Military Review

The most prosperous and disadvantaged regions of Russia. Riddle: who did not count the Ministry of Regional Development?

59
At the end of the year, according to tradition, results are summed up in various fields of activity. There was no exception and summing up in December 2012 in terms of the well-being of the Russian regions. The rating was compiled by Russian experts on 64 items, which were structured by 11 different groups.


The calculation was made using the methodological base of the Ministry of Regional Development, which today is headed by Igor Slyunyaev. Research went on throughout the year. Based on a study of unemployment rates, wage arrears, construction rates, production volumes, electric energy consumption, financial activity, investment attractiveness and much more, the index of each subject of the Russian Federation was compiled separately. The index was compiled by the level of income of citizens, the quality of housing conditions, demographic indicators, the development of education and health, environmental safety.

As a result, the regions of Russia took their places in the consolidated rating, the first three places of which went to such subjects of the federation as Moscow, St. Petersburg and the Moscow region. At the end of the list, Ingushetia (with its 47% of the unemployed), the Republic of Tyva and Kalmykia were identified.

Such a rating has been compiled for more than a year, and, in principle, fundamental changes in its top are not yet noticeable. On the one hand, this speaks of the stability of certain Russian regions (of both capitals, regions of oil and gas production), but on the other hand, an increasing gap between the subjects of the federation in understanding their competitiveness is also evident. Some use the resources of both their own and other regions (for example, Moscow), while others are forced to sit tight on subsidies and reflect on how much more can be pulled on the grubs allocated from the federal center. Local authorities are often not ready to make radical legislative moves in terms of the development of financial and industrial areas of the region, and the federal center is not always ready to share the tax manna, which is legally concentrated in its main volumes in Moscow.
Any rating gives rise to controversy, and even more so, a rating that in some way differentiates the quality of life in certain regions of Russia. Disputes arose both around the list of the most prosperous and around the most economically disadvantaged Russian regions.

To introduce the subject of discussion, we present both lists.

The top ten looks like this:
1. Moscow (72,9 points).
2. St. Petersburg (68,6 points).
3. Moscow region (60,6 points).
4. Tatarstan (58,4 points).
5. Krasnodar Krai (54,3 points).
6. Belgorod region (53,4 points).
7. Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Area (53,1 point).
8. Tyumen region (52,4 points).
9. Voronezh region (49,1 score).
10. Nizhny Novgorod region (48,3 points).

End of the list (anti-rating leaders):

71. Dagestan (32,3 points).
72. Kabardino-Balkaria (31,9 points).
73. Karachay-Cherkessia (31,7 points).
74. Buryatia (31,2 points).
75. Jewish Autonomous Region (30,7 points).
76. Trans-Baikal Territory (30,7 points).
77. Kurgan region (30 points).
78. Republic of North Ossetia-Alania (28,9 points).
79. Republic of Altai (27,9 points).
80. Kalmykia (25,2 points).
81. Tyva (21,7 points).
82. Ingushetia (20 points).

You will say: why does the list end on the 82 line, in Russia is the 83 a subject of the federation? Which subject was unrecorded? And this subject is the Chechen Republic. For some obscure reasons, the Ministry of Regional Development does not provide data on monitoring the situation in Chechnya. Well, or Chechnya does not give the Ministry of Regional Development the opportunity to conduct this monitoring ... In general, this republic was out of the rating list. Perhaps for a reason: the less you know, you sleep better ...

The principle of disputes about a particular place in the region in the ranking is born on stereotypes that live for decades. One of these stereotypes: well, where there is oil and gas.

Of course, the presence of oil and gas in the depths of the region adds economic advantages, however, as you can see, from the published rating, and regions with a certain potential for oil production go to economic outsiders. The same Dagestan has, it would seem, all that is necessary for a sharp jump in the region to the top of the rating: this is a prosperous demographic situation, the availability of natural resources, the opportunity to actively engage in agriculture, and a high level of education (judging by the results of the USE Dagestan schools, where the so-called 100-ballnik more than in any other region ...). However, information about a high level of unemployment, crisis phenomena in the financial system, weak investment attractiveness continue to come from this southern region of the country with unenviable regularity. But for many residents of the same Dagestan, those regions of Russia that were among the foremost possess certain amazing magnetic properties: the flow of Dagestan citizens of Russia to Moscow and St. Petersburg does not dry out. It would seem that you need to study and work for the benefit of your own republic, so that it is not a train car at the tail of the train, however, people are drawn to where much more modest work is made to receive substantial money ...

