Military Review

Rostec conducted comparative tests of body armor used in the Northern Military District zone by the Russian and Ukrainian military

60
Rostec conducted comparative tests of body armor used in the Northern Military District zone by the Russian and Ukrainian military

The Russian state corporation Rostec tested body armor used in the special operation zone as part of the new project “Our Crash”. The testing involved one bulletproof vest of Russian and American production, as well as a bulletproof vest produced by “one of the eastern countries” in the cheapest category.


Rostec tested body armor used by the Russian and Ukrainian armies in the Northern Military District zone. All body armor of protection class Br5, including the representative of the “eastern country”. Shooting at the body armor was carried out from a distance of 15 meters, using a Kalashnikov assault rifle chambered for 7,62X39 mm with a regular bullet, a machine gun chambered for 7,62X54 mm armor-piercing and a sniper rifle chambered for 8,6X70 mm Lapua Magnum.

As tests have shown, the Russian bulletproof vest "Obereg" withstood all hits without allowing a single penetration. At the same time, the American body armor was pierced by an ordinary 7,62 mm AK bullet, which came as a complete surprise even to the testers. The body armor of the “eastern country” also withstood all the shots, but the 8,6X70 mm Lapua Magnum cartridge left an impact dent of such a size that it was incompatible with life.

It is noted that the Russian "Obereg" was the only one that withstood all hits, including the 8,6X70 mm Lapua Magnum, although it was not designed for such a bullet. The "Oberega" plate consists of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene, ceramic plate, Kevlar and an additional layer.

This slide remains from the so-called .338 ammunition (8,6 to 70). State tests do not involve firing this ammunition at all (..) With this level of barrier impact, the body armor is considered to have passed the test

- said Pavel Pavlenko, director of the Oktava company that produces “Amulets”.

The fully equipped "Obereg" body armor weighs 11,5 kg; Rostec is now working to reduce the weight to 10-10,5 kg.

60 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Ross xnumx
    Ross xnumx 2 October 2023 11: 38
    +2
    Only such messages can raise the mood and confidence in the presence of brains of the Russian “Lefties” and “Kulibins”.
    1. And Us Rat
      And Us Rat 2 October 2023 11: 50
      -1
      Quote: ROSS 42
      Only such messages can lift your spirits and confidence.

      Well, that’s what they are designed for - to raise morale among the masses. fellow
      If the Americans had conducted this “test” with a review in their media, the “results” they voiced would have been diametrically opposed. lol
      The REAL results of such tests are never publicly announced. Because the task of such publications is not to convey information, but to create a narrative in a Hottentot manner. wink
      It is not a fact that there were any tests at all in reality. The journalist was ordered to do it, and he fulfilled it. request
      1. APASUS
        APASUS 2 October 2023 12: 19
        +11
        Quote: And Us Rat
        If the Americans had conducted this “test” with a review in their media, the “results” they voiced would have been diametrically opposed.
        The REAL results of such tests are never publicly announced. Because the task of such publications is not to convey information, but to create a narrative in a Hottentot manner.

        I fully admit that there were such tests, this is technical analysis, without it there is no way in war. And ours have a similar vest. But what ours will never write is the percentage of these vests in the army. Yes, they exist, but the Ministry of Defense may not purchase them or may purchase them in limited quantities for special forces, for example, and that’s all. The trick lies elsewhere
        1. Boris Manzhela
          Boris Manzhela 2 October 2023 18: 47
          +4
          TA-dah. Armata and SU-57 are the best in the world, but are there many of them at the front?
        2. -Igor-
          -Igor- 3 October 2023 04: 22
          +1
          If there is a technical possibility, then every self-respecting manufacturer conducts comparative tests. It’s just hard to imagine that in the publications of their tests (read, advertising) they would talk about how crap their products are compared to their competitors.
      2. Ross xnumx
        Ross xnumx 2 October 2023 15: 26
        +7
        Quote: And Us Rat
        Since the task of such publications is not to convey information, but create a narrative in a Hottentot manner.

