Military Review

The annual survey “Evaluation of state political figures” is gaining momentum

14
From the conversation between John McCain and Condoleezza Rice:


- John, this is unheard of! Russian on their site "Military Review" conduct a survey of public opinion! Without our sanction and control!
- A clear violation of human rights, an attempt on the freedom of personal opinion! Need to connect the Hague court!
- Yes, I do not care about the rights of Russian from this site! The thing is different - this is a recurrence of their eternal predilection for collective work and joint decision-making! And this is Russian "weapon"Much more dangerous than their" yadren-loaf "!
- Condoleezza, do not take in your African-American head! The time is working for us - the Russians are swinging for a long time, and the time of the survey is inexorably expiring ...
- John, Russians, you see, your brains in Vietnam beat off your brains! You forgot that they harness a long time, but they drive fast!




5 June 2013 started on our website annual survey "Evaluation of state political figures». Currently, the first, field stage survey is approaching its equator. On the mailbox [email protected]through which the dispatch and return of the completed questionnaires goes, it becomes hot — there is an intensive exchange of messages and files between the organizer of the survey and its participants:

- Ready to participate in the survey, send the form!
- Dear survey participant, send the evaluation file, give confirmation of its receipt!
- File received, thanks! Start filling out.
- Strictly adhere to the instructions when filling out the questionnaire. Creative success!
- Forward the completed file. A very useful survey, not in the eyebrow, but in the eye!
- Levada Center will never dare to do this!
- Your file has been received, the results are recorded in a common database. Thanks again for taking the survey!

This is the second survey on a given topic. The first was held about a year ago, in April-May, 2012, and coincided with a landmark event for Russia - the inauguration of the now three-time Russian President Vladimir Putin.

Purpose of the survey - to form a generalized view of the leaders of modern Russia, Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan in comparison with the leaders of the Soviet era. Accordingly, the defendants in the survey (objects of evaluation) are: Joseph Stalin, Nikita Khrushchev, Leonid Brezhnev, Mikhail Gorbachev, Boris Yeltsin, Vladimir Putin, Dmitry Medvedev, Viktor Yanukovych, Alexander Lukashenko and Nursultan Nazarbayev. Note that compared to last year, the list of respondents to the survey is significantly reduced. This made it possible to significantly simplify the evaluation procedure and, at the same time, enrich its content with new items.

The basis of the survey, the method of multidimensional evaluation, has remained unchanged. It allows you to evaluate the defendants in the three factors-criteria: "Strength / Activity", "Moral" и "Competence". Last year, for example, Vladimir Putin, against the background of election promises, received the following estimates:

2,27 Strength / Activity (on a scale from -3 to + 3)
Moral 1,05
Competence 1, 93

I wonder how Putin’s grades will change after a year’s presidency?

What is new about the survey participants-2013? First of all, this is the question of According to the respondents, whose interests are (or were at one time) those involved in the survey. To answer this question there are five possible answers:
1) State Interests
2) People's Interests
3) Interests of elite-clan groups within the country
4) Personal Interests
5) The interests of external, alien to the country forces

The following two new items introduced by the proposals of the survey participants themselves. It is about intra-and interstate relations between our countries. Within this topic there are two questions.

“What type of society, in your opinion, is actually formed in Russia, Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan under the leadership of the leaders of these countries?” Here are the following response options:
1) State Socialism Society
2) Society of the early "wild" capitalism
3) Society for Advanced Market Relations
4) Society of domination of elite clan groups
5) Society of the cult of the individual
6) Something else (free answer)

“What, in your opinion, are the main motives of the integration processes within the Eurasian Union?” Possible answer options:
1) Mutually beneficial cooperation between independent member states
2) The revival of a centralized empire state
3) Satisfaction of interests of elite-clan groups of one of the participating countries
4) Something else (free answer)

Thus, in its substantive part, the survey goes to a higher quality level. Accordingly, an analysis of the results, on the basis of all the questions raised, can provide richer food for thought ...

Some visitors to the site may argue - why make a garden, conduct a survey and find out a generalized opinion? Who needs it, this generalized opinion? I have my personal opinion and I am not going to refuse it! What is there to argue? You can, of course, remember the old army joke - if you are so smart, then why don't you go? But, most likely, only military people will understand its deep meaning. As they say, there is a joke in every joke ... For civilians, of whom there are many on our website, another proverb is more suitable - alone it is only good to woo the girl, everything else is better to do together. And this is right, this is in our folk tradition that has been going on from time immemorial.

This is how we differ from the Western tradition, which sets the priority of the individual over the public.
However, everyone is left with the freedom of choice - either to become a participant in the survey, the creator of collective co-knowledge, or continue to stew in the juice of a personal opinion, slurp a stew cooked according to Western recipes ...

To participate in the survey, you must submit an application in any form to the email address [email protected] In a reply message, survey participants receive an Excel questionnaire file, which must be returned in the completed form. until 20 June 2013.


Welcome to the project, mailbox [email protected] waiting for your applications!

Stanislav Vasilenko, nickname “just Vasilich”
14 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. ziqzaq
    ziqzaq 13 June 2013 08: 41
    +7
    The survey is an archival and archival matter, so comrades .....
    1. Quiet
      Quiet 13 June 2013 21: 30
      0
      The survey is an archival and archival matter, so comrades .....

      Nefig go in for a trip !!! REFERENDUM ONLY will make the ax head nonsense am
  2. fenix57
    fenix57 13 June 2013 08: 47
    +4
    Quote: ziqzaq
    The survey is an archival and archival matter, so comrades .....