It is surprising that at the very end of the list was Kalmykia. I remember that during the time of the management of this region, Kirsan Ilyumzhinov, Kalmykia was considered one of the most promising Russian regions because of very serious investment attractiveness. Elista in the nineties saw a kind of "New Vasyuki" of the new time. But then it turned out that the territory of the republic attracted businessmen by the fact that there was an opportunity to evade taxes. In Kalmykia, Operation Steppe took place, during which numerous offshore companies were liquidated. From this point on in the Kalmyk "New Vasyuki" things went wrong.

Incidentally, at the same time (the second half of the nineties), investigators were engaged in the elimination of offshore companies in the territory of the Republic of Ingushetia. Investment projects thereafter and here began to quickly turn off. Today, Ingushetia occupies the last place in the list of economically prosperous regions of the country and leads in the number of unemployed, despite the fact that the region itself is a truly tidy field for economic investment. But who will invest their money there, where there are no guarantees not only that they will start working, but also that they will be able to be returned back? .. If you believe the official statistics, then in Ingushetia the lowest average annual income per capita is Russia. For comparison, it is in 6,7 times lower than the average per capita income of Tatarstan. This is a huge gap in the framework of one country, which clearly needs to be leveled so that the country does not completely split according to the principle “the rich do not understand the poor”.

The published rating gives food for thought to the heads of the regions, because the very fact of being in the tail end of the list speaks of unrealized potentials and unintelligible personal management effectiveness. With all due respect to the heads of regions who are at the bottom of the list, it is necessary to recognize that the work they are doing is obviously not effective. If the region cannot provide itself economically, then it is worth thinking about the effectiveness of management activities.
For example, in the Republic of Tyva, their own regional revenues make up only 24% of the total republican budget. In Ingushetia, even less - only 16%. Obviously, with such a return, there is no need to talk about economic efficiency.

In general, now we should expect from the leaders of a number of subjects of the federation reports that the Ministry of Regional Development has counted wrong, and that everything is in order in their wards. Who would want at the very New Year to get the nuts from the federal authorities ...
Author:
59 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. domokl
    domokl 20 December 2012 09: 03
    +11
    I looked and wondered ... Well, how much can you step on the same rake? We read the reports of officials and make a list ... And if you just compare the arrival of departure from region to region, you get a completely different picture ...
    1. older
      older 20 December 2012 09: 40
      +7
      Here it is ... It also seems to me that all these statistics are clearly tied to government requests ... The rating is simply adjusted ...
      1. SSR
        SSR 20 December 2012 13: 32
        +4
        In general, now you should expect from leaders a number of subjects of the federation

        What kind of leaders are they? leaders in pumping money into your family budget?
        Most unfortunately just like that ...
        1. Botanologist
          Botanologist 20 December 2012 15: 21
          0
          Local authorities are often not ready to make radical legislative changes in terms of developing the financial and industrial spheres of the region

          To be honest, the local authorities do not have any powers to legislatively regulate the financial and industrial sphere. This is the subject of federal law. And it would be interesting to see how deputies of Ingushetia amend the Civil Code of the Russian Federation and the budget of the Russian Federation lol
  2. klimpopov
    klimpopov 20 December 2012 09: 06
    +8
    No Chechnya in the ranking? Is there a part of Russia? Hmm, I have to see ...
    1. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov 20 December 2012 09: 21
      +11
      Quote: klimpopov

      No Chechnya in the ranking? Is there a part of Russia?

