A Doctor with a capital D

7 224 73
A Doctor with a capital D
The N. N. Burdenko House-Museum on the grounds of the Penza Regional Hospital named after him


“Please don’t write about me that I come from a peasant family, that my ancestors practically wandered the world…”
N. Burdenko

Glorious people of the Russian land. Truly, sometimes you just have to get sick to gain access to... interesting journalistic information. And sometimes it's easy to get sick, but getting treatment "where you need it" is difficult. But this time I was lucky. The Burdenko Penza Regional Hospital was on duty, and that's where the ambulance took me. Some people endure it for three days. They wait for it to be on duty and don't want to go anywhere else! Although the hospital is very old, it's full of state-of-the-art buildings, and the doctors (and their equipment) are very good. The surgeons are absolutely hand-picked "grenadiers," as tall as the lintel. Only one was short! There's even one black doctor. And obviously a good specialist, otherwise what would he be doing there among such "pros"? It's a complete "Hindi-Rusi bhai-band," but in the good sense of the word. So, three or four days later, you're back on your feet. In good weather, you can walk around the grounds. And there is also a house-museum of N. N. Burdenko, who was included in history our medicine a very worthy page with its name.




Bust on the hospital grounds

I'd known about this museum for a long time. Many Penza residents had seen it through the bars of the hospital grounds. They'd seen it, but I doubt they'd visited it, because you have to go through the hospital entrance, which is both far and inconvenient. Incidentally, I'd been there before, but with a very specific purpose: to photograph the preserved head of a notorious Penza gangster from the 20s, nicknamed Alle. There was an article about him on VO with photographs of this head, and, what's more, today the photographs tagged in it are unique, because this head is no longer in the museum. At the request of his relatives, it was finally buried!


And this is his portrait on one of the floors... Under the portrait are the orders he was awarded.

But the museum itself is intact and well-appointed, and its director, Darya Vladimirovna Suchkova, greeted me with more than a warm welcome, giving me a personal tour and telling me many interesting things. And, taking advantage of the lack of crowds, I took plenty of photos, although, understandably, the exhibits behind glass were traditionally difficult to photograph.


A model of the Burdenko family home. I love models like this. They tell a lot…

Well, it makes sense for me to repeat this story in a purely journalistic interpretation and tell about the truly heroic fate of a man from the Penza region, a doctor with a capital D, Nikolai Nilovich Burdenko.


One of the rooms. As you can see, people lived in that house quite crampedly…

He was born on May 22 (June 3), 1876, in the village of Kamenka, Nizhnelomovsky District, Penza Governorate, to a family of peasants. His grandfather was a serf who had been freed from serfdom.


Here is this document on stamped paper, certifying the transition of the future doctor’s grandfather to a free state!

But Father Nil Karpovich, the son of a serf, became a clerk, and then even the manager of a small manor house and, according to his passport, a "Penza bourgeois"! In other words, he rose quite well for the times. He sent his son to study at a zemstvo school (1881-1885) and dreamed of his son becoming a priest. Thus, young Burdenko found himself at the Penza Theological School (1886-1890), then at the Penza Theological Seminary (1891-1897). But… he became disillusioned with his "divine career" and, in September 1897, enrolled in the medical faculty of Tomsk University.



This is how Nikolai studied.


The seminary building. It's in very poor condition today, and naturally, there's no longer any hospital in it!


His teachers and mentors


A very joyful document for Nikolai!


The tsarist government's obvious concern for young and immature minds!

And then it happened that, although Nikolai signed a certain paper in the photograph, he nevertheless took part in the student strike of 1899 and was expelled from the university. However, he applied for reinstatement and returned to the university. In 1901, his name reappeared on the list of strikers; according to some sources, it was there by chance. However, Burdenko was still forced to leave Tomsk and, on October 11, 1901, transfer to Yuryev University (now the University of Tartu, Estonia), to the fourth year of the medical faculty. There, apparently, there was "more freedom." But it's also worth noting that the tsarist regime didn't persecute young rebels all that harshly. It didn't close off the opportunity for them to study...

While pursuing his studies, Nikolai Burdenko was also active in the student political movement. Eventually, after yet another student meeting, he was forced to interrupt his studies at the university. At the invitation of the zemstvo, he arrived in the Kherson province to treat an epidemic of typhus and other acute childhood diseases. Here, by his own account, Burdenko first encountered practical surgery. After working for almost a year in a colony for children with tuberculosis, and thanks to the help of his professors, he was able to return to Yuryev University, where he began working as an assistant in the surgical clinic.

From January 1904, he volunteered as a physician's assistant in the Russo-Japanese War. During a battle near the village of Wafangou, while evacuating wounded soldiers under enemy fire, he was shell-shocked and wounded. For his heroism, he was awarded the St. George's Cross, his first military decoration. In 1906, he finally graduated from Yuryev University in Tartu, Estonia, and received his medical degree with honors.


Here is this diploma!


This is how handsome the young doctor Burdenko arrived in the city of Penza.

For several months in 1907, he worked at the Penza Provincial Zemstvo Hospital, while gathering material for his dissertation. He filled in for his friend from the front, Dr. V.K. Trofimov (senior physician at the Penza Provincial Zemstvo Hospital from 1874 to 1897), who had gone on leave. "served as head of a 100-bed surgical unit".


His words…


And he lived here...


His colleagues

In 1909, he defended his dissertation, "Materials on the Consequences of Bandaging...." In 1910, Burdenko was already a private assistant professor in the Department of Surgery at Yuryev University, and then an extraordinary professor in the Department of Operative Surgery and Topographic Anatomy.