        In Russian it sounds like creating a set of words that reveals (somehow) a double standard?
        Why such ornate phrases to describe an ordinary phenomenon?
      3. svp67
        svp67 2 October 2023 16: 30
        +9
        Quote: And Us Rat
        Well, that’s what they are designed for - to raise morale among the masses.
        If the Americans had conducted this “test” with a review in their media, the “results” they voiced would have been diametrically opposed.

        There is footage online of Ukrainians firing at a slab from a Ratnik... They were very surprised by its results, saying, in short, that they should shoot in the face or legs...
      4. Alexey Lantukh
        Alexey Lantukh 2 October 2023 17: 58
        -1
        It is not a fact that there were any tests at all in reality. The journalist was ordered to do it, and he fulfilled it.

        Nevertheless, although this is propaganda, even those with little knowledge, like me, still have questions. Why didn’t they remember our main AK-74 chambered for 5,45? But they didn’t remember because it doesn’t penetrate almost anything at all, neither eastern, nor northern, or even homemade.
        1. I_Alpharius
          I_Alpharius 2 October 2023 18: 40
          +2
          Let me disagree with you.
          It is the speed of the bullet that gives armor, not its caliber. The 5.45 has a higher speed than the automatic 7,62 and has higher penetration.
          Just for fun, you can watch the tests of Alexey Smirnov (he has his own channel on YouTube, where they shoot with whatever they can, you can find the name of the channel yourself, I’m not writing because I don’t know whether the VO administration will consider it an advertisement)
          1. Rus2012
            Rus2012 2 October 2023 19: 51
            -3
            The 5.45 has a higher speed than the automatic 7,62 and has higher penetration.

            ...don't tell me my slipper... :) :)
            7,62 pierces the rail web. And 5,45 ricochets off branches and fences...
            Therefore, the military has a strong belief about returning to 7,62, when all the infantry in armored vehicles are roaming around... Haven’t you heard? Your grief
            1. And Us Rat
              And Us Rat 3 October 2023 01: 59
              +5
              Quote: Rus2012
              7,62 pierces the rail web

              Armor-piercing only. But the armor-piercing 5.45 also penetrates it. I’m probably just too lazy, I haven’t posted a verification of this myth on YouTube.
              VPN to the rescue.
            2. Sergei N 58912062
              Sergei N 58912062 3 October 2023 01: 59
              -1
              Quote: Rus2012
              The 5.45 has a higher speed than the automatic 7,62 and has higher penetration.

              ...don't tell me my slipper... :) :)
              7,62 pierces the rail web. And 5,45 ricochets off branches and fences...
              Therefore, the military has a strong belief about returning to 7,62, when all the infantry in armored vehicles are roaming around... Haven’t you heard? Your grief

              Rus2012 fool don't talk nonsense!
          2. Alexey Lantukh
            Alexey Lantukh 2 October 2023 21: 15
            +4
            The armor is taken by the power of the impact on this very armor, i.e. shot energy. It is proportional to the speed and mass of the bullet. Those. at the same speed, a more massive bullet will penetrate better. Of course, the design of the bullet itself also matters. Moreover, the further the goal, the worse 5,45 is 7,62.
            1. forecaster
              forecaster 3 October 2023 18: 46
              +1
              E=(mV*2)/2
              those. an increase in mass by several grams (50-100%) merges with an increase in speed to the second power (about 20% squared increases the growth of E by 400%). As we can see, the energy benefit of increasing bullet speed exceeds the increase in mass for this system by an order of magnitude.
              Unfortunately physics...
              This is a prohibitive action, I agree, ALAVERDY
          3. APASUS
            APASUS 3 October 2023 11: 19
            -1
            Quote: I_Alpharius
            Let me disagree with you.
            It is the speed of the bullet that gives armor, not its caliber. The 5.45 has a higher speed than the automatic 7,62 and has higher penetration.

            School physics lesson.
            If a Mercedes at a speed of 200 km per hour collides with a KamAZ traveling at 20 kph. Which of them will suffer more?
            1. Nikif
              Nikif 3 October 2023 16: 14
              0
              Physics.... There are such quantities as the product of mass and speed. Masses per square of speed...
              For your example. When a small particle collides with a satellite in space, it gets pretty bad... So mass is only one of the components. Important, but not the only thing that determines everything.
              1. APASUS
                APASUS 4 October 2023 08: 44
                0
                Quote: Nikif
                Important, but not the only thing that determines everything.

