Why are the Knesset so afraid of Palestine, but... not of Palestinians?

49
Why are the Knesset so afraid of Palestine, but... not of Palestinians?


Palestine.net


The other day, the Knesset, the Israeli parliament, which, contrary to all norms of international law, meets not in Tel Aviv, but in occupied Jerusalem, voted for a resolution rejecting the creation of a Palestinian Arab state. Moreover, by an overwhelming majority of votes – 68 to nine.



Thus, a new step has been taken to further deteriorate the situation in Palestine. Israel, like many other countries, including Russia, needs Palestinians without their own country, primarily as cheap labor: it’s much easier to control you, keep you in line, only occasionally allowing you to “let off steam.”

“...The Israeli Knesset strongly opposes the creation of a Palestinian state west of Jordan. The establishment of a Palestinian state in the heart of the land of Israel would pose an existential threat to the State of Israel and its citizens, perpetuate the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and destabilize the region." - the resolution says.

However, judging by geography, it is the Israeli state that is located in the core of Palestine. Moreover, with “additions” of territories, long ago as a result of a series of wars captured from the Palestinian Arabs.


The resolution also notes that in the event of the creation of an Arab state in Palestine “…Hamas will soon seize power and turn it into a base of radical Islamic terror, acting in coordination with the Iranian-led “axis” aimed at eliminating the state of Israel.”

Where do terrorists come from?


At the same time, for some reason, they are silent that the Hamas movement and related organizations arose “thanks to” Israel’s occupation policy in the Arab regions of Palestine and Tel Aviv’s denial of the right of Palestinian Arabs to their own state.

The resolution was adopted by all parties in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's coalition and far-right opposition parties. And even received partial support from the centrist National Unity Party of Benny Gantz.

Meanwhile, members of parliament from the center-left Yesh Atid party left the meeting so as not to support the chauvinistic frenzy of the majority of parliamentarians. And the chairman of this faction, Yair Lapid, spoke in the media in favor of

“the coexistence of two equal states in Palestine. Otherwise, there will always be bloody conflicts here and interethnic enmity will be indefinite.”

According to the politician, interstate borders can be clarified during negotiations, and these borders may not coincide with those determined by the UN on November 29, 1947. But these negotiations are possible “if the Palestinian Arabs create a state. Otherwise, instead of territorial demarcation, both sides will receive constant bloodshed.”

It is characteristic that the Knesset decision took place during the ongoing bloody “cleansing” of the Gaza Strip by Israeli forces. the troops. Which doesn't really bother Palestine's Arab neighbors, except for the verbose resolutions of the Arab League and the like.

At present, the possibility of introducing an Arab oil embargo against Israel and countries supporting its occupation policy is not even being discussed - based on the experience of the 1973 embargo...


Territories of fear


Today, few even in the UN remember that Tel Aviv’s refusal to create an Arab state of Palestine, prescribed by a UN resolution back on November 29, 1947, was initially accompanied by a phased occupation of the territories of this state.

Already in 1947–1948. The North Palestinian Galilee was captured - at least 35% of the territory of this state. In 1948–1949 Israel occupied the western part of Jerusalem, part of the West Bank of the Jordan River, as well as the region adjacent to it.

At the same time, up to a third of the territory of the Gaza Strip (Al-Quds) was annexed not so noisily and demonstratively. Two decades later, in 1967, Jerusalem was completely captured, and the rest were also occupied, including most of the western bank of the Jordan River, areas of the entire adjacent region and about a third of the Gaza Strip.

Only in 1994 did Tel Aviv finally agree to the creation of the so-called “Palestinian National Authority”, but in fact this is a structure completely dependent on Israeli policy. Already because it cannot in any way counteract the expanding - since the early 50s (!) - network of Israeli settlements in the Arab regions of Palestine.

In addition, this administration never advocates the restoration of the legitimate borders of the Gaza Strip, the de-occupation of the Galilee with the repatriation of Arab refugees there, or the clarification of the borders of the region - the West Bank with Israel and Jordan.

