The program to counter the cosmic threat can be implemented

46
The Federal Target Program (FTP) to counter the cosmic threat may receive a start in life. Russian experts from the Institute of Astronomy of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Roskosmos and TsNIIMASH have created a draft target program for countering space threats, including meteorites falling to Earth. According to Lydia Rykhlova, head of the department of astronomy at the Institute of Astronomy of the Russian Academy of Sciences, the program involves protecting the planet from asteroid danger and space debris. The project contains proposals for the creation of new telescopes in Russia. According to Rykhlova, the project, designed for 10 years, has already been developed, approved by Roscosmos and "is on the table" with Dmitry Rogozin, who oversees the Russian defense industry.

The draft of the prepared target program is designed to protect Russia from meteorites. On the morning of February 15, residents of several regions of the Urals became unwitting witnesses of a global event. Residents of Chelyabinsk and neighboring areas first saw a huge glowing ball in the sky, which then broke up into several parts. Later, only traces of smoke remained in the sky, which looked like a plume from a flying airplane. A bright flash from the explosion was visible over the territory of the Chelyabinsk region, as well as over Yekaterinburg and Tyumen. Experts have estimated the power of the air explosion in 300-500 kilotons, and the shock wave formed after the explosion caused damage to thousands of buildings, many of which lost their glazing.
Only in Chelyabinsk, more than 1200 people turned to doctors with cuts and bruises, by a lucky chance this event went without victims.

According to Rykhlova, the fall of meteorites can be predicted if Russian scientists receive more telescopes. At present, we cannot foresee such situations, in particular, because in Russia at present there are almost no wide-angle and high-quality telescopes. The telescope installed at the Pulkovo Observatory functions on enthusiasm, absolutely outdated equipment is installed here, another telescope is being built in Irkutsk, but its construction lasts a very long time, Lydia Rykhlova noted.
The program to counter the cosmic threat can be implemented

According to Rykhlova, it is not enough just to find an asteroid, it must be studied. Small telescopes with special equipment may be engaged in the study task; they are still lacking in Russia. Our country occupies a very large area in longitude, so we need at least 3 wide-angle telescopes and some smaller for monitoring. At the same time, a single center is needed to collect and process incoming information. That is why today we face 3 tasks in order to create a Russian system for countering space threats: monitoring and detection, creating a single information and analytical center and creating a risk assessment system that will determine how dangerous the detected space object is to us.

The prepared document, which includes a detailed description of the components of this system, including space-based telescopes, has been located in Roscosmos since 2012, where it has already been approved. However, the total project costs at the level of 58 billion rubles (almost 2 billion dollars) for 10 years in Roscosmos were considered prohibitively high. According to Rykhlova, scientists were simply told that there is currently no such money. In turn, Andrei Ionin, a corresponding member of the Russian Academy of Cosmonautics, noted that he respects the position of Roscosmos, but it is not his task to decide whether to allocate funding or not. As we see today, meteorites pose a real threat to Russia and its citizens, while Roskosmos is solving other tasks and is not responsible for the safety of Russian citizens. In the case of Roskosmos, he had to go with the received document to the government if it was clear that his funds were insufficient for the implementation of such projects.

At present, work on such systems is quite actively carried out in the USA, the EU and, possibly, in the PRC. No one at the moment wants to depend on someone else’s information on dangerous space objects. In Russia, individual universities and observatories are working in this direction, but they are scattered and divided into small programs. The situation is aggravated by the fact that after the collapse of the Soviet Union, the country's best telescopes remained in places with the most transparent and clean air — in the mountains of Armenia and the republics of Central Asia.

Last Friday, Dmitry Rogozin tweeted on the need to develop a system for detecting space objects dangerous for the Earth. In this case, the Deputy Prime Minister cited the example of the United States and Australia, where there are programs for the early detection of asteroid danger. It is worth noting that Rogozin expressed a similar idea and 2 a year ago, as Russia's special representative for missile defense (PRO) - a system that is being created by the United States in Europe. At that time, Rogozin proposed to redirect efforts to missile defense to asteroids.

Currently, the Federal Targeted Program represented in Russia requires funding in 58 billion rubles, it is worth noting that this amount has already caused a mixed reaction in the society and the press. In particular, there are quite a few negative comments today, for example, that 58 billion rubles is 12 Phobos-Grunty or that currently the damage from the fall of the Chelyabinsk car is estimated at 1 billion rubles. program it will grow to 59 billion rubles. Lydia Rykhlova has already managed to respond to these claims, noting that at present there is a completely sick society in Russia: no one talks about cuts.

