"Toad head" from all the vicissitudes of fate

88
"Toad head" from all the vicissitudes of fate
If you saw the movie "City of Masters" (1965) in your distant childhood, then you may remember that such a helmet is shown in it, however, it is worn by an infantryman, not a rider. Apparently, the film's costume designers found it somewhere and decided to use it as a purely knightly attribute!



I love the whitening row of tents,
There spears and helmets burn in the sun,

Bertrand de Born, The Song of the Minstrel, translated by A. A. Blok

History knightly weapons. Recently, we have somehow moved away from our knightly theme, but it is nowhere in history. weapons didn't leave. Moreover, we have not yet considered much in it, and today one of these gaps will be eliminated - we will tell VO readers about the so-called “toad head” helmets (frog-mouth helm in English) or stechhelm (stechhelm in German) - a very original type of helmet, characteristic of the XNUMXth - and the entire XNUMXth century.




"Toad helmet". Miniature from "The Romance of Tristan". 1410-1420 France. National Library of Austria, Vienna

And here is another very curious miniature from The Romance of Tristan. It very clearly shows how a knight in a “toad's head” helmet strikes with his spear under the visor of his opponent's bascinet helmet and hits the chain mail covering his throat. Obviously, this blow for the rider who received it will be fatal!


And here we see that the flat tops of the "toad's head" could also be decorated, and they even wore crowns! Miniature from "The Romance of Tristan". 1410-1420 France. National Library of Austria, Vienna

Moreover, this helmet, no matter what the miniaturists draw in their manuscripts, no one has ever used in real battles. And they used it exclusively as a tournament helmet for a spear tournament duel - geshteha. That is why he had such powerful protection for the neck and entire face. Traditionally, it was included in the tournament semi-armor kit, which was called shtekhtsoyg. This helmet was not mobile, but on the contrary, it was completely motionless attached to the cuirass in order to form a single whole with it.


Miniature of Jean Fouquet from the Book of Hours of Simon de Vary with a portrait of the client. 1455 Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles

The characteristic features of this helmet are as follows: first of all, the flat shape of its upper part and the wedge-shaped front part extended forward. Thanks to this, no matter where the tournament spear fell into this helmet, it always slipped off it. The back of the dome was rigidly connected (by forge welding or with rivets) to the dome of the helmet. It turned out that the protection of the face, neck and collarbones were combined into one. This achieved complete solidity of the protection of the upper body and the exceptional strength of the helmet itself, arranged so that inside the head of its owner would not touch the metal itself anywhere!


We continue to study the miniatures from the "Romance of Tristan". In this miniature, we see how the knights exchange blows directed at each other's helmets, but they cannot cause any harm!

Nevertheless, this helmet could be removed from the cuirass. To do this, he had a buckle at the back for fastening a cuirass to the back, and a latch at the front, which provided a rigid attachment of the helmet to the breastplate.


But on this miniature from the novel "Lancelot du Lac" (also "The Death of King Arthur"), 1400-1425. Paris, National Library of France, something strange is depicted - a foot duel with swords, and both combatants are depicted in helmets "toad's head", and even with additional holes for breathing. It seems that there are no such helmets in any of the museums ... And for some reason blood is literally gushing from under these helmets. How did you have to try so hard to get hurt like that in these helmets?


A black and white photograph from the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, showing a complete tournament armor from the collection of this museum, along with a toad head helmet and besagu round plates to protect the armpits

The balaclava had a rather complex design and was designed in such a way that it was tied to the helmet from the inside, but its ties were tied on the outside. And it was thick enough to protect the wearer's head from injury in the event of a direct blow to the helmet with a spear.


Tournament armor with a "toad helmet" from the collection of the Dresden Armory. Author's photo


Balaclavas and "toad helmet" from the collection of the Dresden Armory. Author's photo


A knight, dressed in the same armor, and on a horse to participate in the so-called "tournament of the world", that is, completely safe for both man and his horse! Metropolitan Museum, New York

Due to the fact that the “toad helmet” did not fit too tightly around the head and neck of its owner, unlike other combat helmets, there was enough room for air inside, so it was not too hard to breathe in it, and it was removed from the head through top.


