Military Review

The Ministry of Defense of Russia plans to attract universities to carry out research work within the framework of defense programs

57

The Russian Ministry of Defense plans to attract Russian universities to carry out research work within the framework of defense programs. As previously reported, in early October, the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation announced the start of the 1-th All-Russian competition of research works for the Armed Forces. The main goal is to attract the intellectual elite of the country, regardless of age, to the development of advanced technologies aimed at strengthening the state’s defense capability.

Currently, representatives of the Ministry of Defense have begun a series of meetings with the leadership, scientists and students of leading technical universities of Russia. One of the first such events was held at St. Petersburg Polytechnic University (SPbGPU). The main goal is to assess the scientific potential of the educational institution for the implementation of research works for the Russian military department.

As the ARMS-TASS correspondent was informed by the organizing committee of the competition, scientists of SPbSPU presented 20 projects that could become the basis for future R & D projects commissioned by the Ministry of Defense. In particular, these are developments in the field of automated software systems, modern communications and radio monitoring, the element base of modern electronics, sensors and instruments for recording physical parameters of objects, environmental and medical technologies, modern building materials and a number of others.

According to the vice-rector for scientific work of SPbGPU Dmitry Raichuk, such meetings are important for the development and clarification of research areas at the university.

In turn, the head of the Research Center "Bureau of Defense Solutions" (SIC "BOR") of the RF Ministry of Defense Anton Tyurin highly appreciated the prospects of a number of developments presented, which can later be used in the interests of the military. Moreover, according to him, some of the projects may be submitted to the competition held by the Ministry of Defense.

The competition program includes five main areas: information and telecommunication systems, promising types of weapons, military and special equipment, transport and space systems, life sciences, energy efficiency.

Students, graduates and postgraduates of universities, as well as scientific, innovative or production teams capable of solving large-scale scientific and technical problems can become participants in the competition.

The authors of the projects that are of interest to the Ministry of Defense will have the opportunity to realize their ideas with the financial support of the military department. Also, the winners and prize winners may be invited to take part in the implementation of projects as part of scientific groups, or even lead such work. In addition, regardless of the place occupied, bidders may be made offers of employment in specialized units of the Ministry of Defense of Russia.
Originator:
http://www.arms-tass.su/
57 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. ShturmKGB
    ShturmKGB 16 November 2012 14: 46
    +6
    It's time to attract ...
    1. klimpopov
      klimpopov 17 November 2012 12: 46
      0
      Cap evidence the other day visited MO again!
  2. JonnyT
    JonnyT 16 November 2012 14: 52
    +5
    Right! the more ideas the higher the likelihood that one of them will be truly breakthrough !!!! The main thing is that the head of cafes and the leadership of universities lead the right policy

    Right! the more ideas the higher the likelihood that one of them will be truly breakthrough !!!! The main thing is that the head of cafes and the leadership of universities lead the right policy
  3. Gorchakov
    Gorchakov 16 November 2012 15: 12
    +5
    Still just planning? This should have been done yesterday ....
  4. anchonsha
    anchonsha 16 November 2012 15: 26
    +1
    This is the thing ... And do not save too much here ... Perhaps we will go out in people !!!
  5. geo185
    geo185 16 November 2012 15: 46
    +1
    It is high time. The huge scientific potential of our universities, in fact, was not needed by anyone, except perhaps to the Americans.
  6. boris.radevitch
    boris.radevitch 16 November 2012 16: 44
    0
    It’s time to comrade all the universities! angry
  7. Konrad
    Konrad 16 November 2012 16: 53
    +13
    This is a good thing, against the background of the dissolution of military institutes, in which scientific work was also carried out, for example, in Rostov-on-Don - RAU ... On August 29, 2011, this glorious military school, which was recently referred to as a branch of the Strategic Missile Forces Military Academy named after Peter the Great , within the framework of the so-called "reform of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation" ceased to exist ... The Novocherkassk Higher Military Command School of Communications was also closed. And how many of them are there in the country?
    In a month and a half, RAU would have celebrated its 60th anniversary ... A jubilee script was already being prepared, a sketch of the jubilee badge had been developed ... But the minister’s order to close the school prevented a big holiday.