By right of veto


Most recently, in April 2024, the United States used its veto power in the UN Security Council, blocking a draft resolution prepared by Algeria on the admission of Palestine as a full member of the UN. US Deputy Permanent Representative to the UN Robert Wood explained that Washington used the veto because “We are not sure that Palestine meets all the criteria to now be considered a full member of the world body.” In addition, the Palestinian Authority “is not carrying out the reforms that the United States insists on.”

Of course, Israeli Foreign Minister Israel Katz welcomed this decision... There is no reason to believe that the Knesset’s refusal to create an equal Arab state in Palestine will cause, for example, the imposition of UN economic sanctions against Israel. Moreover, they have not been introduced since the initial period of Tel Aviv’s aggressive policy, that is, from the late 1940s to the early 1950s.


In addition, a number of Arab oil countries are interested in using the trans-Israeli corridor (Ayatollahs and sheikhs and even rabbis decided to get down to business) for the export of oil and petroleum products. These countries do not at all strive, including for political reasons, to be completely dependent on the Egyptian Suez Canal and the parallel Sumed oil pipeline (Suez - Port Said)...
49 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +6
    24 July 2024 05: 29
    I didn’t find an answer in the article to the question: Why are the Knesset so afraid of Palestine, but... not of Palestinians?
    1. +2
      24 July 2024 07: 15
      Quote: parusnik
      I didn’t find an answer in the article to the question: Why are the Knesset so afraid of Palestine, but... not of Palestinians?

      But why did the authors write this?
      Israel needs Palestinians without their own country, like many other countries, including Russia, first of all, as cheap labor:

      After all
      Russia has always supported the creation of a sovereign state of Palestine, the president said. “Israel, as we know, was created, but Palestine as an independent and sovereign state was never created.”

      The authors do not hesitate to lie
      1. +9
        24 July 2024 10: 47
        Well, yes, everyone in the Russian Federation knows diligent and hardworking workers from Palestine. That their Arab brothers from other countries are in no hurry to accept themlaughing
  2. +1
    24 July 2024 05: 31
    “...The Israeli Knesset strongly opposes the creation of a Palestinian state west of Jordan
    What about the UN resolution on the creation of two states, Jewish and Arab? It turns out that the Knesset stands much higher than the opinion of the majority of states in the world?
    1. +3
      24 July 2024 08: 50
      Quote: Dutchman Michel
      It turns out that the Knesset stands much higher than the opinion of the majority of states in the world?

      Yes. this is called "sovereignty".
      Russia, too, finds the strength not to bend under the “resolutions of the assembly,” but to do what it considers right and beneficial for itself.
      True, the nuance is that we will be punished for this with sanctions, blockades, cancellations, etc., but Israel will not. Well, “that’s how the world works” (ts)
    2. -1
      24 July 2024 10: 14
      Quote: Dutchman Michel
      “...The Israeli Knesset strongly opposes the creation of a Palestinian state west of Jordan
      It turns out that the Knesset stands much higher than the opinion of the majority of states in the world?

      Another thing is interesting here - if the translation of this wording is correct, then it turns out that the territories north of Nazareth are declared the subject of bargaining, because they are no longer “west of Jordan.” Is it possible that this is a kind of proposal for a variant of dividing the territory, which the elite still recognized as inevitable? By giving up everything north of Nazareth, Israel takes everything else along with Gaza, and fences itself off from Syria and Lebanon with a buffer state. Geopolitically this might be favorable exchange.
    3. 0
      24 July 2024 11: 45
      It is the Arab states that are against this resolution. This is where the whole war began - the Arab League tried to destroy the state of Israel on the second day after its formation in accordance with a UN resolution.
      According to Resolution No. 181 of the UN General Assembly of November 29, 1947 on the division of the British colony of Palestine, two independent states were to be created on its territory - Jewish and Arab, as well as Greater Jerusalem - a territory controlled by the UN. Each state was to consist of three territories bordering each other only at corners.
      The Jews agreed to the division, but the Arabs refused to recognize it and demanded the creation of a unified state entity in Palestine [12] [13]... On May 14, 1948, the independence of the State of Israel was proclaimed, and on May 15, 1948, expeditionary units of the armies of five Arab states entered former Mandatory Palestine. Most of these Arab countries, except Egypt (which was formally independent from Britain), themselves gained independence 1-5 years before Israel. The entry of Arab regular troops was carried out with the aim of destroying the new Jewish state and, according to the declaration of the Arab countries during the invasion, to protect the Arab population and create a “unified state entity” in Palestine... The Arab countries rejected UN Resolution No. 181. In the Arab League declaration (telegram No. S/745 dated May 15, 1948), sent by Arab League Secretary General Azzam Pasha to the UN Security Council when Arab troops had already invaded Palestine,[107] it was stated:[12][13].. The goal of the Arab countries is to create a single state in Palestine... The Supreme Arab Committee and the same Arab League countries insisted on the creation of an Arab state on the territory of all of Palestine and rejected the option of creating Arab and Jewish states[109].

