Military Review

The military correspondent named the important problems of the RF Armed Forces that emerged during the special operation

92
The military correspondent named the important problems of the RF Armed Forces that emerged during the special operation

The Russian military participating in the special military operation demonstrate miracles of courage and a high level of military skill. But the special military operation also revealed a number of shortcomings and shortcomings in our armed forces. War correspondent Alexander Sladkov wrote about them in another publication on his Telegram channel.


One of the first and most important problems is poor communication. The military began to pay attention to this problem at the very beginning of the special military operation. The military correspondent writes that the poor quality of communication is especially noticeable on the front line. The troops do not have easy-to-operate radio stations. This, in turn, sometimes leads to tragic consequences, and also makes it very difficult to interact during assault or defensive operations, retargeting artillery and aviation.

The second important problem is the lack of vehicles on the front line. Here, writes Sladkov, we are also losing. Meanwhile, military correspondents do not stop emphasizing the need to provide the warring units with motor transport. In the Telegram channel Reporter Rudenko, for example, they wrote about the need for cars like cash-in-transit vehicles.

The third problem is no longer in the logistical support series. The military commissar notes the weak level of training and low morale of some of the mobilized servicemen. In addition, there are often "nightmare" examples of non-compliance by military personnel with instructions and regulations, failure to comply with orders. Discipline in many divisions is also "lame"

Much depends on the commander. Where he is experienced and demanding, things go. The level of battalion commander-brigade commander is decisive. Their mistakes lead to sad results.

- emphasizes military commander Sladkov.

However, now there is a successful work on the existing errors. They are gradually being corrected, although many problems remain to be solved. And they need to be solved by joint efforts - not only by the army, but also by government agencies, industry, business, and society as a whole.
92 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. The comment was deleted.
    1. The popuas
      The popuas 5 January 2023 16: 34
      +23
      Pravdorubov in Russia never liked hi and sycophants, yes ...
      1. nik-mazur
        nik-mazur 5 January 2023 16: 43
        +8
        Quote: Popuas
        Pravdorubov in Russia never liked
        If we already generalize, then the attitude towards truth-tellers and sycophants is very different and depends on many factors. But who in Russia has never been loved is the ̶p̶i̶z̶... whistleblowers who whistle artistically and are not responsible for anything.
        However, this is so not only in Russia ...
        1. The popuas
          The popuas 5 January 2023 17: 11
          +19
          Then they are chosen for 30 years in the elections wink...
          1. nik-mazur
            nik-mazur 5 January 2023 18: 11
            +2
            Quote: Popuas
            Then they are chosen for 30 years in the elections
            Do you understand the difference between "love" and "choose"?
            By the way, they are chosen absolutely everywhere and always, starting from the moment the ancient Greeks came up with democracy. This property of any election, by definition, is practically...
            1. Krasnoyarsk
              Krasnoyarsk 6 January 2023 13: 29
              -1
              Quote from: nik-mazur

              By the way, they are chosen absolutely everywhere and always, starting from the moment the ancient Greeks came up with democracy. This property of any election, by definition, is practically...

              Are you suggesting a return to autocracy? Or learn to choose with your brains, not with your heart and ears.
        2. filibuster
          filibuster 5 January 2023 17: 13
          +8
          that's who in Russia has never been loved, so it's ̶p̶i̶z̶ ... whistleblowers who whistle artistically and are not responsible for anything.


