A deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation suggested that civil servants “voluntarily” transfer two percent of their income to the needs of the Northern Military District

A rather controversial, at least at first glance, initiative was made by the first deputy chairman of the State Duma Committee on Education, a member of the “A Just Russia-For Truth” faction, Yana Lantratova. The deputy proposed creating a charitable subscription “Contribution to Victory”, within the framework of which some categories of civil servants and deputies will “voluntarily” transfer two percent of monthly income to the needs of the SVO. Lantratova has already sent a corresponding letter to Russian Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin, Russian media report.

The deputy believes that these contributions could be made by State Duma deputies, legislators at the regional and municipal levels, heads of state-owned enterprises, federal budgetary institutions and state corporations. The money will be transferred to the state fund for supporting participants in the special military operation “Defenders of the Fatherland,” created by decree of Russian President Vladimir Putin in April of this year. Now branches of the fund are open in all Russian regions. The main goal of the fund is personal social support for veterans of the Northern Military District and assistance in obtaining all required support measures.

It seems that in this situation Russian civil servants should be at the forefront of the patriotic movement

— the first deputy chairman of the State Duma Committee on Education is confident.

She explained that in Russia there are many people who want to make their contribution to the fight for the liberation of the residents of Novorossiya, for the future of the country. Lantratova did not specify what prevents them, without “instructions from above,” from depositing money both into the presidential fund and transferring it to other special accounts, from where the funds go to support SVO participants, members of their families, and humanitarian aid to residents of Novorossiya.

Moreover, millions of Russians and thousands of businessmen regularly transfer money and provide other assistance to soldiers on the front line and residents of new regions of the Russian Federation on a voluntary basis. Volunteers say that older people sometimes literally demand to accept part of their pension in order to “help their sons at the front.”

In addition to the above category of officials and civil servants, a deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation proposed to recommend participation in the charitable subscription “Contribution to Victory” to those civil servants-managers whose families’ average per capita income exceeds three subsistence minimums.

The initiative of the Fair Russia deputy may be correct and good. But its mechanism is very reminiscent of the times of the USSR, when “voluntary” contributions were collected at enterprises and institutions, either for the purchase of lottery tickets or for some other socially useful cause. These collections were mainly carried out by representatives of trade unions or party workers, who received the corresponding directive and orders from above. The money was collected from a list of employees.

It was possible to refuse the contribution, but this could be fraught with all sorts of very unpleasant consequences, for example, in the form of deprivation of bonuses, public censure or career problems. With regular sabotage, they could be expelled from the Komsomol or have their party membership taken away, and this was already completely bad for Soviet citizens of that time.

It should be borne in mind that if regular charitable contributions begin to be collected using the voluntary-compulsory method, then among some of the citizens included in the “Lantratova list” this may cause, albeit not obvious, latent resistance. This will not at all benefit their attitude towards both the authorities and the special operation itself and its participants.

Comments

[Orange Bigg]

A deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation suggested that civil servants “voluntarily” transfer two percent of their income to the needs of the Northern Military District

And who will this 2 percent go into? Ukraine already had a similar law. Nothing good came out of this. You should not copy the unsuccessful experience of the Western training ground.
I wonder, do the deputies of the State Duma of the Russian Federation transfer two percent of their income to the needs of the SVO? Or should state employees do this, otherwise our deputies live poorly, but we can take 2% from state employees? In general, that is, taxes that go to that including the army.

[Lev_Russia]

Why was...??? They want to triple the military tax for individuals in Ukraine from January 1, 2024, according to a bill proposed by the country’s Ministry of Finance. Since 2014, all individuals in Ukraine pay military duty in the amount of 1,5% of accrued wages. In July, the military was exempted from paying it.

[Egeny]

And who will go into his pocket...

There is no need to count money in someone else's pocket, it is indecent.
And the fact that the Duma and the rest of the bureaucratic riffraff will not become poorer is certain.
You can... and not voluntarily, and not with two...

[coinsam]

And what was the failure? On the contrary, it was successful, although unpopular.

[alystan]

I wonder if deputies of the State Duma of the Russian Federation transfer two percent of their income to the needs of the Northern Military District?