Doctorate in medical sciences!

In July 1914, with the outbreak of World War I, Burdenko was appointed assistant to the head of the Red Cross medical unit. In September 1914, he joined the active army as a consultant to the medical unit of the Northwestern Front. He participated in the offensive on East Prussia, oversaw the evacuation of the wounded during the Russian army's retreat from Kovno, and performed surgery on the wounded during the Warsaw-Ivangorod Offensive.

In the summer of 1917, he was shell-shocked for the second time at the front. After treatment, he returned to Yuryev University and was elected head of the surgery department there. After Yuryev was occupied by German troops, the German army command offered N. N. Burdenko a chair at the university, but he declined and evacuated to Voronezh in June 1918.


Burdenko's article on the effects of warhead gases

After the Revolution, Burdenko became one of the main organizers of the hospital service of the Workers' and Peasants' Red Army. He trained nursing staff at the courses he founded and organized civilian healthcare. From 1918, he headed the surgical clinic at Voronezh University. In 1923, he was invited to Moscow to head the Department of Topographic Anatomy and Operative Surgery at the First Moscow State University.


I noticed this chair at the Burdenko Museum. I had exactly the same ones in my old house, built in 1882.

From 1924, Burdenko served as director of the faculty surgical clinic at 1st Moscow State University, where he organized the neurosurgical department in 1924. He also became one of the founders of the Central Institute of Neurosurgery, and served as its permanent director from 1934 to 1946. In 1946, this institute was named after N. N. Burdenko. In 1934, Burdenko began working as a consulting surgeon at the Red Army military hospital (in 1946, the hospital was named after Academician N. N. Burdenko). During the Soviet-Finnish War (1939-1940), he again returned to the front, where he operated and organized surgical care for the troops of the Workers' and Peasants' Red Army.


His words, his memories...


His books…


His office…

From the beginning of the Great Patriotic War (1941-1945), N. N. Burdenko served as the chief surgeon of the Red Army. He personally performed several hundred complex operations on wounded soldiers and commanders. In 1941, he suffered his first stroke. While still recovering from his illness, he consulted with the wounded arriving from the front and, again, performed numerous operations. He developed the scientific and organizational foundations of military field surgery. Under his leadership, uniform principles for the treatment of gunshot wounds were introduced on all fronts of the Great Patriotic War. During the war, N. N. Burdenko proposed effective methods for the surgical treatment of combat injuries and developed a theory of wounds. In May 1944, he developed detailed instructions for the prevention and treatment of shock (one of the most severe complications of war injuries). He actively advocated for the introduction and widespread use of penicillin and sulfidine in military hospitals.


Clock from the house-museum


A piano and a kerosene lamp

And here is the result of all these and many other measures carried out at that time with his participation. Soviet doctors managed to return 72,3% of wounded soldiers and 90,6% of sick soldiers to duty, which amounts to a total of approximately eighteen million men (with the standard strength of the Red Army being 7,5 million) and is an absolute record in the history of war. For comparison, in the Wehrmacht, less than half of the wounded were returned to duty. According to statistics, each new soldier fought on average for only 10-12 days, after which he died or, having been wounded, was evacuated to the rear, only to return to the active army after treatment. Thus, Red Army medical facilities returned 85% of the soldiers and commanders admitted for treatment to duty. Thanks to the efforts of military doctors, no serious outbreaks of infectious diseases, much less epidemics, were recorded at the front or in the rear during the war.


Tools that N. N. Burdenko could have used


These are definitely his glasses.


One of the military orders of N. N. Burdenko

On the initiative of N. N. Burdenko and in accordance with a plan he personally developed, the USSR Academy of Medical Sciences was established on June 30, 1944. On December 24, 1944, he was elected its first president and became the founder of the Soviet-Russian school of neurosurgery. He developed treatment methods for oncology of the central and autonomic nervous system and pathologies of cerebral circulation. He performed operations to treat brain tumors, pioneering the widespread use of such operations (having developed original methods for their implementation). He was a member of the editorial board of the multi-volume publication "The Experience of Soviet Medicine in the Great Patriotic War of 1941-1945."

On January 12, 1944, Burdenko was appointed chairman of the "Special Commission for the Establishment and Investigation of the Circumstances of the Execution of Polish Officers of War by the Nazi Invaders in the Katyn Forest (near Smolensk)" (under the Extraordinary State Commission for the Establishment and Investigation of the Atrocities of the Nazi Invaders, chaired by N. M. Shvernik). In 1943, the German occupiers discovered the graves of approximately 4,3 Polish officers in the Katyn Forest, out of 21 Polish prisoners executed by the NKVD in accordance with the decision of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) on March 5, 1940. The Germans organized an extensive investigation involving the international community and foreign experts, the results of which were actively used in propaganda. The Soviet side, in turn, blamed the Germans themselves for this crime. After the liberation of Smolensk, a commission for a "preliminary investigation" of the Katyn case was created under the leadership of the People's Commissar of State Security Merkulov (in 1940, one of the members of the "special troika" that passed sentences) and the Deputy People's Commissar of Internal Affairs Kruglov. Burdenko apparently sincerely believed the Germans were guilty of the massacre. On September 22, 1943, he wrote to V. M. Molotov, reporting that the methods of executing Soviet citizens by the German occupiers in Orel were identical to the method of executing Polish officers described in German publications.


Photos from those years

On January 13, 1944, at the first meeting of the Special Commission, held in the building of the Neurosurgical Institute in Moscow, Burdenko stated:

The focus of our commission's work is establishing the timing and methods of the murders... The murder methods are identical to the methods I discovered in Orel and those discovered in Smolensk. Furthermore, I have information about the murder of 700 mentally ill people in Voronezh. The mentally ill were exterminated within five hours using the same method. All these methods of murder reveal German handiwork, as I will prove in time.


