The Return of the Paddle Wheel

42
The Return of the Paddle Wheel

Many believe that the paddle wheel began to be used as a ship's propulsion device at the same time as the steamship appeared, and the first paddle ship to make regular trips was the steamship "Clermont" (USA, 1807). The propeller was not even discussed then - its working versions appeared only in the second half of the 30s of the 19th century.
However, the first mentions of a paddle wheel driven by human or animal muscle power date back to ancient times. A Roman bas-relief dating back to the 6th century BC depicts a vessel with three pairs of paddle wheels driven by oxen.


A paddle-wheel vessel with an ox drive (from an ancient Roman bas-relief)

According to a number of manuscripts, in 1161 a junk equipped with paddle wheels powered by a windmill was built in China. Leonardo da Vinci did not ignore this mover either, and a sketch of a paddle ship was found in his papers. There are other written testimonies about paddle wheels, but they could not yet find a worthy use for them due to the lack of a drive engine.


Leonardo da Vinci's paddle boat

In 1707, the world's first steamboat, built by the French scientist Denis Papin, appeared on the Fulda River in Germany. It was powered by paddle wheels. Although the tests ended with a boiler explosion, a start had been made. The first truly operational steamboat is considered to be Robert Fulton's Clermont, with two paddle wheels 4,7 m in diameter with eight blades 1,2 m wide. Fulton's brainchild was also the first stories combat steamship - steam frigate "Demologos", built in 1815. It is interesting to note that it was a catamaran, in the space between the hulls of which a paddle wheel was placed, thus protecting it from combat and navigational damage.



In 1815, Russia also joined the steamship club: in St. Petersburg, the owner of a mechanical foundry, Karl Berd, built a cargo and passenger steamship, the Elizaveta, with a 4-horsepower engine that drove 2,4-meter-diameter side wheels with six plates. On November 3, the steamship made its first voyage from St. Petersburg to Kronstadt, showing an average speed of 9,3 km/h. Thus, Russia became the third country in the world (after the United States and England) in terms of the time it took to organize its own steamship construction.


Steamship "Elizabeth"

What is a paddle wheel? It is a ship's propeller, which is a partially submerged cylindrical structure with a transverse axis of rotation, around the circumference of which rectangular blades (plates) are fixed. The ship is set in motion by the thrust of the plates periodically entering the water.

Initially, the simplest design of this propeller had fixed blades, which significantly reduced its efficiency - the efficiency was only 30-35%. The blades entered the water with an impact, and left it, "scooping out" the water, which entailed vibration and increased noise. To soften the impact with the water, the diameter of the wheels was increased, especially on seagoing steamships. Gradually, the wheels reached truly cyclopean sizes. Thus, on the Great Eastern (1858), designed by I.K. Brunel, the two paddle wheels had a diameter of 17,7 m, and each of the 30 blades was 3,9 m wide and 1 m high. Their maximum rotation speed was 11 rpm.


Steamship Great Eastern (1858)


Sectional view of the Great Eastern's engine room

Attempts were made repeatedly to rid the wheel of the above-mentioned shortcomings, but it was not until 1829 that Elijah Galloway managed to patent a paddle wheel that was free of the main shortcomings. The rotation of the blades so that they entered and exited the water perpendicularly was provided by a hinged eccentric mechanism, driven by the wheel itself. This design turned out to be so successful that it exists with minor changes to this day.


Paddle wheel with turning plates (Sytin's Military Encyclopedia, St. Petersburg, 1911-1915)

These and other improvements to the wheel led to the fact that from the mid-0,30th to the beginning of the 0,35th century, the efficiency of paddle wheels increased from 0,7-0,75 to XNUMX-XNUMX, that is, twofold.


Battle of steam paddle ships - Russian steam frigate "Vladimir" fights Turkish armed steamer "Pervaz-Bahri". November 5 (17), 1853


Paddle steamboat races on the Mississippi River (19th century)

In addition to the design of the blades, the wheels also differ in their location - onboard and stern. Stern wheels are most common on American rivers. Such vessels have not sunk into eternity - in a new guise, the rear-wheel "passengers" "American Queen", "American Heritage", "Belle of Louisville" and others make cruises along the Mississippi.


