Military Review

American journalist considers Hamas attack on Israel a “failure” for the Palestinian movement

27
American journalist considers Hamas attack on Israel a “failure” for the Palestinian movement

The plan of the Palestinian Hamas movement, which had been preparing an armed raid on Israel for two years, turned out to be a failure. This conclusion was made by American investigative journalist Seymour Hersh, who refers to his own sources in the US intelligence services.


According to Hersh, Washington allegedly has information that Hamas has been preparing a raid on Israeli territory for two years. The Palestinian movement was counting on help from Hezbollah and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), but this did not happen. Neither Hezbollah nor the PLO invaded Israeli territory.

The main purpose of the raid was to disrupt negotiations between Israel and Saudi Arabia, according to American intelligence agencies. Hamas feared that if Israeli-Saudi relations were normalized, it would lead to the isolation of Palestinian radical organizations.

As for financial and material support, Hamas receives it from Iran, Hersh’s interlocutor claims. But the Iranian authorities did not realize the consequences of a Palestinian attack on Israel in terms of civilian casualties and international reaction. In fact, the Palestinian movement acted as a pawn in a chess game played not by Hamas.

However, one can argue with the conclusions of Hersh and his interlocutor from American intelligence. Israel’s relations with Saudi Arabia, and other Arab countries, suffered a very strong blow, anti-Israeli sentiment in the world increased, the West received another “headache” and an expense item in addition to the Ukrainian conflict, and strikes on a hospital in Gaza caused sharp discontent among everyone peace.
27 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. 75 Sergey
    75 Sergey 19 October 2023 09: 57
    +2
    Well, I agree, they did something stupid, knowing the Jews - what did they expect?! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
    1. knn54
      knn54 19 October 2023 10: 12
      +1
      Hamaz is not the WHOLE Palestinian movement. In fact, the legitimate power of the Palestinian Authority represented by the PLO in the Gaza Strip fell as a result of the Hamas coup.
      Although, against the backdrop of ongoing events, disagreements (even for some period) will be minimized
      1. Clear
        Clear 19 October 2023 10: 28
        -3
        Quote: knn54
        Although, against the backdrop of ongoing events, disagreements (even for some period) will be minimized

        So Israel is doing everything for this.
        For Palestinians, living conditions have remained virtually unchanged. Even before this, those who came in large numbers destroyed them, but it seems that Israeli citizens will not be able to learn Ukrainian songs and post them on Tik Tok for a long time.
        1. Fisherman
          Fisherman 19 October 2023 11: 02
          0
          That's right...it was Israel that financed Hamas together with the USA and the EU, they are controlled by MI6 in terms of reconnaissance and command of detachments, until recently the USA supplied them with armored cars, and Netanyahu financed them in order to have “his own Palestinian opposition”. So no Hezbollah (Shiite) and other Palestinian movements have followed or will follow the lead of Sunni Hamas. But the fact that Hamas, with a light blow, lowered the level of fairy tales about the coolness of the Israeli army, technology and intelligence below the waterline - it just so happened that it turned out that Israel had a heap and a small cart of disgrace. Hamas took revenge on the entire Arab world in 3 days, wholesale, now every Arab and Persian player in this region will kick Israel through their “proxies” so hard and painfully that the return does not arrive (Ukraine has shown that this is possible, Pandora’s box is open, whose there are drones, missiles, grenade launchers and fighters - no one answers).
      2. voyaka uh
        voyaka uh 19 October 2023 11: 35
        +5
        "the power of the Palestinian Authority represented by the PLO in the Gaza Strip fell as a result of the Hamas coup" ///
        ---
        When the short battle in Gaza between the PLO and Hamas ended in victory for Hamas, the massacre began.
        The wounded PLO fighters who were being treated were thrown from the roof of Gaza's main hospital (built by Israel, by the way) by Hamas.
        Quite in the style of the Islamic State, although long before it.
    2. Clear
      Clear 19 October 2023 10: 23
      +1
      Quote: 75Sergey
      Well, I agree, they did something stupid, knowing the Jews - what did they expect?! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