      Hi Klim, so Ramzan sits in chocolate, see the rating more than Moscow.
      1. klimpopov
        klimpopov 20 December 2012 09: 29
        +35
        Hi Hi! Apparently out of the rating, in general, I got tired of the "exclusiveness" of Chechnya. Here events in the city (I will not escalate) are taking place, the people are already ready to rise, though so far only for rallies. But what is the government's reaction to this? Will you try to guess? It turns out that the young guy was stabbed by two Czechs - this is a simple everyday life, and when the Czechs and everyone else like them were kicked off ... chilled - this is interethnic enmity, and the Russians are wrong, we need to be more restrained ...
        It’s necessary to clean and lubricate Saigu’s patina ...
        1. Alexander Romanov
          Alexander Romanov 20 December 2012 10: 21
          +12
          Quote: klimpopov
          It turns out that two Czechs were stabbed to death by a young guy - this is a simple routine, and when the Czechs and all the others like them were mobbed off .. they were ethnic strife, and the Russians are not right to behave more restrained ...

          This is the case everywhere, they greyhound seeing how their power protects., But such behavior of the power will lead to blood. Moreover, the power itself will receive the cuffs
          1. Sinbad
            Sinbad 20 December 2012 10: 32
            +12
            Stalin was right! At 24 hours, I solved the problem.
            1. klimpopov
              klimpopov 20 December 2012 10: 39
              +7
              Twenty-four is not twenty-four, but from 43 to 57 the years were calm, there are witnesses ...
            2. Kaa
              Kaa 20 December 2012 11: 51
              +14
              Quote: Sinbad
              Stalin was right!

              And he had the right to do so:
              "" The attitude of the Chechens and Ingush to the Soviet power was clearly expressed in desertion and evasion of conscription into the ranks of the Red Army. In January 1942, when recruiting the national division, only 50% of the personnel were drafted. In March 1942, out of 14 576 people deserted and 13 people evaded service, who went into an illegal position, went to the mountains and joined the gangs. In 560, out of 1943 volunteers, the number of deserters amounted to 3 people. " Ingush, 000 1 more brave sons of the mountains evaded conscription, which totals 870 49. Being in the ranks of the Red Army, 362 thousand Chechens and Ingush were killed or missing. Is this a lot or a little? The Buryat people, two times smaller in number, which the German occupation did not threaten in any way, lost 13 thousand people at the front, 10,7 thousand were inferior to Chechens and Ingush Ossetians one and a half times.
              According to March 1949, among the special settlers there were 4 Chechens and 248 Ingush who had previously served in the Red Army [946]. Contrary to popular belief, a number of Chechens and Ingush for military merits were exempted from being sent to the settlement. As a result, we get that in the ranks of the Red Army there were no more than 10 thousand Chechens and Ingush, while more than 60 thousand of their relatives evaded mobilization or deserted. - from a memo addressed to the People's Commissar of Internal Affairs Lavrenty Beria "On the situation in the regions of the Chechen-Ingush Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic", compiled by Deputy People’s Commissar of State Security, Commissioner of State Security of the 2nd rank Bogdan Kobulov based on the results of his trip to Chechen-Ingushetia in October 1943 and dated November 9, 1943: http: //superrossiyanin.narod.ru/history/history_page_1.html
              1. chehywed
                chehywed 20 December 2012 22: 13
                +5
                Continuing the theme

                Memories of a German saboteur of Avar origin, Osman Guba (Saydnurov) are very eloquent, he was planned to be appointed Gauleiter (governor) in the North Caucasus:

                “Among the Chechens and Ingush, I easily found the right people, ready to betray, go over to the side of the Germans and serve them.

                I was surprised: why are these people unhappy? Under the Soviet regime, Chechens and Ingushs lived prosperously, in prosperity, much better than in pre-revolutionary times, which I personally saw after more than four months in the territory of Chechnya-Ingushetia.

                I repeat, Chechens and Ingushs do not need anything, which struck me as I recalled the difficult conditions and constant deprivation that mountain emigration found in Turkey and Germany. I couldn’t find another explanation, except that these people from Chechens and Ingushes, changing moods towards their Motherland, were guided by selfish considerations, the desire under the Germans to preserve at least the remnants of their well-being, to provide a service, in compensation of which the invaders would leave at least some of them available livestock and food, land and housing. "
        2. Shuhrat turani
          Shuhrat turani 20 December 2012 11: 24
          -3
          And what are you afraid of terms? Would rise and have done everything as it should. Maybe the Kremlin would be taken by storm ... We must act, not chew snot ...
          1. klimpopov
            klimpopov 20 December 2012 12: 01
            +4
            Hahaha I am moved by your comments ...
          2. Karlsonn
            Karlsonn 20 December 2012 15: 22
            +10
            Shuhrat turani belay request what

            Sorry, comrades, that is off topic, BUT:

            Exactly 95 years ago, the All-Russian Extraordinary Commission to Combat Counter-Revolution and Sabotage under the Council of People's Commissars of the RSFSR was formed!
            BEST OPERATION OF CHK, OGPU, NKVD, MGB, NKGB, KGB, FSK, FSB -
            HAPPY HOLIDAY!