Modern American rear-wheel passenger vessel “Queen of Mississippi”

Similar steamships were built in the Russian Empire based on American prototypes: the Amazon, Niagara, etc. sailed along the Volga. In recent years, rear-wheeled vessels have again begun to be built at domestic shipyards, but we will touch on this below.

Paddle wheels have both a number of advantages and many disadvantages. Let's focus on the main ones.

Advantages:
• In conditions of limited draft of the vessel, the stern paddle wheel creates a thrust that is much greater than the thrust of the propeller.
• Outboard paddle wheels allow you to turn almost on the spot.
• The towing thrust is higher than that of screw-propelled vessels, and it is also possible to operate at shallow depths, since the wheel sizes do not exceed the vessel's draft. Therefore, in the USSR, the construction of river wheeled tugs continued until 1991 (BTK series pusher tugs).
• A wheel propeller, unlike a screw propeller, allows for inspection and repair without docking the vessel.

Disadvantages:
• When the ship rolls heavily, the outboard paddle wheels alternately come out of the water or sink too deep, the vessel yawing, making it difficult to maintain course. In addition, the wheels are subject to high dynamic loads, which can lead to their breakage.
• Lower efficiency compared to a propeller.
• Reduced operating efficiency when the immersion depth changes (for example, due to pitching or changes in the vessel’s draft).
• Greater weight and dimensions compared to a propeller.
• The use of paddle wheels requires the main engines to be located above the waterline, which reduces the available useful volumes, and in military navy - increases the vulnerability of the engine room and the paddle wheels themselves.

Due to the above-mentioned shortcomings, the wheel quickly disappeared from the scene on sea vessels and ships, but is still used in river fleets today. Now let us briefly dwell on the history of the paddle wheel's use on ships of the domestic river fleet.

Since 1816, paddle steamers began to operate on the Volga and its tributaries, and in the middle of that century, about 200 steamers of more than ten companies sailed along the river. Since 1862, passenger steamers of the so-called "American" type began to sail along the great river. Three-deck ships were very comfortable, many cabins had bathrooms, French buffets and kitchens. This was complemented by a common room with a grand piano, library, etc. Many of these "passengers" survived almost until the middle of the next century.

In 1882–1888, seven rear-wheeled passenger and cargo steamers of the Amazon type with a power of 7 hp, a passenger capacity of 500 people and a carrying capacity of 400 tons were built according to the design of the American engineer Dumbar. The last of them was used on the Volga until 390.


Steamship "Amazon"

In addition to passenger tugs, numerous wheeled tugs were also built. The most powerful of them was the Rededya Prince Kosogovsky (since 1888, the Stepan Razin), built in 1889–1930 at the Motovilikha Cannon Factory. The power of its steam engine reached 2000 hp. After a radical reconstruction in 1928–1930, it could tow a train of barges with a cargo of over 35 tons. The vessel was in operation until 1958.


Model of the tugboat "Rededya Prince Kosogsky"


Steamship "Stepan Razin" (former "Rededya Prince Kosogsky")

In 1911, the world's first paddle-wheel motor ship, the 800-horsepower passenger ship Ural, built at the Kolomensky Plant, entered the Volga expanses.

Steamboats began to appear on the rivers and lakes of Siberia, the Far East and Central Asia.

The first Siberian steamship, naturally a paddle steamer, was the 1838-horsepower Osnova, which entered service in 90 and was built in the Turinskaya Sloboda to transport goods along the Tura and Tobol. In the spring of 1852, steamship navigation began on the Amur as well – the paddle steamer Argun, built at the Shilkinsky Plant, entered its expanses. In 1861, the first paddle steamer, the Saint Tikhon of Zadonsk, appeared on the Lena River. In 1863, the construction of the first steamship Yenisei for this great Siberian river was completed in Yeniseisk.

