Military Review

Errors of national policy in Russia on the example of the creation of Russian and Tatar identities: an opinion

26
It is not a secret for anyone that today’s general vector of development of Russia is not defined, and Russian society is in need of some kind of universal idea that can unite and unite all social strata. However, the years go by, and the vector is not located and the consolidating idea is not formulated. What is the reason? I will try to answer some questions that, it seems to me, are long overdue and every day bring the socio-political crisis in our country closer.


First of all, this is the ideology of Eurocentrism, which is adopted by the leadership of Russia. Eurocentrism is a set of false assumptions: a civilization mission, combined with universalism, multiculturalism and, as a result, the creation of national states within large ones, such as Russia, India or China. They are the targets of the West and the United States and are subject to deconstruction through the "self-determination of peoples" and the creation of armed conflicts in their territories.

Unfortunately, it is on the basis of this approach that the Concept of National Policy in the Russian Federation has been developed. It does not reflect reality and does not provide answers to urgent questions. The situation that has developed in Russia in the relations of ethnic groups is a real antagonistic conflict. While it exists in a latent form. At its base is a series of national issues (Russian, Tatar, Mordovian, Jewish, etc.), the resolution of which is delayed, but all of which are caused by a policy of constructing a "civic nation" that effectively abolishes ethnic groups in Russia.

Consider these problems on the example of the formation of Tatar and Russian identities. The identification of Tatars and Russians comes in the form of a Russian super-ethnos — a cultural-historical type made up of Turks, Iranian-Alans, Finno-Finns, Eurasians, Slavs-Russians. The system "I - we" exists in the Russian-Tatar type of education and training, the type of general stories, self-consciousness - “I am Tatar” and “I am Russian” with two native languages, general literature, their roles and statuses in the social structure of the Volga economic region and Tatarstan.

Identification of the so-called "Russians" into a civil society-state is a nominalistic constructivist fiction, which disappears when the argument changes. After all, statehood is a variable structure. Identification in Russian superethnos, Tatar ethnos - primary, genuine and primordial, autochthonous. The form of the state is easy to change, and ethnic identification cannot be changed by population and socio-demographic.

State, regional, socio-occupational identifications and identities are secondary, imposed by force without an essential identity. Of course, statistically it is possible to show the growth of all-Russian identification, but it is the external form that quickly forms and quickly disappears, not denying the separatist process, not denying terrorism (in Tatarstan it will increase), but suggesting it in line with the growth of Tatars' self-awareness.

At collision of primary and secondary identification secondary disappears. Considering that the external geopolitical factor aims at eliminating the Russian people and the Russian state, ethnogenesis in the “national” subjects of Russia will support the separatist process, if it is not organized by solving the emerging super-ethnic issues.

Another factor is Wahhabism. This is an indicator of the genesis of new social and ethnic groups. And this is not pure terrorism. His terrorist image and behavior - reactive and constructive behavior should be considered in the model of Eurocentricism and Western aggression against all the peoples of the world.

Another reason is the administrative and territorial structure of Russia. In fact, in the economic regionalization of Russia, the title ethnos act as subjects. Distorted descriptions of reality are created, on this basis, political decisions are made that accumulate errors and lead to a general catastrophe.

However, it should be borne in mind that the people in power on moral and educational grounds cannot make decisions on truth, justice, equality and decency. In the Russian Federation "a criminal state is created by thieves and for theft" (M. Weller), and therefore the judgments of scientists cannot influence decision-making.

In general, science in Russia has never influenced decision making, except for the Soviet era. Official positions, opinions, points of view, probabilistic statements and statements are not relevant to scientific and balanced judgments. Official optimism, realism, meliorism, probabism and aggressive constructivism are not relevant to healthy scientific pessimism.

Theories of self-determination of ethnic groups V.I. Lenin, cultural-national autonomy of K.Rener, superethnos (N.Ya. Danilevsky and L.Gumilev) are not outdated. The territorial principle never allows compromise and equality; he brings with him only struggle and oppression, since his essence is domination. The time of the republics, if ethnic groups want to develop and compete with other ethnic groups, it’s up! Russia will face the fate of the Austrian Empire, if by 2025, the republics will not be replaced by ordinary economic regions.

Not the last role is played by other political steps of the Russian leadership. For example, the result of the current educational policy of the Russian Federation will be the development of self-awareness of titular ethnic groups for the exit of republics from the Russian Federation - due to the lack of identity and the accumulation of cultural differences. This is how the sociocultural dynamics of non-Slavic subjects of the Federation unfolds. At the same time, the Russian super-ethnos is being deconstructed in order to form an assimilative population group.

The problem of migration is obvious - stimulating migration is necessary to increase the rate of profit in a private-ownership and democratic economy and to assimilate ethnic groups. Only partial migration is natural in order to preserve ethnic groups as a natural evolutionary diversity, and therefore migration should be prohibited by law, and the state is focused on equalizing working conditions in all regions of the Russian Federation.

All these contradictions are most vividly, although in a hidden (latent) form can be observed in the Republic of Tatarstan. In Tatarstan, the construction of a purely Tatar Islamic highlighted reality is now taking place. The leadership of Tatarstan actually constructs the Islamic reality (Islamic barbershops, studios, taxis, festivals of Muslim fashion, cinema, etc.), in which representatives of the Russian ethnic group have no place. This constructivism is based on strength, not truth and justice.

Equally, the construction was the image of the world in the national socialism of A. Hitler, which, by the way, is no less objective than Turkic fascism or the present constructivism of Moscow in the form of non-interference in the affairs of the Tatar criminal elite.

An analysis of the state of education and culture in the Republic of Tatarstan shows their general degradation. In particular, the deterioration of the knowledge of Russian literary language leads to the degradation of the scientific discovery and inventive thinking of the Tatar ethnic group. The imitational nature of technology parks leads to degradation; imitation of transformations in secondary and higher schools (for example, Kazan Federal University); ousting the Russian component from the academic and artistic elites; the schism of the Russian school into Mari, Chuvash, Mordovian, Udmurt, Jewish schools.