They could transfer one salary at a time painlessly.
They definitely would not have suffered from hunger/cold.

[IL-18]

some categories of civil servants and deputies will “voluntarily” transfer 2% of INCOME. This could be much more than the salary.
And it’s very interesting whether the tax office or the FSB, apart from the conscience of the transferor, will determine the income?
Maybe they will start thinking about how to destroy the fifth column?

[Warrior with machine gun]

Where do they get such enterprising “geniuses”? And with the juiciest billionaires it’s weak...?

[topol717]

Quote: Warrior with machine gun

Where do they get such enterprising “geniuses”? And with the juiciest billionaires it’s weak...?

Why do people in Russia always want to take something away from someone???? Nobody wants to earn money themselves. No one is offering to invest money in the chemical industry, but each beast wants to take away from the other? Money must work. A person must have a desire to earn money.
And if everyone knows that the money will be taken away no matter what, then there will be no point in straining. This is how the Soviet Union ended, in which there were no rich people. Most likely, modern Russia will end up like this too. Because why try to do anything, anyway, either Usatiy will come with a new tax, or another madam will ask to share, and the poor people will always support such people. The only trouble is that capital will flow away to places where they are not robbed.

[alexku69]

On the contrary. The USSR died and died because too many people began to believe that THEY ARE... earn much more than they receive :) Especially in a government intertwined with the guild workers... I wanted to monetize (legitimize) my income from power

[paul3390]

Actually, there are taxes that also go to the army.

I would propose an alternative project - to disperse all the deputies to hell, due to the lack of at least some sense from them, and transfer the huge salaries of servants of the people that have been released to the war. Another plus is that there will be fewer idiotic laws... Otherwise, this crazy printer will sometimes leave you in a daze...

[Escariot]

Quote: paul3390

Actually, there are taxes that also go to the army.

I would propose an alternative project - to disperse all the deputies to hell, due to the lack of at least some sense from them, and transfer the huge salaries of servants of the people that have been released to the war. Another plus is that there will be fewer idiotic laws... Otherwise, this crazy printer will sometimes leave you in a daze...

So what, the president will rule without Parliament? It will then already be a monarchy. No, it’s better to choose normal deputies

[faiver]

It’s better to choose normal deputies

- so big, but you believe in fairy tales... There are no normal ones

[AdAstra]

And there, it’s not just their money that goes to their salaries.

[alexku69]

“The so-called partners,” as the overlord said yesterday, will not understand...

[your vsr 66-67]

It was possible to refuse the contribution, but this could be fraught with all sorts of very unpleasant consequences,

Whoever wants what, says what he wants!
Almost all of my work experience is in the USSR. And I don’t remember “voluntarily” collecting any contributions, especially for lottery tickets! .
Yes, there were dues to the union. There was also a mutual aid fund, purely voluntary. There were subbotniks. But there were no other contributions!

[topol717]

Quote: your vsr 66-67

Yes, there were dues to the union. There was also a mutual aid fund, purely voluntary. There were subbotniks. But there were no other contributions!

Come on. I went to school in the 70s. constantly asked to give 20-50 kopecks to the “offended” children of Africa. When I was working, they collected money to help Chernobyl victims and Stepanakert.

[your vsr 66-67]

Quote from: topol717

Quote: your vsr 66-67

Yes, there were dues to the union. There was also a mutual aid fund, purely voluntary. There were subbotniks. But there were no other contributions!

Come on. I went to school in the 70s. constantly asked to give 20-50 kopecks to the “offended” children of Africa. When I was working, they collected money to help Chernobyl victims and Stepanakert.

I studied at school in the 50s and 60s. In the 70s, he was already working full time, having served in the army. Therefore, I can’t say anything about the school of the 70s. But about Chernobyl and Stepanakert victims I will say unequivocally: it didn’t happen! At least on the railway. D. transport was not collected from us!
Maybe I worked in the wrong structure?

[Hariton]

They didn’t collect anything like that from us; they collected Komsomol and society membership fees.
They didn’t ask for Chernobyl victims. Maybe Ostap Bender cheated you. I collected contributions for 2 kopecks, and tickets for 10 and 20 kopecks during school holidays as an assistant projectionist.
Yes, under totalitarianism, children were forced to work, so without making noise, 2 kopecks will not be asked for contributions.