In an interview with the Gazeta.Ru edition, Rykhlova noted that the program was not developed yesterday, not after the fall of the meteorite to Chelyabinsk, but rather long ago. Work on it began in June 2010 of the year after the joint RAS Council on Space and the Roscosmos Presidium. Then the Russian scientists were told: “It is necessary to start creating a system for countering cosmic threats.” In the US, a similar service operates from the 1998 of the year, with its help they discover asteroids, including the well-known 2012 DA14, which flew at the shortest distance from the Earth. At the same time, in Russia, all information about asteroids is taken from this American system, since we do not have our own.

Initially, only asteroid-comet safety entered the Russian FTP, but a year later, according to Rykhlova, it was suggested that the program should be finalized, referring to man-made space debris. The developed target program for countering space threats provides for the modernization of small (mirror diameter up to 60 cm) institute and university telescopes in order to make them modern and can be used in these works. At the same time, the development of a number of wide-angle telescopes is necessary (the diameter of the mirror is about 2 m). The total sky is about 42 thousand square degrees. In order to monitor this entire area, Russia will need at least 3-x telescopes, which will need to be placed in different parts of the state, as the Russian Federation takes a lot of space in longitude.

The most important thing today is observation. The size of the meteorite, which fell in the Chelyabinsk region, was about 15 meters. On the one hand, this is a small celestial body, but on the other hand, it is the size of a typical five-story house. One can only imagine the consequences of what happened if the meteorite had not exploded in the sky, but had fallen on some of the cities. It is to prevent such cases in the future and necessary observations, while not only to determine the trajectory of a celestial body, but also its composition. All meteorites are different, among them there are stone, ice, iron, etc. In order to establish this, spectral and photometric observations of celestial objects are necessary.

At the same time, it is necessary to take into account the fact that ground-based telescopes are limited in their capabilities: the earth's atmosphere often hinders them, they can watch the sky at night, plus the light from modern large cities should be taken into account. Once the Pulkovo Observatory was far from Leningrad, today it is practically in the city and the starry sky is very hard to see from Pulkovo. The same situation with other telescopes, primarily institute ones. That is why the program involves launching space telescopes 1-2, so that they, when launched into near-earth orbit, are engaged in searching for dangerous objects using spectral and photometric methods. All this requires 58 billion rubles. At the same time, this program will help attract young people to science, improve the qualifications of existing Russian specialists.

Taking into account the fact that over the past 300 years, the statistics are maintained quite well, under the Chelyabinsk meteorite stories led to a massive injury of people (until now there was a 1-2 impact on a person without a fatal outcome, and as a result of the fall of the Chelyabinsk meteorite, more than 1000 people suffered). Therefore, the expenditure of such funds on astronomy, a warning system, tracking of cosmic bodies and warning people is justified.

Yes, we are not yet in a position to divert the cosmic threat from the planet, but we can warn the population about the danger. If astronomers had warned people about the fall of the Chelyabinsk meteorite in time, advised after a bright flash not to approach the windows, many would not have received bruises and cuts from broken glass and broken frames. The frames and windows would have suffered, but not the people, they would have managed to get by with a smaller number of wounded, therefore a warning system about the space threat must be created.

Information sources:
-http: //rus.ruvr.ru/2013_02_20/Kosmicheskij-monitoring-nebesnie-tela-vozmut-pod-kontrol
-http: //vpk.name/news/84771_fcp_byila_sdelana_ne_posle_padeniya_meteorita_a_uzhe_davno.html
-http: //www.fontanka.ru/2013/02/15/174
46 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Svobodny
    +5
    22 February 2013 09: 09
    A hole was made by the Barnaul drill. Diameters 140, 160, 180, 60000 mm
    1. +1
      22 February 2013 12: 45
      Quote: Svobodny
      A hole was made by the Barnaul drill. Diameters 140, 160, 180, 60000 mm

      The news said imported, possibly Mora, at 10000. wink
      1. Axel
        0
        23 February 2013 10: 51
        Quote: Vladimirets
        The news said imported, possibly Mora, at 10000.

        Mora drills for a long time, rather Rapala
  2. +1
    22 February 2013 09: 26
    It seems that it’s impossible even to effectively warn of a space threat to one country, there should be a network across the planet.
    1. avt
      +5
      22 February 2013 10: 06
      Quote: Vladimirets
      It seems that it’s impossible even to effectively warn of a space threat to one country, there should be a network across the planet.