            ACTING - GOOD LUCK, VETERANS - HEALTH,
            FAVORED - ETERNAL MEMORY!
            1. Karlsonn
              Karlsonn 20 December 2012 15: 24
              +1


              agents? surveillance and wiretapping ...

              interrogations, torture ... and expense!

              this is a service! this is a holiday!

              not that Wed..th New Year!
              1. Karlsonn
                Karlsonn 20 December 2012 15: 32
                +3


                again:
                - All involved, Happy Holiday !!! hi drinks soldier
                1. Karlsonn
                  Karlsonn 20 December 2012 17: 46
                  +2

                  laughing , minus I see, there is a person who does not love the state security organs bully .
                  1. Karlsonn
                    Karlsonn 20 December 2012 17: 48
                    +2


                    Song from the film "Crown of the Russian Empire"

                    Lead showers hit
                    Music: B. Mokrousov Lyrics: R. Rozhdestvensky


                    Do not grieve for your son
                    The evil share of the curse
                    On the seething Russia
                    He rushes the horse.

                    Civil war rumbles
                    Dark to dark
                    Many paths in the field
                    Only one truth

                    Lead showers
                    They prophesy trouble
                    We shouldered
                    And war and need.

                    Well, it’s good reason for our fate
                    A star flames
                    We swear to her life
                    Forever, forever.

                    And over the ominous steppe
                    Let the raven not circle
                    We're forever
                    Going to live

                    If thunder strikes again over the world
                    The sky will burn with fire
                    You just whisper to us
                    We will come to the rescue


                    1966 g ..
        3. soaring
          soaring 20 December 2012 11: 27
          +10
          Hello everyone! Klimpopov "It turns out that a young guy was stabbed by two Czechs - this is a simple everyday life, and when the Czechs and all the others like them were kicked out by a crowd ... it is interethnic enmity, and the Russians are wrong to behave more restrainedly ..."
          Yes, in general, everywhere and everywhere these black ass .... e !!! Quite often there are some quirks on their part and nothing happens and will not happen to them for this, and if one of our commoners does this, they will be imprisoned for a long time (they fired at the Kremlin and received a fine of 1000 rubles. Dances by the eternal flame. ..) We must try to dance with them there near the mosque, only I'm afraid they will cut off their heads and they will not have anything again, and I will be to blame myself - as in the joke "I threw myself on the knife several times in a row" Our authorities, apparently, either do not try or cannot control the situation, and this can turn into a big carnage for all mother Russia. The Czechs got it everywhere ...
        4. JonnyT
          JonnyT 20 December 2012 12: 41
          +10
          Consequence: the Russian participant in an accident with Dagestanis and the FSIN himself was stabbed with several stabs.

          The Investigation Department of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation in St. Petersburg claims that after a minor accident on the 64th kilometer of the Ring Road with the participation of Dagestanis and FSIN officers, a St. Petersburg resident inflicted five knife wounds on himself, from which he died. This is reported by the St. Petersburg Channel 5. The accident happened on December 17.

          The widow of the deceased 37-year-old Grigory Kochnev, Ekaterina does not believe the version of the investigation. Gregory - an athlete, a member of a voluntary people's squad - never had a suicidal tendency, in addition, he was an exemplary family man who went to pick up children from kindergarten. And not only that, the investigation adheres to, to put it mildly, a strange version, the police, who had the documents of the deceased, deigned to call the widow and tell about the incident only the next morning, although the news was reported in the evening by the media.

          The relatives and friends of the deceased also claim that the information from the investigation does not correspond to reality. And the doctors, according to them, after examining the body, also expressed doubt that a suicide had taken place. It was just that there were "correct" witnesses near the accident site, who told an incredible story.

