Makarevich made a new open letter

209
A famous musician called on Russians to learn to love and respect themselves and those around them.

8 August 2012, Andrei Makarevich published an open letter to Vladimir Putin in MK. Returning from a regular tour of the country, the rock musician was shocked by the scale of corruption in Russia and told about it. Today "MK" publishes its new open letter, this time addressed to the citizens of Russia.


LET'S TRY WITH PUTIN

OPEN LETTER TO CITIZENS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION


Some time ago I wrote an open letter to our president - I could not resist. I received a lot of reviews - someone expressed warm support, someone laughed at my naivety. Even the president himself answered (I did not expect) - he advised the following letter to be addressed to Russian businessmen so that they themselves would not provoke bribe officials. I have looked narrowly at businessmen (to those that have not left yet) and understood that besides the banal “hold on!” I have nothing to say to them. But I'm not talking about them now. And not about the president.

Let's imagine the impossible: tomorrow we turn on the TV, and from there Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin, just like Yeltsin, who once led him, says: the Russians are tired, I leave. Worked, not sparing the strength, did everything I could, I'm leaving. Thanks to everybody, you're free.

So what?

Do you think that from this day our life will go differently? And the police (forgive me, the police - what's the difference?) Stop robbing and pressing us and start, on the contrary, to defend? And officials will stop cutting the budget and divide kickbacks and take up their direct responsibilities, which they apparently have? And doctors will stop pulling money from the unfortunate patients and will be engaged in their treatment? And the Ambulance will not carry passengers for five thousand on a counter with a siren, and will hasten to help those who need it? Will the priests stop blessing the Orthodox attack aircraft and start treating our souls? And the deputies will no longer make us laugh and dishonor the country and take care of what they were chosen for? And the courts will begin to judge by the law, and not by the dictates of the heart and the call is not known from where?

And if you really think that this is how it will be - maybe try it now, under Putin? After all, he did not give instructions to the cops to rob us, officials to steal, deputies to fool around. I will keep silence about the trial.

And do not inflate the cheeks and shout about patriotism. Patriotism is love for one's homeland. It is impossible to hate each other and at the same time love their homeland. Because homeland is not power, not a state, not birches in a field. Homeland - we are with you. I you he she. And until we stop humiliating and robbing each other, dragging ourselves around ourselves, until we learn to love and respect ourselves and those around us — no one and nothing can help us. Neither the Lord, nor the patriarch, nor the coordination council.

Even Putin.
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

209 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Brother Sarych
    +2
    November 10, 2012
    Yes, Putin did not give such instructions, but he created EVERYTHING so that it was SO and the perpetrators would not be punished for IT!
    Now it has become really interesting, recent events is it just a small fraud especially falsified, or the desire to change the situation?
    We sit and look - we will draw conclusions a little later ...
    1. Taratut
      +7
      November 10, 2012
      Remember that Putin answered Makarevich. Type corruption - this, of course, is not good, but what can you do.
      If I really wanted to end corruption, I could really do something for this. I’m not talking about executions according to the Chinese example, but about the real everyday struggle.
      Here is a concrete example for you. Almost all tenders in Russia are pre-signed. What will be the price, how many kickbacks will be, etc. , who will win. Of course, you can use law enforcement and even some switches will be punished. But you can give up on your business. You will not receive any more orders.
      And the consequences are obtained. The bridge, which in Europe costs a billion, and in China half a billion - we have five billion, and even immediately rains.
      Money allocated for GLONASS is stolen. Money allocated for defense is stolen in the same way. And do you seriously believe that a country can rise in such conditions? No way. In the US, the fight against corruption is not floundering around every corner. But the corrupt official has nothing to wait for. You will not pay off.
      1. Cavas
        +25
        November 10, 2012
        Quote: Taratut
        In the US, the fight against corruption is not floundering around every corner. But the corrupt official has nothing to wait for. You will not pay off.

        Naive Chukchi young man! laughing

        In the modern United States, candidates of all levels are asking for voter support, if only to eradicate the ill-fated corruption that impedes the fight against the deep crisis in which America is.

        It is often surprising for an outside observer to hear all this - after all, the United States is not some kind of backward African state, symbolizing the venality of politicians. Of course, there is the legendary state of New Jersey, where police officers constantly handcuff one or another elected ruler convicted of extorting or receiving a bribe. The same thing happens in the territory of the remaining forty-nine states, but, according to the observations of journalists, researchers, human rights activists and politicians, the phenomenon that can be called “legal” corruption, that is, the legitimate use by elective politicians of their official position to maintain power in hands often to the detriment of the interests of voters.
        1. Taratut
          -2
          November 10, 2012
          Corruption is everywhere. But we would have their problems. The fact that there is an exception is our rule.
          Even the impoverished and highly corrupt Ukraine built two autobahns. And Russia, drowning in petrodollars - not a single one.
          More on tenders. We won the tender. And we would agree for less money, the state would save.
          The profit is not bad. But we were immediately told - half should be given.
          And well, after that, the officials would somehow begin to help us, work out the money. Nothing of the kind, as if deliberately also crap. Set deliberately unacceptable terms. According to the technology, it takes 45 days, and they gave us 30. That is, we are doomed to pay forfeits, penalties and ruffle our nerves in advance.
          1. Cavas
            +10
            November 10, 2012
            Quote: Taratut
            There is corruption everywhere

            Already there is progress and it pleases! laughing
            Quote: Taratut
            Even the impoverished and highly corrupt Ukraine built two autobahns. And Russia, drowning in petrodollars - not a single one.

            We are waiting for Hitler! request
            In fact, the answer is simple, everyone who builds roads has wives, lovers, children.
            And if they build a quality road, they will live on one salary!
            And then goodbye London for children, a vacation with a mistress and shopping for his wife.



            Quote: Taratut
            More on tenders. We won the tender. And we would agree for less money, the state would save.
            The profit is not bad. But we were immediately told - half should be given.

            The realities of the Russian market, and you wouldn’t give away so honest ?!
            I’ll tell you more, I saw how they win tenders at the lowest prices, and then they feed children, hospitals, convicts with counterfeit goods or low-quality products in order to earn money. Because participating in them do not take into account any factors, sometimes you don’t even know the prices. Only the manufacturer can and should participate in the tender, but not the intermediary.
            So start with yourself!
            By the way, tenders are now electronic.
            1. Taratut
              -6
              November 10, 2012
              Quote: Cavas
              There are already shifts and it pleases

              What are the shifts? Since corruption is everywhere, is it not so bad?

              Quote: Cavas
              In fact, the answer is simple, everyone who builds roads has wives, lovers, children.
              And if they build a quality road, they will live on one salary!

              So what's good about that? And those who build autobahns in other countries have no children or wives? Or lovers?

              Quote: Cavas
              Only the manufacturer can, and should not, participate in the tender

              You are clearly special. wink
              Manufacturer WHAT?
              There are many different manufacturers and subcontractors in our process.

              Quote: Cavas
              By the way, tenders are now electronic

              Though positron. The winner is agreed in advance.
              1. Cavas
                +2
                November 10, 2012
                Quote: Taratut
                What are the shifts? Since corruption is everywhere, is it not so bad?

                They recognized that corruption is everywhere, and not just ours.
                Quote: Taratut
                So what's good about that? And those who build autobahns in other countries have no children or wives? Or lovers?

                I wrote you my observation, and not the excuse of corrupt officials and thieves.
                In other countries, probably also there, so they do fake operations there, and they also cripple people (London).
                Quote: Taratut
                You are clearly special.

                Sometimes he participated in tenders in order to lower the walrus of intermediaries or drive them into minus.
                Quote: Taratut
                There are many different manufacturers and subcontractors in our process.

                Did you win the tender for the PROCESS? laughing

                Quote: Taratut
                Though positron. The winner is agreed in advance.

                Not always and not everywhere, here you went too far or just did not directly encounter them.

                Sorry, I went to Ryazan, I'll be back later. hi
                1. -7
                  November 10, 2012
                  If you are conducting a polemic in this form, then do not return from Ryazan. Ryazan is a good city. But there, in my opinion, the question "why glasses?" do not answer "myself".
              2. +5
                November 11, 2012
                Quote: Taratut
                Though positron. The winner is agreed in advance.

                Oh e-eey !!!!! He conducted similar trades himself several times. As a customer it is natural. And I would be glad to push the necessary contractor, not for a bribe, just so that later, not to waste your nerves and not to run around the courts. For the price is knocked down and naturally any peel wins. After which you run not as a Customer, but as a beggar: "Do it, please. Well, do it." After all, there is a demand for the work done and the development of budget funds. And the quality ... Good work is never cheap. And those who make conscientiously the price do not greatly knock down. And we would be glad to pay more, but the result is good, but the law does not allow. They also offered money, but at least platinum bullion !!!!!!! Even if I cannot find out the name of the firms of the participants. And don't say that we don't fight corruption. We have a couple of people gave "weakness". There are cops right there, (or what are they there now, "show-off"? laughing ), the police are shorter, like the hell out of a snuffbox, with cameras and copied numbers of notes. I don’t know what ended for them, changed their place of work. So, distributing the contracts, I considered the money before the salary. But with a clear conscience. Also very not bad, for me anyway. And the participants themselves are engaged in fraud at auctions. How ? Another topic. The easiest method is you pay me and I withdraw from the auction, but don’t pay, so I will bring down the price, you won’t be glad (if in the end they win, but they really didn’t plan to do it, then it becomes the customer completely crying crying crying ) That's how it is in real life. And grandmother's gossip on Rambler .......
          2. +4
            November 10, 2012
            It turns out Taratut kicked back and now he cries.
            1. Taratut
              0
              November 10, 2012
              Quote: kush62
              It turns out Taratut kicked back and now he cries.

              You can not give and die under the fence.
              The system is so arranged.
              1. Born in USSR
                0
                November 12, 2012
                I wonder how many years would the respected Taratut be sent to a rollback in one of the countries in which, in his opinion, they fight corruption so well?
          3. +3
            November 10, 2012
            Quote: Taratut
            Ukraine built two autobahns. And Russia, drowning in petrodollars - not a single one.

            In Novosibirsk, the roads have become really better, although traffic jams have not diminished, but you can already ride and not in a jeep
          4. 0
            November 10, 2012
            So why give half? Give 10%, they will not run to court :-)
          5. +1
            November 11, 2012
            Quote: Taratut
            .... Even the impoverished and highly corrupt Ukraine built two autobahns. ...

            ABOUT! And where? otherwise I didn’t notice ...
          6. 0
            November 11, 2012
            Quote: Taratut
            Even the impoverished and highly corrupt Ukraine built two autobahns. And Russia, drowning in petrodollars - not a single one.

            Open your eyes, this year in Kuzbass surrendered a large section of the autobahn.
            Are you a nice person living abroad? You think you know better from there?
          7. +2
            November 11, 2012
            Quote: Taratut
            Even the impoverished and highly corrupt Ukraine built two autobahns.