[alexku69]

And she just made a reservation that SOME civil servants and deputies

[AUL]

Quote from Orange Bigg

A deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation suggested that civil servants “voluntarily” transfer two percent of their income to the needs of the Northern Military District

Should we calculate income taking into account bribes?

[Yu-81]

Just as you shouldn’t copy the model of a socio-political formation. You look and everything else will begin to correspond to the aspirations of the people.. Or do you only see this as a problem?

[kakvastam]

From state employees - two percent, and all sorts of Abaramovichs are too poor to help the army. Maybe Ukrainian.

[Andrey Yuryevich]

Quote: kakvastam

From state employees - two percent,

from us, from pennies...we can’t handle it. If we run out of potatoes, we’ll turn to chaff. On TV, they ask for money for sick children from whom? Yes, from the old people, who else is watching the zombie box? Old people are no strangers to carrying things.

[your1970]

Quote: Andrey Yurievich

Quote: kakvastam
From state employees - two percent,

from us, from pennies... we can make do with it. If we run out of potatoes, we’ll switch to chaff.

Are you a civil servant? Head of a government agency? And yet you live on chaff?

[Starover_Z]

Quote: kakvastam

From state employees - two percent, and all sorts of Abaramovichs are too poor to help the army. Maybe Ukrainian.

So indicated from whom

These contributions could be made by State Duma deputies, legislators at the regional and municipal levels, heads of state-owned enterprises, federal budgetary institutions and state corporations.

And why not?! Or should only the budgetary population be able to provide assistance?!
And for the indicated categories it was possible to write this into the “obligation”, otherwise we often only read about “golden parachutes”! "Gazpro-o-m", "Rosneft" - AU?!

[Tatanka Yotanka]

what's the point? just now the Defenders of the Fatherland Foundation distributed the 1,314 billion rubles allocated by the government to itself, most of it, more precisely 97%, Chairman of the Defenders of the Fatherland State Fund Anna Tsivileva https://www.vedomosti.ru/society/articles/2023/06/19/981074- fond-zaschitniki-otechestva-raspredelil-videlennie-pravitelstvom

[Starover_Z]

Quote: Tatanka Yotanka

what's the point? just now the Defenders of the Fatherland Foundation distributed the 1,314 billion rubles allocated by the government to itself, most of it, more precisely 97%, Chairman of the Defenders of the Fatherland State Fund Anna Tsivileva https://www.vedomosti.ru/society/articles/2023/06/19/981074- fond-zaschitniki-otechestva-raspredelil-videlennie-pravitelstvom

I ran the article through the link. A good “feeder” - they didn’t start working, but they started getting paid.
Almost in the style of “Popandopoly” - this is “for you”, this is again “for you” and again “for you”!
New version of "Rossnano"?!

[Zoldat_A]

Quote: Starover_Z

A good “feeder” - they didn’t start working, but they started getting paid.

My mother, who taught Russian literature at a university all her life, always says: “Read the classics - everything is written there.”

So what does our dear Nikolai Vasilyevich tell us about charitable foundations in the drafts of the second volume of Dead Souls?

Suddenly, like the wind blows, we will start charitable, incentive and who knows what kind of societies. The goal will be wonderful, but despite all this, nothing will come of it. Maybe this happens because we are suddenly satisfied at the very beginning and already consider that everything is done.
For example, having started some charitable society for the poor and donated significant sums, we immediately, in commemoration of such a commendable act, give a dinner to all the first dignitaries of the city, of course, for half of all donated amounts; for the rest, a magnificent apartment is immediately rented for the committee, with heating and watchmen, and then the entire amount remains for the poor, five rubles and a half, and even here in the distribution of this amount not all members agree with each other, and everyone shoves in some of their own godfather

A century and a half has passed - but as they say today...

[Neo-9947]

Read the classics....

.......................................

[topol717]

Quote: Starover_Z

And for the indicated categories it was possible to write this into the “obligation”, otherwise we often only read about “golden parachutes”! "Gazpro-o-m", "Rosneft" - AU?!