      In my mind, yes. In practice, they will give a pair of telescopes to astronomer-devotee fans, they will sop the rest and calm down. Until the next car.
      1. 0
        22 February 2013 12: 43
        Quote: avt
        In practice, they will give a pair of telescopes to astronomer-devotee fans, the rest will be sopped and calm down

        Well, relatively to us it is clear. But, in principle, if everything even as it should be done, without theft, will anyone pull such a project alone?
        1. 0
          22 February 2013 21: 17
          Quote: Vladimirets
          Well, relatively to us it is clear. But, in principle, if everything even as it should be done, without theft, will anyone pull such a project alone?

          everything is simple, you need to fill up the shops with modern telescopes at a reasonable price. and everyone can watch the sky.
      2. 0
        22 February 2013 13: 38
        avt
        Quote: avt
        In practice, they will give a pair of telescopes to astronomer-devotee fans, they will sop the rest and calm down. Until the next car.


        But Aunt, how is it - Lydia Rykhlova thinks differently: "Lydia Rykhlova has already managed to respond to these claims, noting that currently an absolutely sick society in Russia: nobody talks about cuts. " These are we idiots and sick. And the fact that the Pulkovo Observatory in Zh..E, apparently also only now became known. And before that, everyone who talked about it, yelled - just sick people ...
        Yes, wonderful things.
        It is undeniable that absorberia, telescopes, etc., for their maintenance are needed. But the theme of the early-late meteorite warning is utopian. Moreover, for one state, our .... With such a collapse, everything was once carefully, wisely created.
        1. +5
          22 February 2013 13: 52
          Quote: Z.A.M.
          an absolutely sick society in Russia


          Well, yes, Tolya (Perminov) came "two percent" and placed hucksters at key posts, set up a kickback system, then Popovkin, his protégé, continued the glorious work of increasing the Pacific underwater satellite constellation. But these are not specific "effective managers", they are our society is sick. Now the UK does not have time to file criminal cases. Here is the latest news .. Following Urlichich, another ex-Permian protégé Galkevich went.

          On February 21, investigators of the Fourth Main Directorate of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, operating in closed territories and sensitive facilities, detained Alexander Galkevich, the former president and general designer of the Gonets Satellite System OJSC.
          My webpage
          1. 0
            22 February 2013 14: 27
            Well, in fact, every year the threat from outer space is more and more relevant, and the main dangers, as it seems to me, are not asteroids at all, therefore, a space monitoring system is vital, and on a scale precisely one country , well, the exchange of observational data will become possible only if they have their own data, otherwise no one will tell us anything ... Well, antimeteor systems, as I think, will be able to deal with satellites at any moment and ....
  3. +2
    22 February 2013 09: 35
    A good cut blbl will come out ...
    it’s not for you to master GLONAS. There is a larger project.
  4. Straiser
    +2
    22 February 2013 09: 36
    Huh! There is no money, in recent corruption cases, the figure is 63,5 billion rubles, so the government must recover the money from the perpetrators! Just enough, even stay more;)
  5. Region65
    -2
    22 February 2013 09: 44
    the news showed a video shot by one of the residents of Chelyabinsk .. after all, a meteorite was knocked down by something ... a video from YouTube, I haven’t downloaded it yet to watch it in multiple repetitions, but at first glance it’s clear that it’s not editing. ... the meteorite is really catching up with some kind of crap, after which it already flounders and scatters into many parts ... no one knows? who is such a sniper in our air defense? :)
    1. +4
      22 February 2013 10: 27
      Quote: Region65
      the news showed a video shot by one of the residents of Chelyabinsk .. after all, a meteorite was knocked down by something ... a video from YouTube, I haven’t downloaded it yet to watch it in multiple repetitions, but at first glance it’s clear that it’s not editing. ... the meteorite is really catching up with some kind of crap
      I saw this video too, but I can’t vouch for authenticity, today anyone can skillfully fake it .....
      Quote: Region65
      who is such a sniper in our air defense? :)
      but if he was shot down, then obviously not ours, the S-300 and S-400 and (the A-135 "Cupid" system which only guards Moscow) are not able to intercept such an object flying at such a speed ... yes, I think in the whole world does not find a complex capable of intercepting such an object ... so either he banged himself, or "hello to sleepwalkers" (Well, wait a minute!). I remember here on the site one friend wrote more than once in different topics that a stone does not explode when heated. I wrote to him that it explodes, for example, sea stones in furnaces wassat
      1. Region65
        0
        22 February 2013 14: 34
        Well, the stones certainly explode :) and not necessarily in the ovens :) we will always go to the seaside as a child while swimming - we bake potatoes in the fire :) well, there were humorists among us who put stones for fun with potatoes :) oh how pounding on the legs when waving :))) well, and sleepwalkers - that's for sure ... glory to the sleepwalkers!)))
      2. +1
        22 February 2013 15: 56
        Quote: evgenii67
        and in the whole world there is no complex capable of intercepting such an object

        Intercept this one, but catch up ...

