A new fuselage on someone else's wings: at what engineering cost did the Tu-104 usher in the jet age?

22 385 68
A new fuselage on someone else's wings: at what engineering cost did the Tu-104 usher in the jet age?


Seventy years since the first scheduled flight - September 15, 1956
What does a person who hasn't worked on the Tu-104 know about it? aviation On purpose? That it was the first Soviet jet—one. That it flew fast—two. That it crashed—three. Experts are debating something else: what engineering feat the Tupolev Design Bureau used to create a passenger airliner in about a year. On March 22, 1956, a Tu-104 landed in London with a Soviet delegation on board. There was exactly one jet passenger plane at the airfield—and it was Soviet: the British Comet, which had been grounded by that time after a series of crashes. Six months later, on September 15, 1956, this aircraft made its first scheduled flight from Moscow to Omsk to Irkutsk, having spent, according to Vnukovo Airport, 7 hours and 10 minutes flying time.



Resolution for the year: How the Tu-16 became a springboard


On June 11, 1954, the USSR Council of Ministers, by Resolution No. 1172-516, instructed OKB-156 to develop a passenger jet. D.S. Markov was appointed to lead the project, while A.N. Tupolev retained overall management. Exactly one year later, on June 17, 1955, test pilot Yu.T. Alasheyev took the prototype Tu-104 on its maiden flight. Twelve months from the resolution to the first flight.


A line of Soviet heavy twin-engine multi-role jet aircraft Tu-16 (NATO reporting name: Badger) on the airfield parking lot

To understand this speed, one fact is needed: by 1954, serial production of the Tu-16 bomber at the Kharkov plant No. 135 was already in full swing. According to stories According to the program's materials on domestic jet aviation, all the Tu-16's lifting surfaces and landing gear—the detachable wing sections, horizontal and vertical tails, engine compartments, main landing gear assemblies, and their nacelles—were carried over to the new aircraft. The powerplant was also carried over: AM-3 engines with a proven production chain. The production tooling, the mastered technology, and the trained workers—all of this already existed. The most complex part of the aircraft to develop—the swept wing with the jet engines at the root—did not need to be redesigned.


A Soviet experimental passenger aircraft Tu-70 in a hangar during construction.

By that time, the OKB had already used the unit-based succession scheme once: the experimental Tu-70 passenger aircraft was built in the late 1940s using the Tu-4 bomber's unit base. The Tu-70 never went into production, but the organizational and design logic—a passenger aircraft on a proven military platform—was proven.

Why "civilian bomber" is an imprecise formula


The Tu-104 is often referred to as a converted Tu-16. This is a convenient abbreviation, but technically it is incorrect, as detailed in the article. Tu-104: The First Civilian Bomber The fuselage was designed from scratch. The diameter increased from approximately 2,8 to 3,5 meters—an increase of about 70 centimeters—but this necessitated a completely new skin structure: as if a thin tube were replaced by a wide barrel with a different load distribution across the frames. The transition from the mid-wing Tu-16 to a low-wing monoplane required a new center section (the structural unit connecting the wing to the fuselage) and a complete redesign of the mating assemblies. Inside, a pressurized passenger cabin—initially with 50 seats—was installed, along with wardrobes, a galley, and civilian navigation equipment.

It turned out that the transition to a low-wing monoplane raised the landing gear's height so much that passengers had to climb a rather steep ramp. The military geometry of the components dictated the proportions of the entire aircraft.


Soviet Tu-104 passenger jets at an airfield in Moscow (Vnukovo Airport), presumably in 1956.

The original version carried 50 passengers. By the Tu-104A, capacity had increased to approximately 70 seats, and by the Tu-104B, to 100, with a takeoff weight of 78,1 tons (according to the type specifications). Cruising speed is 750–800 km/h at altitudes of 10,000–12,000 meters. The Tu-104B datasheet lists two range figures: 2120 km with a commercial payload of 12 tons—enough to fly from Moscow to Omsk with room to spare, but not to Irkutsk nonstop; and 2750 km with a reduced payload of 8,15 tons. The difference: minus 3850 kg of paid cargo in exchange for an increase of 630 kilometers.

The military origins did not go away with the tail guns.


