Military Review

Expert Yury Krupnov: “Confusion turned out”

33
Expert Yury Krupnov: “Confusion turned out”
The founder of the Civil Initiatives Committee, Alexei Kudrin, suggests eliminating the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Federal Drug Control Service, dividing the police into three independent levels.



What consequences this may lead, the Chairman of the Development Movement Yuri KRUPNOV reflects.

- It is not for the first time that Alexey Kudrin acts as a subject, about whose activities we can say the well-known proverb: “The road to hell is paved with good intentions”. As head of the Ministry of Finance, he drained the country's economy, practically eliminated a long-term loan and normal money circulation. This paralyzed the full activity of the industry. Of course, Alexey Leonidovich never said that he is achieving just such results. He sincerely convinced the public that he was eager for de-bureaucratization and macro-financial stabilization, and he fiercely struggled with inflation.

Having established the Civil Initiatives Committee (OIG), Kudrin proposed a police reorganization plan developed with the help of experts. And again, the concept is based on supposedly extremely good intentions and concern for the public good. They say that the police are overloaded with work and are focused on the performance of indicators. But the law enforcement system as a whole slows down economic growth and creates instability ...

The measures proposed by him should result in the liquidation of the Ministry of the Interior and the Federal Drug Control Service (FDCS). There will be three levels of police: municipal - accountable to the city authorities, regional - subordinate to the governor and federal, which reports to the president. Kudrin hopes that the division of responsibility will complicate the emergence of the local "police mafia" and prevent new Kuschevka.

Just the opposite! The rejection of the law enforcement vertical, which, for all its flaws, ensures relative stability, will lead to dramatically negative consequences - to the merging of local criminals and "werewolves in shoulder straps" from the municipal police. To the formation of local zones of local total and unlimited violence against the population by the criminals. Moreover, with the recent extraction of a colossal economic effect from such a situation. There will be "superkushchevki", against the background of which the massacre in the above-mentioned Kuban village may seem like a minor incident.

To offer, like Kudrin, to liquidate the Federal Drug Control Service means to objectively play into the hands of the drug mafia. This service, created by 10 years ago, has proven its effectiveness in combating the “drug lords” that swept the country at the time. Already by 2006, in many respects, it was possible to reverse the mortality situation, reducing it among men and women aged from 15 to 34 years. Because there was a barrier in the path of drugs from Afghanistan.
A unified law enforcement system allows criminality to be curbed by the authorities from above, if this is not done at the lower levels. In Kudrin, all levels of the police are autonomous, independent of each other. But then how to effectively deal with crime? To liquidate the unified system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, to completely and irrevocably divide the police into levels, instead of “stitching” them, is to inflict a powerful blow to statehood. No federal service for the disclosure of crime officials proposed to create, will not replace this system. An investigation is already a post factum, but it is necessary to preempt a crime.

For nothing, Mr. Kudrin once again tried to impose supposedly "universal" liberal patterns on real life. The result was embarrassing. It remains to hope that the part of the public, on whose behalf Kudrin and Co. like to broadcast, is aware of this faster than in past years.
Originator:
http://file-rf.ru/context/3011
33 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. alexng
    alexng 13 November 2013 08: 21
    +3
    Zadolbal already this Kudrin with his curls.
    1. I do not care
      I do not care 13 November 2013 11: 53
      0
      Kudrin climbs to reform the Ministry of Internal Affairs laughing It remains to Nurgaliyev to take care of the Ministry of Finance,
      , and Shoigu, education. Although I think the latter would have better results.
    2. Alez
      Alez 13 November 2013 12: 38
      +1
      Kudrin on a stake, you can on a rocket and out of sight out of Russia. Ginger chubais and other liberals in the Netherlands hold gay parades.
    3. Mizhgan
      Mizhgan 14 November 2013 04: 17
      0
      It is high time Kudrin to withdraw from the political arena.
  2. domokl
    domokl 13 November 2013 08: 22
    +2
    It’s interesting, but when Kudrin is looking at the West, is he on his knees? Or is he still on his feet? The proposal is delusional precisely because local authorities, including law enforcement agencies, will very soon become shtetl.
    1. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov 13 November 2013 08: 28
      +7
      Quote: domokl
      It’s interesting, but when Kudrin is looking at the West, is he kneeling? Or is he still on his feet?