            Can you start with yourself? "Professional" you are ours. In Russia there is no concept of "Autobahn", there is the concept of "Motorway". If we talk about the network of highways in Germany, on which there is no speed limit, then in Russia there naturally cannot be (traffic rules, alas). If we are talking about quality, then I recommend that you first find out what the concept of "quality" is according to international standards. These are the "pros" who build roads in Russia, in the fall and in the rain. You lay the coating and roll it in like this, you would have torn your hands off (this year I had a chance to supervise the work of super-road workers from the customer, who are hindered by all corruption, and the material itself is frankly ruining it). Start a skating rink for half a day (Japanese by the way) !!!!!!!! Do not start and roll the site with a vibrating plate !!!!! Take a row, and then in the midst of work ask: "Help people." request
            Quote: Taratut
            According to the technology, it takes 45 days, and they gave us 30.
            But in the end, three months !!!!! request crying
            And finally, information for consideration:
            "The state company" Russian Highways "plans to put into operation by the end of 2014 on the federal highway M-4" Don "a section in the Rostov region, fully complying with the standards of the German autobahns." hi
          8. besfamilnij
            +2
            November 11, 2012
            da bylo by tebe izvest´no chto na zapadah net korupcii tolko potomu chto na vpolne lagalizovaja i dazhe naznvanie est komitet politicheskogo ili ekonomicheskogo lobbi ... i imenno on reshaet kto korupcionzem oy vomit potomu
          9. +1
            November 11, 2012
            Corruption in the United States on a scale that our officials do not even dream about. One simple example is the money for the presidential election campaign from corporations and firms, for what? Clear stump, so that later they return and make a profit.
        2. +3
          November 10, 2012
          There is a lobbying law in America. That is, in America, a bribe is only what is given to an official unofficially, and lobbying (in the form of gifts, contributions to foundations, resolving issues that are not cheap) is a legal activity. So the crystal honesty of the local politicians is a big question.

          In what I disagree with Makar - he just relaxes. That is, he does what, in principle, the entire Russian intelligentsia has been doing. The first step is the groans of "game", "unwashed Russia", "ah and oh", and then revolutionaries grow fat on this dough. There is nothing easier than writing a letter to Putin. It is much more difficult to say - "Such and such a comrade is a thief and a bandit, here is the proof. A letter to Putin is bold, beautiful and not dangerous. Facts about corruption are tough, concrete and dangerous. Who chooses what ....

          And in what I agree with Makar - the issue of updating not only the personnel, but also the principles of the existence of the entire upper echelon of power is somewhat overripe. Today, Iraq is already refusing a high-profile deal for 4,2 billion due to the corruption of the Russian side. And you can shout as much as you like - "you yourself are also very bad", or "America made you, we know", but unfortunately no one would think to say "Russia and corruption? - What are you talking about?" Because Russia and corruption are, unfortunately, close concepts, and they need to be broken in earnest and concrete, and not to laugh it off, they say, people are to blame, they give bribes. People live in the rules that the authorities imposed on them, by which we were forced to live. And you need to fight the system, and, I repeat, specifically, and not pour snot.
          1. +1
            November 11, 2012
            Everything is correctly stated, do not add or subtract. But why are there so many who still howl "Start with yourself! Stop giving bribes and everything will change!" How much more naivety there is in our dear fellow citizens ... It's sad.
      2. +7
        November 10, 2012
        Not me invented - "In the wrong hands - always seems thicker." You don't have to look at your neighbor and be jealous, as he has everything, everything, everything. If you are a MAN, do not whine, but do your job well. Everything is done by human hands, there would be a desire. If you don't, don't take it, if you don't want it, don't let it, if you want to live well, work. Offend - give back, Create a strong family and prolong your family.
        teach to respect the elderly and not forget your ancestors. Then there will be no time for whining about the vicissitudes of life!
      3. rolik
        +7
        November 10, 2012
        In China, huge corruption (even though they are shot there as partridges), in Matrasia there is no less corruption. And it’s good that we have such scandals in connection with corruption. Mean with her REALLY started to fight. Worse if quietness and surface, and missiles fall, the technique is not developed.
        By the way, recently, don’t be too lazy to watch the press, the revealed corruption schemes are becoming more and more, so they started working on them. And remember the 90s, what scandals on the topic of corruption have you heard ???? Or nastalgia at the time of EBNa overpowered ???
      4. nickname 1 and 2
        +4
        November 10, 2012
        Taratut,
        Quote: Taratut
        And do you seriously believe that a country can rise in such conditions?
        And in which? What are you waiting for? What do i need?
        Yes, it's like a lascivious woman - you watch her follow - do not guard!
        So is corruption: each on a camera hang on a lapel! and on the microphone - they can, agree.
        Makarevich is right - the people want, do it!
      5. -3
        November 10, 2012
        I totally agree.
      6. 0
        November 10, 2012
        Again, the United States cites a positive example! Are you holding a candle in an American court? Yes, they even have a legal form of corruption, entire offices are lobbying, they even pay taxes. And you say nothing to wait for mercy! But Cosa Nostra only in the novels of Mario Puzo, probably exists?
      7. akbarr
        0
        November 11, 2012
        In the US, corruption is officially legalized. That is why they don’t bother, why talk about what is familiar to everyone and in the order of things. That’s where our "fucked-ups" have such servility and faith in the beacon of democracy! Of course, there is no corruption in the USA, and there are also rivers of milk running and honey fountains pouring out of the ground.
        Need to grow up
      8. 0
        November 11, 2012
        Quote: Taratut
        In the US, the fight against corruption is not floundering around every corner.

        They just steal quietly and that’s all.
    2. +12
      November 10, 2012
      If you take our state, then under Yeltsin it was an oligarchic society, where the institutions of power were subordinated and served large entrepreneurs (or rather thieves), laws were written for them and their preferences (cancellation of articles for pederasty, impunity for pedophilia, etc.), At this point, the first appearance of Putin took place, whose first task was to inflict a military defeat on the siparatists and stop the collapse of the country, which was done with the elimination of two influential "parties" that ruled Russia, i.e. Gusik and Bereza (analogy Trotsky, Bukharin), the second phenomenon is the defeat of the conspirators who tried to usurp power led by Khodorkovsky, who bought the majority of votes in the Duma, including the Communist Party of the Russian Federation (Tukhachevsky, Yagoda). Further, the GDP created a transport and energy empire from Russia and stopped the control of Western corporations over resources, stopped disarmament and defeated the flower growers, where economically (Ukraine), where physically (Georgia), moreover, at this time, the charter was on a long vacation, having set to the throne of a fool who only turned the clock hands and turned in the wrong direction. When leaving vacation, he faced an orange conspiracy and an attempt by external and internal forces to bang it, but retained legitimacy (won the election). But now a great purge has begun, primarily from the army, although high-profile cases and arrests of big bureaucrats have gone everywhere. Well, it was not before that. In general, in a nutshell, yes, you have already seen it with your own eyes. History repeats itself, the defeat of the Leninists (Yeltsinites) and the great purge, industrialization (modernization). True, the Great War goes on, but let's hope we win as always.
      1. +5
        November 10, 2012
        hrych,
        I support fully and completely +. You can’t look at reality flat, it is often much deeper.
      2. +4
        November 10, 2012
        Support.
      3. Kaa
        +18
        November 10, 2012
        Quote: hrych
        If we take our state, then under Yeltsin it was an oligarchic society

        After the first letter from Makarevich, I thought: "Where did the person who wrote such lines go - Do you remember how it all began, everything was for the first time and again, how boats were built. And the boats were called - Vera, Nadezhda, Lyubov ...
        It all started with publicity - we have "vowel" journalists who, for "evergreens in sufficient numbers and their own mother, will be called a representative of the" first ancient profession ", without thinking about who they themselves then come from ...
        It all started with "building boats" ...
        "Hope" - apparently, for a happy capitalist future. It began with cooperatives - video porn rental, sale of fixed assets, bought for pennies at fixed prices from the state and resold at "free prices" - from here came the geese and birches and many others, the rest either went bankrupt or did not "fit in."
        "Love" - ​​to what, "to the native ashes, love to fatherly graves"? First of all, again to evergreens. And for them - "love" on Tverskaya, on the district, on the ring, love for one's sex, for "culture"pop culture, love of the" party "life, debilitating programs and TV series on zombies?
        "Faith" - in what, that "the West will help us, Europe is with us"? Or the belief that for the "evergreen" in the church the sins of theft, perjury, usury, and blasphemy will be forgiven? And they are not released, it does not work !!! So, I chose the wrong church, I will try another - "Who believes in Mohammed, who in Allah, who in Jesus, who does not believe in anything, even in spite of everything, the Hindus have invented a good religion ..." - let's try, maybe there will be accepted.
        And a generation has grown up, about which the same author wrote: "You can walk like a neglected garden, or you can shave everything off, I saw both of them more than once, who did you want to surprise?" And indeed, after the 90s, who can be surprised?
        And the current letter reminded me of other lines - "Here, a new turn ..." - there is some kind of turn in the life of society, examples with stool affairs - only flowers, so let's "fit" into it without new "jambs".
        The police take bribes - and no one offered a "bamazhku" to the traffic policeman in order to excuse himself for exceeding? Grabber doctors? And no one tried to go to another doctor, if they ran into a scoundrel, extorted money, or made an official complaint to the chief medical officer? The bureaucrat drags on the question, do the prosecutors and judges solve the questions out of bounds? Yes, e-my, how many regulatory bodies we have, they are brushing us off, when complaints-appeals are single, if any of them accumulates a "critical mass of stocks" - they take action. But we spare our nerves, time - and create an environment in which "everyone pays." Maybe we'll listen to one of my favorite authors of my youth "And as long as we do not stop humiliating and robbing each other, dragging ourselves away, until we learn to love and respect ourselves and those around us, no one and nothing will help us. Neither God, nor the patriarch, nor the coordination council.
        Even Putin. "
        1. -2
          November 11, 2012
          Quote: Kaa
          Maybe we will listen to one of the favorite authors of my youth "And until we stop humiliating and robbing each other, dragging ourselves away, until we learn to love and respect ourselves and those around us, no one and nothing will help us. Neither God nor the patriarch, no coordinating council.

          Only if this author starts from himself. And he will stop calling all those who dare (!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) to think differently as "lackeys".
          Quote: Kaa
          Neither the Lord God, nor the patriarch, nor the coordination council.
          Even Putin. "

          It is an insult!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! For example, if I voted for Putin, this does not mean that I cringer before him and put God above (read carefully the text, delve into irony). Of all the candidates admitted to the election, he seemed to me the most suitable for this post. And so the majority voted. And we were all recorded in lackeys. Yes, Putin has fans, like Makarevich. So what? They are not the majority. Why all under one comb? Why does he insult us? Why does he insult our choice? And calls for what? Oh, no hat for Senka.

          Purely for fun: it would be interesting to see the fight between fans of Putin and Makarevich laughing bully
      4. nickname 1 and 2
        +2
        November 10, 2012
        hrych,
        Right. The analysis is accurate but far from complete! A lot of things have been done and right things.
        As young people say today = stupid! Here are a lot of whiners (sorry) today stupidly want something from Putin. They want easy, simple and unreasoned decisions, movements, decrees, etc.
        Ended up raspberries friends! From what we are in ....... what the former have done!
        You can scatter a house in 1-2 days. And build a minimum of 1-1,5 months.
        Quote: hrych
        True, the Great War goes on,
        and THIS will be all right! am
        1. +2
          November 11, 2012
          Quote: nick 1 and 2
          .... Here are a lot of whiners (sorry) today stupidly they want something from Putin. They want easy, simple and unreasoned decisions, movements, decrees, etc. .....

          That's it! Tooting!!! +1000 !!!
          Corruption suits us first of all - the people. We are happy that you can give the GAI officer on his paw, and he will turn a blind eye to the fact that I walked 190 km / h where there is a limit of 110. It’s satisfactory that you can pay a human being = in the BTI, and he will not notice the redevelopment of the apartment with some inconsistencies with the rules . The businessman is completely satisfied that it is possible for the money faster and easier to certify products that otherwise would not have passed according to the requirements. The head of the enterprise is satisfied that he paid a little - and the sanitary station, labor protection and firefighters will not notice much. You can agree with the tax, and with the investigator, and with the judge. And this also suits them: no matter how much you say about a decent salary for a civil servant, but never a salary will give such an income as corruption. You can’t buy a yacht and a villa in Nice for a salary. Therefore, this situation suits the vast majority of our people from those who really could somehow fight corruption.