    According to the charter, any military unit that has lost its Battle Banner is subject to disbandment, and those guilty of such a disgrace are subject to trial by a military tribunal.

    In the war years, this happened, as a rule, only with the complete death in battle of the personnel of the unit. Or ... in cases of betrayal. And today, in the peaceful atmosphere of our days, by malicious cruel intent, I parted with my Battle Banner and one of the best forges of the military personnel of Russia ceased to exist.
    1. Sinbad
      Sinbad 17 November 2012 17: 54
      +6
      In your comment, dear Konrad, you mentioned betrayal. So, this is it, only the punishment for the traitor is very soft, more like an encouragement.
    2. Ghenxnumx
      Ghenxnumx 18 November 2012 19: 53
      0
      Quote: Konrad
      And today, in the peaceful atmosphere of our days, by malicious cruel intent, I parted with my Battle Banner and one of the best forges of the military personnel of Russia ceased to exist.

      And the officers are still not provided with housing - Serdyukov, when visiting the RAU, was outraged by the presence of cars on the territory, but when he was told that these were military vehicles living in Santa Maria (this is the name of the officer's hostel) and waiting in line to receive an apartment, he I was very surprised ... but limited myself to just the phrase - "So many ???"
      To ruin the best educational base, the training staff of the RAU, and without worrying about the consequences - what else to expect from чMO, not serving a month.
  8. webdog
    webdog 16 November 2012 17: 05
    +3
    It is high time.
    students have a very creative, non-intentional approach to the task at hand. sense will be uniquely positive. the potential is huge, the main thing is that they should not let a good decision on the brakes ...
  9. atos_kin
    atos_kin 16 November 2012 17: 43
    +2
    It is necessary to revive the "well" forgotten old. Such a system not only existed, but also worked well in the USSR. It started with the decree of the Council of Ministers of the USSR dated 24.02.51 No. 543-271 "On measures to ensure the development of new models of mine-torpedo and sweeping anti-submarine weapons", signed by I. Stalin. Gradually, the Section of Applied Problems under the Presidium of the USSR Academy of Sciences, which was created on the basis of this resolution, began to engage the best minds of the USSR in the tasks of the defense industry. Unfortunately, the average "reformers" have spoken this system. Good luck!
  10. homosum20
    homosum20 16 November 2012 18: 22
    +2
    The idea is great. As a St. Petersburg Polytechnic who graduated from the Polytechnic Institute in 1985, I would like to note the participation of the Polytechnic University in the development of the T-34 and in many other breakthrough military technologies and tools. An open, fresh look, without restrictions "no" production technology, economic efficiency (not the main thing in the military sphere) is a very effective tool.
  11. greenk19
    greenk19 16 November 2012 18: 50
    +1
    By the way, the research institute that developed the mines for missiles and which sold the stool works or that's it. If that's all, then I can talk with my niece, she will be able to draw them for the state (the teachers in the kindergarten greatly praise the work). It’s interesting, of course, that they sold everything out, dispersed the professionals who understood their business and now expect that yesterday’s schoolchildren will raise their defenses. Of course, the technical base will allow them to break ahead.
  12. Lissyara
    Lissyara 16 November 2012 19: 35
    +2
    The thought is correct and useful.
    Although I'm still angry. Thanks to the great "perestroika and reformers" in the country, a powerful scientific machine of the defense industry was practically killed by the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation in the form of the Scientific Research Institute of the Ministry of Defense and military universities (Scientific Research Institute 25 Main Computer Center No. 1 of the Ministry of Defense, the Zhukovsky Air Force Academy, etc.) the first thing that came to mind).
    The trouble is that breaking everything is simple, but restoring the system to at least 1991 level will be very difficult.
    I hope that under Shoigu, the scientific system of the RF Ministry of Defense will still rise from its knees.
  13. Dustcoll
    Dustcoll 16 November 2012 20: 09
    +1
    They don’t pay money, they still want students to work for them.
  14. boris.radevitch
    boris.radevitch 16 November 2012 20: 21
    +3
    All universities military training! am
  15. Volkhov
    Volkhov 16 November 2012 20: 24
    +2
    Has anyone read the terms of the MO competition? There is an interesting feature of determining the winners - you need to get at least 20 points, but you cannot get more than 18 even with the maximum in all sections. And ideas ask for the global levels of Star Wars ... which stand like Gazprom.
