"German Stalingrad": the Breslau garrison fought to the death!

36 331 37
"German Stalingrad": the Breslau garrison fought to the death!
Silence on the Oder. The photograph shows a view from the Groschelbrücke bridge over the Oder River in the northern part of Breslau. May 1945.


General situation


In the final stages of the Great War, the defense of the Third Reich began to rely on “fortress cities” (festungs), which were supposed to tie down and delay the Red Army troops.



On July 25, 1944, Adolf Hitler declared the city of Breslau a fortress that had to be defended from all directions. The Führer appointed Karl Hanke, who was endowed with extraordinary powers and was the commander of the Volkssturm militia units stationed in Breslau, as the city's Gauleiter and commandant of the defense area.

The city, located in the rear and least subject to Allied bombing aviation, became the center of the evacuation of the military industry. Defense factories from other cities were moved here, workers were brought in. As a result, large warehouses of weapons, ammunition and food were located there.


A battery of Soviet 152mm ML-20 howitzer guns fires at German positions in Breslau.

The city was literally packed with German refugees who had been evacuated from the eastern regions of the Reich. Up to 1 million people had accumulated there. On January 19, 1945, Hanke ordered all the population unfit for military service to immediately leave Breslau, which had been declared under siege, and evacuate in the direction of Dresden. Trains and buses could not take such a huge number of refugees. The bulk of the refugees went on foot.

During the evacuation, which was not properly prepared, panic set in. It was a freezing time, and many thousands of old people, women and children died. January 21 was called "Black Sunday".

Despite the evacuation, up to 300 civilians remained in the city. According to various estimates, between 10 and 80 civilians died during the siege.

During the Vistula-Oder operation, troops (To Berlin!) of the 1st Ukrainian Front under the command of Konev entered the territory of Silesia, reached the Oder and the approaches to Breslau. Soviet troops fought to capture and expand bridgeheads on the western bank of the Oder in the areas of Steinau, Brig and Oppeln (The Death Blow to the Third Reich's War Economy).

On February 8, 1945, the 1st Ukrainian Front began the Lower Silesian Operation. Marshal I. S. Konev recalled:

“The main blow was planned to be struck from two large bridgeheads on the Oder - north and south of Breslau. As a result, the encirclement of this strongly fortified city was to follow, and then, taking it or leaving it in the rear, we expected to develop the offensive by the main group directly on Berlin. ”

On February 13, the mobile units attached to the 6th and 5th Guards armies, advancing towards each other, joined up west of Breslau. On the same day, having carried out a rapid maneuver, the corps of the 3rd Guards reached the Striegau area. tank armies. Counterattacks by German units that tried to maintain the corridor to Breslau were repelled. Soviet infantry quickly created a tight encirclement ring around Breslau.



Soviet forces


The encirclement of the fortress was completed on February 16, 1945 by the forces of the 6th Army under the command of General Vladimir Gluzdovsky and the 5th Guards Army under the command of General Alexei Zhadov. But already on February 18, the 5th Guards Army went to the outer ring of encirclement in the Berlin direction, and until the end of the siege it was led by units of the 6th Army: the 22nd and 74th Rifle Corps, the 7th Fortified Region, an engineer brigade, and two flamethrower battalions.

Additional artillery, including heavy (siege), there were no tanks or self-propelled guns. Therefore, the Germans repelled the first attacks quite easily.

Later, the army was reinforced by the 349th Guards Heavy Self-Propelled Artillery, 87th Guards Heavy Tank (from March) and 222nd Tank Regiments.

The air blockade of the fortress was carried out by the 71st Anti-Aircraft Division and the 173rd Fighter Aviation Regiment from the 56th Fighter Aviation Division. From March 10, 1945, the 10th Corps was connected to the blockade. Defense.


Machine gunners of the 1st Ukrainian Front during the battles in Breslau. March 1945

German defense


The city was defended by the Breslau corps group (according to various estimates, from 50 to 80 thousand people, including up to 30 thousand militiamen). The military commandant of the city was initially Major General Hans von Alphen, and from March - General of the Infantry Hermann Niehoff.

Political power in the fortified area was retained by Gauleiter Karl Hanke, who was endowed with dictatorial powers. He shot and hanged everyone who wanted to leave the city without the Fuhrer's order. Thus, on January 28, the second mayor of Breslau, Spielhaten, was executed by order of the Gauleiter.


Mayor of Breslau Wolfgang Spielhagen (1891–1945). Member of the NSDAP, in 1940 he served as the acting head of the city administration of Breslau, and from 1941 he was the 2nd mayor (deputy chief mayor) of Breslau. According to eyewitnesses, in January 1945 he proposed to the Gauleiter of Lower Silesia and commandant of the "fortress city of Breslau" Hanke to declare Breslau a free city due to the futility of resistance. On 27.01.1945 January XNUMX he was shot on Hanke's orders, and his body was thrown into the Oder.

Soviet war correspondent Viktor Shilkin noted:

"The SS men, led by Hitler's Gauleiter Hanke and the garrison commander, the fortress commandant General von Nihoff, established a bloody regime in the city. In the garrison, there were two SS men for every squad of soldiers. The SS men shot anyone who avoided battle or defensive work. Not only deserters or soldiers who tried to go into captivity were shot, but also their families."