Toad head helmet, ca. 1500. Most likely made in Nuremberg. Weight 8097 Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York


The same helmet. Side view with balaclava straps

One continuous viewing slot was very high, not at eye level, but “on the forehead”, so that again during a spear duel, when the rider leans forward, he had a good view - but as soon as he straightened up at the moment of impact, no spear could might have fallen into that gap. It simply met a solid wall of steel in front of it, along which its tip slid. Thus, getting into the viewing slot was completely excluded, and there were no other holes (except for the holes for the balaclava strings) on it.


Toad head helmet, 1475-1500 Weight 8769 Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York


Knight of the middle of the XIV century, dressed in tournament armor. Illustration from Viollet-le-Duc's book. The helmet of the grand helm type is shown very well - a transitional form from the combat topfhelm of the XNUMXth century. to a purely tournament helmet "toad head"

That is, this helmet, in fact, was an absolute protection for a participant in an equestrian tournament. However, this was achieved at a rather expensive price: due to the fact that the thickness of the walls of this helmet was 3 mm or more, its weight could reach up to 10 kg.


And this is how the head of a knight in a balaclava was placed inside the “toad head” helmet. Drawing from the collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York

The origin of the "toad head" helmet can be clearly seen when comparing it with the topfhelm helmet. Rather, with its later variety "sugar loaf", which by the beginning of the XNUMXth century had already fallen into disuse as a combat one, but continued to be used in tournaments. This happened both due to the inertia of thinking, and due to the established tournament tradition that came back from the XNUMXth century.


Miniature from the manuscript "History of the Trojan War", 1441 Germany, German National Library, Berlin

Such helmets with a high crown were convenient to decorate. A voluminous helmet with helmet decorations was clearly visible from afar and made the figure of the rider himself ... more monumental. However, the protective properties of this helmet were also good, and in terms of protection, "sugar loaves" even surpassed bascinets.


Cuirass and armor helmet stehtsoyg, 1494 (with later replacements and additions). Made by Lorenz Helmschmid (Augsburg, c. 1445–1516). It was part of an armor ordered by Maximilian I (Holy Roman Emperor from 1508 to 1519) from two famous gunsmiths, the brothers Lorenz and Jörg Helmschmid. The armor was used in tournaments held in Innsbruck, Austria, in honor of Maximilian's marriage on March 16, 1494 to Bianca Maria Sforza (1472–1510). Quite popular in the German-speaking territories, the gestech was a form of duel in which two opponents on horseback used blunted spears to dislodge each other from the saddle or strike at the tarch (small shield) covering the chest and left shoulder. The armor used for the geshtech included a helmet firmly fixed on the chest and back, as well as two hooks - supports for the spear in front and behind, so that the rider could hold the spear in weight. It is believed that these parts were made in 1494. The total weight is 19,94 kg. Philadelphia Museum of Art, Philadelphia


In addition to the hook in front, this armor also had a hook in the back ...

That is why, even in the XNUMXth century, topfhelm was still used in tournaments, and they were especially popular in England. And, of course, all gunsmiths sought to improve their protective properties, since now the need to have a good view of the helmet for hand-to-hand combat no longer existed. After all, tournaments began to be divided into horse and foot fights, and the armor for them was also special. Now no one in armor for a foot combat entered into an equestrian battle, just as a horseman in armor for equestrian combat did not participate in a foot battle. The unity of combat and tournament armor is now in the distant past!


And again, a very instructive miniature from the "Romance of Tristan" - a knight in a "sugar loaf" helmet strikes with a spear directly into the viewing slot of his opponent's sallet helmet

The helmet began to be assembled from metal plates, gradually stretching it in height and forward, and the viewing slots, taking into account the rider's landing in the tournament saddle, were raised higher and higher. Over time, the "sugar loaf" completely lost its qualities of a helmet for hand-to-hand combat, lost its pointed crown - and that's how it turned into a "toad head". That is, a helmet that has become an extremely popular element of tournament equipment for geshtech, for which in the first half of the XNUMXth century even a special set of tournament armor was created, called shtekhtsoyg.