How a swept wing taught a lesson at 12 kilometers


The swept wing is the Tu-16's most significant technical achievement. It allowed for cruising at 750–800 km/h, unattainable for straight-wing aircraft. However, swept wings exhibit a characteristic behavior at high angles of attack: when exceeding the critical angle, the aircraft is prone to a sharp increase in pitching momentum—a so-called "pitch-up" (a spontaneous nose-up). The nose pitches up, the aircraft climbs above the design ceiling, the speed drops below minimum, and the aircraft stalls—and recovering from this behavior at high altitude is virtually impossible.

In less than four months of 1958, there were four "catch-and-go" incidents. On August 15, near Khabarovsk, a Tu-104 lost control and crashed from an altitude of approximately 12 kilometers, killing 64. On October 17, a Beijing-Moscow flight with stopovers, commanded by Harold Kuznetsov, encountered severe turbulence over Chuvashia. At an altitude of approximately 13 kilometers, the aircraft pitched up sharply, lost control, and crashed. All 80 on board, including diplomatic delegations from China and several other countries, were killed. According to the investigation, the cause was loss of control while approaching a critical angle of attack in an updraft.

Following the investigation, the maximum operating altitude was limited to 9000 meters, up from the previous 10,000–12,000 meters. The stabilizer pitch was revised, and the center-of-gravity constraints were adjusted. The risk was reduced, but the wing's basic aerodynamics remained unchanged: the altitude limitation also meant a reduction in fuel efficiency on every flight.


The nose section of the crashed Soviet Tu-104A jet airliner, which crashed on February 7, 1981, during takeoff from the Pushkin military airfield near Leningrad.

The comparison is indicative. British de Havilland Comet, designed as a passenger aircraft without any military component base, suffered catastrophic failures of the pressurized cabin in 1954 due to fatigue cracking near the square windows. The nature of the problems was fundamentally different: for the Tu-104, it was the aerodynamics of the inherited swept wing at passenger altitudes; for the Comet, it was the lack of understanding of the fatigue life of the pressurized structure under repeated pressurization cycles. Both programs operated in modes that had never been flown regularly before, but they failed in different ways. Read more about the Tu-104 accidents and the 1981 crash that claimed the lives of the Pacific Fleet command. fleet, — in the material How Almost the Entire Command of the USSR's Pacific Fleet Perished in a Plane Crash.

Seventy years later: what remains


At the Civil Aviation History Museum in Ulyanovsk, one of the few surviving aircraft stands outdoors. It was the same aircraft that astonished the British press in March 1956—and the same type that, two and a half years later, discovered the bomber's legacy over Chuvashia.


Aeroflot operated the Tu-104 until the end of 1979. During this time, according to available data, the fleet carried approximately 100 million passengers, logging approximately 2 million flight hours on approximately 600 flights. According to open sources, the type suffered 23 fatal accidents during its service life. Between 200 and 201 aircraft of all variants were built (sources differ); production ceased in 1960.

The engineering choice of 1954—to use an existing wing rather than design it from scratch—was sound: it gave Aeroflot a year of development instead of three and allowed it to launch scheduled jet service. The price was not that the wing was military-grade, but that the swept wing didn't perform as expected at passenger altitudes. Neither a triumph nor a tragedy—it was an engineering compromise with a clear outcome on both sides.
68 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. + 34
    15 September 2026 05: 37
    Harold Kuznetsov deserves a special mention.
    It was his broadcast of what was happening to the plane, essentially a live report on his own death, that revealed the details of the disaster and provided invaluable material for analysis and subsequent modifications to the airframe.
    It is worth recalling that the motives of Kuznetsov's life are reflected in the feature film "Once Again About Love" starring Doronina and Lazarev.
    1. + 12
      15 September 2026 11: 12
      Quote: U-58
      Harold Kuznetsov deserves a special mention.
      It was his broadcast of what was happening to the plane, essentially a live report on his own death, that revealed the details of the disaster and provided invaluable material for analysis and subsequent modifications to the airframe.

      Exactly, but Tupolev refused to acknowledge the design defect for a long time and blamed the pilots for allegedly not knowing how to fly the plane.
    2. + 13
      15 September 2026 15: 06
      This legend has been debunked several times. Immediately after the publication of "Death Live" in the "RG" newspaper on August 24, the Omsk office of "Rossiyskaya Gazeta" received a call from Lev Andreevich Stepanenko, former head of the fuselage shop at the former aircraft plant No. 166 (now the Polet aerospace production association). From 1956 to 60, the plant was engaged in serial production of the Tu-104 airliner. A total of 61 aircraft of this series were produced in Omsk.