Studying in such schools specifically develops de-identification, provokes the growth of racism and nationalism, leads to the formation of self-consciousness of the Tatar people - for secession from the Russian Federation and forcing out of Tatarstan people of non-Tatar ethnicity.

Literary Russian language is a sufficient condition for the development of the ability of scientific thinking in general; thinking is difficult in the languages ​​of mathematics and physics without a literary language. Ultimately, such a model of education, with which the Federal Center agrees, leads to the elimination of the Russian Federation as a whole on the basis of the ongoing constructivist policy of shaping the population as a civilian state community (V. A. Tishkov). This is just a matter of time and duration of the decay of Russia on the basis of oil money and the export of oil and gas abroad.

I note that today the Federal Center is not Russian, it is deeply cosmopolitan and represents not the Russian people, but the pseudo-ethnos - “Muscovites and Leningraders”, parasitizing on the Russian people and the ethnic groups of Eurasia, including on the Tatar ethnic group. This is also a condition of growing ethnic and interregional tension, which is constructed artificially in order to maintain the power of the Center. Therefore, the Slavs-Russian abandoned in the ethnic republics to the mercy of fate and will never be supported.

The agglomeration of institutions at the University of Kazan, the merger of universities in Moscow and other cities, the wild definition of effective and inefficient universities - barbarism, obscurantism, a complex of homo debilis (weakness of intelligence) power. What is needed is not giant centralized freaks such as the Far Eastern University or Kazan University, but consortia and the Confederation of Universities, which have funds ranging from 25 million euros to 100 million euros, while maintaining and increasing state financing of all universities, regardless of ownership. Growth funding required at least 15% per year.

What is the social system in Tatarstan and what is the measure of violence and coercion in government? The current Tatarstan is a feudal-clan, criminal system, a system with limited access to property and power, lack of upward social mobility, a system in which policies of resource usurpation, deprivation of access to power, abuse of power, inequality and hierarchy are carried out. Duration of employment positions, lack of cadence lead to curtailment of investments and their inefficiency.

In addition, the Federal Center today has no theoretical and experimental basis for national and reproduction policies. He sells the local criminal elites the right to exploit local resources and control, non-interference in the affairs of elites and their struggle for the necessary for the central government election results to the State Duma and presidential elections, loyalty to the people in power.

As a result, instead of calm and balance, we have acts of terrorism and Wahhabism, growing inequality and hatred. At the same time, there is no real protest movement. Under these conditions, the bourgeoisie increases profits by reducing the cost of labor, reducing spending on education and health care, without investing money in fixed capital and increasing productivity of labor. In Tatarstan, purely Asian feudal clan capitalism is being formed with a racist component.

To escape from this development option, a model of the joint history of the Russian and Tatar ethnic groups, the Eurasian history in its geopolitics and confrontation of both Turks and Slavs - the West is necessary.

In the meantime, the future depends more and more on the randomness of the struggle of the clans than on the deterministic and stable processes. They lead to the death of the Russian people, the Russian state, including the Tatar people. The probability of accidents, allowing to generate an expanded reproduction of the Russian and Tatar peoples, is reduced.

As for the "historical grievances" between the Russians and the Tatars, there is something in history that must be remembered, and that, while preserving knowledge of him, in the words of F. Nietzsche, one should forget. The history of the Russians and Tatars was formed as a common one, we together stood in competition with the West and the East. We have a common Russian great history, and separately we will disappear. Our destiny is to live, fight and die, or survive - together!

Tatar ethnos is a subethnos of the Russian people. His death will not allow parts to survive, because with the death of the Russian people in Eurasia, other peoples will establish themselves, among whom there will be no place for either Russians or Tatars. Today, both Russians and Tatars have approached the line of historical and biological death, crowding out into non-being. The Russian people can survive, if only it preserves its integrity, and individually no Eurasian ethnic group will survive in competition with the EU, China, Iran, Turkey and Japan.
Author:
Originator:
http://www.regnum.ru/
26 comments
Ad

The editorial board of Voenniy Obozreniye urgently needs a proofreader. Requirements: impeccable knowledge of the Russian language, diligence, discipline. Contact: [email protected]

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. smel
    smel 31 May 2013 06: 34 New
    15
    Well. Opinion after all. But personally, I largely disagree with the author. Too abstruse, categorical and gloomy. But it is necessary to start with history, with the reasons for unification in the past and the search for additional incentives in the present for the joint development and preservation of national cultures and interests. The Russian people are so great that they were able to defend their independence, integrity and unite many other nations and countries around them. By the way, we paid for this with human lives and hardships.
    1. annenkov242
      annenkov242 31 May 2013 07: 21 New
      +5
      Russia, in the 90s, represented as a herd of horses rushing to the abyss, while everything worthy was trampled, and now a leader has appeared who is slowly leading the "herd" in the right direction, and Thank God.
      Everything is needed, time.
      1. Ivan.
        Ivan. 31 May 2013 08: 08 New
        +3
        As for the necessary direction, it is exaggerated, just aside from the abyss - then the People must say their word, I hope it will be soon and He (we) will not listen to any "shepherds".
        1. Z.A.M.
          Z.A.M. 31 May 2013 08: 49 New
          10
          Quote: Ivan.
          then the People should say their word

          Must, must ... Yes, and he will say, here we are talking on the site.
          Just hear no one and no reason.
          The author very correctly said the phrase Weller - "In the Russian Federation" a criminal state was created by thieves and for theft " Well, who will listen to us (the people)? The thieves?
          Or, an impotent government with the State Duma?

          "Condition Analysis education and culture in the Republic of Tatarstan shows their general degradation. "This is a quote from the article.
          Unfortunately, the degradation of all of Russia.

