Military Review

American expert: Russian President was right in starting a special operation in Ukraine

46
American expert: Russian President was right in starting a special operation in Ukraine

The President of Russia was right in starting a special operation in Ukraine. He correctly calculated that for the West the fate of this country and its inhabitants means much less than for the Russian Federation.


This opinion was expressed in an article published in the American journal Foreign Policy by Harvard professor Stephen Walt, who specializes in international relations.

The Russian leader understood, Walt argues, that the US and Europe were not prepared to pay a heavy price to save the Kyiv regime by risking the lives of their citizens. As Putin expected, the West limited itself to military supplies to Kyiv and the imposition of anti-Russian sanctions. The American expert notes that the Russian economy has withstood powerful sanctions pressure. In his opinion, Putin, starting the NWO, initially understood that the country would be able to overcome the consequences of the introduction of large-scale restrictive measures by the West. Contrary to the expectations of the White House, the sanctions failed to stop the defense industry of the Russian Federation, cause discontent and mass protests of the Russian population and force the Kremlin to abandon its plans.

This is partly due to high commodity prices, which Russia continues to export. After all, the world is not limited to the West. And a significant part of it did not go along with Washington and did not break off economic cooperation with Moscow, continuing to follow its national interests.

As the President of Russia stated earlier, one of the main goals of the Russian special operation is to protect the population of Donbass from the aggression of the Kyiv regime, which regularly shells residential areas and civilian infrastructure in the region. The armed forces of the Russian Federation are striving to ensure that Kyiv has lost the opportunity to act in this way.
Author:
Photos used:
http://kremlin.ru/
46 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. dmi.pris1
    dmi.pris1 17 February 2023 09: 31
    +8
    You can agree with this expert professor .. But for me, the GDP was very late with the special operation. But now it has no role. What is not done is not done
    1. credo
      credo 17 February 2023 10: 28
      +2
      It seems that the professor only stated the facts after a year of SVO and no more (according to the more extended information of his statements):
      Stephen Walt, a professor of international relations at Harvard University, listed four important points regarding the conflict in Ukraine in which Russian President Vladimir Putin turned out to be right. The opinion of the scientist leads the publication Foreign Policy.
      The first point concerns Russia's success in overcoming the restrictive measures of the West. Vladimir Putin launched a special operation confident that his country would be able to withstand any sanctions. "He has proven himself right so far," the professor said.

      Secondly, the Russian leader was aware that the people of his country would treat the possible costs with understanding and agree with the chosen course.

      As for the third point, Vladimir Putin was aware that other states would follow their own interests. They will not condemn Russia everywhere. In particular, we are talking about key members of the global south and some other prominent countries such as Saudi Arabia and Israel.

      The fourth point, the most important, according to Stephen Walt, concerns the following. Vladimir Putin is aware that the fate of Ukraine is more important than Russia, not the West. For Americans, Ukraine has never been particularly interesting, but for Russia it is a neighboring country.


      But the fact that Vladimir Vladimirovich "was delayed at the start," as well as our entire political elite, is a fact that no one disputes. The delay has been over 30 years, and as a result we got a NATO bloc on our borders, US biolaboratories almost along the entire perimeter, a weakened economy, thousands of sanctions and the robbery of the country by our own and other "benefactors".
      1. Andrey Stavropolsky
        Andrey Stavropolsky 19 February 2023 08: 53
        0
        30 years ago Yeltsin was in the Kremlin consultants sat, if anything. Why are you posting nonsense?
      2. Fluk54
        Fluk54 20 February 2023 08: 02
        0
        I agree with the last paragraph on all 500!. The process of rethinking the current situation, understanding Russia's place in the world and what our "Western partners" want from Russia, has dragged on unacceptably for our elite.
    2. Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov
      Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov 17 February 2023 11: 50
      -1
      All objective data say the opposite - he hurried with the special operation. Wait a little longer and either the money would have run out to support this hohland or they would have attacked, and we would have been a noble posture of defenders.
      1. art having
        art having 17 February 2023 12: 06
        +2
        Agree. It was not worth it to be the first to climb .. At least they would not look like invaders to the whole world ..
        1. Reptiloid
          Reptiloid 17 February 2023 16: 29
          +1
          Quote from Snay
          ..... At least they wouldn’t look like invaders to the whole world ..