The garrison and the remaining inhabitants of the city were convinced that their job was to hold out at this strategic point until the Wehrmacht launched a counteroffensive and liberated them. There was a belief that the troops of Army Group Center, located southwest of Breslau, would break through the encirclement. Also, at first, the soldiers and citizens believed in the appearance of a “miracle-weapons", which would save the Reich, and the success of the offensive in Silesia and Pomerania. Rumors were spreading about the imminent collapse of the anti-Hitler coalition, a conflict between the Western powers and the USSR.

In addition, the front had stabilized relatively close to the city, and artillery cannonade could be heard from there, which for a long time supported the garrison’s hopes for the imminent arrival of help.


German soldiers, father and son, both Iron Cross recipients, take up positions on the outskirts of Breslau (now Wroclaw, Poland). They are likely from the Fortress Regiment Wehl, formed from Luftwaffe ground personnel. They are armed with Sturmgewehr 44 assault rifles. February 1945.

The city had enough food for a long siege. The situation with ammunition was worse. But it was delivered via an organized "air bridge". The planes landed at the Gandau airfield. Also, during the siege, small units of paratroopers were airlifted into the city and the wounded were evacuated. Thus, on February 25, units of the 1st battalion of the 26th parachute regiment were airlifted, and on March 6, a battalion of the special purpose parachute regiment.

The Gandau airfield was under constant threat of capture. Therefore, Hanke decided to build a new airfield in the city center along one of the main streets of the city – Kaiserstrasse. To do this, it was necessary to remove all the lighting masts, wires, cut down trees, uproot stumps and even demolish dozens of buildings (to expand the runway) for almost one and a half kilometers. There were not enough sappers to clear the territory of the internal airfield, so the civilian population had to be involved.

At first, Soviet intelligence underestimated the enemy, believing that separate units of the 20th Tank Division, the 236th Assault Gun Brigade, a combined tank company, artillery and anti-aircraft units, and 38 Volkssturm battalions (about 15 thousand people) were located in the city.

The Breslau garrison began to form only in early 1945, when the Russians broke through the German defenses on the Vistula line. On January 26, the 609th Special Purpose Division was formed (consisting of three infantry, an artillery regiment, and a tank company), and the active formation of Volkssturm battalions began. By the beginning of the defense, the 269th Infantry Division was in the city, but it mostly managed to leave Breslau before it was encircled. Five fortress regiments and an artillery fortress regiment (2 divisions and 6 fortress batteries) were formed from various and training units, Air Force, and SS units.


Gauleiter of Lower Silesia Karl Hanke inspects the Raketenwerfer 43 mounted grenade launchers

At the same time, the Breslau fortress had a large combat-ready reserve that could be used to reinforce the front lines. It consisted of much less combat-ready Volkssturm militiamen, workers from military factories and enterprises, as well as members of National Socialist structures and organizations fit for military service.

The main forces of the German garrison were concentrated in the southern and western areas. The southeastern, eastern and northern parts of the city were covered by natural barriers: the Weide River, the canals of the Oder River, the Ole River with wide floodplains. In the north, the terrain was swampy, which did not allow the use of heavy weapons.

The Nazis created a strong defense. Numerous stone buildings, gardens and parks allowed for the covert placement of fire weapons and their camouflage. The roads were blocked in advance with heaps of stones and logs, barricades and ditches, mined, as were the approaches to them, and were shot at. At the same time, the city itself and its suburbs had a network of good roads, which allowed the Germans to quickly transfer their tanks, assault guns and artillery to the dangerous area.

The armored vehicles were in the commandant's reserve (up to 50 units), and they were used in small groups (1-2 tanks, 1-3 self-propelled guns) in active areas to support the infantry.


A column of German troops enters Breslau. Ahead of the tractor, the Sd.Kfz 10 tows a 75-mm anti-tank gun PaK 40. The German units are preparing for the defense of Breslau, which is declared a fortified city. February 1945

Assault


On February 18, 1945, the 6th Guards Heavy Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment (349 ISU-8) was transferred to Gluzdovsky's 152th Combined Arms Army. Each rifle regiment allocated an assault group (combined battalion) for combat operations in the city. Assault battalions of the 62nd Separate Engineer-Sapper Brigade, whose fighters were trained for urban combat and the capture of long-term fortifications, were also involved in the assault. The personnel of these units were armed with protective armor, ROKS flamethrowers (Klyuev-Sergeev backpack flamethrower), portable launchers for rockets, captured Faustpatrones and explosives.

The assault groups' combat operations lasted from February 18 to May 1, 1945 (in anticipation of the enemy's complete capitulation, the troops blocking Breslau ended their offensive operations). Due to a shortage of forces, the Soviet troops mainly operated in the western and southern parts of the fortified area. The offensive was uneven: sometimes there was an intensification, sometimes a pause. During the pause, reconnaissance, regrouping and replenishment of forces, delivery of ammunition, and targeting of a new quarter were carried out.