          And further. On migration - the author is a separate plus.
          The article is very true.
          1. Ivan.
            Ivan. 31 May 2013 10: 15 New
            +2
            Quote: Z.A.M.
            Must, must ... Yes, and he will say, here we are talking on the site.
            That's just no one to hear and no reason.

            I mean to say is to do power can do anything only after the slap.
            -In front of the herd is a horned ram. Sheep thinks that he knows where he is leading them and he just goes ahead - not dusty and a good choice of grass.

            So we are not sheep, but they are trying to convince us of this! The power cannot determine the choice and be responsible for the development of the People, only fulfill its business, and for this the People themselves must fully realize what was written long ago - THE ONLY SOURCE OF POWER IN THE COUNTRY IS THE PEOPLE, no matter how convinced he is that he is only a philistine and a consumer and everything that is his strength is patriotism. Strength is in unity, which means that this is our powerlessness (since we do not have it) and the main reason for this is SMD, which bring "viruses" of different nature into the unity of the People and distract it to various passions and instincts without disdaining open programming.
            1. Z.A.M.
              Z.A.M. 31 May 2013 12: 10 New
              +3
              Quote: Ivan.
              THE ONLY SOURCE OF AUTHORITY IN THE COUNTRY IS THE PEOPLE-

              Naturally, I also wish this ... Again, I studied the "Theory of State and Law" ... But the reality does not confirm this. Unfortunately.
              There are thousands of examples. Rosbalt article.

              “The laws that are flying out of the“ mad printer ”by the hundreds (as the country's parliament is now called) not only restricted the rights and freedoms of most Russian citizens, but gave unheard-of powers to all kinds of overseers who are called upon to enforce the new rules. We are talking about police officers and prosecutors, private security guards, metro and station controllers, clerks of Roskomnadzor and even employees of housing and communal services ...
              ... "On May 12, we were beaten at the Kursk railway station in the capital of Russia. This was done by a crowd of drunk guest workers whom Russian Railways dressed up in the uniform of inspectors. These inspectors extorted money from us for the opportunity to leave the platform in the city with bicycles - we asked to open the luggage turnstile, and the controllers said that they would do it only for money, "eyewitnesses of the events told Live Journal ...

              ... And here is another telling story - in Cheboksary, employees of local housing services stood at the entrances and exits of the city and engaged in extortion, demanding 2500 rubles for each driver’s wagon. The videos that the victims publish are staggering - the gopniks in orange vests behave exactly like the bandits from the 1990s, even the same threats: take to the forest, score with a baseball bat, rape. When amazed drivers call the police, they are told that the local government officials took the relevant decision, delegating the authority to levy illegal tribute again to migrants from local utilities.
              More details: http://www.rosbalt.ru
              This, incidentally, is on the issue of migration. And you say ...

              And I agree with
              Quote: Normal
              This is not a mistake. This is a conscious policy. our leadership. The author points to this in the article.
          2. Normal
            Normal 31 May 2013 11: 51 New
            +2
            Quote: Z.A.M.
            The article is very true.

            Despite the abundance of special terms and, accordingly, the difficulty in perceiving the text. That's just the title
            Errors of national policy in Russia on the example of the creation of Russian and Tatar identities: an opinion

            Does not correspond to the real state of affairs and the content of the article. This is not a mistake. This is the conscious policy of our leadership. The author points to this in the article.
            1. Normal
              Normal 31 May 2013 12: 00 New
              +2
              Quote: Ivan.
              -In front of the herd is a horned ram.

              Actually (in a real, sheep flock) there is not a horned sheep in front, but ... a goat. Very proud of himself, narcissistic and sacredly believing in his infallibility, his messianic destiny and exclusiveness ... GOAT! ... Vile animal ...
              1. Z.A.M.
                Z.A.M. 31 May 2013 12: 21 New
                +2
                Quote: Normal
                Quote: Ivan. - In front of the herd there is a horned sheep. In fact (in a real, sheep flock) there is not a horned sheep in front, but ... a goat. Very proud of himself, narcissistic and sacredly believing in his infallibility, his messianic destiny and exclusiveness ... GOAT! ... Vile animal ...

                wink
                I also wanted to answer Ivan. Like, okay, he compared us with the "sheep" laughing But compare Putin with a ram lol laughing
                Although you went further
                Quote: Normal
                Very proud of himself, narcissistic and sacredly believing in his infallibility, his messianic destiny and exclusiveness ... GOAT! ...

                wink
                1. Normal
                  Normal 31 May 2013 12: 31 New
                  +2
                  Quote: Z.A.M.
                  Although you went further

                  I wrote about a sheep flock wink Alas, this is the harsh truth of life ...
                  1. Z.A.M.
                    Z.A.M. 31 May 2013 12: 42 New
                    +2
                    Quote: Normal
                    I wrote about a sheep flock

                    Volodya, yes laaadno wink
                    drinks
              2. Dilshat
                Dilshat 31 May 2013 19: 34 New
                0
                The name of this goat please. And for a long time many people complain about him but no one says who he is. Just like in a joke: A jealous husband hired a detective. A detective reports, your wife and an unidentified man rented a hotel room. Through the window I saw how they drank , then undressed, then closed the curtains. I saw nothing more. Husband-Oh, again this damned unknown!
                1. Normal
                  Normal 31 May 2013 22: 29 New
                  0
                  Quote: Dilshat
                  Name of this goat please
                  Well, if you want - Obama! Are you satisfied
                  Read carefully
                  Quote: Dilshat
                  I wrote about a sheep flock

                  Should I name each goat at the head of each flock?
                  I wrote about the general rule. Do you have any objections? Judging by the nickname, you should be in the subject. Particularly comprehend yourself hi
                  1. Normal
                    Normal 31 May 2013 23: 23 New
                    0

                    Quote: Dilshat
                    I wrote about a sheep flock
                    Of course, my quote. Just made a mistake.
    2. Russian
      Russian 31 May 2013 09: 00 New
      +5
      Quote: smel
      Well. Opinion after all. But personally, I largely disagree with the author. Too abstruse, categorical and gloomy. But it is necessary to start with history, with the reasons for unification in the past and the search for additional incentives in the present for the joint development and preservation of national cultures and interests. The Russian people are so great that they were able to defend their independence, integrity and unite many other nations and countries around them. By the way, we paid for this with human lives and hardships.