                That's it . A person judges penetration by the speed of the bullet and that’s it!
                But you didn't notice it
            2. Eug
              Eug 4 October 2023 10: 30
              0
              In this case, the collision energy will be distributed equally.
          4. savage3000
            savage3000 5 October 2023 00: 37
            0
            Alpharius,

            The 5.45 has a higher speed than the automatic 7,62 and has higher penetration.
            + + + + + + + + + + + +

            Don't talk nonsense. Their penetration is approximately the same.
      5. Rus2012
        Rus2012 2 October 2023 18: 46
        0
        Our Army (My name is Legion, for we

        Legion gavar sh?
        Do you have any idea what kind of legion you are???

        Devil and Satanists. Honor the forbidden Klimov...

        But you have nothing to do with Rati...
        This is ours, Slavic and against you
        1. Ulan.1812
          Ulan.1812 2 October 2023 20: 41
          +1
          Is Klimov banned? Strange, but I bought his books. This was a long time ago, maybe even before the ban?
          1. Rus2012
            Rus2012 2 October 2023 21: 20
            0
            Is Klimov banned?

            https://ru.wikisource.org/wiki/%D0%9A%D0%BD%D1%8F%D0%B7%D1%8C_%D0%BC%D0%B8%D1%80%D0%B0_%D1%81%D0%B5%D0%B3%D0%BE_(%D0%93%D1%80%D0%B8%D0%B3%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B8%D0%B9_%D0%9A%D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%B2)/%D0%9F%D1%80%D0%B5%D0%B4%D0%B8%D1%81%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B5
        2. And Us Rat
          And Us Rat 3 October 2023 02: 04
          -1
          Quote: Rus2012
          what a legion of you

          An immortal who writes obituaries for empires.

          Quote: Rus2012
          This is ours, Slavic

          This is your conceit. tongue
      6. Aster Klaster
        Aster Klaster 3 October 2023 11: 52
        +1
        There is a Murican YouTuber. Looks like a destructive ranch. Conducted a test of body armor. Ours is their Chinese. Ours was not inferior to the Murican one. So there are decent people there who tell the truth.
    2. Silver99
      Silver99 2 October 2023 11: 54
      +6
      It would be nice to establish mass production and reduce the selling price
    3. Irokez
      Irokez 2 October 2023 12: 28
      -3
      Quote: ROSS 42
      Only such messages can raise the mood and confidence in the presence of brains of the Russian “Lefties” and “Kulibins”.

      I still don’t understand this post, is it approving or again critical, as usual with such critics?
      1. Ross xnumx
        Ross xnumx 2 October 2023 15: 34
        0
        Quote: Irokez
        I still don’t understand this post, is it approving or again critical, as usual with such critics?

        I don’t like it when they start showing some kind of arrogance, more than the stated weight.
        Have you decided to demonstrate personal servility again or is it just performing the usual routine duties of a service worker?
        So will it be clear?
        Only such messages can raise the mood and confidence in the presence of brains of the Russian “Lefties” and “Kulibins”.
        1. Irokez
          Irokez 2 October 2023 23: 04
          -1
          Quote: ROSS 42
          the presence of brains in the Russian “Lefties” and “Kulibins”.

          Unfortunately, your posts are usually criticized rather than constructively offered, keeping up with the times.
          As I understand it, only some incredible accident or event gives our designers brains, but usually they have no brains, so what do you understand?
  2. Smoked
    Smoked 2 October 2023 11: 38
    0
    It seems to me that after such a massive use of drones dropping fragmentation explosive devices, now the field uniform needs to be made resistant to small fragments of hand and other grenades up to 40mm.
    1. pettabyte
      pettabyte 2 October 2023 11: 52
      +1
      Yes, it can be done so that the armor-piercing 40mm will not break through the mold material.
      Only this entire form will be pulled into the body upon impact.
      If you want to not only stay in shape, but also survive - there’s a lot of weight, a limitation of movement.

