Eumenes of Cardia. Unusual and atypical diadoch of Alexander the Great

29
Eumenes of Cardia. Unusual and atypical diadoch of Alexander the Great

Earlier, we have already talked about the collapse of the empire of Alexander the Great and the division of this failed state between the conqueror's associates, who declared themselves his successors - the Diadochi. More details were given about the most successful of them - Ptolemy Soter and Seleucus Nicator. And today we will talk about the diadoche, the most unusual and clearly distinguished from the general series.

Atypical diadoch


Among the diadochis (successors) of Alexander the Great, Eumenes of Cardia draws special attention to himself.



First, he was a Greek, which greatly weakened his position. Other Diadochi were Macedonians, they knew each other from childhood, they were even considered friends - and this did not prevent them from sincerely hating their rivals. What can we say about some stranger who accidentally "wormed his way" into the ranks of Alexander's closest associates.

Secondly, Eumenes, along with Perdiccas, turned out to be a loyal supporter of the Macedonian Argead dynasty. Moreover, Eumenes is called one of the creators of the cult of Alexander the Great. In 319 BC. e. he, having taken the post of strategist of Asia and commander of the royal army, became the founder of the so-called "empty throne ceremony": he erected a tent with a golden throne, next to which lay the royal regalia and the coat of arms of Alexander. In front of the throne was also placed a golden table with a brazier and a censer. The officials and commanders who gathered for advice bowed to the throne, burned incense and myrrh, thus giving Alexander honors as a god.

Meanwhile, the rest of the Diadochi immediately began to figure out the borders of their own states and with undisguised irritation looked at the nominal kings that interfered with them - the feeble-minded Philip Arrhidaeus, the half-brother of the great conqueror, and the young Alexander, born by Roxana after the death of the Macedonian king. The illegitimate Heracles, whose mother was the Persian Barsina, also interfered with them. In the end, all the descendants and relatives of the great king were killed, including his mother, Olympias.

Thirdly, almost all authors write about Eumenes with great sympathy, sometimes opposing him to other diadochi. So, Duris of Samos, a student of the philosopher Theophrastus, in his work Makedonika, which begins with a description of the death of Alexander the Great's grandfather Amyntas III in the battle of Kurupedion, puts Eumenes on a par with Demosthenes and Phocion. But to other diadochi, he gives simply derogatory characteristics. Duris calls Polyperchon a drunkard, reproaches Antigonus One-eyed with a peasant origin, accuses his son Demetrius of intemperance and striving for luxury, calls Lysimachus a former robber.

Plutarch considered Eumenes one of the great figures of the Greek stories, and Eumenes, the only one of the Diadochi, became the hero of one of his "Biographies" written by him. For comparison with Eumenes, he chose the Marian Quintus Sertorius, undefeated on the battlefield, but killed during the feast.

The Roman historian Cornelius Nepos wrote in his book On Famous Foreign Generals:

“If the merits of Eumenes were accompanied by happiness equal to them, this wonderful person could not become greater, for the measure of a great person is virtue, not success, but had much more glory.”


Eumenes of Cardia in the drawing by M. Burg, late XNUMXth century

Let's talk a little about this politician and commander.

Youth


So, the future diadoch Eumenes was a Greek and was born around 362 BC. e. in the small town of Cardia, located on the banks of the Dardanelles. His compatriot, friend, and possibly relative was Hieronymus of Cardia, sometimes referred to as the "historian of the Diadochi".

There are two versions about the passage of Eumenes. According to the first, the future Diadoch came from a very poor family. Duris of Samos in "Macedonika" reports that Eumenes' father was a cart driver. Claudius Elian wrote:

"Eumenes was born of a father who was deprived of funds and played the aulos during the funeral."


Avletist, image 480–490 BC e. Louvre

But Jerome of Cardia claims that Eumenes came from a noble family, and his father was connected with the Macedonian king Philip II (father of Alexander the Great) "by bonds of friendship and gratitude." Cornelius Nepos adheres to the same version.

The second point of view seems more reliable, since it is known that the father of Eumenes, having moved to Pella, became one of the close associates of King Philip, and his son, according to some information, even studied with Aristotle along with Alexander, Hephaestion, Ptolemy, Crater and other offspring noble Macedonian families.

Eumenes ended up in Pella in 342 BC. e. The reasons for his family's move to the Macedonian capital are unclear. Plutarch believed that Eumenes' father could have been expelled from Cardia by the tyrant Hecataeus, a hereditary enemy of this kind.

