“Kursk Raid”: NATO test attack - last call for Russia

379
“Kursk Raid”: NATO test attack - last call for Russia


Such a Course, such Kursk


What is happening is the result of the dismantling of the USSR and its military machine, as well as the entire destructive liberal course that continues, no matter what. Neither the demographic gap nor the increase in the Central Bank rate will stop Moscow’s course.



Kursk is the first time foreign troops have entered our territory since World War II, not counting the conflict on the island. Damansky from China. Let us add that the approach was successful and so far long-lasting. The first in almost 80 years!

The USSR had a powerful army - 3,8 million people. (1991), and what is happening now would have been impossible then. Not a single reptile in the world could raise even one dirty finger against us. But our youth know nothing about this except “sharashkas and gulags.”
This operation can and will lead to the collapse of the Ukrainian Armed Forces. But this is not about Ukraine: this is a “call” for us!

Kursk raid: last call for Russia


Meanwhile, Kursk is a fundamental challenge for us. NATO is now closely watching all this, calculating where our “limit” is.

We physically cannot close our borders. We need a powerful army, according to various estimates, at least 3,0 million people, which we don’t have yet. So Kursk is not a call for Ukraine, which will inevitably collapse. This is the last call of Fate for us. There won't be any more.

Based on the general analysis of the actions, it was clear that a NATO attack was possible. Military expert K. Sivkov and a number of other experts, including the author, wrote about this (“Will NATO go all-in: scenarios and risks of conflict”). They even named the dates - August - September. But now few people expected that NATO, through the hands of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, would inflict a significant military and, most importantly (!), reputational blow on us. After all, we are, after all, the second army in the world!

The Ukrainian Armed Forces in Kursk have an absolutely unfavorable position - in fact, they are surrounded by operational forces, and according to the laws of military science, they will be hit from the flanks, dismembered and destroyed. The map shows that their ring is being tightened, but we (for some not entirely clear reasons) cannot completely close off supplies and the supply of reserves - therefore, most likely, they will hold out there for some time.

According to Forbes, as well as the TG “Two Majors”, the Armed Forces of Ukraine used the most elite reserves: the 22nd and 88th mechanized brigades and the 80th separate air assault brigade of the Armed Forces of Ukraine; Kyiv could send about ten thousand to invade the Russian Federation military. According to the latest Ministry of Defense report for 13.08.2024/2030/35: during the fighting in the Kursk direction, the enemy lost up to XNUMX military personnel, XNUMX tanks, 31 armored personnel carriers, 18 infantry fighting vehicles, 179 other armored fighting vehicles, 78 cars, four anti-aircraft missile complex, two launchers for multiple launch rocket systems and 14 field guns artillery.

As the “Two Majors” TG writes, the 80th and 82nd brigades of the Armed Forces of Ukraine were withdrawn from Kursk due to losses and problems with logistics, another company of the 24th Special Brigade “Aidar” (a terrorist organization banned in the Russian Federation) appeared, as well as battalion of the 92nd separate assault brigade, detachment of the 8th separate regiment of the Special Forces Special Operations Forces (separate center of the Special Forces "West"), 2nd separate detachment of the center of the Special Forces "Omega" of NSU. The rotation is underway.

But, taking into account the factor of taking 28 settlements, the area occupied is about 400 square meters. km. — and the unknown fate of about 2 thousand people, everything could be much more tragic. And all this looks like a new raid by Basayev (terrorist, eliminated during a counter-terrorism operation).

How could we leave such a dangerous region (the Sudzha gas station and the Kursk nuclear power plant) without proper cover? According to military expert Shurygin and others, intelligence provided a report to the General Staff: “I know for sure that a month ago there was a report that a concentration of Ukrainian Armed Forces forces had been discovered, which, according to intelligence, were preparing to attack, but there was a response to this report from the very top : “Don’t panic, and in general, it’s best to see from above.”

So who will bear responsibility for this? Oddly enough, there is still silence. Why, according to the TG “Two Majors”, did they change local commanders (and not only), removing those doing something, sending them to improve something elsewhere? Where were space intelligence, the FSB and other law enforcement agencies looking? Or are our information transmission channels not duplicated?

And here is the 2022 analysis (Topkor): “Instead of Kherson, the Ukrainian army may try to attack the Kursk region.” And how much was written about this in 2023 and 2024 after the first “Belgorod raid”. And what was the reaction?

The purpose of the raid - new negotiations?


However, if the Ukrainians, God forbid, nevertheless gain a foothold in the Kursk “bridgehead,” the Battle of Kursk-2 may end with new Minsk or Istanbul - to the delight of our oligarchic party of the world. Putin said that the purpose of the raid was to strengthen Ukraine’s position in the negotiations: and this is true. But there is another, bad scenario - a second, more massive attack.

Not long ago, Deripaska, considered a member of the Yeltsin “Family,” representing our country at an APEC event, gave an interview to Nikkei Asia.

Quote from August 8: “Deripaska, who said he was in Japan to represent Russia on the final day of the APEC Business Advisory Council meeting earlier this month, criticized his country’s defense spending, calling the war in Ukraine “crazy.” “If you want to stop the war, you first need to stop the fire,” he said, calling for an “immediate, unconditional ceasefire” in Ukraine.

When asked about the Kremlin, he replied: “They [the Kremlin] don’t touch me, we don’t touch politics.” Is this not an ultimatum from the peace party?

Kursk raid: NATO strike, NATO rehearsal


Once again: this is not a blow to the Ukrainian Armed Forces. This is a blow from NATO, which is now “charging” its supercomputers and AI systems with the invaluable information received and modeling how best to launch a future and not at all nuclear strike on Russia. How many foreigners are there gaining invaluable experience?

A combined strike may follow (not from NATO territory), which may combine the same raid (possibly more than one) and an attack with cruise missiles and a “swarm” drones from the territory of Ukraine, F-16 - from NATO airfields, along with simultaneous sabotage on our territory (see Crocus, Dagestan - there was a run-in). And if NATO finds a few more of these leaky pockets on our border, then we could simply be paralyzed.

As former Trump adviser Katie McFarland said, Zelensky wants to use all the capabilities of the Western weapons due to failures at the front, so he asked for the restrictions to be lifted. “It (the stalemate - approx.) has persisted for a year and a half... Therefore, all Zelensky’s requests for help (he wants not only to get additional weapons, but also to use them in a completely different way against Russia) are aimed at remaining on an equal footing... Ukraine wants to raise the rate."

Russia: the second army of the world


Russia is the second army in the world. How about this? So we have:

1) Corruption is the main threat to national security, as it turns the army into a feeding trough for officials. There are questions about the quality of the construction of defense lines in Kursk, expressed, for example, by the former State Duma deputy General Andrei Gurulev (and not only). The old leadership of the region promised to build a defense line, estimated at 15 billion rubles. Photos of this “line” were shown. According to Tsargrad, allegedly “leaked” information about Belousov’s audit indicates the opacity of the military department’s expenses in the amount of about 11 trillion. rub. This is almost a third of the budget!

2) The same applies to the level of qualifications of the command, someone sits in the trenches, someone builds dachas. At the same time, the military officers who showed their best side during the Northern Military District - Surovikin and Popov - fell into political disgrace due to the danger for our oligarchy, which needs peace, even on Western terms. According to Tsargrad, the commander of “Akhmat” stated that the Ukrainian Armed Forces’ breakthrough into the Kursk region “has a surname, name and patronymic.”

3) Why do we allow the concentration and collection of enemy reserves, although all the media are writing in the same way that the war now is a war of mobile groups. What a mobile group! About 10 thousand people, columns of equipment, etc. came to us. Fiber-optic control of drones was used. On the Ukrainian side, their DefenseAnd we were not prepared for all this.

4) Russia does not have enough army to protect its long borders - relying on nuclear weapons is a wrong strategy, NATO will fight the war with conventional weapons, and that will be enough. Kursk is a hello from the 90s and Serdyukov’s reforms. We need an army of about 3 million people. In particular, in 2023, the German publication Bild estimated that the Russian Federation could, if it wishes, increase its army to three million people. A number of our military analysts gave the same assessment.

5) Yes, but we have units of the Russian Guard, FSB, etc. What are they for? To counter “revolutions”? But this way you can “look through” the main thing.

6) It becomes clear that a new mobilization is needed, not only direct, but also of the entire society. Perhaps the “cream” of youth, the product of liberal democracy, will run again. But whose youth are these? There is another one - and there is more of it. But without unity and involvement, as during the Second World War, there will be no victory.

Russia's main problem is lack of leadership



There is a theory by A. Toynbee: challenge - response. NATO also has the concept of the theory of five strategic rings and the Boyd OODA loop, as the MK newspaper wrote about. The first looks for critical points in the state management system, the second works proactively. The beginning of the SVO was quite proactive, impressive and was just ahead of the curve. But after Istanbul, the nature of the Northern Military District changed (which was the main result of the “agreements”). We did not have a bright initiative, except for Mariupol, Avdiivka and a number of others - grinding is underway, although our successes do not raise any doubts. But in the meantime, NATO is “probing” us, striking airfields, as well as elements of the early warning system for a nuclear attack and more. NATO is looking for our “holes”. Can we generate effective responses?

Kursk is a challenge. Answer: a new army, mobilization of the entire country and victory. Tsarist Russia lost the war, and the USSR won. So which path will our leadership take? Fate wants us to change, but we drag our feet, like in Tsarist Russia. The elite is waiting for Trump, but he will not be allowed to become President.

We will not let anyone steal our Victory


I don't want to cast shade on anyone. But war is war, and the actions of the enemy’s Anglo-Saxon intelligence were the same both during the time of Admiral Ushakov and now. According to the revelation of US General Franks: “We bought victory in Iraq.”

Why do we have such problems with supplying the army, with decision-making? Oligarchic factor. Let us remember what people were talking about at the end of the First World War after the obvious failures of the Tsarist Army? There weren’t enough shells, but what now? Question about supplying the army, it’s great that people are participating in the war, even with participation and money, but why do volunteers often buy the necessary equipment?

Every year in this company everything is the same. Everyone is shouting: Ukraine is finished. But this happened in August 2022 before the Kherson maneuver, and last year, at the same time after the offensive, and, finally, now. There is no one to fight there. On TV they show the beating of military commissars of the Armed Forces of Ukraine.
No: nothing like that. Yes, their losses are huge. Bandera's Ukraine is doomed. But Ukrainians are like pearls and twigs. Ukraine is supported by the EU, the USA, and mercenaries are involved. There will be a replacement for Ukrainians - Poland, the Baltic states and not only.

The end of the Ukrainian Armed Forces is a dangerous illusion. This is a simple “misconception” of the liberal and also foreign media, which work against us and create dangerous illusions. Nobody wants to receive bad news, but the truth is always needed everywhere. And now Western media are racing to criticize the raid - supposedly there is no point. And even if the incoming Ukrainian Armed Forces are destroyed, the meaning and benefit for NATO is undeniable. What the West writes, read it the other way around.

The reason for escalation is the expansion of the front by Russia


According to retired colonel of the SBU of Ukraine Oleg Starikov, expressed in the spring: “There will be a military event in August-September. I call this a general battle that will lead to escalation or de-escalation and, perhaps, will become the basis for the start of negotiations.”

The West, Starikov added, is preparing an air group of the Ukrainian Armed Forces for the upcoming battle. Obviously, we were not talking about any “general” battle in the traditional sense. But there is a hint of something “special”. And here it is - Kursk.

“If Russia does not agree to the terms of the peace summit, we will force it to surrender,” said Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni.
According to a July 2 statement from US Assistant Secretary of State James O'Brien: "... as Jake Sullivan said last week, if Russia tries to expand this front, Ukraine will be allowed to reach targets at a greater distance."

Epilogue: we are told that “the mission is impossible”


So: Ukraine and NATO have raised the stakes. Place your bets, gentlemen!

For the first time since World War II, the enemy is on our territory. It is clear that we will use everything to destroy the raid. But there is no adequate “response”, other than destruction and “squeezing out” from our land, the assessments are blurred. During the Soviet era, everything that happened was impossible. SVO is the payment for the collapse of the USSR and the destruction of Russia in the 2s. We see the collapse of the Yeltsin matrix, which was imposed on us in the 90s and beyond.

It is unlikely that the current liberal-oligarchic system will be able to win in the Northern Military District by capitulating and annexing Ukraine.
In 2014, we could take not only Crimea and Donbass at once, but all of Ukraine (except for the western part). But Moscow preferred the Minsk ones. For 8 years we watched the Donbass being bombed, and this “contemplation” ended with the Northern Military District. The SVO is in its third year and we cannot achieve complete victory. And only the bombing of Kursk-Belgorod forced us to go on the offensive to create a buffer zone. Zones are not enough - all of Ukraine (except for the western part) must become one whole buffer for us - forever and ever. And now the war is at our gates.

Obviously, this “spiral” is disastrous. The further we drag out time, the worse and worse it gets. A little more, and NATO will come into play.

Since 2014, society has been de facto “latently” instilled with the idea that it is impossible to resolve the Ukrainian issue by force: that is, a bad peace is better than war. Meanwhile, there is a solution, and it lies in restoring the tough active strategy of the first part of the Northern Military District, when we wanted to win.

The state must urgently abandon the destructive liberal raw materials model. Not to “grind”, but to win.
379 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. -36
    15 August 2024 05: 40
    The author, foreign armies did not enter the territory of the USSR after the Second World War and are not entering now. Now everything is happening within the territory of the USSR and between the peoples of the USSR. This is a civil war, but not yet an invasion.
    1. +35
      15 August 2024 06: 33
      Whatever you call it, the Kursk region is Russian territory. Or do you think this is the territory of another state?
      1. +2
        15 August 2024 07: 26
        Journalists are panicking, authorities are panicking...The West is winning another information victory.
        Yes, the West is looking for weak points...

        But you don’t need to look for everything bad, as the author of the article does. For example, the same swot analysis involves searching for strengths and weaknesses.

        Let's look for our strengths, which can become a point of growth. I'll name a few:

        1) The most severe fight against corruption, including the return of the death penalty. Just like in China.
        In Russia, a lot of things are rotten... But this is also a strong point - rot and corruption can be removed quite quickly.

        2) We haven’t started yet (c). Yes, that's true. War has not been declared on Ukraine. This is a theater of the absurd - there are fighting, gas is flowing, Russian money is flowing to Ukraine (albeit through a dozen intermediaries).

        But this is also a strong point - to start a full-fledged war. Bandera's followers do not follow the rules. Why are we fighting with white gloves?
        Also, a sore point for two and a half years now is the enemy’s logistics. Bridges, ports, railways. Everything is intact, everything works. There are no brothers in the West. This needs to be realized.

        Will victory be ours? (question mark). Victory cannot be missed. It has already been prepaid for decades with the blood of the Russian people.
        1. +4
          15 August 2024 14: 48
          A lot of nonsense. And here are the facts: a full-fledged war began a long time ago, but nothing happened. We can no longer defend our territories.
          1. +2
            17 August 2024 17: 34
            But without unity and involvement, as during the Second World War, there will be no victory.


            Unity during the Second World War was ensured by the fact that the people fought for the PEOPLE'S state and were motivated IDEOLOGICALLY. And today this state does not exist!

            The authorities of modern Russia have abandoned the left turn and announced it publicly. The elite is preparing a new wave of privatization.

            Russia must be saved, that’s a fact. The enemy must be defeated, this is also a fact. But the elitist-capitalist essence of modern Russia does not contribute to this.
        2. +12
          15 August 2024 15: 11
          Why look for them, weak points. Look up, there they are
        3. +3
          15 August 2024 15: 12
          Corruption is blooming and smelling in China. The executions of high-ranking corrupt officials there are a reality of the internal party struggle. Like our landing of the former Minister of Finance
          1. +4
            15 August 2024 20: 03
            In China, the population density is much higher, and therefore the percentage of corruption is higher. Try to control such a mass of people. But the Chinese authorities are quite successful in this.
          2. +3
            17 August 2024 23: 47
            Let's compare what China has achieved in 34 years and what Russia has achieved? After this comparison, will your conscience allow you to compare their corruption with ours?
            1. 0
              18 August 2024 01: 45
              And the difference in the achievements of China and Russia is due only to different results in the fight against corruption?
        4. -1
          16 August 2024 15: 23
          This is by agreement, if something goes wrong, both Russia and Ukraine call the United States, they will pull both of them back, missiles will be launched at bridges, ports, a bank bank, and the enemy will immediately be given the go-ahead to bomb deep into Russia, carry out terrorist attacks on cities, and so on. tomahawks will enter the arena for 2500 km. Well, further to hell, you want this, what’s stopping you from volunteering, if you want a penny, they’ll take it anyway, so at least your grandchildren will live.
        5. +5
          16 August 2024 15: 56
          The toughest fight against corruption

          Who will fight, Leopold the cat? So the main corrupt officials are his friends, but he doesn’t abandon his friends, which means he won’t fight them...
        6. +6
          16 August 2024 17: 22
          Do you call a statement of facts panic?
          Not a single “hostile boot with a weapon” has set foot on our soil since 1945. Fact? Fact.
          The Ukrainian Armed Forces are fighting using NATO weapons. Fact? Fact.
          Now in the Kursk region, where tanks melted in 1943, Ukrainians wear Wehrmacht helmets with “double zippers.” Fact? Fact.
          What kind of "swot analysis" are you talking about? You're not at a paper clip sales meeting!
          I was born in the USSR. And for me the current situation is bitter.
          And the worst thing is that the guys lay their heads THERE, and the “red stripes” HERE, some have either already forgotten how to fight, others don’t know what to do with what they stole...
        7. 0
          25 August 2024 00: 30
          You have rose-colored glasses. I won’t list what, at least go to Rutube and look at the latest interview with A. Artamonov. Or Sivkova. You probably listen to the gene a lot. Chechnya Apti Alaudinova. This author has smoothed out all the corners regarding the SVO situation. And the main thing is that it’s inside the Russian Federation.
      2. 0
        15 August 2024 12: 26
        Quote: Mikhail Androsov
        Whatever you call it, the Kursk region is Russian territory. Or do you think this is the territory of another state?

