Military Review

On the shortcomings of the army of the Russian Empire, identified as a result of the Russo-Japanese war of 1904-1905

14
On the shortcomings of the army of the Russian Empire, identified as a result of the Russo-Japanese war of 1904-1905

The results of the Russo-Japanese won of 1904-1905 surprised many. The Russian army was not only significantly superior to the Japanese, but at that time was considered one of the most numerous. Meanwhile, as a result of the aforementioned confrontation, our country lost almost all the battles, lost half of Sakhalin and lost almost its entire fleet in the Baltic and the Pacific.


But that's not all. The state treasury of the Russian Empire at the end of 1903 was about 1,9 billion rubles in gold. At the same time, the costs of the war with the Japanese exceeded 2,6 billion dollars.

The external debt of the country at the time of the end of the war reached 3 billion rubles, and the national economy of the empire was practically destroyed.
So how did this become possible?

According to historical information, during the confrontation with the Japanese, significant shortcomings were revealed in the Russian army.

First of all, this concerned technical equipment and equipment. There was an acute shortage of artillery, machine guns and other weapons. The equipment of Russian soldiers was seriously inferior to that of the enemy. There were also problems with the convoy part.

Shortcomings were identified with the recruitment and interaction of army units. Some buildings even lacked engineering units. There were also serious complaints about the combat training of soldiers.

Finally, there was also a problem with logistics, which undoubtedly affected the combat capability of the army. The thing is that material resources, like reinforcements, came to the Far East from the European part of Russia. This took a long time, in connection with which, the stocks of troops were depleted faster than their replenishment came.

In general, as S. Witte wrote: “It was not the Japanese who defeated Russia, not the Russian army, but our order, or rather, our boyish management of a 140 million population in recent years.”

The historian Ilya Shevchenko tells in detail about the equipment and uniform of the Russian army in 1904:

Author:
Photos used:
archive photo
14 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Reklastik
    Reklastik 2 February 2023 19: 51
    +7
    Oh, well, finally, debriefing following the results of the Russo-Japanese War! Very timely, less than 118 years have passed laughing
    1. your1970
      your1970 2 February 2023 20: 01
      +2
      Quote: Reklastik
      Oh, well, finally, debriefing following the results of the Russo-Japanese War! Very timely, less than 118 years have passed laughing

      If there was a debriefing ... otherwise the vidyushka is naked ...
      If not for the loss of the fleet - everything else is a trifle at that time
      1. Metallurg_2
        Metallurg_2 2 February 2023 21: 03
        +1
        And if my grandmother had an appropriate organ, then even under the king they would have flown to Mars.
  2. Metallurg_2
    Metallurg_2 2 February 2023 21: 01
    +2
    And also 13 years of the reign of the king-myrocreator, during which the generals managed to get fat and lazy.
    The commanders of the corps and armies in that war fought for the last time, at best, in the Russian-Turkish war, and then no higher than in the chief officers.
    1. Bingo
      Bingo 3 February 2023 05: 58
      +2
      And by the way, Mikolka the Bloody didn’t understand anything ... The same Kuropatkin, who merged the war, again moved the war front to WWI - well, he merged all the polymers there too
  3. UAZ 452
    UAZ 452 2 February 2023 21: 29
    +9
    Yes, everything was said after Tsushima in one phrase: "The fleet that was preparing for the war could not but defeat the fleet that was preparing for the Highest parades."
    The Russian army, navy, and the state itself is destroyed every time not by an external enemy, not even by any troublemakers and revolutionaries, but by parades and biathlons, other window dressing, a general love for window dressing, show-offs and eyewash. Between effective and spectacular, we always, at the level of an unconditioned reflex, instinct, choose external showiness. This is the bond that, in the final analysis, can cost us the existence of the Russian state.
    1. Andrey A
      Andrey A 3 February 2023 11: 26
      +2
      Well, and the author of this phrase about the Japanese fleet, Klado, how did he prepare for war? This is his idea, following the results of the Sino-Japanese war of 1894-95, that the medium caliber decides everything, the British at that time were already preparing to build the first battleship, where the main caliber was supposed to decide everything .. The reasons for the defeats of our army and navy were incompetence our generals and admirals, everything else is secondary ... At one time, Peter the Great demanded from his son: to pay more attention to the study of military and naval affairs, not relying on generals and admirals. So Nicholas II had to delve more into naval affairs without relying on "professionals", it was necessary to better select military personnel, those who lost the war were direct nominees of Tsar Nicholas. The same thing happened during the First World War. And what about S.Yu. Witte, he played an important role in drawing the country into the conflict, this is his idea: to begin to economically develop northwestern China (Manchuria). How could such a thing come to mind. This is instead of the development and development of their own territory (this is the question of the "boyish" way of governing the country).
      1. rytik32
        rytik32 18 March 2023 23: 33
        0
        Quote: Andrey A
        This is his idea, following the results of the Sino-Japanese war of 1894-95, that the average caliber decides everything