Ultimately, the Soviet indictment for the "Katyn affair" at the Nuremberg Trials was brought against Hermann Göring. However, the Soviet side failed to produce a single witness who could testify against the German witnesses, refute their testimony, and corroborate Burdenko's version of events. As a result, the outcome of the hearings was unanimously assessed by observers as a failure of the Soviet version, so much so that the Katyn episode did not even figure in the final verdict of the Nuremberg Tribunal. Consequently, State Security General G.S. Zhukov, the former commissioner for Polish affairs, was forced to admit that the Burdenko Commission had failed to live up to expectations and "ineptly covered up the case".

Apparently, this political setback had a profound impact on N. N. Burdenko. Already in July 1945, he suffered a second stroke, and in the summer of 1946, a third. He died on November 11, 1946, and was buried at the Novodevichy Cemetery in Moscow.

In 1958, a bust of the scientist by sculptor A. A. Fomin was erected on the grounds of the Penza Regional Hospital. In 1976, to mark the 100th anniversary of Burdenko's birth, the wooden house of his parents, where the scientist spent his childhood and youth (1886-1897), was moved from the former Chembarskaya Street (renamed Burdenko Street in 1947) to the hospital grounds, where it remains to this day.


And here's another monument next to the N. N. Burdenko House Museum. It's dedicated to some zemstvo doctor who worked at the same clinic and was buried on its grounds. But I never found out who it was...

P.S. The author and the site administration express their gratitude to the head of the N. N. Burdenko Museum and D. V. Suchkova.
73 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +2
    16 November 2025 06: 36
    Thank you for the story, Vyacheslav Olegovich!
    It was hard not to recognize the style and the “tilt of the pen”:
    House-museum named after N. N. Burdenko on the territory Penza regional hospital named after him
  2. +5
    16 November 2025 08: 55
    Great article! Thanks! From the photos... This chair was called a "Viennese" chair... We had one of those in our family too.🙂
    1. +2
      16 November 2025 09: 23
      Quote from Songwolf
      We had those in our family too.

      I also noticed that such chairs were indeed widespread even before the mid-70s, not only "at home" but even in "government offices," despite their certain weakness for "continuous" use... there were also hangers using the same "technology" in all corners and offices :)
  3. +3
    16 November 2025 09: 13
    I read it with great interest! Although "biographies" aren't my favorite genre, you successfully sow "kindness and eternity" even among such "diehards" :)
  4. 0
    16 November 2025 10: 00
    One of the rooms. As you can see, people lived in that house quite crampedly…

    Five rooms, a mansion - not bad at all for those years.

    Н
    But Father Nil Karpovich, the son of a serf, became a clerk, and then even the manager of a small manor house and a "Penza bourgeois" by passport! That is, he rose quite high for that time.

    There are even more striking examples of social mobility, such as I.F. Petrov, who started out as a serf apprentice at an Izhevsk arms factory and became the owner of a weapons factory and a chain of gun stores in Russia and abroad.

    In 1918 he was robbed, deported, then exiled, imprisoned for him and his family, his life was destroyed.

    During the NEP, a handy grandfather, son, and grandson opened weapons repair shops, but again, everything was confiscated...

    At the same time, the Soviet side did not put forward not a single witness, who could testify against the German witnesses, refute their testimony and confirm Burdenko's version
    They were afraid to bring "witnesses" to Nuremberg, but they did testify before the commission in the USSR...
  5. +2
    16 November 2025 10: 46
    "Started well, ended badly." This seems like an article about a distinguished military doctor... but Shpakovsky wouldn't be himself if he didn't spit on the Soviet regime. Where does this pathological hostility toward the USSR come from? Let's start with the epigraph:
    “Please don’t write about me that I come from a peasant family, that my ancestors practically wandered the world…”
    But Burdenko was a peasant. According to Shpakovsky, was he ashamed of his ancestors? Not all peasants "traveled the world." Nikolai Nikolaevich's medical work during WWI, the Finnish War, and the Great Patriotic War is recognized by all luminaries of medicine, and his authority in the world is... very tall And why slander him, doubting his professional qualities, dragging out the "Katyn case"? N.N. Burdenko is the kind of person that putting pressure on is uselessHe stood up for his opinions and remained true to himself, as those who interacted with him attest. His life is a story of how perseverance, the courage to ask difficult questions, and the willingness to act can change the world around us. And even today, his methods and principles continue to save lives. Why, then, does Mr. Shpakovsky doubt Nikolai Nikolaevich's integrity by making such statements?
    Burdenko, apparently, was sincerely convinced of the Germans' guilt in the execution.
    Gerhard Butz is a doctor who was the head of the forensic laboratory of Army Group Center, he carried out the exhumation of the Poles, for some reason believe , and to the Soviet academician - no Yeah, it just begs the joke "Gentlemen are taken at their word" And then my card went right... if only it weren't so sad. I don't want to mention the Nazi lies about Katyn, when we remember N.N. Burdenko, but Shpakovsky specially I pulled out this lie. This topic was already discussed on VO - the Nazis shot, it is a fact! The Nazis' guilt for the murder of Poles in 1944-1945 was never in doubt. The Nuremberg Tribunal's indictment, under the heading "Murder and Cruelty to Prisoners of War...," clearly stated: "In September 1941, the Nazis committed mass murder of Polish officer prisoners in the Katyn Forest near Smolensk." This conclusion was not in any way altered or disavowed in the final text of the court's verdict. Recently, the FSB released documents detailing the atrocities committed by the Nazi invaders on our soil. These documents include interrogation reports of Arno Dure, a soldier in a German "special forces" battalion. In the report, he directly admits to having personally dug the graves near Katyn where the murdered Poles were buried. So, after Putin repented to the Poles, but they somehow didn't care about this so-called "repentance," when we officially blamed our country for the crimes of the German Nazis, repeating Goebbels' lies about the Katyn massacre, and didn't know about the existence of this archival document? If we didn't know, then why? And if we knew and still admitted responsibility, then even more so, why? So, why? do not while telling a story about N.N. Burdenko, to slander a distinguished person, in the spirit of the perestroika era.
    1. -1
      16 November 2025 11: 18
      Quote: Unknown
      So, when telling a story about N.N. Burdenko, there is no need to slander a distinguished person, in the spirit of the perestroika era.