        The Sumy region, where the attack took place, is also historical Russia. Only Slobozhanshchina was torn away by the Bolsheviks in favor of the newly created Ukrainian SSR. This is a real civil war, which the West organized with the hands of its proxies in Ukraine.
        1. +2
          16 August 2024 13: 10
          This is not a civil war, but a war of the West against Russia!!!
          1. +1
            16 August 2024 14: 04
            Quote: Lisa Kerner-Tymoshenko
            This is not a civil war, but a war of the West against Russia!!!

            This is a civil war of Russians against former Russians (Ukrainized Mankurts) in Russian territories. The West has been preparing this confrontation for a long time, through a coup it brought pro-Western puppets to power and through whom it provoked this conflict. It is their usual practice to achieve their goals through someone else's hands.
            Initially, the civil war in 2014 was between citizens of Ukraine, with Russia and the West supporting the warring parties. But in 2022, the West still managed to drag Russia into this war.
      3. +6
        16 August 2024 09: 14
        This is the territory of the RSFSR. And whose territory do you think the outskirts are? Comrade is right, this is a civil war unleashed by hucksters, Russians are fighting on the territory of the USSR and on both sides. The Belovezhskaya conspiracy is a crime; all subsequent divisions into appanage principalities are illegal. The referendum told the USSR to exist.
      4. +2
        16 August 2024 13: 08
        The author does not write about Russia, but about the USSR, which is larger than Russia and not equal to the Russian Federation.
    2. +15
      15 August 2024 08: 06
      The participation of NATO troops under the “guise” of mercenaries (“volunteers”) is not an invasion of “foreign armies”? belay Take a “telescope” if “glasses” don’t help you!
      1. +4
        15 August 2024 14: 50
        Does this make you feel better? At least 102 prisoners per day - oh, this is not the West and can everything be written off?
    3. +44
      15 August 2024 08: 28
      The state must urgently abandon the destructive liberal raw materials model. Not to “grind”, but to win

      Again the “liberals” are to blame. I see that many people still don’t realize that liberals in the country ended with Nemtsov, and a kleptocratic model of statehood has been built in which there is no smell of liberalism, and for a long time. It is kleptocracy that is characterized by agreements between bosses and various types of secret fights....
      1. +7
        16 August 2024 11: 07
        liberals ended with Nemtsov
        , I do not agree. Our guarantor once said that he is the most liberal liberal. If you still believe him, of course.
    4. +21
      15 August 2024 09: 58
      Quote: Yuras_Belarus
      The author, foreign armies did not enter the territory of the USSR after the Second World War and are not entering now.

      Enough intelligence agencies. Have you forgotten how the CIA “approved for reign” officials in government bodies, oligarchs for robbery, under Elkin”?
      The "fifth column" and their children are still there. A host of "Potanins" are grinding Russia, far and wide.
      The way the SVO began and is being carried out is reminiscent of Brzezinski’s formula - the destruction of Russia will be carried out, by the hands of Russia, on the territory of Russia, and at the expense of Russia. There is a systematic extermination of the Slavs, at the hands of the Slavs themselves.
      And the authorities, shocked by their actions, are trying to transfer the shock of their actions to TsIPSO and foreign media, perverting it in such a way that the enemy only needs to rewrite “the actions of the Potanins from the authorities” in order to provoke outright hostility towards the thieves’ boss.
      1. -22
        16 August 2024 01: 44
        Are you panicking? What kind of nonsense did you write? If you are not even able to understand why the General Staff allowed the most selected people into Kursk, then you have no need to be clever on the military channel, I advise you to switch to something like the rain channel! And in order to understand the idea, I advise you to read books about the Second World War, I assure you that answers to many things will appear, and the so-called phrases corruption and so on will take on a different meaning, if someone still does not understand, then our supreme one has long been playing a double game where with one On the one hand we are lost, but on the other hand we somehow manage to win! (This is the time that the Americans gave us to stand on our feet, they did not expect that Russia would be able to rise, etc.)
        1. +17
          16 August 2024 09: 29
          Now, if you, a strategist ala Zhukov, were kicked out (evacuated) from your own home, along with another 180 thousand of the same poor people, faith in the success of the grandmaster would be greatly shaken.
          1. +9
            16 August 2024 21: 18
            Quote: Essex62
            Now, if you, a strategist ala Zhukov, were kicked out (evacuated) from your own home, along with another 180 thousand of the same poor people, faith in the success of the grandmaster would be greatly shaken.

            They kicked out not only from UN-recognized Russian regions. Kherson... -refugees. Donbass - refugees, Zaporozhye refugees... I'm sick of this whole victorious war. There are too many, God forgive me, gavnyuks in power. They steal, they eat. They debauch, teach the “stupid” people... Russia needs cleansing. both strength and spirituality. Hang a dozen other corrupt officials in public. Confiscate the stolen goods for the benefit of the country. Families will be sent to the farthest north. Cruel? No
    5. -12
      15 August 2024 13: 50
      All the same, this is a NATO war at the hands of Ukrainians against Russia on our territory. Evidence: armored vehicles and tanks of England, USA, Germany, Italy burned by our soldiers on the roads and fields of the Kursk region. What to do? Continue the military operation, and also use minimal-yield tactical nuclear weapons against the Dnieper bridges and dams. It is also possible to use high-power nuclear weapons to strike with a ground explosion with an easterly wind at the Yavorivsky test site, which is 15 km from Poland.
      1. +7
        15 August 2024 15: 17
        Did the T-62s burned by Jews mean Soviet aggression against Israel in the seven-day war?
        1. 0
          16 August 2024 18: 54
          However, as a supporter of the use of tactical nuclear weapons against Ukraine, which I have written about several times, I have never suggested launching a nuclear strike on a NATO country. Only within the borders of Ukraine.
      2. 0
        16 August 2024 18: 57
        It is also possible to use high-power nuclear weapons to strike with a ground explosion with an easterly wind at the Yavorivsky test site, which is 15 km from Poland.

        Despite the 12 minuses, I still maintain that if Russia and the Northern Military District come to a dead end, and a peace agreement is not concluded, then a nuclear strike on Ukraine is inevitable.
    6. +5
      15 August 2024 23: 03
      That's right. It was the same as in Chechnya. The Chechens sold themselves to the Arabs and Americans and began to restore their order - as a result, they received the suppression of the rebellion by the Russian army. And since there is more and more talk that the collapse of the USSR is not legally documented, the Northern Military District against Ukraine is also a civil war where the rebellion is pacified by the Russian army. The White Guards in the last century also had support from the West with weapons and money. And the troops of many countries arrived on our territory and took away everything they could, setting up concentration camps. Only then were there regular armies of the West, and now they are partly mercenaries, and supposedly retirees.
      1. +2
        16 August 2024 19: 13
        Was the collapse of the Russian Empire in 17 properly documented? Because in this case, the White Guards represented the current government, and the Reds were rebels
    7. +5
      16 August 2024 05: 58
      between the PEOPLES of the USSR?! Are you out of your mind? When did wars take place between nations? The people in any war are victims!
    8. 0
      16 August 2024 08: 55
      Yurasik! For the “particularly slow-witted”, yes, on the territory of the USSR, BUT this is not a civil war! This is a war between the West and us at the hands of our FORMER people!
      1. +3
        16 August 2024 09: 22
        For those who are especially understanding. When people of the same nationality and citizenship kill each other, this is not civil war, is it? The fact that this is beneficial to the West does not change this fact. The liquidation of the USSR has no legal basis for any of our former people. She is criminal.
        1. 0
          16 August 2024 11: 02
          Quote: Essex62
          When people of the same nationality and citizenship kill each other, this is not civil war, is it?

          So citizenship is different. The USSR dissolved itself in 1991 - also through the efforts of its citizens. Some in Moscow shouted “long live Yeltsin” in the squares, others in Kyiv shouted “down with imperial oppression” in the squares.
          Quote: Essex62
          The liquidation of the USSR has no legal basis for any of our former people. She is criminal.

          You, comrade, should be more careful when reviewing history. Otherwise the Belodellians are breathing down your neck: The liquidation of the Russian Empire has no legal basis. She is criminal.
          1. 0
            17 August 2024 02: 33
            Which one is this from? The Republic of Ingushetia liquidated the absolute majority, the Union was a bunch of hucksters, party degenerates and anti-alligent idiots, while the hegemon ate bitter things.
            1. 0
              19 August 2024 10: 26
              Quote: Essex62
              Which one is this from? The Republic of Ingushetia liquidated the absolute majority, the Union was a bunch of hucksters, party degenerates and anti-alligent idiots, while the hegemon ate bitter things.

              Come on. The hegemon then galloped as if on the Maidan. Have you forgotten about the rallies of hundreds of thousands? Or about how the editor-in-chief of Pravda was fired for trying to show the people the true EBN - “as a result of numerous appeals from citizens and work collectives”? How the entire Soviet people as one person watched and listened to the broadcasts of the Armed Forces, and then excitedly shared what he heard?
              Here she is - this one a bunch of hucksters, party degenerates and anti-alligent idiots:

              And then everyone suddenly began to pretend that they had nothing to do with it and had always been against it. Like Ukrainians after Maidan. smile
              1. 0
                19 August 2024 14: 21
                And this crowd of people, for the most part, has nothing to do with the slogan about the abolition of socialism and the establishment of the power of the huckster. The people came out to tell the authorities that they were fed up with coupons and the sabotage of the partycrats. And in this crowd, more than half are anti-alligents, by the way. There are several million of them in Moscow, worthless laboratory assistants and tax inspectors.
                1. 0
                  19 August 2024 15: 33
                  Quote: Essex62
                  And this crowd of people, for the most part, has nothing to do with the slogan about the abolition of socialism and the establishment of the power of the huckster.


                  Do you see the slogans? And there, in addition to the tricolor, yellow and black flags also fluttered above the crowd. In general, “freedom for oppressed peoples” in all fields.
                  1. 0
                    19 August 2024 17: 44
                    Do you see the faces? Who drew these slogans with sweaty hands in the kitchen and then raised them over their empty heads? I brought such people to their senses then, right off the bat. And then no one canceled human stupidity. There were also hard workers there. But they hardly dreamed of being a bourgeois. Initially, the usurpers did not have a direct call for the destruction of Soviet power. They only “traversed” the CPSU, well, the party-shifters were really in people’s heads, even among the members of this CPSU. This happened later, in 93 they finished off socialism.
                    1. 0
                      20 August 2024 15: 11
                      Quote: Essex62
                      Do you see the faces? Who drew these slogans with sweaty hands in the kitchen and then raised them over their empty heads?

                      Well, here's a working class for you:


                      In modern times, this is complete surrealism: Donbass miners stand for an independent Ukraine.
                      1. 0
                        21 August 2024 18: 21
                        Yes, they didn’t give a damn about this independence, they banged their helmets so that they would pay wages for the hardest, dangerous work. Most do not even suspect that the slogan was raised over their heads. And yet, there were nationalists among the miners; time put everything in its place.
                        I’m talking about the main driving force of the revolution, and you’re feeding me discrediting material about the proletariat. I myself know that the working class screwed up. It was necessary to organize in 91 and demolish this huckster gopa along with the degenerate partocrats. They didn’t believe it would end badly.
        2. 0
          17 August 2024 23: 56
          I also believe that the collapse of the USSR is a crime (not just a tragedy, but a crime). And this must be recognized at the top. But be realistic now. Despite all the “legal” justifications, the USSR in fact no longer exists. And there is no “brotherhood” of peoples. Accept it. And we must proceed from this...
          1. 0
            18 August 2024 07: 25
            If there are legal justifications, there will be “lawyers” to change this fact. Everything is in our hands. Yes, it is not yet ripe, but time passes, and a good arrangement of society is attractive to most people. It is not made up of just speculators and swindlers, and it is not just Moscow and St. Petersburg (there, yes, it’s hopeless). Russia is alive.
            And yet, there is no “brotherhood” of peoples, just one people, divided, as has happened more than once in history. And not only in Russia.
    9. 0
      17 August 2024 16: 37
      And the USA and the whole world are helping us, right?
  2. +14
    15 August 2024 05: 48
    A country with a population of 140 million cannot keep 3 million under arms in peacetime, Nicholas was the first to try, the result is known.
    1. +13
      15 August 2024 06: 08
      An army in peacetime is a parasite, and maintaining such an army in full combat readiness is a path to bankruptcy. We need units with incomplete staff in peacetime, ready to accept and arm reservists in the event of war. In peacetime, we need a professional army ready to take the first blow while the country mobilizes.
      1. +13
        15 August 2024 09: 11
        An army in peacetime is a parasite, and maintaining such an army in full combat readiness is a path to bankruptcy.

        Those who do not want to feed their army will feed someone else's.
        And any society has no choice but to feed this gang of professional killers called the Army. Otherwise, society will feed some other, most likely foreign, gang of murderers. And this foreign gang will not be so loyal to the civilian population. If you don't have your own shoemaker, you will be buying your shoes in another country. And you will feed not your own worker, but someone else’s. It's the same with the army. A society that does not want to have and feed its own army will feed someone else’s.
        But every soldier is not just a killer. He grew up in this society. He has friends, brothers, sisters, mom and dad. And in every citizen of his country, he cannot but see people close to him. A soldier of a foreign army has no such attachments. Therefore, any thought that someone else's uncle will come with a machine gun and everyone will live better than before is just nonsense. At best, the conquered country will be turned into a raw material appendage. And, having pumped out all the natural and human resources, they will simply be thrown into the trash.
        If the military profession is to mean anything at all, it must be based on an unshakable code of honor. Otherwise, those who follow the rams will be just a bunch of hired killers.
        1. +18
          15 August 2024 10: 32
          We have a mixed army: previously contract soldiers and conscripts, now we have added mobilized and volunteers. What do we end up with? Conscripts serve for a year and by the end of their service, few can be considered trained military personnel. It turns out that contract workers do not want to die for a salary. The officers were interested in the mortgage that had to be paid. Well, as for the generals, you don’t even need to remember about them. Here I am, an armchair expert in the opinion of turbo patriots, looking at the map and figuring out what needs to go there and here. I know that there is maneuver, detour, flanks, and so on. And the generals, who see there is point A and need to hit it head on, but nothing else. They have a head for wearing a headdress. Well, what can we say about the Guarantor? The leadership environment shows that it is capable. Well, the people. The people got theirs.
          1. +4
            15 August 2024 13: 52
            contract soldiers and conscripts, now mobilized and volunteers have been added. What do we end up with?
            .....
            There have been no volunteers for a long time. Contract soldiers and mobile workers. In the northwestern military district. But here’s what’s interesting. Mobik gets 200k, and I, a contract worker, get the same amount. But in the hospital I have 37 thousand; my mobile phone has the same 200. Everything, of course, is rounded.
            1. +4
              15 August 2024 15: 35
              So they didn’t ask the mobik whether you wanted to go to war or not. After the end of the contract, are they fired or not?
              1. +4
                15 August 2024 15: 42
                So they didn’t ask the mobik whether you wanted to go to war or not.
                .. .....
                Agree. But, on payday...
        2. +4
          15 August 2024 17: 08
          Society feeds and waters the army this way and does not complain, and for many years. And now it helps in every possible way. What more do you require?
          1. +1
            16 August 2024 01: 56
            Yes, I don't demand anything. I simply voiced my vision to a citizen who called the army a parasite.
            1. 0
              16 August 2024 07: 39
              Parasite, I used the word figuratively in the same way as you called the army a gang of professional killers or simply killers. In your response to my comment, you changed the thesis. In your opinion, at least return the surplus appropriation.
              1. +3
                16 August 2024 08: 14
                The word is not a sparrow - it will fly out and you will not catch it. Having passed through two hot spots, I can have this opinion about the army. The main task of a warrior in combat conditions is to kill the enemy, and non-professionals do not live there for long. A killer is a hired killer from the criminal community, do not confuse warm with soft.
                1. 0
                  16 August 2024 08: 30
                  I don’t know how many hot spots we went through, but the main thing is not just to kill the enemy, but to be confident in your rightness and understand why.
                  1. 0
                    17 August 2024 11: 59
                    Let me explain what it means to “kill the enemy correctly.” We must kill him, then another, and another, and another, and quietly, and be sure to return to base alive and unharmed. Killing in order to die yourself is not good. Why were we taught then? To exchange the efforts of a dozen instructors over the course of several years for one lousy one, it won’t be said at the table, a ghoul?
        3. +3
          16 August 2024 11: 38
          If the military profession means anything at all
          “There is such a profession - to plunder the Motherland” - in our country, as it turned out. Which is typical of all former ministers in business.
      2. +5
        15 August 2024 09: 33
        Standards for the size of an army depending on the size of the population have long been calculated and exist. So, according to this norm, the size of the state’s army should be at least 1% of the population. And as for “the army is a parasite in peacetime” - it was said on this matter a long time ago and quite clearly: “The state that does not want to feed its army will feed someone else’s.”
        1. +9
          15 August 2024 12: 58
          Quote: bug120560
          Standards for the size of an army depending on the size of the population have long been calculated and exist. So, according to this norm, the size of the state’s army should be at least 1% of the population. And as for “the army is a parasite in peacetime” - it was said on this matter a long time ago and quite clearly: “The state that does not want to feed its army will feed someone else’s.”

          These standards are very conditional, since in addition to the population, they do not take into account the territory of the country. It’s one thing to maintain an army of 1% of the population for China (0,5% is enough for their perimeter) and another thing for Russia with its 1/6th of the landmass. To fully protect such a perimeter, an army of at least 2% of the population is needed, but it must also be recognized that in order to fully maintain such an army, the population of Russia must be at least 300 million people.
          1. +2
            15 August 2024 15: 20
            The territory of China is actually 60 percent of Russia.
            1. +5
              15 August 2024 15: 33
              Quote from Sumotori_380
              The territory of China is actually 60 percent of Russia.