      No Sasha, he turns his back and bends a little.
      Hi hi
      1. aksakal
        aksakal 13 November 2013 08: 35
        +2
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        No Sasha, he turns his back and bends a little

        - no, after all, sometimes she kneels and faces the west, faithfully looking from the bottom up into the eyes, not forgetting to move
        1. not good
          not good 13 November 2013 12: 46
          0
          Kudrin is not standing, but hooves peek out from under his trousers.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  3. The comment was deleted.
  4. Alexander Romanov
    Alexander Romanov 13 November 2013 08: 22
    +2
    But Putin also put this clown to work. Even the wrong people are in authority of our government. Maybe Kudrin himself should be eliminated, but what, the country will definitely not get any worse.
    1. Rif
      Rif 13 November 2013 12: 40
      0
      I suspect that V. Putin puts them on positions so that "their foolishness was visible."
      1. not good
        not good 13 November 2013 12: 48
        0
        The nonsense is visible, but why do millions of normal people pay for the "luck" of one fool? Although in the logic of the appointees of the GDP one can see the Leninist principle: to destroy it to the ground, and then ... Maybe then Kudrin will go to the premiere right away ???
  5. borisjdin1957
    borisjdin1957 13 November 2013 08: 22
    0
    from the Don.
    Dear Kudrin! GDP is crazy about him! Is it really LGBT?
  6. The comment was deleted.
  7. Valery Neonov
    13 November 2013 08: 24
    +1
    So, I launched the economy around the world, now I’m getting to the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Federal Drug Control Service ... to reform the reform from DAM .. wassat
  8. Alikovo
    Alikovo 13 November 2013 08: 25
    0
    if understood correctly, Kudrin proposes to create a police force in the United States.
    1. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov 13 November 2013 08: 29
      +1
      Quote: Alikovo
      if understood correctly, Kudrin proposes to create a police force in the United States.

      Yeah, the sheriff will choose laughing
      1. Eugeniy_369
        Eugeniy_369 13 November 2013 09: 50
        +2
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        Yeah, the sheriff will choose

        I think the idea is not bad, just not a sheriff but a local. Our local police officer will appear once a month and everything is ok)))) He doesn’t even know who his name is, despite the fact that the inhabitants of his district can be counted on the finger. There was an idea to relocate precincts to their plots, but they didn’t give finances, to see Kudrin squeezed the money recourse
        I’m certainly not an expert, but I think that the Ministry of Internal Affairs is too big, for example, employees of private security agencies seem to be like policemen, but they do security business (prices by the way are Akhov’s belay ), I think the commercial activities of the state. The department should not be engaged.
      2. IRBIS
        IRBIS 13 November 2013 10: 25
        +1
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        Yeah, the sheriff will choose

        And, as you know, the problems of the Sheriff’s Indians aren’t ..., well, further in meaning ...
      3. Corsair
        Corsair 13 November 2013 13: 54
        +1
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        Yeah, the sheriff will choose

        This is one whose PROBLEMS are not ** ut?!?
    2. Nayhas
      Nayhas 13 November 2013 09: 32
      0
      Quote: Alikovo
      if understood correctly, Kudrin proposes to create a police force in the United States.

      No. It’s different there.
  9. major071
    major071 13 November 2013 08: 35
    +4
    The road to hell is paved with good intentions. Naive Kudrin or thought everything out well? He justifies the reorganization by the fact that there is no need to spend money on it, as if they will be taken from the reduction of "extra" employees.
  10. 311ove
    311ove 13 November 2013 08: 50
    0
    I’ll think like in civilian: red came-rob, white came-rob, green came -..... wassat But seriously, how are they already ....... !!!
  11. Was mammoth
    Was mammoth 13 November 2013 08: 51
    +1
    "Seven nannies have a child without an eye."
    That is the whole point of his proposal.
  12. Nayhas
    Nayhas 13 November 2013 09: 00
    +2
    To offer, like Kudrin, to liquidate the Federal Drug Control Service means to objectively play into the hands of the drug mafia. This service, created by 10 years ago, has proven its effectiveness in combating the “drug lords” that swept the country at the time. Already by 2006, in many respects, it was possible to reverse the mortality situation, reducing it among men and women aged from 15 to 34 years. Because there was a barrier in the path of drugs from Afghanistan.