      "I know for certain about three crashes of the first Soviet jet passenger plane," says Lev Stepanenko. "In two cases, Kharkiv-made aircraft crashed, and in one, ours."

      Tu-104 production began at a Ukrainian plant, but its capacity was relatively limited and it was behind schedule. Soon, our company also received the technical documentation for assembly. We entered serial production in August 1956, almost simultaneously with Kharkov. Regular passenger flights from Moscow to Irkutsk began in October. Two years later, serial production of the Tu-104 also began at the Kazan aircraft plant.

      The news of the plane crash reached me in Crimea. The first thing I did was call my Ukrainian colleague, the head of the fuselage shop in Kharkiv: "Whose plane is it?" He replied that he wasn't sure yet, but it looked like it wasn't theirs this time. Well, I thought, that's it – time to go to jail. But there were no complaints about the plant afterwards – no defects were found. During the investigation, I was briefed on the plane's communications with ground crews.

      The captain was a highly experienced pilot. His name was Shcherbakov, the son of the first secretary of the Moscow city party committee and the head of the Soviet Information Bureau. Back then, serving in the aviation industry was considered prestigious among the children of the highest Soviet leadership. Remember the sons of Stalin, Khrushchev, and Mikoyan... On board, there was screaming, noise, panic, groans, and swearing—as we always do, we remember our mothers—the cockpits of the first planes were not separated from the passenger compartment, and terrorism and even hijackings were unthinkable back then. The pilot proved to be a man of rare composure. And just before the crash, his composure remained unwavering: "We're going to die, there's nothing we can do. Tell Tupolev we can't fly above 9 meters. We were going at eleven. We hit a column of air, lifted up, the nose suddenly pitched up, flipped over, and lost control. We fell like a leaf, then went into a spin. Have them pay attention to the stabilizer's angle of attack."
  2. +9
    15 September 2026 06: 18
    As a child, I flew with my family from Novosibirsk to Omsk on a Tu-104 in 1962.
    Before landing, the pilot made such a turn that many passengers, including me, vomited.
    Not the most pleasant memories.
    1. + 11
      15 September 2026 07: 41
      Quote: andrewkor
      As a child, I flew with my family from Novosibirsk to Omsk on a Tu-104.
      I also flew with my parents from Mineralnye Vody to Irkutsk when I was a preschooler. I remember everyone was given special bags for those who couldn't stand the flight or for those who felt nauseous. But my favorite treat was the lollipops. Takeoffs, the taste of which I still remember...
      1. +2
        15 September 2026 14: 01
        Quote: Luminman
        But most of all I liked the Vzletnye lollipops, the taste of which I still remember...

        "Chill" is what we called them.
      2. +1
        19 September 2026 06: 32
        Handing out bags and candies is a tradition on the Tu-104. Several times per flight. And the bags were collected. Filled.
        1. -1
          21 September 2026 18: 35
          As a child, I flew once on a Li-14. They gave me candy and tea bags. It was like flying on a "crazy stool." The tradition of candy and tea bags was carried over to other planes, including the Tu-104, which I flew on many times. But I never saw any filled tea bags.
          1. -1
            22 September 2026 17: 00
            Personally, I've filled it out more than once))))). Well, and I've seen it from others. How the hell was it?;"##flying on a Tu-104 again! After that, the Tu-154 was simply a miracle of miracles. Yes, even the An-12 is wonderful.
    2. +6
      15 September 2026 08: 55
      Good morning, colleagues .
      I flew in 75 from Chelyabinsk to Khabarovsk, with stopovers, of course.
      What do you remember?
      Terribly loud. Sat somewhere opposite the engines.
      1. +1
        15 September 2026 11: 26
        I flew the same thing, I was only 6 years old, but I remember something happened, there was smoke, and the flight attendant walked through the cabin and turned on something on the ceiling, we were landed in Irkutsk and quickly escorted out of the cabin, we were flying to Khabarovsk from Krasnoyarsk.
      2. +7
        15 September 2026 15: 32
        Quote: Blacksmith 55
        Terribly loud. Sat somewhere opposite the engines.

        laughing
        - Why was Hottabych pulling hairs?
        - I wanted, oh most precious...
        - Briefly speaking.
        - I just wanted, oh Volka...
        - Even shorter.
        - I wanted it to be quiet. Am I being concise enough now?...
      3. 0
        21 September 2026 18: 36
        We didn't know what to compare it to back then. It just kept flying.
    3. +4
      15 September 2026 11: 10
      Quote: andrewkor
      As a child, I flew with my family from Novosibirsk to Omsk on a Tu-104 in 1962.