              So yes, but they have a population of billions at this 60%, so even their 0,5% is an unattainable bar for us. hi
              1. +3
                15 August 2024 16: 06
                Well, that’s why the best defense of one’s territory is to be surrounded by allied countries
          2. +3
            15 August 2024 17: 12
            Likewise, we have more than one army, the Russian Armed Forces are one thing, the Russian National Guard, the FSB, the internal troops, the police. Maybe I forgot someone. So I think we're okay with the percentages. There are also Cossacks. And if you scrape the bottom of the barrel, more than 2 million will be collected in peacetime.
            1. 0
              15 August 2024 22: 08
              Quote: vladimmiroff
              So we have more than one army, the Russian Armed Forces are one thing, the Russian Guard, the FSB, the internal troops, the police. Maybe I forgot someone.

              No, we haven't forgotten. Let’s just say that we’ve even gone overboard a little, in the sense that we haven’t had internal troops for 10 years now, because their functions have been transferred to the Russian Guard.
              In short, the Russian Guard is the same internal troops only with more expanded powers than before, only under a new brand. Yes
            2. +1
              15 August 2024 22: 49
              The Russian Guard mainly consists of former internal troops.
            3. +1
              16 August 2024 23: 29
              "What is the size of your army?
              -1 people!!!
              -And in wartime?
              -10..." (KVN, Kazakhs).
          3. +3
            15 August 2024 21: 58
            I would advise you to turn your attention to the army of Israel, which is so unloved by all of us. All of them serve military service, except for this, reservists, after military service, undergo regular training and undergo them in their units, with the weapons and equipment with which they will be fighting. So two birds with one stone are “killed” at once - and the reservists do not relax and the equipment is always in good working order and ready. Therefore, the army is combat-ready, and we have all these games with the army under contract, with the reduction of the term of military service, brought to full... I think you understand to what extent.
          4. +1
            16 August 2024 11: 59
            1/6 is the USSR, and Russia is 1/8.
            1. 0
              16 August 2024 12: 02
              Quote: KLM77
              1/6 is the USSR, and Russia is 1/8.

              Thanks for the correction. Yes, you are right, but this does not change the essence. hi
      3. +3
        15 August 2024 19: 38
        Partially staffed units needed

        In Soviet times, such units were called “cropped”
        1. 0
          16 August 2024 23: 33
          Not really. There were several states. For example, BHSOS is a storage base for senior officers (slang). A lot of equipment, a lot of officers, several soldiers... Purely for mobilization. We had 40% of the combat staff. In groups of troops it reached 75%.
      4. +3
        15 August 2024 20: 50
        It’s thanks to such figures who call the army a parasite only in our country that citizens can hate their army, if anyone doesn’t believe it, read our Russian press during the Chechen war, it’s just terrible what they wrote about the army, we have what we have now with Ukraine. The army cannot, especially in our country, which has such huge territories with such a meager population density and such violent partners, be small and compact; it must be in relation to the military-political situation that exists at the moment, taking into account global challenges and threats. and not in the dreams of some Kremlin figures, there are economic, demographic, social and other laws according to which the army must be built, this is a very complex mechanism and because it was broken by incompetent leaders, we are either reducing military schools or deploying them, the same thing with military districts, mobilization preparation and so on. It’s not possible for us to have such a small and mobile army in our country, that’s nonsense. Well, who and how carried out the military reform, I don’t even want to dwell on this, we all see the result now. We must just stop these wild experiments with the army, starting with the appointment of a civilian minister of defense, just let the military fight in a military way, without any political curtseys, crooked red lines, and so on. Victory will still be ours, we don’t burn people and don’t torture prisoners of war and Let's not shout Heil Hitler.
      5. Egg
        +4
        16 August 2024 06: 32
        Quote: Glock-17
        accept and equip reservists in case of war.

        where will the reservists come from in the absence of conscripts and 2 years of service? Do you think someone will train them in civilian life? There will be just meat, unable to do anything and voting for peace on any terms.
      6. +1
        16 August 2024 10: 50
        But we hold the National Guard. How many are there? Just over 3 million?
    2. +7
      15 August 2024 06: 28
      Moreover, much less than 140 million.
      1. -8
        15 August 2024 12: 32
        not less but more, actually 146
        1. +2
          15 August 2024 13: 06
          It’s funny that there is no one to work and the population is growing. They say all of Tojikiston is going to be resettled in Russia.
          1. -4
            15 August 2024 13: 26
            I didn’t say that it’s growing, and if it is growing, it’s due to migrants
        2. +3
          15 August 2024 16: 13
          The last full-fledged census was in 1989. Then - nonsense. IMHO, the population of indigenous peoples in Russia has long been less than 100 million.
        3. 0
          15 August 2024 22: 53
          146 is with Crimea and Sevastopol, but without Donbass, Kherson and Zaporozhye regions.
        4. 0
          16 August 2024 20: 55
          It's funny that you were downvoted for an indisputable fact. This is an indicator that the SBU tsipso is working and how many of them have penetrated here.
          The evaluation of the commentary may not be given moral significance, but for outside visitors, especially foreigners, it may look like a litmus test - like the people of Russia are oppressed, depressed, do not support or approve of the decisions of the authorities and the actions of our army. Let the enemies try to bite the fig angry
    3. +11
      15 August 2024 06: 29
      they fight not with numbers but with skill. Re-read the story, at least about Suvorov
      1. +1
        15 August 2024 22: 13
        Well, we don’t have Suvorov, we don’t have a general of victory, and if he appears, then these politicians who already called the SVO won’t give him victory and won’t dare to call a spade a spade, I’m afraid when they decide to address the people, brothers and sisters, the enemy is at the walls of Moscow There’s nowhere to retreat, get up, the country is huge.
      2. -2
        16 August 2024 12: 05
        With all due respect to A.V. Suvorov, but today the number is of great importance! Since those times, everything has changed a lot.
    4. +24
      15 August 2024 06: 36
      yes, but then you need a normal mobilization reserve. Where are the military departments at universities and military schools? Why are there not enough officers? Again, like during the Second World War - three-month officer courses.
    5. +12
      15 August 2024 06: 40
      The country cannot maintain an army of almost two million. Of which half are all sorts of secrets, and only half can defend the country.
      1. +1
        16 August 2024 10: 54
        How about 3 million National Guard members? What if we count all the security forces? What if we add officials and deputies?
        1. +2
          16 August 2024 12: 33
          Did you count everyone? RA, Ministry of Internal Affairs, etc.? To the National Guard? I have a negative attitude towards what is piled up, stolen, etc., by our rulers... But where do these numbers come from? belay
      2. +3
        16 August 2024 12: 09
        The USSR succeeded, but Russia cannot? All this can be done, but not under the current capitalist system and sky-high corruption.
        1. +1
          16 August 2024 12: 36
          Of course, it can’t. 260 million people lived in the USSR, and it was a Different Civilization. Now in Russia there are a little more than 145 million and economic, scientific, industrial opportunities are incomparable
    6. +5
      15 August 2024 07: 34
      Automation and digitalization of production is increasing every year. Labor productivity increases accordingly. If we purposefully increase the automation of production processes, then the Russian Federation can easily afford to feed an army of 3 million people in peacetime. In addition, as experience in Syria has shown, the army can bring great benefits to the economy even in peacetime. Now Wagner is promoting Russia's economic interests in Africa. Yes
      The author in the article constantly points out that Russia must liberate the entire territory of Ukraine except Galicia from Eurofascists. What's wrong with Galicia? If left, then, like Chechnya after the first war, it will be a constant source of terrorists. It is necessary to liberate the entire territory of Ukraine, and to harshly and even brutally cleanse all Bandera trash. And if one of the commentators does not like Galicia as part of Russia, then it can be presented to Old Man so that the Belarusians will take revenge on the Banderaites for their atrocities during the Second World War. In Belarus, the death penalty has not been abolished, and Bandera’s supporters can be hanged right in the squares. am good
      It is obvious that Russia is late in making decisions, and only responds to the actions of the enemy, and then belatedly.
      After the attack on the Kursk and Belgorod regions, we need to create a front line along the entire Russian-Ukrainian border and advance on the Dnieper. Forward to the West.
      1. +8
        15 August 2024 08: 42
        Quote: Bearded
        Automation and digitalization of production is increasing every year. Labor productivity increases accordingly.

        And also the complexity and high cost of military equipment. You can no longer send crowds of peasants with spears, you need a mountain of all necessary and high-tech
        1. +1
          15 August 2024 16: 07
          You can no longer send crowds of peasants with spears, you need a mountain of all necessary and high-tech
          To be fair, arming a crowd of peasants with spears was also not cheap, and they learned to do this already in the late Middle Ages, when metallurgy more or less appeared, and not the extremely labor-intensive hammering of a hammer. And even if a peasant fights, he doesn’t plow, a wild loss for the feudal lord
      2. +13
        15 August 2024 10: 06
        Automation and digitalization of production is increasing every year.

        In Russia, the number of industrial robots is only 11 per 10 workers. This is an extremely low figure. In some Mexico it’s even 000 times higher. And the pace of change is also far behind the world average.
        1. +1
          15 August 2024 15: 27
          A plant director I know five years ago flew to NY to attend an exhibition of industrial equipment. Sharing his impressions, he said that it is easier for him to hire a dozen migrants than to install robots at an exorbitant price
          1. -1
            15 August 2024 18: 52
            What is NY, write in Russian.
            1. +1
              15 August 2024 21: 45
              New York..............
          2. +2
            15 August 2024 18: 59
            In the Russian Federation it is a horse, but there it is quite sane and justified.
          3. +2
            16 August 2024 10: 44
            Yes, robots only pay off at very large scales of production. But very large scales only happen when markets are open, which is why there are few robots in Russia.
        2. +3
          16 August 2024 10: 42
          You can't judge by robots alone. Robotization is highly dependent on the industry and its scale. Automation is greatest in the automotive industry and microelectronics, where the scale of production is measured in tens of millions. There are many automobile assembly plants in Mexico that serve the entire American market from Chile to Canada. And even in the best years of detente with the West, our automotive industry worked for the domestic market and a little in the CIS. Because the sales markets are divided.
          1. +1
            16 August 2024 11: 14
            Robotization is highly dependent on the industry and its scale.

            The key factor is wages. The cost of a robot's working hour is 5-8 euros (despite the fact that the cost of the robots themselves has fallen by 20% over the decade). In China, the cost of a worker's hour is 10 euros, in Germany - 40 euros.
      3. +8
        15 August 2024 14: 07
        In Russia, labor productivity is only falling - the reasons are: growing bureaucratization, clumsiness of the authorities and superiors, appointed not on the principle of efficiency and professionalism, but on the principle of loyalty and nepotism, ineffective legality and hence the poor business climate and a general atmosphere of disinterest.
      4. +5
        15 August 2024 15: 24
        Curious what the campaign in Syria brought to the Russian economy? Or the presence of musicians in Mali? By the way, for the operation of Soviet enterprises in Mongolia there was absolutely no need for serious armed forces on its territory
    7. log
      -2
      15 August 2024 07: 44
      If you want to live, you won’t get so excited!
    8. +16
      15 August 2024 09: 01
      Cartalon
      A country with a population of 140 million cannot keep 3 million under arms in peacetime.

      1. Why in a country with an area of ​​more than 17 million square meters? km. only 140 million? Has anyone thought about this in the last 30 years? Has anyone seriously tried to solve the country’s demographic problem (the import of “valuable specialists” from the south does not count)?
      2. Someone very persistently, for decades, has been saying that the country needs a “compact professional army.”
      1. +11
        15 August 2024 09: 27
        “We’ll buy what we need” - the motto of the liberalists after the collapse of the USSR. Because the sovereign country ended, and in the food chain of the globalists Russia was relegated to the fate of a raw materials appendage.
        The central bank again issued an analysis that the production of Russian aircraft in Russia is not profitable.
        And someone constantly says that “we are not the 37th generation.” That is, he doesn’t really want to “front” against Russia’s “stable” in the world system.
        It is strange that communist China can, but liberal Russia cannot.
        Very strange. Nobody in the Russian government wants to understand “why”.
        1. +3
          15 August 2024 11: 45
          The central bank again issued an analysis that the production of Russian aircraft in Russia is not profitable.

          Of course. The laws of economics are the same for everyone. It’s always profitable when you produce hundreds of airplanes, and not only for yourself...
          It is strange that communist China can, but liberal Russia cannot.

          It’s also strange why China is still called “communist” and Russia “liberal”, because neither one nor the other has been true for a long time.
        2. +2
          15 August 2024 15: 29
          Only one name remains from communism in China. Capitalism there is very harsh
          1. +1
            15 August 2024 20: 06
            Try saying this in China, let's see what happens...
            1. +3
              15 August 2024 21: 48
              Nobody likes an unpleasant truth. What doesn't make a lie true? There is nothing left of communism in China.
      2. +3
        16 August 2024 11: 13
        Quote: Doccor18
        2. Someone very persistently, for decades, has been saying that the country needs a “compact professional army.”

        At the same time, forgetting the second part “and mobile reserves in case of a major war.”
        It was precisely this kind of army that Makarov tried to create - from the skeletons of formations from the times of the USSR, where a permanent readiness division could field a maximum reinforced regiment, and the flying air regiments had one squadron. It was planned to combine a contract army of permanently ready brigades fully staffed by contract soldiers and a mobile reserve that underwent year-long training in training centers and formations.
        And then everything went to pieces. Under slogans about saving and trampling on the glorious traditions of their grandfathers, the brigades of the new system were filled with conscripts and staffed their rear and auxiliary units, which ruined the whole idea of ​​formations of constant readiness, fully coordinated in peacetime and capable of carrying out tasks of various kinds in full force and without mobilization "operations". And then the brigades were deployed back to divisions - and again they got 2007: on paper - a division, but only a regimental group can be sent into battle.
        1. +2
          16 August 2024 11: 27
          These division-brigade-division throwings cannot be expressed without obscenity. How much effort, time and money was wasted, but in the end it’s not clear what they wanted at all? Two dozen brigades for almost an entire continent? Yes, this is not even funny... Two dozen divisions - that’s all right, that’s the minimum...
          It was planned to combine a contract army from permanently ready brigades fully staffed by contract soldiers and a mobile reserve

          I may be wrong, but the divisional structure is still closer and clearer to me, it seems more rational and logical for our vast country than the brigade structure. If only as single, highly specialized, mountain, air assault...
          1. +3
            16 August 2024 16: 34
            Quote: Doccor18
            How much effort, time and money was wasted, but in the end it’s not clear what they wanted at all? Two dozen brigades for almost an entire continent?

            They wanted a two-component army.
            Two dozen brigades are constantly ready for low- and medium-intensity conflicts. So that in peacetime they study military affairs in a real way in full force. And not like the “Ivanovo” divisions of “constant readiness”, from which the personnel units learned to the best of their abilities, and imitated the same communication during exercises with mobile phones.
            And in wartime, these brigades had to move out at any moment and fight in full force. Instead of scraping together a combined regimental hodgepodge from the division and then waiting until the mob squad arrives and begins to look at the departments entrusted to it like a ram at a new gate.
            Why brigades? But because the budget of 20 divisions of constant readiness would not last. But it was impossible to get by with fewer connections - the distance between the connections was too large. Before my eyes then was the experience of 08.08.08/XNUMX/XNUMX, when the reserve had to be dragged all the way from Volgograd, and it never made it to the battles.
            And for major conflicts, it was planned to train mobile reserves on the basis of training centers and training units. With periodic collections and deployment of emergency equipment.
    9. +6
      15 August 2024 13: 54
      A country with a population of 140 million cannot keep 3 million under arms in peacetime.

      I’m afraid that in Russia, if you count all the security forces, there are now at least 3 million with weapons, although not all of these squires were effective.
    10. +6
      15 August 2024 14: 46
      If you can't feed your army, you'll feed someone else's.

      Why are we investing hundreds of billions of dollars in the papers of a potential enemy? Why do we trade gold?
      There are many more reasons to ask the current government.

      Now it is quite likely that there will be either internal turmoil in Prinozhin-2 or the surrender of its territory.

      It is not Russia that sets the agenda in geopolitics today.
      1. -8
        15 August 2024 15: 30
        What kind of gold? Where are we trading?
        1. +4
          15 August 2024 18: 05
          Don't you know? We sell on the stock exchange in London.
        2. 0
          18 August 2024 00: 11
          Do you remember an incident about 2 years ago (the SVO had just begun)? When, in my opinion, Sheremetyevo, 2 gold bars of 1 kg each were found on the runway, lost!!!!! when loading onto the plane (were you in such a hurry?))))? The flight was just to London. And (as they said a couple of times in the news, but then they quickly glossed over this topic) it was a private person who took it out...
    11. +5
      15 August 2024 16: 03
      The biggest parasite is the Ministry of Defense, the General Staff and their contractors. You can reduce the army several times, but these will continue to steal like crazy
    12. +2
      16 August 2024 09: 34
      And most importantly, where can wrestlers find so much money? Other oligarchs will not give a penny for the maintenance of such a huge (3 million) contract army. And for the conscript army to be effective, the socio-political model must be changed. Oligarchic capitalism cannot stimulate honest service to the Motherland. Cleanliness is at the core of everything, at the bottom too.
      1. +1
        16 August 2024 10: 01
        Dear, the most effective conscript army in history is the Prussian and later German army between 1860 and 1945.
      2. +2
        16 August 2024 11: 15
        Quote: Essex62
        And for the conscript army to be effective, the socio-political model must be changed. Oligarchic capitalism cannot stimulate honest service to the Motherland.

        The Israel Defense Forces look around frantically - not understanding when capitalism was abolished in the Promised Land. laughing
        1. +1
          17 August 2024 02: 24
          There is no need to compare. The IDF, together with all of Israel, has been sitting on a powder keg since its founding. Every Abram and every Raquel has an understanding in their livers that if you don’t militarize, your guts will be released instantly. She is unique. A conscious choice, almost primitive.
  3. +24
    15 August 2024 05: 50
    I agree with the author of the article. This is a test of Russia's actions in case of a NATO invasion!
    Rehearsal, only with “hands”, or rather heads and the Armed Forces of Ukraine.
    We're convinced. We did our homework.
    And we should prepare to repel NATO forces preparing to attack Russia.
    1. +27
      15 August 2024 06: 44
      I agree. But there is a nuance. There will be no sign of the collapse of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. If nothing changes in our actions. And yes, to a certain extent, we managed to change the mood of a significant part of society towards the Military Military District. The negative side
      1. +6
        15 August 2024 09: 00
        And yes, to a certain extent it was possible to change the mood of a significant part of society towards the NWO. The negative side

        There are always many ways to appease the electorate: pull political strings, push financial levers, pit one electorate against another, and so on. The chosen ones always remain at the top, and the clash of bubbling feces always occurs at the bottom. And the more the feces collide, the greater the benefits for the true masters of the world.
      2. +4
        15 August 2024 16: 28
        And yes, to a certain extent it was possible to change the mood of a significant part of society towards the NWO. The negative side
        rather, the mood towards the state has changed. That it is constantly stirring up something and at the same time is incompetent and does not want to do anything with its incompetence and will not do anything
    2. +6
      15 August 2024 08: 52
      And we should prepare to repel NATO forces preparing to attack Russia.