In 1852, the steamships Perovsky and Obruchev, built in Sweden, were delivered to the Aral Sea in disassembled form from Orenburg on carts pulled by camels, and later sailed along the Syr Darya. These same steamships first appeared on the Amu Darya River in 1858-1859.

From the middle of the 19th century, paddle steamers appeared on all navigable rivers and lakes of the Russian Empire: the Dnieper and its tributaries, the Kuban, the Don, the Seversky Donets, the Vistula, etc.

Paddle steamers formed the backbone of the country's river tugboat and passenger fleet until the 50s. In the 30s and 50s, the fleet was replenished with new paddle steamers designed at a higher technical level (tugboats of Project 733 with a capacity of 200 hp, Project 732 with a capacity of 400 hp, and the Industrialization type with a capacity of 1200 hp).


Project 732 wheeled tug


Izhorets type wheeled tug

In 1951-1959, the last and most numerous series of cargo-passenger paddle steamers of the Joseph Stalin type (74 units) of projects 737 (river) and 737A (lake-river) was built in the USSR. The first five ships were built at the Leninskaya Kuznitsa plant (Kiev), and the rest at the Obuda shipyard in Hungary (Obuda Hajogyar Budapest) - project 737/205 (Maxim Gorky type). In addition, the Hungarians built one ship each for themselves and Czechoslovakia.

Depending on the type of vessel, their draft was 1,26-1,20 m, displacement - 518-542 tons, the power of the main steam engine - 450-520 hp, the carrying capacity - 50-76 tons, speed - up to 19 km/h. On board the vessel there were two lounges, two restaurants, a buffet.

Steamships of this design were operated on the Volga River, the Dnieper, the Don, the Ob, the Lena, the Kama, the Belaya River, the Oka, and the Moskva River.


Passenger ship project 737

The 113-year-old veteran, the only paddle-wheel passenger steamer in Russia, the N. V. Gogol, owned by the Zvezdochka shipyard, is still in operation. The vessel was built in 1911 in Nizhny Novgorod at the Sormovsky Plant by order of the Northern Shipping Company Kotlas-Arkhangelsk-Murmansk. The original steam engine with a capacity of 380 hp provides a speed of up to 18 km/h. Initially, the passenger capacity was 695 (including deck passengers), now, after reconstruction, it is 140 people.


Passenger ship "N.V. Gogol"
42 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +3
    29 November 2024 04: 00
    Good morning!
    From the article ..
    In 1815, Russia also joined the steamship club: in St. Petersburg, the owner of a mechanical foundry, Karl Berd, built a cargo and passenger steamship, the Elizaveta, with a 4 hp engine that drove 2,4-meter diameter side wheels with six plates.

    I would also like to write a few lines about P.I. Kulibin and his research on the “Samokhods” in Nizhny Novgorod.
  2. +4
    29 November 2024 04: 32
    Thanks to the author, very informative, I didn’t know a lot.
  3. +1
    29 November 2024 05: 02
    It's just a pity that the title of the article does not correspond in any way to its content.
  4. +1
    29 November 2024 05: 34
    And in what Russian city was there a factory in 1815 where steam engines were produced, and even for ships?
    1. +2
      29 November 2024 17: 49
      A few words about the Byrd plant (sometimes written Byrd)
      Karl Nikolaevich (Charles) Baird (c. 1766, Westerton, Scotland – 10(22) December 1843, St. Petersburg) – Russian engineer and entrepreneur.
      He studied at the Carron Cannon Factory in Great Britain, where the director of the factory at that time was the famous Scottish engineer and foundryman Charles Gascoigne. In Russia, in 1774, a steam engine was installed in Kronstadt to pump water out of the docks of the Kronstadt Canal, manufactured by order of the Admiralty Board at the Carron Factory. C. Gascoigne was known as the inventor of the carronade cannons adopted by the English fleet.
      In 1786, Byrd was invited to Russia by Empress Catherine II along with other engineers.
      Catherine II understood that it was more profitable to set up her own foundry business than to buy guns. Therefore, she ordered a good master to be found in England and invited to Russia, "without bothering with the size of the salary, as long as he casts cannons without mistakes."
      At that time, there was a law in England prohibiting the departure of specialists and the export of machines from the country; in addition, it was necessary to overcome the resistance of the owners of the Carron plant, whose director was C. Gascoigne. But, despite all the difficulties, the contract was concluded and on May 26, 1786, C. Gascoigne arrived in Russia. Ten more foundrymen and mechanics were invited along with him, among whom was the twenty-year-old, still unknown Charles Bird. Upon arrival in Russia, C. Gascoigne went to Petrozavodsk, where, by decree
      The Senate began the reconstruction of the Aleksandrovsky Cannon Factory according to the "Carron" system. According to his drawings, two new blast furnaces, six air furnaces and the first "cupola" in Russia - a small mobile (rotary) furnace - were built. C. Gascoigne introduced a new method of casting cannons, and now almost all the cast guns turned out to be suitable. Under him, the foundry business reached an unprecedented level of perfection, and after the reconstruction, the plant became the best in Russia in terms of equipment.