Another miniature with a knight in a toad head helmet. Manuscript "Tristan and Isolde", 1447-1449. France. Royal Library of Belgium, Brussels

Moreover, this helmet existed until the very disappearance of tournament fights, it was so comfortable and functional. That is why many of these helmets have survived to this day and are exhibited in various museums in both Europe and America. Stehhelm also gained great popularity as a heraldic helmet, indicating that its owner belonged to the nobility, that is, in the past - to the knightly class.
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

88 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +11
    15 January 2023 04: 48
    And for some reason, blood is literally gushing from under these helmets. It's like you had to try so hard to get hurt in these helmets
    ?
    I was a kid smile I decided to check the bucket on my head and, for fun, my friends strummed the bucket with a stick from the heart ... then my ears rang and squeaked all day.
    And in a knightly duel, they hit the helmet with a heavy sword ... the effect on the ears will be much higher, blood may come from the ears and nose.
    "City of Masters" is my favorite Soviet film... smile
    1. +24
      15 January 2023 07: 41
      I decided to check the bucket on my head and, for fun, my friends strummed the bucket with a stick from the heart ... then my ears rang and squeaked all day.
      So it was necessary to sew a pod out of a sweatshirt! Approximately as in the photo of the author
      Balaclavas and "toad helmet" from the collection of the Dresden Armory.
      1. +14
        15 January 2023 14: 25
        In the morning I "ran" through the comments, and now I began to re-read it more carefully and - I found it! Found the same - "podvedernik"!
        Dear colleague "not the one", you are still the one!
        I was incredibly happy with the podvedernik, thank you very much! drinks hi ))))
        1. +11
          16 January 2023 07: 01
          Yes to health, dear Lyudmila Yakovlevna!
    2. +10
      15 January 2023 15: 24
      Quote: Lech from Android.
      And in a knightly duel they hit the helmet with a heavy sword ... the effect on the ears will be much higher


      It is enough for the gunsmiths to attach a shock absorber spring to the vault or shoulder pad of a toad helmet and the situation with shell shock will be greatly facilitated. The helmet rests on the shoulders and the springs have been known since the Stone Age, in fact.
      1. +10
        15 January 2023 17: 55
        Quote: ycuce234-san
        toad helmet

        By the way, where did this term come from?
        frog-mouth is still a "frog mouth", where are the toads? It is logical, the frog is usually smooth, and the toad is more bumpy.
  2. +13
    15 January 2023 06: 17
    Thank you, Vyacheslav Olegovich!

    A memorable and popular helmet. Another celebration of gunsmiths.
    1. +15
      15 January 2023 07: 42
      Thank you, Vyacheslav Olegovich!
      Join us!
      1. +17
        15 January 2023 08: 52
        Good morning everyone, thanks to Vyacheslav, in some “century” I am not at work and can join the discussion!
        For me personally, the toad head has always been associated with Japanese high-speed trains, or rather the opposite.
        1. +21
          15 January 2023 09: 38
          Hmm ... By the way, why exactly "toads" ... That helmets, that this steam locomotive, I personally have associations with other representatives of the fauna
          Well, it's more suitable, you see...
          1. +12
            15 January 2023 09: 48
            Likewise. We didn't talk.
            And there were also glorious illustrations for the book "Little Baba Yaga". There, at the masquerade, the duck's beak went to the fox.
        2. +11
          15 January 2023 09: 47
          The first association when looking at a photo of a train is a duck's beak.
        3. +1
          16 January 2023 09: 57
          I personally have always associated a toad head with Japanese high-speed trains.

          More like a sturgeon's nose.
  3. +15
    15 January 2023 07: 10
    Thank you! I remember as a child wandering around in the arms museum of the city of Dresden. By the way, the Germans have similar collections with weapons in every museum .... I still remember swords for opening a person and similar devices on this topic. Particularly struck by children's armor for accustoming youths ...
    1. +14
      15 January 2023 07: 14
      Quote: lithium17
      Particularly struck by children's armor for accustoming youths ...

      I have many photos of them. Will have to write...
      1. +13
        15 January 2023 08: 56
        Quote: kalibr
        Quote: lithium17
        Particularly struck by children's armor for accustoming youths ...

        I have many photos of them. Will have to write...

        I saw children's armor only once in the Hermitage. True, I forgot whose they were and for whom they were forged. It comes to mind that something is for Peter II or Paul.
        1. +10
          15 January 2023 11: 54
          True, I forgot whose they were and for whom they were forged.
          Hello, Vlad!
          Don't stress, everyone has forgotten. The children's armor from the Hermitage collection is not personalized, at least not on the display plate.
        2. +8
          15 January 2023 14: 36
          I saw children's armor only once in the Hermitage.