          An off-road vehicle on the ring road crashed into a Hyundai car, in which two officers of the Federal Penitentiary Service were traveling in St. Petersburg and the region. They were returning from service in remand prison No. 6 in Gorelovo, Komsomolskaya Pravda writes. According to employees of the Penitentiary Service, the driver of the crashed Toyota ran into the second lane - meanwhile, the VAZ of the tenth model with the license plates of the Dagestan region braked sharply, another foreign car, Audi, crashed into it. Further, according to the FSIN officers, the man rushed to the VAZ car, rolled up the mirror, crumpled the body, provoked the Dagestanis into a fight and ran back to his Toyota, where he began to cut himself with a knife that ended up in his sleeve.

          Relatives and friends of Kochnev do not hesitate - Gregory was stabbed to death, and the witnesses whose testimony is available to the investigation, his death in collusion. Relatives of Gregory are looking for witnesses and car owners with DVRs that drove on Monday, December 17, about 15-16 hours along the 64 kilometer of the Ring Road.

          Kochnev had two daughters, six-year-old Vladislav and four-year-old Alina.
          1. klimpopov
            klimpopov 20 December 2012 12: 46
            +6
            Yes, I also read it. Who else have questions? Our guy was stabbed to death, and they dumped him into Chechnya, and there he was stabbed to death.
          2. Igor
            Igor 20 December 2012 13: 43
            +5
            Quote: JonnyT
            Kochnev had two daughters, six-year-old Vladislav and four-year-old Alina.


            It is necessary for the family to help financially, what is there with our online fund?
            1. Aventurinka
              Aventurinka 20 December 2012 15: 19
              +2
              +! That’s the reason to start.
        5. Farvil
          Farvil 20 December 2012 12: 54
          +8
          In the Stavropol Territory a complete ass with the rights of Russian-speaking, is taking over the region.
      2. older
        older 20 December 2012 09: 41
        +4
        winked So the Moscow Kremlin is also not included in the rating ...
  3. evgenii67
    evgenii67 20 December 2012 09: 14
    +6
    announce the whole list, please ......
  4. Igor
    Igor 20 December 2012 09: 27
    +5
    In general, it’s time to introduce self-government in the country and let the people choose prosecutors, judges, cops, housing and communal services, deputies, the mayor
    1. Igor
      Igor 20 December 2012 10: 24
      0
      Who erased the floor of my post angry What did I say that?
  5. Wertynskiy
    Wertynskiy 20 December 2012 09: 37
    +9
    It is surprising that at the end of the list the majority are republics, and at the beginning almost all areas. It is also strange in the sense that nobody separates the republic by financing, trying to give them more than to the regions.
    Apparently the CASE HERE IS NOT AT ALL IN THE BOOB, but IN THE PERSON WHO SITS IN THE CABIN (s).
    This once again confirms the fact that separatism and extremism can not be poured with money, you still need to put normal people there at the helm, and not according to principles - if only there would be no war.
    1. donchepano
      donchepano 20 December 2012 10: 02
      +9
      Quote: Wertynskiy
      at the end of the list, the majority are republics, and at the beginning almost all regions. It is also strange in the sense that nobody separates the republic by financing, trying to give them more than to the regions.


      that is why in central Russia ordinary people have dilapidated houses, and in the republics mostly stone palaces. For some reason, it is beneficial for the authorities to finance the republics
      1. Wertynskiy
        Wertynskiy 20 December 2012 11: 09
        +4
        Quote: donchepano
        then in central Russia ordinary people have dilapidated houses, and in the republics mostly stone palaces

        So they have terrible frosts in the republics! Not like in our Siberia laughing !
      2. Shuhrat turani
        Shuhrat turani 20 December 2012 11: 26
        +2
        True, there is nothing to squander the money, anyway, they go to the Caucasus as a breakthrough.

