Guillotine: Why this method of execution was considered a symbol of “humanity and equality”

15 670 35
Guillotine: Why this method of execution was considered a symbol of “humanity and equality”

The guillotine is an execution instrument that became a symbol of the French Revolution, tragically famous for its mass public executions. However, despite its dark reputation, it was originally created as a tool for the humane execution of the death sentence.

History The guillotine is inextricably linked with the name of Joseph Ignace Guillotin, a French physician and member of the National Assembly who proposed using such a device for the sake of equality and minimizing the suffering of convicts.



Before the invention of the guillotine, executions in France and other European countries were carried out in a brutal manner: wealthy criminals were often beheaded, while commoners were subjected to hanging or breaking on the wheel.

Guillotin, being a doctor and a humanist, insisted that all people should be executed equally and quickly, regardless of class. In 1789, shortly after the start of the French Revolution, he proposed creating a device that could quickly and painlessly take a person's life.

Although the guillotine bears Guillotin's name, its design was devised by Antoine Louis, a physician and secretary of the Paris Academy of Surgery, in collaboration with piano maker Tobias Schmidt, who built the first prototype.

As early as 1792, the first public execution using the guillotine took place in Paris.

The main feature of this device is its mechanics: a heavy blade fell from a great height, ensuring an instant and maximally painless separation of the head from the body. This seemed more humane compared to the difficulties of manual decapitation or other painful methods. The guillotine was also considered a means of unifying justice: it was used for representatives of all classes, asserting equality in punishment.

Meanwhile, over time, the guillotine became a symbol of revolutionary terror: within a few years, executions using it reached horrific proportions. Moreover, it was used in France until 1977.

35 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +12
    29 October 2024 16: 34
    Absolutely right. I read the memoirs of Marie Antoinette and Robespierre. Both praised this method very much, wrote that it was not painful at all. laughing
    1. 0
      29 October 2024 16: 39
      But the American method is revealed in the film Law Abiding Citizen? "The Beekeeper"?
      You can destroy any system, but only if you are a participant in this system.
    2. 0
      11 November 2024 02: 45
      drinks fellow
      Velmi vtipné, věřím, že tomu i mnozí uvěří
  2. +2
    29 October 2024 16: 37
    -Guillotin, being a doctor and a humanist,...
    Well, there were no anti-dandruff remedies back then...
    1. +2
      29 October 2024 23: 50
      There were many humanists at that time! In one French film about that time ---- people were sincerely happy about such events. Small guillotines of different sizes were also sold. So that children could learn from mice and other
      1. P
        +2
        21 November 2024 07: 34
        announce an event with the participation of modern aristocrats with the whole family. Tickets will be sold out immediately, and the online broadcast will melt the data center. Donation voting for the names of the next participants will allow you to cancel taxes
        1. +2
          21 November 2024 10: 39
          laughing wassat lol And you can also play the queue, the order of guillotining, days, hours and even minutes! You can also take bets... And how the residents of nearby houses will get rich!.. Whose windows allow you to see everything well!
  3. +3
    29 October 2024 16: 37
    It all depends on how long the executed person remains conscious. On the guillotine, on the rope, during execution, in the electric chair, during the administration of a lethal injection. The less time a person remains conscious, the more humane the execution. hi
    1. +2
      29 October 2024 16: 54
      Quote: fif21
      The less a person remains conscious, the more humane the execution.

      The execution method used in the USSR is the most humane. A shot in the back of the head, destruction of the brain, death without suffering. The Chinese still practice execution by firing squad, although their history includes thousands of methods of execution. hi
      1. +3
        29 October 2024 17: 01
        Quote: Anatol Klim
        The execution method used in the USSR is the most humane. A shot in the back of the head, destruction of the brain, death without suffering.

        Yes, but the Chinese practice executions against the wall, with automatic weapons. They don't bother with humanity. However, just like in Rus' they impaled people, or the Romans crucified them. The most humane thing is to first put the brain to sleep, and then cut the carotid artery. The person dies in his sleep. hi
        1. +3
          30 October 2024 17: 14
          The French continued to impale people much longer (at least until the beginning of the 19th century) than in Rus', but for some reason they remember Rus'.
        2. 0
          30 October 2024 17: 15
          The French, until relatively recently, roasted a hand or hands over a fire before an execution. According to protocol, one was supposed to be roasted, but the bones show that both were roasted.
          1. +1
            30 October 2024 17: 18
            Quote: NG inform
            The French, until relatively recently, roasted a hand or hands over a fire before an execution. According to protocol, one was supposed to be roasted, but the bones show that both were roasted.