      Bird began working at the Aleksandrovsky Cannon Factory in Petrozavodsk, then moved to St. Petersburg. In 1792, Charles Bird had the opportunity to start his own business. Technical knowledge and extensive experience allowed him to organize production using the most advanced technology of the time. A steam engine built on the premises was used as the main engine at the factory. Many researchers believe that this was the first Watt-type steam engine built in Russia (before this, only steam-atmospheric engines were used in Russia).
      The foundry was equipped with tilting shaft furnaces, the prototype of future cupola furnaces. By 1800, according to contemporaries, it was already a large and well-equipped plant. That same year, Emperor Paul I visited it and was so impressed by what he saw that he immediately issued a decree for the Admiralty College: "To introduce into use at the Admiralty, to facilitate manual work <…>, a small-sized fire engine, similar to the one that exists at the factories of the English merchant Berd." Until 1825, Berd's plant was the only enterprise in Russia that systematically produced steam engines, various machines and mechanisms for the needs of the entire country. During this period, the plant manufactured 141 steam engines.
      Some of the work that was done at the plant
      1808 – mechanisms for cutting and polishing glass for the Imperial Glass Factory;
      1809 – bronze bases and capitals, as well as other items for the Kazan Cathedral;
      1810 – fire pipes and steam boilers for the St. Petersburg Mint;
      1811 – steam engines and lathes for the Tula arms factory; casting of the fence installed near the Kazan Cathedral;
      1815 – the first steam ship in Russia;
      1816 – four steam engines for the Shlisselburg locks;
      1817 – steam engines for the Warsaw Arsenal;
      1819 – two steam engines, 16 horsepower each, ordered by the commander of the Black Sea Fleet;
      1818, 1820 – two dredging machines for the Mariinsky system, commissioned by the Ministry of Railways;
      1823 – designs and decorations for the Panteleimon, Post Office, Bank, Lion, Egyptian, 1st Engineering, and Blagoveshchensky bridges.
      For his work for the benefit of the manufacturing industry, Karl Nikolaevich Berd was awarded the rank of Ober-Gittenverwalter of the VIII class in 1811 (a rank of the mining department, corresponding to the civil rank of collegiate assessor and, thus, already giving the right to receive nobility). In 1817, he was awarded the Order of St. Anna of the II degree and received the next rank of Oberbergmeister of the VII class (corresponding to the civil rank of court councilor).
      Karl Nikolaevich Berd died on November 28 (December 10), 1843, with the rank of Oberberg Hauptmann (corresponding to the civil rank of State Councilor) at the age of 77 and was buried in the Smolensk Lutheran Cemetery.
      And for more than two centuries now the saying has lived in St. Petersburg:
      - How are you?
      - Like Bird's. Only the pipe is lower and the smoke is thinner.
  5. +5
    29 November 2024 06: 10
    The article is interesting, but there is not a word about the return of the paddle wheel itself.
    Here it is:
    Type PKS40 "Sura": https://fleetphoto.ru/projects/1205/
    Type PKS180 "Golden Ring": https://fleetphoto.ru/projects/5709/
    Type TSK.566: https://sudostroenie.info/novosti/43115.html
    The first two are passenger ones, the third is a classic wheeled tug, a renewal of the BTK series.
    Of the foreign ones, off the top of my head, the rear-wheeled "Elbe Princess" and the "Loire Princess" with side wheels.
  6. 0
    29 November 2024 06: 25
    Excellent material. There is nothing much to write here!
  7. +3
    29 November 2024 06: 47
    It is strange that the wheel is used when the propeller, which is much more efficient, was invented long ago. Article plus
    1. +3
      29 November 2024 11: 14
      I had not heard of such steamships in the post-war period, new to me. If we talk about the propeller, the author should have mentioned another propulsion device. A water jet. This is also a propeller, but everything is arranged differently, and it works even more efficiently.
    2. +1
      29 November 2024 13: 58
      It is written: that on the riffles (where it is shallow in the river) the propeller(s) expel water between the bottom of the ship and the bottom of the riffle. The bottom of the ship touches the shallows. In such conditions the wheel also provides more thrust.
      Everything is according to the terms.
      1. +1
        29 November 2024 15: 24
        Quote: MCmaximus
        In such conditions, the wheel also provides greater support.
        In such conditions, the wheel turns from a propeller into a soil scoop wink
        1. 0
          30 November 2024 09: 42
          And the screw into the soil thrower. Only the steamer will push off the ground with its wheel laughing laughing laughing , and use a screw to move dirt while sitting on the shallows laughing laughing laughing
  8. +6
    29 November 2024 07: 34
    Quote: Dutchman Michel
    It is strange that the wheel is used when the propeller, which is much more efficient, was invented long ago. Article plus