    The regulations on the competition were clearly prepared in a wild rush when there was no time to read their own table. The amounts of fundamentally impossible prizes like the salary of a locksmith in Moscow, funding from the award fund are clearly impromptu.
    Most likely - collecting ideas for Americans, because The setting and time factor do not allow you to perform complex work here.
    The reason for the rush is the unsuccessful start of the war, when the enemy is so technically superior that the war fails to start - something like an attack by a minor bully on a boxing champion - there is no fight, they drive away with a light push and go past.
    Late to drink Borjomi. In order for there to be parity, it is necessary to systematically build a state, science, and real history.
    The enemy uses other physics, which the "academicians" successfully deny, but cannot overcome. In these conditions, one should not strive for war, one must first save the population from natural factors, preserve production patterns, and then build technical equilibrium not as a growing aggressor, but to protect oneself and nature from dangerous factors.
    Students before milking for ideas need to be saved and trained.
  16. Comrade1945
    Comrade1945 16 November 2012 21: 12
    +1
    As always on time ...
    It's high time already!
  17. Lissyara
    Lissyara 16 November 2012 21: 35
    +1
    Volkhov,
    Here, most likely, the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation focuses on "The main thing is that the authors of projects that interest the Ministry of Defense will be able to bring their ideas to life when financial support of the military department. Winners and prize-winners may also be invited to participate in the implementation of projects as part of scientific groups or even lead such a job."
    But just how much is it for sale?
    1. Volkhov
      Volkhov 16 November 2012 22: 13
      +1
      Scientists who are able to meet the stated topics (how to catch up with the 4th Reich in a month on their knees) will first study the MO itself, be sad and go to robinsons.
  18. razved
    razved 16 November 2012 22: 57
    0
    Fresh, unblocked ideas needed
  19. Gregazov
    Gregazov 16 November 2012 23: 23
    +3
    He resigned as head of the department in 2009. He taught at the school until it closed in 2011. Now I teach at a civilian university. I can compare the levels of educational, methodological and scientific work. The comparison is clearly not in favor of civilian universities. Instead of scattering contests, in my opinion, it is necessary to revive specialized design bureaus and military research facilities. After the restoration of these pillars of the military-industrial complex, we can talk about attracting other organizations. Today, it resembles a Golden Calf Loin.
  20. Rezun
    Rezun 17 November 2012 00: 29
    +1
    Soviet calculators are the largest in the world!
    We didn’t take them for this - half of my flow on the "diploma" was calculating the memory of large volumes, three were "taken" into the "box".
    By the way, two of them in the third year “signed up” to Mozhaiku. So, the “polkans” at the military departments worked out their bread by 105%! To see ...
  21. Simon
    Simon 17 November 2012 11: 05
    0
    Yes, the scientific and technological potential that they had under the Union was not saved, but under the liberals in the nineties, the remainder was lost. But I think that under Putin everything will be restored. And young scientists and designers need to be paid with dignity, and patriotism among them must be raised. Then it’s going to work.
    1. gorez
      gorez 18 November 2012 19: 40
      0
      Ah Simon, Simon, and who in these twenty years with a hook successively ruined the powerful Soviet state. Or do you, too, the tsar-father did not know what the useless people were doing ???
  22. Lissyara
    Lissyara 17 November 2012 11: 47
    +1
    Gregazov,
    I fully support the revival of the institutes of military science!
    I myself began my service at the Central Research Institute of Defense.
    The advantage of the military over the "citizen" is at least that the employees already have basic training (I'm talking about the military), i.e. boil in their porridge.
    And thanks to Shoig that he revived the committee on science at the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, which was successfully buried during the time of Feldmebl. For this, my respect to him! In the sense of respect Shoigu! smile
    1. gorez
      gorez 18 November 2012 19: 44
      0
      And my respect to you for the field marshal!
  23. tank64rus
    tank64rus 17 November 2012 16: 21
    +1
    How many institutes and brilliant scientists have ruined Serdyukov and Makarov. Justified by "economy" forgetting to say that sometimes One invention or development can justify the existence of an institute in several years, or even more. Now intellectual property is the most popular commodity in the world, except for Russia. not prizes of 50 thousand each, but a clearly prescribed procedure for invention-development-implementation-profit from a model of weapons and military equipment. The creation of a system combining patriotism of developers and their worthy remuneration is one of the main problems of all Russian science.