            Sadists! wassat This is something they have left over from the time of the Inquisition. They burned people alive. hi
            1. +1
              30 October 2024 17: 19
              The French didn't have an Inquisition - it was Catholics having fun. At the same time, the Inquisition didn't burn witches, it was Protestants who burned them.
            2. 0
              30 October 2024 17: 21
              Ivan IV, in his letters to Emperor Maximilian, was very outraged by the cruelty of the French and said that it was not humane to behave like that.
              1. +1
                30 October 2024 17: 30
                Quote: NG inform
                Ivan IV was very indignant in his letters to Emperor Maximilian

                A speck in someone else's eye seems like a log. The purpose of the execution was for the guilty person to die in agony, and those who saw his agony were supposed to develop an animal fear of punishment for certain actions. But the reaction of the "audience" and rumors turned the initiator of the execution into a fiend from hell (not the reaction they were counting on). That's why they now kill quietly, and don't make a show out of it. Even in the US, where the sight of a victim in the electric chair led to harsh criticism of the authorities. hi
                1. +2
                  30 October 2024 17: 37
                  The French and the English are real monsters compared to Ivan 4.
                  It's an old idea that it's possible to make Russians European, but it's too cruel :)
    2. +3
      29 October 2024 16: 59
      Quote: fif21
      The less a person remains conscious, the more humane the execution.

      Who and how will determine this? History knows of cases when a soldier's head was torn off, but he continued to run... They wrote about a Chinese man, how he experienced the power of lightning several times...
      * * *
      It seems to me that the opposite of humanism is the fear that one or another method of execution causes in observers.
      The death penalty is an exceptional measure of social protection, excluding any relapse. But this measure should be used as carefully as a surgeon uses a scalpel. Not excluding it completely, as some kind of anachronism...
      And then some began to confuse the shores and completely lost fear, along with honor and conscience.
      1. +4
        29 October 2024 17: 10
        Quote: ROSS 42
        History knows of cases when a soldier's head was torn off, but he continued to run.

        The same thing happens with a chicken. Cut off its head, and it still runs - its heart and muscles work.
        Quote: ROSS 42
        The death penalty is an exceptional measure of social protection,

        I agree! People should not live among people.
        Quote: ROSS 42
        And then some began to confuse the shores and completely lost fear, along with honor and conscience.

        For property crimes - 100 years in prison, without the right to pardon. This is worse than death. hi
      2. +6
        29 October 2024 22: 03
        Quote: ROSS 42
        History knows of cases when a soldier's head was torn off, but he continued to run...

        Moreover, he managed to take aim with his rifle and shoot down the airplane with a well-aimed shot! (J. Hasek, The Good Soldier Schweik)
        1. +3
          31 October 2024 16: 53
          Quote: Good evil
          Quote: ROSS 42
          History knows of cases when a soldier's head was torn off, but he continued to run...

          Moreover, he managed to take aim with his rifle and shoot down the airplane with a well-aimed shot! (J. Hasek, The Good Soldier Schweik)
          What's wrong, Ya. Hasek!
          History, from ancient times to the present day, has a lot of examples of how, for example, one can govern states without a head. For example, we saw it in our own country in the 90s.
          And you about the airplane...
          1. +1
            20 December 2024 15: 28
            And you about the airplane...

            Reality sometimes surpasses fiction. The accident with the English demolition expert Phineas Gage is proof of this. After a metal rod got stuck in his head (below is a computer reconstruction of the injury), he lived for 12 years, and those around him noted that he was a completely healthy person physically and mentally.
    3. 0
      13 November 2024 08: 10
      Quote: fif21
      It all depends on how long the executed person remains conscious. On the guillotine, on the rope, during execution, in the electric chair, during the administration of a lethal injection. The less time a person remains conscious, the more humane the execution. hi

      Isn't it possible to put the patient to sleep first and then administer the poison? Although I think that's how they do it in America - the executioner presses a button and the device sequentially dispenses solutions from three containers
  4. +2
    29 October 2024 17: 06
    The crowd demanded a spectacle...
  5. +4
    30 October 2024 02: 58
    In fact, Geyotin (there was also such a transcription of the name of this Frenchman, who actively sought the use of the discussed murder machine) and the inventor of this "mechanical axe" Louis were not innovators in this matter. Since similar devices for the death penalty to the guillotine were used long before in some German principalities, Spain, England and Scotland back in the 17th century, and earlier, distinguished by less mechanical perfection and greater primitivism. Since the end of the 1939th century, the "louisette" (as the guillotine was first called) became not only a symbol of the Great French Revolution, but also a cruel personification of French justice: public executions with the help of a mechanical knife were carried out until 3000. Even the Nazis in the Third Reich did not resort to such a "freely accessible" form of guillotining, preferring to carry it out only in the presence of an extremely limited circle of officials. Having inherited from the Weimar Republic such forms of capital punishment as hanging and beheading with an axe, Hitler considered the latter method of execution an anachronism, ordering its replacement with the guillotine, and German executioners mastered almost two dozen of these devices to carry out the "such ceremonial" execution (primarily) of the enemies of the Hitler regime. Guillotines became an integral attribute of prisons in Breslau, Munich, Brandenburg, Pankrác prison in Prague, but it became the main instrument of deprivation of life in the infamous Berlin prison Plötzensee. Where Julius Fučík, Musa Jalil, Ilse Stöbe and the women of the "Red Orchestra" group (the men of this group were hanged there) ended their days under its knife, as did almost 40 more condemned people (mostly political opponents of the Nazis, including participants in the conspiracy against Hitler). It is believed that about 16 thousand people passed through the guillotine of the Third Reich, of which more than 1949 thousand were on German territory. But the German biography of the guillotine did not end there. Having inherited from the Third Reich a somewhat improved (compared to the French) killing machine, the justice system of the FRG used it until 1987, until the abolition of the death penalty. The East Germans abolished the "Todesstrafe" only in XNUMX, but their guillotine had broken down twenty years earlier and was replaced by firing squad at that time.
    The French abandoned this type of death penalty only with its abolition, almost two hundred years after the guillotine was used – in 1981. Although the knife of the French “murder machine” did take the lives of the last two condemned in 1977. These were the last victims of the guillotine in the history of its legalized use by the justice system. The last ones at all. Switzerland, Sweden, Greece, Holland, and Belgium abandoned this method of death penalty much earlier.
  6. Mwg
    +3
    31 October 2024 15: 14
    Guillotine: Why this method of execution was considered a symbol of “humanity and equality”