      Simultaneously with the official declaration, Arab leaders allowed themselves much harsher public statements that contradicted its spirit (an example is Azzam Pasha’s statement about a “war of annihilation”). The Mufti of Jerusalem, Amin al-Husseini, stated:
      I declare holy war, Muslim brothers! Kill the Jews! Kill them all![110]
      Original text (English).
      1. +1
        24 July 2024 11: 49
        It is the Arab states that are against this resolution.
        If suddenly your neighbor decided to build a summer kitchen on your plot of land, then you would also be against it wink
        1. -3
          24 July 2024 12: 00
          Israel was originally created entirely in legal compliance with a UN resolution.
          And arbitrary analogies are a crafty thing.
          1. +3
            24 July 2024 20: 21
            Israel was originally created entirely in legal compliance with a UN resolution.

            Wow, how interesting everything turns out for you - I see it here, I don’t see it here, and over there they wrap the fish…. feel
        2. -3
          24 July 2024 12: 30
          The Arabs in the territory of “Palestine” always grazed sheep and camels, while the Jews mastered agricultural production and planted this stony desert with fields, plantations and groves. If you drive through Israel along highways (built by Jews), you will see these groves, fields and plantations. By the way, the oldest Jewish villages have been preserved in Galilee, where they remember their ancestry over the past two thousand years... The Arabs came to this territory many centuries later!
          1. +2
            24 July 2024 14: 46
            The Arabs came to this territory many centuries later!
            The Jews left this land two thousand years ago. For history, this is a long time
            1. -3
              24 July 2024 19: 43
              The Jews left this land two thousand years ago.

              They didn't leave there. How do you imagine that? The top left, but the farmers remained on the ground. Over time, they converted to Islam so as not to pay extra taxes to the caliphs and sultans. And in the middle of the last century they did not call themselves Arabs.
              1. +4
                25 July 2024 04: 53
                The top left, but the farmers remained on the ground. Over time, they converted to Islam so as not to pay extra taxes to the caliphs and sultans
                Then they are no longer Jews. Do you actually know how many Jews lived in Palestine before Herzl began promoting the idea of ​​Zionism?
                1. -1
                  26 July 2024 01: 10
                  Then they are no longer Jews

                  Do you think that religion is primary?
                  Zionism is a secular movement, actually.
                  1. +2
                    26 July 2024 04: 41
                    Zionism is a secular movement, actually
                    Inextricably linked with Judaism and based on it. If there were no religion, there would be no Zionism
                    1. -1
                      26 July 2024 11: 48
                      Inextricably linked with Judaism and based on it.

                      The Orthodox will not agree with you.
                      If there were no religion, there would be no Zionism

                      But yes, then yes...
              2. 0
                1 August 2024 18: 48
                Do you know what the shortest joke is? This is a Jewish janitor.
            2. The comment was deleted.
          2. +2
            24 July 2024 16: 13
            If you drive through Israel along highways (built by Jews), you will see these groves, fields and plantations.


