Military Review

"Monitor the Caucasus and put pressure on Russia"

59



The International Crisis Group (ICG) published a report in early September entitled The North Caucasus: The Challenges of Integration (III), Governance, Elections, Rule of Law. This document is the third part of the project, which is both research and advisory in nature. The first part, which was released in October 2012, was devoted to ethnic conflicts, and the second part - to the Islamic factor, militants and counter-terrorism activities in the region. It is worth noting that previous reports played a certain role in shaping public opinion about political processes, in particular, among organizations and communities in the region that are in opposition to the authorities (this concerns not only Russia, but also neighboring countries, which, one way or another, are connected with Northern Caucasus, either through ethnopolitics, or in the context of religion, or on issues of geopolitics and regional security).

First of all, the conclusions presented in this report are intended for Russia - both federal and North Caucasian authorities, but also for various European institutions - PACE, the Council of Europe, etc. At the same time, the recommendation for the EU is in one proposal - to continue monitor the North Caucasus region and put pressure on Russia to fully implement all decisions of the European Court of Human Rights.

And the findings of the report and the opinion that the ICG want to convey are quite predictable.

It is stated that “authentic improvement of the quality of governance in the North Caucasus is possible only if democratic institutions are established, such as elections, an independent judiciary, and the rule of law. Fair elections, prior to the competitive political process, are a prerequisite for responsible. "

This thesis is clearly aimed at asserting that there are no democratic institutions in the North Caucasus, and instead of them - corruption, violence, clan wars, unemployment, terrorism and extremism under the guise of Islamism, which was repeatedly mentioned in the report. It is noted that "the fight against the criminal activities of clan networks should be vigorous and consistent, but strictly within the law. The first steps in Dagestan give grounds for optimism and should be continued."

But it also says that "the lack of democratic legitimacy and accountability, gross violations of human rights and impunity of officials have made a great contribution to the spread of the conflict."

In addition, the authors insist on further decentralization: "the functioning of the federal system with a degree of decentralization and the corresponding regional representation in the Duma in Moscow will contribute to the integration of the North Caucasus with the rest of Russia. Such integration is necessary for the country's security, healthy interethnic relations and stability. While the conflict in the North Caucasus is expressed through violent insurrection and intense inter-ethnic relations, the lack of democratic institutions, the upper nstva law and people's trust in the state fueling instability ... "Again, we see an indication of the lack of democracy. Although it is not entirely clear how the authors intend to implement decentralization simultaneously with integration. At least, the experience of the EU suggests otherwise. Cultural autonomy and community rights are curtailed in the face of the bureaucracy of the European Commission and the Council of Europe, imposing their "values" and rules on all EU members. The importance of strengthening tolerance and multiculturalism is also pointed out. Although this project was a failure in the leading countries of Europe, as the heads of Great Britain, France and Germany admitted, it is not entirely clear why they want to impose it on Russia. Perhaps, on the contrary, to worsen the situation in the North Caucasus so that the federal authorities could be blamed for this?

Against the background of the support of the Albanians in Kosovo to the detriment of Serbian interests, the recommendation to the governments of the North Caucasus to solve the problems of territorial disputes more concisely and comprehensively seems rather strange.

Of course, we in no way deny the need to improve the overall climate in the republics. More active interaction with local communities, the fight against terrorism and religious extremism, and the launch of various social, political and economic programs are needed, but this must be done not through the prism of Eurocentric geopolitics, but taking into account the traditional way, all-Russian identity and national interests of our country in the region which may be contrary to the interests of other actors, such as Turkey or Azerbaijan.

It should be noted that the report is submitted without authorship. Although the material contains references to sources, it is not entirely clear who was involved in data collection, because in the North Caucasus it is necessary to have its own people. Although the ICG emissaries are clearly available in this region, this approach is not entirely clear. It is possible that the ICG is trying in advance to disclaim responsibility either for the unreliability of the facts presented in the work, or for the possible consequences that may lead to the pathetic conclusions of the report.

At the same time, it is necessary to pay attention not only to the text itself, but also to the structure of the organization itself. Having identified who belongs to it, it will be possible to trace the connection with the region and the interests of the participants. And the list of members of the ICG is quite “stellar”, even, rather, “star-striped” - the participation of US citizens in this structure is so great.

Among the organization’s advisers are Zbigniew Brzezinski, one of the oldest Israeli politicians Shimon Peres, liquidator of the aftermath of the Iraq war in 1991 and conductor of Western interests in negotiations with Yugoslavia in 1999. Marti Ahtisaari, Saudi Prince Turki al-Faisal, the nineteenth prime minister Canadian Minister Kim Campbell and many other powers. In the same place the domestic liberal Grigory Yavlinsky was noticed. The executive committee has Wesley Clark, former head of the NATO High Command, Kofi Annan, the good old US man at the United Nations, philanthropist speculator George Soros, and former NATO Secretary General Javier Solana. You can find the former Foreign Minister Igor Ivanov. Considering the clearly pro-Western orientation of the structure of the Russian Council on International Affairs headed by him (you can see the unfortunate clone of the American Council on Foreign Relations in the name), it is quite likely that his role is not only as a wedding general, but possibly in providing the necessary information to western partners on the same INF.