          No matter how nobly Russia acted --- the West has always blamed the worst.
          For example, in this century, in 2010-2012 (I don’t remember exactly), there was a hot summer, fires and Poles crying crying turned to us for help. Ours and humanitarian and the Ministry of Emergency Situations. And the fires were terrible. Forgotten.
  2. Oleg Ogorod
    Oleg Ogorod 17 February 2023 09: 31
    +9
    It's like a glass, half full for some, half empty for others.
    We don't know much.
  3. Silver99
    Silver99 17 February 2023 09: 32
    +11
    There is only one goal, such a nasty formation as Ukraine should not exist, it doesn’t matter how it will be achieved by complete defeat or carve-up.
  4. corpse
    corpse 17 February 2023 09: 37
    -11
    Are we already looking for an excuse to do a CBO? It looks like the ukrotsipsoshniks got to the topvar and even write the news they need ....
    1. Gardamir
      Gardamir 17 February 2023 10: 05
      -3
      And by the way, as they like to say here. If the West praises, then we are doing something wrong. But judging by the enthusiastic comments, this is different.
      By the way, Russia allowed the FRG to seize the GDR, but not vice versa.
      1. tihonmarine
        tihonmarine 17 February 2023 10: 14
        +7
        Quote: Gardamir
        By the way, Russia allowed the FRG to seize the GDR, but not vice versa.

        On October 3, 1990, the GDR disappeared from all maps of the world, then there was still the USSR and the fault of Gorbachev and his team here. There is no need to hang all the bumps on Russia, and so many of them have already been hung on it.
  5. rocket757
    rocket757 17 February 2023 09: 45
    +3
    As the President of Russia stated earlier, one of the main goals of the Russian special operation is to protect the population of Donbass from the aggression of the Kyiv regime, which regularly shells residential areas and civilian infrastructure in the region. The armed forces of the Russian Federation are striving to ensure that Kyiv has lost the opportunity to act in this way.
    . The purpose of the SVO is much broader ... it will be possible to set assessments, a little later, when it becomes clear who wanted what and who achieved what.
    1. Reptiloid
      Reptiloid 17 February 2023 10: 03
      +4
      Greetings Victor hi!
      Quote: rocket757
      ..... The purpose of the CBO is much broader ... it will be possible to set assessments, a little later, the code will become clear who wanted what and who achieved what.

      Everything is so. The directions are visible now, but what happens later --- we'll see. However, you can see that the fuss with greenery lol greatly reduced.
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 17 February 2023 11: 07
        +1
        Hi Dmitry.
        Minor problems postponed until better times! Some of them, then, will appear again, some will be forgotten, for a long time ... we'll see / see.
        1. Reptiloid
          Reptiloid 17 February 2023 11: 59
          +2
          Quote: rocket757
          ..... Minor problems postponed until better times! Some of them, then, will appear again, ....