Soldiers of the 1st Ukrainian Front in battle on the streets of Breslau

The first assault (there had been separate attacks before) began on the night of February 22, 1945, in the southern part of Breslau. After the artillery preparation, the batteries began to accompany the assault groups. The self-propelled guns moved behind the main forces of the assault groups at a distance of 100-150 meters along the streets from south to north. At the request of the infantry, they hit the enemy's firing points. The self-propelled guns moved at some distance from each other, pressing against the walls of houses, supporting their neighbors with fire. Periodically, the self-propelled guns conducted harassing and aimed fire at the upper floors of houses to support the actions of the infantry and sappers, who were clearing a path through the rubble and barricades. Unfortunately, there were also mistakes, for example, two vehicles broke ahead of the infantry and were knocked out by Faustniks.

Soviet sappers actively used directed explosions, using water supply manhole covers as reflectors. Then, they directed fiery streams from flamethrowers into the breaches made in the barricades and walls of buildings.

To destroy obstacles and make passages in minefields, the craftsmen from the 42nd Mechanized Engineering Brigade set up a home-made production of so-called “sapper torpedoes” from captured aerial bombs – 100-kilogram “cigars” made of molten TNT, the basis of which were rockets.

Our troops encountered fierce resistance, and the Nazis repelled the first assault aimed at the city center.


German soldiers inspect a Soviet T-34-85 tank, destroyed on a street in Breslau. February - March 1945.


The crew of the Soviet 76-mm divisional gun ZiS-3 of Sergeant S. I. Golub at the firing line in Breslau.

New attacks


In early March, the 6th Army was reinforced by the 222nd Separate Tank Regiment (5 T-34, 2 IS-2, 1 ISU-122 and 4 SU-122) and the 87th Guards Heavy Tank Regiment (11 IS-2). The 349th Guards Heavy Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment was significantly reinforced (29 ISU-152). This strengthened the assault forces, and the fighting resumed with renewed vigor.

As before, tanks and self-propelled guns moved behind the infantry, acting as mobile firing points. The infantry line was usually marked with green or white rocket, red - indicated the direction of fire. Tanks or self-propelled guns made several shots, and the shooters went on the attack under cover of smoke and dust, taking advantage of the fact that the enemy's firing point was suppressed or the Nazis hid in shelters under fire. Soldiers burst into the building, actively using grenades.

Some buildings were destroyed by direct fire, and brick fences and metal barriers were destroyed by cannon fire. To avoid losses, tanks and self-propelled guns changed their firing positions only after the houses, floors, attics and basements had been completely cleared. Sometimes heavy tanks and self-propelled guns were used as battering rams, making passages in fences and barricades.


Tank IS-2 No. 537 of Lieutenant B. I. Degtyarev from the 222nd separate tank Ropshinsky Red Banner Order of Kutuzov III degree regiment, knocked out at Striegauerplatz in the German city of Breslau.

In the best traditions of Russian ingenuity, tank crews used river anchors to pull apart rubble and barricades. A tank or self-propelled gun approached the rubble under cover of fire from another vehicle, sappers hooked the anchor onto logs, beams and other objects in the rubble, the armored vehicle reversed and pulled apart the obstacle. Sometimes, tank landing forces were used. One tank or self-propelled gun fired at the object, while another with landing forces on board moved at high speed toward the building, stopping at a window or door. The landing forces broke into the building and began close combat. The armored vehicle retreated to its original positions.

However, these forces were not enough to make a decisive turn in the battle for Breslau. In March, there was only a small success in the center, where our assault groups managed to advance from Hindenburg Square in the north direction by four blocks, in other areas only by 1-2 blocks.

The Germans believed that the city would be saved, they just had to hold out. The battles were extremely stubborn. The Germans fought desperately and skillfully, defending every house, floor, basement or attic. The battles were especially fierce on the approaches to the airfield, in the industrial zone of the city.

When retreating, German units blew up and set fire to houses and buildings to delay the enemy. They destroyed tunnels and sewers, all underground communications, so that the Russians could not use them in the underground war. The Nazis used "land torpedoes" - remote-controlled tankettes of the "Goliath" type. As the city was destroyed, Breslau turned into a "German Stalingrad" - a pile of ruins.

The German "tactics of destruction" turned out to be quite effective. After destroying one line of defense, the Nazis retreated into entire houses and buildings, creating a new line of defense. Soviet units that tried to get through the ruins found themselves in the line of fire. The Germans mined the remaining buildings, set local and continuous fires that had to be bypassed. Wasting time and resources.


Fighting on a railway track near Breslau. 1st Ukrainian Front. A soldier holds a DP-27 light machine gun.

The Chief of Staff of the 22nd Corps, Colonel A. Chichin, wrote about the enemy’s tenacity in his personal diary, saying that the enemy was resisting to the death. On March 27, he noted:

"There is no success. Reasons: little infantry, no cooperation with aviation, no artillery can take the basements, and there is no opportunity to use it in street battles. The Germans are strong with panzerfausts and basements. They are fighting to the death...".

Entry from April 10:

"I will tell posterity how we took Breslau, how we fought with the Volkssturm: until you blow up a basement, an apartment, an entrance or an entire house, these Volkssturm fight to the death. Behind them - behind their backs - are the SS."