      As a child, I flew with my parents on a Tu-124 from Volgograd to Simferopol in the summer of 1965-68. It looked identical to a Tu-104. I remember they handed out lollipops, packets of vodka, and cups of lemonade. I also remember the plane bouncing on air pockets when it passed through cloud cover during takeoff and landing. On my first flight, when it suddenly dropped into one of these, everything inside it would collapse.
      1. +3
        15 September 2026 16: 24
        Quote: Boton
        I still remember
        I still remember the time when smoking was allowed in the cabin...
        1. 0
          15 September 2026 16: 38
          Quote: Luminman
          I still remember the time when smoking was allowed in the cabin...

          In the 60s, smoking on board an airplane was not yet prohibited.
          1. +1
            15 September 2026 16: 45
            Quote: Boton
            In the 60s, smoking on board an airplane was not yet prohibited.
            In the mid-1970s, it was possible too – my father smoked like a chimney. Later, we went to the bathroom to smoke, but in hiding...
      2. 0
        16 September 2026 19: 08
        At the same time, on the same Tu-124, from Volgograd to Adler. Who knew how many more flights I'd have to fly on very large and small planes.
  3. + 11
    15 September 2026 06: 39
    Twelve months from the decree to the air.

    There was pride for the country!
    1. + 13
      15 September 2026 12: 14
      Twelve months from the decree to the air.
      There was pride for the country!

      In fact, a passenger plane was launched into production without adequate testing, without bringing its aerodynamics and control system to a safe level, just to beat the bigwigs.
      Official figures.
      Total losses: Of the 201 aircraft produced, 37 were lost as a result of accidents and disasters.
      A total of 1137 people died in these air accidents.

      Isn't the price for a "record" too high?
      1. 0
        15 September 2026 16: 30
        Quote from Andy_nsk
        Isn't the price for a "record" too high?
        At the dawn of the jet age, there was a British passenger airliner like this Comet, whose fuselage literally disintegrated in mid-air. A lot of people died there too...
      2. -1
        21 September 2026 18: 41
        It's unfair to compare now and then. Back then, hundreds were killed in western Ukraine alone; it was post-war, and every year counted.
        1. +4
          22 September 2026 00: 59
          I don't see any connection between the deaths in Western Ukraine and the launch of an under-tested civilian aircraft. Everyone should do their job until it's fully completed. The design bureau should finish the development, the NKVD should strangle the Bandera bastards. How could the rapid introduction of the aircraft have helped the fight against the Ukronazis? Don't confuse the sweet with the sweet: separate the flies from the cutlets!
    2. 0
      19 September 2026 06: 38
      We had to catch up and overtake. And we did...
  4. + 14
    15 September 2026 06: 48
    Quote: your vsr 66-67
    There was pride for the country!
    That's how it was Country!
  5. The comment was deleted.
  6. Eug
    +4
    15 September 2026 09: 09
    "...the transition to a low-wing aircraft raised the landing gear's parking altitude..."

    I would like to understand how this works?
    1. +8
      15 September 2026 09: 24
      That's about it. The distance from the strip to the plane remains the same.
      And lowering the wings to a low-wing position is equivalent to raising the fuselage. The fuselage (including the access hatches) correspondingly became taller, requiring a steeper ramp.
      But it was possible to depict a gentle ramp of exorbitant length.
      This is THIS length, this is THIS height.
      Choose whichever one you want.
      It's appropriate to laugh at the ramp on the Tu-114.
      The distance is enormous.
      In the US, the first time I arrived, the gangway was a pain in the ass, lasting tens of minutes.
      1. 0
        15 September 2026 10: 13
        Quote: U-58
        In the US, the first time I arrived with the gangway, I had a lot of trouble.

        They had a real problem with the ramp to the Tu-114.
      2. +5
        15 September 2026 10: 57
        Quote: U-58
        It's appropriate to laugh at the ramp on the Tu-114.

        Well, what can you do? It’s a low-wing aircraft with huge propellers, and a fuselage with a diameter of over 4 m.