      No need to drink in the morning, that's what, my dear. And think. With your head, not your butt... Epigraph: Burdenko himself wrote this. His words. No?
      Next... slander against the Katyn case... Where? I merely wrote that he was certain he was right. Wrote it? Yes! NKVD General Zhukov, who oversaw this matter, said outright that they had failed at Nuremberg... to achieve this and that... He said it—yes, he said it. Burdenko is not to blame for this. He's a doctor, not a judicial pettifogger. He did his job, and that's it. Where in the text does it say he's guilty of anything?
      The indictment of the Nuremberg Tribunal, in the section “Murder and cruel treatment of prisoners of war…” states in black and white: “In September 1941, in the Katyn forest near Smolensk, the Nazis carried out mass murders of Polish captured officers.”
      So what was Zhukov, the state security general, dissatisfied with?
      So I pulled out not a lie, but a fact from his biography and presented it—that's all. But you, my dear, put every bast in its place. That's not right!
      1. +1
        16 November 2025 12: 39
        Quote: kalibr
        No need to drink in the morning, that's what, my dear. And think. With your head, not your butt... Epigraph: Burdenko himself wrote this. His words. No?

        As for drinking in the morning or not, it depends on how you feel...after yesterday. laughing You have to think with your head, that's right, but don't cast a shadow over the fence. Don't consider yourself the most smartOver the years, the mind... becomes dull, a quote taken from the text can be interpreted in different ways.
        Quote: kalibr
        Next... slander against the Katyn case... Where? I merely wrote that he was certain he was right. Wrote it? Yes! NKVD General Zhukov, who oversaw this matter, said outright that they had failed at Nuremberg... to achieve this and that... He said it—yes, he said it. Burdenko is not to blame for this. He's a doctor, not a judicial pettifogger. He did his job, and that's it. Where in the text does it say he's guilty of anything?
        Of course, this is a slander against N.N. Burdenko. If you are not aware of forensic medical reports and why they are produced, then you should not even bother – it’s the investigation. always relies on and draws conclusions, based forensic expert! Don't question it! qualifications Nikolai Nikolaevich.
        Quote: kalibr
        So what was Zhukov, the state security general, dissatisfied with?
        Who knows what a retired general might have been dissatisfied with, many years later. You, too, are dissatisfied with the Soviet regime, even though you got everything you could from it. And I'm not putting a finger in it, but please don't write about Burdenko and cite Hitler's lies.
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. The comment was deleted.
            1. The comment was deleted.
        2. -1
          16 November 2025 13: 29
          Quote: Unknown
          There is no need to question Nikolai Nikolaevich's qualifications.

          Where is it questioned?
          Quote: Unknown
          You never know what the retired general was dissatisfied with, in retirement, many years later.

          He was dissatisfied not in resignation, but directly during the process
          Quote: Unknown
          You are also dissatisfied with the Soviet government, although you got everything you could from it.

          Are you really satisfied with everything in Soviet society? Is that it?
          Where is the link to Hitler's lies?
          1. +1
            16 November 2025 13: 50
            Quote: kalibr
            Where is it questioned?
            At the same time, the Soviet side did not produce a single witness who could testify against the German witnesses, refute their testimony and confirm Burdenko’s version.
            Not Burdenko's version, but an established fact!
            Quote: kalibr
            He was dissatisfied not in resignation, but directly during the process

            What exactly was he dissatisfied with? Perhaps his displeasure stemmed from the lenient sentences given to some Nazi figures?
            1. -2
              16 November 2025 13: 52
              Quote: Unknown
              What exactly was he dissatisfied with? Perhaps his displeasure stemmed from the lenient sentences given to some Nazi figures?

              Read the article ...
              1. +1
                16 November 2025 14: 03
                Quote: kalibr
                Read the article..

                And what's in the article? MGB General, in Polish questions, dissatisfied military prosecutor's office , who handled the Nuremberg trials? How does he relate to the prosecutor's office to express dissatisfaction?
            2. -2
              16 November 2025 13: 53
              Quote: Unknown
              Not Burdenko's version, but an established fact!

              In 1944 this was the version.
              1. +3
                16 November 2025 14: 04
                Quote: kalibr
                In 1944 this was the version.

                In 44 it was an established fact, not a version.
                1. -1
                  16 November 2025 14: 09
                  Quote: Unknown
                  In 44, this was an established fact, not a version.

                  Burdenko's words: "The focus of our commission's work lies in establishing the timing and methods of murder... The methods of murder are identical to the methods of murder that I found in Orel and that were discovered in Smolensk. In addition, I have information about the murder of 700 mentally ill people in Voronezh. The mentally ill were exterminated within 5 hours using the same method. All these methods of murder reveal German hands." I will prove it in time."The fact is not proven. The theory is proven.
                  1. 0
                    16 November 2025 14: 40
                    Quote: kalibr
                    The fact is not proven. The theory is proven.