Meanwhile, one of the founders of the ICG is Morton Abramovich, a former US Assistant Secretary of State and a former US Ambassador to Turkey. A number of analysts pointed out that he is lobbying the interests of Turkey, including the Turkish presence in Cyprus. Another supporter of Ankara is another founder, Stefan Solarts, who is also a member of the American-Turkish Committee. Also, the members of the ICG Executive Committee include two Turkish politicians and a number of European leaders engaged in engaging Turkey in the EU, which speaks of the obvious pro-Turkish interests of the organization. Moreover, some researchers drew on its anti-Armenian character.

By the way, Brzezinski and Solarts are co-chairmen of the “American Committee for Peace in Chechnya” - the structure responsible for the open support and transfer of funds to Chechen militants. Another ICG adviser, Kenneth Adelman, is also on this committee.

Corporate interests are also clearly represented in the ICG. Karla Hills is the former head of the US Chamber of Commerce, ex-director of the Chevron oil company and now the executive director of the consulting firm Hills & Company. Chevron-Texaco is listed as one of the sponsors of the ICG. By a strange coincidence, Chevron has interests in the South Caucasus, especially in Azerbaijan.

Dow Chemical, Silk Road Finance Ltd, BP, Anglo American PLC, Talisman Energy and many others are also corporately represented.

Interestingly, the president’s council includes three anonymous actors. It can be assumed that among them is the CIA, which is actively and invisibly present in many similar projects claiming international importance.

After reading the report, there is a desire to prepare your own recommendations for both Russia and the EU. We need to implement comprehensive measures to improve security, especially on the eve of the Olympic Games in Sochi. To intensify the interaction of the authorities with local communities, to consult with analytical centers dealing with the issues of the North Caucasus. At the same time, it is desirable to limit the admission to the region of agents of organizations like the ICG so that they do not create their destructive networks there, which can later be used to disintegrate the region and undermine territorial integrity.

And the EU is to deal with its internal problems, including human rights, which are violated on many points and in many countries of this community.
Author:
Originator:
http://www.geopolitica.ru/article/monitorit-kavkaz-i-davit-na-rossiyu#.Uj8Rt9K-2m4
59 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. experienced
    experienced 23 September 2013 18: 14
    13
    Among the organization’s advisers are Zbigniew Brzezinski, one of the oldest Israeli politicians Shimon Peres, the liquidator of the aftermath of the Iraq war in 1991 and the conductor of Western interests in negotiations with Yugoslavia in 1999. Marti Ahtisaari, the Saudi prince Turki al-Faisal, the nineteenth prime minister Minister of Canada Kim Campbell

    Therefore, this report turned out winked
    By the way, Brzezinski and Solartz are the co-chairs of the “American Committee for Peace in Chechnya,” the structure responsible at the time for the open support and transfer of funds to Chechen fighters

    I propose to open an office of this committee in some Chechen aul and insist that Bzhe and Solarz receive the population there for at least three months a year each. It will be interesting when they are stolen for ransom laughing
    1. Ingvar 72
      Ingvar 72 23 September 2013 18: 21
      +6
      These against Russia will unite with the devil.
  2. fklj
    fklj 23 September 2013 18: 20
    24
    Ruin in the heads of our "leadership". The Caucasus itself was released. Themselves allowed the children of the mountains to arrange lawlessness in the mountains and in our cities. They didn't even want to punish the Georgians for their aggression. Zabzdel in 2008 Supreme.
    What we fought for and disentangle.
    1. FREGATENKAPITAN
      FREGATENKAPITAN 24 September 2013 10: 00
      +1
      Caucasus themselves released..... Who are themselves? I? You? ... Putin? ... Nooooo ... this is Boria, a drunken man, shouting - take independence as much as you want! And with the tacit consent of the "democrats" (who are still spinning at the top) and the joyful hooting of local bays and Western freedom-lovers, everything happened ... And the Georgians were punished enough ... and here is the main point, if If the tanks entered Tbilisi, then at the expense of the aggressor, the question would be different .... We still hammer the truth bit by bit into Western "friends"
      1. Manager
        Manager 24 September 2013 12: 55
        +2
        Quote: FREGATENKAPITAN
        if tanks entered Tbilisi, then at the expense of the aggressor the question would be different.