      As experience shows, preparing for reflection means losing. It is necessary to forestall NATO in its deployment and, first, to liquidate their Baltic bridgehead with the forces of the Union State.
      The secrecy of preparations can be ensured through mobilization in connection with the situation on the Ukrainian front, and the main forces are concentrated, with a large role for Belarus. Then, using the developed road network, at hour H these troops should be transferred to the north and immediately invade Lithuania and Latvia.
      Another group should be concentrated in the Leningrad and Pskov regions for operations from the east.
      In the upcoming operation, the role of the Air Force and Airborne Forces is extremely important, which must not only block the transfer of reinforcements, but also capture Moonsund to place covering tactical nuclear weapons on them.
      I will not write about the political mechanism for the return of the Baltic States to its native harbor, as well as about diplomatic cover, since this issue was worked out back in 1940.
      Only an offensive strategy can lead to victory, and giving the enemy the initiative simultaneously with an increase in the density of troops on the border will lead to a repetition of the tragedy of 1941. The enemy, using all reconnaissance capabilities, will always choose the places and times of paralyzing strikes to develop a general offensive.
      1. +5
        15 August 2024 10: 11
        As experience shows, preparing for reflection means losing. It is necessary to forestall NATO in its deployment and, first, to liquidate their Baltic bridgehead with the forces of the Union State.

        Then, using the developed road network, at hour H these troops should be transferred to the north and immediately invade Lithuania and Latvia.

        And then what?
        I keep my statistics on the number of people in the country who can think beyond a day.
        1. -4
          15 August 2024 10: 13
          Next is Ukraine.
          After the first shock (a la Czechoslovakia in 1968), NATO will have no time for them.
          1. +5
            15 August 2024 10: 18
            Next is Ukraine.

            And this is what day after
            immediately invade Lithuania and Latvia

            ?
            NATO will have no time for them.

            What will they care about?
            1. -5
              15 August 2024 10: 27
              Right away.
              In a serious situation, they can only evacuate; there are plenty of examples.
              Well, think out the whole strategy yourself. At the same time, take into account their main fear.
              To do this, they did not allow the creation of a real Union State led by Lukashenko in the late 90s.
        2. +2
          16 August 2024 08: 47
          Well, you want a lot from the local dreamer. He had already defeated all the enemies here with powerful cutting blows. And in almost every topic lol
      2. -1
        18 August 2024 00: 25
        Maybe enough of the “wet” fantasies? I, too, sometimes before going to bed, win the Crimean War with the subsequent blockade of England (by organizing the construction of battleships of the 30s of the 20th century, the production of hundreds of thousands of Mosin rifles and the training of troops according to the USSR regulations of the 50s-60s), then I tell Stalin about the commander’s a turret on a T-34, an intermediate cartridge and I sing Vysotsky’s songs to him.))) a good way to fall asleep faster when problems pile up in real life. )))) But I don’t voice all this out loud in sentences on the Kremlin websites)))
    3. -4
      15 August 2024 17: 16
      Russia cannot be occupied by force; the author does not understand simple things. No one can control such a territory. But yes, buy the elite. This is what Putin is countering...not an easy task...
  4. +30
    15 August 2024 05: 50
    Evgeniy Viktorovich was 100 percent right when he cursed at famous personalities... time has put everything in its place.
    Now that it has become clear who is to blame, the eternal question arises: what to do?
    Wagner and his paratroopers again distinguished themselves in battle by destroying 7 “bucephali” of the Ukrainian Armed Forces.
    I still hope that the Defense Ministry will finally understand that a modern war with NATO and the Armed Forces of Ukraine requires completely different approaches to military affairs. Now we need to act proactively, imposing our rules of war on the enemy and not wait for the enemy to hit where it hurts.
    1. +7
      15 August 2024 07: 24
      ...Now we need to act proactively, imposing our rules of war on the enemy and not wait for the enemy to hit where it hurts.


      Good idea.
      But with whom to lead the action?
      With the "lesser of two evils"?
    2. +4
      15 August 2024 16: 41
      I still hope that the Defense Ministry will finally understand that a modern war with NATO and the Armed Forces of Ukraine requires completely different approaches to military affairs.
      They will understand, they will come out together with the General Staff and say - we don’t know how to do anything except puff up our cheeks and steal! Although we steal in such a way that the blind can see... In general, we are all in prison and on pensions, and instead of us, these are these ideological majors and colonels. But before that, the cancer must whistle three times on the mountain
  5. The comment was deleted.
  6. +16
    15 August 2024 05: 55
    [quote] this report was a response: “Don’t panic, and in general it’s best to see from above.”
  7. +19
    15 August 2024 06: 04
    The main reason is not the size of the army, but the fact that we have wasted the “buffer” (Ukraine). We didn’t even have ambassadors in Ukraine, professional diplomats.
    1. +9
      15 August 2024 06: 29
      Chernomyrdin could only bleat that Banderaism was bad, but there was no real leverage. Although at that time it was possible to influence, if not ideologically, then economically.
    2. +21
      15 August 2024 06: 45
      They screwed up all their neighbors. By the way, even Belarus to a certain extent.
  8. +32
    15 August 2024 06: 04
    I agree with every letter of the article. The current Russian elite is not capable of leading countries and people to victory. Here it is either defeat and collapse of the country, or a change in the elite. There is no other option.

    Absolutely wild and unacceptable slowness in decision-making, often outright negligence and sometimes clearly visible betrayal when trying to put on a good face in a bad game got to everyone.
    1. +17
      15 August 2024 07: 26
      Well, finally, at least someone said the truth! The elite definitely needs to be changed. And the sooner the better. These are 100% traitors
      1. +3
        15 August 2024 16: 22
        Do you think the elite is elective? It changes only through revolutionary means. This means civil war, unrest, intervention and other joys...
    2. +2
      15 August 2024 09: 15
      Here it is either defeat and collapse of the country, or a change in the elite. There is no other option.

      Absolutely wild and unacceptable slowness in decision-making, often outright negligence and sometimes clearly visible betrayal when trying to put on a good face in a bad game got to everyone.


      As the old GRU instructor in combat psychology said, if everything is done correctly, the enemy will be let down by the rule of three pros: one forgot, the second scored, the third fell asleep... very relevant.
    3. +2
      15 August 2024 19: 59
      Here it is either defeat and collapse of the country, or a change in the elite.

      The thought is sound, but... One thought haunts me. Does this elite even have a first name, last name and position? Chubais should not be offered.
  9. +32
    15 August 2024 06: 16
    Perhaps the “cream” of youth, the product of liberal democracy, will run again. But whose youth are these? There is another one - and there is more of it. But without unity and involvement, as during the Second World War, there will be no victory.
    Yeah, that is. according to the author, let the “cream” of youth go, and the capital and capitalists, the fathers of these youth, will be protected by other youth, whose fathers only have loans and mortgages. “The cream”, not long ago in Feodosia, crippled a Russian guy, if If migrants did this, all the authors of VO would call for revenge, and if the cream did it, that’s in the order of things. Russian cream can do what they want.
    The state must urgently abandon the destructive liberal raw materials model.
    Bees are against honey.
  10. +24
    15 August 2024 06: 16
    It is very doubtful that Russia needs an Army of 3 million; it’s just that with such a large Army, the country will “go down the drain.” The problem is actually within the country.
    Our Shoigs are “friends” with the Abramovichs, the Peskovs with the Ivanovs...., here an Army of even 5 million will be “powerless”.
  11. +28
    15 August 2024 06: 17
    NATO, through the hands of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, will inflict a significant military and, most importantly (!), reputational blow on us. After all, we are, after all, the second army in the world!

    In order for the second (third or hundredth) army to fully realize its potential, it must be led by commanders corresponding to this army.
    An army of rams led by a lion will always defeat an army of lions led by a ram
    (Napoleon Bonaparte)
  12. +22
    15 August 2024 06: 22
    The state must urgently abandon the destructive liberal raw materials model. Not to “grind”, but to win.

    Guys, democrats, what is a “state”, it is not like a reasonable or stupid “Godzilla”, it is the power that created the laws. Who owns power in modern Russia? Let's not deceive ourselves - the oligarchs, that is, the owners of factories, newspapers and steamships. Where did they come from? As a result of a pro-Western anti-constitutional coup d'etat, deceiving the people with “democracy” and the “CIS” as a renewal of the Soviet Union. We received predatory privatization and the collapse of a great country, which was overrun by Western agents. Those who betrayed their country to please their carcass are essentially agents of foreign influence, just like everything else in the West and with the West. What then should we expect now? The state is no longer a people's state, and we have capitalism, with a bunch of legalized thieves, bandits and renegade traitors. Therefore, we have what we have.
    1. +8
      15 August 2024 07: 36
      We rise from our knees according to the Constitution written to us!!! At the expense of the oppressed but conscious part of society. How long will this resource last? He is being exterminated in all possible ways on the basis of the Constitution, i.e. in law!
      1. +9
        15 August 2024 08: 51
        Quote: klev72
        How long will this resource last?
        Is there another choice, if we talk about preserving Russia? Everything is “feng shui”, the sale of raw materials and Soviet military developments, the failure of healthcare, science, education, but everything is presented as great achievements, during holidays and fireworks. Only what is done is impossible not to do, but how is it done if you take the SVO...
        Puffing up cheeks, ostentatiously butting heads with dear Western “partners”, with the dream of making peace and living as before, without sanctions. In fact, the West is doing more good for Russia than our moneybags, because without these sanctions, no one would have remembered their industry and agriculture. The United States is about to abandon Russian uranium, for God’s sake. It was we who had to introduce retaliatory sanctions against them and cut off everything critically important to them, such as uranium or titanium.
        But we even continue to pump gas to our enemies in Ukraine, and we will if they don’t blow up this pipe themselves.
        No, democrat guys, with this reality Russia will come to ruin. We spend tons of ammunition on the Northern Military District, what is left in the arsenals in case of a big war? If the last nuclear trump card remains, will it be used against dear Western “partners”? Question...
        There is a war going on, blood has been shed, the hour of truth is coming, as Mr. Comrade Gorbachev said, “who is xu” will be shown soon. Russia should be like a great country or become a colony.
      2. +7
        15 August 2024 08: 56
        We rise from our knees according to the Constitution written to us!!!

        Who wrote the Constitution? Miners? Combine operators? Builders? Cooks, each of whom can rule the state? Or, after all, by those who climbed up? Like all other laws, has anyone ever actually read it? I recommend reading it in your spare time, interesting stuff! There are so many interesting things there! Just don’t be surprised if questions start to arise as you read. For example: “Where is all this?” or “Why does this point contradict this?” Because the main thing is not what is written in a huge pile of laws and regulations, but who stamps them, who interprets and makes decisions on them. That is, whose interests they actually represent, and not in a beautiful little book. Here is a simple example - Chapter 1: “The generally recognized principles and norms of international law and international treaties of the Russian Federation are an integral part of its legal system. If an international treaty of the Russian Federation establishes rules other than those provided by law, then the rules of the international treaty apply.” What does this mean? Here's what! If, for example, the UN or some other international agency decides that speaking Russian, for example, is intolerant towards Caucasians and Asians, of whom we have more and more every month, then we will have to submit. Nonsense, of course, but according to the constitution it turns out that way.
  13. 0
    15 August 2024 06: 24
    And that’s why the enemies of the USSR couldn’t live in peace? They had equal and mutually beneficial relationships with the enemies of the USSR in the West and Europe; 50 world leaders came to them for Victory Parades. But no, they decided to destroy it all. And why? Certainly not for the good of our country and people.
    1. +7
      15 August 2024 06: 52
      How why? Read Lenin, “Imperialism as the Highest Stage of Capitalism”
      1. -7
        15 August 2024 06: 54
        What does Lenin have to do with it? The enemies of the USSR first became friends with the enemies of the USSR in the West, and then sharply quarreled with them, and are not even able to explain why, for what and for whom, what specific benefit this will bring to our country and people.
        1. 0
          15 August 2024 08: 44
          Quote: tatra
          What does Lenin have to do with it? The enemies of the USSR first became friends with the enemies of the USSR in the West, and then sharply quarreled with them, and are not even able to explain why, for what and for whom, what specific benefit this will bring to our country and people.

          Russia began to restore its economic potential and army, which made the leader want to return the territories of the USSR. They will expand and press all over the world. But this no longer fit into NATO’s plans and they did not need the revival of the USSR
          1. 0
            15 August 2024 11: 09
            Firstly, nothing is recovering economically there, on the contrary, in the last 10-12 years the economy is worse than in the 2012s, and he himself, in his speech about “galoshes” in XNUMX, admitted that there is an economic crisis in the Russian Federation, and since then everything is only getting worse.
            Secondly, he doesn’t need any USSR, all this is his offense, he himself admitted that if it weren’t for the coup in Ukraine in 2014, when Yanukovych was overthrown, he wouldn’t have needed Crimea.
            1. +2
              15 August 2024 13: 45
              Quote: tatra
              Firstly, nothing is recovering economically there; on the contrary, in the last 10-12 years the economy has been worse

              So this is already a time of hostility and confrontation. And the recovery is zero
              1. 0
                15 August 2024 13: 49
                The 2000s are a FREEBIE from the sharply increased world prices for the export of Russian natural resources and raw materials, and from the huge income from them, Putin raised salaries and pensions well, people began to buy more goods, products, services, and from this the economy grew.
                And when world prices became lower, our economy became worse, because real inflation became greater than the increase in wages and pensions.
                1. +1
                  15 August 2024 16: 50
                  Quote: tatra
                  Zero is a FREE

                  A freebie that gave mountains of money for the army, as well as foreign policy. Russia began to actively bully, the war in Georgia became a turning point there.
            2. +2
              15 August 2024 15: 35
              Oil just ran out at $178
  14. +5
    15 August 2024 06: 34
    The end of the Ukrainian Armed Forces is a dangerous illusion. This is a simple “misconception” of the liberal and also foreign media, which work against us and create dangerous illusions. Nobody wants to receive bad news, but the truth is always needed everywhere. And now Western media are racing to criticize the raid - supposedly there is no point. And even if the incoming Ukrainian Armed Forces are destroyed, the meaning and benefit for NATO is undeniable.


    The author’s conclusion is absolutely correct.... The aggression of the “West” is based on unlimited generated finances, the gradual replacement of the “AFU” with mercenaries and non-Soviet weapons systems.
  15. +7
    15 August 2024 06: 39
    You can, of course, be a total optimist - but it is clear that if stage 1 cancer is easy to treat, then stage 4 cancer - you can only desperately believe in a miracle (though it happens once in a million).
    The management started playing at costume balls in the Catherine style - and decided that the gas station they had built was indeed the dominant one in Europe.
    A country with huge borders. Along the borders it is slowly but steadily becoming restless - all sorts of ... countries, Armenia. It is impossible to maintain an army capable of covering the entire country, the economy is not the same, the programs of the Ministry of Education are not the same, the productions in theaters and television are not the same.
    This SVO is a small test of the coincidence of virtual reality, built for us by the media, with reality.
    It doesn't match very well.
    And the problem is not just with the “elite”. She left behind a destroyed real economy, the mentality of thieves, migrants and sanctions.
    ONLY school graduates, due to their illiteracy, really believe that one small country, under the conditions of sanctions, is capable of building the entire economy in the long term. Illusions about “friends” like China also remain only among schoolchildren.
    And THERE, in 2 years, the shares of military enterprises have grown sharply - there is money, production is being modernized and not for supplies to Ukraine. And for the future 5-10 years.
    And what do we expect for the next 5-10 years???
  16. +24
    15 August 2024 06: 52
    Guys, stop driving the canoe. The USSR had a huge army of 3,7 million and powerful weapons. And there was money for the Army, free education and housing because we didn’t have the oligarchs Deripaska Abramovich and other ballast. The state had the money. And until we have a powerful army and Until we get rid of the oligarchy, everything will be as it is. And it will end in complete collapse and it is already happening, which is what I have been writing for a long time. Who wants this?
    1. +11
      15 August 2024 07: 13
      A powerful Army against an external enemy. But for Russia, the internal enemy is terrible - these are the Abramivochs, Deripaskas, Shoigas, Surkovs... and here the Army is powerless. I am not saying that a strong Army is not needed, but other structures must fight the internal enemy.
      1. +14
        15 August 2024 07: 35
        But for Russia, the internal enemy is terrible - these are the Abramivochs, Deripaskas, Shoigis, Surkovs...

        The winner of the honorable first place was missed.
        1. +6
          15 August 2024 07: 39
          I was “embarrassed” to name the winner of the honorable first place. Still, I want to hope and believe that at least he is for the Russian State. hi
      2. +4
        15 August 2024 09: 44
        in the absence of ideology, it is very difficult to determine who the enemy is and how to fight him, alas.
    2. +8
      15 August 2024 07: 47
      Quote: Alexander Odintsov
      Guys, stop driving the canoe. The USSR had a huge army of 3,7 million and powerful weapons
      Only the population was twice as large and there were no contract soldiers, who cost much more than ordinary conscripts. I’m already silent about the developed industry, which could provide this army with everything necessary
      1. -3
        15 August 2024 10: 17
        It’s not true about contract soldiers.
        There were very much, as if not as much as now. They just weren’t shining, and they weren’t particularly noticeable against the backdrop of 4 million.
      2. +2
        16 August 2024 11: 25
        Quote: Stirbjorn
        Only the population was twice as large and there were no contract soldiers, who cost much more than ordinary conscripts.