They tried to use the 87th Guards Heavy Tank Regiment in the northern sector, but it was unsuccessful. The sappers were unable to clear all the road blockages in time, and when the heavy tanks moved off-road, they got stuck in the swampy terrain and became easy prey for the enemy. After this failure, no more active actions were conducted in the northern direction.


A group of German soldiers during a break in fighting in the suburbs of Breslau. The corporals in the center and on the right are armed with a Gewehr 43 (G 43) self-loading rifle.


Soviet machine gunners and a Maxim machine gun crew on Neukircherstrasse in Breslau. March 1945.

"Easter battle"


The assault on the city took on a positional character. Our troops recaptured the enemy house by house, block by block, slowly "biting" into the depths of the city. But the German garrison also showed persistence and ingenuity, and fought back fiercely.

The commander of the engineer battalion of the 609th division, Captain Rother, recalled:

"The streets between the German and Russian positions were littered with rubble, broken bricks and tiles. So we came up with the idea of ​​laying mines disguised as rubble. To do this, we covered the wooden bodies of anti-personnel mines with drying oil and then sprinkled them with red and yellowish-white brick dust, so that they were indistinguishable from brick. Mines prepared in this way were indistinguishable from a distance of three meters from the brick. At night, they were laid with fishing rods from windows, basement hatches and balconies or from the ruins of houses, unnoticed by the enemy. Thus, a few days later, a barrier of 609 such anti-personnel mines disguised as bricks was installed in front of the 5th engineer battalion."

In April 1945, the main fighting took place in the southern and western parts of Breslau. On April 1, Easter Sunday, Soviet aviation and artillery launched powerful strikes on the city. City blocks went up in flames, buildings collapsed one after another. Under a curtain of fire and smoke, Soviet tanks and self-propelled guns launched a new attack. The "Easter battle" had begun.


German machine gunners fire from a window of a building during fighting in Breslau. April 1945.

Armored vehicles punched holes in the weakening enemy defense, flamethrowers destroyed pillboxes and bunkers, concentrated artillery fire from close range swept away everything alive. The German defense was broken through, our troops captured the main "artery" of the fortress - the Gandau airfield. Breslau was completely cut off from the Reich, since the "internal airfield" on Kaiserstrasse was unsuitable for landing large aircraft that brought weapons and ammunition, and took away the wounded and sick. It became obvious that the fortress's position was hopeless. But the military-political command of the fortress city did not respond to calls for surrender.

The battle continued in the following days. The main battles were fought in the western part of the city-fortress, so all tank and self-propelled regiments were subordinated to the commander of the 74th Rifle Corps, Major General Vorozhishchev. Armored vehicles supported the actions of the 112th, 135th, 181st, 294th, 309th and 359th Rifle Divisions.

On April 3, the 6th Guards Heavy Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment was transferred to the 374th Army. The self-propelled gunners were tasked with reaching the right bank of the Oder River in cooperation with the 294th Division.

By April 15, despite strong enemy resistance, the task was partially completed. From April 18, the SPG regiment performed the same task, but now supported the offensive of the 112th Division. In the battle on April 18, the 374th SPG regiment lost 13 ISU-152 out of 15. The Germans were able to disperse and destroy the landing force (50 people), the rest of the infantry of the assault detachment was cut off, and the Faustniks burned the SPG. Later, the self-propelled guns of the 374th regiment helped our assault troops take several blocks.


Soviet ISU-122 self-propelled gun, destroyed during the fighting in Breslau. March - April 1945.


Artillerymen of one of the rifle divisions of the 6th Army fire 45-mm 53-K guns at an enemy stronghold on Gutenbergstrasse in the city of Breslau. April 1945.

On April 30, 1945, our troops stopped the offensive, waiting for Germany to capitulate. Breslau did not surrender even after Berlin capitulated on May 2, 1945 (The Fall of Berlin: "We finished him off!"). On May 4, the townspeople, through the priests, suggested to Commandant Niehoff that they lay down their arms to stop the suffering of the people. The suffering of the civilian population had become unbearable. The general gave no answer.

On May 5, Gauleiter Hanke announced in the city newspaper (its last issue) that surrender was prohibited under penalty of death. Hanke himself escaped by plane on the evening of May 5. He landed in Prague, where he joined SS units that were trying to break through to the west and surrender to the Americans. He was captured by Czech partisans south of Chomutov and placed in a prisoner of war camp. In June 1945, while a group of German prisoners attempted to escape, he was probably killed by Czech guards.

After Hanke's escape, General Niehoff entered into negotiations with Army Commander Gluzdovsky on the issue of the honorable surrender of the fortress. The Soviet side guaranteed life, food, the safety of personal property and awards, the return to the homeland after the end of the war; medical care for the wounded and sick, safety and normal living conditions for the entire civilian population.

May 6, 1945 Breslau capitulated. By the evening of the same day, all German troops were disarmed, our units occupied all quarters. On May 7, 1945, gratitude was declared to the troops who took Breslau, and in Moscow salute was given by 20 artillery volleys of 224 guns.