        So what>? Who cares about the US? What are they giving us to drink? And how are they behaving? They do whatever they want.
        As for the Caucasus, Borya just started, but now everything is in Putin's hands. Is he what is inactive? Or that they at their top think that "My hut on the edge I don't know anything" or "if I'm in Israel. Yes, it's all bullshit. Until we put things in order at home, fuck who will take us seriously!"
  3. Blondin nikonov
    Blondin nikonov 23 September 2013 18: 28
    +8
    I think somehow we ourselves will figure it out without ovsk and geyropskih organizations ......
  4. Vitaly Anisimov
    Vitaly Anisimov 23 September 2013 18: 30
    +9
    Everyone "worries" about our Caucasus. They don't sleep at night and think about human rights (so that it was like in the 90s), well, well ..
  5. bif
    bif 23 September 2013 18: 42
    53
    The only thing for which we can say THANKS to the owners of this agency (USA), so for the "invention" and application of the Zero Tolerance Concept, they ran it in the 60-70s of the last century on their broken rockers.
    "... Where it is enough for a law-abiding person to shake his finger and he will become even more law-abiding, bikers-lawless bikers must be stripped of three legal skins, otherwise they will not feel the force of the law. And do with them until they too a finger will be enough.In the future, this law enforcement tactic was called "zero tolerance" and in certain circumstances was used more than once in the most democratic countries in the world.
    And now about the main thing. I believe that young and passionate people from the Caucasian republics who really want to be respected, but do not quite understand what it means to respect others, is a contingent worthy of exactly the same therapy. In this sense, the main slogan of the Saturday Manezh “E ... be the Caucasus, e ... be!” Deserves the most careful study for its application in legal practice.
    I am sure that the result will be the most positive.
    Once I witnessed how this method was adopted by the sheriff Oleg Zanasiya, head of the police department of the city of Olonets of the Republic of Karelia. Before him, the local Chechen diaspora was terribly corrupted by a former district prosecutor. As a result, they felt like masters not only in the city, but also in the office of the chief of police. Sheriff Zanasiya did not conduct a showdown or sweep. He immediately planted the most violent four, good for what, and in relation to ordinary Chechens he turned on the regime of legal terror. Speeding - the maximum fine, parking in the wrong place - the maximum fine, the goby thrown to the ground - the maximum fine, the fine not paid on time - 15 days of arrest.
    The slightest attempt at resistance was followed by the challenge of a special mobile power group, which, with all its appearance, showed one hundred percent determination to act on defeat.
    Six months of such therapy - and the Chechens have become quite Russian themselves. Even the French. Or the British.
    And somehow I really want this regime of zero tolerance to be prescribed for the above-described social group of people throughout the country. So that for lezginka with shooting in the center of the city they would fine everyone to the maximum, and for the second one - they would put him. So that for a jeep ride in the Alexander Garden, the rider is so measured that he would not need a jeep for a long time. So that when one Aslan takes out a gun or knife, the other Aslanes scatter in fear, because they knew that they would not be witnesses, but accomplices in a preliminary conspiracy and no diaspora would help. In order for national quotas upon admission to universities to be recognized as savagery, and for public explanations for whom a woman of “my people” should or should not marry, the leader of this people was subjected to political ostracism. So that all these indicatively harsh reactions of the authorities are legally pure and maximally public.
    So that those to whom they are addressed feel: they have where to fit in and have someone to respect ... "
    1. Heccrbq .2
      Heccrbq .2 23 September 2013 18: 49
      +1
      Your idea is excellent, but in this country and system this is not possible (((
      1. creak
        creak 23 September 2013 20: 29
        +4
        It is said very clearly and in the case ...
    2. michajlo
      michajlo 23 September 2013 19: 54
      +4
      bif RU Today, 18:42, _130923 / pon

      Good evening, dear nickname!

      The above example is very good and I really liked it. good
      Just for the sake of its quick and positive effect, it should be distributed to all of us everywhere and it is so simple to DEMAND from the local power structures to START to fulfill our duties of protecting US citizens.

      From myself I’ll say something else. What if we want or intend to demand from others order and legality, then first of all WE ourselves must comply with all these laws and decrees !!!

      And if something is wrong, then how quickly to apologize to others and more "not to pretend, God knows what."
      For example, if I am a citizen of Ukraine, I’ll fly to Russia tomorrow, then in order for me to feel safe, I myself must first observe all the paragraphs, and then I know clearly that nothing will happen to me.

      In addition, in my opinion it is very useful to remember and apply 4 “basic phrases of human communication” everywhere (they are taught in kindergarten or in the first grades of the secondary school):

      - Good afternoon / morning, evening.
      - Be so kind, tell / explain to me.
      - Thank you very much / Excuse me, I was mistaken.
      - Goodbye / I wish you all the best.

      And as a rule, then incomprehensible situations do not arise, and if something happens, then everything is quickly settled without the hassle and spoiled mood.
      1. bask
        bask 23 September 2013 22: 21
        +4
        Quote: michajlo
        Good afternoon / morning, evening.
        - Be so kind, tell / explain to me.
        - Thank you very much / Excuse me, I was mistaken.
        - Goodbye / I wish you all the best.

        This is an appeal to the people of Russian Slavic culture.
        The Chechen’s appeal to the Chechen, with other nations (Nokhchi, official translation, you are a Chechen, not an official, there are people). With this question, everything is said.
      2. Horn
        Horn 24 September 2013 06: 41
        +5
        This is all fine, but savage people mistake politeness for weakness and cowardice. And the weak and cowards, in the opinion of the savages, should be robbed and humiliated so that "others are afraid."
    3. Aleks tv
      Aleks tv 23 September 2013 20: 20
      +7
      Quote: bif
      And now about the main thing. I believe that young and passionate people from the Caucasian republics who really want to be respected, but do not quite understand what it means to respect others, is a contingent worthy of exactly the same therapy.

      Thanks for the comment, bif.
      Yes, no one is going to belittle the Caucasus.
      But the Caucasus understands only power and respects only the strong.
      This phrase is key.

      They acutely feel weakness and liberation and it will not work under any sauce, even under money.
      I had a chance to visit Grozny before the war, as well as communicate with these people for a long time, I know what I'm saying.
      I hope Andrey (bask) will comment on his point of view, he knows them well ...
      1. Alex 241
        Alex 241 23 September 2013 20: 27
        11
        Hi Lesh, words of General Ermolov: Indulgence in the eyes of an Asian is a sign of weakness, and I am strictly inexorably out of humanity.
        1. Aleks tv
          Aleks tv 23 September 2013 20: 45
          +9
          Hi, Sasha, I haven’t seen for a long time.