        He-he-he... it’s just that in the USSR contract soldiers were replaced by officers who were shoved into positions that in the West are occupied by all sorts of sergeants and warrants (technical knowledge + responsibility). There are rumors that the overabundance of officers in the crews of nuclear submarines appeared because Comrade Gorshkov sincerely believed that the sailors did not need to be paid - and after two years of training and gaining experience, they served for another year - and went on demobilization, exposing their combat posts.
    3. +1
      15 August 2024 08: 24
      Alexander
      You are right, the oligarchs are the very agents of Western influence within the Russian Federation. As food for thought, news from 09.08.2024/XNUMX/XNUMX interview with Nikkei Asia Oleg Deripaska said:
      When asked about relations with Russian leader Vladimir Putin, Deripaska refused to answer. “No changes,” he answered shortly.
      “They [the Kremlin] don’t touch me, we don’t touch politics,” the entrepreneur added.
      hi
      1. -2
        15 August 2024 17: 12
        Quote: Gomunkul
        oligarchs are the very agents of influence of the West

        Thieving generals and ministers are not oligarchs, are they?
        And who are the “directors” of supposedly nationalized enterprises?
    4. +7
      15 August 2024 08: 43
      until we get rid of the oligarchy
      Let's get rid of the oligarchs and live in a bright capitalist present, without oligarchs. laughing If you decide to get rid of the oligarchs, you also need to get rid of the social system that has established itself in Russia.
      1. 0
        15 August 2024 17: 29
        By the way, there are no oligarchs in Kazakhstan; everything there belongs to Western capitalists. And the state can’t do anything about it at all.
    5. +5
      15 August 2024 09: 15
      All enemies know that Russia can only be defeated from within! Therefore, order must first be restored at home, and then dealt with along the outer contour of the borders. We are being torn apart precisely for the reason that we are not allowed to calmly concentrate on development goals, decide and write anew - to adopt the basic law of the country, the Constitution! There are countries that don’t have it at all, and there are those who have changed it several times over 30 years! They have prepared for us a swamp of push-pull self-destruction. The lower classes cannot, the upper classes do not want to. Classic! The time to change the Constitution or lose statehood is approaching and woe to the blind.
      1. +3
        15 August 2024 10: 16
        You're right. We are now being defeated from within, brazenly and easily - by corrupt officials, oligarchs, feeding officials, etc. However, there comes a time when our internal weakness can be converted into real external blows. And this moment has now come. It is visible in Kursk.
        1. +2
          15 August 2024 10: 41
          Quote: Alexander Odintsov
          And this moment has now come. It is visible in Kursk.

          What happened was cruel, impudent (on the part of the enemy), and, indicatively (the 1000th anniversary of Suzdal seemed to be more important for our government). It seems that the events in Kursk are the beginning of the end, either of an incompetent, henpecked government, or of Russia itself. There was information about the Banderaites preparing a “dirty bomb”; even more than that, everything was already ready for use. This will be the final test of the reaction of our leadership, if they start chewing snot in the name of peace and humanism, we can assume that NATO will be drawn into the conflict.
          1. +3
            15 August 2024 11: 29
            Ours will burn down the Ukrainian Armed Forces just a matter of time and price. But we have not yet seen a clear response from the state and the leadership to all this, our latest humiliation. This is alarming. It cannot be ruled out that all this grinding is being done to instill in us the weakness syndrome. So that the threshold for society's perception of our failures falls below the plinth. Then, if anything, negotiations are not far away, although now everyone is saying the opposite.
            1. +7
              15 August 2024 11: 55
              You know, Alexander, it seems that everything is going according to the scenario already written for us. We are losing people, both civilians and our own soldiers, equipment is deteriorating and being lost, and arsenals are being emptied. Finally, in essence, Russians are killing Russians. What could we offer Ukraine, our oligarchs instead of theirs? We have no bright ideology, by and large, no national idea. The consumer society, the cult of money, if we take this as a basis, then this ideal, fetish, for Ukraine itself is more attractive directly with the West than with its capitalist lackeys.
              Now SVO, everything could have been resolved in 2014, but...
              Russian President Vladimir Putin, after a meeting with the current OSCE Chairman Didier Burkhalter, made several important and unexpected statements on the situation in Ukraine. First, Putin informed the world community that Russia had withdrawn its troops from the borders of Ukraine. Secondly, he suggested that the southeastern rebels postpone the referendum on self-determination of their regions scheduled for May 11. In addition, the president emphasized that early presidential elections in Ukraine are “movement in the right direction,” and that there is no “key to solving problems in Ukraine” in Moscow and never has been.

              Why, why did we leave the legal field, and, having recognized the junta, allowed it to be legalized, after which Crimea already became annexation, and the belated North Military District became aggression.
              Is that how it was intended? Well, then everything is going according to plan... It is not our oligarchs that are a threat to the West, but the residual Soviet nuclear missile potential. Russia is still the only country in the world that can destroy the United States. Our traitors cannot simply surrender - the people and the army will not understand, but, bringing the matter to a head, and handing over the nuclear missile shield under external control, to the shameful ultimatum of the West, may be the final goal, from the starting point in 1991 . Here, it’s either us or us.
              1. +4
                15 August 2024 14: 09
                You are right, I have the same opinion. The script has been written for us and we are following it. But its ending is not completely clear. Why did we so cheerfully save the Takaev regime in Kazakhstan, but did not provide similar assistance to Yanukovych, giving him completely bad advice? Was it really impossible to clear Kyiv of thousands of nationalists? Why didn’t we support the Russian Spring of 2014, when the Ukrainian Armed Forces did not leave the cauldron to the cauldron. Why did we let the fascist vermin raise its head without destroying it in 2014, when in a significant part of Ukraine we could have been greeted with flowers? Because our country is hostage to world trade and the oligarchic economy. Nothing will soon be a terrible bummer for them. We are waiting for May 9, 2025. Everything will be different at this parade.
    6. 0
      15 August 2024 09: 41
      Quote: Alexander Odintsov
      And it will end in complete collapse and it is already happening, which is what I have been writing for a long time. Who wants this?

      There is nothing to add, you are right about everything.
    7. -1
      16 August 2024 01: 57
      "The USSR had a huge army of 3,7 million and powerful weapons" ///
      ----
      Did it help in the Afghan war?
      9 years of the Afghan war + a sharp, many-fold drop in oil prices,
      which was exported to Western Europe and provided foreign currency.
      And that’s it - no USSR.
      1. 0
        16 August 2024 15: 14
        Why distort logic? Afghan - special operation. We are talking about the protection of borders: whoever came to us? But the United States lost in Vietnam, and who was behind Vietnam?
        1. +1
          16 August 2024 17: 31
          Not only me, but also other participants in the discussion are trying to explain to you:
          maintaining a huge army in peacetime is a guaranteed path to default (bankruptcy, collapse) any country.
          No one will interfere, it won’t be necessary - the country itself will go bankrupt from the exorbitant costs of maintaining the army
          1. 0
            20 August 2024 21: 06
            This is a wrong point of view. Classical economists also wrote that the economy does not incur productive costs. But the army is security. He who does not feed his own army will feed someone else's!
  17. +2
    15 August 2024 06: 56
    Currently, the official expenditures of the Ministry of Defense amount to about 6 trillion rubles. per year.
    Unofficially, of course, even more, all regions bear a significant additional burden of supplying contract soldiers, purchasing equipment, etc.
    An army of 3 million people will cost 16 trillion rubles.
    And the country’s entire budget is only 36 trillion.
    But there is also the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Russian Guard, the FSB, the Federal Penitentiary Service, the Investigative Committee, and the Prosecutor's Office. That's a few more trillion.
    Can the country's economy withstand such a load? Are there any economic calculations on this topic?
    1. +2
      15 August 2024 07: 09
      The logic is great. That is, Katz offers to surrender. When it comes to preserving the country, is money the determining factor? We need to think about victory, in my opinion, and then about the peace budget. Therefore, at all times, the fastest achievement of victory was the main goal. You can't fight forever. From this point of view, the concept of SVO in its current form is disastrous.
      1. 0
        15 August 2024 07: 33
        But none of those who talk and write about victory can explain how it can be achieved based on the real situation, and not “sneaky tricks,” and no one can explain what such a huge benefit all this has brought to our country and the people.
        For now, these people have nothing else but AGAINST.
      2. +3
        15 August 2024 07: 44
        The power of any army is finite, and is determined only by the scientific and economic potential of the country. Everything else is fantasy.
        In order to triple the size of the army, it is necessary to triple its technical support. We need to build a couple more tank factories, three aviation, automobile, etc.
        Today our military-industrial complex already works in 3 shifts, seven days a week.
        Enterprises today have a staffing crisis. No one to work. For known reasons.
        To build one new large plant you need at least 3 years and 1 trillion rubles.
        What will we arm the additional 2 million people with?
        Today, even Channel One shows very outdated weapons in its reports on LBS. Where is the new technology?
        1. -5
          15 August 2024 09: 25
          To Deripaska. We must give up.
          1. +6
            15 August 2024 09: 34
            We have to give up
            Some naive person, you seem to believe that we have democracy and the millionaire deputies sitting in the State Duma express the aspirations of ordinary workers, Deripaska’s interests, they express them. They themselves cannot say, apparently they are embarrassed, so Deripaska expressed the will of the ruling class. This just as during the years of the Paris Commune, the bourgeoisie of France no longer wanted to fight the Germans, but ordinary French people had the desire, on the basis of these contradictions the Paris Commune of 1871 arose, its fate is sad.
            1. 0
              15 August 2024 10: 05
              This is not naivety, but objectivity. It is possible to evacuate 180 thousand people from the Kursk region, but it will not be possible to evacuate it all. The population will not understand. Therefore we will have to fight.
              1. +1
                15 August 2024 10: 23
                It is possible to evacuate 180 thousand people from the Kursk region, but it will not be possible to evacuate it all.

                You underestimate our top talents!
                You cannot evacuate and leave it to the enemy. Put a comma.
                The population won't understand.

                They will ask you to be understanding, there are funds available.
                Therefore we will have to fight

                You will have to, and not only for this reason.
              2. +5
                15 August 2024 10: 31
                Correct objectivity, the bourgeois government will hand us over, don’t have too much patience.
                The population won't understand.

                The population reacted with understanding to the pension reform and will react with understanding here.
      3. 0
        15 August 2024 15: 42
        Are. During war, everything is decided by money, money and more money. In direct or indirect form. Without injections into the Ukrainian economy, the Russian Army parade on Khreshchatyk would have taken place long ago
    2. +2
      15 August 2024 07: 14
      Can the country's economy withstand such a load?


      Suggest giving up?

      What if “fat cats” are put on a diet? Have you considered this option?
      1. +3
        15 August 2024 07: 34
        And who will plant it? The one who bred these “fat cats”?
      2. +1
        15 August 2024 07: 49
        What does it mean to cut fat cats? Gop-wait, did we come around the corner? ))
        Expropriate all businesses like in 1917?
        Do you want a new civil war? Think about what you are offering!
        Billionaires have been keeping their assets in the West for a long time since the beginning of 2000, (partially under sanctions) and now in the Middle East. Chests of gold don't lie in millionaires' mansions.
        1. +4
          15 August 2024 09: 07
          Do you want a new civil war?

          Are you ready to fit in with the fat cats?
          And the chests of gold are not even capable of digging up the beds themselves. All these are the working hands and heads of engineers. And the tank plant on Kirovsky is idle, and there are many places where it’s worth putting your hand and head to work.
        2. 0
          15 August 2024 15: 16
          keep their assets in the west
          .....
          In fact, the assets of “factories, factories and steamships” are located mainly in Russia. It's not money. There may not be very many of them.
      3. +3
        15 August 2024 08: 48
        What if “fat cats” are put on a diet?
        Ask the non-friendly and friendly partners who remained to seize the real estate, the accounts of the fat cats that they have, and transfer the proceeds to Russia.. It turns out that you, the drones, will begin to cut the drones.
        1. +1
          15 August 2024 10: 02
          The question was about what means to support the Army.

          How these funds are obtained is another question.

          The truth is well known to everyone: “whoever does not want to support his own army will support someone else’s.”
          1. +5
            15 August 2024 10: 29
            "Whoever does not want to support his own army will support someone else's"
            And we are already supporting others by supplying strategic resources there, and that’s why we have reduced our own a long time ago.
    3. 0
      15 August 2024 07: 40
      Well, they gave about 30 trillion rubles to their Western partners, which means there were no problems with money and a good army could be built and maintained.
      Or do you not feel sorry for the money for your partners and their armies, but do you feel sorry for your own?
      1. 0
        15 August 2024 07: 54
        Economic educational program.
        Our Central Bank kept about 300 billion dollars in Western banks at interest. They came under sanctions. Currently unavailable to us.
        Nobody gave anyone money.
        1. +6
          15 August 2024 08: 12
          Nobody gave anyone money.

          My message did not contain the word "gifted".
          Currently unavailable to us.

          Now they will always be available.
          Economic educational program

          Continue the economic educational program and tell us why you should keep money in “partner” banks at 1%, if by investing it in your own economy, you can get much more?
          1. +6
            15 August 2024 08: 51
            if you invest them in your economy, you can get much more
            And why didn’t they invest in their own economy, but kept the money in the “savings bank” (from) their partners?
            1. 0
              15 August 2024 17: 44
              Because otherwise the sanctions and Maidans began much earlier and more harshly. Where are you investing your money? Have you decided to get into the big leagues? Eh no!
          2. 0
            15 August 2024 15: 47
            Alternatively, because they would eventually end up there, only not as funds from the Central Bank, but as the personal savings of Russian oligarchs
            1. 0
              16 August 2024 07: 27
              So that Russian reserves would not go to his friends, the court oligarchs, Putin gave them to strangers (although, perhaps at that time, they were his own) oligarchs. Sur.
              1. 0
                16 August 2024 18: 28
                No idea. But not only the Central Bank of the Russian Federation invested in American Treasuries
    4. +1
      15 August 2024 08: 24
      Are there any economic calculations on this topic?
      Probably there is, but not for the general public
    5. +2
      15 August 2024 08: 26
      Can the country's economy withstand such a load?
      Of course, it can if the state begins to fight corruption and theft in a real way, and not just in those cases when it is forced. wink hi
      1. +3
        15 August 2024 09: 37
        if the state begins to fight corruption and theft in a real way

        And if, without if, it has not yet begun to fight and will not begin. hi
    6. +4
      15 August 2024 09: 50
      You are absolutely right. As the Ministry of Finance reported, in 2024 it is proposed to increase defense spending by almost 70% relative to 2023, to 10,77 trillion rubles. However, with an increase in the size of the army by 2 times, our expenses should also increase by at least 2 times, reaching 22 trillion rubles. It is absolutely clear that our current budget and the current design of the financial system simply cannot afford this. The entire budget is only 36 trillion rubles. But this means that we just need to change the financial system. The country's budget is clearly insufficient not only in this regard. The USSR financed its army and supported and helped half the world and managed nothing
      1. 0
        16 August 2024 10: 53
        And, in the end, the USSR budget failed.
  18. +3
    15 August 2024 07: 08
    ...This is a blow from NATO, which is now “charging” its supercomputers and AI systems with the invaluable information received and modeling how best to launch a future and not at all nuclear strike on Russia...
    But meanwhile NATO is “probing” us, striking us...


    The author of the article cogently revealed the purpose of the NATO bloc. NATO is Russia's real mortal enemy. The countries included in the NATO bloc should be considered by the Russian Federation as enemies.
    The policy of the Russian leadership towards these countries should also be hostile. Russia must cause economic damage to NATO countries.
    Stop supplies of gas, fertilizers, etc.
    1. +4
      15 August 2024 07: 38
      NATO is Russia's real mortal enemy.

      For us, he is your enemy, but for the top, he is the owner, he will give the money if he wants, but he won’t give it if he wants.
    2. -1
      15 August 2024 08: 53
      Stop supplies of gas, fertilizers, etc.

      Russia, the only supplier in the world of these resources?
      1. +1
        15 August 2024 09: 54
        Russia, the only supplier in the world of these resources?


        It doesn't matter. Russia should not supply its resources to enemies. This is clear.
        1. +3
          15 August 2024 10: 25
          Russia should not supply its resources to enemies

          These are not enemies, these are not just friendly partners laughing
    3. +2
      15 August 2024 16: 50
      But the people themselves don’t owe anything? There are crowds of vacationers in these very NATO countries (EU, Turkey), holding nest eggs in dollars and euros, buying exclusively imported equipment, clothes, etc..
      1. +1
        15 August 2024 17: 26
        But the people themselves don’t owe anything? Crowds of vacationers in these same NATO countries (EU, Türkiye), holding nest eggs in dollars and euros


        Respected.
        What part of the people are you asking about now?

        One part of the people is in the ranks of the Workers' and Peasants' Army (RKA) and participates in the SVO. Another part of the people who are close and empathetic to the soldiers of the RKA helps them in any way they can: sewing, knitting, transferring money, etc.

        And there is a small piece of people with their servants, who “rest in crowds in these very NATO countries (EU, Turkey), holding nest eggs in dollars and euros...”.
        So you need to ask them. I guess there are very few of them on this site.
  19. +7
    15 August 2024 07: 21
    There is no such call that would bring some sense to the Russian ruling oligarchic class, which completely lacks the instinct of self-preservation and reason. This has never before been at the head of Russia. NATO's direct entry into the war became absolutely inevitable after the events in the Kursk region. "There are no red lines."
  20. +2
    15 August 2024 07: 26
    Will the Russian economy be able to support this army? God forbid you have to sell a couple of yachts or the palace of some respected gentleman!


    nope. a villa in Nice is sacred, but you can protect your homeland from lapta with a cutting, so they showed Mikhalkov on Nepolzhiv-TV in the cinema
    1. +1
      15 August 2024 09: 27
      Will the Russian economy be able to support this army? God forbid you have to sell a couple of yachts or the palace of some respected gentleman!


      nope. a villa in Nice is sacred, but you can protect your homeland from lapta with a cutting, so they showed Mikhalkov on Nepolzhiv-TV in the cinema


      We have a highly developed civilized society, it requires many top-priority specialties!
      Traders, brokers, lawyers, marketers, managers, insurance agents, journalists, network headliners, bloggers, businessmen and many others!
      But since all these crafts are so important to them that more doctors and warriors are needed, then let them save them and their children from serious illnesses and other dashing misfortunes and fierce enemies.
      1. -2
        15 August 2024 15: 51
        You forgot the teachers. And pensioners. If we started Yaroslavna’s classic crying. And they brought doctors in in vain - they now make good money compared to the general background. Teachers, by the way, too. And the state has not offended the soldiers lately - the salaries were good and the benefits were good. And what side do businessmen have here? They are definitely not on state support
        1. +2
          16 August 2024 01: 49
          And from what side are you talking about salaries and incomes? Here we are talking about something completely different.
          Although... whoever is in pain speaks about it. I'm talking about a shortage of personnel.
  21. +5
    15 August 2024 07: 46
    And now the war is at our gates.