          "Your place is poor, but clean, -
          said, leaving the Hermitage. "(c)

          Such a gloomy day.
          1. +6
            15 January 2023 15: 00
            But it's warm. Half of the calendar winter ends.
            1. +3
              15 January 2023 18: 21
              As a rule, it is cold in the Hermitage in winter.
              1. +3
                15 January 2023 20: 52
                You won't get cold from this cold. And attention is not dulled.
      2. +10
        15 January 2023 12: 56
        Good afternoon, Vyacheslav! smile
        Thanks for making me happy again. good
        And they used it exclusively as a tournament helmet for a spear tournament duel - geshteha.

        In our department, it was under this name that it passed - "Tournament Armor". There were several different but very similar helmets, and I was always struck by the thickness of the metal on their front.
  4. +20
    15 January 2023 08: 33
    ... and the "toad" has one undocumented advantage!!

    1. +8
      15 January 2023 13: 09
      This is understandable, but how did they deal with the other? laughing

      1. +5
        15 January 2023 13: 38
        You know, uncle, sometimes your pictures are boring. Better think about how WWI soldiers defecated.
        1. +6
          15 January 2023 15: 06
          You know, uncle, sometimes your pictures are boring.

          Thanks, darling. smile
          Better think about how WWI soldiers defecated.

          You are somehow on your own, but you may not share your thoughts.
          1. +3
            15 January 2023 18: 55
            Thanks, darling.
            Suddenly, uncle! You yourself have chosen such a nephew.))))
            1. +3
              15 January 2023 20: 53
              Come on, they don't choose friends, they just met on the crooked roads of the site and somehow got along. smile
        2. +10
          15 January 2023 15: 15
          Quote: 3x3zsave
          how did WWI soldiers defecate

          1. +3
            15 January 2023 16: 58
            Hello Ivan! smile

            Without Josef Lada's illustrations, the book would have lost half of its charm.



            By the way, we, in 1963, filmed the film "Big Road", a film about WWI and about Hasek.

            Yakovlev also played there, in the photo he offers Gashchek, who has been captured, to drink.
  5. +18
    15 January 2023 09: 19
    foot duel with swords, and both combatants are depicted in helmets "toad's head" ... And for some reason blood is literally gushing from under these helmets.

    I would venture to suggest that the miniature depicts the final part of the equestrian battle - broken spears are visible in the background, and spurs are on the legs of the combatants. Before starting to peck each other with swords, the knights seem to have put each other properly with spears, after which they fell from their horses, got up and continued their communication. And the horses ran away from sin. After such adventures, the blood could come from anywhere. smile
    But seriously, I was also surprised by the presence of helmets of this type on knights in battle, while modern researchers almost unanimously call the "toad head" a purely tournament gadget.
    Possible explanations for this contradiction:
    1. Tournaments are depicted on miniatures, not real fights.
    2. The miniaturist saw only tournaments and only imagined a real fight based on them.
    3. The miniaturist followed certain canons that prescribed to depict knights in this way.
    It is reluctant to describe all the pros and cons of these versions in one person. I propose to discuss. smile
    1. +11
      15 January 2023 09: 53
      The first question I would ask is - what are these characters from Lancelot of the Lake?

      For some reason, the cycle of "King Arthur" does not cling strongly.

      One Round Table like it.
      1. +11
        15 January 2023 11: 27
        Quote from Korsar4
        what are these characters from Lancelot of the Lake?

        You need to read Thomas Malory. Just the end of the XNUMXth century.
        But I liked the Arthurian cycle as a child. But for some reason I never imagined the knights of the Round Table in plate armor - only in chain mail and Norman helmets, although I didn’t know what they were called then. But for some reason, in all the movies that I happened to watch based on Arthurian, the knights are dressed in plate armor.
        That's why I don't like movies about King Arthur. smile
        1. +7
          15 January 2023 11: 48
          Movie watched. True, in a foreign language. The creation of a hole on the ice into which the adversaries fall through is another interpretation of the Battle on the Ice.

          Didn't like either "King Arthur" or "Gladiator". And I didn’t watch Troy and Spartans.
        2. +10
          15 January 2023 15: 23
          Quote: Trilobite Master
          But for some reason, in all the movies that I happened to watch based on Arthurian, the knights are dressed in plate armor.