          Come on, only these have been chosen for the last 30 years.
          1. lis-ik
            lis-ik 5 January 2023 17: 30
            +29
            Sladkov did not name the main problem. She is in those who successfully burned through and sold the Soviet legacy, simultaneously blaming the USSR, those who, as usual, decided with the help of show-offs and agreements. As always, slip on the ball, but nothing came of it. Those who rattled about unparalleled weapons and Europe disappearing without Russian gas, but they managed, about trading for rubles according to muddy schemes, about the missing billions. That's the main problem here.
            1. filibuster
              filibuster 5 January 2023 18: 15
              +10
              Well, this is our main "string" The tsar is good, the boyars are bad, it's just that now the bad boyars are mobilized, their motivation is bad.
            2. yuriy1863
              yuriy1863 5 January 2023 18: 41
              +14
              The most interesting thing is that almost all these nine years of hostilities in the Donbass, half-hints were spoken about military advisers-commanders from the Russian Armed Forces. It was transparently hinted that the first successful actions of the LDNR militia in 2015 were carried out under the leadership of officers of the General Staff. Then questions:
              1. Who, when and how collected, summarized and analyzed the long-term experience of the database in Ukraine?
              2. If such experience was taken into account, how did it affect the improvement of combat training and logistics of the RF Armed Forces?
              3. Why, then, this experience was not taken into account when planning the NWO?
              4. A separate question about higher educational institutions, whose real estate has been actively "demilitarized" all this time, and the training of cadre officers dressed in "office" uniforms and brought up in the spirit of "managers".
              In the LDNR, during this time they perfectly learned what was needed, with what performance characteristics and in what quantity for the corresponding combat unit.
              Therefore, Sladkov, who, as far as I know, has a military education and experience in personnel service, with his article portrays himself as simply a naive college girl.
              1. Postcode
                Postcode 9 January 2023 12: 00
                0
                All experience was analyzed. The situation is that our main successes (Debaltsevo boilers, etc.) date back to 2014 and 15 years. Then there were positional battles, without the initiative of the parties in the tactical part almost everywhere, there was no talk of operational. That part of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, which. stupidly sat in the trenches, went on rotation to the training grounds, where NATO specialists began to work with them. Everything they were taught there, everything they provided, on the front line in the LPR and DPR, it was not necessary to "sit" in the trenches against each other, conducting periodic artillery shelling of each other, waging a sniper war, no special tactical frills are needed. Therefore. those art historians in civilian clothes who arrived in the ATO zone (at that time) did not particularly train their military leadership gift. When planning the NMD, it was not necessary to take into account the experience of this confrontation, there was a team to approach Kyiv on the 5th day, moreover, there was no storming his team, no one planned this. Those who ordered it all. for some reason, they considered that by the 5th day the army would capitulate, being demoralized and moreover. will go over to the side of the Russian Federation (remember the speech of the Supreme High Command) ..... there was a huge political miscalculation, which now the military has to deal with. Everyone in Chechnya knew that there was no normal communication. then in Georgia. It is not the fault of the military that they were not given this connection, the soldier / general fights with what his homeland gave him, sometimes he is lucky to get trophies, but not everyone lives up to this.
        3. private person
          private person 6 January 2023 15: 11
          -1
          But who in Russia has never been loved is the ̶p̶i̶z̶... whistleblowers who whistle artistically and are not responsible for anything.

          So we have the entire State Duma of the Russian Federation, they talk a lot and are not responsible for anything. And while it is considered that they were chosen by you and me.
      2. fa2998
        fa2998 9 January 2023 21: 18
        0
        Quote: Popuas
        Pravdorubov in Russia never liked hi and sycophants, yes ...

        Well, what is "truthful" Sladkov said! Bad connection. This is a consequence. And the reason is, apparently, theft. Show-off! As soon as the hostilities began, it turned out that there was no ammunition (neighbors and volunteers are buying), they are buying Chinese walkie-talkies, UAVs, first-aid kits. Old Soviet equipment - infantry fighting vehicles, armored personnel carriers, T-62 is going into battle. hi
    2. Nikolaevich I
      Nikolaevich I 5 January 2023 16: 39
      +5
      Quote: zloybond
      Therefore, the general, offended by the truth, demoted the Donbass officer to sergeant ???

      Comrade "man and ship"! That is Krusenstern! What is this story? what
    3. fruc
      fruc 5 January 2023 16: 40
      +6
      One of the first and most important problems is poor communication.

      This problem, as it was all my life in the army, has remained. Apparently nothing has changed. Saying: -No connections, at least ...... hit! remained relevant. We have to rely on the old proven method of communication on the battlefield - "obscene flag".
      1. begemot20091
        begemot20091 5 January 2023 16: 46
        +5
        who ..... in the rain and in the mud?
        -Our valiant connection!
        1. Diana Ilyina
          Diana Ilyina 5 January 2023 17: 58
          +2
          I think there is a sequel.
          If there is no rain and mud, then ... the head of communications.
      2. Arkady007
        Arkady007 5 January 2023 20: 33
        +10
        From the history of the connection.
        Head of communications of the front, Major General A.T. Grigoriev was arrested and shot on July 22, 1941.
        1. Andy_nsk
          Andy_nsk 6 January 2023 10: 59
          +1
          Head of communications of the front, Major General A.T. Grigoriev was arrested and shot on July 22, 1941.

          well, if you touched on this topic, you should open it.
          On systemic shortcomings in the organization of communications of the Red Army in 1940 A.T. Grigoriev reported in a letter to the chief of communications of the Red Army, Major General of the communications troops N. I. Gapich, but nothing significant was done to correct this situation

          Well, not only Comrade Grigoriev was shot, but all the leadership of the OZVO, headed by D.G. Pavlov. Russian tradition: punishing the innocent, rewarding the uninvolved!
          1. Krasnoyarsk
            Krasnoyarsk 6 January 2023 13: 39
            +4
            Quote from Andy_nsk

            Well, not only Comrade Grigoriev was shot, but all the leadership of the OZVO, headed by D.G. Pavlov. Russian tradition: punishing the innocent, rewarding the uninvolved!

