Military Review

Nanotechnology: no money, no innovation

177
Recently, in our country, against the backdrop of statements by government officials about the start of a full-scale fight against corruption, a peculiar fashion has emerged. The fashion for identifying amounts, let's say softly, is not quite targeted spending of budget funds by one or another ministry or department. Ministry of Defense, Ministry of Agriculture, Roscosmos, Olympstroy, etc. And now in the role of this “so on” is such a Russian company with state management as Rosnano. The same company that was created more than five years ago and was supposed to literally gush forth with ideas and implemented projects regarding the development of high-tech industries with the release of competitive products.


Five years have passed, and now they have decided to pay attention to the activities of Rosnano. More precisely, attention was paid before, but this time they decided to also count the money that the company, led by the unsinkable reformer of all time, Anatoly Chubais, managed to “master”. The verification is just beginning, but its preliminary results are already known.

It turned out that over the years of its existence, Rosnano has mastered the “wrong direction” 21,8 billion rubles, of which about 3's billion are the costs of developing, creating and subsequently introducing in Russian schools Russian ultra-thin black-and-white tablet computers, option set of which meant working with text and graphic stationary images, but not working with video files ... There was a time when Anatoly Borisovich personally reported to Vladimir Putin about how Rosnano works efficiently, vlyayas with more than 100-billion-dollar funding, which the company comes from the state budget. This report looked like a demonstration to Vladimir Putin of a tablet developed in Rosnano.

And everything seems to be already tuned in that the Russian-made tablet computer will appear to the pupils of our schools, even black and white, even if without the video support function, even late, but still relatively inexpensive (the price is up to 12 thousand rubles) and , most importantly, your own, "homegrown." But ... As the weeks went by, the months passed, and the know-how presented by the head of Rosnano did not go to Russian schools. The reason turned out to be utterly banal: the final price of the “Rosnanovsky” compact computer turned out to be comparable to the price of the most expensive foreign analogues, one of which (Anatoly Borisovich himself uses a tablet from a well-known overseas company). True, foreign “analogs” are colored, they are connected to the Internet and they reproduce videos ... Therefore, the “Millennium Project” died out, and billions of budget funds turned out to be unknown where, and it is not known how to return them from there to the budget.

Another Rosnano project, which caused some confusion, was another 3 billionth (penny to penny) project for the production of silicon components for solar cells. Moreover, the company did not intend to take the designated three billion from its existing budget, but made a request for this amount to the Ministry of Finance. The project was named by Anatoly Chubais’s office as a priority, and therefore capable of ultimately producing an excellent profit, but only with the project came a real incident. It turned out that similar materials in their factories are already being manufactured by our Chinese neighbors, and the commissioning of the production capacities of the PRC cost much less. Moreover, in those years, while Rosnano was hatching the idea of ​​producing polycrystalline silicon, the world price for this material fell exactly 25 times (not without the help of all the same Chinese productions). Such information led to the fact that from the Ministry of Finance a refusal to allocate the designated billions came to Rosnano. However, the refusal of the Ministry of Finance did not upset the company's management, and Rosnano decided that the battle was not lost yet, and that solar panel plants based on that very polysilicon would soon start growing like mushrooms after rain.

Anyway, Anatoly Borisovich was not used to giving up after such failures. Well, lost, you understand a dozen or two billions from the state budget - it does not matter, they will give more, which means that projects will continue to appear. Moreover, in the case of the current work of Mr. Chubais, it is practically impossible to present any financial claims to him. Why? Yes, because the essence of the work "Rosnano" declared in the form of a company focused on the development of an innovative economy. And according to international standards, conducting such activities is fraught with serious risks. For example, the proposed innovative projects in the United States of America are implemented at best on 20-25. That is, 7-8 projects from 10 suffer a complete collapse and do not bring any benefit to the economy. So then we blame Anatoly Chubais? .. It seems that most of the projects are not being implemented in his company: recently the only development that Rosnano can boast of is the so-called “FemtoScan” - a scanning probe microscope that has found application in medicine. But, comparing the domestic "Rosnano" with foreign innovative companies, we should not forget about one important moment. The fact is that in the same United States the state, if it participates in the financing of developments implemented by such companies, the level of this financing is several times, if not ten times lower than the level of private investment. Moreover, in the overwhelming majority of cases, foreign companies receive a specific task, for the solution of which specialists are already attracted and funds are allocated. That is: the task has been set - please, seek its solution. But for the time being, everything is given to Rosnano itself: here is the 130 of the billion rubles of the budget for you, and do what you see fit: a tablet, so a tablet; dry closets, so dry closets. And is it really necessary for the Russian and world markets - the tenth question.
Naturally, this approach unleashes the "generals" of the company, which (the "generals") does not feel at least some kind of control over themselves. There is an opportunity to write off any failure on world statistics: they say that you point your finger at us, this happens to the whole world. Yes, it happens - no one argues, but only in the foreign version loses the private investor, who, after losing the investment in an innovative company, is unlikely to trust it for the second time. And in our case, the state loses money, that is, every Russian taxpayer. And after the next loss of funds for the “project that didn’t justify itself,” the financing of Rosnano from the state budget still continues on a solid scale - with the same rake again and again ...

Of course, this is not a reason to abandon the strategically important innovative projects. This is a reason to establish control over the activities of the company, which operates with colossal budget funds with minimal returns.
Naturally, someone (for example, Anatoly Borisovich himself) can say what kind of return you would expect if Rosnano has been operating for only 5 years. Just wait, they say, at least for years 20-25, then the implementation of innovative projects will increase significantly. However, if such a variant of the company's work continues, then you can wait at least 25, at least 125 for years, and the return will be the same: money is lost, understand and forgive ...

By the way, Mr. Chubais claims that the specified amount in 21,8 billion, it turns out, has not disappeared anywhere:

I want to draw the attention of those people who raised the topic with great enthusiasm, that we either stole 21 billion, or wrote off 21 billion, or threw away ... We didn’t steal, didn’t write off and didn’t throw it away. We have created reserves.


What are the reserves? For what purpose? If to translate into reality innovative projects, then with such solid reserves, it took Rosnano to ask 3 a billion rubles from the Ministry of Finance for the implementation of a polysilicon project ... the reserves have been accumulated ... It turns out that either the words about the reserves are another bluff, or these considerable funds are not at all needed for investing in innovation.

By the way, analyzing the words of Anatoly Borisovich that no one stole anything, wrote off or threw it away, we need to recall the following situation. Not so long ago, the head of Rosnano launched a cry in which he called for investing funds from pension funds into projects of the company he headed ... Like, why would the money lie on the accounts if you can start the implementation of the next project? However, I immediately recall the main, excuse me, “excuse” of Rosnano representatives about why not all projects work - statistics, they say. And if we are guided by world statistics, it turns out that when investing a billion or other from a pension fund in “nano-ideas”, at best, only 20% of funds will work. The rest of all statistical calculations will go down the drain. And that’s how the Pension Fund, which itself can’t patch the holes in short supply, will tell the retirees about why the funds have melted - that’s another question. It’s at least naive to expect that 100% of the “pension” money will give a positive return in Rosnano projects.