The German garrison lost about 30 people killed and wounded, and more than 45 were taken prisoner. Several thousand more wounded were taken away by plane. The trophies included 559 guns, 534 mortars, 36 tanks, and about 7000 vehicles of all types. The Soviet total losses were more than 31 people.


Senior Sergeant I. Kireev fires a captured German Faustpatrone grenade launcher during a night battle in the city of Breslau.


Soviet ISU-152 self-propelled guns on the street Breslau (now Wroclaw in Poland). With a high degree of probability, the ISU-152 in the photo is from the 349th Guards Heavy Self-Propelled Regiment (regiment commander Lieutenant Colonel Nikolai Shishov).

The meaning of the "miracle of Breslau"


The defense of Breslau was exploited by Goebbels's office, who compared the battle to the Battle of Aachen during the Napoleonic Wars. The "Miracle of Breslau" became a symbol of national resilience. The German garrison fought for almost three months, held most of the city until the end of the war, and surrendered only after the capitulation of the entire Reich.

Thus, the German military historian Kurt Tippelskirch noted that the defense of Breslau became “one of the most glorious pages in stories the German people. "

However, he also noted that the defense of Breslau had strategic significance only in the first phase of the Red Army's winter offensive of 1945, that is, in January and the first half of February 1945. At that time, the Breslau fortified region attracted part of the forces of the 1st Ukrainian Front, which made it easier for the German command to create a new line of defense from Lower Silesia to the Sudetenland. After February, the defense of the fortress no longer had military significance; several Soviet divisions besieging Breslau did not reduce the forces of the Red Army.

That is, Breslau could have capitulated without damage to the Wehrmacht already at the end of February - beginning of March 1945. But the political significance of the defense of the fortress city (propaganda) had more weight than the military one.


An assault group of sappers led by squad leader Senior Sergeant Vasily Mozgovoy from the 58th Engineer-Sapper Battalion of the 62nd Engineer-Sapper Nikopol Red Banner Brigade crawls and drags boxes of explosives to blow up a house that the enemy has turned into a fortified point.

Why the Red Army was unable to storm Breslau


The answer is simple. The front command almost immediately withdrew all forces from this area, except for the rather weak 6th combined arms army of Gluzdovsky. The 6th army conducted the siege mainly with its own forces (two rifle corps - 7 rifle divisions, 1 fortified area), without additional artillery and tank forces. Its forces were too few for a full-fledged assault from several directions, which would have definitely led to the fall of the fortress. The Germans could maneuver their forces, transfer reserves to one dangerous direction.

At the same time, the Soviet command initially greatly underestimated the size of the enemy garrison. At the beginning of the siege, its numbers were estimated at only 18 fighters (not counting the militia), but as the siege dragged on, the estimate of its numbers increased first to 30 people, then to 45 people.

Thus, the number of troops in the 6th Army was initially smaller than the German garrison (essentially, an entire army), and there was not enough artillery, tanks, and aircraft, which were used in other, more important areas.


Soviet soldiers fire from a PTRS-41 (Simonov anti-tank rifle model 1941) on Welfstrasse in Breslau. Author's title: "PTSR sergeants L. Myasnikov and A. Kryukov fire."


Soviet ISU-152 self-propelled gun from the 349th Guards Heavy Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment and T-34-76 tank from the 222nd Separate Tank Regiment in battle on Breslau Street

They also underestimated the strength of the enemy fortifications: powerful stone walls of residential and industrial buildings, which, in essence, became separate fortresses; long underground communications, including railway lines, where bomb shelters, bunkers and warehouses were equipped. Large-scale underground communications allowed maneuvering forces between city blocks and districts, transferring not only infantry, but also artillery. Numerous factories, enterprises, railway junctions were turned into strongholds, resistance centers. The ring railway lines with their high embankments were an impregnable obstacle for our tanks, were good positions for German units. Main highways and roads were also prepared for defense, bridges were mined.

Also among the objective reasons for the long defense of the city were the geographical features of the location of the large city. It was covered on both sides by natural barriers that interfered with the actions of mechanized units.

It should not be forgotten that the Germans were still a strong and skillful enemy. Good knowledge of the terrain, flexible maneuvering of reserves in dangerous directions, and competent use of artillery significantly slowed down the advance of Soviet assault troops into the city center. A successful solution was to move the resistance line inside the city blocks (the so-called "Niehof Line"), which reduced the effectiveness of the Soviet assault groups.

The Soviet High Command was busy with larger tasks: Königsberg, Pomerania, Berlin, western Hungary, Vienna. Breslau no longer had any particular military significance. The fortress was doomed, and its fall was only inevitable. Therefore, no special efforts were made to capture Breslau.


A column of German prisoners of war on the march to Breslau
37 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +4
    7 May 2025 05: 55
    Breslau no longer had any particular military significance. The fortress was doomed, and its fall was only inevitable.

    Why then burn resources and people on it? Surround, blockade and wait for capitulation.
    1. -3
      7 May 2025 07: 40
      Quote: Puncher
      Why then burn resources and people on it? Surround, block and wait for capitulation

      True. The same situation with the Courland cauldron - endless assaults by the enemy, firmly blocked on the peninsula.