      “It turned out stupid,” this is exactly the assessment of the Jews.
      And, in fact, it turned out as in that expression:
      - Why do you have a black eye under your eye?
      - Let them not interfere!
    3. Netwallker
      Netwallker 19 October 2023 10: 35
      +2
      Today, data was published on the number of foreign citizens killed or missing as a result of the Hamas terrorist attack. The tragedy affected citizens of 41 countries:
      Austria – 3 people killed;
      Argentina - 17 killed and 8 missing;
      Australia – 1 missing;
      Azerbaijan – 3 killed, 1 missing;
      Belarus – 2 killed;
      Brazil - 6 killed, 2 missing;
      Cambodia - 1 killed;
      Canada - 5 killed, 2 missing;
      Chile - 1 killed, 1 missing;
      China - 4 killed, 3 missing;
      Colombia – 2 missing;
      Eritrea – 1 missing;
      Estonia – 1 missing;
      France - 22 killed, 3 missing;
      Germany - 12 killed, 7 missing;
      India - 2 killed, 4 missing;
      Ireland - 1 killed, 1 missing;
      Italy - 4 killed, 5 missing;
      Kazakhstan – 1 killed, 2 missing;
      Latvia – 2 killed;
      Lithuania – 1 killed;
      Moldova – 2 killed;
      Nepal – 5 killed;
      Panama – 1 missing;
      Paraguay - 1 killed;
      Peru – 1 killed;
      Philippines - 4 killed, 1 missing;
      Poland – 1 missing;
      Portugal - 1 killed;
      Romania - 4 killed, 1 missing;
      Russia – 18 killed, 8 missing;
      South Africa - 2 killed, 1 missing;
      Spain – 2 missing;
      Sri Lanka - 1 killed, 1 missing;
      Sudan - 1 killed;
      Thailand - 15 killed, 5 missing;
      Türkiye – 3 killed;
      UK - 10 killed, 5 missing;
      Ukraine – 23 killed, 1 missing;
      USA - 29 killed, 10 missing;
      Uzbekistan – 6 killed, 3 missing.
  2. StopTheUSA
    StopTheUSA 19 October 2023 09: 57
    -1
    Sure sure...
    Here you can only smile laughing
  3. AAK
    AAK 19 October 2023 09: 57
    +1
    the hospital needs to be dealt with, the situation there could be a consequence of the actions of both sides: either an Israeli air strike, or Hamas’s own missed missile - this happened many times in the former Ukrainian SSR, when their own anti-aircraft missiles fell on houses and other objects, and there were also 3 or 4 proven direct missile attacks by Bandera on their territory...
    1. Colt
      Colt 19 October 2023 11: 27
      -1
      we need to deal with the hospital,


      There's no need to deal with anything. Bucha and Boeing were pinned on Russia “in 6 seconds.” And no evidence worked. The same is necessary with the Israeli Nazi punitive forces - the hospital was definitely bombed by Israel! And don’t care about their excuses and evidence. They are a priori guilty.
      1. surf dude
        surf dude 19 October 2023 12: 57
        0
        the hospital was definitely bombed by Israel![quote][/quote]
        Exactly! And in Bucha there operated a bloodthirsty, Zionist-imperialist special forces named after the blue and white banner, a puppet of small-shaven men and mattress makers!
        Change the dealer, they are selling you something wrong.
  4. APASUS
    APASUS 19 October 2023 09: 59
    +1
    Hersh is of course a smart guy, but in my opinion he’s wrong:
    1 It is not yet evening and participation in the battles between Hezbollah and the PLO is very possible.
    2 The material and political damage inflicted on Israel on all fronts is simply enormous.
    3 When did Israel suffer such losses, when did the Israelis fall into captivity in the hundreds?
    4 They essentially tore up the agreement between Israel and the Saudis
    5 There was a unification of Arabs around the world.
    6 The issue of Palestinian statehood is again on the agenda
    and on and on
    1. Clear
      Clear 19 October 2023 10: 33
      0
      Quote: APASUS
      Hersh is certainly a smart guy,

      So, I beg you, on what side and in what place is he smart, if winked

      Quote: APASUS
      1 It is not yet evening and participation in the battles between Hezbollah and the PLO is very possible.
      2 The material and political damage inflicted on Israel on all fronts is simply enormous.
      3 When did Israel suffer such losses, when did the Israelis fall into captivity in the hundreds?
      4 They essentially tore up the agreement between Israel and the Saudis
      5 There was a unification of Arabs around the world.
      6 The issue of Palestinian statehood is again on the agenda
      and on and on
      1. APASUS
        APASUS 19 October 2023 13: 49
        0
        Quote: Clear
        So, I beg you, on what side and in what place is he smart, if

        When you get any of this, you can call him a liar! In the meantime.........
        prize
        George Polk Award (1973) Letelier-Moffitt Human Rights Award (2004) Bingham Honorable Mention Award (1969) Orwell Award (2004) Lennon and Ono Peace Prize (2004) Pulitzer Prize for International reporting (1970) George Polk Award (1969) George Polk Award (1974) George Polk Award (1981) George Polk Award (2004) Sam Adams Award (2017) Freedom and Future of the Media Award[d] (2005) International journalism Manuel Vázquez Montalban Prize[d] (2007) Weintal Prize for Diplomatic Reporting[d] (2005)
  5. Enceladus
    Enceladus 19 October 2023 10: 01
    0
    Drink Hershey Cola and your hair will be smooth and silky! What kind of Danila, what kind of player?! (c) Brother 1 There are no other words. I also have a bunch of insider sources, but I don’t consider myself a journalist. Security is more expensive. If the information were to be published, then he would either already be ashes in an urn or known throughout the world. And so - the editor’s money was spent.
    1. Clear
      Clear 19 October 2023 10: 39
      +1
      Quote from Enceladus
      then he would either already be ashes in an urn or known throughout the world.