                    By no means.
                    7. The conclusions from the witness statements and forensic examination regarding the execution of Polish prisoners of war by the Germans in the autumn of 1941 are fully confirmed by the material evidence and documents extracted from the Katyn graves;

                    8. By shooting Polish prisoners of war in the Katyn forest, the Nazi invaders consistently carried out their policy of physical extermination of the Slavic peoples.

                    (Signatures of the members of the Special Commission follow)

                    Chairman of the Special Commission, member of the Extraordinary State Commission, academician

                    N. N. BURDENKO.
                    1. +1
                      16 November 2025 15: 08
                      Quote: Unknown
                      I will prove it in time.

                      That's what he was proving...
                      1. 0
                        16 November 2025 16: 30
                        Quote: kalibr
                        That's what he was proving..

                        More precisely, here he proved it.
        3. 0
          17 November 2025 16: 35
          Of course, this is a slander against N.N. Burdenko. If you're not familiar with forensic medical reports and why they're produced, then don't bother. Investigators always rely on and draw conclusions from forensic medical examinations! Don't question Nikolai Nikolaevich's qualifications.

          I will risk. wink Nikolai Burdenko is NOT a forensic expert. He is a surgeon. laughing
    2. -2
      16 November 2025 11: 29
      Quote: Unknown
      I don't want to mention the Nazi lies about Katyn.

      "The investigation conducted by the General Prosecutor's Office of the Soviet Union (1990–1991) and Russian Federation (1991–2004), acknowledged Soviet responsibility for the massacre, but refused to classify the act as a war crime or as an act of mass murder."
      What does Burdenko have to do with this, and what do I have to do with this? Do you personally have more reliable information than the Prosecutor General's Office of two historical eras?
      1. +3
        16 November 2025 13: 05
        Quote: kalibr
        "Investigations by the Prosecutor General's Offices of the Soviet Union (1990–1991) and the Russian Federation (1991–2004) confirmed Soviet responsibility for the massacre, but refused to classify the act as a war crime or as an act of mass murder."
        What does Burdenko have to do with this, and what do I have to do with this? Do you personally have more reliable information than the Prosecutor General's Office of two historical eras?
        Just don't do that. The USSR Prosecutor's Office in the 90s, then the Russian Prosecutor's Office in 94-04. What will the prosecutor's office issue, for example... today, tomorrow, in six months, and for that matter in the future? It's like... something in an ice hole, where the current flows, so... a flower. So, according to the president, the historical era began to change, and immediately FSB archival documents appeared, and maybe they'll reach the prosecutor's office. The best answer in terms of unscrupulousness;
        Volodin noted that "we respect our history, and where mistakes were made, we try to evaluate them objectively, and if we see that this objectivity is lacking, then we need to return to this, rethink it, and draw conclusions."
        This is an EXAMPLE of tacking! It feels like a good school.
        1. -1
          16 November 2025 13: 31
          Quote: Unknown
          What will the prosecutor's office conclude, for example...today, tomorrow, in six months, and in the future?

          When it's over, we'll talk about it. For now, we have what we have!
          1. +3
            16 November 2025 14: 07
            Quote: kalibr
            When it's over, we'll talk about it. For now, we have what we have!

            In the meantime, there is the Goebbels lie, which is being spread by certain circles.
            1. +1
              16 November 2025 14: 08
              Quote: Unknown
              In the meantime, there is the Goebbels lie, which is being spread by certain circles.

              Statement of the Government of the USSR and the Government of the Russian Federation
              1. +3
                16 November 2025 14: 33
                Quote: kalibr
                Statement of the Government of the USSR and the Government of the Russian Federation

                Who believes what? On January 26, 1944, all the major newspapers published her report, which left no stone unturned in Hitler's Katyn myth. Why did the Soviet government's statement in 44 cannot be believed , and are late statements at the current moment accepted as faith?
                1. -1
                  16 November 2025 15: 06
                  Quote: Unknown
                  and are late statements at the current moment accepted as faith?

                  Because they are late. Knowledge accumulates...
                  1. +1
                    16 November 2025 16: 11
                    Quote: kalibr
                    Because they are late. Knowledge accumulates.

                    Late ones aren't because they're piling up, but because the government has shifted—you have to be on top of things. The key is to sense which way the wind is blowing.
                    1. -3
                      16 November 2025 16: 14
                      Quote: Unknown
                      The main thing here is to feel which way the wind is blowing.
                      What's hidden always becomes clear. This also applies to the accumulation of knowledge. Some people think the trees sway and create a wind. But it's the wind that sways them, even though it's invisible.
                      1. +2
                        16 November 2025 16: 25
                        Quote: kalibr
                        The ainæ always becomes apparent. This also applies to the accumulation of knowledge. Some people think that the trees sway and create the wind. But it is the wind that sways them, even though it is invisible.

                        Those who think so are a different matter. But those whose instincts, as they say, are unerring, always move in the right direction when the wind changes, under any government.
                      2. 0
                        16 November 2025 16: 27
                        Quote: Unknown
                        But those who, as they say, have an unfailing sense of smell, always move in the right direction when the wind changes, under any government.

                        Yes, there have always been such people and there always will be!
                      3. +1
                        16 November 2025 16: 35
                        Quote: kalibr
                        Yes, there have always been such people and there always will be!

                        Who would doubt that.
                      4. +2
                        16 November 2025 16: 43
                        Quote: kalibr
                        Yes, there have always been such people and there always will be!