    This is exactly what the article says.
    1. -1
      29 November 2024 10: 52
      Quote: Grossvater
      This is exactly what the article says.
      The article doesn't say anything about this, except for river vessels, but there the paddle wheels can be replaced with a water jet propulsion system, which is more efficient.
      1. +2
        29 November 2024 13: 47
        The water jet is effective at high speeds. At low speeds, its efficiency is the worst.
        1. +1
          29 November 2024 15: 22
          Quote: MCmaximus
          The water jet is effective at high speeds
          The water jet is effective at shallow depths. Just right for rivers
          1. 0
            30 November 2024 09: 40
            At shallow depths high speeds. For a tugboat or a passenger ship - no way.
  9. BAI
    +3
    29 November 2024 07: 56
    Somewhere around 1972-74, I don’t remember exactly, I had the chance to travel from Kazan to Moscow on the paddle steamer “Dzhambul Dzhabaev”.
  10. +1
    29 November 2024 08: 57
    It can be added that Russia's river fleet was the largest in the world, with the majority of steamships being of its own construction, and the majority of the world's motor ships were also Russian.

    This is such a "plough"....
  11. +3
    29 November 2024 09: 14
    Wheeled tugs of various designs were built at the Semipalatinsk and Pavlodar shipyards until 1986.
    1. +1
      29 November 2024 13: 54
      kor1vet1974 (Korneliy), sir, I'll correct you a little. BTK-9 pr. 3.1721K was delivered in 1990 by Semipalatinsk Shipyard. BTK-40 pr. 4.1721 by Pavlodar Shipyard was delivered in 1990, today it bears the name "Bolat Karentayev". BTK pr. 1721L was also built for Lena in Yakutia in Zhatai, the last vessel BTK-610 was handed over to the rivermen in December 1985, and it still operates on Lena, as does BTK-608 built in 1983.
      1. +1
        29 November 2024 15: 28
        What's wrong, basically? BTK also went along the Irtysh
        1. +1
          30 November 2024 10: 35
          kor1vet1974 (Kornelius), respected, It's not just the dates. There's a whole five-year difference... BTK was designed mainly for the Irtysh. Although "Svir", which was born as BTK-621 project 3.1721K in Pavlodar in 1989, was assigned to Cherlak, at the beginning of the 21st century pulled and pushed barges along the Pechora, and ended its life in Arkhangelsk.
          1. +1
            2 December 2024 10: 21
            Weren't they built in Pavlodar and Semipalatinsk? My comment is that paddle steamers - tugs were built up until the 90s, that's all. What you wrote to me was described in detail in the magazine "Tekhnika-Molodezhi", in a special section.
  12. +2
    29 November 2024 11: 47
    Project 737/205 (type "Maxim Gorky")
    Moored in Kyiv as the Nekrasov Hotel, renamed Bogdan Khmelnitsky. All the Soviet decor - bronze bas-reliefs with stars and a hammer and sickle remained, as did other interior elements. They planned to completely restore it, but due to a fire in the hold during major repairs, they had to replace the steam engines with diesels, connected to the original paddle wheels by hydraulic transmissions. An amazing experience of traveling into the past (we stayed there). Photos - in a camera stolen from a pocket in the Azores, alas and ah.