Gazprom and Rosneft should invest money not in SVO, but in the development of production, so that in 5 years they will receive taxes from these organizations and more than now. Otherwise, not only will we not have mechanical engineering, but also hydrocarbon production will collapse.

[dmi.pris1]

This means managers. By the way, the same head doctor of the Central District Hospital has a good salary. But with us everyone will take action and pay - EVERYONE.

[Doccor18]

Quote from: dmi.pris1

apparently managers. By the way, the same head physician of the Central District Hospital

Don't touch the main ones, they still have to finish optimization...

[tralflot1832]

The tax on the super-rich in Russia will bring 117 billion rubles to the budget in 2023. They won’t be offended.

[Ross xnumx]

Quote: tralflot1832

The tax on the super-rich in Russia will bring 117 billion rubles to the budget in 2023.

Are they the ones who receive more than 5? Is it with 000%?
And according to the progressive scale, they had to pay 350 rubles and those $000 billion that floated out of the country in 000 could give 243 rubles...
What did you want? Oil and gas are not in Russia for the purpose of swindlers selling it at exorbitant prices and skerries of profits abroad...

[tralflot1832]

ROSS 42. This tax applies to oligarchs of Potanin’s level and above. More than a billion dollars, this is normal. Are you aware that Potanin deprived his children of an inheritance? If he dies, everything will go to charity.

[alexku69]

But until he dies... Let him pay on par with a janitor from Perdyansk...

[Labrador]

The level of populism is off the charts!
If you want to donate, donate. But why impose a mandatory or voluntary obligation on others!? And the answer is simple: to pump the system! Well, you don’t even need to think about it and you can promote yourself.

[Seal]

Quote: kakvastam

From state employees - two percent,

I agree about the Abramovichs. But you brought in state employees in vain. It is clearly said that civil servants. Of course, they are also state employees, but they are a “special part”, so to speak. It is again proposed to impose this tax on deputies. In the end, how many of them can simply be imposed on the Russian people.... It’s time to tax them. I would like to hope that we are talking not only about state civil servants (who hold positions in the state civil service), but also about those who occupy government positions.

[Hariton]

State employees are not civil servants!)
For example, military personnel are not state employees.
Civil servants have different pension legislation.
And public sector employees in the region can be up to 40% of employees on an employment contract.

[Escariot]

Quote: kakvastam

From state employees - two percent, and all sorts of Abaramovichs are too poor to help the army. Maybe Ukrainian.

So it's voluntary. Abramovich doesn’t want to voluntarily - it’s his right. But the school teacher wants it. Maybe.

[ALARI]

within the framework of which some categories of civil servants and deputies will “voluntarily” transfer truthfully put the word voluntarily in quotation marks. This is exactly what happens with us “voluntarily”

[Prisoner]

Let them also unfasten the illegal ones. Don't go to a fortune teller, there's a lot more to it.

[trophy]

It would be better if this madam “not a bird” was engaged in her direct duties. And it would be absolutely wonderful if she directed part of her irrepressible energy to justifying the word “fair” in the name of her party.

[Aleksandr21]

Why not force Russian oligarchs, multi-billionaires and simply rich people to transfer some percentage of their income to the needs of the Northern Military District? After all, they earn money in Russia... and the time has come to help the country, especially since they have the opportunity to do this.

This is in any way better than under pressure to oblige civil servants/public sector employees to transfer a percentage of their average (or even low) salary... then everyone needs to be “obliged”, otherwise it will turn out strange when teachers/educators/workers education/doctors and others will transfer salaries to SVO when in business/trade and other areas they will not do this... all this will only lead to negativity and social tension, and in general it is not worth implementing the idea in this way. ...... if you shake it, then really rich people who won’t lose much from this.

[your1970]

Quote: Aleksandr21

oblige civil servants/public sector employees to transfer % of their average (or even low) salary.... then everyone should be “obliged”, otherwise it will turn out strange when teachers/educators/educators/doctors and others will transfer salary at SVO

I'll tell you a secret

Quote: Aleksandr21

teachers/educators/educators/doctors

quite NOT civil servants. Moreover, they are often not even state employees in big cities

[75 Sergey]

So maybe their property is better than that....