And Duris of Samos says that Eumenes, while still in Cardia, attracted the attention of Philip, who visited this city, having distinguished himself in military exercises in the palestra. That is, even if the father of Eumenes really was a good friend of Philip, this young man took the first step towards the rise on his own and without outside help. However, the Macedonian king brought him closer to him not as a bodyguard or commander of one of the military units, but as a secretary: Cornelius Nepos reports that Eumenes was in this position from 342 BC. e. until the assassination of Philip II.

Eumenes' successes in this field, apparently, were so obvious that he retained his position under Alexander, who a few months later appointed him head of his office - archigrammat. Other associates of Alexander contemptuously called Eumenes a "Greek scribe", but Cornelius Nepos reports that the man who held the position of archigrammat was "initiated into all the secrets of the state." Many Western historians refer to Eumenes as Alexander's chancellor.

Archigrammat of Alexander the Great


Eumenes was responsible for Alexander's correspondence and the royal archives, compiled the texts of decrees, and also kept a kind of journal - "Ephemerides", which outlined the official version of Alexander's deeds. Only fragments of the Ephemeris have survived.

For example, those that in 319 BC. e. Antipater, who did not like the rumors about the "moral degeneration" of Alexander, who fell under the spell of Persian traditions, and about the poisoning of this king, ordered the publication of the diadochus by Antipater. The spread of such rumors was related to Antipater's own sons - the royal butler Yoll (and therefore he was suspected of poisoning Alexander) and especially Cassander, whom the king once beat his head against the wall in a fit of anger. The fact is that the young man, brought up in Hellenistic traditions, laughed at the sight of the courtiers falling at Alexander's feet. Here is how this episode is presented in Oliver Stone's film "Alexander":


Cassander and Alexander, frame from O. Stone's film, 2004

Since then, Cassander hated Alexander and was so afraid of him that many years later, already being the king of Macedonia and subjugating Hellas, he almost fainted when he saw his statue in Delphi (the sculptor, apparently, managed to convey the appearance of the conqueror well and reliably). It was on the orders of Cassander that the relatives of the great king would then be killed - his mother Olympias, widow Roxana and son Alexander.

But let us return to Eumenes and his Ephemerides.

It is believed that one of the copies ended up in the possession of Ptolemy I Soter and became an important source for his book on Alexander the Great, which the first ruler of Hellenistic Egypt wrote shortly before his death.

Eumenes was also a member of the royal council, which included somatophylaks (literally translated as bodyguards, including, for example, Perdiccas, Ptolemy, Lysimachus, Leonnatus, Peucestes, Python), as well as Alexander's closest friends - Hephaestion and Krater.

And Eumenes was also responsible for supplying the Macedonian army during its campaigns - from food and fodder to weapons, wagons, pack and draft animals. They say that he divided his subordinates into two groups: the first had to give a forecast of needs, the second were responsible for the practical implementation of supply plans.

The importance and indispensability of Eumenes is also evidenced by the fact that he retained his position, despite the hostile attitude towards him of Hephaestion, who had a huge influence on Alexander. It is curious that after the death of the royal favorite, Eumenes contributed a large amount of money to the construction of his tomb and offered to make contributions to other associates of the king. By this he earned the gratitude of Alexander, but not of other future Diadochi, who were not at all pleased with the initiative of Eumenes.

Eumenes is considered Alexander's like-minded person in his "Asiatic" policy aimed at rapprochement between Hellenic and Persian cultures. Among others, Eumenes was a participant in the famous wedding in Susa (took place at the beginning of 324 BC), when Alexander himself, already married to Roxana, also married the daughter of Darius III Stateira and the daughter of Artaxerxes III Parysatis, and on 300 of his closest associates married noble Persian women.


"Wedding in Susa". Painting by an unknown artist of the XIX century. Alexander and Stateira are depicted in the center, next to them are Hephaestion and the Persian princess Dripetida, Stateira's sister. After the death of Alexander, these girls were killed in Babylon on the orders of Roxana with the consent of the regent Perdiccas

Eumenes then got Artonis (Artonis) - the sister of Barsina, the mother of the illegitimate son of Alexander himself. It should be noted that only three participants in this wedding did not divorce their Persian wives after the death of the king. One of them was Eumenes.

Eumenes also participated in the multi-day feast arranged by Alexander in honor of Dionysus, after which the deadly illness of this king began and began to progress rapidly.

