I envy you ... you are doing what is not ..."
              wink

              - well, in that case, we in Kazakhstan have our own "plan", since you don't even have one for Putin laughing In the Chui Valley, there is enough "plan" for everyone. Py. Sy. This is not "Garage", this is "Gentlemen of Fortune". Confused. Here in this you are similar to the Peaceful Military, it is not surprising to confuse you yourself. laughing laughing
    3. Yarosvet
      Yarosvet 6 December 2013 19: 05
      0
      Quote: military
      our "statist" just hesitates



      Putin's plan is in action! "...
      1. Nevsky_ZU
        Nevsky_ZU 6 December 2013 19: 21
        -1
        Jarosvet, the bottom photo, obviously provocation. Even a first grader will say.
        1. Yarosvet
          Yarosvet 6 December 2013 20: 13
          0
          Quote: Nevsky_ZU
          Yarosvet, bottom photo, clearly a provocation

          here is a provocation:
  6. major071
    major071 6 December 2013 15: 33
    +7
    One could turn to a sense of duty to the Motherland as an additional motivating factor.

    The question immediately arises: Who should I contact? To the government liberals? Yes, their homeland smells of green candy wrappers, they are here to fill their pockets and dump them to the west. It’s good to look at Russia from the window of a fashionable limousine or to get news via Twitter, getting a big salary and kickbacks for all kinds of deals. And try to make them work normally, as it should, but for the money that ordinary Russians get, they will immediately howl. negative
    1. military
      military 6 December 2013 16: 46
      +2
      Quote: major071
      The question immediately arises: Who should I contact? To the liberals from the government? Yes, their homeland smells of green candy wrappers, they are here to fill their pockets and dump them to the west. It's good to look at Russia from the window of a fashionable limousine or to get news via Twitter ...

      you can still delightedly delve into the presented yotafon ... repeat
  7. Oskar
    Oskar 6 December 2013 15: 33
    +4
    It is necessary to give 10-20 years for failure to fulfill election promises (at any level of power: from the deputy and the head of the faction to the governor and president). This will ensure unprecedented economic growth. And then for everything they punish, but not those people.
    1. kaktus
      kaktus 6 December 2013 17: 41
      +1
      "To promise is not to marry!" wassat
  8. Andrey57
    Andrey57 6 December 2013 15: 35
    +4
    I will venture to suggest that Vladimir Putin understands all this no worse than you and me. And it does not put pressure on the Government precisely because it itself is afraid of these changes

    In domestic economic policy, the GDP has no opinion at all if it allows the liberals in the government and the Central Bank of the Russian Federation to impudently declare that the Washington Regional Committee issued the Central Administration for the further collapse of Russia, and the government will strictly follow these "valuable instructions", while spitting on decrees President.
    As for the plans, normal economists have been shouting about them for more than one year - this is an import substitution program, a small example, Kazakhstan, which has embarked on a dense import substitution program, this year has an increase of 5% per year under the same "unfavorable market ". According to the calculations of such economists as Glazyev, Grigoriev, Khazin, when adopting the import substitution program. Russia would have an annual growth rate of 6-7% per year for 10-15 years. So we draw conclusions about who runs the state.
    1. olviko
      olviko 6 December 2013 16: 38
      0
      "In domestic economic policy, the GDP has no opinion at all, if it allows the liberals in the government and the Central Bank of the Russian Federation to impudently declare that the Washington Regional Committee has issued the Central Administration for the further collapse of Russia, and these" valuable instructions "the government will strictly follow,"

      Well, right, because the ruble issue of “sovereign” Russia is completely tied to the US Federal Reserve. Since 1996, ruble issuance has been based solely on the amount of currency received, “having converted” which the Central Bank “has the right to issue”. The government uses the received rubles for its own purposes, and the Central Bank invests the acquired dollars, for example, in the “securities” of the US Treasury. So we support the overconsumption of the United States, its defense industry and science, while sterilizing dollar inflation along the way. At the same time, emissions based on the currency board mechanism:
  9. predator.3
    predator.3 6 December 2013 15: 41
    +3
    The new forecast for economic growth on 2013 year from the Ministry of Economic Development - 1,4%. It was preceded by forecasts in 3,6%, 2,4% and 1,8%. It seems that if the year had not ended so unexpectedly quickly, we would have waited a couple more adjustments down. The forecast for 2014 and 2015 years has also been lowered - from 3 to 2,5% and from 3,1 to 2,8%.