    Is the author serious? Yes, buying drugs is easier than buying alcohol after 21 p.m.! Not for nothing the Gosnarkokontrol is called the Gosnarkokartel ...
    1. Eugeniy_369
      Eugeniy_369 13 November 2013 10: 05
      +1
      Quote: Nayhas
      Is the author serious? Yes, buying drugs is easier than buying alcohol after 21 p.m.! Not for nothing the Gosnarkokontrol is called the Gosnarkokartel ...

      I support unconditionally. This department was created to
      to attach tax police officers.
      On July 1, 2003, by decree of the President of the Russian Federation V. Putin No. 306 dated March 11, 2003, the Federal Tax Police Service was abolished without explanation. Most of the functions of the Federal Security Service of Russia and the state of 16 thousand units are transferred to the Ministry of Internal Affairs. The material base and 40 thousand staff units were transferred to the newly created Gosnarkokontrol.
      Who wants to see forty thousand unemployed, healthy, evil men? Yes, and Cherkesov had to be attached somewhere, still not an outsider laughing
      Before its creation, I believe the drug departments in the Ministry of Internal Affairs worked just as well.
      The author of the article apparently never encountered the work of police-police, then such nonsense would not have written. Let him come to me, I will show him in action-Refusal from the law enforcement vertical, which, with all its flaws, provides relative stability, will lead to sharply negative consequences - to the merging of local criminals and “werewolves in uniform” from the municipal police.
    2. dmb
      dmb 13 November 2013 10: 14
      +2
      The author is certainly disingenuous. It is clear that Kudrin's proposals are yet another "manilovism", but Krupnov, speaking about the centralized system of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, shyly keeps silent that it will work effectively only with real social equality. Under capitalism, this is a priori impossible, especially with our Russian mentality. You don't have to go far to compare the level of crime, including hidden crime in the 70s and now. Of course there will be those who want to remember Sweden. They can be reminded that the society that exists there is called "Swedish socialism", and it is not so good there lately. And it is necessary to compare not with San Marino or Andorra, but with states similar in area, size and composition of population and relative level of development. There are only two of these, the United States and China. The fact that the crime rate in the USA was higher than in the USSR can only be disputed by the crazy woman Lera. China is probably not worth talking about.
  13. pv1005
    pv1005 13 November 2013 09: 28
    0
    I suggest reforming (reducing) EFFECTIVE MANAGERS, and put professionals in their place.
  14. Zerstorer
    Zerstorer 13 November 2013 09: 52
    0
    This is not the time for such reforms. Although oddly enough there is some common sense here. If we create a specialized structure to deal with something, then very soon there will be a symbiosis of these fighters with what they are fighting. For example, the Drug Control Service in the United States (well, or whatever they are called there). They have their own lured drug dealers, and they themselves destroy their competitors - this is mutually beneficial cooperation. And given that half of us live in our country not according to the laws, but according to concepts, and close interaction between law enforcement agencies and criminal groups ...
    In general, specialized services to combat anything can only work effectively under tight control.
    1. Grbear
      Grbear 13 November 2013 10: 16
      +1
      Dear Zerstorer.

      To combat splicing (symbiosis), there are internal security agencies and a non-functioning personnel rotation system.

      With what I agree, it is that working with "dirt" and not getting dirty is a difficult task for any person, especially in our corrupt-tolerant value system.

      And Kudrin is a zapadlenets negative .
  15. Sterlya
    Sterlya 13 November 2013 10: 27
    0
    Where do these "economists" come from? There are also in Russia. many smart honest people. Why are most roosters in power
  16. ed65b
    ed65b 13 November 2013 10: 41
    +3
    Federal Drug Control Service (FSKN).