          In the Caucasus should be: Clearly, Clearly, Firmly.
          Without any "changes" and "additions".
          Such should be the policy in that region.

          Let me explain in other words: you need to be “not cruel”, but “tough” and consistent in your actions and actions.
          1. Aleks tv
            Aleks tv 23 September 2013 21: 32
            +6
            That was remembered ...

            This is the answer of 7 oSpN (before the "second") to those who say that "Russians mountain dances don't dance "...

            We all "dance" who do not want to live peacefully.
            It’s just better not to touch us.

            And all the politicians - on the count, there they belong. There is no Stalin on them.

            1. Alex 241
              Alex 241 23 September 2013 21: 47
              +5
              Chechnya We are from Special Forces
              1. bask
                bask 23 September 2013 22: 27
                +2
                Quote: Alex 241
                And all the politicians - on the count, there they belong. There is no Stalin on them.

                Quote: Alex 241
                We are from Special Forces

                Good evening. San, Lesh (once again). They don’t give politicians su *****. Russian people live humanly. And resist every beast !!!
                1. Alex 241
                  Alex 241 23 September 2013 22: 29
                  +2
                  Hi Seryozha, I wish you health, I have got scores with them since 89!
                  1. bask
                    bask 23 September 2013 22: 44
                    +6
                    San I am Andrey.
                    This sheriff, Oleg Zanasiy, but the president of Russia.
                    And that’s all, they started to work as mantras-GDP, without alternatives ,,,. There are smart and principled people in Russia. Oleg Zanasia is not the head of the police department, the city of Olonets needs to be worked, but at least the first deputy, the minister of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.
                    1. Alex 241
                      Alex 241 23 September 2013 22: 50
                      +1
                      Sorry Andryukh, he simply pereklinil, I saw everyone today, except for Seryoga, the problem is that a whole generation has grown up, who believes, using Alcapone's words, that with a word and a gun you can achieve more than just a word.
                      1. bask
                        bask 23 September 2013 23: 04
                        +2
                        Quote: Alex 241
                        a generation that believes, in Alcapone's words, that a word and a gun can be achieved more than just a word.

                        So it is necessary to explain to this generation that they are wrong. And we must live according to secular laws, and not, the laws of the mountains.
                        What is profitable, said and done in practice, the sheriff from Olonets-Zanasiya.
                        Quote: Alex 241
                        But the Caucasus understands only power and respects only the strong.

                        The rights of Lech need BREAST FORCE and the inevitability of punishment. And not of any diasporas.
                      2. Alex 241
                        Alex 241 23 September 2013 23: 14
                        +1
                        Quote: bask
                        explain to this generation that they are wrong.

                        Andrei, everything has gone too far, you can hardly explain it.
                      3. bask
                        bask 23 September 2013 23: 21
                        +3
                        Quote: Alex 241
                        everything went too far, you can hardly explain it.

                        Sanya, maybe it will sound self-confident on my part (but, I was born and lived in the ChIIASSR) and I know their mentality 100%.
                        One hundred pounds will be well understood. Unfortunately, under the current regime in Russia, there is no one to explain.
                      4. Alex 241
                        Alex 241 23 September 2013 23: 32
                        +1
                        Quote: bask
                        Unfortunately, under the current regime in Russia, there is no one to explain.
                        Most likely, in fact, this problem was stolen at the root. It seems quiet and calm, people are fighting for themselves. Remember the case of beating a biker.
                      5. Alex 241
                        Alex 241 23 September 2013 23: 33
                        +1
                        ......................................
                      6. bask
                        bask 23 September 2013 23: 43
                        +4
                        Quote: Alex 241
                        Most likely, in fact, this problem was stolen at the root. It seems quiet and calm, people are fighting for themselves. Remember the case of beating a biker.

                        There are thousands of such cases in Russia.
                        Murders in the city of Pugachev, paratrooper.
                        There will be a war, that’s for sure. The anarchy and corruption of the authorities in this matter are pushing the country into the abyss. That even the Syrian massacre will seem like a child’s game of soldier’s.
                      7. Alex 241
                        Alex 241 23 September 2013 23: 45
                        +2
                        You read the thoughts of Andryukh.
                      8. bask
                        bask 23 September 2013 23: 59
                        +2
                        Quote: Alex 241
                        Read mind

                        Yes Sanya, it’s not only with us. Among my friends, almost everyone thinks so.
                      9. The comment was deleted.
                  2. studentmati
                    studentmati 24 September 2013 00: 11
                    0
                    Quote: bask
                    There are thousands of such cases in Russia.
                    Murders in the city of Pugachev, paratrooper.
                    There will be a war, that’s for sure. The anarchy and corruption of the authorities in this matter are pushing the country into the abyss. That even the Syrian massacre will seem like a child’s game of soldier’s.


                    Don't be so emotional ...