            Is this Pavlov innocent? Is a military leader who voluntarily or involuntarily lost control of the troops entrusted to him innocent? Wake up, daddy.
            1. Andy_nsk
              Andy_nsk 7 January 2023 13: 01
              +2
              Is this Pavlov innocent? Is a military leader who voluntarily or involuntarily lost control of the troops entrusted to him innocent? Wake up, daddy.

              Yes, I actually wrote about Grigoriev, and yes, everyone else just fell under the brush. Arranged shooters. Then it was necessary to start executions from the General Staff, they predicted the main blow in the south-western direction, the main tank forces were concentrated there. Why was no one punished for losing the largest tank battle (almost "dry") near Dubno-Brody? And they punished the leadership of the ZOVO, which received the main blow from Germany. It is not surprising that it was there that the Germans had the greatest success at the beginning of the war, I do not think that if someone else had been in Pavlov's place, the result would have been very different. Well, the fact that they were nevertheless posthumously rehabilitated is not an argument?
    4. Luka Nord
      Luka Nord 5 January 2023 16: 42
      -4
      Quote: zloybond
      Therefore, the general, offended by the truth, demoted the Donbass officer to sergeant ???

      You need to follow orders or pretend that you are following them when they suffer losses and try to save the fighters .. And then follow the order all the same, but more tactically .. Okay, I'm talking nonsense hi
    5. Sasha Koblov
      Sasha Koblov 5 January 2023 20: 37
      +2
      Complained for telling the truth? If for this the general is ill.
    6. YOUR
      YOUR 6 January 2023 04: 35
      +10
      The surname of the general, the surname of the victim in the studio. Otherwise, your comment is nothing more than a lie.
      So for those who are not in the know, there is such a document called the Disciplinary Charter, it lists all types of rewards and punishments. One of the punishments is a reduction in military rank by one step. There are restrictions that an officer will never be demoted to sergeant or private. The last military rank for him will be junior lieutenant, if he was a lieutenant before. The demotion didn’t just come and tore off the shoulder straps, which, by the way, is prohibited by law, see “On the Status of Military Personnel”, not a movie, however, life, a bunch of documents need to be drawn up and there is still a gradation of who and whom can be demoted. Up to and including the division commander, they do not have the right to demote an officer ON ONE step. They can only write a report to the higher command to which they can attach a list of violations committed by this officer. Each must be confirmed.

      You either didn’t serve and you don’t know the charter either Svidomo
      1. 28st region
        28st region 6 January 2023 04: 46
        +1
        Yes, he will answer you. He will pretend that he did not read and put a minus.
    7. svp67
      svp67 6 January 2023 04: 57
      0
      Quote: zloybond
      Therefore, the general, offended by the truth, demoted the Donbass officer to sergeant ???

      For what truth? Who reprimanded whom?
      1. 28st region
        28st region 6 January 2023 09: 47
        +1
        Yes, no one demoted anyone, so he wrote from the bulldozer.
  2. Luka Nord
    Luka Nord 5 January 2023 16: 38
    +1
    Much depends on the commander. Where he is experienced and demanding, things go. The level of battalion commander-brigade commander is decisive. Their mistakes lead to sad results.

    Everything is so sometimes .. But such is the war! We learn to fight and every day we get better and better.
    I remember this back in the Second World War, the comfrey calmly told and showed the young "commanders" what and how to do How to survive and how to take the height with fewer losses .. And how to get rid of the screaming at the headquarters when they demanded frontal attacks, etc. hi
  3. AC130 Gunship
    AC130 Gunship 5 January 2023 16: 38
    +22
    And what new did this Sladkov reveal? Even Lenin wrote 105 years ago: mail, telegraph, telephone. No means of communication - no communications
    1. Vladimir_2U
      Vladimir_2U 5 January 2023 16: 49
      +9
      The troops do not have easy-to-operate radio stations.

      Wow, "easy to operate"! Where did Sladkov hang out?! There is no closed connection as a class!
      1. alexmach
        alexmach 5 January 2023 18: 40
        +3
        They say there is a certain "Aqueduct" and in general it is not even bad in concept, there are nuances with bugs in the implementation (this is probably also a strange thesis about "easy to operate"). But its main problem is precisely that there are not enough of them in the right amount.
        1. Al manah
          Al manah 5 January 2023 22: 00
          +2
          Take a look at Avito - it is littered with aqueducts ...
        2. Vladimir_2U
          Vladimir_2U 6 January 2023 07: 17
          +1
          Quote: alexmach
          They say there is a certain "Aqueduct" and, in general, it is not even bad as planned, there are nuances with bugs in the implementation

          Specialists say that even what is there are grassroots stations, there are no repeaters or nodal stations. Accordingly, communication with artillery, for example, directly from scouts is IMPOSSIBLE.
          1. stankow
            stankow 6 January 2023 11: 54
            0
            If you mean the connection between the spotters and the OP artillery, then it is not needed. KP can not be bypassed, so do not shoot.
        3. Moore
          Moore 6 January 2023 08: 08
          +1
          There is a KTS R-392 "Peanut". In SPN they are quite satisfied.
          1. Vladimir_2U
            Vladimir_2U 6 January 2023 11: 25
            0
            The characteristics are worthy, the question is saturation with a complex of troops.
  4. Kronos
    Kronos 5 January 2023 16: 43
    +12
    Where are they resolved? Since April, they have been telling how they are being solved and nothing has changed.
  5. StarWarrior
    StarWarrior 5 January 2023 16: 45
    -14
    1) for the development and speedy mass production of the most modern, cryptographically protected means of communication, to throw all the design bureaus of all the leading state corporations of the Russian Federation - Rostec, Roskosmos and others.