        Clado didn't invent it. It was a worldwide trend. Look at the Wittelsbachs, what they have with the main caliber, and what with the average.
        Quote: Andrey A
        So Nicholas II had to delve more into naval affairs without relying on "professionals"

        He tried, but he was first convinced that the 1TOE was capable of withstanding the Japanese fleet, and then that the 2TOE would kick the ass of the monkeys.
  4. Vladimir80
    Vladimir80 2 February 2023 21: 56
    +1
    Yes, the most unpleasant analogies come to mind ...
  5. alexoff
    alexoff 2 February 2023 22: 28
    -2
    On the one hand, the army is doing poorly with equipment, on the other hand, a one and a half year budget went to the war. It's kind of unclear...
    1. Region-25.rus
      Region-25.rus 3 February 2023 10: 45
      +1
      Somehow it is not clear ...
      you mean incomprehensibly? )) Someone from those in power (and a lower rank but in the subject) had such a sickly gesheft!
  6. egorMTG
    egorMTG 2 February 2023 23: 19
    +1
    - The inability and unwillingness to learn from the past can critically come back to haunt the present or the future...
  7. Timofey Charuta
    Timofey Charuta 3 February 2023 12: 15
    +3
    Quote: "And with regards to S.Yu. Witte himself, he played an important role in drawing the country into the conflict, this is his idea: to start economically developing northwestern China (Manchuria). How could such a thing come to mind. This instead of the development and development of their own territory (this is the question of the "boyish" way of governing the country)".

    For me it remains a mystery. Russia, having the vast expanses of Siberia and the Far East that had not really been developed so far, climbed even further at the beginning of the twentieth century, started some kind of Russian FOREST concessions right in Korea itself, as if Manchuria was already not enough. For what? Annoy the Japs? Is your taiga not enough?

    Now they will start scolding me and calling me names, but Western cartoonists constantly portrayed Russia as an Octopus with tentacles launched into Asia. In the gang of other world imperialists, tsarist Russia, after the suppression of the boxer uprising, began to recklessly divide China and Korea.

    And no need to justify nodding at the Japs. Justify your tricks with other people's evil deeds - wash yourself with mud (one of the great ones said). For the Japanese, the situation was generally the worst of all - without foreign resources, but with a rapidly growing population, a full scribe was sneaking up on him. You cannot build an industrial empire on fish and rice, and without it you will quickly become a colony yourself.

    The tragedy is that it would not work to agree with the samurai to jointly oppose the West, peacefully dividing the spheres of influence. Both Russia and Japan at that time were completely dependent on the West both technically and financially. Both countries built their navies largely in foreign shipyards. They were successfully played off, and everything ended with the terrible Tsushima (the Japanese did not lose a single ship!)


    .
  8. Nikolay Malyugin
    Nikolay Malyugin 4 February 2023 05: 16
    +2
    But why did society react so negatively to this defeat? One of the reasons lies in the following .. Even before the start of hostilities, the entire central press with pomp foreshadowed the victory of Russia. A collector of military awards told me an interesting thing. "We knew that there was a medal" For the victory over Japan ". Such a medal was very expensive among us. And when the Philharmonic was broken, the boys found a bag with such medals in the basement. The price dropped sharply. " An interesting thing is history.