Military Review

“This is the weak point of the Armed Forces of Ukraine”: the Bundeswehr general spoke about the shortage of officers in the Ukrainian army

20
“This is the weak point of the Armed Forces of Ukraine”: the Bundeswehr general spoke about the shortage of officers in the Ukrainian army

One of the most serious problems of the Armed Forces of Ukraine at the current stage of the conflict is a serious shortage of commanders. General of the German Bundeswehr Andreas Marlow, who met with journalists at the Klitz training ground in Germany, spoke about this. The words of the commander were reported by the Reuters news agency.


As follows from Marlow's statement, the Armed Forces of Ukraine have lost a large number of officers and sergeants in battle for a year and a half. Therefore, now the Ukrainian command is very concerned about the training of command personnel. The Armed Forces of Ukraine need fresh cadres of military leaders.

This is the weak point of the APU

- the German general spoke about the shortage of officers.

However, it is unlikely that the shortage of officers in the Ukrainian army can be covered by the forced mobilization of civilians. A professional commander cannot be trained in a few weeks from yesterday's accountant or manager, who studied at the military department of a university twenty-five years ago.

The only way out for the Armed Forces of Ukraine remains the assignment of officer ranks to the most experienced and distinguished soldiers, for which earlier President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky abolished the requirement for special education and higher education in general for awarding officer ranks.

But the trouble with the Armed Forces of Ukraine is that there are fewer and fewer soldiers capable of becoming commanders of platoons or companies, since the counteroffensive “wipes out” the most professional and motivated army personnel. The command “protects” the officers, practically not sending them to the front line, which, in turn, complains about the rank and file, which finds itself on the line of contact without commanders.
20 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. aszzz888
    aszzz888 19 August 2023 07: 29
    +3
    “This is the weak point of the Armed Forces of Ukraine”: the Bundeswehr general spoke about the shortage of officers in the Ukrainian army
    Soon, not only will there be no officers, but the last crippled villager will be raked up for "meat attacks".
  2. Thrifty
    Thrifty 19 August 2023 07: 30
    +2
    Not a problem, do the serfs need to be driven? So put your own Poles there in many parts for a long time already in full charge, driving their serfs to slaughter.
  3. dmi.pris1
    dmi.pris1 19 August 2023 07: 33
    +1
    One of the solutions is short-term courses for sergeants. Having tasted all the charms of the front. There is little sense from civilians, mobilized (even those who once served, reserve officers). Now the methods of warfare have changed. However, this also applies to us. from the school, will he be able to command a platoon in a difficult combat situation?
    1. saigon
      saigon 19 August 2023 07: 42
      +3
      It all depends on the person who can and with a bang, who can’t do a damn thing, and without a sensible lock, a platoon can stupidly put down, although here it depends from the company commander to the devil how much he can help and teach in quick basics.
  4. Egoza
    Egoza 19 August 2023 07: 46
    +2
    The only way out for the Armed Forces of Ukraine remains the assignment of officer ranks to the most experienced and distinguished soldiers, for which earlier President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky abolished the requirement for special education and higher education in general for awarding officer ranks.

    Walk, rogue! You look, and the title will be given! For a short time, before destruction. I would assign ranks to everyone, the entire army at once, and the problem would be solved! ))) We don't have privates! Entirely lieutenants would be. )))
    1. Reptiloid
      Reptiloid 19 August 2023 19: 15
      0
      Quote: Egoza
      .... Walk, flaw! You look, and the title will be given! For a short time ,.....

      This is a short time with the title, perhaps "an unbearable burden" for the uki recourse After all, then their families would have to pay more pensions? And this shouldn't happen. hi
  5. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 19 August 2023 07: 46
    +3
    One of the most serious problems of the Armed Forces of Ukraine at the current stage of the conflict is a serious shortage of commanders.
    This problem is reluctantly, but recognized in Kyiv. Not only officers are being knocked out, but more or less trained sergeants, who, at least for a while, can replace platoon-level officers. In a word, wherever you throw it, a wedge is everywhere. And over time it will become more and more apparent.
    1. Simple
      Simple 19 August 2023 08: 03
      +2
      This process of degradation in the HFU cannot be stopped - the foundation of the defeat of the HFU is just beginning to form.
  6. Irek
    Irek 19 August 2023 07: 51
    +2
    All the literate and stubborn were sent to visit the Bandera, only slag and mercenaries with scoundrels remained.
  7. rocket757
    rocket757 19 August 2023 07: 51
    +5
    Yes, yes, and this, too, is a problem .... although these are just consequences, the main problem is ... but there was nothing to jump, it becomes so, so obedient go / Yo / ticks, listen to foreign guardians.
    1. parabyd
      parabyd 19 August 2023 08: 27
      +2
      In this regard, the question arises: are Ukrainians so different from citizens of other countries? There is a fact that fascist views and activities were promoted from above. Could society resist this? Swap Ukrainians for Russians, Germans or Italians, would anything change? In my opinion - no. Citizens of all capitalist countries +- would equally perceive this propaganda.