    It may be better to disperse this government, as in 1998, and appoint those who can handle it!

    “All issues related to the implementation of presidential decrees are under my personal control,” Medvedev said. Commenting on the implementation of the presidential decrees of May 7, 2012, the Prime Minister noted that all the goals are long-term in nature, and the work as a whole is designed until 2018. At the same time, he noted that now it is necessary to understand what has been done and where there are problems.

    Those. he still did not understand what he was doing and what he was doing, and he still wanted to sit and rant until 2018!
  10. sanyabasik
    sanyabasik 6 December 2013 15: 45
    +2
    Vladimir Putin’s decrees, as we recall, were greeted positively and even somewhere with enthusiasm.

    I think that I am not the only one who considers these decrees to be populism and empty promises.
    1. military
      military 6 December 2013 16: 52
      +1
      Quote: sanyabasik
      I think that I am not the only one who considers these decrees to be populism and empty promises.

      Naturally, you are not alone ... but at the time of the publication of these decrees there were much fewer of us ("non-believers"), and the post-election euphoria in a society based on pre-election promises was immeasurably more winked .
    2. Yarosvet
      Yarosvet 6 December 2013 19: 13
      +1
      Quote: sanyabasik
      I think that I am not the only one who considers these decrees to be populism and empty promises.

      Has anyone watched them in writing? smile
  11. Grbear
    Grbear 6 December 2013 15: 46
    +4
    The author, I hope sincerely, is wrong about the incentives and professionalism of the team. All this is there. Agree that doing well is bad - you have to be able to. Examples: minObraz - successfully destroys education; Ministry of Economy and Regional Development - professionally assessing the prospects of the real economy, do not offer solutions, because any of them will hit the breadwinners of the country - state corporations and unnatural monopolies; Consumer supervision does not want to protect its citizens from counterfeiting products (microbes and mold do not live in Products), because "Pyaterochka" will be upset.

    И this is not sabotage, this is the execution of a command - do whatever you want, but do not touch these ...

    Everything will be so until everyone understands that it is impossible "to be a little pregnant", because terry capitalism with a "human" face - This is not even a paradox. hi

    The state must determine with whom and for whom it is. For their citizens or for individuals. am
    1. Vadivak
      Vadivak 6 December 2013 15: 59
      +2
      Quote: GrBear
      The author, I sincerely hope, is mistaken about the incentives and professionalism of the team.


      Vova plays music ......
      1. Yarosvet
        Yarosvet 6 December 2013 19: 14
        +4
        Quote: Vadivak
        Vova plays music ......
        1. Vadivak
          Vadivak 6 December 2013 20: 59
          +2
          Quote: Yarosvet
          Vova plays music ......


          Dima is dancing hopak ....
          1. Yarosvet
            Yarosvet 6 December 2013 21: 31
            0
            Quote: Vadivak
            Dima is dancing hopak ....
  12. avt
    avt 6 December 2013 15: 48
    +2
    Quote: ziqzaq
    It seems that Khazin has some calculations that if corruption is reduced to an acceptable level (not even completely!) And the number of officials is reduced to the level of the USSR,

    request laughing Just think of a binomial of Newton! Yes, for this, no Khazin with calculations is needed. But we are not in the 37th year.
  13. Stinger
    Stinger 6 December 2013 15: 53
    +1
    You might think that the decrees are written personally by the president. Those who write, or at least agree, are the ones who should do it. And the desire to please when writing (approval) obscures the mind. Everything works out smoothly until you start doing it. It is clear to the student that no "small business" can save such a huge country. Only industrialization based on the latest technologies. Instead of encouraging firms that import and implement the latest technologies, as the Japanese did in their time, and now the Chinese, they again threw Chubaishin.
  14. grafrozow
    grafrozow 6 December 2013 15: 56
    +4
    And we began to wait. But soon unpleasant signals began to appear and the first conversations that the government could not cope with the tasks assigned to it. We cautiously assumed that if it "does not pull," then it makes sense to change it to a more capable composition. However, Vladimir Putin himself rejected this idea, explaining that too little time had passed to ask for the execution of decrees. And we began to wait further.
    How long ??? Medveputy rage with fat, I work hard 12 hours a day, it's time to pick up a gun, it's time ....
    1. Vadivak
      Vadivak 6 December 2013 16: 03
      +7
      Quote: grafrozow
      ? Medveputy rage with fat, I work hard 12 hours a day,


      Yes, we are aware ..