    I support, I have already participated, it's interesting to see the overall results! hi Forum users, remain indifferent.
  3. Alekseir162
    Alekseir162 13 June 2013 09: 40
    +3
    I participated in the survey, answered honestly, as I think. I invite everyone to participate in the participation.
    Thanks to the author for the work.
  4. fenix57
    fenix57 13 June 2013 09: 44
    +4
    Quote: fenix57
    Quote: ziqzaq
    The survey is an archival and archival matter, so comrades .....

    I support, I have already participated, it's interesting to see the overall results! hi Forum users, remain indifferent.

    Dear comrades, I forgot something. I’m changing it! Forum users, DO NOT stay indifferent! hi Shame on my gray head .... crying
    1. Gato
      Gato 13 June 2013 11: 31
      +4
      Don’t be killed. You understand everything. drinks laughing
  5. denisey
    denisey 13 June 2013 10: 32
    +2
    I participated in the survey, I want to believe that those in power will see this poll and take certain actions!
    1. Papakiko
      Papakiko 13 June 2013 16: 05
      +1
      Quote: denisey
      that those in power will see this poll and take certain actions

      Well they will see.
      Well read.
      And you believe that knights will fall and forehead will begin to punch the earth or give gifts to needy and robbed to the thread citizens with rested speeches ?!
      The survey is a necessary matter, but in the purely interest of the customer.
      Who is the customer of the proposed survey?
      1. denisey
        denisey 13 June 2013 16: 35
        +1
        Quote: Papakiko
        Well they will see.
        Well read.
        And you believe that knights will fall and forehead will begin to punch the earth or give gifts to needy and robbed to the thread citizens with rested speeches ?!
        The survey is a necessary matter, but in the purely interest of the customer.
        Who is the customer of the proposed survey?

        the point is not that they will see, the point is that the opinion of a certain number of people will make decisions that are beneficial to the people and not to the oligarchs sucking out all the juices from the people!
      2. Just Vasilich
        13 June 2013 18: 38
        +4
        Papakiko: Who is the customer of the proposed survey?

        Perhaps you will not believe, but there is no customer as such. There is an initiative of an individual individual, not even connected with the administration of the site "VO". My initiative is the same site visitor as you, like many others. The survey is conducted among site visitors and, above all, for site visitors.
        1. Papakiko
          Papakiko 13 June 2013 19: 07
          -1
          Quote: Just Vasilich
          The survey is conducted among site visitors and, above all, for site visitors.

          For voting and social polls there is the right side of the resource page, which can easily be adjusted to your needs and aspirations. (After coordinating with the administration, the latter will not be resisted by trends and trends).
          It is very democratic and clear for all groups and layers.
          And your "secret ballot" does not correspond to the aspirations of either the liberal public or all the rest of the visitors painted on national flags.
          And now, the FAQ will give you a "secret vote" and who is the customer?

          Quote: Just Vasilich
          do not believe it, but there is no customer as such.

          V.V. Mayakovsky verse "Listen."
  6. Taoist
    Taoist 13 June 2013 10: 48
    +4
    "One is nonsense! One is zero! The voice of one is thinner than a squeak. Who will hear it? Is it a wife, and then if not a bazaar, but close." (from)

    Do you want to be heard? Take the survey!
    But seriously, the very idea of ​​such a survey and its results are important because our attitude to what is happening, past and future of our country forms the future in which our children live. So, self-relieving ourselves from any actions, we are self-alienating from the future. Yes, alone, the impact of each is negligible and its strength can be neglected (and neglected). But, having formed a vector, the strengths of each turn into something that neglect will not work.
  7. vezunchik
    vezunchik 13 June 2013 11: 20
    +2
    By participated. I look forward to the results with interest.
  8. USNik
    USNik 13 June 2013 11: 31
    0
    To participate in the survey, you must submit an application in any form to the email address [email protected] In response, the survey participants receive an application file in Excel format, which must be returned in full by June 20, 2013.
    How complicated it is, is it possible, right on topvar, to file a survey form?
    1. Just Vasilich
      13 June 2013 12: 25
      0
      USNik: How complicated it is, is it possible to file a survey form right on topvar?

      Unfortunately not. The site does not have such a "saw" (technical capability) to implement the methods used in the survey online.
      1. Gato
        Gato 13 June 2013 13: 30
        0
        Is it possible to simply lay out a link to the profile file?
    2. sergo0000
      sergo0000 14 June 2013 08: 03
      0
      Quote: USNik
      How complicated it is, is it possible, right on topvar, to file a survey form?

      At first glance it is possible. But as soon as I received the file, I immediately figured it out! hi Absolutely nothing complicated. Spent a little more than 30 minutes on the whole form. good We are waiting for the results! Join!
  9. pahom54
    pahom54 13 June 2013 13: 41
    +2
    Today I sent the answers to the questionnaire. This is a good thing, but I want to note that the next time (if there is still such a survey) it is necessary to raise questions more correctly, otherwise it can be difficult to characterize a figure before, in the middle and at the end of the reign. As I understand it, the overall result is implied.
    By the way, according to the results of my assessments, Stalin - Putin - Lukashenko - Nazarbayev lined up in a row (this is the program itself, the coefficients were derived). He answered - I tried honestly, as I myself perceive everything. And such a result ...
  10. Egoza
    Egoza 13 June 2013 16: 24
    +1
    The survey completed and sent. One of those rare cases when the survey is really competent and interesting. I sent a link to other resources to my friends. Let those who are interested take part, even if citizens are not participants in the HE forum.
    Thanks to the author. It will be interesting to look at the results.
  11. Uncle lee
    Uncle lee 14 June 2013 05: 18
    +6
    We are waiting for the results, as the losers of the exam results fellow
  12. PWG
    PWG 19 July 2014 12: 18
    0
    Oh, sorry missed an interesting poll. Will there be a repetition?