            Purely idle interest. Who cultivates these fields and plantations? Who sat behind the paver levers? Cognitive dissonance arises in the imagination. belay
  3. +2
    24 July 2024 05: 47
    As soon as the secular understanding of the struggle for one’s rights disappears, a disorderly movement in this direction begins. Moreover, those countries that participate in this direction become hostages of their own foreign policy. It’s good that this is all balanced by demonstrations against Israel’s wild policies. For some was not beneficial to the PLO. And now everyone in the Middle East is reaping what they did to this organization.
    1. 0
      24 July 2024 08: 52
      Quote: Nikolay Malyugin
      Someone did not benefit from OOP

      yes, not everyone likes Object-Oriented Programming as a paradigm, and not everyone is accessible as a style of thinking))
  4. +3
    24 July 2024 06: 11
    68 versus 9. Wow, it turns out there is a fifth column in Israel, and not a small one!
    1. +1
      25 July 2024 11: 43
      Quote: Victor Leningradets
      68 versus 9. Wow, it turns out there is a fifth column in Israel, and not a small one!

      These are apparently those who considered the text of the resolution unacceptably soft. smile
  5. +2
    24 July 2024 07: 54
    I think Israel is simply afraid of the creation of Palestine on its doorstep. In addition, geographically it is difficult to imagine what kind of Palestine it will be - no one seriously expects that Israel will leave the places paid for with its blood.

    Israel's fear is based on a misunderstanding of who will govern Palestine. It is easier to deal with Hamas on the territory of an unknown entity than with Hamas at the head of a recognized state. Israel is surrounded by enemies and does not want to increase their number.
  6. -1
    24 July 2024 08: 00
    Well, who are the peaceful victims of genocide?! They got out of Europe unfinished and dropped them off where they didn’t need to. It seems like your ancestors lived there. That the United States was settled by Europeans and taken away from Indian tribes. That Israel is squeezing foreign territories. The Australians are lucky - no one cares about them. And no one will send emigrants there - it’s too expensive to transport them. What if the gypsies in England now start a riot and demand their own state?!
  7. +3
    24 July 2024 08: 03
    So you read VO and your soul becomes calm. Almost nothing is happening in the world, Jews, Arabs, elections in the USA, Northern Military District, migrants.. And so .. “everything is calm in Baghdad” (c) smile
    1. -1
      24 July 2024 08: 55
      Quote: kor1vet1974
      Almost nothing happens in the world, Jews, Arabs, elections in the USA

      but in essence, yes... as I remember the “Vremya program” in the 80s - everything is the same: Beirut, the Gas Strip, the Israeli military (tm), the new American president...
      and everything "the imperialist West is rotting"))

      True, we have to be honest, over these 40 years we have had a fair amount of comfort in life) partly thanks to banal technical progress, but not only)
      1. +2
        24 July 2024 09: 53
        "
        program "Time" in the 80s
        Yes, it was somehow livelier, the same Iran-Iraq scandal, the Iran-Contra scandal, events in Grenada, the Falklands conflict, news from Latin America, the Sandinista revolution in Nicaragua and then their fight against the Contras, Ethiopia, Poland, Angola, Mozambique, boycott of the Olympics, The Goodwill Games, the Canada Cup and the scandal associated with it, when the USSR national team refused to award it, and a lot of interesting things... As for decay... it was rotting... Grenada, it seems the New York Times, called Grenada in one of its articles just a pawn on the world chessboard won back by the USA from the USSR. Russia, modern, has a lot of pawns, has it at least won back from the USA in 30 years? For 30 years, the game of giveaway has been going on on the part of Russia. And so many interesting events are happening in the world, but are not reflected on the pages of VO.I about sports. The Peoples' Friendship Games, which should take place this year, have been postponed to 2025, the DPRK team, to Flew to Paris for the Olympics.
        1. +2
          25 July 2024 11: 50
          Quote: kor1vet1974
          Yes, it was somehow livelier, the same Iran-Iraq

          Civil war and intervention in Yemen.
          Although... there is always a war in Yemen. But Yemen did not attack its neighbors with ballistic missiles then.
          Quote: kor1vet1974
          Iran-Contra scandal

          Biden Jr. smile
          Quote: kor1vet1974
          news from Latin America

          They never change. Although no, Miley was not there then. smile
          Quote: kor1vet1974
          Poland

          Belarus. smile
          Quote: kor1vet1974
          Angola, Mozambique,

          Nothing changes either. Only now some imperialists, with the help of national liberation movements, are expelling other imperialists who took control of the country with the help of other national liberation movements.
          Quote: kor1vet1974
          boycott of the Olympics