  24. Lissyara
    Lissyara 17 November 2012 19: 10
    +2
    tank64rus,
    Alexander, yes, they began to destroy it before them. The first stage of the collapse is the collapse of the USSR. To build a powerful officer training system at the Higher School of Higher Education is not years, but decades. I can judge by my university. After the collapse of the Union, many teachers in 1993 from Kiev went to Gorelovo near St. Petersburg. However, to create an engineering of radio electronics on the basis of a political school of air defense is not an easy task, and all the more so not within a year or three. But then it was closed.
    Stool reforms were even worse. To drag two Air Force academies from their homes to Voronezh and Krasnodar is generally chaos. I understand that the land in Moscow in the Dynamo metro station is worth a lot of money, that’s why the Zhukovsky Academy doesn’t. The march is in Monino, and nobody cares that there is no place there. Most importantly, they put the bubble in their pocket. I just have a lot of friends and comrades from these academies. Well, how can a sensible person, a teacher, with the rank of colonel, who has 2 a year old before his demobilization, who has an apartment, break loose from his place to nowhere? Feldmeblyu and Makarych absolutely did not give a shit about that, in their eyes only the little dear shone, like that of uncle Scrooge.
    And this stupid epic with overclocking, unification-connection of various scientific research institutes of the Ministry of Defense (he went through it himself)? They simply killed everything in the bud, with the original crossing of a snake with a hedgehog (such as the Air Force and Strategic Missile Forces, departments very close in profile, unless you can just simmit one word "military").
    Here it would be necessary for all these reptiles Stool and his "puff battalion" (puffs were called brothels in the Wehrmacht) to take away all the stolen money, confiscate all property, and use these funds to start restoring military science and military schools. And what the bastards have done with military medicine. Well VVP has forbidden to mock Kirovka in St. Petersburg.
  25. boris.radevitch
    boris.radevitch 18 November 2012 06: 50
    0
    All universities must be attracted and not honestly! am
  26. 77bor1973
    77bor1973 18 November 2012 09: 24
    0
    From St. Petersburg State University, several thousand draft dodgers must be drafted into the army, this will be help to the army and defense.
  27. tank64rus
    tank64rus 18 November 2012 13: 14
    0
    I read that Madame Priezzheva met with Shoigu and proved that she did everything right. The genius of military science in a skirt.
  28. APASUS
    APASUS 18 November 2012 14: 35
    +1
    As I understand it, until this moment, the enterprises themselves were engaged in R&D? Now it’s clear why our advanced military equipment is behind the West.
    Science separately, production separately ... and how do we even produce something?
  29. Horla
    Horla 18 November 2012 19: 48
    0
    The task for ordinary universities is impossible. For centuries, only the institutes and research institutes associated with the defense industry have possessed the necessary laboratory and research base, and the best intellectual cadres were sent there. The civil institute can make a discovery in the military field only by accident. It is also necessary to remember that all military developments they went under the stamp of secrecy, and at best, information could only get into a specialized research institute and also military. A civilian university does not know what the army needs. It does not have secret scientific information.
  30. rpek32
    rpek32 18 November 2012 20: 08
    0
    Am I scared alone for the future of defense?
  31. The comment was deleted.
  32. Alex 241
    Alex 241 18 November 2012 20: 16
    0
    I absolutely agree with you, a sober and unbiased look at the problem by young designers. How many designs are buried in the bowels of secret libraries, only God knows!
  33. The comment was deleted.
    1. Alex 241
      Alex 241 18 November 2012 20: 20
      0
      According to my information, an infrared homing head was developed, in particular a noise immunity system, which then somehow got onto Stinger in a strange way and took part in the development of the MiG-23 chassis
  34. The comment was deleted.
  35. Alex 241
    Alex 241 18 November 2012 20: 30
    +1
    And how many such ideas, I also asked the rocket launchers: why not make warheads not with circular expansion, but directed actions? They looked at me like a supporter.
    1. Ascetic
      Ascetic 19 November 2012 00: 03
      +2
      Quote: Alex 241
      And how many such ideas, I also asked the rocket launchers: why not make warheads not with circular expansion, but directed actions? They looked at me like a supporter.