      Too abstruse, categorical and gloomy? Yes, now the threat of radical Islam is more serious than ever! Here, there was a great article:
      http://warfiles.ru/show-31430-prezident-kluba-voenachalnikov-rf-ukazal-na-serezn
      ost-ugroz-radikalnogo-islama.html
      I will give only some excerpts:
      According to him, a number of internal and external factors contributed to the emergence of radical Islamism in modern Russian history. Among the internal factors, the general, in particular, called "a sharp differentiation of social groups after the unjust privatization of state property, the collapse of the production sphere, unemployment and impoverishment of the population, corruption and deafness of the authorities to the needs of the common man, which have reached an exorbitant level of lawlessness, due to which in some cases the population demanded management from the federal center and did not meet with understanding. "
      Anatoly Kulikov is convinced that one of the factors that influenced the spread of radical Islamism in Russia is "the overpopulation of emigrants in many regions of Russia."
      The speaker recalled that "in the world, states are faced with the problem of Islamism, which makes itself felt not only by sermons, but also by real bloodshed, terrorist acts, and unleashing civil wars." “Russia has already survived practically all of the above, but the threat has remained. The terrorist underground in the North Caucasus has not been neutralized. The problem of radicalization of Islam in Central Russia and the Volga region has turned out to be deeply neglected,” he stated.


      But our government doesn’t do a damn thing! They have money, money, money ... am
  2. aszzz888
    aszzz888 31 May 2013 06: 36 New
    +1
    First of all, this is the ideology of Eurocentrism, which was adopted by the leadership of Russia. Eurocentrism is a collection of false premises: a civilizational mission combined with universalism, multiculturalism and,

    Identification into the Russian superethnos, the Tatar ethnos - primary, genuine and primordial, autochthonous.


    Perhaps in one school this, probably Russian, although "I am tormented by vague doubts," studied with Gorbachov. Who are these winged, sophisticated phrases to? Fuck the brains of the people? Bold minus.
    1. Karabin
      Karabin 31 May 2013 08: 18 New
      +7
      Quote: aszzz888
      To whom are these winged, sophisticated phrases? Brain to the people?

      So learn, people. Not all perceive poster slogans and advertising slogans.
      1. aszzz888
        aszzz888 31 May 2013 08: 24 New
        0
        What to learn? And "poster slogans", etc., are accepted by those who have no mind of their own.
    2. Rustiger
      Rustiger 31 May 2013 09: 28 New
      +4
      Quote: aszzz888
      To whom are these winged, sophisticated phrases? Brain to the people? Bold minus.

      Oh well. Let's "lower the level" of the information supplied and move on, if not to comics, then at least to pictures -
      Do the flags tell you anything? But "Tricolor" (blue-white-red) is the STATE FLAG OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION, which includes the Republic of Tatarstan, but it is not even close in the picture. And in the opinion of local Natsiks, one should not be in the "Volga-Ural Jamaat" !!!
      1. Normal
        Normal 31 May 2013 12: 46 New
        +4
        Quote: Rustiger
        And according to local Natsik ...

        Now a low-current character will appear and begin: "Everything is fine, beautiful marquise. And we are doing well ..." that's just about the "sad surprises" he will modestly keep silent
        1. Rustiger
          Rustiger 31 May 2013 14: 50 New
          +3
          Quote: Normal
          A low-current character will now appear and begin

          You know, Volodya! For some reason I am confident that "Zhenya" will not appear again. For that, yesterday's "forum baby" with the nickname "Young Putin" will appear. In terms of the style of writing posts and a firm mindset, this proves that "the process of reincarnation has passed." "Meet" in the comments - pay attention.
          Actually, I like people like that somewhere. With their unyielding position opposed to "public opinion". I confess that for the last month and a half I have not even "minus it". He argued, often disagreed, but did not "minus". Maybe because I don't consider him such an ardent opponent to me. ... ...
          1. Normal
            Normal 31 May 2013 23: 11 New
            0
            [quote = Rustiger] "Zhenya" will not appear again [/ quote
            Well, actually, he threatened to change his nickname. That is why I did not specifically track it and missed this "great" event on the site. Thank you, I will definitely pay attention. Still, Zheka is our property, and although I am his constant minus player, at a personal meeting I will definitely treat him to a glass of good beer and talk to him (if he does not mind) "for life." He always believed that such people are necessary for society and always separated them (in personal perception) from what they preach.

            "I may disagree with your opinion, but I am ready to give my life for your right to express it"

            Voltaire.

            Of course, this is liberalism and not timely, but a complete rejection of this principle is the path to totalitarianism, dictatorship and, subsequently, tyranny
    3. matross
      matross 31 May 2013 12: 32 New
      +2
      Quote: aszzz888
      To whom are these winged, sophisticated phrases? Brain to the people?