      As for my personal perception, I am not ashamed of the citizens who voted for me. All these eight years I have been plowing like a slave in galleys, with full dedication. I am pleased with the results of my work.
      Putin
      Press Conference February 14, 2008 in the Kremlin

      About the conditions of slave labor on this site
      http://www.putin-itogi.ru/rab-na-galerah/




      1. grafrozow
        grafrozow 6 December 2013 21: 03
        0
        Quote: Vadivak
        . All these eight years I have been plowing like a slave in the galleys, with full dedication. I am pleased with the results of my work.
        Putin
        Press Conference February 14, 2008 in the Kremlin
        Laughing, cool joke. +++++
    2. The comment was deleted.
  15. sashka
    sashka 6 December 2013 16: 00
    +2
    Chubais will build an anode
    Fine. Just lovely .. So long and long waited. Where else to put money. Pockets prevent walking ..
  16. Fin
    Fin 6 December 2013 16: 15
    +4
    nobody in the government really knows how to achieve high performance.

    And there no one was going to reach them. The main principle of liberals is non-interference in the economy, the market will do everything itself. For 8 years, the economy grew by itself, at the expense of sold resources, and then the crisis got close - banks and oligarchs were flooded with dough, they seemed to slip through. For 4 years, no conclusions have been drawn, the re-equipment of industry, construction of housing, infrastructure, roads have not begun. There is a sudden "unexpected" decrease in rates, and they do not know what to do, and even too late, the results will be visible in a few years. And so they have not been doing for 13 years. A donkey who stood in the shade in the sun will not work. Therefore, now they will begin to talk about subjective reasons, the hand of the West .....
    LADIES together with the "government" are incapacitated. The maximum they can do is cut somewhere in the budget, add somewhere.
    1. Yarosvet
      Yarosvet 6 December 2013 19: 23
      +1
      Quote: Fin
      LADIES together with the "government" are incapacitated. The maximum they can do is cut somewhere in the budget, add somewhere.
  17. sashka
    sashka 6 December 2013 16: 45
    +3
    "Kalina" yellow ended. We will wait for the next "twist" .. The clownery continues. The holiday is endless.
  18. polkownik1
    polkownik1 6 December 2013 17: 09
    +1
    Today Medvedev said that he was satisfied with the work of his ministers. And our situation is better than in Europe. The prime minister could not speak like that without knowing the opinion of the president; in Russia this is not yet possible. This means that the author's idea of ​​a "jerk" does not work ... We will wait for "to dissolve by itself."
    1. Yarosvet
      Yarosvet 6 December 2013 19: 27
      +1
      Quote: polkownik1
      Today, Medvedev said he was pleased with the work of his ministers
  19. saag
    saag 6 December 2013 17: 19
    0
    If the presidential decrees began to merge, that is, the assumption that by the year commercials will merge himself too, and that he himself will be to blame, just like Yanukovych
  20. polkownik1
    polkownik1 6 December 2013 17: 20
    +2
    And two more words about incentives. Sitting in a "sharashka", the great aircraft designer Polikarpov created the best fighter of the Great Patriotic War, the I-185 in three months. German designers in two months created the Henschel-162 jet fighter in the same years; they managed to put it into series ... You can talk about "the trunk at the back of the head", you can talk about patriotism. I think there is only one thing: to apply any methods of stimulation to our existing government. Useless. They can not ! They are not Polikarpovs and not those Germans. All sorts of leaps should be planned and started with the selection of personnel, extremely tough and honest. And then the incentives ...
  21. sashka
    sashka 6 December 2013 17: 35
    0
    These forecasts for whom? For lady or gdp. Maybe for the Bad. ? Amazing Russian Language .. We can do everything. We can do everything .. And as the last slut we go anywhere. Shame on you?
  22. KazaK Bo
    KazaK Bo 6 December 2013 17: 37
    +2
    Quote: AVV
    The only incentive for the brotherhood of managers should be his current position and work for the good of the state !!! And if such an individual fails to show the confidence of the state and the people, then deprive him of the opportunity to head some kind of state institution for a period of at least 5 years !!!