          And with whomever you talk - in words, everything is against corruption, "the president and the government don't do anything about it, you bastards!" What should they do?
          What should Putin do ?! if he really starts tightening the screws, everyone will shout about dictatorship and repression, the howl of the "human rights activists" will immediately rise - the ghost of Stalin will appear over them again, and this makes them lose their nerves instantly ...

          The authorities can fight corruption only by forceful methods: trial, confiscation and exile. For the most "striking" cases (as with Serdyukov, "in especially large" and "... caused damage to the country's defense") - "tower".

          Our spoiled society does not suit such prospects, - we are democracy used to. And they themselves are somehow not in a hurry to fight corruption either.

          And who is to blame for everything? Of course - Putin!
          1. nickname 1 and 2
            0
            November 12, 2012
            Rink,
            We want freebies! And from her we lose all endurance, head, decency, conscience, and, in general, a human face! We want permissiveness. We want to satisfy our envy!
            And Putin, I think, understands that the people are sick. And he can heal = TIME!
            Only time and or a great shake! And planting, shredding will not help!
      5. -3
        November 10, 2012
        Nonsense, the consequences of the propaganda of the corrupt press and television.
      6. +2
        November 10, 2012
        [quote = grunt]

        That's right. I don’t feel like fighting again, I feel sorry for the sons and grandsons.
    3. Region71
      +5
      November 10, 2012
      Quote: Brother Sarich
      but he created EVERYTHING so that there were SO and the perpetrators would not be punished for IT!
      Oh, how much reasoning. It is necessary to think simpler than citizens. Human nature is such that one wants to take something that is bad, or when they give it. Then it becomes commonplace and the person himself does it so that he lies badly and is given to him. To prevent Putin from saying, put things in order in the state maybe in one year. A year and not a presidential term. It’s enough to start fighting corruption realistically. Sow, confiscate illegally acquired property. Or do you think that under Stalin the officials’s souls were different. Yes, the same people were there, only they knew what the slightest violation could to go to public construction sites to redeem so to speak. When the punishment is cruel and inevitable, I don’t want to violate it. But the fact that the officials have created conditions in our country under which they hold a position not for work but for gain is the fault of the authorities first and foremost the turn of the president.
      1. Brother Sarych
        0
        November 10, 2012
        What am I talking about? Who was punished? So far no one, for that matter, but I want to hope that they will still be punished!
      2. 0
        November 10, 2012
        I support. And, I think, we must also declare those bastards who betrayed our agents for the rush to be "traitors to the motherland" and sentence them to death, the kororaya will be carried out there and then when we deem it necessary and possible! And let them think ... And those ... and possible others ...
      3. +4
        November 10, 2012
        Quote: Region71
        Or do you think that under Stalin the souls of officials were different. Yes, there were the same people, only they knew that for the slightest violation, they could go to public construction sites to bathe so to speak

        By the way, under Stalin, even during the war, there were thieves and bribe takers - if you wanted, you could get rid of the front. So do not idealize. Simply, the majority was eager for battle in order to save their Motherland and defend the Fatherland. Now there has been a substitution of ideals. Each official is trying to get the most out of his position - maybe he will slip through. But since the ass becomes thicker from good nutrition, the moment comes when it will finally nip it.
      4. -2
        November 11, 2012
        Quote: Region71
        Or do you think that under Stalin the souls of the officials were different. Yes, the same people were, only they knew what the slightest violation might

        They can. They can ..... But the trouble is that under Stalin they took and stole. request
    4. NKVD
      +6
      November 10, 2012
      It’s better to entertain the audience rather than write letters, a clown, by the way, the actresses after our footballers the most useless people in our country receive millions of fees and do nothing to the country, they do not produce anything .... they only write letters
      1. rolik
        +3
        November 10, 2012
        He is a musician)))) But now he is more interested in politics. Probably a sweaty shaft of inspiration subsided towards old age, then where else to go, just into politics))))
    5. rolik
      +5
      November 10, 2012
      Terry corruption has blossomed even before GDP. In the 90s it was naturally limited by crime, now crime has grown into a legal business, corruption has remained and has taken the remaining place. Why VVP is to blame for this, because now you are not faced with bandits and corrupt officials, but mainly with corrupt officials, that's all. Corruption has always been, is and will be in all countries. The only difference is in its size. And in countries where there has been a colossal change in worldview, economy, morality, it will be a hundred times more than in established formations. And it is not the GDP that is to blame, as many want to present it, but comrades Gorbachev and EBN. Thanks to them, we now see what we see. And Makarevich, why didn't he shout about corruption in the 90s? And her then was no less than now. It was just that then our favorite artists and musicians did not have to strictly report and pay taxes. Now, as soon as they try to take control of the incomes of our “poor” and “poor” figures of the melpomene, a howl about corrupt authorities and a return to the totalitarian past immediately begins. Is not it? Previously, the bandos took taxes from them, but you will not turn to them with a return (the head will be torn off right away), and you can even shout with the tax accounting system. An honest musician is being strangled, robbed, oppressed, horror-horror, what kind of corruption is there in the country. And when you traveled around the country before, did you see her? They saw, only on .... you were on it, the unaccounted for loot was stacked in your pockets, and rejoiced.
      I advise you to read Poplar's book "Big Chinese Passage", where everything is told about corruption through the eyes of an American.
    6. -3
      November 10, 2012
      I support you in your words. Makarevich well done! Although you can argue. Remember the Russian proverb: "The fish rots from the head."
    7. S_mirnov
      +1
      November 11, 2012
      The singer is quite excusable for such naivety that sounds in this letter. Anyone who thinks that everything can be changed without touching the GDP and the oligarchs, let him think about the question - how can you win a battle if your commander is a traitor and the cartridges are sold to you?
      This appeal to the citizens of Russia is the right thing, the situation in the country depends on the president, but who is at the helm of the country depends only on the people of Russia! So it is written in the constitution, and if someone forgot, then he should be reminded. And in order for the people to really decide something in this country, it is necessary to increase the political activity and consciousness of citizens.
  2. +4
    November 10, 2012
    Well, this time, courtesy from him is nowhere to go. Here, in principle, a public and famous person should behave this way!
    Well done, what can I say. And of course I’m right.
    Only now it seems like some kind of excuse for a naughty schoolboy.
    Well, what to take from a Jew !? winked
    1. -5
      November 10, 2012
      sergo0000 alas, but Makarevich is a Belarusian, and I would like that this wonderful bard be a Jew! request
      1. arhipelag
        +8
        November 10, 2012
        laughing laughing uhahaha, Belarusian !! ?? laughing
        1. sefirs
          0
          November 10, 2012
          Ready to subscribe to every word of Makarevich.
          Yes, let him be at least three times a Jew - as the groupenfüller Mueller used to say bully (or maybe not Muller ...)
          1. +4
            November 10, 2012
            Quote: sefirs
            (or maybe not Muller ...)

            That said Holtoff. The one who received (from Stirlitz) a bottle of cognac on the head.
            1. sefirs
              0
              November 10, 2012
              Right Holtoff.
              You are absolutely right, tan0472 smile
              Damn, I forgot the same .....
              But that's what you and the "general" good
              1. +1
                November 10, 2012
                Quote: sefirs
                But that's what you and the "general"

                laughing"general". I just typed in Google - Semn. instant. spring three times a Jew. bully hi
          2. 0
            November 11, 2012
            Quote: sefirs
            Ready to subscribe to every word of Makarevich.

            “Don't steal,” he didn't say. And you don't need to subscribe to it. It is enough to simply observe. I am also against murder, infliction of grave crimes, fraud, and then you want it according to the Commandments, you want it according to the Criminal Code. Corruption is a type of crime. And it is, alas, indestructible. Sometimes they were hanged / shot for theft, sometimes their hands were chopped off. There was not one thing - not to steal. The anti-corruption banner is an eternal theme. And any opposition can ALWAYS wave it. And start with yourself ...... Live the Commandments, for that matter. And do not create an idol for yourself.
        2. Taratut
          -3
          November 10, 2012
          He is a Jew by mother. On his father - a Belarusian with Polish roots.
          But what's the difference. Caesar Kunikov is a Jew, so what?
          1. Brother Sarych
            +3
            November 10, 2012
            You still reach great-grandmothers! If you do not care (I personally do not care), then why emphasize such details of his genealogy?
            1. +3
              November 10, 2012
              Quote: Brother Sarich
              You still reach great-grandmothers!

              You can not go to great-grandmothers. According to Jewish tradition, nationality is written by mother.
      2. Fox 070
        +9
        November 10, 2012
        Quote: Aron Zaavi
        , and I would like that this wonderful bard be a Jew!

        Dear Aron! What's wrong with you? Have you started giving up yours? Or is he "cross"? It seems that I have not heard this! Although in relation to Makar I do not care who he is by nationality and if you refuse him, then you are definitely not a Zionist. And as long as he does not do nasty things to my people, he will remain an excellent musician for me, the creator of the legendary rock band.
        And under his words:
        Because the homeland is not power, not the state, not birches in the field. Homeland is us. I you he she. And until we stop humiliating and robbing each other, dragging ourselves, until we learn to love and respect ourselves and those around us, no one and nothing will help us. Neither the Lord God, nor the patriarch, nor the coordination council.

        I can put my signature. hi
      3. +4
        November 10, 2012
        Do not offend the Belarusians, but rather read the book by Pyotr Podgorodetsky "A car with Jews". Or go to the Central Jewish resource
        SEM 40.
        http://www.sem40.ru/famous2/e191.shtml
      4. Horde
        +5
        November 10, 2012
        http://sem40.ru/famous2/ - известные евреи


        Jew Andrey Vadimovich Makarevich - singer, poet, composer, writer, artist, producer, television presenter and leader of the rock band Time Machine. People's Artist of Russia (1999)
        1. Karish
          -4
          November 10, 2012
          Quote: Horde
          Jew Andrey Vadimovich Makarevich - singer, poet, composer, writer, artist, producer, television presenter and leader of the rock band Time Machine. People's Artist of Russia (1999)

          You can say what you want, but I respect Makarevich, he is a symbol of our era and his songs will live in us until his death. He stuns his position and there is a lot of truth in it, everything is true. only you find it hard to admit it. You think that a person scolding reality scolds Russia, this is far from the case. And in Russia there were different periods, both good and bad, and Russia was and will be. This time will pass (of Putin), it may end well, it may be bad, but it will pass, there will be someone next. But for the fact that the following did not repeat the mistakes of the previous ones, we need people like Makarevich who reminds all of them of approval. that not everything is so wonderful. And mongrels will bark at anyone who is against power. Up to Makarevich’s value of 99% of our website, even theoretically can’t be reached. Respect people who have achieved something in life and respect their opinions
          1. rolik
            +17
            November 10, 2012
            KarishIt's just really surprising why he started doing it now, and not in the early 90s. When the miners knocked on the pavement with helmets, when the officers were shooting (because there was nothing to feed the family), when we successfully sawed our missiles, and gave our oil and mineral resources to the mattress toppers for thanks (Yavlinsky - s..ka and the Sakhalin 2 project) ... Where was this "voice of truth" of our country. Sang and sang old 80s songs? And then "suddenly" woke up. I am very surprised at this.
            1. Karish
              +1
              November 10, 2012
              Quote: rolik
              Karish, It's just really surprising why he started doing this now, and not in the early 90s. When the miners knocked on the pavement with helmets, when the officers were shooting (because there was nothing to feed the family), when we successfully sawed our missiles, and gave our oil and mineral resources to the mattress toppers for thanks (Yavlinsky - s..ka and the Sakhalin 2 project) ... Where was this "voice of truth" of our country. Sang and sang old 80s songs? And then "suddenly" woke up. I am very surprised at this.