      It is necessary to take into account the fact that if a really working missile defense system is created, then breeding using the so-called technology By "bus" 6-10 blocks will be carried out in a very short time. Not in option group "crumbling" of blocks, and thus a "bus" with delivery according to a slightly different algorithm for selecting targets on the enemy's territory. On this occasion, there are just disputes between Solomonov and Efremov. Solomon as opposed to the bus
      I am sure that the future lies with individually guided blocks. This means that each of them will have its own management system. At a certain moment, they seem to scatter in different directions on the principle of the crowd which makes it difficult to intercept, and after that everyone is already flying to the intended target. This means that each of them must have its own high-precision control system so as not to lose accuracy if it is needed. Have your own propulsion system with a fuel reserve. Everyone still needs a set of technical means to overcome missile defense.
      "Bus" - it is common for all units, flexible: guidance system, fuel, means of overcoming missile defense. It is worth remembering that the option proposed by Solomon was once, in the 60s, was considered and rejected. Rejected because it requires one and a half times more costs in terms of weight, and even entails a loss of flexibility in overcoming missile defense. This solution can only be implemented on rockets with a large throw-weight, that is, heavy liquid ones.
  36. The comment was deleted.
  37. Alex 241
    Alex 241 18 November 2012 20: 48
    0
    And so it goes, such a principle ....................
  38. The comment was deleted.
  39. Alex 241
    Alex 241 18 November 2012 20: 57
    0
    Conservatism according to the principle, no matter what happens, and so the peace and quiet, the bosses love.
  40. The comment was deleted.
  41. Alex 241
    Alex 241 18 November 2012 21: 22
    0
    I am humorous on this subject, but I think the meaning is clear.
  42. The comment was deleted.
  43. Alex 241
    Alex 241 18 November 2012 21: 29
    0
    There is a film "Kursk submarine in troubled water", if you want to throw it off.
  44. Lissyara
    Lissyara 18 November 2012 23: 15
    +1
    rudolff,
    Why grin? Normal for those times. I had a diploma project - I rewrote the functionality of 286's healthy kungs (point of guidance and UPC) on two 4 machines. And the most interesting, everything worked.
    However, the deputy. He praised the chairman of the SEC and confirmed that I would go to serve at the Scientific Research Institute of the Ministry of Defense, but on the other hand, hinted that with such modernization how many plants and people would remain unloaded. The final result - in 2002, the IWC company successfully transferred all this to the same personals, because at that time our military-industrial complex was dropped below the plinth.
    And also on projects. When he served, there was no such division into global and small (at least in our research institute). Something was done in its entirety, something in pieces, depending on the TOR and the results of R&D.
    And for students. In the 90s, attracting a student to the army is something impossible. As far as I remember, everyone and everything was mowed. I do not mean a drill in units, but a "jacket" in a research institute or VVUZ.
    1. studentmati
      studentmati 18 November 2012 23: 27
      +2
      The failure in science, and in particular the military, is colossal. How many years will it take to catch up and drive is unknown? And the saddest thing is that today's students, with programs and dictionaries, make so many spelling and other mistakes in the Russian language that it becomes even worse. Either complete fuck ... you are either already recruited, or potential agents ....
      1. Ascetic
        Ascetic 19 November 2012 00: 07
        +3
        Quote: studentmati
        The failure in science, and in particular the military, is colossal. How many years will it take to catch up and drive is unknown?