      Usually these two moments occur in one event winked
  6. tralflot1832
    tralflot1832 19 October 2023 10: 07
    0
    10 kg of bombs have already been dropped on the Gaza Strip for every square kilometer. So for statistics. It can be compared with the bombing of cities in the Second World War.
    1. Nikolaevich I
      Nikolaevich I 19 October 2023 10: 22
      +1
      I’ve been talking about Jewish fascism for a long time now...I’ve mentioned it more than once at VO! Especially since 2014! At that time, those Jewish “comrades” were still actively appearing on VO in the “chapter” with the “Professor”, who have been absent from this site for some time! That’s when I “heard enough” of the “theses” of Jewish fascism! It was then that I first used this expression: “Jewish fascism”! Since then, the situation, in general, has not changed, nor has my opinion!
    2. Clear
      Clear 19 October 2023 10: 44
      0
      Quote: tralflot1832
      Can be compared to the bombing of cities in World War II.

      It was the bombing of the allies (USA and England) as acts of intimidation.
    3. ism_ek
      ism_ek 19 October 2023 10: 52
      +3
      Quote: tralflot1832
      So for statistics. Can be compared with the bombing of cities in the Second World War.

      Well, compare for statistics.(((Before the last assault on Sevastopol, the Germans dropped 15000 bombs on it in two days.
      I'm not making excuses for Israel, but Hamas is greatly exaggerating the attacks on the Jews.
      After all, no one actually bombed the same hospital. Apart from the cars burned in the parking lot, there was no other damage.
  7. Huarabey
    Huarabey 19 October 2023 10: 11
    +1
    Is this an attempt to quarrel between Hamas and Hezbollah and the PLO?
    1. Nyrobsky
      Nyrobsky 19 October 2023 11: 17
      +1
      Quote: Warabey
      Is this an attempt to quarrel between Hamas and Hezbollah and the PLO?

      No, this is an attempt to wash the pants of Netanyahu and Bidon.
      As for Hersh’s conclusion regarding the “failed attack,” it is very premature, since everything is just beginning and the outcome of this whole undertaking is not yet obvious.
      It is clear that Hamas will not be able to cope militarily, but apparently it did not have such a goal; the bet was made on the fact that Israel’s image defeat would be worse than the military one, which is what is happening.
  8. Gomunkul
    Gomunkul 19 October 2023 10: 16
    0
    The plan of the Palestinian Hamas movement, which had been preparing an armed raid on Israel for two years, turned out to be a failure. This conclusion was made by American investigative journalist Seymour Hersh, who refers to his own sources in the US intelligence services.
    The actions of Hamas only played into the hands of the United States and Israel in implementing the plan to build a “Greater Israel.”
    "Great Israel" covers the area from the Nile Valley to the Euphrates.
    The Zionist project aims to support the Jewish resettlement movement. In a broader sense, this means the withdrawal of Palestinians from Palestine, which will ultimately lead to the annexation of the East Bank and Gaza Strip into Israeli territory.

    link to source: https://www.csef.ru/ru/oborona-i-bezopasnost/340/velikij-izrail-plan-sionistov-po-pereustrojstvu-blizhnego-vostoka-4088?ysclid=lnwui29faq264815917
    It can be assumed that the plans of Hamas were known, and perhaps were prepared with the support of the intelligence services of the United States and Israel (the emphasis in the actions of Hamas is very similar to the actions of other terrorist organizations that are being prepared by Western “partners”). The purpose of this provocation is to free Israel’s hands to implement the plan for building the Great Israel.
  9. rocket757
    rocket757 19 October 2023 10: 31
    0
    American journalist considers Hamas attack on Israel a “failure” for the Palestinian movement
    . Another version, a prediction... what will happen, who knows.
    Wait and see.
  10. Denis812
    Denis812 19 October 2023 10: 32
    +2
    The main purpose of the raid was to disrupt negotiations between Israel and Saudi Arabia, according to American intelligence agencies

    Absolutely agree. Any anti-Jewish sentiments or anything else is a minor matter, but if the Saudis and Israelis normalized relations, then for Hamas and other radicals it would be almost a fatal blow.
    In general, they didn't have much choice.
    Either strike while you have the strength and funding, or quietly fall apart.
  11. digger
    digger 19 October 2023 10: 40
    -3
    Hamas will never lose to the weirdo from the USA! Because Hamas has already publicly lowered and crushed the image of the IDF and all Israeli intelligence in front of the whole world, and even destroyed the image of the vaunted tank. All. These facts of failure will remain forever...even if Israel completely destroys Hamas...but in reality this is never possible. HAAMAS just needs to survive and he will already win.
  12. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 19 October 2023 10: 54
    +1
    armed raid into Israel was a failure.
    With respect to Hersh, but he is not entirely right. In terms of immediate support for Hamas from Hezbollah and others, it may not have justified itself yet, but it has caused significant damage to the image of the IDF in the Arab world and beyond. In addition, Hamas completed a number of tasks set before it at the first stage. And talking only exclusively about failure is like Biden’s stupid statement that “Russia lost the war in Ukraine.”