      In the dictionary, ask about what is incomprehensible!
      Bleat, or is it already a reform of education in action? Soon, apart from the labels on the bottles, no one will be able to read and understand anything!
      Is it not humiliating for someone to write such posts? Like - I didn’t understand anything, give comics !!
      Sorry for the harshness - it’s boiling.
      However, you
      Quote: aszzz888
      Bold minus
  3. treskoed
    treskoed 31 May 2013 06: 40 New
    -1
    the result of the current educational policy of the Russian Federation will be the development of self-identity of titular ethnic groups for the republics to leave the Russian Federation

    A strange position, to say the least !!!
    1. Mrtermit
      Mrtermit 31 May 2013 08: 49 New
      +2
      They veiled how, simply to say profesionally, you begin to think that you won’t have to bite your elbows. Start trying, drinking vodka is not a problem.
      I understand everything, everyone has a lot of good thoughts in his head, but as I understand from my experience when a person is busy with something, it makes no difference what kind of politics in the country are what his neighbors eat, and what kind of grades to study for subsidiaries of GDP) It just works, and rather all the main idea in the country should be connected with the family! but there are many drawbacks and demagoguery rises right there ...
      Okay, all good morning, Reading from Tatarstan ... hi
      1. Umnichka
        Umnichka 31 May 2013 16: 41 New
        +3
        Good afternoon. Reread calmly what you wrote yourself - I hope it will be a shame for such a low level of writing ...
        The idea is simple - we survived together in confrontation with the West, and then we need to be together, including on this basis, otherwise our grandchildren will reap grief - the processes described are not quick, but go according to their own laws. For me, all the people who do not pull the blanket primitively only on themselves are brothers. And in Europe, every man for himself, their sick society, brings us death.
  4. avant-garde
    avant-garde 31 May 2013 06: 40 New
    -2
    Today on the site is the day of Western lovers ?! Che for the articles laid out anti Russian indicating how everything is fine in the west ??? And how bad everything is in those countries that are against this very West!
    1. dmitreach
      dmitreach 31 May 2013 06: 46 New
      +1
      Have the habit of reading links to the source. About the Foreign Article, I think - such a joke. Like: watch the citizens, how Polonia is freaking out. Do not take Pshekkov insanity to heart.
  5. yustas
    yustas 31 May 2013 06: 59 New
    +1
    Yeah, and it was just recently said that Siberia wants to secede. I have a question for the author (not the translator), the Lord, but what kind of mushrooms do you have and why do you eat so much of them?
    PS Dmitrich, I wish you good health.
    1. dmitreach
      dmitreach 31 May 2013 07: 18 New
      0
      Hello, comrade!
    2. fisherman
      fisherman 31 May 2013 07: 27 New
      0
      and will appear with a frequency of 5 to 10 years ...

      they have such a job :)
      1. yustas
        yustas 31 May 2013 07: 31 New
        0
        No matter how I relate to GDP, but it begs to be obvious, there is only one opinion on his work in the place of the President of RUSSIA, comrade! Looks like all Tolerasts twitched, and splashes out of them. They no longer know what fairy tales to tell, but the trouble is, we ate them in the 90s, but pearl barley with stew is always better, so let them now eat what they cooked.
        1. fisherman
          fisherman 31 May 2013 07: 41 New
          -3
          just re-read this article after 5 years to laugh :)
          1. Rustiger
            Rustiger 31 May 2013 08: 42 New
            +3
            Quote: fisherman
            just re-read this article after 5 years to laugh :)

            Enough to live here the last 5 years, think about some of the events that take place, look impartially at the change in the names of leaders of all levels to one, certain, read some statements on the forums, especially of course on Tat.yaz, not to laugh!
            But "netatars" are 48-52% here. ... ...

            I suggest that the "fisherman" think about resettlement (after 5 years) to Tartar-stan. Of course, to constantly "laugh". ... ... like in Kosovo. ... ...
            1. Mrtermit
              Mrtermit 31 May 2013 08: 58 New
              0
              "to look with an open mind at the change in the names of managers of all levels to one, certain, read some statements on the forums"

              http://tatarstan.ru/ Вот тут по фамилиям советов местного самоуправления, по каждому административному округу есть большое количество документации и пособий по различным вопросам изложенных не в завуалированной форме )
              1. Rustiger
                Rustiger 31 May 2013 09: 05 New
                0
                Thanks, countrywoman and namesake!
                Or already "rehmet" laughing . . . Do not wait, who so earnestly desires this.
                Hi Elmetfrom Zelenodolsk and KaZangi!
                1. Mrtermit
                  Mrtermit 31 May 2013 09: 45 New
                  0
                  fellow
                  you know, when I read something about radicals, it’s in my head the music from the song: (Well, who needs war, no one is interested)
                  They didn’t finish the stadium, but then at my place one all-tramp went shouting that the construction budget was stolen by 37%, which again could not be met)
                  Hello to you, namesake) hi
            2. Avenger711
              Avenger711 31 May 2013 12: 11 New
              +1
              Well, I live here. What's next? A bunch of old people in the Kazan Kremlin, who have already been put in a little place with "independence", who would like to steal with impunity, but in the center of Russia there is no way. All this generation of Tatars from villages with their clan manners is gradually dying out. Young people, even though Russian, even Tatar, are in principle the same, no significant Nazi sentiments can be traced. In 30 years, when the old clans have died, the issue will resolve itself.
  6. v53993
    v53993 31 May 2013 07: 06 New
    0
    The dog barks, and the caravan goes on. Not the Poles to teach us how to live.
  7. fenix57
    fenix57 31 May 2013 07: 09 New
    +4
    "The Russian people can survive if only they preserve their integrity .."- I agree with this phrase.
    1. kavkaz8888
      kavkaz8888 31 May 2013 08: 54 New
      +2
      Russians are friends of RUSOV. Russians are the core of the nation. If you want, a military caste, nobles. For those who wish to self-determination, Article 282 of the Russian Federation. After a couple of years, when the imprisonment is over, under supervision. The fan of revolutions has not calmed down, deportation to any country.
      Something like that.
      Russians are ALL who live in Russia.
  8. individual
    individual 31 May 2013 07: 10 New
    10
    Zhirinovsky is right when he proposes to abolish national republics and create a territorial division of Russia according to provinces.
    The power elite of the national republics does not rely on the whole people inhabiting the territory, but on the natives of a particular nationality.
    This shift in consciousness in priorities creates an antagonism towards the Russians and their displacement from the social life of their compact ethnic group.
    The threat of Russia's collapse is real.
    The author of the article correctly writes about the cosmopolitan composition of the current government, which does not contribute to the unity of the Russians and the preservation of Russian statehood.
    1. Captain Vrungel
      Captain Vrungel 31 May 2013 07: 45 New
      +6
      Why it happens? The answer is on the surface. The church should be, as it was, outside the state. Religion is opium for the people. Why did the division by nationality begin? Yes, because temples, mosques and houses of worship began to arise, like mushrooms after the rain. When the councils and thoughts of all ranks were filled by clergy (businessmen from religion), when the former communist apparatchiks began to pray fervently in temples, repaying their thieves' sins. What did the sudden religiosity of the masses lead to? And besides, they gave everything into the hands of religious people and they began to take it away to national apartments. Well, who are the worshipers and by whom are financed, clearly without words.
      A man without faith is an animal. But he should come to faith himself, and not follow, like a ram, priests, imams, gurus, and other preachers.
      Maybe it's time to remember that the "Guard Tower" magazine was illegal on the territory of the USSR. Probably correct. We are building a secular state or religious enclaves.
  9. annenkov242
    annenkov242 31 May 2013 07: 35 New
    +5
    [quote = individ] Zhirinovsky is right when he proposes to abolish national republics and create a territorial division of Russia according to provinces.
    The power elite of the national republics does not rely on the whole people inhabiting the territory, but on the natives of a particular nationality.