      There was no military necessity for storming the encircled and blockaded Danzig and Pillau.
      1. +14
        7 May 2025 07: 48
        To call Breslau the German Stalingrad is to insult Stalingrad: the entire might of the Reich was directed at Stalingrad, this was the decisive battle of the war, and only a weakened army was directed at Breslau. Breslau meant nothing.
        1. +2
          7 May 2025 08: 54
          I agree, the scale of what is happening is very different. And Stalingrad was not surrendered!
          1. 0
            11 May 2025 14: 34
            Samsonov did not delve into the details and did not read the memoirs of the fascists.
            What really happened there?

            Robbery, drinking and executions. Breslau 1945

            “By the end of March, the differences in the situation of people became obvious. While some were dying of wounds in crowded hospitals, others started drinking every weekend. While some fought fierce street battles day after day, others did not intend to deny themselves the joys life.
            Officially, the presence of women in military units was prohibited, but this did not stop some officers from visiting neighboring houses. The more hopeless the situation in Breslau became, the more clearly signs of decay appeared among the army.
            Erich Schönfelder, an officer who was constantly on the front line among the soldiers, described the situation in those days: “The feeling that life was ending forced many to try to take everything from it in the last days or weeks. As a rule, consolation was found in women and wine. Formal orgies became a widespread phenomenon. The number of robberies of abandoned apartments grew day by day.
            Not only deserters, but also civilians became robbers. The next morning, many were dragged out of the stinking basements to the formation with very young girls. These were lost youth. But who could blame them?
            This is the appearance and decay. Compare with those Nazis that are now. One to one.
      2. +7
        7 May 2025 16: 00
        Quote: Olgovich
        The same situation with the Courland cauldron - endless assaults by the enemy,

        My grandfather died there. He fought in 1941...
      3. The comment was deleted.
    2. -1
      7 May 2025 12: 14
      Quote: Puncher
      expect capitulation.

      It is dangerous to wait, the new administration in Washington could come to its senses and reconsider its relationship with Uncle Joe, but thank God it continued to be in a vegetable state until the Berlin blockade.
    3. +2
      7 May 2025 19: 06
      I completely agree! The same with the Reichstag. Why was it necessary to storm it? Bomb it to rubble and that's it. Thousands of lives of Soviet soldiers would have been saved!
      1. 0
        8 May 2025 09: 55
        Quote: solovyov-igor
        Same with the Reichstag. Why was it necessary to storm it? Bomb it to rubble and that's it. Thousands of lives of Soviet soldiers would have been saved!

        Also from Berlin
  2. +1
    7 May 2025 06: 22
    Why the Red Army was unable to storm Breslau

    The answer is simple.
    This is not simple at all. A set of standard formulations about the lack of forces and resources, etc. And of course, this.
    The situation with ammunition was worse. But they were delivered via an organized "air bridge". The planes landed at the Gandau airfield. Also, small units of paratroopers were airlifted into the city during the siege, and the wounded were evacuated. Thus, on February 25, units of the 1st battalion of the 26th parachute regiment were airlifted, and on March 6, a battalion of the special purpose parachute regiment.
    Outside not '42, and not even '44, '45 and the question is, Where is our Air Force? Where are the fighters? Why didn't they organize a blockade of the city from the air? In order to deliver reinforcements to the encircled city, it was necessary to use transport aircraft, this is the Yu-52, which at that time was already an anachronism, and gliders are not pulled by jet fighters. Interesting explanations from our air defense forces.
    The commander, who had extensive experience in airborne operations, set up an air bridge to supply it. Luftwaffe aircraft delivered cargo gliders to the encircled forces at night, and dropped equipment and ammunition by parachute. They broke through to the city from different sides, and the anti-aircraft artillery could not close all approaches and organize a reliable barrier. By this time, the 56th Division was taken over by Guards Colonel B. V. Bitsky. He achieved the division's participation in blocking the encircled group from the air. For this purpose, the 173rd Airborne Division was transferred to the Rudniki airfield near Czestochowa, and two radar posts were deployed 3 and 15 km north and west of the city to control the airspace around Breslau. In ten days, the regiment carried out 65 patrol flights, during which two landing gliders were shot down. To strengthen the air blockade, the 45th Aviation Division flew over to the Sroda airfield in the Czestochowa area.

    During a month and a half of combat operations in the Breslau area, the regiments carried out a total of 246 sorties. In 68 of them, the pilots managed to detect the target (11 times by guidance from the ground with subsequent use of the Gneiss-2, 8 times by free search with the help of the onboard radar, in 15 cases - in the beams of searchlights, and the rest - visually in natural light). The fighters conducted 13 air battles, in which the crew of Captain Kaznov shot down two He-111s, and Lieutenant Shesterikov - a landing glider.
    Yes, the successes were not impressive, so-so. But the airfield is in the city, they could have easily rolled it out with artillery, but what can you do, on May 5th Hanke himself flew away from it. This is probably the main reason for the protracted siege.
    1. +1
      7 May 2025 08: 21
      Quote: Unknown
      But the airfield in the city could have been easily destroyed by artillery, but on May 5th Hanke himself flew away from it. That was probably the main reason for the protracted siege.