      Well, if the fabric does not tear, there is a chance that the soldier will get stuck somewhere, say, on barbed wire.
      They say this is one of the reasons why they didn’t try to make the form from something wildly durable.
  3. dmi.pris1
    dmi.pris1 2 October 2023 11: 41
    +9
    Another thing is interesting. Is this wonderful body armor already widely used by the troops? Oh yes! For sale - 113 kilo rubles (this is the previous version). How much does a new, lightweight one cost?
    1. Smoked
      Smoked 2 October 2023 11: 51
      +6
      Of course not. The story of last year with the sudden lack of equipment in warehouses, which was on paper, quietly faded into oblivion. Who cares now when we need to unite.
    2. pettabyte
      pettabyte 2 October 2023 12: 13
      -4
      Judging by the advertising posters, a contract worker is given 500 thousand rubles at a time. and then also the salary.
      In my opinion 120t.r. he can afford it.

      No, I don’t argue that they should be in warehouses for the entire army, including conscripts and reserves.
      Only now, they’ll steal it, cut it down even before the purchases, and then they’ll rot in lousy storage.
      1. dmi.pris1
        dmi.pris1 2 October 2023 13: 08
        0
        Eh..They write a lot of things on the fence..Perhaps local authorities in rich regions give lifting allowances. Krasnodar Territory - we don’t have that.
      2. hhurik
        hhurik 2 October 2023 18: 48
        +3
        What else should you “afford” at your own expense? wink Is there a tank, an armored train, a box of ammunition, an airship? I would like to note that when under feudalism this was the mainstream - the king ordered the vassal to appear on horseback and in arms - he nevertheless first placed this little man on the land, as a landowner, so that his tax-paying population would be fed and equipped. He recruited military slaves as his servants from there, at his own expense.
        It’s not clear that someone wrote off the villages with people to the soldiers of the Northern Military District. Unless it's a Far Eastern hectare, there are no people there - just bears. How much does a bear skin cost? Is it enough for an armored vehicle? Is it good for a helmet and a warmer? fellow
  4. Siberian 66
    Siberian 66 2 October 2023 11: 44
    +4
    It's great that our body armor is so good. The main question is that it should be used by our military (although its weight is, of course, too big), and not those fakes and crafts produced by scammers both here and abroad..
    1. pettabyte
      pettabyte 2 October 2023 12: 15
      +1
      I don’t know if it’s true, but I read that it happened that our soldiers took out the plates so as not to interfere, a long time ago, almost in Afghanistan.
  5. KVU-NSVD
    KVU-NSVD 2 October 2023 11: 45
    +5
    Is this an advertisement for this armored car and the company? Apparently, everyone passed, it was just that the Amer apparently had a defect, otherwise penetration by the weakest and non-penetration by more powerful cartridges cannot be explained. The Chinese confirmed without limits. Testing requires a statistical sample, but otherwise it’s just bullshit or, as in this case, an advertising campaign
  6. Vadim S
    Vadim S 2 October 2023 12: 02
    0
    I read what armored vehicles and those holding 12.7 can do, but there is no chance of surviving in it.
    1. pettabyte
      pettabyte 2 October 2023 12: 17
      +3
      Yes, it will be possible to survive in it.
      But WALKING is not a fact.
      Without frills, ala exoskeleton.
      Well, there will be a walking tank (of which there won’t be many).
      And then they’ll take out RPGs/ATGMs/bring in artillery.

      Balance is important here so as not to get too carried away ala “they built Mouse here.”
  7. Ratmir_Ryazan
    Ratmir_Ryazan 2 October 2023 12: 26
    +16
    Russian bulletproof vest "Obereg" withstood all hits without allowing a single penetration


    Stupid and mediocre show!!! How can?!

    Where are these Charms in the Northern Military District?! To whom are they issued and where?! I haven’t seen them here at anyone’s house for a year in the Northern Military District.

    Compare the poor Modul-Monilit with the NATO and Ukrainian models, which were issued to mobilized and contract soldiers. Compare both in terms of weight and security.

    Better yet, put the Monolith Module on those who made it and who accepted it for the army and make them run around in it.