          What else is good in my opinion? Society began to unite against all sorts of liberal grimacing artists, and it's good that many of them ran away. It's bad that someone supports them. But all this is visible. There is hope that the state budget will get rid of these grabbers.
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 17 February 2023 16: 06
            0
            In our country, and in many other places, society behaves passively ... just muttering under your breath, scribbling on social networks, expressing your dissatisfaction, THIS IS NOTHING and NOTHING, at this stage, in our situation ...
            And for more, few are ready to go ... we wait until they set fire to it or something worse happens.
    2. Magog_
      Magog_ 17 February 2023 10: 36
      +2
      it will be possible to set estimates, a little later
      I would not like to see such a result: Russia will get the embittered destroyed part of 404, and the West will arm the highly motivated remnant of the outskirts "for the extermination of Rus" with increasing volume. So that in the end it doesn’t work out like with the USSR: according to the results of WWII, he made the main contribution to the defeat of the enemy, and the winner is the United States ...
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 17 February 2023 11: 05
        +3
        A stick is always about two ends, at least!
        You can look at the problem from different angles and without going into lengthy arguments ... everything will depend on us, on our leadership, what we will get in the end ... the story of the Chechen Republic, such a good example! If you look at our history, at world history, there are plenty of DIFFERENT examples.
        1. Magog_
          Magog_ 17 February 2023 11: 29
          +2
          history with the Chechen Republic
          The experience of the USSR showed that the most prosperous and "prosperous" republics of the Union (due to the redistribution of the Union budget to the detriment of the RSFSR) after the collapse of the latter became in the forefront of Russophobia and the destruction of everything "Soviet" ... This paradox has not yet been explained ...
          1. Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov
            Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov 17 February 2023 11: 45
            +1
            And what is there to explain. Few of the common people knew about the budget in favor of the republics, and everyone saw the difference in living standards. Several generations grew up on contempt for the Russians, which the authorities supported in every possible way.
            1. Magog_
              Magog_ 17 February 2023 12: 23
              0
              and everyone saw the difference in the standard of living
              It turns out that it is necessary to follow the example of the West in domestic (and foreign) policy: "the more you rob, the more you are loved, respected and imitated"? "Simple man" looks at the rich man "from the bottom up" - a psychologically banal secret of the success of the countries of the "golden billion"?
          2. Reptiloid
            Reptiloid 17 February 2023 12: 14
            +2
            Quote: Magog_
            .... "prosperous" republics of the Union (due to the redistribution of the union budget to the detriment of the RSFSR) after the collapse of the latter, they became in the forefront of Russophobia and the destruction of everything "Soviet" ...

            Everything is clear here. The USSR never reproached them with subsidies, developed and promoted "them" culture, art, science, folk art. So they believed that they achieved all the good things themselves (And where would these cultures be without the USSR). And when the subsidy was gone and the standard of living fell, Russia became to blame
        2. Reptiloid
          Reptiloid 18 February 2023 17: 22
          0
          Greetings, Victor hi Somehow I missed your comment yesterday.
          Russia began to return the lost in the 90s.
          Also, speaking of the NWO, we can say that finally good words about socialism were heard from a high rostrum! Yes, "the first swallow." There must be a continuation
      2. Nyrobsky
        Nyrobsky 17 February 2023 11: 20
        +3
        Quote: Magog_
        according to the results of WWII, he made the main contribution to the defeat of the enemy, and the winner was the United States ...

        The US has already lost. Having muddied this project, they expected to get all of Ukraine, but immediately lost the Crimea, and subsequently 4 more regions, which is not the final result in the list of future territorial losses. As a result, mattresses, for any reason, will have to accept the reality that will develop as a result of the NWO and, at best, they will try to bite off part of Ukraine, but already without industrialized regions, which are also rich in minerals. All their dances with tambourines, missiles and tanks, associations and coalitions, in comparison with the plans that they hatched, will have near-zero exhaust and catastrophic image losses for the United States and its allies, with an unequivocal loss of hegemon status and leading positions. Mattresses themselves led the world to reformatting from unipolar to multipolar, and in fact they will have to admit it, which can only be called a defeat
        1. Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov
          Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov 17 February 2023 12: 16
          +1
          The states do not need Ukraine from the word at all - to use and to own - these are different meanings. Spent - used - thrown away, and to own is to feed and care, why?
          1. Nyrobsky
            Nyrobsky 17 February 2023 21: 04
            +1
            Quote: Ivan Ivanych Ivanov
            The states do not need Ukraine from the word at all - to use and to own - these are different meanings. Spent - used - thrown away, and to own is to feed and care, why?

            Not needed in current state.
            And at first, the mattresses opened their mouths to the whole of Ukraine with the Crimea, where they had already seen their ships on the roadstead in Sevastopol, and absolutely not embarrassed, through open sources, they were looking for contractors to re-equip the buildings of the former pioneer camps into barracks for American marines. Now, having broken off in the main, they act according to the principle - "at least a tuft of wool from a black sheep", and therefore they do not feel sorry for either Ukraine or Ukrainians, if only to spite Russia.
      3. Reptiloid
        Reptiloid 17 February 2023 12: 07
        +2
        hi I have doubts about the embittered. recourse most of them will run away to geyropa to get lace panties there ..... another thing, they can gradually return ..
        Quote: Magog_
        ..... So that in the end it doesn’t work out like with the USSR: ...