And the first participation of Eumenes in hostilities as a military leader was noted in 326 BC. e. during the Indian campaign.

Defenders of the Argead dynasty: Eumenes and Perdiccas


After the death of Alexander, his associates, with great difficulty and after long disputes, agreed to recognize Perdiccas as regent of the empire. He was a hipparch, that is
commander of the cavalry units of the Macedonian army. And it was to him that the dying king handed over his ring with a seal. A little later Perdiccas, on the advice of Eumenes, married Alexander's sister Cassandra. It is believed that Eumenes was a key figure in the negotiations between Alexander's associates, who categorically did not want to obey any of their former friends. It is curious that the cavalry units of the Macedonian army and the foot soldiers of the phalanx supported different parties in this confrontation.

This is how the Macedonian phalanx looks like in the drawing by Andrea Masochetti:


The Roman historian Cornelius Nepos later wrote:

"The famous phalanx of Alexander the Great, which went through Asia and defeated the Persians, got used to glory and self-will, did not want to obey the leaders, but sought to command them, as our veterans are doing now."

And Plutarch can read that the phalanx of Alexander

"had a high opinion of herself and was impudent."

And this is the image of a Macedonian cavalryman in the high relief of a Boeotian sarcophagus:


Eumenes, being a supporter of Perdiccas, nevertheless contributed greatly to the achievement of a compromise. Becoming chiliarch of Asia, Perdiccas appointed Eumenes as his successor as hipparchus. In addition, on the initiative of Perdikkas, Eumenes received one of the satrapies - Paphlagonia and Cappadocia - into administration.


Distribution of Satrapies Perdikkoy

The problem was that these lands still had to be taken away from Ariarat, the satrap of Darius, who had entrenched himself in them, left in his former position by Alexander who conquered this province. Antigonus One-Eyed, the "neighbor" of Eumenes, who became the satrap of Cilicia and Great Phrygia (the western part of Asia Minor), and the satrap of Hellespontian Phrygia, Leonnatus, refused to help, the troops had to be allocated by Perdikka himself. Eumenes, who led them, conquered and pacified his region, quickly becoming a very popular ruler there. In a short time, he managed to create his own army.

Very soon, the Diadochi began to fight among themselves. The reason was given by Ptolemy Soter, who organized the abduction of the embalmed body of Alexander the Great, which was sent to Pella in a luxurious sarcophagus. Perdiccas organized a campaign against Egypt, but was killed in his tent after an unsuccessful attempt to cross the Nile, during which up to two thousand soldiers died. The conspiracy against him was led by Python and Seleucus. The question arose about the new regent of the empire, who, at a meeting of the army, was unexpectedly invited to become Ptolemy.

The fact is that he won universal gratitude by providing active assistance to former comrades in distress. However, Ptolemy by that time realized that it was no longer possible to save the state of Alexander, which was literally torn apart by the closest associates of this king. He preferred a “tit in hand” in the form of a self-sufficient Egypt.

Python became the new regent, and he was soon replaced by the strategist of Europe, Antipater, an old Macedonian commander who was a faithful companion of Alexander's father, Philip II. During the absence of Alexander, Antipater ruled Macedonia and won the war against Sparta and her allies (the decisive battle was the battle of Megapolis in 331 BC).

General and Diadochus


Meanwhile, Eumenes acted much more successfully than Perdiccas on his front. He defeated Ptolemy's allies in turn. The first to speak out against him was his own subordinate, the governor of Armenia, Neoptolem. In the army of Alexander the Great, he commanded an elite detachment of argyraspides - warriors who were awarded silver-plated shields for high valor before going to India.

The battle of Eumenes and Neoptolemus was the first in which the famous Macedonian phalanx was defeated, fighting against the antitagma - an army recruited from the eastern peoples of the conquered provinces (the idea of ​​\uXNUMXb\uXNUMXbcreating such detachments belonged to Alexander the Great). One of the commanders of the antitagma cavalry was Pharnabaz, the brother of Artonis, the wife of Eumenes, and Barsina, who gave birth to a son from Alexander. In the center of the phalanx, Neoptolemus really overturned the foot soldiers of Eumenes, but the Greek was well aware of the weaknesses of this system. His cavalry units defeated the flanks of the opposing army and captured the enemy convoy. After that, the Macedonians of the phalanx not only surrendered, but even went over to the side of Eumenes.