    No, she's already outside the gate.
    Only this is still a small war, which is not important to the majority of the population.

    Meanwhile, there is a solution, and it lies in restoring the tough active strategy of the first part of the Northern Military District, when we wanted to win.


    There are hardly any resources for this.

    But all this, in my opinion, is not the main thing. I proceed from the following.
    1. No NATO aggression threatens Russia if Russia does not behave too aggressively, that is, does not try to annex Ukraine or anything else. Simply because they don’t need it, and we have nuclear weapons.
    2. Our senior management initiated the CBO for internal policy reasons that have now been resolved. Their goals have already been achieved, only the minced meat cannot be turned into a live cow.
    3. Escalation, another wave of mobilization, transfer of the economy to a war footing could destroy Russia as a state - then, of course, not only NATO, but also petty jackals will intervene. However, this option will destroy the “food base” of the authorities and the authorities themselves, so there is no point in expecting escalation.
    4. The leadership is completely insensitive to losses of territory, since these losses do not affect military goals.
    5. Apparently, the leadership is fully confident that the enemy is suffering significantly greater losses and that their strength will be depleted earlier. Then it will be possible to sit down at the negotiating table and somehow finish, in general, the performance that has already been played.
    1. +1
      15 August 2024 07: 52
      Here is, finally, an adequate comment.
    2. +7
      15 August 2024 08: 14
      1 The era of colonial wars has passed. Today it is not profitable in every sense.
      For example, China conquered Russia long ago. Without firing a single shot, with a smile. Economically. And we work for the Chinese, buying goods from them.
      2 Political problems are far from being solved. Their failure is dangerous for the state machine.
      3 Accurate description of the situation.
      4 Management is very sensitive to territory losses. The image losses are great. Kursk does not excite the population.
      5 Management must have accurate, objective strategic information for the present time, and not as in the spring of 22.

      We need an objective, real look at the situation. Living in a fairy tale will lead to collapse.
      1. +5
        15 August 2024 08: 36
        2 Political problems are far from being solved.

        They are not even specifically named...just phrases like denazification. There is no ideology
        1. +6
          15 August 2024 09: 42
          There is no ideology
          With one hand they erect a monument to the fascist I. Ilyin, with the other to the communist F. Castro, but they erected it, just to annoy the United States, in front of the American embassy, ​​and I. Ilyin, Solzhenitsyn are sacred. And from the articles on VO you can see where they sort fascists into good ones and bad ones.
      2. +3
        15 August 2024 10: 35
        "2. Political tasks are far from being resolved. Their failure is dangerous for the state machine."

        The voiced ones are not, but the real ones, I think, have been resolved.

        "4 The leadership is very sensitive to the loss of territory. The image losses are great. Kursk does not cause delight among the population."

        I think differently. The leadership has a huge rating, a “reserve of trust”, the next elections are not soon. I see no reason why this leadership will somehow take into account the mood of the population.

        "5 Management must have accurate, objective strategic information for the present time, and not as in the spring of 22."

        I don't think anything has changed for the better since then. The people are somewhat different, but the system is the same. The voice of those who disagree sounds even quieter, but the applause does not stop. Public criticism of the authorities is needed, first of all, by the authorities themselves.
      3. +1
        15 August 2024 15: 36
        Point 1 cancels points 2 - 5.
        If what is written in paragraph 1 is true, then China must establish its own administration in Russia, send managers who will optimize the economic activities of the controlled territory and resolve the issue of the appropriate number and composition of the population living on it.
        I hope that you are wrong, both in assessing the current state and the future.
  22. +1
    15 August 2024 07: 53
    . The Ukrainian Armed Forces in Kursk have an absolutely unfavorable position - in fact, they are surrounded by operational forces, and according to the laws of military science, they will be hit from the flanks, dismembered and destroyed.

    All supplies of the Ukrainian Armed Forces hang on one single road, which goes through Sudzha. Cut this road and things will get really bad for the pots.
  23. +4
    15 August 2024 07: 54
    The army is not a burden, but a calling card - the strength and glory of the state and the people. For Russia, a strong and large army is a historical necessity to repel the claims of the West!
    1. +2
      15 August 2024 09: 34
      the first time foreign troops entered our territory since World War II, not counting the conflict on the island. Damansky from China
      Why "not counting"? Why should this case not be considered? So that it would be more convenient to say in the next paragraph “not a single reptile in the world could raise even one dirty finger against us,” although this is not so? Or does the PRC have a clean finger?
      1. +4
        15 August 2024 10: 08
        Dear brother! Everyone sees in everything what they see. The conflict in Domansky is a separate issue. There was no need to talk about him at all, because the background of that event was completely different. And China, despite the damaged relations, was not an enemy for us. . And the thesis about the USSR is absolutely correct. The whole world reckoned with us because they were afraid of our weapons, including nuclear ones. And in the 90s, liberals did everything so that no one would be afraid of us. The task of the state is to return this fear. For our enemies. Then there will be peace and silence at our borders. All the best
        1. +3
          15 August 2024 10: 13
          This way, you can selectively ignore any facts, leaving only those that are conveniently integrated into the desired version. You just take it and ignore it.
        2. 0
          15 August 2024 18: 38
          And China, despite the damaged relations, was not an enemy for us

          It was you, Alexander, who got excited!
          If it weren’t for L.I. Brezhnev with his unforgettable “As long as I’m alive, there will be no war!”, we would have controlled China in 1978. And the methods were the same as those the United States is now working on.
          It was then that his comrades slipped him the Afghan non-war adventure. And he, kind soul, waved! And this nonsense went: here you can, here you can’t, but here is a report about friendship.
  24. log
    +7
    15 August 2024 07: 54
    Due to my age, I hope that I will not see the death of Russia. although everything is heading exactly towards this. Thanks to our bourgeois "elite", which has no homeland. I hope that as a result of this war, “October the Seventeenth” will come!
  25. +2
    15 August 2024 07: 57
    We must live in peace with other countries, especially with neighboring ones. Then you won’t need a huge army or a lot of money for its maintenance and weapons production. And then all this money can be used for the benefit of the country and people.
    The USSR and the West were ideological opponents, but still their relations during the Cold War were better than the current relations between the Russian Federation and the West, although they do not have any ideological contradictions, they are equally against the USSR and for capitalism.
    1. +6
      15 August 2024 10: 08
      This is no longer possible. The failure of the image, that is, SVO, has already occurred. From now on, the West will always treat Russia with distance and distrust. The unprecedented outbreak of Russophobia in the West will bear fruit in the future. Russia will remain “bad” for a very long time. In books, films, historical studies, documentaries, computer games and so on. Both the oligarchs and the Kremlin will do everything so that after the war “everything will be as before.” But this will no longer happen.
      1. -2
        15 August 2024 11: 04
        It is not known what will happen. Yes, as long as this one exists, there will be enmity, but it is not known what will happen after it. All this hostility is not beneficial either to the enemies of the USSR in the West and in Europe, they have lost a lot economically, or to our officials, oligarchs, the “elite”. They all want their old lives back.
    2. 0
      15 August 2024 20: 47
      Are you serious? You can smell liberda a kilometer away. The USSR was not threatened, but was forced to have a powerful army, that’s why they respected us and feared us because...
      You have a complete lack of logic, throw utopian thoughts out of your head, and remove the emblem of the USSR from your nickname, don’t disgrace it, it suits you...
  26. +7
    15 August 2024 07: 59
    All whistleblowers about mobilization are invited to sign a contract. And you can raise money and prove your patriotism with deeds. What's stopping you? Hemorrhoids with radiculitis?
    1. +1
      15 August 2024 15: 57
      Sofa with gravity anomaly
  27. +4
    15 August 2024 08: 13
    We need a powerful army, according to various estimates, at least 3,0 million people.

    With sticks and shovels?
    It’s the 21st century, the army must be high-tech, but we can’t even provide normal communications, and without communications these 3 million are just a crowd and is this what we need? I have an example from WWII, when rifle
    the division could not take a strong point at a height, and then only two companies and 2 tanks destroyed this strong point, losing only 8 people and two tank commanders, one of them was awarded the title of GSS.
    And the breakthrough into the Kursk region should have been stopped by high-powered troops, i.e. glorious aerospace forces, followed by clearing by airmobile units, but....
  28. -4
    15 August 2024 08: 58
    This whole SVO is Putin’s personal project. He selected people, built strategy, etc. etc. He did a lot - he raised the country from its knees in the 2000s, but he is not a magician and, like most of those around him, he created a pleasant environment in which he felt comfortable, without sane opposition. Now that thunder has struck - it has come out of all the cracks and Putin is trying to shut it up after the fact if possible - naturally all miscalculations lead to casualties.
    1. +8
      15 August 2024 09: 45
      He did a lot - he raised the country from its knees in the 2000s
      I have always been interested in the question of who brought the country to its knees and to whom, the main thing is when and how, that it had to be raised and brought to its knees again in front of China.
      1. -2
        15 August 2024 23: 12
        If you were born in 74, you should know that the leadership of the USSR in the 80s fucked up all the polymers, failing to solve the problems that arose in the 70s. And Yeltsin/the reformers practically rammed the country down to zero. Regarding China, I don’t agree, now we are situational partners, but China does not have the task of tearing Russia apart.
    2. -2
      15 August 2024 11: 13
      How easily the enemies of the USSR succumb to the propaganda of their anti-Soviet government, starting with Gorbachev and the perestroikas, repeating manuals, myths, words, phrases, cliches after the government and its propagandists.
      1. -1
        15 August 2024 15: 59
        Adherents of the USSR are no better, because they also broadcast their myths
        1. 0
          15 August 2024 16: 00
          I thought for a long time about answering according to the poor principle of “defense through attack”?
          1. 0
            15 August 2024 16: 07
            Are we already on the same page? I didn’t sleep with you during Brudershaft
            1. 0
              16 August 2024 18: 29
              I didn’t sleep with you during Brudershaft

              Don’t pay attention, really. *Tatra*, he’s such a *Tatra*. Like a Communist, but? Never been in the ranks, never had a party card and in general. Not worth it. laughing
      2. 0
        16 August 2024 18: 32
        Gorbachev

        Yes, it was your Gorbachev, yours! bully And the perestroikas were also from the ranks...of yours.
        words, phrases, stamps.

        Twenty-five again! On all sites you have been broadcasting the same thing for many years. Try to think more rationally and more creatively. Trying is not torture, and no one will give you a sentence.
        1. 0
          16 August 2024 18: 40
          It is useless to expect not only the truth, but also logic and common sense from the enemies of the USSR. Well, of course, Gorbachev, who gave YOU freedom of speech and action, together with YOU launched a total slander against the Bolshevik communists, with automatic justification for the crimes of their external and internal enemies, praise of Nicholas II, kulaks, White Cossacks, White Guards. nonsense about “Russia, which fed the whole world” before the communists, of course, is not yours.
          And you not only did this to Gorbachev, but also tossed your other benefactor, Yeltsin, to the Soviet communists and their supporters.
          And some of you have already given your third benefactor to the Soviet security officers.
          1. 0
            16 August 2024 18: 49
            From the enemies of the USSR

            I am not *an enemy of the USSR*, unlike you, I was and am engaged in real production.
            Gorbachev

            Yes, he is yours, yours. The fosterling and promoter of the party you are trying to cling to.
            they also planted it on the Soviet communists and their supporters.

            Who planted it? The CIA? Exactly? Not the Politburo of the CPSU Central Committee?
            Soviet security officers.

            This is who? Those who knew everything, but preferred to *hang out nicely*? *Soviet security officer*! Yes, it sounds loud, but??? 1991. Irina, come on, eh? Write normal comments, really, without these *enemies of yours USSR and communists*. Everything will work out for you, I believe in you.
            1. 0
              16 August 2024 18: 56
              Stop talking nonsense. YOU, the enemies of the communists and the USSR, have nothing and no one at all. You do not have the history of your country before YOU destroyed the USSR, and not your history of your anti-Soviet period, you simply threw out the reign of your benefactors Gorbachev and Yeltsin from the history of your anti-Soviet period.
              You don’t have YOURSELF, you all cowardly have “nothing to do” with what you have created, with the results of your highly paid work, you don’t have each other, each of you only has “but I, me, me.”
              And with all this, you also seriously imagined that you are even more worthy than the communists and their supporters to own the country.
              1. +1
                16 August 2024 19: 01
                Stop talking nonsense

                I'm just freaking out!
                You don’t have YOURSELF, you all cowardly have “nothing to do” with what you have created, with the results of your highly paid work, you don’t have each other, each of you only has “but I, me, me.”

                Lord! Have the pills really run out? bully
                And with all this, you also seriously imagined that you are even more worthy than the communists and their supporters to own the country.

                Irina! You won’t believe it, but I’m...a simple worker. And? I work, unlike you. Yes! Friends? There are. As it should be, not many. What about you? hiFinally, the traditional question: Were you in the ranks of the *Leninist Guards*? Do you have any party experience? bully
              2. +1
                16 August 2024 20: 01
                Stop talking nonsense.

                Ira, do you believe in the victory of the Northern Military District? laughing
              3. +1
                16 August 2024 20: 16
                Do you have anything to say? Specifically? I'm afraid there's simply nothing to tell you, dear Irina. So? It happens. Dare. Through thorns to.. the stars, no?
              4. +1
                16 August 2024 20: 36
                Stop being responsible nonsense

                Khinshtein is not yours? Again? Again? Well, all of them are not yours! Why the hell did he block YouTube? What? Again, like-mindedness prevented you and people like you and Khinshtein? You’re just fed up with your like-mindedness. The fact that people want to think differently, you and people like you are just you don’t see. Just understand! There are other people! And everything will become clear to you.
              5. 0
                17 August 2024 12: 26
                "Stop talking nonsense"...
                Were the friends of the USSR not taught to conduct discussions within the bounds of decency? Without insulting other people's opinions and getting personal. Find out at your leisure what the term “nonsense” means.
  29. +2
    15 August 2024 09: 22
    The important center near Kyiv - Pokrovsk remains 8-9 km away. Russian troops in Toretsk, Krasnogorovka - part of the quarter remains. And this is also a full-fledged city, which is very bad for Kyiv media-wise. They decided to interrupt all this with an attack on Kursk.

    In theory, our leadership should speak live (in an interview or something else) and directly state that the offensive in Donbass will not be suspended under any circumstances. This is from the point of view of the “strategic contour”. This is not even for us, but for the strategic customer of the Armed Forces of Ukraine.

    The internal contour is due to the maximum possible of those who are officially assigned to the law enforcement agencies, to form second-echelon units, which will immediately occupy nodes on the ground and populated areas, from where the army will squeeze out the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Otherwise, they will be able to continue to maneuver with the tactics of small cavalry units.

    Well, so much has already been said about striking a blow specifically at the Kyiv regime or its individual representatives that I don’t even know what else to say.
    1. -1
      16 August 2024 19: 29
      our management

      I’m afraid that our *leadership* was the only thing capable of...carrying the notorious briefcase for Sobchak. Oh, and it’s not for nothing that Yeltsin left him on the farm. Gloom. The wait for our country...is very bad.
  30. +5
    15 August 2024 09: 23
    Not long ago, Deripaska, considered a member of Yeltsin’s “Family”
    Yeah, the oligarchs and the government are like flies and cutlets, the oligarchs are separate, the power is separate. The author probably doesn’t realize that the government expresses the interests of the oligarchs? And Deripaska’s speech was just: You go there and tell them that, in principle, we are ready. There is no need to invent all sorts of parties in the world and look for fifth columns. Many Russian oligarchs have assets in Ukraine and the SVO is already in their throats if they thought that as a result of a quick SVO, they would be able to squeeze out additional assets from the Ukrainian oligarchs, which they had their oligarchic eye on, but it didn’t work out to squeeze out, somewhere The process was delayed, but in some places it didn’t work out and there was a danger of losing more assets. And there’s no need for these slogans: “Satire fearlessly fights for humanism and the cause of peace!” (c) SVO is a military method of dividing Soviet property and resources that Ukraine and Russia have been dividing among themselves for 30 years now. They once wrote that SVO is a civil war, I wouldn’t say. But the fact that two of the three founders CIS, they are kneading each other, no one will deny, “this is such damn music, such damning, eternal youth” (c) In other words: “The cancer and the beetle met by the river, they were talking little words, they were finding out who was stronger and who had the longest mustache” (With)
  31. +10
    15 August 2024 09: 29
    The elite is waiting for Trump, but he will not be allowed to become President.