        That's for sure, the main thing now is to take all necessary measures to preserve what did not manage to reform Serdyukov.

        Here are the most important and urgent decisions of the new Minister of Defense of Russia,
        - Military aircraft will return to the airfield of the polar Tiksi (Yakutia). The strip will be repaired next year.
        - All activities initiated by the predecessor related to military education and military science have been suspended.

        - Suspended all measures to unite air defense and space forces in the aerospace defense. However, like the merger of the military academy of air defense in Tver with the Mozhaisk academy in St. Petersburg.

        - With understanding in the troops, the decision was made to suspend the liquidation of a number of military hospitals announced during a visit to the Plesetsk cosmodrome.

        “Agreed: to suspend all procedures for the liquidation of a number of military hospitals. On December XNUMX, we will prepare a meeting on military medicine and its budget, ”said Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu.

        - The relocation of the Military Medical Academy from the historical center of St. Petersburg to the outskirts of the city was also suspended.

        - The General Staff began to adjust the defense order. The price of the issue is tens of trillions of rubles.

        - Suspended transfer of military camps to civilian authorities.

        - Finally, the epaulettes, which under the former minister at the military uniform slipped on his chest, will now return to his shoulders.

        As for the first official foreign visit, it has already been announced, the new minister Sergey Shoigu will apply to China - country where corrupt top-level officials are shot publicly, inviting schoolchildren to be executed. The visit will begin the day after tomorrow
        1. studentmati
          studentmati 19 November 2012 00: 11
          +1
          And most importantly, keep the professionals! They are already mentally prepared for retirement, but the new generation of professionals has not yet been raised and it may happen that there will be no one to raise.
          1. Ascetic
            Ascetic 19 November 2012 00: 18
            +1
            Quote: studentmati
            And most importantly, keep the professionals! They are already mentally prepared for retirement, but the new generation of professionals has not yet been raised and it may happen that there will be no one to raise.


            I agree. Soviet professionals already by virtue of age and alas ruthless time are already departing. Our generation, who were 40-50 years old in the 90s, was engaged in anything but non-military science, when the research institutes and design bureaus were dispersed, then the youth ran to where. Therefore, a demographic failure has formed. And we are already losing a new generation, Billions are being flown in, but there is no money for worthy pay to talented engineers and they are fleeing to America.
            1. studentmati
              studentmati 19 November 2012 00: 26
              +1
              To solve this problem I see two options:
              1. when our generation, to whom for 40-50 returns to production and grows personnel. It is returned either for money or for the homeland;
              2. or a new generation of effective managers creates masterpieces of the military industry. I am writing, and I myself understand that under item 2 I am writing complete nonsense, although this is what our leaders are calling for. The sad thing is that there are no modern effective managers, they did not begin to study, buying tests, exams and diplomas.
              Therefore, see the first item.
              1. Lissyara
                Lissyara 19 November 2012 14: 07
                +1
                On item 2.
                Alexander, let me disagree. And the new generation has effective managers. If they are paid a normal salary (and not "stool" it in the bowels of the Ministry of Defense), then with these efforts it is quite possible to revive the defense industry in a new light. Enterprises should be headed by strong managers who will be able to provide normal working conditions for the engineering and design staff and workers, so that employees do not look "to the left." The argument may not be right, but remember the Soviet times. There was no staff turnover at the enterprises of the defense industry, and getting there to work was not easy. This is what we should strive for.
                Well, I completely agree about the "purchased crusts". Especially when they are bought by people who are responsible for people's lives (doctors for example). For this, you must immediately plant. In general, I am a supporter of training in responsible professions "outside the zone of paid education." An abstract example is a student or student studying for money. "Comrade Colonel, give me 10 thousand re for" good "in combat training." This would be complete nonsense. I hope that this can only be seen in a nightmare.
                1. studentmati
                  studentmati 20 November 2012 00: 01
                  +1
                  I do not argue that there are educated and really good leaders. In his commentary he wrote in an exaggerated way. But it is in the salary that the whole question is. In Soviet times, the defense industry has always been a priority industry. Today the priority is being proclaimed, but at the same time they say "work on market conditions", and this is wage clamping, cost cutting, attracting cheap foreign labor (which is absurd for the defense industry) and other market mechanisms of the modern economy. There are many examples of effective defense enterprises in the West, but they were created for more than one year and, which is no less important, with serious state support. And we still see that almost the entire defense-industrial complex was destroyed 20 years before the foundation, and now, with a creak, we begin to raise and revive something, stuffing ourselves with bumps. Only one thing will save that the backlog created in the USSR has a deterrent combat potential.
                  1. Lissyara
                    Lissyara 20 November 2012 15: 13
                    0
                    In general, the state (and even the commercial structures that work for it) should fully provide the defense industry.
                    All the same, these are not teapots, pots, tevilizers. The product is "piece", unique and high-tech.
                    You cannot live according to the principle "He who does not want to feed his army will feed the enemy's army." I also adjust the defense to this statement (it seems like this phrase is attributed to Bonopart).
  45. The comment was deleted.
  46. The comment was deleted.
  47. talented villain
    talented villain 19 November 2012 11: 45
    0
    After reading all the comments above, I want to share some thoughts. I myself am a graduate of the Polytechnic. We cut off the military department, despite the fact that I have a specialty