Within 10 days, the army of Crater, perhaps the most authoritative and beloved commander of the Macedonian army, entered Cappadocia. He was one of Alexander's two closest friends, as well as a personal friend of Eumenes himself. At the same time, Crater condemned the Asian policy of Alexander, who wanted the Macedonians and Greeks to come closer to the Persians and other conquered peoples, which greatly increased his authority in the troops.


This is how Crater was seen by the audience of Oliver Stone's film "Alexander", 2004.

More recently Crater, Antipater, Leonnatus and Cleitus the White defeated the rebellious Greeks in the Lamian War.

Among others, more than 11 thousand hitherto invincible veterans of Alexander the Great were in the troops of Crater. But now, at the battle of the Hellespont, they were defeated by the army of Eumenes.

Krater was sure that none of the Macedonians would dare to attack him. He seriously hoped that the warriors of Eumenes would go over to his side, and therefore, in order to be recognized, he did not put on a helmet. But Eumenes directed against him the cavalry of the antitagma, one of whose horsemen inflicted a mortal wound on him.

Participated in this battle, commanding the left flank, and previously defeated by Neoptol. He died in a duel with Eumenes, and Plutarch gives a description of this battle, worthy of becoming an episode of some heroic poem:

“With terrible force, like triremes, both let go of the reins, and, clinging to each other, began to pull off the helmet from the enemy and break the shell on their shoulders. During this fight, both horses slipped out from under their riders and rushed off, and the riders, falling to the ground, continued their fierce struggle. Neoptolemus tried to get up, but Eumenes broke his knee and jumped to his feet. Leaning on a healthy knee, and not paying attention to the injured one, Neoptolemus desperately defended himself, but his blows were not dangerous, and, finally, struck in the neck, he fell and stretched out on the ground. Full of anger and ancient hatred, Eumenes began to rip off his armor with curses, but the dying man imperceptibly slipped his sword, which he still held in his hand, under Eumenes's shell and wounded him in the groin, where the armor did not fit tightly to the body. The blow inflicted by the weakening hand was not dangerous and frightened Eumenes more than hurt him.


Battle of Eumenes of Cardia and Neoptolemus during the Battle of the Hellespont. Engraving from 1878

Thus, Eumenes unexpectedly became one of the most prominent commanders of his time, which greatly frightened his enemies. The former associates of Alexander the Great did not like the upstart Greek anyway, but now they realized that they had received a serious opponent with whom they would have to reckon with and negotiate.

So, Neoptolemus and Eumenes are shown by Plutarch as old and irreconcilable enemies. But the death of the Eumenes Crater was very saddening. There were two reasons.

Firstly, Krater was his friend - one of the few close associates of Alexander in the environment.

Secondly, Eumenes understood that both the other Diadochi and the Macedonian veterans of the death of Crater would not forgive him. And so it happened: after receiving the news of the death of Krater, the enemies of Eumenes tried to ensure that he was sentenced to death in absentia at a meeting of the army. Because, as Plutarch says:

"He (Eumenes) an alien and a foreigner, slew the first and most glorious of the Macedonians with the hands and weapons of the Macedonians themselves."

In general, the words of Crater turned out to be prophetic, who, according to legend, dying, said that victory over him would bring Eumenes both respect and hatred.

In the next article, we will continue the story of Eumenes. Let's talk about his war with Antigonus One-Eyed and his allies - Seleucus Nicator and Python, the betrayal of the Argyrospids and the sad fate of the last defender of the Macedonian Argead dynasty.
29 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +3
    10 December 2022 05: 24
    Curious . This is not in my two-volume Plutarch Comparative Lives.
    The author of the article is an absolute plus. We are waiting for the article and the next, and a separate one about the navarch
    Neacre.
    1. +5
      10 December 2022 06: 10
      A number of "Comparative Descriptions" are erroneously attributed to the hand of Plutarch. More precisely, they were written much later, in the Middle Ages, attributing authorship to the famous Plutarch. These works were included in the bibliography as "Imaginary Comparative Descriptions".
      About the authenticity of the story about Evmon, honestly - I don’t remember, since I read both. “Everything was mixed up in my head - confusion” (c).
      I take this opportunity to thank Valery for this essay!
      1. +2
        10 December 2022 06: 50
        Hello Vladislav! smile
        I join you in your gratitude to Valery.
        It was not so much the diadochi that quarreled over Alexander's inheritance that caught on, but the outright meanness of some of them, I mean Cassandra. Killing children, mothers and wives just because you cracked your head against the wall, it somehow doesn’t really fit in the mind, even despite the hefty bloodthirstiness of that time, and of the human race in general. But the children and the mother... request
        1. +7
          10 December 2022 07: 30
          Hello, Uncle Kostya.
          Quote: Sea Cat
          Kill children, mother and wives just because you cracked your head against the wall,