It is noteworthy that Rosnano does not care about the possibility of an inflow of private capital, but again directs its views on what lies closer to the state budget. Still would! Chastnika try to attract black-and-white tablet, and the state does not need to attract money - they will flow if you remove the last restrictive barriers ...

PS According to Rosnano, in 2012, the revenue of the so-called nanocenters amounted to 365 million rubles. What a sly, however, report. The trick is that the concept of revenue is significantly different from the concept of profit. Profit is revenue minus expenses. And what is the annual profit of the centers controlled by Rosnano, if only the monthly salary of the head of the company itself is estimated at 2 million rubles, and the average salary of hundreds of Rosnano employees is about 300 thousand rubles? And is this profit at all? It would have been - the company "Rosnano" would have long trumpeted about this at all angles ...
Author:
177 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Denis
    Denis April 23 2013 07: 59
    63
    Money is not enough for him?
    It’s not necessary to think about money, but to get ready. Berezovsky and all his pip brothers have been waiting for him
    1. vadimus
      vadimus April 23 2013 08: 27
      16
      This redhead clown nano loot came up with a campaign. He riveted a lot, but he is not visible .....
      1. Nicholas C.
        Nicholas C. April 23 2013 08: 31
        61
        Another would have been shot long ago. And this one is unsinkable, unkillable, impassable, more alive than all living things. Another question is who is more important in the current government. But there is also a strong aspen stake.
        1. Kaa
          Kaa April 23 2013 09: 02
          17
          Quote: Nikolai S.
          Another would have been shot long ago
          And he, for nanotechnology and for reporting for money, according to an old habit, will issue nano-vouchers and will again be in chocolate ...
          1. Patriot of Russia
            Patriot of Russia April 23 2013 18: 57
            -1
            Quote: Denis
            Money is not enough for him?
            It’s not necessary to think about money, but to get ready. Berezovsky and all his pip brothers have been waiting for him
            where to go and why ?! he and his brothers and under Putin do not live badly
          2. Patriot of Russia
            Patriot of Russia April 23 2013 19: 02
            +5
            Quote: Denis
            Money is not enough for him?
            It’s not necessary to think about money, but to get ready. Berezovsky and all his pip brothers have been waiting for him

            where to go and why ?! he and the brothers under Putin are not living badly. support each other, so to speak
            1. captain dvv
              captain dvv April 25 2013 22: 03
              +2
              correctly. Chubais plus others like Serdyukov and Vasileva are afraid of nothing. Our sovereign today confirmed this on television in front of the whole country.
          3. cumastra1
            cumastra1 April 23 2013 19: 33
            +7
            we drill nano-holes in nano-nuts so that we insert a nano-bolt into the nano-hole
            1. opkozak
              opkozak April 23 2013 21: 30
              +5
              Quote: cumastra1
              we drill nano-holes in nano-nuts so that we insert a nano-bolt into the nano-hole

              That's the joke happened. Another scandal arose around the Skolkovo innovation center, also known as the Russian Silicon Valley, located near Moscow. As Skolkovo security officer A. R. Borodach told reporters, during a night walk around the premises, he discovered damage to the lock doors in the nanotechnology block and broken gates of the aviary with nanorobots, and the aviary itself was empty. When it became clear that one of the experimental nanorobots escaped, a state of emergency was declared immediately on the territory of the complex, a special unit “Alpha” was called from the capital, and the 55th Moscow Internal Troops Division was put on alert.
              Fortunately, a fugitive was soon found. Nanorobot stuck in a hole in the fence while trying to squeeze into it. On their own, security officers managed to stun and pull out the innovative development.
              According to the Center’s management, the nanorobot did not receive significant damage and returned to its native Nanoblock after replacing several lamps.
              An official audit has been launched on the fact of the incident, and the State Duma of the Russian Federation will soon consider the possibility of providing additional funds for the modernization of Skolkovo security systems.
          4. maxim1ch
            maxim1ch April 25 2013 20: 00
            -1
            Pfff, all documentation and reports from RUSNANO since its inception are in the public domain
        2. Vadivak
          Vadivak April 23 2013 09: 52
          44
          You are a unique liar, Anatoly Borisovich. You lie every second

          - G. A. Yavlinsky
          1. Papakiko
            Papakiko April 23 2013 18: 42
            +1
            Quote: Vadivak
            You are a unique liar, Anatoly Borisovich. You lie every second

            Quote: Denis
            It’s not necessary to think about money, but to get ready

            Once they are now ANAS they are very busy.
            Here is an example of "nanytechnology" in production from Chubayka and the "ghouls" that have stuck to him:

            A similar production has been operating in Yekaterinburg since 2002 and was called "Uralplastic" now they are "Penoterm" their website:
            http://www.penoterm.ru/
            http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOA5BTdrlz0
            In this video, the "Cheshire Cat" is used at all, a subtle hint. wink

            Such is it, NANO.
            1. Dim Dim
              Dim Dim April 23 2013 22: 11
              +2
              They just forgot to add to this story that everything is produced on imported equipment and from imported raw materials. And the rest, a beautiful marquise, all is well, all is well.
              1. maxim1ch
                maxim1ch April 25 2013 20: 03
                -2
                If good raw materials and equipment were produced in Russia, it would be possible to use it. And they didn’t produce raw materials because there were no working factories ... And RUSNANO had nothing to do with it, no one wants to risk it ...
          2. Denis
            Denis April 23 2013 19: 14
            10
            Quote: Vadivak
            You are a unique liar, Anatoly Borisovich. You lie every second

            - G. A. Yavlinsky
            And that honest one from the same trash
        3. sir
          sir April 24 2013 07: 53
          +4
          on red am
      2. Vadivak
        Vadivak April 23 2013 09: 37
        34
        Only mass executions will save the homeland.

        But seriously, if such a scum is free, then someone really needs it


        1. aksakal
          aksakal April 23 2013 13: 28
          +8
          Quote: Vadivak
          Only mass executions will save the homeland. But seriously, if such a scum is free, then someone really needs it
          - you need a redhead pampering, you need a redhead playful. Need to threaten with a finger.
        2. svp67
          svp67 April 23 2013 17: 18
          +4
          Quote: Vadivak
          Only mass executions will save the homeland.

          I think that so far there are enough selective ones ... And this is a citizen, clearly on that list.
          1. captain dvv
            captain dvv April 25 2013 22: 10
            0
            our people knew life better than us therefore and came up with the proverb that the fish rots from the head. no shootings are needed. in power should stand a person really wanting to rid it of corruption and not imitating the fight against it. that's all.
        3. fokino1980
          fokino1980 April 24 2013 21: 25
          +3
          I can’t believe this power while CHUBAIS is free !!!! And there are millions like me. Reasons You Know Everything.
          1. captain dvv
            captain dvv April 25 2013 22: 12
            -1
            I agree with you
        4. Spike
          Spike April 24 2013 22: 03
          0
          Better hanging, for clarity !!! But in general I agree. am
      3. Andrey Yuryevich
        Andrey Yuryevich April 23 2013 09: 48
        34
        eh Kvachkov ... Kvachkov .... so what are you ...
        1. Vadivak
          Vadivak April 23 2013 09: 54
          37
          Quote: Andrey Yurievich
          eh Kvachkov ... Kvachkov .... so what are you ...



