American analyst: the United States has no experience in waging a war with overcoming defense in depth and without air support

21
American analyst: the United States has no experience in waging a war with overcoming defense in depth and without air support

The United States can do nothing to help the Ukrainian army in overcoming the layered defense built by the Russian troops, the US military simply does not have the appropriate experience. This statement was made by RAND Corporation expert Dara Massicot.

The US military has no experience in dealing with the defense built by the Russian troops, especially without the use of aviation. In addition, they have never encountered an enemy at the level of the Russian army, and all models of combat operations are designed for operations in Afghanistan and Iraq. It is useless to use them in Ukraine, they simply will not work. In a situation where the Ukrainian army cannot overcome the Russian defense, the United States cannot help in any way.



The Ukrainians are currently facing some of the most sophisticated defensive fortifications we have seen in decades. (...) American troops are not experienced enough without air superiority

Massicot said.

According to the analyst, the results of the counter-offensive of the Armed Forces of Ukraine will depend on a number of factors that are not mentioned in public reports. In particular, the consumption of ammunition, the use of artillery and real losses, and not those that are voiced.

Recall that the counter-offensive of the Armed Forces of Ukraine began in early June, for three months the Ukrainian army failed to crack the defense built by the Russian troops. In Kyiv, they planned to take Tokmak and Melitopol within a few days, cut the land corridor to the Crimea and go to its borders in order to "dictate their terms" to Moscow. Instead, the Armed Forces continue to fight for several villages, suffering huge losses.
    Our news channels

    Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

    21 comment
    Information
    Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
    1. +5
      1 September 2023
      These are the results you come to when military planning is entrusted to artificial intelligence. The supercomputer is good for moving units in strategy and for Miner to drive.
    2. +7
      1 September 2023
      The United States has no experience of waging war with defense in depth and without air support. Yes, they don’t have everything, because they can fight only with states like "banana". The last serious military campaign for the United States was only Vietnam, and even then until they were opposed by air defense (S-75) from the USSR. soldier
      1. +3
        1 September 2023
        Quote: Appraiser
        Yes, they don’t have everything, because they can fight only with states like "banana".

        That's right ... Or by proxy ... We look:
        The losses suffered by the United States in the Korean War were incredibly high. Lost 1 bayonets killed, wounded and captured, including 567 American soldiers. The KPA captured, damaged and destroyed 128 enemy aircraft, 405 tanks, 498 armored cars, 12 combat vehicles, 224 ships and vessels, and 3 guns. Captured 064 small arms, 191 grenades, 13 mines, 350 communications equipment. US losses in the Korean War exceeded by 564 times the losses in the four-year Pacific campaigns. The American newspaper "US News and World Report" writes regarding US losses in the Korean War: "US troop losses are 7 times greater than the losses in 695 major wars - the war of independence, the war in 925, the war with Mexico, the American-Spanish War , war with the Philippines.
        US losses in the Korean War are not just losses, but the first defeat in their history.

        Therefore, Vietnam, with losses of about 50 killed and 000 wounded, was not so sad for them ...
      2. +2
        1 September 2023
        American analyst: the United States has no experience in waging a war with overcoming defense in depth and without air support

        In their manuals, it is written only how to drive the Indians with bows, guns and guns!
        They even forgot how the Nazis stuck them "do not indulge at all"!
        And here, even with the wrong hands, it is impossible to fight.
        And if it weren’t for the Ukrainian army with commanders from Soviet schools, the war would have ended long ago!
    3. +7
      1 September 2023
      And also in close combat in urban environments.
      1. +10
        1 September 2023
        Americans can only level cities with civilians
        The United States would NOT be able, like the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, to NOT touch Ukrainian cities for a year and a half
    4. +3
      1 September 2023
      The United States can do nothing to help the Ukrainian army in overcoming the layered defense built by the Russian troops, the US military simply does not have the appropriate experience. This statement was made by RAND Corporation expert Dara Massicot.
      This is not news, actually...
      1. +7
        1 September 2023
        in general, the Armed Forces of Ukraine have no chance against either the US Armed Forces or the RF Armed Forces
        and the delay in the NWO is connected, not at all with Ukraine
        The Russian Armed Forces are grinding the military potential, resources and stocks of NATO countries and the US Armed Forces
        1. 0
          2 September 2023
          Of course, they grind the resource, but you shouldn’t flatter yourself like that with us, as the resource is not infinite. Enthusiasm alone is not enough, in society there must first of all be an idea (meaning) for the sake of whom and what the NWO is going for, since a lot is at stake. soldier
          1. 0
            5 September 2023
            mainly HP loss on SVO up to 68% of fragments
            so we are waiting for Ratnik-3 with an exoskeleton
            3,5 mm titanium plates 30 kg, 10 mm ceramic: boron carbide 20 kg,
            5 mm UHMWPE 10 kg + exoskeleton 20 kg
            total weight 80 kg
    5. +4
      1 September 2023
      "The United States has no experience of waging a war with overcoming defense in depth and without air support." Well, apparently, they thought in the USA - so ... we have no experience, but there are "brave Ukrainians" ... what a "luck", wait, we'll set up a "skryment" (an experiment, just in case). winked
    6. 0
      1 September 2023
      The United States can do nothing to help the Ukrainian army in overcoming the layered defense built by the Russian troops, the US military simply does not have the appropriate experience.
      But what about the landing operation in Normandy in 1944, promoted in all American films? What about crossing the Siegfried Line in 1945? Probably the whole point is that the enemy (the Russian army) must have rested and does not want to give up, but wants to win?
    7. +3
      1 September 2023
      Yes, even with resistance, confrontation in the air, they have no experience, they are not used to losses, Vietnam was a long time ago, they forgot when they lost 60 or more aircraft per day! There was such a record.
    8. +2
      1 September 2023
      so mattresses, except for colonial wars that boiled down to punitive actions, never did anything, well, with the exception of the Second World War
    9. -3
      1 September 2023
      And patriotism began to bang ... The key here is without air superiority ... And so they defeated Iraq dry
      1. +2
        1 September 2023
        Quote from kip2
        And so they smashed Iraq dry

        don’t write nonsense and you will be happy, they bought Iraq, but didn’t win, where they were resisted, they raked it off at the most don’t indulge
      2. +2
        1 September 2023
        Quote from kip2
        And so they smashed Iraq dry

        With the help of traitors surrounded by Hussein ... Knowing the potential of the Iraqi Armed Forces, we were very surprised at the transience of the campaign ... Afghanistan did not even stand sideways in comparison with the armament of the Iraqi army.
    10. +1
      1 September 2023
      Well, don’t fight with priests .... sign and sign
    11. 0
      1 September 2023
      The US military has no experience in dealing with the defense built by the Russian troops, especially without the use of aviation

      Well, that's why they have the largest aviation fleet in the world !!! This is the same as writing Russia does not have superiority without its fleet of tanks. Another analyst of second-rate tabloid newspapers decided to flash an idea fool
    12. 0
      1 September 2023
      This is Dara - a serious lady, a specialist in the Russian Armed Forces. But even she does not say that the war would have ended long ago if adequate leadership had been in power, both for them and for us. And it probably wouldn't start at all.
    13. 0
      1 September 2023
      The United States has no experience in waging war against layered defenses and without air support

      Well, now they are acquiring this experience, consider it for free, in Ukraine.

    "Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

    “Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"