The military community of Russia - against the Minister of Defense

1
The military community of Russia - against the Minister of Defense The scandal around the misbehavior of Defense Minister Serdyukov during his visit to the training center of the Airborne Forces near Ryazan passed into a new stage. After several days of shock, the stools' brains creaked turned to the “wet” command, and the “entire stool army” undertook to resolve this scandal.

Immediately passed the team on the network agency "deny everything!"

First, at one okolovoennom forum got a certain gentleman under the "nickname" "falcon", who immediately went all the blame on Krasov and accused him of begging. They say that Krasov asked 200 millions for the proving ground from the minister, but when he saw a mess around, he gave the beggar a fair dressing.

And this "falcon" referred to a PERSONAL conversation with the PARTICIPANT.

A flock of frenzied patriotic lemmings on these sounds of the flute immediately, of course, became excited and rushed towards the pipes from the Moscow Region shouting: here it turns out, as it really was! The number of links and repost to the "falcon" has gone too high.

But I questioned not only the reality of communication of this “falcon” with the “participant in the incident”, but also his good faith in general, because he simply couldn’t communicate with the participants (I proved it, listing all those who were at this scene and explaining why he didn’t meet with any of them), turned everything over to one person, and turned only Serdyukov into whitewashing.

Today it is clear that this gentleman just lied. The only question is: he did it with the filing of "curators", or simply by his own frenzy-patriotic initiative, out of personal love for Serdyukov.

Then, in different forums and blogs, a whole chorus of okolokremlyovskiy and bloggers and journalists close to the Ministry of Defense, as one, undertook to cast doubt on the minister’s mat, and even the fact of the scandal, calling all of this an invention of the survivors of the old people. "Elderly survivors of the mind" turned out to be such prominent and respected people in the army as the former commander of the airborne forces Vladislav Achalov, the former head of the Ryazan airborne school, the Hero of the Soviet Union Albert Slyusar, the former chief of intelligence of the airborne forces Pavel Popovskikh. This, to put it mildly, was alarming. It was possible to call people so legendary and understand the price very well only if they had serious evidence of their wrongness.

For a long time there was simply no evidence. Everything went on the fingers and in general.

Then information appeared on Lenta Ru with reference to a conversation with the scandal participant Hero of Russia Krasov, where the scandal was described as follows: “According to Krasov, the head of the Defense Ministry during September 29’s visit to the Seltsy training center made a number of comments. In particular, Serdyukov expressed displeasure at the incomplete repair of the canteen and engineering networks. The conversation was very emotional both from Krasov and Serdyukov, but it was a business conversation, the commander stressed. The Ryazan School has already begun to eliminate the shortcomings identified during the visit of the Minister of War ... "

Then came the famous statement of the commander of the Airborne Forces Vladimir Shamanov. In his opinion: "... The conflict between Defense Minister Anatoly Serdyukov and the commander of the Ryazan Higher Command School of the Airborne Forces, Colonel Andrei Krasovym, was invented from scratch.

“The defense minister really doubted the feasibility of building a temple opposite the academic building,” said Lieutenant-General Vladimir Shamanov. - The fact is that the temple is far from the nearest villages, and the cadets themselves are in the training center for a short time. The minister offered to move the temple to one of the villages so that parishioners could look after him. "

And finally, almost ten days after the first information appeared, Grigory Naginsky, one of the people closest to Minister Serdyukov, spoke on the pocket Kremlin "REGNUM" with such text.

"We passed, looked at objects that are unfinished from 2008-2009. In my understanding, the previous commander violated everything that could be broken, because there were no kopecks for 2009 and 2010 for the year, therefore The fact that he launched builders who have accumulated 180 million rubles there is, in my understanding, illegal from all sides. Therefore, having walked around and inspected these objects, we also ran into a shop located in the military unit. such eyes hatched on the minister ra defense and me: who are you? There is no cash register, nothing, trade is in progress.

Nothing terrible happened there. I believe that if the people who stood behind us on 120 meters heard something, thought it out and put it on the Internet, they are dishonest people. I can say that there was no rudeness and mate, but elevated tones, when someone trades in the territory entrusted to you and someone builds on 180 million rubles, probably, this causes a natural outrage and, accordingly, a conversation on raised tones.