    2) load KAMAZ, GAZ, VAZ with a state order for 6 × 6 armored cars and not cash-in-transit, but with armor that can withstand NLAW exactly.

    3) each mobilized - a pocket brochure of the Charter of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. During a sudden night check, he must recite the chapter of the Charter by heart.
    URGENTLY replace the worthless Chapter 33 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation of 1996 (Articles 331 - 352.1) with Chapter 12 of the Criminal Code of the RSFSR of 1960 (Articles 237 - 269) and strictly apply them regardless of rank.
    1. fruc
      fruc 5 January 2023 16: 49
      +6
      ... often there are "nightmare" examples of non-compliance by military personnel with instructions and regulations, failure to comply with orders.

      Also introduce field guard watches and gauntlets.
      1. StarWarrior
        StarWarrior 5 January 2023 16: 51
        0
        Yes sir! Great idea.
        And decimation.
        1. Petr_Koldunov
          Petr_Koldunov 5 January 2023 18: 34
          +2
          Quote from StarWarrior
          And decimation.

          Great idea. A vivid example of collective responsibility, in which the innocent are drawn. Ever since my military service, I remember how it was used. No, not decimation of course .... laughing laughing but all the same, the principle "one flew in - the whole platoon swings" - also, whatever one may say, but the responsibility is collective. And it worked!
    2. topol717
      topol717 5 January 2023 17: 03
      +7
      Quote from StarWarrior
      1) for the development and speedy mass production of the most modern, cryptographically protected means of communication, throw all the design bureaus of all the leading state corporations of the Russian Federation

      Yes, we have already developed 1000 pieces of all sorts of different ones. But they are not needed at the parade, so no one wants to buy them and will not. The generals cannot understand at all why an ordinary walkie-talkie needs a walkie-talkie, because he must report to the sergeant, he to the ensign and further down the chain, as it is written directly in the Charter. And as you understand, the ensign is next to the private, so there is no communication problem for them.
      Quote from StarWarrior
      2) load KAMAZ, GAZ, VAZ with a state order for 6 × 6 armored cars and not cash-in-transit, but with armor that can withstand NLAW exactly.

      They are already loaded, but the question is why exactly 6x6. Maybe MTLB is needed, or maybe just a collector's field. Or maybe a quad bike.
      Quote from StarWarrior
      3) each mobilized - a pocket brochure of the Charter of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation

      Maybe first bring this charter into the proper form, to the form of the war of the middle of the 21st century, and not the time of Peter the Great. So far, this charter is precisely of Petrine times, when they fought in formation and ranks, but not ONE military man understands this.
      1. stankow
        stankow 6 January 2023 11: 57
        0
        Walkie-talkie to an ordinary? To speak with a sergeant who lies in the same trench with him? Or maybe a tablet to send e-mail? laughing
  6. The comment was deleted.
    1. Pulkovo1942
      Pulkovo1942 5 January 2023 16: 58
      +10
      It seems to me that citizen Sladkov has significant problems with conscience ......

      Sladkov has a video on his channel where he eats in a cafe and calls himself a Putinist. And the Putinists have one slogan: the boyars are bad - the king is good. In the place of the boyars, anyone can be, including the mobilized guys.
      1. sdtreew
        sdtreew 7 January 2023 14: 39
        +1
        Quote: Pulkovo1942
        And the Putinists have one slogan: the boyars are bad - the king is good.

        Russophobes have one slogan: the tsar is bad, the boyars are good.
    2. alexoff
      alexoff 5 January 2023 18: 04
      0
      The National Guard in Balakliya fired back for several days, because due to poor communication they forgot to tell them that forty thousand ukrovoyaks were advancing on Hummers with machine guns and they had to drape.
    3. alexmach
      alexmach 5 January 2023 18: 36
      +1
      It seems to me that citizen Sladkov has significant problems with conscience ......