    We are armed with the "Concept of Public Security" voiced by General Petrov, this is a worthy direction for Russia. VVP adheres to this concept, because even Stalin became the full-fledged master of the USSR, in the middle of the war. It is difficult to remove at once all the infection that got in with the help of the West in the 90s, which surreptitiously oppose OUR development plans.
  10. Igarr
    Igarr 31 May 2013 07: 53 New
    +8
    Good such an article. Clever.
    From these words alone - primordiality, probabilism .. land reclamation - he takes a dumbbell.
    For academics, apparently, the article is designed. Although, for the Russian subethnos, these same words can be said quite completely in Russian - nationally, probabilistically ...
    In my opinion, there are also right sides - for example, "..design is pure Tatar Islamic dedicated reality.. ", and the Tatar part has nothing to do with it.
    The same is the wrong design - it is proposed to create a "melting pot" of the type of "American values". What this leads to - we know, we swam: first we will abandon women, then our parents, then we will love animals, etc.
    At the same time, Russia was a Fusion of cultures and nations in life.
    Not denominations, not religions.
    A - CULTURE.
    So I see.
    ..
    I will add more ... the combination of dissimilar materials is an extremely interesting area. Galvanic couples, diffusion welding - a lot of prospects.
    And, let's say - stainless steel, the only good thing is that it is stainless. And that’s all.
    1. yustas
      yustas 31 May 2013 08: 04 New
      +2
      Quote: Igarr
      while Russia in life was an ALLOY of cultures and nations.
      Not denominations, not religions.
      A - CULTURE.

      + comrade! I am with you for all the limbs and most importantly the fact that in my head!
      1. Igarr
        Igarr 1 June 2013 21: 52 New
        0
        ".. and the main thing is that in the head! .."
        Eustace - Igarr ..
        the best comment ..
        stings in my head ..
        which we eat ... and we taste the world.
        I can’t imagine myself - without manti, without dumplings, without pasties, without pilaf (in all its varieties), without Lithuanian (or Belarusian) zeppelins. without fat, without planing ....
        The world is food.
        Yes, I do not want one dough heated in a microwave oven (and then quick cooking) - TO USE.
        This is not food. Not a feeling.
        .
        Farhad market in Tashkent .... Cafes in Klaipeda .... eateries in Vladik ....
        and they offer me - whipped up ... in a hurry .... ???
        I do not wish !!!
  11. Lakkuchu
    Lakkuchu 31 May 2013 08: 01 New
    +9
    Present-day Tatarstan is a feudal-clan criminal system, a system with limited access to property and power, lack of vertical social mobility, a system in which there are policies of usurpation of resources, deprivation of access to power, abuse of power, inequality and hierarchy. Duration of occupation of posts, lack of cadence lead to curtailment of investments and their inefficiency.
    In addition, the Federal Center today has no theoretical and experimental basis for national and reproduction policies. He sells the local criminal elites the right to exploit local resources and control, non-interference in the affairs of elites and their struggle for the necessary for the central government election results to the State Duma and presidential elections, loyalty to the people in power.
    I don’t know how things are in Tatarstan, the residents of the republic know better, I think the author is not far from the truth, but reading these lines I recognize Dagestan. Exactly the same. Clans tear the budget to pieces and squabble among themselves for access to resources. Arbitrariness, violence and impunity of the "elites" reign in the republic. Hence the growth of protest sentiments, and one of the reasons for the radicalization of Islamic youth.
    1. bairat
      bairat 31 May 2013 08: 50 New
      +2
      This is definitely not written about Tatarstan. The whole city is under construction: the metro is being built at an accelerated pace, stadiums, roads, transport interchanges - why all this to criminal clans? This is all for the people, they do not ask for nationality at the entrance to the metro either. So the author scratches where it does not itch, although apparently he really wants to comb it.
    2. Rustiger
      Rustiger 31 May 2013 09: 00 New
      +1
      Quote: Lakkuchu
      I don’t know how things are in Tatarstan, the residents of the republic know better, I think the author is not far from the truth,

      I confirm everything that you quoted as a person ALL your life here.
      And the article itself, mind you, "MISSED" just those who have not lived for a month neither in modern Tyrtar-stan and Bashkortostan, who cannot compare the "mood" of the people 15-20 years ago and now. As always. People who are farthest from the question will give a bunch of arguments in the "inconsistency of the presented arguments", thereby leveling the thought conveyed to the readers by the author.
      1. Vladimir_61
        Vladimir_61 31 May 2013 11: 05 New
        0
        Quote: Rustiger
        thereby leveling the thought conveyed to readers by the author.