    I’m embarrassed to ask, President of what, the Russian Federation? No? Then why are they waiting for him in the Russian Federation? Trump received dual citizenship? No too?
    Maybe the “elite” that rules the country is American in the Russian Federation, since the Russian Federation is waiting for who will be the President of the United States?
    Then what kind of declared “sovereignty” is here, is more reminiscent of a colony. lol
    Somehow I got confused in the types of schizophrenia pouring out of the media...
  32. -4
    15 August 2024 09: 41
    You need to have 10 charges in order to guarantee counterfeiting the richest families in America and Britain. And most importantly, they should not know where and what is aimed at them. Let them not be nervous. The PRC and the DPRK are doing the right thing by not giving any information about their nuclear forces. This is unnecessary. All agreements with them are not needed. If the Chinese and Koreans can do this, then Russia can do the same. It is the aggressor who needs to know what and where. It doesn't matter to the defender. Their cities, villas, banks, nuclear power plants and the Yellowstone volcano are not going anywhere. Retribution is like that, it is cruel. C'est la vie.
    1. +2
      15 August 2024 16: 01
      They also forgot to mention the Khibiny system
  33. +2
    15 August 2024 10: 49
    In 2014, we could take not only Crimea and Donbass at once, but all of Ukraine (except for the western part). But Moscow preferred the Minsk ones. For 8 years we watched the Donbass being bombed, and this “contemplation” ended with the Northern Military District.
    This has already happened somewhere: when you choose shame between war and shame, you get both war and shame.
  34. -2
    15 August 2024 12: 17
    There is no need to have an army of 3 million. It is quite enough, for a start, to destroy Great Britain with nuclear weapons in FIG.
    We will be sad about England, of course crying , but we will still have memories of their culture in books and films. This is quite enough.
    The rest of the countries will sit down on their butts and thank Russia just as Japan now thanks the United States. with smiles and bows. feel
  35. 0
    15 August 2024 13: 43
    Write about raising the stakes and immediately make minimal bets, why without western Ukraine Russia can only be strong when it is within its historical borders, and this includes western Ukraine, Central Asia, the Caucasus. If you yourself refuse all this, then why are you surprised that someone is attacking Russia?
  36. +1
    15 August 2024 13: 49
    What is happening is the result of the dismantling of the USSR and its military machine, as well as the entire destructive liberal course that continues, no matter what.

    This basically says it all and the main thing is impossible to argue. hi
  37. +3
    15 August 2024 13: 58
    According to Tsargrad, the commander of “Akhmat” stated that the Ukrainian Armed Forces’ breakthrough into the Kursk region “has a last name, first name and patronymic.”

    Everyone knows this name, but no one will name it.
  38. 0
    15 August 2024 14: 12
    Why did they stop mobilization? There is no need for total, 300 tons per month. It would have been enough to continue 50 tons per year (that’s 3-5 people per month from the region) and now there would already be 100 tons of reserve and without any excitement. I don't understand...
    1. +3
      15 August 2024 16: 38
      Quote from Pilot
      Why did they stop mobilization?


      Because 300 thousand were called up, but 900 thousand fled abroad. If mobilization is announced, even more will flee, or worse, they will rebel.
  39. 0
    15 August 2024 14: 29
    I don’t know what the author is using and what kind of drink is in the way, but this nonsense about “mandatory mobilization” and “an army of 3 million people” is impossible to finish reading.

    Especially the links to telegram channels, tik-tok warrior apti and degeneral gurulev are pleasing. These are sources that have exactly 0 credibility.

    I think there is no need to explain once again that mobilization (and how, dear author, will we provide for the mobilized, where will we get money for them?) will lead to an overstrain of our economy, an increase in discontent in society and the importation of hundreds of thousands of migrants. And we will lose everything.
    Well, the USSR had a huge army. And where is the USSR now? Where is he?

    There is nothing wrong with capturing a dozen villages. These are just the little things of life on the scale of the Northern Military District and the NATO confrontation as a whole.

    To the author, good health and speedy sobering up.
  40. +3
    15 August 2024 14: 41
    Russia can paralyze this state, but for some reason it does not do this. This is not the 20th century, but the 21st. What kind of war is it in the trenches? The enemy must be broken morally and very quickly. It is necessary to liberate your lands at any cost. Be it through threats or blackmail. What's the... difference? Let it be the destruction of Lvov or Ivano-Frankivsk. Bandera's creatures must leave our land with their tail between their legs or lie down in the sewer with their face down. You need to give a damn about the world community which does not exist and which was invented by the elders in the Politburo. Citizens. You need to love and take care of your own, not your non-brothers.
  41. +1
    15 August 2024 15: 04
    I still don’t understand who the last call was to. Good for both us and Ukraine. According to the author, the Polish-Chinese border will remain, apparently... laughing
  42. +1
    15 August 2024 15: 07
    The stories with Zelensky, Zaluzhny and the “truth with divers” about Nord Streams in light of the Ukrainian Armed Forces’ attack on the Kursk region look interconnected. In just three days, it was launched openly in the Western media. For disrupting the negotiation process, albeit phantom in many respects, before the debates in the United States, it seems that someone in the West will be merged. The British have to finish the game at some point. True, this has never made it any easier for the Kursk and Belgorod regions.
  43. +1
    15 August 2024 15: 32
    During the Soviet era, everything that happened was impossible

    Wasn’t the Second World War during the USSR? Or what is not possible? Isn't war with Europe possible? So this war has happened at all times, the war with Europe is our struggle for a sphere of influence, it may sound cynical, but this is a natural historical process, and I think this will not end in the Northern Military District, and the war with NATO (Europe) is inevitable and does not depend on the socio-political building
  44. +1
    15 August 2024 16: 41
    Oh, yes, yesterday there was an article again about “pauses in negotiations.” The repressed oligarchic SUVs and the same foreign affairs are pursuing their line of agreements. One box every day of destruction of our country.

    Some statements by Deripaska, who values ​​everything in money, are worth it. And there’s all this brotherhood from the 90s... They think that they are the elite. But we know what floats to the top
  45. +6
    15 August 2024 17: 04
    The main problem of Russia is that the West is absolutely not afraid of our nuclear weapons. And it is not afraid because the elite of the Russian Federation will not use it under any circumstances due to the fact that its children, its real estate and most importantly, its Money, more than 500 billion, are in the West .green rubles. Regarding the same S. Korea, the Amers cannot even think about attacking it, because that Elite does not have its own interests in the West. If the amerofascist had fear, everything would have been the same as during the USSR, no one could even blather against it, in the worst case, maybe they would supply Stingers to the country of U., a few machine guns, but no one there would even be able to imagine about the attack. Here it is, the main difference...
  46. +3
    15 August 2024 17: 33
    L'ucraina non capitolerà come dicono in quanto anche se uccidessero 11.000 soldati ucraini, questi saranno sostituiti da altri 30.000 che verranno armati dalla NATO … [sappiate che ci sono ancora 30.000.000 di abitanti in Ukraine.. da l'ucrain} a potrebbe diventare la nuova Syria .. finché non finiranno i finanziamenti e le forniture di armi la guerra continuerà, oppure dobbiamo aspettare un cambio di regime negli Stati Uniti. Infine leggo discorsi sulla corruzione, io da italiano vi dico che chi governa la nato sono dei corrotti, i politici europei e americani sono dei corrotti, quindi non cercate il fallimento nella corruzione, il presidente Putin deve per adesso continuare su questa strada … il tempo è amico dei russi e nemico della NATO
    1. +1
      16 August 2024 06: 16
      Thank you, Friend, for your support!
  47. +4
    15 August 2024 18: 36
    We have in power the 6th column of inveterate traitors, who seem to be our own, but not for Russia. And Mongo has many of his own: one destroyed Silicon Valley and abroad, the second ruined the army and was promoted, now they will also pull the Ministry of Emergency Situations and how many of their loved ones. Stalin needs to be woken up.
    1. The comment was deleted.
      1. 0
        15 August 2024 21: 00
        Yes, the same one))) He treated Poland kindly, so... BE STALIN!!!
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. 0
            16 August 2024 02: 14
            Yes, He took pity on you! He fed me during the war and after, and freed me from the Nazis. I could have reduced your sins to zero, but I didn’t, it’s a pity... He was kind.
            He didn’t bully the Russians, study History not from Wikipedia.
  48. 0
    15 August 2024 18: 51
    Who is causing panic? I listened to Mikheev’s hysteria at Solovyov-Ptashechkin’s. He squealed as if the Abrams were thundering across Red Square. Karen Shakhnazarov also left not far away. Gurulev pours gasoline on the fire.... As if on purpose, in order to spread panic. Shouldn’t we close down all the television shows that serve as a feeding trough for all kinds of alarmist talkers?
    1. +1
      15 August 2024 19: 56
      Mikheev asked Solovyov the right questions that the authorities in Russia do not want to answer. Therefore, he is right. What was it, an agreement or betrayal? But there is no answer.
  49. The comment was deleted.
  50. +3
    15 August 2024 19: 26
    In the USSR in 1991 there were three million in the Soviet army and about eight hundred thousand in the internal troops of the USSR Ministry of Internal Affairs and the border troops of the KGB of the USSR (somewhere in the region of three hundred thousand PV)
    1. 0
      15 August 2024 23: 14
      The maximum number of Internal Troops of the USSR Ministry of Internal Affairs was 250 thousand people. A significant part of them performed the functions of the modern FSIN.
  51. The comment was deleted.
  52. -3
    15 August 2024 19: 53
    it would take a very long time to explain this to Odintsov. That’s to describe everything in detail. But in short: all the conditions were (were being created) for the Ukrainians to rush to Kursk (Bryansk, Belgorod). This decision was made at the very top! It was precisely necessary for the Ukrainians to attack territory of Russia. But for what? This answer will appear within the next year. Maybe more. But when the result is obvious, everyone will come to the conclusion: but if the Ukrainians had not invaded Russia, Putin would not have been able to pull off this geopolitical step (maneuver) for the benefit of Russia.
    1. +5
      15 August 2024 20: 31
      It was possible to withdraw civilians in advance.
      This did not happen. I feel sorry for the dead border guards and conscripts who gave their lives for this “super plan.” And civilians who believe this cranberry!
  53. +4
    15 August 2024 19: 53
    The author's article is controversial here. The most important question is a question of political will. The will to make decisions. No will, no decisions. If the top government leadership of Russia does not have such political will, there are no solutions to existing and emerging problems. We, I mean the people, do not need to be convinced of the need to defeat Ruins and NATO on the battlefield. But the President, the Ministry of Defense, the General Staff, etc. Do these structures want Victory or not? It seems that they do not. After all, we are no longer fooled by words, by all this blah-blah, we judge by their deeds. No ? And if it’s about business, then this is all, then this is either a conspiracy of the generals against Russia, in the person of Gerasimov and Shoigu against Popov and Surovikin, or this is an agreement between Putin and the West, or an outright betrayal of the interests of the people of Russia by the Government. Here is the answer to the question: it was in Kursk and there is Truth and what awaits us next.
  54. +1
    15 August 2024 20: 18
    Indeed, the “Yeltsin matrix” is leading the country to disaster, but for this matrix, transformation is tantamount to suicide.
  55. +5
    15 August 2024 20: 28
    You know, it’s a shame to watch when the Kursk region is covered by two strongholds of border guards!
    It’s a shame to listen to the chief of the general staff at a meeting of the security council with a report of two sentences: “the enemy will be defeated..”.
    It’s a shame to listen to the Supreme Commander-in-Chief, who constantly tells us that he is capable of acting proactively.
    We, Russian people, have seen and heard all this more than once over the past ten years of Ukrainian events!
    Stop talking, start thinking and doing, you are only riding on the spirit of the Russian people.
    This is true to your face!
  56. 0
    15 August 2024 20: 53
    These, how to call them without obscenities, from the Armed Forces of Ukraine only know how to fight with the dead
    https://eadaily.com/ru/news/2024/08/15/predvaritelno-dvuhsotye-veesushniki-sorvali-flagi-s-mogily-vagnerovca-shot
  57. +2
    15 August 2024 22: 06
    If we continue to chew snot, without being responsible for the nuclear submarine Kursk, or for SPotoki, or for the bridge, or for Second Kursk and Belgorod, etc.., then NATO, constantly increasing its forces and means in Ukraine, will send in its troops and trample them on Russia, like Hitler with the support of all of Europe. Only POWER can stop them, and while it is gone, we must act!! The military potential of the EU and the West will be restored much faster than we expect ((They are just buying time now, deceiving us and Putin once again!! Well, how long can you keep stepping on the same rake?
    1. +3
      16 August 2024 06: 10
      Absolutely right, and this power should have been used a long time ago! The West is only afraid of bad power and our actions should be unpredictable, and not calculated 10 steps ahead. We must really scare them, let them look beyond the line beyond which is the death of all their capital, oligarchs, where there is nothing else - only ashes... Only then will they stop! It is necessary to draw lines, but these should be furrows beyond which there is no movement. And these Western Ukrainians should know that only they are and will be responsible for everything that is happening now, and not their prostitutes and sixes.

      I'm a humanist. Of course, a humanist.
      But the one who responds to the whistle with a whistle
      And to the enemy’s blow with a blow,
      since
      I don't want to
      to die in vain.
      And if they beat you and you remain silent -
      what kind of humanist are you? You are a stupid sissy
      What a cunning bird catcher
      taken from the branch
      lives in someone else's
      in someone else's cage chirps!
      /Nikolai Gribachev/
  58. +2
    15 August 2024 22: 24
    It is very difficult to disagree with the author, very much. Question, no, not a question-thought. But the thought is so fleeting that you can’t catch it by the tail. Everything is written in the article. We can think, we can decide no. 2000 It's 2024. Period.
  59. +3
    15 August 2024 22: 33
    Quote from Deon59
    Well, what can we say about the Guarantor? The leadership environment shows that it is capable.

    Napoleon said:
    A ram army led by a lion will always defeat a ram army led by a lion.
    If the RF Armed Forces have successes, it is not thanks to the leadership, but in spite of it.
  60. +3
    15 August 2024 22: 46
    In the 90s, people were told that Russia did not need an army. In the 2000s they bleated about a “compact professional”. The result is natural and predictable. Kursk is just the beginning of a new stage in the Northern Military District, which is not the most optimistic for the Russian Federation.
  61. +4
    15 August 2024 22: 55
    The first call was Wagner's raid - it immediately showed if the pros would go to Moscow. It didn't reach many people. So we got a breakthrough to Kursk. The generals do not understand that at the front and on the border the sergeant understands more than them - if they crossed the line - hit him with all guns and do not report to Moscow and do not wait for its decisions. But as the police say, when they kill you, then come and write a statement.
  62. +1
    16 August 2024 02: 45
    According to the latest report from the Ministry of Defense for 13.08.2024/2030/35: during the fighting in the Kursk direction, the enemy lost up to 31 military personnel, 18 tanks, 179 armored personnel carriers, 78 infantry fighting vehicles, 14 other armored combat vehicles, XNUMX vehicles, four anti-aircraft missile systems, two launchers multiple launch rocket systems and XNUMX field artillery guns.

  63. +2
    16 August 2024 06: 01
    3 million people in peacetime is impossible! Look at what is happening now in the labor market - there are simply no people, not only are there not enough of them in the police (where there is a shortage of about 150 people now), but also where they pay quite normal money!
  64. +2
    16 August 2024 06: 19
    It’s persistent, “except for the western part.” What, there are no Russians in the western part, eh, author?
  65. +2
    16 August 2024 07: 05
    You can give everyone sticks and put them in a chain around the perimeter of the border. Call it a sacred duty, and the highest goal of life.
    Or we can make it so that our attack aircraft will finally be able to fly over the breakthrough point.
    Don't think that going back to the Stone Age will solve all problems.
    This won't solve anything.
    Get rid of cave mentality.
  66. +1
    16 August 2024 08: 57
    "Parquet" in Moscow Region needs to be filmed!!! And not only in Moscow Region!
  67. +1
    16 August 2024 09: 48
    Ukrainian Armed Forces, Kyiv could send about ten thousand troops to invade the Russian Federation

    From all corners they shout that about 10 thousand people came to us and at the same time they add that they came
    According to Forbes, as well as the TG “Two Majors”, the Ukrainian Armed Forces had...: the 22nd and 88th mechanized brigades and the 80th separate air assault brigade of the Ukrainian Armed Forces

    Now let's do the math. Brigade 6-8 thousand people. 3 separate brigades already 18-24 thousand + some other units of the Ukrainian Armed Forces. That. either arithmetic is lying, or they are lying to us about 10 thousand. people Where is the truth?
  68. +2
    16 August 2024 10: 05
    The author is right in one thing: to win, Russia must cleanse itself of corruption and show the will to win.
    Russia has been cleansing itself of corruption for so long that during this time it was possible not only to defeat corruption, but also to shoot all the sparrows and doves. And then it turns out that they captured a corrupt senator, who has so much over the hill that it would be enough for an entire region in Russia. And he was a senator for a long time, and the FSB and the GPU, and the KGB, and the NKVD all sorted out the real estate of senators, and for a long time they did not discover that some in the West had tidbits. Hence the question: is there corruption in power and how is it combated, if even senators suddenly have a modest little money from the bourgeoisie.
    I don’t want to say anything bad about our parliamentarians and senators, but the only question is how, after so many years, the FSB, GPU, KGB, NKVD did not discover a decoy Cossack in power.
  69. The comment was deleted.
  70. -1
    16 August 2024 10: 39
    First you need to return to military service for a period of 2 years.
  71. +3
    16 August 2024 10: 52
    Almost everything is clearly and precisely stated.
    But most likely “Tsarist” (Ruling Elite) Russia will win, and “USSR” (poor and powerless proletarian) will lose, i.e. The government will continue to get greedy, but at the same time it will achieve victory by mowing down huge numbers of people, and so that the people do not “revolt”, the remaining people will be given even greater bans and restrictions on expressing their opinions and opportunities, forcing them to work many times more to compensate for the losses received.
    1. +1
      16 August 2024 17: 14
      . everything is clearly and precisely said.

      Good girl!
      I applaud while standing good hi
      For the clarity and accuracy of your own opinion.
      1. +2
        16 August 2024 18: 42
        For the clarity and accuracy of your own opinion.

        You know, Lyudmila Yakovlevna, I’m very sorry for our guys who are dying in this adventure, I’m very sorry for our people, ordinary civilians who got caught up in this monstrous plot. I’m really scared for our country. Who is to blame for this? The name is known.
        Good evening to you, my friend! We haven’t talked for a long time. hi
        1. +1
          16 August 2024 18: 55
          . We haven't talked for a long time.

          And good evening to you, dear Friend! love )))
          I replied to you in a personal message.
          1. +2
            16 August 2024 19: 19
            I replied to you in a personal message.