      You are a nice person, you haven’t seen his recent post about Odessa and the demolition of the monument to Catherine. There, Grubnik from Odessa was bombed by this Sladkov.
  7. EFIM LYUBIN
    EFIM LYUBIN 5 January 2023 16: 48
    +14
    Why be surprised! A repetition of June-July 1941 And then and now the bulk of the commanding mass of the type of parade-parquet generals ... This is how much blood must be shed on the front line to throw these out of the army ... There are no censored words for their name!
    1. Kronos
      Kronos 5 January 2023 17: 04
      +3
      Then some of these generals died in battles, another part was removed or shot, and now the general will generally not go close to the front and will not punish anyone.
      1. shikin
        shikin 5 January 2023 19: 59
        +2
        Yes, already 8 generals died in the NWO (according to the wiki). And colonels, I think, definitely no less.
    2. alexoff
      alexoff 5 January 2023 18: 06
      0
      More like a Finnish war, only it would not be Stalin, but Nikolai 2, who would be at the head, and there would be only Bluchers in the army ...
  8. Pulkovo1942
    Pulkovo1942 5 January 2023 16: 52
    +6
    The military commissar notes the weak level of training and low morale of some of the mobilized servicemen.

    They weren’t sent head-on to storm the trenches) Adult men don’t understand why they should risk the future of their families for the sake of some kind of demilitarization.
    *here should be a picture of Pikachu with a surprised face*
  9. Former soldier
    Former soldier 5 January 2023 17: 02
    +5
    In addition, there are often "nightmare" examples of non-compliance by military personnel with instructions and regulations, failure to comply with orders. Discipline in many divisions is also "lame"

    In the trenches of authority. Apparently, new platoons / companies need to be formed around groups of already thoroughly fired experienced fighters, regardless of the stars and badges.
    1. stankow
      stankow 6 January 2023 12: 02
      0
      The authority he is on vacation. Zsli and in battle, instead of the commander - the khan of the unit.
      1. Former soldier
        Former soldier 6 January 2023 17: 59
        0
        Zsli and in battle, instead of the commander - the khan of the unit.

        Nobody prevents the commander from being authoritative both in battle and at rest.
  10. faterdom
    faterdom 5 January 2023 17: 10
    +16
    The mobilized are part of society. The other part feverishly continues to withdraw billions abroad, another part shits on TV, or portrays CROPS from Israel and the Baltic states. Another part - drapanula to Georgia and Kazakhstan.
    Of course, there should be discipline and order in the army, there is no question ..
    And in the state - no?
    And if you judge for something mobilized, then next to him, but it is better to judge before him the saboteurs of the branches of power, the deserters of V. Lars, the decomposers-Serebryakovs and Ahidzhakovs.
    Give an affectionate but weighty kick to Ernst.
    And much more is needed, but not done.
    And then purely elite-general thinking (in a bad sense): I can do everything, a soldier - nothing, because, and who is he here?
    1. antivirus
      antivirus 5 January 2023 18: 58
      +7
      I foolishly thought that the experience of 14-21 was taken into account.
      And the rake is flying and flying.
      And the horses keep neighing and neighing. And the generals all give the right orders.
      And then they report on their correct execution.
      Does Sladkov himself understand what he is talking about?
      The beginning of everything is a primary school teacher and a kindergarten teacher.
      "Faggot".
      25 years before the claims or admiration of those mobilized and the cadre army --- it is necessary to educate and give the necessary education in pedagogical schools.
      Then they will bring up in their own image and so on in a chain.
      Flight of the 90s
      And now it's not too late... and tomorrow... you have to change from a part-time job to a scholarship in a striptease to the essence of life
      1. aglet
        aglet 6 January 2023 11: 57
        +2
        "The beginning of everything is a primary school teacher and a kindergarten teacher."
        okay finally, your son should be raised for a salary by someone else's aunt! and you finally can’t be in business, you just point out, add a little patriotism there, a little courage there, and diligence there. and if it turned out, what happened - you scream: it's someone else's aunt to blame, it was she who raised my children. you must raise your children yourself, and by your own example, including
        1. Poplar
          Poplar 6 January 2023 19: 06
          0
          They must educate together: you are at home, the teacher is at school. But the most important thing is to teach the same. So that the child does not have a split: dad says one thing, the teacher says another. But now it is not. The school does not teach, but provides educational services.
  11. filibuster
    filibuster 5 January 2023 17: 16
    +14
    and low morale of some of the mobilized military personnel.