        The thought should be clear, clear and expressed in simple words. Because and minus the article, which is cluttered with specific terms that spray sense. Not everyone is familiar with the terms. Intelligent juggling will leave suffering self-conceit. Do not rush to conclusions. It can also be said, for example, that someone did not live in Khabarovsk, Krasnodar, etc. edge. We are trying to consider the main reasons, not being distracted by the particular ones generated by these reasons as well. Without finding out the reasons, do not understand the consequences.
        1. Egoza
          Egoza 31 May 2013 11: 47 New
          +3
          Quote: Vladimir_61
          The thought should be clear, clear and expressed in simple words.

          On this occasion - until the ideology is changed, there will be no sense! It's time to return to socialism, taking into account the mistakes of the past, and developing it further. And this can be achieved peacefully, if there is a desire. There will be resistance at the local level and from the west. Locals "explain" at the level of a referendum of the people, to the west - do not care.
          And nationalities can represent their cultural and technical achievements, as it was under the USSR. "Days of Culture .... Republics throughout the Country", VDNKh ... and there will be no claims about "ethnic oppression".
          1. Vladimir_61
            Vladimir_61 31 May 2013 11: 57 New
            +1
            Quote: Egoza
            It's time to return to socialism, given the mistakes of the past, and developing it further

            Right. The essence is the idea and this is the main thing. And first of all - enlightenment, that is, not invented theories that serve as a support and "justification" for the anti-human power of terry capitalists, but a scientific substantiation of the benefits of cooperation of all in everything. Namely: the common good. When in a single family someone is unhappy, can such a family be called happy? Both small and large.
        2. Karabin
          Karabin 31 May 2013 12: 16 New
          0
          Quote: Vladimir_61
          The thought should be clear, clear and expressed in simple words.

          And the lines are straight, parallel and perpendicular.
      2. Avenger711
        Avenger711 31 May 2013 12: 22 New
        +3
        Well, I zaminusuyu, although I was born and live here. Compared with the beginning of the 90s, the local Nazi bastard was squeezed, and there was no one who wants to sleep in the forest, if something happens, every night. Young people, who, regardless of their nationality, are eager to tear the thread to Moscow, especially cannot be pulled anywhere. There is a tip from the Tatar clans, but it will die out of old age and the question will be solved by itself, although you can speed up a kick from Moscow, just ask why you have one Tatar in the Kremlin.
  12. My address
    My address 31 May 2013 08: 02 New
    +2
    I agree in many ways, for example, with stupidity (or a crime?) In highlighting, protruding the culture of each nation. They have achieved isolation, suspicion, and statements about bad neighbors. In the republics, demagogues are gaining much power. They got into a mess, in Tatarstan and Bashkiria, the more mosques, the more contempt for non-natives.
    Before the collapse of the Union, relations were more humane, both within one region and between nations. Then choked separatism. Apparently not satisfied.
    1. iulai
      iulai 31 May 2013 11: 46 New
      +3
      You got your relationship with Tatarstan and Bashkortostan! And only those who live in these republics, regardless of nationalities, can discuss the provisions in our republics! And no one wondered why Moscow takes 70% of taxes? First, find out how much the US states pay to the center. Moscow is the center of the empire! And while the Empire exists, there will be protest moods. And what about only in Moscow the most intelligent, and the rest? And in Dagestan, the elite was appointed by Moscow, do you think the stolen budget money does not go to Moscow? Even during the Chechen wars, money was laundered in Chechnya, weapons to the militants that were brought from the United States? no, sold by our corrupt generals. It’s just that thieves from Moscow are tired of not only the whole world, but also the regions! THE FISH ROTS FROM THE HEAD !!!
  13. Karabin
    Karabin 31 May 2013 08: 16 New
    +2
    Dark, but essentially true.
  14. Vladimir_61
    Vladimir_61 31 May 2013 08: 41 New
    0
    Minus article. Probably someone will have to read it with a dictionary in order to translate the terms and learn the meaning. It's simple: you need to unite on the basis of cooperation of peoples in everything. What does the power do? Crushing and separation. In words, one thing, in fact the exact opposite. Whom do they serve?
  15. Vtel
    Vtel 31 May 2013 09: 37 New
    +1
    Russia now lives without ideology according to the principle of a "criminal state with thieves and for theft" (M. Weller), and therefore there is a catch of "fish" in troubled waters. If each ethnic group begins to pull the blanket towards itself, the whole country will get a blanket. When there was a strong power in the country and order, there were no rushes and dreams. Comrade Stalin would definitely not have allowed this. I would not like to, but apparently the future war will unite us again.
  16. Imperial
    Imperial 31 May 2013 10: 48 New
    -1
    I am a Tatar, I am a Tatar, a man of simple outward appearance, I am a solid guy with a Russian soul The rest is all unimportant ...
  17. master_rem
    master_rem 31 May 2013 10: 48 New
    +1
    Quote: individ
    Zhirinovsky is right when he proposes to abolish national republics and create a territorial division of Russia according to provinces.
    The power elite of the national republics does not rely on the whole people inhabiting the territory, but on the natives of a particular nationality.
    This shift in consciousness in priorities creates an antagonism towards the Russians and their displacement from the social life of their compact ethnic group.
    The threat of Russia's collapse is real.
    The author of the article correctly writes about the cosmopolitan composition of the current government, which does not contribute to the unity of the Russians and the preservation of Russian statehood.