          In the 2004 film, Arthur is a Roman and his knights are Federated Sarmatians. One might say, according to Demusil.
          1. +6
            15 January 2023 16: 00
            I already have a strong aversion to the cinematic Arthurian. As if someone cursed this topic - I also didn’t have a chance to see a single sensible scenario.
            In short, not mine. smile
            1. +8
              15 January 2023 16: 01
              Well, yes, about like modern series on the theme of the Second World War ...
              1. +2
                15 January 2023 17: 05
                God forbid, I don't even go to the TV wassat
              2. +3
                15 January 2023 18: 26
                If you expand to WWII, good series happen.
            2. +8
              15 January 2023 16: 24
              Quote: Trilobite Master
              I already have a strong aversion to the cinematic Arthurian. As if someone cursed this topic - I also didn’t have a chance to see a single sensible scenario.
              In short, not mine. smile

              Of the Arthurian books, perhaps the best is Gentle Hills.
              Although not bad in the trilogy of the same name, King Arthur put forward his version of Bernard Cornwall.
              I advise you to look through both works.
              1. +3
                15 January 2023 21: 41
                Vladislav, does Gentle Hills have an author? Can we reverse the trend?
      2. +7
        15 January 2023 13: 45
        Hello, Sergey! smile

        There was also our film "The New Adventures of a Yankee in King Arthur's Court" in 1988. A very richly costumed tape, I don’t know how much the armor corresponded to the real ones, but everything looked very beautiful.




        So there the main character dealt with the knights by means of a machine gun.
        1. +7
          15 January 2023 14: 54
          Hi Constantine!

          I didn't even finish reading Mark Twain.

          And from the hits in the past, the Polish film "Princess Anna's Ring" is recalled.
          1. +5
            15 January 2023 17: 02
            The Poles had a film about getting into the future called "Sex Mission" laughing
            (in our box office "New Amazons")
            1. +2
              15 January 2023 20: 54
              It was a phenomenon for classmates. Widely discussed.
              1. +3
                15 January 2023 21: 51
                Yes, the boys had something to discuss there! wink laughing

                1. +2
                  15 January 2023 22: 09
                  How is the research going?
                  - Good. The thesis that men are the missing link in evolution between us and apes has been proven.
    2. +12
      15 January 2023 09: 57
      Almost all miniatures have a mixture of tournament and combat elements.
      Most likely point two.
      Point one is missing. In no case is there a separating barrier practically obligatory for joust of peace, aka shtehen, aka gestech (gestech) (there were experiments with tournaments under Maximilian, but they were later than the time of writing the miniatures in the article.)
      The article lacks an explanation of joust of peace and joust of war (rennen- gestech). But this is generally a separate article.
      Well, there were universal armors that turned into tournament ones by means of a special set. They were in the 16th century. Whether there were such in the 15th century, I don’t remember.
      1. +7
        15 January 2023 11: 47
        Not for the sake of holivar, but for the truth. smile
        Quote: Engineer
        Point one is missing. In no case is there a separating barrier that is practically mandatory for joust of peace, aka shtehen

        Was the toad's head used in horse buhurts? Considering that buhurts could start with a spear collision, I think it’s quite. And the image is quite drawn to the buhurt, this can theoretically be indicated by the background on which the fighters are depicted - it can be interpreted as a fence of the stadium.
        1. +9
          15 January 2023 11: 57
          Under Maximilian, yes, it was used. As for the beginning or middle of the 15th century in France, I don’t know.
          But hardly anyone will use the "toad" in a foot race. Rather, he will change into more suitable clothes before a foot fight.
          In the figures in the article there is not a single equestrian buhurt. Guess why.
          It is necessary to analyze each image with reference to the episode of the work that it illustrates. Otherwise it's pointless.
          .
          1. +7
            15 January 2023 13: 39
            Quote: Engineer
            It is necessary to analyze each image with reference to the episode of the work that it illustrates. Otherwise it's pointless.

            I agree with this. But too lazy to search. smile
            Quote: Engineer
            In the figures in the article there is not a single equestrian buhurt.

            The weapon is sharp. Buhurts on tournament weapons were carried out, at least in the days of toad heads. Okay, convinced. smile Or did you mean something else?
            As for the foot duel, here, it seems to me, the hypothesis of a judicial duel between two equestrian fighters who fell from their horses and continued the fight on foot explains everything.
      2. +7
        15 January 2023 12: 36
        Quote: Engineer
        The article lacks an explanation of joust of peace and joust of war (rennen- gestech). But this is generally for a separate article.