        In general, it's better to browse
        http://topwar.ru/index.php?newsid=24449
        In Chebarkul, where a meteorite has fallen, unscheduled airborne maneuvers will take place, and the General Staff of the Armed Forces for the first time in 20 years conducts a sudden check. Coincidence?
        And this is not the only article on the site!

        wink
      3. +1
        22 February 2013 21: 07
        I was in the news when I saw (I watched without sound), decided without any hesitation, that the Chinese missed the states by the ICBM. Then I realized, of course, that nonsense ...

        I remembered the immortal: "Saddam Hussein is bombing us!" (film "Armageddian").
  6. +1
    22 February 2013 10: 10
    Therefore, the expenditure of such funds on astronomy, a warning system, tracking cosmic bodies and warning people is justified.

    Well, I don’t know, on the one hand, the danger seems to be quite real, but on the other hand, not every day, not even every year (the frequency of the fall of large meteorites is about one in a hundred years) such "stones" fall from the sky. And then the speed of entry of such an object is about 40 km / sec (the time of flight is less than a minute), and the speed of an anti-aircraft missile is about three times less. So I don't understand what kind of department it will be, what it will do, if only the development of the budget. However, these are just my thoughts out loud, maybe the experts will explain to me what the trick is. winked
  7. +5
    22 February 2013 10: 47
    I don’t understand one thing .. nakuya? ohh .. scientists will study meteorites in a bunch of telescopes and? Well, they saw them dancing that he was flying in the direction of Chelyabinsk for example, and then what?

    Ministry of Emergencies will start to cut the siren? Yes, while they will coordinate all issues, he will already be in the atmosphere. Launched right away .. and? Where are the people then run? We have bunkers prepared for current from officials throughout Russia, the remaining bomb shelters are in a deplorable state, people will die more for panic.

    It is necessary not only to observe, but also to develop systems for intercepting meteorites (which is clearly archi difficult, given the speed of objects), to restore bomb shelters, etc.

    And so this is another drank dough and nothing more.
  8. +4
    22 February 2013 11: 43
    I think that our astronomers, and especially the functionaries from science, will take advantage of the situation and try to raise the issue of asteroid danger.
    It is true that in our capabilities to observe space, we have lost a lot. Pulkovo- 100 years old, Zelenchukovsky reflector (once the largest in the world), in my opinion, does not work. An observatory in the highlands is needed, and not one. science must give money.
    And the question of asteroid danger was, is and will be. Humanity will never be able to counter this threat.
  9. Durant
    +3
    22 February 2013 12: 05
    In my opinion, the creation of such a system within the borders of one country is already a gamble. February 15 demonstrated to the whole world about a threat that is purer than "threats to democracy" or "terrorism" ...
    The earth is round and still rotates and a system of this kind must be created across the planet and by the forces of the entire world community, otherwise it is all inefficient.
    1. 0
      22 February 2013 21: 11
      I believe that X-COM-scale programs in real geopolitical and other settings ... mmm ... It’s difficult to implement! Here.
      1. Durant
        0
        23 February 2013 07: 24
        I don’t quite understand what X-COM is, but it seems to me to try in any case, such a threat will unite many ... yes, it seems to me that the efforts of the G20 countries will be quite enough, and they will conduct a dialogue quite successfully. Here)
  10. biglow
    -1
    22 February 2013 12: 26
    An attempt to create anti-meteorite protection will improve the existing air defense systems. So the benefits will still be
  11. 0
    22 February 2013 13: 47
    Quote: biglow
    An attempt to create anti-meteorite protection will improve the existing air defense systems. So the benefits will still be


    watch rockets in telescopes :)
    1. 0
      22 February 2013 21: 14
      Well, why just watch. Using a super-uber-megararadiotelescope to a gas state ... A good project for cutting a budget.
  12. Avenger711
    +1
    22 February 2013 14: 04
    That is, damage every 100 years per billion rubles, and 58 billion at once. Normal ...
    1. 0
      22 February 2013 14: 32
      As I wrote here.
      Was there a boy?)))
  13. +3
    22 February 2013 14: 31
    http://online-films.ckoro.ru/news/pro_meteorit_i_krejzi_rashans/2013-02-21-4672#
    comments