    Did you watch the match at Solovyov yesterday? Wolfych broke a glass with water, after the words "democrat" from the audience laughing
  18. Dawn
    Dawn 31 May 2013 11: 27 New
    +4
    "The literary Russian language is a sufficient condition for the development of the ability of scientific thinking in general, without a literary language, thinking in the languages ​​of mathematics and physics becomes difficult. Ultimately, such a model of education, with which the Federal Center agrees, leads to the elimination of the Russian Federation as a whole on the basis of the constructivist policy of formation population as a civil state community (VA Tishkov). It's just a matter of time and duration of the decay of Russia on the basis of oil money and the export of oil and gas abroad "- golden words, but there is no one in the government to hear them
  19. Hort
    Hort 31 May 2013 11: 31 New
    +4
    the main mistake is the division of the constituent entities of the Federation on a national basis (republics in the composition). There should be an administrative-territorial division, as before the revolution.
    1. AntonR7
      AntonR7 31 May 2013 23: 55 New
      0
      I agree that even in the minds of the nationalities it would not be that they live in an independent country, sealed only by a federal agreement with the federal center, the republics should know that they are just regions of Russia. Otherwise, it is a time bomb for separatism. The country must be unitary. I myself live in the Kazan province and all the time I hear "here in Tatarstan, and there in Russia", as if Tatarstan is separately outside Russia, even in our region they want to do it for the knowledge of the Tatar salary supplement, that this is not a forced imposition of the study language, here's why I'm Russian. I know the state language, Russian, and I'm happy with that.
  20. pav-pon1972
    pav-pon1972 31 May 2013 11: 44 New
    +6
    He lived and studied in Naberezhnye Chelny (Tatarstan) - the city is a hard worker (KamAZ plant). He studied at the 23rd school. To say that there were frictions on national grounds, I did not notice before entering a military school, went to visit each other, walked on Sabantuy. I was surprised by the festive mood during the holiday and I wondered why there are no such holidays in neighboring regions (Kuibyshev, Chuvash Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republics). However, in the beginning of the 90s, the TOTs (Tatar Public Center) appeared, climbed into power and pressure began to begin on other nations. Since the city was international, about 500 thousand people left more than 155 thousand non-Tatars. in the period from 1991-2000. The authorities in both the Republic and Moscow knew about this situation. No one touched Radikalov (TOC), even at the level of the city authorities, because they paid, and the leaders of the TOC studied in Saudi Arabia. That's where you need to peck ...
  21. Abakanets
    Abakanets 31 May 2013 12: 19 New
    +5
    Russian is Russian, Tatar is Tatar, and so on. There cannot be a "Russian" Tatar or a "Russian" Jew, there can only be a Russian Tatar and a Russian Jew. All of today's crap with small nations got to us thanks to the scoop, because Lenin himself spoke about the priority of the development of national regions, and Trotsky called the Russians the firewood of the world revolution. According to the calculations of Soviet scientists, without the revolution and the policy of the USSR, most of the small nations either disappeared or assimilated. Thanks to this, there is a paradox in Russia, almost all nations in the Russian Federation have statehood to one degree or another, but Russians do not, since the word Russian is mentioned in the Constitution of the Russian Federation once, namely, Russia is built on the blood and bones of Russians, and no one did not do so much for the establishment of this great power.
  22. Valery-SPB
    Valery-SPB 31 May 2013 12: 47 New
    +1
    One could argue with some judgments, but ... The article is professionally firmly knit together. The author is well done.
  23. The comment was deleted.
  24. varov14
    varov14 31 May 2013 13: 28 New
    0
    This is a normal article, and some of the hats are simply amusing. They believe in Putin as a prophet, and I have long been interested in him for ... tsa does not itch, it ends badly, although it seems to be turning in a course, but it is painfully careful. 10 years ago I wrote that Russia should be divided into districts - seven districts, regions, oblasts - name it whatever you like. It came to my mind from the "bolda", I just saw the future of Russia one day and I really didn’t like it, but by nature I don’t believe in devilry, but I have been suffering for 10 years already. Since then I have been following politics, trying to read various sources and perspectives I don't see any rainbow ones, sometimes I try to express myself somewhere, although in fact I don't care - you live, but I feel sorry for the grandchildren.
    1. matross
      matross 31 May 2013 14: 52 New
      +1
      So this is your idea about seven districts or Putin? From your confusion is not clear. belay What did you see in the future from the "bolda" and it scared you so? And why should we live - and what do you want? Can you decipher your message.
      By the way, hello to my grandchildren smile
      1. Igarr
        Igarr 31 May 2013 15: 46 New
        +2
        No, you will not die of old age ... you will suffocate from laughter:
        "..What did you see in the future from the" bolda "...
        ... And why should we live - and what do you want? .. "
        ..
        but for some reason I immediately remembered ... seven skinny cows and seven fat ones ...
        Three components and three founders ..
        well, etc.
        And not with BOLD ..
        Hello to the ancestors!
  25. Svyatoslav72
    Svyatoslav72 31 May 2013 18: 55 New
    +1
    In vain, of course, abstruse words and phrases were used, this always leads to misunderstandings or a variation on the theme of the unsaid or implying otherwise.
    Everything can be said more simply: 1. The absence of Ideology leads to the absence of Politics. 2. All ruling Power, in form and essence, is an organized crime group (Organized Crime Group). 3. All resources and finances, State potential are in the hands of the Oligarchs who are not interested in the national mentality of the state-forming people (Russians). AND! therefore they are subjected to "humane destruction". 4. Weakness of the State Power, and its criminalization, is a breeding ground for the flourishing of local Feudal-National Elites (which take their toll, ruining the integrity). 5. Nothing will change for the better, due to the absence of: Russian Nationalism; Russian mentality and Russian Statehood (replacing it with illusions that never work in the existing reality).
  26. Ivanovich47
    Ivanovich47 31 May 2013 19: 35 New
    0
    The article is tricky, for an ordinary person (at least for me), mostly incomprehensible. After all, everything is so simple: all people must live in harmony and respect for each other.