[Escariot]

Quote: Aleksandr21

Why not force Russian oligarchs, multi-billionaires and simply rich people to transfer some percentage of their income to the needs of the Northern Military District? After all, they earn money in Russia... and the time has come to help the country, especially since they have the opportunity to do this.

This is in any way better than under pressure to oblige civil servants/public sector employees to transfer a percentage of their average (or even low) salary... then everyone needs to be “obliged”, otherwise it will turn out strange when teachers/educators/workers education/doctors and others will transfer salaries to SVO when in business/trade and other areas they will not do this... all this will only lead to negativity and social tension, and in general it is not worth implementing the idea in this way. ...... if you shake it, then really rich people who won’t lose much from this.

Why do the oligarchs HAVE to transfer some percentage? It's their money and they can do with it as they please.

[Aleksandr21]

Quote from Escariot

Why do the oligarchs HAVE to transfer some percentage? It's their money and they can do with it as they please.

Because they OWE the Motherland, because... Most of the oligarchs in Russia made their fortunes in the 90s, and at the expense of the broad masses of the population, somewhere they deceived them, somewhere through connections they bought state funds on the cheap. assets, etc. and the oligarchs of the new generation... who are we? Those who are associated with power, i.e. people related to the oil and gas sector of the country, their heirs and other associates.... where is capital made in our country?

These are not Steve Jobs, not Elon Musks and not other gifted individuals... their money and capital were earned differently and they MUST help the country in this difficult hour.

[alex aircraft]

First, they will test it on officials, then they will start collecting from all citizens. In fact, this is an analogue of the Ukropov military tax - 1,5% of the salary. He can first deal with people like Bulgakov and ask him delicately, jerking the shutter of the TT - where are the 1.5 million sets uniforms???

[Skorin]

As if now citizens do not pay for SVO and much higher than 1,5-2%! Through an increase in excise taxes and other indirect taxes, through an increase in prices, through the dollar exchange rate, etc.

[Smoked]

Like in Ukraine, but there in the end they forced you to deduct from your salary :) One people really)))))))))))))))

[Vasilenko Vladimir]

deputies can pass 50 percent painlessly
I hope this citizen has already listed?!

[faiver]

Why only 2%? Let’s get 20% from the State Duma deputies, and 30% from the “SR” faction.

[Hariton]

And also with an advance quarterly payment!

[Wratch]

Why don’t the deputies transfer their “poor” salaries yet??? Well, yes, this is the salt of the Russian soil, they don’t care. But to rob state employees and pensioners, yes, in our opinion, in Beijing’s way...

[Shumi2010]

I can offer to transfer my trade union 1%...

[Uprun]

From the experience of serving with the law enforcement agencies, I can say that this initiative will look like this: father commanders will oblige their subordinates to write a report asking them to withhold 2% of their salary, and whoever refuses will receive another report, well, I think everyone understands which one and where. It is necessary not to call, but to do.
Now, if this lady had quietly contributed to the fund from her parliamentary unemployment benefits for 1,5 years, and then, “accidentally,” some well-known journalist found out about this and promoted the initiative, then, oh. And so, verbiage is a vicious initiative.
Charity comes from the heart and at the call of the soul, giving to a beggar on the church porch, do you consider yourself a hero or a patriot?

[faiver]

commanders will oblige their subordinates to write a report asking them to withhold 2% from their salary

- yeah, that's about how it will be

[Hariton]

She thought about this, limiting the list of groups of civil servants. Will hit women with a salary of 35/40 rubles.

[Uprun]

You won't believe it, but ml. The PPS sergeant is also a civil servant,
Service in the internal affairs bodies is built in accordance with the characteristics of the public service enshrined in Federal Law 8 of the Federal Law “On the Public Service System of the Russian Federation”, as well as in the Federal Law “On Service in the Internal Affairs Bodies of the Russian Federation”.

[Graz]

shake the oligarchs how much the common people should take the rap, there are only a few billionaires helping the army

[Escariot]

Quote: Graz

shake the oligarchs how much the common people should take the rap, there are only a few billionaires helping the army

Why should the oligarchs be shaken? Do oligarchs have any other rights under the law? If an oligarch has earned money in accordance with the law, then it is his legal money and cannot be taken away. If an oligarch stole money, then he should be in jail, regardless of whether he helps our army or not.