          ...and here we go again! ©
          Quote: kor1vet1974
          The Canada Cup and the scandal associated with it, when the USSR national team refused to award it

          There are even more scandals here - WADA alone, asthmatic athletes and the Williams sisters are worth something.
      2. +1
        24 July 2024 17: 53
        But in those years, the creators of Time and their curators well understood the role of Yemen and the role of Lebanon. Now you won’t hear much about them, but their role in the region has not become less.
  8. -2
    24 July 2024 12: 53
    God gave the land of Israel, including Palestine and the west bank of the Jordan, to Moses and his people, who walked from Egypt to the Promised Land for 40 years.
    Believers' support for Palestinian statehood means disagreement with God's decision and open opposition.
    If Palestine gains statehood, it will inevitably become a springboard for terrorism and the fight against Israel, and any response will inevitably become a pretext for war between two state entities – Palestine and Israel.
    In this case, the entire Muslim world, and not just the Muslim world, will side with Palestine.
    As it is written in the Bible, after the war and the victory of Israel, on whose side God will fight, Christianity will spread to the whole World, the capital of which will be Jerusalem.
    1. +1
      24 July 2024 18: 02
      Quote: Jacques Sekavar
      God gave the land of Israel, including Palestine and the West Bank of the Jordan, to Moses and his people

      God gave, God took away. The Jews lived a little on this land, and then were deprived of it as having failed to live up to the trust. They were scattered by the will of God. And the UN decision is not the will of God, but a human mistake
    2. 0
      1 August 2024 18: 51
      In the meantime, the springboard of terror is in Tel Aviv and Washington.
  9. +1
    24 July 2024 13: 07
    A certain Chichkin and Podymov are working hard to work off their agitprop rations, trying to imagine the state of the surrounding reality not realistically, but in accordance with the “party line” and are tormented by this mournful ideological accordion of Soviet agitprop.
    Meanwhile, any individual who has had experience of communicating with Palestinians in his life is two hundred percent sure that the Palestinians, the scum of the Arab world, are not able to create any full-fledged state.
    No Palestinian state has ever existed. And Jerusalem has never been the capital of either “Palestine” or any other Arab state - not until 1967, not a thousand, not one and a half thousand years ago.
    The most radical Arab nationalists generally consider “Palestine” and “Palestinians” to be invented by Zionists.
    It would be better if they wrote an article about Rosstat.
    1. -3
      24 July 2024 18: 35
      Quote from Frettaskyrandi
      A certain Chichkin and Podymov are working hard to work off their agitprop rations, trying to imagine the state of the surrounding reality not realistically, but in accordance with the “party line” and are tormented by this mournful ideological accordion of Soviet agitprop.

      Yeah. And students at the best universities in the USA and Europe are doing the same. And millions of people around the world.
      1. +1
        24 July 2024 19: 38
        Are you a student at the best US universities? Or Europe? Can you give an example of similar opuses by students of these universities?
        1. 0
          24 July 2024 19: 52
          America is witnessing a rapid stratification of the democratic electorate, often leading to confrontation. The most obvious example is what is happening in the best American universities. Anti-Israeli protests continue at 23 universities and colleges, most of them among the country's elite educational institutions: Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Columbia University, Harvard, Yale, Princeton (the last four are part of the famous Ivy League), University of Michigan, Berkeley and others.
          https://iz.ru/1687308/andrei-kuzmak/molodost-i-iarost-antiizrailskie-vystupleniia-v-elitnykh-universitetakh-ssha?ysclid=lz02z7jfa6846445531
          1. -1
            24 July 2024 19: 54
            More than half of the TOP 50 leading American universities, including Harvard, Columbia and Yale, are in turmoil; a number of universities have already had to switch to distance learning, and students and teachers of Jewish nationality were advised to refrain from visiting campuses. The most difficult situation is at the University of Southern California, Harvard, the University of Texas and Columbia University. The “fire” broke out as Biden signed a $26 billion aid bill for Israel.

            The reason was the actions of the administration, which decided that the situation with rallies in support of Palestine was out of control; the leadership decided to call the police. In New York alone, 133 students were arrested.