          Participants in the unsuccessful attempt on Anatoly Chubais were prosecuted for not fulfilling a combat mission.


      4. evgenm55
        evgenm55 April 23 2013 10: 39
        15
        That’s the whole point, he’s far from being a clown, but with whom he has been twirling and turning for more than 20 years, he’s not even clowns anyway ... In any case, he is a cancerous tumor on the body of my Motherland. adequately, no, not with a scalpel, it won’t help. Only hard radiation ...
        1. ramzes1776
          ramzes1776 April 25 2013 14: 27
          0
          Quote: evgenm55
          In any case, he is a cancerous tumor on the body of my Motherland.

          While he is at the head of this company, no discoveries should be expected. He made the "Sharazhkin" office "Horns and Hooves" out of it by cutting our budget money. And if they come up with something, then these developments will be the first to see "overseas" ... The Cossack was sent for a long time.
          1. maxim1ch
            maxim1ch April 25 2013 20: 05
            -3
            The company has not taken money from the budget for many years, and it would be useful for you to read about one of the 32 production facilities launched with support, including budget money!
            1. ramzes1776
              ramzes1776 April 25 2013 23: 38
              +2
              Quote: maxim1ch
              The company has not taken money from the budget for many years, and it would be useful for you to read about one of the 32 production facilities launched with support, including budget money!

              You’ll tell tales to your grandfather !!! You are probably one of the effective managers who receives 300 thousand a month at one of the enterprises producing nanotanks with nanowires and inventing black and white tablets at a price of 30 thousand apiece. negative
      5. postman
        postman April 23 2013 13: 46
        +4
        Quote: vadimus
        This redhead clown nano loot came up with a campaign. He riveted a lot, but he is not visible .....

        Back in 2012, he clearly set his priorities:
        until 2015 IPO (in 2013)
        Ministry of Economic Development: Now the company can place an additional issue for 5 billion 971 million 300 thousand ordinary registered uncertified shares with a par value of 1 rubles. The authorized capital of Rusnano now consists of 53 billion 741 million 700 thousand ordinary shares with a par value of 1 ruble, after the placement it may increase to 59 billion 713 million shares.
        June 20, 2012 Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev signed a decree according to which he approved the privatization in 2012-2013. the state block of shares of Rusnano. The document notes that the Russian Federation plans to privatize 10% of shares of OJSC "Rusnano" and reduce its share in the company to 90% by issuing and placing an additional issue of shares in 2012.
        - 49% of shares in private hands)
        The first 10% of the shares is planned to be sold to private investors this year, Kalyuzhny specified. He did not cite the names of customers, explaining that "we want to sell more expensive."
        RUSNANO announced its intention to register in Switzerland (Boris Berezovsky, managing company Rusnano Capital, the company Noga lives here, liked to open firms such as Forus and Andava)
        Rusnano Capital in Russia will have only a representative office, but not a branch. And it is right. Why is it needed, this branch? The branch must keep records and pay taxes, but the representative no
        - as with RAO UES (he) = trust management.
        RUSNANO will invest 500 million rubles in the creation of the Pre-IPO fund.The target volume of the fund is estimated at 1,8 billion rubles, of which RUSNANO's contribution will amount to 500 million rubles.
        -the retirement benefit (a golden parachute) from $ 10

        RAO "UES of Russia" ceased to exist in 2005.
        According to various sources, the “golden parachute” for top managers ranged from $ 250000 to $ 750000.
        The management of OGK-2 did not begin to trifle and requested 557 million rubles in compensation.
        The "Golden Parachute" by Mikhail Kuzichev, the former CEO of OGK-2, amounted to approximately 60 million rubles
        Mosenergo OJSC paid to top managers who left the company on April 1, 2008, compensation in the total amount of 94 million rubles.

        .

        In general, these gentlemen (a total of 89 large state corporations for 2007) in 2007 the state cost 3 billion 108 million rubles, receiving an average of 34,9 million rubles for each.
        1. mark021105
          mark021105 April 23 2013 17: 32
          +8
          The farther, the more I affirm in the thought that iPhone in all these schemes is in proportion. where I didn’t have a hand, there is everywhere Zh_O_P_A.
          1. Dim Dim
            Dim Dim April 23 2013 22: 15
            +7
            Well, the redhead was noted even before the iPhone, and who can remember at least one useful thing for the country that the redhead did not ditch?
          2. captain dvv
            captain dvv April 25 2013 22: 17
            +1
            You really think that Dimon was deciding something. or the last name Putin is afraid to pronounce.
      6. opkozak
        opkozak April 23 2013 22: 22
        +8
        Chubais's friend?
      7. skeptic-
        skeptic- April 24 2013 21: 03
        +2
        At one time, saffron said that every privatized enterprise was another nail in the lid of the tomb of communism.

        It seems that he will soon begin to say that every ten zananonized billions of ours, i.e. taxpayer rubles - this is another hammered nail in the coffin - already the Russian Federation. Just some kind of undertaker, on our head. That's who the alpenstock would come in handy for.
    2. Atrix
      Atrix April 23 2013 10: 16
      15
      Here is the video in the topic)))
      1. Krapovy32
        Krapovy32 April 23 2013 18: 10
        +4
        Quote: Atrix
        Here is the video in the topic)))



        As it smells fried, this red-haired nano figure will dump to London in a nano-micro-plane. With such "guardians of scientific technology" and enemies it is unnecessary negative
        1. valton
          valton April 23 2013 19: 56
          +7
          It would be funny if it weren’t so sad from the way that UNPUNISHED plundered Russia.
        2. zvereok
          zvereok April 23 2013 21: 07
          +3
          Quote: Speckled32
          As it smells fried, this red-haired nano figure will dump to London in a nano-micro-plane. With such "guardians of scientific technology" and enemies unnecessarily negative


          By the way, about the prohibition of accounts over the hill ... You only need to tighten up if you find - a traitor, and shooting, then, after the first 10 corpses, 10 will be thought about.
      2. valton
        valton April 23 2013 19: 39
        +5
        Per movie +100.

        I suppose the whole Western world laughed when this "goat" was launched into the garden where such a juicy cabbage grows.
    3. elmi
      elmi April 23 2013 11: 09
      +9
      I’m sure that even if the Accounts Chamber finds thefts, they still won’t put Chubais on, if Serdyukov and many ministers are not put in prison, what example do they give to other ministers? - the robbery will not be planted.
      1. captain dvv
        captain dvv April 25 2013 22: 26
        0
        Olympics, the summit in the Far East, Skolkovo, Moscow region. Further, you can continue to infinity. Everywhere huge thefts. It may be enough for us to console ourselves with the tale of the good king and evil boyars. In the modern world this does not happen.
    4. vezunchik
      vezunchik April 23 2013 11: 55
      +2
      And he is already looking there. Look at the photo. not for long .....
    5. datur
      datur April 23 2013 14: 13
      +1
      [quote = Denis] Money is not enough for him?
      It’s not necessary to think about money, but to get ready. Berezovsky and his whole pip brotherhood have already been waiting, it’s just time to send him a scarf !!! wink yes
      1. yak69
        yak69 April 23 2013 20: 18
        +1
        Red, this is not a stool for you! He will not even be called to the prosecutor. If stools are free, then this one is finally irremovable.
        There was such a story about him (it seems from Korzhakov). At one time, bronze tablets on his office were often changed, then one position, then another. Khoz was tired of this and decided to make universal - for all time: Anatoly Borisovich Chubais. So he walks with this sign, from one office to another.
        One word - "ETERNAL Jew"!
        1. yak69
          yak69 April 23 2013 20: 23
          +9
          For distinguished moderators: the word "Zh.D." in Polish means "Jew"
          In Polish (żyd), Slovak (žid), Czech (žid), Lithuanian (žydas), Hungarian (zsidó) etymological correspondence to the Russian word Jew means both “Jew” and “Jew” (sometimes with spelling differentiation - in Polish and Czech, this word is written with a capital letter in ethnic meaning and with a small letter in religious), and does not have a negative connotation.
          Wikipedia.
        2. Aaron Zawi
          Aaron Zawi April 23 2013 20: 37
          -3
          Quote: yak69