[ankir13]

Deputies will obviously not lose two percent of their salaries? Wow, is salary their main income?!? The main thing is that it actually goes to the requested needs, and the deputies will do it easily, and they will also receive positive coverage from this! And the comparison with sports lotto fees and “regular sabotage!!! (you can even shoot)” is completely inappropriate in the article - the event is on a different level.

[Fedor M]

Another “drug-addicted deputy”...

[Boniface]

What kind of Game?
Deshman PR?
And so growth prices for everything (goods, groceries, gasoline)!!!
Putin said clearly yesterday - there is MONEY in the country!

It would be better to come up with a proposal to increase wages for Russians by at least 10-15%!!

[Million]

Are these “people” capable of this? Of course, there are exceptions, but they are rare.

[Amateur]

Old anecdote:
A deputy consults with his faction leader
- Do I have to pay taxes on my deputy salary?
- yes, I should
- and from the money that they give me as bribes?
- if you are an honest deputy, then you should!

[vovochkarzhevsky]

Well, military pensions pay 15% today. At the same time, they are not civil servants.

[Turbuta Dave]

My friend is a civil servant, he quit a week ago.. He received 30000 rubles.. He worked at Rosvetnadzor. In general, civil service is very little money.

[Hariton]

If you take away 2%, then, according to the beauty, they will at least love their homeland more.

[Smoked]

Well, what did you want? Gentlemen, capitalists, you have a cartoon about “like grandfathers with Nazism”, if you please, please transfer it to the defense fund.

[faridg7]

Send this one a blast. We collect funds and help targeted, for specific needs, specific departments, and this suggests that officials create another feeding trough. Not only will they go into this fund for a share, but it is also unknown who will decide what and how to spend these funds, as a result, the troops will receive something that is not needed, and when it is no longer needed. Better deal with the Central Bank and the Ministry of Finance, who are engaged in outright sabotage in the economy

[zontov79]

I fully support it!! These should be at the forefront!

[akropin]

Or maybe it’s like this - State Duma deputies give one of their monthly salaries to the needs of the fighters?

[Omega options]

A good start.
But we need to bring it to launch.

[Saffron]

These initiatives of theirs are extremely harmful in the sense that they have designated a circle of people, and local officials with salaries of 100+ under the hood and with the words “we will fulfill and exceed” will force all public sector employees who have a minimum wage salary, from which another -2%, to do the same. . They simply forgot that inflation last year was 18.5%, and the salaries of the same state employees were indexed by 5.5%

[r5555]

She would go to suck somewhere else and from other places..

[Hariton]

She also suggested reviving LTP! )
Dangerous half-sheet. Why introduce new deductions, these are unnecessary labor costs, if you can simply not index the salary.
So that every month on the pay slip, a civil servant (I hope not a military man), looking at 500-1000 rubles of new deduction, would be proud and increase his patriotism? She wants to be cursed every month?
Yes, a State Duma deputy will pay 10000, but it’s out of the blue for them.
In 2024, there will be no indexation of salaries of federal civil servants. The current budget law provided for their increase by 4%.

[opposite28]

She also suggested reviving LTP! )

She always offers something. The question is who is she? (in the mental sense)

[Hariton]

And perhaps I will support it in the variant: separate groups of civil servants, their parents, spouses and children, and not only from annual income, but also from property.

[faiver]

you are... let's be more careful with mental meanings

[Brother Geographer]

I wonder if Chubais, who is still half of Russia’s due for his privatization, will chip in for his own? Or is this all concussion of air from the mouths of enemies of the people? While the enemy is sitting in the rear, you can’t dream of any victory.

[Hariton]

You don't need that rusty little bit of his filthy money. The main thing is that those who escaped do not return.

[faiver]

so that those who escaped do not return

- well, a grenade can explode for anyone on an airplane...