        In the USSR, the situation in Ukraine became possible due to Khrushchev, connivance from above and Ukrainization that took place (which I do not understand). Yes, of course, there is always an opportunity to repeat. But experience! How much is possible on the same rake?
  6. Maks1995
    Maks1995 17 February 2023 09: 47
    +1
    IMHO, someone here is fooling around.
    In the title - "right, starting a special operation in Ukraine", that is, about demilitarization and so on.

    The text is something completely different. That the consequences for the Russian economy are not fatal, resources are being sold, the West will not send troops.

    Well, in the end, in the spirit of the USSR - a reference to the opinion of the great Secretary General ... - "As the President of Russia said earlier, ..."
  7. smok1961
    smok1961 17 February 2023 09: 57
    +2
    Putin he was wrong napadając na sąsiedni kraj i. Putin mogąc cofnąć czas na pewno by tego nie zrobił.
    Inwazja już jest klęską Rosji.

    - upadł mit o wielkiej Rosyjskiej potędze militarnej. Od roku Rosja walczy najbiedniejszym krajem Europy .

    - Rosja miała szansę z Niemcami wypchnąć Bidena z Europy i stworzyć nową siłę konkurującą z Chinami i USA. Niemcy mają technologię, a wy surowce. I Niemcy łącząc się z Rosją Nord strrem , byli przekonani, że właśnie realizuje się wielki plan rosyjsko- niemieckiej koalicji...

    Wasza inwazja na Ukrainę bardzo zaskoczyła Niemców. Do tej chwili nie mogą zrozumieć co mieliście w głowach robiąc ten bezsensowny krok.

    - wszystko pogrzebaliście w ukraińskim błocie ...
    -do związku Rosja - Niemcy nie ma powrotu. Nie ma powrotu do nowej potęgi niemiecko- rosyjskiej w dającym się przewidzieć czasie.

    Na zachodzie wszystko wróciło do normy. Niemcy są pod amerykańskim butem. Rosjanie też znaleźli sobie nowego pana.
    Rosja już jest i długo będzie pod chińskim butem.

    Putin gdyby mógł cofnąć czas
    1. Daishi
      Daishi 17 February 2023 10: 04
      +2
      oops, I feel Poland will be divided again, under the very spine
      1. smok1961
        smok1961 17 February 2023 10: 13
        -1
        Jestem przekonany, że tak było gdyby nie inwazja Rosji na Ukrainę. Gdyby nie powrót USA do Europy, Niemcy musieliby wcześniej czy później sprzedać Rosji kraje nadbałtyckie, Polskę, Czechy, Słowację. W przypadku Rosyjsko - Niemieckiego sojuszu, te kraje byłbyby zależne od Rosi tak jak teraz Białorus.
      2. Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov
        Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov 17 February 2023 12: 18
        0
        God did not give horns to a vigorous cow. Geography is a verdict.
    2. Kuziming
      Kuziming 17 February 2023 10: 05
      +1
      Pomysl jest jasny. Atak bez sily jest błędem. Ale czekanie na atak wroga też jest błędem. Głównym błędem jest gospodarka oparta na korupcji.
    3. tihonmarine
      tihonmarine 17 February 2023 10: 23
      +2
      Quote from: smok1961
      Putin gdyby mógł cofnąć czas