    I am personally always alarmed by the word "control" What is there to control, protect? You have to fight, not control. Ksati deputy on drug addicts well, a very rich man or rather his wife. Babos from where, from Afghanistan?
    1. Eugeniy_369
      Eugeniy_369 13 November 2013 11: 56
      +2
      Quote: ed65b
      Ksati is a deputy for drug addiction. Well, a very rich man, or rather his wife. Babos from where, from Afghanistan?

      You can see right away Edward in the subject))))))), I also read about the wife of Kalanda Vladimir Alexandrovich. Lucky for him or her?
    2. alone
      alone 13 November 2013 19: 32
      +1
      Where is this all from? - asked Y. Nikulin's wife in the film "The Diamond Hand"

      from there !! - answered drunk Nikulin.
  17. not good
    not good 13 November 2013 13: 02
    0
    Maybe it’s not in a hurry to reform, but rather strengthen control over and responsibility of the authorities, but rather strengthen personal responsibility (which would always be extreme), well, in the worst case, transfer your own security to the hands of a competing structure (like the FSB), otherwise any reform our government has it either just to sew a new uniform or a revolution in Serdyukov’s way, which is then neither the department nor the guilty.
  18. Ivanovich47
    Ivanovich47 13 November 2013 13: 08
    -1
    One gets the impression that Kudrin is being manipulated by someone from across the ocean. The Americans really want to bring chaos and discord into Russian society. And Kudrin's "ideas" are aimed precisely at this.
  19. Fobos-grunt
    Fobos-grunt 13 November 2013 13: 25
    0
    Quote: dmb
    You don’t have to go far, compare the crime rate, including, hidden, in the 70s and now

    Then there was a really strong Ministry of Internal Affairs under the leadership of Shchelokov NA. The call of a modest police squad made an impression that today (not always) a special forces group with machine guns and grenade launchers could make.
    In contrast to the Ministry of Internal Affairs, there was a strong KGB of Yuri Andropov. Between the secret services there was serious competition from which ordinary citizens won. The scandals surrounding Minister Shchelokov and his suicide seriously damaged the situation in the Ministry of Internal Affairs, in the country as a whole, and as a result contributed to the collapse of the USSR.
    Today everything is distributed there is no competition: "hand washes hand"
  20. Peaceful military
    Peaceful military 13 November 2013 13: 45
    +1
    Lord, when will these liberalists be neutralized? Well, how much more do you need to ditch the people so that this scum was swept away, or is it all, the point of no return is passed?
    1. Eugeniy_369
      Eugeniy_369 13 November 2013 15: 22
      0
      Quote: Peaceful military
      point of no return passed?

      No return to where?
      1. Peaceful military
        Peaceful military 13 November 2013 22: 19
        -1
        Quote: Eugeniy_369
        Quote: Peaceful military
        point of no return passed?

        No return to where?

        For the "guys from the armored train" I explain, the point of no return to the future ... Only liberalized people do not want to see this. Well, these individuals are enemies of Russians and Russia / Rus. hi
        1. Eugeniy_369
          Eugeniy_369 14 November 2013 22: 16
          +1
          Quote: Peaceful military
          For the "guys from the armored train" I explain, the point of no return to the future ... Only liberalized people do not want to see this. Well, these individuals are enemies of Russians and Russia / Rus.

          Eco kicked you request , well, drink a little to calm down wassat
          For children "shell-shocked in childhood" -LIBERAL - a political freethinker who thinks or acts freely; generally wanting big freedom of the people and self-government.
          It is because of such a pancake of "statists" that the people are in favor and consider it to be.
  21. DimYang
    DimYang 13 November 2013 14: 18
    0
    It is time to recognize that this is an enemy of the state and the Russian people. Well, already with them. But what to do with them, so the people have long passed their sentence to them.
  22. DimYang
    DimYang 13 November 2013 17: 00
    0
    Someone minusanul. Well, I'm talking about Kudrin and his ilk.