                    There will be no war in the foreseeable future. Corruption flourishes and flourishes, I agree. But the police force is strong and mobilized, under control and ready to be deployed on command. The Syrian scenario for Russia, the stage passed in 1917. The world has changed and for Russia a sluggish economic scenario with a smooth and peaceful settlement of territories by "good neighbors" is more likely.
                  3. Alex 241
                    Alex 241 24 September 2013 00: 16
                    0
                    Hello hi. Just everywhere there is a murmur, got it!
                  4. studentmati
                    studentmati 24 September 2013 00: 22
                    -1
                    Quote: Alex 241
                    Hello hi. Just everywhere there is a murmur, got it!


                    Hi, san. A murmur is gossip. Remember how worse it was? And nothing, there were no war. I agree that there is an internal political struggle. But the situation is under control, do not forget that the chessboard has a strategist.
                  5. Ruslan67
                    Ruslan67 24 September 2013 02: 09
                    +2
                    Hi Sasha hi
                    Quote: Alex 241
                    everywhere there is a murmur, got it!

                    Already not a murmur growls already am A little more and everyone will become sour and fun
                2. bask
                  bask 24 September 2013 00: 36
                  +5
                  Quote: studentmati
                  Don't be so emotional ...

                  When on your own skin, you will experience all that horror of democracy in Ichkeria style.
                  And the genocide of the Russian population of ChIIASSR, in another way, does not work emotionally.
                  Sorry for the primacy.
                3. studentmati
                  studentmati 24 September 2013 00: 48
                  -2
                  Quote: bask
                  When on your own skin, you will experience all that horror of democracy in Ichkeria style.
                  And the genocide of the Russian population of ChIIASSR, in another way, does not work emotionally.
                  Sorry for the primacy.


                  No matter how hard it is, you should not be like the "beast", otherwise the "beast" will win, knowing all the pros and cons of strategy and tactics.
        2. Aleks tv
          Aleks tv 24 September 2013 00: 00
          +2
          Quote: bask
          One hundred pounds will be well understood.

          Once again, good evening, Andrey.

          RIGHTS FOR ALL HUNDRED !!!
          They’re very knowledgeable, they’ll never be late.
        3. bask
          bask 24 September 2013 00: 25
          +2
          Quote: Aleks tv
          it will never be too late.

          Leh is for sure.
          The main thing is to correctly formulate. That would be to the brain, each ***** came to.
  • bask
    bask 23 September 2013 22: 11
    +4
    Quote: bif
    Six months of such therapy - and the Chechens have become quite Russian themselves. Even the French. Or the British.

    Dear Bif, YOU wrote the PROGRAM. How to conduct law enforcement agencies, judicial authorities, in relation to immigrants from the S. Caucasus. 100% !!!!!
    The psychology of the Caucasian and his reaction to are clearly described.
    Quote: bif
    “Zero tolerance”

    Just like that !!! And on the scales of all of Russia, all immigrants from the S. Caucasus will behave
    Quote: bif
    became quite a Russian. Even the French. Or the British.

    Excellent KOMENT !!!! good
  • isp96
    isp96 24 September 2013 05: 18
    +2
    If you go to the polls as a candidate and this will be part of your program, then I will vote for you!
  • rinat1955
    rinat1955 24 September 2013 12: 01
    +1
    Ha ... such a practice has been tested for a long time and has been used in the Republic of Tatarstan for decades.
    Here, the main thing is that the owner should be on this earth.
  • major071
    major071 23 September 2013 19: 10
    +8
    Well Brzezinski - the old political forgive me ... God! An ardent supporter of anti-Russian politics. And when will an old woman with a scythe come to him? winked
    1. GREAT RUSSIA
      GREAT RUSSIA 23 September 2013 20: 22
      +3
      Quote: major071
      Well Brzezinski - the old political forgive me ... Lord! An ardent supporter of anti-Russian politics. And when will an old woman with a scythe come to him? winked

      Death with a chainsaw will come to him, only in this way.
  • ddmm09
    ddmm09 23 September 2013 19: 12
    +3
    Quote: Heccrbq .2
    Your idea is excellent, but in this country and system this is not possible (((

    Perhaps just everything has its time.
  • alone
    alone 23 September 2013 19: 34
    +6
    "thank you" you need to say to the hunchback and ebnu. one ruined the country, which was like he was in charge. and the other from a hangover yelled at the whole of Russia "take sovereignty as much as you can." to finally solve the problem of the North Caucasus, it is necessary to work hard with the peoples of the region and neighboring countries. Believe me, sometimes this leads to good results. I can give one example. The cooperation of the Russian and Azerbaijani special services led to the fact that in 2008 the southern group of the bandit underground was defeated , and all of them were destroyed. half in Russia and the other half in Azerbaijan.
  • zennon
    zennon 23 September 2013 19: 49
    +1
    Brzezinski and Solartz are co-chairs of the “American Committee for Peace in Chechnya”