    1. Universities and so participate in the development. The only question is which universities and which students. MSTU named after For example, Bauman has released such a monster as KAMAZ-43269 Shot (BPM-97). In our university there is a council of young scientists. They even develop all-terrain vehicles. But to fall into this caste to a mere mortal, whether it be seven spans in the forehead is unrealistic. I checked it myself. What is the use if these nonsense is given the opportunity to raise the military-industrial complex? Zero.

    2. A grand scientific reserve? We were engaged in laboratory work on captured German machine tools, the youngest of which was 1932. Training programs are out of date. Many of the subjects studied are not relevant. Do you think universities can draw up a technical project? Never. They have no material, technical and production base. As there is no access to the necessary secret information.

    3. I studied, practiced and worked before serving in the army on conscription in a super cool artillery research institute. Do you know what kind of work they gave us? To put it mildly below the level of our capabilities. Do you know any response to any suggestions of promising ideas? Correctly! "Very well. But you have no experience in doing this (but where does he come from?). And there is no money (the neighboring department is already developing a "budget utilization tool" by employees who have hardly passed diplomas for "ud"). So it won’t work. ” The same ideas at scientific conferences were not even heard by the jury, since all the places and applicants were already distributed in advance. There is no need to evaluate others.

    4. Fresh ideas? For two months I explained to the supervisor that in my project I took into account the experience of military operations, which I studied according to special reports. Do you think such an idea was welcomed? No! By the way, after the army they didn’t take me to work in the same place, but they offered to engage in “routine” instead of development. So much for the love of young initiative cadres, efforts to stop the “brain drain”.

    5. Regarding the "jackets." I served on a draft and saw young lieutenants. Is it necessary to compare the level of knowledge if an ordinary soldier explained to the officer what and how to do it? “Boots” are no better than “jackets”. Everywhere there are excellent students and do not care. So “boots” - “boil in porridge” is not the same thing as standing in dresses, revenge on the road and cleaning the snow. "Jackets" at this time the granite of science gnaw.

    6. In general, this whole idea is a stupid and pathetic parody of the American DARPA project (http://www.darpa.mil/NewsEvents/Releases/2012/10/02.aspx).

    Out of curiosity, I’ll try to take part in the competition. My idea, without exaggeration, is a new one, which has no analogues (even to the most amazing one), I have been inspired by my service in the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. In other words, fresh, new, from a young specialist, created on the basis of practical experience.
  48. The comment was deleted.