    Today I listened to the press conference of our restless liber optimist A. Medvedev. Despite the direct hints of his counterpart in an interview that it was time to leave ... our second liberal Kinder kept on bending his line ...I will work until 70 years old (God forbid us from this !!!) ... I like what I do ... and I am pleased to observe the results of my work! The results of his work ... however, very deplorable ... only the growth of the economy fell more than 2,5 times ... It turns out that our prime minister is pleased that our economy, under his incompetent leadership, is falling apart !!!! And he enjoys the results of such a failed activity. Nonsense ... however! Of course, now is not the 37th year ... but even in the current CC there are articles, in a pinch, FOR NEGLIGENCE !!! Is it time for our PRESIDENT and the PROSECUTOR GENERAL to familiarize the Prime Minister with these articles of the Criminal Code? Maybe then he will not be so pleased with his work and there will be another interest in the results of his work .... So it’s not about lustration (removal) for 5 years .. but more serious claims to those who are ruining the country's economy and looks with interest and pleasure at the results of his disgrace.
    1. Yarosvet
      Yarosvet 6 December 2013 19: 30
      +1
      Quote: KazaK Bo
      Despite the direct hints of his counterpart in an interview that it was time to leave ... our second liberal Kinder kept on bending his line ... [b] I will work until 70
    2. military
      military 9 December 2013 10: 14
      0
      Quote: KazaK Bo
      Today I listened to the press conference of our restless liber optimist A. Medvedev. Despite the direct hints of his counterpart in an interview that it was time to leave ... our second liberal Kinder kept on bending his line ... I will work until 70 years old (God save us from this !!!) ... I like what I do ... and I am pleased to observe the results of my work!

      mother walrus! belay give birth to this insane person back! ... am
  23. basmach
    basmach 6 December 2013 18: 01
    +2
    Well, the May decrees are in good agreement with the current reduction of the federal budget by 5% and the freezing of salaries to the federals (army, police, etc.) for 2 years. Let's add that of the 16 trillion rubles worth of products supplied abroad (real products, note), the budget gets only 5 trillion. This is the result of his long and fruitful activity as president and head of government. And it is stupid to accuse officials of something (negligence, sabotage, etc.) This is HIS team, which he selected, nominated and leads. which, accordingly, carries out his orders, otherwise the punishment in the form of a corruption scandal follows. However, the created image of the "one and only irreplaceable" continues to operate. And the bulk continues to believe in a good kind caring (but knowing little about the affairs of our sorrowful) king and creepy negligent thieving venal boyars of his (who dynamite the king-father himself) .It is interesting that such a GDP and a gop-company should make it so that they stop believing in it and they realized that he was leading the country to destruction. But just won't it be too late?
  24. demotivator
    demotivator 6 December 2013 18: 17
    +1
    Such statements by Putin’s subordinates are nothing but a mockery of him. And what? At first, a huge suitcase was served at his porch. Is there a hint? And after a few days, his own government declares that the president signs his decrees, in particular the May decrees, being, to put it mildly, not in himself. Our president’s colleagues have publicly stated that Putin’s decrees are not feasible. Read - we will not fulfill them. Maybe Vladimir Putin demanded the impossible from the government? No, quite feasible documents. Today, ministers say they will not comply with Putin’s instructions about reducing housing costs and creating new jobs, and tomorrow they’ll put the device on the Kremlin in general on any issue? God forbid that the Minister of Foreign Affairs or the Minister of Defense in an interview with the BBC begin to say that Putin is certainly the president, but they fully support NATO’s position on Syria. Or the Minister of Transport will say that throughout the country we will change asphalt roads to tiles.
    A reasonable question: can the president of Russia really demand the impossible from the government? No, many have read these decrees. In other very capitalist countries, much more was achieved in less time. And even in communist China and Vietnam. There is a simple conclusion: our government is worse than the governments of Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan, China, and Vietnam. I don’t even want to talk about the USA and the EU.
    1. Yarosvet
      Yarosvet 6 December 2013 19: 36
      0
      Quote: demotivator
      job creation
  25. demotivator
    demotivator 6 December 2013 18: 25
    +2
    Quote: KazaK Bo
    economic growth fell more than 2,5 times ...