        GIVE BABLO TO RUSSIAN GOVERNMENTS !!!!
    2. Doktor-2
      Doktor-2 20 December 2012 11: 09
      +4
      Maybe they deliberately lower their rating so that the hand of the giver does not become scarce? And Chechnya is not there, so as not to annoy anyone once again, because we know how much they are piling into there!
  6. fenix57
    fenix57 20 December 2012 09: 40
    +9
    Yes, Chechnya is all in Moscow, and therefore not on the lists.
    1. Sinbad
      Sinbad 20 December 2012 10: 36
      +3
      Yes, Moscow has long turned into a leech on the body of Russia. And the rulers, apparently, forgot that Moscow is not Russia yet!
      1. Wertynskiy
        Wertynskiy 20 December 2012 11: 58
        +3
        Quote: Sinbad
        Yes, Moscow has long turned into a leech on the body of Russia

        Yeah, this is Moscow raving about the ideas of Wahhabism, harboring the militants, it’s Muscovites constantly rattling issues of separatism. No need to look for easy, wrong ways out of a difficult situation.
        1. MstislavHrabr
          MstislavHrabr 20 December 2012 21: 28
          +3
          No ... In Moscow, 80% of Russian companies doing their business in our country and abroad are simply registered. And accordingly, they pay taxes at the place of registration ... Even if their entire business, all means of production, land, factories are located in the regions ... An office, a couple of secretaries and advertising agents give much more profit than thousands of hectares of agricultural land, etc. d. Let's move the apparatus of the president and government somewhere in the area of ​​Samara, Tambov or in the river. Tuva or Kalmykia and see how the economic indicators of these regions change!
          Or even better, we will transfer the capital to one of the Caucasian republics and relocate the families of our officials there ...
          1. chehywed
            chehywed 21 December 2012 00: 45
            +2
            MstislavHrabr
            Holy truth! A few years ago I was surprised to learn that the Murmansk region is a subsidized region. In the region, the most important sectors of the economy are: non-ferrous metallurgy, mining (extraction and processing of apatite-nepheline ores, extraction and concentration of copper-nickel and iron ores), chemical, fish, ship repair, woodworking industries. Actively logging. Rich deposits of oil and gas are discovered on the shelf of the Barents Sea. Among the leading industrial enterprises: Apatit OJSC, Kandalaksha Aluminum Plant, LUKOIL-Arctic-Tanker OJSC, Nickel Association (Monchegorsk), Kovodorsky Mining and Processing Plant (iron ore concentrate), Murmanrybprom Production Association. Kola NPP. Kislogubskaya PES. Cascades of hydroelectric power stations on the rivers Niva, Tuloma, Paz, Kovda, Voronya. The leading branch of agriculture is animal husbandry. Cattle (milk and meat breeds), deer, poultry, and pigs are bred. Sea transport (main port - Murmansk (K&M)
            But all or almost everything is registered in Moscow and St. Petersburg. Ie they work, and we only ask for food here.
  7. serjant4
    serjant4 20 December 2012 09: 46
    +4
    in Chechnya, everything is in "chocolate", why bother people again ...
  8. IRBIS
    IRBIS 20 December 2012 09: 58
    +20
    What national policy - so is the rating. It shows that it is mainly Russian Ivan who plows. He also feeds the "Makhmuds" who love to live beautifully, but absolutely do not want to work. Return them to your republics, let the economy be raised. We need to stop giving them various preferences, make them live according to the laws of the Russian Federation, and they themselves will go home to the mountains. In the meantime, only ratings and no concrete measures to improve the situation.
    1. Shuhrat turani
      Shuhrat turani 20 December 2012 11: 28
      +4
      Pavilno
      SHARE OF MAHMUDS FROM THE EARTH OF RUSSIA, AND WITH THEM AND IGRAGIMS ALL TO THE SAIDS !!!!
      1. Karlsonn
        Karlsonn 20 December 2012 17: 57
        0
        Shuhrat turani

        Dityatko, everything is clear with your mental development, but answer this question:
        - Have you read the resource rules? Read carefully? Why didn’t they remember anything?
        1. Shuhrat turani
          Shuhrat turani 21 December 2012 00: 01
          +1
          Will you ask the majority of members of the forum about this? as soon as the "interethnic" topic is touched upon, only such appeals are written ... Or what is allowed to Jupiter that is not a bull?
          and what you, my dear, may be clear about my mental development? Have you looked into my school diary? a rhetorical question, do not strain, do not answer, anyway nothing positive will come of it ...
          1. Karlsonn
            Karlsonn 21 December 2012 13: 44
            0
            Shuhrat turani

            Quote: Shuhrat Turani
            And you ask about this at the majority of members of the forum?