          Not for that, of course. In that situation, no one needed Alexander's relatives, but interfered with absolutely everyone, so they were doomed. They were killed by the one who had the opportunity to do it, that's all. Morality and morality in such cases at all times were not even secondary - decimal, why should the era of the Diadochi be an exception?
          1. +6
            10 December 2022 07: 38
            Good morning Kostya and Mikhail!
            Nothing new under the sun, several times I watched how “colleagues” shared a higher position, many, because of an increase in salary of 500 rubles and the prefix “senior”, are ready not only to jump into bed, but also to sell their own mother.
            Sad but true!
            1. +5
              10 December 2022 08: 24
              Hello, Vlad. smile hi
              Each has its own scale. Someone goes to meanness or crime because of a position, someone because of a bottle, someone because of power over part of the world. This is our reality.
              But politics has its own morality, or rather, its absence. And rightly so, I think. Honesty, principles and moral cleanliness of rulers are almost always very expensive for their subjects, both in the time of the Diadochi and in our time.
              1. +4
                10 December 2022 09: 28
                Mikhail, I know your point of view on power and, in principle, agree with it.
                "He's... a son of a bitch, but first and foremost our son of a bitch."
                1. +5
                  10 December 2022 10: 18
                  The idea that you are led by scum and villains is unpleasant in itself, but when you get used to it, it seems to be nothing ... One can only hope that our sons of bitches are the very best sons of bitches. laughing
                  1. +4
                    10 December 2022 14: 01
                    Quote: Trilobite Master
                    The idea that you are led by scum and villains is unpleasant in itself, but when you get used to it, it seems to be nothing ... One can only hope that our sons of bitches are the very best sons of bitches. laughing

                    This scheme is ideal for a monarchy. When the head of state knows that he will transfer his power to his son (daughter).
                    Under a republican form of government, this option will be possible if the family and children of the official plan to live here and not only now but also tomorrow. Moreover, a democratic system will work effectively in the case of a number of key points.
                    1. Recall of deputies of all levels.
                    2. The prohibition to replace the positions of the civil service for two generations in a row.
                    3. A similar ban for the highest commanding staff of law enforcement agencies.
                    4. Rotation. And draconian as in the Roman Republic.
                    5. Election of judges and prosecutors. I would add to them the heads of the territorial police departments.
                    6. General military service for men. With no exceptions.
                    7. Expansion of the number of issues to be resolved in referendums, including those related to municipalities.
                    I understand that the above is absurd, but I can not offer another.
            2. +5
              10 December 2022 09: 42
              many because of a salary increase of 500 rubles
              What is called: "10 grandmothers - already a ruble!"
              1. +7
                10 December 2022 10: 11
                A salary increase of 500 rubles is nothing. Empowerment is everything. Now, as far as I can judge, the situation is somewhat changing, but even ten years ago, the Ministry of Internal Affairs could safely be called a CJSC. The powers of authority were completely shamelessly and practically openly converted into money, and it was not 500 rubles.
                1. +4
                  10 December 2022 10: 38
                  Well, this is the secret of the "half-coat". Another thing is interesting. Judging by outward signs, over the past 10 years, the Ministry of Internal Affairs has been purposefully "diluted", turning it from a power structure into a state unitary enterprise. Question: why?
                  1. +6
                    10 December 2022 12: 58
                    Quote: 3x3zsave
                    emasculate