Explain to me why the temple should be in the territory of the military unit? Here the dining room stands, here the people jump from the parachute, and here the temple, well, with what fright should it be there? The village is a place where the paratroopers come to work in the field, and then they return back to the city of Ryazan, there is a temple. I am absolutely in solidarity with the Minister of Defense - what I saw there, causes indignation. Orders to transfer the temple was not.

The training center is, was and will be. Money as it was allocated, so it will be allocated, but by non-aiming we will deal separately, there are special organs for this. If all this is left with impunity, everyone will otryut their military units and on the territory of the military forces who will, that horrible will build. "

Actually, on these three pillars the whole defense of the minister is built. All his advocates and admirers now rely on them.

Well, let's just analyze these texts point by point in order to understand how much they protect and justify the minister and how much they refute the statements of the Union of paratroopers.

So, about the very fact of the ugly behavior of the minister and the insult of Colonel Krasov.

“The conversation was very emotional both from Krasov and from Serdyukov” (Lenta RU)

“The Minister of Defense really expressed doubt about the expediency of building the temple opposite the academic building” (Shamanov) - while the full text of Shamanov’s statement was not found.

"I think that if the people who stood behind us on 120 meters, heard something, thought it out and put it on the Internet, these are dishonorable people. I can say that there was no rudeness and no mat, but elevated tones when The territory entrusted to you is someone who is trading and someone is building on 180 million rubles, probably, this causes a natural outrage and, accordingly, speaking in a raised voice "(Naginsky).

And what do we have?

Two sources of the three confirm the "emotional conversation" Serdyukokva and Krasova. You can, of course, assume that they exchanged innocent barbs and swooped in the terms of the first-time noble girls. At the same time, Naginsky makes a reservation "if people ... heard something ...". That is, people could "hear something" ..

What could "people hear"?

Mat from Serdyukov's lips - for no one news.

So, during a review at the General Staff following the results of the Georgian campaign, he, in the presence of a whole room of officers and generals, switched to the mat, indiscriminately accusing the military of being guilty of the blunders of this campaign.

A year before that, in summing up, in the same General Staff, Serdyukov did not hesitate in expressions, but a little more in a narrow circle expressed everything he thinks about the military leadership.

Serdyukov's strong motto was also heard by Black Sea sailors during his blitz visit to Sevastopol in February 2009.

So you can, of course, convince yourself that the communication of the infuriated Serdyukov with some colonel there was like an electrician, to whom a friend dropped molten tin on his leg in kindergarten: "Vasya, you're wrong!" - but I personally do not believe in it.

Now about the essence of the conflict.

What was Colonel Krasov to blame for?

“In particular, Serdyukov expressed displeasure at the incomplete repair of the dining room and engineering networks.” (Tape RU)

"The Minister of Defense did indeed doubt the feasibility of building a temple opposite the academic building." (Shamans)

"In my understanding, the previous commander violated everything that could be violated, because there was not a single penny for 2009 and 2010 for the construction year in the Village, so the fact that he launched builders who built 180 million there. rubles, in my understanding, is illegal on all sides. Therefore, bypassing and inspecting these objects, we also ran into a shop that is located in the military unit. People had their eyes on the Minister of Defense and on me: who are you? there is no apparatus, there is nothing, there is trade "(Naginsky).

Very interesting! Three sources - and all three explain the conflict in different ways!

Tape Ru - with an incomplete repair of the dining room and communications, Shamanov - with the construction of the temple, and a friend of the minister - with some kind of illegal construction and a store where there is no cash register.

Strange disagreement. It seems that by lowering down the "ukazilovku" to extinguish the scandal, the MO did not even bother to choose a line of conduct. And in vain! Because when folding them, it turns out just a wonderful picture.

The approval of officials of the Ministry of Defense on Lente.ru about unfinished communications as the cause of Serdyukov’s anger is simply torn to pieces by Naginsky, whom this very construction calls illegal and violating all norms. At the same time, for some reason, the commander of the Airborne Forces, Shamanov, is not at all aware of what caused this scandal. In his opinion, this is a temple built on the site. But for the Naginsky temple - only an annoying trifle, which, moreover, Serdyukov is not going to endure.

Great!