              In general, 20 years is also a period to understand something in life.
              In general, a strange approach, the 90s. What did Putin do in the 90s? Take an interest.
              In the 90s, in general, everyone was in shock and there was a collapse, and everyone survived as I could. Now is not the 90s, and what role. The only question is what he says - true or false. That's all.
              1. 0
                November 11, 2012
                Quote: Karish
                In general, 20 years is also a period to understand something in life.

                Around 2009 I watched Makarevich’s interview, where he assiduously told that the time of political struggle and acutely social topics had passed for him, he was tired and so on ... I was surprised, this is a rocker. Well, we snickered, my friend. And less than a year, and hello ..... Burst ....... Why would it ?????? And wealthy guys are behind me .......

                We are not discussing the songs of "Time Machine" here. I grew up on them. Do not mix sour and unleavened ...
          2. +1
            November 11, 2012
            Quote: Karish
            And mongrels will bark at anyone who is against power.

            Well, you violated the commandments of your IDOL.
            Quote: Karish
            Up to Makarevich’s value of 99% of our website, even theoretically can’t be reached.

            Where do we go request
            Quote: Karish
            Respect people who have achieved something in life and respect their opinions

            In your opinion, Putin, as I understand it, hasn’t achieved anything in life laughing
        2. 0
          November 11, 2012
          Quote: Horde
          Andrei Vadimovich Makarevich - singer, poet, composer, writer, artist, producer, television presenter and leader of the rock band Time Machine. People's Artist of Russia (1999)

          And also a self-proclaimed SuperNew Testament author. There is so much about it, and so little of me. But still I would venture to challenge HIM myself.
          Do not assume the functions of God or the Prophet. Better yourself to follow the commandments. And learn to respect others. And do not support the defilers of the Temple. As well as violators of the Criminal Code and AK. Maybe then it will not be necessary to compose a New Testament. Enough of the Old and New. Or at worst the Criminal Code and the Russian Federation AK. hi
      5. Fox 070
        +7
        November 10, 2012
        Quote: Aron Zaavi
        Makarevich Belarus,

        "Belorus" Makarevich and "Russian" Margulis.
        1. +3
          November 10, 2012
          Quote: Fox 070
          Belarusian "Makarevich and" Russian "Margulis.


          As Pyotr Podgorodetsky, a member of the group, writes in his book "A Car with Jews" - "from the whole group, only Alexander Kutikov was a Jew according to his passport."
      6. -2
        November 10, 2012
        You are five !!! You are our sick !!!
    2. 0
      November 10, 2012
      Quote: sergo0000
      Well, what to take from a Jew !?

      Makarevich Belarus parents from the Pinsk district in the Brest region.
      But in principle it doesn’t matter. I was honestly upset that no one goes into the essence of what was written in the letter, the letter is not about corruption.
      The problem is in the souls.
      1. +1
        November 10, 2012
        Quote: saturn.mmm
        Makarevich Belarus parents from the Pinsk district in the Brest region.

        I confused a little with another Makarevich from the pedigree. So I apologize.
        But again, this is basically not important.
    3. nickname 1 and 2
      0
      November 10, 2012
      What does nationality have to do with it? Why smear people? Why be like the Nazis?
      Who is reading this forum? What age? There is no indicator! A chatter goes like in a bad smoking room. Yes, not in the smoking room, you are friends! Indeed, in a smoking room, many will hold on to the language, if small ones are present.
      Purely Russian carelessness! How will this affect the minds of young people, has anyone ever thought twice?
      1. +5
        November 10, 2012
        Nick 1 and 2 ...
        I never suffered ... to bind people and the nation. Unpromising ... how warm.
        But he could not stand it ...
        "Not by washing, so by rolling .." - so they say.
        Makarevich, the same age, the bright stream of a stagnant "scoop" - turned ... you can't take the definition right away ... into whom.
        First letter - lowered on the brakes ..
        WHAT did Mr. Makarevich want to achieve second ??? "Sa * ra, we still get them" ????
        So I will definitely say - it won’t get it.
        "They have grenades of the wrong caliber ..." - a replica from the White Sun of the Desert.
        ..So here too ..
        Good musician, good ... presenter. Just a good man ...
        What for to be drawn ... empty?
        I do not understand...
        Is someone paying again?
        1. +1
          November 11, 2012
          [quote = Igarr] "They have grenades of the wrong caliber ..." - a replica from the White Sun of the Desert. [/ quote "Yes, his grenades are of the wrong system" ... good
          1. +1
            November 11, 2012
            Yes, right.
            This is my simple retelling simply.
  3. +1
    November 10, 2012
    The civic activity of Makarevich is not in doubt. Man is not indifferent. I would not want to believe that Makar is promoting with the goal of creeping into power at the end of his musical career.
    1. Karish
      0
      November 10, 2012
      Quote: arkady149
      that Makar is promoting in order to get into power at the end of his musical career.

      Where is he PR? He was known throughout the country when they did not even hear about Yeltsin or Putin. In power? Yes, to hell with him? Money? He has enough irkh for grandchildren, earned among other things by his work and talent. You know sometimes a person is simply not indifferent.
      1. +1
        November 10, 2012
        I do not believe ... in not indifference.
        Then I would act differently.
        And not lousy scribblers ... send out ... blogs.
        In the time of Ivan the Terrible .. et-seter - were called - anonymous letters.
        The whip, the rods, the chopping of the hands, the writer is a quartering .... normal punishments.
        We read. We are discussing.
        And alive .... still.
        So it goes..
        1. Karish
          -1
          November 10, 2012
          Quote: Igarr
          I do not believe ... in not indifference.
          Then I would act differently.

          Everyone acts according to his own strength and skill. You probably are not happy with everyone, and at the same time you don’t grab a bump and do not climb barricades.
          Quote: Igarr
          In the time of Ivan the Terrible .. et-seter - were called - anonymous letters.

          Anonymous - were anonymous !!!!! Do you catch the difference?
          Quote: Igarr
          The whip, the rods, the chopping of the hands, the writer is a quartering .... normal punishments.

          T.E. — the time of Ivan the Terrible, in your concept, is simply an idleal of public administration and relations with the people laughing
  4. Lavrik
    +3
    November 10, 2012
    Quote: Brother Sarich
    Yes, Putin did not give such instructions, but he created EVERYTHING so that it was SO and the perpetrators would not be punished for IT!
    This EVERYTHING was created long before Putin. But to create IT and not specifically fight it - I won’t believe it. Another thing is that he fought not efficiently enough.
  5. +11
    November 10, 2012
    I would like to say: "Mr. Makarevich is enough PR from scratch." Enough to offer common truths, and tell well-known facts. Better please your fans with new songs.
  6. +3
    November 10, 2012
    but we began to approach the main thing. Respect is above all and this is not in Russia now. There is no respect for elders, no respect for younger ones. On the one hand, I support Putin that he is trying to firmly suppress any sabotage, but on the other hand he is alone and can’t do anything.
    1. Fox 070
      +1
      November 10, 2012
      Quote: Gentleman
      . respect above all and this is not in Russia now.

      Tell me, sir, do you have this in your country? Have you defeated corruption yet? Cope with drug addiction? Have pulled the vast majority of their citizens out of the poverty line? ... Apparently not! So what kind of banana are you trying to talk about Russian problems ?! Deal with your country first and don't "support Putin on the one hand." He has enough support at home.
      1. +6
        November 10, 2012
        Felix, well, a man is sitting on a Russian site, how can he not discuss our problems? Yesterday, I was discussing with them about their problems, don’t do it so rudely please, corruption is a disaster that his country can’t be helped in ours.
        1. Fox 070
          +4
          November 10, 2012
          Quote: Joker
          , how can he not discuss our problems?

          Quote: Joker
          Corruption is a misfortune, that one’s can’t get enough of his country and ours.

          Oleg, if a person wants to suggest or advise something, it is not necessary to poke our nose at our problems! What, in his country of respect in all forms from all the cracks rushing? I think no. Therefore, one should not point to this as soon as the problem of Russia. They would not humiliate us yet and would not accuse us of lack of respect! We survived, damn it, they will soon begin to poke from all sides: not so sit, not so whistle, not so cabbage soup. Enough, tired !!! What kind of fashion went, only the lazy one did not kick the Russians for anything !!! am
          1. 0
            November 10, 2012
            Fox 070,
            Hi Felix! Catch plus buddy !!! drinks
            1. Fox 070
              +1
              November 10, 2012
              sergo0000,
              Thank you, Sergey! Well, really, got it !!! drinks
        2. 0
          November 10, 2012
          Quote: Joker
          Corruption is a misfortune, that one’s can’t get enough of his country and ours.

          And where is corruption
          And do not inflate the cheeks and shout about patriotism. Patriotism is love for one's homeland. It is impossible to hate each other and at the same time love their homeland. Because homeland is not power, not a state, not birches in a field. Homeland - we are with you. I you he she. And until we stop humiliating and robbing each other, dragging ourselves around ourselves, until we learn to love and respect ourselves and those around us — no one and nothing can help us. Neither the Lord, nor the patriarch, nor the coordination council.

          I would describe this as a call for a national idea, goal.
          We are a society, collective or group of people living in the same territory.
          Makarevich PR is just ridiculous.
  7. +4
    November 10, 2012
    It is always easier to blame others for something than to do or change something yourself, especially if you know that you won’t be anything for it. Everyone should do his own thing, then there will be order.
  8. in reserve
    0
    November 10, 2012
    Makarevich said well, but turned to conscience (deputies, judges, etc.). but did she still have them. what
    1. +2
      November 10, 2012
      And where was his conscience in the nineties, when the Union collapsed, when he stood on the barricade, when he was on the swamp and for years he supported the "pusi-wright". And in general, he stood for democracy, which now led to all this that he saw on tour. I am glad that his conscience is now awake. Better late than never. fool
  9. +7
    November 10, 2012
    And why is Putin always blamed for everything? Was there such a corruption situation with him? Or does someone think that bribery can be defeated at the click of a finger? He is the president and, a priori, is responsible for everything, but he shouldn’t be blamed indiscriminately. He is a man, not the Lord God.
  10. Rezun
    +7
    November 10, 2012
    Makarevich was reborn — I listened to his songs from the very beginning — my peer wanted a warm and satisfying old age!
    Took in due time from this site (s):