    On the u-tube is still blocked laughing
    About Chelyabinsk meteorite
  14. 0
    22 February 2013 14: 42
    Absolute naive !!!
    Clever men launched a meteorite dummy (whether it was a rocket, including a ballistic one, but without a warhead) and competently cleaned up after themselves.
    Further: veiled, ringing, puzzled.
    In short, they created the appearance of necessity.
    And now they will finance and develop ...

    This is my personal (maybe not quite right) opinion.
    1. Durant
      +2
      22 February 2013 14: 51
      quite "similar" to a warhead
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AaLvTZqXNmU

      Not a single earthly object flies at a speed of more than 8 km / s in the atmosphere ... and here at least 18.
    2. 0
      22 February 2013 16: 07
      Quote: timhelmet
      maybe not quite right

      More precisely, completely wrong!

      There is a video how specifically warheads go towards the goal!

      What is interesting, several articles have already been posted on the site, and read the comments on this article. Such an impression is she _ First!
      Therefore, links from penultimate !
      bully
  15. 0
    22 February 2013 14: 58

    It seems that while the link is working laughing
    1. 0
      22 February 2013 19: 27
      Works ?
      Well, if in your opinion it can be called work, then yes it works.
      laughing
  16. +2
    22 February 2013 15: 07
    Upon the adoption of the program, the politics were filled with plenty, officials rolled back, the warriors demonstrated a prototype of a super-wunderwafer of a cosmic scale, and two school telescopes were presented to astronomers.
    And only an old Chelyabinsk resident Vasya cried bitterly, having received an increased housing bill, and said - "It would be better if this meteorite killed me right away."
  17. 0
    22 February 2013 15: 47
    I have a feeling that even if a comet the size of a state flies into us! And a lot of money is allocated for its elimination, they will still be sawed by a bureaucrat with 3 chins !!!
    There is already a thirst for money overcomes all instincts. Probably they will be sure that they can fuck ... in Martian NEW- London))
  18. Octavian avgust
    0
    22 February 2013 15: 57
    Chelyabinsk opinion:
    There is such a science, called trasology. This science is about traces left. I’m not an expert in it at all, and even we weren’t taught it, but I know about her. With mathematics, geometry and other exact sciences, I have always had great difficulties. When I see the formulas, consciousness immediately blocks. Therefore, all my judgments are just a little observation and reasoning at the level of the "peasant."

    In general, when I read opinions and comments about aliens and meteorites, I decided in more detail to be convinced of my original opinion.

    I reviewed on the Internet all the videos found about accidents during the launch of space rockets and not only. The sounds of the explosion and the accompanying large number of screens coincided, as well as similar tracks.

    Here, for example, the characteristic sound that happened on February 15.02.2013, XNUMX near Chelyabinsk:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kYUrqdUyEpI&feature=endscreen
    or what are the tracks
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dH64pEOzBkc

    From the video we shot on February 15.02.2013, XNUMX we can see how the object ignites, the track begins, accompanied by a bright glow (the self-liquidation of the object apparently began). This is followed by an explosion, a large ball of smoke, a bright glow, a flash. The track continues, but forks. Apparently, the object broke into pieces. The trail continues, still accompanied by a glow. The trail ends, a little more glow of the object continues. And this means that the main part of the object was either able to survive, or its movement continued along the movable trajectory inertia. Judging by the visual speed, the "main part" of the object flew outside the Chelyabinsk region, I think it even easily crossed the neighboring ones. Now the hype with a meteorite around Chelyabinsk will allow you to easily and without too much attention pick up the "main part".
  19. Mr. Truth
    0
    23 February 2013 01: 07
    Give nuclear weapons in space!
    1. Durant
      0
      23 February 2013 07: 26
      its efficiency in airless space is very small ...
      1. 0
        23 February 2013 13: 35
        Quote: Durant
        very small ...

        More precisely, no wink
        In most cases, an air shock wave (IWV) is the most powerful damaging factor.
        Light radiation from a nuclear explosion
        Penetrating radiation
        Nuclear pollution
        Electromagnetic pulse (EMP)
        In space, it’s straight very effective, especially the first factor wink
        Have seen enough of the television series ...
        1. Durant
          0
          23 February 2013 13: 58
          Namely, I would also add thermal effect to this list, this is probably the only thing that can cause damage ...
          1. 0
            23 February 2013 14: 40
            Quote: Durant
            thermal exposure

            Hmm.
            In space, where everything has heat protection !!!
            The sun shines there not childishly!