                        And, naturally, the first of them is you.
                      5. -1
                        16 November 2025 16: 45
                        Quote: Paranoid62
                        And, naturally, the first of them is you.

                        Thanks for the compliment. I've never been one for those with impenetrable foreheads and always dressed appropriately for the weather. I strongly advise you to do the same. You'll get a cold in your testicles if you walk around in your underwear in the cold—you'll have a lot of trouble!
                      6. 0
                        16 November 2025 16: 48
                        Quote: kalibr
                        Quote: Paranoid62
                        And, naturally, the first of them is you.

                        Thanks for the compliment. I've never been one for those with impenetrable foreheads and always dressed appropriately for the weather. I strongly advise you to do the same. You'll get a cold in your testicles if you walk around in your underwear in the cold—you'll have a lot of trouble!

                        Be careful. Even being an author doesn't always protect you.

                        There is no discussion, I said what I wanted.
                      7. -2
                        16 November 2025 16: 49
                        Quote: Paranoid62
                        Even the author's status does not always protect.

                        Why doesn't he protect us? From human stupidity, alas, yes, I completely agree with you on that.
                      8. -1
                        16 November 2025 16: 50
                        Quote: kalibr
                        Why doesn't he protect?

                        From Smirnov)
                      9. -1
                        16 November 2025 16: 51
                        Quote: Paranoid62
                        From Smirnov)

                        I don't know what I wrote here that would give him grounds to punish me. I just can't figure it out.
                      10. +1
                        16 November 2025 16: 55
                        Quote: kalibr
                        If you catch a cold in your testicles while walking around in your underpants in the cold, you won’t have any problems!

                        Good luck
                2. +1
                  16 November 2025 16: 17
                  Quote: Unknown
                  On January 26, 1944, her message was published in all the central newspapers, which left no stone unturned in destroying Hitler’s myth about Katyn.

                  When the Lend-Lease announcement was published in all the major newspapers on June 11, 1944, many here in the Military District vehemently disputed it, writing that it couldn't be trusted... They wrote that paper would endure anything.
                3. -1
                  17 November 2025 09: 47
                  Quote: Unknown
                  Why the statement of the Soviet government

                  That's why there's also a statement in all the newspapers of the USSR.

                  PEST DOCTOR GROUP ARREST

                  Some time agoA terrorist group of doctors was uncovered by state security agencies, whose goal was to shorten the lives of active members of the Soviet Union through sabotage treatment.

                  Among the participants in this terrorist group were: Professor M. Vovsi, general practitioner; Professor Vinogradov V.N., general practitioner; Professor Kogan M. B., general practitioner; Professor Kogan B. B., general practitioner; Professor Egorov P. I., general practitioner; Professor A. Feldman, otolaryngologist; Professor Etinger J. G., general practitioner; Professor A. Greenstein, neuropathologist; Mayorov G.I., general practitioner.

                  Documentary evidence, research, medical expert opinions and confessions of those arrested have established that that the criminals, being hidden enemies of the people, carried out harmful treatment of the sick and undermined their health.

                  The consequence is establishedthat the members of the terrorist group, using their position as doctors and abusing the trust of patients, deliberately and villainously undermined the health of the latter,

                  and therefore there are a sea of ​​them:

                  The case of the anti-Soviet "Right-Trotskyist bloc"

                  On the orders of intelligence agencies hostile to the USSR The defendants in this case, representing foreign states, organized a conspiratorial group called the "Right-Trotskyist Bloc," which set as its goal the overthrow of the existing socialist social and state system in the USSR, the restoration of capitalism and the power of the bourgeoisie in the USSR, the dismemberment of the USSR, and the separation from it of Ukraine, Belarus, the Central Asian republics, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Primorye.

                  The investigation establishedthat the “right-Trotskyist bloc” united in its ranks underground anti-Soviet groups of Trotskyists, rightists, Zinovievists, Mensheviks, Socialist Revolutionaries, bourgeois nationalists of Ukraine, Belarus, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the Central Asian republics.

                  etc
        2. -1
          16 November 2025 13: 39
          Quote: Unknown
          Here is an EXAMPLE of tacking!

          But all normal life is a maneuver. Only sheep go straight ahead, and even then, sooner or later, their stupid heads get knocked in!
          1. +1
            16 November 2025 14: 12
            Quote: kalibr
            But all normal life is a maneuver. Only sheep go straight ahead, and even then, sooner or later, their stupid heads get knocked in!

            Of course, the creepers and cockroaches survived, the dinosaurs didn't. But for some reason, when you come across a creepy crawly thing on the road, there a strong desire to crush it.
    3. -1
      17 November 2025 09: 33
      Quote: Unknown
      "In September 1941, the Nazis committed mass murders of Polish officer prisoners in the Katyn Forest near Smolensk." This conclusion was not altered or disavowed in any way in the final text of the court's verdict.

      it is not there at all - the Tribunal did not support the Soviet accusation due to lack of evidence and did not include the Katyn episode in the verdict. .
  6. +3
    16 November 2025 11: 10
    Thank you, Vyacheslav Olegovich!

    A doctor is undoubtedly one of the most worthy professions.

    Under any government.
  7. +3
    16 November 2025 13: 02
    In 1906 he finally graduated from Yuryev University Tartu (Estonia) and received a medical degree with honors.

    N.N. Burdenko graduated from Yuryev University in Yuryev, Livonia Governorate, Russian Empire (now Tartu, Estonia). That's right!
    1. -2
      16 November 2025 13: 33
      Quote: Amateur
      So it will be right!