    This is how to understand "... growth ... fell"? You can simply say that the growth stopped and the decline began. Or kato more. But growth has fallen - that's something!
  26. Enot-poloskun
    Enot-poloskun 6 December 2013 18: 40
    0
    For our country to have economic growth, we need to invest in our economy.

    I do not understand why the government is storing money in stabilization funds!

    It would be better to invest money in Russia, at least in large infrastructure projects (roads, cities, industries, etc.). Even if half were stolen, there would be normal economic growth!

    And now ... Oil this year is more expensive than the government predicted. Dollars that way for 10 ...

    And growth is below the baseboard!

    PS For such a growth, you need to put some small iPhone in the ass to vibrate!
    1. military
      military 9 December 2013 10: 26
      0
      Quote: Enot-poloskun
      PS For such a growth, you need to put some small iPhone in the ass to vibrate!

      a jackhammer for him, not an iPhone ... and so that it "vibrates" ...
  27. Karabin
    Karabin 6 December 2013 19: 54
    +3
    The May decrees of Vladimir Putin, as we recall, were greeted positively and even somewhere with enthusiasm. Because it seemed that the president, now back at his post, would ask officials for their implementation in all severity. And because of this, in the depths of my soul, confidence was born that one way or another they would be fulfilled. Well, even if not 100%, we are all human. But even being 80% fulfilled, they promised us the May decrees of Vladimir Putin, as we recall, were greeted positively and even somewhere with enthusiasm. Because it seemed that the president, now returning to his post, would ask officials in all severity for their implementation. And because of this, in the depths of my soul, confidence was born that one way or another they would be fulfilled. Well, even if not 100%, we are all human. But even being 80% fulfilled, they promised us a lot of pleasant and useful things for the country ..

    A lot of water has flowed under the bridge since May. And where is the demand? The guarantor has repeatedly stated that he is pleased with the work of the government. So maybe the decrees are really impracticable? Or was the "galley slave" so overstrained during the first two terms that he was unable to control the progress of the execution of the decrees and exercise considerable power?
    It seems to me that the May decrees mentioned by the author were precisely designed to arouse "enthusiasm" and expectations of "many pleasant and useful things for the country," which they coped brilliantly with. Now I would ask the signatory of the decrees for deceived "expectations with enthusiasm", but no, the guarantor for the author of the article is a sacred figure, and is responsible for the decrees, and not for the final result.
  28. Beck
    Beck 6 December 2013 20: 26
    +2
    Putin is not to blame.

    The government is not to blame.

    The officials are not to blame.

    That’s all, CORRECTLY say, apologetically the Jewish-Masonic secret world organization, financial bosses of the West, dermocratic and liberal propaganda, the machinations of the British backstage, the actions of aliens who fell under the influence of the United States and, in addition to everything, anti-Russian otherworldly forces.

    It is they who, by all kinds of their countermeasures, reduce the growth of the economy, and the government has to puff for them. The main thing that needs to be done for prosperity is to overwhelm the US economy until it is completely ruined, put all amers back in the Stone Age. All the Masons in Antarctica, to the penguins. Small British banks on the City to disassemble to the foundation. All the shit and liberals are united and merged into one, and in the Caspian Lake they should be drowned, half a gram of sugar sprinkled on the tongue, and on the neck of the pebbles and in the lake of the blasts. Against aliens, put up a sanitary cordon led by Onishchenko in near space. Along the entire border of the state to place psychics, clairvoyants, northern shamans, rural fortunetellers to drive away otherworldly forces.

    It’s only after all these gruesome events that the Urashniki have suggested more than once that the figures for economic growth will begin to grow in leaps of the driven hare.
    1. Yarosvet
      Yarosvet 6 December 2013 21: 35
      0
      Quote: Beck
      To place psychics, clairvoyants, northern shamans, rural fortunetellers across the state’s border to drive away otherworldly forces

      Performed...
    2. aksakal
      aksakal 6 December 2013 21: 59
      0
      Quote: Beck
      Putin is not to blame.

      The government is not to blame.

      The officials are not to blame.