            You know? If you are afraid to tell the truth, then... it turns out very sad in our country. So? What do we have? Commander-in-Chief - what is the percentage of voters there? Including in *electronic*. Everyone deceives him, although he is a judoka and a chess player and in general...*a man anywhere*.His...General Staff. It is enough to look at the face of this *chief of staff* to understand *Hu is Hu, Mr. Putin...*. This is understandable, right? Next. Boyars.MillYar, RottenberKhi and so on. Let's skip. Yes! Did you, my dear, know that your son received the Rotenberg badge of honor? Which one? *For the development of Moscow sports. *They should be comparing awards with Kadyrov's son or with the marshals of the DPRK! I don't know how to cry , or that... smile. Bottom line. But the result is sad. The people don’t need this SVO, but the Russian people are dying. In a word? Everything is according to plan! Anti-Russian.
            1. 0
              16 August 2024 19: 33
              Everything is according to plan! Anti-Russian.

              The destruction of the white population is a global plan. It, the white population, starting from Ancient Rome, created this civilization, which degenerated into a dead-end capitalism, from the point of view of transnational corporations. Now a new society is being created - a caste one, which has been repeatedly described in literature. The white race is not suitable for such a society, because it requires paternalism, care from the state, all rights and freedoms, and understands a lot about itself. So draw your conclusions.
              1. +1
                16 August 2024 19: 40
                The white race is not suitable for such a society,

                How fitting! After all, they swallowed literally everything! And the revision of borders, and that Nazism, and the wrong Nazism, and * a pseudovirus *, and a pseudo-Olympics!!!! (A man beats a woman, well....? The norm, however! Boxing. )The white race is ready for anything. Islam? Oh, and they will finish the game with this.
              2. +2
                16 August 2024 19: 43
                findings

                What am I talking about? Is the Russian population even capable of nominating their own LEADER? And is there such a thing? He is simply needed. He, not this *motor of portfolios*.!
                1. 0
                  20 August 2024 12: 23
                  No one will let people's leaders into power. The election campaign needs money, but the common people don’t have it.
              3. +1
                16 August 2024 19: 57
                white race is not suitable

                A Russian loves a Russian woman, and she loves him. It was, is and will always be. Power? Fuck it... to this judo chess player. Oh, and they’ll finish the game.
    2. +3
      16 August 2024 18: 12
      mowing down huge numbers of people, and

      And this is the very plan: reducing the population of the Slavs to the required level. Then the GDP waited and waited and drove a drunken bulldozer at its neighbor. The question is, what were you waiting for? Remember the ambassadors in Ukraine - each more beautiful than the other! Everything was done as if on purpose, with with one goal to bring to a military conflict. And subsequent events only confirm this. This howl is very strange.... NWO.
  72. +2
    16 August 2024 11: 44
    And who will pay for an army of 3 million?
    Yes And the most important thing is not this, the most important thing is that the future belongs to robots; it is already very difficult for a person to survive on the battlefield.
    And the enemy entered Russian territory because he is not afraid after all these brown lines.
  73. +3
    16 August 2024 12: 00
    the commander of "Akhmat" said
    He declares so many things that it is unclear when he is fighting.
    Yes, but we have units of the Russian Guard, FSB, etc. What are they for?

    To protect the authorities from ordinary people, obviously. The National Guard and other special forces of the Housing Office alone amount to one and a half million bayonets. The army is even smaller.
    we are told that “the mission is impossible”
    While the government grants immunity to Zelya and the Dnieper bridges, and every day portrays the negotiated cat Leopold, the mission is impossible. Betrayal from above can ruin any achievements of the people.
    1. +4
      16 August 2024 18: 15
      Betrayal from above

      It was there from the very beginning.
      capable of taking away any achievements of the people.

      And what can our country be proud of at the moment? Science, production, medicine, the welfare of the people, the standard of living? There is only one category of *citizens* for whom everything is OK. Friends and friends of friends of the *great and only*.
  74. +2
    16 August 2024 13: 15
    On the one hand, real army reform is overdue. I think that first of all, universal conscription is necessary, when every healthy man of military age would be obliged to serve in the army, for example, for a year, and then be called up a couple more times to “keep in shape” for short periods of two to three months. Everyone is healthy, without exception. We would then have a mobile reserve, just like the National Guard or the Terrorist Defense, whatever you call it.

    On the other hand, there are a couple of limiting factors.

    The strain on the economy will reduce our competitiveness.

    In the hands of an ambitious leader who is into geopolitics, a well-functioning military mechanism can lead to great disaster, since our political system does not provide public control over the state and the military mechanism can be used without an important reason and with devastating consequences.

    I don't know which is worse.
    1. +2
      16 August 2024 18: 24
      universal conscription,

      *-Here you go, their professorship is ready for battle, and ours only know how to look through microscopes!*
  75. +2
    16 August 2024 14: 55
    Everything is absolutely correct. In the West, too, everything is not sugar, otherwise they would not have come. The people in the border areas need to create self-defense on their own. That's what we're working on.
  76. +3
    16 August 2024 15: 52
    Do you remember? When did the US start talking about supplying Javelins? What a shouting, squealing and stomping of feet there was that the red line was so close! And today there is an attack on Russian territory using Western technology!!!! Do you feel the difference? But the lines are still the same. And the point is not at all in the lines, but in the inability or unwillingness to make tough, very tough decisions. Now, if at the very beginning about 50-70 Eskanders would have flown across Rzeszow, there would have been screeching, screaming, snot from the entire NATA, but it wouldn’t have been what we have now. And no one would use the 5th Amendment, I’m sure. But the strategists at the top know better, so...... We are watching. And our guys and ordinary people are dying and running.
  77. +1
    16 August 2024 19: 11
    During the Second World War, the USSR did not trade with Germany and its allies and did not feed enemy enterprises with natural resources.
  78. 0
    16 August 2024 19: 24
    Yes, almost from the first day I have been writing everywhere and asking - when will there be a major strategic offensive, with a directly stated task - the defeat of the military component of the junta and inflicting a decisive defeat on them?
    I wrote a couple of years ago - it is necessary to recreate a strong conscript army, increase the service life to three years, increase the size of the Armed Forces to 3-5 million people, in the ground forces there are at least 100 divisions, of which a third are tank divisions. They must conduct combat-like exercises every day. In each subject of the federation, a fully combat-ready division, tank or motorized rifle, and a special forces regiment must be created and equipped.
    Etc.
    I wrote all this a long time ago, I understood, to which I received answers in the spirit of “will you write isocopters?” and “nuvotsamiidi” and “show me how to do it.”
    Nobody needs it? Well, ok, but what do I need more than anyone else?)))
    Finally, I got tired of it and I don't write about it anymore.
    1. +2
      17 August 2024 05: 17
      In addition to the army, we need powerful advanced military science and powerful advanced industry!
      Remember US industry in World War II!... And ours too!
      But the proper conclusions have not yet been drawn ABOVE!
      And it’s “stressful”!
  79. +3
    16 August 2024 19: 44
    The unsuccessful design of the oligarchic Yeltsin statehood will not take root in our country, and will be swept away by the course of history. The only question is how. Either carefully, safely, through reforms - or it will crash. Russia can only survive as a Stalinist-socialist country; this is dictated by objective external conditions, by all geopolitics.
    A great country is great inside. And this means a very strong country internally. And very strong means it is also fair, and this is only socialism.
    Because a strong country without internal justice is either an absolute feudal-class monarchy or an oligarchic dictatorship. Both are short-lived and doomed.
    1. +1
      16 August 2024 20: 10
      The unsuccessful design of the oligarchic Yeltsin statehood will not take root in our country, and will be swept away by the course of history.

      Well, finally!!!! Question of questions. Could Yeltsin give the farm to someone else? And could *a stranger* do anything wrong? Russia? I don’t know. But the blow is insidious. Two peoples? This is forever. This is not even *Banderaism*, these are families where people died. This is... for a very long time. Who is guilty? Forever.
      1. +1
        16 August 2024 20: 44
        Everything is much deeper than one person.
        I give this analogy. In the West, Iran after the 1979 revolution was called the “ayatollah regime.” So, we also have a kind of “ayatollah regime,” only our “ayatollahs” have their own religion, it’s called “cutting the loot.” There was an “Islamic revolution” in Iran, and here in 91-93. - "revolution of grabbers"
        1. +3
          16 August 2024 20: 50
          revolution of grabbers"

          My friend! This is not a revolution of grabbers. This is the evolution of the Zaputinites! And the first of them.... yes - Putin! And? Rotenbergs!!!
          1. 0
            16 August 2024 20: 58
            "revolution of grabbers"

            Ukraine. I’m afraid that we have parted ways with the *good* relationship with the local forever. Even with Odessa. Glory to Putin!
            1. -1
              16 August 2024 21: 30
              Ukraine is part of Russia, it’s not going anywhere
          2. 0
            16 August 2024 21: 07
            The personality of the ruler does not play any role here; it is much deeper. I tell you, it's like a religion. Religion penetrates deeply into public consciousness, into all spheres of society and the state; it is timeless and beyond individuals. This is how we have our “religion” - “cut the loot”, “eat and consume”. Change as many ruling personalities as you like, it will not help. Iran also has elections and a president, but the real power is with the ayatollahs, i.e. religious leaders. And their power is based on религии
            1. +2
              16 August 2024 21: 10
              Personality of the ruler

              Oh, my friend, how right you are! And? I'm afraid that the Russian Federation....You understand.
              1. -1
                16 August 2024 21: 14
                We will wake up, the awakening has already begun, there would be no happiness, but misfortune helped, this is about us
                1. +1
                  16 August 2024 21: 18
                  We'll wake up

                  How I want to believe! We. ..In a Grebenshchikov-type steam locomotive.
                2. +2
                  16 August 2024 21: 24
                  We will wake up, the awakening has already begun, there would be no happiness, yes

                  It's sad;
            2. +2
              16 August 2024 23: 44
              Nonsense (to put it mildly). The entire history of mankind is the history of individuals. Where they were not - we have no idea/don’t care what happened there...
  80. 0
    16 August 2024 19: 54
    No need to panic. Just look at the map of Russia. Talk to the members of the SVO. (TO THOSE WHO ARE AT THE FRONT). And you may understand that there is no need for forced mobilization. We need volunteers who will make good and motivated specialists in all military professions. You cannot draw conclusions based on the criteria of the past of the Soviet Army. Yes, I agree that individual defeats can be inflicted on RUSSIA, but it cannot be won! The victorious regulations of the West, sooner or later, will turn into bitter tears. There will be no negotiations! At least not on the terms of Ukraine and the West.
    1. 0
      16 August 2024 21: 14
      you can't win!

      They will come. And? They will see Putin’s Russia. So? Why the hell no one needs them. And?
    2. +1
      17 August 2024 05: 06
      In our time (21st century!) it is IMPOSSIBLE (!!) to fight as soldiers!!
      We need to fight with high-tech - robots of all stripes, AI systems and so on...
      And here all these industries have been destroyed! And no one answered!
      Plus an impenetrable bureaucracy - after all, even in 2,5 years, A LOT could be done!!!..
      BUT ! ....
  81. 0
    16 August 2024 23: 35
    The most stupid and sabotage phrase I hear is “we haven’t started yet.”
  82. 0
    17 August 2024 04: 48
    According to the results of a survey among Russians from June 24 to 30 (VTsIOM), the level of trust in Russian President Vladimir Putin was 80,9%.
    In this case, 8%(!!) said that they rather do not trust the head of state, and 11% abstained from answering.

    Assessment of the activities of the Russian government and its chairman Mikhail Mishustin 53,1% and 52,8% (VTsIOM).
    In the FOM survey as of June 30 54% respondents rated the government’s work as “rather good” 25% – “rather bad”, and 21% of respondents found it difficult to answer.

    The level of support for the United Russia party was 37,9%.
    In the FOM survey 47% of respondents expressed their readiness to vote for the party (!!!), if elections to the State Duma took place next Sunday.

    I AM SHOCKED BY OUR “PEOPLE”!!! ,
    HAS BEEN TURNED, BASED ON THE NUMBERS, MORE THAN JUST INTO A POPULATION...
    I EXPRESS PURELY PERSONAL ASSESSMENT -
  83. +2
    17 August 2024 07: 25
    An army of 3 million in modern Russia? Ten percent of able-bodied men under uniform? Author, who, women and children, will work in the economy?
  84. 0
    17 August 2024 11: 56
    A very competent article, without pathos or hysteria. But for now nothing will happen. As long as the president supports his friends, nothing will change. Capitalism is like that....
  85. +1
    17 August 2024 14: 00
    Russia cannot declare war on Ukraine, because then the NATO bloc, providing support to Ukraine, will attack us. That's why there is a group of 500 thousand there. She's on high alert. And partial mobilization must be carried out.
  86. +1
    17 August 2024 15: 01
    Meanwhile, there is a solution, and it lies in restoring the tough active strategy of the first part of the Northern Military District, when we wanted to win. ........................ Not to “grind”, but to win.

    From the very beginning of the North Military District, the purpose of which was the denazification and demilitarization of Ukraine to protect the Russian and Ukrainian population from the aggressive Bandera bastard who came to power in Ukraine, taking into account the most active and comprehensive assistance to it from the West, it was clear and was expressed thousands of times, in including in the Military District, that a positive result of the SVO can be achieved in a fairly short time, if our Armed Forces destroy to hell all the supply routes on the border of Ukraine for Western military equipment, ammunition, mercenaries, etc., without which Bandera’s Ukraine could not hold out for a long time. And let the Bandera evil spirits try to deliver all this to Ukraine along Bandera’s paths as in the 40s of the last century. However, to the greatest regret (and surprise), in response, the opinion was spread that this was supposedly not effective, since it would be quickly restored, then in general there was no answer, and the position prevailed that we would use all this equipment as a “legitimate target” grind But at the same time, the question was somehow omitted: what forces would be required for this grinding and what inevitable losses they would incur.
  87. +2
    17 August 2024 15: 18
    The author of the article panickingly demands the mobilization of everyone and everything in Russia for a victorious war with NATO countries. At the same time, he does not find the courage to name the names of the main culprits of the situation to which “we have sunk.” This is his internal mobilization. Hence the question for the author, who will mobilize the entire country to repel the internal and external enemy of Russia? Who and where will find money, weapons, equipment, weapons, equipment and commanders for a 3 million (as the author of the article wants) modern army. We do not have a Communist Party, and the people are not ready to hand over their last money to the greedy hands of the thieving authorities.
  88. +1
    17 August 2024 22: 03
    “The friendship-people-brotherhood policy of Leopold the cat” is failing. This is a fact. The country's policy must be strong and tough. Both internally and externally. A “kishlak” is being built inside, and outside there are songs about the friendship of fraternal peoples and a parade of “red lines.” The world respects only the strong and tough.
    1. 0
      19 August 2024 07: 27
      I liked the words of Lukashenko in an interview with Yevgeny Popov, “There will be no “red lines”, it is the state border. As soon as they are reached, the answer will be instant!” And it looks like we still have a lot of red pencils in store...
  89. +2
    17 August 2024 23: 52
    Voivode Shein's head was cut off. We've got a couple of assholes shot in the forehead, the rest have sobered up a little.
  90. 0
    18 August 2024 03: 00
    well, don’t read 2 majors, leave them to sell finks to someone else
  91. 0
    18 August 2024 08: 41
    Very sad conclusions arise.
  92. The comment was deleted.
  93. 0
    19 August 2024 07: 06
    The author advocates a strong army of 3 million people. A strong army is needed, but not by the number of bellies for meat assaults, but by technical equipment!
  94. 0
    19 August 2024 07: 19
    Quote: 61
    The author advocates a strong army of 3 million people. A strong army is needed, but not by the number of bellies for meat assaults, but by technical equipment and highly qualified specialists!
  95. 0
    19 August 2024 12: 21
    Expert Sivkov is strong. I saw no point in reading further.
  96. 0
    19 August 2024 17: 21
    And communications on the territory of the Ukrainian Reich were, and remain, inviolable. The bridges in our rear are being destroyed by the Wehrmacht, and we are being delicate. Or is the slogan “we’re not like that” still in use? As they said then, they say, we do not want to look like barbarians in the eyes of civilized humanity. In other words, we all long for the West to open its arms to us again?
  97. 0
    19 August 2024 20: 54
    Food for thought: today our army is fighting not with humans, but with drones. Our troops are suffering huge losses from enemy komikaze drones. At the same time, without even having time to fire a shot. And the drone gunners calmly aim Ukrainian artillery at our units. And no one is stopping these drones from performing their functions.
    Let’s add cluster bombs to drones and artillery and we’ll get a simply terrible picture of a dozen Russian soldiers killed and hundreds wounded.
    What about our regiments and generals? Nothing!!! Everyone knows everything and no one does anything. Meanwhile, our men lie down in packs in the fields and forests.
    And the Kremlin still believes that it is necessary to fight exclusively with white gloves. Even the enemy’s entry into Russian territory, the killing and capture of Russian civilians will not in any way affect the conduct of hostilities. Banderlogs play *the tape*, but we shouldn’t do that. Because no one in the Kremlin suffered from these *cassettes*. And the fact that after such an arrival five or six people will die and the same number will be seriously injured - so this is true, collateral damage. Then more men will catch up. The Kremlin will simply raise wages a little more and the men will catch up. As long as there is someone to catch up. And then it will be possible to announce mobilization. And now it’s time to line up the ranks of young people.

    Excellent Kremlin policy! True, it is directed NOT for its people, but AGAINST the people. It’s just that someone wanted to exterminate a good half of the male population of our country.
    So think about it: who really runs the country? And why did the people of Russia become like sheep being led to the slaughter, but they, these people, obediently go there?
  98. 0
    20 August 2024 12: 05
    Both the Russian Empire and the USSR carried out mobilization. Some lost, others won. This is not the key here. The USSR was a state for the people and the measures were quick and effective. People saw and felt the care of the state. Socialism was the reason why people wanted to protect their way of life.
  99. 0
    21 August 2024 09: 13
    THIS IS THE LAST warning that if you start to fight, you have to fight for real. In this case, EVERYONE involved in the fact that this happened MUST be brought to justice... At a minimum, fired without a pension!
  100. 0
    24 August 2024 16: 53
    Kursk is the first time foreign troops have entered our territory since World War II

    This is another clear demonstration of the complete incompetence of the top officials and their system...