        I had a detailed series about tournaments here. With every imaginable detail! But a long time ago, really. But you can type in a search engine "Tournaments. VO, Shpakovsky V". and there will be a revelation to all.
    3. +7
      15 January 2023 11: 04
      Quote: Trilobite Master
      1. Tournaments are depicted on miniatures, not real fights.
      2. The miniaturist saw only tournaments and only imagined a real fight based on them.
      3. The miniaturist followed certain canons that prescribed to depict knights in this way.

      All this could have happened overnight!
    4. +16
      15 January 2023 11: 45
      Shalom, Orthodox!
      I propose a fourth option. This is an ordeal, a duel.
      1. +7
        15 January 2023 13: 42
        To that miniature, where the knights fight on foot, such an explanation, in my opinion, is quite suitable. There are judges in crowns, and broken spears. But the presence of toad heads on knights in a group equestrian battle is more difficult to explain.
  6. +10
    15 January 2023 10: 40
    That is, this helmet, in fact, was an absolute protection for a participant in an equestrian tournament.

    As experience shows, absolute protection does not exist.

    In 1559, King Henry II of France was fatally injured in a tournament. The spear pierced the helmet.
    1. +10
      15 January 2023 10: 45
      It doesn’t happen, but in fairness, they write not about breaking through, but about fragments of a spear and / or about a helmet visor.
      having landed directly in the visor, which rose from the blow

      Francois de Vieville
      That is, it was hardly a "toad's head".
      1. +13
        15 January 2023 11: 23
        Or we can talk about a banal non-compliance with the instructions for using a technical product. A helmet, that is. Let's invite an visiting jury to our meeting and listen to a few more witnesses. Well, not just Francois de Vieville in all sources to read:
        Many sources indicate that the king's visor was not closed enough. Claude Aton, a French friar present at the tournament, wrote: "The visor of his [the king's] helm or morion was lowered well below his eyes, to see more clearly and comfortably." Jean de Serres, a sixteenth-century historian, also reported that "the king's taker (...) was not closed properly." Donaldson, Librarian Emeritus of the Royal College of Physicians, Edinburgh, also described the king's impatience, writing that, according to Gaspard de Saux-Tavan: "King Henry II was so impatient that he did not wait until the visor of his helmet was closed properly"
        The visor either did not completely close, or completely open galloped towards Montgomery.
        "Observe safety regulations."®
        1. +8
          15 January 2023 11: 35
          This goes without saying.
          The problem is in the visor. All discrepancies - either it rose from the blow and a fragment of the spear entered the eye, or a fragment entered the eye because the visor was opened more than usual.
          This all, by the way, speaks for a "closed helmet". His smaller visor is usually fixed with a hook on the bottom and a pin on top. Perhaps the gunsmith, on the orders of the king, improvised and conjured with the clamps to provide a greater view without ensuring the necessary reliability of their installation. Or he removed one of the latches (or the king did not wait for the second one to be installed) or something else like that.
          1. +6
            15 January 2023 12: 55
            Quote: Engineer
            The problem is in the visor. All discrepancies - either it rose from the blow and a fragment of the spear entered the eye, or a fragment entered the eye because the visor was opened more than usual.

            There, like a sliver, it also got into the right eye, which is somewhat strange, apparently the visor was quite open.
    2. +8
      15 January 2023 10: 58
      Quote from Passeur
      there is no absolute protection.
      In 1559, King Henry II of France was fatally injured in a tournament.

      So he (at least in miniature) seems to be in a "bascinet" ...
      1. +10
        15 January 2023 11: 03
        On the miniature, most likely close helmet - "closed helmet", sometimes considered a subspecies of arme. He took two. Most likely it was he who was on the king on the fateful day.
    3. +10
      15 January 2023 11: 06
      Quote from Passeur
      The spear pierced the helmet.

      It didn't break through! A splinter from the spear flew off and hit the viewing hole and the king in the eye. He was not killed, but the state of the art at the time led to suppuration and meningitis, from which he died.
      1. +13
        15 January 2023 11: 53
        The death of King Henry was the result of an interhemispheric left-sided subdural empyema superinfecting a post-traumatic interhemispheric subdural hematoma. The primary infection developed in the right orbit, probably due to a wooden foreign body left in situ, and spread into the cranial cavity as a result of infectious thrombophlebitis of the facial veins. This new diagnosis contradicts previous versions. The first version was that the king died from a severe head injury. Some authors have proposed the diagnosis of epidural hematoma, given the observations of Ambroise Pare, who could explain the slow death by the classic lucid gap. The available information contradicts the presence of a severe traumatic brain injury: the king did not lose consciousness, and the description of the autopsy of the brain does not correspond to an epidural hematoma. The 11-day interval was not associated with any intracranial hypertensive crisis. Others have written about the counter-blow, always quoting Pare, which cannot be confirmed by the mechanism of the injury. Most authors have discussed the infectious cause of death. The term "abscess" appeared repeatedly, with Miguel Faria even offering a differential diagnosis. Augustin Cabanet, drawing on the writings of Meseret, a controversial historian born in 1610, spoke of post-traumatic meningoencephalitis, but without details.