    No need to change your principles ...
    1. +1
      November 10, 2012
      After all, he has already bent under us?
  11. +7
    November 10, 2012
    Nobody wants to do anything! Better to sit and wait for someone else to do something! Especially I always liked the reasoning of people of some of my acquaintances about corruption. They always have an ardent aversion to corruption, but none of them goes through the maintenance of the car, they often like to tell how they got rid of the "traffic cops", how they solved their question there and there. How resourceful they are!
    1. +2
      November 10, 2012
      This is what I always say about this, because we ourselves are pushing this corruption from below and it is another side. and all sorts of bribes for drinking alcohol, traffic police for violations, everyone when something starts to think, can anyone put it in order to speed up the process? So it is born of corruption and thanks to us, the officials they steal there is not clear what they are sitting, and these minor ones directly affect our lives. Someone went to do some sort of help and put a bribe in order to speed it all up, and the next one went to do it, so that boss will now specially pull the time so that they can pay him the money, and we do a disservice to ourselves.
  12. +20
    November 10, 2012
    Makarevich says that it’s right, everyone knows it without him. But I stopped respecting him after visiting the Gorbachev’s anniversary in London. He didn’t give a publicity to these letters so that they would not be forgotten by the people. Talent left, the tomatoes wilted.
  13. +18
    November 10, 2012
    There was, to put it mildly, a very bad impression of Makarevich! Everything he said is known to everyone and was even before Putin. But for some reason this "fighter for justice" used to be silent, but now it has broken through. Everything is very simple: in the 90s and early 2000s, Makarevich was happy with everything, people flocked to his concerts, flashed on television - the money went. Now old age outside the door, they began to forget, money does not go, but you want to eat. So he saw the light!
  14. 0
    November 10, 2012
    The well-known piz ....... ol Pavel Globa predicted in the spring that the revolution would begin from above, the fight against corruption and all that, I remembered in connection with recent events. Who? Putin? But did not Putin legitimize Yeltsinism? Yes, he seems to be on the hook himself, and many understand this.
  15. Georges14
    +4
    November 10, 2012
    I looked closely at the showmen (those who had no conscience left) and realized that apart from the banal "bring down!" I have nothing to say to them.
  16. serge
    +3
    November 10, 2012
    Makarevich licked Putin. Everything depended on Putin in the previous letter, nothing depends on it. Vane.
  17. +9
    November 10, 2012
    It's funny, but the last phrase betrays a banal cynic in Makarevich - to call for "love each other" and write "Lord God" with a small letter is his complete resume.
    What kind of faith is he?
    It seems to me that he’s just seizing the moment, because some top-level movement has begun, and the experience of the old comedian tells him that he must be somewhere nearby and look very good.
    1. +4
      November 10, 2012
      Support!
      This is a letter from a man who himself deliberately got into the shit and is now trying to "wipe himself off" with the cleanest that he knows about us.
  18. toguns
    +8
    November 10, 2012
    as for me, another PR and cheap populism of Makarevich.
  19. +3
    November 10, 2012
    I have only a couple of questions: We all of course know the state of affairs, and if we don’t know, we guess. The question is how to really take and break this corruption machine? Take everyone and plant - then chaos will come, because for the place of those whom they planted, a war will begin, and then certainly it will not be up to the people. Any attempt to break this car overnight will lead to a collapse nationwide. The fact is obvious, that is, you cannot take them with a snore and forehead, so you need to create such conditions, situations and so on - so that they would torment themselves or take up the mind (although I doubt the latter. And just say that they say Putin has come and he should punish all the reptiles, it’s simple. But nobody really knows how to do it. So there’s a vicious circle. And if Putin were sure that removing all of them he would solve all problems - so and he did it. And why something, but you can’t call Putin stupid in any way. But we must continue to repeat, he must, but not God, he really is. And it would not hurt to do something ourselves.
    1. 0
      November 10, 2012
      Dear Averias, I have already written about the system here, I will repeat once again - laws need to be adopted well-developed, and for this to choose the guys who are tested and smart to the Duma. SYSTEM is primarily the laws and their strict implementation. In many ways, I agree with you on the collapse, and that it is impossible to take everyone and put them in jail without changing the profitability of their places. But the fact that "no one knows" forgive me, I do not agree. They know! Not in our country, so in other countries. Experience, that is, you need to apply effectively. Take the best! In the meantime, we take the worst ...
      1. +1
        November 10, 2012
        So I don’t argue, it’s just that I expressed my thoughts a bit wrongly (you can say a bit harshly), for which I ask you sorry because I wrote in a hurry, I was driving in a car.

        And on account of the fact that - "They know! Not in our country, so in other countries. Experience, that is, it is necessary to apply effectively." This is, of course, correct, this is of course always, there are enough countries from which you can take an example of the fight against corruption. But, there is a small but that turns into a big problem. This is the scale of our territory and the mentality of the people. If the first criterion is still okay (you can take control), then what to do with the mentality. After all, it’s like, for example, there is such a Vasya Pupkin, all of himself normal and caring for the interests of the country, honest and smart in discrediting connections, not noticed. And then this Vasya clap, put on a big post, give, as they say, the reins of government - let's say dare. And then out of nowhere, this Vasya begins to have little thoughts in his head, damn it, but what actually happens? I do not feel fair, why the predecessor could make money on the "candle factory", but what, I'm a redhead or something. And it began, then it seemed to take a little, then I accepted the "gratitude" in the envelope, then closed my eyes (again, not for free) and did not notice how I became the same corrupt official. And in my head, then the ideas are bright, the thoughts are pure, only good things are something that is all for later and then put off. And then a metamorphosis, a change in personality occurs by itself, Vasya does not notice this, he quickly gets used to cars with flashing lights, and to VIP boxes and lounges. He sharply distanced himself from the people and became the one with whom he fought so hard. This is of course my fantasy, but in my opinion it is not so far from reality.
  20. Brother Sarych
    0
    November 10, 2012
    It’s not necessary to plant everyone, but the rest should start from the top, seeing that fasting and merit do not help much, they themselves will be scared and moderate their appetites! Impunity corrupts ...
  21. +2
    November 10, 2012
    Colleagues, we’re all talking - corruption, corrupt officials ... and so on and so forth ...
    And let's look at the root - and the model that we took for execution in 92 - import and overseas.
    Maybe it was originally flawed and not subject to modernization?
    And the same notorious "pilezh", with which one well-known type is struggling, was not invented by us. In the same USA - it is used on an equal scale. Let's remember the price of the famous hammer in their store and the price of the same inventory tool in the budget in the armed forces ...;)))
    About 5 the same about the same bank loan interest.
    Islamic banking from this point of view is a fairer instrument.

    So what are we going to do, returning to the origins of a just world?
  22. +5
    November 10, 2012
    Andryusha (sorry for boorish familiarity, and it is a pity that this modest comment will never be read to those to whom it is directly addressed), do you think that you opened a certain forbidden secret with your letter? .. Do you think that only you are so smart and you alone in the whole world crave justice? .. You are mistaken. However, it is human nature to make mistakes. But you repeat your mistakes with tenacity worthy of a better application. And this is no longer a sign of wisdom ...
    Andryusha, you think that after you cooed nicely with Medvedev, and after you lit up in the election campaign of Prokhorov, at least someone (who thinks for themselves!) Will believe in the sincerity of your revealing match. You are a naive person, if you think so ...
    Andryusha, I like your songs. Your old songs. They were written sincerely and from the heart. Do mercy on all your fans - don't write new ones. And don't do the old ones. Do not spoil anyone's positive attitude towards that "Makarevich", and even "that" "Time Machine". Go away. Leave the way any public person who respects himself and those around him will act, who has done an act that is different from his words. This is my good advice to you. Advice from a person who grew up on your own songs, and who still knows their lyrics almost by heart ...
    1. Horde
      -1
      November 10, 2012
      ndryusha, I like your songs. Your old songs. They were written sincerely and from the heart. Do mercy on all your fans - don't write new ones. And don't do the old ones. Do not spoil anyone's positive attitude towards that "Makarevich", and even "that" "Time Machine". Go away. Leave the way any public person who respects himself and those around him will act, who has done an act that is different from his words. This is my good advice to you. Advice from a person who grew up on your own songs, and who still knows their lyrics almost by heart ...


      he will not listen to you, so that soon we are waiting for the new Minister of Culture of Russia - Jewish, honest and principled - if this is possible ...
    2. Rezun
      +1
      November 10, 2012
      Chicot 1 Deployed, but we're together !!!
      with SW.Resun.
  23. 8 company
    -2
    November 10, 2012
    So it is so, and Stalin personally was not involved in executions, and Putin does not call for corruption. However, it is from the head that the fish rots, think about this wise saying, Andrei Vadimovich. After all, it is precisely the power that creates the conditions and the system by which the whole people are forced to live.
    1. +2
      November 10, 2012
      8 company
      Hello. The saying, of course, is wise, but ... what if you put a fresh head on a rotten fish, it will immediately freshen up? The impersonal definition of "power" is touching ... after all, breaking the system that developed in the nineties is not such a simple matter, and certainly not a quick one ... it is the inertia of millions of interested people ... what to do with them and where to get others (all the more, after replacing moral values ​​for new - the so-called Western - green and rustling)? Are you suggesting to shoot? Other radical effective means are not visible .... And they have already begun to plant. What's missing then?
  24. 0
    November 10, 2012
    Quote: Cavas
    The realities of the Russian market, and you wouldn’t give away so honest ?!
    I’ll tell you more, I saw how they win tenders at the lowest prices, and then they feed children, hospitals, convicts with counterfeit goods or low-quality products in order to earn money. Because participating in them do not take into account any factors, sometimes you don’t even know the prices. Only the manufacturer can and should participate in the tender, but not the intermediary.
    So start with yourself!
    By the way, tenders are now electronic.


    Do you happen to live on the moon? Naivety and incompetence are simply amazing! Have you tried to fight the SYSTEM? So how is it? What tenders are you talking about here, my dear? Such a system is incorporated in FZ-94, understand me? Pledged! The main criterion is the price, and not the presence of your production base, super-specialists, etc., i.e. a real opportunity to fulfill the order efficiently and on time. Price! Who is lower, he won! Without an assessment of the possibilities and concepts - how can they manage to do so cheaply? Due to what innovations? What scientific idea? So - FZ-94 really contributes not to the fight against corruption, but to the collapse of production, its destruction. And, this is already my personal opinion, everyone who has ever voted for this law should go into political nonexistence. Into the sump! And never come close to lawmaking.
  25. vladsolo56
    0
    November 10, 2012
    But Makarevich is still naive. Is it really getting old
    1. 0
      August 9 2013
      You have long quarreled with your head
  26. 0
    November 10, 2012
    In fact, everything has long been said by the cat Leopold: "Guys, let's live together!"
  27. +2
    November 10, 2012
    Instead of thoughts, Makar has senile crumpling and tears of sentimentality since the article "Blue Bird Stew". Bends down with a PR smell.
  28. 0
    November 10, 2012
    Guys! How many emotions about Makarevich's statement! They have already remembered his nationality, and the folds on the sheet, it seems ... But it is very simple to object to Andrey Vadimovich, and to combine many of your posts into one maxim. The state at all times and in all countries needed only one thing - to create a system in which its citizens would be more convenient: not to steal, than to steal, not to violate, than to violate, not to take / give bribes, than to do it, to work honestly and with dedication than to chase a noodle and beat thumbs at work. That's all why the state is needed! Such systems are created ... in a bunch of countries. But not with us. They cannot create a system for US. Well, they can't, that's all. We put forward such people ... but are we to blame. As Makar and some others suggest, "start with yourself" - this is complete nonsense! You cannot start anything in the SYSTEM with yourself. For to fight her ... personally, I am not Don Quixote. That is why we rage against Putin and others like him because we do not like the system created by this government.

    But there is no need to touch Makarevich as a poet, this is low. He is a wonderful poet! And a good rebel. Sometimes you can sit at the same table with Comrade First and Comrade Second, why not? And Shevchuk sat down and others. There is nothing renegade in this. You read his poems, in poems there is more Makarevich than anywhere else. He doesn't think so much like you and I, so what, don't care in the face? It somehow turns out in a cattle way. Yesenin accepted the revolution, but Bunin did not, so we must divide them into "friend or foe". And not read one or the other, depending on class preference? Rave!
    1. Rezun
      +2
      November 10, 2012
      Quote: mike_z
      But it’s not necessary to touch Makarevich as a poet


      ... was a POET, became n and to t about ....
      1. Fox 070
        0
        November 10, 2012
        Quote: Rezun
        ... was a POET, became n and to t about ....

        The fact that a person has lost his voice does not yet make him "nobody", the main thing is that he remains a MAN, and does not become a Judas. And there is nothing to kick him for age-related disadvantages, EVERYTHING WILL BE THERE ...
        1. +1
          November 10, 2012
          Quote: Fox 070
          The fact that a person has lost his voice does not yet make him "nobody", the main thing is that he remains a MAN, and does not become a Judas. And there is nothing to kick him for age-related disadvantages, EVERYTHING WILL BE THERE ...

          And he didn’t lose his voice, sort of. Recently I was at his concert with Creole tango - I received real pleasure. It was a lot of new. So screechs are brainless, they are on any site, they just need to hear an opinion different from their own and that’s all - the enemy of the people (they, it turns out, is the people, it turns out))) And you can throw stones at poets and philosophers ... How all is not new. Thank you so much.
        2. Rezun
          +1
          November 10, 2012
          I don't even breathe there ... you "-" in response (I just I think)

          The fact of the matter is that a man managed to become a POET, but could not stay with him ...
          For me it personal a loss...