    You can not read further ...
  • Radoslav
    Radoslav 23 September 2013 19: 56
    +2
    I did not understand why Abkhazia and South Ossetia were not highlighted on the map as independent states, what Georgian licking in the full sense of the word drew such a map.
  • chunga-changa
    chunga-changa 23 September 2013 19: 59
    +1
    Yes, these will not calm down until they die. Well, not for long.
  • Ivan Ural
    Ivan Ural 23 September 2013 20: 02
    +1
    Ah, these are from the geyrops ... well, you don’t pay attention to the men, they’re all weird there
  • GREAT RUSSIA
    GREAT RUSSIA 23 September 2013 20: 19
    +7
    And you read this:
    In addition, the authors insist on further decentralization: “the functioning of a federal system with a degree of decentralization and a corresponding regional representation in the Duma in Moscow will facilitate the integration of the North Caucasus with the rest of Russia.
    What the hell is decentralization? It is because of this decentralization that Kadyrov is building monuments to whom he wants and most often demonizes Yermolov. But this is real political separatism. And what the hell is integration. The Caucasus is an independent state? I myself am a resident of the North Caucasus and no integration is needed here. Damn Yankees. The economy of the North Caucasus should be made self-sufficient by at least 60-70%, but the North Caucasus should remain politically dependent on the center by 35-45%. And it is just necessary to pursue a centralization policy . Decentralization can lead to a new Chechen campaign, and not only in Chechnya. And also to aggravation of ethnic struggle and as a result of strife.
  • Nymp
    Nymp 23 September 2013 20: 44
    +5
    Now I watched a program on TVC about how the type of geyropa does not like us. How do they (all kinds of Ryzhkovs) cry, so I want to be in a geyropu. They and the Caucasus will gladly give the NATO-Amer lackeys just to become gay men. I think if in mother Russia you can’t get rid of this garbage, you can soon tear us like pieces of pizza with your bare hands. And the Caucasus is one of them.
    1. GREAT RUSSIA
      GREAT RUSSIA 23 September 2013 21: 52
      +5
      Quote: Nymp
      Now I watched a program on TVC about how the type of geyropa does not like us. How do they (all kinds of Ryzhkovs) cry, so I want to be in a geyropu. They and the Caucasus will gladly give the NATO-Amer lackeys just to become gay men. I think if in mother Russia you can’t get rid of this garbage, you can soon tear us like pieces of pizza with your bare hands. And the Caucasus is one of them.

      The Caucasus is a geopolitical fortress to protect the south of RUSSIA. Therefore, the loss of the Caucasus would mean a geopolitical catastrophe in size equal to the collapse of the USSR. It is not for nothing that they say if there is oil, then the Caucasus is its father. The British, and now the Americans, are drawn to the Caucasus, since if they will manage to tear the Caucasus away from RUSSIA, then a "parade of sovereignties" will begin, which means the collapse of RUSSIA and its subsequent destruction. No one will give up the Caucasus. The Americans and the entire West will not get a millimeter of the Caucasus. RUSSIA is not a rag. The USA relaxed too much after the collapse of the USSR, so now let them pay for it. So this should not worry you. I myself am a resident of the North Caucasus, and you can be sure here in the Caucasus, to the west are set up with the same hatred as other inhabitants of RUSSIA. The USSR was also a motherland for us. And yes, in general, hatred of the West is in our blood.
  • major071
    major071 23 September 2013 21: 29
    +9
    There was spotted a domestic liberal Grigory Yavlinsky.
    Oh how! On your own already? Give the Caucasus! Freedom to the parrots! What other slogans can and should be shouted to lie down to the west? Tell me, otherwise I just don’t know what to do. request
    And it’s just like this: Yavlinsky and Brzezinski - This is the future of Russia! wassat
    1. Nymp
      Nymp 23 September 2013 21: 32
      +2
      Quote: major071
      And it’s just like this: Yavlinsky and Brzezinski - This is the future of Russia!

      They call this "the conscience of Russia" This is how you have to defile everything Russian, what to call such a conscience ?!
    2. Russ69
      Russ69 23 September 2013 21: 49
      +4
      Quote: major071
      There was spotted a domestic liberal Grigory Yavlinsky.

      Okay, liberals, and here on the site, there are far from liberals, everyone thinks how to separate.
      In general, send on further, this International Crisis Group, where on further. Let them go to Saudi Arabia, from Qatar and arrange their gay-European values ​​there.
      In general, these "experts" should be allowed here. What can they offer so good?
  • nbw
    nbw 23 September 2013 21: 39
    +4
    Among the advisers of the organization are <...> Saudi Prince Turki al-Faisal
    Sometimes it seems to me that the Americans (with their satellites) openly mock the rest of the world. Mock simply. Saudi prince preoccupied with human rights! B *** b !!! A representative of a country in which a medieval nightmare is created with these very rights is taken to teach someone!
  • Yugra
    Yugra 23 September 2013 21: 49
    +2
    I would like to say to gay Europe: guys, don’t get involved in our affairs, don’t meddle in Russia. We are not responsible for the consequences. And if several countries are “blown off” from the map of Europe after our strike, then it will be too late to admit that the attitude towards Russia is wrong ...
    1. nbw
      nbw 23 September 2013 21: 53
      +1
      And if several countries are "blown off" the map <...> after our strike, then it will be too late to admit the erroneous attitude towards Russia
      Hehe. Yes, we got these "pugs" - mattress covers smile
      There was a quarrel between the Russian ambassador to the UN Security Council, Vitaly Churkin, and the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Qatar. To the latter’s threatening statement (“I warn Russia: if she doesn’t abstain from the veto and doesn’t take a UN decision, she will lose all the Arab countries”), Ambassador Churkin quietly replied: “Once again blather something in this tone, and your Qatar will not will live until tomorrow ... ”
      http://telegrafist.org/2012/02/07/3501/
  • major071
    major071 23 September 2013 22: 05
    +7
    You know, the more insignificant and smaller the person, the more ambitions he has. The same applies to countries. Wow, we’re now blowing our cheeks, as we blow on you, and to you complete alles. Yes, no matter how much you cheat your cheeks - you still get one big PUK! Settled-look!
  • Jogan-xnumx
    Jogan-xnumx 23 September 2013 23: 13
    +3
    First of all, the conclusions presented in this report are intended for Russia - both federal and North Caucasian authorities, but also for various European institutions - PACE, the Council of Europe, etc. At the same time, the recommendation for the EU is in one proposal - to continue monitor the North Caucasus region and put pressure on Russia to fully implement all decisions of the European Court of Human Rights.