          One word - "ETERNAL Jew"!
          Those. Do you think that if his mother is Jewish, then the man is Jewish?
          Father - Boris Matveyevich Chubais (February 15, 1918 - October 9, 2000) - veteran of the Great Patriotic War, retired colonel, after retirement, teacher of Marxism-Leninism at the Leningrad Mining Institute.
          Mother - Raisa Efimovna Sagal (September 15, 1918 - September 7, 2004).

          And then what to do with the only Nobel laureate of Russia Zhores Ivanovich Alferov? Is he Russian or Jewish?
          Born in the Belarusian-Jewish family of Ivan Karpovich Alferov and Anna Vladimirovna Rosenblum.
          1. yak69
            yak69 April 23 2013 22: 28
            +4
            for Aron Zawi
            The expression "Eternal Zh.D." is taken from the Bible.
            Agasferus (lat. Ahasverus), or the Eternal Jew - a legendary character, according to legend, doomed to eternal wanderings on earth until the Second Coming of Christ.
            This name is already a common noun, as a symbol of heartlessness, mental stinginess and inhumanity.
            And do you not know, dear, that Jewry is inherited EXCLUSIVELY on the maternal side. In addition, my comment is not about nationality, but about a set of qualities. Ia myself have a great attitude to all nationalities (according to the education and conviction of Ia internationalist). In my life there were many Jewish friends and friends. I learned a lot from them. And I always very accurately separate the Jews and the Zionists. Some are just people, others are the fiends of hell.
            So, nationality is not an indicator for me, and I don’t see anything offensive here. I’ll tell you, several names to which I always bow my head: Utesov, Smoktunovsky, Gaft, Bystritskaya, Alferov, Yehudi Minukhin, the present Wasserman and many others.
          2. alexander rus.
            alexander rus. April 23 2013 23: 29
            -2
            Yes, all of them, as V. Vysotsky sang "... from ours, from the Poles, from the Slavs ...".
          3. Alex Nick
            Alex Nick April 25 2013 01: 00
            +1
            Among Jews, maternal kinship is considered. Stop talking.
    6. Patriot of Russia
      Patriot of Russia April 23 2013 18: 56
      -1
      Quote: Denis
      Money is not enough for him?
      It’s not necessary to think about money, but to get ready. Berezovsky and all his pip brothers have been waiting for him

      where to go and why ?! he and his brothers and under Putin do not live badly
    7. Vovka levka
      Vovka levka April 24 2013 23: 05
      -1
      Quote: Denis
      Money is not enough for him?

      They are always not enough.
  2. yurypetrunin
    yurypetrunin April 23 2013 08: 00
    14
    An abscess on the body of Russia! And the abscess head is Chubais. Yuri Petrunin. Gatchina.
    1. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov April 23 2013 08: 11
      29
      Quote: yurypetrunin
      An abscess on the body of Russia

      Rather, the Rusnano washing machine for washing money. 5 years ago, Chubais said that the company’s turnover will be 900 billion, what’s the result now? wink
      For what this red cockroach would not take, everything goes to dust, EVERYTHING !!! But it amazes me even more why Putin is constantly appointing someone.
      1. vilenich
        vilenich April 23 2013 08: 15
        15
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        But it amazes me even more why Putin is constantly appointing someone.

        As one famous comedian used to say: "Something is probably wrong in the conservatory!"
        1. Alexander Romanov
          Alexander Romanov April 23 2013 08: 26
          +3
          Quote: vilenich
          "Something seems to be wrong at the conservatory!"

          Yeah, damn it, he has the wrong grenade system.
      2. PPL
        PPL April 23 2013 08: 28
        13
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        But it amazes me even more why Putin is constantly appointing someone.

        This is how the "father" of the constitution A. Sobchak bequeathed, to whom all the current "democrats" were either advisers or a swing member ... lol
        Sobchak about Chubais: "a young man who lacks knowledge, but has a great desire to change everything."

        The original of this material
        © "Faces", # 3 1996
        1. not good
          not good April 23 2013 09: 22
          12
          Time has passed, the person is no longer young, but still can not stop ... But in hell a warm company was waiting ... Yeltsin, Gaidar and others with a great desire to change everything .... am
      3. Vadivak
        Vadivak April 23 2013 09: 47
        +7
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        But it amazes me even more why Putin is constantly appointing someone.


        Sasha, maybe he appoints himself? Well, an honest person cannot have such dirt next to him.
      4. iulai
        iulai April 23 2013 09: 48
        18
        Alexander, this Chubais failed the unemployed, the former deputy Sobchak, V.V. Putin to the wino. The drunk made him the prime minister, then career trampled. So Putin thanks his godfather, appointing him to feed on bread places. A crystal-clear honest person will not be put on a high post; you need a good hook. A hook with a leash is probably in the hands of Red. That is why it is unsinkable!
        1. Tverichanka
          Tverichanka April 24 2013 01: 34
          +2
          Quote: iulai
          So Putin thanks

          Don’t share, where is your awareness from? Is there a reliable source? Then announce it. And if these are your personal assumptions, please write so. There should be objectivity.
          Quote: iulai
          on a high post, you need a good hook.

          And about honesty and dishonesty, you understand very well that what you wrote does not correspond to reality. Then why write lies? Earn popularity and epaulets?
        2. captain dvv
          captain dvv April 25 2013 22: 36
          0
          gang law. everyone in the gang must be tied, and then surrender. Yeltsin’s gang could not bring a crystal-clear person to power, otherwise everyone would have sat down in a month. they may be thieves, but by no means fools. when at stake hundreds of billions of words and promises no one believes. you really need something serious to hold a person for me ...
      5. Akatsubasa
        Akatsubasa April 23 2013 09: 57
        +4
        Quote: Alexander Romanov
        But it amazes me even more why Putin is constantly appointing someone.

        It's funny that all the stealing comrades simply retreated into the shadows. The same old man Pekhtin) Crick was about an apartment in Miami, and now quietly quietly pushed into the shade in RusHydro, where there had just been a check and certainly no one would look in the near future) it turned out) He is not Pekhtin, not so modest)
      6. donchepano
        donchepano April 23 2013 10: 04
        +7
        Quote: Alexander Romanov

        It amazes me why Putin is constantly appointing him.