        It's a trap! © laughing

        By the way, the Tu-114 is the same Pax based on a bomber, and a low-wing aircraft made from a high-wing aircraft.
        1. 0
          15 September 2026 15: 30
          impressive military successes
          Quote: Alexey RA
          The Tu-114 is a similar Pax-based bomber.

          Well, yes, it was designed in 1955 based on the Tu-95 bomber.
          1. +3
            15 September 2026 16: 52
            And by the way, the Tu-114 has never had a single crash (at least, certainly not involving passengers). Although, it would seem, the same basic principles apply: from bomber to passenger, from mid-wing to low-wing, swept wing...
            1. 0
              15 September 2026 17: 21
              Quote: Quzmi4
              It would seem that all the same inputs: from a bomber to a passenger, from a mid-wing to a low-wing, swept wing...

              The internet reports that the Tu-114 was not prone to aerodynamic lift—an involuntary change in angle of attack and pitch that can lead to a sudden nose-up and loss of control.
              1. 0
                16 September 2026 11: 07
                It's in the details like these that the devil lies. The Tu-16/104 has a significantly lower wing aspect ratio (the ratio of wingspan to mean chord) than the Tu-95/114, and this apparently accounts for its tendency to overshoot. And its military origins and precocity, as the article suggests, are not the cause of accidents.
                1. 0
                  19 September 2026 06: 28
                  If the test pilot is fighting, then the plane clearly has problems.
    2. +2
      15 September 2026 10: 53
      The location of the fuselage relative to the wing plane
    3. +1
      15 September 2026 11: 43
      The height from the concrete to the wing remained almost unchanged. But the fuselage seemed to rise (low-wing configuration).
      The height of the chassis supports has also increased.
    4. +1
      16 September 2026 19: 10
      Probably maintain the distance from the air intake to the surface.
  7. +4
    15 September 2026 09: 14
    The accident rate is like that of a military aircraft.

    I once flew Moscow-Kutaisi. The flight was delayed an hour. I asked the flight attendant why it was delayed. Her Georgian-accented reply stuck in my mind: the plane was old, and while they were fixing it...
    1. +4
      15 September 2026 10: 02
      Official figures.
      Total losses: Of the 201 aircraft produced, 37 were lost as a result of accidents and disasters.
      A total of 1137 people died in these air accidents.
  8. +4
    15 September 2026 10: 07
    As a child, I flew with my parents from Vladivostok several times. My ears hurt a lot during landing, because apparently the cabin pressure regulation system wasn't perfect yet. Several stopovers weren't a burden, nor was any discomfort, because even before arriving at Vladivostok airport, the Kneviches had experienced real adventures – a 600-kilometer trip in the back of a truck along terrible country roads, with transfers to the cabins of fuel trucks. The family hitchhiked through the taiga, each in a separate truck. I adored those minutes waiting at the airport, where various airliners were taking off – a Tu-104, an Il-18, and a Tu-114, all of which I was fortunate enough to fly.
  9. The comment was deleted.
  10. +2
    15 September 2026 13: 55
    It's possible (and it should have been 20 years ago) to make the Tu-204 (214) into a military version: a radar and airborne early warning system. Or maybe some kind of Tu-22M3M replacement, adjusted for modern anti-ship missiles and cruise missiles.
    There should be fewer unique aircraft. Identical avionics, cockpits, turbojet engines, systems...all of this simplifies production, logistics, and maintenance.
  11. +2
    15 September 2026 13: 59
    As old man Hottabych said:
    "How fast and comfortable this air chariot is, it's just a little noisy."
  12. +4
    15 September 2026 13: 59
    Tu-104, as DH Comet were the firstborn.
    All the illnesses and all the plane crashes flowed from there.
  13. The comment was deleted.
  14. 0
    15 September 2026 16: 57
    I never flew a Tu-104. I smoked Tu-104s when there was a shortage, and you couldn't get Java, Cosmos, Rostov, or Nasha Marka. You had to smoke Bulgarian, or even Cuban Liberos or Partagas.
    1. +3
      15 September 2026 17: 43
      Did such cigarettes really exist? I think they were called Tu-134, and there were also "Stewardess" cigarettes, which prompted our dean to joke during a volcano hike on Kunashir: "Better a stewardess than a Tu-134!" and the students burst into laughter, though they probably didn't understand anything about family life...
      1. +3
        15 September 2026 18: 16
        However, I got it mixed up. There were Soviet Tu-104s (red stripe), and Bulgarian Tu-134s, blue with a white stripe.
        The Tu-104s flashed by and quickly disappeared, but the Tu-134s were still around, even when Gorbachev was gone. Later, I remember they gave us some "Krupka" tobacco during military training; the partisans smoked it after the movies so much that the searchlight above the barracks could barely penetrate the smoke. The first secretary of the regional party committee responded to the partisans' requests, but I don't know where he found it. I bought some of that shag for myself, too, and rolled my own cigarettes, and my wife kept packs in the closet with her clothes to protect them from moths.
    2. +2
      15 September 2026 19: 25
      Faterodom.
      Ligeros and not Liberos, that was the name of this brand.
      Very strong.
      1. +2
        15 September 2026 22: 26
        And the translation, paradoxically, is “easy”.
        Ligeros was a brand of Cuban cigarettes exported to the USSR in the 1970s and 1980s. They were known for their exceptionally high strength.
        They were made from dark Criollo cigar tobacco, which is known for its high nicotine content. The cigarette papers were wrapped with scraps and crumbs left over from Cuban cigar production.
        The paper was made from bagasse, the fibrous waste product of sugar cane processing, which gave it a sweet taste.
        The cigarettes were unfiltered.
        In Leningrad, we ate at the Havana store near the Gorkovskaya metro station. It was a beautiful, stylish store.
        1. 0
          16 September 2026 08: 33
          Quote: balabol
          Ligeros was a brand of Cuban cigarettes exported to the USSR in the 1970s and 1980s. They were known for their exceptionally high strength.