      How could an airport help a 45-strong group? They need several trains of shells a day.
      45 thousand is the number of the Sevastopol garrison at the end of the siege. This is extremely large. It takes time to break that many people.
      And it is not entirely clear who was pinning down whom. 45 thousand rabid Nazis on another section of the front could have created much more problems.
      At the very beginning of the SVO, they were distracted by the assault on Mariupol and lost momentum.
    2. BAI
      +1
      7 May 2025 09: 21
      45 and the question is, where is our Air Force? Where are the fighters?

      The same question. It only remains to remember that in these parts in February - March 1945 the Panfilov DIVISION was surrounded. 300 people remained from it, the division was disbanded. And this was at the end of the war.
      1. Fat
        +4
        7 May 2025 09: 59
        Quote: BAI
        It only remains to remember that in these parts in February - March 1945 the Panfilov DIVISION was surrounded, of which only 300 people remained

        The 8th Guards Rifle Division fought and was surrounded in March-April 1945 in Courland. This is the Baltics, or more precisely Latvia. request
        1. 0
          11 May 2025 14: 38
          Friedrich Gieriger recalled these events: “The spirit of the population was completely undermined by two explosions. On March 30, the premises of the party cells in Gneisenau and Elbing were blown up. Everything was done according to the model on July 20.
          Briefcases filled with explosives were planted in them. The attackers themselves were able to escape unnoticed from these buildings. One can only guess what was the reason for these actions. Maybe it was revenge for the unceremonious treatment of women and children who were building the runway at constant risk to their lives...
          Judging by the identity of the explosions, the attackers were related to each other. All those who worked at party headquarters died... The serf newspaper and radio kept silent about these events, although rumors about them began to spread at the speed of light.
          So we learned that, despite all the vigilance of the Gestapo, in the surrounded city there were not only resistance groups, but active ones.
          In addition, a certain internal resistance was felt among the desperate population. People were dissatisfied with the dictates of party officials, and therefore these attacks did not necessarily have to be the actions of communists.
          In the Kleschau Strasse prison, the number of people executed “for defeatism” increases every day. Death has reaped a good harvest."
    3. -1
      11 May 2025 14: 37
      There were successes.
      Look at the memories of the besieged

      At the end of March 1945, Paul Peikert wrote in his diary: “Decisive events are taking place on all fronts. Königsberg has fallen. Danzig has been taken by the Russians. From the territory of Hungary they are approaching Vienna...
      Styria is in a critical situation. All territories west of the Rhine, from Emmerich to Mannheim, are controlled by the Americans and the British. Their tanks are rapidly approaching Würzburg and Nuremberg... Most of the territory of the Ruhr is also in their hands."
      Such information increased the feeling of hopelessness of the Breslau situation. The hopes that were still glimmering at the beginning of March that the city would finally be unblocked completely disappeared by the end of the month. It was difficult to hide the obvious lack of ammunition.
      Hugo Ertung wrote in those days: “Soldiers from the reserve units often do not even have a pistol in their weapons. There is no need to talk about rifles.”
      At about the same time, Ertung wrote: "In the reports from the front, the wounded, apparently for some stupid conspiracy, are called "mulattos", and the dead - "Indians". Their number is steadily increasing every day, and therefore it is difficult to establish which forces are actually holding the city."
      Population dissatisfaction reached such a high level that on March 26, unknown persons set fire to the Haase brewery, which supplied soldiers and officers. This was followed by several actions that were somewhat reminiscent of the assassination attempt on Hitler, which was carried out on July 20, 1944. Two headquarters of local NSDAP bodies were blown up.

      Source
      https://oper-1974.livejournal.com/977438.html
  3. +2
    7 May 2025 06: 43
    I'll give you a seditious thought:
    Exactly the same thing should have been done with Breslau and Königsberg. They were smart enough not to lay down people after the unsuccessful storming of Courland!
    And it is also extremely offensive that Breslau was given to the Poles practically "for free". Meanwhile, there was an opportunity to significantly thin out both the defending Germans and the Poles, throwing them into a "meat assault". In general, our losses in Poland were mainly in the battles in Silesia and Pomerania. Well, and in East Prussia, of course, two-thirds of which were given to Poland.
    Happy Holiday!
    1. 0
      7 May 2025 16: 08
      What happened to the German civilian population after Breslau was given to the Poles?
      1. +1
        7 May 2025 18: 14
        The Poles made a big deal.
        Mostly old people. Women and children - they fled in what they had.
    2. +1
      8 May 2025 09: 59
      Quote: Victor Leningradets
      I'll give you a seditious thought:
      Exactly the same thing should have been done with Breslau and Königsberg

      The idea is clear, I agree. But Breslau was constantly being stormed. As was Courland...
  4. +3
    7 May 2025 07: 40
    Apparently, our fighters did not avoid serious losses. This, in my opinion, can be judged by indirect data. Vorozheikin, twice Hero of the Soviet Union, who fought in the 272nd regiment throughout the war, was by this time forced to leave for Moscow to take the position of inspector. He writes with resentment that he was very unfriendly, after leave due to injury, by the regiment commander Vasilyaka, who accused him to his face of undermining and trying to take the place. The position of squadron commander was occupied. Vorozheikin's students, including Lazarev, became squadron commanders. Vasilyaka and Lazarev died near Breslau on May 1 and 4, not living to see victory for several days.
  5. +1
    7 May 2025 08: 32
    The defense of Breslau, an example of good leadership.
    .
    "...In the garrison, there were two SS men for every squad of soldiers. The SS men shot everyone who avoided fighting or defensive work. Not only deserters or soldiers who tried to go into captivity were shot, but also their families..."