        Marc Zanello, Philippe Charlier, Robert Corns, Bertrand Devaux, Patrick Berche, Johan Pallud. (2014).
        Translated by Burchevsky S.A.
        1. +10
          15 January 2023 12: 38
          considering the observations of Ambroise
          With all my great respect for the founder of military field surgery, Pare would not have understood even a tenth of the garbage that his followers piled up. At the very least, Pare did not know Latin.
      2. +9
        15 January 2023 12: 38
        It didn't break through!

        Of course it didn't. Yes, and the helmet there was somewhat different. But what a discussion!
        1. +9
          15 January 2023 12: 41
          But what a discussion!

          As usual on the topvar, hamster-illiterate? laughing
          1. +9
            15 January 2023 12: 50
            Yes, no one seems to be yelling about Russoarians leading to enlightened socialism.
            1. +7
              15 January 2023 13: 16
              Yeah no one seems to be yelling


              Yscho didn’t wake up, they’ll sort out the “politics” and soon they’ll be knocked out. wassat
        2. +7
          15 January 2023 12: 44
          Discussion about something else. However, I think that in that case the helmet was different.
  7. +7
    15 January 2023 12: 42
    Gorgeous illustrations! Thank you !
    It is instructive that times are changing, technological progress is moving forward, and the means of full protection, as they were heavy and fettering, have remained so, even heavier than they have become.
    It is understandable - defense is secondary, the first number will always be an attack.
    1. +7
      15 January 2023 13: 20
      technological progress is moving forward


      Yes, and for any means of protection, an inquisitive mind always always finds a means to successfully open it. wink

      1. +7
        15 January 2023 14: 57
        - Be smart. Ancient people managed without can openers.

        They didn't even eat canned food.
        1. +3
          15 January 2023 18: 34
          They didn't even eat canned food.


          They ate each other, it's easier and the meat does not have time to spoil. Yes

          But why did the Aborigines ate Cook?
          For what - it is not clear, science is silent.
          It seems to me a very simple thing:
          They wanted to eat - and they ate Cook!
          Read completely


        2. +3
          16 January 2023 01: 06
          The heroes of the dialogue also did not try canned food. Although, in my opinion, an attempt with a belt buckle could be successful if the edge of the buckle was sharpened on a stone.
  8. +7
    15 January 2023 13: 32
    Just some miracles!
    Some of the pictures won't load. Some of them appear, then disappear.
    Okay, that's not the point...

    "But on this miniature from the novel "Lancelot du Lac" (also "The Death of King Arthur"), 1400-1425 Paris, National Library of France, something strange is depicted - a foot duel with swords, and both combatants are depicted in helmets "toad head", and even with additional holes for breathing. It seems that none of the museums have such helmets ... And for some reason blood is literally gushing from under these helmets. How hard it was to try so hard to get hurt in these helmets ?"

    Why is it strange? The holes in the helmets are quite large, and broken spears are scattered around. Looks like they got each other through these holes. And when the spears were all broken, they switched to swords. At least that's how it seems to me.
    1. +6
      15 January 2023 16: 06
      It's written that way. Out of curiosity...
      1. +3
        15 January 2023 18: 27
        It's written that way. Out of curiosity...

        Aha! ...
        Not for fun, but only for wassat )))
        Everyone immediately tensed up and in various ways began to reconstruct the custom of a bygone era, reasonable explanations rained down ...
        And she almost said: "The people of future times will be surprised, trying to rationally explain our behavior!"
        But I am silent. For it is inexplicable to ourselves.
    2. +7
      15 January 2023 17: 06
      something strange is depicted - a foot duel with swords, and both combatants are depicted in helmets "toad's head", and even with additional holes for breathing. It seems that none of the museums have such helmets ...