          Oh, and there were also Partagas and Montecristo, also thermonuclear hi
          1. 0
            19 September 2026 21: 41
            Quote: Kotofeich
            Oh, and there were also Partagas and Montecristo, also thermonuclear

            N. Upman has been forgotten. wink
  15. +2
    15 September 2026 18: 29
    What is that two-headed miracle in the first photo?
    1. 0
      16 September 2026 11: 09
      AI rules(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( (((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((
  16. 0
    15 September 2026 21: 42
    Author: Aeroflot operated the Tu-104 until the end of 1979. During this time, according to available data, the fleet carried approximately 100 million passengers, logging approximately 2 million flight hours on approximately 600 flights. According to open sources, the type suffered 23 accidents during its service life. Between 200 and 201 aircraft of all variants were built—sources differ—and production ceased in 1960.


    We take the number of passengers and divide it by the number of flights – we get an average of 166 passengers. There's a discrepancy.
    Although, it depends on how you count.
  17. +1
    15 September 2026 23: 01
    In fact, the Tu-104 didn't break any new ground. More "analogue-networking." The first jet passenger aircraft was the De Havilland Comet in 1949. However, it didn't fly for long. After a series of crashes due to structural issues (the angular windows on the hastily designed fuselage acted as stress concentrators), it was withdrawn from service. On this subject, Nevill Shute (who not only authored "On the Beach" but also, surprisingly, designed a rather exotic series of high-speed fighters in the 40s, as well as head of the British Military Engineering Establishment during WWII) wrote a novel about the industry, "No Highway," in which he, as a designer, predicted these tragedies back in 1948. The third jet passenger aircraft was the French Sud Aviation SE-210 Caravelle, which flew in May 1955 – a month before the Tu-104. But regular service there only began in 1959 (by the way, it's sitting here in Tesla in a rather sad state, I feel sorry for it). So, the Tu-104 was rightfully either second or third—depending on how you count.
  18. +3
    15 September 2026 23: 51
    What kind of horror did the AI ​​draw again with two muzzles and no pods for the chassis, but with a machine gun cabin in the back?
    1. 0
      16 September 2026 11: 10
      And what about a wingtip with a wing-to-wing refueling system for a PASSENGER aircraft?!
  19. +3
    16 September 2026 01: 00
    I remember the Tu-104 because of the Moscow-Odessa flight crash in 1979.
    In which my classmate's mother died.
    After this air crash, the operation of the Tu-104 was completely stopped.
  20. +2
    16 September 2026 09: 02
    One day in the mid-60s, we missed a flight from Moscow to Vladik, which wasn't surprising, since Mom was carrying our daughter in one arm and a huge fiber suitcase in the other. She also had to slap and kick me, a repulsive kindergartener who was always trying to hide somewhere in the airport, to hurry. We arrived in our small town on the shores of the Sea of ​​Japan, amidst numerous adventures on planes, trains, and trucks. Mom was quite a famous figure in town, as in addition to teaching all sorts of slackers at night school, she was a shining opera singer on the community center stage and a local television announcer. Naturally, the whole town knew we were dead, as Flight Tu-104 had crashed, and everyone we knew approached Mom in amazement on the street, asking, "Are you alive?"
  21. 0
    19 September 2026 06: 20
    The desire to be first and adventurism cost both us and the British dearly. The Tu-104 needed to be replaced quickly. There are too many sad stories about it. I even know someone who returned his ticket for the Tu-104's last flight. From Odessa. I checked later. Everything matched.