      Religious countries might have some chances, yet they have their own strong ideology, but they also successfully pick up the keys to them, mixing the ideas of fascism and religion, as a result, Shiites howl with Sunnis, Islamic states and other evil spirits appear.

      It is very difficult not to succumb to such propaganda, for this you need to have independent thinking, a strong character and strong moral convictions that would run counter to propaganda. There are few people with such qualities. They won't do well against the crowd. They tried to educate such people only in the USSR, but this did not save them from degradation and collapse.

      The moral of this fable is this: 1. Do not rush to scold the Ukrainians, we are just lucky that for some reason or by chance, there were no personalities like Ukrainians in power in Russia. Otherwise, we would have gone to war with Beijing in orderly rows.
      2. Educate yourself so that at least you can go your own way and resist propaganda. No one but ourselves is interested in this. God forbid that such people gain a critical mass, then we will live
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 19 August 2023 22: 19
        0
        If yes, if only...
        Give an example, when something appeared in our country, manifested itself, which can be called "lose human appearance" ???
        Those. we have ever hated other people, residents of a neighboring country, all without exception, just for that ... but for nothing, in general.
        All the same, Soviet education, our people have a consciousness, they have not been able to eradicate it, so far at least.
  8. The comment was deleted.
  9. Dmitry Trukhtanov
    Dmitry Trukhtanov 19 August 2023 08: 21
    +7
    The same thing happened with their beloved Nazis, the bulk of the officers and motivated died from 41 to 43,
    1. saigon
      saigon 19 August 2023 16: 26
      0
      The citizen does not lead people into amazement as you famously destroyed the Wehrmacht officers by the year 43.
      Motivated even in May 1945, flew planes to Berlin (Kriegsmarine submariners), and some of them did end up in Berlin. Well, ss and wafen ss did not end at 43, however. Hitler's Germany and the Wehrmacht in particular collapsed at the end of April 1945.
  10. faterdom
    faterdom 19 August 2023 08: 51
    +3
    Bundeswehr officers can take a vacation and then "die in a plane crash"
  11. rotfuks
    rotfuks 19 August 2023 10: 21
    0
    From the German point of view, it is impossible to fight without officers and sergeants. And for Ukrainians, fighting with semi-partisan formations is just what is needed. Judging by the large number of video messages from Ukrainian soldiers to Zelensky, only the vertical of power works there and officers are useless there. Each forelock is his own officer and commander.
    1. voyaka uh
      voyaka uh 19 August 2023 22: 54
      0
      "only the vertical of power works and the officers are useless there. Every forelock himself an officer and commander."///
      ----
      This is called horizontal, not vertical.
      And it is right. Giving independence to the junior commander,
      the time for making operational decisions is significantly reduced.
      This is how Wagner successfully worked, this is how the Ukrainian elite units work.
  12. Beaver
    Beaver 19 August 2023 11: 12
    +1
    The commander is a fighter who knows how to think. It takes brains to think. But where can poor Ukrainians get them?
  13. Andrey_10
    Andrey_10 19 August 2023 21: 41
    0
    I do not agree with this opinion, at one time I worked in the military registration and enlistment office, and I know firsthand about the number of reserve officers. So I’ll tell you there are quite a few of them, and even if the Ukrainians have losses of 300+ thousand, then there are 1 million officers in the reserve, that’s for sure
    1. rocket757
      rocket757 19 August 2023 22: 12
      0
      Man is different for man, and soldiers and officers are not the same.
      Quantity does not necessarily translate into quality.