    And also tell us where the Kevlar is in this Module-Monolith and how the KAPs help reduce transobstructive trauma. This will be very difficult, because the Monolith Module has neither one nor the other. And this is against the backdrop of the fact that most of the wounds in the Northern Military District are from shrapnel.

    While on vacation I bought an assault Ratnik on Avito for 95 thousand. Again, the question is why Avito has 6B45 body armor, even new ones, but SVO doesn’t have them.

    But in general, it’s high time to move on and make a more protected body armor that would include protection not only for the chest, back and neck, but also for the shoulders and hips.

    A lot of people have already died, but in Rostec they are just doing it for show.

    I pray that the retribution for this betrayal, and window dressing is betrayal, since it brings nothing but harm, will overtake everyone!!!
    1. hazarn
      hazarn 2 October 2023 13: 17
      +2
      Quote: Ratmir_Ryazan
      even better, put the Monolith Module on those who made it and who accepted it for the army and make them run around in it.

      I confirm what was written above, I talked to an acquaintance - they are removing these monolithic modules, otherwise it is impossible to move, without it you will at least have time to fall, and in this miracle show from Rostec there is simply a standing target. And everything about NATO is true
    2. K_4
      K_4 2 October 2023 13: 25
      +1
      By the way, I want to directly ask an eyewitness. A friend of mine here (not my closest one) returned on vacation from there. We started talking. He said in plain text that among the mobs there, they weren’t in a very good mood, besides all the drinking, it was unclear what, when, how long they should sit. Grit for another six months and it may turn out like in Bumbarash: “I don’t care, I don’t care...” and so on in the text. I would like to know how it really is, what people really think there.
  8. Codett
    Codett 2 October 2023 12: 36
    +2
    The most popular seems to be a monolith module, but its comparison will clearly not be in our favor, in general it’s a disgusting tile, it’s made by NPO Spetsmaterialov. I saw the video on YouTube, but now the account has been deleted from it, although you can search for somewhere else you can watch it,
    how the author shows in detail the structure of the body armor, how everything in it is adjusted and taken out. There is no anti-ricochet layer, no anti-traumatic layer, inside there is a 58M protective element from NPO Spetsmaterialov.
    The absence of an anti-ricochet layer is fraught with bullet fragments getting into the face and hands. There is a KAP, it's cheap. Next, the “Module-Monolith” plate was shot with a standard 5,45 mm combined arms cartridge. The first hit is a through penetration. For comparison, here are three hits with the same cartridge on the St. Petersburg BR-4 plate - and not a single penetration.
  9. Whowhy
    Whowhy 2 October 2023 13: 38
    +3
    Well, actually, our guys are armed mainly with 5,45mm machine guns, and those who came on vacation from the Northern Military District complained that Ukrainian armored vehicles couldn’t penetrate Ukrainian armored vehicles with this caliber. But they complained about their armor that they were too heavy. Considering that the Ukrainians use mainly 7,62 caliber, the arrival of which becomes very bad even without penetration.
  10. kill the fascist
    kill the fascist 2 October 2023 20: 32
    0
    It's good if so. The question remains: how many of our fighters on the LBS have this Amulet?
  11. Fangaro
    Fangaro 3 October 2023 11: 03
    -1
    For such testing you should be sent to honorable retirement.
    One at a time...
    Let's then determine the average salary in the country according to Miller, Vyakhirev and Timchenko?
  12. Aster Klaster
    Aster Klaster 3 October 2023 11: 56
    0
    Well, now we need to make enough of them so that each soldier is given 5 units per month. If necessary. Otherwise, I still see how collections for vests are happening. Although it's less. Drones and cornfields/loaves are requested.
  13. Wayfarer_2
    Wayfarer_2 3 October 2023 12: 59
    0
    Why did they check the cheapest body armor in the eastern country? However, as it is written in the article, they practically passed the test. Because the 8,6x70 caliber is practically not used in the Russian army. And if it is used, it is extremely rare. But if we put our cheapest body armor for testing, what will happen in this case? I would also like to know how these body armor holds a bullet from 5,45x39 cartridges, because this caliber is the most common in our army (AK-74 assault rifle). Unsatisfactory, incomplete test. The impression is that the article is advertising.
  14. dump22
    dump22 3 October 2023 16: 23
    -1
    The fog was then released - an unknown body armor “from an eastern country”, an unknown body armor “from the USA”.
    There is no way to name the exact article.
  15. tabex
    tabex 3 October 2023 17: 23
    -2
    I'm interested in the question: will the "sergeant-major" replace the "used" slab of the same amulet promptly? Or is the fighter looking for opportunities at his own expense?
  16. bone1
    bone1 3 October 2023 18: 29
    +1
    In general, it is reasonable to compare body armor of the same protection class - but what about this? - And what is this mysterious “eastern country” or do the testers themselves not know? And the main thing is that the machine gun with the 7,62X54 cartridge does not penetrate the body armor from 15 meters?? - don’t hang your head. Where did they unearth the miracle Judo-Lapua Magnum and why and why didn’t they fire from the PTR?
  17. bone1
    bone1 3 October 2023 18: 29
    -1
    In general, it is reasonable to compare body armor of the same protection class - but what about this? - And what is this mysterious “eastern country” or do the testers themselves not know? And the main thing is that the machine gun with the 7,62X54 cartridge does not penetrate the body armor from 15 meters?? - don’t hang your head. Where did they unearth the miracle Judo-Lapua Magnum and why and why didn’t they fire from the PTR?
    1. savage3000
      savage3000 5 October 2023 00: 29
      +1
      Kostya,