      Ja sam nie rozumiem, dlaczego Niemcy nie zwrócone Polsce Prus i Pomorza.
      1. smok1961
        smok1961 17 February 2023 10: 37
        +1
        Dlatego Polacy tworzą największą armię lądową w UE. Polacy Niemcom nie wierzą bardziej niż Rosjanom.
        Rosja nie ma pretensji terytorialnych do Polski i inwazja na nasz kraj nie jest logicznie uzasadniona.
        Co innego Niemcy. Oni nadal marzą o Gdańsku i Prusach.
        Gwałtowne dozbrajanie się Polski nie spowodowane tylko obawą agresji ze wschodu.
        1. Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov
          Ivan Ivanovich Ivanov 17 February 2023 12: 29
          0
          Poland has never been able to live with its neighbors. "Hyena of Europe" - very correct words.
  8. APASUS
    APASUS 17 February 2023 09: 59
    +3
    The problem is rather in the half-hearted position of Putin. It is already clear that the world will change, but we must go to the end.
    It is time to form parallel structures for countries free from "democracy". IMF, IAEA, UNESCO and others .........
  9. Oleg Ogorod
    Oleg Ogorod 17 February 2023 09: 59
    +3
    The US and Europe are not ready to pay a big price for saving the Kyiv regime, risking the lives of their citizens.

    Yes, they do not care about the Kiev regime, no one was going to save it and is not going to, the goal is a change of power in Russia and the removal of Putin.
    Well, at the same time the liberation of Ukraine from the excess population.
    This is what Western investments are investing in.
    Now Putin is helping them liberate Ukraine. From the local population.
    Ukrainians actively moved to Europe, now they are forced to look for work there, and not the highest paid, the work of farm laborers.
    Putin's NWO stopped (one might say destroyed) almost all the remnants of Ukrainian industry. There is almost no work in Ukraine, except to repair and modernize military equipment. Well, the power industry still has to constantly patch up broken substations.
    For Europeans, this is like a balm for the soul. They did not need the Ukrainian industry back in 1991.
    Therefore, sanctions against Russia are being introduced gradually.
    And weapons for the Armed Forces of Ukraine are being supplied gradually so that the hostilities continue as long as possible, grinding Ukraine and exhausting the Russian economy.
    In order for empty store shelves and empty refrigerators to reappear, as in the 80s, and then the discontent of the people will come, then it will be possible to try to stir up another Maidan.
  10. t-12
    t-12 17 February 2023 10: 04
    -4
    Is there any other news, except for the statements of state officials and "experts"?
  11. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 17 February 2023 10: 23
    +2
    The President of Russia was right in starting a special operation in Ukraine.
    To some, though a minimal part of the American society, comes an understanding of what happened on February 24.02.22, XNUMX and why it was necessary. Most of it doesn't and won't. What can we say about American society if in Russian society, although a minimal part of it, including those who have fled abroad, still does not understand this and continues to express its fi.
  12. Ivan Ivanov
    Ivan Ivanov 17 February 2023 10: 42
    +1
    The President made a mistake only in terms and methods.
  13. Konstantin Cherny
    Konstantin Cherny 17 February 2023 11: 41
    0
    this is the same professor who said in 2011 that the United States has lost its position))
  14. _Ugene_
    _Ugene_ 17 February 2023 15: 30
    -1
    The armed forces of the Russian Federation are striving to ensure that Kyiv has lost the opportunity to act in this way.
    and what is the result? they have been fighting for a year, as a result, Donbass began to be shelled much more than before
  15. mr wolf
    mr wolf 17 February 2023 23: 14
    0
    Quote from Snay
    Agree. It was not worth it to be the first to climb .. At least they would not look like invaders to the whole world ..

    To understand who looks more like an invader, one should study the history of the United States. At the time of recognition of independence by England, pindocia occupied only 9% of its current territory. Some territories were bought, but most of them were annexed. Moreover, the purchased lands were also squeezed out from the natives. This is called buying stolen goods. In their subsequent history, there were still quite a few such "spins". Hawaii, for example.. The Virgin Islands. And where they brought their democracy, it’s impossible to count at all ...
  16. Down
    Down 22 February 2023 09: 44
    0
    Quote: rocket757
    The purpose of the SVO is much broader ... it will be possible to set assessments, a little later, when it becomes clear who wanted what and who achieved what.

    This is where the complexity of assessments lies, certain goals of the SVO are understandable, acceptable, but the results ..., there is great doubt that the mobilized will get something, but the oligarchs who have sat out will be more lucky. If the first die, they are "obliged", and the second sit back and receive new factories and, as a result, capital, it turns out to be an imperialist war in its purest form, and this is a weakness in the position of motivation, although a logical outcome in case of victory.