            MAY INTEREST IN THE ADMINISTRATION?

            Quote: Shuhrat Turani
            and what you, my dear, may be clear about my mental development?


            all.


            Quote: Shuhrat Turani
            Have you looked into my school diary?


            God forbid! everything is so clear.


            Quote: Shuhrat Turani
            don't strain don't answer


            don't worry about me.


            Quote: Shuhrat Turani
            all the same, nothing positive will come of it ...


            Of course it won’t work out, such as you, I’ve heard enough from the end of 80’s.
  9. vladsolo56
    vladsolo56 20 December 2012 10: 12
    0
    And who needs it? what are we talking about? Well, it’s very interesting for me to know who lives and how, for me it’s important how I live
    1. Shuhrat turani
      Shuhrat turani 20 December 2012 11: 30
      -1
      Quote: vladsolo56
      And who needs it? what are we talking about? Well, it’s very interesting for me to know who lives and how, for me it’s important how I live



      and to be aware of whom to hate and who to blame for all troubles!
      1. Karlsonn
        Karlsonn 20 December 2012 18: 03
        +3
        Quote: Shuhrat Turani
        and to be aware of whom to hate and who to blame for all troubles!

        good laughing
    2. Wertynskiy
      Wertynskiy 20 December 2012 12: 08
      +2
      Quote: vladsolo56
      And who needs it? what are we talking about? Well, it’s very interesting for me to know who lives and how, for me it’s important how I live

      And why do you advise everyone? If roads are not being built in my city, and there are only freeways, are they silent too? Kadyrov turned into a local tsar - well, let and, why, there is a lot of money in Russia. So do you think I should think?
      1. vladsolo56
        vladsolo56 20 December 2012 14: 31
        +1
        But whatever you think, it will still not be your way, but as the authorities say. Only one way out will learn to live without power in a community of like-minded people
  10. anfreezer
    anfreezer 20 December 2012 10: 21
    +16
    I think the governors of the regions and the presidents of the republics should also wear such an invisible T-shirt, put it on ... and the Ministry of Regional Development does not see you point-blank .. laughing
    1. Ares1
      Ares1 20 December 2012 12: 09
      +3
      Quote: anfreezer
      Minregion does not see you point-blank

      Or the "stepson" of the President of Russia does not see the Ministry of Regional Development point-blank. However, the sum (90,1% of federal funding to the budget of the "stepson's region") does not change from the change of the places of the terms.
  11. Grenz
    Grenz 20 December 2012 11: 01
    +10
    Rating given nonsense - on behalf of the head slobbering something and smeared on the table. In addition to Moscow and St. Petersburg, everyone else is in the same ... with a slight difference in depth.
    And Chechnya is a black bottomless hole where not only our money goes by trains, but as Kadyrov said, Allah still helps.
    Here on the uniform there is an article "Storming Grozny" So the commander of the marines concludes that Grozny was rebuilt as Las Vegas, and we still live in crumbling barracks and hostels.
    Let Mr. Slyuntyaev remove the flasher and drive 100 kilometers away from Moscow and get his rating and count. In surprise, that he was informed and that there really is.