        Here is the answer about unsinkability ...
      7. vezunchik
        vezunchik April 23 2013 11: 57
        +3
        The question and answer ...
      8. Roll
        Roll April 23 2013 14: 55
        +2
        wassat Where Chubais victory is everywhere, he is a brilliant manager. Voucher privatization, the most honest and sensible, and the people unfortunately could not appreciate it, well, they don’t appreciate the good, it’s the tradition of the people. Rao ees sold at such prices that you are surprised. And to breed potanins and promissory notes is such a talent to have. As for nano, it’s not so simple, both with the skolkovo and the Olympics. This is a trend of recent years and Chubais didn’t stand out.
        1. matross
          matross April 23 2013 18: 02
          +2
          There are thousands of them. The redhead is just in plain sight, public, taking into account the past. They will never be defeated by "fighting corruption". They are our state power and system. And here we are fluttering - to shoot! yes to the bunk! We are nobody for them, not even the "electorate". Who has not yet understood this - see the next series ...
  3. artist-mamluk
    artist-mamluk April 23 2013 08: 03
    16
    Repression and only cruel repression in relation to stealing bureaucrats can change all this rotten swamp.
  4. awg75
    awg75 April 23 2013 08: 03
    19
    a thief should be in prison, and such a gnida like a redhead should sit for life
    1. Pit
      Pit April 23 2013 09: 35
      +8
      Quote: awg75
      sit for life

      Or hang out on the gallows in the center of the palace square
      1. donchepano
        donchepano April 23 2013 10: 05
        +1
        Quote: Pit
        Or hang out on the gallows in the center of the palace square

        First, return the loot
      2. not good
        not good April 23 2013 12: 34
        +4
        Well, why at once on the palace, the Forehead place historically in Moscow, let it hang first, and then with a tour across the country, so that everyone could spit.
      3. Denis
        Denis April 23 2013 19: 23
        +5
        Quote: Pit
        hanging out on the gallows in the center of the palace square
        No, don’t have such a place
        hang me in my yard
    2. mamba
      mamba April 23 2013 09: 44
      +3
      Quote: awg75
      such a gnid like a redhead should sit for life

      Popular wisdom says: "Fear the redhead, yes the bald one." The bald lip-slap, the same Malchish-Badish, whom grandfather Arkady Gaidar scribbled to his family and the whole country, has already died, but the red-haired thief is more alive than all the living. Never sit him. Who will put him in prison? He's a monument! A living monument to the "vertical of power" in Russia.
    3. Gemar
      Gemar April 23 2013 10: 13
      +4
      Quote: awg75
      such a gnid like a redhead

      Chubais is red, caulked. Rows money shovel.
      ====================================================================== =================
      The blanket ran away, the sheet flew away. And the pillow, like a frog, galloped away from me. I'm behind a candle - a candle in the stove. I’m for a book - that run. I will not buy NANO things from Chubais ...
  5. PPL
    PPL April 23 2013 08: 03
    +3
    "... a Russian-made tablet computer ..., even black and white, even without video support, albeit late, but still ..."
    Are such NANO technologies planned? sad
    Well, at least this time they did not let the swindler rummage around in the pockets of pensioners.
    But I think that this is not his last "tour" ...
  6. fenix57
    fenix57 April 23 2013 08: 05
    13
    In general, Chubais needs HYPER MONEY to "get" a NANO invention. request How much can you believe ....
    1. Rustiger
      Rustiger April 23 2013 10: 18
      17
      Quote: fenix57
      How much can you believe ....

      Believe to whom ?????? Nanotolia? To Putin? Ha ha ha . .
      A year ago, I thought Poo was such an "iron cunning rat" who was about to grab hold of it and start. ... ...
      But with each passing month, "illusions" disappear. ... ...

      Ministry of Defense, Ministry of Agriculture, Roscosmos, Olympstroy, etc. And now, the role of this “so on” is played by such a Russian company with state administration as Rusnano.


      Further . . . Judicial system (prosecutors near Moscow), Costs of the APEC forum, Health, Road construction, Utilities, Ministry of Internal Affairs, Distribution of quotas for the extraction of marine resources, Development of minerals, etc., etc. . . .
      Name at least one industry where there is no theft!
      Yes, in such a situation, any president, if only he is interested in the prosperity of his country, would have taken up if not an ax on the block, then certainly a whip. And the Way plays the role of such a cunning guy who kind of lurks and waits. . . What?
      Or do you think that he is not up to date? Every month he turns into a bitch! Into a selling, managed crib. . .
      1. Vasily T.
        Vasily T. April 23 2013 10: 33
        +2
        Yeah, they used to steal billions from millions before. Appetites are growing. Who would give them a Thai pill! Putin! AUUUUUU!
      2. TUMAN
        TUMAN April 23 2013 13: 51
        +5
        Quote: Rustiger
        Every month he turns into a bitch! Into a selling, managed crib. . .

        No comments! good
      3. Rrv
        Rrv April 23 2013 17: 15
        +5
        Quote: Rustiger
        Every month he turns into a bitch! Into a selling, managed crib. . .


        Just does not turn, but always has been.
      4. captain dvv
        captain dvv April 25 2013 23: 02
        +1
        Yes, he was originally so. just at the beginning everyone wanted to believe in a change for the better. and when, after 13 years of promises alone, he didn’t do anything here, then people realized who our president is.
  7. Andrew 121
    Andrew 121 April 23 2013 08: 06
    +7
    Zadornov said read the last name Chubais on the contrary and understand everything. Syabuh he is syabuch .... and the red Syabuch is generally tin for the people.
    1. Vadivak
      Vadivak April 23 2013 09: 52
      +6
      Quote: Andrey 121
      Zadornov said read the surname Chubais on the contrary


      Sagal his last name. Mother - Raisa Haimovna Sagal
  8. Boris55
    Boris55 April 23 2013 08: 06
    +7
    Another "Horns and Hooves" ... disgusting and disgusting ...
    1. AndreyAB
      AndreyAB April 23 2013 09: 06
      +9
      If it were just horns and hooves, then these horns and hooves trade technology for the cordon left and right, and young talents, creating unbearable conditions for them, are delivered abroad, and this is treason to the country.
  9. xaxaes
    xaxaes April 23 2013 08: 14
    +1
    Is there really no head at all ?, such a company should receive approval for new projects from scientists who should determine the prospects and competitiveness of the project, at least in the medium term, and not the thieves known to everyone in the country, who have a brazen and unflappable physiognomy they lie in the eyes and continue to stuff pockets! A b / w tablet is really funny!
    1. mamba
      mamba April 23 2013 09: 36
      +6
      Quote: xaxaes
      such a company should receive approval for new projects from scientists who should determine the prospects and competitiveness of the project, at least in the medium term, and not the thieves known to everyone in the country, who with a brazen and unflappable physiognomy lie in their eyes and continue to fill their pockets!