  13. +4
    29 November 2024 12: 00
    N.V. "Gogol" is almost as old as "Aurora". In 1941, the hull was replaced during a major overhaul, and in 1959, it was converted from coal and wood to fuel oil. Apart from individual parts of the steam engine and steam boilers, if anything is left that is not new, it is the foundation board. In the early 80s of the last century, it was possible to work on it a little: welded and re-welded, all over again, to the last nut, by the golden hands of the workers of "Zvezdochka". And for many years now, cruise and entertainment trips have been taking place, in just a few hours, from the center of Arkhangelsk to Solombala down and a little above Novodvinsk up the Northern Dvina. From Severodvinsk to Arkhangelsk, with the opening of navigation, and from Arkhangelsk to Severodvinsk in the fall, the transfer of the steamship is a whole operation, since the Dvina near Arkhangelsk is cleaned only in one sleeve - Maimaksansky and the river fleet on the Northern Dvina it has been dead for about 25 years due to the shallowing of the river... I don't remember whose plans it was to save another paddle steamer "Stepan Razin", it was brought to Severodvinsk, placed on the shore near the yacht clubs on the island of Yagry in the early 80s. The ebb and flow of the tides quickly broke the hull of the ship, and it was dismantled in a few years. And the unraised car and fuel tanks in 2021, from a depth of 6 meters from under silt and sand with a layer of almost 1 meter, sent greetings to environmentalists with a rainbow film on the surface of the water.
  14. +3
    29 November 2024 12: 01
    Well, the disadvantage of the stern wheel is that it creates a low pressure zone at the stern of the vessel and it is pulled back, also a loss of power
    1. +1
      29 November 2024 13: 54
      A propeller ship has even more: if you stop the engine and propeller at full speed, then the wave coming from behind can lift the ship or throw it aground or throw it over it if it is small.
    2. 0
      30 November 2024 09: 48
      The Americans loved stern wheels. All according to the conditions. Where their conditions coincided with ours, it was great. Stern wheels have another big drawback - the rudder was placed in front of the wheel. Its efficiency was low. I just don't know, maybe someone somehow placed rudders behind. But they still can't be in the stream, as in a screw scheme.
      In general, American steamships are incredibly beautiful! And rational.
  15. +1
    29 November 2024 13: 44
    Quote: Olgovich
    It can be added that Russia's river fleet was the largest in the world, with the majority of steamships being of its own construction, and the majority of the world's motor ships were also Russian.

    This is such a "plough"....