    1. evgenii67
      evgenii67 20 December 2012 11: 22
      +10
      All of you probably watched a video of Vladimir Vinogradov about how he traveled to Chechnya ..... ruins, dirt, and there is a video with the same Vladimir Vinogradov 10 years later, so Grozny really turned into Las Vegas, but we have In the Smolensk region, for example (and not only), such houses are almost split in half and people live in them., Yes, they live, but there’s nowhere to go ....
  12. Shkodnik65
    Shkodnik65 20 December 2012 11: 07
    +7
    [Quote]Based on a study of unemployment levels, the presence of wage arrears, construction rates, production volumes, electricity consumption, financial activity, investment attractiveness and much more, an index of each subject of the Russian Federation was compiled separately. [ angry / Quote]
    Oh, and this crafty thing - official ratings, indexes. Well, take for example OFFICIAL inflation. At least someone can determine the REAL level of decline in life in the country from it. I am absolutely sure that all these studies are a waste of taxpayer money, and also harmful. angry
  13. TekhnarMAF
    TekhnarMAF 20 December 2012 11: 13
    +11
    Riddle: whom did the Ministry of Regional Development miss? Rather, something crazy!
  14. jagdpanzer
    jagdpanzer 20 December 2012 13: 48
    +4
    regarding the foregoing: these nations have already hesitated .. doesn’t the government see interest? it will end with a bloody mess because someday
    1. thatupac
      thatupac 20 December 2012 15: 16
      0
      Faster than the Russian Russian killed than the Caucasians run over. It is proved by Hoe in Kushchevka.
  15. Penzuck
    Penzuck 20 December 2012 15: 29
    +5
    I personally heard from the news: "Inflation was 8%, prices increased by 6%, and the level of income of the population increased by 25%." Maybe not quite so, but close to it. If salary has not increased relative to the level of prices (or inflation), then what nafig income?
  16. Nechai
    Nechai 20 December 2012 17: 34
    +3
    Quote: older
    It also seems to me that all these statistics are clearly tied to government requests ..

    "There is truth, there is a lie, and there is also statistics ..."
  17. huut
    huut 21 December 2012 06: 27
    +1
    The rating was compiled by Russian specialists

    The calculation was made using the methodological base of the Ministry of Regional Development

    RIA Rating Agency experts (RIA Novosti Group), as part of a joint project with the Moscow News newspaper, compiled a rating of regions
    The Ministry of Regional Development gave the data, others thought. So he probably has everything calculated, why he doesn’t share - this is strange, yes.

    http://www.riarating.ru/infografika/20121218/610486725.html
    Here is a rating card for several indicators. Chechnya is not in any.
  18. Boris55
    Boris55 21 December 2012 16: 56
    -1
    "... You will say: why does the list end on the 82 line, in Russian same xnumx subject federation? ..."

    Not. I won’t say that. I taught arithmetic, I can count to a hundred :)

    Chapter 3. Federated device
    Article 65

    1. Within the Russian Federation there are subjects of the Russian Federation:

    Republic of Adygea (Adygea), Republic of Altai, Republic of Bashkortostan, Republic of Buryatia, Republic of Dagestan, Republic of Ingushetia, Kabardino-Balkarian Republic, Republic of Kalmykia, Karachay-Cherkess Republic, Republic of Karelia, Republic of Komi, Republic of Mari El, Republic of Mordovia, Republic of Sakha ( Yakutia), Republic of North Ossetia - Alania, Republic of Tatarstan (Tatarstan), Republic of Tuva, Udmurt Republic, Republic of Khakassia, Chechen Republic, Chuvash Republic - Chuvashia;

    Altai Territory, Zabaikalsky Krai, Kamchatka Krai, Krasnodar Territory, Krasnoyarsk Territory, Perm Territory, Primorsky Territory, Stavropol Territory, Khabarovsk Territory;

    Amur Region, Arkhangelsk Region, Astrakhan Region, Belgorod Region, Bryansk Region, Vladimir Region, Volgograd Region, Vologda Region, Voronezh Region, Ivanovo Region, Irkutsk Region, Kaliningrad Region, Kaluga Region, Kemerovo Region, Kirov Region, Kostroma Region, Kurgan Region , Kursk Region, Leningrad Region, Lipetsk Region, Magadan Region, Moscow Region, Murmansk Region, Nizhny Novgorod Region, Novgorod Region, Novosibirsk Region Omsk Region, Orenburg Region, Orel Region, Penza Region, Pskov Region, Rostov Region, Ryazan Region, Samara Region, Saratov Region, Sakhalin Region, Sverdlovsk Region, Smolensk Region, Tambov Region, Tver Region, Tomsk Region, Tula Region, Tyumen Region, Ulyanovsk Region, Chelyabinsk Region, Yaroslavl Region;

    Moscow, St. Petersburg - cities of federal significance;

    Jewish Autonomous Region;

    Nenets Autonomous Okrug, Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug - Yugra, Chukotka Autonomous Okrug, Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug.


    If anyone is interested - count how many subjects in the Russian Federation according to the basic law.