[Ross xnumx]

A deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation suggested that civil servants “voluntarily” transfer two percent of their income to the needs of the Northern Military District

Why so modest? Without any calls, I transfer 1 rubles monthly to the needs of the SVO, which is 000% of the pension + about 3 rubles for treatment for children... But I do not have any authority to pass a law on a progressive scale of personal income tax for millionaires for the duration of the SVO ( up to 33%, as Roosevelt did in his time in the public interest (Since 500, Americans with an annual income of more than $75 thousand were required to pay a 1935% income tax)...
You can also impose a fifty percent tax on the withdrawal of capital in foreign currency at this time...
And there, either the donkey, or the padishah, or me... Or the North Military District will end...

[your1970]

Quote: ROSS 42

up to 75%, as Roosevelt did in his time in the public interest (Since 1935, Americans with an annual income of more than $500 thousand were required to pay a 75% income tax)...

At the same time, Roosevelt completely confiscated gold from the population.
But I am for the tax - with both hands!!!

Z.Y.
- Grudinin will be taxed, he will raise the price of strawberries for Muscovites and everything will be fine. He...

[viktor_ui]

Well-groomed Yana Lantratova, just like this whole State Duma to the heap. She will collect this tax from the spa salon by hand to begin with??? All government officials are required to pay 20%, MONTHLY, from their personal pockets for the purchase and development of the UAV system and its derivatives.

[Alexander X]

Well, in our settlement (Tver region) we already have similar local initiatives. The leadership of the local administration visits households in villages and, voluntarily and compulsorily (“otherwise they won’t give you any certificates”), collect money either for new sites for garbage containers or for children’s playgrounds... The undertaking, in general, is not bad, if not a requirement to pay in cash a sum determined by the administration, and not a request to participate in an undertaking, which retired residents can do...

[Dizel200]

Transferring it yourself and taking voluntarily-compulsorily 2 percent are completely different things.

[opposite28]

It seems that in this situation Russian civil servants should be at the forefront of the patriotic movement

— the first deputy chairman of the State Duma Committee on Education is confident.

It is presented as a payoff from the population for whom the civil servants themselves created the problems. It’s like a group donating money for someone’s birthday or funeral. Very "patriotic". And it turns out there is some kind of avant-garde movement, holy shit...

She explained that in Russia there are many people who want to make their contribution to the fight for the liberation of the residents of Novorossiya, for the future of the country.

Reminds me of Soviet-era slogans like: Freedom for the oppressed peoples of Africa! Let's help them in their fight against global capitalism!

[Alexey Lantukh]

Free Luis Corvalan! Death to American imperialism!

[Gomunkul]

But its mechanism is very reminiscent of the times of the USSR, when “voluntary” contributions were collected at enterprises and institutions, either for the purchase of lottery tickets or for some other socially useful cause.

The author forgot to mention the Soviet Peace Fund.

[HAM]

Mlyn, we still haven’t come to our senses from the “Yarovaya Law”, when the cost of a minute of conversation on a mobile phone increased from 19 kopecks per minute to 1 ruble 80 kopecks, so another “guardian” appeared....
Deputies with such salaries went nuts.........

[Alexey Lantukh]

It would be better if this deputy proposed an official war tax of 5 percent on salaries over 100 thousand per month. It would make more money and it would be fair.

[your1970]

Quote: Alexey Lantukh

It would be better if this deputy proposed an official war tax of 5 percent on salaries over 100 thousand per month. It would make more money and it would be fair.

Can't you read? This is exactly what she suggested - only 2% and not 5

[Alexey Lantukh]

The deputy proposed creating a charitable subscription “Contribution to Victory”, within the framework of which some categories of civil servants and deputies will “voluntarily” transfer two percent of monthly income to the needs of the SVO.

Actually, the text is clear about voluntariness. I propose a mandatory tax.

[Escariot]

Quote: Alexey Lantukh

It would be better if this deputy proposed an official war tax of 5 percent on salaries over 100 thousand per month. It would make more money and it would be fair.

From what side is this “fair”? Here there are two people: one has a salary of 50 thousand, and the other 500 thousand. Even at a flat rate of 13%, the first one will pay 6500 rubles in taxes, and the other 65000 rubles in taxes, i.e. 10 times more, and all their rights are the same. Is this fair? And you suggest that the second one (who already contributes 10 times more money to the budget) should pay even more?!