It turns out that either the Defense Ministry in the person of Serdyukov does not even consider it necessary to bring to the commander of the Airborne Forces, what it (MO) in the troops entrusted to him (Shamanov) is dissatisfied, or Shamanov - a senile marazmatic, completely lost his connection with his own troops and “forgetting” reasons for displeasure MO.

Or there was simply no real reason for the highest separation!

And now one more piquant detail that, in my opinion, puts everything in its place: "Colonel Krasov Andrei Leonidovich, Hero of the Russian Guard, was appointed head of the Ryazan Higher Airborne Command School (Military Institute) named after Army General V.F. Margelov in January 2010 of the year by decree No. 52 of the President of Russia. " That is EVERYTHING that Mr. Naginsky dumped on the head of Colonel Krasov in his “explanation” of the reason for the highest wrath of Serdyukov, has no relation to Krasov himself! Both the “samostroy” and the temple in Seltsy were built BEFORE its destination, which was held only 10 months ago! Let me remind you that in Soviet times, when the army was, unlike the current one, organized and efficient, the senior officer was usually given a year for full entry into office. Just by default, because the year is the standard cycle of the life of the troops.

Well, Krasov could not, independently, without an order, take and decide that the temple in Seltsy was superfluous and destroy it, and at the same time, on its own initiative, assess the scale of the construction and “deal” with 180 millions of rubles. Actually, for this purpose the commission, which was supposed to HELP Krasov with the problems that had accumulated here, should have arrived.

And now a few more points.

Nowhere in the directives and orders of the Defense Ministry and the General Staff there are no instructions explaining or ordering the construction of temples on the territory of military units. Temples and chapels are usually built by the general decision of the military and their families in a place that is most suitable for this and does not interfere with official activities. So, for example, right at the entrance to the building of the General Staff in the territory of the Moscow region a church-chapel of saints Boris and Gleb was built. And Serdyukov passes him every morning. For some reason he does not bother him.

How did he “prevent” a small wooden church being built in Seltsy? And by what right his deputy, Mr. Naginsky is outraged by his presence, no one here can explain.

So what remains in the dry residue?

And it remains extremely unsightly storywhen the head of the school appointed by 10 months ago, Colonel Krasov, Hero of Russia, who was awaiting the arrival of a commission headed by the Minister of Defense and solving the accumulated problems on the spot, instead of the calm constructive visit of the “reformer” (as lemming in love with Serdyukov positioned him) ran into boorish, nothing unjustified dressing and flow of battle. And when this story became public, all the forces were thrown at the whitening of the presumptuous "reformer" and the salvation of his reputation.

I have no doubt that Serdyukov and his patrons have enough administrative resources behind the Kremlin wall to force any of the participants in this story to sign under any of its scenarios and even take all the blame on themselves. The ethics of a state official leaves them no other options.

I have no doubt that a public relations campaign against the Union of paratroopers will eventually lead to the gradual extinction of the scandal and the removal of Mr. Serdyukov from the fire of criticism. But all the efforts of the Kremlin and the PR people are powerless to make us respect a person who, having imagined himself untouchable, violates all ethical and moral standards and goes on people like on a ladder.

... And we will know the truth. Perhaps, not now, but soon, when the minister himself and his patrons will become past. The truth is that poison that acts even through the years ...
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

1 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. 0
    30 November 2017 12: 37
    In the military publications of Volodin and other masters, words on military topics should be paid attention not to facts, although they are also very important, but to the spirit of the articles, their focus and double standards, which, given the appropriate staffing conditions, can interpret their contents in a completely opposite spirit. The spirit of the Inquisition and Beria. An interesting system of arguments. First, the author expresses her own speculations about the character, and then, on the basis of her speculations, draws “realistic conclusions” as to what could be and what should be expected. The spirit of Skuratov overcame 400 years and now faithfully serves military careerists from various official clans. For our country, which is at the forefront of world contradictions, I consider such behavior, not limited by any moral and legal standards, dangerous. There were no and no saints on our planet, especially in Russia. And in dialectics, negativity is the other side of positivity and vice versa. They say: "The law, that drawbar - wherever you turn, that’s what happened." Speculative thinking is very dangerous. Therefore, people should be judged by their positive potential.

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"