      Our Kremlin rulers do not listen to professionals, but are guided only by "effective managers". And those are busy stuffing their pockets and, of course, unfastening certain amounts to the top. That is why they are unsinkable. This is how the "vertical of power" works in our unfortunate Russia. Examples can be omitted: and so everything is on hearing.
      1. Danash I
        Danash I April 24 2013 21: 59
        0
        where do they come from, effective managers? Boys with foreign diplomas, brainwashed come to the government. I don’t understand! Speaking English fluently does not mean thinking in Russian.
        1. captain dvv
          captain dvv April 25 2013 23: 29
          +1
          Leave alone the middle management team.
          They have nothing to do with it. All the troubles are from our homegrown top managers. Neither Serdyukov and Shuvalov, nor Medvedev, Ivanov nor Putin overseas universities did not stop the theft when they reached enormous proportions. And such a situation is very satisfied with all of the above.
  10. omsbon
    omsbon April 23 2013 08: 15
    +6
    [b] Where there is Chubais, there is deception and theft! [/ b]
    [b] The red thief should be in prison! [/ b]
  11. pinecone
    pinecone April 23 2013 08: 16
    +8
    Absolutely unsinkable and untouchable. The shadow ruler, or controller, is incomprehensible.
    1. Fornit
      Fornit April 24 2013 16: 58
      +1
      looking, however ... "From where? From there ..." (c)
  12. Kostia1970
    Kostia1970 April 23 2013 08: 18
    +3
    Enchanted he (Chubais) or what ?! Unsinkable (oy), probably does not skimp on kickbacks ....
  13. Grishka100watt
    Grishka100watt April 23 2013 08: 19
    +6
    He’s sitting there, crap, and he knows that all of Russia hates him!
  14. krasin
    krasin April 23 2013 08: 24
    17
    Tired of Chubais, Serdyukov, Sochi, Shuvalov and the nano-successful thieves with them, it’s time and it’s time for them to cage. If we had a normal president, like Lukashenko, the bones would have rotted these successful thieves!
  15. Semyon Albertovich
    Semyon Albertovich April 23 2013 08: 25
    +4
    How much money these "great managers" ate without giving anything in return - DO NOT COUNT. I really liked the idea of ​​the Russian peasant Vasily Melnichenko / Sverdlovsk region / to give Chubais a salary of 12 thousand rubles and let him work. Who wants to read his ideas, find his collection of speeches on You Tube - it will be interesting.
    1. Fornit
      Fornit April 24 2013 17: 00
      +1
      A better life-long pension of 4500 rubles without the right to work ...
  16. zvereok
    zvereok April 23 2013 08: 29
    +6
    And this is all because we have "Excessive corruption" or "Landings where?" (C) And it all started with the fact that "Parliament is not a place for discussion"

    Recently, I read an article how twice the Olympic swimming champion refused to play for the Russian team after officials from the sport wiped their feet on him.

    I was surprised by the comments, some say he wants a gorgeous mansion in California ... Well, in the sense that he was surprised that a person has real achievements and he cannot, and this is gorgeous, plus he betrayed his homeland. And the deputies, whose achievements are, to put it mildly, dubious, can be called "a modest dwelling," and they don't talk about the betrayal of their homeland, they seem to have such a job they can do.
    1. PPL
      PPL April 23 2013 08: 34
      +5
      It all started much earlier!
      In March 1990, Chubais and a group of supporters proposed a project for market reforms to Mikhail Gorbachev, providing for the option of forcibly restricting political and civil liberties (freedom of speech, right to strike, etc.)
      "A tough course ...". Analytical note of the Leningrad Association of Social and Economic Sciences // Century XX and the world. 1990. No. 6. P.15-19.
      1. zvereok
        zvereok April 23 2013 21: 04
        +1
        To me, my deceased, my dad, may he rest in peace. He always said that Chubais was selling flowers in the transition. I always took it for granted, and now I think, where did it come from?
  17. UFO
    UFO April 23 2013 08: 29
    +4
    "The fish rots from the head", when God is a golden calf, the people are in "flight". hi
    1. Bigriver
      Bigriver April 23 2013 08: 44
      +6
      Quote: UFO
      " The fish rots from the head ",..

      As a fisherman, I note - this is a common misconception.
      She begins to rot from the internal organs winked
      With a well-fed and smug belly of the fish.
  18. Canep
    Canep April 23 2013 08: 34
    +5
    If you want to ditch the case, appoint Chubais as the head.
  19. Vrungel78
    Vrungel78 April 23 2013 08: 49
    +5
    When will this democratic pad al rest? Yeltsin, Gaidar, sobchak take your brotherhood. One thing will be disgusting: they will say at the funeral, they say, oh, what a great man he left, a democrat of the first wave, etc. So they talked about all these geeks. And Naina was trying to say that EBN almost never in my life licked. Here is the lying old t-var.
  20. Temer
    Temer April 23 2013 08: 52
    +4
    For Chubais, the "butyrka" has been crying for a long time. They put him on truancy there.
  21. Strashila
    Strashila April 23 2013 08: 54
    +5
    It has already been ... and for how long ... like Hans ...

    “The city in which the king lived was big and lively, every day foreign guests came, and once two deceivers stopped by. They said they were weavers and said that they could weave a wonderful fabric, better than which could be imagined. then it is unusually good, and with a pattern, and besides, a dress made from this fabric has a wonderful property of becoming invisible to any person who sits in the wrong place or is impenetrably stupid.
    "That would be a wonderful dress! - thought the king. - Put on such a dress - and you will immediately see who is sitting in your kingdom in the wrong place. And I can also distinguish the smart from the stupid! Yes, let me have such a fabric woven as soon as possible!"
    And he gave the deceivers a lot of money to get to work immediately. "...
    To be continued by Chubais, I feel sorry for the king’s current ... even two ... they’re naked.
    1. Raven1972
      Raven1972 April 23 2013 09: 53
      +2
      Chubais’s cheeks became scarlet,
      He can tell everything
      But can't show
      Because nans are very small ... laughing
      All these Nana, Skolkovo are nothing more than offices for cutting budget funds, but what is more terrible - for the export of technologies and young specialists developing these technologies am
  22. smart ass
    smart ass April 23 2013 08: 58
    +5
    Made Ginger cat guard sour cream)
  23. Alex66
    Alex66 April 23 2013 09: 01
    +4
    What is NANOtoly responsible for and what is the risk (of his head), eh, we should be the head of Lukashenko, otherwise ours only excuse their accomplices
  24. Orik
    Orik April 23 2013 09: 02
    +3
    laughing Did you expect something else? Plus red, minus innovation!
  25. Tartary
    Tartary April 23 2013 09: 02
    17
    If Rusnano's budget (130 billion rubles) is divided into 40.000 entrepreneurs who closed their business in 2012. it will turn out to be 3 million rubles for the "nose" - not very bad "lifting" ones ...
    Many of them today are curtailing their business, or rather, most simply go into the shadows precisely because of:
    -high taxes on social programs;
    - wild competition in the absence of maneuver opportunities;
    -lack of long and cheap money to replenish working capital - primarily (!)
    But it is the presence of these working capital that makes it possible to develop the scope of the chosen activity ...
    The overwhelming majority of the abovementioned entrepreneurs are engaged in trivial business - buy-sell, cuts, massage in a bathhouse, and other worthy occupations, but 10-25 percent is a specific production area, often it’s quite technological, with its equipment spent on concrete money, which has its own, even residual, but value ...
    Such funds fall under the sovereign's program for the development of innovative activities ... Sovereign money is allocated under the program, which successfully flows into kickbacks in those very banal spheres of activity - buy-sell in bulk, sell through your store, kiosk, etc.
    Out of forty thousand, there will remain approximately 8000 persistent production workers and each with its own theme (!)
    130 billion / 8000 = 16,25 million rubles (?) - this is not a modest amount for the organization with serious production.
    But here's how? It turns out that the salaries of managers of the NANOchubais feeding trough will be much more important than the development of small and medium-sized businesses in Russia ...
    And here's a helluva lot of interest ... Where are those "lucky people" whose developments are being introduced everywhere by Chubais? Where are their happy faces? What media do they write about? What TV channels seem to these colleagues of mine who invent, implement, rationalize?
    Although I am an enthusiast in my field, I study the topic of innovations a lot, but I have no facts that the "red-haired uncle" or his couriers would scour the country in search of talents ...
    Maybe they prowl in a special way?
    Maybe even innovative ?????????? lol
    1. Papakiko
      Papakiko April 23 2013 18: 45
      +1
      Quote: Tartary
      Out of forty thousand, approximately 8000 persistent production workers will remain and each with its own theme (!) 130 billion / 8000 = 16,25 million rubles (?) Is already not a modest amount for organizing serious production ...