          He became a POET - but could not take place ---- it hurts and bitterly, I respected the dummy ....
      2. 0
        November 10, 2012
        [... there was a POET, became n and to t about .... [/ quote]
        But this does not happen in literature. The poet is tested by the peak, it is true. And over the years, he may not reach his own peak. But he remains a poet forever. By the way, the last disc of "Machines" is quite up to date! ..
        1. Fox 070
          +1
          November 11, 2012
          Quote: mike_z
          , the extreme disc of "Machines" is quite at the level! ..

          Unfortunately, I have not heard. By the way, I wanted to ask you, do you have (or were) related to aviation?
          1. +1
            November 11, 2012
            Quote: Fox 070
            Do you have (or were) involved in aviation?

            No, I’m a ship officer (in the recent past), I only crossed paths with aviators on aircraft-carrying ships.
  29. +3
    November 10, 2012
    Why the hell, this gunky, parhata su. Will teach me? You play your bespontovye songs and play on. Do not go into the "fathers of the nation", without you there is no turn. How long will the shoemakers bake our pies?
    1. vardex
      +4
      November 10, 2012
      it was precisely all his life that he was always dissatisfied with the power of either the Soviet or the present, and as for music, nothing came to his mind, and he was trying to draw attention to himself with some kind of high-hater in see letters to Putin.
      1. +1
        November 10, 2012
        Totally agree
    2. -4
      November 10, 2012
      Or maybe su.a is you? And shameless. Everyone has the right to their opinion. And not what to spray with saliva. even if I disagree.
      1. +2
        November 10, 2012
        Can. But I am not teaching anyone to live without having the right to do so. And he just teaches, and does not "express an opinion"
    3. -1
      November 10, 2012
      rexby63 today I learned a lot of interesting things about Makarevich hi , however, he was and will remain the creator of the "Time Machine", and even the neighbors at the entrance do not know the majority of those who abuse him, but your post was especially interesting. You spoke so strongly, what can you tell about yourself? Without details, just what did you personally do for Russia?
      1. +4
        November 10, 2012
        To begin with, I repeat, I do not teach anyone, and do not try, except for my sons. I was a simple worker, I was not, I was not involved, I was not a member, except for the Komsomol. And for Russia, I personally have not done anything special, I have worked all my life and continue to work. That's all. And to credit the creation of a musical group - you like it, I don’t. And his civil position is not like - this is the position of a walking girl.
      2. Georges14
        +4
        November 10, 2012
        This is true. Makarevich and created the "Machine", but what did it work for? That's right, to the collapse of the USSR. All these "twists and turns", "we want changes" (here really is not a Makarevich, but just a drug addict) - all this worked, unfortunately. And the nostalgic ones - "I grew up on these songs" - have nothing to do with it. Someone, mb, grew up on the songs of okudzhava, but it turned out - a liberal-fascist ... sad
        He who was not a revolutionary at the age of 20 does not have a heart. Who has not become a conservative by the age of 40 has no reason ... wink
      3. +2
        November 10, 2012
        Quote: Aron Zaavi
        Have you personally done for Russia?

        So I personally live in Russia, work, pay taxes, raised the sons of officers, I will soon bring up grandchildren. And who are you to ask. Stirlitz, or what? Let your beloved Andryushcha and Yarmolnik collect dogs in the trash and hunchback in kiss .. kiss.
  30. gen.meleshkin
    -2
    November 10, 2012
    Finally, I heard from Makarevich smart and mature words. I didn’t even expect this. Can a rotten intelligentsia really think sensibly? The corruption system was brought by Californian boys from AI and introduced by the traitor Yeltsin and Gaidar, and for this the criminal code and the State Duma and others were prepared.
    1. +4
      November 10, 2012
      But I remember how he threatened on TV to "shoot the commies" from his personal shotgun. There is no trust in him.
  31. andrey9031
    +2
    November 10, 2012
    Often, they’ll forget
  32. +3
    November 10, 2012
    Thoughts aloud about everything and nothing. I understand I would write: I asked so much for such a concert, but this one in N-sk so much. etc. naming specific names, once he knows everything. Well, it’s good to write an appeal before the election, the words are right, you can’t see the deeds !!!
  33. 0
    November 10, 2012
    judging by the sharp change in the direction of Makarevich’s thoughts, Putin’s response was harsh))))))
  34. +2
    November 10, 2012
    Only by the methods of Comrade Stalin and in no other way can this problem be solved
    And do not console yourself. that it can be somehow different, otherwise it will not work out if you are not different.
  35. -3
    November 10, 2012
    Well, that's right, as long as Putin will: open Jewish museums, rub graters with Solzhenitsyn’s widow, show cranes the way to spawn, catch pieces of amphora in the Black Sea, etc. in the place of what would lead the country - where does the order come from?
    1. +3
      November 10, 2012
      Do you think that if the cranes, instead of spawning, will cope on your head - will this be the order?
  36. +4
    November 10, 2012
    Makar is simply a rotten provocateur. In the end, he, like Kasparov, will be dumped in America. But we once loved his songs ...
  37. Stasi.
    +7
    November 10, 2012
    Makar's second letter really looks like an excuse for a naughty schoolboy. It seems Putin in response to him managed to put the brains. Well, he wrote the first letter because they began to forget him, not the popularity as in the 90s, according to which he is nostalgic.
  38. Yankuz
    +4
    November 10, 2012
    Quote: Horde
    Jew Andrey Vadimovich Makarevich

    So what? A lot of Jews glorified Russia and the USSR with their talents. Including Makarevich.
    PS. But in vain he climbed into politics, and for a long time, - this is a dirty business. So he smeared himself.
  39. +5
    November 10, 2012
    What a multifaceted person (Makarevich). Man. Sparing himself at 120% at concerts, he took the time to do the work of investigators, prosecutors and all other government officials. bodies and revealed this terrible corruption. She is so visible, money shoved, shouted, sweared at each other right on the streets. Well done.
    The person is used to publicity. Now she's missing. I sympathize. Talent doesn't last forever. Age takes its toll. And instead of the "bird of luck" letters to the president fly out from under the pen.
    Well, that's a genre too. But it's a shame. For the idol of youth, that "lane like a bull to a red light." And now nothing new from the stage, except for letters to the president. Yes, this is how worldly glory passes. I'm afraid the phase will come soon "And only the one who has nothing to say - he shouts the loudest." Naturally, from the swamp area.
    1. nickname 1 and 2
      +1
      November 10, 2012
      homosum20,
      You know how nasty you wrote. And all in a bunch. I am very indignant at all THIS Swamp "army" but, nevertheless, I SHOULD respect myself!
      Quote: homosum20
      Man is used to publicity.
      - Well, what does it have to do with it. He has enough.
      Quote: homosum20
      idol of youth, that "lane like a bull to a red light."
      Yes, neither of which he does not per. They attributed this to him! And then what he wanted, and now he does, that's what he wants, and not what -
      Quote: homosum20
      worldly glory passes

      You know, it seemed to me - the man dropped the "shit" - maybe! but you smeared that shit. What for? He, they are artists = people are not gods! Have the right to small and not small nonsense! And we must respect ourselves and theirs.
  40. +6
    November 10, 2012
    Makarevich can be treated differently, but ...
    This is a damn BUT!
    It is impossible to recognize his work and it was difficult for me to realize that this person became nothing and nothing!
    There are songs, there is a singer, there is no person!
    Base?
    Final diagnosis: Celebrating the birthday in London (!) Of the one and only last Secretary General and the first, also last, CCCP President!
    How I said everything!
  41. 46bob46
    +1
    November 10, 2012
    Do the doctors stop pulling money from unfortunate patients and start treating them?
    I don’t know how where in our provincial Kursk BSMP surgeon
    showed me the root of the salary of -7500. Candidate of Medical Sciences Z.Y.
    He explained popularly why the district police officers were paid 25 and more: they spent 15 minutes on the patient, he diagnosed and prescribed treatment. All the services were provided. Try to say that the state does not care about its people. sad
  42. 0
    November 10, 2012
    It is amazing how many people in Russia whose call to be human causes idiosyncrasy.
    1. +2
      November 10, 2012
      You can say so pretentiously, but rather, that all these appeals cause a soreness.
    2. Georges14
      0
      November 10, 2012
      It is amazing how many people in Kazakhstan whose word Russian causes a surge of hatred. sad
      1. 0
        November 10, 2012
        Zhorzhik? How do you know?
        1. Fox 070
          +1
          November 11, 2012
          Quote: srha
          Zhorzhik? How do you know?

          Sergunchik, so drooling through the monitor spatter !!! Get close ... (You have a strange nickname - shit, as if the word is not finished ...) hi
          1. 0
            November 11, 2012
            Classic reasons! True without the manifestation of intelligence.
  43. 46bob46
    0
    November 10, 2012
    Specifically, in essence, a person in the material sense does not need anything,
    God forbid everyone in the profession and in general in life. But if they give the order, he puts in jeopardy everything that has been acquired by honest labor. Are there many like him?
    No one wrote letters to the people on these topics from our nation, only for a bite
    our "golden" intelligentsia interceded.
    1. Georges14
      +2
      November 10, 2012
      Probably all that gained honest work in the 90s? Did he EVEN PAY TAXES? This is not even funny.
  44. 0
    November 10, 2012
    It’s just that Putin is here and * moreover *, every year the same struggle, struggle, but they steal already not being ashamed of billions, think of billions, probably if we look like this, the whole country's full budget goes into the pockets of a thief, with the tacit consent of or even modest participation in it.
  45. dmb
    +5
    November 10, 2012
    Guys, I don’t understand something. And why is corruption stopping you.? You wanted her so much. In 91, destroying and breaking the state, you did not understand why you are doing this? Yes, it was not the party that interfered with you, but the laws adopted by the state. These laws stated that the caught bribe-taker would not get rid of responsibility with one out of a thousand bribes he received (and this is how responsibility is established today), but will receive a real, very long time. And his property will be unambiguously confiscated, and not as now. Ask how many times property confiscation has been used in recent years. This state prevented you from pouring left vodka, selling rotten chickens and Chinese toys that are hazardous to the health of children. It prevented Makarevich from giving "leftists", and "leftists" - universities from graduating illiterate doctors and lawyers. Now you have a different state. Here you can do all of the above, only you need to pay for it with a part of the profit that you earned thanks to it. So, as in that joke about Berezovsky, either remove the cross or put on panties.
    1. Georges14
      +2
      November 10, 2012
      Right! I would just like to note that that state differed from the current one not only by the rigidity of legislation, but also by the presence of developmental meanings.
    2. nickname 1 and 2
      0
      November 10, 2012
      dmb,
      Quote: dmb
      Something I guys do not understand.
      - I agree. How many people in the world (if I hadn’t appeared, I would never have known) live by the principle: all the bastards, only I am good !!! And all one - they are all thieves !!!
      You need to look in the mirror more often! Who is to blame for everything !!! angry fool

      And then they will survive! Everything will settle down, everything will work out! And THESE are all the same, they will still be crutched!
  46. 0
    November 10, 2012
    This is also Makarevich.
    DOESN'T HOPE HOPE TO ME
    There is no hope for me
    That will flicker, then somewhere will disappear.
    And in the mysterious country
    Nothing will ever change.
    And it’s even easy from that,
    After you miss the pile
    The referendum was held at a beer,
    Memorial services will be held under vodka.
    And there’s no need to look for reasons -
    They just love sheep herd.
    Well, the fact that they are being cut in a herd,
    So after all it is not all, so after all it is less and less.
    And the road goes in a circle
    They do not need a lot of sheep.
    Throw food into the pen
    That's all the problems of lamb.
    To solve the problems of lamb,
    There is a vote.
    Everything on the cards, everything is legal
    Everything, of course, inside the pen.
    Why are the rams out
    There, after all, a mind is not needed.
    It’s hot in the nights of fear
    There is a shepherd and his shepherd.
    Shepherds without much hassle
    Over the rams put experience.
    Without asking about their wishes,
    They put the experience of survival.
    Barbecue evenings
    Loudly clatter their tongues.
    Surprised by a herd with steeps -
    Oh, tenacious! Well, tenacious!
    1. Karish
      0
      November 10, 2012
      Quote: Cynic
      Surprised by a herd with steeps -
      Oh, tenacious! Well, tenacious!