    I flew on one as a child, when I was in kindergarten. The memories are terrifying. Just waiting for the flight on that tin can, where I was constantly vomiting and the noise and vibrations were terrifying, was torture. Smoking on board really helped.
    And then I learned that a drag chute was required for landing. If it wasn't used, there was a risk of crashing the plane on landing.
    Tupolev's authority and adventurism allowed this aircraft to be pushed through and kept in service.
    1. -1
      21 September 2026 06: 11
      That's your idea, but the government's idea was that you could reach Vladivostok by train in a week, and the Urals in 3-4 days. An airplane was needed to monitor and maintain the territory. Especially considering the war with NATO was at stake. And 2-3 thousand over 15 years of operation is a government trifle. We die more from bootleg vodka every year.
  22. 0
    19 September 2026 21: 51
    However, swept wings exhibit a characteristic behavior at high angles of attack: when exceeding the critical angle of attack, the aircraft is prone to a sharp increase in pitching moment—a so-called "pitch-up" (a spontaneous nose-up). The nose pitches up, the aircraft climbs above the design ceiling, the speed drops below minimum, and the aircraft stalls—and recovery from this behavior at high altitude is virtually impossible.

    I don't get it—didn't the bomber have this problem? It also had swept wings. And I doubt it flew at lower altitudes.
    1. 0
      2 October 2026 20: 29
      Well, why not? 1507 Tu-16s were produced, 126 were lost in accidents. Let me remind you that of the approximately 200 Tu-104s produced, 23 crashed, so the ratio is roughly the same.
  23. -2
    21 September 2026 13: 17
    I think if they'd thought to move the engine under the wing and shorten the landing gear a bit, they could have created a monstrous aircraft similar to the Boeing 737, the most successful aircraft in the world. Unfortunately, we chose to copy the Boeing 727 or Caravelle and lost the boat. A Boeing 737 equivalent only recently appeared, almost 60 years later, and yet our MC21 suffers from numerous teething problems. They inexplicably increased the cabin diameter, adding extra pounds. And the saga of the black wing, instead of an all-metal one, significantly delayed the entry of our copy into service.
    1. -1
      2 October 2026 20: 40
      And how is the MC-21 a copy of the B-737?
  24. +1
    24 September 2026 10: 18
    "A little lie breeds great mistrust" is a well-known expression.
    I read and read the article until I came across this passage: "...by 1954, serial production of the Tu-16 bomber at Kharkov Plant No. 135 was already in full swing."
    A question immediately arose for the author: what is your connection to aviation?
    Not only were the Tu-16s not in full production in Kharkiv, they'd never even seen one there. It's a well-known fact that the Tu-16 was produced from 1953 to 1963 by three aircraft factories: Plant No. 22 in Kazan, Plant No. 1 in Kuibyshev, and Plant No. 64 in Voronezh. That's all.
    It is especially offensive for me to read such scribblings, since I lived not far from the 135th plant, and my father worked there for some time.
    1. -1
      2 October 2026 20: 39
      The author made a mistake.
      It happens..
  25. -1
    2 October 2026 20: 33
    To understand this speed, one fact is needed: by 1954, serial production of the Tu-16 bomber at Kharkiv Plant No. 135 was already in full swing.

    What kind of nonsense is this from the author?

    Serial production of the Tu-16 was deployed in Kazan, Kuibyshev and Voronezh.
  26. 0
    11 October 2026 23: 28
    It’s a pity that the topic of the Tu-104 was not touched upon, as a flying laboratory – it is both cosmonautics and testing of aircraft missiles.