    The Ukrainians are acting in the same way and their troops are showing great resilience.
  6. BAI
    +2
    7 May 2025 09: 16
    But they were delivered via an organized "air bridge." The planes landed at the Gandau airfield.

    Even in 1945, the Germans were able to organize air supply for the encircled group
  7. -3
    7 May 2025 10: 31
    The stupidity of the generals is astounding. Why spend almost 4 months storming a city that is surrounded and cut off from supplies? am
    1. +2
      10 May 2025 18: 24
      Glory to the armchair strategists and prominent military leaders of the pen and keyboard. Follow the right path. Then they stormed so that the war would end.
  8. -3
    7 May 2025 10: 53
    In the garrison, there were two SS men for every squad of soldiers. The SS men shot anyone who avoided fighting or defensive work. Not only deserters or soldiers who tried to go into captivity were shot, but also their families."
    looks like an example of ridiculous Soviet propaganda.
    Which was later mirrored in post-perestroika anti-Soviet propaganda about the NKVD barrage detachments supporting rifle regiments with friendly fire in the back, and about the repressions against the families of Red Army soldiers who surrendered.
    1. +2
      10 May 2025 18: 21
      And what propaganda is correct, Dr. Goebbels, in your opinion, if Soviet propaganda is absurd.
      1. -1
        11 May 2025 10: 57
        Our most correct one, as the famous song goes:
        "Our honesty is known to all,
        If not, then to hell with it
        !"
        laughing
  9. +3
    7 May 2025 11: 19
    Isn't the title of the article too grandiose? Breslau to Stalingrad is like Singapore sideways. I am grateful to the author for "working through" the details of the battles, but to call it a second Stalingrad is a disgrace.
  10. +2
    7 May 2025 13: 46
    That is, Breslau could have capitulated without damage to the Wehrmacht already at the end of February – beginning of March 1945.

    It is impossible to capitulate without damage if the Wehrmacht is still fighting. The troops that besieged the fortresses can then be used elsewhere.
  11. +1
    7 May 2025 19: 12
    I apologize for the error. The commander of the 728th IAP, Lieutenant Colonel Vladimir Stepanovich Vasilyaka (9 shot down personally and in a group) died from air defense fire near Breslau on May 05,05,1945, XNUMX.
  12. 0
    8 May 2025 07: 42
    Many thanks to the author! good
    Very interesting, I didn’t even know about the storming of Breslau.
    This is the article! My respects!
    1. 0
      8 May 2025 08: 07
      TacticMedia has a great video on YouTube by Isaev about the storming of Breslau. And there the storming of the city is laid out on the shelves.
  13. -1
    8 May 2025 08: 46
    And what, did the fascists take Stalingrad? Is the author a provocateur?
  14. 0
    8 May 2025 17: 48
    Quote: Olgovich
    Quote: Puncher
    Why then burn resources and people on it? Surround, block and wait for capitulation

    True. The same situation with the Courland cauldron - endless assaults by the enemy, firmly blocked on the peninsula.

    There was no military necessity for storming the encircled and blockaded Danzig and Pillau.

    To block means to keep significant forces near these fortresses. At least three times superior to the enemy. There are several hundred thousand people here and there + equipment. And experienced ones must be left. But where to get people for further advancement? Experienced soldiers and officers were needed in all directions. Yes, people will die during the assault, but at least there will be no splinters in the rear...
  15. -1
    8 May 2025 19: 54
    Why did they storm a city that had been fortified in advance? To block it, call in air force heavy bombs and quarter by quarter transform the fortress city into a pile of rubble.
    Any German who wanted to surrender would have left the city (if he could...) - the Red Army would have taken him prisoner as expected - if he stayed in the fortifications - your German problems.
  16. +1
    8 May 2025 23: 43
    The overall picture: Marshal Konev's First Ukrainian Front, besieging Breslau with one, albeit weakened, army, nevertheless played a very important, and perhaps even decisive role in the storming of Berlin (and, accordingly, the capitulation of Germany), and when Hanka fled to Prague, a spontaneous uprising of the Czechs broke out there and Konev, before the appointed time, began an offensive to help the rebels. And he liberated Prague (after Victory Day).
    So, Breslau, of course, tied down some forces of the 1st Ukrainian, but, as it turned out, we surrounded no lesser forces there.
    Which could have made life very difficult for us during the storming of Berlin, or even Prague.
    But it was already too late to play the role of a “heroic example” after Germany’s capitulation.
  17. Eug
    0
    12 May 2025 06: 29
    Am I the only one who sees a possible parallel between Breslau (Wroclaw) and Kharkov?