    Well, what to expect if people were driven into the army from under the stick, no one can clearly explain either the goals or plans, even against this background, events are taking place such as the strike of the Armed Forces of Ukraine on vocational schools in Makeevka, it would be strange to expect otherwise.
    1. aglet
      aglet 6 January 2023 12: 02
      -2
      "Well, what to expect if people were driven into the army from under the stick"
      nothing that these people took the oath? is there something "not sparing your blood and life itself"? or is it just words, like the president?
  12. Old Horseradish
    Old Horseradish 5 January 2023 17: 18
    +7
    The most important problem is the impossibility of asking those who are responsible for everything that happened and is happening. And this is the main reason and everything else is just a consequence.
  13. Anatoly Proskurin
    Anatoly Proskurin 5 January 2023 17: 24
    +11
    I don’t understand anyone: during the Second World War, in comparison with the Fritz, we didn’t have field VHF communications until the Americans began to supply radio stations. What parallelism now this problem arose when all taxis in every city 8 years ago had walkie-talkies?!!
    Did you talk about motivation? Well, yes, yes, what words to say to a mobilized person who must go under bullets and shells, lose his life and health, and Moscow WALKS in nightclubs, and the sons of officials and deputies in restaurants, and not in a trench !!! .... it's hard to come up with a literal word...
  14. Arkady007
    Arkady007 5 January 2023 17: 28
    +17
    The main problem of SVO is lies at all levels.
    Fake reports and reports on the basis of which grandiose plans are built. On the basis of which conclusions are drawn about the course of hostilities.
    Fake reports deep in the rear, that everything is fine and every day is getting better.
    Fake reports that life got better with the onset of SVO.
  15. RED_ICE
    RED_ICE 5 January 2023 17: 37
    +7
    "low moral character of some of the mobilized military personnel"
    The men were torn away from families, work, the usual way of life. And who else thinks that they want to fight and die? They wrote somewhere on the site that even among the regular military and contract soldiers there were many refuseniks. You can't force someone to do something they don't want to. And if he manages to force, then he will do it very badly.
  16. Carlos Hall
    Carlos Hall 5 January 2023 17: 42
    -3
    Of the problems you list, and without being there, I take it for granted that the indiscipline of the mobilized is the most serious. Under Stalin, this would not have happened, you yourself know what needs to be done. If the authorities are not respected, then turn it off and let's go,
  17. rocket757
    rocket757 5 January 2023 17: 49
    +3
    The military correspondent named the important problems of the RF Armed Forces that emerged during the special operation

    Much depends on the commander. Where he is experienced and demanding, things go. The level of battalion commander-brigade commander is decisive. Their mistakes lead to sad results.
    . The command staff must be trained in a new way, remove the incompetent and not wait until another tragic incident occurs through their fault !!!
    This is important, among other things.
  18. Stas157
    Stas157 5 January 2023 18: 14
    +3
    . low moral character of some of the mobilized

    This is when a pampered Muscovite, Sergei Zverev, for example, got to the front - the star is in shock!

  19. opuonmed
    opuonmed 5 January 2023 18: 23
    +1
    and ische reconnaissance and drones shock drones reconnaissance drones high-altitude drones, etc., etc.! almost a year has passed and along the way nothing has changed, well, if the soldiers are such a fig saint, what can I say about drones
    1. Andrey Karpov
      Andrey Karpov 6 January 2023 09: 29
      0
      taldychu wherever possible. how it got stuck with oil - in 1 month (!!!) they bought a whole FLEET of oil tankers and transferred them to our ports, and this is not a toy. Western media wrote about this in December.
      And in a YEAR, they couldn’t rivet a couple of tens of THOUSAND geraniums ??? What is this anyway? betrayal or stupidity?
      1. Two diplomas
        Two diplomas 6 January 2023 18: 03
        0
        And one small bridge could not be covered by air defense.
  20. 16112014nk
    16112014nk 5 January 2023 18: 31
    +11
    In Russia, the most important thing is missing - there is no ideology. It is possible to win a war without ideology, but at a very high cost. The victory will be pyrrhic. So far, there are no clear signs of improvement. Lots of words, but deeds...
    1. antivirus
      antivirus 5 January 2023 19: 07
      +2
      Forbidden words were spoken.
      Generations have matured and with a life expectancy they will command for another 20-50 years.
      And expand the east range, and border crossings.
      No one needs exchange trading within the country.
      Ms21 in the series when they promised the first rvz?
      Highway density.
      Salaries in villages and small towns.
      And so on and so forth.
    2. Ingvar 72
      Ingvar 72 5 January 2023 21: 50
      +2
      Quote: 16112014nk
      In Russia, the most important thing is missing - there is no ideology.

      This is the main problem. removed from the tongue. People don't know what they are fighting for. At least the bulk. Everything else is already being added.
      1. Two diplomas
        Two diplomas 6 January 2023 18: 05
        +2
        Well, some people still believe that for God, the king and the fatherland (I specifically write with a little one because in modern life all these concepts are perverted to the limit).
  21. Fangaro
    Fangaro 5 January 2023 18: 53
    +6
    I'll give a little of my opinion from the couch ...

    One of the first and most important problems is poor communication....
    The troops do not have easy-to-use radio stations ...

    Simple radio stations or simple radio stations protected from interception?
    Baofengs are easy to use and cheap. You can't protect yourself from eavesdropping. It is possible to protect from receiving information. Each radio station has a 2-character number. Each direction of movement of 2 characters. Each action of 2 characters. Change the decryption page once a day. Everyone hears everything, but only those who have this page understand.