                    Perhaps. True word.
                    The Ministry of Internal Affairs, in my opinion, is being turned into something faceless, gray and amorphous. The initiative of the performers is tied up with various orders, instructions and orders, from which it is impossible to deviate categorically. Each employee has his own set of such instructions, which he must know at the level of "bouncing off his teeth" and execute in the most scrupulous way, nothing more is required of him. Roughly speaking, no one in the trenches or at the top is interested in the disclosure of a particular capercaillie, much more important is the absence of excesses, any emergency situations and reports with the correct numbers. Specific disclosures are required only for high-profile cases, which, in general, are few in comparison with the general mass. And so everything is strictly regulated and no one will receive an award for an uncovered complex "grouse" that has not become resonant, and no one will receive a penalty for an undisclosed one, if all instructions are followed. But for non-fulfillment of some point of some instruction, you can catch a specific penalty, even if this did not affect the course of the investigation.
                    Police officers are turned into officials, and their work is turned into a boring routine, a mechanical repetition of the same actions over and over again without elements of any creativity.
                    Is it correct? I think yes. The work process is manageable, the results are predictable, the control is debugged, the costs are planned, the number of possible failures is strictly regulated. There is a disclosure rate, the top leadership of the country is satisfied with it, it must be kept, but the undisclosed, if it fits into this percentage, do not care. And so on at all levels, starting with the police. Nobody needs a warm heart, a cold mind and clean hands. In the cinema there is for the audience - that's enough. And in life - statistics, reporting.
                    What for?
                    This is the very logic of the development of the institution of law enforcement agencies in a democratic constitutional state. It cannot be otherwise, in my opinion.
                    At the beginning of my career, I had a chance to work with employees who were inherited from the USSR, and my teachers, too, were all fragments of that era. They were completely different people. I'm not saying "better or worse", but others. "Operational work must be carried out aggressively, offensively, operational positions must be constantly improved, investigation must be carried out creatively, avoid templates" - that's what I was taught ... Now they teach something else - "the rule of law, scrupulous observance of instructions" ...
                    Another state, other rules.
                    1. +6
                      10 December 2022 13: 45
                      Michael, I will not comment on your comment (sorry for the tautology). If I get hooked, they'll fire me for hell. I will add only one thing - today's real scourge of the organs is a terrible shortage of personnel. Those who remained work for two or three people, and this is at best.
                      1. +2
                        10 December 2022 14: 25
                        - This is a terrible shortage of personnel.
                        Today I heard an announcement in a trolleybus: "Law enforcement in the rolling stock of the State Unitary Enterprise Gorelectrotrans is carried out by employees of the National Guard." What is called, sailed ...
                      2. +4
                        10 December 2022 14: 29
                        In the St. Petersburg Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, there is a competition of almost twenty people for a place, Vlad. Some secondary educational institutions, such as "Petrovsky College", which prepare, including operas, also - five or six people per place. That is, there are people who want to serve in the Ministry of Internal Affairs. Where do they go after graduation?
                        Something is not right here in the system itself.
                        By the way, I noticed, communicating in this environment, that many employees are hereditary, that is, their parents either served or continue to serve in the system. Also a certain marker - good or bad, I don’t presume to judge. request
                      3. +6
                        10 December 2022 19: 50
                        Quote: Trilobite Master
                        In the St. Petersburg Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, there is a competition of almost twenty people for a place, Vlad. Some secondary educational institutions, such as "Petrovsky College", which prepare, including operas, also - five or six people per place. That is, there are people who want to serve in the Ministry of Internal Affairs. Where do they go after graduation?
                        Something is not right here in the system itself.
                        By the way, I noticed, communicating in this environment, that many employees are hereditary, that is, their parents either served or continue to serve in the system. Also a certain marker - good or bad, I don’t presume to judge. request

                        The given figures are beautiful before passing the medical commission. After it, no more than 5 people remain for a full-time place in prestigious universities of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and 3 in the rest. The sets themselves are 50-60% docked in comparison even with the hungry 95th. Girls have their own competition, they used to get 10%, then they increased from a share to a third. And the number of universities of the Ministry of Internal Affairs after the reforms of 2011 decreased from 28 to 14.
                        However, having trained and served the prescribed 5 years under the contract, half of the employees go to free bread. They just can't handle it psychologically. Moreover, this has always been the case, since the 90s, but the working conditions have sharply become more complicated with the general reforms.
                        The mentoring institute was killed while being transferred to the police. Newly minted leaders "ate" potential competitors.
                        So in a heap. I'd better keep silent.
                        Now for the dynasties. In the police (police), the army, the Ministry of Emergency Situations - this is good. Employees' children are perhaps the most motivated and understanding of what cadets (students) are going for.
                        Judging by the system of "conflict in the Ministry of Internal Affairs", it is impeccable. There are flaws in other power departments.
                        Well, somewhere like that.
                    2. +2
                      10 December 2022 14: 00
                      The real history of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, that of manual labor, that of Soviet deputies, that of modern times, in its entirety and with the described changes, usually poorly visible to the average person - this would be an epoch-making work. if someone undertook to make it and at the same time would live to completion ....
                      Only from this picture it would be possible to assess the change in state policy and the entire state as a whole. But let's not wait, most likely ....
                      Especially if the hypothetical author suddenly gets to post-animator times .....
                      1. +5
                        10 December 2022 20: 04
                        I will surprise you, there are such multi-volume works. There is even a discipline history of law enforcement. The question is, what do you want to find in this work - you will definitely not find it.
                        If you want the truth about the police in the early 90s, watch the first series of Streets of Broken Lights, although the book is better. You can read about the 60-70s in the story "I am an investigator." About the post-war police - "The Era of Mercy".
                      2. +5
                        10 December 2022 20: 30
                        About zero - the first episodes of "Capercaillie", but I don’t know anything more or less truthful about the tenths. smile
                      3. +1
                        10 December 2022 21: 16
                        I will surprise you, there are such multi-volume works.