      What's wrong ?
  47. prunx
    +1
    November 10, 2012
    Quote: Cynic
    After returning from another tour of the country, the rock musician was shocked by the scale of corruption in Russia and spoke about it. Today MK publishes his new open letter, this time addressed to the citizens of Russia.

    I don’t understand something, was he engaged in concert activities on tours or did he study the corruption component? Then let him present the circumstances and results of this study. Guys, this is nonsense. Yes, in fact Andryukha smoked on tour.
    1. +3
      November 10, 2012
      Quote: prunx
      I don’t understand something, was he engaged in concert activities on tours or did he study the corruption component?

      And what to understand then?
      He conducted a study of the corruption component in concert activity!
      И
      was shocked by the scale of corruption

      One thing, when somewhere, somewhere, someone unfastens it, but when their own, vital!
      Seriously, it’s essentially black humor, and practically everyone starts cutting the truth of the uterus when oblivion is on the horizon. bully
  48. +3
    November 10, 2012
    OPEN LETTER TO CITIZENS OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

    A voice in the desert, because now we, as a people, have no single goal. Each for the homeland in words, but each for himself in practice. And here it’s not up to sentiment, few people will refuse that it lies badly or can easily stick to their hands. And on these hands can be given only from above. However, the tops are not up to it, their hands are sticky.
  49. 0
    November 10, 2012
    Quote: Taratut
    If I really wanted to end corruption, I could really do something for this. I’m not talking about executions according to the Chinese example, but about the real everyday struggle.

    Dmitry, are you married? If you’re married, you’ll understand that any marriage is a compromise, but why did you decide that the position of husband is harder than the position of president?
  50. +3
    November 10, 2012
    Makar was blown away, backtracked, but sorry ...
    At first there was a treatment of claims to Himself, now - with a claim to the people.
    In our country, unfortunately, everything and everything is built to please One.
    Well, perhaps, blind people do not see this.
    “And if you really think that this will be the case, maybe try it now, under Putin? He didn’t give instructions to cops to rob us, to officials to steal, to deputies to play the fool.

    No instructions, just keep silent and self-deny.
  51. IGR
    IGR
    +1
    November 10, 2012
    Read Podgorodetsky's "Machine" with Jews.
  52. +4
    November 10, 2012
    Why, this asshole didn’t write any letters under EBN, although the whole people were groaning and dying out. And he hung out with the rest of the gang and made money. Now he suddenly saw the light and finally saw corruption and bad mussars and corrupt officials, and most importantly in time, just when everyone listed above began to be taken by the udder. By order or what? Andrukha? I personally don’t listen to this bastard’s songs on principle, ever since he promoted the hunchback in London on his anniversary.
  53. sapulid
    +1
    November 10, 2012
    Damn, just like the “Special Report” on RTR :))) Grunt in the “arc” with the authorities, and at the same time “piat.”
    I stopped respecting him after his participation in the PR campaigns of Alkota and Brokeback.
    What's next? "White bows" and "State grant for the democratization of Russia"?
  54. georg737577
    +2
    November 11, 2012
    What a joy! Makarevich suddenly learned that corruption was rampant in the country (for this he had to go on a tour, beyond the roundabout...) and was so amazed by this that he shared the news with Putin. And he heard something like that, in connection with some businessmen... You need to be closer to the people, gentlemen! And then suddenly the people themselves will come closer....
  55. bobik05
    +1
    November 11, 2012
    The fish has its tail between its legs?!..
  56. wax
    +1
    November 11, 2012
    Pops needs to start with himself - first, pay taxes on all types of income.
  57. Ash
    Ash
    0
    November 11, 2012
    Bought musician.
  58. Fox
    0
    November 11, 2012
    after all, Makarevich is a mess... it’s still the same... so, I decided to promote myself...
  59. 0
    November 11, 2012
    "Let's imagine the impossible: we turn on the TV tomorrow" - and there they tell us that Serdyukov was imprisoned in a pre-trial detention center for theft!
  60. +1
    November 11, 2012
    How many forum members responded to Makarevich’s letter; there is a lot of interesting and instructive content in this letter. I would agree with this if it were not for the personality of the author himself. I stopped respecting him after his vile attacks against the Soviet government, which nursed him and educated him. This shifter doesn't deserve respect.
  61. zemlyak
    +1
    November 11, 2012
    Yes, this is pure PR, Makar in Prokhorov’s party, and this letter is the votes of voters, votes in support of Prokhorov. This letter expresses ordinary human principles (don’t kill, don’t steal, etc.) they are simply expressed publicly, the letter should cause controversy in society, draw attention to your person and the party. .Ordinary PR. And you are a Jew, not a Jew, he’s a goat, a provocateur, that’s who he is. Where was he five, ten years ago? I scuba dived and drank vodka in my ear on Channel One. The PR guy sucks
  62. aleksey
    0
    November 11, 2012
    Yes, this “letter to the people” is about nothing.. I opened everyone’s eyes, my dear. It would be better if the composer wrote a new hit! Andrey, take care of your professional business, it will work out better
    He’s now in Prokhorov’s party, if he started working off by shitting everything in a row, then that’s stupid..
  63. Gorchakov
    0
    November 11, 2012
    I personally didn’t emphasize anything new from the old circus clown Gorbachev.... At least I could come up with a new reprise.... The eternally crying Jewish clown.....
  64. +1
    November 11, 2012
    Makarevich is just a man, the goals of his social activity are not clear to me. I understand the purpose for which all sorts of abominations happening in our society are constantly being discussed and negative emotions about Russia are constantly being whipped up. I propose to discuss the amers with their “ideally democratic voting” or “absolutely democratic Lithuania with a contempt from America.”
    Why aren’t we discussing trillions of dollars to put out the so-called crisis provoked by the “advanced Fed” or billions of dollars for prodigies like the F-22(35).
    It can easily be destroyed in a few months, but it takes decades to rebuild. I'm watching "Strike Force" - a series of documentaries about Soviet weapons. And constantly in the middle of each film I come across phrases like “if it weren’t for the collapse of the USSR, the Ulyanovsk TAVKR would have been completed,” or “if it weren’t for the collapse of the USSR, the Orlan series would have been completed, etc.”
    How can we supply the An-124(225) to the troops if there are no factories in Russia for such production? How to start building aircraft carriers if the only dry dock for ships with a displacement of more than 50 thousand tons remains on the “orange outskirts”. The production of Il-76 was revived. we can build frigates, there is developments in composite armor, it is quite possible to restore the BZHRK. This is only what is needed in the defense industry, but what about the production of agricultural machinery, the production of machine tools and conveyor lines. And no one thinks that all this production was in the USSR, and then “privatized” and stolen or exported in the 1990s. What took decades to build has been destroyed over the years. And it will take decades to restore all this again.
    1. pavlo
      0
      November 12, 2012
      And for the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, and about Fakushima, who will hold the answer? Otherwise, it’s quietly hidden. Where are you human rights activists, and Greenpeace people, awww?
  65. 0
    November 11, 2012
    “The level of corruption indicates the degree of decomposition of society. In turn, the decomposition of society actually means nothing more than the individual moral decay of many individuals who are naturally an organic part of it, in fact, who grew up in it and from it.”
    Animals live according to laws that prohibit them from weakening the pack. If the leader has the right of primacy to prey, then he gets it for everyone, but at the same time, his bestial conscience will never allow his kids to go hungry. In addition, he always takes the main blows to protect his family. Corrupt officials are more like jackals and hyenas.
    The experiments of the famous neurophysiologist, academician P.V. Simonov convincingly show that altruism is inherent even in rats: if a rat has the opportunity to eat the treat given to it by pressing a pedal, but at the same time cause pain to another rat, then in 66% of cases it will not do this.
    HERE IN RUSSIA: The main corrupt officials in Russia are ordinary people and doctors. What can the expanding fight against corruption lead to? The authorities, joyfully agreeing with the opposition’s cries about “swindlers and thieves,” will actively seize the living – motorists, doctors, teachers, employees of emergency departments, etc. Moreover, for the service-punitive class the loss will be small. “Women give birth to new ones.”
    True, in the last week something has broken through - high-profile cases of theft have appeared in various sectors of the economy. What is it for? Has the highest power come to its senses? I would like to hope.....
  66. Alex 241
    +3
    November 11, 2012
    How long will people who earn money from us pretend to be the conscience of the nation? I would like to ask, what have you done for the country? Concerts on Red Square? And all of this has gone from you! Spinal law, etc. Include the zombie box except Pugacheva, Galkin and no one lives in your entire camarilla in the country. In Rus', a man was always a plowman or a warrior. And who are you? Relish and a lot of other crap. I would sit and not blather, It would be better if I helped an orphanage, or donated money to a child for an operation. And with your letters you know what they are doing.
    1. +1
      November 12, 2012
      Good evening, Sash! Let me quote from your comment today: “Contemporary art has been replaced by Jewish life: on November 10, the Jewish Museum and Tolerance Center will open in the Bakhmetyevsky Garage building.” Andrey Vadimovich is a typical representative...

      "And in idle joy and in bitter misfortune
      May each of you be true to yourself
      Wear masks, wear masks,
      Only under a mask
      You can be yourself!"

      Separately, I would like to note that I respect the hero of the article, as a musician and performer of the early times!
      1. Alex 241
        0
        November 12, 2012
        Hello Sasha, you just continued my thought, apparently another concert is coming soon, and we need to lick the “electorate”.
        1. 0
          November 12, 2012
          One word Jew! The funny thing is that I don’t really want to condemn him. He built his entire life and the entire “Machine” on his mentality. And he created a lot of beautiful songs, zhuchara, don’t you agree? And probably all because... But then the era with which he fought passed away, and Andrei, as a true native (by virtue of genes and upbringing) of the Promised Land, found himself in the right place at the right time! Those who know how to adapt in a changing world survive! I won’t quote his own poems... By the way, they sounded in the 90s too.
          1. Alex 241
            +1
            November 12, 2012
            Sasha, let’s not tie it to nationality. There are people everywhere, and you know who. I’m a Pole on my father’s side, a Cossack on my mother’s side, and what will you call me? And how will you react? The devil you wrote about is a Jew............
    2. pavlo
      0
      November 12, 2012
      Well done, well said.
      1. +1
        November 12, 2012
        I think it’s unlikely that he will get involved in politics. It’s just that songs are selling worse now! So the search for alternative sources of income is underway. Or maybe he just got old? But I think for sure the approach to the problem is still national (I don’t want to offend anyone.)
        1. MG42
          +2
          November 12, 2012
          Quote: studentmati
          I think it’s unlikely that he will get involved in politics. It’s just that songs are selling worse now! So we are looking for alternative sources of income

          Speaking of alternative sources of income Yes Dinner is served!