    because it is the embodiment of the typical European idea of ​​humanism. A couple of years ago they (Europeans) killed a giraffe and fed it to other animals because there was nothing to feed it with. Euthanasia, again. Europe is not against death if it concerns someone else. But they like to talk about Russian "gulags".
  7. 0
    31 October 2024 15: 38
    how many have I slaughtered how many...
    I repaired and re-repaired these guillotines... laughing
  8. +1
    31 October 2024 16: 54
    The main thing is that the separation of the head from the body is painless. laughing
  9. P
    0
    1 November 2024 22: 06
    The guillotine is not only a wonderful mechanism, but also a beautiful song la guillotine permanente
    Deputy Guillotin
    In medicine
    Something expert and something raspberry
    Fit a machine
    Pour purger le corps français
    From all the projects
    C'est la guillotine, ô gué[Ann. 1]
    It's the guillotine

    To catch the trahison
    The High Rapine
    These are amateurs of beauty
    These are virgins
    Thank you for what you do
    This doesn't mean the effect will be lost
    It's a guillotine, it's a tongue
    It's the guillotine

    Force of complicity
    The horde is muted
    A gagné sans and penser
    Migraine maline
    Pour guérir ces messieurs-là
    A journal of men
    In the guillotine, the gué
    A la guillotine

    France is on the move
    The noble vermine
    On the whole, it's a secret
    Everything is in ruins
    Mais de nobility in the garden
    To make the transition
    By the guillotine, by the goose
    By the guillotine

    Messieurs les nobles mutins
    Don't forget your money
    Soufflant par des efforts vains
    The intestine war
    If we do not stop you
    You are very noble
    In the guillotine, the gué
    A la guillotine

    Let us search
    Rest assured
    Traits on bond
    It's like a pestle
    Comme on n'en veut pas manquer
    On punit without deplanting
    The machine rests, it goes
    The machine is resting
  10. 0
    4 November 2024 08: 08
    Quote: fif21
    The most humane thing is to first put the brain to sleep and then cut the carotid artery. The person dies in his sleep.

    If an individual has earned the death penalty, then I will be least concerned with choosing the most painless execution.
  11. 0
    11 November 2024 08: 39
    Quote: fif21
    However, just like in Rus', they impaled


    "The sooner you sit down, the sooner you get off," as Vladislav Tepes said.
    Vlad (Dracula) borrowed this method of execution from the Turks, and they from the Byzantines. So this is an achievement of the Romans, the Romans, if you like. Rus' is in ... tenth place in terms of borrowing.

    In the art of torture and execution, as in many other things, the most "civilized" nations are ahead.
  12. 0
    11 November 2024 08: 43
    Quote: ROSS 42
    Who and how will determine this? History knows of cases when a soldier's head was torn off, but he continued to run...


    An educated person. The spinal cord is also responsible for movement, but the latter does not have consciousness.
    Birds, like their ancestors - dinosaurs, have a very developed spinal cord, which is why they can run with their heads cut off. But not very purposefully, by the way... laughing
  13. 0
    11 November 2024 08: 46
    Quote: NG inform
    It's an old idea that it's possible to make Russians European, but it's too cruel :)


    But will this stop Western cultural regulators?

    **** this is Europe! Well, it really looks like it. The non-brothers are the most like true Europeans among the Slavs. Well, Europeans of 80-90 years ago.
  14. 0
    14 November 2024 14: 27
    If this method is so honorable for them, then let them give it to Macron! He will be delighted.
  15. 0
    5 December 2024 01: 06
    They executed their king and queen, and finally Robespierre plundered the one with a crew of 6 veteran soldiers. The commanders of the Bastille were not beheaded in a humiliating way, but cut off, and then drunk with alcohol and glory, thrown with their head impaled on a spear, and this is their national holiday. am