      Yes, of course, that's both better and more correct. That phrase was worth thinking about. But looking for anti-Soviet sentiment in this article is worthy of a complete idiot!
  8. -1
    16 November 2025 13: 36
    Quote: Amateur
    Haven't you filed a lawsuit against me yet as you promised?

    And it should be a lesson to you and others, but I have health issues, and legal proceedings are time-consuming and nerve-wracking. For me, that's more valuable than fighting with various idiots right now.
  9. +2
    16 November 2025 13: 53
    Quote: kalibr
    Are you really satisfied with everything in Soviet society? Is that it?
    Where is the link to Hitler's lies?

    Yes, the Soviet power has me arranged. The very mention of the Katyn affair is Nazi propaganda.
    1. -3
      16 November 2025 14: 07
      Quote: Unknown
      Yes, the Soviet government suited me.

      In everything? And the smugglers, and the special distribution centers, and the world's number one abortion rate, and N.S. Khrushchev...
      1. +1
        16 November 2025 14: 20
        Quote: kalibr
        In everything? And the smugglers, and the special distribution centers, and the world's number one abortion rate, and N.S. Khrushchev...

        Let's say we fought the carriers, but every carrier is different. Special distribution centers? Well, former party members know better. As for abortions, back then there was a birth rate, now we're dying out. Khrushchev, well, every family has its black sheep.
        1. -2
          16 November 2025 15: 03
          Quote: Unknown
          Let's say we fought the carriers, but every carrier is different. Special distribution centers? Well, former party members know better. As for abortions, back then there was a birth rate, now we're dying out. Khrushchev, well, every family has its black sheep.

          So, there were shortcomings. So does pointing them out mean being anti-Soviet? Every family has its black sheep? But it's a bad family if the black sheep could be the head of the party and the country. Only a very narrow-minded person could fail to see all this.
          1. +1
            16 November 2025 16: 20
            Quote: kalibr
            So, there were shortcomings. So does pointing them out mean being anti-Soviet? Every family has its black sheep? But it's a bad family if the black sheep could be the head of the party and the country. Only a very narrow-minded person could fail to see all this.

            Only saints are without flaws. "Errare humanum est" — "To err is human." Pointing out flaws is necessary, but slandering and vilifying, especially against a former party member, always stinks. Circumstances, and more circumstances. Yeltsin, too, was a real goose. Did they criticize him, speak out in the press, call for him to lie down on the rails? Or do we approve out of habit, etc.
            1. -1
              16 November 2025 16: 24
              Quote: Unknown
              but to slander, to revile

              Where is the slander and vilification in this article? And as a former party member, that's precisely what he knows how to do—not from a layman's perspective, like you, but from the inside, based on documents. And it's precisely this approach that smells wonderful. Although often it smells like archival dust. And yours smacks of somewhat immature judgment.
              1. -2
                16 November 2025 17: 09
                Quote: kalibr
                Where is the slander and vilification in this article? And as a former party member, this is precisely what he knows how to do—not like you, at the lay level, but from the inside, based on documents. And it's precisely this approach that smells wonderful. Although often it smells like archival dust. And yours smacks of somewhat immature judgment.

                What about where? Isn't the Katyn affair slander and defamation? What can I say to a former party member? Drive out those who betrayed once, those who betrayed once will betray twice.
                1. -1
                  16 November 2025 18: 49
                  Quote: Unknown
                  Where, and isn’t the Katyn affair slander and defamation?

                  I was right about the immature judgments.
      2. +3
        16 November 2025 14: 53
        Quote: kalibr
        And the smugglers, and the special distributors, and the first place in the world in abortions

        Yes, it was terrible in the USSR, it was so bad, they didn’t even let people breathe... It’s a different story under 21st century capitalism! wassat A brutal war has been declared on abortions; there are no smugglers or special distributors. Yes Apparently, the birth rate will soon break African records and we'll all be living like the UAE. fellow
        1. +2
          16 November 2025 15: 05
          Quote: Doccor18
          It was terrible in the USSR, so bad, they didn't let people breathe...

          Not terrible, and not all that bad. Personally, I consider the period from 1971 to 1977 the best period in our history. But... no one has eliminated the problems, and their accumulation has led to what we have. We had our problems then, and we have ours now. This is the objective reality of our existence.
          1. +3
            16 November 2025 15: 27
            Quote: kalibr
            Not terrible, and not that bad.

            Then the constant search for unpleasant facts from the past of the Great Motherland, sometimes completely far-fetched, just "so that it would be" is completely incomprehensible...
            Quote: kalibr
            There were problems then, and there are problems now.

            Everything is known through comparison. It's precisely these attempts, often biased, that lead to regular verbal battles, including on VO...
            Quote: kalibr
            This is the objective reality of our existence.

            Objective means unbiased. But where was the last time you saw something like this? Some authors and articles make it clear from the first words or lines which side they're on...
            In any case, thank you very much for such a pleasant topic for the soul and the eye.
            1. 0
              16 November 2025 16: 09
              Quote: Doccor18
              In any case, thank you very much for such a pleasant topic for the soul and the eye.

              You see, there's not a hint of a "search" in it. It describes what happened and how. And I try to write impartially, relying on documents. But...understanding comes with age. I know younger people who still can't forgive the Soviet system for the lack of tights and good underwear... Me either, by the way. But I can understand. But they can't. They're still too young. And that's why they write like that. They want, if not to change the past, then at least to take revenge on it.
              1. +3
                16 November 2025 16: 31
                Quote: kalibr
                But...understanding comes with age.