    what In my opinion, the North Caucasus is an internal affair of Russia itself. Or isn’t it? Territory of the Russian Federation, citizens of the Russian Federation, jurisdiction of the Russian Federation. What, sorry, horseradish would the snout put there all these PACEs (or passives), coupled with their dominant - Indians?
    And if they are so worried about freedom with democracy, is it not time for us to worry about the same? To create a similar international group, within, for example, the SCO or the CSTO (there are those who want to), and start monitoring the same France, Belgium, the States, all this shelupon in general, for the same democracy, the rule of law, and more. According to their own template. With reports, conclusions, recommendations, coverage in the press, on TV ... Yes, more shit there ... Journalists have a little more money to pay for them, they will not only print it all, but they will also run their own print runs. lol As they say in kho.khlyandii: "Their lard - they also hit in the face!" laughing
    Well, it's time for us to learn adequate answers! The foreign ones respond to their spitting in the same way, and not just wipe themselves. recourse You look, and the "democrats-human rights activists" will reduce their agility. Will hiss. Because, reptiles - they are reptiles. But they will be careful not to spit poison at us. Recoil can be ... torment, in general. angry
  • Bakht
    Bakht 23 September 2013 23: 37
    +3
    ADDRESSERS OF RUSSIA

    What are you noisy about, folk-like?
    Why anathema threaten you Russia?
    What angered you? unrest in Lithuania?
    Leave: this is a dispute between the Slavs,
    Home, old dispute, weighted by fate,
    A question that you will not solve.

    For a long time among themselves
    These tribes are at war;
    More than once bowed under a thunderstorm
    Theirs, then our side.
    Who will stand in an unequal dispute:
    Puffy Lyakh, il true Ross?
    Will Slavic streams merge in the Russian sea?
    Will it run dry? here is the question.

    Leave us: you have not read
    These bloody tablets;
    It’s incomprehensible to you, alien to you
    This is a family feud;
    The Kremlin and Prague are silent for you;

    Pointlessly seduces you
    Fights of desperate courage -
    And you hate us ...
    For what? answer: for whether
    What is on the ruins of flaming Moscow
    We did not recognize the brazen will
    Who were you trembling under?
    For the fact that they plunged into the abyss
    We are idol over kingdoms
    And redeemed with our blood
    Europe, freedom, honor and peace? ..

    You are formidable in words - try it in practice!
    Or the old hero, deceased on his bed,
    Unable to screw up your Izmail bayonet?
    Is the Russian tsar already powerless to speak?
    Or should we argue with Europe new?
    Il Russian weaned from victories?
    Or a little of us? Or from Perm to Tauris,
    From the Finnish cold rocks to the flaming Colchis,
    From the shocked Kremlin
    To the walls of immobile China,
    Shiny bristles,
    Will not the Russian land rise? ..

    So send us to us, Vitia,
    His angry sons:
    There is a place for them in the fields of Russia,
    Among the coffins that are not theirs.
  • Valery Neonov
    Valery Neonov 23 September 2013 23: 47
    0
    Yes, the composition is impressive, powerful group; how they let Yavlinsky get there, just listen to the recommendations of these obvious enemies of Russia, then immediately give the Caucasus and push the borders ... hi
  • Andrey Peter
    Andrey Peter 23 September 2013 23: 49
    +1
    I am so tired of the opinions and recommendations of foreign "experts" (and some "ours") that I want to send them ..... So let's not even discuss this topic. Just "hammer" - they still won't hear. It is better to discuss what is happening in the country from the point of view of you and me. And I hope they will listen to this. I think you understand what I mean.
  • voliador
    voliador 24 September 2013 00: 58
    +2
    Let, for starters, deal with their homosexuals, and then they will teach us life.
  • VladimS
    VladimS 24 September 2013 01: 41
    +2
    Quote: Heccrbq .2
    Your idea is excellent, but in this country and system this is not possible (((

    Minus for "this country". Because this is your country, my country, our country! Cut on your beautiful nose.
  • IGS
    IGS 24 September 2013 02: 46
    +1
    This is a farce ... and impudence bordering on rudeness. What organizations with big names with huge budgets have not come up with and are coming up with to "help" us. And we are not creating anything like this to help them ... and rightly so. This should be done by qualified sanitary and epidemiological specialists headed by Onishchenko. I wonder if they themselves understand who we are holding them for? laughing And what do we put on these reports? In general, it’s time to raise the issue up front, in the Baltic countries, on our borders, fascism is emerging. It is time to deal with them harshly, including forceful methods. By the way, this is our duty.
  • individual
    individual 24 September 2013 07: 29
    0
    The crisis group from Brzezinski to Yavinsky represents the haters of Russia with the next theses and teachings on how to do more dirty tricks of Russia.
    The grave will fix the Western advisers, but it's time to deal with our home-grown "teachers" ourselves. am
  • evgenm55
    evgenm55 24 September 2013 07: 35
    +1
    Quote: Heccrbq .2
    Your idea is excellent, but in this country and system this is not possible (((