      We rolled up "eggs" to the NANO, they pointed out to us that our project was NANANE.
    2. Fornit
      Fornit April 24 2013 17: 06
      -1
      But I’m thinking - why is Nanotolik’s salary only 2? What prevents him from doing 222? Is conscience really? Where is this limit guys? what
  26. AndreyAB
    AndreyAB April 23 2013 09: 03
    +3
    They found someone to engage in innovations, they let the goat into the garden, during the "fruitful work" of Mr. Chubais, foreign science probably received a new impetus for development, and Russia received nano-profits from nanotechnology, as always, Mr. Chubais continues to contribute to the collapse of Russian science and economy and no one notices this, just as they did not notice the activities of Mr. Serdyukov.
  27. Uncle lee
    Uncle lee April 23 2013 09: 10
    +9
    Yeahhh, Koreyko nervously smokes on the sidelines ... He even had klister tubes and a barrel of water, and this one has NANO, go see, and billions are dripping
  28. Bykov.
    Bykov. April 23 2013 09: 15
    +2
    ... Nano-checks: no money, no innovation ...

    Natural and the only possible result, given the reputation of the "red-haired", which is surprising, except that: - How in general was he entrusted with something?
  29. Grbear
    Grbear April 23 2013 09: 18
    +2
    In principle, the situation with Nano reflects all the flaws of state-owned enterprises. First of all, this is the lack of an effective and objective regulatory body. The Accounts Chamber, as a permanent organization, is subject to corruption and, moreover, its reports are not grounds for active prosecution.

    For RosNano, the controlling body could be a gathering of specialists from the RAS, collected at a time (probably, that's why they are being dispersed). Gathered, consulted and "ate". Another time, they gathered others, to another direction, etc. Analysis of the effectiveness of other state corporations should be done according to the same principle. The report should be published in the media and "for the distribution of elephants." For specialists, this is a week of work. For the treasury, there are only pluses for which it is worth paying.
    And "Red" has nothing to do with, in such "water" another will start.
    1. Grbear
      Grbear April 23 2013 09: 30
      +1
      And, you can collect a "flock" of 5-year students of specialized universities and graduate students and "launch" them into a state-owned enterprise. They are science and part-time. If they "buy", then there will always be an honest one, and the "purchase" will appear, which means that the whole group cannot be in the state service. Well, something like this.
    2. Fornit
      Fornit April 24 2013 17: 10
      0
      Quote: GrBear
      even chamber, as a permanent organization, subject to corruption

      Especially when Golikov comes to the place of Stepashin! From there will be expanse - that !!! The husband is her (Khristenko) from the same detachment ...
  30. darksoul
    darksoul April 23 2013 09: 18
    0
    When this red-haired little bit was already going on, the tenacious sv ... ch, it was necessary to think of putting him to such a position altogether, or rather they didn’t think or pursued other goals. With such a leader, Rusnano will develop such innovations that SKR will then have to rake them for a long time
  31. SPQR
    SPQR April 23 2013 09: 22
    12
    I wonder who is behind Chubais, because even in the most corrupt state, a person who has robbed the entire population at least twice should at least retire (if corruption is so strong even at the top) or sit down (if everything is not so hopeless), but how to explain the fact that such a person does not sit or does not quietly retire, but is assigned to oversee innovative development? I understand Medvedev clearly does not shine with his mind like 93% of ministers in his office, but Vladimir Vladimirovich clearly a smart person leaves this creature (sorry An Atoliy Borisovich but you can’t apply another epithet) at this important post. What conclusion can be made?
    1. Chubais has so much succeeded in licking the ass to the bosses that it can no longer exist without him;
    2. In Chubais, the owners control not only Chubais itself but also the entire top of the country;
    3. Chubais himself rules the country (which would explain a lot), a sort of gray cardinal, because it’s clear that if he officially participated in the elections he would gain 0,0000000000000000000000000000001%, and it’s cleverly obtained through Dimka and Vovka;
    4. He is an unrecognized genius of the era, and we did not understand his cunning plan;
    5. He is a recognized genius but we just don’t understand the cunning plan;
    6.He is an alien;
    7. He is an agent of the CIA a kind of introduced pest;
    8. An ordinary thief by the will of fate abandoned to the top;
    9. It is a punishment sent to us by Stalin so that we can appreciate the genius of Stalinist rule a sort of comparative option;
    10. He is the scourge of God sent to us for our sins.
    1. mamba
      mamba April 23 2013 09: 59
      +2
      Quote: SPQR
      What conclusion can be drawn?
      3. Chubais rules the country himself;
      7. He is an agent of the CIA a kind of introduced pest;
      8. An ordinary thief by the will of fate abandoned to the top;
      10. He is the scourge of God sent to us for our sins.

      Well, why be so verbose? You yourself answered your question in p.p. 3, 7, 8, 10.
    2. Temer
      Temer April 23 2013 16: 57
      +1
      6.He is an alien;


      Absolutely to the point !!!
  32. igor36
    igor36 April 23 2013 09: 23
    +7
    Give these 30 billion to support small businesses, to provide cheap loans and get the output of the country's development, the emergence of the middle class and the development of mega-brains, and not nanochubais.
  33. Asketxnumx
    Asketxnumx April 23 2013 09: 27
    +3
    "And the king is naked!" How long will he get away with everything ?!
  34. Akatsubasa
    Akatsubasa April 23 2013 09: 30
    +2
    Oddly enough, nanotechnologies are developing in our country, but not thanks to, but contrary to state funding and Rusnano, headed by Chubais)
  35. holding
    holding April 23 2013 09: 31
    +3
    It is really incomprehensible how this subject manages to constantly spin at the top, next to huge money? After all, it is clear to anyone that this is a "dirty" person. And the same Putin does not know ????
    Summary-the head decomposes with a stinking smell and further.
  36. tttttt
    tttttt April 23 2013 09: 36
    +8
    Gentlemen, if in the near future Chubais is not exponentially destroyed, there can be no doubt in the betrayal of the president and government. Sometimes I ask myself the question: Who controls Russia after all? Putin or Chubais? I have not yet found the answer.
    1. mamba
      mamba April 23 2013 10: 14
      +1
      Quote: tttttt
      if in the near future Chubais is not exponentially destroyed, there can be no doubt in the betrayal of the president and government.