      In fact, there is nothing strange in this image, since in the figure Lancelot (left) and Gawain (right) are not wearing frog-mouth helms, but Tournament Bascinet or great bascinet helmets. Such helmets were used for foot combat, opponents were armed with axes , spears, swords and daggers. This helmet is in the collection of the Metropolitan Museum.

      It’s just that the author, with all his desire, cannot cover all the knowledge in the field of medieval armor. It's quite normal.
  9. +3
    15 January 2023 18: 14
    And one more thing.
    "Miniature of Jean Fouquet from the Book of Hours of Simon de Vary" with a portrait of the customer. 1455 "
    Behind Simone de Vary is a kneeling woman. With his right hand he holds a large vessel with heraldic images, with his left he lifts the lid, from under which blood flows, flooding the surface of the vessel and falling on the floor. It's some kind of allegory. I tried to find an answer to what it all means, but I couldn't find it.
    Everyone just talks about the "toad head".
    And further.
    Simon de Vari was born in Bourges into a wealthy textile merchant family. Despite this, his only achievement was a modest career as an official of the crown under Charles VII and Louis XI of France. And in one of the articles his motto flashed, they say, I live as I want.
    And it's all.
    So what kind of allegory is shown in miniature? Apparently, it was quite understandable to the then reader.

    And... my God! What kind of illiterate texts gives the search engine. Either an interlinear, or so they write now.
    1. +5
      15 January 2023 18: 41
      What kind of illiterate texts gives the search engine.


      And on many forums, in the comments, it’s better or something, “as I hear, so I write.” wassat I don’t consider myself a great literate person, but at least we were taught something at school. request

      Good evening, Luda. love
      1. +4
        15 January 2023 19: 44
        Good evening, Kostya! )))
        The point is not that sometimes commas are skipped in comments or incorrect cases - a person edited, changed his text, was in a hurry, but there was no time to check everything again. The point is in a monstrously clumsy presentation of not only thoughts, but facts in articles on some sites. After all, it is not the user who writes - the author! If you already started a site and posted an article on your own behalf - check it from and to! Consider every sentence!
        But... Speaking of writers. I have come across the opinion that without editorial processing, reader spitting would fly into the texts of many great ones)))
    2. +4
      15 January 2023 20: 15
      You need to look at two pages at once.

      Simon de Vary kneels in prayer to the Mother of God. She appears in the miniature on the next page, seated on a throne with the baby Jesus.
      In the background, the maid is holding not a vessel, but a shield with the coat of arms of his family.
      Family coat of arms in more detail.
    3. +4
      15 January 2023 22: 22
      So what kind of allegory is shown in miniature? Apparently, it was quite understandable to the then reader.

      It turns out that the question of such a strange type of shield was also of interest to historians from the J. Paul Getty Museum. It turned out that in the XNUMXth century the miniature was "redrawn" by painting over the coat of arms of Simon de Varie and drawing the coat of arms of Bourbon-Condé, moreover, not very neatly.
      Initially, the shield with the coat of arms looked like this.
  10. +4
    15 January 2023 21: 48
    As always, a wonderful article from Vyacheslav. Thanks a lot!!!
  11. +1
    16 January 2023 12: 48
    no one thought that the helmet ... was not intended for a human head? On a cynocephalus (pseglavets), he would have been just right in shape.

    Yes, and weight ... 10 kg on the head, 30-50 kg - armor on the body, 5-7 kg of "body kit" on the arms and legs. Plus a shield and a spear ... Well, this is almost a centner! Something very, very doubtful that a 50-60 kg person of those centuries could briskly fight with double the weight on himself. Either the "heroes-not-we" lived there, or ... it's a lie. In modern FANTASTIC books (not to mention films) there are also beautiful pictures. I won't be surprised if in 500-600 years they will also be perceived by historians as "documents", just like our feature films.
    1. +1
      16 January 2023 19: 20
      Quote: Bayun
      Yes, and weight ... 10 kg on the head, 30-50 kg - armor on the body, 5-7 kg of "body kit" on the arms and legs. Plus a shield and a spear ... Well, this is almost a centner! Something very, very doubtful that 50-60 kg

      Here is a good description of the tournament armor with a "toad head", maybe it is not quite complete, but 60kg will not even come up there.
      https://andrewbek-1974.livejournal.com/1918868.html
  12. 0
    21 January 2023 20: 48
    I was not particularly fond of the Middle Ages, but here I read it with pleasure.
    Thank! Very informative hi

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"