    ...In the Reporter Rudenko Telegram channel, for example, they wrote about the need for cars like cash-in-transit machines...

    "Purses" protect against simple small arms. They are not designed to protect against military weapons with a caliber of more than 7,62. Paper money from shops and exchangers is not hunted by those who have DShK, RPG and other weapons that I may not have heard of.

    The military commissar notes the weak level of training and low morale of some of the mobilized military personnel ...

    Moral qualities depend on setting a goal.
    De .... and De .... - this is not the goal.
    Odessa should belong to Russia - the goal.
    The Artillery Academy of the Russian Army will be in Sumy - the goal.


    In addition, there are often "nightmare" examples of non-compliance by military personnel with instructions and regulations, failure to comply with orders. Discipline in many divisions is also "lame"

    There is only one thing I can say...
    Rogozin sent the fragment that struck him to listen to France in the Russian Federation, with a request to transfer it to the President of France.
    Was Rogozin allowed to do this? Or is his discipline an example, as it should, replicated by our own media?

    ...successful work on existing bugs is underway...
    ... And they need to be solved by joint efforts - not only the army, but also government agencies, industry, business, society as a whole ...

    State your goals!!!
    Not "let's all do our best together."
    And the goal! Or goals. Odessa is part of the Russian Federation. Rye bread (GOST 2004) at 24 rubles per kilogram. Pork carbonate at 287 rubles per kilogram. SU-34 at 27 million rubles per unit. The monetary allowance of a lieutenant without a position in a motorized rifle unit in peacetime is 104 thousand rubles.
    State your goals!

    Maybe after defining the goals, the influence of journalists on government structures, industry, business, society as a whole will change.
    1. Alexey Lantukh
      Alexey Lantukh 5 January 2023 20: 22
      +6
      However: Yes, there are no or few protected RSstations. And where is the military cellular communication, which was promised after South Ossetia, where our officers happened to lead units through the cellular communication of Georgia. Moreover, encryption is present in cellular communications. Really after such a shame did not do anything. There is no talk of wired telephone communication, which in some cases would be appropriate.
      Armored cars for delivery to the front line and evacuation? If the Chechens ordered it in advance, then what prevents others from doing it?
      Target? She doesn't speak up. The people and the troops do not need to know what they are striving for. And what are we fighting for then? And where does the discipline if the goal is not clear. If the Russian offensive does not follow in the winter, then it will be completely sad.
  22. Mikhail Kononov
    Mikhail Kononov 5 January 2023 19: 33
    +7
    All this was voiced even after the three-day war in Georgia. Something has changed? No. In general, they ruined everything that is possible and. which is impossible.
  23. Andron78
    Andron78 6 January 2023 00: 07
    -3
    But Sladkov is right somewhere. It is with pain in my heart that I read about the exploits of signalmen who, under enemy fire, change damaged antennas for kshm. Well, what a century in the yard that we are not able to provide troops on the line of contact with small-sized means of communication, and depth due to repeaters.
    I don’t quite agree about cars ... lightly armored vehicles may be needed, but the same Tigers can perform any function, the only question is their number.
    Discipline... that's the trouble, that is, that is, the most serious problem. I don’t know how to do this, but somehow we need to get rid of the term “mobilized”. And then, as if by this term, they were taken out of the brackets of a military organization, giving them the right to gouging. They are military personnel, with all the rights and duties.
    1. Eug
      Eug 6 January 2023 11: 49
      0
      I also think that repeaters will be very useful - both in terms of depth, and especially - the safety of UAV operators and signalmen.
    2. Andron78
      Andron78 7 January 2023 01: 47
      -1
      Minusors, write what you disagree with and what is wrong, it's more decent and informative than hiding behind impersonal sticks
  24. Wolf
    Wolf 6 January 2023 10: 10
    0
    The most important thing is to quickly correct the shortcomings. The Russian army did not fight for 75 years on such a scale. Afghanistan has shown shortcomings. All this is normal, in order for the army to start functioning NORMALLY it takes 1-3 YEARS. If it starts in 1 year, it’s very good, in 2 years it’s enough, in 3 years it’s bad, in 4 and beyond TREASON IN THE TOP OF THE STATE.
  25. Plover
    Plover 6 January 2023 10: 52
    -1
    Sladkov, although a correspondent, is still a military man. Now the real state of affairs has come out, that all non-military, but able to think and analyze a little, people understood all this. And he is a military (!!!) correspondent - where has he been all these years? Or does he become a war correspondent only during hostilities, and before that, no, no?
  26. Eug
    Eug 6 January 2023 11: 44
    +1
    For what decade already - communication, communication ... it seems that they have already reported on the introduction of a new super-duper communication system on the battlefield - and where is it? Or are they still primarily giving out obsolete products from warehouses?
  27. VladMirU
    VladMirU 6 January 2023 14: 16
    -1
    Quote: Andrey Karpov
    taldychu wherever possible. how it got stuck with oil - in 1 month (!!!) they bought a whole FLEET of oil tankers and transferred them to our ports, and this is not a toy. Western media wrote about this in December.
    And in a YEAR, they couldn’t rivet a couple of tens of THOUSAND geraniums ??? What is this anyway? betrayal or stupidity?