            Read on WWW.KP.RU: https://www.kp.ru/daily/27597/4923975/
            1. -3
              24 July 2024 20: 10
              Inspired by the example of American universities, students in France also began to act - on April 24, about 100 students from the Sciences Po Institute of Political Studies in Paris set up a tent camp on the campus. Sciences Po is one of the leading French universities; five of the eight presidents of the Fifth Republic graduated from it - Emmanuel Macron, François Hollande, Jacques Chirac, François Mitterrand and Georges Pompidou. After negotiations with the management of the institute, most of the students stopped the protest, but some of them still had to be removed from the campus with the help of the police. Classes were moved online, and the institute's management said it strongly condemned the actions of students who undermine the educational process and announced the punishment of those involved in the protest.


              Palestine supporters also protested at another prestigious French university, the Sorbonne, on April 25, the day Macron gave a keynote address there on the future of Europe. Protesters called on the president to support the Palestinians and accused him of "complicity in the massacre in Gaza."

              In mid-April, actions in favor of Palestine were held in Rome by students of Sapienza University, one of the oldest and most prestigious institutions in Italy. After clashes with the police, in which at least two people were arrested, the students chose a non-violent protest - on April 17 they chained themselves and went on a hunger strike. They accused the institute’s leadership of not only ignoring, but also “silencing the academic community’s call” for peace. Students also called for an end to cooperation with Israeli universities.

              By the end of the month, pro-Palestinian protests began in Britain. Students from the University of Warwick, Coventry, pitched tents on campus to protest the university's ties to Israel; Students from University College London (UCL) gathered outside the school on April 26, chanting “No more money for Israel’s crimes!”

              On April 23, the banner of American student protests was taken up by students at the University of Sydney in Australia. They also set up a tent city on campus and set out traditional demands for the university administration - an end to cooperation with Israel and the manufacturers of weapons supplied to it. In the following days they were joined by students from the University of Melbourne.
            2. 0
              24 July 2024 20: 23
              In New York alone, 133 students were arrested.

              Your data is outdated. Already 217 as of today. Of 37 students and 000 teachers. This is about "covered". All this foam will subside and everything will go as usual.
              1. 0
                24 July 2024 20: 34
                Not all participants were arrested, but only a small part of them. Your version about the agitprop rations and the ideological accordion of Soviet propaganda has nothing to do with what is happening. Simple common sense and a little philanthropy or humanism.
                1. +1
                  24 July 2024 20: 42
                  Simple common sense and a little philanthropy or humanism.

                  There is no common sense in this movement. It would be very instructive to bring Palestinians to Russia in commercial quantities instead of Tajiks. To enlighten the mind and bring sanity.
                  1. 0
                    25 July 2024 08: 57
                    We figured out the agitprop ration using the example of student protests around the world. Now all that remains is to figure out whose soldering you are working on. Knesset? Synagogues?
                    1. 0
                      25 July 2024 12: 31
                      I just have to figure it out

                      Yes, yes, keep watching.
    2. +1
      24 July 2024 19: 56
      The most radical Arab nationalists generally consider “Palestine” and “Palestinians” to be invented by Zionists.

      In-in!
      And the “Palestinians” pay the Arabs in the same coin.
    3. +1
      25 July 2024 11: 53
      Quote from Frettaskyrandi
      Meanwhile, any individual who has had experience of communicating with Palestinians in his life is two hundred percent sure that the Palestinians, the scum of the Arab world, are not able to create any full-fledged state.

      Let's rewind history 100 years ago and replace the word "Palestinians" with "Jews." laughing
  10. 0
    24 July 2024 15: 59
    Israel needs Palestinians without their own country, like many other countries, including Russia
    belay belay belay
    Russia has always advocated the creation of a full-fledged Arab state of Palestine.
  11. 0
    28 July 2024 01: 03
    Israel is the defender of the civilized world from the wild Arab Wahhabis. I am sure that Israel's victory over Palestinian militants is only a matter of time.
    1. -1
      1 August 2024 18: 55
      So another joke was born - Israel is the protector of the civilized world... This is something out of the jungle, down to earth.