      And the main thing is that the machine gun with the 7,62X54 cartridge does not penetrate the body armor from 15 meters??
      + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +

      Think about it! Br5 holds 7.62x54! Wow, huh? How long have you been from kindergarten?
  18. Rus2012
    Rus2012 3 October 2023 19: 54
    0
    Quote: Sergei N 58912062
    don't talk nonsense!

    Moron? then it's forever, alas...

    https://s30116489994.mirtesen.ru/blog/43659455184/7,62h39-vozvraschayetsya
    The report submitted by the Ministry affirmed on the basis of the experience of the hostilities in Afghanistan and Iraq that M-4, surpassing the enemy’s main weapon (AK-47) in accuracy, is inferior to it in a number of other equally important characteristics, such as reliability and unpretentiousness. But the most important thing is the insufficient penetration ability of the NATO 5,56x45 cartridge. The document indicates the episodes when the bullets could not penetrate even the sides of the truck at a time when the lines from the AK carry walls made of bricks and foam blocks and hit the fighters hiding behind them.
  19. aiden
    aiden 4 October 2023 03: 20
    0
    It's really true. One American demonstrated this on his YouTube channel
  20. Kip2
    Kip2 4 October 2023 09: 02
    +1
    Advertising and nothing more... and weight is the main thing. So you can put armor from a tank in a case and say that our unique body armor can withstand an RPG shot))) and don’t care that it’s impossible to lift it
  21. Mekey Iptyshev
    Mekey Iptyshev 4 October 2023 09: 40
    0
    There are already dozens of videos on YouTube where different armor plates are tested with different bullets. Everything does not depend on the country of origin. Specifically from the manufacturer. There are so many videos where one Russian armored vehicle is weak, while the other one holds everything. The same with the "Chinese", etc. Both ours and Ukrainians make videos. The Ukrainians and ours have good stoves. The military conflict made it possible to test body armor from a variety of manufacturers.
    And judging by the number of test videos, an armor-piercing bullet of 5,45 gives 7,62 bullets per light flight speed.
  22. Russian Patriot
    Russian Patriot 4 October 2023 09: 59
    +1
    It is noted that the Russian "Obereg" was the only one that withstood all hits, including the 8,6X70 mm Lapua Magnum, although it was not designed for such a bullet.


    Well, it turns out that the security class is higher! Since he can withstand shots not intended for his 5th class.
    Then it must be compared with the same NATO body armor of a higher class.

    These are not tests, but advertising window dressing.
  23. savage3000
    savage3000 5 October 2023 00: 27
    +1
    It is noted that the Russian "Obereg" was the only one that withstood all hits, including 8,6X70 mm Lapua Magnum, although it was not designed for such
    ××××××××÷÷÷÷÷÷÷÷÷

    Wild nonsense. Just .