                        Well, "History of the Great Patriotic War" - too. The only question is what is there from history .....
                        The question is, what do you want to find in this work - you will definitely not find it.

                        This is what I'm talking about)).... For I'm just interested in the real thing. Almost always and everywhere. What to do, bastard feel
                        If you want the truth about the police

                        Nuuu ...... This topic, as already said, is still a topic)). The end of the 80s and until almost the middle of the 2010s - and so I know. Not in its entirety, of course)), but, in general, enough. It happened lol As for films and books .... In general, I agree, given that this is still officialdom, although ..... "close to reality." Of course, the claim is not against the authors. especially since I read and watched almost everything.
                        Well, thanks for writing. Not so often found on .... non-core)) forums, a sane description of that dupe ..... Merci !!
                        If it were also about other ... industries to write like that, the thought of a "night cap" would come. It was at Pokrovsky wink .
              2. +2
                10 December 2022 21: 10
                What is called: "10 grandmothers - already a ruble!"


                So this is what kind of grandmother you hang on ... laughing



                Hello Anton! drinks
          2. +4
            10 December 2022 21: 01
            Good evening, Misha. smile
            Yes, not for this, of course ...... so they were doomed.

            Yes, this is all clear, I just could never understand the pathological thirst for power in a certain category of bipeds, for which they are ready to step up over heads and over corpses. I just don't understand. request
            A salary increase of 500 rubles is nothing. Empowerment is everything.

            "Expansion of powers" - but they can't feel like a peasant without this expansion?
            1. +3
              10 December 2022 23: 18
              To each his own, Uncle Kostya. Someone, in order to feel like a man, needs ten mistresses at the same time, someone needs to fill the face anyway, someone needs to show off the weak, and someone needs to command people, decide someone's fate. There are various mental disorders.
              Quote: Sea Cat
              could not understand

              I personally know people who understand this very well. And they do not understand how you can think otherwise. smile
              1. +2
                11 December 2022 00: 18
                . There are various mental disorders.


                I, probably, also have a kind of mental deviation: I do not need a bunch of mistresses, although I have never been a monk; I am disgusted to humiliate the weak, especially by massacre; and to command people and decide their fate - God forbid.
                I just live and try not to spoil anyone. request
                1. +1
                  11 December 2022 10: 17
                  Quote: Sea Cat
                  also a kind of mental disorder

                  There is an opinion that every person has manias, like phobias. He just might not be aware of them. For example, I don't know, well, let there be orangutans. A person is terribly afraid (or passionately in love) with orangutans, but he can live his whole life without ever meeting a single one, and without learning about his passion.
                  Maybe, Uncle Kostya, you are terribly afraid of blue ladybugs, and riding a giant albatross will give you the greatest pleasure ... It's just that everyone has the opportunity to compete for power one way or another, but to fly on an albatross ... smile
                  1. +2
                    11 December 2022 10: 23
                    And what ... to fly on an albatross ... Not a bad idea, I will dream. smile
  2. +5
    10 December 2022 11: 08
    Great job. I look forward to continuing.
  3. 0
    9 January 2023 17: 00
    No more articles about Macedonian and Diadochi. People went through the cult of blood arapis and wore them around; no one knew them except for the Ptelomeans, there was a problem with longevity. The homeland of the Greeks was eastern Anatolia, they fled to fight in their homeland, but no one was waiting for them there. And how it all ended and the fact that new people came for whom they trodden the path and St. Anthony called the Macedonian pagan. That's all. Cockroaches survive.