    So it is necessary to change the system of this country and, at the same time, those who brought the country to such a system. We have good luck, experience and examples, the Great Stalin left good practice for future generations. Therefore, every liberal-thieves howl ... only howls at his one name.
  • soldier's grandson
    soldier's grandson 24 September 2013 08: 31
    +2
    under Stalin, nominations were put into power after inspections and purges, and now there are no ideological comrades in the Duma and the government; power has become a big business with unlimited possibilities where they can think about the people when in their eyes only bucks the same can be said of the power structures
  • dmb
    dmb 24 September 2013 09: 33
    +2
    Much noise from nothing. Is this the first such report? Attention is drawn to the fact that the report, judging by the title, was concocted in English. It will, of course, be a great success among the shepherds from Upper Balkaria, as well as the inhabitants of the village of Starye Atagi of the Chechen Republic. I doubt that the Chechen Guarantor was able to read it in the original in spite of his professorship. Well, grandfather Markel from the village of Verkhniye Mandryki quotes phrases from the report literally by heart. This is what I mean. This masterpiece was written exclusively for the Western public, and also not for the whole, because the burgher from Hrenweinstadt is more concerned with the prices of pork and beer than the rights of Lema Barakhoev from the village of Alleroy. Of course not, the report worries a number of our compatriots. But how will they be kicked out of the OSCE tomorrow, and what will he do in Russia so unloved by him, whose interests he has defended for so bravely for many years within the walls of the European Parliament. He does not know how to do anything other than "bravely defend". For example, if Astakhov is suddenly kicked out, he will at least go to defend the crooks again, and the "defender of Russia" is a complete byad.
  • Betahon
    Betahon 24 September 2013 09: 46
    0
    "The dogs are barking, the caravan is coming" (Eastern wisdom)
  • Sergey Medvedev
    Sergey Medvedev 24 September 2013 10: 34
    0
    In addition, the authors insist on further decentralization:

    Yeah. They also had a plan to decentralize Russia into 8 independent states. At that time, we immediately organized federal districts. Just 8.
  • pahom54
    pahom54 24 September 2013 10: 51
    0
    They just named those involved in the development of these reports and conclusions on them, and everything becomes clear: they are completely enemies of Russia (and long-term and zealous ones). Well, how long will they teach us ??? They demand the "democratization" of the Caucasus in THEIR spirit, but the goal is one: the collapse of Russia into pieces and pieces. In the Caucasus, if you do not apply tough management methods, there will never be order. And at the moment there is no order in Chechnya, so far they are only Russia (it would be better to suck it off), and they are waiting for it to be more convenient to stick a knife in Russia's back. And what kind of democratic voting are they talking about, that everything seems to be all right there ??? This order became clearly visible during the survey about the symbols of Russia, when as many people voted for the fact that the Grozny mosque was a Russian symbol, as in Chechnya there has never been in 100 years in total! But Zbigniew Brzezinski liked it, ..uke ...
    Only force, and then conviction ... Only in this way can order be restored in the Caucasus. But no - tries to let them out of Russia, but create such an iron curtain so that the fly does not fly. And to return everyone from Russia to their homes, let them live ... There is no economy, they do not exist, they live only due to the robbery of Russia, and they talk about some kind of democracy ... After all, their democracy is understood one-sidedly, especially with regard to Russia and its citizens . Bandits talking about democracy ... Strength and only strength, and to hell with them, not decentralization!
  • Norady
    Norady 24 September 2013 11: 00
    0
    Quote: fklj
    Ruin in the heads of our "leadership". The Caucasus itself was released. Themselves allowed the children of the mountains to arrange lawlessness in the mountains and in our cities. They didn't even want to punish the Georgians for their aggression. Zabzdel in 2008 Supreme.
    What we fought for and disentangle.

    take it easy with provocations, however. thinner work is needed, more delicate;)
  • everest-82
    everest-82 24 September 2013 21: 44
    -1
    Quote: fklj
    Ruin in the heads of our "leadership". The Caucasus itself was released. Themselves allowed the children of the mountains to arrange lawlessness in the mountains and in our cities. They didn't even want to punish the Georgians for their aggression. Zabzdel in 2008 Supreme.
    What we fought for and disentangle.

    Into the account: “Ruin ​​in the heads of our“ leadership ”, but this is not necessary - from your sore head to your healthy one. Leave those piggy squeals for Swamp, it will come in handy there.
    What does it mean: “They released the Caucasus themselves,” and what do you want them to use scorched-earth tactics - such things on your territory and against your people, you can afford, unless cannibals. You strain your brains, no ...? I will tell you - the Caucasus would leave us (the world community would help it: economic blockade, political isolation, etc.), and this would be the beginning of our end.
    And about: "... to punish Georgians for aggression ...". You have no idea, as in the previous questions, and this is no exception. With Georgia we were already exposed as aggressors, we barely laundered ourselves, and the United States did not doze off, and it’s too early for us to measure forces with them.
    So, so as not to smack nonsense, often strain your brains - if they are ...