          1. +1
            November 12, 2012
            The strong-willed survive! First of all!
            1. Alex 241
              0
              November 12, 2012
              Here's Sash, where does the spirit come from? I'll send you a video now,
              1. Alex 241
                +1
                November 12, 2012
                listen carefully, here’s where each letter is relevant to the topic, and how it’s written about us...................and not here’s a new twist...........
                1. +1
                  November 12, 2012
                  Looked! Thanks Sash, video of our time! I am sure that for the youth of the 90s it looks like a movie about the “three musketeers”. There was a terrible break in the patriotic education of soldiers. And today we need to start from COMPLETE scratch. For many people no longer know who Gagarin is, or that America won the war of 1941-1945. And these are not allegories, I heard this myself from children.
                  1. Alex 241
                    0
                    November 12, 2012
                    San agrees, in pursuit of the ruble and not always a long one, but just to survive, we devote less time to children, but I swear our Russian children know who broke the back of the Nazis, and who Gagarin is.......Next May 9 I invite you to work with me, we’ve been working with veterans for 5 years on this day, and I don’t regret it one bit..... this feeling cannot be expressed in words.
                    1. Alex 241
                      +1
                      November 12, 2012
                      our favorite film. interesting Makarevich knows that there is such a film?
                      1. Alex 241
                        +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        .......................................
                      2. +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        I watched it three times. Overall, I liked the clip! I hope that there is already a new generation that understands, respects and appreciates the feat of their grandfathers and great-grandfathers. Otherwise, it’s similar to how the Russians defeated, for example, the Poles. Ask today's youth when was this? (For example). I will be glad if I am wrong in my assumption.
                      3. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        Sanya, I'm Polish on my father's side laughing
                      4. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        This movie is why I ran away from kindergarten.
                      5. +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        And I San live in “two songs”, in the language of “furshchikov” from modern Poland. My father was born on territory that, according to a well-known treaty, at one time became part of the USSR and Germany. I still want my relationship, but I can’t establish it. The FSB doesn't "know". Ha ha ha... If you dig deeper, then here are the Swedes and Lithuania? I experienced the disaster of April 10, 2010 as a personal tragedy. In human terms, first of all! And in terms of fraternity, although controversial. And in terms of aviation. Complete SHOCK!!! No matter how they try to present this catastrophe as intentional, I will never agree. Everything happened almost before my eyes. And if not in front of me, then in front of my fellow students, with whom we slept side by side in the dorm!
                      6. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        Sash, well, this is our fate, to be children of many nations, but to swear allegiance to one, as for 2010, there is a human factor. Although I do not have all the information, and this is my personal opinion.
                      7. 0
                        November 12, 2012
                        I was brought up in the spirit of atheism, but when I saw the scene of the disaster (the nearby buildings and the highway were no more than 50 meters away), I doubted that anything had happened at all? Well, there are fragments of the glider (the takeoff is nearby, which doesn’t happen). And television and the press are trumpeting... On the same day, Patriarch Kirill commented on what happened: “By the will of God we came to earth and by his will we will leave.” I’m not conveying it verbatim, but the meaning. In fact, you can’t tell or discuss everything here, but I’m constantly studying the topic and still, after 2 years, new facts emerge, but old ones are lost, for some reason?
                      8. Alex 241
                        +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        Sasha, I listened to the recording of the negotiations between the Yak42 crew and the Yaroslavl hockey players, 19-odd minutes, I was tense by one phrase between the 2nd pilot and the flight attendant: AND YOU TELL ME THIS ON THE LAST FLIGHT? Can you imagine that a pilot with the engines running could say this? Exactly. LAST,,,,,,,,
                      9. 0
                        November 12, 2012
                        And I studied this catastrophe inside and out! I don’t remember the phrase “in the last”, I’ll re-read it. If so, then this is definitely the prediction of the flight attendants! But in the case of Lokomotiv, unprofessionalism was clearly demonstrated, rather a loss or erosion of professionalism. It’s very sad to remember and talk about this. Phenobarbital was found in the blood of the co-pilot, who reflexively pressed the brake. If you're interested, I'll email you what I have.
                      10. +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        The movie is right! Makarevich knows that such a film exists, I’m sure! I read his books and articles. Andrey skillfully bends to the changing world!.. But why? Either for money or a far-sighted Jewish calculation?
                      11. Alex 241
                        +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        San and God bless him, there is Chertok, Tsandler, Kapitsa, I had an SUV teacher Zeldes, for me he is a RUSSIAN officer, I had the honor of knowing the officer who saw Korolev and Gagarin.
                      12. +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        That's it, Sash! The main thing is that what we got, rather earned it with sweat and blood, rather than bought it, is our education. And it is our Soviet education that helps us survive in the modern world!
                      13. Alex 241
                        +2
                        November 12, 2012
                        This is how we are Sash, for some we are scary, for others we belong.........
                      14. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        .................................................. ..
                      15. Alex 241
                        +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        .................................................
                      16. +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        I am sure, San, that we will complete the tasks assigned to us!, no matter what! And if necessary, we will show “army ingenuity” in full (in fact, a unique thing). We always remember that our Motherland is behind us!
                      17. Alex 241
                        +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        Sash, as Kovpak said: remember that there is nowhere to retreat.
                      18. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        Here Sash, I already posted it, maybe I didn’t see it.
                      19. +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        So the conclusion is that there is no time to relax! In the ranks, not in the ranks...
                      20. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        Build a holy place. soldier
                      21. +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        There is already such a place... And there is a fellow soldier who went into this profession in 1996. Although his name is Father Sergius, for us he is always Sanya. Which he is never offended by, but is always happy about our very, very rare meetings. Maybe they are alive and praying for us?
                      22. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        Sasha always has someone praying for us!!!!!!!!!!!! And you say you’re an atheist.
                      23. +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        Sash, I deleted about Loko, I managed to, sorry, I know what I’m talking about. And about atheism, I’ll say that Sanka “Father Sergius” and I are from the same office, and managed to serve together, and called and campaigned with us. And now he says - come at any time, but only with a passport. (Apparently there is control there too?)
                    2. +1
                      November 12, 2012
                      I accept the invitation, Sash, we’ll write to you closer to the day. And kids about national heroes (my opinion) are more likely to get information about the history of Russia from people like you and me. Maybe, of course, I’m exaggerating? But it’s better to be “over safe than under safe.” What I mean is that there is a systematic and purposeful erasure of heroes and events that are significant for Russia in textbooks and the Internet.
                      1. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        Sash, I believe that there is genetic memory, I have written about this more than once......and children need to be pushed in the right direction......and there are many positive examples.
                      2. 0
                        November 12, 2012
                        For example, in my city there are less than 20 veterans of the Great Patriotic War left, and those are no longer active. Namely, our task is to ensure the continuity of generations. Why ours? But because we were brought up on the examples of our grandfathers, and in the “dashing” 90s no one remembered such examples.
                      3. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        Sasha, first of all, is the task of the state, which these veterans SAVED!!!!!!!!!!!!!
                      4. 0
                        November 12, 2012
                        Salute to Moscow, it’s the dead of night, why aren’t we sleeping? belay
                      5. Alex 241
                        +1
                        November 12, 2012
                        Sasha yes we are all about our own......... request
                      6. 0
                        November 12, 2012
                        Yes, I just arrived, I’ll be having lunch soon. The box is silent or doesn’t want to answer.
                      7. Alex 241
                        0
                        November 12, 2012
                        I’ll email Sasha now.
  67. +2
    November 11, 2012
    I just want to ask Makarevich: what happened between the first and second letter?
    because things are really obvious. corruption has always been there. and it will always be until an ideal society is somehow built in which everyone, everyone, will be white and fluffy Eloi.
    What does Putin have to do with it anyway?
  68. WW3
    WW3
    +1
    November 12, 2012
    Carriage disputes are the last thing,
    When there's nothing left to drink
    But the train is moving, the bottle is empty,
    And he wants to talk.

    And the two did not agree on fear, but on conscience,
    The wheels drove away a dream:
    One said: “Our life is a train,”
    Another said: "Perron."

    One asserted: “Our path is clear,”
    Another objected: “No time for fat.”
    One said, they say, we are machinists,
    Another said: "Passengers!"

    One said: “Freedom is our reward,
    We are taking the train where it needs to go."
    Another said: “There is no need to wonder:
    As we sit in it, we will get off."

    And the first one shouted: “The road is open for us
    For many, many years."
    The second answered: “Not so much -
    It's all about the price of the ticket."

    And the first one shouted: “Wherever we want, we’ll go there,
    And we can, if necessary, turn it off,”
    The second answered that the train would pass
    Only where the path is paved.

    And both came down somewhere near Taganrog,
    Among the endless fields
    And each went his own way
    And the train went on its own.
  69. 0
    November 12, 2012
    This is how I see it from my life experience: The hand washes the hand.
    Those. The essence of corruption is that those who take bribes go up the career ladder, and those who give these bribes move them up.
  70. pavlo
    0
    November 12, 2012
    And for me, it’s not for Makrevich to talk about this and cry - it’s also the voice of the people! An ordinary buffoon - he’s just KYu! Probably he is slowly paving the way to power.
  71. Vanek
    +1
    November 12, 2012
    How to defeat corruption? Elementary - DO NOT GIVE!!!

    Do not give for what, they (police, ambulance, officials, etc.) ALREADY, and once again - ALREADY receive wages.

    Even the president himself responded (I didn’t expect it) - he advised that the next letter should be addressed to Russian businessmen so that they themselves would not provoke officials into bribes.

    Don't give or even hint. It's really simple. I spent three years decorating the dacha. Why so long? There’s no number there, there’s something else here. It's all little things. They hinted in no uncertain terms: “We can speed it up.” I didn't give in. As a result, the entire event lasted for THREE years. BUT! As a result, I am the happy owner of a dacha plot of twelve acres. Since the officials didn’t have anything to do, excuse me, to...... get up to, they couldn’t just say: - No, we won’t sign! Everything is done as expected, with all the buds and commas.

    - No, we won’t sign!

    And, you ask, on what basis should they not sign? When is everything right?

    DON'T LET IT!!!!!
    1. nickname 1 and 2
      0
      November 12, 2012
      Vanek,

      Right! Very true!
      It’s like this for us: there’s a chance to become the owner of some kind of jackpot. We lose all restraint and are ready for anything. My nerves were shaking, my head was foggy.
      But if it’s so calm, I won’t give it to you. I'm not a giver.
  72. 0
    November 12, 2012
    Makarevich is a poet, Makarevich is a musician, Makarevich is a chef, Makarevich is a public figure and finally Makarevich is a politician and...
    1. -1
      November 12, 2012
      Makarevich is clearly meddling in the wrong place :) He would be better off writing an open letter to the great figures of Russian and Ukrainian show business... Otherwise, there is such heresy on the screens that everyone has long ago been disgusted by watching and listening, and almost no one has rude language in a song or on TV surprises...
      It’s easy to stand up and criticize the authorities - Makar successfully did this even under the Soviets... If he is so smart, it would be better if he proposed real ways to fight corruption and would lead some influential organization fighting it...
      As one famous character said - “Devastation is not in the toilets - destruction is in the heads”... And the task is precisely for people like Makarevich to heal these same destroyed heads, and he is doing God knows what...
  73. AAA
    AAA
    0
    November 12, 2012
    It would be better if he continued to sing good songs.
    1. enkor
      0
      November 12, 2012
      The repertoire has been exhausted. There is a desire to rule. Previously, cooks ran the state. Now we are moving to the next level.
  74. 0
    November 12, 2012
    In the comments “started for health, ended for peace” As always, the Jews are to blame for everything. What does nationality have to do with it?
    1. 0
      November 13, 2012
      Quote: d.gksueyjd
      What does nationality have to do with it?

      What does it really have to do with it?
      Judge them by their deeds

      It is by their deeds that we judge. Nothing personal .
  75. +2
    November 12, 2012
    Makarevich, hello! Cut your curls and go write good songs and never get involved in politics. What did you do in the nineties, Putin now has to disentangle your freedom, which you saw on tour. hi

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"