    And there is a place to read about this. I recommend the excellent book by V.S. Gavrilov, "Ship Power Plants. History of Development". It is more captivating than any detective story.
    And yes. At the end of the 500th, beginning of the 1000th century. The development of diesel engine manufacturing in Russia was proceeding at a very fast pace. Unfortunately, Russian factories were unable to overcome the XNUMX-XNUMX hp mark. The reason for this was precisely the almost complete absence of a serious manufacturing industry in the country.
    Alas!
    And yes. When Junkers patented his two-stroke engine with a PDP, the Russian engineer Koreyvo, working in Kolomna, presented a working model of such a machine.
    In general, I recommend reading it. The book can be downloaded from the Kamchatka Regional Library website.
  16. +1
    29 November 2024 13: 44
    Good article! And for the current, mostly shallow, Russian rivers/rivers it is quite possible to build vessels both for tourism/walks and for cargo delivery, if only someone would undertake it...
  17. 0
    29 November 2024 13: 51
    Quote: Dutchman Michel
    Quote: Grossvater
    This is exactly what the article says.
    The article doesn't say anything about this, except for river vessels, but there the paddle wheels can be replaced with a water jet propulsion system, which is more efficient.

    Everything is written, read carefully. And there is a comparison of the propeller with the wheel. True, it is not written in plain text that the advantages of the wheel become noticeable only in calm water, at shallow depths and with a constant draft. Probably the author hoped that the readers would guess this themselves. Apparently he was wrong.
    "Consider that your reader is smart." The phrase is attributed to Tvardovsky, if I'm not mistaken.
    PS about the efficiency of the water jet. Source? I, in my naivety, always thought that the water jet has too much friction loss, which is why it is used more as a maneuvering propulsion device. Well, or when there is no other way out. You can't put wheels on the PT-76.
    1. +1
      29 November 2024 15: 30
      It's not like you're going to put wheels on a PT-76.

      A number of combat vehicles will remake water surfaces by rewinding their tracks (wheels).
      For example, BMP-1/2
    2. 0
      30 November 2024 09: 52
      Still water and shallow depths - these are all rivers. On the sea, wheels died quickly. But on rivers, there are different conditions. And on some, wheels are still relevant. Maybe they are not needed on the Volga. But on the Lena, they are. In the end, wheeled tugs can be used on certain sections with rapids. And on deep water, put another tug and push the barge further.
  18. +1
    29 November 2024 15: 15
    The Return of the Paddle Wheel ////
    The article is interesting, but there is little about the "return". Although such a mover can be very popular. Especially on inland waterways and at a new technological level. For example, a diesel generator plus electric motors on the wheels. This will free up space and give designers room in the layout, will help fit the designed vessels into the existing dimensions of the locks
    and will help in the development of small, non-navigable rivers
    1. +1
      29 November 2024 18: 21
      The PKS family is a "high-tech paddle wheel" - it has a special profile of the plates, independent control of the wheels and the absence of a rudder blade as such, the vessel is completely controlled by the wheels. These motor ships are diesel-electric - most modern paddle ships have an electric or hydrostatic drive of the paddle wheels. It is interesting that the new generation of BTK, previously they were purely mechanical. But its propulsion remained classic - eccentric wheels. The architecture is also classic, with rooms on the portages, many later BTK have more modern superstructures.
  19. 0
    29 November 2024 15: 28
    Quote: KVU-NSVD
    only about "return" is not enough

    Nothing at all. That's why I wrote that the title and content are not connected in any way.
  20. 0
    29 November 2024 15: 30
    Quote: KVU-NSVD
    space for designers in the layout,

    Everything has already been invented before us. Read Gavrilov.
  21. 0
    30 November 2024 01: 25
    There is a way to upgrade the wheel drive, eliminating most of its shortcomings.
  22. 0
    30 November 2024 09: 54
    I doubt that the wind can spin the wheels so that the ship moves at all. It's all just a project. Both the Chinese and Da Vinci ones.
    1. 0
      1 December 2024 17: 36
      Any propeller will work with a windmill, a propeller with a windmill drive was, for example, in the Soviet book "From Idea to Model". There were also different wheeled vehicles.
      1. 0
        1 December 2024 17: 57
        As something of an expert in wind propulsion (I've spent most of my life in sailing - namely racing), I seriously doubt that any wind turbine would be effective on anything larger than a flimsy boat. And there are so many problems there that for some reason no one has even thought of doing such crap since Da Vinci.