      That’s all, CORRECTLY say, apologetically the Jewish-Masonic secret world organization, financial bosses of the West, dermocratic and liberal propaganda, the machinations of the British backstage, the actions of aliens who fell under the influence of the United States and, in addition to everything, anti-Russian otherworldly forces.

      It is they who, by all kinds of their countermeasures, reduce the growth of the economy, and the government has to puff for them. The main thing that needs to be done for prosperity is to overwhelm the US economy until it is completely ruined, put all amers back in the Stone Age. All the Masons in Antarctica, to the penguins. Small British banks on the City to disassemble to the foundation. All the shit and liberals are united and merged into one, and in the Caspian Lake they should be drowned, half a gram of sugar sprinkled on the tongue, and on the neck of the pebbles and in the lake of the blasts. Against aliens, put up a sanitary cordon led by Onishchenko in near space. Along the entire border of the state to place psychics, clairvoyants, northern shamans, rural fortunetellers to drive away otherworldly forces.

      It’s only after all these gruesome events that the Urashniki have suggested more than once that the figures for economic growth will begin to grow in leaps of the driven hare.
      - You are proposing a case, not just all Americans to Antartida, but Wall Street guys (the criteria will still be worked out. Bekov is going to penal servitude in Karlag (this is near Karaganda, you'll like it).
      And according to Beck, the true culprit is to exchange the people for another people. Then there will be happiness
  29. sashka
    sashka 6 December 2013 20: 44
    0
    nobody in the government really knows how to achieve high performance.
    Golden words. Then look our rush.
  30. I think so
    I think so 6 December 2013 22: 01
    0
    Loafers and sackclaws whined in the Kremlin ... How are they trying to get them to fulfill their (!) Election promises ... Guard! Where is democracy? I think that if someone can’t do something, then it should be replaced by someone who can ... I don’t believe that in Russia EVERYTHING has already become impotent ... there are probably real men too, but every thing has overshadowed them and prefers on television and in the press ...
  31. Ivanovich47
    Ivanovich47 6 December 2013 22: 21
    0
    Reading another opus on "another downgrade of the growth forecast for Russia" You start to think: But what is the political and economic elite of Russia doing to ensure this growth? The answer is simple as true: NEVER MIND! So what growth should we wait? The Russian economy is "pulled" by the swan, cancer and pike. And the load of the Russian economy stands still.
  32. Alex 63
    Alex 63 6 December 2013 23: 57
    0
    I think that democracy is not something that meets the requirements of the Russians to the political structure of the country. We always hope that a new one will come (Gorbachev, Yeltsin, Putin, Medvedev, Putin again) and finally bring (perestroika, freedom from the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, the fight against crime and devastation, order, the fight against corruption ... - choose yourself), those. We hope, as in all ages, for the GOOD Tsar, father. And as always, he is not to blame, here the boyars (officials) are interfering with him! Maybe it's time to introduce the monarchy, since everyone in their hearts hopes for the Tsar? We are waiting for everything to be done for us. We cannot go to a rally with demands, for example, introduce a law stating that: "if such an individual fails the confidence of the state and the people, then deprive him of the opportunity to head some state institution for a period of at least 5 years !!! regrettable as it may seem, with Serdyukov, who failed his job in one post, and he was transferred to another state post, and generally convicted figures or those involved in especially grave corruption cases, to deprive such a right to work in state structures for life !!! "- quote from of this forum from AVV (1) SU Today, 14:59
  33. avg
    avg 7 December 2013 00: 26
    0
    The plan is very simple. For a couple of years, declare a moratorium on new reforms, great ideas and breakthrough state programs, and take elementary restoring order.
    It would be nice to invite a couple of tax officers-mattress officers to share their experience of how to deal with "fat cats", but they will definitely turn out to be CIA officers. yes
  34. Samsebenaum
    Samsebenaum 7 December 2013 11: 18
    +2
    "The Ministry of Economic Development has worsened the forecast for the growth of the Russian economy."
    What do we want? Which way we are going, the path will lead there.
    For many years, entertainment and shopping centers have been growing like mushrooms after rain ...
    If domestic new factories and plants, farms and research centers had grown so quickly, we did not discuss this problem today.
    Not in May decrees alone. A development strategy is needed.
    I would, to be honest, instructed the Communists.