      Do you still have doubts? iulai in his post at 9-48 he explained everything popularly.
      Quote: tttttt
      Sometimes I ask myself the question: Who controls Russia after all? Putin or Chubais? I have not yet found the answer.

      I am sending it there again.
  37. waisson
    waisson April 23 2013 09: 37
    +2
    Inevitably, the poklyny Berizovsky asked to Russia to engage in the science of such crooks again for all sorts of frauds that can be cranked up on the first wave. A Chubais it’s high time to isolate him from the karmushka but whoever removes it and that’s the power to heal must be healed and not healed and cut so that a new government independent of today's power grows and has never been in power
  38. individual
    individual April 23 2013 09: 38
    +2
    EBN instilled a universal love of the people for Chubais, for vouchers, Putin developed, spudded and increased his respect for the author of RAO UES and the "nano-saw" of the magician.
  39. TRex
    TRex April 23 2013 09: 44
    +6
    Another soap bubble burst ... What do you want? The question is where else to send this red-haired dog? Where are we doing badly and urgent intervention of an "effective manager" is needed?
    Nobody really answered for the tragedy at the state district power station, and he put his rake on it cool.
  40. seller trucks
    seller trucks April 23 2013 09: 50
    +4
    really wanted Anatoly Borisovich to move to the deserted house of Boris Abramovich as soon as possible
    1. Fornit
      Fornit April 24 2013 17: 13
      +1
      ... and it’s possible to directly hook up in the freezer (I think - more fairly) ... am
  41. unclevad
    unclevad April 23 2013 09: 52
    +2
    As soon as Chubais was assigned to nanotechnology, it immediately became clear that a BIG kirdyk would come to these very technologies in Russia. With him only such technologies (from the Internet): in the market an Armenian sells footwear under the sign "NANATEKHNOLOGIYA". They ask why? - "Listen, dear, my wife's name is Nana. She is a technologist. And I also sew shoes. So it turns out: Nana, the technologist and me." They say that the shoes were decent smile
  42. optimist
    optimist April 23 2013 09: 57
    +6
    Interesting: where is our "great and wise" guarantor looking? It looks like there are at least 2 options here: either the Washington "regional committee" does not give a redhead in offense, or the guarantor is "in share" ...
  43. El-bog
    El-bog April 23 2013 10: 02
    +5
    And who keeps them in power (brought) Chubais, Medvedev, Serdyukov, Kudrin ... Only they are bad chtoli, and that person, of course, is D'artagnan ...
  44. Uncle lee
    Uncle lee April 23 2013 10: 10
    14
    In Slavic mythology, a Chubais-pot-bellied red rat with a face like a human, a small malicious house spirit that threatens to turn off the light (RAO UES) makes various nasty things. Everything converges !!!
  45. DeerIvanovich
    DeerIvanovich April 23 2013 10: 20
    +2
    it’s not clear, of course, that it’s time to the highest degree of redhead selling ...
    but here’s a funny situation: I’ve already noticed many times that there are quite a few troll accounts, there are separate accounts that are engaged in arrogant anti-patriotic activities on the site, but for the most part troll accounts perform the task given above: now there’s one task to provoke people to revolution (according to the plans of the organizers: fall-winter), which should overthrow the current government, because they are no longer needed by their owners.
    on the basis of what such a conclusion is made?
    but on what basis:
    1. DeerIvanovich
      DeerIvanovich April 23 2013 10: 37
      +1
      fourthly, the company began to apply comprehensive pressure on ordinary people who do not care about the Internet and, in fact, cannot be affected through it. This is expressed, for example, in a sharp increase in tariffs: in some provincial towns, people manage to enter such percentages of increase that people go on an assault on the administration, about which there was already a story in news feeds or, for example, transport rates were increased. and this is only the beginning, there will be increases, and even unplanned
      fifthly, according to statistics for 2012-2013, militants were destroyed in the North. The Caucasus during the course of special operations is as much as in the last 5 years, why would it suddenly ... but in order to delay as many special forces as possible from the center.
      sixthly, already a blow to offshore in Cyprus.
    2. DeerIvanovich
      DeerIvanovich April 23 2013 10: 42
      +1
      the first three points are not published, it’s strange: the error supposedly contains a text that is forbidden for publication: although the system would write a message what word is prohibited!
      in brief, the first three points:
      taking advantage of the fact that the authorities somehow strangely relate to persons involved in landmark cases, troll accounts on this site, and on other Russian sites, are engaged in inducing visitors to these sites into protest moods, at the same time drawing historical analogies for example with the year 37, thereby hinting that there was sheer horror for the bandits, although in essence this is a significant exaggeration of the facts that took place. In general, they use a double purpose: to create a protest mood and create a myth in the minds of people about the year 37.
      1. Tverichanka
        Tverichanka April 24 2013 01: 54
        +2
        Quote: DeerIvanovich
        Useful purpose: create a protest mood

        You know, you are very right in many ways. I repeatedly paid attention to what you wrote about. It’s alarming.
        1. DeerIvanovich
          DeerIvanovich April 24 2013 13: 53
          0
          Yeah, alarming
  46. mamba
    mamba April 23 2013 10: 35
    +3
    as in the Pension Fund, which itself cannot fix the deficit holes in any way, they will tell pensioners why the funds have melted away - this is another matter.
    The stories of the Pension Fund officials are well known: "The Pension Fund has a budget deficit of several trillion rubles, and the state does not have the money to close this hole. Therefore, we cannot pay you a full pension. Regardless of the coefficient calculated by us, you will receive only half of the amount due to you. . All endure and you endure. "
    And at this time, the authorities are convincing us that the situation with the Pension Fund is completely open: http://www.rg.ru/2012/12/07/pension-dok.html
    Where is the money, Zin !!?
  47. Koshel2901
    Koshel2901 April 23 2013 10: 39
    +4
    With Chubik it is necessary to act as the Italians acted with Mussolini
  48. Manager
    Manager April 23 2013 10: 43
    +6
    Patriots are there to say.
  49. iliq
    iliq April 23 2013 10: 59
    +3
    So the most important innovation breakthrough breakthrough Skolkovo nanotechnologists forgot:
    -renaming police to policemen!
    But at once everything fell into place, the content began to correspond to the name!

    ps well, and this - from 500 of the suspects turn into witnesses ...
  50. IRBIS
    IRBIS April 23 2013 10: 59
    +1
    And their salaries are never "nano". It's high time this office was shaken up. And it should be shaken by parasite control specialists. And to treat "nanotechnologists" as with discovered worms. Well, first you need to give them an average salary, like those of hard workers in Russia. So there will be at least some profit.
    1. Atrix
      Atrix April 23 2013 11: 16
      +1
      Quote: IRBIS
      And their salaries are never "nano". It's high time this office was shaken up. And it should be shaken by parasite control specialists. And to treat "nanotechnologists" as with discovered worms. Well, first you need to give them an average salary, like those of hard workers in Russia. So there will be at least some profit.

      Listen, yes they are ready to work for free))) There you can cut so much money that they themselves are likely to pay money just to stay at the trough.