                Depends on what...
                Quote: kalibr
                I know younger people who still can’t forgive the Soviet system for the lack of tights and good underwear... I

                And I know a lot of young people who would laugh at these “problems,” against the backdrop of astronomical mortgage payments...
                Quote: kalibr
                ...that's why they write like that. They want, if not to change the past, then at least to take revenge on it.

                There's no one and nothing left to take revenge on. But there's a very "bright future" ahead, and that's something worth thinking about. But... not only do they not pay for this, they can actually "upset" you.
                1. +1
                  16 November 2025 16: 34
                  Alexander! Everyone's life experience is different. For some, a mortgage is a burden, while others can afford it without a care in the world. Some can't find work, while others change jobs like gloves, climbing higher and higher. For some, the "future" seems bleak, but for others, it's very bright. What matters here is the social group and where a person sits on the social ladder.
                  1. +3
                    16 November 2025 16: 49
                    Quote: kalibr
                    Everyone's life experience is different. For some, a mortgage is a burden.

                    Life experience and the burden of a mortgage are quite different, don't you think? Young people, educated and well-established in the workforce, are forced to choose between a mortgage and having a child. And many, life experience tells them that in modern society, it's not entirely logical to toil half their lives for a banker just to have their own little corner. Not a mansion, not an estate, not a manor, not a comfortable and spacious home for a large family, but a "corner." And spending more than 50% of your income on food and utilities is also uniquely insane in modern society, especially in a country with incredible amounts of arable land, a very intelligent population, and incredible resource potential.
                    Quote: kalibr
                    Some people can't find a job, while others change jobs like gloves,

                    Anyone can change things "like gloves," but finding someone with decent pay and who treats you like a human being is probably rare...
                    Quote: kalibr
                    but... for some people it is very bright.

                    And we know these people.
                    Quote: kalibr
                    What matters here is which social group and which place

                    More likely, in which family/clan...
                    We don't take natural geniuses into account; there have always been too few of them to have any impact on the statistics.
                    Quote: kalibr
                    social ladder...

                    Social lifts "on preventative maintenance"...
                    1. -1
                      16 November 2025 16: 52
                      Quote: Doccor18
                      Social lifts "on preventative maintenance"...

                      I wouldn't say so...
          2. +1
            16 November 2025 17: 47
            This is a concrete answer to the question: “When was life good in Rus'?”

            I like your version of the answer. Although, of course, a lot depends on one's regional affinity.
  10. -2
    16 November 2025 14: 05
    Quote: Unknown
    What relation does he have to the prosecutor's office to express dissatisfaction?

    As a result, State Security General G.S. Zhukov, the former commissioner for Polish affairs, was forced to admit that the Burdenko Commission had failed to live up to expectations and had "ineptly covered up the case." That's all I know and what's presented in the article. Why guess?
    1. 0
      16 November 2025 14: 47
      Quote: kalibr
      As a result, State Security General G.S. Zhukov, the former commissioner for Polish affairs, was forced to admit that the Burdenko Commission had failed to live up to expectations and had "ineptly covered up the case." That's all I know and what's presented in the article. Why guess?

      The MGB and the military prosecutor's office are two different agencies. The state security general should have done a better job on that case instead of blaming the prosecutor's office.
  11. -1
    16 November 2025 15: 09
    Quote: Unknown
    The state security general should have done a better job on that case and not blamed the prosecutor's office.

    Probably. But I was describing historical events. "Would" is inappropriate in them.
  12. +1
    16 November 2025 18: 33
    Reading about the Katyn massacre raises questions. After the defeat of Poland, part of the Polish army was interned. And that's not captivity. Then the captured Belarusians and Ukrainians were released to their homes. Now they're finally beginning to remember that the Poles killed more than 40 captured Red Army soldiers in 1920. Comrade I.V. Stalin never let such things slide. And those sadists who exterminated our Red Army soldiers got what they deserved. And finally, why doesn't anyone remember that in 1941-1942, an entire Polish army, the Anders Army, was formed, armed, and equipped, from captured Poles. At that time, the Polish government in London had the closest relations with the Soviet government. But then, when the Anders Army left the USSR for Egypt on London's orders, relations were almost severed. But even later, two more Polish armies were formed on Soviet territory. And they dug up officers, or something, to form these units. And now the Poles claim that these two Polish armies took Berlin, and the Red Army only helped them a little. That's how it is.
  13. +1
    16 November 2025 19: 54
    However, Burdenko was still forced to leave Tomsk and on October 11, 1901, transfer... to Yuryev University..... But let us also note the fact that tsarism did not persecute the young rebels that much.

    In much the same way that the Soviet government "not too harshly persecuted" those who changed their region of residence before expected arrest in the 1930s—and thus avoided arrest. The costs of a lack of technological progress. Nowadays, they're too lazy to promptly enter a thief into the border database, but back then, they could only dream of today's opportunities.
  14. +2
    16 November 2025 20: 10
    Why write unverified facts? The Nuremberg Tribunal considered specific issues that the countries of the anti-Hitler coalition would not raise during the hearing. These included the Munich Agreement, Hess's flight to England, the events at Katyn, and several other matters that were inconvenient at the time. And what does Burdenko have to do with it?
  15. 0
    17 November 2025 09: 36
    The article is interesting. But there are some ambiguous passages.
    He personally performed several hundred complex operations on wounded soldiers and commanders.

    He personally wounded soldiers and commanders, and then performed operations?
  16. 0
    18 November 2025 07: 13
    "The Autocrat of Russia, etc., etc., etc." - And rightly so.
  17. 0
    18 November 2025 09: 33
    And congratulations to the author on his recovery. Next time you're sick, listen to the Bad Signal "Katyn" podcasts—they're very factual. Wishing you good health.