    Both......
  28. Two diplomas
    Two diplomas 6 January 2023 18: 01
    0
    There is only one problem and everyone knows his name.
  29. Photon
    Photon 6 January 2023 18: 12
    0
    Quote from: nik-mazur
    This property of any choice

    Well, not any. Theoretically, there may be quite fair and competent elections. But those in power (and those with money) prefer to take advantage of the incompetence and non-subjectivity of voters, and to be able to manipulate public consciousness.
    1. Sergej1972
      Sergej1972 7 January 2023 15: 10
      0
      What to do with the lack of education, intelligence, indifference of a very large part of the voters? And with the fact that in any election program some points are to your liking, while others are categorically unacceptable? And no program is completely satisfied? By the way, a new trend. And a rather large mass of voters has appeared in our country, whom promises to increase social spending, increase benefits and pensions do not attract, but repel from this or that political force.
  30. Fangaro
    Fangaro 6 January 2023 23: 01
    0
    The Russian military participating in the special military operation demonstrate miracles of courage and a high level of military skill. But the special military operation also revealed a number of shortcomings and shortcomings in our armed forces. War correspondent Alexander Sladkov wrote about them in another publication on his Telegram channel.

    Neither those who directly participated earlier and are currently participating, nor representatives of the RF Ministry of Defense, nor in the Presidential Administration of the Russian Federation, nor in the Ministry of Economic Development, nor in the analogue of the Soviet Minsredmash, nor those who are from the "moneybags" who decided to live here and continue to live, before this wonderful news and you wouldn’t know that there are communication problems, there is not enough transport, the preparation of replenishment depends on where the partially mobilized one got to, and the absence of geographical coordinates that mean the achievement of the goal of the NWO?
    How many the author of the news will open his eyes.
    /sarcasm/
    1. Sergej1972
      Sergej1972 7 January 2023 15: 15
      0
      Heir of Minsredmash Rosatom. What side is he to solving these problems?
  31. AlexWar
    AlexWar 7 January 2023 14: 21
    0
    Loss of communications, loss of command and control. I have already spoken about the fact that, unlike the Ukrainian army, ours does not know what and who and where is located. Apparently, orders were also given in the Kharkiv region when the units were already dumped, leaving the equipment behind.
    Why there are no communication systems, you probably need to ask a question to the signal troops until this direction is developed.
    You remember that in 2020, Mr. Mishustin cut the military budget and he didn’t care that the army didn’t have that. As I remember, this amount was cut by 30% He should also ask the question why the air defense troops are still sitting with the S-300?
    Mr. Serdyukov, why did he cut the military units and military universities. A man who did not understand the army was sent to manage it.
    Military correspondents clearly understand who is to blame, they just indirectly ask a question. Where is the connection?
    There is apparently a connection, but not enough. Apparently our fighters cannot request support where they need it.
    It turns out that we have means of destruction for the enemy, but we cannot request them.
    In American films, an infantryman can request both helicopters and missile strikes. The question is what can we do?
    The enemy has highmars and will hit the communications troops first.
    We surround Bakhmut and I immediately have a question: why can't we drop troops there?
    After all, before landing, we can bomb the territory with volumetric detonating bombs, everything will burn out there with the enemy.
    Assemble attack helicopters from behind and send troops behind them to land.
    There will be casualties, but how many prisoners will we take then?
  32. AlexWar
    AlexWar 7 January 2023 14: 43
    0
    Motorized rifle units, if they must go forward, then airborne assault units should be thrown behind enemy lines and cut off all their rear lines and communications.
    Literally a month of siege and any city will be taken
    If we cannot transfer troops across the city, then with the support of Iskanders and Toss, we can transfer troops behind enemy lines and create a strong point there.
    The helicopter flies well, why can't it automatically fire missiles in the direction of irradiation, in the direction of the weapon that has already been pointed at the helicopter?
    We, like, cannot defend ourselves against MANPADS, but MANPADS still need to be aimed, but if you shoot on the machine, then it’s seconds and the rocket will already fly in the place where they were aiming.
    The one who shoots him with MANPADS must be held for several seconds and he will not run away, but the rocket is already flying towards him.
    Or even not rockets can be made, but a heavy machine gun, which will stand on the machine and aim at the aiming point
  33. flyer
    flyer 9 January 2023 10: 53
    0
    There are many problems, the main thing is that their announcement should not become a cry of one crying in the wilderness, which often happens.