[AdAstra]

Only one has 43 left, and the second has 500, and with 435 you can buy more than with 000, right?

[Alexey Lantukh]

In my opinion, this truth is clear to a goat, only many have their own shirt closer and much closer to the body.

[alexku69]

Don’t include Lobachevsky’s mathematics here :) It’s better to calculate how much a person will have after paying the tax on 50 rubles and how much on 500 rubles. It will be better this way

[16112014nk]

The oligarchs need to be shaken. Ukrainians, like Akhmetov, sponsor the Armed Forces of Ukraine, but there is silence about the help of our oligarchs, like the Sechins and Millers, for the needs of the RF Armed Forces. Only Abramovich helps, and only to the “NavoZOVites”.

[Escariot]

Quote: 16112014nk

The oligarchs need to be shaken. Ukrainians, like Akhmetov, sponsor the Armed Forces of Ukraine, but there is silence about the help of our oligarchs, like the Sechins and Millers, for the needs of the RF Armed Forces. Only Abramovich helps, and only to the “NavoZOVites”.

Akhmetov sponsors the Armed Forces of Ukraine of his own free will, because if the Armed Forces of Ukraine loses, he will lose all his factories, but our oligarchs, to put it mildly, are not delighted with the SVO, because it causes only losses and the sooner the SVO is curtailed, the easier it will be for them to return to the European market . Therefore, they will not help voluntarily.

[Emil]

All civil servants are superfluous, but deputies of all stripes can be “appointed” more %%%... they don’t get emaciated By the way, has this deputy already started, as they say, “with herself”?

[old64]

Or maybe it would be easier to make a deputy-senator tax on SVO? It's no secret that the wages of this category of citizens for SPL are an order of magnitude higher than the minimum wage. Plus all sorts of benefits.

[Beck69]

Yeah, suggest it. They will make a parliamentary and senatorial proposal on a tax on workers of 2 percent.

[Furious bambr]

Is it possible to reduce all factions that are, like, deputies??? and creating the appearance of parliamentarism in our country?

[faiver]

you didn’t specify the method of abbreviation, there are options here

[Pankrat25]

you didn’t specify the method of abbreviation, there are options here

Personally, I prefer the ancient French method with quartering...

[gx200gx]

And the deputy has already transferred her percentage or simply noted her initiative, most likely not even her own, just to be heard.

[AdAstra]

Deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation is the first. """""""

[vadivm59]

This is what the lady said without thinking! 2% of INCOME! right now! no matter how it is, from SALARY, that’s welcome. but from income....bang and butter!

[Sergey3]

Oh really? There are all sorts of civil servants. Ambulance workers struggling to make ends meet are the same in the civil service!

[Hariton laptev]

State employees are doctors, teachers, and ordinary administration employees. And as soon as managers are obliged to pay 2%, instantly this entire category of employees who are not highly paid will be voluntarily and forcibly obliged to support their managers.

[alexku69]

Let's list everyone who is among our civil servants.

[alexku69]

The deputies... are somehow cautious in proposing everything. Why not offer a crowd and the IMPORTANT THING!!! VOTE for a differential tax scale?...

[Beck69]

Just like Valya the Seagull, they send her letters in bags, asking her to take away part of her salary...

[Master 2030]

From what income? If official, then even 3 rounds will not be enough. But if from the real ones, then the army will reach Lisbon in a week.
Ceterum censeo Washingtonum delendam esse

[Fedka]

Sometimes I drop 100 rubles at the post office. There is a large cardboard box, collected by the cashier; her husband has been in Ukraine almost since the first days of the SVO. She says batteries for mine detectors are for sappers. Well, she explained that the batteries literally last for half an hour. I'm no expert, but half an hour is not enough in my opinion. Well, the sappers know better. Sometimes people throw it if they have an extra ruble in their pocket.

[Cypa]

Like in the USSR - voluntarily forced

[Alexander]

Or maybe deputies themselves should set an example to follow?

[Mazunga]

on the SVO I myself scroll through the five-hat every month, I know when and where, and the deputies can give 50% back to the SVO; they won’t lose weight, again, people’s love)))

[Omega options]

Well done, smart girl!
We must translate words into deeds.