            All the noise _ No nuclear weapons in space, due to the possibility of using space-based nuclear weapons to strike on the surface of the planet!
            There is practically no protection. The flight time is a maximum of a couple of minutes!
            1. Durant
              0
              24 February 2013 13: 27
              Quote: Cynic
              In space, where everything has heat protection !!!
              The sun shines there not childishly!

              What thermal protection ... tell the comets.
              The Sun is shining the same for everyone, and a meteorite (for example, Chelyabinsk) seems to have not come close to the sun so much so that the temperature on it in his whole life would exceed the temperature that a nuclear explosion would tell him ... so that nuclear weapons are only against comets capable of opposing something ...
  20. Volkhov
    +2
    23 February 2013 21: 33
    “Russian astronomers” are completely out of the question - in this case, the telescope will not help, it is better to give their salaries to the crows - they reacted in advance to the threat from space - much cheaper and more reliable.
    I especially like the estimate of 2 billion dollars, compiled in a day and got to the vice-premier ... you can’t drink the skill and here they are specialists.
  21. 0
    24 February 2013 08: 05
    Who will say - what separated from the main meteorite and flew forward? is it possible in principle? Or near Chelyabinsk the Predator to look for a time?
    1. Durant
      0
      24 February 2013 13: 32
      Of course it is possible ... a meteorite flew, reached the dense layers of the atmosphere, exploded, but large fragments flew further ... a mineral meteorite so the explosion is natural.
    2. +1
      24 February 2013 13: 34
      Quote: cumastra1
      Who will say what separated

      And what exactly do you want to hear?
      Here either
      If you watch the video, then this that caught up with the object and passing through it overtook it.
      As you put it
      Quote: cumastra1
      and flew forward

      The object collapsed.
      At such speeds, the apparatuses of our civilization do not fly, and if they fly ... It hurts a little time to make a decision.
      or
      Elementary glare, like on other videos this is not fixed?
      And there is still much that flies in different directions, plasma?
      1. Durant
        0
        24 February 2013 18: 58
        it’s nice that not many are being taken into this video ... as if nobody had ever seen glare on the glass of a car ...
        1. 0
          24 February 2013 21: 01
          Quote: Durant
          it's nice that not many are on this video ...

          As you can see many:
          Quote: Volkhov
          The charge coming from above launched an explosion, and plasma flew forward and to the sides

          wink
    3. Volkhov
      +2
      24 February 2013 19: 29
      Clouds of plasma - their motion compresses its own magnetic field.
      The charge that came from above launched an explosion, and forward and to the side the plasma flew into which a piece of ice had turned. In an explosion of synthesis, there are no more solid bodies than megatons. Locals will gradually turn into Predators, birds and animals have already disappeared.
      1. Durant
        0
        25 February 2013 09: 03
        What kind of scenario is it for the domestic fiction action movie write? it should work out well ...
        1. Volkhov
          +1
          25 February 2013 09: 34
          There is always enough reality - those who do not believe in theory, practice flies.
  22. Durant
    0
    24 February 2013 13: 27
    Quote: Cynic
    In space, where everything has heat protection !!!
    The sun shines there not childishly!

    What thermal protection ... tell the comets.
    The Sun is shining the same for everyone, and a meteorite (for example, Chelyabinsk) seems to have not come close to the sun so much so that the temperature on it in his whole life would exceed the temperature that a nuclear explosion would tell him ... so that nuclear weapons are only against comets capable of opposing something ...
  23. 0
    24 February 2013 20: 59
    It is interesting that such a thing can be written in such a topic to deserve the highest measure of social protection, it is simply interesting.
    Although different creatures roam the net, sometimes in essence bitchiness!
    drinks
  24. 0
    24 February 2013 23: 19
    "On countering the threat" wink
    Intersely, but the ordinary market can not be organized?
    Two percent of respondents are notified, not a little.
    1. 0
      25 February 2013 10: 35
      Quote: Andriuha077
      and ordinary market can not be organized?

      No.
      More practical
      Quote: Andriuha077
      Two percent of respondents are notified, not a little.

      Mmm
      This is a magic two percent, they can be specific 100% of the members of the distribution group!
      Are some more equal than others?